從反懷疑論的角度來看戴維森的詮釋理論

全文

(1)OO~d'b.~. f'F'P'J'. ift. 0. d'b"~/f~eB. :m~lff{lM--t. :.a:ft~~JJ~. *. W' ,~~~ -I}] gz ~ T fiJi Jti! tJ Jt£ ~q: ~ , 1Ul~'~~~. ffi , S'J. s'J. ~ fa -ft tJ ~ ?i~)c*bZ.f!j ~. .w.. Po~s'J~iw;. *~±:!.!iB'J.. /f'~'~*1£ 3J. m ftt ~ f!j ~ 1i§rm~mm'. Mp';!~~~~o -~ftXT±:o. ~~~~q:5i; :m~IUl~'O:: 1Ul~' ~!Ho ~ ~ ~ ~. rm s'J. rp, s'=J f!j"'" !"F. s'J*rm~~~. f'F. P Illl. ,. '. ~. 1.li rT. "'I I. 0. ::l ~. ~. ~. ~L!1*§t(,. ,"' ,. iIOI."'lI:. !ElJ. "'" 1111. s'J a\t ~ 5t~~*I£~A. 'ft tlt. Jti! o ~~f[J~ ~!I:t I S'J % ;flj M 7i- f'F ~ J:. It ~. '*. , ti f'F ~ EI3 £ m. B'J gil. !j<!fm-~3*~i1 ~.Affi~s'J )c *1£ El ~ If! f!j ~ ~. s'J. ' Ie" ~ -ft A f'F ~ JJ tJ. x.1t. *~ , ~-t. ~11!l. ffWl. @. **~. I. -* ~. /J ~. B'J. fAtf*l£rm~~. @. It. ~ ~,. -I}]. 0. fiJ ~\·. 8~. JFd. <JX:. ~. ~. -=-±. ~. ~. , , 1i: EI3 f.r ~. f£. /f~Jt. -. i:i. ~ ~. R Itt. liT a\t 1& :gr _. ~. fig. ,. ~. ft t.J±. , 1[" ~ 79 fF' It Ie" ,;. Jti!. ~. f!i. i& ttl. *~. !f ~. *WJ. II'II. J:!. fX. ~. 8~. ~. ~,. J1. ~. o 6 2.

(2) 0. 0. 0. 0. ~~o~~~~W~~j@~~ • • ~.E.~~~~-~~~~EOO~o~~~-*~Ej@.~ID E - ~1IJp.t~-R~*~~:l1;\l!l:~ • • E~lrt~1W--~~~~:tK j $!.~E~~ - ~iW-!II~~ - 1 ~ I *~ ~ J - ~~.~~lrt~1WtrE 1 ~lI~~~ErK:W~~ - ~~~SJIiW11 {l!;!EW~ {oBl~ - j $!~~~~~aJI!E~ lrtW!~~ - ~;tj;;f.E-~E I *~~ J ~~~~Wl@~~~m~-*~~~ • • ~.~~EID~ o +~~~~*- 1~~W*I@~.~ ~ - !1!IW@~~~~wg{]I]~~lHnatural sciences)~-<~~lHhuman sciences)E~.~{ll~-N~E~~ !I!IW@~~E j $!tr'~~Ifi~ - ~~I~.ffi:::Wlt:~(intentional behaviors)E-<~~lrt - {ll~EID~~~;I;l;1~~ ~~noK WMrK: WE:1!{::::W - f§ mj f.E- ~#:[;iffi {]I]~~~Sltf,E[],llti~~;I;l;1;;!C'--~!I!IW$!~IfiE-P1~ ~~~~~.CR~ ~@~Jlun - M 1 ~~('$-N~.~~HH:JIiIIl(positivism)E-P1~--~ 1 ~~~j(~IIHHmHanti-positivism)E1:::j~ - -<~~lrtEID~~~;I;l;1~~~f.E-noKwlBIK~{]I]~~ ~lrt:fbrK:W:1!{::::W--~~,\i)g~ - {ll~noKw. .~?1+H:JIiIIl~~~,\i)~~. 1BIK~{]I]~~.ErK:W:1!{::::W-~~~~f.E-noKwW€~.;;!~E~;I;l;1::W o .~+H:JIiIIl~j~~~-Ww!~~-. 0. ~~~~lrt-N~E~lrt - ~~~{ll~~~.M#:[;~~~lrt*~Ii-N f§ (#~ffH~~lrt) W~@I,,~m~- -~ 1 @ I~~~ - ~~~~-N::W.fi<:\~~E~;I;l;1 - ~~~~lrt~ti:\!!!l- - f§~W!lrt~~~MI;I;l;1~(physical Iaws)*(E[ - -<~~lH~~~~lrtEfcl- -<~~lrt:fb~~ -. 1~.ffi:i!J lt:~·· o( ~~~~M~~-N::W.fi<:\~~ - -!$lj\l[]-N. ~~~~~~II!f,IR.tii'E~;I;l;1- @:~~:g~~lrt~~M~~E~;I;l;11 ~. 0. ~1 1 @1~~~E#~~+H~. ~~~~;I;l;1~~~-N o W~@~~~E#:[;-~f.E-~*-<~~.tr:fb:1!{::W.&~~#:[;-~~~W1~MI.. 1t.m&·. ~ 4Q~#(rationalize)-<~Elt:'Hactions)~M1DHI~QH. - glf.Rlj\l[]-. -<~~.~:1!{::w:fb.~~~#:[;~~.W1~~ • • ~o . ~.~+H:JIiIIl~I~~~--<~~.E[],lltiW~W!~. (understand, make sense of) ':l1;\l!l:'. II.

(3) $Et-J@: Jtlj. ~. m~. 69 ~. ;;;-~;f§~. S. ~ IU] *It ~ jZ;j Et-J ~ i» =* ~ fj. m "". ~ ~ft!!{t ~. 1111 ;f§. Et-J ~. tJ~#Wim. ~~mEt-J a::tJR 69, -Et-J ~ EI3 Zrm5C~ " (1) MB A ?!\f£o>c rmimmH , (2) (3) ,c.". m ~ Et-J 69. $. ~fii. ~ ~ - 13 :m'65C~. ~IJ. P7. !E. /f'. 3:: R~. i5lJ;:~~. /f' 69 ~ {t. ~ooWt¥3 ffl flU I!I§ JJX. :Jn~r§. M~oo~. {" 2- ~ 00 H ~ ". (I). ~$krJEt-J ~ 14= ~ 13 ~ii] raj tlD ~ FfT ' jIiJ ?. falilJ"ilJ.. 32tt tJ R§ *IE Et-J tJ : ~. _ ~. RR!!. !l. ~. -. ~ ~. ~;. ~. 89. g::s. ,~, *.Ei. !. ~. *. lb $ ~ ~ Et-J !'IO ' - ;l.§. lij m Wt ~ ~ f~ ~Ij. fLOO~~pg>crJJX.~~~U. ft &.. !:. to tE Et-J. '.~I!I!-.J. ~. jZ;j A t~ ~ ~t!i r. 3::~~~~,. rm~Et-J.sIUI~:JnZEt-Jft~, 3' ~fii ~ , ~. ~ 13 ~ - IT 69 ft ~ ~69fL~ ° 69&" tbt~Et-JIT. _rIB'. 1~1!Jl. '. A*. {~'~"ilJ. ~. ~. ~ ~ $. ~ ~ ~ ~ >c &. ~ tb t~. $. tJ. EI3. ~*IE~~ 13 ~ ° ~~~~51. fifii ~ {s'z: - Et-J fifii Et-J 69 iii! f~ '69 tjt~~&.ft~. 1l] ~1 $ 69 ~ ' I T ~Ij ,- Et-J. ~~-.fr~lI. ~tb~~~ A89£6J,". m~fii£3::lm~. /f'ft69m~. * flEl ~ ~ §" ~ft'fLlc~ '~f~~. 1'f~~W7,. ~~mEt-J~~. "ilJ m jZ;j JJX. A ~i1!=*jZ;j>c {tftM!H ¥3 ° ,,~~. /f"-MBN~. lm:7l-/f". 0. "fr~~~m*1E. ~fiim~~~69. ~~Q~ ° ;A~ ~=**ftQI!I!~. ~~>Cif'~!~. JJX.. ~. 3:: W. ~,It:,. ~IDt~MB~~ - ~ aI 1: 69 ~ f~-~' #WiM ilfIEl69~m~. ~Jlt,-Et-J. 13 ~'fEjZ;j~ ~rettJJlt69. ~~IDt~~-. 1l]'. ~. »~. 00. 69~AA/f' 00 ft m ~ "ilJ jcJ69Et-JIT~ ° mITtb~. tEEt-JlmJJX.3::. 1* 89. mEt-JfO~. Et-J:m~~. @. ~j ~. o?!\lm.xom. o. 9=' ,. ~[g. ~.x~M69·~~Et-JAlm~~. mJllm3::. * {". @. )c" II. fifii iff 3:: A #Wi $ ft * !'IIJ 00~HtJ*0069IT~; 1:; ~Q jIiJ. ~. II*:. fi,e,. *~ $i!t. ft if! tb Z 69 ~·tt; ~oo ~ $ jZ;j ~ jcJ '&0 Jlt 69 °. 1~1UI~. ft =±. i1!mtb. ~~~f~~'. 1:lI~!,-jl~~32tt~ttif!Z. $ ~ ~ jZ;j _ *IE ~~~:r!5C~ ii,c" ~ ;l.§.:~ m~ MB ~ 00 ~ ~ MB~~~~ Et-J :1J:JnftMBg -. $Wt~Et-J 14=~~~ ~ jZ;j (1) MB. =fg ~. $§1l'~ffl~. ~. f4~*IE~. ~. .x~,-&.. *IEAMlf~.. ~~tJ~~ ~IT:f!jZ;j~. o. 6 4.

(4) ~fffiljLlIR'h:(.E '~~111~$~ .• [i[1lt.. 1 1f<~~~~~gf>~:;&£'esr'*ftr1~ •. !El~~.~~~~'~m1~~.E~~. ~o*~.E~~~W~W~~~·!El~~~~~~W~~E~~~·*.~~.E~~~~~~o. ooK~. 0. 0. 0. ~~~~$.~~. 0. !1!1~1llf~~. ) W!t!f:ffi. 0. m:: ) W~·· ~ja~,g1¢W~~£,'~m1. 1 ~lI:;&m1~Wa.E~BE-N.~~I!!!S:~~~~~~.E~~ 0. bridge law ) J!I!f}~ '~rI~Wa~'~.~Wa. • ~~>~m1"':;&m1:ffijl!jt}~;l;!:1~~laf,g1¢W. principles) •. iliif~\Hi*~U$~:lb 11~$~~~:lb~fl\.crj!t!f.E~~W 1 W~·· ~ja~1¢WiiH'$!.E '~m1"':;&m1.EJ!I!f}~;l;!:1~ (psychophysical bridge law ) J!I!f}~'~~~Wa~:;&m1~Wa !1!1~~~~-&.E~~~Q;l;!:1~ • '~.~Wa-N~BE£'. ~~~~(constitutive. wBl:iW:.~~I!!!S:~~£,~[i[ ""~m1.EjI!jt}~;l;!:1~(psychological. r ~~~4o;l;!:1~ J (synthetic a priori laws)*I~.IIItM-N. 0. !~I~~I I ~~~4o;l;!:1~III)!<~~.E. W~~~~~W~W-N~·~~~~~~~ • • :ffi.~~I!!!S:~.E.~oW.~ • • ·~.~Wa~~m1 ~Wa~~wrell!qr~~. 0. 0. •. ~~:8. ~. ~. •. ~N ~±tffi-II¢(). ~ ffi-±t fKII¢(). iliif• • ~ r ...... ±t...... 11¢( J !~I~W~~.~.~ • ~i[:@: • • ~~I!!!S:~. postulate of non-reflectivity) Cg'*ffi-±tNII¢( •. postulate of transitivity) ( g,* ffi-±t Nil¢(· m:1 N ±t fK II¢( •. g,*,~~I!!!S:~( the. •. ~.~Wa~~m1~Wa:lb.~~I!!!S:~·~~*~~~~~BE~~~Wa~:;&m1~Wa.E!t!f~·~~~M~~Wa~ HE:lbf·!:H!~~~~i!~. •. g,*l!!tl!lf'~;l;!:1~fa{~~ (the. W:~;l;!:1~fa{~~ ~-t::1.E~. 0. 0. ~.(ii'~~ • g,*$~. !1!~@!.~. 0. .. r 1 W.:t!:III)!<,~ •. .E •. (Dlllm:1lt~. • ~~ ) @!. r ...... ±t ...... 11¢( J !1!1~@!.~~~~~i~~.E !1!1~~lI;l;!:1~fa{~~esr:g1Il)!< r ...... ±t ...... 11¢( J !1!1~@!. r ...... ±t ...... 11¢( J :lb~BE~~Hl!~·~ll;l;!:1~fa{~~ • *11S$W#f-E:-~Il1f. ~.E~~IEIl1*. r ......±t ... ... 11¢( J. ,~.~Wa~~ !~I:tH~Wa:ffi.~i':lI!!!S:~~@:~[i[C'-·il • • ~·. ==o.n.

(5) 0. 0. ===. '~WEW~(description) • ~~ • {nlH{¢Wt1jqr I !@~~ '~~E~~If,m.JP'(open sentence) • !1~IWlt.m.JP'D(~:ffi"-iBfII. :&~~~E 0 J ((1970) : 211 ) lE~m~'~.EW~· ~{IlE~¥e!:ffi"~lI.+Wl-t11~:tt~(non-extension)~~E'~ Mllt.1g~ • mm.g· r :!;tll~rnd ' r W;U!)Q J ' r ffi~*, J ' r 1mInrt!« J • r ~~ J o.g:::)j. r ~ 11 1W;U!)QmllilIll!1fi*~fg[ ~ J ' r ~ 1 !I~~mtt(IIII!1fi*~)g!~ J ~:t!~,~.-iBfII.:& if~~~~~~ . '~W~~E!t~$!JI!!IS~J!lJ~~til!!lS~ (the normative principle)~~ell!!lS~(the holistic principle) ~til!!lS~~ii'f'-->· &;J.g~. ~~~l~dmrK~. •• .g~.. r ~!l!!!J$:N->~~+<E~*m~ J ~ r ~~~~iII1nIIIE(E"( J. 0. ~til!!lS~~. I ;(lI*lrn. ~.~EU!)Q~·~~~~.~~.~E~.·~~~~~~~t.~E~~ o ~ii'I!!IS~~~~*~~.~ ~;(llmrK!JgjE-iBfII.~. RI!!IS~.g·r.g~~w;U!)Q*~~a·IE~~W;!l!!!J~·~~.W;~aoJ,r~~W;~W;~~~E-iBfll. o J~. 0. 0. •. I@. .g~·~~~~~~~E~. 0. r ~~~W~ffi~*,fL-fK:mn~~$E lt:~ J .g~~E~~~ , U!!!!~~lt:~~.~!I~IW;(II~ii'I!!IS~ • ~{.lJ~$* ~~ffi~~~ , ~~~lt:~ .g~~~~ffi~~q , ~~~lt:~ • ~{.lJ~~.~ !I!'W;(lI~ii'I!!IS~ W!I~IWItl!I~81~fL- • ~ • {.lJ~~'~.~~-N~::::§~ '~~~~E~~!!;~:ttl[EIli* .. .g~,~ ,~. ~~~ii'I!!IS~~'~.~~E!!;~:ttlI!!lS~. ~~~~.~til!!lS~·~~~~K.~~.~~E~.~K~~~*~~ o ~~mrK~~~·.g~~~W;U!)Q~~~W;~~o. .~I!!IS~~~. 1!@~~~U!)Q~E~~·~~~~~~~WEU!)Q~B~~~WE o ~~m~~·. ~~~u!!!!~E~~EI!@.~IE~~~~E!t~~li*·~~~~~~~mrK~~~~~~~~E~~~u!!!!~. ~mrK~E~~~E~~.~E~~ o I!@~~~U!)Q~-N~::::§~~#WE~~·~WI~~~U!)Q~B~~K. • ~~mrK~ti:!I~~t4J '.{Il!Il~~. • ~l¢W~~~{4JEffi~~q~u!!!!4r~. 0. !1!IW!@. ~~~~~~E~~~E~~.~E~~~$~I!@~~~~E!t~:ttl~li* o I @W~~~E~~.~W. - -. --. 4t1ijtt:1:(f;K~~~~~!l!!!J4r~E~~q~U!)Q~. --.

(6) (1) 1 j:. ,.». ~ (I). &. ag 1fJ. ~. ff. ~. ag. •. ~~ ;~~. 1B. •• ••. " 8]. ~~~~o*~D~~«~~ , tt ~ ,~, ~!J !f. ~ ~ ~ ~ • fllj IlJE R'~o*~,.~.-,?. ~~~. ~-.. ~. ~ ~. ~ 8~ iF' ~~~. ~~8 tt~~ ~~. 0. 'X~~~.@~.. ~~mXHoA~. iF' .ft!! 1R ~D ~ ~ • .. 1B. f~ ~ ~ •. E. * {,' 1W< m. H~-~m~.1t;.. ~~OOffiom~.,. •• D~. ~8~~. 89 1: ~ ~;J ff ~ 1B ' iF' • ® ~. m~~M ~. 0. ~. • •. ~ ~ M~¥'. 1B~@~ ~~~~. flJ Flt: ~ T ,~, ~ ~ . m@1BOO *~~.. ~X~. ~,. ,~,.. W. $.A~-ir8l~~~o~~ ~.~. -165.. t:. fffi A. t& ~. ~ ~D .~. ~~~~. :IE.!!i3. ~ m J:\: ~ J§ " ~ *~~~. fllJ. "Jl:t.. -.~. .*~~!f.~.~.. ~.t. ~~~~W~~~.. T~~. mWfffi'~~.1W<'. m,~ %R~. 6 7. jt. 1B. ••. I**It. o. ••. ~~'~~~HE~~~-~.m-m. ~~~~~llEmm,~~~w~@*~ ~~~~.~m~m~~,~!~~~~ ~~~~.~~~*~'*~.W~,~ ~~~m~.~H·~~~~~~i~~ J( • ~ • ir8l H ~ 1t; • • 1..6 0 fllj , ~~~~jt~~~~~~~.%ft~ ~~.A~1B~mm1B~~ ~m~ ~-~~.~1B~~~~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ *I£?ti¥ It~ 8~ ~#m®.'~~~~~,~ .~.~. li Xiti. 1M Dli. '~~'~-~~~'~~~H~. .~m~~.~.~~~.ft~~B~m .~~~~~W.~-~-~~.~1B~ Tm~.~-~~1B~~m~o~~~~. ' ••. ,.. ~. .~,. ~-@W~~~,*~~ ~~~~@~~M'1B.e.m,. ~. ~. ~% ~~@~~.1B~~ ~~~.~ ~o -~1B~~~~ff~ *'1B-~ ~~m~,~.~, 'w~m~~~@~ ~~~~~~~'~~1B~~~~~m~. ,~~. *'1B~~,,~,e. ••. ~!f.~~E m~ ~~'.m*~~tt. ~~~~ ~~~~. ~M~# ,m~ft. fffi~~m. *~. ~ff~~.~~1t;~. ~~,.. ~. ~ W ~f. X. ~ ~. tt-~ ~~m. ~~,m~E.Wm ,~m.~m~~.. ~~~OO ~Mm~. ~F. ~~~. w~. * mH. .~~.OO1R~~~. ~~~ .

(7) ~~~ Ia' ::§;~'I~:tn$ 0. iHI~*lt:fti~n~~I-'-Ii~I!1!IW!@:!IU§. 0. -. 0. -. !J!lQ4N:fti~~!t~itJ. 0. -. ===. !t~t-- 1 !@i\*'lI!:Ia'W;litJ:fti~~(a priori)~. ~~*'lI!:mf.!lIa'W;l:fti. - J.E-~~!I!IW!@~~. ~~ffii:J.E-W;l~1W~ti:!€!J!lQ4N. J.E-~~!I!I~!@~~. -. i\*'ll!:l~~:ftiIW$Ull!~l[IJ(J.E. ~o!J!lQ4N:fti~~!t~itJ~~t--l!@~~.~:fti,~ • • ~:fti~~-~!@~~~*~~~~~:fti*'lI!:i\~~ ~+<e~mf.!I~itJ:fti Ia'~. - J.E-~~!I!IW!@~~. ~~-~.~:fti-~~~~~~~~~~J.E-mf.!I~IW.~:fti!t~itJ~~o*~~~~~~o~E:fti~~. 0. w~~~~~~~. - ~~J.E. .~-mf.!Im~~~~~~~~~:fti.~ow~~~~~~~-~~~~~~~~~~!@itJ.-~~~~~. 0. J.E-~~~!@:ili. ·-~~~~~~~.t!M~~ - ~~~~~J.E-.*M~~ ~ - ~~~llr.~~~~!@t;~ - ~~-<Il~:Ir~~Ifii:<~Wl~iil. ~~~~~~~~~~~mf.!I~w.~:fti!t~:ili~~-~J.E-mf.!I~~.~:fti!t~:ili~~-~.-~.*lt.. ~~-J.E-Ia'W;l~W~~'~~:fti~~~~~~~.~~~~~~~o~ • • ~W.~:fti.~w~-~~,. ~~:fti~~~~~.~~~~~~.~~~~~~~:fti!t~itJ~~-.~~~-~~'~~:fti~~~~~. '~IW'~~:fti~~~~. -. 0. 1tl~ - o..~*. 1. 0. 1. -. ~~:;E~1JR{ 1 !@,~.~~. 0. -. o..~. - ~~l[IJ(la'~*. !I!I~*I~ - ~~ffii:Ia'~D~. ~R-Pl~Pl-Ml. !@~IW.tto:'la'~~~~II~IW~~~ ~.. !@~IW~f,TIj; -. ~~!I!IWW~IllI~4~lJI(X)(Px++Mx):fti~~. !@~IW~~ - ~mf.!lti:!€jBI!f.;&:. m!I!IW:!iil~IW~~~M,~~tt~o::. R-Mll~m!l; - ,~ • • tt~Ia'~~~IW~~~:ftiM,~~tto::~~!Jt~. 0. -. ~~~~~~~.~~~~~~~~~Nl.~~N~~~~~~~~~~~~~:fti~.-~~-~IW'. 1. ~~:ftiffil!~~~mf.!ll!@t-k\I!!!I:fti~4No. *. 0. W!~:ftiM,~~tt~~*~. :HR-Ml.

(8) .~~~.E~.~~.~-~~.~~ •• E~.~~.~-*~~~m.~~o~~-g~~~~. ~~.~~.~~~.E~.~~.~*~~W€~W~~-~~~~W~.'~.~~~ill~oW. 0. (X) (Px-MxHr- - ~~~~~~) $1'~W~~ - ~~WR-Ml-a- - ~~~l¢~ ) $1'~.~~ - e?I~ -,~ .'~.~~~ill~ ( X)(Px-Mx)~~ 1@~'d@ - ~(x) (Px-Mx) ~~W 1@ft\€*~ - g,*~~*~~II'~.ill~ii?-$;~E'~.M,~~:!± - ~~ - .~$;~E~$! - ~~ ~nR. ~~~~~-~~I$1~.~~~~~~I@~~~~oN~~l~~~-~~W~.'~.~~~ill ~o. - ~~(I!!t'~~~Wa~.~~I!!J§~J(:!K ·-J(:!KtnK~~~.~:lliI!!J§~ - ~~,~~~~ii((l!!tK-~'~~~. ~~~W~~~~W~~E~.'~.~~~ill~~~~-a--~~~~~~.~~-~.'~~E~ ~ill~. ~o~~~~K-~~~W~~~~.'~.~~~ill~~~~-tnK.~~.W~-~~'~.~~~ill~. .~(I!!t~~~~~.~~I!!J§~J(:!K-.~~~~_'~_~~~ill~~~(I!!t~~~~~~.~~~(l!!tK-~. - ~~~~f;!S*i~ill~o. W~~~~~~~~~~N=-~~@~~~~-~~~~~~~~ill~~~~o~~~~~~~~. ~.~~-~~(I!!t~.'~.~~~ill~~~I$1~'d@~.~o ill~. 0. f;!S*i$mill~~fi:1!!. -. 11!!~t¥:-!!ill~'- 11!!~:fK~ill~. 0. $f:!!ill. f;!S*i$!ill~K-~~t2~ill~~i\'t;jl;;~ill~ - f;!S*i~ill~tt!~\Ill~N:!:~~ ••• ~~~_~f;!S*i~ill~~tt!~E~~~~-N~~.~.~. ~-~~~~*i~ill~~tt!~~\Ill~-. ~Ef;!S*i~ill~~~~~~~f;!S*i~~. ~g~~~o~W€.I~f;!S*i~ill~~W~~~i\'t-~~~*iN~i\'tW~@~:!:~~.-~~~.~~. ~~~.tt!~N-~~f;!S*i~ill~~.~~a~i\'tWW€~.~~:!:-a-~~~~*i~.°:fK~ill~a~~. ===.

(9) ·. ~~~~~~~~. ~~~.~.~. ~ gt~3:t't-L)i~~ftf2ii~ ~m~~s'J~ 0 ~ ~ ~ L- ~ II s'J 110 {tt ~ tE 110 H ' 1* ttl ~N ~ ft~;~ / m~E~ • • • • • ~~a. pg. m.. :t't {§. ~ -L.' iJllj -----, ~ {:j] ~ ~ ----, ttl {:j] gfii * jPJ ~IJ Z 11:: s'J II fa :t't ~IJ rl'j S9 :t't ' ~ $ • ~ 11:: m ~D 1* ~ ~ @ ;fO i§: tf:l 1* @ ~ ~ ~Ij Il'fJ ~. ~ fij --u*~~~. 0. ••. oo,~~~,. ,-m. g ~ ~ ~. OJL.'. ©. ff- 'L' ~ $ $ ~ :t:l ?t,;. iF' $ :E' r;j ~ ¥/J isj ~ .~~~~~~~~tl~~~_ffIlm~. x~ ;.f'=' ~-t. 'll'fJjPJ - $~~. ~Jttj. oooo~~~~f~ft~ft~~'~~~1*. '*. m. ffij ~fii J]!b 7} , 0 m;f§ , ~ ,u ~~~----'~&~Il'fJ~ • •. T. ;f§ ff jPJ ,. ~. $. ~~~:t't~~~~~~¥ff~~m~~m. ttl19. ©. ~:~@~~----'~~~~jPJ~m~'-~ ~. -. ~ i~. )[. ~. :t't L-. ~Mo~m,@. o. L-. S9 i~ IUl ~ ~ M j1)1J ~mm~_~~.~~. 'L' ,U. .~M:E'~~.tE~~~~~~1*~g*. ~~.~'*~i§:~~fa~~~~~. o. .. ~~~;f§ftft:E'.~~~e~·g.~tE,. .~~Il'fJ~~~'·~~~i~$,i§:R. ;f§ lit ~ ~ , m ::l , Il'fJ *It tl tl • ~ g11 II S9 ~ ~ :tt£ Y' ~ ~ II ' ~ If* ~ .±: ~Ij ~Ij ;m *~ ~ :t't~/.ggL-~Z O ~~o fIE. ~ ,L., ~ S9 S9 ' ~ ~ ft :tt£ T ;. ,. ~. ff- S9. ~ S9 tE ~ ~ P'3 ,e" L-. ~ ~f. {,'. '* '*. ,L.,. ;f§. ~IJ ~. •. ~. IUl pJT • ~ *~ tl ~ it - ~ ~ -g;- tm {I§l i§: o~:tt£B* It 1m ~ •. •. ~~II~mm~.tl~~'~{:j]~~~tE ~:tt£~~~~~m,~~gt;'~~~1*¥ ~ ~ ;fO ~~ ,L., ~ ~ ~ S' ~ ~ ~f ~ {I§l. m. gt fa. Jl-. ~~M~~~~.~'~~~. ,~. ;f§m$~~~ft~ft~.U~B. ••. ••. ~. $M. iF' tit ----, ~ 5' ~ , ~ ~Ij ~ jIlt @ 1* s':J II s':J .::: :E' s':J s':J :t't s':J 1* m ~1*~tl@IIm~m~;f§M.~~~~m ~~~~.~~m~~Il'fJ.~m • • ~1*. Il'fJ tE ;f§. Jtlj ,L.,. gt. ~. {F'. ~~. ~~,m~~fl~fl~:t't~~~i§:~~¥ {~ ~ ~ ~ ,L., • ,L., g2 *~ 2 M ~f ~ {I§l IUl ~ ~ ~~ ~ ,L., 11 ft if ~ i~ ~ ~ ~. • 11: If* ~ ~ ~ 7} If* If* ,L., {tt gfii ~ W'l £ , i~ If!! *fr ~ ~ ----, / i~ Jtlj i~ :II i~ ,:.. $ A ~ , pJT 00 ~ ,L., 89 ' ~ ~ {tt ~ ~IJ ~ ~. '*. ~;~~~~faftfa.~:tt£.~$~~~ ~ - .':E'M~~~~~~#~~fa o . ~. {I§l ~ pJT ,~, 0. Jl-~. ,L., 11. ~. t§. $ JtIJ. ~ ~. fl. ,L.,. ~ ~. tl L- • ~ , i§: tf:l {:j] ~. '*. jIltll'fJ,~.m~.. o. - $ tJ iJl J M ~Ij. ~. t~. '.m~~.. o o. 7.

(10) ~~5~E~~~E~. •• ~E=~-$~. ' ~~~~%E.~~~" o. •• ~-~.I@~~~~~E. ~~~~~~.~~WE~~~m~~M··I@~~~5~E~~~~~~~.~K~~~mE=~~~. Mo.~~~-5~~~m~~~~~E-~~~~.~~~~Nl*~M~~I@o. •••~~~~o.~~-_~~~~Ml@~.. ~_~~~~@~~~.~~~M~~E~m~~~-~.~~~~~*~~.~~~~~~~=~. -. ~E~~~~o~~-~.~.E.~~~.-~~~. 0. ~~ -. ~~~.~~.~E. ~:g~~~~~~~:lt~!lI)Q4NErK:t4I:t:~M·-~~m~~~:g. 0. E~~~~m-~~~~~~m~~~~~E-~~~~~M~~~~m~~N1E~~-~~~M~~ 1 @!E~t4I. r ~'IN~~* J ~ r ~~!lI)Q*~~~ J. 0. !1!1~~II~~:ltt:lliE~~Et(\~. - ffil)~r~~~. .~~-~~.~~I~ll=~E~~~-r~~~~~~~~E~mJ~r~~~I~E!lI)Q4NJ-~~. 1 ~11~1tE~~~ -. - ~~~~E'~~" '~~EJ\I!fJ±I2~~.~~~:?M. 0. 0. [~~I-E),*~~~~-e$'~.$'~. - [~~) ~~,*$'m\'{' \ ~~~~~~. .gii~I~H~It~~E( 1973: 233)' .. ~~~W~E~Et(\~I. o ~~~~~.~.E.~~~:ltt:lli~~~~~~~~E~-~:g~.~. .E.~i!l~~. -?<~~~,*~~t-\I\4~4rl$'~~-'-\~~.'%. - ~~~~ [1e1tl) ~+-'-\. $'~4r14~t-\I\"'~o~ \ .l!I/(brings.. .into the picture):l&.~;t;~~% *~%~.~~~~\~;t;~~~m\'{'~~~t-\I\$'o.

(11) ~~ ~ ~!;K-~\IIU!l33:i!:mttil$i.g@:~~~,Hlf~:fb 1 IR~ 0. i!:mtti~33:111@!~~". (0:') 1E[1II\Effu1~~~ (The Principle of Causal Interaction)" ml~~ 1 ~lI,~ • • tI:~~Ml.tI:~:B-lIE[,* fu1~o. (~) 1E[,*:fbtt\ll::l;f;1:\!t:~~~(The Principle of the Nomological Character of Causality)" l¢WIE[,*fu1 0. 0. ~(o:' )~;;~~ ~ ~~II~~,~ • • tI:. ~:g ~ ~(~)~£.&.~ ~ !1!1~~lI@!~IE[III\Ef~~I$i~~lI~:$$:fb~M~~:l;f;1. gUl$i~~JR~ ~ !1!11!J~1I~:$$:fb~ M~~:l;f;1~ K-~I$i~:$$:fb'~ Ml"-~~:fbf!l!li~:l;f;1~~I$i:W:$$:fb'~ Ml". 0. i$W ~ ~!;ta~~!I!I~111@!~~-H-!lt33:.ij1i$ 1 IR~£, 1 IR~c:'R. (0:')~(~')1$i{[J~:fb ~ f§lt-P<lit1~ ~ ~!;~\IIU!l~i1f:mtti~~~t'--.(o:') ~ (o:')~I$i.ij1i$IIR~~:fb.ij1i$~. 0. (p..M) ,~m:fb.ij1~$~~(The Anomalism of the Mental)"K-l¢W:W:$$:fb~M~~:l;f;1~ ~ .~~ta~~:JnK. ~:fb~~~l¢W~:$$:fb~M~~:l;f;1~. 0. ~~~*~~~~9.!'~ • .• t!::. c:'R. 0. ~~Ml.tI::fb@!~IE[III\Ef~~l$ig£, ~:fbl@~. 1 MIDIj(~. 1 @!~Ml~~ ~ ~ffit ~ta~~~~~ I @~Ml.tI:. 0. !1!1~I$i.ij1i$ 1 I~~:fb 1 IR~c:'R. 0. ~Ml:fb.~:l;f;1~~~!; I MI$i=:$$:fb~Ml:l;f;1~o~~~I$i~~W@:~~~.t!::l¢W.IE[,*fu1~:fb~ • •. t!:: ~. .g,*i1f:mtti:fb$i$ 1 IR~~I$i~~:fb ~ rn:jIDIj(~~M~~:l;f;1~I$i~I~:fb 1 @!:\!t:~ ~ 1ffi"~~i1f:mttif§lllIa ~ '~Ml. .~K-ta~~~I@!~.o~:mtti:fb~9.!Ml~~~@!~~*\IIU!ll$il@!~~.Ml~~.gIll\Ef~Ml.K-l$il@!~. ~:ffi ~ll\> ~ lWi~~~~::t:~!f:IiHe!l!)g.:mtti:fb~Il:!f:I~IDIj(~4[I:l;f;1:ttl~C"·~~~~ml-ffi~~i1f:mtti~~It:fb..

(12) ~~~.:fb'h'£l~. •. •. ~m)!<. I. @!~~~<;J:fErrn!$. JiLl~. • ~~( thought)~. • ~rmlt:fli!t~~t\E~rmI!:E.p:;::l;tl. • {l.l;;;~~rml!:.:fb~~ (. • W~*~~mH~:a:rml!::fE~~!t~~t\E·· fE!I!I~:gllrmlt.:fb. !I!I~~. ~1I~.~~{w. ~~~rml!:~~.:fb+<rrn!tE. I @!~~-K!I!'~@!~~.:fbja~i<tolW.:fb~.p:;:;l;t! • • I 0. • !1!1~~~~~-<~llIt~~'CtJ>(· ·EIE~ • ~rmlt.:fb!t~~t\E~rmlt~~:fEl¢#:ili.#. :fEl¢#:ili.#(;t~g:;~jjjllll[Je. ~1I~.~~{w. ). ~~~rmlt:fE.p:;::I;i:1l~~~~. ~~@f§-@:fEll1I[J !t~~t\E. I. I~-@::t!:lll;:~. l~~~~. (;t~g:;~~~[J·~~~.-<~llIt~~~o.8~·#~~-<.~·rmlt:fE~W~~~~~~:fE~W·fE~. ~~~.:fbjjj.~~~.~fE.l¢#~~:fE~.·.~~~ • • :fE~~~~ • • :fEo~~ja~.~~~*~ ~~~.:fbrrn!$·eE~.(;t • .:fb~.~~~m:iliN~~ja~fE~o. ~;;;ru~~~·*~~~~~~~It~~.I@~=.~.:fE~~o~~~*-<~~#8~.~eE. 0. :jmItR • ~;;;~~!I!I~@$~~++1. rml!:~~·EIE~~;;;~.e.:fb~ • .:fb~~·ja~~~@.p:;::I;i:1~.~'*~~mH~:a:o~;;;~.~.~(;t~ ~.:fblJ%~~++1~~ .. ~;;;~~:I;i:1$.t~~;;;~:I;i:1~llIte-<I~-@::ilill;:.:fEja~:ili. ~el@!.~.:fb~{Wow~.·r~llIt~-<:fE~-@::ili~.J~~·~~-<~llItern~~-@::ili~.:fE.p:;:~*. I @-<~~~ern~:fE~:ili~ti*~llItl~-@::ilill;: •• ~~4~~ja~I¢ • • ~*~.· ·~;;;:fErmlt. ~llIte:fE~-@::ili~.o8~·~;;;(;t~~:fE.~.++1~·~ • • ~B~~--~;;;~:l;tl$.tfi~f§~@.~ :fE ja~:t!:l .. ~~~~:I;i:1~~-<~llItern~I~-@::ilill;:.:Iti.p:;:~ *~llIte:fEI~-@::ilill;:. 0 I¢;!#} I *,fEll1I[J • {DII!~;;;. *,~ffi\.. I. *,¢~IIiE!!!. 0. ~. I. !!l++1~. • #ja~a\ll¢W~Il!!lJ!'~\\!tlrmlt~~·. .~~ja~,7;1~:a:~. ~~~~~llItern~~-@::ili~.:Iti~:ili~ti·~~;;;~~~llIt~;;;rn~:fE~-@::ili~.:fE~:ili~ti·+<~¢ ~~~@:::fEo. !1!1~@.~~++1~ja~;!#}.

(13) ~ ~~~~m~m~ft*. 1l :N::. 0. ,~,. ~:. 'fr". ~.ti.~m 1cJ$~t~llii!ll;. rg. ~ .-~~~lli~~~ft~~~~.~lli . ~.~~~~*RB~-~lli~ft~~. ~ ~ * ~ .. ~~~a~~-~~~~fitt.~~~ ~~~'~ ~ M~~~m~m~'~fi .~IcJ • • ~fi:N::IcJ.~'i!ll;.ft,~ if PJ 1'1 $ ~ B9 ~ ~ 1'1 ~t ~~ ~IJ lli ' fr, {!! ~ ~~~~·~~~fi~~~~.PJ:N::~. ~ ~~filli~a~*~~~-~.Y~1cJ ~ !~~~a,~~~$.~IT.~~~ • .~ ~ , ~ ~ • $ ~ 17 % ~ A ~ ~ lli ~ ~. ~. ;ffl~fi~$~:N::~~~if~~-~IT. ~ ~ ~. OIL.'. ©. I. x1!t. *.=.. $i!t ~@. ",!tI]. ©. _**eeM~~m+~'*E~M~~. 3tm.~~f1*°·r.' ~J:r.:Z:;;1'1ftRIcJ'. ~~~. .~B ~#lli~M~m.~~~:N::IcJ$! ~ T • ~ ."" m ~ n~ T M B B9 *0 B9 :E: 1'1 ~Ij ~ ~tA~IcJ_~U~~$O~U~~~s= • / J .b , • 1'1 ':2 fi 1'x. fr, ~ '1' , ii±. -rx. IT ~: 17" 12 § *l ~ ~o ~ B9 ~IJ ~ 1r, , M ft • rr, ~ -;ff ~ fi • ~ !DJ ~ fi m :N:: B9 jffi ft 1r, ~t - ; Il* ,: ~ ~ ii=I i!ll; 51 ,,~ e ~ ~ ~ '" fr~ B9 ~ ~ ~ ~F m n" #" 1"0 , *~ ~ ~ ~ 1'1 T J ~ * B9 m - .~ ft ;;x. ¥1 ~ 89 8 '- B9 IcJ $ :N:: ~9 1'1 $ ~ g3 11eJ ~ fr, ~ ;ill.. .t;:.. ~~-~~PJ~~·~m.%~~fi~~~ ~ - m~$~~'~·B~$'~~~~ ~ 11eJ ;f§ 2 ~ 1'1 IT ~IJ :ttl! ~t PJ W f!IJ ~o B9 ~ 111 2". ~.K~Mo~ft~~~~'*~~$~ ~~~~~~'~M':N::m ~ '~$~' 13 ~ 51 1f ~] m ~ • ~ m /G B tiP ft $ ~JJ ' ~ ~ ~ B9 ~ IT ~ $ $ 1r, ~ m to ' 1r, ~JJ *0 ~ tiP ~~~-~~~~ ~ ft~ft~PJ~ftft,. ff~~PJ' ,M~~~~~-Ufi~~~ W~~~@&~lli·fi,~~' ~~~~~ 'it • Jt IJ i'f& :N:: ~ B] ~ '~ -, ~ ~ :N:: lli 89 ~ ~JJ til ~ -;ff , ~ . ~ ft IT B9 ~ W m 1'1 - ~ * ifi ~ ~ ~~~~~~~lli·M,mM.$$/G@ .mm~~. o ~PJ¥ftEPJi!ll;;f§~~m. MA~A ~ $~~UA~PJ~lli~~~~ ~if~~~~jffi~.~-;ff~~-'MM~ o ~mftm~ ' ~~IcJPJ:N::~M~~~~ fllli~~~lli.'~~~~.fi~*~@ ~~~~~~~.~fiR;f§fl~'$fifi ~m~~~~~$~~:N::~~~ft;f§~~ ~ fleJ L - t) B9 0 fi fr, fbL 0 B9 .;f§~~~~f1*~f1*~~o ~m~~~ ~lli~mlli~#til#~M~ :N::*o~~. • ; * m A lli M. o 7. 4. l.

(14) ~. 1:. 11. • l!! ~. ~. 1r,. tt . 1f tIQ 8'3. *IE. f~. [iiI fX 8':J. ~. 1r, , ". ~ g~ o ~ lE ~f ~t. aIt ill lit II ~ *IE J.~ ttl! 1'1 JI,. ~ ~. ts. IY-J 1fJ. ~. * 11 4. *I. • • IY-J ~. 3M ~. ~. 5e JiIJ. ~ ? W-. § ~. ~ )Ie ~. j§. ,. T. 1r, ,. IX. 'II. ~. 51. /GtIQ, ~ g{ti~8':JJI, 8':J taaltmirf'm1f1fIlJt&fX§ti~ ~ $ ~ fX ~ lli ~ &. )Ie ::$: ~ 1: ~ ~. ~ ~ ~ ~ lli /G ' II l}] 8'3 tm ' ~ 8':J 1F ? J.~ 8'3 ~ fj§ fX 1'1 tIQ. 118],~, 11~,~,. 1r, ,. 0. 00 It ~ m ~. 1r,. l'lP 1'13 II m ' !@ Wf ~ ~D tE tIQ ' ~ fX fX . fX ~ 1r, 1r, ~ W, e ['2, *IE 8':J ij ~ ~ ~ § "F ~ fX ~ ~ W ~ 1r, ~ M tt 8':J ~ ;i.e' ~ 1n ' ~ 8'3 ~ D ff: 0. 0. -B- 1r, $: &. II e JiIJ .~ tIQ ~ 8'3 rt 1[ ~o ff. ffI} 3l 1f fi. 't '. ', .. JI, ~ fX ! 1f *IE 1r, Qffil ff: {JJ .. !. ~ ~ Ij}j *IE ~ ~ ~ ~ :m tJ *IE M~8]' ~3"~~ii1ij[iiI!oJ'-B-~. 8'3 51 lli :$ tJT ~ ... '. :&" . ~fX ~f. 1r,. Efl 1f. 1J~ ~~. :mtIQ z,~. 1J~. J'JT A. JI, &'1f. ,Ff:,. ~fO. J'JT ~. fX. 1r,. &. 1'13. 0. ~ ~ ~t ~ , ~. . M lli - 1'1 &" t±l 2 {tel 8"1. 1r, *IE. 1r, T. $~fXtlQft -B- ~i1ij I!fit M. 1r,. I1t1QIIJI,ill. tIQ 8"1 :m -. ill'~FoIlJ. :. I1~~T~ ~ ~ ~f. ,. {tel. 8"1. ~. . II ~t f4: fX ~D 1'1 ~ r 1r, 8"1 ' 8':JfXllifXfX. .. * 1r,. ~. 1r, 1r,. ~t ~. m. ~. ~. ". f~ 8':J ~. ::t IlJ. ~WtM~t),. m. ~ I 13. 1Jft. 1r,. c1f. II 16' 8"1 ~. m~~~tE. g{~~f*. ~lli. fOlRf Efl '. ~ ~f. ib :m 1r, " ~~ 1m°IlJ~~ Jl,f,ijt),'r. 1f. JI,'rJli-B-. ,~. ;i.e.,. fXltmfX*~ITITfX~~. 8':J"IL. ~EB. ®. 1fft'~I1 ~. 1r,. 8':J. ft 8"1 tIQ. 1r,. '1[. '~{JJlj}jm. ~~IlJM'. ~~ttJ:m~. ,. ~. -B-. ~. {tel. ftJl,~~tt. 1f~i5'ftE1ID. ffi~tlQ1ffi. oo~-~fj§ m~oo, 11 ~~~~,. ~:m~~~t ~ff:~f01n ,[iiI~~-. fffi ,Ff:,. ~. !oJ. 1tel. IT~-1'1I1. tb fD 00 8"1 1'1 8'3 !': JI, IT $: II !oJ 1f ~ Jilj ffi1'1Fo o /G *IT~. Fo. ~. 8'3. ~. ~1mff. 1n ft. ~1lJ' ~Jm~. :*:. fOm1f. W,. $. g~. ,. IZ9. ~~. .fL. *~. A. 1~ ..0.. ,;~". =1t. ........... C' (1) (1). <. (1). ..,. ~ ~ QJ ~m. eg. ~i. f! fi. ~. r *IE. ,~. fX~. 1r,. ti. ~'ii:. *~. 515E ~Ij rr& ~Ilt ~~ ~~ Ij}j B~ lt~. *IE ~ ~~ ~D *f;. [iiI B'J. @J1lJ. ff! fjg. ill 1'1. jipjo ~ ~ f~. 8':J. .fj ~. =.6. Qffil 0.

(15) ~m~~~~lllm~£'~~ ~. t$l1 ilt3£' ~. ~aD( ~ HI-~~~J;l<tnlW~~~{Wllt!WIDIj(~~Il[£'I~~. 0. ~.l[i'~~ ~ {DIII~e:;;;. ~~e:;;;£,~.~~IDIj(~~Il[~~e:;;;£,~~~~~e:;;;~~~~IW~~{W~~e:;;;E~.~~£,~~E~~£,~ 0. 0. 0. ~ - ~~e:;;;{[JrLJi!~~~~~~£,~ :~ - t$I~[i£:£, !1!'~~lfll~dt$l~Iii\IIJ.!E~l!J£' ±:(~~ - .g~ ~ ~mJ!~ e:;;;~~~~~~£,fI*l€1t$1~t$li!Il[£,~~~ij( - ~$*$~"*~li ~ :$:~~~iI~I€1£,~;l;l;1t$1~~~i!1l[ - iiHllHjtlW! I *,~~fL-I§!I!'~@!~tlI~~· '~=#{:;HI-~~~ ~ W~~~q~l]Im;fu1£~~i!. ~HI!'~@!,~*,E~~. ~E~.~~~~~~~~~.~~HI-~Iilt3£'~~-~~·HI-~~~~~~~~~~~HI-~{[JrLJ~~~. ~~~~£'~~t$li!Il[£,o~ •• £,IW~~~t$I~~~£'~e.o$~~ •• £'~W.~ I@!~~~~~. I@!. £,K~t$I~~~.~EW£'~~~mE~{Wo~~ij(~~- I@!~~~~~E~~EI@!.~!E~~~~. £'.~~.~t$I~K~~.~IDIj(~i!Il[~i!~~~£,~~~~~EIDIj(~£,~~~£,~~~~E~~o. ~~~~~NE~~~~{w£,~~~~WI@!i!~~~~~~~~~~~.~£,~~~£,~~~~£,g. ~·$~I@!~~~~£,.~~~.o I@!W~~~~~~~~~.~~~~~~~.~£,~~~.~~ 0. ~~IDIj(~l±!8:~{~·-{Dlllt\~· ~i¢W~~~t4J£'m~~q~~~ !1~'~@!~~~!IN~.~£,i¢~.~£,~~ - W~ .£'@;tS~tI!HH~ I @!~e.'h:(£,~*· .~=#{:;~e:;;;~*, I @!~~ I @!i!~£'~~~m~~q*~ - ~~~e:;;;~ - ~£,~~q~.~E~~t$I::I;:::~·~ I @!~~~~~:fh'~. ~~*,.~~@!~M£,.~~~~ - ~e:;;;~fitj~~~. - iif• • ~(1975:. 156-7)". ~~~~~~WI@!~~~~~~.~E~~:fh'~~5m~-~~~~.~.,m~~~{Wo ~~!I!I~@!~e!..

(16) @. ••. 1: " ~ @. ~. &.. • ,. •*a. ~$;ir'~~. jJ.flET. A69 ~. 11I-g-~1::'. 11" if: ir, m. ¥.f W fIE ' :fi ~ 7;: fiiJ 69 R:: ~ !t!!. /f' :fi m :w ftFatt, 69~AmR::' 1:: ~ jJ. ~ Fa fIE 11" it ~, ~ fO z m ir, ~ B9 ~f tE ; ft ~±~J6'. 7;: ~ $I!lit ~ IE 5t T. fr,. -. ~ 0. 69m-~~. ir, ir,. Ii ia. Fa. 111. ',R~tt N~~jJ.. IY-J I. 4. *I. IY-J. it. " Jm ~. ~. ~. fr, !3 B9. ~Ij Fa m ft 69~R::~. ~f!"~~. 'fR, B9B9. ~mFaFa. fr, R:: ~ ~ Jm ~ 'llJP. 1Wi69N?. $;*~Ij~. I!litg§~*l. T ' fr'~ fIE l\t Jm ii-r., if:*I1Wim fiiJ ~ $ '. FaFJTl!litfH ~~T1f. '69f1EFa ~ ffl! if: ~ fr, R:: fiiJ B9. 0. Fa~*~f1. ~ 1:: f! fr, ~IJ R::~' J6' ~. 11". m :fi. :fi. 1~. ~. *1. /f' ~ R:: !1!!.. ~lfti ~. IUltiml\f.~. m -. ~~~1!lit69 ~, 11:~T::1J 0. B9 B9 fIE .t. it@'. -,. ~Fa:O~~ '~m-lr~. r)t' /f'~~. 11". ~. ir,. fig B9 Iff tE Fa 1}. ~ fIE/f'7;:~* -~~,. ~1Wif!~Q~. ~~~:O11l M Q ~ ~ 171J. 11"W J§Il. !t!!.. '{jjji :fi i7}: J. -~m,. 0. mt;/f':o~Q. ¥.f~figm! JE fIE tJ f~ r~ 69 m ~ ~ fr,. -tl2.'Fa~ FaFa'f-f!~ 1Wi~~ ·ftI ~:o~~~ $; ~f ' . ' mAte J 3'F-~~BX:. o. 7 7. JE te. ir, 1r, t~. 11: -tl2.'. B9 if:. ~. $;. ftP.~1Wi~. ir,. 3'F-. ~f ~. fiiJ 69 JE fr,. Fatttelllil:. ~R::'*-. ir,;i. :t,. ~ .~. ,. 111. :0 §. fm~~m~ ~. ir,. /f' :ir fIE tt ~Q fig ~ M.¥ =': lE: 111 0. 11"1Wi~tEFa. lI-];fk~ntll-]Jt.* ~ :<l ' 0 0 1i!!. tt iVc. ~ ~ -! ~ , J:. ;k .i. {OO ~,. "*0. ,ff-1it,. ,. *-. ,-----~ ti1ntJ:.~:Jt~, ~ , :<l A.. if.. ~ {OO ,pf- -i- 1Ja ~. at. - -e: .~. t; ;r- It ~ J:. ' ii:l x 4e.. ' $,- 1'a; ~ =1f lI-] ;fk ~ 1i ~ *~~:<l/£" ' >Ill. ..:..'. db ~. -;tJ.!~~bi5. t'. 100 lI-] ~ J:. j'J .~ 'II ~ {1: 1+ 1 ' ~~1nt!ZJ.!~ 6(..1_ ~ ,pf- 'fU , ~tl\~;"', ~~. lI-] $ll -'". :fa. 0. 0. ,. ~.. Ji:. ® 11"\. ... JJ'l 1rl :. lI-]'=1f~~-;:;--:k. ~;r-->IIllt.~ .. rJj'1~ij'J~~ , JI#.. {tl J:. ' --- ~ Ji1.*f It;t~ ~ {~ lI-] ~ 4e.. ... R'!. ~ :§.... J.!. :fi.. 1t ti1. bJ.. "'J. ;fk. 0. J:.. {fl. :§.... ;t It ;r- '1 1 Jft ~ Z lI-] -!- fit nt tl\ .3i. o 11: ~'/'i , "*a. I. ~~' ,IJ~J!t. 11]lt~Ji1~~. :<l,;fQ, !11"\ 11;. "*a. lI-]. *-. o. 100. ~. ~. 1i!!.. .~. Z. :<l 'f ;t p,r 5~. 11: ~. '. {fl. =1f =1f. ±. -*0 11: .~ 1£. 1*". >Iii ' .:...... '1"... p,r. {f ;fk ;fk. ~. ~~~, (7. {,,).-. :-t-. .l.Jt.. ~'1OY. ~. 1'%. . ~at~4e..~100. £!. It :<l J:. J/(. 4e.. ~ 1. 'f '1. ~. f)... ~ ;ft.

(17) #~~~~M ~~~~ft~~~~ ~ ~Fa'_~ o ~~'M~ili'~~ ~ ~~~~~ft@~R~m~~~@~.~. PI f'1= fr,. f~ ~ J{IJ ~ H~~Ua~,. z~~.w~m ~m~R.ilitt ~~~~T~~ .~~®,a. 7~R~ftft~. ~ ~ ~ ~ fr, fr" , ~,~~~~ft. ~~.~~~V. Fa. ,. T. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 ~ ~~~U-~~.~,. ~"-Mlli.~~. ~ftftM~~~~~~ ~D~~~~~Fa_~ ~~~~ll~~~M~ A'~~~m~,~,. 1f. ~ PI fJ: "J': ;fo ~ ft ~ ~ ~~~~.~m~.~. ~~;Fa~~~m~~. .~Fa~.R~. Fa~A'~-T. .PIA. ~. R. :ttl!. ;f;{l, ~ ;$: Fa R ftft:ttl!~Fa~~.~:ttl! a~mS~FaA~'M ,.~~~~~~~@. ~ JlIJ. Z. 0. ~~,. ~~~~~fi~ -~~~._~. ~~~~~~. ~. R. ~ ~D. J!. ill:. ft. ,:ttl!~*~#~ ~~.ftA~~ JlIJ ~ fr, ; tl: ~. m. ~ffi~.R'.. tl:' R. ~. S9. 1m. 1f. 0. - m~~-.~. ~.#7fi.~ ~,~~~.a ~ft~~m,?t,. ~~ffl~MR~ ~.~~T~~ ~*~~,~~ ~~~-#*~ o~®~~$~. 'Z~tl:-s9. ~~Fas9fim. *~ $i!t ttl1ll. "M @. T~Mft~ft~~Fa~ ':ttl! ~ fr, 9=' fr, ~ ~ ~ ~~. @~lafflFa~~~~~. MAfr,~~M@~Mfi. :ttl!~ft~R~Fa ~~fr'f~tl: 0 ~ m ~ ili ~ $ ?t, ffi~.Z~~A ~~~~*m~ fi; '~$.A. @ )c~. ~D ~ @. ~-,~Fafift. s] fr,. OIL...'. o* ~~@~S , , s] _ &~G*~,ftFa~M !~. Ma~H~~~~~~. ~ ~ ~ ~F ~ R~~~;fOFas9. ~. m -=±. ~~:.'~Fam~.. ~~~~~~fi !~~'~-~. =rg. ~@~ft~-~~~.. m_. ~ ~ ~ ~'=] @ J5JTAiJYt.~ 0. ~ ~ ~ ~~mt/i1l. R •. ~. 0. .~~.~"J':~o o . ~ 0 :r~ttl:t.Fa$~D*1E ~t;. _. -. ~. ~. *. ~. '~~M*~,~ft~ ~.Rm'Fa~'~: ~~~Fa~~~ • •. =. ~%~~~~~~T~. MAA*~,a~ft~ ~.@$lli~'lli~~ M*~~G~~~~~ ~~-~M~*m~@ M~M$Fa~~~.: _~PI'~'~A~ ~,~~~m.m_ RR~~~OO~M~. '~Fa~@FattFa~. tsf~~ft,. ~1ii~~. o 7 8.

(18) ~~iHIi:fb;;lFa~?Jj~f-'-f§lJI!';I}@:llE~~ 0. !J!IQ<W:fb~el.. ~itJ~~~. 1 !@~*'l&!tnf,gitJ:fb~~(a priori) ~~. 0. ~~E.~~~~~~~f@~m.~:fbr~e.~:fb~~-~@~~.*~~K~~E*'l&!~.~~~. 0. 0. 0. -. 'Jil~mf!:ig~~ 1~flW1fjE ~sg~!I!I;I}!@I!!!§~ - ~~*'l&!mf!:itn~E·-~sg~!I!';I}!@I!!!§~ - ~*'l!l:l~~:lbflW~~~ ;!;Q~I-E-tn~,g !1!';I}!@~~~mf!:iii~~:lb.{~I!!!§~(the principle of charity):lbtH.rK:t4J ~~ ~t4JI!!!§~mf!:i 1@~!J!IQ<wtn*'l&!~rtnflW~~E~~-~@I!!!§~I-E- • • W€~~~:lb~~~~o - ~~~~~ii~~~€$t~f-'-I§!I!';I}l!!tn~::ili' .~~ 1 @!flW::ilim~~~~~. flW~~~;!;Q~~~:fb~n;j. ~~~~:lb~*flW::ilim~E~~-~~~~~~flW:lb*'l&!~-~~~!J!IQ<wr~m~~€::ili:fb~~o. ~mf!:i-~~~~~~~~E-~.~~~~- l@tn~:lb~&!~.IMmf!:il@!~el~~~~~~I~. - ~mJ!<~~~~:lb~ 111!!ll!\itf¥~!!l. 0. ~~!I!';I}IBl!B!tf¥.. - ii~~.JI!!!l~~KnM.W:ff/!JHIIK:lb~<WSm:lbtn. :lbW<W.~:lb~~-~~~~~$t~~W.l@!.W~~~~~:lb~<wsm:lbtn~::ili°tH~~l!!tn~::ili:lb ~tf¥~!!l. 0. ii~~!I!'!I}!@!i'ii~K~~~~~~~ii~~~vt-.W~<W:ff/!JHllKtn~,g::ili:lb.~~-a-. 1:lill~M*~4Ju. ~::ili°W~~~~~E~~;;lFa~N~-~~~*~.~:.~~~~I~tH~-~@tH~mf!:i-~~~!I:~ ~,gmf!:im~~0~ ~:lb~~o. ii~~~~-~~~!I:~~mf!:i~~~o~K.§.~~~ii~~~~@.~:lb.~o.~~E.~~ 0. 111@~~ o:l!IlJ~ - ~~U~ - ~~4~~m~~0~~~~~<w ~,*~~~I1P(.~~:lb!I!';I}@!i'ii~· ,~~<w~-a-r-d :lb 1 @w!~:lb~<wS~ - wm~~~:lbrK:t4J:lb~'Iff~$Jlg 1 @1\IIIII~:lb r I-E-tn~$.f:lb~!fi.l·-~~ - ~~~.~. =c-=.

(19) til'< 0. 0. ,. ~,*,{l.lm¥< 1. W. -a- ~ if. ~aIi'iBI..r ~~~N. W"Thought and Talk". 0. 0. $±lf,\gllllu:ffi'. WiHR 11 $±~~iiH~+l;jlU?J ~ ~,*,~~~~:ib~~(The con. ~~ ~ ~;jln~ ~ ~,*,~1I1HH~~m¥< 1 $!~It~. ~ mzK~4~1IJ~~~~~mzK~~~ ~ !1!'~$±4~~. cept of belief) ~ Kamz~ftfE~~~4N ~~~~Kamz~~~~~~4N:ib~4N o. 0. ~~+lW"Thought and Talk" (( 1975) :170) ~~~~~ ~ ,*,{oE~~~!~:Hi:$±~~~:B!I!'~$±;jl,U?J. "Rational Animals" ( (l985b) : 473-80) -a- ~ ~td~M.t~~~I$:a.!I!'~$±~n?J .. ~{~\o"~~~~2"fC'- · "\\1t~+o~~~~,*\O"~~. ~+l~!I!I~@!$~~:ibiHR 11 @!*,,~~r--.!I!I~~:ib~$'. .f<9\(- \ ~~~~~~~<,!}~~4r2. . i(o~{~aIi,*~.~N~ti~$~\o"~. 0. .~N~*~~\O"~~N~,*~~~~~o~~~N~~b~~~*~¥~~~~'~~~~~~~~ <':2¥~~"~. . .f<9\(-\~~~~~~~. ~~_~~~$~~~.~~~~~~+·\\1t~~~.*~~~~~·~aIi'iBI..r·~~~~~$~~. ~$~~~~~~~~\~~.i(o~~~~~~~~~~~,*\o"~~~o.f<~. ~M~·~~~W~\~$~~.~\$~ o ~~·tw~~~~"~~~¥~~·\\1t~\o"~~\.~ ~~.~~~~~~~.~~~~~~~~~*~o.

(20) .& - W A s:J 3ft g. B!;} :t ir' ~ :t !!* ~ t!t ~ "ilJ m (n' m ; ;If m 1: ¥X~N~t!tmW;lf~~1'r&~@~.? /G' m r-t III W fIT ,: R *1£ 11 - ~ ~ ~ ~t It. ~. @. iF'. tlli. ~ ~ ~. L--. 0. Ii. ~ @ ~. IX. •. M ~ tr-J 111. ~. •* IX. AB!;}~~~tlli~.~ s:J Jtlj ~ ~ tlli ti ~ s:J ~ ~. !§ ,c:, ('). Fo~!~~;;If~B!;} ~m~*'m~~m. 1'r;00B!;}B!;}!;~ -c"ilJ~* ~~ ilgl ~ tlli -$ , f,J , *1£. 1'r R. Jtlj -. II. *1£ ~~ 1'r ~ ~ ft. ~.m"ilJ~B!;}.tlli~o~~.-¥X~~~ mmfITtlli~mB!;}nB!;} IlIl.~~m~m~~ ¥X~~~Ill~~~m B!;}~ ~A~1'r~*. n -oo~Ao~_,.IlIl. 11 won. 1'r. 0. ;0 - • ~ F.lt:. ~ *'.Y n :'J'~ ¥X$~ ~~/G ~~~~~~~. '~' ~ • ~ 0 ~D ~ ,. ~~. iM. &. ¥X. ~. iF' ~ '~4m:!j ,. J..§. kt:.. •. L---'. _.!1l!.. "". ~mm~~~~ t!t¥X¥X~~~U. ~~~~B!;}~~ B!;}~~~.~. ~ :. tlli 1'Jt:. fi ~ A ~.nn.&~~ .~~r!!*~Fo. -EL 7'E.. •. 115. ~. !. ~. B!;} o. ~. 8 1. ~. s •. ~ III ~. tr-J. o. r. Fo. IlIl. *1£. •a ¥XT • a m " 00 ~. ". tlli1'r~B!;}~~~1'r.B!;}Mq~'.¥X.* ~ ~ ~ 1tY ~ 1& {,' S:J ~ ~ ~ J'JT iF' *1£ '. * ¥X m ¥X ffi Fo ~. IE. if. r. ~. -. fi"ilJ~lB!;}m~. ~tllim~~~~ ~. ,. ,,. «i]. t!t m. ~.~¥X'W~ "ilJ ~ - iF' ~ , ~ tlli~~~~¥XA. 0. '~.Foa*. *•. * :tS:J ¥XiF' ttl:!. ~ ~ ~. ¥IJ. ~. mom~.m~~. Fo ---: 11: b "* 'it h" ill * •" II: *' F.\ •-EL 'c:' fZ5I ~ P7 'F3 iFtt: jl:t .AI:: B!;} ~Fo"ilJ.~~ m~~~tlli~.~ ~m~iII*6~~ ~ m1'r.';lfD. ~11'r~~~~~ ~,tt: 00 ~ ;If m -$ 00. Ill_-~M..*~ ~. IlIl..~*~oo~*. B!;}~Ill.¥X"ilJi.. m*.;If~~~o ~~IlIl.~~11:I'I~ ,:JA. B!;) , • ~ ;"" 1c ~~m~B!;}~., l2. ~ ~ JtiJ m fP] ~ it ~~~,.~*.. ~,¥Xt!t-~~ .¥X~W • • m ~~~~.~~ B!;}~t!t.~~~ ~/Gw • •. ~~.~'m.~ *~IlIl.;If~~~. -$@~~~Fo*. 'itBm~m~'. ~~~IlIl.¥X~~m Fo-~~~m"ilJn. tlli/Gfi'. ~Fa('). n-. ~~~~fi~oo ~fu.w~m.. n. W~~. ~ ~ ~. ~. '. •. tm. ¥X. s:J N iF' ¥.f. ¥Xttli,~.r-tifW ~~"ilJ~~~o. ~oo~mm~~~. *• 1tY ~. /G'. ~~. g A. ;:6. 0. *~. Fa ~ •. Fa. ~:t ~q: ~ ~. 'S Fas:J'. M.B!;}. ~~a~.¥X/G..

(21) ~-~~~~m~~I@~~-~I~~m~~~~~~E'. ••E o ~~~N-m~~e~~~~~E. ~~e~~~~~E~I~E~~-M~-~~~~.~~~~~N~E~~-~~~~~~~~~~~. 0. ~~~~~~~~~~~.~E~~o~~~~~E~*~-~~~~~~WE~~-~~~~~~~m. 0. (~ ~. - ~~~~E~o~~~~~~~lll1[J~~g~E.~. 0. ~~ ~. -. - if.. - ~~~:\l;il~~~ - ~f~i¢Wf.l!qI~ 1@~~~~~~~~ - ~~~~~. •• E~~.~~-~~~~W!~~- •• ~W~.~ •. M~. g,*~~~W!~~. (the distinction between things in fact being the case and things seems to be the. ~-<~;lt4Wn:i!G. N~E. .~~~-~~ I @rn~~EE~~~-~~~W~~-.~g~~~~.~g~~N(.~~~g. ~~~~W 1 @~~E~~~. mj!:i ). case). .~W~.~ •• ~~.~( •• ~*~.)N~E~~-~~~~~~I@ •• ~~.~E~~ o •• ~~.~~@~~~~~~. o ~~.~N~E(~~c-·.~.!i:1~~. ~~~@~~~-.~.~~~E~-Wt. ~~~ ••~W~.~@~~~~I@~~E~~-. •. ~~ •• E~~.~E~~-~~-~~~~~ •• ~W.~ •• ~~.~N~E~~o~~-~~~:\l;il. I ~*H~'gj~ln~~ 1 f@~W!E~~!I!'~@ • • - ~~q~~. ~~~-~:\l;ili¢Wf.l!qI~ I @~~-~@~~~~~I@E~~~~.~E~~-~~-~~~~~~~ o ~!I~~~~.~.W~~!I!'~f@ ,'m;;~!lltr~~t(~E··. .. ... J (1985b)ii~.E\IIQ!t:\;l:1~. -. -. I. ~~ijg:~lIlE~I@:'~~. J !1~~l@~4r~f\-.~*H. 0. 0. lit. €~ . ~W l l@ ~.~ •• ~-=&f\-~~~ .~E. ~~ti!!:ffi\'->~'UHI~.:ffi~t1- ~~~.~~~:ffilll$:l!!5". ~ (triangulation metaphor). ~. o ~~. o(~Wl$jW!:E~~tr. ~~~~~@~.~~~W!~E-~~~~~~Wlf@~~E~~W~~~~~@~.~~~W!~. E o. 0. ~~~.~.~~~.~~ . 4N~~a2..

(22) @. 1:. ~~lli~~m@.. 15]. lli. m 51. §:. IJ\. B3. ~t ~?2,. gjjj l\t :$. ~~~~#~~~~. ~ ~. i§:. ::f' Wi. ta. ~. ,. 0. Ii[. ~ ~. o.. Illi iii. ~{tP.~lli~m~~m~.~w=~o ~~~m{tP.W.fitE~~~~~m~-. '~~~~~.~'~.~~~::f'm~~ mMM~~,~m~~.~~.~fi~~. @. ~~~~~.BX:om~&.#,.Ii[~~~. ~ ~. &.. t.. M ~. IY-J. ffl. ~. *. •• :m. ~ :$. ~. #, , - BX: '. ••. ~. B3. ~$ @. m~. IY-J. ~. 1M. 0. 1. ~,s,llia~~~ o. ~~~U~~~~ S ='!J.=i2'. ll!!!J -='" -.tr E.. 6,,;., -t T • f' BX:;:. B3 B3 = ~ ;!if~~~~~. ~~&=m,~~. 8.,~~tfil}. ~. ••. -. iFI:l. ~. -. ~. , lli. ~fifi. :i:. ~~~.~ - mm. B3. ~. lli. 2. ~ ~1IIl ~. ~ ili ta §: 1~ ~ ~. :. ;:i g. * ~ ~~;#~;~.. ta ~. 8.,. ftQ1. A ~~~~,=~ ~ f:J T ~ ~ ; ~~. K~~~~®~ili. .&~~.~~, ,'I. ~/. ~,..,v. ~ ~ ~lli ~ ~. :J}(,. lr, ::t. -v -+-'"l. "F. A§.. -. ~ ~. iB 1. !. ~ ~ ~ pJT ~ ABX: b " #, ~ ~' ~ ~. i I,!.'. 07. ,. ,1Il.. m~~ •• ~~~ ~~~~*m~I'1. M~~~i~~~. K ~ , B3 'II "-:- ~ .A!.~!~.. .~~~A~~~. i§:~~.~~~A. ~A~.~f'~@ • • '~~~~~ -~~~~~~~ B3 :m. ~ c,'!J J:e f:J ~ W ~ • • ~~3~~. .K~k~~~-. o~M=,~-~. tE~~T.ta~m. DO. '=. ~,15]-7~~~ Um~.M~~. r IJ\ • ~t I~ ~ m B3 fil}~'~S/.. ~~M. ~~~M~~~-. 8 3. ~ ~. ••. -, 1:!i gffi F.il Wi ~ ~ -. o. B3. ~.~'q~'@~o~t.ff~~~.. ;-®{tP.,~~&.. ~. ~.. 1J~~~~~~:~·~~A'!~~~ 1i:.lli*~~~~-~~~~~tE'~~~. ~. *l. ta. A.rr~~~~~·~~~~~~~m. ~~~ °D~mW·::t~BX:::t~~~M· ~~~V~~~~~.,.~~~~~~. ~. •. '. ~~ m.~~*~~~m~tE ~ ~~~.15]~~@~~m~~~ma~ru. !~'ma:$~~~ '"0 pJT ~ IJ\ S ~F ~:gr ~ 51 il3' It ~ '& ~ ~. §. ~ B3 ~ ~ _ ;E m ~ ~~'!~OOT~~ ffi WI] *~ c,~, ~ J\ .. 1'1 Bl. :1(. ~ ~ ~:i:. 1J~~~8. o~m. I=]. 07. ' F3. .=.. J....-..A. 11:ta~f:J~'!fifi~ ~~~3~~!~ 0. '.:f';:*tE~J:e'. P~. ~~~~.!~~. ~.~lli~~m~. ~~fi~~U~m ' . ~ ~F B3 :& ~ ~ g~~.~~m~. ~o~~~~ffi~.

(23) Y:.. ~tl:~*. ~F .~ -ft #J 't 116 !t. ·tt 11';' 4X 'iii' ,-1'-11"l. ~J:.mi:1l:~ ~ l1!. Jt. : :Jt. iiliiit.]"-A.. ii·tt~1I0. * .. H fit * ~ iX.. 100. ~-t!!..!If~-t!. -;t , 1t 1-3- -:- , f[] ± -;t JZ ·tt Jt.. ~>Ir. ' ,. ,-. ;t. ''12. 1'1" ~ iA.. iilii~J!;_~. 11'1. 'lilmiit.]{ltti-]. ~'-'~j-~. ~i-ft-tll.;ft. !. ~ '~i. t.t: ~. ~·ttit* ' *E iX. #.if 1Q fU '-' J'J ~ -t!!.. ,-,:1l:J.t .. ttit Jlt:. J.t '-7' ~ ff 1- l' "\1 ~. *. (t:J"it.]*.1t. ~~*it.]Je. fjiJ 1t -t! ~ ~;f .~ :fa -;t d(. 1I~·f.tH a~ :fa j. ~ 100. *. =~01tA.. P!+-t~~. ll~a~~..;.. 117. '-'. ..". JZ. -<-. jB!: ' til rJj PX"~~it.] 7 it.] it tt it.] , .X; :fA: "\1 ·tt. i§.t-tt{fiX. ~IJ 1~ ~. *. 5' ~,. 0. ft 1t .Jt 1M a ~ rJj if ffil 1f :::: ~ 0. ~J!;1t-'* ~. , tl. 100 it.]. ~. PJT8~. 110 pg. ~. Ie.., $Z. ~. E $:. P'I iID. ~. m :t:. :::::~~~~~A. tE. ~. 0. rJt. m~. ~. if:. ~. IJ\. F~'. -, '!&. lI~1:~mmz1i] 0. ft8~*rm. 11* '!& I=j:J ?!:; jjj$ t§ -=f ' Jlt !~ ~ Z ffi1 ~ it). '- ~ 0. fg ~ ~ =±. [.m7i-01n-'*14~fI. ale,.,. ~ *l 1n ¥ Jlt 1@ ?G '!& ~J ~ ~ . )c~. C)1~IUl'~-rm~l4ffi't±:l1f ~~t¥,. ,. 1:.) PI]. ~~pff$:,@~;7Ji~. *~. *. ttlm. m. 5j1f 8~ 1:.) a',L' IUl ~pff-*tlAmffi{IE,~1n ~. @. @I tE @I Ie.., #iIJ ftt!. ~ it). ~ ~ tl (ft A II " ~ ~ 14 ~ _ -=f. 1M II 8~ P'I ft. ~t. ./tIl. @. 1$ , ffili 8~ JIIlJ. ! ?f. fr~ g: 14 m ~ f $: ~MxrJt~~~m:~~8~. ~, ~. ..E!.. Jt:.. fffi. AZl. H=l. 1'1:1. ¢. J.t. 4m: ~'". 0. ,. ,_. <;J. N:.. ' it). 1n $; J§: U i~ tE 14 7i- ~ i~ {IE A ~ fF tE ili M ~ ~tt 5t ~ • Ie.., Jfl! ~ ~ 8~ ~ 1m tI -tQ ffili _. ,. -,. :=;1, <;Pj. ~. ~. f'!'l I!3J. IJ-. 1.lL. II. *-=f -, it).~ g '- * -=f 14 'OJ. ;::: ~. ~. 0'. ~~~'P'I~~/G'-\2. I!3J 5j, rm ~ - W2, ~ i1= IJ\ 8~ ~tlftft~@~IUlt±:l~M 5' ~ ~ ~ 1f IUl 1i] 1n ~ jjj$ Jfl! r; .... ~ ;jl. g. ** *. ~J.h4m:F!,.~-,_m~ ~ ~ "" I9I'J ;}" ",c.,. 0. 1f $; 7i- Ie.., (~ o's!:! "8 , rJt tE • -=f ft "mJ 1JX: ft !Jf. IE i!t P'J '- -=f fr, JIIlJ ~ 7i-. 1!\!i 1:£. 0. ~fr~IE7i-!Jf.~" ~$:m tlmt±:ltE~8~¥rm~tf:J1$ #iiJ ~ L, • • F,,9 fj£ ~ ~ ffi 14 o A 11 IJ'm IJ'm li!! ~ IUl - it). 8~ ~ ftt!. P'J 8~ , 5t 1n @ 14 JIilJ *l ~ ~ pff $Z tm 8~ IJ\ wlJ \ ~ 0. ~tl. IE. tE~~~~$:~1J'm '1f ft itt jjj$ IJ'm iif ~ ft 1m fr, 1:1 ~ IlJE ~ PI fr~ jjj$ ~ ft ? tE1:.) ~ ~ Ie." fr~ -;q;g PI] ~ {IE. 5j-§ ~:fO :<$: I~'. $;ki1EP'l1f~'fl~ !Jf.P'I~lJ.@ftffiffili IE ~ ~ EI3 JIilJ fr~ it). ~. ~ #iiJ. ~. m. ~. E. {ii. ~~. 0. *. 1!\!i*.&8~*m~. o. 8 4.

(24) @. 1: II fa ~ @ ~. & 1tl. li. ~ ~. 1f!I. ~. tll PJ\- ~ fXfX~. ir, ir, ~ z;W-\1J ra' {t t'I!2. S9 fX T iV' M. ~. ~~~ o ~ *l. 1iTI:iE%':R. J3..tES9 '!1B~. fX 1: P~ iP' , , m-fX AA- J,~ iF'. 1l\IimllT. •* IX. 1*/GtJ. ~ ~. ~f. it ~. " ~. tIJ. ~~@] ~f$'1i:. iIJ. ~. ~o~. tE~ft!!.. =:::@:tE 1If£';::' 2 69 2€. ra' m ~ ~ S9. S9 JiJT. r l\'l. tE'{&. {3'LfX. tm: iF' m 69 ~ t9: ~1l\Ii?i ~ 1* JiJT. (J)lR:tt! o. :iE. ~IJ. tE ttl 69. tilfXm. • iF' 11. o 8 5. '1. 1~ f.j- ill *'ilt-#~ rF- 1~~,. ~~itJ.t~kk. iF' . ~ %':R. ,lIi. 0. ~51. fIE. 1:£. -!-:W~. :;t~-5t. 1ft. fIE. ~Ij. 1m . ~. r-o. ~. ~Ij. c..,. ag. ag. ~ ~. -!-:m= ~. fo. ~. -e. ~. ag. ~~-5t. ~ M~ ~ 0J ~51 ~. $f.:WW o. M: H. ~'g ag~. ~ iIi ~~ ,. ~I. ~i!l ~n . '. :l:: 1~ ~ p~ ;fro Ji.. -#. JlIS, ~ f.;] 1t lUI ~ 1. 1- i'- i'l JI. til It ;ffi ~ Z -#- ~ iJt -#- 1>';'. fit. litl1i'E: -Il;.~i ;Y fC" 1ft. 9f,~J.o~1M. fJ.. ~ 1- 4X. JlIS 1- 1t. , 69 Alt. fX t.t *l. :. '~H jtJX,. fJ... -if ~ ~ 1I"l ~ ~ J.-t. ~ ~Ij. lSI. '.,...~9f-#. !. rll,. ~ ~ ~ ~. -I- aQ Ji.. 4X. 1t ~ 1l "t. 1M J.t. a. 1; im. .~ ~ ~. 0. 1 ~'''''kiJt~k lSI 1ft 4X. • JlIS #J t: ;fro o ,f,!; 1I"l ,lj:. 1>';'. '. i'l ~ it 1~ ~ ~ 4X. -#",l- 1!l. ~Jl. ;. 1M 1- 1'<- ~'7 I JlIS 4X.. 1m ~ . -&im~. -ff~. 0. ~ 1M fll. ..... 2€. Ji..t~~'J' ~.t£.1 0. .t- ag m. ~..... ~1t°1oo~:l::~o 1- Jl~ 1l. :: ~ JlIS ~ ~ , ~ 1+ 1- J.t ~. "t.. %':R. Wl. *. *. l\t. ~51 9.X f,J :Wj!~ o ~ fIE. ~. ~:f;t-#-~1tJi..1-! 100 ~ 1- It J.t J.!!. .t£. .;:. ~:;t , ~ Jt- ~ -#- 1m 1SI:l::~i~t\.1-aQ '--' ..;:. ;ffi,:l::;;r k :. ~ 1>';' 4X. J.t k 4X. {It!i.. ·ti. 1M Ai'J 1M j 4X. ~ 9f ~ 100 ~ ;. 1M 1+ It fJ.. Ji.. ;fro Ji.. i'l ~ il: J.!!. 1>';' "t. ~ Jl~ it -:; -f k ·ti. ,fa "1<., ~ k "" JlIS ;fro ~ JlIS 1M 1- _ 1- ~ I 1>';' t\.. *. ~ 7'~ @. *l. k:. ~ 1M ~ ~ it J.t <f lSI fll it Ji.. t.t\ .::.. JlIS J.t o iJt ill J.t JI!!.. 1m ~ .t£.. i. m. ~ j\!!.. ----, Jl~ ~ Jl~ ,to &. 1M Jl~1m1~~~ 0 4X.~ 100 '-- {It -12>. 4X. ~ 1M III '-- :::;- 4X. 1- 1M j 1t 1~. i!tm~ ~ ~.lt ~~o. ~. A. 1- ;fro #J 1 ~ J.t ' , 1>';' , ~ ; .t£. ~ ----, JJ ·ti. k Ji.. fJ.. 4X. Ji.. . , tJl - 9:l. Iti~ ~ ~.

(25) 0. 0. !1~1~111<!II:~~!I!I~~~~E - ~~WS ~S -N~~~ 1 ~~~~:lh'~ - lIIllt\2~~-W<~!I!I~~~ - ~. 1H~WJIiH-¥-~E~.l§S~~fo\l~~ I Wlll<!II:~S - S - 0 - ~-a-S ~S~~~~EJ!i!It.~. - 0. ~~~~-~~~~IW~.-M~~~~~-~~~~~~~~~I.~~~~~~~E~.E~I~ •. ~~.E~. ~~~~~m~~~-N~:lh'~~ 0. ~!I!I~@!~;\;l:1~~~~~~~~:fb~.~~~~. I. @!111~{H. ~~m~~~E~~o.1H~~~S-O~~S-o-~~~~~~~.:lh'~.og~-~~~~~~. 1 @!III<!II:~ ~.~~~~E~.o. - ~rt:~~~~~~IlJ~~~:fb~~~~~~~ 111 ~{H~:lh'~~. 0. 0. ~l§S~-Y~~~~. ®~~~@:iti~~:lh"~.. ~W.~~~*.I.~:lh'~~~~o~~~~~~:fb~.~~~~~~W~~:lh'.~-~~~~~ ~ll*~:lh'~~. ~~~c--!jji~~~g@:~~~:fbiIlt\e - ~~~~~:fb~lfJtn~D(~~~~~m!-Y:lh'~\€J. ~~~-g~.~~-~E~~~~E.~~~~~~~~~m!~~-Y:lh'~\€Jo~~~~~-~~.~~. :fb.~-~~~~~~~~~-N~:lh'~~~-~g~M~.~MW~-Y·~:lh'~~~~:lh' • • • ~~~~. 0. it.(C.'lfn. ~~M~.:fb~.I~og~·~~~.~~~I@!~·~~@!~E~~~~~~:fb~W~~E~.~~. I ~~ • ~~~IE~ I @!ll!!Kf:1:1EiI*ll~~~~~M~ii~~~IE:lh' 11 1<!II:~. ~E·~~~~~~~~E~.~~~~E~~·~~~.;\;l:1~~~E~~~~:lh'~~~o lIIllt\2~~~~o\l~~~~. - !1!I~iI*I1~:lh' I ~W~~~~~~~~[iI* 1 ~]E~W~~~~~ - ~~~~~~~fL-lel!l!I~W~Imf;/E~a. ~. ~W~~~~~~E~~~~.EI@!~~~&~·~W.~~IW~*K~~~~I~.*~~ ~. lWE\W:i~· ·1111[]~~~~~E*~~~:t:~c-·. 0. J (ii~~· [1992]:264)€H ~IffW~~:lh'~~(private pers 1 !!g[~. J (il~~· (1989):198)~~!I!I~iI*I1~. pectives)E-K~4a(converging)W~~+H~:fbtH~~I~33:.

(26) D~~. @. 1:. m fa ~. j,)E ~. IX. *l ~. -'m~fflf!~.~~~~-~m~~,. OOftl!.1E'Mft~,~,~~oo~~m. A /f ±: ~ ~ III. ~lJ. fF~;;$: ~. * {[ & '. tJ 1t ff -. 1:: t8 1E ?t- ff. {~. $. 4o/.J~~A.±:.~ ;~~Wmij}t~A ~lJP'3Qj)§.~ft=-::-~@? .~~~~89 ~@ ~ D1::~~(,O&~~~~~~~ M ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ Pi ,; it §: & ~. * -, \3 1E 7'U ~. ~ ~ ®. ~1E~OO~~~ .~mAA • • 4o/.J1E'~tE~~ ~lJ~mftl!.ifrj(=-, ~. ft./f~~§.-. •1E 85 r9.. m. ~ ~ !(!; & 1E. ij}tlliff,~~!(!;a ,~~~~.~W ~'~i~lliM~ 1;)&- ,, ' ®~a. ft.oo~@ o m~. ~. l!.. •. .~A=1E ~~§.fl~ 89 19. D • "". n'I~~~~~-. ~a-. ". •. ~~~~~±:~ tE ~ 13: ~ R: .~ ~~ftl!.~~~:. ~ T89 ,L., ftl!. _ EE. T -hlJ ~ 1E. _. 0. -n-. 89 {~ fI;3. ttm:. u:: ~ ~ /l,;"m*§-=~J.h 1''0 r'J ,"-, ,~, I~ .~ ?§: 89 ~ ,A ~. m. , <:". ;. !t o. ,~ ,. .N:::.. -. !!. it. ~:IE.~~ 1EJ16~ ~. -. ~. ~;. oo~{~~~ ~ ¥f rm A. ~ ~ ~,~ *[ ~ 0. L-.. ~ ~. {~ ~. , 8~ ,L., 5E • tel ~ ft§'lI'te~?t-. ~. ~. ¥f :t!t!: 1m ',it~~~. _. is'. 11=1. ff.-l'.:E~ R*!t{~ 0 1E. - W :iIJ m .~ ~ a OOAftl!.~~ft~ A ~ JJ ~'" ~ fa ~. !1EL lEI.. 0. ' t ! Jt. is. 0. ~. * ~IJ. 'L). m ~. @ /f. R. ~ ~. ~. & :x. ~ - ~ ~ :lEff~~{~' A. ®. ~. +I! g. ~ ~ = <R. ~. ~iS~!~ ff 'J: §:. ~~.~~~ff. ~. ~. ~ 1= ® {~I tE ~ 89 ·= ?trIa /\. {,",":IE. f9.. '1E' ~tel'. •. Illff'm~. ~ ~ ~. lJlJ ij}t R fi: 89 ~ A. ~. .llJJ ~. •. ,. ~.1E89~JAib ~~~fiLP~:EI~. W~ ttA. o. 'ff 1ER. /K~-EL2LH=!. ~;.§*Jt!~~ isj & 7'1J • 111. ft §.. 8 ?. 1J M M. 1;) tin lJlj:f:. ~~~~~~oo. tt-J. ~~. -m. m. ~I'. *" ~. W~. ttfl. .~.,~. ~ftl!.~~~~T;R~~&R~.' ~ 8~ ~ - tel §. at ~ ~ A ,<:" ~ ~ ~ ~ T' {FE ~ ~ "Ito...... -i:;l;§ . ~, "'J -= -;¥ ~ ,u III ~ ,~, PI} if.1t:. (,0 89 ' F3 ,~, ~ ;;01 is ~ -. IX ttl. ~. .~~A~. tE. .~~~1Eff~~a&~A~~~~ ~~~~~ffl~~M.@mA~fl~. @. tt-J. ••. '~~m.~. ft. 5E ~. ~ ~. ff ~ m is'. _~~{~89. ~~ is. =. ~. clZ,. ~++h'" <VL 07. E-!T~. ~ f,* ~{4= ~ .:. 89. jB. ~f!. ~ ~ ~U~. 1JJ16 '1E ?t-' [fff ~ ~?t-. 5E' m ~. m~. ~. ft {~. ,L.,. II P'3. @. ft tt ~. • ~. 9:0 ~. 't fF' 1E ~ ~.

(27) ~mJ!<~:f6i=~~\t>mJ!<~:f6-N~ii13~l!!!€:~.l.j:f6I'!IDCR. 0. '. ~~~~e1.ffi\~~$.(:f.%:f6)af,M. 0. .00. .g~ ~ 111<![~~II\Il~~. ~~~.g~I@~.ili~M~~.~~=~~(~=.~~~)~~:f6~~~E~~%~~.E~~~~~ ~%~ti:!m:~{~. .g~~ • • mJ!<.~~ ~ ~.~~1I*Wlf,\gllll[]{R:~~:f6tt~.l.j ~ ~Jl!!. 1 @~)a~%:f6<![~. ~ 111<![~~1i\\lt?. ~WM~;;*l!IfI!Il!IfI!Il11<![\!)~:f6l!*ll@!*,~·· 1 @!~~ffiK~~¥rN;:1t,1gI111[]fo1~:f6~ ~ ~nnK~~.~~~1'!ID ~:f6f,M~(~nnK~~~~~)~~~~~nnK~ti:!m:~~oWl!*I@*,~~~~ • • ~B~ 1@~ • • • • ~ r {J!;!:ti J ffi~~~~lf,\glll1[]~t<tI:f6M® ~ mJ!<nnK~1t,1gllll[]{R:~~~:f6~.. 0. £)ffo1~hf,M{J!;!:ti~ffi~rIN~1t,1gI111[]~t<tI:f6M~ ·~fE ~'t!::. 0. ~~.~i1ffi~~:f6~~~'t!:: ~ !1~1~mJ!<1EI~ ~ ;Jt*,~:;@m!{ot~lt:l1 1 <![fo1. @~~~;;E~I2mJ!< ~ ®1E~i=~~:f6fo1~ ~ hf,M~~~{<tI:f61t,1gllll[]~~~c-·. 1 @!~1;t ,. ~:f6l!*I@!*'~~\t>~~~~o~fE.~~~~*.~E~~~ • • • • ~~I*,:f6~~o~ • • ~B~ .. ~HlBto~ mJ!<fo1~~~~~~~ ~ ~ {.l.1;;@ii13~ffi~~~~lf,\gllll[]. W(The Second Person) ~ ~ it• • ~ ~ ~~~ffi~~~1t,1g III[] ~ I @!~~~~~ I @!~~mJ!<fo1~~-N IIII[] ~1l {R: m! ~:f6 r ~ @! J (the) #: [i[:f6 M ~ (the concept of something's being 'the' common cause):f6 ~. ~o~~~.nnK~IE~~ 1@!~~~~r~@!J#:[i[:f6M~.gKmJ!<~2~~~o~~~~~~~~~~. ~~~:f6~.{R:m!~:f6r~@!JM~~[i[~~~~~r~@!JM~~mJ!<.~fo1~E~I@~:f6~.{R:m!~. :f6M~o~~@!~~~1I*mJ!<~fo1~.~~~~~{R:E~:f6~~~.-N1 o.~*~~W~;;:f6~~E~.. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ • • ~mJ!<~:f6.~E~r.~JEM~~~~~~~.~@!M~~mJ!<~~. mmJ!<<til';; ~ (![~ *1111 . ~. ~~~~~r.~J:f6M~o-N~~~~~fiffi\~[i[:f6MIEI~mJ!<~~~.g.~~~ffi\~[i[:f6M~~~~~. frt;~i\I @. !l!t1~!!Hf~l-N ~:it 1~1Il ~~<li;;il';;~ (![:it *I mw . -\E.i&,* ~ ~fiJ~i!l.i1lil. .!!IiMI-N~~ $10.

(28) f$mW • :t:~~$I~JI/:IE~jg~.gr<-<~/J:r1~·. ::1~. I ~ -< r--.~:~Hg/J:r1~tW\Ii3~~at:~~:fhill\~mW~@::fhC'-·. ~~~.M.~.N~~~~~~~~~~~~~·~*~~~.~.~~~~~ o iH~~~ ( (1997):26)". 0. \. ~*t!i:$'~~. 0. ~r.!llll~*'$' \ ~~[+o~~J -mItJ • \ ~~ \ ~~~-mItJ$'~-i: • ~III~~ \ ~. ~~ftl~~~It~~~.;:~:¢$'~~\'-· \ ~~*,~~~*t~· ...... ~~ \ ~~*'$'~4r2······~~~ ... ~ \ ~\\I~*'$'~~ ~~(~*, ...... ) ··1~~~~~~. ~~. •. • ~~~. ~ \ 1-<' ~ ~~..J,*,&, ~~ \ -<'$~t!i: \ III~*,$' \ ~ • \o£~-mItJ$~. It~ -<.'*~~.&.~~~~~ ~~~1jf~ • '&'>l':!l~~$'~2~~~~ ~~~~~. 0. .&.>l':!l\\I~*,$'~\ 1~-~\I-<' - -4-mItJ~~~$'~';:t!i:$'~~$'¥ \ $'~~ • ~~.&.~~ [~I\. 0. -<'J :2 .~~~';:Iii:$'~~ 1~1I1~*,$'~ \ ~. 0. ~~~~~o~~~~~~~.-4 • • ~~~. o ~~~~,*~';:t!i:$'~~ • • ';:t!i:$'*-i:.~~~~ ~~~~$'~~~~. I $!111$:~:fh 1~~. 0. )E~,*,~~!#!~~lf,m ll"n.~· ~~~Jl;l;l:1~~~I§~!!l~.. 0. ~~-<~~M~~~~:fhill\~mW~@::fh·~~.~~~iII\~~:fhill\~~~@:g~~·~~~~~~M ~~~~j;)!qI.

(29) :2:~jijijli~ ra9 ~ 11 1: '-' {It. ~)i~~~'. . :±it~~?t\~ JJi ~Ij $It; .. iTQ p~ -"7 J. ~A--'. til. I'iIJ .~ ~ --r o1l~'-:"""'::fh -. ~~~4.fI3to/;. it * iI Ii -tWi*EJ;t1:-t ~ I'i IJ ~g. 1rl. .~. ;If} if.] {fl]. ~ ;I; 13 <f' -. <f' Sg ~ 11§l "f .~ ~ 1i ~~ 1t 1),. it. I!ti N. ,J;j:. ~ -t '~ffii.~tb :l(.fI¥1rl.' 1f"l ~ fI ..1;- 1'- r--IJ:. -t-,~]E'::::' 1 J fft )£ 1t {It 1! ~ eo , 51 iTQ P-1 'ilL. 1. lit. fo. ~ ~. ,. lit. ~~-if.] .. ~ - ffl fOO ~ J~ :: 1I§l;lt~iWfh". 1:Sg~Fit~~. to/;~~O!.tMfh ~I!. i!ti Jtt ' nI ;f... ~~. l' .fI o. 0. "f. '-s-. 1),. ",. if.]. ilL ?l. ~;~t?E;;r. ~~~~~51rJjIi. ,ij:.~:5L~'. 1:. i.~*'ii?it. to/; l], ~q: 1t -=- : ;f.. , .R J.-t fI3 ~ }t-:m:AIl;lf}r--I. -tt..fOOf~~tk~ ~~M1'1f.£ :1r~1I;T:t: ;f~ ~~ :00 ~ ~~~fOOif.]~ if.] ff. N. ~ ·tk ~I:. fo,f 1'.:£ ffi ~ J;t if.] 14- Sg Sg J-j <f' ~. m. -. - ~ li!P B!:j B!:j 5t±:1~' f§.I(!;I,. B!:j. $. ~ ~. * 1f {If'. ~ ~ ~. 0. 920. ~. ft. t§M. ~ ~ ~~ ~. ~~ 1f ;f0 ~ rm B!:j m ~ :X:T7J3i~mfX~?~~ pJT /G ~ IT ~ ~ 1r, ~ - B"J *i. ~ ~ ~ B!:j ~ ~ B!:j '7' B!:j ~ ~ P]' IUl f~ @] . I': '2 ~ fi~ ~ ¥ 'g:. 110. fl§l 1N 00:. ~ ~ ~ ~ {JJ ~. ~. O.e.,. @. X~. mfI§l1~B"J;@1Ul. *-=. ~t. T BfX~=1f @]t)ffI Ii. t:1I! ~ fi fi'3 IDt 'g: ~ Z. ~JttJ. J!m~tt--OJt~/GB"J ,~,. ~ 3j1j. :n 1. 0. fXibfX~B"JM~~fX~. ~iZIJ. @. ~ 1r, .;" ~t B"J ' , 1r, , 9;offl/G~~-~~920~. 1r,. , =. ~. .!::L. ""I:.. l'lt;. "'". :;;. 0. -'-'". lIffii. J;;r. I"J. =. a. '",,". ~. ii"n IIIJ. fX ~t 920 i 920 ' ~~ ~ fX ' 1r ~ lt ~: ~:1't ~ 3i 1r, ftf J -L.' fX ~ fX • ~ ~ ~ ~ 1f 11 1r, B~ 1r, Zt ~ ~ f~ J1;f ~ - At,~' b'-. ~ At, -=U: - =n; ~~ P2~~:.<E ,~7 ~ ~~t. B'J ~ f§ tt ..:" 920 ~ IU - oiffl PIB!:jf.t, ~~~9='M9=' ..I:. PI PI ~, ;f0 fX ' B"J = ' flot: fig fig ,5lt ~fr' fX ~t fi'3 ~ fX tt ~ tE ~ B"J 1r, ~ M ~ 1r, : ! ~ ~ ~t::t ' B"J 110. *~I1B"Jm~~~O~Yffil= ~ IUl ~ ~ • - A ·8 •. ~pgo~-~~~,fi'3 ?£frmIi.m-QfX~/GIi.. !B"J~ib~~1r'fX'@ib ~,t!: tEl ~ ~ fi fX ~ 1r~ t) pJT ; Ii. Z ! B"J 1r, f~ ~ ~ ~ fl pJT !:! tt B"J ¥ 920 fX 1:. lt t) :@ ~ ~t - fX 1r, B"J ~ ~ ~ M ' ~ m 1r, 9;0 ~ ::::- 1:. m 9;0 :1't ' =- .e., ~ ~. I. .e:". ~T1f~.?1Ffi'39='fX*. ~ ~ ~ t.:,. ~. S!:j )jft li!P M B'J 1r, OJ M PI ~ , B"J ~t Ie., /G , 920 fi~ 920 920 - ~ 9=' m. ~. :::::rm~tt~~i7ffil~B"J~ *13. ~t 8!:J ; fX fX 0 ffl ~t 0 ~ ~ ~,. ?1F 1r, 1r,. ~ ~ ~. o 9 o.

(30) (j). ~. 1:. ~. iii. iii ~ (j). . ~. IX. ~. ia. at;. 1fl. ~. *. ~. It *l ~. at; ~. t!. ~. Iiii. ~. -iIi. 00. Jf.l. o. ~I]. 1ft.. ~ ~. ;1f. 't ~. ~51 ~. 1r'l. ¥1J. .i!. fi'J. ~. 1r, fJ i'f pfT. ~ ~. 1& jffi. tm. *~. 1r, ;if'. ;i. rr. ~. 00. f5. ~. 3m, ~. fie:. ~. #. ~. ~. ~. ifJ ~. Z-. ~ ~. "! ~. Z,. ~. 1rJ. :t 1: t£. •. ff. ~. $ 0. ~IJ fit. ~ ftl!~ Jl. 1i: Jf.l fiEJ ~ B'=J ' ~ ~ ~ f1i :tE i'f ftl! !it 'j' 3m B'=J ;i ± tm i§ ~8 ~ :tE *6 ft Z ' -~*~~-,~, EpfTZ -& , ftl! :! B'=J j&1 lfr W tJ pfT ~ ;LfI" Z ~ f- f§li'f 1R ~ tJ :::: fJ. ~ fa' n§ L- Jf.l J.!:1; W~ ~ ~ to ~ ~ B':J ' , ' j' ~ ~ ~ ~ r.o {S f;t ~ -.J ~." l J ~:~ :1E._ "" ~ gill ~ § i3' 1t ~ ;m :!P: ~ ~ , 15 B':J 3m ::. c I1c Jf.l ~ EI3 Wl '£ IDj:, = : ftl!' ~1n~mft!!.7:7fiEJ fr, i'f ~ + :tE J.!:1; B':J ~ fu'; ;if' !!if ' ft - M' }J rz:;j , ~ 0. 0. '*. =. fIE 'j ' lfr J.!:1; ~ ~ ~ ~ fr, ft ~8 ~ ~51 ~ !ZSl j! ~ ~ M' IE ~ -, :;. ~ B':J ~ i'f :~ B':J J ! i :tE ~ ~ :@.!!if ' oii] #t m jffi Jf.l fig J.!:1; {~ ~ L- T fIE'! ,~51~Wl' ffi!i!it@¥ffl ftl! ~ t.¥ ~ ~ lfr *6 3m J:t fr, fiiJ ~IJ i'f po *4 ~IJ :! Jf.l *M'!!if~IE~t> ' :!P: ¥1J ~ fT 'j' ft!!. jI JiJ{ i§ !~B'J1ift B'=J '~~ ~i'fWtQtJ:Ai~~:! t.¥;if'# ~f%~~:®t J ,e:.. ,,,. B'=J jl. *. 0. ~. B'J. ~~. -j! ~ 0. iTO. it i'f. ~ ~. .i!. #. ~;if'. }J. ~. ~ ~. pfT £if.. ~. B':J. Z-. ji. * jffi. ifJ ~. 11;. -*. '*, .", 0. ~fPJ. 1r, ;if' ~-t. rl. .~~. *It '. 'J.!:1;. lIfPJ. B':J;!: Wt j! it lfr. ,1Ft Fa ~51 it ft B'=J M: ~~. 0. ___. AE!.. ~. ~. fP~ ,[!,. f- 'j' *. R ,t..~. *I.l , ~,. 1itBft ftfft:! 'm mlfr' ::t is?. B'J tfI;J ~ ijg ~51!!if ~ :tE ~. *. 0. ~f~flEB'J~t.¥. J'. B':J!it fr,. ±. ,~!it~'*~ 'j' gill ~ , W Wi ft ~ 00: !f.f B'=J Z ~ ~ ~Ij ~IJ ~ fa'. '* gill ft fj§. i'f -, fIE ~. II ~. f-. L-. ~. i§. B'=J. ~ 'j ' ~ ~ ~ ~IJ. iRIi El 'm. :®t ;!:. ~51. J:t. 0. =. *1l ~. t~ ~. 61. .~t. ~ 0. -/{a. *' ~. 1rJ. l. lr.]. 1l ~ }]~. 100 .~t. .. ~ ~. 1rJ. :Yt:. 1: t£ i'J. ~. it l. J.Y. a~ ~. $ 0.

(31) ... ~t.-~~S~~.~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~.~ER~(~~. ... o~~~.~.~~~~~.~. ==c-,j. •• ~~~-r.~. ••E.~o~~W. E.~-~~.~~~N. ~~J).~~~~-~~~~~.~m~~~~~~~~~~~~~-~~~~~ .~.~~~~.~H~-g~~~~. ~~~~~m~~~€.~~.Mo )W~~.~~~~g€~.~~~~~~~.~~~~~K~~~. 0. +Hl!~~~~.M~C'-·g~~~~~ - ~W~~tf,ml)l1aE~~~~.~{1l~:!h'IIQ'lN~4ff~~t4J - fEI~{ll~~~ R!.rn\{ll~N~~ti:!€ •• g,*~~~«r:<ji •• ~:!h'$fnaa - iIfi. - ~~IfJ~\1»({llfL-I§.!I!I~W~,*· .g,*g:!h'D(~W*'llt~~m~ - iIfi. - ~~~~~~~IW.~~MI~:ttl.4N - D(~~~iIfi:gJ)W. (~~~tl1~~~~WQ~) !1!'~W.4Nh'.lli!:!~. 0. ~ItE~m~~~~~iIfi~)om~W~~E~,*-~~~~~~~~~~•• w~~.m~~:!h'.~~m E~~:ttl~~~$!n~. 0. Wltrd-J;><~. ~ •• ;m.~.~:fI\!jHllK~~ ~~:ttl~$!!l~aa - tl1~~W~EfljqIW-J;><11fDt "On the Very Idea of a Concep - ~ •• fr:;~W - ) m)~~~~ ) :gJ)~l!!~.~-Y~~"*~~~ - ~. tual Scheme" ((1974))~. ~~~~~.~~~~.~~m~~~~~o~ •• ~g€.~mw~~~.~~E.~~C'-·. 0. ~~-t.~)W.~~~~.~~m~W~~~IIQfL--~~~~~~~~.~~m~.m~~~~ ~:H;'.~~m. iI!R ) I@I~IIQ~ - ~:!h'~~~lIll~~.\~~~~~~~W·-)IH.{j!jIE~~~ - ~;m~~;;:!h'~~WQ •• ~oji •• ~-rIWlli!:!~~~.~~m~~~ o MIW.~E~~. ~:!h'~~~~~~~.~W~.

(32) ~. 0. 0. l!lR11@1~1H~~' ~:ffi'-t<fIfn~!/(IQ~~~·~~~!Il;;~~:ffi'!/(Ig4N~~I\II!!!~-N~· -gjrn:j~~-y. I @1~:E~~. • ~~+<lfjg~~~~~,~~(I1f;~${ff%:Eif,lg.(O' • ~~~W!;!!!\I1P({lJ~~(I1f;g:ffi'({Dffi~ • ~-N~~n • ~ilCffil:~ 1 J ((1974):187) {Dffii\~ • ii~~:ffi'!I!'~:le<I1it~~$Pt! 1@1111Diil@~:ffi'lt.IgI11I[J\ii':;j. @.:E~~~iffif'-.. ~.j!*~~:ffi'!/(Ig4N. ~~~~W~~·~~~~-t<fIfn~!/(Ig4N~~~·~~~~~~~~!/(Ig4No~#~ili~~~·~.I@.4N. I {W~@l~H!~~~~.4N~. ··D~~~~~W~~ll*~!Il;;~.4N~mfL- • ~~~l@.4N~.tr~-t<ftfa. ~.~~~~~~!Il;;~.4N5.~~E!/(Ig4N·~~~~~~~~!Il;;~~~~.4N·~~~~.~@.4N5 .~. ~~4N·~~~~.~@.4N5.~~~I.~~~~.4N~mo~~.-gj~~~I@.4N~m\ii':;j~~. 0. 0. • ~ ••. ~~,\il~~. • ilf:m\.JIJ~~j!~~~· . ~=llt~~~~ • ~~-t<. the Very Idea of a Conceptual Scheme" tr • ifm\.tHl!Ill\~<li;~l!lR 11 ~1~~fL-~.~.4N:IllB. m1~l!lR 1 ~1~~fL-~.~.4N:IllB1BIK. W "On. ((1974): 184). ~~g::fh'~~~~~' ~mWi~h~~~~III(.lI1l+<iffia!z!j~~~l£~~~~H~~~~jM1ftlE~~m\:fb'Ia':\lM ~. HIIK. ~~~~4N~~~·-gj~~~~4Ne~~m·~~·~~.m~~_~.~~-N~\ii'~~~~~~!/(Ig4N··. ~.·~~\ii'~~Wl!lRI~~~fL-~.~.4N:IllBHllKoili~·ilf:m\.~.~~*~~r~~!/(Ig4NJ~r~~. ~~~~!/(Ig4N~J~~@.4N~~I~~o~~~:;j~.~5m~~I@!/(Ig4N~·~.·r~~!/(Ig4NJ~. r<~~~~~.4N~.J~~@.4N~~~I~~o~ •• ~.~~~~~~~~~~~.~~~~.. !1!1~~I~~IH~-gj~~~~·. 1@ffiK~~.~~~E.4N5.tr. 0. 4N~_'~~~~~-N~~_~~~~!/(Ig4N'~~.~~~~-N~~_~~~~!/(Ig~.~~~~~~_~. 0. -N~~~~.4N~m-ti:!G::I!I~:ffi'.4N~m ··IH!ItI~ · . ~~W~~!/(Ig4N:ffi'!/(Ig~~ l!lRll~I~~fL-E.~.4N:IllBHIIK~~~liI:ffi'. ===.

(33) ibtl!!Q4f-! . W~~~*+<:tfo(~~~~ib 0. ••. --Y .. ~it~~. 1!!I$ • {ll·:~lf«I{W!I!lm 1~. 0. =='<t". t~!HDE+t1~~ 11 ~11\I~HI1 ,jL. ib.~.4f-!*.ib~~~ib~~.W.~·~~~~ib.4f-!~~~~~~~~~'~.'*~~~~ib.. ~*:fbH.·~~~~~~.~~~W€.~~~~·~~~~~.~~~~~~~~ibtl!!Q4f-!·M~·~. 0. ~~~~~tfilw!~W€:fbW!~~~IE1«r{W{ll-!EI(!lfH!~4r~~m~~~ibffi~~J ' ~4f-!' ~w!~:fb.~~lI* {II/II 1@l~{IT]nJ.~~[j[ib!tH~~mMr . ~~~=l*~~1l*{IT]nJ:fb.4r~~m '.~=l*~1l*t--..:fb~~ ~~~f@I~rn:::. ~.1«r~~~~~:fb~~~oW~.:fb~~jL-·r 1.~~~.~~[j[ib.4f-!~m%ib~4f-!·W~~~*. +<:tfo~~~~ibJ~@l.~~~.~@l~~··I~~·~.~~~~1l*{IT]nJ:fb.4f-!~m·~~~.~~~. 1@l.~~[j[ib.4f-!~mo 1@ltl!!Q4f-!:fb~{w·~~~~~~~Wib.4f-!~m%ib.4f-!~~~~·!EI~·~. .~~~~1l*{IT]~:fb.4f-!Bm·~~~.~~{wl@l.~~[j[:fb.~~m%:fbtl!!Q~·~IE.~~I~~~. ~~~~:fb~~orn:::l~~·~.~~~1l*{IT]nJ:fb.~B~·IE~~~I@l.~~[j[:fb.~~~·~~~. ~~. +t1~~11ll!!tIIP~ffi~jL-:fb.~.4r~*.:fb@~~!!lW· ~~~~. 1•. ~~~~~ 1@l~~~. . ~~~,~~I@.:~!I!lm:gJ]~~~~!1r+WJ:l:H:fb+<:tfo(~tl!!Q4f-!1E~2~,~*~{1l. ~~~[j[t--.~@l~:fb.4f-!~~%:fb.~~~~~.~~~~~~{w~%:fb~4f-!o~lE· 1~~~~~t--.l. 0. @l.~~[j[:fb.4r~B~%:fb.4r~~~~~. ~~~:/;%:fb. 1@l~~ . ~~ 1@l.~~m~~iW\ 1@lltmIIIlQ~ 1 $S!/l;. .~~I@.::fb.4f-!~m%:fbtl!!Q~W~~~*+<:tfo~~~~:fbo iHI~~~~~ 11 ~1~ffi~jL-:fb.~.4rq*ffilK:fb~. ~~~~.:fb~~o~~~M~~~~~.~ib·~~·~.~~~~~~~a~HI1~~~~:fb!/l;~~~. 1{wMl~--Y~~~tlp(!l!'m@l~~. 0. {IT]~~. ~it~~~IIIIQ·. I. ~~iIi:W~. 1@l.~~I@.::fb. ~:fb.~·~§·HI1~[~~~@~~:fbHl1~~~~.~~~.~~*~~~~~N~.·~~~~~~. {¢ .• ~~. ~~W.

(34) .~~~J~@~.-~~.~~~~~@~.-r~~~~.l@~~-~~~~~E~~~~~~~. ~~lffi"I@~. *~E~~-~~.~~S-~~-~I@~~~~~~.m~~~~.MJ~@~. o ~~~~~-~. liI!\ I @!~~W;~mrK~~~~~~f;!3~E~~ - o(~~~lm§~~~Wf.E-:$H*~~E.4rqfi~~ .. ~.~%E~~~~~·~~~~~lffi"I@~~~~~~f.E-~I.llif.E-~E~~fi~ o ~~~~~I@!~~. .~~~~II@~~~lm~~~~.M~~~·lffi".~~~.lli f.E- ~~~~.~~~~-~~~~~*. ~-N . . ~liI!\ 11@!t.!gllllamrK~~~~~~!t.mlllla~2:1i:1~MElfflg~· o(~~~~.M~~~:lb!t.1glllia . ~~~!t.1gI1Ila~m!iDill ~~-*~~lffi"I@~~:lb~~~~~-lffi".-~~~~~-lffi"I@E~~~f.E-~I@~~~.m~~~~ • • ~~~ o ~~m~~-~W~~~.Mf.E-~ I ~~~IE~~ •• -~~f.E-~IE~~I~~:lb~M (:>< ~~~>-*~)*~-N - ~~~!t.1glllla:><:lbmliDill!!~(.~~ . !t.1glllia ~~~~!t.1gI1Ila>-~!t.1gllll~lR:wg~!t.1gI1Ila:><. :><2~I~g:><W~.~I~'lR:wg.~~.mrK~~~*:lbE~)*~-No.~~-N-~W~~~ •• ~. \ *~~~:l&'~~~$-<:l&'. ·~*Wt!*%:l&'~~I+~"'IIf¥~:l&'~+tl~~~~ - ~~t!*%:l&'~~~. 0. ~~ - +tHl~jj!Rll@I~~fL-:lb.lli~4rq:\tl!lIlllK:lbl$\~~~~E-t+l~ - Ia'~*~~ r II@~g4+l~~~~~f.E-~ .M:lb!t.1gI1Ila~Ia'~~ J - t\~~!I!I~P-:l~~ilH~-li~Il2i~E· ~~~nnJ~~·· II@~g4+l~~~~:lb~~ ••E!t.1g IllIa - ~ 11@f.E- I ~~~~ ~~-li~( (1974):185-6)··. ~. 1+~.~~"'IIf o ~*~~*:l&'-¥~~~~.~~-~*-w~*%:l&'~al+~~¥~:l&'.~~~~\. ~.~-~~-~~I+~*~~~ o .~-~.:l&'~~I+~~-<~~-OO"'llf~4*r~"'IIf¥~:l&'.~~.

(35) ~~tJ~~it ~-~*~s!;J ~,~,. ~ ~ ~. 1m~~$;~M §®;t~tf~~S!;J. $f!JfoE!a1t. ~~~.~~m fr' 1m ~ *1 tJ - s!;J ;tk • ~ ir, ~. ~WJ~FPI § 0 ~&i~~17JJRL-*' -~~tJZ{!!~JIt/G' ~~ 0 ~~ 1'1' ~1J1lM~~D17JJPI~D-~ftl!.~1IEI. PImPI~tf· fiiJ~in*PIir';ffi-.~;fij tJ ~ tJ ~ tE ~ ~ /G ~ ~ ~ f~ ~ *1 ~. 1J1l~1J1l~-{~~llJs!;J®t8~tJ~~ ffl ir, ~1f ~ 1IEI foEJ ~ tJ ~ xE EI E T s'3 {t ?IE PI ~ ~ P'J ~ ~ in § T ~ ~ 71J ~;fij ~ ~tJ~®tE~1i~~;tk~-~~ ? .ilm~s'3s'3{t~s'3PI17JJ § ~~~. ~ ~IJ A t~ m~ ~ i~ 0 ~g ~ s'3 § jj .~ *1 ~ ~ ® Ilt ~ IJIP, ~ s!;J - ta • ¥IJ 0 ~ fBi~s'3. m *6 ~. oo?. ~. ~ IJIP, *1lt~7tT?. !iffi. ffij §. 0: ·:ft:'MtE. ~D~NWJ~tl. JIt 1IEI !tIJ ;f.6 ir, ~ *1 • ~/GPI1mt8~. ~§~tJ~~ta~. ~F. g:t ;tk s'3. ~ ~. 1J1l ~ ~ 1IEI ffM !': tE ~. ¥!.J--~. ••. ~. PI~i~EBIUl*ls!;J. ~ ~ - 1R ~ ~ ffl1:i]~mitt~R *&:'WJ@;!Jf-~{t ~~~~s'3g:t~. tJ. itt !Jf-. !!. ~ 0 pJT ~ ~ ~ ,E,. {'F~tE~·. s'3 ~ foE! g:t. ~.. •. ~~~~~~D. t~ ir, 1IEI *1 fiiJ ~tE El ~~ ~m·~~;ffi-~ ®mll4~ 0 ~. ~ ~ fie ..l. § N T~~&:,7t~{~ /G®fr'~' T/G - ~ ~ ~ ftl!. lID PI. m § M·. fZ T $: -. ~ ~. in. ~E~~g{~~. #'*~t~~~t8. m. ~iJ ~ ill $: 1m ..l.{~ 0 • : § ~~~~/f-" WPI § ~~~~. • :. ~. T. tJ. ! .. ~ ft. ;tk 1IEI /G. ~ ~ ~. s'3Wir, ~~~ tal; tJ~D$7t~ 0. i!l!;#-Jlt, T~ • ~p ~ • -fu M ~ # ' § ~-tl~p ~ $; ir, ~ ~ {~ , i~ ~ PI ~ fB IUl. --,. -9;0. ;It.. *~. ~. ;tk. t8 0. ~. @ PI. ~.. ~. tJ~. 17JJ~~m~E · § .~~~. JIt Z s!;J ¥!.J' 0. ~ ~D •. -. ~. fr, . ~PJT{~. ~. * *1 fr,. in PI. ~, ~. ?. 1Y ~ ~ ~. O,e., @. x$f;. ~~. *~. - L. NiIZ!l. ;It. 1;. 100. ff.]. Jl'.. 100 JIll. ~t. ~M. @. :A.. ~. :lXllt. :f~. ~. it ff.] ~ lJt ;It. ff.]---. *. •. :f~. ~*. ~. :if. lti!. f)... -. 0. f~. ~ ~. 100. if: 100 ff.]1l:. J.t. tE ~ JJJ. ~ N ~!;J ~. D. o. tfinPI$;~~ta. ~IJ ~ ~. ~ ~ ~. -t-~. ,~t ~ ~ff.]. ~PJT/f~17JJ~t8. !Jf- /f ~, s!;J. ;RL jJ it. ftl!. 1IEI /G PI~~;ffi-. fZ. -~. S!;J*iiE' ~. ~ta~Ditt~~~. ff.]~. lfFil. :b .,. o. 1; •. it. 100. Jl'.. ~ ~. ~. o. ll}j. o 9 6.

(36) ~~~~EI~~~(~~)~~.&~~~~~~-~~-~~~.~I.~~ o ~.~~~~-g~. 1• • 4r~~~ -. ~'*'~~~{~~-<to~~~;Jit;%g:fb!!!4r~"-11. '. ~~W€.~~:§.~~. I .!t.1g11I1[]. .~~.~N~~W*I.KW~.~o~~@~I~~~~~~~~.~~""1 ,~~W€.~~~. ~~ ~,*,~~.:fb.BW~:§:§~W~;Jit;%~~ o. -. It\~ ~m;~~i :i11W~~M{IJJrlJ:fb.~~~~~~!I!I~~11!!!~. 0. ~~. -. ~~~.:i11~,~. ~~:§lt.!gI1I1[]*tltl@:~!I~@. ~~ I .-<.~~~~~:fb.W~~:fb.~~~-~~-~.-<~~~~~~~@.~~~~~~~ fifa(~~g:fb!!!~. ~~~:§~i~td!I~@~~" "!I!I~@lt.!glll1[]~~mlb!. 1 @:fa;lI.tE:§W!!!J!g~:fblt.!gllll[] -. -. 0. ~~. .4r~~~ !1!1~~1I:§1~dlt.!gI1I1[]W!!!J!:E:fbg~. -. ~~~i :i11W~~~. I ~mlb! 1 @~~W!!!J!g~:fblt.!g lllm ( Mil( - ~~~~{~~ I @. ~~mlb!-~~~:fa;l~W*I@e~[]-~~~~~@e.~~w!!!J!~~-~~~:fbe.~.:i11~.~@ It.!glll1[]C'-".~lfJtil.\$!nIj~mlb!. - ~~~%V~:I1IID~1'--llII:~I.tE~!t.1gI1I1[]:fbg~.<iNC'-" J ( (1974):. e~ ) -~~.~~~~~.:i11a~~~~~~~~o. jjf~lf~""1 ~t:l~~~[~8!]:fb.<iN. 0. il~lfffii~~. -. ~t:l~~. [~8!] !1!1~@.~. -. ~~4t1lt\~~~:i11*~llII:~I.tE~!t.1gllll[]:fbg~.. l~)~~~I.tE~e.:fbS~.~-~mlb!I.tE*~~e.:fbe~:fbg:fb.~-M.~~~~~~I~~~J !1!1~@~~:fb.<iN. <iNo~~lfl.tE:§B~~~:fb~~-.mlb!~I.tE:§~~I@.~~~:fb.<iN~~:fb~:fa;l~:fb~~ o. W~ f§!I~~@§ili.:ib~~1l- - ~~lf*!!!J!:E~~$U~" ". =0><:-.

(37) 14= ~ ~iiJ • . _ RJ. ~ Ii "& {I ift •. ~ ~ ~ ~ 1N fj§~~~~1'JJ.~ ~it:f:A 0 RJirr~ it ~ ~ tJ Ai j!!! ~ ttQ. ::t ::t; tJ. a~ttQT~!R.~'. fr, § ii ~ B9 B9 ffl •. • )§: ttQ ~ fit !6 {Ff ttQ 1f. J:ti:-~*I~fflflJ.. JJ. ~ ~ ~ for ~ l ' *1 ~$Z~~lfij~lfij~!lJ~ &iiJ *- -E- a! pt )§: ~ , ~~~B~? 1I1!R.1l f':'it~IUl't:~ttQJJ.. fl~~a~~~i¥ 1i] ~ ~o · ~ ~ ii Iiir *13 .~ for ffij ~~ ---,. !fu. 0. m;i. 0 ~lL;J! ~~~::t;ffl~~R - fr, fr, ~ m 1't. 1.1. *.. B~ B~ it !X !l 111 --r:. ~~~-f-F:JJ.m:~. 1i] JJ. l:f 111 IIJE.. ?. ; -.fj-. ;-,jt. ~ ='=1. ~ ='=1. iiPJ. iiPJ. 1j. fi§ 1ft.. i¥ Jt ~ 411!:. ~ B~ "" ~. 0. Il<!;.. 1'1'. fr,. J;t ~ ,'iiil. m: RJ 5J1j l:f. B~RJ~~j!!!~m: 7i-tJ~f§~ff~ ~ ff ~ J;t ttQ :f: ~o o. ~1i]~{~B~for. {!!f!lB9~ffl~~. ttQ ~ " ii i ~ffl. fr, ~ it ~. ~~~ J!- ~::t; rm§~ tt B~ it ~~~ ~. B~. 1i] fr,. 'B~. ?. '. ---,. ,. {Ff. ~ lit ffl ~'*l'-----' ~ ~ ~. -PJT~ fIE! ~ ~ ~B9B9. 4~~----~~q.~. ~ J.! :.t. 1Y. -t.. ~ . ~ *-mJ-.r.t""'..,\'ft_. =± tlJc.,. it.]. 5.·J. 1rl ~ 11i. ft. Je. '-'. -z. f~~mt. L-~tJ. §. ~. L. ••. ~.fe.. J. ~ ~ ©. x1!t. *-=.. ~t ~11!l. .J.JJ. ©. *. !. ~ f~ 1l:i ff ~ ft "': 3~ f~. '71...... 5.'J •. *l- ~ s k ,~ lit ff. __ 1;\ ~ ~~ e. it.] f).. 5J,i M - ~ 11::. it.] ~ • ~ f~ 1M: it.] - 1l f~ ----. At. it ~ ---- J~. -z. ,. ,.J'J ... f~ ~ft~fl ~ .... ~.f ~ ~,. f~~j,._-~.ftbtfF ffi ,~ i!. $ ~ Z :i! ~. *. "*. k '-' :tJi K.. : ~ - >'t j,. ~ it Jl. ~ i!. f~ • , {~ ,'.6 ff jz 't ~ t"'" J.! R~ ~ 0 it.] J.! .~ ..( tf J.! 1~. Jl~BX.~~/f-,~~. f.-'" ~ ~ -* k 1'-$. *l-~0. f,t ~. 1i-. B~. -lJi 1t. ;. L. ~ fr'l .fe. ;ft it.] Jl.. ~. -z. ~ $ ---, . lJi. /f- ~" ~ J.! .{t -/CO ~ ---- • k ~ _ _ ~f"T1l.4~~f~$ 1r'1 it .f. /J.J .{t:X. ~ it.] 'f f( - ~ ~ , ' :; ;~ f).. m f~ /f- 'f fl·J ~ ~ ~ it.] ~ fit f).. '0' J?i.. 0 '" -;t 1rl :t<. .tt. a;J : :J--h ~ 1l f1 ~ It ~ J< -X O 71 6) _ .. l!. f).. *- it.] e-.JI#.bJ.-,,-, ~L._ ,~ -~ ~'J if.:X. k J.! /l.. ~ '~'mtf J.!,;t. 1i- -/c'o -t - ~ ~ *' 11::. J.! *-L-f~ : -:X. ~ J • - -t P~ ~ f~ , ,;I; it. $~ ~ J.! ff ~ ~. ~, iQ ~ ~itJJ.. $~. ~ ff -/co '0 J.!f(ll~*-~,. .. ... '-'. fr" Ai 1k[]1'i* ~ {!Ii j(i. e.. 1l. .~ f~ 0 -/c'o ft ~. lit. .... i! · il. .... J~ it.]. ifJ. .it>. it.]. '0.. ~. tt :. . ~5.'J. fl·J f)... ,. _. ~~. s f~ • ~ Jl. ~ G ff 6). 5.1 _ ft ---- J.! :.t .. $ fl::. ~ .fe. ~ ~ o ~ J 'f -t.. ;. * * r£. iii '. it.]. o 9 8.

(38) @. 1: Ii Ii ~ @. . ~. &. ~. •. •* tt-J 111. ".. IX *I ~. tt-J. ~ ~ ~. •. ~. /f'. .~Q. m-. *. fr,. ~. 0. fiJT~. c~ (1). zB'J. rep~~. ''0. El *l. L-Jl.*. ~-'fX. fJ... (fl". ... S. (ii '. J.!.. G. C. -?t.o. ~. '0_. ~. M. ~ ~r2.. fffi ~ fr, /f'!ffi WI: ~t IlT pI:) fj; (i;. ~. m. ~~. gii) M B'J Jt!?, 7i-'. ~ ~o. "*. ~O'. JIt. ,,f®. fX*. ~! jffi. '*. ~ 7t JtiJ. ~ 1:: ~ /f' I'l~ ~ ~ ~. fXfX. !. -icc fi-] flf]. p. ~ ~. ,fD ~M~fX 0. ~ ~t 1l]. fr,. ~S~15~t. ~ii) ~. IDt B'J:9C' 7i- X Jt ~ iTI X1t ! ~ *l $. -. 't B'J IlT fl§ 7i. ~ ~ ~ fffi B'J 0. Jt!?, ~ ;;; ~. ~*l<=lj,"'". ~~'~. B'J . ~ii) ~. tJ m. lim ffl' m- 't. ~. ~~f~~. 5t. ~ ~ii). mt iTI. 1lT'. ~. Z 1f3 ~. =!'t in B'J rep :t:. B'J~f®Jt fiJT' ~m. fj;~ ~fiJT. o. $ ' fiJT B'J. ~. ~tI'=J Et-J~. ~~. JlIJ ~ fi-]. *- ~ , #.. ~~'. fiJT ~. fr,. P f@ ii]. ~~~~. ~ B'J ~ # in ~ ~F IlP. fr, . ;f~. ifQ'~. f®Mf~~. -. B} m. ~,. ~. -,-~. m:t: '-' ,. ~,. z, '-'s. ~~B'J~. B'J. ~. 'f~. 9 9. ~. fX~. ~ . o. *B'J ~. :t:~-,. ~H:tJ~ ~fXS't. •. fr,. Jt. H: IlT. *. tJ. fJ"lJ ~ X fj;. ~ rep 1£ 1l!lI~~Jt!?,. fiJT. 5:E . ~ii). r B'J. (fl" . ~. (ii'. ffl. Ps. ~. fi Jt. ? ~fiJT~~. {I}~iTIjf~tE. ~ f t ~ ~ ~ ~. fXm· ft~f! fr, ? fX ~ ~o . 't fr, .:. [oJ ~ ~ 5Z. ::t ili ~ fr,. * ~. ffi. :'e PI f® ~ IlJ m tJ 1ft ffl tJ. lUl~itifi~ff. fX • ~ 11, ill 51 fr, JtE jf !ffi ~ X 7t ;w WI ~ ft : ~f~!.s~ B'J. 4Br. fX. *13. B'J 8"1 fi ~. J8.. 8"1 ~. ;#... $ fr, f£ 1ft *IE. *-~"* L J.!. -t. i~-N!tE. /f-. fr, ~. '. L. k4t-F#... ~. tf. J:,Q ~'fi-]. fX~f!~~ 8'J. ~: * PJ : ~* f,.,. .ii). ~ tJ. L0. 7\ *IE. ii.\l. m. JlIJ J.!. -,LJ.!. P ~ ~. ~~~~~ ~:t:~~\ji ~ii) ~ fX IDt ~ ~ JtE fr, B'J i[j. JlIJ ~ ~~. ~ffltJ.. ,. -icc •. *-. L-. ~. .)/.;. fJ... •. ~~. ~. - ,. i. S. ,,.. ~. tfL-'. -k'"""". flf] fJ.. t~. f.t -. J.!!.. :t fi-]f.t~. ~lIPI~:t: 0. !m-iti~~ J'~ ~ 11: ~ifB *IE lI~JtE~~ ffl 'P] ;W Wt. fr,. m-o~Jt· -{§.;\tfj;-' f~·. {@~\ji. S flf]. W:~~m:~. Cfl S 1f fi-] f@. /f' -, IlT ~o :t:. L. iTIfi~1Bi~. *- ta$ ~.t- l!.. tf. ~*-fi-] ~.t-. zo~~"*. ~M'P]~i[j. llTJ'&tJfiiJJ!. ~@:~~1t. B'J jf ~. 'P]. L-. B'J. fr,. ffl T. ~. 1& fr,. B'J B'J. fX.

(39) -00. 1~.~g~~~~E~.EE~og~-~~~~~~~~.[l~.~K~~~~EE~~~.~o. ~11. 0. - ~~~~nnK~~~.~~m:fb'~~~~~E~~.~ 1~.4r~~m:fb'~~. •• -~~~~W~.~~-~~~~ •• ~.~~~~E~~~. ~~~E~~~~~~~~~o~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.~g€~~~. 0. [~ I E~E.$.~o~~~~~~. 1~nnK~~E~~~.. •••~E~~og~gg~~.~~E-~~~~.~I~~~. .~-~~~~*~~K~~~:fb'~.~.~.~:fb'~~EH~o~~~~~~~~~:fb'.~.~-~~ ~~~~~~:fb'~~*~~~~~.~. E.~-=.~~~~~.~~E~.~.-~~I~e.~.~~~.W€I~.~.Eo~~~-nnK. ~~f@:.~~m:fb'~ - 1M~~~~:fb'~~.~lj!f:~·++1~.~.~:!tI1l~:fb~~.~~~~\1J>(!I~'~~E~~ ••~-W€E.~~~~m~~E~~~~~-~~-W€~.~~I~~~.~*R~. Eo~~~~. - ~~~nm1¥$ - ~~~~.~ElIt:~~MI~~. S~E~.o~~~~.~~-~~.~.~~~.~~mE~-~~.~~~E~~~~~~-~~~ R~Ell!JI!~~~~~Eo .~~!I~'~:£iII~~~~fMElj!f:~·W"Rational Animals"~. :fb'.~-~~w~.:fb'~m~M~og~~~gE-=.-~~W~.~~~~.:fb'~~-~~~MI~~. ~.~~~~~.~~~og~~~.E-W€.~E.~~~~~~~~~:fb'o. #lim!+-. .. I@~g~~~. ••••• ·W~~~~$.~~~.. •••~~~~.g~~W~ •• ,~~,.~.~~~g~~·~~,~~~~~~g.~o~~.. IIII[[~. 8~. ~.~~g.~·~~.@g~~·a~.~.~~@g~~$.~(ilie).~o.

(40) S@~.(~u~)~~~~~~~-~~~~~.~~~~~.I~~~mo.~~~-~."~~~~~~.@rn~~. 0. 0. W~• • ~. !I!I~~~W~~~+<Ul\KjIIj(.w. 0. (mlli~,~ • •. (I963)1l-@;to;;;j\,I!j~!I~l@~~. ti:l@:~$!O(~~~~~~l*I€JK-O(~~.~~'-~o(~~.~. ( 1985d ) : 87·89. ( ( 1985b): 475) ~. 0. 0. ~~~.~.~~e~~.~1l@~.~I1~.~-.~. 1 ~iljqI~~-p<. "Actions, Reasons, and Causes". - ~W !i.i~~ -. €~~~~~~*~.~~~€~~~ o ~~~~• • ~~~-~~~~~~~~~~~E~~~~~-~~~~~N~ ~l¢WiljqI!II#!.~~ ~~~l@l*I€J~K-o(~~~:;~. WilKa~M~~~l1 o. _ ~~4[]l*+<1+1~-S~.~. 8 • • ~-~~K-~.~I.~~.~-~~~.~~.E.~ o ~. ( 1977) :146; (1985b ): 475. 1982 ) , [1985a] ~ ( 1985c ) 1l-;to;;~~Hlt,!"'#i;I'tti~~~~Ia'Wil~~11. 6~m,Ili*HN'>~ • • @~ • • W (. i!h~. -. 0. ~• •. - ( 1989 ) -. 1 95~. ( 1991a ) - 200. 0. ~ • • ~K-~~. - ~~E{+w::~!t1g~~~~\w;ifl!!l!;l!!\:~!"tl.J>(~~{l.l. 0*tiiN~~rIN~~-p<{+~~*" < !t.mlll1n' ~rINmJ:~ • • :ll;'lll$::~.\!l~> (~~~~+<.~l*,~~ / ~K~' !!l{~ < +~~. -. 1 m:::)N~H:jl& @Hl~*. ~~Ia'~~. 0. ~~,~~~:Ij[]:r.a~~ - ~~I~~~~E-K" fi><. - ~.K-~~ii\i!lf\~ - I ~~Ia'~l!fl~lll!!%tH~Etf.l. - ~ • • Ell l $::;re).\!l1tf~~NI1\l1~£IR~ ~~(~!t1glll1n)mJ:~~NJ!I!Ii~E 1 ~lIat~~f;IE·-.I~ln. ~~~~E.~-e~-@~~-r~~E~~~._\w;~~~I$!~.J-~~~m~~~~ifl!!l.E~~~~o( • •. • - ( 1987) - 450). 0. N - ~ • • ~lll$::~.'lt~~rINI1\l1~£~'req~!I.1g~ln~!t1g~~f;IE e!I!I~w~ • • I~IIT~jIIj(.1'--. ~o~~-~~~W~E~E-W~ • • ~i!h~1l--~l@~~~~~E~-~~~K-Wil~ii\~E~~~"~~~~l. ~ o e~~$!-S~I1~K- • • ~ • • ~~.~E~~ o. -=.

(41) • 200 0. 0. • 159 0 • 201. ( 1997 ) • 23 0. .. i'i~*lt. (1982 ) • 478-80~ ( 1991c ) • 161-2. @~*' . i'i~IHit· ( 1991a) @~*' . i'i~*It. ( 1991b ) . i'i~*It. ( 1991a ) ®~*' ~.g. . •~*It.. ©m,llinD; • ~$*,. Davidson, Donald. 0. - - (1963) . "Actions, Reasons, and Causes", reprinted in Davidson, 1980, pp. 3-19. - - ( 1970). "Mental Events", reprinted in Davidson, 1980, pp. 207-27. - -( 1973) . "Psychology as Philosophy", reprinted in Davidson 1980, pp. 229-244.. -="". - -(1974) . "On the Very Idea of a Conceptual Scheme", reprinted in Davidson 1984, pp.183-98. - - (1975). "Thought and Talk", reprinted in Davidson 1984, pp. 155-70.. - -( 1977) . "The Method of Truth in Metaphysics", reprinted in Davidson 1980, pp. 199-214. - - ( 1980) . Essays on Actions and Events. Oxford: Clarendon Press.. - - (1982). "Paradoxes of Irrationality", in Richard Wollheim & James Hopkins (eds.), Philosophical. - ( 1984). Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.. Essays on Freud, pp. 289-305. Cambridge: University Press.. -.

(42) - - (1985a). "Deception and Division", reprinted in E. LePore & B.P. McLaughlin (eds. ), Actions and. Events: Perspectives on The Philosophy of Donald Davidson, pp. 138-48. Oxford: Basil Blackwell 1985.. ~- (1985b) . "Rational Animals", reprinted in E. LePore & B.P. McLaughlin (eds.), 1985, pp. 437-80.. - - ( 1985c). "Incoherence and Irrationality". Dialectica, 39, pp. 345-54.. - - (1985d) . "A New Basis for Decision Theory", Theory and Decision, 18, pp. 87-98.. - -(1989). "The Conditions of Thought", reprinted in J. Brandl & W.L. Gombocz (Eds. ), The Mind. of Donald Davidson. Grazer Philosophische Studien, 36, Amsterdam: Rodopi, 1989, pp.193-200.. - - ( 1991a). "Epistemology Externalized", Dialectica, 1991,45, pp. 199-202.. - - (1991b ). "Three Varieties of Knowledge", in P.A Griffiths (ed.), AJ. Ayer: Memorial Essays.. Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement: 30, MA: Cambridge University Press, 1991, pp.153-66.. - - (1992) . "The Second Person", in P.A French. T.E. Uehling jr., H.K. Wettstein (eds.), Midwest. Studies in Philosophy 16, Indiana: University of Notre Dame Press, 1992, pp. 256-67.. - - (1993) . "Replies to seventeen essays", in R. Stoecker (ed.), Reflecting Davidson. Berlin; New. - (1996) . "Subjective, Intersubjective, Objective", in P. Coates & D.D. Hutto (eds.), Current Issues. York: de Gruyter, 1993. -. in Idealism. Bristol: The Thoemmes Press, 1996, pp. 155-77.. --(1997). "Seeing Through Language", J. Preston (ed.), Thought and Language. Cambridge: Cam. bridge University Press, 1997, pp. 15-27. (Proceedings of the 1996 Conference of the Royal Institute of Philosophy. ). -==.

(43)