幼兒園園長領導之個案研究

全文

(1)F~:v:i&7Etk~ r ~-~n.fil{,'~.jjff~ J. 2004 ~ 9. J=I • 27 ~ 3 ~,. 429-456. tJJ~JllJI.fI.zfl.if~. ~1! ~ *. f~ 1t~**. ti. ~. *~~~mfitt~~~~·~~-oo.~~ ~) t(tA~!m~~tm{i1J• • • PJT. " ~HfllilpJTt¥Jfl~. •• o§~~ • • W.~(~ 0. ~#~HIT-1f:*t¥J~ra~fl. • 1Vf~. ~~~~"~W~~"X#~~~~~B~~~~I~~~'M~~m~~~~~ $~~~·~mr~mJ~~~~~r~~W~~J~. ••~~.~~~·~a~. ~ffir~~~Iil •• J~~n'.~~ffi• •~~§~M~o~m~~~~~~~. ~*~. ·. tI!~Jj~t§r~~w.a~~. ; fJH~~W!f~w"** " .~~J&~.tt. WJfrjlm~~~~A$ff~~!.!m~~. ~D : r~1i. · ~iIi~J1U.L-~~~W~~~~1!i. " mI~*~M~fI~nPJ&MIAAm~fi J. 0. 0. ~iIi. rg~~~. ~x1[Jj.~flJ.~~~j.. 0. !it. ~,~~~*t¥JmmID• •~&~~~Ifl.~ffiff~~x.'~~~mI.~e. c~lJ~~tlE. Mlm~. 0. : f·Ji.liJf)L " fIl-k4AtJ" WJ5t.OO. • .gA:a~*.M~ • • ~~M~~~. •• ~1t~: a~it*.M~ • • ~~M.4t. .ft~: *"x.~&aa~A (2002)0 M5l.lIllllft.:t.1m~~~. 0. a~it*.M~ • • ~~M"Ii±. 91 1t=-J.iD?U+"'-'Ji±_x.~ (91DFA0200003) *~M.-t. Jt M~~:t. . . . ;t ~ , llll:.*-ltt!. raJ 6ft! .*"~~ft it-f~!IJ *rJ.a~~jJJi\. _x.. 0. ~x..1t3.,ff. 0. 0. ~:t..-.Al~~~M~M_~:t. • •. o. 1: -=ffltf-t:- : ebe@ksts.seed.net.tw 1!t14'- aM: 2003.1.25 ;. ,.~. aM: 2003.9.12;. .-t. aM:. 2004.2.27.

(2) 430. Journal of Education & Psychology. September. 2004. Vol. 27 No.3, pp. 429-456. The Case Study of Director's Leadership in the Kindergarten Hui-Chen Su* Chu-Ying Chien **. Abstract. This study qualitative researches to explore a director's leadership in the kindergarten. The aim is to understand how director Mrs. Lee (faint name) led the kindergarten from the date she went in. Also how she sculptures the image of the kindergarten. Within one and half years the researcher interviewed, observed, filed and took note to collect all the data. Then used grounded theory to analysis and find she clearly used "assessment" as the dividing line in her leadership of curriculum and teaching. Internal and external inferences were likes: "assessment, director's experiences and abilities, also individual personality" will cross interferences with Mrs. Lee's leadership.. Keywords: qualitative research, the leadership of directors, kindergarten. • Hui-Chen Su: Graduate Student, Institute of Early Childhood Education, National ChengChi University .. Chu-Ymg Chien: Professor. Institute of Early Childhood Education, National ChengChi University E-mail: ebe@ksts.seed.net.tw Manuscript received: 2003.1.25; Revised: 2003.9.12; Accepted: 2004.2.27.

(3) WJ 5{.!II!II -k~ ,"~1Il ~bff1L 431. M~~. ft~Ma. 0. *1tJf~~!j. YJJ~~~~t)J!~EI"llBIi.1J}. -'~~i1Jt!. , 1tJf~~{l\. tj::r iE:ij5}fjgt£YJJ~fJ~}~EI"l.~ffl~~tlJJ!. t:£ ~ JE ~ R Rflr Z f§!H1 mJE f~3t (ffl~5!YJJ5G!iI!ilR ' ~W!t~C*JE& ~}tHJJfW ' ~H2-14f~) .Z ' ~t!j~ R-~ , Mz1i1flt:ftgW~9mtm;fO~f41¥J ~~m~,~~~*o~~!ilR-~'. pJTrmW!¥.]I f'f1w~;fDpJTmEl"ltm:1JmfaJ ? lltm5 [~*UJf~lJJmtz 1£~?&mt1f-r ' *3t{'f~z0. (~~~)~~~ffUJf~®~W~A* utf~tIi-fujz. , *3C Blj , 1999). , W~~~1L!JJtj::r1~~D!iI~¥U. ff~~=~EI"l~OO'~~§OOEl"l.~~ m*utf~!j~flj!ilRI¥J1M~][WW~l1~. ~ffi.*EI"l~~o.ffi~.~!j.~~ ffOO1&EI"lmillt~ r Jmffflj!il~*. ' ::f?&. ~1fmJtJ' r.R~1.i* ,~~e*~1£. ~T(YJJ5G~)T'.~R*~'~@. ~ EE~jJL~Mtttt"m.JE J ~utf~~W.R~¥UJl!JOO. 0. '. ~ ~Wz~f§Uf3t.~I{'f;fO~~utf~~. ~~;fO~~~~,~~~1tJf~EI"l~*J! fjg~ffl~Jf~If'fJ:.. ~~5 [~*utf~. EI"lm-lJJmt o. =, ~ ~r~~a t)R~ra'EI"lgJ&~m~j{. , 1£~®. $~-r*~~R~~A-OO!ilffi¥~EI"l ~~tj::r. , tlDfilJ~~YJJ§G!iI ?. :At ~ l (~~a~f * ~o. ~~(Jf1f~MJi!1if.. - , ~DfpJ~m~Jf~fi~Wii A.~pffi1J~~. 1£1£5 I. ~~utf~~. '. utf~~z- (~~~) ~2001~2. *~. R®m~~~~(~ff~!iI~~.~Z. EE~OOm~'A~$~EI"l~1L~fflW~. ~W)®~EI"l~~'~A~~o±~I. ~fJt~pff11imEl"lil~. ?. f'fm~~zfi~*cj!~' ~:1Jf§~Rf4. m[7g YJJ~~~ [7g f§ tDl ~ ~ z 1tJf~. Z~~'~~W~:1Jz~~~o@-~. ~r~tt!!t~Uf~m~R~tlDfilJ1M~][~pJT. ::f ~. (IJ~dl~fW(. '. , 1987 ; W~ft- ' 1987 ;. r%J±fm ' 1996 ; ~tI~ , 1997 ; ~tI &fJ ' 2000 ; Ji*~ 1997 ; ~~~ , 1989 ; JilW~ , 1991 ; M~~ , 2000 ;. ,. I. ~ra'W~ff®~EI"l%3~. OO~EI"l.~~?&W • • o-~~~~6. R®':1J~!ilR~~m~~;fO~R~utf ~W~. , i7fJ~fi*utf~. rn.~J; 'f!j, , ~~~1;j-#1i-~4 ' -titJ!.t¥-!w .#1tt-~.~ Jt (2002). •• ~~ffl~±.~o. ~~o.~*.WJ~. , ~utf~~;fD~. 0. 0. WJ~OO 00 -&~4~ ~-oo ~.

(4) 432. ~1f~ •.:.:JJ."1f1f:. 27f.3AA. (.::.)1aI JXr ~A"~Ji.. ='Wfn!!j;Jj. m.~~ ~ fI-rYJJ)l~ (1t~. ~~~m~~)~m~~~*~Z~~. (-) ~1e.f;j3t-~IJIaJ* (it.. YJJ)l~om~=+~1f:w*~~~,~. .:g)~1Bi.. 1EA~Z~m(~~,±tt~::f~m). flJ~~1Em-~Mff¥i~tfJ¥ilW. *~.fF -1f:. '. &~~Itl:W1f::f~lI!!zm. lftf&JIff3:-*YJJ)l~~. , 1E~~~m~*. ,. Jj :tkJ3:~~ §mI. ~t.J'ti1tff~~. 0. 0. 0. ~1996!Cf.8. (2001!Cf.9 Jj m). -~~1f:~~lli+li1f:~'W~~~YJJ. ®A$m.mAw¥ifi(~~$mm. WM*~. TI-T8) ,. , ~20011f:6Jj~~W~YJJ¥i. *~~~~~,~~~±~wo~~~. ~Ol0614). (X{!f:Ol0227). 0. ~1996!Cf.kJ3:~~~4'" ~jltzD!lJ1. ~'~~~~~$~~.~~o~$m 0. -UrIS I '. I:tt&-B=+{lUJ\f1Jt~:. m§a~Mtt~m'~~®A'fFk~ ~A~~$WmkiID:*J!V~. ,. ' J'tA$. 0. = ' Wfn1J)!~'iJ:j;. (WJ~~. 0. (-).f4X~1r*. lQJ~flJ~~~~tt-ri:ttJ!*~I. l.~$:~*~~±J!1J$o. I~J!ft-~tfJ~OO~~ofF-~~~ $Z~, ~~::f~rft~~~1L '~fmfi~. ~~~~~~~±'~~~~~~~lli. i:tt~J!*~I. ¥i~~Io. 0. (. xftf:Ol0227). 1996 if: 8. 1997 if:. 0. 1998. I. I ~!== I I flj!]i I i. til til ;. I~~I. 1 II!. ill ' i~~'. ,M~ ffii I I~wl ,2 _I JjJfft. i~. I ¥tl. r-.. f:t r-.. 1". m,-". ;. '-". I. I ,. if:. 1999 if:. 2000. ril. ~ Iffii !. m iii. 1=1. i9. Ii!. L!J. '~I. 2001. ~I~I. I. I {ft ''fiti. lIJ. 1111. ~~. 2002 if: 2 Jj. 1996-20021FZ.A.!Jftlbll1.

(5) ~. ~ ~. ~. ~. ~ m1. _. .... ,. Imti~-Nr<. ~.W~2. ~IiP'~~. ~I=I<!-N.tr .~~ • •. o. ".""IBI." .............""...;jt.a,,',,'.,,....""....." .." ... ~. .ti.~~~. ..........,,',,"". ~"" ~ i""~.. v ......."".. ll!I:f........... {E. 0. I!mIl.:"..................... T. ~C~. .~lI"".:v. t............... ..." ~ ---tE:::l........."....."....-r ..............".""......'\.. . . .".. . . .".. . .".. . . . . . . . . . . ".. . . . . . .".. ".. """ . . . .".. . . . . ,,",,"""."".. .. . - ; ".... ffit. ~. •. ,. -<;!g. 1ffi1l". N. II.

(6) 434. 4't 1f 1l-'~ J.!1iJt 1f; 27 4 3 jIJJ. ( ~~pg~l¥]iIDrtil~~rB~Z~~ ) (=: )Jifll¥] !«IJ.~7ttfT. ffl tJW- j£Jifl cp Pff~ij!z~~&. 0. JtJlJtt~iIDrtill¥]·7t~~m. 0. (l)ffI~{t (conceptu3.Iizing). *Uff~~~Strauss~Corbin~mIJ.. nTi-ij. mUff~ifftEJi~H~~~tBm~l¥]$. ~Uff~h$Z7t~wm~~fi~fll¥]7t. ~o.fll¥]~~~7t~~m~~*~~. " 1TIJJ/B]!JJ~OO~I¥]~{I. U7tm~OO~R'{B~@W~~-@~. ( " ~WfE~.. , 2001 ' WI07) nTi-ij I¥] Ffl]~~trgg~1JUff~1¥]nJjU~ffltj[ ( ). JtEl¥]~m ' ~RrB'ili~#*@II¥]ffl.~. 0. l.ml~*i~. ~ 1 ().i.~ : ni5l!pq~MH1B?t!H.Il~1t$~. JI·,'.o.. .... ·'7". (~~!Ht~Jt)'. 0. 0. ). : {tM~~I!i{j' ? : :U~Uttf}tJL,gt~#~::XlfLJ:·"···#~{'*~1r~~.filt~lt~ 11) , ~1*= B l¥]~rdJ-ThltJF~tB* '. 0. (1~Ji. : ~#- ... m·····. *65l!ftggtE!. ~ftg~m~~~~~~.~(.~~.~ftafr.)'~*(~~*Ji.). gt# -::x~~rr:mlfmlJJ. (lhh~fh) ~~Ml±JJJfftgmIfJ~IfF~~t§. ,. ~~*~R-.~~mN~(OOk~.:~~*~4)'PffU~fum~~ ~.(~ •• *~~fh)o~~~J:~~~mllt~lt~m~M.~-::X1¥] lt~lt~,. ,gt~~~~~Mm=±~~m~~. , ~gt~m#l:iJtrg (:fr ~~~ i;p*,). gt '. '*. ' ~¥U71!i45gtlm¥U715457tWT ( mfh J! k ftt' ) , ~gtlmtJ (5i i}iJ#,fi.ft. m.~) # Alm.L-:J.fl ~fim~ /J\~~~~mT ~gt. ~::X~71!i* {tMm~?. m• •. 0. (.~.Jt)'~~~~~~iIDl¥]~$m.~T'W.-"~OO~. .¥tlPB ( *ltm.~) , ~1r,gtlm{fJ\1r~~@A~m*.#~!¥J. (at.-F) , JI)~. ~~U~~R~~~~.~~l:iJu~m@(~*£~~~~~)'*65l!~. ~CP~(C~~fh).~*gtm~~M#mOOI:iJU~T(~k+t.:fr#.~)omff~.I¥]'ff.**E!~OO~(. *)gt~m(A~). i. L. - - ......# ... I. ~f}tiL' J. (. ~. . ~ -t~). mfl. ---~---------.----.-.---.-.,-~--.-~,. 0. _._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _. _ _ _i.

(7)

(8)

(9) tIJ JtIl1I11 -k{Jt ~~. ~1i1f1l:. 437. h£~~~~~~~~*~I'~~h l!-;tii7tt.~~. , ~{r'iJG-k*". J. ( ID1~II!~010723 ). OO~~W~*ffi~®~~z~'~~~ mzm~Fmtf1t®ID~I~. ®*~ 2000$9,F3 z ~!¥J~~1f~~ , -)( ~. flj ~ ~!1~~gffl ~ ~®~ ii~~F .. ~.~ r. ~J. CD~gmfr~~mE~~.~. JEME'-J~~7t!3l~.~~ii!¥J/~\. 1999$11,F3 ftl~®.~~¥}~i{?g. " fU~~WJmrm~i;t~~gi1Hitf~. *~EE~~~~M'ffif~.~EE~fi~. , ~~m~~ , !f"!jJjU~:tEIf'PIti~.. mE~M~~(mm~)-~®1f.o~. ~~ITt¥J:ttfwH. ". ~:fff~~gffiij~~hOO*~~:tEftl~3Cf5J. ~1tita-ff.g*fhtl~:Ii*'A~ ~ f~At. -:t. 0. ~ 1t:;i-. iJ!J *{~ ff.t A. ~. ~fJ!EI BE'-J=tij~. J~l. " flj~~m~)fC&1fiID1 ' @E¥U~gmlE~f1t=f:::t:M• •zlW ·. i!&~:ff-~~ff!M/~~M®". :Ii *~o (~~111 *010704) ~1=r~~mj}]~~ Jtt¥J~-}(*m. ~~ rtt'. '* it ~ If ' ~ ff.t;1f ~1Jf ~. ~~~~~-~'~~~~®h~~@. ~ "'rel!~ t(.Mtit~. -~~~~~®'~~~~~I~~.. 1f{~1t. ' ~~~"tJf~~. ffif~f¥ltE~~. ~.~1rl.. tin!'. 0. ~~~§!¥Jh~7JEE-}(*. #:~" ~§~~~~m~W~". ~*~IJEE~pJT*~Jt~fft- A -$:..... .. ~. '. ,. 11"] tt. {~~iif V~-!. ,. ~1.I;1t)f. .tr.J~it~~it~*. " (~alll *010426). ' III * : r ~JW ~. ®*~1f®~M 19981f.:tE fIj ~ ~:it; A ftl ~ Z:fJ] ,. (,'t11l.k~iJ!J!fLi§)J' ~. *~1fID~mfl1~~OO~M ,r V~ %r:t:. f: -rtf- fft if ' iif V~ 11 1.1; r ::k # 1t tr.J :f j ( t-1l.~010710). Cifi ~ ~ ~ .••••• J-A %r ~ f- ~ ~1.;1f -ff. $.ta. ~. T3:t:~faJ 111 *tt. :;i--;;fi... 0. fj£-@~~mlJJcp'~Iti~I~. R~~~W~~®~~'~~ili~~~. -ff.A~fh~'~~~~.'M;1fM~.. *ta.r..1:R!~ it~Wf.m:~-ff.$fl " ~~~011116). " {S ' 1I!~t!IJ$?:tY~~. gffi~mE~~.~-~. o. J (. , m)fCfti]~gffl~7G. T3 : r ~ »1 A.. tt tr.J ~ tt 't l' it iif V~. **®:fff~mfilJ ' U[¥tltt20001f.lmmh. -k!!tMftJ r y ,. ~~.II!~~~-~~'~.~OOEE~. ~tr.J.$iti!#'. '. 1e i: !lU!:tl ~ , ~ f; ~ l!~l!:tl tr.J. # t•...... ~ iif V~ -k:;i- fll jJlJ A.. J ~4t .. Jl-J-010716). (3);J¥mtfi®IDn.. (~. ~oo~~m®*~~*~~~~~~~. " ~~~iif~!¥JID~. r ff.tit.~~:;i. ~;t}f.llLt ~*1Lfh ... ... ~*":t: Cifi;jf ~ 't-mitr.J~h. 0. J (iW~~~011116).

(10) 438. tt 19 ~'~J£liJf1E. 27 ~ 3 J,ij. 010710 ). 20011f3 J=j ~ID~W1±lWlJ7(rp , T7. ®~gffiUKr;RW~~m*N. ~w~re@~*~~~7('~~-*W. ~ T7 ~ fliP. Y!. J '. :. r. a ~ ~ .R. k. ~'1. "* r. ~ WUK ffj mrp ~f* Jl~l ~. w~~m Z*N. '. rs' jf.lJjr;R. ~i~J!u~¥tt{:f~am. 1::Etl; I¥J 1M fff ~ • ~~:Mz::f ~lt~. l¥J:fEJfgo fS! T7:t3 gffi . T8:t3 OOHt!!1M Z iW ~ iii! 1Mrp~~*W;ffl , ~~~1iro'~ ,. , iJf~~JtUJ~mflr*J~fjZ- J1t. ~~~~1M~o~gt~m~~:~~. 2.~.-~JE:g~5j-I¥JJJ!Hi~. iJf~. !T~.~. gt~¥ijI~~ffi±~l¥Jh~JI. , T8 : r 111 f<.1It!!. !J!- .f. ~ .. i\.fA III f<. $ ! J (UfF~~fL~c020325). '. 0. , {fJ\'fr,41!i295j-¥f@I* ' ~~1!i305j TF)fr. ~ftt!:fM::f~ ~ ~/J \§f.j:R21!i*. jf. , if1~mflJliI~-wIAW~F'1$ItJI¥JW6 IPJ ' ~Z51~t1J51fl* ' ~F~1$ItJ~~. ~. xfOCmlilFJTI¥J53-~fjpq~o. re*gt~~~@I*oFJT~~~~~1rJ~. #thk~ ~a*-. '. ~~. rHe1rJ1£. tfi fh $(.# th a!J ~f~ Hi t1 a!J .t.1£:Y.tJEt a ~ 1:JJ.fl. Mj ..... . 1t'!.1rJ a!J ft J.t $: a -1f 'f -1f 'f a!J riiJ tQ ~ III -k. *. 0. (. 010723 ). 0. JtfJi~{~\. 0. (WJ~~~010710 ). ®~~1*(~Jf);tJ\rsr.'mWJ~ .~T.L-Y-ffj~W• •12:~. fU ~ ~- TI[Mt12: am I¥J~ )~, Z -. ~. r ~~{fJ\12:~I¥J5[~~if1~5[ti~ J '. 3.mWJW5[~~te. ~W~~1±.~~~*~~~A12:~M. (1)¥00. ~;Wlil~1±&liIr*J'-~~~T~~. Trm~fI~.~J~amWJ~~ffi~. ~;tJ\rsr.'if1~±ItJ~~~TI¥J~rsr.,~. ¥iW~tel¥J~~tl····· .. ~WI¥J~~::f3&rrlTo. C!)~~n~ItJ······. ...... .R. .f.-f,t* J:.Ar 1£fiif 't .f. a. ~-@]~OOi±ltJffte~~~T~. ag Jd?1.i ' 1m ~ , -f,t 't .f. a l!.£--f,t :Y.t a~ al!.£- ..· .. ·@Atlt-r;k+1t. ' it *-~.&.t~ , f~.f.1lUagi1!fj- , i1.~. ~&jf.~~I¥J~.(~M)'-~~~ I¥J~W~rp1±jH7}1'f:~.. '. fI~JLNP5[. ti~fm~W:ZP: 1¥; ~{ii~F~ [J I¥JI 1f..a1rJ~k~f'llt{l~ i'fi th. {'f:. 0. ;k+~ a!J. ' :t ~ 't .f. ;k .. -ti A1£...-it.I... t'F ' a III f<. _ -t ~.f. ~ 1:'- .tA~ .. tt A '. ;kr, 0. i1.A.~ a~.f.'£-. i" M:-1t'!.1rJ ~Jl;k a!J i.. t~. 0. '. a~. (tQ 1! 111 f<.. itd~:Y.t ~ M:- a. ' a iif .t:J. •. 1~. 0. ~ ,It. ~~. ~a:fj'£-(.m1I11f<.M~:r)~. flJ '. a~t5t-f,t;t.£-..I:..1l. ' lta*-lt. J.t'sX.kt5t1t'!.1rJ1£.*Ia.~l!fj-'-w... k It -r :fj *- J:..Jiii,6Jf ,. ~ 4;0 l!It. -r bk. ~'a~.1t'!.J.lJ.t'-iJtlllt-rl!.

(11)

(12)

(13)

(14) 442. ~lf${.'~J.'fb1f~. 27;f§. 3 X1J. JfttJftt• •l¥Jliff~ , $1Il~fj~I¥JJ]{~~'M ~~~@m~fr~hrJfttJftt• • JI¥J~. ®f.l~~W~tB-~.~OOlfr ~¥:pql¥J~~pq~. fII~B&~illrflA~~¥:~~'. ~> 2002~5 f3 .~~fjl¥Jml!ifrM~. ffi~fUflI~JfE8IDflfiJl~-TI¥J~~. , It. .... , III-k >a~~:A~~4.~~ • • ft~~. ~OOlfr~¥:pgl¥J~~~l!if'F~f$P) tbbWl. ~~'A.~~~~~-~'~~~~. 1t-A8e..~~tt~~;fo~-r4-~. *--k ' JJl~~fI.~ A~~-~~1JI'. ~*~:a.~~re~~ifi~1iif'~~-r. ~OOllttn~~fQdl~~I¥J!Jf!fl". 0. ¥iWl!t~vs.¥i&l!t. fU~~tnLlt~~¥. Wi ~ }}Ij A I/t ' ~ it *- -Bt JJi4 ft i" ~+M~tt{,t~l/t*fff ' i"uri"1/t ~*f*@]-t- A i"tt : r ft!{,t-~ Jt. ~ffiJW~±I¥J.tf~OOlI¥J~. .~(~~£~.ft1f~.ft~J'IlZ.~. 2.tbbWl~l:fj. ~ .... i&1iif'~~-r. ~ (1)¥iWl¥Jl!t~. ~§~tn~tt. ,. '. tB'!OJ~fuffi~I¥J~W~tB° CDMfr-)i¥fitf~tB-fi~~. 0. *. 0. Jt.~) ~+Jlij~'. 1a.*f. 0. J. (~. ti III-Bt011211 ) @fuID*-*-~~~lUE-ID~. 00l1¥J~~ iWOOB~~fII~fr~ff$tiflI.~ I¥J~~~'~~~~~~-~mg~~ ~ijgJ!~mflIPffI¥J~~ rQ~~. 0 ... 1#'*--BttJ. -m *-t.t ~ -r~ -r4 Jj(. ijrfJ:.re~ -r. k .... i&. (.~.~~{1l020529 ). iWl¥Jl!t~. ~00l~~1¥J"~. , ~OOll¥JiWt*ID. , ~LItflJfII~It~OOl~~l¥Jfi~7J. ~~m/~,*~~&:\?&~{tt:. 0. fII-k : ······A~ft@].$.t~1~JJr5*. W-f~1GfflG~®f'F~ 2002~2,FJ ~~~7 -@~®f'F~. ---{t&-ftt:EUEf'F£ ~~i&l¥Jm-:?X~~~. W1r~I¥J:tr¥. , M';7~ ' tiI~fu~iG7 f&l¥Jf'F£. A1tt~~f-.:r.:t-t.'l!~t1S~~*. t':il~ +M. *- l! A *- ~ -JJr51#.l! 1m ~ -r (.tILlit. ~~1f.j , 1-t4~$.tre{,t~~fI..jf. :t-t.~~-r)tk..~.ff.tt*~~A. l!ffT -t-. fM~ ~-rre-e*}tt--T~A/l~ 1t;. 41iif'+NL~.k*-~*. '. ' 1if ~{,t~~i1Q ~$.t1fT *-ltt.J.l+Jlij ~ , t':il~~~ii.~ 1L l!p. f- • +t: ltt.J.l ' f'1f J-:{ ~ it Jf {,t ~ ~-r~~ ~ JJr5Jt R $.t'f'f~hJff. 011010 ). 0. ' ffiJ ~{,t~75th. (.~-M~~fI.. 0. (.~.fKj ~~f!.020309). flJ til ~h III I¥J ,1fJ E frtn~ III *-* ra~~tt~~*~~~'AOO-Bt~1if ~~~~'~~A~~1if~t.tth~fM'. f'1f J-:{ Atk..1tt 1 f-.:r.:t -t.. 0. J (Wj~. til ~.

(15) *. th Jl.1Il III it~ !f..t:.1Jl Z1f 1f: 443. k~jl}j,~~:Jt~T-*.ttfJ~'~. 020311) .. @r!iliIJlJUlI¥Jj!mtJ:ME ~{:E K;;.I fF-~~~~~~G~~I¥J1fW1U. 20024=1. ur~Wt*l¥J~f~'. l¥J1f-WlJftf!~~~'§'1!r~*. tfJk1&.i~*tfJ. ' l!.ft1rj () ~ -:Jt T3~ ~~$l.ft -.1e 't -t-31m -*.;*~. ' **~rn~. tfJ ~~M.~ ,. .ft~,"b J:.h" 1:. ~IWJ:Jt'fLf-~WJ:.l!*T(). rr~lIT~~~'~l%:m7~~~W. W.j}W1LIUl¥Jtl1tfDm:~m. l¥J~~±IUr!ili~~.T~~~~l¥J~. Pj15~w..MtlPffjj~l¥Jlf3H~. ~i-. ~~~~m~~l¥J~fj'r!ili~Pff**. 0. ffiJ !.Jft~~~- Aftl~*" ' a1rj ~ #J~AA. T ¥ -=-1m It fl5 ~ 8iJi T. 0. , flJl$l%:. mt~mMl¥J~$ ,w.FJi~1'F~mW~l¥J. ~ 1£ J:.. () ~* {t~a.f-.fIJ~~1rj , a~ ~ G 7\:.* 1M: ()' # T -t~ 8iJi tfJ It 1l ~ J,t. ...... ¥1ca~ : it 1m.jl}j~k.ft1rjllll 1e Jt It iA~ tfJ • jlij , Jt. ... .ft 1M l! ~. I~. ,fJf,.ft~mit:ft't"~~~-J,57\:.. *M-*-'I*.ttJUfJ*1~~1f#-. iJil.. ,. a~~jJ~r.AAtfJ~~a*-1i. ~ M~1: Itai$;-t-~.~k)k. ~ #t. tt ' Jt."f" a 1itt tfJ ~ *" ' ~ ~ 1rj -t!!.. .£-ttl.ft1l"1-t-fft_-*.m§:y~. ~-. :.t 1t.1=-i8. m ' 1J[ k 1e1rj i" -!- ~. ~~~ i~~31m,*~. 1t. a~1ttfJ*"~*"~k:tJ,5. lltl1t W ' 1e~~ m a~1ta" it~. 0. .r,!;ka-t-;Fa~~ ... (). , :t. (~~III-&. il'&*- ' 1tit;fl. ~it. tfJ M.~ , a-t. 0. SA ~ rfT l¥J mIU * ' Wf*IiFJil¥Jt5bWJ······ , :ME~$1&~ ~ ~ fil] Ii. 020311 ). (2HJf&tftW fr~ 1& I¥J tftW ' :f fQ] l¥J ~ tI l%: j! '['LJrU<n~~M~ilitftW7. z~ft~m~al¥JMiliti~ml¥J.WJW. fro. 0. CD.1t:m(~~m);fjfl-t5h WJi1~~~;fjfll¥.Jl&f~. ~. ~'~~~~I¥J~~,~~~~~;fjfl. tBW:**3f m~1L~PJ~l¥J ' flJtll%: t5hWJr! ~ *~~:f~1~l¥J;fjfl. 0. :.t ltt.1e -frl ~ fiiJ 11; -t- ~,tIt '1* " 1e1rj. , "*- T3 ~ 8iJi 1e1l"1 ~ 11; -t- -*.. itk. -tt#f.1e1l"1,t!i-=fsAttfJ. (~l%:*ili-~*~'~T~~~-®. "~cpl¥Jm~~1Tl¥J. ~. ,. tfJ. ~ , .ft ~~tl:£ fIJ " 1e1M JJ~U3- fIlM ~. -"m_~_. ,. ~TT15~-~Ij\**ti. ~-fm.l¥J!$LtM:fi~~ ). a : 1t f!l -&1M: *- -=f tfJ +*-;f&. k ?. '*". III -& : ;f&. -=f klltl a 1M *-.I.. tfJ ' a ~ fIJ .:t. .t:J. ,It ~ a. ~. 1M -t- A t. jifl. iJ! 1t-i'. it tfJ ft,~ , ~ -1t a 1M:. ttl *- tfJ ~ £. ~~1e;t. ,. a~it;t1ttfJft'~l£it. '.

(16)

(17)

(18)

(19)

(20)

(21) II.

(22) 450 tijf ~/~.J.!i1T1f:. 27. *. 3. JJJ. (l)tbbWJ~fmjW.~px~W~fll. t£::iF~J{l¥Jliff~~N. '. *~mmJJl¥J~~F. ~m{:J:!;~Mz~~1:EmD.~~N~. : r 00 ~:it1JJ a €fJ -. g. :Y.t it. a. ~~. ,. ( ij! E3 m~~ 2000). 0. ~m:ml¥J~m. J1tm:l;tl'~~:Mi~F (if1.::iFJ!!~). 0. (2)~~affi~~~~I¥JM'1!-fI -T~ I¥JT8~fmj~. ~A~~.~ft*~~~&~n~oJ. ~. .:r- :it In B9 ~ ~ ~ ~ . !ttn~. 0. ;;:;:;::'-'T:"'"",,". r :Y.tit.aJ:.;k.€fJ~~€fJt~~. a:Y.tk.~~'.k.-.OO~~.k. -t- rI ;t It ~ ~ J. 0. (IDOllOO5) P)frjllJ. .J'~Q~~WM~n;z*'~::iF. ~m~W3i:-~FlJf~mmJJm{7lJ. ~~affi~pxAffiJ~1~1j1. m~~~jf~W~wFIEn-HP~~1J. (3)~~. 0. B ittI¥JOO~ ; tt~l:lfflJj. ~W7t~~~pg~;~~I¥JW~W~. ~. FIEn. ~'3". ~m1&~U~-~M"~~. *~I¥J~WJ~~'. ~~~~(. 0. ~ ~11rJ1..A.. ~~ti~fi./~¥. m'~~~~~m~w~~w~~~~ 0. 1IJ~@i~. ~M~pfTl¥J~*" .L-~&~~~W~~I¥J. ; flJmp1H~ EEmmJJ~ra'Wrr<-r1:E. l¥J~tt. '. lIJ~iU'~~1:EmD.~1¥J 1J~{'F. ;Anl¥J~m;. m~px~~~~§~I¥J¥~;m~~m. 'P~~~~.~~). ~~ru~r~1$mJJ~NJocm:fljtil umJEI¥J~. I¥Jm~;~m~~~o~~~~~mJJl¥J ~~;~~~~~~~~~WI¥JWH~. ~pg~'~~W~1:EIIJ~~~l'm~ ,i[~i!fi:f:tH*~;t£fJJtfi~*~' -~~~I¥J~~~~mmJJW~~til~~. 9q]~!WZ~*o (4)~lfJ ' {)E~~lmt~Ira'W.~l:. I¥J~W'RmJJW~~o OO~>T3ft~. o til~~ : r {,t~ltiL ~ t!tjt 1t Jt Jl if ? 1; ~ A €fJ tit ~ , 1f 1.6:.tf; ~. : r *"~-f:..~€fJ~ a 'I: tf T3 ::t ~ -f-t 1M J}I 1J!1100 .~ *~4~if ' ~ iif J-A~:$-~~-fe.J}I. ~~*'iL~Jlif,a~~~m~ifo. ~~.1J!1100""". ~l'*~tn.~.~I¥J&.ru~~jf. *'. 0. (.=..). J. (OC020425). 1~tf.~ (c.r1tE.~) m1fi~. ~N/~~~~~~~l¥Jm~I. ~,~a,*,*~'a~T-1OOtIt~. til~~~~l:fj~~~~ru-~~~l:. *'" '. k -t- N:-8 Ji :I ~l J:. ~ €fJ ::t ~ ~ +J1IL~. 1ft €fJ ' iif J-A 11: 4- J6 " J-A JW €fJ 1; *". f'F ' {B~~~~1J~F~nre:-I¥J~~1f ;. A:Y.tk~~*~m.~_J6~!JIIJ~. tfH~~~~Fnre-I¥J~~. ~~~~~mmJJl¥Jm{:J:!;. 0. DeBevoise1~. , ~til~ rOOA. l:fj : r ft ~~JP'·~.t~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ T tt. ~. ~WJI¥J~.;~~~~l¥Jm~if1.Wtil. ft~€fJft*~~~*~€fJ*W~*'~. ~OOAI¥JA~~{*~~Wf§~ ,tlomff~. ~~~~k~k~.-fe.A'~~~-fe.~. ~m~~ra~~~~*~~ft~,a.

(23)

(24)

(25) *h ~ III 00 ft4J: ~~1m ~ -'If jL 453 :ff&;:~J5-%'~f1fwm:~. e. ~. <:;J. *. O. ~.)~. .,. ~:f~d~:~~If'f7t!CB9~{.\ ~. ••. !&J*ml'J:ff ~~~±~. . ~-:¥=fll. . ~ft:~ifJi\ffU~~gffifr'j. !I!*~fflG~grp~~m. ................................................................................................. ~. Mft:. ./J\~J~~Mzt*:ff{fjJ. O/J\*£l.fflG~ (ij~tH~7G). .................................................................................................. RtUI~~~Ifi. =t 4 i#*i~. ~;fJtIYJ"1f (1998,. :. A 229). 0. it ' ~~\~JHl"J~g I ;If 4 AJ!'1 tt,~ §l G ~ ik Jm.1£J (1i:~ tlD ~ ~ , 2002 ' Jf 0. 142) , ~7~~L8"JG5l~ m*@/f52~~~. *~§!~UfF~~1~Umm~8"J Ijftfj~. *. J. , ttJ58"Jtg.. wp£illm JJiJt1!t Kotter~te I J1i ~h {fJ l!i ~ ~ *.f.. Y 0. ;If -=..1m ~ jf. 0. : 1. ~t B#T 'iif Jl. 2.jftfj~*8"J tem. ~ , 3. ~. 1WrQ]~pg~{llm:~~~ (1:E~ij~~. 2002 ' Jf158). ~.~m~=~)8"JftWB~'~OOk. ~m. .to ~ $- 1t ~ 0. ' 2. {: ~ ~. J (£i:~. tlo ~ ~ ,. fftj[fiil$jft~~*z~. §g~.~tmftWJ~fta~~8"Jj£. r 1t Jt ? J T3ft§ffi ;t ~~f'J {fJ , il-t~?t. ~ r J. ~,~~*Z~m~.,/fm/fro,~. ~iliB"JgE~~~r~'~~~7 flJ=~~Ff~Ji~. § 8"J7t~~1~jftfj~*8"Jpq~~/f~. B~~1fi:R1iE. mJ '. 3! *- J:J. ~t.~.?t. ~ 1¥J@]i§=. I. 0. 0. Kotter. :lF~~pJTijg~tt(;!!X~ffij*. 0. X ' wpliJJi. ~~rrr&fD~tjtg~&8"JW~ffX*/f. (1:E~2¥A8"J~:!J$. $~~O~~~~~~~T~~ft~~. Jt.iE{fJ{£-.'*~ Wi; .f-4tt. I8"J.tt,Mte~~~~8"J,m**~. ft~*~o~*a;lf~~{fJ~~,~ik. ~rr~,ili~~7ft~~I8"J~~~~. ~~,~~.4~{£-~I~{fJ~$~.. 'A.*.~OO~*'~kA6~~~. John P.. ~rj} -~~te. I. ~~~~.hoN~}.~~'~*;t. ~ill*-~~~-~~;If~~{fJ~~'~. {fJ7fM J (IT 010716) 8"JWJj]o. fD**IUI~:!J. ~~~.~A~*{fJ~~ff~o~*~. 3.Jjt~·8"J{$~Wrn{f~. -z iQ JiA ~ ~t~ , ftt} j\ .r.. ~ k. ffj=~1:EIDJ~ cp/flf:tlli~&. 3! {f 1k. .'ttk~A~.~*J(~~~~, 2002 '. J(15). 0. *~~~~3t~f[HifF~. *. J. =~. , ~j!:~Xft8"J I Jj[~. J. I jJ[ q& § !. ftW~~~,~~~ft~~~~m~~.

(26) 454. ~ 1" ~.~J.!Z1t1L. 27 ~ 3. AA. l. '. $~. 1tfhm*. , if-:f.46'~®I1'ff[j2t~? r. 1JIS a -t- ~t ~ -. ~ 1f} ~ •.••••. M*.~~I.'1JISa~~a. ... *. 8iji. ••_. , ~-Jt.~~~. l:l:.~ttM-*~. ~~n®~~~?~@~I~lli~*®. 0. l:1:.~tt".~1t~~. ~!1!~""" tA •. ll!l • ll!l iP $. 1JIS 100 (4l). ~~'~ka~ff~.~*~~,a.. j,' ······~$4 Ya~~. .~~~~'fi.~.~. ~.~ LOI07i6/011107). ~M.~. .~'a.~.~4~.'a~~~.. 4!t. (IiQ~. ffiffJJt* § flJtII~5lZ~.~Wfr~ ( ) ~Ja~fif®~5lZ ' iligt:ffdJlJ~. k.1}W;-tl ,~ kM- • • 1}fJJ tl' 19k~:f'l.'1J.ll:l:.~fJJl!* J" r~~. .~~tII~OOA®.~fil1Jr~a~~. l!k1}fJJ~~~'. .tf!1!~*.'~~.~.~~.'~. ~~#~~. ••• ~ ••• *~f-D~~~. fl$~m~~~~~'~~~o~Ak. m~. "f J:A .1~ qf 'f J& JJi 1~ ~ ~. ~ J. (W5~. ~.*o~~l!~tf~~.~~~~T. , fU~~tE. .fit-J9h,~-.1}.A~~~~M. tII~010227/010706). 0. 2t~zM'B~lli~{tk*~I1JJ1fiI1?VJa*w. r. "T®~fif~5lZ. r {Y:!~w~m~¥J. , r tifU J 0. mlt~ltilli r. "f It. ~.a1'rj~~M- J. 0. (W5~~~~I. 010716/020426 ) rMifI'llifj~5lZ®tBm,~:%(. 4l. ~ffl • • *~flA~.A.~~.~+. jj~®m~IDffiff~®9t:lr""". *-. 7?!. ~~f~~~~Ifr~$=a=®{l'ffm~. SJJ *-.1jiH~ JJi AA-ffl. ~ it-J - -/;JJ J. (. 0. J. iligfrm~~*li~nX;~ 11:. §ifjll~:ilHt r. ita. 1ttf ~.L ~. ~ *{tj; ,. (T6*~) ~11 (.fij~,ft) •. *. 1JIS1t. *~~tt4ttk • • "f~'ffln~.T. *~1!1it. 010225). 0. 0. B. ~r.~_.~~.R~~L*'~$. , 2002 ' ][92) r. J. ~J (W5~~~. {8ftg1*mm~nX;~lJJn®~. *-,ID~1t~~~~®rfiJ§n,~?. ~ 4!t • ~ J:IJ J (Ii:!) tlD. 109). ' 2002 '. 0. lff'iF~#"~f$Dti ~7( , titF~:lfz-IDflj~~~f;f. , m~:f:tH§df~~W~ : r. a1'rj~41f. •• ~it-Ja.~. tEfllrI ' titF~;g-~~~IE{Y:!*Ji~nX;~5ln~mn '. .1JIS.~*.'~k4. ~_~nX;fil1JlJJ~®~~~~~x~®. ~~~~A-*~J.l~~~lt.9hit-J~. r {~HfgrJ. 0. 1.~4~~~oo~~T~N.~It."fn. ~ •••••• J zPfitJ§dti~JinmlJfJf. '. ..=.,...,...., ....... a ~ ~ iii ~ It. -100 qf 'f ~ 'it m~. ~-~~.titF~;g-~.7. A, ~·t!!Alut;t~~ft~.*-~~. -~~~11~:m'~~~.m~~ft~~. ~Pfi.~~.

(27) *'. tJJ 5t.1Il1ll-lk ~ !J :~.:OO li:Jf ~ 455. ~~®r~~J. ~~.v"-7~N. ;. ,~®~~~~~. ~®3ZJk!~IiI~.1E:ff.. " B ~ ~:15 affitifF f~ lI:®t1( , ;~'f'S~~~ill*1E~.m!f[--.C · Jft tm~~m~w®. ,. ; ~~,E,lU~$~®. 0. ~~Jft~I!d~:tEIiI.~~. fttJ1l0. ~~x~ ::E~fB!{ (1987). .;Z. ~m~~-.~~®m---~~~~. ;. B-tlI.1iiJrtJ. ®Jft. 5t~?6ffi{.itBft~~liIflR~1tJ~. 0. t!D~di:ff. ®~t¥]Jft7t.-tlI.~~~~~:ff-.~~. B"J'I:l1?Z~ r. *. a Jlj ~ -!- JtlA.. -:t r 1tJf. '. R~rg~~7t:J£gGffl!!{(.J?J r'lhir~jNh , 1lJ~~~~~~t¥]~~J.t3Z.~. , m:fflHE ( ), Juliet. , *~~. ffi~fi~~~*:tEm~IiI~'m~~t¥] tE~affit¥]JL. ~~~'~~~~*IiI~~~m~IZ. -..·~.~~'M~t¥]~JL;IiI~~~~~ rf}t{E~)fDfArr:tJ ; ~IItf;fIltm~liIt¥]pJT ~®l~~~~·~'w~.~~m~I~E. , ~~. 0. fi~2!{~. ,. fftJJgrPJt¥]~$. ~1iI~ij~~.tg¥U~affit¥].*. :rEt;jij[{JEIfJ2!{~t¥]ftJ~~. 0. ~il. 0. :. ( 1997) .~tmfJ.!8f1lfll~!ifJ.!m 0. lI1~.ft~;ziJf~°3t~*~~~m. fUliffJt:fiJTUJl±mfU3t .!i~£z[]~. (. 0. ), John P. Kotter~ (2002). 0. ~. ?fAa9W¥5!f!IJ-i1@• • ~PXJj]a9 j\~.. 0. .~t:. £i;j)tt~ (1987). ~~iilifIjAjtI1'F)MlE&. 0. ;Jt*El1II ~ ~;z~~1-.~tmH;~pJT w.~itmfljliff~.PJTiii±~3t. m~~t¥]~~~~,,~~~.~~m*. 0. Corbin~. 0. 111. ,. Anselm Straussw. (2001) ilttiJf~JJ. ~AF.I : ~ftO'~iJf~JJ~ lI:03t{t. maJJHi~. ~'i'ilt. ~!¥ft1lEmfilJi£:~. i6lm*~¥!(~r5}f~PJll~l±. 0. o. ~~Ajt~~o~m3t~*~~y~. " (~~fL~C;011225). *xr;t~mt¥]l!~ili~. iJf ~. mfU3t. t']e. ~ -'- rPJ itB1EllU At¥]±itB--.C ~tFuHt ~. lI1~~.. '. JJit!i.~tmtJJ8111:i5BiliI 1"F)Mi/l'J. WJf:lJWr~~~Jt¥]~mJft. , tJ&~IIt~mJft7tfBl:l[1~®15:rt~. ~Bffipx~JLI1JM. 0. ' -tlI.~ , liI~lE~ El. '~~W:f1]m~OOm~IiIf!f~iliift¥]. (1998). 0. Neill Glass~. 0. ~:tn&. 0. :~.m~o. 0. ~±~ (1996). tJJ8f1llll~~.~it. 0. '. ~. ~ • • • "i1@.ft~ • • ~~omft. .~tWiflB~~m~~WliffJi:fiJTUJl±mfU. 3t ~q:3i~. o. ( 1997) " • • ~fJ.!8111[11~~?fm. nm"~~I 1'F);i/l;zmllJiJf~. 0. ~i6lmt~W.~lfEW~liff~nX: ~o. p. ( 2000) " IHlfJ.! ~lIIl11 ~~wmnm a<J1t!lW!l~. 0. rri6l~~f4*WJmliff. ~~t.NSC89-2413-H-134-005 -fi!#-=tt-~. (1997). ". tJJmll1l11~~.~itW~. 0. Biiii1@.jJdfi;ziJf~. 0. M*WiflB~~~. ~~Wliff~.PJT° -fi!#+5:!-~. (1991). 0. It a<J~fif iJf~ JJ 5!. 0.

(28) 456. ft" .'I:i'l!1iJf~ ~t. -i- 3 jfJJ. 27. :. f£-1II.~~. ~m¥f- (2001 ) () ~~~J5',. • rm~u~,~ Jt~*~~H!1:jl¥J~~~ Bi1i& ' 393 ' 0. 41-45. .f=W. (2001 ). 0. ~~I=P¥¥*!l*UL*!.m. fi:f~~ (2000). ~iit(It (2001). 0. .~i~~IIIt1lilbzM.. 0. ~~t. : ftmE. ~~~ (1989). 0. " PJT3t1tllUlliIbR'fRtz. •. ( 1999). 0. <>. ihftlll!ll~!j~. .=lfW'if!!=lf.~z!ftj:l:iJf~o. ~ i&Jff~. w,a 'J;miff ~ rrrm ~. ••. *. ~. o. 0. ihflll!tIl~~.W~~W~. ~I~~.zR~o. • •m~*~*. i&~WiF~PJT1ia±~::Co. M~H. ihftllllll~WH;5ePJT~~. : NSC89-2113-H-134-008-F22 fi:f~~. w•• -~ftmf£~~J!!mzJft. II. 0. 0. JiJf~o. ~~.Z~~o~~m~*~~w~ ~PJT~±~::Co. 1Il.1L.~tBiliIft¥IS1£¥. If ' 12 • 571-602J[ &~PJT.III. 0. 0. • IS.JIM (1999) fttihftrl1*WJ¥ lizM!Mt:ihfllllfffi1¥".z!! 0. "..,.,..,.'....... (2002). <>. ih5e!llIll~~~z1ll~iJf. ~oi&fEt*~fJJ5C.~ffUff~fflftIt±~. :)(0 Daft, R. L. (2001). Organization Theory and. Design. (7th ed). South-Western College..

(29)