資料庫裡找新聞:探討「資料庫輔助新聞報導」
18
0
0
全文
(2) A frHN p ~ r.t ~ ¥U El fflf H~f.t m , ff!. (7Bl±~$f3j(¥~) M~~}fJ.~~~*C~:1}~ ~m,[!f~~~~M~.~Elam~~ff~ • •. <~~15¥~r~r~~c~~i:l~VHT*~m~-~ljrm~. rm:~Z1*J. r~.~~J~~M~.·~~~~li+~~~.. 0. $'I~~m~-{l=~/J\fr::m::(E.~f!J! st1;1. lj[1Jf[1~.~*1~¥~fiU (CIA). i'tfF ' fUm ~~{~ ~tJ:l1§A ~. *1li1&~*$'[~~I¥Ji&$ (ff 1) ~z-~ CIA ~[!f~AJI'&~Affr$~,I¥J*fi~ , ~R Ji~fEI&~~ ~1&~~ , -{ft~.~JfrlljqJ~*i:l. 0. ~i.t~¥U~$11~:t~*.1iffi:£M~~' ~~f1X:If~IDl. 0. :1}OO$ , [ti]9t~fiU~*m1j:t1t~~~*c~~1tn~m. ~o§B~fr~fl:!~}fJm1j:tI¥J~f~*c~~A~:f41!J$Xn. 0. *a*~fJ! ' ::(E&t~0~~pJT~.W~. ,. ~f:W,,9' f~~o~fuli1f~~{I~;fj, ~~~*€l~a~. :l1§fT:frfff. ,*UPlJt, litiJtf!1IDlE~~:t;:tf3j(fTMI1'F~~A~ }fJ;filr*&~Rf!l!prr~jJffilli*1¥J CIA ~R ' ~9:~::(E -fI1.44MB ~litiJtt!' ~'fI/J\/J\~:f4f!l!m~7~. ~ff~%*~$mst~~·~::(Effiff8~st~~. Q. '~ff=5J'Z~;t[z*im~~f~~~. 0. fJ A.~!fS"J~ , ~~*im:i®~~~~~1t~&~ , flff 2%tc:tJ~'jJfJ1¥m ' Jt:E 98%~rhl9Jm1t~~. ~M~~~fF~~~.~·~~~~~Rf!l!tt~. M ' :illL{~mfiRf!l!i~:f¥fD:fr~~m, ::(E~.tJ&:E =fg§~.~ , 8*~fTZff~ tJ r ~~fI~f91J. ~~Xi::(E~m 9:" ~c~fu~fJ!;lft@;:.:ttB~~t~~mB-j. 2). f&¥}~Mt~Ha*~AttB@~m*Mt. 0. 0. tt$~lJU~ , ~~~~m~:f4~ttB~tJDtJ:fr~ , ~. 0. Information System, GIS) l\!X'\m '. Ji~A~:(&Jili/!~~li/!ffr~~$ ~.!foJru:B~ 0. (Geographic. 1tn~n1}ftjA~~. ffl~:t;W-~*.ff~.~~m.li/!~$I¥J.. ~®*JtHI!t=¥fD&:ttBl¥J:ttBlIl~m;f§*i515' IiiYG~:ti!. ~H' ~¥tl~1+1 <fSf3Jl~~M) ~~$.~H*C~~R. ~ro9~1tWI¥J:frffll'l~75to~C~J!fljm~}fJ~gp~Jf. f!l!f!J!ttlliJjj(~ ~c~m~:t;~~AtJ5rr1&~¥U8'~fi:f4ff. 8'91il:f4f!l! ' ~tifntBt:tllirhl9~1tWS"J~~1;~j.A ' .ill!. :l1§flA1tnfM~· ~@;:.~:f41gft: !al$.~AI¥J.~. 1;*9~~~IDIlJlIfQ *a*~fJ!:ET-~f~A~1iiff~:m1flll. , tf1J~@~:(&~$S"J*c~ , &:ttBADMt~tfi. ·~~~~l¥Jgn, <7Bl±~$~~»~. 0. .=~¥~.fJtJifJA{/.I¥J1tW~~r&l~. :f4 ' tJ&:ET-.~A~fIA~f4* §c~3Z.~&:ttB Y::im~@jJ{ftmzf~-f5.}1t§fM:fIi~ , J:1IDJljff~1&~ $~f4~.~H;gjJ , ;t[L§.m~@;:.~;jS~1&¥Ufif4f!l!~ @**-1t (DBMS ) f!J!f~Y::X:fr;fff ' ;t[zf.t:ET-7j~ A a. 0. m~~ff~AA:~~~$~¥~. '{fifN:PA .~[. mB*~ • • • I¥J~AA:~~m*~~.f!J!~7? (~.A~&tJ §c~m7~*I¥J.rCJ9 ,*+,~Fot~·q. ,::(E:i®:t;li~&~ '~~1'1'lff-~-T~;gJi~A. $ ~AA:~~8'~:t;[ti] !ilfE~§c~fJJ:Jf]I~¥U~iJH~jJi :f41iiYG ' 1989 ~::(E:i:~~J:~~$I¥J-~~tJ '. f&~1,@f&.li/! ' 1t~In~ffJi~A -~H¥HH ; {f!.~. ~~~mm.At.~.~'{fi~~~~~~.M. ~;itHT~f:j~, tJtIiJE1t,gfM~:f41¥J~~Z~ *a*~. 0. 0. Eb~~~1i'Ii~f$f!l,l:Y;ff¥,mWiJ 'f~1~~$~~HmtJ~ii r~9i- ' .~1,@i&.li/!fTm*fj~ff~~~. rB*~.~$l¥Jm~~,. ~p~::(E~m~. ? J ~~~c~[ti]~~~~~~~ (NTSB) ~~m. 0. j~Ji::(E¥~~ffiFf~ '~~11'lili~~jifTlLr~' I{f~t~W. 1985. ~1&~$.~H*c~. :f!nu~*~mAA:~~ ~ ( FAA ) S'~~iltiJ::.1EIftl~AA:~. 0. •. ~~.~~.'~TJ:~~A~m~J:r #. ~tJ*~PJTff~$~AA:~~S/JjiliU~¥~~. , f~. .~~~,~m~~®~.~Ag-fl.J:R~. •. f!l!' itf~~®~$jj)f~ff~PXi::(E.~&~ ME~i a. 2.
(3) Jl;f6+~f!I!tJ(;mM. : ~1M. r :In4j1J.ml!:!JmM~~~. J. 'fljm.H~.fl[!fIf'F~~~' ~tFf' ~!ig.:f.w.m. *li*fffJi. '1£ 90 ~tJ*~*~itl~~~ff!l~Ju~r ~. Jt$. $'~~~m*~mJ~~~~$,~y~~52. 1Vl"R~a9-¥p5t:' e*~.ft'(~*JTIVl~-;gflJ.~I f'FA±. ~Mt~1&i2i@]JlIit~0 BJIUt.~IHW ' g[\~oo-JlIit~~~. ~~¥Wa9~D~ r f~m"Rfl$tt*JTIVl J ' ~.H~M. ~1I*~~"Rflfil&~~ff~*JTM~J!t¥~25 ' ~JJ:~~. M~~JJ¥&~S'9~1i:l!~ -. 0. , m~~ r"Rfl}1fiMWJmlVl ¥& J' ~m~ r fl}1fi*JT ~ J (Database journalism) tt~liUjS'9"Rfl}1fiM!l)]mlVlft~ , ~z m-f;1]~m.J:flJ • • S'9.fl$~• • fl*71Jjt~ iTlVlft~-¥p5t: 1£~II~U~~~m~ f& ' ~lf::§7~[\:fft~. r@]J& J ~tHllttt~~flJl¥J~f§ , ~D1'§i..fJi.1£0J3<DN /Wo J;JJ: =flj::1IOO~f§[OJ~~: 1t:19C ' ~[\~~[I]~J[ ~B9"Rflm::f 7{~fliil~ , ~!l:t&\~Ji~:Jm*A:"Rfl ; gG~~:*l!~-aJIJlI3t (Machine-readable) S'9"Rf4 ; ®~~fuW~m • • • • ~m~m*A:.flB91. 0. 0. ~1£~J:~~"Rfl}1fi,®1jm"R~*~o~-:1J. lID ' tt~¥k:tlS'9. r"Rfl}1fiMWJ*JTlVlft25 J ' JliJ~m ~*JtlID~~n~:f'I{t~9Jmiml*A:"Rfl' ~ffJm.*4}1fi. ~°t1:fj~m.H~:f4t5iJ;J~J!l[*A:mM.flS'9If"F .~,~mMS'9r. • • MM~mft.J. ( Computer-assisted reporting, CAR) •. ~J!l[*'&t. ' j!fjtt!t:5HfT ' J,.:J,~mltfj*JTIVl¥&25~f;f. S'9-¥P5t:. ~:XRFf~S'9±~J;J1&~~±. 0. 0. f'l=mJii±~0J3<m~JJ:.~Jl~,' §[\~~-M~JlD1'~. , "Rfl$ (Database) ~m r -M*~ i&!*JiirS'9"Rfl' ~mPT~~~JES'9.~flJ*a~, ®. , ~m~D~~J!l[S'9~D~~ , J;JmrR:. PT~A~~~~·.fl}1fiS'9~:@PT~~:X~'.. mlVl~~.t111OOfl'~' ~i&!~1lS'9AjJflJ[IJ~I ll~HJU~S'9ffE~A~. , ~[I]f~ • J. mlVl.:tf'F$pJT~~S'9rCl'Jm °1£~[\~j!nmlVl¥~25S'9. (Williams,. 1998). ~*"R*4}1fiJ,.:J,. i&!l~~$ , ~mm!1.JIiID~~~JUl3l*JTIVl"Rf-tB~m~-¥. *JtlID:1J~~f¥' fJ!1£~lf::§7"Rf4$~IjJ;J.fft"Rfl;f:£?r~. t§t : ¥U[l]~fg (~~'• • *w~n. ' ~ffT*rernl"R. ~)jJ1£~H~fI ~[\~~1¥;~mS'9.fl~' *¥3J:~[g. ~ § ~ , ~[\~. m~~ ; V)\fm¥&m±.mf~S'9"Rfl$. fl ' fu~g[\~t*~JJft25S'9!lt~-¥p5t:. 0. 0. , ~S'9"R*4 , rm~"R*4$ , J;J&i&mf"Rfl}1fi (Friend, 1994). ~.~~mrmIVlA~J'fu~~~~r.RJ. ( Interviewing data ). 0. ftn~~S'9"Rfl}1fi71Jjt§¥MS'9mM"Rfl~o. 0. ::§7¥~m±W~~~"Rfl~ , f¥n)(JJTIVl~ft"Rfl' A~mtl!. ~[\:ffS'9ffJ~~~~mlVl"R~ '~lJ;iI~flJ*JT1$. 1960 $f-t*M '. m:f4t5{~f;1]f§1Ul 0 Wcj[[.~Rf4t5{S'9~~~- :1Jrnlm~. ~'mM~Jt, J;J&~~~~.. ymlVl~.S'9~$'~-:1Jrnlfu~~7~~Aff!~. ;fi-=f¥~m±.~~t:1j!fl'''R~~S'9.fft1t, D1'~"R*4~~. ItlS'9P'J:@. 0. ~H~"R*4$*A:ffl!mD1'IrmflJf4~:W. tEf$m~'.S'9~Ji~fu1j1~f§~B~j!~ ~iW¥~25 J. 0. f¥"RflS'9:1J$~*Jtrnl~iT"~¥U.,~~tI!~$. '. r .H~MflJJ. 0. il.fftft ' ~[\:ff pfJ;J~i&!¥~n"Rfl$$~~:§. mmriflfl3lm~¥~"R~ (~jffBti ' 2001 ) Jt;X~ g[\~ § ~S'9 "R~.[!fI ~~JJ¥-i JES'9Jij.*JR~. (Computer-assisted reporting, CAR). 0. 2001)· r .H~MM~m¥~25 J ~m : r ~[\~ffl!m.H~ ;fElIUlt5{fi1tJD1'~milH*~ , ~J!l[ , flJ.§ifJ!"Rfl ffl~~~l;IJij. , ~~1f~ , ~"R*4JJl~"RiUl£.~~ , .Uml 1~M~~' ,~trwN~"Rfl' ~fll~.~,*71Jjt , ~f'l=mIVl1\¥J~ti ' ~~ffT*JTMJJ:flj::!tI~ , ~~m~[\:ff f~1JDmlVl¥~25S'9~J!t ' , ~IEli1tH1S'9-¥p5t: J iI~¥UmlVl~'.m.ff~ (Garrison,. 0. ±JmS'9~[\:ff' PT~gOO-i&!1±fl3lmS'9:X.~"Rn1JoJ,.:J,11I ~~J!l[ , ftf¥D1'.~~:f'I{t~$. , f'Fm**mlVl~~~ ~zm: ~"R*4$8~-1I~~ • !l:tJf- ' ~PT~g~t!t¥-iJEI¥J~JTMJJ:flj::® § fj~JL"Rfl}1fi ,~ $"Rn~ffT 19t1~[1 ' <~jroJ~iW~¥~) ~[\~ Jones m ~H~:5ttFf 682 flj::~ftW~£:1~~ffiJAS'9N~"Rfl ' JliJ~. 0. 0. 0. 3.
(4) ~c~ § 9ti¥J~fil-J$i¥J-@f9UT. (DeFluer, 1997). .*4J$.WJ*JT~¥~~I¥J~-{lL)t;~A~ , ~iJ~. 0. ~t-tm*~1\1'1:lz:.**~f)l. W~c~1:f~i¥Jm=~~fil-J$' ~1~Mi~Ml.~pJT{~. J!;i¥Jiifil-J$ fJ!{-tili±1F·P 111ftW@A m7(pffiid:.i¥J. Philip Meyer Meyer ~ 0. ~c~. 1:f n~Ui*JT~* > -~ , fiP.~12,fiS*JT~~~ftJ!;mili±~ N*1iffJ'eI¥J::1J¥! ' {'FfiS~i':frt¥~~I¥J£~ 1967 1fFs~ , ~~~~~.iJJ ' Meyer f*~fj'i":f:t!!~F1*1~@. l£1*~fj¥~~i¥Ji@fjr.p, *~mf~m~It9~fil-J$i!t~il]~. &'Mz1:f*ME~~~~.*4.A'I:.~ffME~5t. ••fil-°~~. tff ' {'Fi±l- *7UI¥J~~¥~~ (Myers, 1991: 17-18) Meyer l£f.I~ifH;fD.~jJf,j::1JIIDf1EiJJfpjUi*JT~* ' ~~ E3 {&~*4J$.WJ1*~fj¥~~I¥J~~ , £~t§'i":m~1¥J. 0. ~fj1gm~~i¥Jm}~!" ~'f?f~Bf'&j{ij~UEl.~pffr&~~. f.I' .L-~~{lL~rt~ff'. Mzm{~0%Ht.f~m. ~~mi¥J.~'~~~mM~~~. 0. 0. 0. Lexis/nexis, DIALOG ~1m~ ~c~*~m m*i!t~1¥J j{ij~.*4J$ (Lauder, 1989) ~{& ' ~rJ~J&!1~f~~~~*4~~ J&!1~nIU~iifil J$~H1:f~'f?f0%ac~ (Public records) ~c~fiS 0. ~~. 0. ~~m~*4J$.WJ~~.~'B~f1E~WJ~I¥J~. T¥~~0%<$~' ~m§5i@5ttffm~I~Jt9J&Jffpff9t. (Ellen, 1998; DeFleur, 1997). (ti4). 1£ 1970 1f{-t*ff~~~ft~~~~cj(~ , ~5~~c. 0. :lz:.H1:fI¥J~m. 0. {g~. *°'i"~~~.~IID.'I:~~~I¥J• • 'JZSI~AA!;m. Ei35~J&Jff~*4J$1¥J3ifI1)lmm~¥IJ:E-=f~.&falJ' .*4~. A±~~,cj(~*JT~¥~~UiIllft tlff~*JT~Ut)B~5&;fIJ. :IJI*&'~JU~i@1$l&~{t~, ~~fiI-~{1!i~'f~~m. .*.OOl&.'ffi~.~.~~@~~~llm.. *11*&,~J[:m*ff~f.I ' ~It9JZS1*3ZR {'Fm ~ T. 1l ¥~~~~El~t~:lJD5~*JT~¥~~1¥J~1l;fD.1l®~ 1J ' ~ftl¥J{'FfiS1gt3 : :lJD5~~~~~~~' ttl:IJD~ JIt¥~~;fDm~t1¥~~ f9U~D 19741f n~~~¥I3¥~> jJf,j{lL~c~i~A~i':f¥~~*r~${4 ' ~i&~~{'@f~m. ~C~f~m;fDm~IJ&Jff~*4J$Efr~*tI~~. 0. 0. ' IDffJG. 0. 0. 0. 'i". £~*,'!!ME~!ffiltT t:J ' 1J!~-@f9UT 'i"~tpjtt1:f~c. 19461fm-g~~{lL'I:~~F",~t!t~~~.:t~~. 0. ~~ :Mrt[g~~ijJjiJJ¥Ij'l:~~ f.4~Llm. B~ , ~~m~~'i"{'F!l!::1J~~~~I¥J~t~~fFm {g 0. 0. 'I:. §)t;~mJ&Jff'l:.ii*4J$~$5t~I¥J~~~. ~iJl£ 19521f~~~ME*. .R~*'i"~~~.~I¥J~~~ffi'®/F~~fiS~. <m¥3~¥~ > 1¥J~7J (David Burnham) @1£ 1972-3 1fFs~ , flJmtl~~5ttffm¥3$.mJl¥J~~~ *4' wt~Y~~~1B~$~~B"JfJ!~~iT~i':f¥~~ (DeFleur,1997:41) ~lJJf)li~J&JffI¥J~~~m~ , ~~ili±~N*::1J$fiS.'~ff* • • *4I¥JME~5t tff ' *~!j1jttl:IJDT 0:tt$~¥~~l¥JfpjUifjll Ilj~~'f. ~I¥J¥~~I~. ?fJ&Jfff*m'l:~~Wftff~*4J$' *JT~~ili~~El:mff~~. ~1£1H&~1f' 'I:~~~:Mrf!R£~~J*VIIJ~1*m ~~§ll*f-'mAA!;ftJ!;m jgt9:~'i"E3. 0. '. 0. ~~. l£~~I¥J'l:ff~"m'i"r.p '~c~;flJmm. ~~5ttfffflmU~$*6* '1£'§::1J*5*i±lmt~iW= @/J\ ~ , m~~1J!8*~IEUiffl15 3t~~'i"jg. , _iJJpff1:fAA!; ftA± (Lubar, 1993) /Fi@Mt!~iEe* ' ~~tI. 0. 0. 0. 0. ~~{'FfiS1*~fj¥~~.!l}]I¥JP3~. tI~~ffil.:IE~fiS*JT~f*~fj¥~~I¥J.~I~' ~1£ *~*5*+Im1f.L-~i&. 1966 1f{~m.l~Hi1i\1 Gl1lliil ~iW~¥~> ~c~IiWT (Clarence Jones) JltIil:f:t!!::1J$ ~*IJ¥j(*c~ , Mzt) 'I:~~{'FfiS.~I~ , ~J.&¥~~~, :tt5ttffT 682 f4'i":f:t!!~1~~7fiJAI¥J~*4(~1 3) , Ii. 1970. 0. 0. 1f{-t~~¥~~±~~tI~~.WJf*~fj¥~~~. W'*?f1*l&.~~~I¥JIDrt°.~~~Ei3~~' '~m' ~*4~A~ ';fDtI~~~gffi:ttrpUEl.~. ". WTffJGfiS~~¥~Af~m~m~~1*~*JT~ii~RI¥J)t;~. 0. 0. 1£ 1980. 1f~WM'~~~fi.+.ffi~LI¥Jr.p*~.ili±. r.p , 1:f=ffJG* (35%). 0. 4. §J1il-@.L-~Ll¥Jii*4J$.
(5) iif.l.f!l[f!U~~Jfr.fi. (Ullman, 1983) iE 1980 iF{-t*M ' ¥~ffr±nooj{ *4J!1ii¥Jttf9HB*~ttW1Jo¥q1LnX: (Defluer, 1997:43) ~ffiJ-m9:~B~~ a!!J=¥4:t$11Uf4i!limWJtf~1i~~' BIJ CPMt)1&:tB1JliJT~& (Garrison, ~¥u 1990 1996). ¥tl7 1998iF·j{*4J!f!~IJ:mi¥U 1021 fI(Williams, 1999:xxvii) iEil&)(1*I~fRinf4iJi;jS~i¥J!Plff,f , .B;!; ra'*~itB1R*4J!1i~:l:m!Plff,flli~nX:~ itffjB'~R*4 J!f!f,;E 1977 82 flttW~~ 1998 8542 fI '~F itfUI¥JR*4J!1im1:t 1977 82 @ttJ~'¥ 1998 i¥J 875 @ iE 1998 iF~~~~~ 11339 @!6lRJ:~ lU~R;jf4J~' El3 12706 fI~*4*~~{~:frti~111ft i¥J)<..:f: ' , ~l§Jf~R*4 (Williams, 1999) il&ffiff[]:l1::~JIj'l111Dif~*I.,~~Wj{*4J!J' tID* ~n~%5t~.~~ • • ~:m-.~ftffl • •R *4 ffliiti¥JR;jf4J~~\~J'H-E~:t~Et1.t~ftffl ' R*4J!f! ~ffl :m-cp i¥J.. ~ i¥J~~ (Friend, 1994) il&~g~F~~~~-@)ji±ttCPM~. 0. Q. Q. 0. 0. '~lUf4i!limWJ1*~1i¥~?Ji¥J~& ';fO~B~i¥JIf'F'I1f~. 1fH2/fEJ5-}i¥Jim1'*. 0. 0. {JE~lH4U~!limWJtfg1i¥~~f5t~B'~. IZSI~* ~ :m-fr±litj{;jSti¥J.n~ft ' j{m0jjfJ$iffUi¥J~. , t)&.nf4iW~~ADi¥J3ijttJ. r j{*4f!l[~M~Jfr.fi'~~ J. :. 0. 0. iE~WI*I~B<J.B~1~. 0. il&~~.~~~-flffr±lit~±~i¥JRmM~. , -ELtI!i0¥~ , 11li~ ~. 0)<, , 1iff~¥~;fD0~~~~ (Anderson, 1976) o. il&~B'~j{mff:iEjj~:fr~f'iii'~. 0. ffr±tt~m~~i¥Jt{lt.'~ffiJil&~j{*4J!Jtttt~~:m. 0. g~:fr~il&~mrrJim~~':fr~il&~f'iii'~~~m. g~*~:m-Rm000i¥J~~~M'~~f,;E~A~. ;xmltJl~1't. *&\ff~~1jJ.~fj!ffl ~M • • f!!-Bll'~~1jJ{j!ffl il&Jf-fR. U~~~lJh!fL1:E. 1940 iFf-t*M1J1!B *~*;.ftJtl~n~ . ffl~)<'Ail&~-@:¥U1i+iFf-t:fJJ M::tOO~51ii!ltJlf4i~ 1951 iFJfM;:F~JI&J&AD~11f fiUrtuma}ji\fl.lf1!!v,L}FlJI.f~*rtl!±t{lt . {'F~~~ 1950 if:AD ~l!HJtat~.Zffl ' ill~~WFfSil&~ t)1tJl~~ 0. 0. *4J!1i ' ~U~\~~1qJ~jiil&ffif~m000r:tiffUi¥J~. i!~R i} m.l5:!itlj B<J5ifi~. 0. !lR*4Z~§. 0. -!t1&il&ffif/f[lffftf4JiW~ilinln~~)i11li. ~~i¥J~m0~fMM. '. 1946 iF~litiffU. nB'~1=ril&~ff$ ill:g~r1i:~ cP mJEi=ril&t{lt~m1i1liil&~. 0. 0. 1955 iF~{rEJI&J&{Di~ 45 $1tJl~ , {fl1960 iF!tJ~ 531 g~ , 1966 iF~~=n~ ; 1980 iF1-tfJJWUWtJ ~~-MJ\n~±~ iE 1990 iF ' JfM;njf60&f~~1I9 fJiJJ\ T$*ru!.n~±~ , t)&mi&! 8MmSB':J~{fJ;& {rEA.n~ J\ +iFf-t:fJJM1T~A.n~tfj:EJ!t)1~ , ~~ !I~1i1~~m ' ~.:ciJll~Bn/f[lfff,€§!tJ il&~tfflh ,ijjj8kJ~Im[ll~lliWnX:~ Morrissey (1995) mtt • tfj'iEflA • • lliU~i¥J+=iF (1980-1993) , ~Wf~il&~Ktt~~1I:jj!ij8M$1~A.. El3i:t ill@ $;$;l!lirff=ril&~immef§imj{mi¥J~!8' $;$;cp5iiJ .f=r il&t{ltimm/ftlleRmi¥J:fr~t1i:~~1* f'Jil&t{lt im~,~J[Nifill®i:t~~{* ' .Mzt)~tID~fl}j , ~meil&ffifRm [lIf~iE 1974 iFW 1986 iF ' ~tt xjj!ijf!tf~lERm~ El3i:t ' 1974 iF~lE;$;~*il&~. njj , zp:j:~:reiFft¥4I1:Umi&!+;\M$t)J:. ~'@[iE-JEff,f~N~@]J!!~mtllei¥J$~N' .Mz~~.*1. fj~,~J[~ft0~*B~. im~fi$JEB"J!lEl3 ' -B~Ij;ff~t§*'§0J5(&Mf*,A~. 1966 iF~lit~~ r (Freedom of Information Act, FOIA). ~1il&HtRm. 0. Q. 0. Q. ~. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. ~~:FI)il&ffif~iif.n~±t{lti¥J±~ El i¥J' *g[55t~. Jrffl1JOt)m!JB' fLf!!r-B=if0J5(:m~flj~i¥JRffl ' ~ ~m~J[f1JrmEJt)Jf:sl1~ 1986 iF1~lE~~iJfl}jJE~ M• • ' ~W~. ' J;)&~F§>flji¥Jf..ij.~Iiff~t{ltfMm :?k..mz1~j{mi¥J~m (Anderson, 1976; Defleur,. ~m.!I;fD.ff:R*4Zffl;~~ • • • ~.i¥J.. & . il&H~f~rU~R*4~i¥J~:l:m[ll~~iF!tJ1JD 5)iE 1977 iF . ~~il&ffif~~ 204 @R;jf4J!1i '. (Public records) , IIJ.f,~Fll!<t{lt. 0. 0. 1fl~. 5.
(6) 1997). 1998 if:rdll¥J*Jt~t '!'tl.-J=I{5iP9 I¥J 1ft 820 ~ A ;)( i& H1 ~ ( Publisher's Auxiliary, Jan. 26, 1998) 'i'1iI:iI~~ 1998 if:~~~~~~0f1fjfoJ;f*4iJt , ~~'B~l4!iiij/N!~~~. 0. !!li~~~Ji §. El31! SflnfRr:t;f=f!fjJ,¥pJ J:Jmt1~i&. H1~m'm~0~~~~~a*m~mi&H1~~~. 0. l¥J,fIfiJ ' flP*llii@:7H~@]1!J@~~ , 151!riit:iI 1979 if: ' 1!~I¥J*ljij(t~tJj , 1!U~1iPlm%~t~..g-~ m§ El31!pfrt~ml¥Ji&H1-X~ ;}(if: ' :li~1!~1£:§ 0. 0. -t:t;f=f!~~~rpiit~{(pJT1'fIHl~Q)"OO3tI¥J~a' ~r.f. i:!i&H1-X~l¥Jk~ °fJi&~IUJQ)"tf~fljffl~1i?F1$;$. 1¥J~~i£' f91J~D!flM=£-=f1'Ji&~lUJmtff~~Je.l¥JfI~. 1970 if:1-trpMi3 1~1ft{:v:~t1~i~. §. f!J;t~0~ , ~13.lt~a~0~J{)l1~~m $~~U1£. * '. 1984 if:'B'~ , 1'Ji&~IUJ!!liQ)"§1'Jij(ktf1~jjml¥J mrt, {!i/f1J~illi~r ..g-JJt!.*llif~m JPJT1Z,~l¥JiBlIl. ~!iffij~. 0. _1l12!I/1'Q~1lJ., !flM~c=aPJT~ffll¥J 0. , /f~~ffi:*JttT¥~!'lI¥J~{$ § 1980 if:. 0. ,@IA~H~~?$JfJ{)l{-t~!iffij~, ~c~~j£rm. 0. @I A iIUi1~1'ffrHi~ffll. ,jiQ)"m*. ~~Ifiifl~ , 7tfJT~~/!J ' i~E<:~*~L~. . iitJ~fu~?$Jf1NH!!m¥U~c=a~~. f'Ji&~lUlmmB!J939i--1i:f1V1tJ~i£' ~UjlH§~tff~ ~~~!'tl.°fii&~IUl/f~~m~tf~~~~!'tl.,~ ~mA~1:t;Wf3t~~. 0. t:t;~Jt1&*1£. 1982 if:1¥J*iJij(. rp'B'7G ' ~D*EfI~WA?F1R~{i~~!'tl. ' =8~fJ~1$;Wf3t mH~fI~~~H~' f'Ji&~IUJ~1'ftf1~~~!'tl.I¥J~~ ( Defleur,. 1997). 0. 1f:£J;Jt.I¥J*~,~Q)"J:J~fJ! ' f:lPf~1£. Davenport. 5jfH~IR;±JJi±ltB"J~m 'i&H1~.fumm~13.lt~m0. rm. 0. ,fIflJ/flt1f:£.:R~j:$:T'* ' $JT~~arJfE1'f~~*lli. f~. (1998:33) , ~c=af~ffl@lA.~~1£i*~JJf~ 2Jl¥Jtl::'{§U ' (88%) , ~m=arp1'f-= o ~c=af~m 1In~l¥JfB. B/f ~N1nf$*ftf1'llj{tj::1'tl A •jffl ~~~1iiIiXfI~VltjllrzH!!ffl Garrison ( 1996) 1£::93 -n~llf!l;i!j:rt:1I311~~Ua, $JTf:lll~lR1'f.~/J\Mll¥Jtt..Wtl~ m*1ft (47%) , (29%). Garrison ( 1998:70) oo:OI?'a.Elllf~1. if:~J=lI¥Ja-Jr:t;m~ , :;t(z~Jf)(ffd:lt~~n'H5iM= ' ::tf.l~m. Garrison. ~i&H1~M~:iII¥J~~~lMo. 19~if:~U4iJt.~'B'~m~r~~£.~~ ~~ J (National Information Infrastructure, Nil) i&. *. ,jt:rp~~6Z-~i&H1flJm~~~~1'Fm1'Ji&~. m0rml¥J~~. El31$; J. 0. ~lt1£. 1996 if:im~. a. r1lT~m§. (Electronic Freedom of Infonnation Act,. EFOIA) :iI$ *1!afln~TfI~f'Fm0~~c~1¥J 0. J.tg{:V:' ~*~~~'B~1Z\~JiJ:J~~~M~~15J;ttf#t0 ~f'Ji&~~Ji~TfI~' :;t(zmkl[g~~Wg~1Z\~JiH!!1UJ1*. AZ~*W~jj*3/-~. tMlJ{)l~M1;f:ftjj~. ( 13%) , mtJffijt:'8*~IlJ:J~ ( 12%) ,. 0. fHR~gB7:H'Ji&~lUlfljliJ;J:f1V1tjfD*lli~~lM' ~13.. tfgc=a~fflmH~jj*3/-. '. {g~tE. 1990 if:1-t '. ~~jj. . ( 10%) I1t9i-~c~pJTW2,~I¥J~~im~mfj~~1:!!. m : 1JD~J{)l1~$JTM*~~ , , J:JE<: 0. m§ EI3$1tUl¥Ji~U~t~~~UB*lli*afM:iI jffl~~~~ I¥JtJjfJ! ' ~IJf~i&H1~(3/-I¥J*llif~fflJ!1'f~$ o'19fJ~1J 0. 6.
(7) r jj*4J!1!.f!tJ~JTM~~ J. il*4J!1!fllH:l<:WfM : !fklli~{lSHiff~f~l±l ' ~::~OtEl!llir¥J~JTMYlRB*~. M>c~.~&,~:1t~.~rm*1TM~~r¥J~. ~ii~mflD~~~lm f9U~D~fiiftJ ( 2000 ) ~~tJt. ~, J..j.1X~JJUJTM.~' liti;g~M~m,~,I"J~ ,. ~~~iilH[3:1t~mflD~&~lmjifjr",~~[IijJJ!to. t)&J!t~$.~~:j:RRo ~c::1tm&:,~J{~rm*1TM1J. ~ij[ , ~~jj~c::1t~j!jH~mfl~itlA~1tf:>c:r. 1[(n&~r¥J~D~ , t)1!JltfttJtm,~,I"J~'. 0. fLmtU:r¥Jgc::1t ' r ~mRRf!l!J. •. ' fufJ. ~g[3:1tJ:~r¥J§. ¥:R:J'EWfM$. 1tf:tg:f[' J..~&lifUf3${t~~ [13]~ , gc::1tmJT!H~fFm ~JTMf~JJii¥J~~ , {.I1f!~g~JJ..;M , j;J&*-El.~~~,m 0. o~~~:1t!fkm~m~.RmR • • • ~. (77.86%) , ~~~f~HflT~Rf!l! (65.65%) , ~':::fl:U~.J:RRf!l! (48.85%) , ~[9::t~i&JfJ~ 0~~mlr¥JRRf!l! (35.11 %) %~ ( 1998 )fu W~JttJl!1:tli3l!lliJ\~fljl tJgc::1t~1T~ 1j;)1¥J~~ *a*~~ , fll~tJ~[3:1tl£~lmJ:Ji[~R lP\t¥r:t~Jt~1t<J=f~ : ~1J;;JjiRf!l! ' ~?}R*4f!l! ' t..t&'III"J*1TMYle ICC?}' Hfi' ;U~fl (2000) 1£ 19981f:fu~*~~JtA~E3fN' *1T~iil± ' ~~E3 ¥~=~91ftr¥J 1100 {v:~[3:'l§~tJr",~~~~ *5*1{ 'f'f 89.5%8"J~c::1tf~mfl~~t£$WfM~~IfF '. :1t &:'5JJ:Fl~~~l£fPl~J:llfmfln~~iiflmr¥J:ffl!t~ ~ ~ , :Ji!-ff,tmt~2JStJfD1'F~**1t~1'Fr¥J~D~ ; tt1f , ~ll{ilJ~mm!lRIiN!{'Fff~m{'F~**1t ~=~U~ ~J'E~iiflm~9:rm8"Jftm ; tt1f~ , ~c::1t~llfuH~mfl. ~I:j:l 27.9%r¥JA*~m J:~. T!$1tf:~RJ&~m,~,; ~llfilJfljm li*3j.f!l!~er¥Jgg1~. 0. AI"J~°f'f~~*1TM~~r¥J~~,~:1t~~~a~ ~JJif¥r¥J~JTM~W~ , 1CC~mgj@/f~ ~1r~lm~~ 0. ~~:1tl£tR~~.j@~~M~&r¥Jfl~~.~. ,. , fDRm~~r¥JfElml~D~. ?JT~ r flD~~flr.j$Jjlr¥J~~ J ' ~ J..~5t~~11. 0. Ji'~ , ~-1I!il~~~mI~fl~f4~iifjr¥J~~ , ~c:. 0. 0. 0. 0. ffl*1TMYlR§ cr¥JR*4f!l!. 0. l£f~mfl~r¥Jgc::1t'ii. 27.8%r¥JAf~m7\:;~RR~. I:j:l'. ,. 0. (Query language) ~~j;(:f4. 51.3%~. 0. ~1I!3~WJ'EmD~~. 1./i¥,5tf(pr¥J~~ , f9U~lll£n.Y~lI~R~~ t)t!<:¥O M11i~tJ. 0. ~J:m~~~7RmM~1£~>C.R • •m. .tml!lli~1~mi¥JfEl~Rm. 0. !fkf& • JlU~flD~$Jjl.. l¥J~&ll*7Jt ' fEl.:Ji!llttll;m~~~mfJ~{~~N f§lJ~ll. ff!Jt~~r¥J9'flU ' f§lJ~oftmflT!$ftf:~~W*1TMlM. ~7Hiff~ (~ll Friend, 1994; Devenport, Fico. ilifa~?JT%\~r¥Jf~Aiii!fI1 (Netiquette) , tJ&~lmfml. 0. Weistock, 1996) f~l±l ~l¥J:@]iJl. '. &. YletR~f3fl.ff~~.f:tiJtRw~. ' ~~*~~:J;JHJf&:IEtt (Garrison,. 195). £J.~$1$. 0. t)J:?JT~r¥J~f~~~Ji~' B*~fJgt~>e/ll:~. 0. *~R~~~R~~~~'~~~~fu~~~R'. f#~~ ( f9U~D ' Marchionini, 1997), *>C/f¥}.~. 1*~ttf9UlZ9tc~f,\iiJ J:~~lIm~w~Jt*~~~. tt~?JT~lM~ifar¥JflD~~D~ , ~~~~~~JTM~~jj¥N. • • • tJ~:1t'~.r¥J~~~Ylft:Ji!~.m~m ffifH • fl:ljfJ1~Jmtm jffiliil:f~JJ[~ , fu~~fr~~~¥U*1T liI'l~lmzrdl ' ~~tfuf¥l£ r .11li1&~ J r¥Jr",~~ : *. ~fElmlr¥J~J'E~~. 0. . WJjU~f~m RRJ.r¥J~~ (Houston, 1996) El3~.~lrJT~N ' j;) -rrJT1'Fr¥Jil'f ffifijlm~~~WJ'E~Jjlr¥J~*~ ; \jft/f1~JE~P1LJ*ffifl1 ' iN!1'Fti7~ , ~~ftff!mmlll1i 0. 0. ~~lmRt./i¥,~~jffifJFl~h!f)Z1~9!~. 0. 0. l£f~mj;(RJIlr¥Jj@~~ 'fJ~j;(:f4J.~ilt8*~. ~c~1!~~O~i. ~#f:-J'Er¥J~~J!t~1f~ ; fJtll;flU~. ,. 'iig[3:'l§rJT~. f~mlinlIl~JJ.**Jc' 1'F~"~li*4JIlf~~'. : ~JTM~l!!!r¥J~D~ , fl~~~fJr.j~~r¥J. , t)&~m~~r¥J~D~. 0. ~r¥JR:f4~$~#f:fJ~r¥JliR~~1f~~'. 'ii*1TM~[3:'l§t£~*4~.~WfM . &:'~Jt~rm = 11 lIDm~. 0. ~J'E~*4[7\] ~, ~~lLmI~-r1:~*4JIlzm ( Houston,. 0. 7.
(8) 41. WI nii"i.iJj;)~l&i¥JJi*4 gC~1£lf'lf~jj*4~ 0. ,t±ttl'WEZ.. AfOjj*4rn'~ 1£1ilf'lJi*4i¥J~fflcp '~~M:fl3mm. MS Access, AskSam, File Maker. 0. jf~~!!. : xl'W (Negotiating) , ( Searching) , " ft.!! (Transforming) , fD ( Evaluating) r xl'W J ~j~~c~m1ilf>!jj~ffij;fDJi*41JJ.j(1L iJJ ~D*jj*4~~A ' W~xT!JJ~fj.L-J-A~1LiJJm :t ' ~J~D:§C~raJ1Tjetg~Efl~~lfXf~1I~ ; ~~~~ • -=f¥!Wf1!*lf'l1~m,~,*tl\iii¥JJi*4 ~O~Ji*4* S .Hiicpfr'f.I~ , J'lUxl'W~fflj;)flJ\ljif'Fm:t ' wU~D. (Information processing) ~gC~f~m1lH~1'Fm.. ~c~~J\l@AJi*4nX:mnp' j;){fte;tkM~l45~~. fM~. -M~Fll1tMi.~l2§m~T1IHii;fD~fMt~.flmw' &'it 1tFgiJJ~*5!~. , F1~~~¥Ulf~i¥Jjf*4 r 1IHiiB:flftjf.l~i¥J~D~ J '. -1i~c~~mw. 0. fI'lJti~. , illL~ JEj;). 0. f*~fj~~j:t¥Ur4i1$*i¥Jffl*ljf~ gC~~\~JjJ\lmw 0. :f13~i¥Jjf~~!!~D~. 0. , ::tfj~~~~~*jf*4 ti2~f~~~D~W1l,~iiji~~D~~rdj , ~\~Jj~~ 0. -fj~D~.i¥Jfl*6 ,~{f. 0. 0. 1Iniijj*4l¥'1fillI~m. ' illL~F~~~1!tJi~NiliU. g}]I~~a~'~G~fI'lJa~tf1§t:~~§t:~1:tt$jf~. Ji'M. ~f!l¥cJ{Tm. xl'W~ffi~1tff:ft'i!!im'~~T~~9ll!(;m~~m. 0. gG~jj~~f!i¥J]!~Ilt§'~, {gffi~r~'. 0. 0. 1il&jj*4 (Obtaining data) , ~ftjj*4 (Summarizing data) , Wtt!jjjf4 (Matching data)~ j;) ~:5tJjUtJDj;)~flA~rf!;.~~ r mrl'l, J ' 1£lbt~~f~~G1Hf.JEIG,cpi¥Jr~~ Jll1!fM~ , illLjE!~{l!ID~,i~"ft.!!nX:mi.iJJ),~~i~lUiijif'F. 1ilf'lffifm:i¥J.Hiijj~ tI~··EiJj1j~~~JlHiill!(;~JiI&B<] cpfr' ' WU~OflJ}fj~fMtj!~51~lfX1~:xftJi*4 ;. l¥cJ~J:t ~gG~!ffl!la~f-'Ji~~' i!!im'{,\cp1t~. tf1~"i.iJ~~~~All!(;*EtrnJJi*4 'vtl~07G~~~ ,~,*tJJ.j(. fl~~JEi¥J El i¥J ( vtl~O~j)ffi~JE~ffl*l*.!R* ' ~~;tkfll. ~*51 El~. .niijj*4pfTmi¥J~NililJ ftxT!JJ~f~cp. (Formulating questions) ,. 0. 0. ~Jjwpfi51il&jj*4pfT3Z: f1i¥Jf-t:ffi. 0. 0. ~,~,*1JJ.j(. , ll!(;.~~fl;tk-ffl*l:fI3~$.). 0. 0. J~m~c~fUme~Di¥J*?':R*' ~f:tJ\l~. r. 0. , ~c~i!!im'~'. , .L-J-1iiJE.Hiijf;f4ff:1£l¥JfllIi. 0. r "ft.!! JJ1!J~tejj*41:tt-eJ:t~W!nX:mg. ~m-~flSl. El i¥J ' ~C~~'~JIlilli~~tHjj*4ff:1£i¥Jf8m. ; ~f&1£~ Mi'Blllcp , jil&Ji*4 1£1]ifl!ID~fl~~c~~\~JjteH~lW cpt&t~~tHi¥Jrn'~ "'ft.!!nX:m~.B<]{Tm-¥p~, j;). fj~J:t. {f~~~{Yf~mJiU~iifTjj*4~!!. ~~~'~f~l&JfJi¥J.H~Ji*4~filiff:1J~fLt1Liittm ' IZSl. Ji*4i!!im't)-)E:;f!i:tfiliff:' ~~*~\j1jMiIl :§c~i¥J1IH~pfT~.lf>! ' l2§IftgC~1ilfXJi*4~\~J[*~~,'. 0. 0. ft.!!i¥J~ffl. 0. (Splichal & Chamberlin, 1994) vU~O~ 0. !f!vtl*~, &-111~c~;W~jlHjj;tk111ffi.Jiif~lW~. Ift~c~~\3Jj7Gf~ffl~7*fI~"ft.!!jj*4' :J5tmftuA. B<]1I-=f¥!Wftfufll: ' ~c~HiilWt:j=ri¥Jrn'Jl!!" ~$t{T"ft.!! nX:m~a.m;~fDfflff: ' VU~Dm ~JriIiXe¥U;tkflSlj!!l*. ~.Hii gC~1:tt~~jj~~~~Ji*4 ' i!!im'tf1&\~Jj. ~~;f!J:t"ft.!! ' ::t~~f~fflm-~l:t~~~jj*4~. 51~~l45f~m;tk1i~fi*f'F1tHly' ~iiA;tk1imff. -rf!;.~f~ , 1&1111l~%3::~ff:1£ ' ~c~gt~\~Jj1~m. :j:¥/JlB~lilli~f:t~m-ffi.Jiiffl,:j:t~i¥J:Xil' ~f&::t~~ii. AjJ~*I£1ID J:i¥Jjj;f4fiA.nii ' .L-J- ~~Ji;r-+"ft.!!i&. {TJi*4i¥J1il& ~c~raJIU~jj*4~rn' , ~~'....L...'I ~!jA~rn' , ~!l1MtrnJjj*4~i~' , 1£tH~~~J:illL1!tJi. JlHiiEiJ~l&i¥J~J:t. ~fI'lJ 'ff!.~-¥~J:1HI3~~~ :t:HIHiiti2gjj~~l¥'1. 1m: ' j;)EZ.~\gJ[3Z:{1i¥J{-l':fl~Fa' , 1iJ1i:,~1if! 3IlfXJiiiRpfT3Z:{1i¥Jf-t:fl ' iiJfj~~1it:~ , ~rdj , ll!(;A. 0. 0. (~1 6). r wpfi5 J~f~~c~1£e~jl&ll!(;~~l&l¥9~,~, {fi 0. 0. , ~c~i¥Jtl!rntljJ:t ' ~\~~~ffl*ll!#&!! El;ft fD.Hiif,lM'F-¥p~~rdji¥J5!*a. 0. 0. 'iliEiJfj~~$tlU:~~1!J::i¥Jj1!li WPfi5imm'~. 0. 0. ~~=.*~ J ' ~f~~c~1:tt~JEl¥'1*~~3&.. :j:1£xl'W,tI~,~"ft.!!~~~~~&cpo~*4i¥J. 8.
(9) ~~_~~~~:~~r~~_~©~~m~J. 3j~PItJ.*~ltfl' fEI.~c:tfB!'.mtl.'lltflML::f ft~"f~. 'ltflrp5I::li:limJ::iZlt=fl9;O.. f~fUl:. )dM1I~ID1.,~,Zffif' ~fl;jfiJJ-j,:mt/N~fI~m:mt~fI. ~c~1:EffMtI¥Jf*~fj¥&~llt~rp I.f'J:'ffif ' irl*ll!! I!I!I¥JIf'J:'m~immf'f~f-lJ~·WIJ~D Parsigian( 1987). fll¥J~m I ~c~ttl1'1Jtl5'f. 0 'i"~c:tfftj;ll1lJ&~ID1.fI. 1!f*~f~l:tl~c:tf~I!I!irl*l ' fDm::reA~ f{£$m::reI¥J~. fil1lfD&:,3Jt1if11¥J f~ fJ Z r"IHi~:1§~ftjffif ' ~c:tfI¥JMA ~f;f' W~~M ' irlif]*,JlTfj~1J ' J-j,&1~fltzg~~. ~)!iJU~itffjJ f'f®~~~IJi!-?f7f~l:tl' ~c:tff*~fj~. ' tzgJ/Uc:tf &:'~l*,JlTfiiJffifl!f-~f¥lt~*,+1IJN. ft~.~c:tfI¥JWPfi5*a~. 0. 0. ~I¥JIWmtf~ I. 0. ;g:T~ID1.-*~J&14' ~c:tfHpmj;)f-tpg~1'J:'i!. , ~~i1ilf*JfH'Mt15~:@(;iln~fmWJI. £*J::ML1Sif'f*I¥J~~ (Johnson, 1993:357;. Hansen & Ward, 1997). 0. ' :@(;U[ffiij [m{£~~z c:p ; ~ffij'i"~~~;lIJiI* ' :@(;~$:@Ififfif ' ttf-IJt:ID1.. 1¥Jl1J~. ,~,pg~gt&:'~JL~~ft¥3:@(;ttJj. ff~J;)1~ I ~!JOOMlDg$$l9(ro'ml¥J~7Jjji~15~. ~1¥J$D1. '. 0. ~c:tfI¥J¥-fJEf*~fjff~' :@(;*!@1~irMl~R*J31i. ~*5~'8~*,+. 0. (:@(;D1:tf ) tt~~~fi~irlif]flfil1ll¥J~ A ft*':fi5J j;)~rlPJ&¥-fJEI¥J~m ' WIJ~O~c:tf{£1i~ J!1[~l1Irp~~1:t~fD5t~ml:tl~*'+7Hffjl¥Jm~ ft ~fu PI J;)~~R~*,+l¥Jmu~ , WIJ~D~c:tff~m llJt.~ tl(11I tJU~ , ~t.zp.~1il1l ' :@(;JIJl:tl1i*,+~*lll¥Jl!* ~lOCm-M. o. ~ffij. gc:tfI¥J:±~ff~~1§~~lIn~fmWJI. ~*jGlOC . ~P&:'~l1t<~ff~tEfffDEll¥JffijJE. 0. ~ffiff,* ' ~c:tff~Jl3ff*fCI¥Jf*~~~I~. 0. :@(;*aOOR*'+::fF~. 0. , WIJMOOw. , PIfj~J!f'fflJ~jGlOCf*w1f~. 0. -EL~c:tf.m&:,3Jt~Jtl.H~fmWJ' ~U~c:tf&:'~l. !. ' ~.~~*,+I¥JMft. 0. .fmWJIAm~M~.f-lJn.WJ~:tf.m~7Jjji~. m~ r Mit J ' ~f~~c:tfre¥-fJEI¥J~*,+pg~ft. ~/Nf!1.. , :@(;MAI1'J:'i&1~rp~~I¥J;jl* ' gc:tfDg$. ~Ml~JE~m~~imID1.'. 0. ,~*,+J!l[,:@(;~®. r Jn~tr.JJ:tf.t J ' ~1J~mW;t-JEI¥JMJjfJ:@(;JIIflFf. I~I¥J*lli:l . ~c:tffu~Mlf;j• •mro' · fefPf~"ft. :mJi~1Jotj,5t$:@(;*lli:l' J;)1J!~tt~f'firlif]1J1f!1.1¥J. ffX;~f'J:'~FffDf~~ , j;)1Il&~*,+ 1:E~*,+I¥J3IJ&i&1. o. 0. ~rpPIfj~f¥1:Elm~I\&t1ii:@(;~iPtl. 1JUM{£~it.~rp~liI:fi~JJFFf (Sequencing) ,. ~~{£1if3j.J!l[rpf{£$5t~. (Grouping). 0. ~ffij. , f'f. '. gc:tf&:'~~~3:. ~ , fj!1~ , :@(;$'~~ 151*ffim:~*'+ ' Wffi5R~pg~. _ • • -~ml¥J~~*~~~ml:tl~f'firlif]flfil1l ErJm,~, ' tzgIlUc:tff'fffif&:'~lre~*llJ;J.J:I¥J¥-fJEJif3j. pg~$~m*,~ml:tl~~~mpgJi*,+l¥Jmli~. ' J-j,&*,1I1ffiiJffifl!f-~f~lt1lJ&Ji~ *~i&131J&I¥J~~~O*~$:@Ifi ' ~IJgc:tfIUI~ffJi flpg ~l¥Jft¥3:@(;ttt-t •~~~I!!I!I!I¥J~~*~~ ~c:tf1¥J. 1*'°WIJ~D~c:tfW~~Mj;)J:I¥JJi~J!l[*f:lA -M~~'[1:. ~1T'M~Af'firl*l1Jm,~~:tf1J!~A~m~. .MJ!l[lm~ttJj~M~~J!l[ZM¥-fJE.ml¥J~. ~~ • re~ID1.pg:§u[ffil!f-m~¥&~3Z+ ' :@(;:tf"~1OC. 1*,. 111ft ' :ML1JDJ;)*ll*fH~JJIl.. 0. ttJjt!!1Q1I!ifPf~fD~*,+~*l1ZrJll¥Jtt~. ~1§i:l~~Jtl. ,. 0. 0. ~D~J&f41¥J~ID1.::fr-ti:lf*. gt~M$.:@(;fPf~ffij~ ffX; -®~ , ~i&1*1E~tm~'Jffij1JD. ~fjff~Pff~ I ~U~c:tf&:'~lllir~JE1f~. J;)ttt-t ' 1Jti~DMt~t J:1¥J1Ii:tf. J&fO~~~*,+I¥J~llti&!~·. 1'Fm1ll1~~~+l¥Jttt-tzm. (Significance) ,. 1J!-m. 0. 'mr&1'. r~~9"~Ut1i. .~*~M~M • • I¥J~.m5tm=MS. 5t : irlif]l!!I!I!I¥J9;O. ' 1lItn~~f;ltj!Bfll¥J9;l1. ' J;)&. ElMirl*l~Rmf*m~*,+J!l[mfmWJ~~I~. ~ml!!I!I!I¥J9;O.· ~flm 5tR~m 715 1J!fl1f~~~i1il. ~ , ill~OO~¥UI!*I¥J:m~ ~®~~~f'f-$15!~. iTf.i~ml¥J$:r~, {£.~I1'J:'mt~'i"rp '~c:tf&:'~1:E. * § ~~R*~l¥JfI*1!.f-: ' WIJ~D Friend ( 1994). 0. 9. I¥J~.
(10) ~H~Cfj, ~3~fJTOO:¥:~Jt.lflijf§jiMJWJ1*~fj¥~~I¥Jlw=. ~~~~. JJH~l*. 9tll~IfX05X~c~1i'¥4 1ili~~~:;F~~Jffnff~~W~. 1~ff~flij~~1t11l::fJE (75%) ,. '. 0. '. ~. ~c=eWJt.lflijf§jiMJWJW~fj~21J~~M'CP 'J!*1¥J#5~. .. 0. , 1fi~-~1=r~;f{l~~~J1JJL:@tfi~ §. 0. ~7I-~. ;;fi~1'1'I~Jff*Djfu1f~Jff*ffiUn~1v:t§. J!~TfJ~;f{lfMi<I::R~{:ll¥Jmt~. m~* § ~~1I:7H~BI¥J'I1f~j2g* fr~~~c=eI¥J*~. 9). 0. 1i ' ~,,~~it : 1=r~mtfM~{:#:-~fln~!j!~II~. ~M'cp 'flij~~WJ~~fj~~FJT)'l:¥Ul¥JiMt0~ § ltN=r. fJ~. m§ B':Jfr1t:Iii.~J1*'TOO. 0. ~Z (70%)' iJ&~f~~rs~I¥JJ~1J (50%) ~rm. ~mtfMl¥J~J11J'. J '. r. 'iJ&f~)JI~lAlftJ. ~t;;~llf;zftJti'~f~ J:t Ef3~fjlf ~~JfftlfMfr~JLjf¥4 0. ~a~, {i~rI*!itA~{~Jt.l 'rm*~rl05XW~1I. 0. 1=r~;f{lfMBS~J11J. ' §. lWfl~~~mWJ~~fj~21JFJT. ~ J! Chamberlin. (. B':J*UI{~Jt.l. & Splichal,. lIDCWi;I¥Ji&*#5¥~ 1=r~;f{lfMAffiUJ1m~c=e3IJfX0:;!t:. 1993:340; Splichal & Chamberlin, 1994) ,. ~c~l¥Jf~Eirt:u ' illzJFflijf~HnJJll:Ji3t::tJi:1:.. ~U~~Ht;f{lfMi&;g.~fMmftJ~VftJII&[(~f ~Jff;f{lrm I¥J. 0. 0. 0. Ji'¥4 iJ*,~ lID ~J:t miff;;e:fr{f ,1=r ~mtfM~i'J:£Hj::f[E] 1¥J1f$~J1ItJi'¥471-Vff: Ef31t;;mUftJ7~Ji ' f~1~~IIJfX1~~Jff1i~ttBs'§;~ffJ~*f~,* ;. fl~~~;¥ij.I~'I'1lIl:L~ , 9!ti'a~rs~:@t::f;f§[E]. fF~-'r~JJiIJ~m$~ii' x~I~Iii~MJi*4'§;~1¥J1=r~. =eg\'Jf*¥UTti'~. gflfHf6J*;;e:mt (Shear, 1998) $I¥J~}!JE ' ~~~Jff;f{lfM1fr,ljt Jt.l :@tfi.=f$~J1m~c=e IfX1~flD~Ji*4 1=r~;f{lfMA~i&*f~Jt.lI¥J.=frt;;ff i'J. "ft. ' ~J3IJr.J~ : 1=r~;f{lfMff~~~1lJA!it1J}fffil'::R:JE mi:#:)(;¥ij. WM=r ~1i~H$mJE '. ~~J:tffi-~fln~~JM~::f[E]. 0. 0. ,. ~;f{l~m1~1t;;m1:#:ti'~ , 19~BI]::f fbbtIJJ~'ti'. 0. , 1T. '. , ~P~$II~*iJ~JU;Z)(;¥ij.. 0. 0. J!;~~$t¥U$tIfXBSJjj{~U 1fi1=r~~fM~U~~tfJt!l¥A. 0. 0. i=rfllliJc&pq;g.°. ?t;; , fffij§jj/!J;lit@~11 1=r~;f{lfM~fI r */NN J I¥J fF1t;; , ~T Jt.l*H~~f!iUt0~c=e~Jf. ; Mrs~9tlll¥JfF Jt.l (DeFleur, 1997) 1£$1*1: ' i'J~~ff.SfjU ' i!'§;~~1£ 1990 n:::f~mltJ~Ht)(~H0F7f]$m ' illz1£ 1996 Jl1v:t!3 Ef3$~' i'Jm~R5X*UI1~mi&Jff)(~ftJ:9E t£J ; gfl~~ru~::f!IT~liitJ1J§. ~ '1g~g{~II~~IJ**i'Jr f;*[I@Altif.L>.J~r~. ~~1'F§m81±l'. ~~~;f{lWJ. '~~$~~~~~'. ;fM~JL~fi. =e.t!P@:!*¥lJflij~ti'~. , ~Pttttm::f¥Urm.)('¥4. (li 7). ~~fj:. 0. - , ~~*i:j;ff1± : ffa~fl~1=r~;f{lfMw:!lfB1§-~fi: ~c=e ' PJT~~1lJI¥Jti'~illz::ffffr ; 1t:IiH~~c=e9;nBrm. 0. ~ ~fffi~c~'**fr*i3t~JJlI, , 1=r~'§flD 0. 1¥Jti'~.1l~'Lt fffr. ='. 0. ftIIIjai~*lpr~ : i=ri&tlfMmf~Jlf·WitrJ. '§. 0. Ef3$f~lE~~*~~:;F~tI. '. 0. 1Jj~1:E 1998. 1t;;JE~pN~@~a~ ,*tfB:B-~}ff;f{lfMWW*ij~~¥U. 0. .=. ,jfg~a~B : ffrOO~¥1ffa~~t1:l¥JlfF '. ~1v:t0F7f]. *ftJ*~ (Henderson, ]998;. ° Ji'¥4 1:~B':J~~:;F~;f{lfM1ili~~ff:ijf. gflll~mm:*f~Jt.l~rs~*f;tm~c=eo. Carney, 1998). rt:ug.~m~IfXfl.)(~;;e:~'ff@g.tttt~. DO' m~fjlf~tlfm~]:!f:#:J!;I¥J~'¥4pq~fJ1~;f§M'gg. r ~§1lJ~{t:j::~~. '9lf~flij~jff4ftJ~{-;j(Shaw,. rjilJ , m*f'F}E~]!!fJT (§± 1OH=r~mtfM~f&I¥J:;;fi 0. 1994) 'l~m.!'ftflLf9IJPU~&~:;F~ID\'iJ1t~ (FBI). JJ11J::f~flfJll, '1JJ. -'¥~IJ7R~~c=efr1llf;z~Jfffl~~)(. 0. ~V~1IUil¥JfRiJ~ [lg ,. 0. ;¥ij.1¥J~~1:. 8). J.:UlitiU:S: : fJ~;f{lfMi'J~~4~"I¥J1JJ:t '. '. ~ff;f§&,f~fnrl¥J-~St~~5t. 0. . flij~mtIj]~§fj¥&21JFJTOOCWi;ftJ$= {~#5'j , 10.
(11) ~~~mm~~:~~r~~~~~~M~~J. ~1}~i1~B9~6Mt 0 ?JT~B9Wi~rmlfn1t ' imm~. tJgfi831i~ 13 83 {t;;1I5UIr9¥.1l:fl ' Jr2 f.{!}0jt;$~17\(jfii&1. mA1r,re~fre:mfifmB9~&' q~jJzMT'x~f!fOO:. fjt¥J~c•.. (Mosco, 1998) 1I:t1l&~yjIH~1Wi&Jff~1}~~c~B9 ~~·.~~m~~m~~.B9~&oi&Jff~Mm. ~f~Jij. '. 0. Jt* ' ~Jj:ff:j{;jqI1J!fp:.t¥Jr",~~ Wi*4I1J- ft~. .~~~Z~~'®~~'~~'~~ff*.Wi~'. '. •jJzWmJJ. ftj{fj~~m~11~H~JkWi;jq. 1UIj{fj~~'!ffi ' flJj*'TrHl~It~1.&JfER~i&1itt!~~fj. 0. ii~IDt~J}g:@:~*:lfJ:~-fi0jt;M. -. 0. qrmif . f~m~~£\*JH'.J·.f~Ju. gt~ff~~. 0. ~t~A~ffli&Jff. . ' 1lJ1t ,~* Rf'I~m1!fii1 ' ®1~f'Ix~fiffii1 '. H!'tMWi;jqJ~f~m~~Jr2.m· ::E~~~--IMtA?JT~. m~~~i&Jff.M~~®Wi~~*~~~~~~. B9~~/f,f,1!m1i~~f19tI!ll:1i~f~m~I¥J?E.' ~j/t. .~it, ~lnlJ0JX£\*JH1.=tgg~Jr2fflWi~pg. H!~fre:m~f'J.B9JJj!flfj, 411:.H!m~5itmi&Jff~1:B. ~. t¥J.*~*. i!fiij!~. ~ffi]. , &:'tM~~IH~1:B • 0jt;~c~/fJ!!. , l1P~R~~0~Wi~B9rm&1t 1i~B9rm&1t ' M:l~ 1960 iff-t ~~i&Jffm .~ialfff4~tft:fijtjWi'¥4)(1.tX ' ~:lL;E-f~*411J ' f~. ~~1;Er&:*~~ft3Ift~., ~~lfB~i&Jff~~rs~1£rm. *~.~~fIJWG~F~fIJ*J:lJ~~~*,~~ (Anderson,. fre:m1i~t¥J~1t,~~~-~~~t¥J~.~~. 0. 0. 0. 0. -§'~Jr2~MWi.' ~iJ0*-ftJ~rHl~It~~9tfj~. 1998) 1980 iff-t~fDlIUj-\i&~M ' ftJt!1:iJ~/J\i&Jff. (Fought, 1997b). 0. 0. ~~Wf~fuml:B' 0~~Wi;jq. mm' fpffijtA.$~M 'i&Jff/ff'§'~I1R)t;~t~0~$. 11J411:Jf~.mJ;J1~' ~1f-*.mtmtmJ:~' 'tM~~1t. ~Wrl~Ti ' ~~ , ~M'J~!fi'~~. ~5t1tB"J~;t.!R7*m/fflJ (Shannon, 1994). ; rq]B~fu~;E-fi&. 1&1}jt;$~~1H~1f (Schiller, 1997:50). 0. i&Jff~. m*~~JTrHl~~r&:*illJ~ , .*411Jfre:m.fI~fllt:. , WX. :ff~'i;E-f1'i'f:lL'Mi1~; ~ffX~f!HI'1 'IW",~0EUWJ~. ; f.§.:ff:'tM~/J\~~1t ' t§tmf'F* ' fIJ*ftf57tt¥J 0JX ' Wi*4l1Jf~m.BPPJgMjr&:*~jjifJ:I¥J~JJIl ' ~ Jlt ' r f~m~f1. J ~fi~fJ;J,0ZP:l¥JfIlJ¥IEi!i ' If. ;i'I~JffBllH~0~~A=t (Fought, 1997a)' ~~1}. ~J:&:ffi]'tM0JX~Wm~~*I¥J~~o. 0. 9H~~t¥Jm~ , ~1Blm~m~M ' ffi±ttm~~. im~flU~mElJHI W~tzo~5}.!flJ~m31'I'1 ' ~r"lH.grmIE 0. *Ji!'it¥JAI~~' i&JffI1R)t;~:lI.fDtjf'I;G-f0JX~c~ l¥JiMr~ , 1IJI~~1H~1f®~q¥iJrm~~m'¥r:p. ••. ·*I3~MA.UWWi~000z~t¥JOO. , 53. ~ , fu'tM'l:nf§l.WJN2~JJ¥&~mr&:~~ft'l~ ~~~Wi~. -1nm 'i&Jfflli.¥:~~HfB7tWi*4~83131rm*~lf' 'tM~. 1383~r:p'i&Jff~mk~~~~~;G-f0JX~~t¥J. ~c:!1*~1i~ffi]§. 1997:52). , ~f!:!;im$/f~~m,~,. 0. W~1}JJJJi ' 1£t'5~~JJ~1f. ' i&Jffpg{fBim~ , ¥tIt!~c ~ , rm~~'1f ' J;J&fImAllIfk a ill1f-*fImA.fkfD i&Jff1i~0Imzrs~t¥Joo~ '~'l:nf§l~~f~m Bl$Ji1Wi. (Schiller,. 0. gr )t;:ff: i&JffftJ~glfB Jl!.flUffi 'Mi ~ 1i'¥4f~ mB9 r<l'l JI·~9H~~131f{ij-ft~:iJ<mf~1}$JJii&1fIl r:p~~. ~Z~. j(IDi,1i*4' tttt~gg1t;mmft!~13 B~:lL*ftlllt¥J'I:. i&Jff::E~t¥JJJ~f91JtzOIf!.~cif<. n1&l1i*4r:p$Jr2f!J~ 'W~tzo1£rmreMAWi;jqm~1Tm. n ' ~~1i;jq , ~~IDE~ , :ltt~¥tI~ , ftJ1Blm*,c~. mllfn ' WGq.~~E::~ , i&JfftzoffiJf'I~'Mi~ . fre:tfl ~ml/f~.m~~.~B9.~':ff:-@ • • t¥J~ M ' tzO*i&Jff/ff1:mWG~1!{t1J'Miti ' ffi]~ltfuJf(Ut: 1Nt~Wi*4 ' m)J!I!~lllfB~'Mi~~rmB91'Jm~JfEJ:1JD iff· i!:ff:~mi&1~0~~c~83i&Jff~~~' ~c~ffi}. ~':W1$&¥1J~ffl~I¥JMAWi;jq:fm~' ~ffi]~mll. I. ~~~~1J[I~~ (Glass, 1998). '. 0. ~yj!J:ff:1'1'1. ±;ttgfD/fIlJ~1i. A.fk:flW1i~01mt!1I5Uzrs'l¥Jft3tJ~. 0. i&1~~i&Jff~~@~ff1i;jqt¥J~~'~OO~. It ' rm~*fl~tzD~lH'J ' f#!:~0 ~J ' f01'Jm*J:l.~Mj:ff: ~®1i'¥4t¥J::E~fre:m~ . !1:iJ*~9tijlilli0JXt¥Jr.! II.
(12) ~ 41. :WJ. 'ffi~~~~~~~~~&~~~'0~~~~. ~JJJ~g , ~c1if1~ff<~~7~t'.J~lm fi5JiS{Rt~ruJ $~i1JOO. ~f~t¥~f2j.&~l¥!J1WAJff4~~~'J'li ,f:t:ff~.n~~~PJ. Jf ' ¥P~~~~~~ , ~~ruJ~F~$14!ff<~ , /f1~. ~gfjt~{WlAllifJ,.;fI . ii:~iJfIi?'U~~JiI~. , ~flHJ\rm Ji~ , ~mt~Ji:t£;£-f-J'L$I¥J~f§;cp 11)$14! f:t1n'1WAllifJ,.;fIf~J~*l\lIttf1JO (Gellman, 1998) , is{RtJllJt~~~71WA~*4f*mi~$14!~lII' fElf:tM. 1999 iF 12 Jj 15 B0{{p , 2002 iFJtJ::lj1];OOifJ' ~iffi~m~*.f!~~~~r~ittl*% F&.J'L$ , tE~~~$~/fJEt.JEI1T 12). 9~c1ifnt:i!I~m.n~~;fSI.~~~. ~'~&f*~M~Wm~~~I¥J~.oo~·~~:~. tB~. 0. 0. ~$In'. 0. ~*~~$§~:t£~:il::~*.f!~~~'. 0. 38 iF (1949-1987) ~:W;~WC~, :W;~~M~iS{ Rt$r~:f:E r {5tH~1~*3t~ J ;t § ~ , ~~*3t~W¥ ~~~~J:~ , 1TiS{A~ PJl~.c,\~iffi~l2-:il::~~~. ' ~. tlD*~nf2j.&rl§j~~J!{' 0~*c~~.n~1t, ~ iJ\0~$itUI¥J)Ii;.' 1-),&.n~W~~AD~~~~. , ~~~.n~f.R~)]¥&~I¥JWJ:t.J ' m~*EIln'fJ is{~~~~fl:1J' ~iJ\~p,'ijdt1t, t.J&1WAllIfJ,.;fIflJ , ~U~itU¥J.n~f.R~)]¥&~ftJm~fzl* ' :t£. ~miS{Rtm$tlmttmtmM¥&~~~mf5'E ,m~1&.~ ~*3t~~*ffi1£&ffm ' {llt!?, -~¥UjiiJ\0~r~~. ~~m:1Jwru::1Jzrs~ ,.nf§if.R~)]¥&~~~J!{fUf'j\jtJt. jltAJ'L$f§;~ , ~*~~$$tl1tl¥J~Jm::tOO~i1lJfiJ:. '~~*~~~m-W~&mM~~&. film. 0. EEIn'J'L$Ii7tJJJ~g/f~' §MiS{Rt~~~*~. ~~~~tl. ' 1JJmfflrriS{1i7t 1960 iFflJlfffl~1TiS{lfP1:J ~D r ~*~~~~¥JR$ J fD r 1TiS{li7tplTJI~ruJ~n~ ~fii3t~!1Ijim~W*l~~~UJ (2: 13) , §M~~jiiJ\0~$raJ*J'L$' Ji 0. ~;fSI.J$$illWJ¥&~:f:Et:J. ' PJ~~raJ:t£~~~~~~ *>c"~Hl!!t:il:::f:E={I~WCl~Jmj!fJ~ti : jnftil-Ml~~J ~¥n~Jlft~ ,t.J&~c~~.;;p.fE. 0. 1T1TiS{~~r~m:il::r ~~1TiS{jiiJ\z01m~~t.J$. ' ifftl. 14!~T:il::. 0. '. li~1n'1TiS{f§;~$0:ffl1&WJiFpg%~J'L. $ iFIJj18. EE$itU~~* ~~mttmt~~lm. 0. 0. ~iS{RtA~~~Jm'~*~~In't:J.~W'~~~. 1999 iF 2 Jj 3 B0fffl ' 2000 'iffiriS{Rtjim0~$~~J~ft. , ~~FiS{JfH~~51M'jiW~~ , iffi. ~iF5JjllB~ll$Ii7tW~o~~ff<rriS{~~$. ~~m~*~;£-f-~~~~'iffi~~iS{RtPJ~rm~. zm:il:: ' ~$~liR01m$,~1n' 90 iF 2 Jj 2 8 zM. ~~±~~~itUjim0~. %F&.J'L$ , {Et~WJJOOJ'L$Ii7tW~~*1i~%F&.W~. , fffi;;P~fUitU~j , ~lltt:J.flT MmtteplT~flj~~~itU ' tb1]~~~~~~~ziffi~ /fRo. 0. fTiS{Ii7ti'iIn'~r~tlOM%F&.J1:$' Jjff<1TiS{~~$jf. ;fI , In' 2001. WJ1liJ\EIEEfEl. 2 Jj 21 BgAP~~li7tltjj~:ffl r1TiS{ jiiJ\0~¥JR$ J ' {rmiS{Rt § Mm~1TiS{jiliR±!l1J &~Nitn000z~t!tl.ff$m r1TiS{J(iJ\0. ~~I¥J$~~~~~~$'~*~~$'.~MA. ~¥JR$J~m~~$~m~'~fJiS{lfP~~m~. ji;fSl.f*~$WJ1liJ\EIEE$~~~$14!°~~z,ji. z~~m;OOi' fffi~f~~G1iffj:i!IiS{Rtjim~~~>c. ~~:t£~$CPf:tln'mMEIEEW~-~f*mi~ ~rJ. '. EEl¥Jf*lI!~.Qg;;$14!mc~,. 0. ~~MAji;fSl.f*mi$~ § ~,~m~.n~~~. iJ\0ImfOiS{Rt~~f*ff: ' ~*~~ , ~~Aji;fSl.1*~. I¥J~B.J6\~JHjr~¥JJfM~. 0. 11lA~;fSI.I¥J~~iJ ' t.J~~1WAA~ffli5¥:~~ , ~f@. 0. i1! ~~AJ(;fSI.z'frrm~IjJ:~ .n~11lAj(tJ.f*~$~~ ~i&Rtmm!ItJ r 5:2:;:tit~CPJG\ J fffi~~~1~~ , ~. ~~$z§~:f:Em~cp*&~~iS{~~~~. 0. , ·t.J{~~~ImD~W~m ' ~fl~~ 12.
(13) j(;jSj.Jil[tttUJTIm : f51![j. ' ff4~!.fEl1t$'G~B"J$~:(£ 1995 if 8 Fl B£-:fti1&(tt 14) , Bfffij~ll3<:H1&:Jt~~fllJT~M. r j(;jSj.Jil[fmWJ*'i'Im¥&~ J. msJ1.~~i1f. 1N1&~IJ~~c~MA.*.B"Jr",'jj!j. 11. EET~'m,~~.R.fD~~1m1lRttfi!qB"J~~.. R1UljiilI1i1lR*~jB"J:E!ll.El3. 0. ~'mWk7~!lfJ3Q2_~~B"J0I~' ~~ttf1J[J7~c~. 0. ~%fla'$f01i1lR0!ffl$- B*lEJ3:;J1.$'-IT. ~~w.it~Ji1lRB"J~~ , ~1~~c~tt~/f~~5¥:¥U. ~$r'OO~ffJE~~%.a'lflB.B"J~WtljJ . ~f1I. m}&,~B"Jtlffl.jfDBlk~. r ~ffiU~~*1J J. (Koch, 1991) (il 16)~~ 0. B"JmlflB ' W~~c~jiilI~ffliI&JM1i Jlt:9i- . il&JMfufUffl r .]~MA.1iRf*. !lfJ~~~~o~c~j;J.H~f'F~A.~l[j}JfD*l£tm.*4. ~lf:J~.;E~0~flj~fEllU1B"J1i1lR 0 (ilI5). B"J.!j;I]' xl[iiffl:::'M3Q2_~~ 'aJng~**~~fj. ~Jlt§AA$~.~W~~~~ffl.R • • •m. ~~B"J ±~f~J3:; 0 19U~O~c~~~A.~~~3IJfXfIi~. tvl'~III/f~o. .;j6t' ~~'mH~7HJf' fEJw.~f1IA.~~~fD*l£iID1i. fl;fEI~/fflJ. Wj$ J. 0. ~DJlt '1f~~~A.~JiMl£tm1iRill~~~c~B"J±~m. ~~'~mM~ft:(£~~B"JmM~~~B"J~m f[J~~. RJlff~_¥UB"JjjR*aii- ' ~ff4~~c~B"J.~P'3~. 0. tt~Mfi!\!li*:i\i" ' 'm~.!j;I]~IDJ¥~~ , ~tt~i$*Jt. 0. ~~fj.~If'FB"Jii:~ , fffi/f~f1~ ; ~f$MC~~fj~. iJ.:ttB1ijHjl~~L1&~ft~~fi!\m!i:&~' ~13U~. tE 1990 if~~JJ:fI'mff~!HHH~~ j;J& 1993 ifff~ ilifiii-${tL1&' tl:fm 7ff~tt[l13!Nfifm!lfJ:W~~ .. ~If'FB"J~{$. ~'.ifi~~ff~~~±~B"Jm!lfJ1i1lR*~o.~. riUw..RJfflm~*~Nii1iJ~F';;O~ or .,~~jj*4. J. ~M~*.OO'~mm!~~m,~~mM:(£~~~. J'l1J~Ji1lRf4ttA.~B"J:W~ , ~ r Ji*4~~ J. m~~oo1t. .R• •!j;I]¥~~il!11HlIH*A~~mM ${!j:, ~*~c~?EffifFa'~~fDm1tJiR' 1JIlbi!!iii. m;t~B"JI{'F. ~f'FiIft§!!J~B9tt19tl/fiil' izslll:t~c~W~iiffl1iR. ~:E!ll. 'fa.§lt~OIl'lJff A. ±~~!lfJ~c~f~*m5~VIfi)1j. ~~mfD~~~~'~ID~rmM§~~Jo~~. mngjJ , fM{t(.fi~A.~~peJE~ B"JR ' ~Hc~ *~\5~:9i-m~gjJ ; {a~~c~~[J*~VIfi:9i-~B~gjJ , J'lIJm~~~~~ 7:: ~tl!!PJ j;J !EIf:~t~mmriU .~~:tI B"JJlffff1mfj [l'l]flB"J~:E!ll. . :(£**B"J.1lRffr±tt ' ~c ~~o*ng~~~.R.Bl:E!ll.1i1lRB"J~gjJ •J'lllW~n f':p~\~B"JmriUu:ft~§ , fu~fflEOO~~. 0. ~~'i$MCB"J:i\i"$~~mlVi:W~~~nI'~. 0. ' ~c~~~~~. r.~ J :W~. nJ'lU~El3~riUU:ftllJ~B"Jn I. 0. . ;l;tt:tifF>. ~f1I~it:~~a·L. 0. ~~·~ft~~mm!lfJB"J~OO·~W~mMB"J*ft :tmii/fw~,@g 1l3i~'m~'fffM±~m!lfJrra~· ~c~ 0. I~AA~~~~mSNG~~£~~~m!lfJm~B"J. 0. ~t.n~;~-IT~· fffi~l!!i~nf#l'mff~~~' f}PX.f~. ~M*~~~'~!lfJ.*• • ~~*~'fu.tt~ Jut~~.jJB"Jm~jlj%m!lfJ. , ~~F~~"rPJ. 0. ~c~tt$.~3Q2~¥~~Jlff5~B"J~,c)\M~' 'E1. 0. .R.~~.~~m-.mmttB"J~!lfJ~. fi5~!lfJBl:E!ll. ,.n~Blkf'F;;O~' j;J&~*a:~Ij=~B"J.. ~'W5~~A.jJ~jJ*~~m!lfJ*N'~ffi~lli. 1lR~:tI;;o~ ~::t1l!]~~~¥~2JB"J~fj~ '~c~PJ. ~.f41tii: . *~\w..OO1'J>It~lEtt ~:9i-Y:iJ:f~. tB • *El~*~ffjll:~JlB"J~f:ij: , ~~ff!lfJu:ft~fing* 1J~Wk.*4 • • ~B"JlUljt~* (Garrison, 1995). ng.:f El1f:ttf2~fflf1lf1ljj1lRBl:E!ll.B"J~~ , ~~c~.1lR Bl:E!ll.;;D~B9/f JE ' fu1±1±PJj;J*~El3:W~jjR1i1f:9GA. ~B"Jta!j;l] . fffi1~j;J~5m (Shelton, 1998) ~'mH&. ~fffi' ~mlift¥:±~.*.ft]lrPJt:t~OOLlY~*~1J!f~. ~~¥~~Bm11\f&' ~c~~*~5~1IiJ1.1'F~'1i. £f' fffi~F~riU~.jJ~P'3~&M'!!!*~ii:~~ffif' W. 1lRBl:E!ll.;;U~B"J5*fuIl3iLttf~ '{a~:(£~~JtP'3$. ~~C~~ffl.RJ!fi.fJfil~1Vi. ~fjEIJ~M!/f~~. 0. 0. 0. 0. '. M!.:f~~. 0. 13. 0. ,.
(14) ~1i- 3Z.1X. ( 19iJ~D Lee & Flaming, 1995). '. ~liffJ'GWi!~~1:E r A~~DfPJ1~~J1!~j(ID1 J ~Jl@~. iTM~::gW~j(~qfil!tQ::~JJ~2i'im~lt!tr&' fuJj[~. (iliM3Z ' ~~f= ' ~ttIB13 ' 1995) jTIj~ ~liiMWfJ'G::t~ , 1il~f§jiID1f4~'Wi:t~~~~e*~l'f -~~~ (19tl~D Dervin, 1990; Marchionini, 1997. 1~1±l. r~5W~. ~illJ~JJOA~*it~~f~&,cpo{g.~~·U:.tQ::~ill~~ f~ ~. y. ~'ill. 1993). 0. I{( (DeFleur & Devenport,. !i!IE~l'f~~~~~mll1~1j'~~~.~DiNVIlFf J:E.. ~). 0. 0. ~fTM~r~lE~j,:J~liliif§¥Nj(ID1f4~'Wi:t.~f§'. 1995; Lee & Flaming, 1995) , ~~flijj~ tfL1Ei (~D Herling, 1995) lfi~*:3Z~'B~ , mt!~Fij 1i8::f{I~Jlt, ~*JtiTM1$~r~pJT:t;lJ!f;!l:~~O~::f J:E. (Johnson, 1993:355)' m.~N7gffi1=.I¥J!IFl::W' ~l!d'B :::l":l'!J~Jil ~I¥Jmt~ jTIj ~{;ffl37tttliE:tl!~m~ r~*. {;;kfi. 31foJj,:Jif1Jz~. ~m1:E~~.~~JTM~m <*~¥~> ~~J1:j;i*4fil!~. (~D. Scott,. 0. 1:E~¥nOO'§M~~fuNl'f~.W~~iN. 0. r ~fifMmWJ1*~¥~2i J liirjl~f~. 0. m~Mf$.f-t~~. ~1=.il2l'f~,~~~ji*4fil!f1t~~~*WII~' j,:J:t!lliJ!li ;!tj;iID1~£!t!~~1J. 0. 0. frIJ1Il'f yl{(~~WfJ'Gr ~H1~mWJ1*IDJ~. *~Wi!#i. 0. 17)i5<:1tl*~m~M~1:E-if.M. 0. ~m~f'F1:t~~~J1:. ji*4~~ _J. I. --1M ' ~nJ3:: '. ~J lii@~]{:t~, :(£I~lf1illM~;ft~, il2~U~§Yt~. ~~ r 1~f~cp~ J. 2000) , ~~~,§fMff~JTM11t~A~ ~iti,. ( ~D~3~ , 1997) ,. ~*.~j5J~jljdi';-iij~jfTM1I!tJ~, fft~fij;i*4fil!cp ~*j(*4 ' 1'F~iTM¥~2i~tj ~ TME:$9cM~O~. ~.~tt~~nOO~WfJ'G~~'r&*~ffl*m~~. ~:;FJ:E.. 1:EiTM:¥1**I7-r~nfM~~~~It (~IJ.£mjUij,. (Learning by doing). 0. :W~Jt~, 1fi/f~fj~TI[~thbWJ~C~m~.~*I{'FCP~. ' <*~¥~> il2fD*~cplEliliF~'g~~:¥il 1'F ' :t;lJ!f;!l: r ji*4~~ J .~j5J~1:EIMWII~ ~{r~1ff. i1:l9~. ~ '~~~~]{~l¥Jilf'F' f'jg~f!J1tlii@~]{j~~~O~r&. 0. ~*itiTM~ff:fj~. ~~tt~9. 0. r ~OfPJ J. 0. J1!~j;i*4. ' mt;;fs:~ ~~m§c~~DfPJfftj(*4r~tI~iTM '. ~'.**~M~~n~~W~~j(*4fil!tIttiT. M. i:l1f'jEil2/f"~~:tl!j;i~~t~fijtJi3'jill~~ , ~J!:t~fr~'lWt~. 0. ( 1&ff.11i BM : 2002 if. 3 Fl 11 B ). ~A!!JKm~ij:§~~O~ , rri~18j;i*4~mWJ1*lW~~. a. 1: i»lm-~titiCP~i¥J(O($' ~~~ (~i5'~~. ~1. 2: ill:~@]~17IJ~~~(Bameet, 1995); (Miller, 1998) : (DeFleur, 1997) : ll¥dITi¥JlIl~PJtJ.~OO~i¥J~!llIL*~i&. , 1990). fifBtt2f'.<Wi~r.n*jijG3£~1l!U~~WJWil15~~litf~cp)L,(NICAR)?fiti:\~&a~Mflj. Uplink. 0. ~1 3: ~wr:;lE~F~ E§ 1JJ3fJ$liJ!!j{;J6t. , ftt!imff:l7 -iljf§~iiJ~*~$:1~r:~i¥JI~'~~11t!.!liJAj{;J6t ~f~~mJ~~~~Ull -if.i¥J1'F*~ra~1J~~~1il 1Ulm-¥~~3£3t~~ 1968 if. 12 fj 15 B (jf§i!iiJ~!W~¥ID 4: 1£ 1972 if.ra~ , ffil~i{£,WJ (..~~ro~~) ~c~E.fffij~ (Donald Bartlett) fDj:m~ (James Steele) fJjff:l.~ 0. 0. 0. 5ttJi'&tth$:jijGfI~ ,j;)1'f:f!X:I§j$:~Ma<J*JU~~ 'ill:.~~lte~~1i 1973 if.a<JttflIli~r.n~~!lJJ;. Albers (1994) 5:. 0. ~J!. 0. H~i&Jl~Ht.*~:lEmtMllli.D~±~' fgJjH~llliJi;J6tJ!J:;lE~F~$. .'. 14. 0. if!f~yM!§ti:\. '. ij!M.D~*MCa<Jmlff~.
(15) ~~~~~~~:~~r~~~.~~~m~j. 1997: 33) •. tt 6: -Wutzo o~~liIrm~~) gc1W Morris. ' iU!lH;:£tJD1jHt[jIj(}fflfXt~!m~1iTfH~OOm~ , ~rmtJD1i"jIj(Jff. 1989. •. Mf£f~J&~TitIE9~~. , ffH1HiP~~~~.~~.*fffitE*Mji.H~ ~~"t#!r&:~.n~m~ , .L-j-@!~m'iln~7Hfr ~3i!. Leonard (1992) •. 0. ~~WT,Q'~JlJim~~MAA~M~~OO. 0. tt 7:. trFJ5JT?Ij~ft:J~~, f*~~;fJ~~c1W1tib"ft:J~W1.ElEI3~~" ' 1'£ 19891f:Jtfifi.~c1W"~fiJf1'Faf,Ji~J~1ltMi* ~1iff~fllOlJ!~ 3i!.. (Quill,. 1990) ,. (DeFleur,. 1997:65-68,70). 0. 0. tt 8: 1'£ 19881f:-{il:~c1WloJ~g~$~tt~ , 11Lr=l1~{7J1!\fn~ , ~~IoJ:i¥:lIfA~.8'liJftiJrmi'iJ~@Hr ' ;H<.t:fA.ffJfA.!Ji'il. :nx.II/!t.!ii!.)E:. (1996). tt 9: flUf. r f7JiW6~Elai.ll~Jmlf>iil? 1ffIAtE 19831f:~mtJF~m1'£~&iI!IIi¥tlnJE ! J. ~3i!. Ray. (1996); Bivens. 0. ~ll:: ' ~m~1lt}Ejj~;J:t:fJtIfiT 15259 {tj:!l¥m$~~~~Bf,J~ftj: , ' il[¥IJ 1996 1t~1ffIIJt$~~~e*J!iZS{tj:~1Z9 ' 1i1f:~~ , ~PW-il[*~@]1f J1t9'f. Show (1994)i:M~~'WIH!lite ' i!1Hf*±iIWl 1993 loJ~jt!tL}'ti.'.$~~1iU;g~A.$-~cifcBf,J'ilH~m~ ~f}Hllt~;J:t:1ffI-T~llr8~.~~ . 0 'ti.'.fl'll~@JJt{*~~ , :f:~Jt~-.li~~lfX~~:t\7t ' ~H~mt;T1is~~~ . 0'ti.'.mrr J\tm~~m:t\ o :f:~~oom~Jt~jf!r1Jm{7JJB5'Cm ' ~JIt~mrrff!;jIlM~Bf,J;ftim ~fffi-f~~t)~ , ~m~T1~9'f. , ~.mz~pfi1ffIli~ -WUtzO-fll:jIj(}ff~]{ft:JIl~1W1!lite:i:~liW1.~l:Bf,JjIj(JfJ~]{: r , - Eljir~~PJf£JMlt~A1:E~· J -fi]~l§ii~Jm;EFF-jIj(Jff~%.fffi :f:.Bf,J£Jl~ 1ffI IJtjIj(JfH~145l:~~~ An § Bf,J11~J~l5f~ , ~ilBf,J~fMli:~~o , t)&-1H'iBf,J~IoJ@*a (Hyperlinks) t)~ • fl\j~f,tZ:g.i'iJ~* ~IE9i1i11:z"GiWift:JjIj(Jf.f~J[ , t9.1ffI4~~~Bf,Jtl~ , ~3i!. Johnson (1996). <~¥¥~~~) ~~?J. 0. 0. 0. 0. tt 10:. 0. 0. 0. tt II: fJ1JtzO::(f 1990 1f:f-l::fJJWl ' tJD1j'l-fll:'lfi:lft:Jmil.M:~~~~fiJT~ . 9~!/¥f*~~li~~1ltce~~1WBf,J11:tll:fffil~t) ff%. tt 12:. 0. ~f~$-ftj:il[~1JEr&:T 19941f:~m.~AllIfL1*~$~JI(OO$~ft:JJL$. 0. ~5?. Gellman (1998).. f!U.m~$m. 18 ft* ' m~i'!V&I1I~~m '~B~li~' Ilffi~m, ~~;U1if:l~.j;)JE&li~*1lt"Gi*4~ , JiT"Giif§lHlli~1W ' (t($~W(;~f-31ffI1*m~,U~1W . p)&;tt~~mlB!0;J:t:f!JfItW(;m'::::'A~iE~:fIfIt1W . ~~ lJm~mMS$~{'I§'OO. 0. tt 13: r [!ll!J~~W~~lIf$ J ~ 1960 1973. 1989 fF.'::::';;X~iE. 0. 2 J=l 26 El *i!1-jjIj(1ifG-Ei' 49 'ti.''¥m 1067 ~%;jJHffjMM=r ' ~~W~ 1965 r 1-jjIj(lifGfiJTJB~IHl'iln~~§!:~'ti.'~~"Gi1lf1.~mm'lB!~~IJ J ~Ij~ 1987 4 J=l 12 El. ~ffjIj(lIJC-Ei'. at 14 : at 15: at 16 :. 76 *i!'¥m 7501 ~%ili'Hffjaffiff • sltzW*J!::(f 1990 fF.~iE 1995 fF. 8 ~ 11 El.~(-)fl'¥m 5960 ~%~Wi!. 0. 0. fJ1JtzOi&Y€J.A.W*~ft:J"Gi~11:*'. r'iln~OOA"Gi*4f*lB!r*J ft:J1*lB!$r~1~JfEiii. , 1oJ*:ff:~Nlf*~If'Fcplil*ft:J1tfft. 0. : ~Nlff:m-IoJlJ!*~c1W£!if*mW~ ~0iE:§:Il' fIt~gc1W::(f.mIf'FJ:J11J5Z,Q,3JlfiJ~iE:a:ft:J'lfill: (fJ1JtzojIj(Jff~~~1WJf~) flf*ff!;j,\!j,*1{ . fffi1±tt~c1WBf,JIl~~rnlJtff!;j,\!j,*l{flf*Bf,Jm~J5JT~N~l . ~fDl=r:mBf,J~*;tt.1H§T nll (Koch, 1991 :64-5) 0. ~tzOfUJWi1tgce. 0. ~~~Lf~~~~~1;t1!\li$fUJf!iX:$-t~ilrjIJ$~m~Jl. '. 1±tlW~~~'W:~.ll~~f'dj~W1.f*~'lfill:Bf,J~Nit~fDrn.itFi~. 3&.. tt 17:. -W~tzO::(fZjSEl$X~~fjcp. ,. ~ff'H~ij! 'B~~1:.We*J! .. ~mJ(~5'.::(f:i:~"GiWi~L~~~. 15. ..
(16) ~~~~~.m.~r$#~.J~.*~0'~Bft~ffl.-ffi~~M*.~@.$tt~.~ffl~ .~o. H$r ' iU~U ~B. 0. .:.Er&l (2000). (2000) *JTM~c:'ffl¥J~~f~m 0. iiMflflfiHtL ' 3 M 5t.lIHWliiM¥mg!li c. : ~~l:BIt&;ji± ~H~.WlfrM¥~~l£tJ.¥~;ji±l¥Jfflm : j;JCPIilJIlif¥~ , Iftfjllif¥~§c:'ff~fiHtLfj~ iiM". .:.Effifij (2001 ) a. a. ~tJit. a. c. fflzt ' ~ 68 ~ , Jt 91-115 fI3~ (2000). : A~ S ¥~ , *JT¥~Jfd: ' cp~ S ¥~~c:'fffY!m~t.lI~D1f~~l¥J. 0. cp.flfl",it1f:itffilietfiHlMit ' tJ~t7~:l1L ; i!t$JTittg . --- ( 1997) ¥~~~~~ftl¥Jf!3lUJro~~l¥J~~ : ~~fj$JTIiflf!(~l¥J~. J&~1f'*:ll. ' ~tlax ' 71,~,lIt±~ , EJ,fSilfl!-lifffiJ®£gUR ~~ "'~ ptB~ (2000, Feb) *JTIifl~afll¥JliI:§tg IIlfWifilE"fU ' 36 Wj , Ji 15-27. (2001 ) *JTIifl~c:'ff~ofilJjl'*4~m i51:*$JTM;¥;~~ (2001/3/5) tJ~t : liIJ:ll.i5I:rb*"'*JTM;¥; iii1x ' ~1iIJ1= ' ptB~ (1995) lIm¥!(~JJ!~~®1i'~ ? ~f~ r ;jujflffij J ~i* ffM¥liHE ' 53 tI ' a. ~1iIJ.m~a~l¥J~n~m. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. :. ••. 0. a. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. ~. 13-53. 0. 0. 0. A Ibers, Rebecca R. (1994). Reporters Tap Data Power. Presstime, 15( 11 ), 34-39. Anderson, David (I 976). Investigative Reporting. Blomington. IN: Indiana University Press. Barnett, T. L. (ed.). (1995). 100 Computer-Assisted Stories. Columbia, Missouri: Investigative Reporters and Editors. Bass, Frank (2001). The Associated Press Guide to Internet Research and Reporting. Cambridge, Mass.: Perseus Publishing. Bivens, Larry (1996, July 5). Freedom of information: Ask and You Shall Wait. Detroit News, p.Al Carney, Scott (1998, July 26). Government Documents Online Increasing, But Not Meeting Objectives. Publishers' Auxiliary. Chamberlin & Splichal (1993). Protecting Access to Computerized Government Records. In 8. P. Semonche (Ed.), News Media Libraries: A Management Handbook (pp. 339-345). Westport, CT: Greenwood. Christopher, L. C. (1998). Technology and journalism in the electronic newsroom. In D. L. Borden & K. Harvey (Eds.), The electronic Grapevine: Rumor, Reputation, and Reporting in the New Online Environment (pp.. 123-141). Mahwah, New Jersey: LEA. Devenport, Fico & Weistock (1996). Computers in Newrooms of Michigans Newspapers. Newspaper Research Journal, 17 (3/4), 14-28. DeFleur, M. H. (1997). Computer-assisted investigative reporting : Development and methodology. Hillside, N.J.: LEA. 16.
(17) L. ji*4J!lifft1t¥JTtm : ~1M DeFleur, M. H. & L. D. Davenport (1993).. r ji*4J!liiMHtb~JTtm~~~ J. Innovation lag: Computer-assisted classroom vs. newsroom.. Journalism and Mass Communication Educator, 48 (2), 26-36. Friend, C. (1994). Daily newspaper use of computers to analyze'data. Newspaper Research Journal, 15 (1 ), 63-74. Garrison (1996). Online Services as Reporting Tools. Newspaper Research Journal, 22(2), 65-79. Garrison (1995). Computer-Assisted Reporting near Complete Adoption. Newspaper Research Journal, 22(2), 65-79. Gellman, Robert (1998, January 26). A Growing Conflict: Freedom Information and Privacy. Publishers' Auxiliary, pA. Henderson, 1. (1998). Arming the People with the Power Knowledge Gives: An OMB Watch Rtl)ort on the Implementation of the 1996 "EFOIA" Amendments to the Freedom of Information Act. Washington D.. c.: OMB Watch. Herling, T. J. (1995). Adoption of Computer Communication Technology by Communication FaCJ!!!y. AEJMC Annual Meeting: Washington, D. C Houston, Brent (1996). Computer-Assisted Reporting: A practical guide. N. Y.: St. Martins. Johnson, Judy. (1996, April). Government Web pages: The Lights are on, But Nobody is Home. The Electronic Library .J..1Q114 9-155 . Johnson, L. T. (1993). The Unconscious Fraud of Journalism Education. In B. P. Semonche (Ed.), News Media Libraries: A Management Handbook (pp. 354-366). Westport, CT: Greenwood. Koch, Tom (1991). Journalism for the 21 th Century: Online Information, Eelectronic Databases, and the News. Westport, Connecticut: Praeger. Lee, K. C. &. c.. A. Fleming (1995). Problems of Introducing Courses in Computer-Assisted Reporting.. Journalism and Mass Communication Educator, 50 (3), 23-35. Marchionini, G. (1997). Information Seeking in Electronic Environments. New York: Cambridge University Press. Meyer, P. (1991). The New Precision Journalism. Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University Press. Miller, Lisa (1998). Power journalism: Computer-assisted reporting. Fort Worth, Texas: Harcourt Brace. Mosco, V. (1998). The political economy of communication: Rethinking and renewal. Thousand Oaks, Calif. : SAGE Publications. Paul, Nora (1996). Computer assisted research: A guide to tapping on-line information. (3 rd ed.). S1. Petersburg,. FL: The Poynter Institute for Media Studies. URL:<http://www.poynter.org/poynterlchome.html>.. Pavlik, John V. (1996) Rewriting the editorial and creative process. In John V. Pavlik (Ed.). New media. technology: Cultural and commercial perspectives. (pp.184-206). Boston, Mass.: Allyn and Bacon.. Ray, Ricard (1996, July 4). Access to Public Information Still a Fight. Detroit News, p. AI. Shaw, Russel (1994). Record Fees. American Journalism Review, November, 44-46.. 17.
(18) Shear, Ellen (1998, April 18). State Personal Records Becoming Harder to Get. American Editor. Shelton, Keith (1998, January 24). Lone Star CAR. Editor & Publisher, pp.23-24. Scott, S. D. (1995). The Technological Challenge for Curriculum and Instruction. Journalism and Mass Communication Educator 50 (2) , 30-41. Splichal, S. L., & B. Chamberlin (1994). The Fight for Access to Government Records Round Two: Enter the Computer. Journalism Research Journal, 71(3), 550-560. Splichal, S. L. (1993). How Florida Newspapers are Dealing with Access to Computerized Government Information. Journalism Research Journal. 13/14 (4 & 1), 73-83. RTNDF (1996). Wired journalist: Newsroom guides to the Internet. (Revised second edition). Washington, D. C.: Radio and Television News Directors Foundation. Williams, M. (1998). The State of Database Today: 1999. Gale directory of databases. G. R. Inc., Gale Research.. 18.
(19)
相關文件
: joint hearing before the Subcommittee on International Economic Policy, Export and Trade Promotion and the Subcommittee on East Asian and Pacific Affairs of the Committee
– Write special code to protect against system crashes – Optimize applications for efficient access and query – May often rewrite applications. • Easier to buy a DBMS to handle
熟悉 Microsoft Windows Server 作業系統、Microsoft SQL Server 資料庫伺服器及 IIS 網頁伺服器等 環境。.
利用 Microsoft Access 資料庫管理軟體,在 PC Windows 作業系 統環境下,將給與的紙本或電子檔(如 excel
拿起一朵刨花,精細的製作手法再再顯現了製作者的用心,這朵刨花
1、曾擔任以國家、重要城市為名,至少以二個版面以上刊登國際 新聞,且發行對象以全國或全球讀者為目標之平面媒體或通訊 社(例如:《美國新聞與世界報導》(U.S. News
利用 Microsoft Access 資料庫管理軟體,在 PC Windows 作業系 統環境下,將給與的紙本或電子檔(如 excel
透過 Java Servlet 程式存取資料庫.