檔案評量在網路音樂教學之探討與應用

(1)

§ M:(£~

pg 9l-8"Ht~:~nff

*~Jm~

, ~

*~~~t~*g~151~~f*~m:~ B!~D1PJ~,*~~~~n~~

, fB~rn~~i§:~f4-f5U

~::aflg~pjtf]ntJl8"JJJ!m§fW!~'Q~ .~~'~*~~A~.o ~rff~Ji§:~~m~~.pg~ ':(£~~w.n$

~,m~~.~~~.~m~8"Jmn' .M~m~m.~m~m~~8"J-~A

.~~ o ~~*~m~~~.7*.8"JWM'~~R~Wn~m~.M~~~ f*jim~pJT M!~8"J~~fi~

-

E!D~ ~-T-~~fi ~ 0 ~

2js:X

pJT

~~N8"J:m:~~ ~

:

(-)ff~~*~IJ!~D1PJ~~fi~~ZP J~*ll*$~ff~9;D~~8"Jf~WHN9!*ff' 1~~~~flg¥-HIL~flWflf~n'&~~ff~9;D~~ ; (= ) ~D1PJf~f'M~aZP.:(£*~nff~

(2)

~--

... F.JU

c:::::::J

lli4* '

3¥:¥iJjig1\f.ltx8"Ji'j(~~ti7WU~j~~~~~ &1l::8kJJ~~

,

j im[f!m

z

JWOO]!!1'j(~:l:tjrtEfJJ~ 0 Etj)'j~~tj(jim~

(W

o

rld

W

id

e Web'

WWW) "6JIf:£1~*

ji

mP'J

?ff

B"J '

TIt!:~-8"~~~~]~zji¥m( (iJIJ~D1i!T$fH4

'

fi~fW~~) W~~

im

ji

;¥4

({J1j~DX~

,

~=g-

,

~~{~WIJJ.~)

,

~1-Tji¥m(8"J71-!¥--8"YF

'

TIt!:~@J71 ~5Crt '

!EBtJ-'im '

~ZPi:l ' &g:iJJ~t-'H~~1-T~[I1J~IJ~W-8"YF*~~$1JJ 0 ~tj( wm~~~W~~.mWlilJJ~~~tt~~'~-8"!EB~eW~~a~'~~A "6Jft[I1JB~Fa'~W[I1J -'I"t!fj:J!z*~W$ih

'

~~tfjlli1~A~~~t~j:Jl8kJ~~1l::~

~1~ff~ij~'"Hlh$&**Kft

'

TIt!:"6Jm{~*~%f]!!~5!j1't~8kJ*~~j:Jt

(R

av

et

&

Layte

,1997) 0

R§llt '

ft~J*jim~L*~1-T~~H~:j;j*~fDtt~8kJ~~A~ftOO*~

TII$&

3ZmKft '

~{~~fm"6Jj;jtt&;iJO*~*~*jl~Z~*lj ({Jlj~D~~~

,

$;R-.t

*~)

,

~f£m%'f~L~~~~1&

' "6J

j;j~~~~~JH~

(Web

Browser)

*~ij nMm~~.m,~m~~ji¥m(mUill~~71-!¥-W~~'~~MR3¥:m§~~ ~n!m

Z - ,

-m~=g-~~*m{~

J

-{[BJ,,-~m1l::8"J$&*l~j:J!(fi3'iWj

,

1itttt~

,

~90) 0

f8

MtE~P'J9}8kJm~~~~$&~~~$' $&*~~§t%'f*tm{7H!~f~~m~JJ!

~D

{PI ~ ~ ~:ijfid~~$&

*

'

ffiJ

m

II!~HZf

;!t

JJ!

m

~$&*

1&

8kJ nX: ~

~

{PI

(H

iggi n s

,

1992) 0 ~9}*%'fRos ~At§itfj~*f4a1±~~:nOO8"J~tf3i:W1±m!m~~~1& 8"J~Zf{r5:nOO8"J~tf3i:f§.tt

'

§DJH1~t~1l::8"JJJ!~(M%'f*~~~~1&~)

(

R

oss,

Su

llivan

&

T

.

enn

y

son,

1992) ;

Spencer -m

~:fJ! J ~~f4:txEl3~~IP'~~"H~nX~~

gm~~W,m~~ft~ffi~~8kJ~., ;!t$~U~~W.~8kJM:tx,m~ft

~.tnm(Spencer

'

1990) 0 ffiJ~~n!m 1±=g-~~3(~:nOOI3"J~*f4:tx

' Higgins

]!!

.

~-ti7t§itfj : 11§-~~tf3i:%'f~1tJi~~~W~~*ffl¥J~~f4:fJi

'

{B~~ItJ~~J!t;f4

:tx ~

:aij~

:i¥

nX:

ffl

M8kJ

B!

m §

t~

W~

*

nX: ~

,

TIt!:

*

flF

¥~

A

~Zf

.

J ( H

i

g g in

s ,

1992) 0 :C'

C-

) Ea:

83 M>

!It-H~I7t! §~ ' ¥9i *~tJ~; f~EtBm~

ElJfF J(

Kr

{I§I

M

OO

Et-J~fr ' ~~P'l~ ~~~~ &ij~.=:.1J ~~nx3<')

C=)

i

831i:

~~mEl

Wi1tijgj

~(~88 ~*f3t-f5 £\~l¥Jt (Tylerb. ~:&~ZPj

IDE! '

~~ ~(Ree' j;j~a;!fj

~*~

0

(3)

§ltJJ!m

z

5J~1~* ~) ~~AAt ttz~~5J j}]o~~

, 1:~~

A ~H~H~~

ser)

*Wi

I§S1~ ~tltt~

,

li

g

i

ns

,

~~~1&

( R

oss

,

~fJXif§$

, miR.ft

iggins

]l! ~~J!l;f4

ig

gi

ns,

(

-)

~~f~~rr.y~~

~~fi.~m~W~~~~$r~~J ~ rM.J&r~~J -~OO' ~ ~~~~~~fi.ft~~~mOc~-~OO~~~o~fi.~~~~~~*~

§

~

,

~U~ (~) ~

fi

•

.3I:.&.J]!~1I5~£*ij~:tJS1g}lIM~

,

ffij~rH'F~rJ~~J!l;£ *ij~:tJW~fJi§:tJ~~JJ!

'

~~fi.1±~<g~D ~ '~~t~~~ijl?:~iiLtS1~~~i 0 ~=M~~ {'FEtlrm.~ r~-J!r~IH'FJ

;

~~~(U~) ~ r~=J!t~rH'FJ

; JfAlt~fJ~

r~

-

f!r

.

~fj{'F

J(

Kn

ieter,

1983) , m:nJt.c}]~if.ft~ff!~,,@;if.81~<g~D ~ 'I'~~&ttijg.=.

{IID

M

iii

0 flU~£ff3i:~1rAm7D

'

-~{m5S~~<g~DW'!'~~~iID~~S1~rmf~ft~* ~,~~~~m~.~~if.~:tJ~MMM ,~m

• • •

~~~~~fi.tt~

~f~~

,

fi.ft~~~:;t~~~~~(fi:&~!l!

'

~90) 0

E§l!

t '

~tzDl!t~~z

ft~~~'if.ft*~~~7~~~~m ~ li~~ ~n&~ff*~~~~~'

ft~1W]J!B!m~~~tJJ~gZjSit~i~

,

*¥~A~c~~lr7M~~1W~fi2~D ~ 'I'¥f~&

tt~=~iID~.~~~o~ Mm~*~~m~.~**~~Wm~~rmfi.

ft.f5X~~f~t~ 0

(=)

~~fi~~.!.m)Jt

~$~*~~~~~~t~{IID~z1?f.~Ei.ij~:tJS1 rg~.J(assessment)

,

~

~~m ~£ff3i::ff

EJ

~S1 rfi.li.ij~:tJrWJ~J ~I~

,TIft

J;)

1~n:r: ~~{lIDlm

Ii

ij~:tJ~~*j 0

tzD

S

iet

s

ema s1

~*~fi.gZjS!itlifF3i:(Sietsema.

]

988) ~ ~fm

~(.a:

88)131

r~.a:~ ~

/J\

• •

~fi~l~HlJ.tij~:tJmrjjizmJi: J

...

~ a { r3 ~iI~

ft.f4~~ffi~~~

,

fIJm~~~rm~WJ~~,*~*~1Tfi~ft*

'

ef5X~

~.~m~ o~:ff~~~m~~.~§~~m*

• •

MfflM~ .~~~~f5X

(

Tylerb,

1942) , fB~

Reeves

H~tfj , 1±ft~g~3t*~P:pJT'EI-2I~?t;fJT ~ ~~~-j' ~ ~

~EdZjSil[gf~Jji

§

~

'gZjS

I

f'F~ft~~~Ei;m~~:gBf)t

; Reeves

TIft~-tf75t1i

.

~,ft.a~.~5J-m~~~~,~~.~~~.~.~'U~*~.~~~

.(Ree

ves

'

1992) a ~llt

'

?i&~:ff~:lI*J.R..tgZjSiI(On-line Assessment)~ltiIJ

'

J;)j~lfifgZjS ~rmif~ft~~~2~D ~ 'm~&:J5iW~niIDpfT~~S1~tJ ,jfz~~~l!l

z

(4)

(-)

~~~lJl.a'SJ~II'1

1±~~~Zf.:nit~

,

tl~~Zf.(portfolio assessment):ff!~~*~tl~(port folio)S"J~:'v:

'

.Eij]~8ffi~t~*~,'1!:,~fD*~S"J-J~~~~1~ 0

Martin-

Kn

iep

5m~

,

*~tl~(portfolio)EJ tj~~£ZRWs"JJ~~

,

i*A~§"1*~s"JJ~it

'

,'1!:,~

~?6

' fJlflfiH '

1f~tJ~ , ~EJ§ctJl<*~s"JfiX~

,

*~J)l:*

'

*~fiXJ1A~J~§

,

~EJ~f~*~1±i~lEf'F*s"J~fjI~

,

*~EB1~A&,'1!:J'iJT£~S"J,'1!:,~:nrt 0 m:m~

m~EJUM~*~~~~MWfiX~mm~OO~~6~o*~m~~~m,~~

gffilffl

§ , EJ

tjm

E*§~tJl<*~fi~rS"Ji'F£

'

~tJfDfiX~

,

tt1*~S"J*~~fjIW

t~~.s"Jti~Ed~¥IJ*~&~,'1!:,~S"J~t~

;

f.t~~ffiJ§

,

EJm'2WrT~Ws"J£Z JJL~EJ tj~m S"J~D~~tji'F~~ tJS"J~t~

,

~1t1~

EJ

tl<:~Zf.fD&,'1!:,S"JW't~

; [Z9®

f.t8m~~:n®§

,

.l§'EJm'2*fD::ffQ]f.t~~iHT1~;m

,

~1~i~JjIHt*~

,

EH~¥IJ

*~~Ml5t~s"J~JE *~tl~s"Ji~m ~~F~IIEi~W1±jj~f!0 fE~::f1JJ

'

E"iJJ~

~~gffitj;%;m1ts"J:nrtWt~fDf~m*~t~~B~

,

J1A~il~lEES"J:nrPJ 0 Ifflf)J;Rf~

m*~tl~~Zf.B*f~ff~S"J~J~~DT

:

~*~tl~iRJE-i~±.~§t~wrm~lf.t .,mm±'~*~~~~~fiX*~[Z9~,~*~m.~A~.mlJJ~'1±*~ m~~OA.~~&~~~WEJtl<:~.'.*~SWf.t*~m~~@*~,ft~ 8ffi~1Sl1I:t51~filiir,s"J.~tl~~ (~*iij\lE~'

'

R

91) 0 (= ) ~~~ ~lJl

ii.

a'SJ

r}J

~~ .~Paulson~ At~tfj*~tl~mi~J::ffQ]mi~;mrts"J§Zfjiit

'

:ff!.L-~*~ ~~'L\

, EEJ

.L-~~~8ffiW*~1~-i~~J[~s"JMOO*f.t*~B"J~~liMi~Zfji:

,

~~-'E2ti5Jf.tF~'N]B"J~~~fjI

,

~~~IJ*fTB"JmiR:nrt

'

*~~DiaJf.tEJ 2B"J£ZJ~ WfiX~~fi~~Wo~~~*~m~'~~~T~~~~~:.~&~tt,~ ~W~~~ffi~m§~ffi~'~~Mmft~~~£'~~KOOrPJ~~tt o lffl f~7C~B"Jm~~Zf!l:W*Jim~gffi~Mtfj:eW~~MB"J~Zf51t~t~

,

.L-~~Zf:l!*~1±*~..t.

~~~;~m.~:ff!,m~~~~~:e~~~~~~m*nJE~.m~

(Paulson, Paulson

&

Meyer, Meyer,

1991) 0

George

§2~tl~~Zf:lt:ff!-~~OOrPJ ~~.m~'E~w~~~~W'~.~~~Mtt,~m.~~~mu~Mtt I¥JEd't~*~ ~~fiJG~ m~PJJt 1f~tJ

'

~ ff.S1l[-T~ t!£f~~Bn ~i~PJ.0 ~71'~1

?ff

'

PJ~ www.ash ~JE~~ Jf~

,

:

>c=i

**',§*~~ &~~ff ~

Danie

(

S

elec

ti

o

*~ Ive

Decid

e

)

ate)

(

Ive ..t.PJT~ti ~1¥m~

8m

JfJ\"iJJ~ t~B"J*~

(5)

I~(port

tin-Kniep

it=,; , ;E[f!!,~ ~~J~§

,

: 0 i!&~~ p~

,

~$& ~~~f~W ~~.I¥J~ ~~

;

~ffi) ~

,

&

H

E

fIJ

~ , E~~ ffiHJJ~f~ ~~~~I~ l ' 1±~~ ~*IJ

'

ft~f ~tj*~

HTt;Zf

i!:

'

I

C. 8"J

~:fJi! , fE MJ- , d'; ... /G'\ I:.:t:. J~

Hi fffi

0 ::tE*~-.t ~ZP!it§if~ -¥!~OOrQ] ~tjMIF:'I'i 1¥J&.~ttl¥J~rt*.m*~1±~~-.tI¥J~IF:'~~~~~~~*&~~~1¥J ~~nX:*WJE[f!!,~~f~

,

rr:l'@miR8"J~¥t=,;Wti7~~W(George, 1995) 0 ~llt

'

*~ .~~ffl*~~$&*W~.I¥JIA'~~1±*~W~.M*nX:~WI¥JWffl o

(-)

~1~~H~m~~.ErSJlJJ~ ~$.~m~~a.7*.I¥JW~,~¥ft~W~lli~~W~ttttW.

a~

,

.tJ&.~ra'8"Jrr:l'@ 0 fBfl~i.Elh$jl§Jtf4tsz8"J~:rtJll~tJ:W~ft~*.W;j!4e"J

ij~tJ

'

~~oo8"Jrr:l'@M~~

tjM

i

R

0 ffi)~~~J*wm*~pJT~~8"J*~fi~--~p

~1l[-T*~fi~(Electronic

Portfolios) ,

EPJT~:fJi!I¥J~*~~8"J~~J1lff~

,

~

~f:tt$&gffi

'

*~

,

)(tB:Wt±OOifJjU~Wmm*~I¥J*~nX:*Wll~tJ 0 f~ffl1l[-T~~

m~~ tj391t:*~1flfJ

'

m1JO*~8"J*~ijJ~

,

~f'F~@]~W§1~8"JIA

'

~

1F:7J'*~mtf~l¥Jf'FJ5b

'

Aw~a~~tJ

'

/f~Na~~8"J1~frJt£

'

?£f~c!x:~fi~r7'l

!@: , ~ftff~9~1mW;j!4

'

~gl*~g:t§~~.~1Ellltl¥Jf'F*W~~~nX:W(http://

www.ash,udel.edu/ash/teacher/portfolio.html)W~tE 0 *~Barrett M~~-T~~fi

~AE~~

:

-JJi~f:tt*~fi~g~§t~~)I:~W{fJ!*~~~Jm~*~nX:*(tzO'3f~

,

~

* '

X* '

~1§-)8"J1l[-Tf4tsz 0 -f~r4i5-f~$8"J1l[-T~~fi~~tjf~ffl~~*5

*m.~#'~~~~nX:*~m~~~I¥J§~'~MIF:~m~~~i5-1±~.1m

&*~fi~~:nOO8"J2f:t?JMIF:

'

::t"ij~~fli:f§'~:f§nX:8"JJJJffl

(Barrett,

1994) 0 ~

~

Danielson

&

Abrutyn

t§illi~~m~8"JMIF:~f~~

:

~)I:~(Collection)

,

~t~

(Selection) , &

;E[f!!,(Reflection)W~ rQ]

(Projection) (Danielson

&

Abrutyn

1997) ;

*~

Ivers

&

Barron

t§illi*~fi~1±~9~fIfi~ooe"J~f~~

:

i

Rm(Assess/

Decide) , §t

l

lJ

(PlanlDesign) , MIF:(Develop) ,

i

H=r

(Implement)W~ZPii(Evalu

ate) (Ivers

&

Barron,

1998) 0 ~J.It~9;O

'

~1§-~$&*~Y6fffi § , *~~~~ff'7'R

-.tpJT~~8"J*~fi~

,

~1~f~tlli~~§!

c.8"Jf'F* '

~rJf'F

'

~J.m&§1§-W*~fi~

f~ilff$[QJ-g;~~~~~

,

~W~flli~J.~~[QJU~~f~*~~I¥J*~nX:*

; ffi)$&

~~~~~~~~~m~~8"Jjl~,~~~-.t*~ftW.'U7M*~1±~~

f~I¥J*~~f~WnX:* 0

(=) .

*

fP;j~

1~

tm

~~.

ErSJ

~

ft

~

(6)

(Showcase Portfolio)

,

~f~~(Process

Portfolio

)fDnX:R~ (W(~m~)(Docu

mentation or Working Portfolio)

0 ~li='Jm7J'~~~J3C.~~±pJT7CnXl¥JlITi~T{'F

~'U&.±mu_~~@nX~l¥Jm~M~~I¥J;~~~~~J~~

_•

_±

_rr

*~@'1f~4-1pJT7CnX8'JfF~

,

$(01PJ}~,~W1&~5i:8?2,~D~f~fffi§5i:§t8'J

;

nX:R~~'J7'E~

J

~7J'*±*~~-pstB:i¥ rFl9Z1&8'Jnx::RPJTg5i:§t8'J(Martin-Kniep, 2000) 0

(-)

*~~~~aAf91J

~*~m*iEE*JRL~~1¥J~1;jtj

,

rr~~~*~~1§-~~*ifd';ftL*¥A1T~~J;t1ft

M.&~M~~Z~mIff ,.*~«~rr-U~ft ' li~~ ~.&~ff~~

~Jj]1?~8"J$#rT

'

~~¥1j8?2,~D

'

'I'~g~~1?~ -1J1ID8'J~D~

,

t)J~:U:1~A1;:u:~Ei

jtff~8'J1?~~

,

~fffit!H~f-~~~Q'W' 0

1j~~**~!I6z~*~m:j:*ffl

: Linux

RedHat7.2 ~*1C

+My

SQL

Wt4nl!~f-'

~~~WftW, ~.ft~~Mz~~~T~- '~*ff~.~m~T~-: :l!iI6llI"~1I .~Ilr"'''_''11 ;.t~.~1II' ~o:M"~"h 11 :il,,~ ,·"H.:w;:Il ~1JW;t_ 'qNo

(7)

~lli!)(Docu iXa"J~~Tf'F IC~*~1±

~

lli!~rJ

~

m

) 0 4fJ~;f~~ z~f'F~£ ~.A

111 :lz:£j;i

~*4J$~I-' I ~-: f1~~~ ~FWr~~¥

-

,

₀

_'5*Jjli

_.

A. ft*JT~~Jt B. ~¥:~gC

c.

f'F~J:.fw D. f'F~lffirj~ - , _{f_~_gC~

-A. if~~ B. {f~~ c. ~~ --- , ~I-'~~ A. ~f.l~D~ [2:9, _W~_g'_iifl!l_~_~_qa

l i '

~\7~J:.~~rt ~ / \ ' mJJi~)J~

t ,

_~_\7~_J:.~_ZjS

_:Ii

A. nX~~ZjSfti B .

rh1f

g

ZjSfti

-

,

_0'5$

_J

_jli

A. ft*JT~M1. B . M1¥:~gc

c.

1'F~J:.

f

!IJ.

D . l'F~IffiIJ~*,

--

,

WI

~g1fffi

--- , {f~gC~ A. :D:~~ B. {f~* c. ~~ [2:9, _~I_-'~~ A. ~I]j[~D~~ B. E]mr",9~

c.

~ffE~rH'F

l i

'

§iIDfIj

:w

00t

/ ~ \ '

*fR

_~~rt

t ,

_m_lM_*I¥lft~

;\

'

*fRJ:.

§!f

:it

A. nX~)Gi!ffti B. rh1f~gZjSfti ~~:±.~rh1fgg-F~~D~

:

- ' ~6illJt A. iii*JT~~Jt

*;¥IJffl

JSP*a-B-MySQL

ji*

4!ii '

fj!~~ft1f~H~*JTs"J~mpost

¥IJ:;$:

(8)

*1£

15I@~%"f J ~-ff'~r:p

,

m1;!tI~j~~~ mail *g@5:&~~%"f a

B. ~¥:~§C

c.

fF~Lf~

*~~~~ML~~ff.m~~~~nrt*~fflftm oo,~m~

D . f'F*fIlTlJ~~

*

*~

EI3

~JJI!

'

"6J

M~fF~~iHTfffrlJ ~~ ,

='\!l~tifFB

mm~~MfiOOm~~~~~fitt$'~EI3@.ftA,*m~~m~~~

81*l¥Jft~Jj]tlg;zfil~ 0

,

~~aG$i --'

/ \

A. if~~

*flJffl menu

~~i31nrtf$:~*6

'

;ZOJlt"6J

1),1£-@1

·

oo~r:p~fJX

~f

-

'

1~ffl %"f/f&\~~t~W a *mm~~M~~A~.,n~~~fi~*~~~ o

_t

*mf;!t§p<H*tWH1E~f'F~Qff'~

,

nf~~~H*t~~ a B. fi~* *m~fiff~*~~'ff~*~~&ff~*~~W~~nrt °

i""\

*f'FfftJ*~:i~8/;J~§1§]~*~~ JSP

&

SQL

jf;¥4J$§g

Fr*~fJX 0 *f'Fl1B*~h

'

~flJffl pfT5I~¥If81if§h*6-g-java appled$:tfjiJJ1@~

*0

c. ~~

*flJ

ffl

tree.htc ~tMM:k~fJH5-g-xml pfTJE~81tag~¥IJtreemenu 81~j(

* '~~~~~8~~~~~U~~o

!TIl

~~~~

A. ~H~~D~

(9)

]:rt>

~ 0

fjjJJW;J)(

:

enu

EtJJ)(

A '

-ar~~

J:.

1'JHtHm

¥~J)(* 0 B. liiJJrt:l'~

*~mfl~h.ff-ffiliiJJ~~EtJftOO'~~~.~~~-~liiJJ

EtJ~~fi~EtJmA,u~*~m~EtJ~~oo.o~m-~-~EtJ

nA,a~~~.~~' .~~ffiH~hl,*~~*~~~~m

nOOS1~D~~ 0

c.

~EtB~IH'F

*m1;tU,,~J:.~EtB~IH'F*~~r~9 0 ~E1±l~IH'Ft)1~ffl 1'F1iB!l!}:iffl (~D

Finale '

2005!t&)$}:iffl~3::

'

~$:IT(zm1~~E1±l~IH'Fti711fC~ I ~~~~ ~1~mllt$}:H 0

l i '

~g~W~

*

~IJm vbscrip *515~*4mI*7'CJJX 0

1\

'

~~J:.~~~

*M~fi~~~

, ff

AjJRJ:.~~W:¥4~

,

~IJmasp*,,~J:. ffll;zW:¥4~

,

1~~ffii11r'*,*~

zm

'

:IT(z§c£~*,*~1&ZfJX*i

'

t)

1~ffl *1i!&~fl~

1E*ftJ

ft~ f7':J

?ff

131

1:&:j:~ 0

t

'

ttE~~~rro

*

m~t§rn~fi~*ftJft~fD~'2*~ft~z71~Ji ' t)1~1~m~t1C~:j:x:~pfT

Wfi

~

131 1i

:¥4

0

i""\

,~~J:.~S 1. fJXJ)(~ZPfti

:

*~IJm

asp

~~

database

z:tX1;jtj.f'F-17hJRJ:.~zpftirt:l'~

,

§ B1:fj:g~m

fi~~.~~~*~~tr*~J:.EtJMMm~,u~~~m~tt~

EtJ~*:W~ft~~f~Z~~ 0

2.

JjJij~~ZPfti

:

*~IJm

asp:W database

Z:tX1ijtj.f'F-17hJRJ:.~zp1tirt:l'~

,

§ B"Jtr[~~~

fi~~ **ftJft~8"JJjJij~tUDft OO~J?fD:tJ

' t)f'F~M~**ftlft~fl~1EZ~

~ o

(10)

~~1[:if~$&~~jJtim!{~*~tm~~zp:m-@I~~f~*;;iHT5ZPil

'

l)J~A TPl~ *±S~*~M*15t 0 ~ZP:m:I1!~.m7B

?Il

~~f~: (-)@1;f~~~ZP _-~~:Wf1±{~ffl

~~if~~P~'itd'it1&1±§2~DW'l'~~RWOOs~fiX*J!fgZfll

'

(

=

)

~jf\~~ZP.-_-~~ ~l£u~~~,*~1JOOs~@1*~W*~*

'

& (

-

)

fiX~~~ZP -~~~~:g-~1£§2~D'

'1,~~&tR~~-=-~OOl£*~...tS~~~:tJ~zP 0 t-!;~ff~~f~W1Jrt~D~=pfT~

:

#t~W-m.ti.JA (Learning Input) -$1:.i!~1i

J:c

tt

t~

,

:#

~

1;-11

'

&. ~' ,~~r1iJ ~

;fi

~j'1 1!!;;ot~

-$

1:.

:;f11

ffl

t'1 11;f~ *~

i1!

11-

j

'111 ~*- ~

(.:ii

~t"

00) I

*

~~*

~

lli

(Learning Output)

---1_...

,.

~~~

*

¥. JJL (Learning Effect)

.:it

~5

-=-

1.7

00 ai]

Afz

;t iL~1-

3r-$

, -- l L . . . - - _ - - , >1'J .:a.. WJt

at.,

-'-I:.

fJ

A fz

1:!

El 13 "" 'J ~b ;f~~H-

i

..

-

'7

WP

!ilJi

1 '

§C

4 ' :

$&.~~ffl@1m~fi.~-m.1±7B~ *~~fi~~~~Wm~J

00 ' -eIt:3 :

~c~¥~

, t:B

-r

'

OO1~

,

1JJE1$ ,

fD

iJl

'

fD*Y;~~t:~

,

1/1tJ~~~1~ffl

'

EI±J

'

rt~~D~8~~2~DW.fi~~¥1¥ ~ZP5TE8hl~5T[95T~~1tbt-5T ffill~[9{[lll~

m;~~~fi~~~m~l£7B~' fi~~u~~OO '-eIM.*.~~~~~~

ffllEfJi~c~¥t

' t:B

-r

'

001 *

'

1iJE1$

,

~D~ , ~D*Y;~1~

,

1/1tJ§~

,

El±Jrt~~n~~\!®

~7Bfi~gIWF~

,

~!f5TEB:H~5TIZ.95T~ii1~5T-5T

'

mIJ1\%lZ]f~~~&

;

fiX

~~:g=-~~~~

z~~1J

~ 'lffl

(11)

l?~A

7 fl1lt

I

='M

1£

{~ffl -~~~ -r Sf

Ii

J)i

Effect)

~ffl

'

EI±! ~[2:g{~~ BW~{~ Jm~W~ ~~~:g:

~?;&*ti~l£~~ZP 18~~=g-~*~~*r5t&~1£=g-~El"Jg2j;D' '11f~Wt)fW~~j]j

~~~'@Mlli~$,~~.ww~ ,m~~.&~±~~ 'M~'M*~

~

,

IffiM!=g-~f1~~{A~

,

J:~JI~];.x~&~~nX:*

'

~f&f'F6bzJ¥J~

,

:g-~H~ ~ , =g-~~@I(~~~~~) , ~ZP7tEBf5ir'&J7t~7t~ ~f~7t-7t

'

iIJ~[9{~W

if&.

0 ~~~~~' ~~~wnX:*~=g-~?;&.~.~

El"JfW

~§ J WfW~ ~if&J ~$~tzD~=~~1ZB

:

4 73'

1 ' ~cM5-1:t ~£~~¥-§~ *~)(JMfPJ§\!j JDiliMfPJ1~m f%wrf~m~

*-

'

*~~fD:g, ~~~~

,

*

i

Ft!f

lfI.-~~fD* ~~~, /F~1~J:Ij wg~~*I¥J~~ ~fD:g,~§~~~ ~~* , 1Et/F~7Z~(& *~~~:g,W

~

,

jfz~glEmHt8 *f.¥J ~ilf~

,

jfz*

:g,~g~i~*B"J n~@':i~i¥J~

£-¥#~fij!tB ~~~£-t}¥~ifW g~~ '

jfz

1:E

£-

¥1¥

~

,

EL/F~btf1¥

~ ' aW ,~~m~' HW '~ ~Bm~' H ~.m~' ~ §C5m~~ 0 B'lf~ ~§m~k-" 0

1 -1

'

~Bi§25Jj~~ 1~

,

~m;B~~c~E1?:~ ~ffif

'

m

tE}5~rJ ~ 0 Hf~g5tm~

1ft

lj:t£-fJ

H

l

fPJ

B"JmJ~

,

1E1~$: P?i~ 0

fJ¥

~flltf~Jffl

B"J

i

?i

*

0

4

'mEW

~g

~

¥1¥

tE

fi

~g

itm

tE

1f

~~lf

~

m

tE1

i

M,

1:t

~¥#

tE1

i

~

'f

D

W'&

I¥JM

~ ' fD~B"JnJE ~ 'fD§f&B"JM ~ 'fD§fJ( LrJmE 11~

,

Mz~~~1i]~g~

1f

'

\

,m~~~tJ¥

1f

'

18~1:tlE1ii ~

,

£L~t!:lE1ii

mtE

ffi~

&~

tEffi~&

~tt

o~

~

ffl

tEf~~ ~

~ffl

tE

~~

(12)

5 ,

~OW ·5· / )TL\~ ~' £*B- ", J;-fLJ f*~(~~U*B~ {~~?Z~~£*B~ /f;;Q7.] / L' =~1=l £*~ , W~:jjEz?~JJJ ~ ₀~_"_~{J)it"-

/f='7.J

' PIC" ~O~~:jj

)

/f~!~ ~oV~:jj

)

-fu

/f

~g~O*,x

)

Mzfj

g1£

~?~JJJ~g~O f.~?~:rj]~g~D*x 6£~?~JJJ~g~D

ffBT~CP~*,6

*,X

)

Mz~g1£ffBT

)

Mz1£ffB-F~cp

*,X

)

TIE.

1£EtE

~

*B~n¥1¥iJj*~ ~CP~*6wJ~ ~*,6*~/f~g

cp

g'x:*'6*B~-1~

K

A

o _nf}¥tb*~ll:_):t₀ _n¥J¥tfj*'~

_KA

₀ _~gn¥ntb*~K

A

O

6 '

~IJ*,x~ ~g~~IEUltilin

:*:

~5z~g~~

J.l:Ji{t

fm~gnffT

tfjp

~1*ntfTtfj~D

~:jj

_ffT

te~D*,xff'j~

_tilin

_ffT

tfj~D*x :g:~1}j~D*x~~ *xS~~:jj 0

:jj

0 B~~:jj ₀

ff

_c

7 '

fijtJ~g~ ~g~~~~t37~ ~g~JZt~:g:~1}j~ f~~J:jJJ~/J/C"0 'Y ':tL~1=1 1}j /f~JJJ:j/C"0 ~~/'Y J ':tL~1=1 1}j f~m ~"1=1 Ia:.=15 [,5:t °m % ' ~~

'wIi

~/I~~c5ffG

'

~N ~~'14§C5m

'

~ ff''J~, ' Ia:.=F'I

n

c5ffG " L' ~JZ!S. w

~7G~ o

l@

.,..."..

0

:>.T'/G~

J!r

_~

;fJ

_.I.T,_7G~

k-'

0 m~ffi7G tilli -~ 0

8 '

EtEA

~gIEtiitilinffT :*:~5zJD~~D1BJ ffJmzJD~~01OJ /fJD~~O{OJn

tfj-f~~ ' =f~

nffT

te-

f~

nffT

tfj-

f~ ffTtfj-f~im

'

=

rJiU-=J~~~ 0 ~ , =f~im~U -

m

'

=f~~iU- f~~iU f~im

~JU5l.. ~R~ ~ O f~~~ 0 ~o

9 '

$.,g)~ ~g~'r1]5tffTtb~ :*:~5z~g~~5tffT

{fJ1

ffij

~

g

~~

5t

ffT

~1*5tffTtfj~

ail

1EiJB~$'~m 0 1:Jj ~

ffB 10JfffQ

tfj~ffB1OJB~H' ffB1OJ~,'~JijJ 0

~m 0 I§Ji5j 0

~

wp

Jj[ §

45t

3n

2n

1 7t

1 '

§c~$ _{7G :::}C:7 ~_E._Jl~t:. _t:.~~1t.z_{" "}

B

21

®m~g~'r1]{~ns 1~~~gr~11X~,~ *~_Flt:.1.:t(B_t:. _"B~~_" 7f<;: ~~ '" 1:1 B~

/f

[PJ

ffij

*1'l"tf' ' 1=1 ~~~~/fl~ffij ~:6~~

/f

l ~ifII B~

/f

ra

j

Iffi

i~m

f~mlF]ii~~ f~mIEtii~~ f£mIEUlB~§~ IEtiiff'j g~£Z

o.g

£Z

0 .:rgrtB~1~ *° -fu~gf~ms·

£Z

0 ~g1~m

:D

rr4

1"1" M'·S~"·/' 1"1" ~;fB tWoB~=f' pp ,

fS

_=f_' ~_u{=f _·_po±_,_:_ti:i·=' com-m_5""_L _1'J,,*~A-A-f_'1'1- _=f'S

tWofA

_8b_>f

_S/jrt

_11¥

_'

_1~_if6_ff,!j_~

_c

~ _GJ_C°i€-fu*~t:./.N_5"_L _-_Flt:.l

~g~~1.N" '&'~tili

fJ

c5JJC

0 Y)JC 0 'I'&&tilit~m 0

(13)

$:s':]

,

.

tQ/f

Ig~D

B

r

Z

#

/f

sJt

ef

D

III J.'

~fj*~~1t

' :illZ

~fj*#~1t, I]! ~fj~$)(1mDJjfJi

f

*

1-I

tt

1

fjfj

1t,

iUf:f1

t

;oo

*

'

Jl51:: f1t~f~;j B-H ~I:J[:J *~ (~ffl ~os

,Imrl-l'

~g~~~I1~{~m

a

~{~mftlc ~

A-A

0 -1'f 0 {~ffiftJt;n 0 r

'tJtA-A-

- 1'f

W}{seJtlftJt

I~A-i's 0

1.1-; fI

r0 ';;t'cc'

V

1

4

, _~!J_U _1iA_Jtt;ftdr_~~_{_~

];[ - -· ;l2E)i'- ~ Mi' ~Ik.HflrfLl JjJE

i'

$fO

~t!l)jt~j5Z x ' ;f1]6~ , tJt~J

X

'

;f{)~t~ ,

f:J

t

il11

~tI ' (,~~J,Ljj:£Jil,A 2~:' ri~r'ff 7 J5I~\G

5GI

JlR

%

7 JJr '

Str,

7 JJ

r

&.*

lEj~ , M*illfrif~tm A~)~ll/j 'I~70

'

J-l

:A:~j~~

,

l:1i1tH~ ~j~ , ~(7Jifm;[E~('jg{t:

ktT

0 ~~t;[E-t~'~;;j

:fO ",.,.

5 , '1'

'

N

~~T l~Jts:lY'.i;fll (ilF~¥1I-~I¥Jtn {*~~4(I'fjtO *{l12m:M~8/'.i

~t)i!f j- , ~f~m

rf:fiffi

f

J-'

*{

L-effi

J~1~rJ" ~f5£)--tJ fIJ~R~I=:JJJ~g

L

I

-l

Cll<:VW'/K(~

*6*±~J\~{~f\:j

t

-

f~'1

tt

l

iF~5!--_ _

u

-

.

;K

(

It

_ffl*~ _l

r.

ftJ¥

I

t

A

0

*:t

0

i:tll

-

j

-

Z

L~I TIX: -=fZLI'~\G~:ii*

{

Z

I

[l

D-)Gi

J;

15*

- ? " 1-=1 '- '

d _ _ ~

,

0

*~1l:5t 0

rt

0

:i

t

jfOM:B"J~~Rg

f[l

H~

B"J

~:tii

illl

;frl*tBj'.i~t~fi1!J fDM:Bf'J~:t~~

r

~

.

.z,..

IE

E

10 tlz

~-'-'~f

-

EEY

'iill

j7ij

IE

_@_i

jill

{~

6 '

fO*:tB'j~~t~

iilJt J--. .J: , ,'n FJ t:. r:h ' 0

fjgIf1i'

€tiii±df

0 0 0

f~m

(if

Ji=.J fIj

m

0

7 '

fiItS

j§€j

B"J

{~ffl ~g~ta

i@l

'

ifl

iiill

1JD

~1]D~~'I'~fi,~

1J

[J

J=:

.

8 "J

$~jj1] §

C

7kn~)]nJ::.~'irlJ

J::.~'I~:DC5JJC

'

TIE

ljJ}G 'im:JJrB"Jfj'-~ ijm' ~&ljlJt~~7G

1'l

i2

lJ

J

Jf:

'

)}RJJt~l/,]f~

~B"Jf~1G 0 IG 0

M27f

i@

1it

0 IG 0

fitJ~.B{J-

,

-=F~ FJJ9~I.Bjj-' -=.f'~ 1iifHIEmff'ijlftB~ ~~~JIJ;rr=till{rE

TJW

B"Jf£e

JI=J ij

t~t) 1t~B"J192HCj j(!}'sz . , - F~li11i

'

'fE]. ~B ~~fj1,1(],:]- '

-=

Jt~IEUi 0

IE

um

0 ~i%:B!Z7\::g, 0 t~1m: 0

(14)

-0

35j

4:53'

~iiJj{

~

1 '

tBfr!f!;'$

pJT~~fE*J@.~g iffi1f!;~g~~wO~

w8~ttlm; , 1t!:~ l:e~

,

illZ~fE®:

fEB:ill

~/, 0

Wo

2 ' ~fi®:

ill-i-

_=,

_"

A

_Hll

... 0 Q

a/jzQi§~~~ $Ef~/... $:f1il.~f~~p 1

fflf'E

'fj

®:W ' 1t!:

W

~A _Qfffi , ~*,«< _''.X./...

1f!; ill

[E]

r:J

~~§1~~1I~jJ

_*

_lIiJJo

'

[

w

r5L

IHf

0

3 ' :j:~5E1'F ₁_'F_~_&_~&~_rAJ 1§1fJ~5E8~rl3~

*&

:e:

~2tt. tml,.,... EB ' -=-~7C - , rAJ%f1X1'F~&

~1±m5Effifrl3~

~&E ~HiE' ~fF~& [7g~

rAJ

5Gf1X o

~~fl::.

rAJ ~fidW}

-=-~7T~ 0

4 '

WJcp

,

WJ*

~~

5 '

®~.:g ~fr

1t!:

m

1L,'1~

6 '

..tJiffJ~

1£&

,W-3I;;:! -=F S

~

*

1E

151

~fjffi

WJ

_WJCP'

Wl"*~~ Cp'WJ*~~ , ~*i1:EfJI...t:f3F

ffCP...t

0 BJl!1!~if§~

ttl

I

L,

'

,

~~11UT8J ~~J'i 0 ®ft~~1f8J ®ft~~fr8"'J :;)zI£~¥U~~ ±~:J;:~~;t~5UE ±~~

,

Jl/L,'1~rAJ ~

,

~1L,'1~¥&E ;g~~o ±;!Hf1f5G~ 0

*'«{

1f!;

~5K~

r%

~

16

! 'X J22:tE!r ' 1~m...tWj~ ~ , ~~/fw~8J ~~~fJE~if§ M~m~, ~~11

_*~

_~

_*

_o

~8J~~m<:* o

7 ' ~1gd'F

1'F

~o

rAJ?61E

1'F

611 fiij

W}

o/C

~ , ~m7-ll:~

6'oZ

.

'

7c~

'

~

m

J~t:g,Jy:rs

'

~ ~70

Jy:rs '

~JU=trJ*tm

lEUio

~r.q:~m~rJ 0 25j 15j fid~g:t~8~tBfr!f!;' 1t!:JIMY~¥U ~~.~ o {~m®:if~ci*fE

-

i-

A

0'

6Hll

0 ~fE ~~:J;:f!<: ~Y

,

~ 1f!;~¥U ~!f.~o 1t!:*ti~~®:W ~fi§1fiHll

'

~y ~~£~ o

9ltE~g~~lt~:

_fF*&

_¥&B

_rAJ

fF~

,

{Bfifr~151 _~/f~~5G_~_' _~ rAJ~r.q:~~* 0 *D~~Jl!5E~r8~

rAJ

~13Z1t~ 0

WJr:.p,

WJ*~~

1t!:

*

ttl I

L,'

~fjffi ~M«1±

f:JI...t:f3

F

WJCP'M

*~

ffCP1~J~ 0 ~

,

~*;J/f~!ft! ;tEl 0 J~..L" ®i!@if~tf8J ®~1f~*tr:J

±~:J;:Ht&~

,

~~~~~Y ' ~IL,'

3Z/L,'1~¥&E 0

fl3

"'f rAJ~s-F-* ~ 0 ~...t~16~~ ...t~*~~~ 31;'l1 , {B~I£/f ~Y,~*~m :g,,~*~~~¥~~~* o ~~~* o 1'F~ol'~~5G

If'JG

f1X1'F

tfl

o

'

f~ ~ , ~ttl8Jt~rs

Y ,

Jl

~€m5j-~

ttltr:J:JsZJJ

®(

~y

,

Jl1H~~:53'

15ZJJl!1=trJ

0 ~&:tJi~U

'

17J~ §t:g,~!fr~FI3~ 0 I

9 '

if~ ~i~ (~ ,'.-.:2~ {>"t :7 ~) M~~~

(-:

~lE!Jiq

1t:

f7t:f:thf~ ~f~~3J

(

=

:

~:ff!'JkJf~ ~~'~1 (-= ~~~w ~fJJ<:A~ ~{ ~~EIj~ ~t

:

j!

r.

(15)

,

-:)::f&

mk

iU

8

_,.:cr._s'*~~ OE! ~~~fFm t~~

[7g

~fi3J~w _~~_{_'F_XY_~~_~ _Wl_~

_[7g

_~/f_'_$1i]

I~\ , [7g;gt§~'jG Jt:m 'jG~ o ~t~;$

,

Ps?G~ ~fi

'

i@D~¥

~

¥

o

!f ' ~~ o ~iUb;*~* 0

-'lJLJD.0.~,,'E§~em

9 '

::g~ ~' ~

c,*'tl&

iJ1J~~i~~~ fJ1/~~M~~ jt*~# ' A**\ \ 1 \ ~iEi3..,. ....

fi3JQ ~""aA~ fIt~\\/~' '

il

fi3J~I=l f't,\\'iA~ \JD\ '

li

~~o

t§~~l~~**

'

li

*

~

~_'{~,'1i-li@~D_'",_:£_{':G:_)IL

(~ ~M~~Et§it ~~iMI~E~~

;1i[~ 1:G:~ _)IL , ~w~ ~o .1\ \ \ 1.m~

,

{i:tI~

*

6~ 0 ~~~ o ~)

B::.pg

~ ,

li

~

~Fa9

~ o ~~M~,~.ft.~$~~ft¥*~$~~.~m.~

•

*~,~~ ~fjffi

.§}]$T37

l_j JJ!§f~Z~m :

(-)

~.~f6JtllJm:ZP:

B

L~*B~~~N1ls1~~§ f~

,

¥-fJj Ij~1£*flI*IjS1~

*~

=fl[fI

_.~:t.lCP

_,

_~~fJf~JjIHl_~~~{N~_._fES1_'ffFi~i@f_l.tSZP

_!¥J

_i5

_)i:gt,

_~₇_OJt)

~ffi~M~.~~.$~~!¥J~~ '~OJ~~~~.~m.~~m'~~Tm

~f~

.

~~~

.

~~*~

0

(=) ~.~f6J~~*~fi.~ZP:lt.$IJ

'

~~-fflf~~~I¥J~~*±ggJI[* ~~!¥Jf~JjlJ:g:~1i~:tJ

'

~OJ~M~~~~t$;!t1£EIJ~:tJLzmij~

,

JiE:~M$.w.

-5FJ 0 --t ~~M!1L:g:.ij~:tJ~.~oom 0

(

) ft.W~~.~

• •

~. '~~OJ~~~~~li~'~fi~@~fi

'

*g&

~~.~~(~m, m.~~~), ~OJ~ft.~~~~~.~~li~ '~M

*~

~

$nX:A~Jt.~§ f~ziim 0 ~~ 0

J5G

fY9hZ:

r

5

i[~~7J' _~JIHJmtIE_~'_(B!:

91) 0 Giselle O. Martin-Kniep '*~

,

mffi%JiE:~TS1 :t~Jffi

:

8 f~

J '

ill

fl"

~.Elj*JTffil~S1 ~(Becomjng a better teacher: eight innovations that work) 0

11

~~Fa9 0

(16)

~i'fi)\:$(~ 90) 0 *~jJ61imj]*~jiHftt£'"t~~~1f~~!}~*IJ)('~~;L1iffJ'E

'

~

fiJ-\ilw~1iffJ'EmG*¥~fr 0

~i'fi)J'

'

~i!t~(~ 90) 0 e i!t1i:1f~~~$J:*,Lrl§1

'

;m~'~$J:W*fIJ

'

8~4'J3' 77-89~o

~fl~~(~ 88) 0 ~~r:p 'JJ\*~±'1f~~~'.~~tJmIJ.,L1iff3i:

'

/\'+;\

,@!I.

4~gffi~*~1C$J:~~~Hitj~ffir;z:~~fr~x~IV, ] i95-123 0

Barrett, H. C. (1994) 0 Technology-supported assessment portfolios. The

Computing Teacher 21, March 1994, pp. 9-12.

Danielson,

c.,

& Abrutyn, L. (1997) 0 An introduction to using portfolios in the

classroom. Alexandria, V A: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Develop

ment.

George, Paul S. (1995) 0 What Is Portfolio Assessment Really and How Can I

Use It in My Classroom?, Gainesville, FL: Teacher Education Resources.

Higgins, W. (1992) Technology. In R. Cowell (Ed.) 0 Handbook of Research

on Music Teaching and Learning, New York: Schirmer, pp. 480-497.

Ivers & Barron (1998)' Multimedia projects in education. Englewood, CO:

Libraries Unlimited, Inc.

Knieter, G. L. (1983) 0 Aesthetics for Art's Sake. Music Educator's Journal,

Vol. 61,33-35.

Paulson, F.L. Paulson, P.R. and Meyer (1991) 0 What Makes a Portfolio a

Portfolio?, Educational Leadership, pp. 60-63.

Reeves, T. (1992)' Evaluating interactive mul timedia 0 Educational

Techonology, Vol. 32(5),47-53.

Ross, S. M.,Sullivan, H., & Tennyson, R. D. (1992) 0 Educational technology:

four decades of research and theory, Educational Technology Research and Develop

ment, Vol. 40(2), 5-7.

Sietsema, R. T. (1988) 0 Southwestern Montana Music Assessment: A Com

parison between Rural Montana and the Extreme Rural National Assessment of Educational Progress Sample. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Montana State

Universi Spe M . Jams] educatio TyJ R esearcl htt] lios on t

(17)

f*flJ '

ios. The ios in the )evelop )w Can I R.esearch )Od,

co:

Journal, rtfolio a cational mology: )evelop-A Com ;ment of na State

University. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 312103).

Spencer, C.l. (1990) 0 Partnerships--An integral part of technology transfer, In

M. Jamshidi & M. Saif (Eds.), Robotics and manufacturing: Recent trends in research,

education, and applications, New York: ASME Press, Vol. 3, 947-952.

Tylerb, R.(l942) 0 General statement on evaluation, Journal of Educational Research,92-501.

http://www.ash,udel.edu/ashlteacher/portfolio.html: Creating and using portfo lios on the alphabet superhighway.