選舉對民主政治的負面影響--以臺灣選舉為例

全文

(1)*1tITJt±f4/Hwa Kang Vol. 13, (1999), pp. 79 - 86. *. Jlt)€; a~. 1! 1t t\ £. tl iiI 1.3 ~. -y~ ~;'1!*A 11'1 The Negative Effects on Democratic. Development of Elections - The Case of Taiwan. 1~'. ;l'~. ~.I-. Joseph P. L. Jiang. ~. i~ ~ j!Uil:W~f!FlKJf*. ... ~.til:f"jflJ1~~. ~ ~.~I!H&ill!ff:*j~1¥.J1[t& ~ ~ tJ~jff1t.~.~PJ. 'rs. 1::. '*. ~ ~.W1tMft±II:f1]±:It!!.i&lf. A ... j~.IHJ r:lJ ~~~g; lffUIiI~ ~ ~. JL~R;~±~l¥.Jmtj~. ~ ~.W1t1ijff{1ii'. ~~. ~~.W:It!!.:tril*. mr. ~. a. , 'Bk'Ji~l~1f1t-f-5!¥ ' k'JttAJm1f1tfT1i!tAJm 1¥r1n:\ ' fJE~~flfjPf.~ , ~Y~:ff@~fiflj]1KHtfll~1tB"JJjJ§B ~~it,,~ , /f> ~1f1ilJ~Fi1ffljB"J1I::t~~~ , !!!1jt~.~f~.:E~l'fJti3&iWIJJl ~rm ' fF~~.:E~¥~1'fJ .:E~m.fll-~/f>~~.l'fJm.' ••~~:ffM~a~.JJl~.:EI'fJ~~mm'M~ ~~j!ff1-r~.:E~1itI'fJ&,~tl7jJ. 0. 0. ~~flltl*~~~?~~m.*~m.gl'fJm~:~ftW~'~JJlff~~~m~~ ~~JJl~?~~~.~I'fJ~.~oo~.'Xftm~~/f>Y~~.~~~ ·MI't:1fit~. , 13- A/f>pJ/f>~. .:E.~g. 0. ~~,a~~~.OO'TOO~~M~~.I'fJ.~.R'/f>~*~M.~.~~. ·. ~.~m~~*.a~.M±'mff~.~~*.~.~~&.

(2) 80 :H~.fi.*~~.w,m.~~ft~®.~li~m.~~~~ootl~m;~* .~.~~~~Wm~'~A~~¥.~~~~~m~~~~.;~~.e~,m JJIJ~.,I}'t1AJtt1f::?; Jf~fi~.~f~ffl ~.~6 *~ ~~~. ~fiA'~WM'~~M~'M~~ IY~ 1r 1~ ~. ;. ([lL])~M ffl1~~AJlmms<Jil. ~~~M~fi.·~-M~~~ffl.*~*. * ~ (J'~ ~. ' ftJt ~:f~ frH'fJfJT ~ ~ ~UJ! ~ iJB%¥U s"J JR. ' :ff:fJ :trjJ~'@1l14J. ~fr9f~t~n"Jtl 001'Fffl. c. , ~~.LEtY€:l~;fS:R: ( Edmund Burke) ;(f Bristol ~.~5fIH!i ' rtJ B~~~: r~~~~~~ ff;Vflj~. '~~~.ff~~hl;m~*~.@~~~~.*~.. • ~faf1E~~Et~5fIJlIfft1~~fr9s/g5flj~. Y:tr;fS:R::@f;JtS"J~~fflff~~. ABff'. ~. 0. J. 0. (1l;f§. *B"J1~~A. {E*l&!E~~MS"JmjJLr ·1tE.1r9~/f-1;1. ' 1~. r 1i>Jru:~~. ~~~~fft&*Jo~~m~~·aM~m~m~~.'mjJ~m~.. ~~a~·~X5/f-~.~~.{E~~~.llio~.~~~~~~w~~~m.m. ~*M.*·~~*l&!E~~~.~o. B~ • • fi-~-(. '$.~'~~. )~.'M~AMru:~~~~M.*.·:tr~~.¥A~~~.~~'.~.. ,:tr~~~~AAm~~**~$~*fl'~/f-~~~.@~m.~~.fi.*•• ~~~W~·~$~~.~~~m.'~~W.M-a~~fflmo. !l~ [P] 'f5:f~16\@rill!. 1t* ll:a1~. S"J ~ ~ /f fi~3.tQ5fIJ ' 1r 1§f:~.1'I"J 1~~A tP:lt 1;1.Ji. ~~~.*~~WA*l&~M~~~o{Eb.~$·~.MOO~$M~A~~~m. mfi~~~/f-*~~·m~g~~~*¥.m~/f-./f-.~K.r~~~±Jfflr m~J '~.~A~~fi~. rLt~~~*:i~JJIJ. 0. o~~~.~.'~.~~M~A§.jJ~~mm~. 1tE.1r~m16'~JBt~-ill>fEafE1tfll~iJl«rJ* 'Nffl1N~1IJ. ~R~11f?fr9 ·~11f?1P~{E*1i:~~~:ktm~fE~*tH* ~~.. U1lr' [ I). ~~A. · ~fE~N~§ B. •• $~~Jf'*~~M~A1Nm. ~.~o{E. ••. -E~$BI,j~~ar€:l~~Hlf!~jI, str*i¥1~~A~~!lWffiff!l*' 11f?~~{E*~ Edmund Burke, The Writings and Speeches of Edmund Burke. Oxford:Clarendon Press, 1996, Vol. 3. Speech to Bristol voters, Nov. 1774, p.69-70..

(3) ~~Jt~±iI&rtrE~~oo~~~-~~~~~~{9tl . A+Aif:.=:..}i. "Pt;:11*J1J3'f:. 0. tnJ1Jti] ( Samuel Huntington ). JfJ~.lltf.l~~. I. 81. J(. ~~;f;tft.B~~. ( Generd Jackson ) Mltf~~Mc f!~ , ~JL1ii,,~~JrWT!i1lff· § d3~ (Sri Lanka Freedom Party) B~X~f:5'rJ1J~1j , -JLJL~~~.*~.Mltmm-~~Mc~~~~.'~H~~~~~m~ ••M~. Ruralizing elections). 0. (2. 1--- A~JL~~~fo.\~51~~1l1. '$m~~H~~~M~m'~Mc~,~~~.;f;t~~~~~*~J1J~~~.~~. o~~~tl*~~M~'~~I~~~.'$m~~I* '~~{,*~Aft;ffr'¥.lRB~~~. .$m~~I~. ••~~~~~~~*.. JL1iO~f-t~ilJ.ftU!B9JU~. 0. ( Peron ). {!:~~~d31J,jj. ••tt~Mc~~~~.'~.mT.~~a~ft.om • •~.~. •• ' •• A~~.lR~~~~~'~~m~~ ~~m'~~ff~~OO.Mm~~~ •• m~ ~o. d~I'$~~~~m.~ft~x~. =: ~ ittM 1tiJ!.B~PJ i'8 ~.~M~,~a~. •• ~I~J~.ttM~. ~~.--~.*~~&. ••. %m~uM,~~~rem.~m.m.&*,~zro~~~~m~~mom&~' ~DJGl,m~~F~JjB't~a~. , ~~~J~:/:tI!.~~[l~~t/f~[l~~. , {!:~flB!~S DlU§t-t;fO~iIJ~. o. ~{rS.~ll:tij(~~tm~~.. '. 1~¥UPN{tal1~1*~IJ~r;p~. , m-M1f:~/l!l!~ (. '**. ~'~~JL)$~h.~. 'fi.~.I~mI.J;fOI.~~~J'~~. ~~WY~1\i~£~2fBIl]JiJf~!1W. '. '1f:~A~$re§. ~WF~~.~I!t*8JtfE~~~fiMrS't~.?91H~:€ff. 0. m~~~fi~~~~.~no~~JLmm~~~,~.. ~m.~,~.~.m~rr*J1J.m.M*~*~.o,**~.~~~.'~~W :9:~7Jitt~OO~O~~~tt. '. ~~~~~'~~mm. 9!~PNfil~A~~~T*IJif1§:~"PHJil~~. ~~ • •~M'ti'Ht. •• ~~m~~~~!. ••~M~~~~*m'~mMu**.'~.~.M~mti~~A£'.~ ~~H,. • •~~.~~o.~~m.MOO,~mA$*.lli~m~m~~;fOa.. 'm~*~.~~*M'~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.'~ jfdi!!.f~:Wf~~A(t>]wMcB~BX~FwMcB~ ~ 1* o. (31.§:t~~Ji~. ,. bt1j[t.:4!~a.m~. , §. '. .!!i~~ftl!.f5jG'. B "Pf~mA~~f01Jf~. ~9!~£IfIJJ~'tff~~ft.. 0. ll:tjr'. iX t1~t. rn~i~lH¥HilH~*fJJIJ~kt~89~ftnl1t~~~. , M:~~Aa£~ll:tiX~.s~~*~fl:M~A MM~~e'9!~~*~~~.tt~~~~~~,~~~mM • • ~More~~~ ------.---~---... ..---~-. ... J Samuel P. Huntington, Political Order in Changing Societies. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1968, p.448-459. [ 3 J iiJjf;j;' ~~I~~ , ~1%[t{Jt9Jj~1T~ 0 rt::lt ' 'P*~.~~fr '-nA{:; 'm;l;;I$i: ( 2.

(4) 82. '. •• 'R~~.A~~m~o-A~O~~$ •• ~~. m~. allt~mt¥JLa ' *1t.~ r 2fJii ~±fJff,JW J 1E!*mJIAI~.~* #J1Ifl:~iU:@ 1OOaiMJiJfMfftfll,Jfitfl ' (4 )E5l~a~1P~t~reaJff0~~rM'~!UE~flI,J~~ , m~ r it ftfl~j)Eif J '~'m-:m~fi:ill~z lltJiJfiil'l r I:t~ara J (Peso politics ) W$~i5( •• ~~.'~W~~ti~~&.~~.~~~a*'E5l*H~+%~.o ~*~.~.z~ft'W.~$ •• ~.,ft~~zW.~Ro~~~M' ~-fR!Ulj!,~~lbX:W~~ , 3?:~~:m~~'I'Hi'TMJW ' W~jt~HhJWW-& ' ~ffl8Jt ~.~.~.~affl. 0. 0. ~~~SJWMom~mm~M~flI,JMm,~*~.gkfll,JRm~M.ft'~:m~,. liS~-m~a~~,~~~.~oM*m~~.~JiJfiil'l~OO~%~~~~N'~. *allt~*x~*~~mm •• ~.,m~~%~~-~~g~~~~.~*~ft ~Jt{](. 0. · W~allti*1fa"J tfift E5l.~®~~~.*.*m~ ••w~.'~~mm~N. 1{~z ' ~.~-$%~af-t~~:t~lIfj;~~a"J. mm~N~~*ffl.'. 0. ~~~fI~ili*.ti.~a°1E!~~~~*{](~~~.'.~.JiJf~~flI,J~%~~ '~~.~~~flI,J~*.A~~Hm~~o~~.W~ ~ iE! J1IHmj::g~,*. •• MlIt~lltftm~?. 0. a~lbX:tt;a~:mmJfl~B"J. .~~?~&.$. ' mJfl-*~.JJu~. ' 1t:a"J~.~~~M~~t:tJiJf. ••a~-.,.mraffln~.~~~ftJ?~~~®mili. *1E~mMt1~~AB"J1t:~m.~fjJ. , fm1P~flI,J § a"JJl.~~Jfl~ ? ~.a±ltffif'.%f$iliI. ft.~*'~.Ift*,~.~~~.~*~mA,~.afflffi.~~A.~~~. a"J.iV ' r3l::fi A~;ffHtfm$ftW~.~~.~~H;J]a~H~. 0. ~.*~ •• W.~M.%OOfll,J.*,~~ •• ~~'~'.=.,~~.~ ~. , *HhJi* '. rn~.~jtl. ' jIltHhJ. ' 1r.HW,flI,J~lr¥J ' mjtHhJ.~~. 0. ~1f1iJf5C:. ' lit. m.~~~~m~'W~MaJffg-AliO~~*~AA.m.~~.~Wmfll,J.~. ( 4). Jean Grossholtz, Politics in the Philippines. Boston: Little, Brown and Co, 1964, Concluding chapter..

(5) A. +}\ 1:F=.Ji. o (5)'£. ~.t-J~.:EiI&7€l(f.J:ff! uo~~-ljit~~.~1?IJ. ffi'f- J1R B!; *=jl~j~t@: ~ ~. *. 83. il! M ' fLli * %j:t $ ~ ~ 1f< ~~ Y fdl1Sz {± ~$I¥J 1j:. ~fi$o~~fr~Aamam%.,~a~~.~~ • •. mpll2J.5t-$¥UJ! ~~a~ft.'[;5I~.*ama*,~aA.~oW~a.~ • • ~~~.~1Jh. 1r9l2J.~@J*. [;5IA~HJ8"J-1JJl~,I,±W~~. 0. ( patron and. mm' •• ffi'f~mM~~ clients). .~5t.~m~*~'.~B~.*~.~.m~~MM~.h~~*o .*~M. •••. ~~~~~~'~~.m~~~. •• ~.~*~h. ,~W~. ±~.M.5~~.~~,m~.~*~ToN*'~~~~*~.~~B~ill~. , ffil£~Y~Bp , 11E1r9IiX:1f<ffl~~~8'9.* ' IiX:;flJffl~~~11lJ*'fI¥JI\$!f ' ~.~. ~-H*'fh. ~W~~,~~*~.~~a~~~'mmffi~~~~~A~.o. f1!!1r9IiX:~f~~AJi*f~~~~~1J' IiX:§BI:f1*ft~' --67~rfIJtJ8~~~~. ~.~.m.ft~. •• ~~'~~M~~*.*.~~~ lJIjfkJ!~MIHH*. A ' ~$jG~bt.* Jj~Rl2JMf!~. ,. '. 1~~A~~.ffi'frl$*=J&\'m. ~JEAiij-. 0. -f.j9:I'l"J'fffm'. majority group ) 8'9~.A~:ll\rtIf~bttt:f~,t~. '. ~~~~tjfiH!Ibt~'t~I2J.~J&~~ ±2fJIiX:$~btff. ,. (. [;5Il.'¥;d»~~fit~~~1lf;. ,. dominant or 1E~n5l'id~. .~N(~~ • • ff~* • • ~).y.btff~~~&*~JE~~M-*'IiX:£~ ~.btffAn~.~~~~'~Y.btDI¥J.~A~.m~m~~~o. • • ffi'fEJT1ffl&~~D~rj'[ , ~ffi'f11*~Pffi'fU1!~.rt1fll1if~ , ~ffi'f1~~IJ~j~1i:;tft f&;fIBIiX:~$fl1DiI~~&* AJ\fL~1iJ1 +=. a ' ~f.f§*Illi5]§t~~~~?Jf~l 1:.~.~~!tJfJ$1tf ' 2fJ[;5I~-1ml2J¥AA±8"Ja.~~1i~1!jJ!l*~HJ;fIJffi'f ' 171;m,~ *A~1IJHfR [6)-fL1i/\~~J!.1i*~ , -MI~$Pfrlf!.A (Sinhalese) A 89f!falt-Wrlf!.J!-F§~.' l2J*~~*±{t~~'I~AM*' ."~3i1~*HJ' z:1i$ 0. -. 0. ,*If!.A~Y!k*li'A (Tamils) ~rJl'1l*:lB-jf.$Jllli8~{I~f!l!J~. (7]. ~.=~-W.An~'~T~~W5t~=~~tt~*'~.I¥J~.m~~' R~1J~~~~~*~M1i~~jUo=~*.1i'~ • • • ~~'~~MM• • ~ ~~'~~~.~~W*'fBA~*~A~~-~ • • ~OOoEJT$~~~~~Mm~ 89~tt'~.~~~.~ • • l¥Jffl~,tl*~B~~ili~~.~fi.~~oft~~. ~1i+.I2J.T~~I£~~~m~~~'**m~~~-~±~~ilil£~*'~~. ( 5. ( 6 ( 7. 1 ~ ,',!1, ~ , fl' ?~lHt!rji m05~ i¥'.I %nY; ~ Jl{~ tr ~ 0 g. ~ t ' ft~Jtit . -JUl {; 0 1 Tunku Abdul Rahman, May 13 Before and After. Kuala Lumpar: Utusan Melayu Press, 1969. 1 Huntington, op. cit. , p.4Sl..

(6) ,.. 84. ~@~t%3::u*s<Jm~'£~ • • N*.~o {13.~tEmltl!&iElJl~~!~jl* T. '. A~@l!&~~~A:&l{~OJ~1ll~¥z:j$~5fIJ7m :@{mlrp~JM!. 0. m:~. rt::ltrPffi:mVc~.. ' $~~j."'j."'*¥lY~J. ..~~~~~ , ll!J1fmr::ltrP~. ' 1it7j(Af6J5M;t1!LlIJtl~t'HIf~.J&Jt. ':@Vcm~~~~.'*~lrt.A~ o (8. 0. $Jt5~ltrP t% BjIiij~{tRs<Jfifffi. ~r~u[l]OJ*~m*~. '. .A'~~ft~. iX~irl{tR1~~. , -~¥~Il!IJE~{5t. rt.[I]~. mr$J. 0. "jE1~AAOJ § EE$1Jn~{$~'I1:t.il. ,~.*~o~*-~~.mA$OJ$M~A~~~ttti.,~ • •. .,~. I* ' Afl~*~ tEIJHt1tj@J~rp , 1$~'I1:#J:i.~*ttt~~~ , At%~JJ.~~ltf $Ij ~ ~ ~f* ~ ~~~'11: III 1m {13.~ t% 3::~.~5'rJIB~:@@'tRi~ ~ s<J 1$~ U -~lfi~ , [ZSI~ t;1r5fF~t~JE{~~AB~ I ;flfJfflp J ,tttt ttJ:JHt1t~ti.£1Jn:ff ~ ~J** t%r~*~UJ:i. ' ~ru~* " '$~~{~~AjJtf§*l&~Jt. ",f$. 0. 0. '. 0. ~o. l.ftJ(~~)A • • *~s<J~~,.§~.~~~ttWffi. ilit¥J I f:il1ft J '*Il~l!&lit, mtB~r'iijs<J{,*~A ' 1±ttOJbI,tEtt!!.1J~*rp"",""=· JIB ~.irl-m:&ltt~s<JU*fffiJJJt£~A:&la#~B~l!&¥fj~fi. ' ~~~1iJfJtl!&ltft~* ?f ft€i *4 mlk s<J PI3 0. 0. tE~.M~'~~~Am~~~~'~~T~-~~U*~~'U*~~ 1f~[lfi1J~. ? ~.$.OJfM~~A1~$U. '. ~[l~[{f.A±fQ~A. '. {13.MIDt~.1Ir. m*U.M.s<J.*~~'~~OJ~¥M~°tEm~1t~M'~1Ir~~ tt!!.3::~t.&. ~s<J' ¥ftR1r5;iBli@i~~:iifTJt~~~ift~ ±JIB~~. , bti!3CiliIE. ~lfi~~.3::~~~mA:iiA~*'OJ~~3::~t.&*~m~~'~~~~§. ( 8) ( 9). t3'~~, 'PIIII'!f¥li ' - JLJLA:¥+Yl Huntington. op. cit., p.388.. +rm ". El. 0. 0. (9. s<J~.

(7) ~.ti~~~ffl~.m.w-~a.~.A~. A+Al¥=}j £.1i~. ( mediocre). 85. zjf1 , ~~IY&l~((fil~:i~Hj¥J;A~j(-f-t/G~Il-f-t. f:E~i=$~~. 0. ~~IY&l*,~~~ft~~~~~,~~~~ft~*-ftm¥J;A'/G~~~~mmM. ~~~**.~~'~ •• ~*±~A~~~*~~#A~m*ft. '.~f:E~.. 0f:E~~'/G.~. ~.~'/G.~f:E*~~f:Effl~~'~.~~+*~~. "*tk Et~iL¥!~ ~. Et~trtH!~'(W]~~m~-~~ltxt~Bf,rlW±~iMlIA~ff~il3fJ. ,. ~.'~-~~°f:E~.m'mm~h.W~.~Am~~m~*'~~~~*m o~-.~.±gm~~.A,m~.~mm.o. ~~~~.mm.~*j('flmM~*./G*~~ •• o~.~-~*m~* m~~.ft,~~tt.R*~fi••. ~~~~ft~x*~~*.oiMlI.~*~fl. a~.*~/G~'~~.~£~~~'~~~~~~'/G~0~~~~. iMlI.~~. ~~~ftm.~~~'~~m.~~*~*m~~ff~Mm~~~.~~mo .~.M•• A.~~'m~~m~~'.~R~ili*~.ill~~.~o 3e~'1'fU (Lucian. W. Pye). 16,Jjmmtf,:JJU rJ.~1t '. If,'gA. IY&lAf$.L1E1Ih~mtf,Jtf.\fi:fE-j!g,. kSIrm&~-fl1'iA. hypocracy ) ~~jis)(1t. 0. I tfMis J. (1o~Il*~1r~f4i~.rHE. ~~~~lf:t~~A"J~jis~5~~Af,Ufli~m~. 1L ' ~w~~. ( populism ). (virtuocracy). 1Ih. ffA* rPJ~{~ (. I ~fiWB~ J ~ r::l9JX-mfrr:fE~ & '. -"Krm B. ~. 0. ~*'±tlBU~.. ~~jisA"J-fl~m. ' iI<]~T7U [9A\'lli~MJ. :. H{~¥J;@]. ••• ~*± 1t~£J!mJSt~j/J , fflJ¥f,*1**~hM:HmA<]¥~ '~Il+1t;tltfo.e*Jtf~ .~.~~*~~~. ~~m~ ;ffW~ ••• R~~~~~' • •Am fi~.fio~ffim••• ~;tim~~~X*~m¥J;*A<]1Ih/G~~~'~~m~ .M~~fi$'~~ff~~&~~o~~~mA<]~~.~mJSt'm~.~~m~. ~~ru~;HE~*m~j~ ,tJ.WJ~¥Ureft¥:JSt'tff~~.. ¥UiJj}!rJj. (11J. Et~§-iLA-tif:-tJjfii!f~*M1~' ~OOLB!Jf:I~fr~I~. '~1r'~. 0. ' .TIt*r,E1*t:fEif!ris ~~~ ~~~.~~OO'ffW~~offi&:ftl?'-mm~~.~~~~ ••~§~ x , +t ~~11Jtl~A"J~t$~~ 'Jl;1faB;f§ ~~ (12l-iLiL-t A 51. J :W¥ljmx*mx~'tf!lA~~.~OO ,,~mzfdjl'l"J1l~/GWr:ftl?~Mtfij!g*. 2!s:~*"';*IID~;J!i! ~ J~ 'I~~ F:y~ J!tt /. 0. (10J. Lucian W. Pye, Asian Power and Politics. Cambridge:Harvard University Press, 1985,. p.22-23,72. (11). §:§.j]' i&~~J~ nm~,. (12J. I. , ~+-Jt!R tfFf¥~' I. 0. f1::1~. , ~a)] , -jLiLli ' ~-u , il1t~~±~J~ J f1::1t, rp~ 0. ~ff±#tiE{.IijJ~. '~iLjv\:::;~)\Ji li. 0. ±:W~~. J. 0. f1::1t ' rpW!iIF.fWi'. -jL1Lt:~1LJL:::S. ' -Jt!R. 0. S.

(8) 86 ~••. '*mN.*•• ~flh~~~~~~~.a~R~~~'~~§~A~. M:r*••~*~~m~m~~%Zli+$~.~*'.M~••~.$.*~ flh J ~Ojlt1E.~~EE1tJtlNmfB8'~*'fo.rJtflhW~~~~_~~t~;;7ffi~-~~ , ft1r9f~;HI:m ~~~~~~~~a~~.~ffl~To. _~$~~,§mM$.(AriM~e). ili~m~~~m~~~ttoM«~. .*~m.~N~*m.~,~~~~.~a~'N~~~MA~~.A~.~.. l\t{. ":=.711;A 4-J(~*~ ~~'~~~.~~711;~711;~,~ •• m~~*~R~~ •• om~*B~••• +711;A.~~~- ••k ••• fi~.'m~.M1E.~A~~3.~**~~OO 0. §mM$.ft~A"J~*~;ffl-Hil.A"J/J\#itr.IS. , ~lItt'l1fYJt T '. A"J;;$::>J. 'tll~~~1f-f«'L<fltB'j"J. '. 0~J/t{H~~. 0. § ~~:1J1l~1I1t~Jl~Jt~~1f-f«'tff~.if. 0. ~~~A*~'m~A~~~.B*~.~'§£M$.~~~N~*••~ 3~m~o~~~~~*~*J(~To;ffl-M~~~.*~~~~.~A~ili*~' ~~frMN.m.A~~~~ •• ~~~.A~~N~~om~*~ •• 8~~m '@~4-J(§$~~'~M~B.~~~flm~'ffl~~~.~o m~~~~,ft~~~~N~. •• ~T'®~ft~~~~••m.~~~;;$:w. ,m~oo~.~~~m~~ftOO~m~~~~~z,m.ft~~~*. , /t~~Jj~fEA~~~aA"JJtt:i£:. 0. ~~O~~1ltl~. ~~~~. ( Joseph Schumpeter ) m~~A"J ' •. ~H~-ml\t{~~~'-m~N~~,.~~am.~~A±.mB~flh~~~. '11: ( legitimacy). 0. (13lff£Atr*±~~:f!fl.J(fijr~tl',~,. ... ( myth ) 1'1!jt.¥iT~~1t ffl. 0. ~l\t{~~m.~~jt.~~~~,m*~-mMmo~J(*m~~*~-~~~±. ; fm.nX;~8"Jl\t{~*~-~~~'fl~~Z± ' ~*.ffm~~~J1!~®~~JL'h. 0. •• ~ ••mM~N'®-.~~m~~~ti,~~~~§ft~~*~M'~ •••m N$N~1iIJ ' llif!nl~*~~8"J~~iij~:J§1tJjfB~~8"J ' ~~;;$:H~-m{EX*n~T .~~~~~~m~~. ffi~~.l\t{~N~'-. ~.~.~~OO~~. 0. ( 13). Joseph Schumpeter, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy. London: Allen and Unwin,. 1976, p.284-285..

(9)