!
!
!
!
"
"
"
"
#
#
#
#
dewlin159@yahoo.com.tw
(TBRI) ! " # $% &' ( )*+(KSAT) , - . / 0123 45 6 789 : / 0 1;< 3 4=> ? @A B CD E F G H I 3 45 6 JKLM N O " P Q 1. RST 1J9 U - ? T V WX70YZJ [ = \ ]=^]=_` a bcdJe f60YZ[ g h i bcdJefX 2. H j ;k +8c;lm8n o p I J3 4 =q=_Jr s 7t A B 97Zu v " w 3 4=? x y KL- ? zI A B LP X 3. u v k +8{x l3=_J3 4=5 6 |=_Jr s A B 137}~ bX Q$% &' *+]3 4=]Abstract
In this research, a hybrid method of computerized adaptive test and individual remedial instruction is proposed. The computerized adaptive testing algorithm is based on students’ item structure and the individual remedial instruction is designed by experts’ knowledge structure and students’ item structure. Computerized adaptive test is first administrated for diagnosing individual student’s learning profile. Based on this profile, the adaptive individual remedial instruction process is constructed and administrated. The difference of pre-test and post-test shows that the proposed method can help students to improve their learning situations.
Keywords: computerized adaptive test, individual
remedial instruction, factor and multiple
1.
1.1
&' ] J= ; *+J J O" w $% J&' ( )*+ * ] J / 01J=a =1 / 01J=a ] J3 4 ¡=1A ¢ ? L£ J3 4=¤ N J¥ ¦ X § ! " # J =_A ¢ $% &' *+q RS ( )¨ ©ª 0 J«O¬ ® Z¬ A ¢ 3 4 = ¯ ° ±? LJ² ³ =_A ¢ ¬ ´ µX qCD E H I J3 4=5 6 JKLX1.2
¶Z· ¥ J¸OQ 1.¹ º X 2.» + &' 3 4=KLX 3.¼ ½ F G H I &' 3 4=5 6 KLX2.
!
!
!
!
"
"
"
"
; ! " # J$% &' * +(KSAT) , - D E T (TBRI)l¶3 4=JK L¾ ¿ 7 À KSAT] Á Â ]TBRI7Ã Ä Å D E X2.1
KSAT
2.1.1
(knowledge structure)
! " #Æ 7 ÇÈ ! " #]=_ ! " #3 4= ! " #X ÇÈ ! " #;«g =É ÇÈ RS= Ê j =n +7Ë *Ì Í Á ! ¬ Î RS=_J=a Ï Ð ]¬ Ñ ÒÓ Ô¬ JZ OÕ Ö× Ê > KJ" #Õ Ö[15]X =_ ! " #c=_0^" #;Ø ÇÈ ! " #¹ º > KJÙ Ú *+A ¢ *R SM N J Û ÒÓ Ê j {ordering theory,OT| [7]Ü > M X F G Ü 0^" #JÝ Þß à á â ]ã ä å e]æ ç è ]é ê ë [14]J " P ì ÒÓ Ê j J&' *+í î Þ 0^ï* ð ñ Ý ò ó ? bJ}~d¶0^Õ ô " #Þ(item relationship structure theory, IRS) [8]Diagnosys[1]X
=_ ! " #ÇÈ Jõ ð . =_ ! "
#ö ? ÷ ø J8ù ú Kû × J3 4=" #¡
=1Æ ? L£ JA ¢ 3 4=[18]X
2.1.2
(CAT,
computerized adaptive test)
x ü J$% &' *+7 ñ G ýþ x ý
;0^ Ê j (item response theory,IRT) [2]¾ ýþ *+. / 01JK x W(ability) c 7(scale score)½ &w
¶ 7 J = 0¸ = *+]= =*+et ;X x ý ; ! { 0 ^ | " # [1][3][4][5][6]¾ ýþ J&' *+Æ ( )ì =_J¬ [14][20]¾ ;n o Ò Ó Ê j » +q=_ ! " # J$
% & ' * +(knowledge-structure-based adaptive testing,KSAT) , - A ¢ J( )X
2.2
!
!
!
!
"
"
"
"
#
#
#
#
$
$
$
$
%
%
%
%
&
&
&
&
2.2.1 # $ ' ( % &
#
#
#
$
$
$
'
'
'
(
(
(
%
%
%
&
&
&
94= ð 10 ¬ Æ 7 F ý7 ;] Ô JÕ ÖX ^;« ! 7 JJ ^Æ " Þ7# Æ $ Þ » + ¸6J Æ % " ÞJ76 ß &ì 6'1×6]6'2×3@ 6J? 1]2]3]6() ;$ Þ» +6÷1 '6]6÷2'3# Æ &ì 6J? 1]2]3]6(= *+ , - . / Ê ]: 0 Æ «" $ 1 2 M (3J ^ ;4 5 $ ce7$ J ^J y 6 p Õ [16]X ^;« y J D E Æ _K J7 @T JØî " Þ8 g " ÞÕ ô ' ? 9 + , T $ Þ » +X% : ; Ê Ý ò < J¬ ¼  = Ê [16]X JÕ Ö¯ ;" $ 1 2 Õ Ö> «¶=_l y 6 H µ? ñ @ A B C D ]X
2.2.2 ) * ) + , -
)
)
)
*
*
*
)
)
)
+
+
+
,
,
,
-
-
-
.
.
.
.
/
/
/
/
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
E Á JÄ Å ß ? g 1ö o ? Õ Jp Õ F . Ä Å × Ê K}1X 1 G ]à 1] . ^" P 2002H I ¸J K =*]Lï M LJN6 ]& ÞïÄ O ^JÞ? ¬ C D ]¬ ]Ç ? @ A Ê ]2SÕ P O ^: Ä Q R S T eýþ X 2002U V W J K =* ]L ï M L JN6 ï& Þ? ¬ C D ]X 2003 X Y Z J ! " # $ % & ─ ' ( ) * + , - . / K =* J=a [ \ . - ] ;^ _ ! ß J* Ø` ¬ H a X 2004b c d J, 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 K ¬ ýþ Æ 7 Q 1.: ; ¬ Q^N]Ç? @ A C D X 2.[ ¬ Qe f ]g 9 Þ h i X 3.j k ¬ Q^j k ]Ü l m X 4.n ð Qo p ` ]q *X 2005 r s t J9 : ; < = > ? @# A B , K =*=a J. - u ` ¬ ? 2ýQ 1.=ZJH a cQ=*v x G Ý Þ ^]Ç? @ A C D ]w Þx )^NX 2.=a 1y ¢ Q=a 1J@ A C D ; =a 1ý> z _X 2006ã { | ]H } ~ JC D E F G H , - . I J K L M N O P Q K ~ =*=a J ! ) " Þï$ ÞJ^ _ ! Ê H µ=a ZÀ  = ì ~ X w Z· Ä Å 1ï ÇÈ Ç È ! " #J¹ º ! " #0^Jo Ð ß & Z· ýþ $% &' ( )*+ ( )=_¡3 4=@ k X2.3
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
#
#
#
#
)
)
)
)
(adaptive remedial instruction)&' 3 4=Æ 7 ñ G 7 ;$%
&' 3 4=(CBRI|Ô
&' 3 4=(TBRI|7· ¸OX
2.3.1
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
#
#
#
#
)
)
)
)
(CBRI,
computer-based adaptive remedial instruction)$% &' 3 4=;=_A ¢ *q l=_J¬ $% ³ = _ A ¢ 3 4=_; / y J$% Ð 6 A ¢ 3 4 ? p Õ ì ¾ G Ý 6 - ? x y KL [18][21]X U ;=_A ¢ 3 4 z _J ^Æ w Þ ¯ 3=~ + , _a J ] i _l~ ¢ M = # ? n ZJS T X
2.3.2 # 4 2 3 # )
#
#
#
4
4
4
2
2
2
3
3
3
#
#
#
)
)
)
(TBRI,
teacher-based adaptive remedial instruction)$% A ¢ 3 4= + , =_ A ¢ *q l=_J¬ { ( )¨ ©| w =_ ! g h i ]=^ ]=_` a e, - A ¢ 3 4=¾ G 5 6 2=_ ¯ ? p Õ ì ¾ G Ý 6 - ? x y KL[20]X - ! + , / = J ¡ Cl= ì ° ±XI / ¢ ¶n 5 £ k ¤ = + , 2c3=_ J=_ J H x + , ¥ ¦ § ¨ =_J3 4= X
3.
#
#
#
#
$
$
$
$
3.1 5
5
5
5
1. © y . ^A ¢ Ä Å D E X 2. ¹ º ÇÈ ! " # ! " #0^X 3. 0QÙ Ú ( )*+X 4. ¹ º 3 4= ! " #X 5. ª $% &' ( )*+÷ ø X 6. ¹ º X 7. X 8. *Q$% &' ( )*+X 9. RS ( )¨ ©k 3 4=X 10.q*Q$% &' ( )*+X 11.» E « 7Ë N° ± X 12.A ¢ ]q* Û ¬ Ê 7Ë X 13.RS7Ë Û ® X 14.RS7Ë Û » +3 4=KLX 15.D E F G H I 3 4=5 6 KLX3.2 6 7
6
6
6
7
7
7
0 Ù Ú ( )*+Ý ¯ ° l± ß ² 94= ð ³ f= J=´ =_¶=a q *? L° zÜ 657nX µ 6 *{]q*|$% &' ( )* +Ý ¯ ° l± ¶ ß · ¸ E M ³ f=_ z4¹f? L° zÜ 128nX 35nt ¶ ß ===_X3.3 8 9
8
8
8
9
9
9
3.3.1 : ;
:
:
:
;
;
;
Ù Ú ( )*+;RS$% &' ( )*+ [15]«8- ? =Ô*+¹ º n +JE M º ^ » ÇÈ ! " #¢ ¶¼ ½¾ ¿ · ¬ J 7" #¸À1@v X ÇÈ ! " #. ! U 0^0^J¹ º + , w 0^Á ]C0^»  }» +8à q Î0à »  }»  X 1 Ä ð αÖ{Cronbach's Alpha| @M αÖ 0.9033αÖH « Å $ ^¥ > Æ XT ð Ç ¶0.575~0.971r s T ð 0.816X@? 0^JÈ ð t ¶0.300X2IRT F É 5 6 7Ë @? 0^JÁ Ý » y Wt ¶ 0.05¸O}2@v X Û 7Ë qu v 0^Ê Ë Ì ¾ ¹ º 0^ JÍ Î ÷ ø A ¢ $% &' ( )*+X 2 CTT IRTα if item deleted a b c X2
1 0.38 79.0 0.901 1.4620 -0.8213 .2775 .3679 2 0.41 81.3 0.901 2.4810 -0.5825 .3780 .4299 3 0.34 97.1 0.902 1.7789 -2.6891 .1863 .9468 4 0.40 95.1 0.901 1.7623 -2.3204 .1643 .4393 5 0.30 91.0 0.902 1.0303 -2.4345 .1803 .1734 6 0.47 90.3 0.900 1.9404 -1.5305 .2429 .0684 7 0.46 57.5 0.900 1.6075 -0.0665 .1173 .1239 8 0.60 80.8 0.897 2.9359 -0.8566 .1571 .8414 9 0.44 85.1 0.900 1.4502 -1.4458 .1619 .7449 10 0.46 76.1 0.900 1.5815 -0.7686 .1979 .7578 11 0.48 70.8 0.899 1.6773 -0.5618 .1520 .7205 12 0.54 83.0 0.898 2.8028 -0.8699 .2391 .8883 13 0.51 88.6 0.899 2.0264 -1.4545 .1754 .6406 14 0.44 76.0 0.900 1.3456 -0.9012 .1633 .7840 15 0.40 93.8 0.901 1.6358 -2.1792 .1713 .0593 16 0.57 84.2 0.898 1.9625 -1.2356 .1214 .1090 17 0.46 58.8 0.900 1.7196 -0.0722 .1364 .4684 18 0.56 79.1 0.898 3.9455 -0.5818 .2682 .3851 19 0.46 78.2 0.900 1.5007 -0.9546 .1738 .8851 20 0.39 69.4 0.901 1.5027 -0.3461 .2429 .5071 21 0.54 81.7 0.898 3.1302 -0.7245 .2790 .2547 22 0.53 81.0 0.899 2.7743 -0.7403 .2593 .2915 23 0.46 94.5 0.900 2.2697 -2.0101 .1585 .6556 24 0.49 88.6 0.899 1.7027 -1.6241 .1409 .1078 25 0.44 88.7 0.900 1.6078 -1.6155 .1892 .6837 26 0.55 92.4 0.899 2.5740 -1.7054 .1358 .2399 27 0.57 91.6 0.899 2.8202 -1.5761 .1448 .3412 28 0.51 74.1 0.899 1.9494 -0.6472 .1660 .5244 29 0.52 80.7 0.899 1.9159 -0.9707 .1740 .3671 30 0.38 66.1 0.902 1.1350 -0.4036 .1721 .7520 31 0.43 75.0 0.900 1.4417 -0.7305 .2085 .7974
3.3.2
KSAT
*q*t $% &' ( ) *+Ï I Ð ]Ñ Ò Ó e [17]]Ô Õ ]æ Ö × e[19]J ß Ø Ù ! " # . JE M =É $% &' ( )*+- Ú Û ' (robustness)N¯ . $% &' ( )*+÷ ø ¶=É c Ü p Õ . ^ KLÌ Æ 0^] * ]- ? Ý * ð X¾ ÷ ø ª #=_ ! " # ¸OÀ2¾ ¿ · ¬ J 7= _" #X 2
3.3.3 < = > ? @ # $
<
<
<
=
=
=
>
>
>
?
?
?
@
@
@
#
#
#
$
$
$
;RS3 4= ! " #OÀ3 ¬ 7" #«2ÇÈ =1] 4É 1E M Þ zI E j ¹ º > K qÎÉ N° ± ® X 3 !!!! """" Á Â 4 ß T = \ { à ]á à |]=^â ]=_` a â { ]A ã |=_T =^]=_ ` a { ]A ã |Ô 7«ã ä É å æ G ? ¢ Lç g h i ¸OÀ4]5 @v X4"""" #### $$$$ %%%% &&&& '''' (((( ))))
5"""" #### $$$$ %%%% """" **** ++++
3.3.4 = > A B
=
=
=
>
>
>
A
A
A
B
B
B
=_ / *]q*qÆ M N x G ( )¨ ©¸OÀ6@v « l =_J¬ w g h i ]=^ ]=_` a e, - A ¢ 3 4=X 6,,,, ---- .... //// 0000 11113.3.5 < = > ? @ # 4 C / D E !
<
<
<
=
=
=
>
>
>
?
?
?
@
@
@
#
#
#
4
4
4
C
C
C
/
/
/
D
D
D
E
E
E
!
!
!
N° ± ;«2ÇÈ = 1]4É 1E M Þ zI E j ¹ º > K¥ Jè é T ZJN lJ V » ê ë ¥ 4 ß @? J È 2 ò ]Á Â ñ Ý ì í ¥ J ¼ î U }î ef7 ;d]b]ï Æ ]ð Ú X 7Ë ë ¥ ñ Ä " P 4.1X3.4 F
F
F
F
G
G
G
G
H
H
H
H
I
I
I
I
J
J
J
J
k + Ü (quasi-experimental design)¹f k +83¹flm8 1¹Xk +8J=_ò ó ô k +8]l m8 ;° N ¹fA ¢ õ ¹3 4=k +ö Ü }÷ Ð À¸}3]}4@v X 32222 3333 4444 5555 6666 8 k +ö 3 4=5 6 3 4= 2S k + ø ù k +8 x lú =_ k +8 x lF =_ ( ) ¨ © T p I lm8 x l ¹=_ ¬ û } 42222 3333 7777 8888 k +8 lm8 107ü ÷ ø T ý 20þ307ü KSAT * 507ü k +8] õ ¹ Z 20þ307ü KSATq *4.
%&
%&
%&
%&
4.1
!
!
!
!
"
"
"
"
<
<
<
<
=
=
=
=
>
>
>
>
?
?
?
?
@
@
@
@
#
#
#
#
$
$
$
$
« } 5 ~ o 75YJ [ = \ ;b c d Je f M T 1 [ = \ JÁ Â ¹ ¨ ;Æ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` a @ b 28.6 % 60.0 % 8.6 % % 0 2.9 % L M c Q R S T 5D U 25.7 % 68.6 % 5.7 % % 0 % 0 C d H I e f 7 8 > 34.3 % 51.4 % 11.4 % 2.9 % % 0 « } 6 ~ o 75YJ [ =^ ;b c d Je f M 1 [ =^ JÁ Â l 0 ^ Ü ? T V W X 6"""" >>>> 9999 :::: ;;;; <<<< ==== 6666 C ! " # $ % & ' ( ) g 1 h i j M > 42.9% 34.3% 20.0% 0% 2.9% ^ _ ` a H I 3 4 2 D J > 28.6% 68.6% 2.9% 0% 0% k 5Y 7 l X l m c n 37.1% 62.9% 0% 0% 0% o p q ` a 34.3% 62.9% 2.9% 0% 0% o p q r : 34.3% 62.9% 2.9% 0% 0% o 8 s n 20.0% 74.3% 5.7% 0% 0% t u v w p q ` a 37.1% 60.0% 2.9% 0% 0% t u v w p q r : 40.0% 60.0% 0% 0% 0% t u v w 8 s n 31.4% 62.9% 5.7% 0% 0% t u v w x & ' [ ] y z 34.3% 62.9% 2.9% 0% 0% ^ _ ` a { I | } ~ 5 f ; 22.9% 54.3% 22.9% 0% 0% « } 7 ~ o 75YJ [ = _ ` a ;b c d Je f M 1 [ ? G JÁ Â l 0 ^ Ü - ?k ' X 7 ???? @@@@ >>>> 9999 :::: ;;;; <<<< ==== 6666 [ \ ] C ! " # $ % & ' ( ) ` a H I 3 4 2 D J [ \ ] 37.1% 60.0% 2.9% 0% 0% k 5Y 7 l X l m c n 37.1% 62.9% 0% 0% 0% \ ] p q ` a 34.3% 65.7% 0% 0% 0% \ ] s n 28.6% 68.6% 2.9% 0% 0% \ ] 8 s n 25.7% 60.0% 14.3% 0% 0% \ ] x & ' [ ] y z 37.1% 54.3% 5.7% 0% 2.9% « } 8 Æ ~ o 60YJ [ g h i ;b c d Je f M 1 [ g h i JT Æ Ú 3 4 =X F ë p ½ ¾ ë J È 7 ½ ?Î Ú J X 8AAAA BBBB CCCC """" DDDD 9999 :::: ;;;; <<<< ==== 6666 V W X = ! " # $ % & ' ( ) V W X = p q ` a 17.1% 62.9% 5.7% 0.0% 14.3% V W X = D J > 14.3% 51.4% 17.1% 2.9% 14.3% V W X = x 9 y z 14.3% 45.7% 25.7% 0.0% 14.3% V W X = x [ 2.9% 62.9% 20.0% 2.9% 11.4%4.2
#
#
#
#
4
4
4
4
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
#
#
#
#
)
)
)
)
K
K
K
K
L
L
L
L
« } 9~ H j ;k +8c ;lm 8Î n o 3 4 =q =_ Jr s 7 t A B 97Z X « } 10~ . ]q * K A ¢ K l° » y H j ;k +8c lm 8F 1 J ]q * K ?u ' q * K ý ud ¶ * K X 9EEFEEFFGFGGG HHHH IIII JJJJ KKKK LLLL 28 82.93 92.46 9.54 48 79.43 92.79 13.35 36 82.17 93.2 11.00 10EEEEFFFFGGGG HHHH MMMM NNNN MMMM OOOO PPPP >>>> QQQQ RRRR t - 9.54 10.71 4.713 27 .000 - 13.35 9.27 9.983 47 .000 - 11.00 11.26 5.861 35 .0004.3 M N O P 2 3 # ) Q R K L
M
M
M
N
N
N
O
O
O
P
P
P
2
2
2
3
3
3
#
#
#
)
)
)
Q
Q
Q
R
R
R
K
K
K
L
L
L
« } 10~ k +8x l3 =_ JA B 7 Ýr s A B 7 ¤ 137X5.
%'
%'
%'
%'
(
(
(
(
)
)
)
)
5.1 S
S
S
S
1. R S T 1 J9 U - ?Æ V W X 2. H j ;k +8c lm 8n o p I J3 4 =q =_ Jr s 7 t A B 97Z u v " w 3 4 =?x y K L XW M N J; & ¶ k +ß @ ?=_ l]ß]ÝK À J=_ t ?A B JL P X 3. uv k +8x l3=_ J r s A B 127} ~ b X J w J& ' 3 4 =- ?x y L P g h i \ =_ J N Ý3 4 = K L ¡H I K À J=_ t ?ý uJA B X5.2 T U
T
T
T
U
U
U
/ ¢ ¶ n q ï Æ k + Ü D E 3 4 =J5 6 . = _ 2 W 78 3 4 =lH I W =_ Jh i X g h i Ý ò + , w ¬ 3 4 =) « Ç n Ø Æ ú K Ç ò ]" # û × J3 4 =X JÝ 6 + , Ç 3 a A ¢ ¦ J =÷ Ð ¨ $ k +ö h i J" P X*
+
*
*
+
+
*
+
j Ä E ¶ ß = ã ä É å æ G ?¢ L ç » w Ã Ü =5 6 7K P X,
-
,
,
-
-
,
-
[1] Appleby, J., Samuels, P., & Treasure-Jones, T. ,“Dianosys - A Knowledge-based Diagnostic Test of Basic Mathematical Skills”, Computers and Education, 28(2), 113-131, 1997.
[2] Wainer, H. (Ed.), “Computerized adaptive testing: A primer (2nd ed.).Hillsdale”, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Publishers. , 2000.
[3] Brown, J.S. and Burton, R.,“Diagnostic models for procedural bugs in basic mathematical skills”, Cognitive Science, 2:155-192, 1978.
[4] Chang, K-E., Liu, S-H., & Chen, S-W., “A testing system for diagnosing misconceptions in DC electric circuits.”,Computers & Education, 31, 195-210, 1998.
[5] VanLehn K. “Student models. In Polson M.C. &
Richardson J.J. (eds.)”, Foundations of intelligent tutoring systems. Lawrence Erlbaum. Hillsdale., 1988.
[6] Wenger E.,“Artificial Intelligence and Tutoring Systems. Morgan Kaufmann”, Los Altos, CA 94022, 1987.
[7] Airasian, P. W, & Bart, W. M.,“Ordering theory: A new and useful measurement model”, Educational Technology,1973,5,56—60,1973.
[8] Takeya,“New item structure theorem”,Tokyo Waseda University, 1991. [9] X Y Z X2003X ! " # . J( ) * +¹ º Ô 3 4 =78 ─EM = ³ f X¶ ß Ì = = =÷ Þ A = j ÄX [10] b c X2004XEM f =_ = ^ X¶ ß Ì = * +ø Ü @ = j ÄX [11] r s t X2005X EM = ! ! ò " L 6]7 J$ Þ Ô X¶ ß Ì = = =÷ Ê = j ÄX [12] H I ¸ X2002XEM =* u ` ¬ X# $ Ì = Ê @ j ÄX [13] U V W X2002XEM =* u ` ¬ X# $ Ì = Ê @ j ÄX [14] à á â ]ã ä å ]æ ç è ]é ê ë X2005X " # Ê j & ' * + & ' 3 4 = % Z ÷ ø X¶ & =a Ñ E «X [15] à á â X2003XEM =É $ % & ' ( ) * +(I)X¢ ' EÈ É =( «Ç ^ Ü ¨ © (NSC 91-2520-S-142-001)X [16] Ä ) X2005XE* M = = = \ + ³ Z X¶ , - X [17] Ï I Ð ]Ñ Ò Ó ]à á â ]. / 0 X2006XE M =É $ % & ' ( ) * +Ú Û ' D X 2006 $ % 1 2 É å Z J E «XE 3 4 =X [18] Ï 5 6 X2005X ¦ " # J$ % & ' * +¹ º Ô / 3 4 = —E M = î f ¦ XE ¶ ß Ì = = =÷ ¹ j ÄX [19] Ô Õ ]æ Ö × ]à á â ]7 8 9 X2006X 0 ^ " # Ê j & ' * +© ^ j k Ú Û ' D X2006 É å : 3 ; Ê E¤ E «X<= =X [20] > ? @ X2006X 5 6§ -F õ ú X¶ ß = = =÷ Þ A = j ÄX [21] é A ë X2003XEM = $ % & ' ( ) * +Ô 3 4 =÷ ø Á Â § Ô 0 ─ 7]B 7 X¶ ß Ì = * +ø Ü @ j ÄX [22] ã { | ]H } ~ X2006XEM Æ C Ã 0 = $ % D / ³ =a Ü XÊ , =¨ 40Ã1X