黑格爾

全文

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

(7)

(8)

(9)

(10) ~.::.-t. .'{ f~ ij ~ 'f Ii 1. fr~ B~ f'( ~{ ~ Jf ltn fr~ ~ 'f j~ .f. *.

(11) ,~. 1~_ r'~"': ,f: /&- !if. . ~~fJ (Taylor, Charles) «~t!~n -~~,mw.~~.t!•• $~~~~,~-gmoo*ft~**, *!K*ftPI J;)jlP.X:T37fJ:::::kEHI : ~~~~~l!:fJ!l!±. (1) *ftJ!l!S1fiiIlZ\~jUlnL~1!f~J!I!'t1~..t" (2) A~a"J,C.\.' ~itllZ\~lI{~?iJE. ". (3) *ft,li!UIIIZ\~Ji~::t.ftfi~*, ~~.~~~ffiS-. (IJ. 0. ..t~=::k§.'X.~~ •• ~*ftm~~J!I!tt~.'J!I!ttn~ ~~ttn~'A.~ft~.R~U~li.~~·a~~~~§.o* fB~WT. (Habermas, Jiirgen). ~~~ «JJ!fi;tt~t!f~t1S1fii). (The. W'. ilp.x:. ~ f[§j. Philosophical Discourse ofModernity). ~JJl*ftz ~. ..t~m~I~~~'~t!.~aA~~~~M~t!f~J!I!S1fii.M'*!K. J!I!'ti. (~it*~tlfi). 'PI J;)J&fi;*ft ' f'FffiS. ~ A~*~tlfi ' ;,t ft~gg. 5tM*ffT~!l*~~S:. ~~..t~.~. ~~~.~. (2J. •. ~;§~, {@lIJ~~.~~Xt!f~~.~,. , ~M;,t1t~r-¥!l~:g.~;fJifj , it.lz: ' 5t*~** "•. , ~M~~* ' ~*..t3Z.imt§~ft!!it,!itJ1&X~~JJ!ft;,tft. .~~Mm,,-nOO,.~.m~m.p.x:~+t~~®n. •••lIJ~. ~;,tftJJlRtt'.MA.~.~§~·§~MW,,~nOO'.~.#. it.~.~~~..t~§~,§. 'A.~~MWR§~~~it.lz:'~. ft!!A5tM'R..t.~R'§B.·J!I!~Mit.lz:~R~"m~~*m.. WTf:E. «!lfi;tt~t!f~~~iii» -1J~Pff~I!1.~~~ r~-11litJJlfi;tt~. ~tl:H.Ilffi~tIa~~m~*J ~~,Ij!!,. IilJ. (3). 0. ,. ~.-f; r~tlff. (Sturm und Drang; Storm and Stress) .lIJIM'MW::t.-r~r1. ffllJ. iillJ::k*1~::t.~-t~o. ' tO$r.."J~t~~-f:Ei*~::k:i¥iftfi. (-tAh$).MaA.'~$~mA,.~m~OOitJJlRtt~~. I. i t:. ~'.M_'~~D~~mA~~W~§~·J!I!tt~att~~~~tIa.

(12) -. ....... M;.. ~. _... _. --.__ ._.. _... _-. ••• ~#~~~~g*~~M~.~.~. ~o~Mm~~oom.~m~'~*I~. •• ~,.~~~·gtt·. ~gtt~~~'~~U~~fi.mm~fi~~~Mm~~~m~~. $. (4]. 0. \. ~fJJ~ «~M'm» -~~. , ~ll~Ei~:$~Mm,'i~Ui~~ , .tlDiliJ. .w~m~2.·~~MM.~~r$~*.$J m}..~j!~§1::~~*~~;{4. (5]. 0. ,~~~oo.~m. $~*.$~~.)(ftJJif{'ti~~~. .. ~W·M.Wgm~MW'$~*.$m~~~~~~'li.~~~ ~. , f!3&"f~JJt..t '. ~ffiHT. '. i!!tml~~gtti9iftfffipxS9@I.~~. m1&.~f'Fli.)I;;:~. 0. ,. ~ ~~J!RHf. ~§z ' tmlElJJif{)(ftpqi.i~l!Ift. 0. ~~'~~~ffi.~,m~Mmm.~~~~~.~oom~·.~m f{)(ft~~fI~~51M. .. ~tlLJJi~. 0. *.~~.=~Mm~m.*mzM'~ff.~-~'~M~m .,~,!~BJj~~Mf{~f(. 0. -ttO~m~'-AOt~m~.-$~~m.~."~wm ~.». 0. niU9rm § ,. +1l.t!!:*c~~. 0. ~M~~,tt*~i5JtJIDH~:=II@Wpx$+ /\t!!:*c*M. ~fI!mR~M. •. ' ~~~:>ctlHIOO ' +tt!!:*c~~.~px~A. ~~~~~.~~~~'E.*~~~. ••. t!!:~-§3~o.~~.. •• ·.*M~~~~~·~~~@~fipxD.'~.~ ~~mtitift~~D ' ~f5tmmg'ti ' ~.EI.tJl~tt~i5Jt)Jttt~~ • ~!t: ~~~~ . :tmt$tm*~~~~D ' )z'iJl.7t.Ll7!t±.~~)i!!m* ' tlD~. ~~~~W. t~. (Herder, Johann Gottfried 1744-1803) • fftffJ (Schiller, Friedrich. 1759-1805) •. Sf~. (Schelling. Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph von 1775.

(13) HII/"'-'. 16. /' ,~. '. M- iij. ~A5$?r!lakJ&5'. 1854) ~Y.H. ~-a.ii'"1~00tI. '. ,. 0. t&ffii '. ~mfifj!t;g~IJH!t,~,~~*ftIlkJ~f~. ~*..t~~1i~ l:.~=~f§1L'31 H. , f.t~mmfg'¥,~~IlkJEWH. ~=fI,~~. ,m~. ,. ,. iWlflillkJ,~~. 0. 3Z.~ff~*~'1J. 0. '. !lUll! ' 1mk0 1)- '31-T ~ = *,~ ~ , j.:).fj!f.t ~m fifjfg'¥1lkJtm!M! ' IfJ iJiIIlJm. tI,. 'fii'l'llkJarm". 5 (Enlightenment). (A) 1mK:kJffii~ .~~. ,. ,. ~~:;$:tM~. .fillkJ~~iI!Ib~EW~$xfj1iJJa~f-t. BJH~fg'¥~*ftIfJf.lI:iH§IJ!f**~~IlkJ,~~. 0. ' +-tt!t*c.!\I. A~1lkJ. rJ.ll!tE.±:tif. 'titJ (Rational Subjectivity) IlkJHJJ!' *§?&IlkJIt.ft:, A!tEI?&1lkJ .~~~,m~. ?&f4¥EWw '. =*~*~*o~~=*~~,m~!3. I.1firfnllkJm~. , ~'±:if!lm~~llkJtI:l~Jl. 'f~tif'±:fim~. ,. f:lt9cEW~$)(fjt!HI!J;!:a~f-tIlkJAx'±:fi,~,~~1fJ. '. ~ :If:1I1mllllllkJ~~~~IlkJ)( ft:JJl f-ttt~flfflti " J.lI!'l:i.±:fttta~. ,. ¥_~m~.mJ.ll!tt~ • • 'A~~~EI~m.EIB~*iI,*m~ *~,jl~EI~!3. akJ. ·ffijAX. *(6]. (Montaigne, Michel de 1533-1592) 1£. rEI BJ '. r~J f'Ffg'~:PJf~~f.t*. (7]. fi~,~~*~EB. «~Xm» (Essais) 0. IfJ • :fJl. l:.~H~JlA~~*mllkJ'±:. .·~f.t.±:ft~~ff.*m~~.~·+-tt!t~IfJ'T~·H • •m -F~. (Descartes, Rene 1596-1650) m¥~*ft1fJ1lkJ r.±:ftflflltiJ '. rJ.ll!tE.±:ftttJ a~ " l:.~~~~*..t~JJll£m-F~1lkJ «7JL~,i1<» ~ IfJ. (8]. 0. m-F~mA~JtIlkJ,~*f£5!1b. (Cogito). ,,~\*ft~. (thinking!). f'Ftfg~tf~lDmf!t~~~?j '~:fJlffijj.:)'@1!W~~IlkJ~tm~1*fjT*. ~~..t.~*ft~tI:lf.l~ot&ffii·~.~~~l£·~ • ~1£1lkJ~~. 0. r.±:tiff§f:i'lttJ. '. ..t.&§?&t!tW. ,t~mllkJ1hIE~..t~IlkJ,~*ft~!IZ\~Ji7't~.

(14) ¥ .:::.. 1: ,~ M- lij 11" ,JjH/i !t. II; atft 1,'". *\. 17 .f-. Jf}J II; 11" ,Jf: itt :if ~. rr'~*,*rrmnn~~rr~~~·.m~.~m,~.-~~ rr~.~~raJ. ,w~~~~att~rr~a'ffim~~.fi~tt. ,1i!:UI~a-F!Pil~ 1f~±. •. ~J. . ~¥JJrr. ,. J!(~tt,~~ ~a-F!ppfT~Wl!'ti::t::fI. , ~~WEE-F~P:EHHF. «m,~~». (Self-grounding) , r!3aJ'EfllJ (Self-defining). .ffl~.EE-F~P:!3a~r!3 • • ~J. ~!3a. 'A (fX). ~. 0. r:pm*c~[§nA,:rnA. , flfW: '. (a). ~-mT*IBIIf£-1mPJliilil~. '. ~. ' §8kJ. f'F~*~~'J~!Jo/J' ~a~rr~.. ~~tE~*IB~rr~r:p~~.1if!. ,~,*la~EE-F~m~~~t!lilnrt. 0. ~~tE. -§'ilifX~~rrf.fW:' §~-jC~~JLrr~a~m~rr~f.fOO:. ~~. r!3 •. '~~~EE~~~M~~• •. [§nA:rnAOf'F~flMf[J~ii*1t-~~m~g~ffi. M'. •. 0. @Jum~~~~a*. ~F~j!ii-~PJlilt¥1.. '. ~~1&. , J5fT~W1;a • t:!~a~ll{E-milPJ.~~. ' ' ,. ~alB~rr• • '.~'~R~.~rr~~IIf£-~3IBa~~·~~ m5.::t::fI~r!3aJ'EffiJ~a,~~~~ • • ~,r:pm~.~,~. .~a~m~$fJtIB. rftJ ,~rrlB.fW:' Xii ' m-'.tm~rrWfiQA' fiQ!jo/JIMf~~r:p-WtHIO ' ftf.tfit!A ' fiQ!jo/J~rrpJTf5EEIBJ1J1ig , ft~ft!! A. 'fit!~IBRIIJ~JH~~~· f'F.~*~IH'F~~. ~R~rr~*~. rfXJ '~~Xil raj IBlJmf~~r:p~~-F!nJ:::*rr raj !it ~~~. 1B§~,x~,f.trftJIB.n,~~rftJ~§.~'.~~*8kJ. §. o~~::t::il.~,~.r1;ftJ. 'EE-F~~::t::m'.R~!3. BMJ'E!3B~rrlB • • ·Xil'!3B.~!3B~~~§.o Jlit~::r:tJ!3~m3'f. ~~1;JL~~*. '. ~*f'F~rr~~~. • !3~m3'f.iffl~rr. 0. ,. ~iffl. '. EE-F:~P:!3ft. '. 9)\F!n~1Ii.lz:~!3ftz9i-1B-~.. !jo/Jiffl~rrlB~~o~PJ~~'1Ii.lz:'!3~lBm-F~~!3ft,jC~~~. rfXJIB~ttm.,. • • ~m.lli~*·~.~ • • lli!3~m3'f.~~.

(15) 18. "~-'". ....... ".. ,J: # riif. {f tilltt ' 0. ,!'*t£~;fi! r~J £~a9~$T¥{fI¥J~~o. 1--'11 (Kepler, Johannes 1571. §~l¥JltI:1t, ~*..tl1ffi§:R:. 1630) ,. fJJDffj~ (Galilei,. Galileo 1564-1642) I¥J § ~f.!.J.¥1ir!mfB[9J. 0. :R: I--,11~m • J«f§~}Jl~-WlJtm7(..t~~l¥JiifT-.1tf'FIf{§* • M~'~ • • ffl¥JaM,~.£~~m.'.ffl¥J.~ • • ·~n. ~~1E!~§~t!t~.f'F1¥J7*~1j £~iIl}1B;. 0. 0. fJJDfIJ~~IJm~¥f'FI'#J@§~t!!~~*. fJJDfIJ~7tfTiitll.~I¥J1i$. ¥}~~llUEl1Spx~~1i~~. ,. , tt$§~}Jl~$¥j~~~tJJ '. .tJ~}Jl§~f!1t;ilmll¥J$~IJ. 0. tilffij • 1ff. .MM~~.§l¥Jttl¥J.m'$t!t~¥I~..t.~~~.I¥J§~t!!~·. :R: 1--,11 '. fJJDfIJ~£~. ,. ~~"1tf'F~~1i~~.~. J'lIJ • .iftfT~1!lt~lil¥Jtl;ffl.tttiifT A~it § ~t!t ~~*ifiIJ ' ~¥-J~~f*, '. • ,~~~IZI~1$I¥J~Jl. 0. Francis 1561-1626). ~IJfjUa1i:H~fN. (Bacon,. fl!i1i{f*.fRjf~· m.ffit.SAW§~~raJ~J3.m. 0. ffijpxl¥J~.~aoA.m*m~,*.~m§~t!!~I¥J • •. M.·. *..t;fi!*.~ • ..t~.m,u~w§~t!!~.pxm.'1Sf'F'liM~. f*,. 0. ~ffij. ~I¥JJ/Jtl~. , j:~fN~71£1it*mfB$ • .tJ~lUfi7!J&f~f·tnftl¥JjJi*,$ • it~D , iJ)\~ttlW.1:i:tlX~1'raJl¥J;&$ !~fNm r~IJ~?,t~1JfJ:J ' 0. r.m*§~I¥J§1¥J. '. ;fi!~*§~n~~~11'J. ~1!U~tt.~f'FI~"'tt. *ifilj , flJffl ;JH*,. (IOJ. ,. ' fl!i1i AW § ~ , iJ)\ffi1Sf'F '. 1'f.itR~3&i5. liM~iH*,.~f'F. 0. ~tt~a~ay~JJl ·_?!3&A~~~lrJ .[§c:.~.fti~J$* ~ cl¥Jifn. =f'-=-=§...=c::..:..ff:....::1£.1i • K:¥PJ±'*~~ ~~_:Im~ii ±.B. ~1£m~~£~I¥J.Ii@~£.£$,~ • • ~7fl!i1iA§±.,§ffi. =.::.-'-.:.;IliiI::....:..-. I¥JI{~. 0. 0. tilrm '. J!l!tt±.at~ta~l¥JmlPX. A~jHt£..t.I¥J*ifiIJ. '. •. §IEiJii.Ii:1JD.tJ,~~. §~I¥J*ifirJ£$m$:ttl*. 0. , tbhWJ. § ~iJii.Ii:1JD.tJ,!,~ •.

(16) W.BA• • ~A·~~·kmftR·K~~n~m~o. ~. !t7t 'l!~¥IJ~~:±.tt~A. • tt:g.~f3i:~~c.~~~ ·}:!m • ~E8t~~~~c.~~ff§~· lEii tfjfi~/~~:±.)(ftr:pl~.tt· ~ 5t:tt °?0JTIL~ Atf$1~.tEf.Ij~~~~~5t:)(ft1ittZr:p • 1itf$r:pA • ~ffj:!;.[EJ~ffEHJ • 1l'lfiii • Qt)'~~!JllE*ffiJ • atlE~iJf'FB:fmmm1* ' 0. tfjI1X:7~~:±.xftzr:p-t!!Q]"t)'NJJlf-txftzr:p-A.Azra'. ~ftR·. ~*'Bnr:pm~.M'~.km~~£~A,. km• •zftft· ft:$. 0. A.~ff§~. ••. ·nW~.. , ~*kt!!~~l1X:k*~IJ~*. m~§mo~~'A.k*.~~ftm.ftRo~~~~r:p,. ~~J. •. r~.. r~ft~~J~A.·~C.I1X:.~c.fftt~£~'~c..~. ~c.~ff~lEii,~.o¥@lEiik,t!!.M~A • •k*Z~~.. &ammj¥. 0. ~~~~r:p. • 12iJ.§?&f4~~Ejij~ • ~~mfl.fJtfl:JI:fl:: '. ft*~iI. ~~-*~~~.~~~~7lEii·§mo~alE~·m.~.·~ gA~~E8·~:±M.~A.·R~I2iJ • • • ~·~.~l!ii~.ffl ~1'F~*~~. , ftit~7f;~~. ' tfjI1X:P}f8!r1 r{,' .!fo/JJ. zrs'~=5t:~n. •. ftR;~az.·A~*§~~~~·X~.-~E8iJ~·~.~1* ~~a~1ffIJ~*~~1*. 0. mtl (Kant, Immanuel 1724-1804) tt-t/\-1F1±11t& «Min}:! ttttt;l!lJ» (Critique of Pure Reason) • -tf\J\~1±11t& OrRJ!lH~. ttt,'J). (Critique ofPractical Reason) -- ..:...tfLO~I±1J:& «~I~1JZ. tlt'IJ»( Critique ofJudgment) Jt1ffM(Fichte, Johann Gottlieb 1762 0.

(17) - - -....... .......... ~~. 20 ,~#:-. ril. 1814) }1IJh1:--tfL[g1f.tB~ «~~~» (Science ofKnowledge) ~?&~~~~tE+I\t!t*c*M '+fLt!t*CfnMIUJt!trg~~*1f. '. 0. }1IJ~. ~.M.rg~~*1f~M,~~~~~.n~rg~~,§m~~'~~. ~Jt;ff;:m. 0. ,. Jt;ff;:mI¥JA~JH3 EI3. ' § ±~11!~ , !ii"!lt~~~~. 1:..ti*~.o EO~attrg~~.'~~h1:-.*1f~~~~~~~ • • ~±.~. ~.'.~.~~~~I¥J~.'~~~~EI3.*1f~.I¥J • •8.~~ {~t!tn. 0. 493&tf.~~~'ijIU:l~.I¥JPJ1lg,ti. 0. Jtm-:m}1IJ~~t'm:~ff~~. ~Wf~~-8-$'ti~1~ ~~~. 0. , ~~~~~{-I.q:t , t'~O~~I¥J±OO~~ q,t• • PH1Hffl~ , ~t'tE «M!f$Jmtittt1IJ» q:t , ~EB-F5e.j;J. *'~nfi~q:tJmtt±att1l!~~.~ft~~.ti°. «• •Jmtittt~». q:t'~$.A • •~ffaq:t'§EI3'§±M~I¥J:m.m:.m~o~.. ~~~~fi~~~I¥JJtm-:m,~m.mA.§~'§±1I!~~~®~ ~ii!!a~rg~~,*,$IIl~~tI. 0. «M!f$Jmttttt~»q:t'~~Ea§?&t!tn.~m.r • • WMJ 'IItnHi!H~A.)L\flq:t$'i:7C*~l¥Ja~~~j:\,. (Sense-datum). .'$'i:.*1f~l¥Jm~'*1f-8-,§?&t!tnn~~~~mmM~.a~, m~o~~~rg.~*1fq:t'A.I¥JE~~~EI3.~tt.M~,.aW .-----~--~---.--~----.-.~-----------. ±~t1JJHi~. t!:!.PJ j;J~~.l--_MtI:~~:i~~~IlRJitJt!:L~ -,,-,n-,-,ff/::...:c~j:\~,;:::..;$JlIJ ' ~ § ?&t!tnl¥J~$1ff ~IfiL'_~l~~_'«~_f$_MJ.!t1J!t1IJ)2 q:t , ~~~}~,lWlpq , Aa*m±*I¥IO'Ji ' ~~~I!~~ I em ~ 0. 0. 0. J. p;J... *1¥JA..:J~Jt'!.;~~_~~_~~l- ' ~:t0.~g'@~:l.fi!~.J!C{~§C~~~ ~ 9.f\HP"g~§ ± a~$'i:~fI*{tj::. «• •Jmttttt1'J» q:t , ~t~:fJi§ EI3{'FA.~t'.~ff , i})\HPIif£1'ftE § ± ' § ~I¥J~~~ r~1TI¥J~t~~!~!L •. 0. n~PJ j;)J~!H'F!J(lI.~~~m~. 0.

(18) ¥;~. ~. ••••• ~~~~g*.~.~. .... 21. *. , "t~HJ~lg!li~EI EB ' EI±:f:EA~t~tEiigfT~$( 1S51t~tt ' ~n~::f:a~1S ' fff:E~.~ , *~~,ti1!t~$I¥JA~'\Ul:~ , &~~mm~EI~1!t~$~ •• ~.~,~tttt~¥EI~·~.1!t~ 1¥J~.·.~~.E~'M.o.8Z'fff:E.~1!t~Z$~A.'. . ~*"J • ~§'i'j;:ziRtEElC;A.'$.&JI.t • I'IWi ' EI±: ~iTIi • ,.t~f~lli · A~It~~~7ff1l~~Wtt. ~¥EI~1!t~~.~l#fl 1Tl1J~I¥JElEB. 0. EI~1!t~Z~'~~~ff~~~tt1!t~Z$o"f:E~~tt1!t~$I¥JA. ~.~·%~~~~EI~1!t~I¥J~~$.m.~lli*~.R.~El2 tJrt~:I¥JJMtl:~J'lIj~1HtEf~'31. ' ~mFi EI EB • EI ±:I¥J~.. 0. (JfiiJMtt. fJ:ttlJ» $ • ,.~~ : r-a.~#.~6~~~·~#4~~. • • ~.#_~. ~~M~To~.~. •• ~~,~~#~~o~L~·.~#. .ijM.~m~·m. ••• ~~a4,~-a5~~ •• ~.. # ~ <f .JIj .::!. ;Jtb .tt ~ ili ' :jjl ~ ~ ~ • ,(1. ~ ~ 4!,-,t1:~3-:1r. r(11~.'t1.#:1r~A$Ji)'. 7t, 'fJlJ.;f,l0. 0. J. (II]. G11#,f,~6. ~~~~<f~#.'~~~M~0.~Mo~~'~'f~40 G11tt,f,~~'t1.1!t-*· ~~'l~;t~~p • • ,t1.· .JIj'::!'~~ ,~~~, ~ ~~. £. ~ J£. ,t1. ~.../:. 99 ik .f!'l. 0. J (121. .~f:E(~~~»$·mllir~m§~J~~afff:El¥J~m~,. ~~~o~~1!t~$fff:E¥~r~~EI~J&*§~'~~EI.~1!t.

(19) ,~. #- iij. ~~~~m§~o. §~J .:L5t~. *fJ~~:tJ. 0. r~m§~J~~~~§r~m§~J. , !lfJ~m§~~~~§ ~a<Jf:tW '. ~fffi. ,~r~m. , J!it~1i!il*"J ' ~ ' ~~§~~?t.Uf:~~§~*~efl:: ,5tftmHmA§ 1T~. ~m~.:LOO~§~~~m'~~~§~.:L~~~~m§~,.*~, fJjjf~:W:. § c.~i!ifJ*"J ' .iift*~~ § ± ' § EBa<J¥-H1. «~~mt8». 0. t:fJ '. .~~~~~M§~~~~§~~~~~~§c.a<J~mtt--~m§ ~~~mf:t~.7~~.OO.:L~~m~·.~,ft~.OO.:L~~§ EB-~ffij. , :W:. '. r~F~J .:L§~~Ri!iIJ '~*"Jrm~~~ r~m§~J. ~~.§~~Wm~M*~'~~· «~~.»t:fJ'.~M.M:. r1t 1.; ~ .t1. fI ~ .;e 1t fI. ~ ~H!l-. ;:t Z ~F ~ -1fJ. 1.; §I , ;tj JIll-. z. ~ ~. ). ,~ ~F ~ (f1 t~ - i l p 1t 1.;. (;tj~!l-. ~ ~). 1.; *-. 0. A-. a. §I. *- fm 1.%. 0. ~F ~. ( fI. t~. ). J (13]. ~i§.:L' ~~§~.:Lfifii:mm~,. fJlJtlO'. ~tt, ~ft, t.~, It=~. ' iJ;:~ ~ffij , .~M3z.t1D1ilJ$ m:W:~Wtit~*IJ*"Ja"J~m §~.:L § EB ' § ±M·r.£ ? § M~¥jj!IjOOffij ~ ,. ,li!!.*f£ '. H'i¥m-:W:tt§~~wm~~*i!iIJ. 0. §~m~.~wm~~~~.§~~§~'U~~~~§H'~:W:§ ~'~Wtit~~~~,~~~.~:w:~m§H~*~o.i§.:L'*~ §EB'§±~Mf:t°§~~. ftJ (Intellectual Intuition). •• OOffiji§'.~M.~'.mr.a<J. , AJ.ifilJ j.;)'ft~ tUi~~ r~~R § ~ J Z. ~,~~~±~tt~.~mw*~m.f:t±e.:LH,~~~f:t±e.:L. ~. , .*~tlfl::tN.:LH. 0. ~~p.nx~m§H.:L~;j1({.'~Bfft. ' ~*W·r.£. .ffia<J~.'~~Z~·~~§~m~m~·*~~~§~,~wm .~. ;l. j'~. f. ~.:L~~~~~§H,.~~. •• ,m.§~'~wm~~~~'~.

(20) M~~·~~~Mtt"~~'.*M. •••ffi~'.~.~&~~~. ~Mm~Z~~rfim~tiJZ~~~·~n~~Z.'Wn.A.. ". *W..t,fEt~~·3Z.~. ~M~~,~~~mw.~~.tt~W~~.~~*~'Bn~ 11::~A'Ji~~ .*M~W. • ~~ZI1~'. ~~mR:'. LI.fJtZtJ.1E· ~~,. 1:£.t~·. ••• ~'.~~~~~~~.".Mtt.~~,~••. ~·.*M,~~mA.ZffiU~.~~·~x~MW"~~. ••~_. ~fj~1:£~m~w:w.~~ r1mm~:ftJ. • m~~a ' flE~~~~:!t* ~~~'t1r:t§IJffiL~,:1f " ~1:£~~WW:w.~~.~ • fim ~ ti ' ~Ij ~~ :x;z...t~~~ . ~.l:.Mtt ¥{II••J: ' .t~· .*M~~. ' ~ur tjtAJJi~tt.~tt~~~~W ' i:iJft•• Ml.§.~~~t5{~~~it;~Ij,~, 0. 4'B~~~~mftwn~n~Dm • • it;,~.~n8~~~~' A.m~· ~JtmlfJ.~tt· ,~,~mIfJZftfJ. IE~DBXWf;2. . faf* (Berlin, Isaiah). RootsojRomanticism) fiJfU.iii~5:E. '. -~~ffit~~. §n~.fii~. '. A!fttmZElti7t~. 0. «tm¥I~.ZfNi1!» (The. , i$HI~.. • fi~~~11::~1fJ {14J. (Romanticism) ". .j;jmtt!~5:E. ~~~m{I1IT~~--t~O' -t01f:1-\:;~ r~tlH.J. iilfJ. ~. '. ,~~W. ~.A~.·W.·B~·~~m~.~Z~o.M..ttm~~~~~. ~.~. ~VJj*Afta~~ '~i~.~· §VJj*fEtMfm~¥~;J:t;~.. it; ,. {t!!'w,zra' , §n1j\~U~PffiR!1n:· :f'~~~it; o~~. ,. fiRm. m~~~~,.~tm~~~~~*n~o~~~~~~.a~3Z.~' ~~~.tm~~~~IfJ,~ur~.~nw:~~~~·~~~u,.~ *w,t1:.~. ---. - _.._. ..... ". _ - _.... - - - - .

(21) 24 .~. eM- til. • •M.,mm~*,.g.~~.h'.~$~R• • •C. i~,m~~ff;JlI¥J~fli:,r~,~~ , ~oom~l¥Jmlm i}MP{lg$~- Tm.' ¥tJ (Schiller, Friedrich 1759-1805) 'iFt~ (Herder, Johann Gottfried 1744-1803) & m~ (Schelling, Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph von 1775 0. 1854) ~AI¥J~r*. 0. .~~3,.~~.,.*~~mWH~@.~ • •DI¥J&.o. .~~ • • &~@ • • D~'5m~~8~m~I¥J~.~'. {t '. &~ A~)L\iI. R~rl~":Fmltt~z~1¥J rm~.i1JlJ. '. Soul)-ihPImWilj~m~I¥J~*-1;IJ1BIT~mf*. •• • •. 0. •• (World. gBfn-,1~,;m~tlam.'. 'B~W~@ • • D~m.l¥J.tt~ett,8~~.~,W. 1m~ti*PiEfJ-t7l' ~tfl~C.~.~~. ~~'tiakJ~$IJ. '. ,. AJjl~ttR~'t:£~J~ ,~,ti. flJ~:(£f~A~ • •~akJ~*zT. '. ARAZr~'7tM. '. A~~~~ff-OO~~I¥J·W5I¥Jtt~oihPI~.'.~~.5m~ ~;H'l¥rj@.~ • •Drtt~akJflfl7t~. , 7tM ' lli*7t~ . ~1LI¥JJJ!* zr~'akJfO~i ' *1f- Too ' 7t~IJ*kJ~$~- T .g.,~;m~akJ:f§~JJft'~ .~~~Mi'&~@.~ • • 1¥J8~ft'~M~~OO.~~ • • Dl¥Jm~~.z- .~~ pff&~1¥J ' *~~ii8~~]I{t fIJ~ • •{ t - , ~Wm~Rm:f!llm~7t~I¥J":Fm=7t{t ' AJ~)L\ • • ~e7tM.~=7t~ofi~~~.Im,.g~ • • D~I¥J • • (Hamann, Johann Georg 1730-1788) • • t~· m~ ,t:;).g.8mte~ ~~r* ft(~§ . :f81*:(£ «.rl~.ZfR~» ~ (15] , t~te.oI -f~f!¥:PA~a~ , &i~HmrYll¥J,~\m~-¥f~ • •~ , PI j;)ID?:~§{li: ~@.~.1¥J8~ft,.te.~l¥Jm~1¥J5;m~o • • mw,~*~ ~~~ • • ,x~.~.~,~~,m8~m~w~.m~I¥JH.' n~~~*l¥Jft~o • • 'ffl~«§·m~l¥Jm'~M¥~:f!llMttl¥J 0. 0. 0. 0. ••.

(22) / 25. 1:.fJ6 (Mystical vitalism) '1iif¥Lt1iHI"J§ff' ~it~H3?!.\tlt~1'~ ~§t:~Wt ' ~1~ql:1ifB"taf1.}~,' ~ltt ' §?!.\7ttm;t~" ~D'ff(161. tH*,. •• ~., •• ~••*m••~.§~-~~.~.o ~.~.wr~fi~.Wft~nJ. • • • ~:. r ~ 1t:.i- ;;t ¥.t§. 6!j 1H.:~ ~t ffJ:JJ. .... l:.. (eternal act of cognition) ,. ¥. ~;;t~W,~;;t~~'-.~A~*~:JJ·~.~A~'. ·t§.;e.#1t. k Jli ~u..t1-:fflt $-'. §. 0. *'. ~ a!j )ii] -. ~ {EJ '. 'f ~ ·ti.". ~·~.¥~~;e.'~~M~Jli~.'~~~§~~.~*W'. j.« · J. (l7J. §?!.\tlt~'M~tlt~'~~*~-~.Wft~~'~.~~'M~~ ~~,.mtH*~~~~.· IL\JI~.~~~§?!.\. lIt9i- ' Mtil! '. l£fili~. ••. W~~;. r§~~.m~~~m'. • J (18J WilWfTfl1f:tlfltltff.'. §?!.\tlt~~=ft5}:ll. r.il:±w!J (Expressionism). Jm~CP. 0. ,. ~~l£'M~tt~Jm~'.~.~~*l£tt.il,~m~,~. 1;fI.j~ ,. 1J;tJcRX. *Jj~~CP. 0. J. 0. Mtil!~: ft!!~ ~. [19J. r::fflJ!~~.il~,1el*I' fl.Rff:(£M,~. , *Jlf14p.xfl1f~tltff.~,~,*1 '. .f!tltff.cpffl£~~~apJT.§ff. PJtJ~ft!Utff:(£. 0. 1!!PJtJ~'. a1tffl£~mflll· &~fl1fflll ~. ,. JL\liX:!jo/]~. '. '. ti.~mljjjf. :J:;:z!jo/]f!' ~al¥1~. &:\~.fHi!i~§~. ,. , HPpJT~IUg~ , 1J;t. !itm~fl1f~ ,~~tit!l!tlE~. , ~ , ~.1:.~7l!ft· ~~ ,. , M:t$ , :Mz~tit1li:llff:(£ • • • ' 1£. MtH.?!'\.fIIlW§?!'\~~-~=._'~. «§~fg~». cP ,.

(23) ,1l(( /~:~.'. 26. _.____.__ .L.__ _ ,~. #- {iii. ?r ;{if -. {OO. ?r.li. '~:i E! i.&.(t.li.. a~ r,Jj ~ , j:~"if. Mt![! , ~~i¥JJlI!~ , MiR 7 §~'±:~if!!1t '. }11Ii. ;fll ~'i"Jc. 0. {.'5t~r",9~. J. (201. 0. A~W~~.W~*.~R.i¥J~D,5t~,~~~m~.±:~~. ~~~~Di¥J~~o~~mW'B~m~~mW.R~mW.r~~. rmWiliJl!J '~*--1:E/f~~ ~IJA~J{fflf$ , 1tt~t~A~lif;p.j't1{.'E ' re. i¥J~~9iD1TD1JJ-m~tt!fMzf'F ~~. , ~J~W*i¥J/fraJ~5H§. 0. ~*i¥J~fJ~Z1J ,mR:7~!1tfifl~QI.~ r.l!19'~1:ii¥J~ft~JJ!. (21]. o~. •• ~**j.H$ , ~~1ttiffi.~in ' 1BJT~i¥Jr",91H!· «*tf5T.Mt![!» (Vieo and Herder) -§if! ' ft(ifil5:2 . :f8HttrmW ' Mt![! , lEtlD-~. ~J{{.'. 0. i¥J~~~A~'±:~~ (Weimar humanists). '&~.~*itt1:.' ~~i¥J~. ~'~-$~*m~~.~2i¥J2W~om~~.if!'~ •• &fi~ n'&.'.~i¥JfiWo~iffi,~aiffi§'W~-~ffi.i¥J2W~o. m*JlI!tt'~~'~@'li.'lim.~i¥JA~'ffm@~.if!'~ lEfO~~:tt!!WJJ[. ffiJ'. 7 ~ *flfirtrt~fJ~i¥J~1il (22]. 0. ~~~D. if! r ~ ftJi:. r~.£~Jzft'~~~2iRJi:~2~ff§~'~2.~~. 21:.~~~'~A~@A1:.~§~'.~.~*~~~*i¥J~~~/f m~'~~A.~*i¥J5t~'IBJT~oM ••• ~A~'±:~~i¥J.$'. 1'8-lEMiR 7 ~~l2EIft. 0. ~~~DBkJ.±:atita~. , ff+t:m~czf&BkJ~i#I~{tif! ' fIT1:.7. @m.±:~,~ftA.~Az~i¥J5t.'mBom*A.~~'A.~ *i¥JfD~~. ,*ft-zPi- '. mrl'±:~~. , ~~1Jm*A.ft!!Azra9i¥JfD~~ ,. *ft-o~~'M~m.~*~~~~mW'A~~~'~~~~~. ~,.~o~*~-W~W'/f~~*~att1:.$z~~oA~~.. ~!1ti¥J.~,m~iffi~~~~'~.®A5t.oM~m.'A~i¥J..

(24) .¥ ...::. ~. .lIr. ,f8.1iJ"1f!f IJi :l.. ftf; st 1~ 'hI:.. /tr". *. 27. J1!...fLJ/Ij ~iIr Ji. .t~~fftt~A~~W@~·~~A~.~att~$Z~QM.m. fiIJ::.Fffi~~liilrmiliilm. 0. t ~&liU~~tf.Jl!lll.s • M.tf.J~r:t t Wilt'. ~Jlt. a.. 7A.AZ~tf.J~-.~~."~~~~.WARAZ~ • • •. tilf t A.tiIfZ!"Ja' , x.~.M~.rJa';m.tf.J t t:l/J~_t!! " _t!!tt r~ If±:fiJ (Populism) ~ , mWPJT~~llttf:[$mtt!3r&ffijr&:J;t!!*6~ffij/t( tf.Jgmt~t~jtz~. .jt ,. t D:;t.tt~~1It®1:.$ru!.~. ]J~tI~~1Rl)(1ttf.Jti1f". fiV!!f~fiIJ. r~ii±:iiJ. 0. _tlf~filJtf.Jgmtt. (Expressionism) ~ ,. ]J~~~~Iiiltf.J~)(f-~;f.:tf.JA!¥. ' gmtttf.Jt±!¥ '. r~ ~ ~iiAIftf.J~IPl~M. 0. J [23J. 0. fit!!~. ~-g~.R~AlfrM~tf.JI~. .. ~tjU~ii7Pff~*mtf.J~~. :. , ~g. : ,§f5~(!fIt, *~fft~ {gfJlltf.JfIIl!i~~ flmttti!¥]J~~IRltf.JJtf~ • itflJ1f!l1iii ' ~1Pltf.J~J1f! • JL\J1f!IIX~tf.Jim 0. ~o.~Z,tilf]J~-If~.~IPl.M'~Iiil~.tf.JAlfo~~tf.J ~)(. • Itm '. ~~~!¥f'Mtf.J~m1t~D [24J. 0. fiij-gZ t i't.~jt)(. ii::ffi1:.tf.JA.fiBAZra'!ifJifAMft· ftf.HIAM®&iM ' _t!!5$ru6lAIi• • *.El1iX!HI • JUlttt±ft 0. ~jt~~~tE~~mJ1f!ttffAIiM.·~.tf.J~~tf.J.~o.. ~~~E.·A~.~BJ1f!tt~~'~.Wmtttf.J.M·~.Z~~ ~lli*o~~. If) ,. ••*~tf.J~.¥~tE~J1f!~tf.J.tt~~tf.JW~tf.J. $BAli\{~fSi7ti~f~'3113 2ff.tf.J1J:S: ' ~1iXA~!31ll!'ti~1lI. 1i~" ~~§1ll!fif1Jtf.JA. ~~.7§E8tf.J~tt" ~t~~WPJT~ ,~. '. ~·.*~~§E8'§±:ZJ1f!ttft·t:l/J~R~tt·~.tt§ft~~* Mft,~.·ft.o~~~~t~~'.*~~§E8·M.nttA~~ mtf.J§ft~J.*M2.~tf.J. 0. m;¥1Jtt. «~¥~Wtf~» (Letters on the. Aesthetic Education ofMankind) ~ ~III ffl. r ~"!(jlr~ J. *ifAm~~~¥*M~J1f!tt.~tt2.~tf.J~M·*.o. (Play-drive). • • ~,~~.

(25) 28 ,~. #-. fJif. «~~h~m~»-~$tE • •ili7m• • ~ • • ttft~tt~M. ~:;fre 'f.tll~1f~. Q/m1il}]~Slt «*IJ~h~m*IJ» ~~'3. t f:l/1x/f. m4mtt~t.!i~~fFfJi.R~::tl!lttfa~Mliffi;~~a9N:7~ ~7~. 0. /mliltrI[fM t. ..AJ~i*~LfJft~jijijtl1lj!IfJ. drive)-9F~ r~~1Jj!IfJJ (~~~w). : ep. ,. ~ifflmili 13 c~. r~'ti1Jj!IfJJ. (Sense. r~f§lij!IfJJ. (Material drive)-.. a.~.fMt_tt1Jj!IfJ~.A~.Slt~amW~r~. '1jJll¥UI1:ff~~*. -gftfll-J (Sense-datum). t 9Fep~r~JlaakJ1:. $'h.~.*Q.~~amW~M*tf:l/1 • • A~~m~amWt. mWakJ. Slt~~. mW~$. Necessity) W~f§. iIi'J t 0. tf!8,t~ma r~.a9,e,~ttJ. r~f§1Jj!IfJJ. t. f{IH-\,;.Ali~.tt~=f~am. t ~~mt:~/f~a9mW~~~~JlmlVZ*1t- ,. 1'}amW~t:iX*. QJ:)..'tii~J'EmW '. Q.1iI}]~m13EB '. tt, 13. tf!8,t"Slt*iliIJ~*iIi'J. '. ~7~f{IJ. ,. A~~J'E. t. ~.::ta. 13::t~mWf'F r~t~~,e,~ttJ. Necessity) a9m W (2Sl Q~ f§1Ii!IfJ1ff1*~ A~ 13 EB ' /f~~mW~tm:J'E. (Physical. '. ~~f§a9~*. (Moral. rjlj!j"@A~fJlf;~!IfJ. Q~iffl'. r~f§1Ii!IfJJ ~. ffi.~'~~7A~~Slt,.Slt~fthQ.~-gftM~~m'tf!a. $nt!iJ!U~*1tf;. , fJlmakJfth Q~§~ t. ~f5H!g~. tt1lj!IfJJ. ,. ~f§9F.r~ffa. f{IJA~mamtYH~~La9.:W:~$. 0. f§& t. r~. 13~. Q~. ,. .~~L~~~.!IfJ~~ • • t~.*1tf;=.~Ma9:;fre,. IiIJJmili 7 ~*o. r~tnakJlIj!IfJ J. (~. a9~~. ,. tf!a~iif~. ••• ~m)$'.~m:. ra~'~~*. •• ~~.~~t.~~T~~*:. 4~~_~~~f_~. j. (Play-drive). '. , • •a9. ~. M'44~&a.M'~~o~~«,. ~#.a_~#4°.~.r~.~~M~~*'.M.~MM.

(26) I. 29. iiri:. ~L::: :;: ,~ #- riHNf: itA :f fI!} at if. 1f :J-I!- -f!- J!JJ s%1i. rk'~.A~~I~4~,~~n~~#~±.,~~. ~~~~#~~{EI"""k~i~,LfUffJJJit*~lt*-. 0. ~:it;;tl>t.,. k. ;;t ~ {!l -Iff JJJ ,.!ff7 1f 4ff JJJ ~ Jal it * 99 It *- ...... JiiT ;If i§(. fit 11 k 99 :f • • ;;t~# .~'~#~.'.~~;k~~~~~~~' ~~~~~.~oiA'A.4~k6~oc~~~,.#~~. ;f it; ,~HJP~ ~ 4b.J. 1f i! iJ] 1;. m:.;t;Xt\jifMjQfJnOOIlJ~*1¥1. PJT~" r~~$Z~f§J. *. ' lJf!. o. !lt9t , ffg¥JJ1:E. r6~_JJJ.~. ra,. ~. 'Llt ~. ~. 1t- ::i- ... .... '. 0. J. t 27l. r~~$z~f§J (Hving form). '~fm r~fEH!.t~~Vfi~$. f§······~f§E!f~731:E~:YlZ'f-l (28). ~. ,. 0. ~$9)\~~fft~. ~$x&:\~1:Efg1:1z'f-l~~~~······J. «~~~"ff.{§». 'f-l xMl. :. .•.. ••• ~~*-'.~~~~:~ __ JJJ.. ~~.~.'.~~~~.M~~*-~.~.~~o. JJJ'. ~;;t~h~*~~:f.~~.ft~~.'~M~~ft~~~. ~. :f 4b.J it 11. ~. m 9r!Jt. ,fii. ~~.-tOOi'JI~l¥1ffg¥tJ~~3t~ ~jl¥1l'~7311J. '. ,. *- 69. 0. J. [29]. I'iJJ:JMtfii±rfOO~'.li~~i1i. ~1Jf'F~m:~Jmtt¥M~t1. tI_tt ' &:'?!.ltttff.zr"m~~ , 'f-lir. 0. '. :±ft¥M~1i. : ffIi.MJlA. ' §. U~dM'lljf!~f§¥M~W. E8~~~. '. ,*~1J. ~m~Z~~om:~Z~~~!ltMl'JmE8f!.~'~'~~lli~~ff.

(27) ,4IIt. 30 r~~ ,~#-. tiJ. :(£I!.!lifft-Jm:ll ' ~m ; ?!,irm ' J:.~~f§:§DY.£'~~f!.flW:: ' ff:(£~ , f!.~~WMtt~~mo.i~'D.~~f!..~~~ft-J~m~~W'. ' 'jf~ mlltJ-ffli;' ¥fJ:m~ f'F~Iti1tjlltJ-*'R J:.;ij!;~~ii AlL1~tt~Ji~ , :§D£, y';ij!;~Jl'¥lj*Ii!~. , ~Wt!tw~$ft-J~m. 0. A'Jtft-JDV1tJ~IJ3§:mlltJ. ~;ij!;~~'~.Ilft-J~tt·~~~6ft-J~~'~rm'~~~~ff~ ~6ft-J~~. , 1J7tfjg~1i]l5 [~~ft-J~~ • D~tirH'F ' ~1m~rp~ , 71J. § tilJ. ~~§~.~o?!,irm'~~.~.~~~Jl'~~'Rt!tW~$'~.~ ~~'Rtt$~~.~offli;'~~'jf~'DmttmlltJ'~~.AlL1§.~. •• tt§u~~~~~o .grmi, ••••g,~.x ••a~ft-JM~,~~.*J:.. ~ •• ~J:.~-*5.o=*5.~$,Ag •• ~§.ft-J~fttt, .~ftM,m.~a. **~U*§~, ~. ,. §~,§~oWy.~n~m,M~~AlL1~§. §~iTIif7j~ft-J~fjftMMfJTJJi*. ~n~f~~~~. 0. •••. ft-J•• ~M ' tB-IE;ij!;J:.. 0. (2) Jlf~.1f.~.:L ~¥ff~. f'F•• 1*lm-$nx'~ft-J •• ~~ ~ J:.' «nififiJJi~.»lli~~M' •• 1*le~~J-~~X'~filli ~J-*/J\IJ 1*lB1&~~ •• Il~' ilJtJ~:(£J:.~f'F~$mti7 tt~~~om-.$·a~ftm-T ••• ~M • • • ~~~fifi.~ .~fr'~ «nififi.fJi~.». 0. x:. ... ••. (.1f~~.1jitt >. (The Positivity of the Christian Religion) ,. (.1f~~f~tl/l&:!tfrJ~>. &1j\1J. 0. «Jt*M.~Iil. (The Spirit of Christianity and its fate). •• ~M~~~». ,. (The Difference between. Fichte's and Schelling's System ofPhilosophy). ,tJfl!~. ••JIj!f.Wl.

(28) ~.cr.,,_C~ r ~. ~r. 1lkJ,'\!',;m • ~Ht-mmt~'t1J.mm. 0. (~~~z"f*i't1) ~~~~1£~~}~, (Bern) 1i~Iif~gililfif. (. -n~)~~~·m~~~·~~~~-tnli~-tfu~~o. i!Jfn~)(± ~~~W~~~tzoiilJElr~-@;~~ .mW!=8iXtltE*~. 0. ~.)(*PJT&~~. ,. ,. ~HB~~~*~~ft. '. IFJ~:5t7@'t~,;m~v-. ~.8IJ~m~~ «~.ffJ.mtEttt~IJ»-~~~~ ~Jtt:j:lPJT5¥:~£~~t$¥~~. 8iXflft~fH~. Ii '. ••. ,. ~~Jn!l:£~f&8iXtlft~~*m~mf~. r¥.~-. J. 0. ~~r~IUg~. '. 0. , ~r'~~A~~. §7t; , ~~~f~lli. :. •• ff~.~.4*'~#A •• *o¥.~. ~*~.~A. 'ii. -I; /]. 0. f~llims~fl~:WJtEfJijtgm~~~fT~. - in ~ A ~.J.t ~. ~ft. , ~lli~&~. • :;t§c.1:EfiitflUEfJ¥ , tttalfl ~~~:Ul~£~f&. ,. ••. *~~.~~~'~. ~?} ~. III ~ 11 -. ~ if..,. ~#.~£.o. Jf ~ M it it- 1111 #r ~A ~. [30]. , I1~~ZPJTt)EI3~t~RIfI~t$~ftf'F~t!t± '. £~ZPJTt). ~*J.mEl3~t$mt!!~fJ;:tzp:JLIlkJMiJ.mm.uJl!~l!&iJ 1f~~llkJtt~h. 0. I1~~Ol!ifTt$iI~*s*--W!ltzD*~~. , flll9EA1Its-' ~f(tlt:j:l~ ~gEl3~J.m~ffi~t~f·nJII~Ifij.ftf'F..tffit$~fr1~- , 9.F!ln~il1m..t8iX fI~fr1~ f'F~{tii..t ffifr1~llkJll~~ , t!!fjiit$~ft ;!t~ , ~~1~:t: 0. A~ms~. , &mJ5J&ft '. 0. ~~ft~*fB*ffJjjt-i!!.fji)t~ms~*1Jttt. ~J~$fIJ.A (~±fM) ~1flt~~~lfllkJ)(ftffJ*-' £\~JHHI1JfT. §.M.m~~.~~i~'~MAIlkJ~.A~*.B~~o.ttz. $i- • ms~x.~iJlM*fB*)(ftt:j:l • • 52m~Yfiilli}Ji!~A. 0. ~?&tfjpx£. ~~m~ms~IlkJA~.noms~IlkJ~.M~M~g~·~~~~~M.

(29) 32 ,~#. iii. ~~~~~~~~ • • '~fi~ft.mu.~.m'~#~.~fi. M~.fto~fi~,ft.~ • • ,.n~.~~fi~~,~fto~fi. , r~1iE.$l5.t'm{Wm~~~~ ~~ ~.y:~r~t€ '*@1'~1l1iJf~fi~At!~BtJ ' 1'~1l~{§~~~ ~tI~~1IJ ' v)\1'~!f~,~J~ , ~n[inttJ ' {i1!iFl~fi{fJmJf~fi~. ' .=OOA.ffo~ti~•• ~fi~m,q{t.~~~.oH.~2R ~iW~:lIr~1iE~IJ~n{W~. ~fi~~l~. 0. 0. Jf~fia~f~.AJjJlf*. IIJA'L\ ' ~'. '. P)Jtn:~2{'~~~flj:i1!fll. ~n[iAa~~tt~t!1T*~. ,. 0. ~~~tp;~E8OJPJ~. ~1tf'Fn[if:f:pl-tE~fI~'I'f~'t1*. ••• t!.m~~'AiFl~~a.~~·~•• ~m~~~;~. .Jf~aftf!llM. '. ~m~f'F~BiIi. $0~.'V)\E8A.~ *~f!~~~i~. (31]. 0. "1tf'F~flt1*~~1~. ••a~.~~~~*·n~~.,.gR~. 0. tE(~.y:~~'I'.tt)-~$,.t!.~~~~~~m. m".~,. •• ~~. (~.y:~~Mf!Il&X~~)$,.t!.~~~~~.~,. "~f'F~lEoo. '. ~5EJf~a~~~1§,\j'!,$¥Ii'Fi~1tm7T~. ,.~~.~~.~tEmW~W~$. ~>. , ~~~. ,~.t!.tE~~~. •• o. ,. ~n:~tJ. (~.y:~~Mf!Il&X~. •••e~~ ••~,v)\~-tftA-AO. ~~~R~~om.~*$'.t!.&.~.~~~$~.~fi~~. R~m~~~'.~W~$m~~.~~DRR~.~'~~.~li. M*fC~a~Jj]tfg .~. 0. • ~l~IJMi~a9ARA~ra'a~~ , fiitfU:E1B'tff! ' j(~~$. §!f* ' ~t!.mtH. .§!;~~~~ilRtM. '. ' nffftEW~1ff1s*~1t~$ , ~*.~~. *mIJ~W. 0. ilRtM '. ~~.§!;~~~tt.~*~fli:iJ5. '. *~~~iFl,n.m~$~M'*~.~~* • • ~#*'~#~1IJ ~,.~.~rr~o~w~. •••••~.'#.~J5tt,V)\1'~~. ~.~.~o~fIi:i'~. ~.§!;~'.*AR.M'§!;~1'~'~±~. ...

(30) ~. '~";. ,:~~.!"t .. ... -. .;~. ::fft<~. •. _. __. ____. ~# • • ~.~~~~g§-~.~.~.*. , !1*ttBR lft~IfR ' flljlJ111¥JlIJf'F ll:t9f.' t31/ifs*t.El.9c1¥J1WI fs 0. ~~'~~~~'~~~~~~~~~IfR~.'~~I¥J~~'~::f~ ~. ,*!tiS Mtflij , ~~.mM ' ~*.tlli~. • ~ftf!.A71~I¥JIAOOtmtifl • JiHI*)(11::~1i;Z- ~::t\: • ~*At3t:£~5}!1Jffl-ijJ#;Zt& • ~MT *t3~~m'A • • m~;Z~I¥J~~·~IfR~~~¥ • • ~I¥J~.;Z Wi ' J:J...t 1if1¥J~*1f(1E* t3 ~l¥Jf~91l¥Jmll!g jjflElf*~I~*Al¥Jtifltf£ • @nx.~-fIEl1l.i~ttl¥Jtifl • J:)J~ffJtl¥Jifnfi ' ~$I¥J~~tI:IJJ! ' :Mz..§.J:.fa]' 0. 0. 0. .1¥J~~·.~~*A~~~~~.~MiSo~~~*~~,t3.fi. J:j* '. tJ{~mjl:9f.~I¥J§~. , ~i*-pJT~I!1~1if-I¥J.*1j , JtnX~. ~,t3~~~l¥Jn1i°:Mz..§.~~$'~~~~~~~I¥J*!tiS'~~ffi ~)ff]~f.t~~. 0. ~*~$:Mz~F~t3pq{.'l¥Jmt~t.~, {IR~9i-1JD~A. !1t1¥J~i$B ~ *,1~ ; ~*~~):1ffI¥J~~ fIij$F~t3pq{.'I¥J~~. 0. • x.~jft~{~:tt~AI¥J{~{~ •. 1$!flll¥J~A11:: 'AI¥J1m~1t: '~~~9f.t]~Jt. 11::'X.~~~~9f.~fIij~nX~~~~'~~~~o~~~~,~nX~ *)(fl::f1j~l¥JfR~" (£1J~I¥J'lIftifl&~ifnim> t:jJ , ~~.1I§tI:I. *1¥J:W,.lf!~fR~~~71.. .Jt~W~WLiR~l¥Jt.1i. '. .*,1~1i. '. '. ~. ~m:~¥.k~*~~~ifnimI¥JJffi. ' J:l*MIE.' .tin1titiEl*Xftp£f1J1:U...::_~1t '. ~~.mo~~fIij.·JffiBmr.J~.iS.~o.iS~~;Z~I¥J!1 ft,~~;Zpq'.A;Z~I¥JM.'.Apq~I¥J~Z.~~I¥J1$~I¥J~. .'.Apq~l¥J~tt~.ttI¥JM~o~~.mM'Jffifi~r.ili.~J. (TheSennonontheMount) t:jJ, {~. r.~I¥J~AJ tr:~1¥J~1l. • ~~~H:tii§I¥J~RJ. ~~I!;t. ,. ' r'ijAHfm. J:.J.m~A~~f'F~$ffil. m;~~~~l¥Jm1i,mn~~~~~;Z~'A.A;Z~I¥J71~,:tt. ftoJffifil¥J~~~1$$'ifnfiB~~~9f.~ttttB"A~*~~~~ ~. , WtJtzJ:l.~I¥J$fi '. jj~A;Zra'fln:Mz.fiJl~-ml¥Jm. ' Sft. 0. ~~. ,. 00.

(31) 34 ,[( #-. t/ij. ~1ll?JF:ffjt~ll::.A~BJ§fla. '. VE~~~;fJfi. '. ~:iL. 0. ~*i5IDII~. H~~'~m~mJ '~~.~.M~.~§.'w.~ ~~7t~. , ~:iL '. j}<JI~ii$!*5. 0. ~Ill. '. rp).. ••m.o. ?JF~i'irlJHI2~~A!K~i:&~. ~fiX.W~fi~.'~&~H~~~D,. 0. ••a.~~fjtM%.W. ~A~A'.~:f~:iL,.~-a~.,~~~~m~A,~#~m. § c.P),9i·~ftl!A • ffij~flW7 § c.ttlflltl:j:l~:l::a~g!H71 • ?JFfPflW 7§ o~w.~m• • ~~I:j:l'*&i'i • • §c.~~~.a·~ li~F'ffipg~ o)~~~pgez' §.IllI~l:tf~fPJ~IllI!%AII(~ tl!*JlJ.1A~~c51:~. '§1l. , §Wfo. ~(¥~~~m~&~~~)I:j:l·~~.*.~~+~~~ ti~1f~mfB. • WljH~~~t~~%f'Fl:t~ ~~~ • • fiA~~*M· • • §{$ 0. ~~Mf~~~.~~{$i'i .I:j:l~r~. ~%J. (Categorical imperatives)' J{IJ~A~~~11 • ~t~t~~~.ti ' t~ E.~~*M'~~o. (¥~~~m~&X~~)I:j:l'~~Mm:. r······fW.~:±:*tt§~~~ ·1f.Jc.,l:j:lm~:±:*. *~teztt······ J [32] '.. 0. ~~J!~~. '. 7kjlmiJimf~:±:. · ~'1WJ~.~~!:1t"~.LTf~~~:t. ¥JirJt~~m~ • ..~~ilTP.Hlrflt~w,:~7i~IJ~ra'a9tJJtilJ -,----,,--'". --. ~. --~-".--~--...,.~---.------------'. A~.A~~~.'.~o~M~~~.. ~_~ ~~~~_~_~!!!.~~. __.___~~,~. r ~ i\'- '*~ 1'f it. ",] ~ #. i}. _~1·tr ~ 18 1Pf •. ~t .ft 1t jl i~At,. #dJUi·. ~. J:. i! a~ -tJJ tlJ '. ~. ~. ' 7tM - --• ff~~ . -~---. -. J:. a~ >tt # ...... 1r- Jdf oj}11 )/::- II. <itt ~ M. ~ A. ...... • J; ~ -11- • 4'- ffi l!( j£. ~~§~~M~~.·&9.#'.M jl. --. J:. ...... J. [33]. • • • ~*£,.ft1t.

(32) ~35 •••. . ....,~# • • • • ~~*~g*_~M~ -"-". $;#. -,. ----"-"-_. --~-. -.. ~. rA.~~5~M~~.·.~,~~.~t~.~,~ ~.fi ~. M- • tt1ir. 0. J [34]. • •~mm·m.$~~.$.~ZT~.ttft.·fi• • @~·~ ~F § E8 § ~ • ~fjfrrT tJf~~t~1T " ..tjjJ;tfltt1T.m ' ~J.g! • 1!$ , @PtE. lil1f~:tt. '. i'i1iI~Jt$ii~~1:.$:tJ. " ntEfHl~Jl~ , :n:;tJH~..tt!HT1t. ~.~" • • z,~-~~an~§~tt1:.$:tJ~.ft°. (• • ~~mw&Jt$~)~.Z~' • • •fi• •~~~mlli mT~m: • • mmw,~~ • • r.J~J.g!m.$~A.li.$ • .. ' ifJiE!P.$~A.tl!J'$~1L• • .:E~ , ~1f~j;J:~~/JIj , fl'jJJt~JjlJ ifJi~Jt&:\~~$~. ~.A:t!tra'~lE.'l'. " • • PJT1~~I~.fk.fl ' 0. I{~M&~r'tER1T~. ~~~.. ' .1I..t.$. .?ipWtltra'-WZ::fl'l·1S~'. , ~¥.Wtlt. $ff!¥JmfllIJ ' ·lilIU~lH±ff~lT.m" J:jjJ;MfflTf~ ,. .@PJT• • ~.'~fim.*~~.&M&Z~" • •ffiMtlt~~. m'M§2~.:E~::f~A~·JJt*'~~~.*Z~~"ntEfiM.~. ~7-WAtlt~ff~ii~~~.~*·~w'~~:n:;t~~ft~~~. . ' &~~~g~~:n~~JJ!lli*" 9Et:, ~~f.M~• •&:\~~i11i~' W.ntEfiJmM~!t ' tt!l:;t:n§j:)!JUE~illli § 213f)~m~~.f1jf* • ~w~mwo ~m..t)(frijl • • •1:.ZP:iM'fiJT.. . ~*Ifft '. ' • • • • fFiM'ft~UI~H1lti. fi*lfft$iM~~ • •~~IlZ~.1t~~*J.g!tni. *~&~o. '. t!'H~;ft3.. (• •~Z.~tt)-)('~lE~W • • •~~• •~~ 1l~.1tZte~fiJT~m~~tni" (• • ~~m~&Jt$~) -)($ ,.

(33) 36 ,~. II- til. ~#HIi~IJJ5U,!Uiffl~1!ff)(. rl:'J. I¥!ffl!t~. ~~mff~ifJit~A. " ft~J1: •. m,,~~mW~~·~J1:J~o~~.x*$·~~.u~~~rI:'J. ~M:k:II!i*~~. • .M:ff~JJl1!tZ$ ; ~ffij • ~~.anfJYil j@~&\~IHA'~m~A1!tra'PlTffa9~J1:~~ , 1ptmt)Jj3&fO~ " *'fC-g. I¥!li$o 0. ~~Zl:'. -I\OO~* O-~. • fifaM~Z:frijf '. · t±:l1t&7 IJ\ff. ~~.¥tm~*~f:E~frt. <.1fi~!Ji!M~m~~*'fCz~~». 0. [35]. •. ~~f~~~5l:. . ~¥JJ~. $·.~~5~B.~$~~.M~~.-~o. :mJl» -ff$. • -f\. j~t±:l.~.1Ita~B.~~3§rml~. «.. " *'fC-g.slft1'~j!. ~m~~.,~.ffij~3&·.~I¥!*'fC-g.Z$·~.m.7~J1:·~ff. §f.t.lL$ff#:±B~l¥!fO~. • l.ptml~l:.~*'fCflfO~ ~*. <tilE1!f "& (~1!ffil¥!mf$"&~$,-m> • "~l:~f$~fiJf~. fiz.~tt> ~X. 0. 0. ~f'F~Wi.x.MW3I¥!~~JI. ftfl::~JJlt±:l*I¥!A~f$.. lf~*MWJ. '. • 9)\'iB~~1!f~mf$~lf~fiPIT~ mt)~1:.~~ • *'fC-g.Ara':51.~mI¥!JjJ~ 0. .~.B*~~~ff*FA~ttl¥!*aUlijl (Cosmic Soul) •. (lifu)n~m~m~*'fC-g.-m:51.f.tJ1:I¥!¥~m~·ffijm~.. tt:*~li!~fl&J~\" ~~*Efi¥mim~. 1:.l:~C;l1::~". 0. 1!!tm~&iB' .~.ZPJTt)~. Mru! • u[*5¥:7M~s!*~.' ra'*~IJ5¥:.*~Z~.. 0. «.*~!Ji!M~m~~*'fCz~~»-ff·ft:51~mt±:ll:~Mru!°mm f'F.~mEl3f$~fiJf~a~W3.A. «*~f$mjt~» MW3mJ!"~'Ji· «f~ f$mjt~»$.t±:lI¥!~f.tmf$·~1It~$9)\Bm.ru!o .*~~. «mIUifB» (Science ofKnowledge). -~$. , fft±:l rft". ::Eft (OJ ~IUlffff1!tW.¥~ " ¥tH:<fi:ttl¥! " .;tttl¥!flU~ PITt) rft~ft (I=I)J "ffff~1:.Z • 1!!tfllf4:m~ J (Fll'St, Absolutely Unconditioned Principle) rftJ • ~f~*@f.t1!!t~~zft • 0. 0.

(34) }f1~ ---"-. $;#. .m~e·. -----~.. ,-,-... ~ • • • • • ~~.~W*~~M~. 37. •••*. ---'~. ---. , ..- -------.". • • •~~~z • •tt·~g~~~.~.~~ft·~~. ~etl·R~r~ftJRrftJffi~~,~m·~M~r.=~.J. (Second Principle, Conditioned as to Content) : r~~ft1'~ftJ (-I I) ., • • z,. '*. • • ftm~~.~ttz~~'~ffftZE~~a,~. ~.~ftZ • • tl"~W'~~~~MrftJZgm'.&Wm~., ~~Z~mffTft~~ffi'~~~Z~~ • • ft,.m~~~'N~ ftZ~mHHJJl. ,m.mz. Conditioned as to Form) part. = -I, -I in part = I). PJT~DJa~~EB. '. r. -. :1ff~~. ,. ~.J (Third Principle,. : rftmH:B-M~Fft' ~~ftl§~fJ1MftJ (I in ., .:1ff~tE. =~. ~. 3!H~lli*~MA~. ~.I!P-{~~.H9ftiIii~~.Z~~H9~EB. .,. tE~f~~. EB~,ft~~~~gm,m~w~,~~·ft.~A.~~mzfJ1,ft. ~~Ml~. , ~!tZft '. WM~.Zft. ~~~MftpJTlIJlm~~~. ft • ~ ,. ,. .,. ~~~M~!tftM~i~. ~~~¥lffftH9mzf:B-. ~~iftM~~RZ~~ [36]. '. , *~ft .,. ~~lJIH71~"{t{'F. .,. *R.~~R~~.~~~~·tE-tAt~lli~~«~~~~». ( Philosophy ofNature) 1St. -/\ OO~ lli Jt& ~ «mDJa a~ ffifU Z ~ *it» (The System ofTranscendental Idealism) ~.~ • ~~m¥fRifH-tt ' mttnttalJ~~.· ~. rftJ Cj{f'F. tlitt.~lfllltJJ. r~$tJJ (life) .,. fPl. ' fPlffl!J.Jla ' ~~~~. ~~H9. , tllJ&~. '. ~t1lfPl. r~~ft~~fPlJ. ' rMftMfPlJ H9 r;7}:: ~m~flflAAMm • ~fHm. '. ' j:J1St.ftt~~~tl[]~fl ' ~fl • ~liWi~~¥ , aIJi§fttJ ., ~~*..tJbj(tlirtlJftJ~~ , rtlJ..tfJ£#. rtfllltJJ '~$tJ· ::f¥'J~ .~ll: Wlf"f* • ¥J~fii~~ .Z~*II • rtlJ..tfJ£Jf ' W!tfrf*Wt14~H91'IiiJTiJ~ , ~~.iZ~EB" <00 DJaR~ffifUZ~*it»~·~~~m~EB1'~~~H9~t14~~EBg~~ • • ~Z_i§~~mllJ~~¥~.~~mllJH9 • • ,~a.,.

(35) 38. ' ,I;. #- fiJ'. , ,!iJl!,mlU~m.*WH'J! «W*r-HJU¥ ~fg' ~ * *'fC~~ ~» ¥'iB¥:¥:<f;:JJ.iiJ-'~ rtJU ' r:±:i1IJ $1fJ: ' ~f~*f!f.tlmllN~ft ' ~~ •• ArM~'~~J ,r:±:a,~aJ~Mm~.'Mm~OO 0. OO~mf.t.~:±:BOOOOo. m.m2~r. Btt~:±:-~fiJ. (Subjective Subject-Object) '~~~~.h1f!f.t.~~IW!lJOO' N~ r~ .tt~:±: -~fiJ (Objective Subject-Object). 0. ft o,!iJl!,. W*~tJh1f!f.t~. f'F¥'iBfR:<f;: , lmfJJttmu!I! ' ,!iJl!,mfif~iS~.J:tOO ' iii~~~$ (31). m. '§' M ' iiffl r ~ 2 iii Jt J (Intellectual Intuition) jfHr,~ ~ , 9J\ N~iiffl rilttJ (Reason) ~lT,~~ , f9'~~fr1£BUi!!,2!:fJ1m~h1f!f.t ~ft~fttt,:±:ntt'~.h1f!f.tft~h1f!f.t.~~llim,~~mf.t.,. •• ttlmil,.~:±:ft'X~~n,.:±:~ft~~~*'fC ft~-.o1£~h1f!f.t.~!:fJ' ,~nw~~.~.o.m •• : ¥'iB~lmfJJ,. r~~a~~,~. ••. '~T.~~aA~.'~#A. •• ~~a •• '.~A~~,~at~A~a~~'~~A Am'-~~4~~*~t.~t~o.~~~~A~.M~ a~.,~~o. 3l:f1t JjX. i;q ,. ••• ~ft4~a~~,~~~~*~.t~,. ~~. 4 3l ~ ~ 4. ,!iJl!,mfifJtf~D~ffifiHI~. ~ ~. •. ~. t. ~ J,t ~.. r7.l<fm:~fTIb1J J ' r1::1fti J. 0. J (38]. 'i!l:t.*~. •• ~Mf.t'lmllN~ftM~Mf.t.,~~, «W*~WD.f9'~**'fC 2~~»-~~,,!iJl!,m.~~ •• ~1£D~~~~&f.tW*~o.

(36) [11 Taylor, Charles. Hegel, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1975, p.55.~jH1JIltm:~j~ •. m:$..t:!l!tE H. S. Harris roli'F Ba Hegel's. Developmendll51 ii'iH~. Ci!l1lt~§t55 glP})\OJ~:±l §. •. : Harris, H.S.Hegel's. Development, Oxford University Press, London. 1972, Vol. I, p.499.. [ 21 . Habermas, Jiirgen. The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity, translated by Frederick Lawrence, MIT Press, 1985, pp.23-44.. [ 31 [4J. raJ ;m 51 • pA. liff~~lii.'llaJi!:;~rol8~~ Robert B. Pippintt Modernism as a. Philosophical Problem - . cp ~. , !'.lilt mt Ji!:; 1i!i 1€l8 ~ ill ffiJ Wl m. 0. ~ft $. Modernism as a Philosophical Problem, Basil Blackwell, Cambridge,. 199\, pp.61-79. [ 5J. Taylor, Charles. Hegel, pp.80-87.. [ 61. Edwards, Paul. ed .• The Encyclopedia ofPhilosophy, The Macmillan Company and Free Press, New York, 1967, Vol. 14, pp.69-72.. [ 7J. Montaigne, Michel de. Essais, Pierre ViIley ed., Paris. 1922-23. Vol. 3, p.13.. [ 8 J Descartes, Rene. The Philosophical Works of Descartes, translated into English by Elizabeth S. Haldane and G. R. T. Ross, Dover Books, New York, 1955, pp.131-199. [ 91 . HOffding, Harald. A History of Modern Philosophy, Dover Publications, Inc., New York, 1955, Vol. I, pp.167-172. pp.173-183. Kepler, Johannes. Cosmographical Mystery. Galilei. Galileo. Dialogues Concerning the Two New Sciences. translated by Henry Crew and Alfonso de Salvio. The Dover. Publishing Company. New York, 1952. [ 10 J Bacon, Francis. ~ First Book of Aphorisms" , in The Age of Reason: the 17th century philosophers, edited by Stuart Hampshire, The New American. Library, New York. 1956, p.24. [Ill Kant, ImmanueL Critique of Practical Reason. The Liberal Arts Press, Inc., New York, 1958, pA4. [12J. Kant, Immanuel. Ground Work of the Metaphysics of Morals. translated by H. 1. Paton, Harper and Row, New York, 1964, p.120.. [ 13 J Fichte, J. G. Science of Knowledge, with First and Second Introductions,.

(37) ,~. ~~~9 ~\,c .. -. ~-" "~~--, ,,~". -". .~ #- IiJ. edited and translated by Peter Heath, John Lachs, Cambridge Uni versity Press, Cambridge, New York, 1982, p,22L ( 14 J Berlin, Isaiah. The Roots of Romanticism, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey, 1999. pp.1-20. ( IS J r&J WI 51 ' p.l. (16]. r&JWl51' p.49.. (171 Schelling, F. W. J. Ideas for a Philosophy of Nature, translated by ErroV E. Harris and Peter Heath, Cambridge University Press. Cambridge. 1988. p.47. (18J. r&J WI 51 ' p.42.. (19J. Herder. J.G. Samtliche Werke. ed., B. Suphan, Berlin, 1913. Vol. VII, p.3S7.. ( 20] Schelling, F. W. 1. Ideas for a Philosophy of Nature, p.42. (21]. Schelling. F. W. J. The System of Transcendental Idealism, translated. (221. Berlin, Isaiah. Vico and Herder, The Viking Press. New York, 1976. p.. (23]. Herder, J. G. Samtliche Werke. Vol. XI. p.22S.. by Peter Heath, University Press of Virginia, 1978, pp.29-31. 193.. [24] Berlin. Isaiah. Vico and Herder, p.165.. (2s1 Schiller. Friedrich. Letters on the Aesthetic Education of Mankind, edited and translated by Elizabeth M. Wilkinson and L. A. Willonghy. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1967, Letters 13. 14. IS. pp.88-109.. r&J1l(J51' (27] r&JWlsl' (28J r&JIFJ sl • (29] r&J lfiJ sl ' (261. (30]. Letters 15, p.103.. Letters IS. p.103.. Letters IS. p.10I.. Letters 14. p. 97.. Hegel. G. W. F. Early Theological Writings. translated by T. M. Knox.. University of Pennsylvania Press. Philadelphia. 1948. p.7\.. r&JIFJsl' r&JWlSI' [33] r&JWlsl· [ 34 J r&J WI 51 ' (311. p.79.. (32]. p.211.. [35J. p.212.. p.225.. Taylor, Charles. Hegel. pp.66-75.. [36]. Fichte, J. G. Science of Knowledge. Part I. pp.93-1l9.. [37J. Hegel, G. W. F. The Difference between Fichu's and Schelling's System.

(38) of Philosophy, translated by H. S. Harris and Walter Cerf, State University. of New York Press, Albany, 1977, p.IS7. (38]. i6.l~51· p.174..

(39)