全球治理與非營利組織

全文

(1)<f'~ffit· <f'''K~1L+-=-1f.7;"}]. •~. 71-95 J{. ~ ~ #t JlI! ~ 3F 1ft fU ~J1. *** ~.L aJj 1~*".~ ~ ~**. -¥. 1ii. •• ~~~M.&a~.m~~7~*~~W'~$#.~m••w ~~~gWa.~~fiZ~~,~~~~g •• ~'#.~m.~ •• ~~0~ ~~~. .h~~ • • o.~,*~m~~~#.~m.w~~~g~ ~~gW#.~m.~~~'U&.U.~~~~~g~. ~'~fi.~.tt#.~m.~.~ {J'~~ , 3iOOml±U~i}~HIi!.~. '~OOM~~. .~m.~.~.. •• ,.*.m~~~gW#.~m.z.. 0. gm~:~~~·~~~~·#.~m.·0~.h. Abstract Under the framework of the global governance, the establishment of the public-private partnership is one of the most popular trends to non-profit organizations. Thus, this paper intends to explore the relationships between global governance and the non-profit organizations. For a broad understanding, two theories are examined, including the third-party government theory and the public-goods theory. A potential dilemma of the public-private partnership is also discussed .. *)(!&~1nm:li:il&W:tk¥Wcr.1itt4¥¥~ 2003lf3 J( 21-42 *~~~~m*¥~~fi~¥*~~o ** ~~~~m*¥~~fi~¥*1'J±:tE. •••. tti""ilt::t. '. 0. 0. 71. ........... J3 28 B1=.~z ~J~ 11:. r tt-J ~~)~ if ~.f!rb1T.

(2) Keys Words: Globalization, Global Governance, Non-profit Organizations, Public-Private Partnership. +~re*·.m~&WRmR~~.~B~~g~¥~ ~¥jH*l}L&.i&1El$:I:ji~~. ••. ·m~. •• ~. ~*~~1t· Keohane & Nye Jr. (2000: 7) ~~ffl. ~1t~f~59Ht~~t~8"J~W'. .~. ~~1t~!tIJ~ r~W?fJT~pf; J ~9l:lr '{~~W~. 0. _~¥~~,@~~_*~~n~~~~*m~u·~~g~_*&m=~w~ a~. _. rffi~~ • • Jo~.~~~t~~~·a~W~I~~. ~~~~*~~B~.*'. ~~,. .~ rJm~&!itJ. _*fffi · ~. ~.8"J. .~~. ••~~~_**5~~~m;~ •• ~¥t~. (Unrestricted War)' ~~IfriJ~rT&{ttm51~~t§7@]~. •• ~¥t~. r ~~J~ J ' weJJ{ttwrlll~*~~rJtR~P~~. .ff~~fM:Ei (Great Satan) ; ~$:I:ji~~t~~ r ~!lI1IH-'lli J. (butterfly effect). .~'ffM.*m*~~~¥$:I:ji~.~~.,@~~.*~=~~._~=:I:ji ~*;/]o~i~B~.. · El ai}p~5;tt~ , YO. Clark (2000: 97-98). fiiT ~ , ~~i&. W·~.~&$:I:ji~WA±~~li~·.n~m=:I:ji.a~~~g~'~9l:lrA ~1t$:l:jif~. r 1S014000 J tJ&a~-ESfDzp:*ll~ (Greenpeace) :om~~.W~ r f:lii1: ~.ff (Responsible Care) J ~ ; ~;frr*&)(1t~~t~~ ~. , ;tt~{j\.aa~. ~~~~~9l:lr~~~~.~.~.~~.)(~~.;tt~)(~(~~~~.~) ~~A~~'i"~. I. ? ~,~ , ~~1t.~1E~ ~~.. (nation-state) V)\~~~§7If.. ·. ~~.±.~mlii7tnlZ~~tJ!f~~.:t~(economic. globalism) ·1J.~~'±'~(mi1itary globalism)':$~ ~~.±. ~(environmental globalism)' ffi±tt&:iZ ft~~'±'~( social and cultural globalism)~ [911lIID fft:1*~Il'li . ~~1t1*f!~M~tJ!f~~'±'~ . '§m~~§~:r~tli. . mU1ftli. . ~*tli. . ~mtli.~ o. $~X~,~~~~*~~~~~&~*fft:~ffi~~*x~~~ffi~~*~~§'~~~lli fJf.7t Im~:f!lL~~~fJl ; 1J.~~'±'~J:llif~~~§~fllfIft<fif~~ , '§1'I5flJffl:ff:t1J . ~ft~!ItJ iit~*~. , ~U~O~~l:AJM~ r ~JMizp.~ J (balance of terror). I. ~ 911 .{41&~t!mfj~j;ff!ItJ:ff:t. '. 191J$~~'±'~~~ El ~tttt~~~tJ!fflJ~. ; :$fl~~'±'.1*f~~~~:t£*i\~W#CP~~'J,f ft~~.A'!»jt¥J~• . ttM!Jt~JI' ~~m&t::!>f~h~fjA~~aft~~. ; ~ttttt&:iZ1t~~ .±.~ttttf*j)j*~tJ!flk.$~~'±'~iI:~ ~ J (isomorphism)t¥J~l~. , '§m11l~ . ~m . ~ftt¥Jft1l~~ , j!~ r 1I=U%.:t . 9t.~~~imm11i (ITJ1Jl(~ • ~lm7t · 2002A: 476-477) 0. 72.

(3) ~J;ft~~J£~~~*~1 ~Ji~. f§rrtlD~3&~~~L7t. '. m~t*f*jl~~lfe~Ht. '. EEl'~~Wtm~~Pff. .=. '&~~~lli~~~~~~~~~~~~o. ~.OOfi~~~~*~'%.~~~3&~~~~~~I~'~~ • • ~.~. ~j;J~. ri§~~J 25(1i£&~_ r~J&M~J. ' ~9':lE[jj]M~:lE~miii$iJIA0. $r~,~~~.~~~~o~~'¥~ili*~~~~$~~z~1i£~~'~~$ ~iEf§!l1r;R;~~~g (government failure) PffiJ [~Z~ rl:l~}l!IUl~:fP<IL\¥UJltl±ng~fl. %~. '~.¥Wffr±fr0~1fPff~~. ? I1t-~;m-TI[~tI%~1fIDlZ± Pff:¥:' § 0. 1990 1f.t~~. 0. ,. M§gtt~.~a~.~gR'~M~~.A~.MMfrg*m~mmM. , IDffX~~~~r~. rJjm~. , flA:lE~~~;ff4?1- '. ~j;J0~$5tS~. .Jo@~.~.~~~~·.$~~~~=~~~~'. r 1F~fU*J3.. • • MRm~~~&Mfr. ~~~.OO'#~W~.fi~UA:lE~~.~A'W~~~~1f*~~~~&M fr.~'#~W~.~.W~~.M~-~Do 1F~fU*Ji • • W~~mflW~~$rr5Effz. '.R&~.~~·~.~~. .'lli*#~W~.ff~~l±%.~$~~m, a{~m~)[I~. jlllf L '. , ~fi '. ·m~W~.~fi~. :1JD~~~1t~i{?H~W0~MltlWla~Jl!~. ~~MgR$~~(~§~'#~'. 1fH' ~Mfr. ~~~)Mr;R;~~. 'l±M~*~W~ • • ~~~~~'#~W~.~B~~~.mfl~. ~ffl]OO°. ~I1t. '. ~m5tW5E. fi~~~mfIW1F~flj*J3..H1*zliff)'G. ~mizWf!;m. ,. ~*. ~W~.W~~mfl~.~'~WM~~~mflW#.W~.~H. 1~. , j;J&~j;J~181±~~1Eifl~1F.flJ*J3..~gJm:)[I~ , .~3J;1'F*~,~ , a;ffdim~~mflW1F~frl*J3..z:fP<'L\IU1!. ~ , ~ J)jt jh J! .JIi! ~f " EE~. 0. r. .frl*J3..s~H{~ziW. *U ~! _. ~.'t11F.flJ*J3. 0. ~ IVJ ~. J W r 1F~frl*J3.. J pg~:t§'i'~~ , ~1±~18~~mf1l[W1F ' 1f £\~5t!im1F~flJ*J3..W~~mfl. 73. I.,. . iii. :i. ..... ~. I.... '. '~. ~. ~.

(4) % ' :11" ~ flj *,fi~ tf lff ?P t§ !IHJ:)J¥J m ,~P/ij 1l ~1iJ ~D i} 1% Jfr± Itit ~ 2 (civiI society organizations)' m'::::iiBF5 3( the third sector)' &:1FiI&H~H.I3.~4( non-government organizations) , 1:E~~:1F~ffH,fi~1J1ID ' ~~J:J:1FiI&mH,fi~-~liJte:f~1i- 5 , § JWifi5t tf ~ *1Ci¥1 ~ ~111::1F~fIH,fi~?t!j@H~* ~Jjf*I&:1F~fIH,fi~-~1iJ ' 19U~IJ r ~V~tS- ~ i¥1 ~ §. ~;fJ*I~?t~~*1C J. System, ISIC) , r ~~Jtl. 6. (The U.N. International Standard Industrial Classification [l':IJtmi¥1-~*~~mi1JI~?t~;fJ* J. 7. (Eurostat's General. Industrial Classification of Economic Activities, NACE) , ~ *~i~HJE~tt:bb It (The Council of Charitable Statistic) i¥1 r ~*~f>H.I3.~?t~;fJ. J. 8. (The National. Young, Koenig, Najam, and Fisher (1999: 324)~~~ , 0~fft±tUl!..1g'@;Jt~ , ;E;l~iftthbtt ' ~ff ~., m~$' Itt ' *~~m' ~~lIlm ,~tt~ ; Dekker and Broek(1998: 11-12)~~~ , ;E;1Il*1!..;!!0~Jii±tt*1!..B3m{J\~* ; Naidoo (2001: 82)~~ , 0~ffLttt*1!..llJ!1~H~~~tfifiJ ' ;E;1Il~~~~JfJ*l!..; 0~fft±tt*Jl.-tl2~~*~~?;t:J~ r~':::'$r~j (Third Sector) , 1'tf~~:fr~ iTitR;fD~*Z.rd]B3~.(Salamon, 200l: 27, Brown & Kalegaonkar, 2001: 291); fffiJj~'f~~*fffi ~ '~~~JfJ*Jl.(NGOs)~0~ift±tt*1!..am{J\B3~*(Brown&Kalegaonkar, 2001:291); Brian O'Conell (2000: 472-475)IVf~f~1:B ' -~)"~M0~jji±tt*1!..~IPJ~;E;JJi*1!..~1I1r.$r~ , , 0~Jii±tt*Jl.l¥JfB.J!J1 ' 0~jji±tt*fl.B3.I£~*1gt5 : l.1I)..(individual) , 2. ifLtTil(community) , 3.~Jff(government)' 4.Jt~(business) , 5.$JJi(voluntary) , ~~~flJ(nonprofit) ~1I1r.gBr~(independent sector)~ r ~':::'$r~ j , ;ttcp:tJ;J~1iJj(m.:::.gBr~)~m'L<rJJt!~ ; Richard A. Couto(2001)fEl,&~~1PJ Brian O'Conell B3~1! • 3 Nye Jr, and Donahue(2000: 13)~E~ , m':::'$r~B\'[i~!:iJfl!.7t~ r ~~~JfJ*JU~ j (NGOs),& r ~~ tfiflJ*l!.. J (NPOs) • 4 ~{i*~~~ , PJTID!1~~~Jff*l!..f~~ r §~~:£!![ , fA)..t1~ , lPJ~l'J;Ji§'flj~§1¥J ' fffiJ;Jf'@~ '&~t!f$~~~~~ra~~~~$B3l1lm(2000:23-24) ; lIiflt!i'" ' Ji*fE~g~~ , NGOs ;!!-m~~ tfiflJ*Jl. ' fffi li;!!fA)..*~.gB3l1lm(2000:63) • 5 fJutzo ' Pierre and Peters (2000: 83-91)lt~~ , :f:E1twr)Efli~~1El:£!![fElt3T ' ~~~Jff*J.H~(NGOs) ~Jl)l{~gB:5t~JfJB3~f1 (Pierre and Peters, 2000:83-91 ; ~Ji$ti ' 2002: 69-72) ; .wr~nM~ ~*±1t.T NGOs B3fLt1Jt1J(2000:14-16); aJlJ'i!ilE~~~~~Jff*1!..~1ihj;f rfmJE~~1El:£!![B3l' J Z.1t~fElt3(2000: 41-42) ; *~x~M~~ft.~H~~Jff*1!..f:t~~rm{~;;;t~.(2000: 43-51) ; ~~aJl ' ~'fx~ , L!:~~f5t!MMW~~~Jff*Jl.fiMiI1B3~I~1;M~~ (2000: 72-84) ; ~ "[2cp(/FJ;J NGOs 1ffiilj]j!;~rOJ-llI r ffB3~~1Ell!l! j B3~*fE(2001: 22) ; IIVisFlj¥11E~~1El:£!![fElN~ ~~~'[i~~.gflJ'&~~~mMI3.~MI£B3JjjtIZ9(2000: 17-24) • 6 ISIC f~EI3~~~JNI:BB3f}lJ:t ' mJ;Jtt~tIt~~~*~~tr5t1J*1tiHB3fnt5L ' 1948 1f-~~i3"~PJT ~*f:l ' ~~§~jmw~tIt~~~~~tr5t1Jal.nzB3~*1t ; {t(~7t~~*1t ' ~~.gf'Ul!..a:rtJ:rJ!i~ : ~fif ' f@&lWJii±ttIf'F ' ;ttftl!)ji±l!ll'i:w±ttWllI)"HlU~tr5tIJ • (s I§l£i:~~ , 2000: 371) 7 NACE {~E13~»H:tt;IPJR{t(. ISIC :JJOJ;JaJ(~~JNI:B;;;t~*1t ' ;!tcp~~~flJ*R.!:iJtJ:rJ!i~~ : ~ff ' IVf~~JN ' U:JJf@&l ' ~~x1t. ' ;ttftl!0:tt;ij~~ • (s [§l£i:~~ , 2000: 371-372) 8 NTEE f~E13~~1I1r.$r~(The Independent Sector)B3:5t:R~.~~~t!f*1EiHmttpJT~JNI:B*. 2. 74.

(5) 1::-Jt'$~l.!!J!..~~ .f*~ m~. Taxonomy of Exempt Entities, NTEE) , & University). J'ifTfi:z. r ~F1fflj*~.ElJi~~7t~ J. f:J ~ mif jz: WI 9. (Johns Hopkins. (The International Classification of. Nonprofit Organization, ICNPO) (Salamon and Anheier, 1997:56-81 ; IT r!§ ~ , 2000:371-374). 0. '. ffij:tE.~LJW. ~Fa~~.El.~. ,. ~IU~~~Ji.. '. mh~~M3.. ~~nlli~,m~~~Rm'~ffi~.~.fi&mz~.o. , fjj)H9j7t (2002B: 5-10) :f'~ff~f§~5(lU~lli ' :tE~F1ffrHfi~~f;ll;jJtHffi 1Jffij , 0~ffr±1U.El.~ZiBlllla. ' ~-g~F~-~qJ{*~f;II;j.~ffij~Fit$::g~qJ , ~Fi& mfM3.~{*mfflm-t~~II~Hi ' ~F~-¥-f)E~~z01it*fi. ' ffij~Ffi'frHfi.JWmfflPJ m~-~~~z01it~.El.~lo ~mjDEi~,PJ~qJ~~ , l'ffi1ij{arf.l::gm~Jfi*& ' :tEi&mf& ¥Ifif:l{~. 0. ~. ••• ~~'~0~m*. .-~qJJIUm~{~Z.~Ji::X. zM3.~W~#1f~M3.~ziB. (tiD. -). ,ffij~~tt#1f~M3.. 0. .~·*m~~#fi'~M3.~W)Em:Afi0~.~~~$,~m~~~M~. ffr~fflll: ; AfiitAttB{llZl'1fflj~~r~~~Fi&mf~Ji~. ;A. r l'7t~c~~~pH!5U J. IIl*JIIJ ;. ~fi~m.m&~m~~$fi.m • • ~M3.~offijli~ttM~(~~~*'~. )'i&mflli.~i&mf~~m~zM~itA'fi'~7t~~.~,#~~~itM.W ~F~m-~F1ff!J~Ji~W)EZ~. 0. I¥J~Mf ' 1:.~~~~~fjtJ:i!!UlI¥J:P3llM~~F~flJ*.IUii ' Jt:7t~f'tl'il~iX ' :#~m 26 fmmllJ ~m. : ~~ , ~m '. JL,~~m. '. ' t€m~ff ' .~if~ , ~B~7*1l ' ~~ , *to/J~m ' tt~3i:. , 0#3i:~W~JfU~. ' ~~mllJ ' 1f1f-JfJ& ' AjJH~~ , ti~3t1t ' lil~ , IIJto/Jf'tllUl ' , ~;fI105 ' lii±T!ia5{:if; , , f4~if~ , lii±ltf4~if~ , Jt:t&jji±ltfrj~ , *~;ftllUl ' RWJfrj~~ (5 [EL.6:~~ , 2000: 372) 9 ICNPO v'Flf~1n.r:),*~~mllJfi&~7tIHI~ · Jt:~~F~f!J*El.MIi~ 12 flli~ , M::JJO.r:)~7t ri~. 0. fflG 27 fI;;j(k&~Mf 10 . 0. ~m7j(2000:52)~£~ NGOs. NPOs *ftt~~M:1';ftl[i:l]. 0. ~)'[;. ,. NGOs 3t~:(£H~~}JH!t1JlID~*. IUlIL' NGOs 1¥J~1&w~m~ r mWJ~~ J I{'Fr:fJI¥J:P3tsW1&* ' il&m:iJiID~IjIUlIL' NGOs WiI& Jf1 ' mWJ~I¥JIUl{* ; iID NPOs 3t~~*IUlJL'H~~t1H~WWilflJ*El.;<:'~{'F · .r:)&iI&Jf1~*151-~ I¥JrJ:l~ , [i:l]~-futt~lUliL'~Ji.*6mW*~if'Tf~l¥Jr,,~~ ; jt;;j( , NGOs 3titjj1¥;~ NGOs W~~ ifr±ltW*~~~J&ffmtJl¥J-jii • 'J:i!!:iJiI&Jf1' 51-rimIUf~&fkAiE::~M:~f'F~ , iID NPOs jj1¥;~lUliL'*El.*~ . .r:)&~ r $r~ J 'ilf'F-fl~~l¥Jif~~~ ; , :(£~~iiJWri%Ylw. :iJlID ' NGOs jj1¥;W r f¥j:iJIlI% J ' .~IlI% ' ~~WJri%1=f1Ul . iID r ~t:iJllI% J' ~~ri% ' WilflJ~%~rjjj1¥;~ ffl NPOs • 11. r 1'7tftcEi~~~$IJ J f*t~. : ~li:~F~flj*Ji.~*El.Ei~7t~~~Ji.~Ji?lJ~ , ,ftlGjii , ffij~Ji.1¥J. Ei~'illf!ffl1nJt:**,ij~~~?JTW::jiWJ;<:.tJ~. 0. 75.

(6) ~1~M::X. :£1t!. 3:J4<'!10 ~Jf±fr*ll*l. ~. ~lfH. Jff. *&. fIl11&:ftX. f'1. wf. 1*f'Ft1JE:' ,. 11JA. ~. II. Jf±W!. ~. I. ffi-fillr~. [ i&M. ~:f3}*~. : ~IE. I. ~. fi~~::x. *&. 11::~. ~Fi&M~fl*l. ~. ~. II. ~31z:fr,mfr. ¥IE)H~'. tBMHt ' 2002B '. ~J*tE0 ~jf[UJ*J3JIl~*E.. ' lfJJ1!2R. gfiMM~~'fia~.~M.~ft.ft+~~M~W.m~ff.ftX.. *¥fHl=;- ,. ff.~~. : NSC-90-2414-H-004-031'. ~::x'~~m@~~~fi~~~~~~~mn' ~~Hff~~B!fij~. , L. S. Finkelstein ( 1995) ~?2-m. 10. 0. *~~ffl~.~M~fi.. ' ~~mJJ1!~1iI@~~ft~!j!~UtL*1&. ~llim~.~~.,~~.m.~~~.~~~~~~~~.M~~~~~~~. *'6* (#{§!1l1 ' 2001: 157-158) ~lliK&~"Governance. 0. .~Mf*.~ J.. Without Government: Order and change in world politics"-:jf. ~'~mmJJ1!.~*.~~~.~M~·. (governance is order plus intentionality) , ~2Rff~~limn ~r~'~. N. Rosenau & E. Czempeil ~ 1992 ~~mJJ1!~m~~~~. ~;3~. ,. .~M{*~ffmn~. ,. ~tl. fElJ.l:trs~~. li~~'~®ffmn~~~~.JJ1!~IDftX.¥.~~'~fi~~~. (Rosenau & E. Czempeil, 1992:5) , ~ffjj , ft~:jf~~**fr-=Y~J*¥i3JJ1!--'~. EjHii~:W)E (~Ut$tl. ' 2002:65). 0. J. N, Rosenau ft 1995 ~"Global Governance"~UfU~~ , ~~?2-~~~mJJ1!m:w JE:~~~:g..M::X~A~$mn (~*~!U.~*J3.~) ~:JiJH{fj~Mt (systems of rule ) ,. 76.

(7) 1:-J;Jt~ft J;flf ~~ .. -flJ. m... ill IE9 ~JUm ~ ME ~~ ~ijili1TlW~-tGgDj( ~tm § *I ' 3! fffi f.f ~ tm!l- ~ A~ § ;fJmltl ~ ~ ~[jJ'I1:B~~. (Rosenau, 1995:13-14 ; ~Ut$ti ' 2002:65) 0. Finkelstein ~)C"::tlt~Zf. Rosenau. Rosenau. f.f:i::~mfJI!~W<j£i&1m-lJi1Z.. B~Jf5E~~~.pJT/f''Pl.. ~1tw~U~ff!U~mfJI!ff~~-tmmltl. '. (activity) ,. -W:lfU~t:::W:l~. '. itn*~~)HfftiJ$ fffi~FfflJ~Ij~ME. 0. , f.fflff~~~WJ~ , Finkelstein ~~~:i::~. mfJI! .[jJ~ • • g~~mfJI!ffltl'~M& .~ • • ~~~~ (Finkelstein, 1995:368; I'Jt$ti' 2002:65); ~i§iZ' :i::~mfJI!f~H~MH~~Jf~g f* '. ~P~±.~. ,. .~.~ftb. f~7.l:. ' 2000: 10) M.. Smouts. ti1Jtt~~[jJ~..t.fti1&WJ~~P3ft~$. ~:l§~*€iMUH[jJ~. ~~*&i1&m~.,m*~~~~~~ft.~.~~gb(. 0. Rosenau ~Jf5Ei&1m-f~'#P] , fS Finkelstein ~Jf5E~iJlSI-a-ilJ!J~. ~,~~tm.m'8.~~± • • :l§f.fm-mfJI!.. fJI!~. ~~.,. m. '~~0~i1&m~~Aa,~*~~~&n0U • • ~0~~. Smouts. ~m. r:p'R~. ~.~P3~'~$XUw~~r. (Commission on Global Governance) ~j!!*m-. ,. 1995 .i'j:."Our Global. ~5E.:ft~i1:§. ~mfJI!~. *J (Smouts, 1998:81-83) ~. Neighborhood"¥&E$~~~. 0. ,. mfJI!~~fl0~~l~fll!l. A&• • WfJI!1t~~.5~~~E~~.moE~~ffiliE~~/f'~~~~U. ffi~~~.~ffltl~M.~W°1t'Pl.-a-~.m~A~.~I~ • •mm• •m,. fu'Pl.-a. #I~~~fI~~~;~~mIE9 • • '~~m-A~m • • ~~.~~~1t. ~1j~:fBi~tm. 0. ~:i::~!I-~fffi §. , i&1:tmfJI!-@:j!~i1&WJf\l9~lHlf*. '. fBm~~\~~'Pl.. -a-#i1&Rm.·~fl0~.lW·~~.0~'U&:i::~.*ffi.,~mIE9:i::~m fJI!i&1f~$~. 'fuiH'~,~lJitz.~.ftm~:i::~1i111HllR. Neighborhood, 1995:2-3:. .f~7.l:'. 2000:10-11 ; RmM;,~ ,2000:20;. ;Ut${i , 2002:65-66) M. Smouts ~~ , ~~~~~~ 0. ~r. -fj~W. J. r. J~~qEa~~.b'~~5E.~ffi. Millb5E.m~l:HmfJI!~[9lJI~M. ;. 2.mfJI!f*~~m-tbb.. : '. 1.mfJI!~/f'~-~m~fJ fffi~FPJ3'n~c~~lili!. lW (Our Global '2001:2-3 ;. '. ~5E./f'. ~.fffia~~.tt, fu/f'~-flmltl. ; 3.mfJI!. '. fffi~. ~¥W &~U0$F~&. fl$F~(f;Jffltl:l§. ; 4.mfJI!~/f'~-@I~~tUm ' fffi~~~m-*~i&1fTlW:l§M.liltl fffi7fJJVG~--fl.tU (Smouts, 1998:84 ; .f~5f '2000:11 : IJt$ti ,2002:66) 0. 77. - ~. ~ ~. = t -=,.

(8) ~~'~.~~E.,~¥~~~~.& ),~~~.~~r~¥~~~. • tl:tWiH9. ••. ~~~.m.~R. ••@.(M. •• J~~.aA ••ttR~~tt·. ~. •. ~. ~~~W~.-~R~~~*~rr~~~'M.. (Work Bank). Ji~;L.1J~rr.· .is~~~~ (UDNP). ~~~~.~rr~~'~~wrr~. •• ~~~~. *R~fj~*;L$~· ~~~.~~m~m~~. *~~~{'F~J!UJ3.k:l (OEeD). •• Wrr~~RH.~. W~.~'H.~~~~;LJi~~~~~~o ~~¥~J.lif~~JL' (Institute ~~~~H.~~~N'~fiW~RW.~'E. ~~~.1JMW~rr~'~.H.~. of Governance, Ottawa). •• ~.~. ~WID~'U&~~.~.~~.~~~~MW ~ iU WijJ;fj] •. ~. • 1'9 ~ f4 •. if. (. International. Institute. ~ ~. JL'. ' f1Pfd:.~ffi~.1JW.,~&. of ~.W~il~~*~~m'.~WH.~.~~ .w~.·. Administrative). *. ~~~1~-fj~fi. f4 _if ~ ~ IL'. (Tokyo ~~.~~1~-*fl~ft~{lfWi. ' ~fjWiM. N~mis,@~-mis~H.~~~~.wm~. Institute of Technology). JErtW~FJErt8'9JJ~. I@~~~. ' ~]~U. r ~¥m~~~. J. .. ~~~~fj0~~~A~OOA~. ••~~~~~. ·$~~~~:1Jrt~~m· ~t4*~. : {'F~~~ ~. ,. .~~, 2001 '. 40 ~ ,. r ~¥~~ : .:tRW.1J~mfJT J ' Flm;W. m4:wI ' Jl 2-3 •. ltJi,.UJPJt£ r.:tRJ Wrm1J J ~OO1ID[Q]W~~¥ ~~·m-'~~~~~rr~ •• ~.:tR~~M~~~* • .:t'~UJ~~~~m ~llt, .~~ (2001:3-4). 78.

(9) L. ~JJK~i; J!~;J~ m~,. -~~ffi~%W~. mm~~±ft'~~$m. , [8l(11~~UJi.. (nation-state's family) ,. '. *' *IJ m.. r~~~%%~J. : ~-~~ffi~F[8l(1%fr. ~~itfttl. r ~~tE~iI&mllIft J (transnational sub-political group) , §-2i7~F il&ffiH1i. (NGOs)' 1}~~1JJ ' ~[8l(11}PJ ' ~Bj(Jl*m~t)&~Bj({~Hl~ **~ ~:tfPJT*Ji~~. 0. ,~mM~~mli*~WlilJJ~~Bj(~*'~-M1}Um.m.W7~Bj(m~' ~Bj(m~f§$3t~[8l(1~Fa~J;)[8l(1%iI&Jff~±ft~ril~[:Jij7~FiI&Jff1!~F~l¥JmJJ:. 0. m= · m~WMfmm~~mft~l¥J~J.L. (governing) l' [nJ. m~~jf~8W{.$Mfl¥J*1fril. 0. , Mfril£*.1.~-fi r fjt.1. rmr J. B~lli~~~m.W. [!S]l~t. l' {~~ with government ' lli::fi" ~ without. • Wril ~ l¥J ± ft liB 111.1. · government. 0. l¥Jt:R:mWfJtD~f~. r~.1.rmrJl¥JD~m~~~,. , rmm~. ®~*~rMl¥J~. ~'lli[nJ.~.W7.1.Mm~l¥J~~~~o~m~1'~~iI&Jffl¥J[nJ.~'E.. ~-fi~l¥JMfm~~'-~~~l¥Jn~*Mfmn*l¥J~~' ~~FiI&Jff1!~F~liIJJOOMl¥J~~. 'm~~iI&Jff. 0. ::fi"rm~Bj(m~JE.~2:~~~[I~ -. !~ .'. :il I. .,. 1. I'. I. 0. •. ,. • 'I. , I. ! •. :~Bj(m~JE.-.~. iF{~. 1995. {'F. :tf. J. N. Rosenau. •. JE. ~Bj(m~~~JE~~~~~M~l¥JA~mlJJ(~%~. ¥tl~~*1i.) l¥Jm~!J~Mf. ·. *Mf~~~ftUfr. 1JJ*~*~fi§~'~rm~~~M~A~§~mlJJ~ ~~~t~El¥J~1U. 1995. L. S. Finkelstein. 0. ~Bj(m~~-fi~~~%~ftrm~l¥Jm~DIJJ'~~ r)t::fi"±ml¥JffI~~7t~~. 1995 2001. ~~ii~. r ~Bj(ril~. 0. m~~~fi1}~Ul¥JMA&~.W~~~[nJ.ml¥JH. ~~*J. ~n~B'gm1m. ~~$. fjtr. 0. J W r ffttJ J ~Mi.ffi. ~Bj(m~ $t=i~~ml¥J±ft~. ~JE~Bj(m~o~5'c'. %)1} , lli§-2i~~'t1. ~iI&m~ft:~~'m~WMfmm~~fflft*l¥J~J.Lo JiH*~:1'F:tf~~o. 79. I.

(10) .~~kti~¥~g~~.&~¥~.~~~.~,*~~m~~~g~~ ~~ J;J~ r ~g.:ta. j. W r ~g~fF. PWMOOrOJ:1JDJ;Jft~ (tzo~=). j. :. ~g.:ta. m - ffl3 r~ ~!jJ i& J1~HJ3._. ~mm:LY~J. m ::::. ffl3 F~ :1P 1t ffj *13._. mg~{'F. ~:fI. m~~iM. 0fltbh1J. m = ffl3. r~. ~~,ti~g.:ta~B:~~~~~¥~.~~~.·~~mg~~~.~. m-ffl3r~. (i&jf:f) m.:tll ' m=ffl3r~. (~mmil::~) &m::::.ffl3r~ (1~1;2i:1F1tflJffJl. .&#i&jf:fm.)~m~¥mg~~._o~~,.~m·.M·lliw.~m.. &#i&jf:fm.(~!jJ.H+~. ••. •• )W~.II~~B •• ~·~~~~~~~m. ~~,ti~g~~~i:~¥mg~~~~~~~~~eM,~e.egw. W~fl.f4~t71~ItII.~~. ,. mgj!H'F~JJ!~5tOOrOJ. ' ~:1F.*1tz~$Ut1JJJ~g ; Pierre. , ~~~*Mcm:fl~tzofilJ~m:ffr-0:tt~fH~&. and Peters ~:fI1JrOJ)1.~"~mgftt!!,6. ~fii&jf:fi&.~.~"~#i&jf:fm.,~~~~.:t.®~~,~m~.~~m.. m r 0flffl3r~~:tt~ ~g~. j. . fjBMi7t (2002A:479-481) ~~m. m=ffl3F~!fIrOJm~~$!J. iIJ:t${f, , 2002:71-73) ; 1I ' 1:E~~m~~m~ · m-ff~r~:wJrOJ~1I12 .. (Pierre and Peters, 2000:83-91 ;. . ~m-ffl3r~WJ:wJrOJ0flJbb1Jltllf*,~;fI. 0. .~·*~~m~¥~~~m~~mg.:tm1:E.~M~tbh~~'~~lli~ 1I·m~~~W0Utbh1J.~5t~~~~~eM·. 12 ffM~~1t"F~flrJjfli ' ~~!V;l Cary Coglianese international institutions"-:SCrp~~ElM~iIi:l1lli. 0. 80. (2000):(£ "Globalization and the design of.

(11) ~. ~ , ~J;jtjh 11. *. ~t; J£ • .1f. '* ""1. r ~~**U ~_~*!l_~. ~.Il.. ~M~M~,rr~~~~ • • ~,#.~m.~~0~S~~~ • • D~~. M~0~S~~~~&~~~~~~~o. - " i}~btMJ1.Jtm~)~ ' 0f.b.S~gfl'iL&:Jff ' :ll::~ , m-=-{flW~& ffliI53U 'jtfilJlY;]ftf'FW7t ji~: Max O. Stephenson. Stuart Langton ( 1983) ~1Jlt£m. IY;] .E£.'. rr~I~);j<.fJUd:t!f1li*l:. ( 1991 :110) ~1J;t~mFJTID!j0f.b.S~II~L&:JffWf.b.'gjW~ra9-fllJJfrn~lilJJ~f*; Harding (1990:110) ;t~m. '. 0f.b.S~f*fl'irr0f.b.$r~rp. : Bailey ( 1994:293). ~*,~m&~m6b~~fJlJJ. 1Y;]1I{1t[ , ~mte-~.m~JE~. , ~~{N~~W~filJg , ~JEJ,j.a)(. ~gm Harding ~JE~{IH~l'HllL~l:. , ~gm0f.b.S~ n* § :In~~-ffliI$r~;L.flJ~~. ; gJ;!~I3)] (1994: 61 ) ~1J;t~m ' 0f.b.S~f*fl'i~JE$~~~W ~~ ft<: - fI:f .:In L&:Jfftf{1~ • :lnf.b. {flW~ , ffiH~:.:ln0 f.b. $ r~ *B ftfffl ft<:~ IDl f* ' ~ .W~~.$~;L..~AW§.mfilJ·.M-.&7tI • • ~m~W.~(rr~ ~ . ~lJ9j7t ' 2002C:86-87). .M '. FJTm;L.i~:m~·fJlJJ. 0. ~0f.b.S~IY;]~~fffl i§i ~1Dl{*~£WIHltt~rr:ln r m~. ,. ,. Moulton and Anheier ;t~m ' L&:JffW~~.frj~13..9tJLS. t§li {N~ J (mutual dependence) ,. ~~~~-tv1;:Elf:c£~. mtem =~L&:Jfff!~lfB (The third-party government theory) & 0jtM~~lfB (The. public-goods theory),' 7tfJTL&:JffW~~~flJ*JU~;L.S~~f*. 0. m-=-~L&:Jfff!~mm,rr0.E£.ft.rp#~~m.~mm0jtMIY;].~.~. (Salamon,1987) , jfd:*~r&:l51I. '. IZSHlt '. EE~fffll:AW$D£~IY;]~~.flJ*J3..~m#e~if.*B"J. .~Iii:l1.W~*~:1JA (Lipsky and Smith, 1989-90) ; rrlf:cL&:JffID~. m-.IY;].M~. '1i#.~m.~~~g~'L&:Jff~~ft~~m,.m#.~. *J3.. ~f1~ m 7t L&:Jff$ r~ fJ L&:*~ ~ 5'f- ' J! itJ W~:f &\ ~ IY;] fJ L&::1Z te. 0. 0~Mf!.IY;]7tfJT~.wm=~L&:Jfff!~~~ffi&,~mmL&:Jff~m~0~ ~lliA.,mmM~&~~~~ft • • ft.*~IY;]:ffilJ.*,mWIiL&:Jff.$~ 7}m{~0jt~t&ijili~~. , ~¥.fJJ*13..=tWffrrlY;]~Ii'11: (Weisbrod, 1988) 81. 0. .!. ~I. ~I. ~I ~. ;. J.

(12) ' m.::::.f:f1&JfJ:tJ.~!./iH}~M:£.I~Jiij- , tlm: 1& JfJ Wm -= $ r~ 113 Ii 11:< :m I¥J fi3 tg Wi ~ ire ~ /f · {8 ~ f:f ~ 5g{ ~ ~ {J' ta tJ Moulton and Anheier (2000:108) ~:m. (coordination) ~mtR:~fW:£JH\::;1t~~ff,f*~rp~~l¥Jlfid~11~ 1IEI)j~. , tI))]9j7}. (2002C). ~Ifj. Moulton and Anheier. 0. 1¥JIIf!~~~:il-~~{$. ,. ~~~:m/f~~m.::::.f:f1&JfJIIf!~~~~0~MIIf!~,~.~~m::~.~m.ffi. tlm:1&JfJ~~'~.~.OO.~~ft~~om_f:f1&mIIf!~.~r~1&JfJ~J'1&. m.~~m=.·:m*.m~~7}~,~~.~m.~ftUA~.'M~~-.. r$ti1t J ' ~ ~ Z ' ~{*!l!J.l rt=u r ::br* J $ti~fj~1¥J ~-.~:£]. ; 113 &:f:i£ . 0~MIIf! •••1&m•• mm,~.~m ••oo'~~1&JfJ~a'~~1&m •• ~m~~.m.*~~.~~.g*; •• ~,m-=f:f1&m:tJ..~0~MIIf!~' .~7}~S~I¥J~~,~*a~~fiz'~~1& •• M~*al¥J~m •• (~ ~t~1¥J. [g). 0. IIf!. ~ m-= f:f 1&mIIf!~!1iJ. fi3 tg JE {i'l. f3i{J'~~ ~1&m1t. m.::::.$r~. ••m{:#: ' 1&. 11i{il~~. IJ\~~1&m. m.oo MIIf!:!1iJ. /:\.. ',L.;. j:f: /,r". ij. 1&mftA. ~M~~m~.m-$I*~~~M r~.oo. .~*m. : {'Ff:f~lE El1I~~ , tl)M17} , 2002C ' r :j¥.flj~IIf!z"WbtJlUl{* J ' 1&~m:1IEI)j~£kI ' ?E.flJ~IIf! ' 'E1~t : t9M13t1t ' fJJJWi ' ffi{ 95 0. fW~~1Ul0U"WbtJI¥JJE.,~mmU$M~~~.$M&#.~m.o*3t ~:m,tl~.~m.~~'0U"WbtJ/f~~~W~~I¥Jfi3~lli.'~.~.ff7}. -¥-fi3~t7JA. '. 1¥J.~11~·. ~cpmff~f3iIL'IUl.. · 0fk"WbtJ~0~~~E.fU*Ji.~W0~miU9J. §1¥J/f.~~~M~Mr~ •• ~J&r~*~~7}~J·.A1&. m.R~~~·~.~I¥J~ •• ~Mm.·~m:r0~~WJm~~~.0~. ffI¥JEI~·W1&m~~~.0~.R~fim0~~~I~,~epr.ff~~JI¥J ~.o. 82.

(13) 1:- J;Jt ~* !!. ~ ~~ .. llJ ~.Ii.. ="~'1.\~tJ;ZlIl~ii1'F~!i!e ~T~~~~~~~~,a~~~~m*~m'~m'&~~~~~~~o. 1.~1!l ~~*,~~~ma~Ma8~~.'A~#.~m. •• ~~~ffl'&.~. •• ,~~*a ••• ~.~~0Ugh~~I,~.aMMM~~.~ )7'f-1:Q. ~ 11 A {$ ~ Wet ~iU~f;1J , • fIJ m. &e M Ms:frA1f.*1t ~ ~¥. fIj m. ¥A fT ~~]l .ooo~a~m ••• &.~m.~ •• ,#.~m.~M.*~~.~.~* .,~.~~~#.~m.~~~ ••• ~~A'~®~~7#.~m.~ •• ft, Salamon (1999) mte ' ~ 1977 ~~ 1996 ~ , ~m~F.flj*J:l ••~*_ ' ~ ••• ~~tt~e.e~50%om7W.~m••• a~.~,#.~m.~~ ~~~. ~.~~~~.~'~~$M~0~o ~F.fIJm.rm.1t&gl~~iS~'M'~. ••. 0. t)JBmR~m19U. ' Bloche (1998). •• a~~#.~m ••• m~~.'M'tt''M'#.~m.~~~.~mMAUm q,#.~m.e~~~~m.~~~'M'tt,a~~.g~ •• #.~m.'® .@]~~rtJ~~~U Melnick et at. ( 1999) ~1J~fflf§&:~~fl ' ~£m~F.flJ*J:l.fta m~~T'Mtt.~m •• ~~~,a~.~~~~#.~m.~te~.~~.· .~am.~ill.~ •• ~~~'ili~~~ffiWe~.,am.~.~#. ~m ••• ~m •• ~gh~~~~.'#.~m.~m~0MW.~m •• ~ ~.,~~~ •• ~*~.~,m~~~*~~a~,~mM~m.gR~~~ ~~ •• ' •• 7~~m ••• *1tr*M~J~*,amft#.~m.~~~; ~~'~.~'~~.~m •• mm~A~.~'~.~m.~m.~~~~M •• ~;m=,~~.m~g**1t~.~,.~m •• mmtt#.~m.~~a .~~gm.·~~,a~'#.~m.,.~m.~e •• ~ •• -.~~g hrm~ , .frU§'.11:11:A~~{~~~vr.jW*.*fi.1i:gh ' ®~F.fIj*fi.~lJm~~ ~Ett.~~~f;1J~~~'~&~I~ •• ,.~m.~.#.~m.M@~. 0. ~.~~~~~*,®#.~m.~~~.~~'.B~~~.~,~q,.~. m.&:.~aR.#.~m.~~$:fr~· 2.~1!l. 83.

(14) 1~0. ~m~~.~~~0U.~.R'~~~~0~~~.~~.a. -'.~~~R~~mff'.~~*~~.~R • • ~R.~.ffl'&~ffi~~ f;!UfiU~~Jlo.. '. ~~.~g~~~~16~. ~~~. 80 1:f:{~J;J~~R~~x1fi. : flJmr~tt~RJ!!ije:~f:!tJ!!f*B"J~fH~ lit ' ~'l~~D~~x~~R.%t ' ~1j£\;~giPildE:*B"J15 0. ~·~~~.&m.~~'.~~'~~.M~R~.~'~*~~.~~R~. ( Private Finance Initiative;. , .!@fflG~~t . ~ • . f*{'F&~J& ~.;L.~~,~~.~&g~'~~.M~ • • ~o 1980 90 1:f:{~ , I.59i~.&~~~.~J&~.{t;L:±'!* ' i'&rm ' 1997. PFI). 0. 1t( PFI. . ~*;Ljf:}-ES~t:E0~HfH~~W~. ~ • • ~R~~.'~*.~.&I.~~'~~M0U.~~.~(~ffim~. III. 0~~~~&:iJ) · 5§i~~i& • ~.&m-rmr~rs~ · ffl~:lr.tbh~1m1*' ; 1±~ • • ~. "~. ~mM. !is ::;. , ~rm7t~.~~.~* · :g~7t~U1t(*Jf I.~~~:iJ ~I.0fL.~~§~59i~ : l.~{:!t~i&.~J;J1i-;Li~!H~.~ ; 2. ~i&¥H§:&~:lr..g~I~ , ffl~.~!ttrlJf!±liI~~~.R~*~~1=r;L.r. : 3.mt~0~. ::. m.~~w. ". Iii!. J. II;'. 1,1 . '. ~{*EfflG~~I.fi::§IX~~PJ~ 0. ' Ffi~ge:ij!.;L1If.W~tl7. 0. ~I.;ffi'~1±.~Im1*'.m.r. '~JL~1~1t~i&' Falconer and Ross( 1998:133) 1E1lli ' ~.~. ~ • • 1Jrh~.I.f&Mt ' 59i~0fL.~J;J~X~~Jff ' ~J;Jff!±liI:±'~ . .g{1p , iRI!X0fL .~~fI{fil Falconer and McLaughlin (2000) 0. .~~fLA{£.~J&~i'&~. ~'l~. ,. ~. .. ~~~, ~I.~16~~Jfft:E~*:±'ZJjf:}-ES ' "~fflG. .~~'~.~M~~M'~JffM.~{'F~'~ • • ~Jff~m'~Jff~.mmu $r~~J;JWflJ~~.. '. ffJ~IfflG~0fL.~ff~0~Hf;U~~-~. ~**~JL~*flj!fIm{*,A (stakeholder) ~ff!±fr. ' tElLt '. 0. 1ti• • ~R;ffi'. ~R*j[~~*flj~1m. 1*'lIlftcp , mfl~*~~li~ , ~mfU~1m1*v\-~0fL.~~~ , ~JffB"Jjf:}-EStE~ .~.m~~~.gA~~.*'~~~.~~Jff·~.~#.~m.·ff~0~ HfH~~~~~~. , 0~W~JffrJj~~*3~~;f§~5!il'~ , ~mflJ!f1m1*,~ljfflG~m~. ~.mo. ~~ • • ~Jffrm~. m-rmr~rs'~.:tJ. i&R·. , ~{*~cp~~%tff~0~HrH~ , ~~itf1JD~Jff .. ~*&. ' i&Jff~.1l!~~&HfH~d1.~~~7t ' .:tJ1m1*'E~A~*&. ·#.~m~·HliI&0~m.;Lcp;~~I.rm~'i&JffiR.~.. 84.

(15) ~J;fU~l.!.~-1f. :fHJi~. ~Afi.tt,ft~~~~~~.~Z~~g~o. 3.Iffli~. :1.}fktbh t]:t£fIffi ~ I¥J m~ tf: !f!5Ef~ , *:g~ 51:1.}fk 1bb j] *Jl~ I¥J ii~ !IiUJHltlHN /J\ . • ~*$51~~~~fi:1.}U1bbj]I¥J•• ,~~*.ftm~tt.~~~,m.R~' tE 280 1~ ~ ~~cp , fl1l7 f~ ~ ~~~?6[1:lJ:1.}fk1bbj] (Collin, 1998), g~tBnX: Collin and Hansson (2000:201) JifTm r.rr J (cudgel) :1.}fktbhj]I¥J~!fij:~~ f§)t;' 0. ~a~~I¥J~. :fIffi~am.~Ma~.~R~ft&~g~I¥J.~tt,~~,~. ~f'Frt1~1tjlnJft1E:~~~F~~FifflJ*Jl~ ~ff&. • fi59t*l¥J~ffjU.ffjU. ; litPi- '. !Iffl~am. ' ~7JU~CP:*& f3 tEi~. ' ifD.~~ · ~FifflJ*Jl~~U1Jjf§~~~~ . 1fii~.mz~ , 3lfm~pq~f§. ,i... ~m.I¥J,~m*~.tE~.~.~W51~'~31.~~ft~H#.~am,fu. I. #.~m~-ft!f!5E~~.~o~*'.~~~~~~:M~1bbj].~~~~~ f1Lt)~~~~ '1:E~. • •. lEfk$F~ ~li,!. m~. 0. l¥Jam!g!Jt~, amftfk$F~1¥J1iI7JU. '. , ~~fl31fWfi ' :1.}fk1bbj]~~f~*l¥Jm.~5111J5Z ' ~Ugfjj§lli~31 J.ltit. t!r ifD ':1.} fk 1bb j] ~ g!j if tm If ft (Ancona and. Caldwell,1992; Bante1 and Jackson, 1989; Murray, 1989; Watson et al., 1993) ; oo'~~l¥Jm~~~~ ~,~. ~. .~~.~.~'K~R~~ft~~.~Al¥Jg~o~. I¥JpqtE.~~Pi-1:Em.I¥J~~,~~~~m.mW:1.}U1bbj]tE!Iffl~m~. ffffl (Collin and Hansson, 2000:206) .~Z,. •• ~~amMj§~~I¥J~.,tE1E:.~amM~~ ~F.flJ*Jl~rJj.ft~J~; ~~~Jmjfl~~iJfiJifT~ , 1fJ. •• aml¥Jrm~.MJ'.$51~.~~.am,~~&.~jfI~tt~~lE'* ~tEffd:1iI±:ilM~~ ~:tr-f~i&m ' 1E:~' ~:g~F~~:lJtbhj]1¥J r ~~ Fs'MffJil: J !. am;ifD!Iffl~~~~*~~ffi~.~ilt!r~~I¥J~~(*am),rt1~ilt!r~~1¥J .m,am-InJ~~M.l¥Ja~,tEam.j]±:.z~,:1.}Utbhj]m. •• ~31~·. ~~~amMa.j]B~ •• ,:1.}Utbhj]I¥J~'B.~ft,m~**gJmjfl~, ~iJ #U ifHiUJtU. (t<D ~ 1i ). 0. 85. ............ ~. .. •.. I til. ~. "I. i. 0. ~:1.}U1bbj]. .~ ,:1.}fktbhj]~lffiW3. ....

(16) $!. £1M. ~. ~. ==~~ttl§ Jl(S,a Jl.:!l'. ifZi:mx. ~r~~~Zi:. ~:tlmx. cf.f5t. ~f#~. ffd:~. m~~f#rJ. ~~JtI~. ~~7t:¥. -=.Jitbbh. 1m*1t. 0Utbbh~~.~~r~ffJ~. '~B.r.ff.MJ~m.'~~~·. •• ~B.rn., •••• ~·-=.Jitbbh,~ ••• 7t:¥,xm~w~~~~.~~~~ •• ,~ ~~&£IM$!~-MA~~tt~*.~_.~~,. ~#.~m. ~@~.afi~#.~m.mft.w~~~g*,~~.~-~.~~~tt#.. ••~0Utbbh~.~•• rr~.· •• 7t~ M.~'~~~.R~m~~r#.~m.~~7t.J. ~m.~~¥~@. D. (ICNPO )7t.~~, 1;t$r~l1JIJJfijll.ff~ 27 MAff1-t~t1~~~*fi.( ~D~7\)' *~.~ (2002B:89-90) :. ~~IliTwr~ 2002. 3. Fl. 22 Bnm'~it~1MiTB. '. X{iI!~O~~WffF.B. .. ~. ~~IfF.~;.~~u~.-ftftftfF.~R.m~.m~;~~~A.it.wr~ .it~ff~~~~A.~&.RW~~'ID.m.~a.~m,~w. ~. ••. it~~Aamm.lli{~fj! ~1i~ 1991 fF.E:i3.it~*wrPfTf**,pg; @tf:I:~*~~~tfHf:I~ 1995 fF.~m.it~~~&ffd:wr.awrNGOalm~mo. ~~.#~~.Awr·~~~.~Im.&~~~.tbbwrw~.~a~.ft i&'f;TJ~.w~{*. 0. f§~tlD ' ~~.;f*~~.awr.~t". 86. •• wr~tJJ$t~m".ffli . $¥JJ¥ !.

(17) *. ± J;jt ifj Jl'. ~ ~ ~ *11 ~11. ~ :±JJJ¥~~lt. '. :±JJJ¥~rfH6\~J;I~},[~iilt'Hm~~lt COCOO)' @:fiW~~~fH&~. ~m~~iilt~~~~,.~~~lt~~~~~~~~'~~'~W~iilt~~. FJ:i1¥J. &1i.ltll '. Olympiad). a. 1:E~. .~&$. M~~'. ;/:j.IUx1t '. ~V!tJmlb (Culture. ( Youth. ~ltQ]IOlffi'i1:E~iilt$1=rMrs~ ,±~~. Camp). a. .~~iilt~~.~~~~.lt~E~~*~lt.~'~~~~~ii~§~~. '.~~iilt~.~~ •• M1:E-.~~~·. ~iilb.ltffi~. TiJ ' ~iilt~t5I:tJ~m~+:A7d~mUW ' 2008. 1fflP~~t*~¥J1f. ~m~li. : ~~g'[!ltalt. 1¥J~.~fflb~M~A~~ft'~.I¥J~.1:E~r~ml¥J.ttJ'OO~glt1:E~. ~*~7t51:1f~~'Dlt~lt~.~ftRn~~~I¥J~~'~~.~.~~~1¥J ,~lt~ff~ffi'iI¥JM~'DltM~ffl¥J~*' .~;f[l. ~$ID1:E~.~ftW~. Umm ~ ~~ r5 ' 2j( ~ m® ~~:9:ji fU ~~ tJ &IJ\ ~ ~1'FWd: ~~!jo/J f§ g I¥J tfu. ~ftRti.,~~~ft.~-. .1¥J.~~M.tt~~~ft~1:E**.~ii~. A~;~~~.~Iti.g~~~B}'[ftR~WmW.~;.~WU~ti.W~ ~.m±~~~r5~~. ,. , fJH:ftU~mB~D~ , ~mlb~mumtp{J\. 0. :*:$r~mrr~oo.. f9lJPD~J+. ~~~ ~. (Foundation for the ICRC). lt1l!WftmA!jo/J& 0. A±;!t*Ji~ ~~J+~~llI. ttiijrfiinx~~llIlt~UW~~ftR~f*~t;7]. , JtiIJ¥Jt. ' 1E:~ , ~~~~ •• ' , &~FftR*Ji.B }'[{kf¥gf* ' Mathews 1Olffi'i1:EfiTI*;fij{ftR OMB fJiHfiUtff ~ · ~JfD~ffftfft~: ' ff~ Sylvia Mathews ~JfWftR. :&Jtflli$~&~J!!ji~. 0. •• WftRB}'[~~mH'~~~Mft =:~~r5f¥1:E~~'i"[~~~ , t:£~1'F&5N~ft.!ItIJl~ ,. rr~.'~.~~-~Bji#.~ti RW1E:~ij!)l~~avcD. '. aRW#.~ti.ti.~$.mffilli,~#.~ti.Wft~~~.~~~5N~a ~~~.~,. 3. Fl. ~.m~'m~~~m.I¥J~Hti.,~~. 22 B~J~~~~~3Ilffl~B. •• ~lt~wro. ; .~WU~~ 19991f~~m~zp:~f~~;. ~~~A. •••• w~m.~~~~tfum;~~~.m~~,ft~ft.!~~ B~m.'~ ••• #~~~.lt'~~~.~Iti.&~.g.SltWW'i'tfu amB}'[~t;7]~.#~~;~Wft~;!ttimHB~~tio'~U+~ •• ~ftlt1l!. .~.lt&mw. 87.

(18) Wil&mA¥l1&:1£~A±:tUflm~*J+f£1Efr W&.~0. ' ttJ~i}iH~~£1Efr~tjW~mil&. .~m~D.~Wil&W.B~U.~~~.~'~®,#.~m.. waW.~~~.B~~~~m.M*. (2002B:I04-105). .~tt,u~~.aW~I~. 0. ,~.~tt#.~m.m.~~. •• Bm'0Um~~ •• ~*~~. M~·~W~~W.M~m •• '~.0Um~~.~D ~.§M~~~#.~m.~~·. ~®~~~. ••• 0~Mfr~~~tt,. ~-~®ili~mlli~.#.~m.~~~o~.#.~m.~mfi~.£~fr~ mm.tt#.~m.~,~.*~~m~~~Mm~m.,~~*m~m~r~. ~J~D,m.m.~~.~.~.#.~m.~~~~~~~.~?~~'~. •• ~~~*~r#.~m.m.~.J •• ~.~~am~~~.~£*m~· ,m~~~.~#.~m.~.~BR·~~M~~ft~~,~~~-~. .~#.~m.,~~#.~m.~~~~~tt~~.M~aW~~*.·®:1£. •• ftA.~~~O,m~·~fi~.£1Efr.*~m.~.~~.#. ~m ••• ~~~~~$.'§Aft~mfig.£~frW~.~ •• ·~~*$ ~~~. ~~F.flJ*fl.~~mF~Itl' tlD{6J?I*~%<:~~~m~?. IH&. I. 0fLWb~{~:p.~.. •• Drm~.BJwr~.M.J~,aW. a.~ •• ~•• BR'#.~m.~*~aW~B~.*m.,~w •• ~~ ~0~fr±fr ? ~fi~m~l~. ~. fit. 1.x1'tWP~~. .~W.frM. .~tE~F.f[J*fl.. ~*&~fit. 1.x1't'&fiVltj. t!tWx1't~J:I. (World Cultural Forum, WCF) 2J~~ !jJ~~f*~£~~fr INTERNATIONAL OLYMPIC COMMITTEE, IOC) !jJ~iiliTfr (Lions Clubs International) 3. arH9!i{~ ~gB 2.fi~W1iJf~ 4.*JJ~.& ~ ~~!z~ ~1!ffrifi~*fl. (Waldorf Education) !jJ~*~Wbfr (International Association of 5.r%~fi~ Universities) .~nJGAfi~~fr (International Council of 6.~A~fi~ Adult Education). 88.

(19) 1: JljU{J J!.$t ~f.f :fll ~r..&\ ~li~Uft=.g~F~1i1f~~1t (The International Society for Third-Sector Research ,ISTR) 8.g!)}t1R~~ M, ~ Wg1:=.*R~ (Medecins Sans Frontieres, MSF) ~~~A'~15~1iJ (International Federation on 9 .l¥lf![l! z * Ageing) 10.{,'~~m fB titW{J\~fW1:=.~~Hm World Federation for Mental Health) f~Ufl~jj ~ ~~ ~ 1ft (International Committee of l1.jtftg~mH~~ the Red Cross ) 12 .iii±1t H~~fJH~ ~1imliZ*Jl~ (Free The Children) 13.~~~f4~m ~~~.~I*R. (National Voluntary Organizations Active in Disaster, NVODA) WJ 14.*~~ 1:=.mt¥J ~~Miimh1ft (Care). 7.1i1f~. 3.~m. 4.Wti1iJm~~. 5Z¥-i 5.$:tj!. 15 .Ifl!:tj!{*~. ~ ~.t~d3f!JZp:*li~. (Greenpeace International) 16. f*~1tJ4o/) ~~~~1!ta1iJ (Jane Goodall Institute) 6.~~Wfj:~ 17.*~~ , ~1t, W titW~ItIiWJ1ft (World Council of Credit Unions, WOCCU) i!f±1iI~~ 18.fj: ~f~ Ml' ~~~A'fifJj~ (Habitat for Humanity International) ~~~1f1:f.1t (Young Men's Christian 19.~~WII~ Association, YMCA) 7.mtl!'M~~ 20.0~ M~B"J titW0 ~Wti1ftrq]~ (CIVICUS) t~iI&. *Jl~ 21. 1* ~mtl!fl~ ~~B)HJl~ (Transparency International ) ~ 22.iI&.*li~. .. 1!~~.. 8. ~~*W~jgJi 23.~~*R. IWt¥JWf!fJ. Foundation). 9.~~~t1mltJ. ~~!/?j~*Jl~. 24.~~~tEmltJ. tcm~~:::k:Mfi~}fr:1iJ (The. Bill &. Melinda Gates. ( Amnesty International) 25 ~*Jl*~ 10.*~j( '±~C~f!fJ~{~ft1ft (Missionaries of Charity) 11 ~ 26. 1£ ~ WW~ ~ titW*~ ~ ~Jfa i:I ( World Economic Forum) 1ft ' ta1iJ ~1ft'mh1ft 12.jtf1Q1JfID 27.jtftl!*g~ tltWiftittglfai:!l (World Social Forum, WSF) ~*4*~. : 1Iryjfl~ , ~MJ:5t ' 2002B:13-18 89. 0. I I.

(20) ~~~~~. •• ~~.,~~~g~.~~.ttm.~.~~,. ~#.~. JZL' ~ • • r.ff• • J~ • • ; .·~.&.ft~=~A~~tt.*.~ •• B~' ~~~.~m~~.~~,#.~m ••• B~~.,.~~~.~m. m.~M~~ili0Umn~~~~~~~o0Umn~~~~~r. Z~ • • ~·~~.z.*~~'~~~~~~. .'~.~W.$~~. ; fffjfj:£.~j~~F.fIMtl •• 1'F*~,.PJj;J~~ , $.;fi~ •• ~~~0 '~ •• m~ •• ~ •• ·-~OO'~$.*¥$~·~ ~ . Pi~mjjj$Dz ' ;fi~APi~mm$Z~F.f!J*J3..5Z~ , .~~iE:~tzD1PJ.ff!fl~ i60i'1tzDfPJ•• ~~ , mOO:~~~fffj~~ ; ~-~OO ' ~F.fiJ*J3..,~~i][g&i]rlf~ .~A~ •• ·mft~~,~ •• m~ft ••• m'fu~ •• AA~m~~0& tzDfPJID!~lf~1i~~w~Hm. III' ,I. jfr±.z~.. 0. .~'0umn~ffi~.~~.~,~m.~~~#. m1E~N*U. :. ti~'~0Umn~~~fffj§'*$%~.~~~~~.Z%I'fffj#m.. ,I·. I't I. §mz%.,. •• ~Rz~~#~~~~~~~~'~~~ OO~~~(~~m~M@z~ ••• )&H~~~OO~~~~(~W~~~.)' 0&mnM•• Z%Itttt.$.~.~·~mm.&~~.~ ~%Ilf m.~ , ~llt · ~t~~~.l1i~Rm.ff!lf1JlJ~aJHt ' ~:t:k~~F.fIHIl. •• ~. , ~fjg~~F.fiJ*J3..lfA~±tt· ~~ , {tm.~~~~.&!i~OOLPJijf1JlJ~aA ~'ffi • • •~L.ft~.,~~,#.~m ••• ~R •• ~0 •• ' ~# .~m.~~~fi.~~·~.m~.m~.IA'fu~m#.~m •• ~~ • •. 8~~WJi. ~;~ ~,. '#.~m. •. , 8~~F.fIHJ3.*~~±ttfffj§. '~.iJ&R~fIJJtl. .flJm.~f;O~.~1}. ~0umn~.'~iJ&~nftA#.~m.~.~,~fffj~~-~. Jtl. •• ' ID!~§fIJJtllifflM.~~WwH~~~~ID!1t:*m . fffjgt~ .f!HJ3..futt~iflfiJJtl ' 1ff~1E0fltbbni&lf~~~mzlf~ r ~§ J ~ •• ; fffj&. ~F.frHJ3..z~~. 90.

(21) 1:-J.ijU~!£$!.~~*:f:tl tL~. ~~&g~~~.,#.~m • • §M~~tt,~.~~~~~~~.o. &ti~&g~~.~.~.*.'ffi§M.~~'~~~~fr~~~A~.'® R#.~m.~.~B~ U~~®~,#.~m.m*~~tt~A~fr.tt,~®,.*m~#.~ m.ft.m.~.~ZM,.aZ.~~g@#.~m • • • • • ft.,.~,. §Mamm~M~g@#.~m.Z.Ro. ~~*13 -'J:tIX$?} IT. ~'2000' 0*Wi~ - ~~!fi!.J'Ef.ffit. tIBJl~. '. i=J~t. , j!)H9J~ , 2002A ' r ~F.fIJWi~Z.J~IfI~ J Wi~ , i=J~t : ~M1:t1t ' W1t& ' J{ 475-496 a. : JCOOlli1t& '. I:. a. !&~~iIBJ.l~~.. ' i§!JIJ. ,. a~m*w.~ft.ft+~~M@ • • ~~M.~.fi. 'M•• ~:. rIBJ.l. ' j!)M1~ , 2002C ' r ~F.fIJWi~ZWh~f:Rl1* J ' !&~~iIBJ.l{~~. ' ~P.fIJ WifJ!! · -Et~t : WM1:t1t ' ;fJJ1t& ' 81-124 *_:t, 2000 ' r ~~1tft~F~JfHf:l. (NGOs) tim~1Ul1*Z~W J ' *B1:!i:*c.WJJ ~lI ' m11 ~, 43-51 !X!:~BJ.l ' 1994 ,r ~f.Lmr~tbb~m!WJmr1J.~-~a:1E 21 ~m~~¥IH5 J ' S§:r~ , m 56:j:t§' J{ 61-67 a. ............... 0,. a. ~9=:t~. zmlll6 J '. , .a~ , 2000 ' r -Et.**~ft~~~F~m*li. (NGOs) ¥)jj!tre~JlJ~lI. ' m 11. ~. ,. J{. 72-84. ~5.2~. , 2001 ' r ~~1E:1fJ!! : ~ftft1l~SkJMffT J ' Jf 1-24 a 91. ~~. a. BJ.lJ5fr ' 2000 ' r ~:E*1E:1f!!!l : lfI~ftOO~N J ' *E:t!tre~JlJ~lI ' m ,II ~, f*~~jg , 2001 ' r ~:E*~~ft~~1i~ J ' ~~IUlHM'¥f& (~~*.) , J{ 157-171 a ro'.ft1iEf~. .J. ~. NSC-90-2414-H-004-031o. '. ."1.. I~. rr~.'j!)M1~'200m,~.tt~&R.m.Z~.'Wi~m~ftMMZ~'fi . !X!:~BJ.l. ~~ ....... 36-42 16 ~ ,. a. , m40 ~ , m4 ~ ,. ~ ~. I.

(22) t~ff~. In •. t.~~~+~~~~. • • ~lwoo,rA.~.fi~~ffl~:.~~fi#amm.~~~J'~W~1 38 ;g 4 W3 ' Jf 1-40 ;UJ;${i , 2002 ' r ~~fflf.lm~rT~@fJ~5E{llfi~m~Jm: : ffl~~~l¥Jm.fim. m. *Ji J. I. m. 0. ' rra!!i!&m~¥&. ~ 34. I. W3'. 57·83. 0. 8ij~1mt ' 2000. ,r a. NGOs 1:E@fJ~Wd:frpJTf7:h~I¥J~~fiJJJij~J' ift!ti:J~fA¥ijffii:l;l1 m11 M ' 52-61 lf5Lflf ' w*i~ 2000 ' r f;E~~filf;;~~a.:jpam*Ji.1:E~l*fflf.lr:pI¥J~~fi '$:{)Ifi : t).~~m~am~~~19~ J ' *JTi!t&cl'A¥ijffii:l;l , 11 M ' ~ 62-71 If!fJT~ , 2000 ' r ~~~ra'~ctfrjJ : a. NGOs fi~~fft±frcf,(1i£ J ' *JTi!t&e.I'A¥Wt1 , ~ 11 M ' ~ 12·16 0. ,. m. 0. 0. .~.,woo,r=+-t!t~#.~fi#amm.~~~~J'mmel'A¥M.' ~. 11. M ' Jf. 17-24. 0. =' ~3tgB5t Ancona, D. G. and Caldwell, D. F., 1992, "Demography and design: Predictors of new product team performance," Organization Science, 3:321-41. Bailey, N., 1994, "Towards a research agenda for public-private partnerships in the 1990's," Local Economy, 8:292-306. Bantel, K. A. and Jackson, S. E., 1989, "Top management and innovations in banking: Does the composition of the top team make a difference?" Strategic Management Journal, 10: 107-24. Bloche, M. G., 1998, "Should government intervene to protect nonprofits?" Health Affairs, 17(5): 7·25. Brown, L. David and Kalegaonkar, A., 2001, "Civil Society Support Organizations and Sector Challenges," in Zhao LiQing and Carolyn Lyoya Irving (eds.), The Non-profit Sector and Development, pp.291-298. Hong Kong Press for Social Sciences LTD. Clark, William C., "Environmental Globalization", in Nye Jr & Donahue (eds.), Governance In Globalizing World. Brookings Institution Press, Washington, D.. 92.

(23) ~. '*. it:; iI $t ~~":ltl. il .. C., 2000. Coglianese, Cary, 2000, "Globalization and the design of international institutions", in Nye Jr & Donahue (eds.), Governance In Globalizing World. Brookings Institution Press, Washington, D. C., 2000. Collin, Seven-Olof, 1998, "In the twilight zone: A survey of public-private partnerships in Sweden," Public Productivity and Management Review, 21 :272-83. Collin, Seven-Olof and Hansson, Lennart, 2000, "The propensity, persistence and performance of public-private partnerships in Sweden," in Stephen P. Osborne (ed.), Public-Private Partnerships: Theory and practice in international perspective. London and New York:Routledge. Couto, Richard A., 2001, "The Third Sector and Civil Society: The Case of the "Yes" Campaign in Northern Ireland," VOLUNTAS, 12(3):221-238. Dekker, Paul and Broek, A. van den., 1998, "Civil Society in Comparative Perspective: Involvement in Voluntary Associations in North American and Western Europe," VOLUNTAS, 9 (1): 11-38. Falconer, Peter K. and McLaughlin, Kathleen, 2000, "Public-private partnerships and the New Labour Government in Britain," in Stephen P. Osborne (ed.), Public-Private Partnerships: Theory and practice in international perspective. London and New York: Routledge. Falconer, P. and Ross, K., 1998, "Public-private partnership and the new public management in Britain," in L. Montanheiro et al. (ed.), Public-Private Sector Partnerships: Fostering Enterprise, Sheffield: Sheffield Hallam University Press, pp. 133-48. Finkelstein, Lawrence D., 1995, "What is global governance?" Global Governance, Vo1.1, No.3, pp.367-372. Harding, A., 1990,"Public-private partnerships in urban regenetation," in M. Campbell (ed.) Local Economic Policy, London: Cassell. Keohane, Robert 0.; Nye Jr., Joseph S. "Introduction", in Nye Jr & Donahue (eds.), Governance In Globalizing World. Brookings Institution Press, Washington, D.. 93.

(24) I,. ... C.,2000. . / Langton, D., 1983, "Public-private partnership: Hope or Hoax?" National Civic Review, Vol. 72, pp. 145-157. Lipsky, M. and Smith, S. R., 1989-90, "Nonprofit organizations, government, and the welfare state", Political Science Quarterly. 104 (4):625-48. Melnick, G., Keeler,E. and Zwanziger, J.,1999, "Market power and hospital pricing: Are nonprofits different?" Health Affairs, 18 (3):167-173. Moulton, Lynne and Anheier, Helmut K., 2000, "Public-private partnerships. In. the. United States". in Stephen P. Osborne (ed.), Public-Private Partnerships: Theory and practice in international perspective. London and New York:Routledge. Murray, A. I., 1989, "Top management group heterogeneity and firm performance," Strategic Management journal, 10: 125-41. Naidoo, Kumi, 2001, "Building Civil Society Globally: Reflections on Board Trens and Current Challenges," in Zhao LiQing and Carolyn Lyoya Irving (eds.), The Non-profit Sector and Development, pp.81-94. Hong Kong Press for Social Sciences LTD. Nye Jr., Joseph S. and Donahue, John D., 2000, Governance in a Globalizing World. Brooking Institution Press, Washington, D.C. 0' Connell, Brian., 2000, "Civil Society: Definitions and Descriptions," Nonprofit. and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 29 (3):471-478. Pierre, J and B. Guy Peters, 2000, Governance, Politics and the State, London: Macmillian. Rosenau J. N. and E. Czempeil, 1992, Governance Without Government: Order and. change in world politics, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,1992.. Rosenau J. N., 1995, "Governance in the twenty-first century," Global Governance,. VoU, winter, pp.13-14. Salamon, L. M., 1987, "Partners. In. public serVIce: The scope and theory of. government-nonprofit relations", in W. W. Powell (ed.), The Nonprofit Sector: A Research Handbook, New haven: Yale University Press.. 94.

(25) ~J4t)~ J1:~~F. '*. ;flj U~. Salamon, L. M., 1999, American's Nonprofit Sector: A Primer, New York: The Foundation Center. Salamon, Lester M., 2001, "Toward Civil Society: The Global Associational Revolution and the New Era in Public Problem-Solving," in Zhao LiQing and Carolyn Lyoya Irving (eds.), The Non-profit Sector and Development, pp.27-40. Hong Kong Press for Social Sciences LTD. Smouts, Marie-Claude, 1998, "The proper use of governance in international relations," International Social Science Journal, No.155, pp.81-89. ,Stephenson, . J., 1991, "Whither the public-private partnership," Urban Affairs Ouarterly, 27:109-127. Watson, W. E., Kumar, K. and Michaelsen, L. K., 1993, "Clutural diversity's impact on interaction process and performance: Comparing homogenous and diverse task groups", Academy of Management Journal, 36:590-602. Weisbrod, B. A., 1988, The Nonprofit Economy, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Young, Dennis, Hollister, Robert M., Hodgkinson, Virginia A. and Associates (eds.), 1993, Governing. Leading, and Managing Nonprofit Organizations: New insights from research and practice, San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers.. 95. Iio......

(26)