歐洲安全情勢變化對兩岸關係之意義及影響
26
0
0
全文
(2) li~'ffi~ili6.7.~~*~~•• ~.B~~W·*~ •••• ~ •• .~~~~~~Z~.~~•• ·.~~.~~~.M~~~*~m.M. ~tf-1 (NATO) ~*Wi~m.~~~li!tIJ~il&m.~!AraJfij~§Jff!. ; maZ '. ~«~~.M~*~~~nkA~~E~ ••• ~~~·*~~n~r~. A. J. (intervention) , Ml.~F1Ji~1n.$=fffl. '. ;ttftl!.~fJ;J.t±\OO~w. ~·~~•••• ~.MW.il&m~~.m.'.~kA~ ••. '. ~j!fi~. o. r ~~ um~~][ J( New Strategic Concept i w..M1JIJ~m!tIJ~~lliJji-x~~~il&m ' ~~~~t*m:~~-'-~~il&Wt~~ 4-4~B ra' · ~t~~~~~~~~J.!I!.Jt !£ftll~.?}li~~·r'l1f~~~ft. . ~ ,I;).~tf-1-fLfLfL4tm B0:ffl~ 0. i¥HtJTtll~~:F~:#:~I~ (FRY; ,1;), ~fiiHfijiVJ~M) ~~. , -IN:~1S.~t~.!It$B. .~7~~~*4- •• ~~¥~~.~~.~°.!lt-.m~*~ft,~.~ ~rl:1~~*1i/fitlZSl.!ltijt~-@I~~k. AIZSI*. 0. :1:8 8~ . tiJf*U.M~~tf-1:fi!~. itkA~~.$.~'~.~.N~~~om:~¥oo@~~-~m~~:m •. 1996 4.M~~~~1H:&~f*~ft~1Ji1MHii.~il&jfi·[j:'§'7f,:. 1nfJ[.flj~~~:!I:. , mt~.M~. ' ~.t&~• • ~~~*!E~ r il&*~j}~ J ~JjJU~U ' 1ttOO:m. Zk A~~$l9i~.~ §. ~/ff.!Q '~5:1U~*~#~~~~~il&mfD~umfil5. ~E~~/f.ffilliJ'~~A. ••• MW..~~~~~E~~~n~g~~. ••Mm*§J~r~~~m~J~~~~N'.·~·$·~ .~4-4~~~~~~~m~l9i •• itL.~fi.am~A.$.*'.$ ~o$.L'. ~7~«~~~m~o~~*~'~~~~~~e~~~~m~il&mA~® a.,a~~.m.ft.~~OO~.~3*·m~~'~~Hm~OO~~®. .~ili ••• ~.~'~~.~1ntiJf~.~~um~~~.«·~~~m*:fi!. ~~kA~~ ••• ~,§n~~~~J.!I!~ •• ~~m3:maZ'~1nff. ~ , mt±\~=f~~t! tp~ffiH~~o. • '. 5.2.~?Jli~!i. ~~~~limn~~4. *.1n.~~~j]~ ~*iIl~~'jG ~1i~t. i1B 1ft ~ ft!l N. · J.!I! ffii. (incentive) , ~ ~. f:t53-00rn:i\oJIl~ .iI$£;~.~ . ~t~. ~~~liiI~~~W.. ®IH!W 6. ,. 'i'~ili/f. tQ.~4~utf~*~. -fi§*mm~.$. ~:XEt1! ? n~1UIt1. 1JHlltum J IiJ. (Towar(. (ASEM) ~~. Policy for China-E. f*rmf*, J X14 (B 1ljf;.mi£1n*lm ft: ;!t= ' -fLJl 7 ElJ3 , jd5lH5J lJJ Ii. (European. *'. •• ¥-M~A~~~~'./f~~.Mn~Z.~'. W.-~J.!I!~ft~~. w«§ f&1J\/f~*~~IIT' ~fij~ft~~4*~.~1tI1'11f~.B~Il~WtiJf~{j\ 2. 3. ~1JII~t~ r *'f~@.~ J a<JJ"J~m~M1"The Alliance Strategic Concept: in Press. Communique NAC-S (99) 65," at http://www.usia.govltopicaVpoVnato50ltexll99042411.htm. ~fjV a.1t~fBlfJJ"JiI&· :::f'~fBlfJ~~:t.J-=fffl JiI&J&~Jilt;Z.-a<Jr lIi~0~ J (RAND Corporation) B:.!'f!!l!!tI1~t~.*~~1tftrf5;Zf~ii • @~~*lE~tJF}dt~a<J~ mii~ ; J! Margarita Mathiopoulos, "The USA and Europe as Global Players in the Twenty-First Century," in Aussenpolltik, No.2, 1998, P.43.. 4. Hanns Maull, G (London : Routh~. s ~$~WW52~ Pacific) ';;$:3t 6 7. ~ ftf!:{£ J"J a<J f£ il "Leader: China e "ChinaIMilitary (08-03-1996), N.
(3) ~~~~ • • ~~tiM~H~Z.~&~.. In. mt~it~~JH*!~. .'.ili~~~Btt!¥J~" ••®~·~~~~~~.~~M~~~.MK. 1t*gUfJT~.ooW. 1f!!¥JfEl Ml_1f{. @Jffl;~~z'. ~>CJ5JT~W® r. fr. 0. .'§M~®~~m.m~~.'ffi~OO!¥J •• ~*~~·.a~&M. 1l~~!¥J~ItJ~Im4. 0. r *ZP#§~JtI J. 1£.~JtlA!¥J01H~'. 5. (Pacific Asia) ~. ~w, v[HI.~. *.~~~!¥J~n~~·K~1£m~±.~~~~~§~!¥J~~$~'ili=. lifmlll. ~*~~%~~#.~Z~~,~!lt~~!@:~1£~~~.'~~~m~~~. 0. J31};fp®r~~. :':::~3i:ii!:i&~,. ~15- ~ 3i:~ ttw. .m!¥J~N'~~~.~~2~tt~~'. • • ~frAM. Ml~!¥J.~. (incentive) ,~~~~~:t:~~~t~JlI$~ffiamlM1¥!¥J1lf~. 0. ~jffi ,. ;fi. ..~,. f!~1z:'ms~jjpj. r ~~IIlJJl J (security concerns) ~~~ • .oo.fil201Uu m:~$t!¥JjUR ' ~t~;fO • .oo.~ AliI~5i-.~!¥J1EII1,G\x~~tt59i ' mmi,.t*fE M~.liI~~~.;fOZP!¥Jft.ffjj~'*n#M1¥~~•••tiM•• ~ ••. t.oo~.:f t;ft:J:fi!s. ~MlW6,~~&~nm~~1£~.~.~~.N~ffim.!¥J~.~o~W. -fJJU1Ufli!@: : ;f.N. fI.~if:!¥JUff~*!~.,G\1~ ,{JJitt~*Ilt~~B. : ' miJl~.oo£. -.*mm!¥JJlI.1lf~o~M~1£~~.~~W~~ffih~?frA!¥J~~~. ,J]j{~U ' 1i!ffiJj!. :fi!3h~~:fi!. •• ~M~$.:K-, •• -ftft~if:~~~r~§ lJtI~1B! J (Towards a new Asia Strategy) • -ftft1\if:3Utft r §.(;lll$tt :fI J (ASEM) !¥Jtiii!itlfijtl · [PJ~0:tn r r ~.!! '.Ml1*~Wl~m J (Long-term Policy for China-Europe Relation) '-ftftftif:R:im.~ r .~filM!ft~OO~ 1*Ml1* J ;)(1'4: (Building a Comprehensive Partnership with China) ~l!tltJl'F .~ • .oo.£~*fE•• §~liI~*!¥J •• ~~,m.e.aml~1¥Ml1*Bm~ ~;K=,-ftft1\if:=RAB •••fiti~:J:tJlI.~.a.ffjj.~.~. ~7 , *mH}}fiI%1mp)'59i?'UDIl?!J.Jt~t*~fI~fla.!¥J~±~~ , ffjj.~. 1Z ' Iftn-f:f. (European Parliament) ill:if:*J!$t1&:im.:@1~~#MlM.Mlf*;Zlk:Jl;)(. gm.:fbfB!lt~B. #ifD~~."J. II tf~ s ~1~:J:t ,~,~,~. $~~'WBEIJ 1I1i&!~A~!¥J ~hf1ii~1m!¥J. r~Zi!.. '. ~~-m®~. •. .oo.~2~.~~M.~@A. .~~?M.~.±. 0. :fl.. !~WiiJf3lC{,\. cept: in Press. 4. Hanns Maull, Gerald Segal, Jusuf Wanandi (eds.), Europe and the Asia Pacific, (London: Routledge,1998), P.80.. 5. ~~.Wti~~~~.~B9MOOm~~r*~~~~J.r~*~EJ (~a. '9fU1411.htm.. Pacific) • *3tf~fN.~~.'11ftrflii*ffl r *~~~~ J. ~ l!iJ J ( RAND. M~:.t£pgB9~ur*~~mJiI*~B9~*. :/dt~B9~. 'layers in the. 6. '. B9ffl1:t ' .m-§t.5a#i. ~7J~~*~~E. 0. Ibid., P. x.. "Leader: China engages," in Financial Times, October 18,1999. "ChinaIMiIitary exercises off the Taiwan Coasts," CFSP Presidency Statement Brussels (08-03-1996), No.55 I 4/96 (press 54)..
(4) (out of. ~*L {JE.,f$t T::. ~a).~~@&~~i¥J~~~~'B~.~A• • ~.g~~.~.~.. , ~t~*!lr: (crisis manag.. {tf:8 • 3i5:5tf1#~t.tm.l¥i1i~fs!~i¥JmWrI. r f4*~ (Kosovo). 0. ¥i=~. ,. ~t~!I:k151~f.JliI'l1:. m~ J 3tM'~t~-Tm iJw.1ti~. ?. ~~. , E~.gW~t~. ~~i¥J.~*.,m~~ff~• • *@~mmmfitti¥J~.,m.m • •. J=l ;ru r:p ~ t.t ~ t~:r5l~ J¥j ~ g i¥J 59i l.!Uf ~ , 9 ;. ~t. *ffU.. i.ifEj! I±lMP¥ ~. m. -m i¥J?It rI. ji-~iID § , r:p~:1pEl~IDlil¥u~t~fnl1:EiJlIl~i§jiH~if!i~-m. r 5."2%1ti. J (Asian Kosovo) 10 , .mI'I1i~i¥J~1t~*Lti1a~ijrr;ttt.t~~ 3t~~.i¥Jm9;o (perception) 'jiiIDalIlfJ5!TBVI r :k~5'i-~ J i¥Jm~jJim. ""f ' t.t~~l'~ fF._J=l=+1ZY , ~1'5'i-:p.:. , ~n. i¥Jf4*~. 0. ~~~i¥J;ru~1. E-TB~ • • i¥J~~.~.om~~.~m:ki§#mJ¥i¥J~~m9;oW~~:5t. +=Fl ~ Transatlantic P. ~. ~J. ~~~.m~~t~~1&.~D~1IDt.tmJ¥i¥J'I1i~~1t '.~L~B~'3'l:~R1fl. , 11Ulwrt.t~t~~~~~i¥J~ltU1'Fm '. ~il~~:@.i¥J~@. ,. JU~.ml59i. li. (CJTF:C. mZ-i¥J.~.~,r:p~ffi.r:k~5'i-~Jm~t.ti§~59imi¥J:5t~~.,~. ffEE-T Jj! ff~. 3i~. i¥Jm7TJff*&~ '~UJ§~~.¥u.m1i" /\i¥J:lLfjjWfj,. ~~: fJ!ff~~. , ~~IJ11i~~~,f$t¥Ij.~.~1ID$;jj(it.lfiiiJW.3C~ZJt ' .m.~p*&\fl *?Jti¥J~::h~t5 'f4*~~~J '*1if~x (East Timor). BMli¥J':ki§. ~~.~':kB~.Tmmfs!~m~o. ~~trt.t~~. r iJ.F=~.~~1tJ. ~. 0. ~J!~~~'11:. Christ :k1W1I::kg§t'f. ~~~.ZW'.~3C~M~1ID~~.~~.i¥J~~:.~1:E.~i¥J~. •. (W.. tB. r~t~*~. Carter). ~{-tB. @W~.,.g-.~i¥J5'i-xW~~am·5.~*.1ti~·~r:pw.~~~ ~i¥JM1:E~~,r:p5."2~liIi¥J~~W~~~~,~~wri¥J~~~~~~~~'. 8. ~~*~~. •• fi~~*~~• • ~~~~~SM-ftft~~E~=+AB~. II. Robert Faloll (Belgium). 12. William C. (. '~M~*~~MAm.m~~~.J·-ftft~~-~+EB~'~~~~~ .~~ B4-0145/96 ~~.J ,-ftft'R~-I:::;~+/\B~ 'a.1£jjJ~m~fi]1!!. ~~.JW-ftftft~=~nB~rW~~~ft.~n~~~~~.J 9. 5IUIHf' r mki~~~~~. '''PilaT.' ~+/\M ' -ftftft~'R~ , JV\·. UBMIT=View & CQRETURN=&CQPAGE=2 ; ~t~~~~~~t&jt;5t:fff J 10 . .. r~mAffi' Ytm• • J 'A.~EUI' -ftftft~E~+[gB '~-I:::;Ji&; "Special Rqx>rt 719: Consequences of Kosovo-Views from East Asia," at bttp:!1 pdq.usia.gov/scripCslc:•••. 13. PP.25-27. "The NATO. 14. Warren Chr. 15. October 21, Jltm.~~. 16,1999 ; at I. :. Willy Wo-Iap Lam, "Self-Destructive Nationalism," in South China Morning Post, May 19,1999.. June 30, 199. Senator Ric Roundtable.
(5) ~~~~ • • ~~ftm~~.z • •. &... l~. ~1iI tt (out of. ~*L{lEmG7"~t;~1~inft1J*1El¥J~lBj!ffllm5 0 gt~~~mi~.3l:~.*l¥Jft.lftffiJ. ~~i!f.ft(M. 13 . ~t~*.ur~~tL~ 7". 11t~.ooW~t;~ [ff~:f.N.~fI. fD. r ftig;gm~ J (conflict preventation). (crisis management) l¥J~~. ,. r ~mJ«:J:!I! J. l¥JJJiUW -111111. A1~EHJt~U~l£ r ~:1J1:iL~~~1Bj!f J. ¥~1itl¥J • •. l' . tt~~~fl5E:ttBl&~fJ r 3l:~!liUlli J (export of security) II ~..=.fj - +IZB B ~t~**~~-g-~f5lt1lffiJttf¥j~.ooI1J~ , ~IDfB;ft~1§m~,*1i. ~-Mr5211#. .,.~~~m~7"*~~~BM~IiI.ftig;gl¥J-.~.~D. 0. ~7"ltJf~~ 'mlBj!f~m. ;ft• .. ~~!f!l£ffj-~~*fF,¥NpmtS~ln~t~ft1J*1E~lBj!fjl]~l¥J~[i]. , x~. ff).:5e 51: ~fU~'. • • fF,¥~M.~~*M.'m*.~~tt~~oo~*~~m~·.~-1111 Ii. + - fj ~t ~ ,~ ~ mi¥6 • • ~ L ~ ~ r * j!§ ¥F ~ jI] 11J{ J (A New. g%1WfU~7t. Transatlantic Agenda) W-11117\~~*B;f*i¥6~. L~5E*JimG r ~-g-~~ffi). , ~U~~11#~ Ht3'&:ff! ' J1J. ~J. {fE;e:-=f:EJ~:tE!jIG~U1f:~~i&J&'§ ~~ §. ,l¥JJL~Wfj. ~rPJ. :Mt!r.r*&:H~·. BIWll¥J r *~¥F~ifB!:I.~ J L (Transatlantic Forum). :J. 0. ~mM.. (CJTF:Combined Join Task Force) ,'~~:::t~~a}jlWHt. ' iltfr,. IDfB ' *¥.5(fJ~ffU1Ulli t:rgW3~l¥J~t~~1Bj!f. J. iU~±~ r ~t~iR*d6\. ,12WJ:J:!I!~f9i~:.t;aWf4 (Marc Grossman) a}j~ r ~t~d6\~. ~~trttlil:b.)~JWj~ (broad range) ~nez~~lli@]~. iiiil (W. Christopher). J. 13 ,. M~f9i~P51!f!:.Wf~. WM~~g~~~flJ (W. Perry) -tE.lEJff~m r ~t~~.. *~~*~¥Fmff:l£~~l¥J~lBj!fflJ~ J j:~ 11# l¥J ftJ. lli~*. : :EJHf:~~ffi)~;fOJ,~ (William S. Cohen) tn-1111)\~j!§~~B (WEU). aJ:iJ!~1H\ltE. I±\. 0. 14 ,. $~~t}~ (R. Lugar). r ~t~**d6\~JHe-!~Wf.Wth.~~~Um~IBj!f§~m:. J. IS ,. J!f!J3 Bf~. -f;-!M'~*1E (J.. Carter) ~~~MI!m~3l:i£1imr..~::{fj!f!:.*WT~ (Z. Brzezinski) tt~2*~:f;jg~. p#jHJJ~~ fJEIZSl~. ,. =+/\8~. II. Robert Falony, "Is the continent's security more assured now?," Socialist Le Martin (Belgium) ,March 13, 1999.. 12. William C. Cohen, "Remarks at the Transatlantic Forum of the West European Union, June 30, 1998," USIS (ed.), U. S. J njormatlon and Texts, No. 30 (July 30, 1998),. P~fttHJI ~*-IH~flHs. J. :. PP.25-27. 13. [ ; "Special. v/sc:ripfslc••. ~~ff-.. , ffifA. 0. Post, May. 14. "The NATO's Role In the Next Millennium: Constant and Emerging Goals," March 16,1999 ; at http://pdq.usia.gov/scriptslc•••UBMIT=View&CQRETURN=&CQPAGE=!. Warren Christopher/William Perry, "NATO's True Mission," in New York Times, October 21, 1997.. 15. Jltm.;f§~tJO-fLfL-t;fF-+-}g ~JM.fJ r it! ' ~1III~mfB~1tlli J !:P~mfB"Ji. ;. Senator Richard Lugar's Ausjahrungen vor dem Deutsch-Amerikanischen NATO Roundtable der Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung in Washington, D.C., 5-7, November 1997..
(6) lWitlH~~~1.I. '!\G 1r~;t gt~. '811 ~~ ~ ~~ fljfl:b 1¥J:lL~ . 1iitt~t~ fi ~F.l8 t~ lli~ t~ !.IZ\~itir A t:lmrliP;i Wi:1J. ~~~~~;LfJJ. ijg~~I¥JJ:fI$OO~' iiP~-a-7 ~~;w]~lf[§VitM1~ijg5z:~~t~I¥J~)JUfT~~.. *~~tt r ~jj.~t. 1}::ffi1¥J. 11t~. !!Uilit ff pg. r ~~wHil¥~E J (Strategic Acessment) ]!!TIl[ § ::r-5lj:tBf~lli ' - E!. CP~~111 ftl}B:s:2r:1+l ' ~~f!Pfi15RI&wr!fll~i1&:m;L!.IZ\~'~ t.!D~fEH.::ffi m¥WT£1£ r *fJtfi J (The Grand Chessboard) -ilf1~2 *~wri1&:mJt&!I1l¥Jlli. ' , ~ , ~ , cp~ , ~PN~:l:tBa~~;7C* (player) 7 ~ • itf:B-~ 1m .'~ fti 15) , tJf) M~ t~ I¥J ~fT~~I! 16!!I!IDfIfJ::ff,.titOO. ¥u t& {-fJ lit. *fE ~ ~ iliU !;ilG lit f. ~;w].~~I¥J~.li~Im~'$.I¥J~~~~~~.7~-~B~.o-fL. a'91E:IBl,\) , J!~. fL-1f.~~,~~~.~t~15RI&-*~.~J:fI$15~l¥Jm.,~cp~m-fL. ~~l&~~~~. fL. iE;!( J. ~~a'9lli• . ]!!~I®l~t~I¥J~.j]iI!f!.1I~Hi£{$.?i§.:s:2~:l:tBl&I6. o~. 0. (-fLfLfL) 1f.~~ ~Iv.:i*~ (Defense National University). 0. 1f.+. =fj fflG:lL r. ~t*[§#-€d'F!!I!$1lt. J. (North-Atlantic Cooperation. ,-fLfL[lB1f.ftfj 91114 r ~JZP:~f:f.~lm1* J (Partnership for Peace) &-fLfLt;1f.1ifj ~1lUIWTiE:it~. r £~:5<::{tp J (The Funding Act) :MlP.:1G r ~~}H*[§#~#!!I!$it J (Euro-Atlantic Partnership Council) ,i,t~fi ~{~1lUIWTiti:~ , lv.:iiBllifJ! r *fJtfi J cP PfT~1¥J r wr~B;fI J (Hegemony. Council). of a New Type). 18,. litffijlfk;i[§~M1~~""~~r:uijgj[fJ!wrJ:fI$~M;Lil&m. ( OSCE) I¥J~~ f~Hi 11001¥J:lL ij1. .t5-m3i:!!I!it~ ¥ll~iliU ' ~53IJ~. i¥J J~J!IJ ' 1f. ~~J!~) 'ii. ::f ijgIDt~ t¥.J 1~ g ~F,*W-€l~pm ¥.J~fi.l&'~j. 16J~%. 0. lW~F. ~&o.?i§.~~.**n~it • • ~t~~M~~m~.~I¥J~.J:fI$.M'.. ~!;ilG!.IZ\ gj[~ ~ ~. -~.~.m~I¥J~~~~§.'ill::r-~~~.~ • • I¥J~~'mlm.ill~. r ~~f!JaJ. fj rJ1~M.*.'11~~~~.j:tB5z:~~t~f1i¥j ~M~~'*[§#MWf1r~~WaJ . r~~Iv.:i.J ,~r~~ • • JI¥J ;gift ' ~tt~1;:]!!~~-3& ' {§'~.f1~t¥J.~~~1tl¥J.Ji!!! . ~4"ill~~. ie ' 1i1r.1Jl~fU. ~*I¥J.IDfIfcpo~~l!m~~~~a~~I¥J~m'.3&[§.Mn&fi~OO~. mr~mi¥J~t*~. ~~~I¥J~~. 1!J~~~JiW-€l. ~~VitM.*l¥Jt~N. ,. 0. -. ~cP~t5-.3t!!I!itl¥Jfti15~1lUIWTl¥Jt~NI9. , J!~.MIJ~. E. ~1(k::~:~~1¥J. t5-m3tJJl!.it~. .m::r-lWl¥J~[2;Jo. 20 it§&xM.:fB~! 16. 17. 18 19. Zbigniew Brzezinski, The Grand Chessboard: American Primary and its Geostrategic Imperatives, (New York:Basic Books, 1997), Chapter VII Conclusion. Zbigniew Brzezinski, op. cit., Chapter II - The Eurasian Chessboard. Ibid., Chapter I - Hegemony ofa New Type. Karl-Heinz Kamp, "Das neue Strategische Konzept der NATO," in Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte, No.lJ, 1999, PP. 19-25.. i1=1f.f?l;fl Ji Karl. ;;... 0. 21. Karl-Heinz ~. 22. -i1i1)\1f.. ~~f;¥~-. cit., P.4S..
(7) ... .~~~.~~~fiM~~~Z.ti~~.. °mJ~ft~~. A. i5' #fi PPi~ 'ijJ. rr. I9~IJi~~~. versity) i};{fj($. '-SCPtEftfl1 d) -.f1~5l. *.m~ (pJayer) rfjj'''!if1,t~~ lfllll~. -it jf;.CP1Em-it 0. ic Cooperation ip for Peace). ing Act). .M!aJG. a~~. ••~~~~.~~~*.~. In. ~R~.NO-ftftA*~.. ' ~t*3 r il&mta~/J\ii j (Policy Coordination Group) .1lt 1!~f1 r ltJJ!HjtilWrr!!JJii J (Defence Planning and Operations) ml±l~fr ~~."li~rrl*J~l)¥i~lfIJ ' &-~~¥Ji~:w'~titEm-~t*3~1~¥Jirr*i:mtt$j , ~m ~m~M.~rr.Ett • • rr!!JJ~'~~ • • • ~~~~ • • • ~ii. (OOCE)~~.?~ • • ~Z~·~~a • • ~~ • • • E.m~,.~ Mm~OO~~.'ffiW~.~m~~a~~.~'~~~~W • • ~D.tE ~ii~~~.~mlff:l;~*~~20 , ~WJm~t*3.t!t*c~W5t} • • rr!!JJffI~~ ¥U~fM ' ~JjU~ OOW• • wr 1*J$1"'~~~~~t1i! ~ ~ ~m-mJtm~ ~,tt5tR:fI 1¥JiE:1I11L.' , J!!~~ • • n~i§'I!t~.~~~i.!i!. ( • • ~*J1.) fj~~mJtw ~~E~~~~~~~$'~A.~~ • • •E • •~~~r~~ffl~~1*J .j~~~'@W~ffl.~.~EI*J~ • • ~.(~~~.·.~.D • • ••M.) ,w.~~Zm~I,~~~tEA:fI~.WAm • • ~~.'~ 1'fj~lljUt*3{*I3ffil±l.:g fIJ;Jtm:~ , ~t*3~$~~~~1-t~~• • njf,tjG~ ;}(~~;.tlnitZ:fJJ. 0. iJ ). 'itffi{.1r. (Hegemony ~~1Jf! ZiB{n;. i.~1Jf!' ~. if!. fJR. fl11& Mf~t*9f1i¥i ~JOO.~j($. ~4'fl1J1li~ ~ 1rIE ffii@J. ! ~1Jf! I!lW ~. 'eostrategie. rJlitik und. .~.~~ffim.~.:m~~W~~'*$ID~~.~R~~W.ii~W~t ~.rr.Ett• • rrD~~:fI.~'~~~ffl~~E • • ~~tt.'fJ1~~ IEJ~~. r .~~~• • III J ,~&~t*3$~tE.~E~.:mtt ~~£'~Ji~~.rJtt$j ; ~~W r .~'ttff j ~~~~ljrmf*,!tl~t*3~.~W 0. iW:1.fpJT~~. r~~M~j~.m~~o.m®.,a~~.~*~#mw~.~~m~. , f.§.~a • •fr A f3P#~~~~.ftj:*~ , ~t*3**.rr.lliit1:.;forrl!J~ , WE~~.~F~~ ii~~~ • • • ~m.~~.'@W*~~~.$r~ • • ~j ;.~Z, ~~~~~t*3~.~f:t~:r:wrl'l~Jm~~N~ r *~ffoW j ,!t~f*1¥i~t*3W5t} lEe '. mrJf1iUljfiffiU~t*3~1~.tlOfflOOW1$*1trwllii5t}~1If~. I!JfitmUJi.~~IEJ~Z:fIfIj22. 0. a~ • • ~~~• • • ~m~~.M-ftft- •• ~~m~~~~~~,~~-ft ft=~m~~t~.&.±mDm~$.'~.~~R~A~m.~.'M~~ P .21.. >1- Jf. Karl-Heinz Kamp, op. cil" 0. 21. Karl-Heinz Kamp, op. Cil., P.22.. 22 -ftft/\~~m~!llflWjffiJlt~l'm'l!HT?rI:?&~m ' m~1i$~ Rudolf ~3t~~-1J. cit., PAS.. . mr>1-~ Klaus Kinkel. JlIH~~&:~-1J. Scharping 1~. ; Margarita Mathiopolous, op..
(8) R=ttt' § M~t~1JftF~tM~t!UC~.m;:t.~ttt~B'gjim ('WIJ~ofi15~~~~'WIi ~ • • •k*m• • • tt~.~.ft).~~~'W*~.~ • • ~tM~t~ _*Jlt1:!l!0 ~~~:~~>I1:~~r",~mB'g~* ' ~P~~1~U1E*7IJm r 1iX?J+I:R~± J (European pillars) B'g$ , ~ , ~.::::.~ , ~$tt2::f-$5I: ° $~i1ti:(£&tMftit1Jo~fi15m.1¥J :U:~ , ~::f:RM~t~*tt:i&!~B'g{:f~ ; ~~tM~t~~~ft:fI3fSB'gft~Niltn1¥ ~ ,{fi::f&tM~t~:(£fe;~Jlt1:!l!&~ffa;fDtt~B'gM~r: ' .*M~ r ~mWJ ~ J (collective self-defense) B'gpg~ ; 3§.tn. ' ~m~~W3j;)*gt~~~t~ ff!t!j!Jj~~B'g~lIlttflji;,1:23 , ~ltt;1t~IIltt.~~ftj[~jE r ~m;: {:f~ J (out of area) W r ~m;::fIJi;,1: J (out of interests ) ;fEl~~ ° ltt.~fmil~&(!9ct!::Ut~B'gppHI ~m:;1t-'.~M~~B'gr~~~i;,1:J'*~~~IiXHMnB'gm$;;1t=, *g§#m~tM~!'5J:fIji;,1:B'g~:g3!JB.t)~m:~~ , ~t~ff!fr.TJ$fr.TJtE. ?. ~-.:.Wffij. , IiX~Jtl~~:iH~tt,G\~t~p.xm.~mff~~~IIlttB'gI~ , ffli\.llitilll~J[E13PJT1i p.X~ ~~!'5J*tt24 , J!fifH'::JtmIDi ' IiX?JtlMnMz::f1fi~~t~P.X~ r i!!:~.~ J (global policeman) ° ~JCf:tmF.l ra~~t~i};fpB'g~~IIltt.!l5 ' ~:5<:$gt1titi7 .~m1'iJB'gml$, ~~:EJl~~~t~~ff!~~m;:~1IJ~B'gfilt($ , G!ktnwttMM ~f*1!)l r mfi151''l-x J (preventive diplomacy) W r mfi1511J~ J B'gmnm .H::f~ 1'iJJ-~m;MB'g~ ~t~~{&JEl,::~H.*IDM~~a;fD{:f~1J'if ' ~::fR.Hl-i.Ntn~lI I. t\L51 ' f\j tt.2wG:R~j ?JtIy:~11i~B'g~mi ( Kyrgyzstan) ,~ NATO alliance). 26 ,. ~.~.*ZP:#5 fi&~.ff~ir~ 1X1JtI~~'11i~B'g~. e .~~ §'bEttJ'I1i~ ~fft.wrpg$m~ ( bandwagoning ). ~~1f£~t~_*W: P:l1t) ~ 1'iJff I¥J ~ rd I\!ftf ; ~-1nm ' ~g§1iiil1*:1£~11 fljliili J (buffer ZOI. .J~IIlttB'g~.jj (Bishkek;. ~if!1ifi. '. 15.1. ~5jti~. I. p'x~~B'g~±~~o. 2' Sergei Repko, "\I. 26. IiX?J+IMn tM ~t~ ~~ ft ~1Iltt 5t ~ B'g ~ = @] JlL'iS'JlIJ ~. t) ~11i fftjl WI pg gIH.~~~ft ' jL;;1t~t~~[]*Y!J7 A:ftU1Efi15m;:9'l-B'g1lJ~ , j§f.t~wrf4WB.~ :ttl!m;:;fElIm~~mp.x rrzwrill7<;:~MJ (Pan-Slav Confederation) :tt3§.W$ ~ , • • ~~$B'g r t1tt&~~ J (rogue states ; 'WIJ~offtM ' ilB ' ~t$!t , fft. Vol.48, No.30, (p Ben ArisiDavid. Electronic Teleg. 27 "Russians in join 28 $D!I Thomas C. Alliance Pattern 1990), PP.137-1. I. Security, Vol.l~ 29 . 23 W. Christopher/W. Perry, "NATO's True Mission," op. cit•.. 24 WI!I7f-ft Hubert Vedrine ttBJJiiff~if;'&'!>f~t~~;f-:~:~flJ£tfi!&ift!!~l¥J5fil11:M. : J!. "Follow U.S. Strategy, Albright Urges NATO," in International Herald Tribune, December 9, 1998.. mJflilfffj5&.fl \ii< _-f!UI Wi r. '*. Bringing the R(. 1994), PP.72·1 1 30. r ll~Jlir~ ~ J. Future of u.S·,.
(9) ~~~~. 11t1J1B8 ~ ~~'Mi. tiL~. !;f!~~JJ;;ft¥3. ~~~ • •I¥J • •. , tUtt:;2~milI~~5EI¥Ji*ft). £m••. •••. ~.**~~z. ••&.w. *EJt<:~Ut~~I¥J.{J~M2S. 1~. , lm?5.3&~. ·~$A~~~'.~MWtfJ~'~.~M. r &;;ft~~M J (anti .~M$• • § A Igor Dygalo Ktirm1rth~ ~ ~f;f9} 11fffif. (Kyrgyzstan) '~~51' ug-R51~~J3.Jt<:-11lft1f)cB9. t J (European. NATO alliance). fJo ~ 1t1J;1!H'~. JiliJfil~JB*ZP:Uftii~I¥J!IIi~ftii Bumy ~Wm~~Uftii Varyang ~lmWtfJ. 1¥J~1JtRlnN~. ~.~.fi~~.$.mn,mUt• • • ~ • • ~mf;f;;ft~~* • • • ~·. M~r~.f$Jj. ~~~~• •I¥J• • • • ~~'.MMI¥J.~tttt~tfJ~.u'~.M • •. *ge,±:~;;ft¥3. ~.~*&I¥J • • S.'&tW.~MI¥J~.~~.fi~·ilI$*~~.W~. ( out of area). :/j;;ft*9B9PWtm ~$;;tt.-=,. 26 ,. 1n~~Mpg$·f• •I¥JT'.f.I. (bandwagoning). 29. '. 1ff'§}1li;;ft~*tJi~~~Lt:. ~f;f.~M~l&. r 1£*~fi~1!! J rli!HHJ (hide) I¥Jm~30. §B9lEm. fHil1jJl fE PJT1i. f.ill*flf;;f t~tJi*lt1ilii: I¥J Jit~ • &t'l"iWl¥J• • • ~*~ , iW)lJtPWUt~liiftm!m P9fP)'.l:iJfil¥J~rl'I~ ; -~OO . •Mf4T'~I¥Ji&*~1• • m*T'r-r~fJDM;;ft~1¥J J!ftf: : ~-~OO · ;;ft~;;e;~Jl:b~HH.~Mrm7t~.$f;f~l¥Jmiiii ' T'fli.Iib. r1!tW.~J. 1n~~.§ft*~.~Z.~W~'fu*~.~~~~.~Ma.~ftr.. (tfJ&t1t:.? tItD1jfWll. IT~ J (buffer zone) 1¥J.*1C.~. :t. ? ]:f§ -'-?}J ffij. rmg • RT'~ [R~HD1*ft~. 1{!UIWfr*J F-if.WBllI,* 'K.¥WtfJ ';;ft., w. $. *". §. Z '. ;;ft~~~Al¥Jm. • ~.~~*1C (B. Yeltsin). ~ ~ Vi. ' !f;¥ JJU m ~ f;f ~. r i!iij.~ J W r. m. ~$J\Fl rl'I~iWtttt:;ft51. (Bishkek ; ~llI~Ml§fJ&) WIT~~.RB~l¥Jm-1:!Jlffi:. r !ltE.*~~kf.. !!II * J (I am ready for battle, especially with. 25. Sergei Repko, "We'll Never Be Allies," The Current Digest of the Post-Soviet Press,. 26. Vo1.48, No.30, (August 21,1996), PP.21-22. Ben Aris/David Rennie, "Yeltsin presses for anti-NATO alliance with the Chinese,". 27. 28. Electronic Telegraph, August 26, 1999. "Russians in joint exercises," in South China Morning Post, September 29, 1999. :fj;OO Thomas Christensenllack Snyder, "Chain Gangs and Passed Bucks: Predicting Alliance Patterns in Multipolarity," International Organization, Vol. 44, No.2 (Spring 1990), PP.137-168 ; Jack Snyder, "Averting Anarchy in the New Europe," International. 29. Security, Vo1.14, No.4 (Spring 1990), PP.5-41. r :m.~ff5&n!J {*f~~t~n!::tJL#~~~tl~~IiiX:.I¥.J~~;tff1JoM ' iU1:1f;:::f~F ii;.i"i ~llUI WI nxJ~ ~t ~ fi\( jt : Randall L. Schweller, Bandwagoning for Profit: Bringing the Revisionist State Back In," International Security, Vo1.19, No.1 (Summer. [g:m~;Yl. ld Tribune,. J m~l¥JjjfjJifUR~0Sl~. ;. 30. 1994), PP.72-107. r i.e!.~lfime J f*IDl.:lI. ffUI WI. ; Yl Bruce Russetl Allan Starn, Russia, NA TO and the. Future of U.S-Chinese Rea/ations, at http://fas.org/main/nato/ceern/nato-final_vs.htm..
(10) Westerners) 31 , IE.&~tf:l~Mm~I¥J!IJJI~:I:J!. WG*?i'iyX;f!!S. 0. .1J£1nlW3Cl¥J®lN' ~:gm~tkt:J**I¥J*~~tttRmHJ§Jj<;~~I¥JJJjUW ' ~~$;~~ffUIWfPJffgfj~I¥J[H& ' 3?1n~~~~tkt:JMm~if~Wf~41¥J.'8OO~.Wm.MD~'W~~~~~ • • ~.~~~-MM~a~-~~U ~~ , ilJ~~ ~tkt:J ~ $$1W e*~~*'t~I¥JtJ>IHf:t. ' g;gJ:EffUIWf:::f tt:fij"Jl$.& .D1'F . :::tjt~tkt:J~$tf:lijt*.f~.Zt& . ~t*9;fIH.f~Wf~41l!tf:l i§ ~.WMi *,~~f:ffi'iJ~ml¥J¥rHim1im ' utJ:E~Wf~4fHj~:iti§*mi!JiH'VJ\32 $WI. . 1W ~ • .!F-1n-1L)\=~tQ.lit~tW[§:rl!!f1.JIJ}dt*900~.D~' ilH&tQ.~~§~ ~Do~~[§~ • • •~W~W~~.~I¥J~~OOi§'B.~.~e • • • • • [§.Mnl¥J~$~J:E(~~.&.~.) ·.a~.~.$~~~.W ~~~w.talllfKf · .MJtfiJ:~t~D:If:\.E!p~miEl1nijt.l¥JfR~~~ .M~ ~tfj~~iIDW~4~*.~~*?i'i1Xfe:~I¥J~J:!iI!' §fJf&tf:lijtWjljlX?&:::f[qJI¥J'fPJ ~~,.~w~.a~WijtWMaI¥J5~:fij"~o~MUrA• •1n~.J~ 'E'7GJtfiJ:~tkt:JWm.MD:If:\ . RlZ9m~.*fE2i,~[§~• • • ~JtI~~.1'¥1¥J-1i1 ~.El:tJ ' [qJfKfWf;iJ:EB.~*~'IW~3i!J't:fij"IiF~.El1'Fm ' fg~Mfi~t*9~:a7JiH~. resm.r~'~~. *fEW$.3?*?i'i&W.:::f.'fPJ,~m&3?~.~M.~~~J:!iI!tt$;~J:E'~. ~.I!m~m. £1n~m~*ta~.&~~I¥JMn·ID~r~• •1nA.JI¥JW• • • o~. 1¥J~~=lt.. ' .MJt fiJ:~ tkt:JWm. MD:If:\:£lH~1ftlH~~ J:E1¥J.1IIi! § . ' 00 ~. 1&~~Wj.~. 0. 0. ~!It -~ ~mffifS. .~mW*?i'i&A&I¥J • • ·~~.~~utl¥J.~§.olZ9!1t,~reM~*. A~JJI. tift. 0. 'M'f.. r~gIf. BfiI~*~. iii ' fit! 1r~ PJ 1 Wf~41*~:::f. ~'fg*~\l ::;t=lt~t*a rtl.rt:l~m. ~=lt**tlO efl.t~~ .+~. ,lUIWTI¥J if.9: ~tl.l¥Jr. ~~~lr. ~o.1J~. 31 B en A'nsID aVI'd R ' op. CIt•• . enme, 32 urif.*~wr;f.'H¥H.H?4I1"~Jif . t!t~~!;f~t¥::J!fH.rt:l~lmmtl:lW15 . llti:ilifli$lilY@ff9tJ ; mti'-$:OO David A.V. Fischer/WilIaim c.Potter, "NATO Expansion: The March of Folly," Moscow News, No.14 (April 11,1996), P.5; Alexei K. Pushkov, "Don't Isolate Us: A Russian View of NATO Expansion," The National Interest, No.47 (Spring 1997), PP.58-62.. 33 fMi~9i-:!Hl!;.*~"ilJ. (Andrei Gromyko) fIi~t!tm j§ 00: J;J.~:Itf:!l1~,~ttUI! ' t:iP~$ ; "NATO in the 1990s: Moving from Theory to. 1l.El..r.t~t¥::Jt~Hffg§fJf?f~ifnX:~. Action," in Strategic Forum, No. 12, November 1994 (Washington, D.C.: Institute for National Strategic Studies), P.2. 34 . fKf1l!Ul!fflJ ElOOfi r ~ '11~~li..EL f. Taiwan pef. g; ~ :::flit:;1. 3S~*!f '. *~~~. IXM!;f**i.x1¥JfB~~~1J:a: ' Eltrufli.r.t1n~*iI&1trIUJm ; Je."East Timor: EU. 36 "Declara. Heads of Mission Troika Visit/Conclusion," 27-30 June 1998, at hUp:l/ ue.eu.intlNewsroomlLoa... 102&DID =54942&GRP=1265&LANG=1 ; Stefan Ulrich, "Osttimor ist nicht Kosovo,". Exercise 43184&G. in Siiddeutsche Zeitung, September 10,1999.. 37 "CFSP. P.
(11) ;~~tBlllUm. '. •... M'afH3i.'~'I1i~~1tt1~J¥1U!1*z~~&~.. ~.~.ffl~~.~~n~,~.~*~~. ,a~.~. re.ftlOOi¥J~M~~~~·~.a~i¥J~mtt.~.W.tBmfftt.~.~. !~WTf4tB.15:u • ~~3f7JJl1tJ.. tiff- r. :~ltfi.$&. E5.~*. ill §. ..;. 181. A~r.I· 'M:fJJf!UIWTzmtJ.~~&W~t*3:frAf4~*r",~m r",'mm~ft J. i¥JnU& .. '. .:t~~,1Sl,~~fa. ~WjmJNB~52~~7t~tB11f~. . 1*lI'ltE. i¥Jrett~flj~.~1f(35. l4!i~~M~~t*3m~n~~~}H~~i¥J:ll.. ~.Bn!lEi. ~'.~m~#W • • WTi¥J~~.r.I~~~~M.tti¥Jm~'~~~MW.. 'Wi. WTf-t1*m~5[~.gHIl:ll.· ::ftEi!Ui*~ttkli!I$~~j].JJ05$W • • WTi¥J*~fj. 1&ift~~§~. ~'{E!.*&:\ltW~jtmfj~~ff-~r &~1IiI~~ JffiJ~~fElf5Ji¥Jm~'~m~. OO~8!lm~. ::.t~~t*allf5JftrnJWf7;rffi~~~7t~i¥Jl~~. .. ,. ~rJ!J!~*IU&¥tl~jt&W. ${JEIVG3(~~. r~.~mm~~Jwr.:tllm~~a::f~~j]~mJi¥Ja~~j]·~~::f. 1i~·~M!ij. ~_**~W:frA~~H~'~MI¥J~1f(~~.rW~*J.r.W~J~. ~~::ff5Jl¥Jrm. mfl~fH~~. •. .+~*.M~~jttEAlI~mi¥J3(~.~~~'~rJ!~~n~.~w. it*.1:ftlJi¥J lff~;Y; i¥J ~1iJ. 11UIWTi¥Ja~~mJU~mfjWJ' ~¥tl~t*3 • •ZEli¥J' w~t*a.~7m$. l*3~~~iI. W~.i¥Jrfi-::fa.J (~5[~~1IiI·~5[~-~-~·::f5[M~.~A. ~*~~, ~U. .:t.~~mlVGzm~m.)w.~~jtW~D~i¥J.m1&.~,m~R~j]. l!m~~·. i¥J~1i• • ~~~;. ~EI~. :5. , ffiJ~. ~te:! :f41ft. *. '.MOOW~~mn• •tB• • • ~,~.~~. &.~~~~ffa~W~·. • • a~ • • ~·~ • •m• • m~.w~~jt M.nr-1iJ~~Ja • • • @.1i~, • • ~mmlt~ • • ~.i¥J-.~ ~ *4!*Mll:t-~1* ' .:t~~;flUf-fLju\~~rJ!@J!!~jt~j]'Ifi!I~~. ~tI!Rffl7 r ~tt~!UI:~ J (deeply regret) 1ZB1lI*36 , tJ.& -fLfLfL~-t::; Fl it B OOW r ~?*~m~iU J 5Imi¥J~~ • • ~5&n{* ' IIXMtI!5$llfijJ~~ r fIH!:~ 'IiW~E liW:zp:m1R:~lIlr",~mi¥J&\~'~ J 37 (necessity of resolving the question of Taiwan peacefully through constructive dialogue) .~llIJJ!.~-WU ' ~£mIlXM jz9::f1W~ .i&ItJ-• •:frA ~~~*nM~.W:zp: , J! W~~t*3Jj(.i¥i~rJ!z 0. ~ flj!f! iifi1 100 {9~ The March of. "Don't Isolate. :Spring 1997),. ~.m ' ~1J~it: m Theory to. : Institute for. 35 !~j4'!!llf'. r. Ii'. *~ij~~fft:p'L'). Jl. ,. 1itnx~ 1i'~_@l~±n::,5'2~ ? J ifPfJ~ar7tmfl~ (M:§: ~1i+1\lfI'. -tL1u\1f:tLf3-. =8'. Timor: EU. 36 "Declaration by the Presidency on Behalf of the European Union on China's Military. wsroomlLoa•.. cht Kosovo,". Exercises off the Taiwan Coasts," at http://ue.eu.int/NewsroomlLoa...D=73&DID= 43184&GRP=336&lANG=1 .. t. 37. "CFSP Presidency Statement, Brussels (20-07-1999)," No. 10256199 (Press 232) ofEU..
(12) ~.lW~Ilj. .~~m~.w~~~a~~~'~.m~w • • • • ~.~OOM~.r~ Sl~~t¥3~ff~iktE~'jjf[$+f1HTIJJ J. $~M~~ftf. •. '. ~&WT1:E~t¥3Iit~::RZP: J::~f71:!t~~¥~~ , .TIf[::f{~:j~~}jtWTf3}~{f~fM~t. ~~t*~rt.u~~. ¥3M*~ik~Iit~$.,~~~~we~.~~~.~ • • •ft¥• • ~~. • littttB~a~~fE3~7t. rtJ l{!$ MM.TIf[ /j MJiU ' ;fN:$:J::iJ. m'.M~*.~tt.1:E.~&WT~mh,~~~&~~~~~~Iit~~. s~t*tt~~!. 1it~-&i"{'F~~. ,. littttW~t¥3~*JTIit~ilf~iI'ii~~*. '~ • • • ~W~.~~1:ET-~eWW5n(.~.)~~~ • •Ho *5~~~W~~~~~.D.~m1:E• • ,~~ft~::f*'~::f~1:EIit~ @]1r!~~:$'C~,rr; J::{f7JU. 0. IZBiF-M~~~j-1. r *100.. 31 m1 J ~~ifff. '. ~~~Il. .mllir.~~"~m~.§.J~¥~w'~m~-~~~.~'*WA .EW~a.~h.~.o~M*~'. *~~ffi!i!!~ar. M1:E.M~*S. "* 'ffjj~&WT!J. M{f~ir Ajjlijj. $.J::'. • • ~~~.~~wm~.~~r~. ~. m1a.J ' • •E~*.~&WTS.~e.~*.m.~ffi.,litt*5~~. *fllU!~&Wi!. J!¥~~.~~§.fffi~ '~Jf:ML.:;Y~~"'". ~. we~~§.~Sltt,~~r~J ·~~~~'jjf[$ME~~'~~~S~·. ri*t!i 27 ~ lU&J .TIJJ. .m~~~a.·~.J::'5nK.gJ::~r~~ • • • J '::f.~~~~. It~~::flj :f;it~. .r~J ·~~~'.E~::ftt~~.~~~$~~~~~~~~o~~.. ~1tJ. E~*~~Sl~~~~~.M::tjtBflL. ..M~*m. ::f~~~.~t¥3WfJX&Wi~~~~ilf. ffi~S~t¥3B~S~~~ff~. ' ~M~WTf3}W~t:gg~~m.iEJft ' ~ 4-iF-1ZB R T iU~t¥3E. + JEfJiF-~ • •a. 0. ~OO,~~@~E.• • ft~g(Clli)~a~1:Er*5~~~.~~$ttJ. (Euro-Atlantic Partnership Council) ~~;f1tJT*ll~ffi~~~ r GUUAM ~~~ J (GeorhgiaIKyrgyzstan' Ukraine' Uzbekistan· Azerbaijan· Moldova) 40. ~ooJ::~m~~~t¥3ffi~~~ik~*~~W~~-&i"{'F~~, JfJIUS~-?J7tlJU~. ~&Wi~~.h. 0. ** GUUAM. MU~~o*"~~-.ffitl~~&Wi~~l{!$. (marg. Wif-t_Mt~~. ~~;fllj~'1l*. .*#lWfff~~. 41. William Pfa. [nternationa. ~.E' .~~[7g~~~*1.1Hj(-a:rtJ-~S~t¥3~~~a, ~WTf-t~~~~flll[;!P. 42 ~m~J;J1:E. ttR~§'t¥~m*1a· wwmttm7t~&Wiimm~tJJti~-51Hi1&±~~.tt,. 43. tJ-.~.El.~t¥3M*~.~~. fi. 44. B. Brzezinsk "China to bu. 45. 7,1996, P. P "Russia to tc. 0. 38. Bruce Russet/Allan Starn, op. cit... August 30,1. 39. Graham Hutchings, "China tests mobile missile that can target Europe," in The. Morning P. 40. Electronic Telegraph, June 1, 1995. "NATO'S 'NEW DOCTRINE' INVITES QUESTIONS IN EUROPE, DRAWS FIRE ELSEWHERE" April 28,1999, at http://www.usia.govladminIOOSlwwwh9a28.html. 46. singtao.com Frank Chin Vo1.159, N(.
(13) ~tJH3i:'~'11' ~ ~ft ~ jifjj f!¥ IDl 1*':<:: :@: J.l:& ~ II!. -9rmWJ15f:~ r ~. 183. ~~oo~~I¥J~~~~~~~~,m' rr:pJZOO~.~~~fim~ •. •. ~MI¥J.~'~~.7.~oo~~~I'I\MtiKMMI¥J~.~m~'KMM. rf3J.& ~.$:lttft. fM~tJR~JlU~~,;J!{-t1tl¥Jiflgfg r:p:::tt3JifJi)miZ§'13l¥Jf3J.15i:ftl~~~41. t1L;~U1M~1Jr1¥J. ~ • • MM~~R~m.~~,oo~r:p~~~m~.~~~M~.~I¥J~.. , m~~~fE. i&itI¥JfJ!J1JrJ} tt!HI I¥J Im~ fU. .~,a*~&&ti • • M.G·~.$M£m• • I¥J~M*m.'~~.. :7:3t~~.38. ,. ii! ~ftl t1£~i&m l¥Joo:t}l , ftl!.lii :¥:m!1I®KMf3J. Jlt~~ ~m- rEil ;ft JR ftE ij[~ 43 ~ iflg i'45:tE~Mm~(fnL~*~ , mm Vg;ftk(.J~~r:tIDtmf~Mf3J.~~*.I¥JJJ!.f1If ffijffXKlWT!Mr:p~x~~~';J!~-¥lttl~;ft*9~JJtJ5.fil¥J~rt~ , mJj!RP~~ .~~ftAM~~.,&~~~~Jlt-~*9~.ffijB~.~• • I¥J~*· • • ~,oo~.M~~m~~I¥J~~~#~**S·~.~*'~.~ ~1l1Uf. mKiM!M r:p ~ *~ic)l:~!1:~ rm f* ' ffi!f-ft£;ftJR {.ttfj rEilKWTf3J.14 ~ 72 ~ r ll*tw 27 ~ J (Sukhoi-27) $t::ii!~~l¥Jm,~,44 , :i&~!l:13x~~M~ r i:J JOO.k& J ~r~JJMm!M r ll*tW 30 ~ J (SU-30) ~:f{ll¥Jxg 45 , ii6:tE*lilGY. 'lt~~m~. .~M~~I¥Jf1J~'R.mKlWT~lt.~~X:tE.~~M*.~BB~r~. ~If( • ;fi~WI'I\. ~ft J. 0. R~~1:EImIil!. ~'~m~tf1 If~. , *31U/\. ~1IiEr:pl¥Jr~. '~*iZ§'~P/il ~~m~1T~ ~~~m~. ~#a ~iFfii ' 11m. rif':~.lt~. i*Ill!$lt J rAM~j~~. fOldova). m;ftJRlt~~~.ffijjt~l¥JmKlM~• •MMti~, r:p~&~qr"g~Jlt~ft 0. *'. ,. r. J'. m~~~i'Fl¥J~ra'RP~lttJJtk. ; &Z ' a • • • ~~M~~I¥J~~,mKlM!Mr:p~~~~iflg~~OOI¥J • •till'mK MM• • I¥J~.$.~*~.~A.~~~I¥J~@~,~qr~~~!MGY13ftl r:p ~w~ , .~FmKlMI¥J~. t1£f:tz:111l;fblt:JiI:¥:9Ef1J ' fiUIWT ff! ~3&tn Wr:p:;f:t (marginalize). .*.nm.rmmtt~M.~rm~JI¥JIIiE.·m~n'.~'~~A.~. 40,. ~-W-f!U~. lfiI¥J ~'!fl $ !t~~raljRrJ i'j~lt. ' f{j. 41 . International Herald Tribune, November 11,1999, P.8. G~W~.~-AAA~A~=+~8.li+~g~~~* • • ~.:<::~~· 43 B. Brzezinski, op. cit., Chapter VI- The Far Eastern Anchor. 44 "China to buy 72 Advanced Fighter Planes from Russia," in New York Times, February 7, 1996, P. A3 (N), A3 (L). to tell Advanced Jet Fighter in $15 Billion Deal," South China Morning Post,. 45 "Russia. thtml. !II.8. '. August 30,1999 ; "Mainland preparing to buy SU-eO fighters, says Russia," South China. e," in The. \WS FIRE. William Pfaff, "Russia's Near Future Will Depend on Western Connections," in. Morning Post, August 26,1999;. -:fLAA~A~-8(http://www.. singtao.com/specd3/sd3iO 10 I.html). 46. Frank Ching, "Sino-Russian Pact A good Sign," Far Eastern Economic Review, Vo1.l59, No.21, (May 23,1996), P.40(l)..
(14) refiUfWTtfi}d ti\t:J .mM § I¥J fi!!J m1lJj:ijt cp ~!Q~lIXrJ+lI¥J :9d~ ~ IlJjt~t~jli~~lI:: CP~~ •• ~CPI¥J •• ~.'~M*.~.IlJj.cp~ ••• WT~fi • •~ M . jt~lIXM.~ti\t:J#I*~~I¥J.flitl . J!-aJ t)J~*re cP ~tE.*P:JA~~i&*?!fH1 *'~ ~-.-aJR••I¥J••• ~no~~• •~~I¥J~m,~ •• ~~~mT-~~~~~•• WTI¥J~~~ff~~'m~MWT-~~~~WTM~ ft~~~*~I¥J •• ~~~~O~lIXM~%~§' rcpJ '.~~§~~fi 1¥J• • ~~· ••tt• • • **.~~R.~I¥J~~ •• ;.§Z'~ •• WTt~W~t*r~:f:fJ8rE.J~fHIl¥J~~~~~IlJj~~M . ~ti\t:J~~Mir Atlmlpp;ji¥. •••. g{*,~pff1t¥tll¥J~~$:fli~tt/J\:m~. ~.a~. ! ". 0. ••• WTmm~~*.lIX~m •• ~~pp;ji¥g.I¥J •• &~. •. *i&~ tJ.@i*f*Jt±lEI¥JIEIID•• W~IID~•• ~~.:t~l¥J~ti\t:J~~~$~ ~ •••mM~ •.• ml¥J.~.WlIXMm%~~m$m~•• WTm~~~ o~~~*~4·*~~pp;ji¥~.B~~~~~ ••• WT@~~~IIDI¥J li• •~·*ff.mnIIDI¥JE~o~ft'.IEIIDl¥J •• ~§'~m~ti\t:J** R~~-*~H •• WT~.lIXWcp~~.I¥J~.~'~~~.~.WTM.~ ~nl¥J~~~~'ft~~*.tfi •• WT~m~~i&~fHI*l¥Jm.~~,~~ m~~~( •• ~m.)I¥J.W~~W~R·.~R~.m~ti\t:Jm~~·~ •• ~cp~.fflr •• WT~J*$:~6nl¥J~.,~.~tE.:f:f~*.~.M Sl~~ti\t:JtE~~~~fM~*Mik;.~.~I¥J.Jjt· r tl.r~Hm~~1t J l¥J~ t&tt~ft~-*.~ lIXMW~ti\t:Jm%~pp;ji¥.~l¥JtJ(fi!iH!.~I!r . tE.~fI~.~ ~IIDl¥J5&•. m-~}j1:i£.:Iti\t:J~iFcp~J&rf¥J~M~ml¥J13dl.~ . ilJtJ.~1tEP (1&~fI}1M.) .§ Z . .:It:5'!i&m~* •• *im.[7g$l¥J~~.:t.'[1fMf, 11[J~1tt~n (jL;f~~m) I¥J~~ . :::f~ r cp -' . ~rI'Ij~~-aJn!;••••• ~ 0. o. tl1tlV pff@i~!t1¥J ~~,~~. , 1:i£~ti\t:J0~1 ¥4*aj]jf,~ti\t:J. .ft.·pp;j{lfl {7t.?JtlM1GiI&~ ~Ptru~ ti\t:J it-. t!!. iiH,f*J 1¥J.l!1& ' -aJ 4i&~~.1Jt13l ~l¥JrafflIffii. .Z*U~. ,. n~%ra~I¥J~~ ~flU~J.m~~:E1l. ~!;Z5Si~H.f. MW~ti\t:J.~\1Jl. ~~~~JtI1'. jaJ~xW~~w.. .~'IW • •!lB. IID$:Mik;.~t. M (West Eurol. «,cp~WlIXMg~tE.~Rm~~-AAA~r~~.~J~l¥Jm~o*.. ~~¥.M$j. ~ft·tl • • -aJR~m~nm%wcp~~l¥J~.·~~*m~Gm~.~l¥J. MI¥J•• ~Jt~. ~~~mfi·mtlmlpp;ji¥g~tE.~~.m~~~~~l¥JirA~J!m~m.·. M ~. 0. ~fffl. ' JH. ) ~.~ti\t:J]. 47. Ibid... .M1ttpp;ji¥~'. 48. Henry Kissinger, "Storm Clouds Gathering," in Washington Post, September 7, 1999,. l¥J~mns;t. 49. P.A19. u:tlJ~, (Alastair Johnston) , r~m~~liiJt5!fimJ '~IIJlftJ' mR:B~m1iWl' -fL/\fL~fLf3. ' ]'!/\1\3§:fL-='. 0. :.. ~~~~~m. ~~m~ft;tjt.
(15) RX1JtI3i:~11i~~Ht.!:t. jf4ttW~.I1:. mJ¥1Ul1*z.g'$t&~.. 185. ~.ffi.~.~ • • Mft.~mti*.Q. :;mrr1tL$*6'. ~~'WJ~ffim~H~~~ti~~kAm~M~~~.·x~-~~. ·~~i&:*J!1t. ~ , f;t~t~0m~~~~ail~ji;;ff::fl:BtEfilJ ~ft~fifljJJl5, 1.Elm:re~~~~~. ~:gmfll. ~9*aA7F~t~**~~.~~W~~Ji!1l!.~~~f~ff . ~ E3 ti9i-f*II'2lJ. fff '. j'f~:wrf4tz;J. $filtJ. il!§;ru;mrr. 1J}IX?m~:fBil&mt-g ~1it01ffl~7F~tf-=J::f • .L~. z' fUl!'J4 At:J'#fJjj[jJJ¥. Q. ~1iIf3. zliu · ep~iEPff~~t~f~~HI~~tHf:J. (Javier Solana) W$. r t!tJlf.W~ J E3. . f.El§j·~ cp X I!lIIIfiJ~t~tt-t!t*c~~~~rEJfJJ::f.~IDt~~.~±~~fjt~ Q*m{l\M~~ mM~.E'~~~~H~ti~~M~~OO.~ • • M~~~.E: -4'1i.R~~?*,Ji~:J:~.::fIffl~~~lSJJfti~m. ~t*~gt~\~~~CP~NRCPpJT. t9:i:.&:~. i::tt~**. IDVI¥J r a;flI~ J 'JtW~H~~8;I,*Mf*,lt~.~.~t~~mtit:l$~~11f ~z1UIfi ' :;tJtcp~.te!1fUI~lli@l~~~ijl~2*~~fIJ~ZcP 'tE*ll§ 1J~~r~a~~~flj~:3f-~ ; ;tt= ' ~t~9T&x~::ffJF~k A~Ilj<~~II~ , ~1J(.L~@I~Mt!!1l! (case by case) ~1J~~I:t:t7h~~~'I1:*ft5fDtE~ . W~mJ;fj ftz• • Hgt.~.~.~~~kA.t:l$~~II~~fiI:t·~ • • ~filJ'IX. ~:wrf4t.fs¥:. .W~t~.~.$~.m~fIJ~~.~Q. Jr~Il12f$¥ ~jJ[~T.. 'l. :g.Iff Ufi ff{]. U~. 'WI% r1&ft ,~ mJf-iXM 1t J. !f '. ~B1~CP~lHIt~~~~. ff{]1ff. .~~~M.ti~~M~~~.'~Y::fftm~cp~~m~~·~~~. pJ~~i~ifilG. ~~xWJi~il&~~~fi~~a~~~~o~~M*z~'WZ~m~~~5. iJ.~1~EP. . £*J::eEIJ~Y~11ffE:.~t~~WJ~ . #;}::f~ijg.1J IID~M~~~fti~ • 91f.:Af3 r~f41l1t (Cologne) $rr~i% • • ~ , ll§~W M (West European Union) !liftiE~f!UfllA.WZM~.ffjU . ft3lHJzlJ:J:~~;fI~ f$x~WZ~$~!1l!:J:. (Council of Ministers) , 1fl1£~HU!~** . IX. :.1'1i~,. [$IJ9g ~. Q. !;~L.. fJ5(1Pff{] ~tx.. '. .,*11f.~~~~~. M~1J*~.~.Q]mgIl'21~~tr«:J· ~lltll§~WMti~m~~m.~~~Hfffi:.p.;tt .·~w'~~~~mfi~+=@I~am(::f~mw.~·~~·.~~= ~. ). ~.~t*~.:f~. . ~~~ft~:ll.~.~~ffju~tf-=J~~~~rEJ fRtfiEf:1f.* 0. WZ~ti~~.~M~~@.gI:t,a~*~~~.MI:BJt**ftA.~~II~. 7, 1999,. liWl·. ~~~1J~:~-'*ft~mfi~~$'~m§~~~&tiltJ~~:ll.~·ili. ~J::.WJ~m~~MII~;;tt=·~~m~~ID~m~OO~~W~~'ili~. ~~m~ft¥~mI:t~~.Mt!!1l!;Jt~·. • • f*II'2r.*~.~J. '"m~.
(16) OO~3tJ1~i1m3i::@it~7;k:. ; It[g , ~~ r f4*~m~ J. ,~~~tf3~~3i:. nn~~=J1. :@it~lli~.~~~3i:~~~;ltn'~M~~~~ftm~~~m~~-n. DJtr:p~W~. , fit1J.~.I3.r:p~~B~ ; m:~. regret) l¥J '§ fJt. -~~~'~m ••~M~ft.~.~OOkA~.OO~·m.~tt~.M~. =~liit~1!t1. •• -~w.=~em~~.m:~'&~~.M~~'.=~~~r:p. 53~~~=J1t. n/\~ r¥~P1:iz.1!I1fJ§l)]J. ~,~. (Dessert Fox) ~m~. ~ft~i1m~~~~~'~ME.~~~~~.~~ffi~.m~.Tr:p~,. If! ' IUmt~*3. •• ,.[g~W.n~~•• &r:p~W~M~li§l)]H~1 ~#r:p~fit1Jm~.*~- •• ~ ••~~.~.~*~~m~.~I~~. El3 ' W.A.:f:Il¥J1 fIlrJlm J l¥J*1 J{UT~~z.54 (. li~~.~~m~. ~~.~W.~*~~'~~~.~I.~~em~%~.~m~H.~. jtW~.~~. •• ~W~.~-~@.~~'.~~OO~~r:p~~~*rn1Jolli. el¥J~Jf!w.. +~* ~Mf,:tWr:p~~li§l)]*~~r:pB7E*e~¥u~t::$:i&:f:IW.ilm%.:t::f:I. 1t~$~~.l¥J. ••. 7;k:m:)( f!f:~*. ' mr:pm.r.ijm&m~II~~l¥J~~ , .~*$f51 l¥J~Mm%~~f~fi5~t::$:i&:f:I~1!1'-.l¥J7R:Ji~/o .• ~ , ~MIiVJ%&mJt~ .~~,-gmr:pm.~m.~.M •••• ,r:p~~~~.~~.~~ff fi'iJ~~l¥JIDMWfilEg 1t~~[]JIt ' ~.~~.~r:p~~[gfi!:W~§l)]fit ' ~:!i!WiU ~ffd:it-~~.l¥JY~.fJ~sl ; ~ § Z. ' ~.f,:t~:f:Ie1M~~¥~.:t:i&m~ -~~~'B~~~.IiVJ%l¥J~~W~~,~ •• ~rp~~~1Jmff~.l¥J. J::l¥J~~JE:~. ~M. '. W.±%.~.~o.r:p~.~.*~~ft~~1J.~.~~'W~i& ~ijE~~if;~;.trt:ilOO~~*i. .1!tHP_~J:i\Z. ~~~itWWJ. 0. ~$·~mft~,~.m%OOWm~~~H~':!i!~it~r~~~Jl¥Ji&.. .~_~~rm~fJJl¥J. ~-~~Aj. .:5i:M~mi 53. ~1niJl~1ti!. ••~m?~a~~tt.~~*~~mitW~.. f.l&~it (European Council) ~. pq ~:Pf!nl!3Jft *mifffiiJ'tilt. l¥J@.1l.~~: -nn[g~~~. m1r~~tim. ~7+[g~.&Wr:p~H~z.7;k:m.. (1999: 1 ; 1998: 2 ; 1997: 3 ; 1996 :. ¥tlaiit.~ ~~~~II:. 7 ; 1994 : 1) • ltrp.fil¥J-f!l¥J:!i!. ' mit,*.~M+nliVJi&J&.Wr:p~~. Commission. fJ~m~-~l¥J~~i&.'~Wr:p~~~~~l¥J.~i&.·E~.~&~lli. (COM (95) t m~mil!i:m. ~.m*Wrp~~.~fflfit1J~*~§.·lt~·mitft~~~[g~~~~ H~~m~g~z.~m.,~ltrpl¥Jm~~~~~*~*fiz..~:. 54. M~~'tilt~. aiitff!*lM ~~ifPii!;. so Richard L. Grant, The European Union and China : A European Strategy for the Twenty-First Century, (London: The Royal Institute ofintemational Affairs,1995), P.2. SI Ibid., P.3.. ~x.m~~~.~-~~~~liR=+A8.~r~MM~~.W~~.m.J. J1t-E1~;. ~El~~!1f.. m1nlffl~~. Building a ~.
(17) ~rffl~:i:'FR~!I!{t!f~i¥IHI1*Z:l!Ui&~.. 187. 3t~~t*9~~31:. ftfLRif.=F.1 +.liSI¥J. ~~~~lf)l-1L. BJttp*f;j-Ei'1fL$'tMIiF · ~§lflnIX:Mjli16.it.fJUfJ r ~~jft~ J (deeply regret) 1¥J'B';fi3t.IVI~&:f;j:lL~ . mt7G~.oo.~m~~.IHM1t(?t;@~tp*I¥J¥IHl ;. tp*18-Ei' ; Alfi !l.f Pl tt I¥J ~ 'WIHilf , ~==JJU~U[Z:;Jtp ~=F.-Ytp~.. ml¥J 1[1tJ IHJ1* . ,fill¥JilJF: · 1§J1U ~~~I¥JIHJ.t~. B4-0145196 Mf~~~. , '&~.itPl~§~~.l¥JnUi!l. =~~it~~~f;j-ftft.liif.~~itm&rWtp~~:lL.~~~IHJ~J~~. ".~fj:.=F.1ftS~~itE~RRrWtp~~:lL~OO~~IHJ~J~~~I¥J@. J!I ' ~1f:ii!!~~f;j-Ei'#i1W~I¥JIHJ;[,\ ; ~ § Z ' ~it3t~-Ei'.1*~ln ~1: ' E:l IE ' W}JII¥J1I1W:*,JIWr · ~iftgt~:lt1¥.;fSJnsp..~~itJJ!~~n -~M~ r-Ei' .~eJI¥J~M~~'~~~~*~-~M~~~~~#m~~$WE:l~~. ~T~ntz~·.lIiID.·~.oo.~.it~7~-ftftRfj:.W-ftftftfj:.M1t. fif;j-Ei'#i• • ~~~~r~.~*JI¥J.7Gtt:lL~~·~~*~~~ff:fSJA. ¥.J 5iR:*: ~l=I.1J Uf. .1¥J~JJ!lfm·&:.~~itf;j-Ei'.~~.1tzIHJWW~m·~.~·IX:~~. t>tMUI~*1:.. *~#~.oo.I¥J.jli16~m• • ·~*ift~s:ttp*iI&~~.1JI¥J •• ·:lt~RRI¥J. '¥ . fHi- il&mit ~ •• ~:*:$1)}. ~~3t~~.I¥J~IX:~~.·WIX:.oo.3~iI&W • •ln~*W~I¥J~.·. i~*iftm~:ft!J. ~~&B!p"~nti&ml¥J'WIJT. ~ s:tIX:M IDi9iff:. ••• itlfM~l¥Jn1t~~ili~~ri&.~.JI¥J~~'.*~.~~~:lL. 0. ••. LI¥J~*~~~~~o'&?t·gtlX:.oo.~~I¥J~~R~*~·~.~z~.~. · r,,'~ltR~ln~.oo.~~it. (European Commission). alit • ~~lf~ ~~~1:iI&~1¥J. ;.1J1#:s:-Ei'.1¥J ,iID"§" J I¥J il&m ~Jtf.it WIX:M. ". ~it*,~t.iJI. 17 : 3 ; 1996 :. J&~lftp*~ ~ 1I:ft!J&:H9H±l ?gRY1t~nt~ ~(9tl: -~-. .-AA~$~~+A8~B~r~~~~~.~~~~.5.J .3![ffl~~fJOAliI1~*,fi~ S3 . . •~~~~. •. pg~1if~JJUIU\5 : (l)~~~~t* .. ~~tJlfliPrifo¥~~*1f- . {l3.t!HEJA!1#iWPrifo¥1'1~ ~1n~~lfi~. ; (2).1JEcp~"~~~"Hr]ZJ!IHI1*:M!*lffllil~.JE ·1Jlf.cp~0ml jji;m{xW1W?5L""F i!f1'J!iUJf~j\1J ; (3)1Jlf.I.t.OO?ili• • !1CP~1ifg~ . j;)J.~t*~~~ .~ • • • liI1~m~~~.tt·~~1nA~·~I· • • • a·~~.~.~~ ~~B9:R~ ; (4).*fA~lttlH.;]i.~~~~~t~rr~.at· "Resolution on the Commission Communication on a long term policy for China-Europe relations" (COM (95) 0279-C4-0288195) 54 1i.~ifB'iim : (1)!1~WiPri~IJi1ZmHm~B91Hlli~'ll.ff-IHI1;1]. [EJIF-¥WI~Pri~fjg1t M~.1'1~:M!~.3MOOMB9~~;~~m • • m~~.rr.~.m.[EJIF-¥~. ~~.*lfflmffZaR(a~m~)·. • • • ~~ft~,:M!%~ • • ~JECP.~. ~~tfp~ ; (3)3![fflPri~Fd'j;fOZJSM~'P'mffl. :M!1Jlf.~M~.&fA~lt~fPJ1JE{ll!~nlG ~trategy. for the. 'airs, 1995), P.2.. ~-§~;~WI~.~iliM~r~~~mJB9.Wln.,n.:M!.~.Ii~~$ "13~B9ftfU~Ij""F~nlGz. ffl1n g§ . . . ~ ~. OA 1!!:W*Ji~ J. 0. ; (S)3![ffl r -@CPiIJ J. I*~IJ. . {§'1'[EJ?X:1t~~'ll.[EJIF-¥~. "Resolution on the communication from the commission . Building a Comprehensive Partnership with China" (COM (98) 0181-C4-0148198).
(18) -.~.E.~~ • • ~~.M,. • •~~*ti~~~.~.~*~A~.. fDG~~~~.. ~§·~.a~~a.~.*·~.*W~*-¥OO~~~~.§~(C~. ~~A:iji:. Decision Procedure) *~ , ~.M § W1iIDWm~Fs~~~H~gf*f.';jMU~1*~~@]. aJt~*:rm~. .~It. .W1~.MWm~g~~~ffi~ft-A~~~'~.~.~~~~~~~b. tx#i9'err m1¥JJl'JIt·. W.~.~·.W~ft,~~~~.a.~.~.M~W#~.~~'~~~. :gt~U~af~. ~~*z.13t. 1¥Jtu~. '. **~~- J::i~~5Up)iiilf~. '. , ~.M~P~:f:jJL\ft- A llif{E9i~J~'lFF~~ •. ~tgiIDWj!§"1J~~~A.ffl~b. '. ]!!~~~f;7Ja~!tlmiJJ. r *~. ).'f.5C: J ~m.'!iw.~.i§'!i • ili~1:f:* ' a{r'~~~tgW~.M~~~).'f.5C:J!x:~ *~·~.~~7~~*j!§"#~~g~~~.,~~~ft~A.ffl.~*L~ *~jf~~A.ffl~c~i:@:-JJi~.. g. 0. 0. '. r. . fit. 59: ~§z.. r 1ijS1Jfb,]=9!f. fW~Z. ~'M!$'~1L~~W.~tg~itftlm;fIJmriJ'!!:f:j. , ~*Lti~~~ftj!§"1Jg1*~*1t~. ¥tli:l#ffmFfl. ~tgmft-It*~Jl(lJIif~WpJf:f:j~t¥=.1J1JG~~~).'f.5C:!Ul. *I?a:i~~tI. ~t¥=.1lma~~~@lr$ftt~~~Ml7(.. .~j§,EVGJtmilf.. f*. '. :. 551f}g,t~~ili~OORP)*~iJJ~-iJtiJt&j!§"1Jx'§'*~. ,. ~tgf~:p.e~. 1f}1JF~~.M~~!1Z'.fF.f*f7,hji{m~iIf~~IDI!lf!l'Jl'J{g· ~tij!§"1J1¥J¥JS. §.. '. ~~M.ff-}". ~.~:rotf~. r p)~~m1§1¥J~t¥=.1m[IJ J ~m~ . J!~f{E~ffi~~pJT ~1¥J r *~"f.x J .~e~@Amf{E~~m ' '8-1JiID.:lmiJJpgtfB~&~t¥=.111i ~ , ~-1JiIDm~~~fF.f1~~~.M~@j*~ . 3Z.!1Z,~~~~t¥=.1J1JG~~fit,{EIWi •. ~~~):E'. ~1:f:ARW.~R. (G~)ffi~~1¥Jft.~;fIJ~. -3&5[~~1. 1J*fF.f ' ~P) r ~~~ICA (hawk) J:fO r ll!fIU1t~~~~ J *mrrs¥~~56 ·. 1&f)J~.i§:tr. ;fI3W~$~~~ff:!!;~t¥=.1J1JG~~tiP!2~~m, +JE.M~~~iIDWj!§"1J~~1¥J~. ~). ~~~·~~*mmr~~*.~A.·rr.~.~A.(~~)Jwr.*~. .f'Fm. &iID·.~~.iIDJ1¥J~~B.omW1-@j~.~~mm~~.~~.m1¥J. *ii.,1;. ~:p.T.-l$:J;m~m. r ~'¥.~ J:. ~.a¥JS.rA~m[IJJ. R z.W1~tg~*~~iJJ!l1!UlfB¥JS.::ffl*~. (T. Blair) ~JEf. '. 1¥JJ!x: .Wfll. m~~1¥JM. • PJf~ J. ~. W):EBit (C. W~ARz.13t~.~mw.~~~~a~~liiJJfl:i:@:mMOO~~-1JiIDW.. .M)ti~1!ll. MJi!~tg~XA.~alj~, §m~7~' ~m~~' ~tg~*Iif*;@W~ff:!!;~t¥=.1. ~lm:. r f~. ~~.1f}f 55 . David Wastel!. Andrew Gilligan, Tom Baldwin, "NATO defies China's bomb fury,". Electronic Telegraph, May, 9, 1999. ~~ rW~~~.~~~~m.w.m. •• ,. 58 J. '.~~OO~ft,. fLWl'-fLfLfL~t;F.l· 57. ~~AJ=j ~1l]~tiIljiI*E2 Stephen Byers IDJr"'~tJj[, ~m::lt*,,]w1l::!MJ¥j~mIJj[. t&~~-fl[IWWJ~VgI¥'l~~. 0. David R,. Telegrap. 59. r. 60 . Chris Pa. thefutur,.
(19) ~~~~.~~~~M~~.~.3&... t~)1UA~m. l~. 19:7/- :XJ~~. • • ~I¥9~ • • • IUJ~'~~ • • • ¥~~~l'~ft~r$.~J~MA* m~Am;~-~oo~W~~~~;:ft*I¥9~~~A·f.j~• •i&J(f• • r~ ~~*M~ (~jflUJ~) 1¥9¥JJf$ (something has to be done) J 58 cp*!ltll r tti5~"F J I¥9{9lJ-=f:lt.l'M1f)[~ . iID~~::k~l4!i1:E r ~f;jtJ J (tactics) ffll¥9~M,ttttfu.~~~·.~.~~~~+~B~~M.,~• • ~m it~Jg1&1~~~ , ~aJl~~ r ~gTffl:f&~iJ'..m ' ;:ft~fu~.T¥W~f&:f:j:gm B'9iJ'..m . ~3.}*~rtcl~~~~~~lXmI . l'ij~m513I~~:ltffl!:f:j:gmB<]{:f1BJ~~ J S9; ~i3L' ~ • • *€iJETcp*OO-=f' ;:ft*~~gtf.j:7/-'§'~:{I~~~~+~. ~~WtJ:fJ!. "F1U~rtcl~~~l¥9ff{li. ~fjjj; (Co. ~i*~I¥9@J ,~1'7iW1&;. 0. 8<]i&m~1J. loJ'::t:lt~ fl!ltJr::k~. 0. 0. ~fD1M~~. iW~L~-Wtl.~B~~~fJ;J, :p.~g::R:fifIX~~;:ft~~~~3.}*~f~:ittJN. IS 1*1¥9 fflfE~ VJ 8<] ~i- 3( IUJ. ¥Ui5tM~j¥, t;jPl'~7RIX~Wcp*l¥9i&mlUJf*l'Wt~cp~~· ~jfflfl~r A. f'!1J;J,:p.Sl' fl.~-ij8i ' rtHcp*P,ff Jffd cf':l'1W. .1X~~A~j¥lUJ~I¥9~.~~~.'~.~~1:E~IX~-ft~:7/-:X.~~. 11ltx: lJn~. 0. '*~fDZjS F~m56. ,. m~l¥9~. r tJ1i::k!jl ~ tlt ff.J 1¥9. .~~±... i&mI¥9J}]f1~. J 0. 1¥9~ •. . ~~~Pill~@A~~}fjtt.~ • *:tt£iIDi3 '. ;:ft~~.CP~~~1¥9iJ'.1tf:J!ElJmT -lJiiJ'... ~~~~. '. ;:ft*f1~1§7t~~~. ~PIX~~ftl¥9J1. , ;:ft*gt~ft~imff.J5tfti§~pg$~~I¥915iOO ~~~~)1U~±'~ B'9~.ti.'~ • • • • "~U.mm1M'~#mmtilX~:ltf&~~ • • • • • • I¥9~15i'M*W • • mP,ff.r*~~:XJI¥9.Mo~~tilX~+~~ -3&::R:fif;:ft~J~.m~~l¥9ft£~[] , cp~rmf.j G-8 fJ!ml¥9~3.}*~:fOZjS~~ , it 0. ~ill~~~~.l'~l'1:E~~~~~Wt~"F~.~(:lt~+~~~~.~ ~). ,m:fif~~.~.rG~~• • ~~~T~~Wt1:E~ • • ~W~~I¥9~. ,. ~~mJwrcp~J1~~~~M • • J 'B~i§~~~.~~.OOI¥9¥®.. *.~. J1~'Bf1~~~¥~Jg;. )i&fff·. , Cp~~P*&:\f1~TUT* 1iU~tJ!tf~1tU!1l1¥9 W~Ejt (Chris Patten) l£;ttlH'F r *~!fi!i§~ J (East and West) cp~~ r (IX. I]WJf.j~. !ail) f.jcp~iI&mmHj1fIL\mj]JfM¥UJg; J 'K3I**~Il¥i§~~~ff!-3&f.jCP. ~ffl!;:fcf3. ~.:. 0. r~(cp~)~m • • • • ,a~l'~~;~*~m~Am.m.,. .1'~~mi&~~~~.~~I¥9~~J~·m~Ejt§n~~IX~~.Wt.~. nb fury,". 'm=+ ~wu){~. Rennie, "Blair's hard line on Kosovo causes rift with China," Electronic Telegraph, June 7, 1999. ~ r~.m~* ~.~.J 'AM8~,-ftftft~~~+~B·m~~· 60 Chris Patten, East and West: the last governor of Hong Kong on power, freedom and thefuture, (London:<acmillan, 1998), Chapter 9.. 58 David. ••.
(20) (external Relations) '~~M:ftItJ~[5.J11-xII&Jf'i. ~~~1~~. ~m~®§'~~~~~[5.J~~M11-x$~o~~'W~m~11-~~~§~. M*H{*Ef"j ,If:j , ~ 11-.;p. , W.~MB"rW11-.~. afi-~~~~~Wb·a.W~mftilitiM~H~.ffi~.$,a~~U. : Jt- '~Mff!$HI~-EJ~titJLJ!~~~*~~H{*; Jt= · ~.§.ti~~~5A.~ •• &m~~;Jt-'ff.M* •• H~ti.M *~3I~m~, {ElM*MC-~9C1;k:~{tt:&\~j\u):m r i3fitJ (voluntary) , rfD ZP:J ~ rfigmJ (agreement) ~J1jUW61 p),W~m~ftf:ItgfD~tJ!b ,9;HMrJg. ~~1Wl. M*'P3RXP)'T=~~. 0. .N.~&~.MtiM*~rIl&.*MJ '~fi~~.M~Jf'i.m~-&H. ffi-lJiftfl1 fLfL1\~t: ~~::I1!r tL. Baroness Emma. r~~Mi. , ¥A~.~~~{f:$W~m®&~.Mti~tJitW-EJ~tH{*~. &~:$'i-b1. f;TIM*H{*~7EP:r. Nicholson fiJf§ ~~ (tone) 62. afr'56m~. ' ~~D~7H[m. r 11-::;:.~~. J mlJ::tr.t. .§~,~t. 0. ~§¥tlr. (TRA). r4. MI!NJ~ J B' ~~.~~~M~P:r.~W~M.M~~~~mfiN~rn.. ~. JiJ2r,B. r n~.~II&I& J (Red-Green Coalition) ~re:. ' m~RX~ 1!NJ~~11-a.m.~ •• ~~fDII&~m~~~~~'~Jf'i.M&¥W •• ~ 9~3&.M.,L\*iI!if!?l~~1!NJ15~iU~Jt~~~*63 , J!i!.~J::~~~.li~~ , iJ2~ ~~::t;;~,~.Mft Am*Im{*~r",'9 ~t*,J5I:lI~m.M~~ , .~if.M¥A ~.RX~*.&m'W~~~H~W.~Mti11-II&.ffi.~"~ •• 'iJ2~ •• P:r~m~~MftAm*H~~~~~·.~'~~~~~MI!NJRftAM. ®®ti~~. *H~W~M.Mtim*~~~~~§ff!'m~~~~ff~~~~R~H. {~~mft. ; •• ~'~.&fifiti-EJfi ••g~~~~~~~ff!tiJf'i'*~~W~ ~~*~Jf'i~film,Jt~~*~~~~II&~~ •• W~I!NJ~~~~~~~'. ~~,~:. H~. , f9Il~D~1!NJ. :rejt.~D1. m11-XJ ]. ~*.. 0. i. I. ~~Ma*~~J::~·ili~*'~M~M~tiM*H~~~rfDzp:m1;k:~~J. I!JlP)'fD. P),§M~. ~~~o. re:.. J. '1. ~JL~,miJ2~±~~'~~ffi.~~~I!NJ.~~~§*I!NJR~~~§W~ 64 . JiU!!~. 61 Simon Macklin, "Nurture Taipei, says Patten," South China Morning Post, September 3, 1999. 62 Ibid... 63. **~15-tlttt9 ~ ~. ;. Vivien Pik-Kwan Chan, "Cross-strait feud an. 'internal affairs'," South China Morning Post, September 9, 1999.. (B)(4)1'N. PJTIHfI. ftJ1.~JM 65 . Richar( 1997)..
(21) \W.: 7JtI ~~'I#~~HJHt!:t iiW ~ 1IIl1* ~inlU~:~.. 191. , ~t*~UE~t#fMt~~~jJ1r A. 9l-3ti&:m. tp;!:t~m.i'1iJliJ:tl;\;. ~1¥J~IDfit. m~IH!1*I¥J~.'w~~~m~WiJliJ:tl;\;·~~*~~m~IH!1*l¥Jm~~. £ltffFlJP) ;Jt=,. m' ~9l-.>Jl~~~f~ B 1~ PJug*5tJUJJ!['ij'5ti$:I¥JJ~jJ. (*i'1~M. JJ(;1MBM~jftif.*~t*~j~A.~~.wm~r.,~JmpJT~~I¥J~~lfIi'. f) , r. ili-~~~¥~~~m~: r~~I¥J1rA~.~m~~-I¥J~*~WJo. m. '~M[7g j§-~IUJ. ttcp;!:tI¥J~~~~*;e. 0. 0. cp;!:tmcpffi.1rAm~IH!1*~r~.~jJJ·~.~~.~m~~~o. *3&EJl-:J.Mff3. fLfL1'\if.iJ#ijfB~I¥J*~~~1VllfJ;l..>Jl~cp;!:t3C~mfftfj, ~ilitliJlmJ~~~~:1J. $tt~r ru:~iliuiJ. J. 0. ~:t;;!IY+f}if.* '~~fJ;l.~1}rnl1rAm~$~~'Wtl-T. '. Emma. rMam~.Jtfjmz.·~~.*1}rnl1rA.Wm~~E~·OOcp;!:t~*. !tlUJ1*1¥J. &:W:9i-JJ1rAr cp~[7gll& J' ill:*-c!Zm~"OOW:l~~~ffi'WHklJi.Wft3s ; ~~ Z . ~t*~~*lJffl~~~~frj1l¥JlI&m£imn:t;;~1W.1W . r~~flH§:f~iJ~t:m fi@~r-Mcp~JlI&.o~.,cp;!:t*.~M.~~ff• • riJ.IH!1*$J (TRA) m-~(B)(4)~(B)(6t4 ~JJttm1rAm~E~ . tt~~ §HWW rMa m~.JI¥J@.:1J~·cp;!:t*3&mEJ~mfftfjeg~.~~~r&WiJ ••. :~~51. ~Jmr&:W£JJmiJJl¥Jm*.~o rru:~MiJJ~.cp;!:tmMl¥Jg~·. :~fflGlt. ffijiIDW~~PJug1r. 5S . [*tlro:t~. . , mT. AiJ#ijE~~P~~$i!mjM~lI&1f:1m. ' ~.tlt~t*i!i£!.Zr~~ ~jf;fftloW*~~'f ' .xtlOfPJjl1:ff,I~J1j~~Mfr A~~1f{ , .f*~**mmnr * II!J9l-XJ.~I¥J~$I!lo. ~M¥A. £*L,~cp;!:tw~~~m~~±%~~~~~JJtffij~'R~~.$JJ. , 'm~. .~~m~II!J~i$:,.¥e"~riJ.~.J~~II!Ji!fi-.~~.~~o. frA~. ~§n~, rCPJI¥J.$JJ.W~'CP;!:t.~~~G.~~.,~.tltm$~. g:1iJ1H!. ~~~frAm~E~I¥J~JJt'EJ.~~~W~.~fi~.~oBi!-~~~. ittWCP. ft.·CP;!:t~.~.~~WiJmn£'.~~ff~~$M~~~1rAm~lH!~. 'Fm,. I¥Jf.iJJt cp;!:t EJ l-:J. flJ ffl r &:~t ¥J ~ MJ ~ ft~ cp 52:tm Wi !JH~ 53 -1iI r f4~ 7c fB~J·m~mMt~EJ.~cp.tmE •• -ftftOif.Wru:~~~M.MI¥J.. ~!JifflJ. 0. §-Q!t& =I 1!!t t::I. M~~.~~~~a. ffl • • fi~&M.¥~'~ ••• fl5*~#~E~~W~~~ •• 'K.~~ flJTBmllllf;1] J : (B)(6)~tJ5~llJijJ r *1t~~~~fj!U] ..tJ.t!HJi:{f~~JfM!i:lft1J~111!ffl ~.~¥~'~~&~.A~~~&~ ••• ~~~ff~J .. nber 3,. ud an. •• rff~~~~#~~E~*~~~~M.~.,~mR. 65 . Richard Bernstein, The Coming Conflict with China, (New York: Random House, 1997)..
(22) ~'.~~~~~Amoo~~~~OOo$~~~miliwm.M~fi.$~~. 1'3 rl'l~$:ttW9i!. ~~ft~. , ~~te:!f3·p~~~*Wt;tfB~@]M~~~~~l}l1t~~~~&:ti 0-8. ml.~ttll,~,~. ~~~~~~~fi~u,.#~.¥~ft-§~o.~~~.~~~~,~. 8mlll'~~. ••ng~~-m.~~'M.W~S*~# m~ti.~W.~fB~ilim~~~~~' •• $~~r*~~~J.M~~. ~~*~ *~~*1j~E<. ~~-.o.~~~~~'~~M*.~*§.~.~~.li.~~M.~. ~Mf~~3[:M. •• §~1'1tR.~W~'B'~'m~~~Am~OO~'W*~ti~ EftOO~W.ffWfB~.l}l~~.ti.o.~,a~.w •• 1t1'1t~S* §:ttl!.Em~ZfiIJ~m.~( player t Jt.•• ~J[W ••• :S:ili~TfflawOO~ , iI:ft-iEl!*)~J~' &:{!U.~Im{J\ •• 1t1'1t)t~~~tiawOO~~fifB~. l}l'~Sffi.m~~E~~~~••• ~~~.m~~J~ol}l.~,~~ 1'~fi •• Jt..*~.$.ms.~'*~W.~OO:ttl!.~~*~•• ~W§ *:ttl!.&~~~w'.MW~em.~:ft.~~.~.~~q•••W,~ft , t! ' $~~t~.f~~J.1:.~ , Jt~m~§*~q~Jist!'!P~~,;rH~m.~ !1rti ~~~W~~~~*1'~'**R~ •• ~S~~:ft*§:ttl!.E~Jt~~M.. :ttSWll '. *~~~S$~.*~~~'. ~'. 7. ,. 0. W~H~ti=¥ (strategic counterweight). ,~m~1'1t.m~li.g{*~1IfE. ~~Jt.. ~IZS. •• ~J. $ :tt it fIi*~:5 (Nancy B. T IDwUIij!W~-E!. lWaitf. (sup~. Dialogue) ~ tJII{**~. , !l;l. ~:rt'~fi~ E~OO~~1. •• ~~1')t~~~Jt§*:ttl!.&~~M~~' m*0 1'1t~JtawOO~~~.~fi.wo*.~ft, ••••• *Jt§~ •• ~ ~~M.~,.~~ft~fiOO.'~1' •• ~:ft*~:ttl!.&.J.1:..m,~~~. *~-tl2W~~. o4-1f:.+. W*~'~I. -~~~*;&:~'. ~W~~~.$ID~f!frf~. , J!=FfiJ~ • • •~$~. r *fi§~~M J. (Bosnia-Her. Mm*YJJ. ~~. ~ • • ~¥;; U. g. , r "7+1"fjgiH-t~I5'~n,~ J. ,.~f1jNln1f1J (~t:fj'n ,~_ +1\M. '. ftftft~1\~=+A8·Rli~¥liA·. 67. 68. Margarita Mathiospoulos, op.cit., PA8.. mtll~~~Jm Gerhard SchrOder W$~~Jm Lionel Jospin urM~fjil!li.ltHaI¥J~. , 9l!::iLM1t-ffij5!itkI¥JItM • AM~;l"E:$ttpp:j~r-t!:!:*c.I¥J§~ ; "Paris und Berlin. ~ij~ff:ft~~. E7!P:&¥U*~. lliffiili~TJ. Mli.:S::fftl) ~~ J.1:. f'F~1. wollen europliische Einigung vorantreiben," Saddeutsche Zeitung, September 27, 1999; Craig R. Whitney, "European Union Vows to Become Military Power," New York 69 70. Times, June 4, 1999. Zbigniew Brzezinski, op. cit., Chapter VII - conclusion. John C. Kornblum, "German-American Traditions: Past and Future," Speech at the Annual Conference of the "Atlantkc-Bracke" on July 1, 1998 in Bonn (official transcript), P.2.. 71 . Nancy Ben. 72 . Vol. 40, N< Ibid., P.1S Encourage October 28.
(23) ~~~~. ••. ~~~M*M~Z~.&... 1~. ;tff~rr.$irf'F. ~~~~W~'$,~~~~*m(8~MRm~~'$'~~m~~.E~. ~;ff!JijlG&:ti. G-8. .~~~m~lli~~~~.*~~a*&~m'~~0~±~re~*~AG. i!i~(8~1t. '. 8~~,~p~~.llilfthOO(8~~o. l§(. ~~I1~.m*~~. 1'f.x j m~il[~ i1lJJ(8~~J.lf;I. ~. , ffij*J1irti~. !.:;;Y;;.nlG.m~. , r~~fTfB•• :nla#iflf~. :@.~l:.'~m. MM*m'~hm*OOtiW~~.a~.~~(8.~m.'~~A.' ~W.~ijlG&~~.~~~.,~m.m7~~~m(8~.~~,~.~~~. ••. ~.~(8~M'~~m • .if:.~.irmA •••• l:..*~~~Mm.~.~ ~~~,~~.m~~~~~~ll~ffij~~o~ffij,~&a#i~~~~.~'. .~X •••~.~~~.~'~• • ~ •• ~.1J~. !f:i~~~P?t1t*~fF.~~IJM~(8.iif;!j71. 0. l:.~:;;Y;;~'ffiti. m'ili'ta:l:)£*~~t5'tj;J5E. (Nancy B. Tucker )~tt$' ~mti~~OO~"ij]' P)J*l&:;;Y;;@J~( Do Nothing) , ~W[IDijJwft3'@.. (Mediate) 'il:&!alll~~~tU (Pressure Taipei) ,{!f:~ta. :jp::tt ~ 71t! W5l!. Ilfjalll ( support). ~~#,~lft. Dialogue) ~1im.hA72. ·;M~m~. ~~*tt'~7~_~~r:;;Y;;@J~jhA?i-,~m~~~ft.~~ijlG~~(8. 0. tk!:!. ' 1f!.18@f1i~fI A ( Encourage tiD5fi!:~frlfJ;£il[~.if:.*~' r j ' a .=..(8RIiJ. ijlG7h1f1J@J~sbtafltlJ~~ti~1S 0. (8ti~~~~. ~A'Wrr~~.@J~~~sbt.~~$·. fiIJJ1UWf~(8!!l. lii~OO~~1'F$'. , t:J'g*&,. r IDijJw j. ,~.~m~.if:.*ooti~. 1W~&'*~l?E~. (Bosnia-Herzegovina) ,~t~, ~~ijlG.miJmwr~r~~.. ,. .~~iISi~. ' f§"tiDlli-1X ' E£. ti5l! ~Jt/ ~.1J. ~l:.~~ir~~m*~:@'~~fB.~~$'~~~~~§1WtialllWl&r~. ~lli'*/'iiJ?i. ~tj!;mJ. ~j. 0. 4-.if:.+. =+1\Wj,. ~.itBgI¥J~. iris und Berlin. ,eptember 27, ~r," New York. 'peech at the. onn (official. j ~mPm ' ~~~~hOO~~Pm~ •• X~ , ~fJlr~¥gdt*9~~Pm;ff!J ,~,*tt ' ~mWl&afij]w~~OO~ , $j{{lE~~~tu!}!GafltlJ~~ti~lS~mPm ' ~ ~~~~£*ll~'~lft~~m*~~:@.~:;;y;;~~~m'*~fF.~~OO!!l ~.#~(8?t. •• ,. mijlG~~~§jp:.r.WallljZ.o~-~ffij§,. E~ &¥u*3t1W-frJpfTm¥U~tir~'. ,t!D~~~iS~M~t*9~~.irm3C:@' .ffijlli~~m,ijlGff. m.h@••• ~a#i3C~·:@'.l:.,~~m*.. ~jJij~iS~.~:*.~alllijlGftJ{~~M~t*9~ma#iOO~ '~*l:.~.7f3~~ m1lll1'F~~~@. , ~t*9~~~m~1~l&~ .R.lli~1&!JJ~m~ft3'@. •. 71. Nancy Bemkopf Tucker, "China-Taiwan: US Debates and Policy Choices," Survival,. 72. Vol. 40, No.4, Winter 1998/99, PP.150-167. Ibid., P.152 ; Harvey J. Feldman, "America's Response to the China-Taiwan Talks: Encourage but don't Interfere," The Heritage Foundation Backgrounder, No.l230, October 28,1998..
(24) '~~'~~~~~li~®~'~~~~~~&~~~~ 7f;~~~W;fDZ!S~tk:.c.", il~~l¥Jl¥JfAt~.1~* J. 0. ~~. p]zJ1lH1i'!1:E~~~~1jtf15~~Jf! r tfil1~~~ wt~!lt ' ~tJir~~lfft"Glffi~~~mW.$1tJ~I¥J@1. :::f1~:f~. , :g.r,. ~~~~bi~. t!l*~~~ft1. Jf!,~ft.~.tk:r.W~~~JI¥J.~'~~~~~~~~~~fl~m, -tl1~UJ~~~.1t~1r- A~f'F. , ~~~IEi1if.c.,,~~~~~~~~~~. ;. •• ~~ ••• ~~*~.~.~~~&~'A~;fD~~o~~~.~*~ :fJ!tfj~1*~!3 EB ' , A~ , ~lM~fJ!f1.®/f''t*-~~tk:{", ~UJij~'31 .~m~~.~.~~~*~~$;fDZ!S.~I¥J.N' ~~$~ • •~ l¥J~ft!ffi!IJJfttCPJt:~$I¥JMt~£m ~t~r5c.m~mZ~JJ ' ;ffi~~re r ~~. ~Wi~~~r",~;. .~.J~-$ft.~rA~~~~~~~I1.J,ffi.WN~~B.7f;tfj. ~$mpJTm' ~. ~m~rfJ!f1.~m~~.~~~m1*~~~~~J~~~,%~~ft~m. 1§-li~.lt~. .~il.~m~~~o~~IE~£~m.~.~®g~w.~~mtfjjt~~. A~~.~~. 0. ~. • • fl!IJJr~~.~~m~J~.$,EN~~~~.~~~~~flr!3. .~.J ~~I'&. itBf!tg,. *. ~§~F:tt!1 Wi. ~*~g{~,. XJ. m~~.~~·. 0. ~n~~~fim~~m-~~.'m~m~~1r-A~~g.£*~~. .~~~nN'm~ma~M~~~il.OO~M~~~~.g,a.~.~ ~~~~~·~®,~m~g.1:E~,~m~~*~~~~~~ID.~. ••. , :;t;K.iIT-$.*~~~~1§-~~x ••$flltJ~~*~~~ ( ~jtJt •• ~m'~.;fD.~B.~.~),-tl1~~eBtk:~~.~.tt~ ••fl ltJa1§-, ~~Ait~tri1if{,'~~JHtrl1.-fL/\O-$.f-t~&~~. : ~§z, ~~fi3~. ~. . 59ift.7~j. ?JtI~~~~eii. re<:OO. ' ~~**-tl1&;, .n~m. Wx:m1!f~.~. ~.~~~~~.-.~M;fD~~,~~~,.~~.~n-tl1ti~~.~. .m••m3i:. ID.~r~.tf~Jfi3~.~1t ••mmo.e*•. ~~~*~1:E •• §. -. .~ sA fit~1.~. r. it UJfmtfj:fJ!;s~~fit~~ ~19:. ( f?lJtl[]. ~fl~.~~.g,. ~~1j~fE~.~§A~fltmtk:{.t'). ~1ID .xf&Hii. tI;fD~~X~. ::tftgWi~~.. 0. ***§!tt!"fiI. (American u. ~~~.~-tl1~.7ffililtJ~~~.·~~·~m •••~ •• ~~~UJ.. ~~~, ~O~. £~ ~ ~~IIlt.JOgti*§!tt!Wi~.1J ~ii::IIlJL' B mSAM.. ,. f,!it~. JI!P). . f§.~~m~~i¥J:lL~fJJtr~~jt*'J~.ft.•• ~jJ§:~ , iii ~~-.~'~~B.!3~trm~miIT*~#M~~ ••• M·~-$.+~E. re#X~WTmji!. ~f:E~m9i-x~~~~'fiff§flLf-~~~jt*'Jfblf~*'tU.r3'. tlffi3~ ~UJl. 1Iiiil!1il.1ti~. ~*1J3i:~. ,. r~A~om.*,*,m~~$,.m~~p]9i-~.~~~~B~p]~1:E~~ 73. "Die Amerik;.
(25) 1X7ffl3i:~'~~Ht.HI:~JM iifYi$1Ml ~Z ~~'jt&~.. 195. f~mrEJt:p:#~. ~~1'.'&~.~$B.~ ••I¥J:#~n,~•• ~.mM.W~.~~. ~ r 'tl:lt ~ r1UM. ~1¥J~~~m'*~~~~~I¥J~am~~~~~~-~~~~,.~~~~. !.$fti~l¥J[§. M*~aml¥Jil1'F~ra~. ~m~rr-=fm. .. '. ~" ~6. tm~c~~~~ ~m~1~tza~~. :1[.\, ~CJtJ~ij. I. in DC. .~.g~~~'.M~*~~.~R.:ttB@t:f~-m~mCJm~l¥J~. i~f*Jre r :m~. , ~tkt-J.1'~1J!J1:.~~iWl¥J*MJJilII~ , ;t;tJ)]tJ~W[)1jlii- HM *~Q~:ttBW!,~~ •• ~17}jlrmw¥.JI¥J~~·~~'.~~~1£iW. L.HPEJm~tB. ~$ffiffim'~~~~~I¥J~~m~~~~:It~~~$~~,~t:p~~If{~. 7'C~1{fil~m. ~A1'~ •• '&*L.ill.*~~~~~il~D~'~~E~~•• ~m~. mmtB~ blB t:f. A~~fti~I¥J~~~~~·~~L.,~m~w*Q~*~~~~~~~~~. Mn~rrr. ~~g~'x~ftW~~~~;t;tB~~~~Q~:ttBw!~~~I¥J~~'~~.. :9i-$m~lli~. ~W!~~~rp~~. M~*.~~EEI¥J~D~A~$~~g~,m£~~~~~t:p~~JJ~~D. f*£*L.1'~ ,~~~*tU. .'.~7.MI¥J~~tt~~'~XQ~~~~~Z.'.MMM.*WQ mi~*I¥Jt:fg!5. . ti*Qw!~~1¥J r ~~1t J. (Americanization) .~I&rEJ~. ~17}jl~~.. .;. ~fti.·. :;PEE ( ff£~t~. t:p:#**~~~~. ~ t:f ~ m;fJtt:ai. . ~tffi-~ffi'i~B .m••MR~~t:ai~~.~~~~~,~;t;t.rEJ.m~mw.~ •• ;~. F!~1£if.mam §. -~ffi'iX~.~;t;t1£*Qlii~~~I¥J.~$.,~~t:p:#~~~~I&.~~. f7tltza. .~~:9i-~.am*7'C~iW~~~~am§.'~~.~~~.:I!~.~m1£~. ~'[j:I¥J.$rr. r9~1f{ (. ~.~.J~~~l¥Jm*~~.1'~fi~~W~~~~.~'. •• ~-~~'~~W.M~*m~r~am.~g~J·. ~iW.M;fJt.~.t:p~r:mQ~~amJ ,*eL.B~t:p:#m~~r:ttB~ i&~i!!~~am. J. (double geo-political strategy) ~Arn:t§!. *:ttBw!I¥J~.JJ'~~1£~~.~:mI¥Jif.mam.~*.~~~~r!¥i•• ~J. 3!Uj!Q:ttBW!. lR~HPCJ!¥i. , t:p:#B*~.~¥UEt:f.M:fJ.HJ~~m ~.~·~ •• ~~.1£*~~~ ••• D.·.1£~.~~rr&~~~. ~ a/;J JE [OJ ,. 1m. ~'~1'~~~~~~*~~~~l¥Jg~·~~,~~aml¥J~m~~·~:#. ~. re•• Mm.Q~:ttBlii~~.li~.t:p'~.M~1£Q~:ttBw!17}jl~-~~. ~. §~*JJRfi¥. (American unilateralism) • rp~~1£~. 1tT~~ , .CJtf~~m~JJl.ffiI &\~j[~I&~~am~D·. tza*••MW~t~t:fr m. qo]~1£~L. 73. "Die Amerikaner rufen bei mir an," Die Welt, October 6,1999..
(26) ~~~Jm~ffl~~~. 1,li , .5i;t~. ._m. '~~2*~~~~~.~~~~~.m~-. ~'fgjJ"H~f$f. ~1t. I ::fMt~lm J ~M~j7q ,. 0. .5i;t 'i"MI1j ~fNJt~~ffij i§ ,. m. ~ *if$f:(£. PJfj~:5b~~~~M~fj~:fJt~:~:1J~. ; &Z ' ji\ij~1Ul ~-g~~~M~~~.~A~.~~.'~~~~M.~• • ~ffl~.' ~MRfr~~~~W~:1J~*~M~~?$~~~W~~~~M~~~~ ~Aji\ij~~~m.~wzre.'~4**~~~~.~(&2~.~~~) f§Fa~JJ~8tr::f.~W2~~~~:fOZP:~~J:E:. '. &,~~~t~. I *~9f..3C: J iI&. .~:1J~o*.£.~W~~.~A±• • •~'.*~~.~'ji\ij.~.J 74 ,. ~. I ~~frtrta. J. (AIT). r- ~ff. (Richard Bush) ~WH:hfr. ~~~ji\ij~7Ji~$j(fi~1 tr.::ffj~::f.~tI~rr. J( It [Taiwan] cannot afford. not to prepare for the worst). 7S. 0. i!-t]~ll!iEe*{jl~fr!llf.1I$~.*tr~tJ&. ~IM.ji\ij~.J~~$'~$::f~ltr.~ • • ~~.~.J~iI&~.~D. 1Z94' ~~ • • •M~~~~~~~~Aji\ij~1IJ~' tr~t{PJ->¥~:fi~IG\~~ ~g§:1J~~~ A trmi~~~~IG\ , :flt*Z~mfr~ 13 a~*1tMfB~Z~ 0. 13~. ji\ij~ra'~. llPtJ .~'ffli§. f(fj'~..§.. ~~ff~. .MC~~. ••. ~~. 1M. ~~2¥f ~1l1. 74. r~Ma.J~.ma.B~r~~M~J~~~~. .•ma•• ~~.m. t:l'1II • ji::ltlHUI (wml) . -fLfLfL1F+ F:l-t; 8 ' W C9. 75 . "Remarks by Richard C. Bush at the Annual Conference of the Taiwan Chamber of Commerce of North America," Chicago, Illinois, June 26, 1999; "Taiwan and the Future of US-Taiwan Relations," Los Angeles, September 25,1999, at http://www.aitorg.twlbush 0616.htm; http://www.ait.org.twlbush915.htm..
(27)
相關文件
好了既然 Z[x] 中的 ideal 不一定是 principle ideal 那麼我們就不能學 Proposition 7.2.11 的方法得到 Z[x] 中的 irreducible element 就是 prime element 了..
Wang, Solving pseudomonotone variational inequalities and pseudocon- vex optimization problems using the projection neural network, IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks 17
volume suppressed mass: (TeV) 2 /M P ∼ 10 −4 eV → mm range can be experimentally tested for any number of extra dimensions - Light U(1) gauge bosons: no derivative couplings. =>
For pedagogical purposes, let us start consideration from a simple one-dimensional (1D) system, where electrons are confined to a chain parallel to the x axis. As it is well known
The observed small neutrino masses strongly suggest the presence of super heavy Majorana neutrinos N. Out-of-thermal equilibrium processes may be easily realized around the
Define instead the imaginary.. potential, magnetic field, lattice…) Dirac-BdG Hamiltonian:. with small, and matrix
incapable to extract any quantities from QCD, nor to tackle the most interesting physics, namely, the spontaneously chiral symmetry breaking and the color confinement..
(1) Determine a hypersurface on which matching condition is given.. (2) Determine a
