H3Ǻόԋҥ
่ፕǺޣჹαຑፕኧໆޑख़ຎำࡋǴჹႝηαౢғ༾১ޑॄӛቹ ៜǶ
ҁଷҞޑӧܭΑှαຑፕޑኧໆࢂցჹႝηαٰ҅ӛޑቹៜǴ
ᡍϐࡕளޕ่݀ࣁόᡉЪБӛᆶচҁଷޑ࣬ϸǴӢԜόԋҥǴαຑፕޑ ኧໆ༾১ॄӛቹៜႝηαǶ
ᇡࣁǴჹܭౢࠔ܈୍ܺޑαຑፕኧଯਔǴޣૈԖ׳ӭޑα
ёаୖԵǴӢԜᇡࣁёߞࡋၨଯǶόၸჴϐࡕวǴޣჹαຑፕޑ ኧໆ٠όӵځдӢનख़ຎǴЪኧໆຫӭჹႝηαϸԶԖॄӛޑቹៜǴচӢё
ૈࢂࢌৎᓓαޑຑፕኧၸӭޑਔংǴޣؒԖᒤݤӄ᎙᠐ֹǴԶၗૻ
ޑϣёૈ҅ॄय़ຑሽࡐӭǴӧၗૻၸӭޑݩΠǴޣؒԖᒤݤ܄ޑղ ᘐᓓޑᓬӍǴЪёૈ࣮ډαኧໆϼӭǴౢғ॰࡙ޑЈǴϸԶؒԖ᎙᠐ޑ ཀᜫǴӢԜ٬ளຑፕޑኧໆຫӭǴჹႝηαޑॄӛቹៜߡຫεǶ
Ѥǵຑፕޑຑሽϩଛࠠᄊჹႝηαਏ݀ޑቹៜ
H4Ǻԋҥ
่ፕǺޣჹຑፕϩଛࠠᄊޑख़ຎำࡋǴჹႝηαਏ݀ౢғ҅ӛቹៜǶ ҁଷҞޑӧܭΑှຑፕޑຑሽϩଛࠠᄊჹႝηαਏ݀ࢂցԖ҅ӛޑቹៜǴ Զၸᡍϐࡕ่݀ࣁᡉԋҥǴж߄ຑሽϩଛࠠᄊǴჹႝηαਏٰ݀
҅ӛޑቹៜǶ
ӵ݀ӧᆛၡჹܭࢌৎᓓޑຑሽࢂठћӳǴ܈ࢂठᇡࣁόӳޑ၉Ǵ
ޣӛ࣬ߞຑሽޑϣǴӢࣁ೭ኬ߄Ңεৎჹ೭ৎᓓޑ࣮ݤठǴߡ
ᇡӕαޑϣǶԶαޑຑሽόठਔǴޣค܌வǴόޕၰবБω
ࢂ҅ዴޑǴӵԜٰߡ٬ޣؒᒤݤ࣬ߞαޑϣǶ
ϖǵαБӛᆶᆣϯำࡋჹႝηαਏ݀ޑቹៜ
H5Ǻԋҥ
่ፕǺޣჹαޑຑፕБӛᆶᆣϯำࡋޑख़ຎำࡋǴჹႝηαਏ
݀ౢғ҅ӛቹៜǶ
ҁଷҞޑӧܭΑှαޑБӛᆣϯำࡋǴࢂցჹႝηαౢғ҅ӛޑ ቹៜǶᡍϐࡕ่݀ࣁᡉԋҥǴϷޣຫख़ຎαޑຑፕБӛᆣϯำࡋ ਔǴჹႝηαਏ݀ޑ҅ӛቹៜ൩ຫεǶ
αኞޣჹࢌৎᓓޑຑሽठਔǴޣߡӛ࣬ߞαϣǴচ Ӣࢂ೭ж߄ԜαኞޣڀԖёߞࡋǴόᇸܰᙯᡂдჹᓓޑᄊࡋǶα
ኞޣჹᓓޑຑሽϸϸᙟᙟǴલЮठ܄ǴޣჹԜαኞޣޑ܄
аϷᄊࡋౢғ፦ᅪǴӢԜߡό࣬ߞԜα܌ຑፕޑϣǶќБय़Ǵऩαϣ
௶ॊၨࣁύޭഋॊǴԶߚкᅈᆣ܄ӷਔǴޣКၨᜫཀௗڙαϣǶ
ޣ࣮ډαޑϣкᅈㄐጜӷѡǴᇡࣁԜαኞޣޑЈᄊॶள፦ᅪǴ
ԖёૈࢂჹЋණวᆛၡᖳقǴ׆ఈᡣᓓޑຑሽफ़եǴωࡺཀቪркᅈᆣ܄
ޑຑሽϣǶ
Ϥǵၗૻᙦࡋჹႝηαਏ݀ޑቹៜ
H6Ǻԋҥ
่ፕǺޣჹαၗૻᙦࡋޑख़ຎำࡋǴჹႝηαਏ݀ౢғ҅ӛቹ ៜǶ
ҁଷҞޑӧܭΑှαϣޑၗૻᙦࡋǴࢂցჹႝηαਏٰ݀҅
ӛޑቹៜǶᡍϐࡕޑ่݀ࣁᡉԋҥǴ߄Ңޣຫӧཀαϣޑၗૻᙦ
ࡋਔǴჹႝηαਏ݀҅ӛቹៜຫεǶ
ޣӧ᎙᠐αϣਔǴགڙޑᆣऩၨࣁܫǴЪࣁඍזޑਔংǴჹ ܭЎകޑϣ൩КၨܰௗڙǶ೭ঁЋݤΨததၮҔӧჴ୍Ǵޣڙቶ
ϣນ܌གਔǴჹԜቶڀԖၨଯޑӣᏫࡋǴΨᡣቶᡂளၨࣁԖਏǶ
ޣӧ᎙᠐ֹαЎകࡕǴགډ҅य़܈ࢂॄय़ޑᆣਔǴჹЎകϣޑӑ ຝКύҥᆣਔଯǶٯӵǴޣ࣮ډαᙚޑϣඔॊԖ፪ǴԶԖඍ৹ ޑЈਔǴ൩ჹЎകϣౢғӑຝǴΨගଯჹᓓޑӳགࡋǹќБय़Ǵ
ޣ࣮ډচҁ഻ޑᓓǴӧԖαϩ٦ޣගϷǴᓓᗺޑНྗςόऩа۳Ǵ ԜਔޣߡགڙډѨఈޑॄय़ᆣǴԶቚуΑჹԜЎകޑӑຝǶ
ќБय़ǴЎകϣӭኬ܄ำࡋຫଯǴΨ൩ࢂϣຫߏǵߕԖྣТаϷ
ပೱ่ਔǴᡣޣჹαϣ׳Ԗᑫ፪Ǵӧ BBS ǴҗܭόૈܫறՅޑკ ТᔞǴӢԜαኞޣ೯தߕပޑೱ่ǴЎകϣኬǴՠߕΑᓓ ᗺޑྣТǴቚуΑЎകޑё࣮܄Ǵޣ൩ૈόѝЎകޑϣٰགྷႽᓓᗺޑ ኬηǴڙډЎകϣቹៜޑำࡋΨ൩ᡂள׳ଯΑǶ
Ύǵௗԏޣவӛჹႝηαਏ݀ޑቹៜ
H7Ǻԋҥ
่ፕǺޣޑவӛǴჹႝηαਏ݀ౢғ҅ӛቹៜǶ
ҁଷҞޑӧܭΑှޣҁيޑவӛຫଯǴࢂց൩ჹႝηαٰ
ຫଯޑ҅ӛቹៜǶҗᡍၸࡕǴ่݀ࣁᡉԋҥǴ߄Ңޣҁيޑவӛ ຫଯǴ൩҅ӛቹៜႝηαਏ݀Ƕ
ޣவӛำࡋଯਔǴ൩ࡐܰڙډдΓཀـޑቹៜǶӢԜऩ೭ᅿ ᜪࠠޑޣӧԖဂᡏᓸΚޑݩΠǴܰӢࣁεϩޑΓӕཀࢌౢࠔ܈ࢂ
୍ܺॶளᖼວǴԶᡣдჹࢌౢࠔޑᖼວཀᜫቚуǴ܈ࢂቚуჹচҁόགྷᖼວޑ
ౢࠔϐᑫ፪Ǵ٬ளαਏ݀ቚமǶ
Ζǵௗԏޣำࡋჹႝηαਏ݀ޑቹៜ
H8Ǻόԋҥ
่ፕǺޣޑࡋǴჹႝηαਏ݀ౢғॄӛቹៜǶ
ҁଷҞޑӧܭΑှޣҁيޑவӛຫଯǴࢂց൩ჹႝηαٰ
ຫଯޑ҅ӛቹៜǶҗᡍၸࡕǴ่݀ࣁόԋҥǴ߄Ңޣҁيޑவӛຫ ଯǴ൩҅ӛቹៜႝηαਏ݀Ƕ
ᇡࣁޣჹҞࠔจᏱԖၨӭޑޕਔǴКٗ٤ѝԖᗺ܈ֹӄ
ؒԖ࣬ᜢޕޑΓόܰڙډαਏ݀ޑቹៜǶࡋଯޑޣόӵӕ
ࡋၨեޑޣǴததӧᆛၡཛྷ൨ၗૻǴЪдॺόܰڙډႝηαޑቹៜǴ Զࢂ٩ᏵдॺҁيޑޕǴٰղᘐαޑёߞࡋǶՠჴ่݀วǴ
ำࡋຫଯޑޣǴϸԶຫݙཀαޑϣǴҗӭ᎙᠐αၗૻѐቚуԾ ρޑჹܭᓓޑޕǴԖ٤ޣޑࡋёૈ൩ࢂவӭ၌Ԗᜢᓓޑၗૻࡕ ԶಕᑈቚуޑǴӢԜޣޑำࡋຫଯǴ൩҅ӛቹៜႝηαޑਏ݀Ƕ
ΐǵႝηαਏ݀ჹᖼວཀӛаϷαᙯཀᜫޑቹៜ
H9Ǻԋҥ
่ፕǺޣჹႝηαਏ݀ޑख़ຎำࡋǴჹᖼວཀӛౢғ҅ӛቹៜǶ ҁଷҗᡍၸࡕǴ่݀ࣁᡉԋҥǴ߄Ңႝηαਏ݀ຫଯǴჹޣ ޑᖼວཀӛຫԖ҅ӛޑቹៜǶ
Γሞٰྍޑૻ৲ቹៜޣޑ،ǴӢԜαӧޣຑᖼວ،ۓਔࣁ ख़ाޑୖԵ٩ᏵǶޣӧᆛၡ၌ԖᜢᓓޑၗૻǴЪԜαਏ݀ࡐεਔǴ ൩ჹቚமޣޑᖼວཀӛǶҗܭᆛሞᆛၡޑᑫଆǴޣຫٰຫܰཛྷ൨ډ Ԗᑫ፪ᓓޑၗૻǴЪᇡࣁǴαޑਏ݀Кቶਏ݀ᗋाԖቹៜΚǴ٬
ளޣᇡࣁႝηαޑख़ा܄ቚуǴӢԜΨᡣѬቹៜԾρޑ،ۓǶ
H10Ǻԋҥ
่ፕǺޣჹႝηαਏ݀ޑख़ຎำࡋǴჹᙯཀᜫౢғ҅ӛቹៜǶ ҁଷҗᡍၸࡕǴ่݀ࣁᡉԋҥǴ߄Ңႝηαਏ݀ຫଯǴჹޣ ޑαᙯཀᜫຫԖ҅ӛޑቹៜǶ
ѐᓓࢂຬၸٿঁΓаǴӢԜޣ࣮ډԖᑫ፪ǵ܈ϣᙦ
ޑᓓᙚЎകਔǴߡགྷाעЎകᙯ๏ᒃܻӳ϶ॺޕၰǴऩჹБΨ഻೭ৎ ᓓǴ൩ёаଆѐǹϸϐǴऩޣᇡࣁԜα܌ٰޑਏ݀ࡐեǴ
ޣჹܭע೭ጇЎകᙯрѐޑཀᜫΨफ़եǶӢԜޣຫख़ຎႝηαޑਏ
݀ਔǴ൩٬ளᙯޑཀᜫቚуǶ
ಃϖക ่ፕᆶࡌ
ӧҁകύǴಃஒਥᏵകޑᡍϩ่݀ǴଞჹΟঁࣴزҞޑǴࣴ
زว٠ளр่ፕǶಃΒ߾ஒჹܭᆅჴ୍य़ගрࣴزଅᆶࡌǶಃΟ߾
ࢂᇥܴҁࣴزϐज़ڋࣁՖǶӧനࡕಃѤஒࡌ҂ٰࣴزวޑБӛǶ
ಃ ࣴزวᆶ่ፕ
ǵቹៜႝηαਏ݀ޑȨૻ৲ϣȩӢનаϷځख़ा܄
ޣӧ᎙᠐Ԗᜢࠔ܈୍ܺޑαૻ৲ਔǴதҗܭૻ৲ϣࢌ٤܄Ǵ ቹៜډдჹܭૻ৲ޑёௗڙࡋаϷౢғుڅޑӑຝǶҗҁࣴزჴวǴቹៜ
ႝηαਏ݀ޑȨૻ৲ϣȩӢનԖǺ
ϣၗૻ܄
ຑፕޑຑሽϩଛࠠᄊ
αБӛᆶᆣϯำࡋ
ၗૻᙦࡋ
аΠ߾൩ૻ৲ϣӢનঁձǺ
1. ϣၗૻ܄
αޑϣᡏჹޣԶقࣁԖǴΨ൩ࢂૈ಄ӝޣ܌ሡ ਔǴޣ׳ݙཀαޑϣǵӣགྷࡋΨၨଯǴӢԜٰΑ׳εޑႝηα
ਏ݀ǶԶقӧቶޑሦୱύǴޣᇡࣁቶޑϣޕځىޑౢࠔ
ၗૻǴЪ٬ޣᅈཀਔǴᖼວޑՉࣁωԖёૈౢғǴӢԜၗૻ܄ຫଯޑቶǴ
ځሽॶޑຑሽΨຫଯǶԶӧαՉᎍޑᔈҔǴޣૈவଯၗૻ܄ޑα
ύǴפډќځᅈཀޑၗૻਔǴ൩ჹԜαౢғၨӳޑຑሽǴΨቚуα
܌ᙚޑౢࠔ܈ࢂ୍ܺޑӳགࡋǶ
2. ຑፕޑຑሽϩଛࠠᄊ
ႝηαЎകϣࣣևठ܄ޑຑሽਔǴޣКၨߞҺຑፕϣǴ ջჹεࣣԖ࣬ӕᄊࡋޑᒧ߄Ңᇡӕ(ಡ܃Ǵ҇ 97)Ƕҗҁࣴزϩ่݀
ளޕǴຑፕޑຑሽϩଛࠠᄊჹႝηαਏ݀ڀԖᡉޑ҅ӛቹៜǴӵ݀ӧᆛၡ
ჹܭࢌৎᓓޑຑሽࢂठћӳǴ܈ࢂठᇡࣁόӳޑ၉Ǵޣӛ
࣬ߞຑሽޑϣǴӢࣁ೭ኬ߄Ңεৎჹ೭ৎᓓޑ࣮ݤठǴߡᇡӕαޑ ϣǶԶαޑຑሽόठਔǴޣค܌வǴόޕၰবБωࢂ҅ዴޑǴ ӵԜٰߡ٬ޣؒᒤݤ࣬ߞαޑϣǶӢԜऩαඔॊࢌᓓޑᓓ ᗺऍښёαਔǴж߄εӭኧΓࣣᇡࣁԜᓓගٮޑ१ނӳӞǴ܌аᓓޑຑሽ ൩ϲǴ֎Ї׳ӭޣޑݙཀǶ
3. αБӛᆶᆣϯำࡋ
αϩ٦ޣჹܭࢌৎᓓޑຑሽࣣࣁठ(ࣣࣁӳǵᚯ܈ද೯)ਔǴ
ޣӛ࣬ߞԜϩ٦ޣޑຑፕϣǴӢࣁ೭ж߄ϩ٦ޣԾρჹᓓڀԖۓ ޑߞۺаϷᄊࡋǴόᇸܰڙډቹៜǴӢԜϣΨڀԖۓޑϷёߞࡋǶ ԶӧᆣϯำࡋБय़ǴЎകޑϣഋॊၨόύޭǴܴᡉкᅈㄐጜϷᆣ܄ӷ
ਔǴޣᜤаௗڙԜϩ٦ޣޑαϣǴБय़ࢂӢࣁ೭ёૈࢂჹЋᓓ
ӧᆛၡวѲόჴૻ৲ǴᡣޣჹٗৎᓓౢғόߞҺགǹќБय़
ޣᇡࣁǴวѲ೭ᜪЎകޑϩ٦ޣޑำࡋၨեǴӢԜၨόௗڙαϣ
Ƕ
4. ၗૻᙦࡋ
ЎകޑၗૻᙦࡋΨჹႝηαਏ݀ౢғ҅ӛޑቹៜǶЎകޑၗૻᙦ
ࡋջࢂࡰϣ๏᎙᠐ޣޑགڙǴаϷЎകϣޑӭኬϯำࡋǶޣӧ᎙
᠐ֹαЎകࡕǴགډ҅य़܈ࢂॄय़ޑᆣਔǴჹЎകϣޑӑຝКύҥ
ᆣਔଯǶќБय़ǴЎകϣӭኬϯำࡋଯǴΨ൩ࢂЎകӷኧၨӭǴԖᆛ ᇞೱ่аϷྣТϩ٦ਔǴޣၨᜫཀ᎙᠐ЎകǴΨჹЎകϣౢғၨଯ ޑᑫ፪Ƕ
Βǵௗԏޣҁي܄ჹႝηαਏ݀ޑቹៜ
ҁࣴزჴ่݀วǴӧௗԏޣҁي܄ύǴȨவӛȩჹႝηαਏ
݀ౢғ҅ӛቹៜǴԶȨำࡋȩБय़ǴᆶҁࣴزଷႣෳϐБӛ࣬ϸǴΨࢂ
ჹႝηαԖ҅ӛޑቹៜǴаΠஒଞჹٿঁᡂኧӚձǶ
1. ௗԏޣவӛ
ޣޑவӛၨଯਔǴߡܰڙډдΓཀـޑቹៜǴԶׯᡂচҁ ჹᓓޑགྷݤǴѐவεӭኧΓޑཀـǶӧᆛၡШࣚύǴޣѝाѺрᓓ
ޑᜢᗖӷǴ൩рኧҞᚳεޑαၗૻගٮ๏ޣୖԵǴԶق
ޣ࣮ډεӭኧΓࣣᙚࢌৎᓓਔǴ൩ჹ၀ᓓޑӳགࡋቚуǴԶቚу ځཀᜫǶவӛำࡋଯޑޣǴၨᜫཀவдΓޑཀـǴѝाԖΓ ᇥᓓӳӞǴ൩ᆉޣҁيᇡࣁٗৎᓓ࣮ଆٰද೯ǴΨׯᡂдЈύޑགྷ ݤǴቚуΑдѐޑཀᜫǴӵԜٰߡቚமႝηαޑਏ݀Ƕ
2. ௗԏޣำࡋ
ҁࣴزႣයௗԏޣำࡋຫଯǴཛྷ൨αၗૻޑԛኧ࣬ჹٰᖱၨեǴΨ
ၨόܰڙډαਏ݀ޑቹៜǴӢԜଷำࡋଯჹႝηαਏ݀ౢғॄ
ӛޑቹៜǶёࢂჴ่݀วǴޣำࡋଯǴ߾ჹႝηαਏ݀ౢ
ғ҅ӛޑቹៜǶҁࣴزᇡࣁǴӢࣁ೭٤ޣҁيޑࡋǴ൩ࢂҗ᎙᠐α
ၗૻԶቚуޑǴ Brucks (1985)ၸѐࣴزௗԏޣࡋϐၗǴځύԖ൳ ጇፕЎଷௗԏޣࡋᆶཛྷ൨ၗૻԛኧԋ҅КǴӢԜдॺӧၗૻޑᇆ٠ όၨեࡋޑޣեǶำࡋຫଯޑޣǴϸԶຫݙཀαޑϣ
Ǵҗӭ᎙᠐αၗૻѐቚуԾρޑჹܭᓓޑޕǴӢԜௗԏޣޑ
ำࡋǴΨჹႝηαਏ݀ౢғ҅ӛޑቹៜਏ݀Ƕ
Οǵႝηαਏ݀ჹᖼວཀӛаϷαᙯཀᜫޑቹៜΚ
ҁࣴزჴ่݀วǴႝηαਏ݀ჹᖼວཀӛаϷαᙯཀᜫࣣԖ҅ӛ ޑቹៜਏ݀Ƕ
җܭႝηαεӭኧࢂҗε܌ኗቪӧᆛၡޑૻ৲ǴჹޣԶقǴ дॺࢂж߄ޑ٠όࢂቷǴԶࢂႽдيᜐޑᒃܻӳ϶ޑද೯ΓǴӢԜၨ
ܰௗڙႝηαޑૻ৲ǶҗܭᆛၡޑᑫଆǴޣຫٰຫܰӧᆛၡᇆډԖ ᜢᓓޑαၗૻǴαޑϣΨ൩ӢԜჹޣޑᖼວ،ۓౢғቹៜǶ
ᇡࣁǴαޑቹៜਏ݀εܭቶਏ݀Ǵ٬ளޣᇡࣁႝηαޑख़ा܄ቚуǴ ӢԜΨᡣѬቹៜԾρޑ،ۓǶ
ќБय़ǴᆛၡޑᑫଆԋၗૻኞၨၸѐِೲǴޣѝाᗺΠࡪᗖǴ ൩ૈஒαޑૻ৲ኞ๏Ծρيᜐޑᒃܻӳ϶Ǵ܈ࢂܫډёаᡣ׳ӭΓ࣮ډޑ ѳѠǶޣ࣮ډԖᑫ፪ǵ܈ϣᙦޑᓓᙚЎകਔǴߡགྷाעЎക ᙯ๏ᒃܻӳ϶ॺޕၰǹϸϐǴऩޣᇡࣁαϣؒԖЇวдޑᑫ፪Ǵ܈ࢂؒ
ԖՅϷೀਔǴαᙯޑཀᜫΨफ़եǶӢԜޣຫख़ຎႝηαޑਏ
݀ਔǴ൩٬ளᙯޑཀᜫቚуǶ
ಃΒ Չᎍཀ఼
җܭεӭኧޣၨ࣬ߞαૻ৲ޑϣǴቶςคݤӆѺޣ ޑЈǴӢԜႝηαޑख़ा܄ჹҾٰᇥςВቚуǶќБय़ǴᆛၡၲΓΨອ
೭ި॥ዊ౦ैँଆǴ೭٤નΓᏧԾρޑӧᆛၡШࣚኖଆТϺǴӢࣁ֎
ЇΑӭޣᢀ࣮дॺޑЎകǴԶ֎ЇΑӭቷගٮ၂Ҕǵ၂ӞǴࣗԿࢂௗ
ډቶᐒǴӢԜຫٰຫӭΓ׆ఈԾρޑЎക܈ပૈ֎Їډ׳ӭΓᢀ࣮Ƕ ჹܭҾаϷགྷाԋࣁཥжၲΓޑပ࠼ǴҁࣴزஒගраΠࡌǶ
ǵαϣᔈቚуၗૻ܄аϷӭኬ܄
ҁࣴز่݀วǴऩαޑϣၗૻ܄ᆶၗૻᙦࡋޑӭኬ܄ଯǴ
ޣߡၨݙཀαޑϣǴௗڙࡋΨၨଯǶӢԜჹܭགྷ֎Ї׳ӭΓ᎙᠐ޑα
ϩ٦ޣǴдॺᔈ၀ाӃΑှޣ׆ఈ࣮ډࣗሶኬޑϣၗૻǴٯӵᓓ
ޑᓓᗺаϷ୍ܺӳόӳǴ܈ࢂᓓޑӦՏǵᓓᗺޑᜪࠠǴᔈ၀ஒ೭ ٤ޣݙཀޑၗૻඔॊమཱǴаቚуϣޑၗૻ܄ǶќБय़ǴЎക ϣޑӭኬ܄Ψቹៜႝηαਏ݀ǴЎകύନΑуΕа܌ගޑၗૻϐѦǴ ඔॊޑϣᔈӭЪ၁ಒǴӧϟಏᓓਔᔈܫΕᓓѦᢀаϷᓓᗺޑྣТკ ТᇶշǴ൩ૈ֎ЇޣޑݙཀǶаPTTऍ१ހࣁٯǴҗܭBBSࢂคݤ
ၩ࣬ТޑǴӢԜதԖӭαϩ٦ޣஒԾρޑပೱ่ܫӧBBSЎകύǴऩ
ࢂޣགྷा࣮׳၁ಒޑྣТਔ൩ёаᗺ᎙ѐǴӵԜٰٗ٤ؒԖပ
ೱ่ޑЎക൩ѨѐΑ֎ЇΚǴӢԜऩࢂӧBBSǴऩૈуΕပޑೱ่Ǵ൩
ૈቚуޣ᎙᠐ޑΚǴΨቚуပޑΓǶ
ќБय़Ǵαϩ٦ޣΨᔈᗉխ٬ҔၸࡋᆣϯޑЎӷ௶ॊǴऩࢂޑ ӧᓓύᎁڙډόޑ୍ܺǴΨᔈ٬ҔύޭഋॊޑБԄǴᡣޣమཱޑΑ
ှวғၸำǴԶߚѝࢂㄐጜǶԶჹܭᓓޑᄊࡋΨᅰໆόाᇸܰᙯᡂǴᙯᡂ
ਔΨᔈᇥܴҗǴωૈό٬ޣჹαϩ٦ޣѨѐߞҺགǶჹҾԶقǴ αΨόѨࣁᅿԖΚޑ࠹БԄǴҞςԖӭࠔจ܈ࢂᓓፎပ࠼ኗ ቪ၂Ҕ܈၂ӞޑЈளǴӢԜҾёаा೭٤ပ࠼ᔈ၀ቪрॊගډޑ൳
ঁख़ᗺǴа֎Їډ׳ӭޣ᎙᠐ǴᕇڗനεޑਏǶ
ΒǵҾᔈӧᆛઠࢎࠔ܈୍ܺޑፕ
αޑቹៜΚமεǴЪኞೲࡋזೲǴӢԜࡐܰ൩ቹៜౢࠔࠔจ
ຝǴ܈ࢂ۫ৎޑᎍ୧ኧໆǶҾऩӧᆛઠࢎፕǴόѝૈගٮޣ
ঁᆶࠔจೱ่ޑѳѠǴቚуޣޑ۸၈ࡋǴҾΨૈၨܰޑᇆ
ډԖᜢޣჹౢࠔ܈୍ܺޑཀـǴΨჹޑׯԖཱུεޑշǶќ
Бय़ǴऩԖჹҾޑౢࠔ܈୍ܺԖॄय़ޑཀـਔǴҾૈӧಃਔ໔๏ϒ ӣᔈǴૈനזޑӒᐒೀǴаխޕၰॄय़ૻ৲ޑΓຫٰຫӭǴډคݤڋ ޑӦǶ
ಃΟ ࣴزज़ڋ
ҁࣴزᗨΚᝄᙣ၁ᅰǴՠ٩ฅڙډѦӧӢનޑቹៜǴԶԖࣴزޑज़ڋǴ аΠҁࣴزϐࣴزज़ڋǺ
1. ၗᇆޑज़ڋ
ҁࣴز٬ҔᆛၡٰวܫୢڔǴЪ༤เޣૈளډλᘶނǴӢԜεϩᆛ϶
ࢂЬ༤เҁୢڔǴჹܭคཀᜫ༤เޣޑၗ߾คவளޕǶќБय़Ǵҗܭᆛ ၡᓎቨज़ڋǴᆛၡೲࡋϼᄌਔჹ༤เޣޑЈԋቹៜǴԶ٬ளเᚒݩ ёૈԖ܌ୃᇤǶ
2. ༤เኬҁޑज़ڋ
ҁࣴزୢڔวܫӦᗺࣁѠεץ፮፮ჴ֝Ǵҗܭεӭኧޑᆛ϶ࣁᏢғǴԃ សቫΨୃեǴεϩύӧ19ډ25ྃϐ໔ǴၨલЮځдԃសቫаϷՉޑཀـǴ ӢԜӧᔈҔሡӭуݙཀǶ
3. ख़ፄ༤เޑज़ڋ
җܭҁࣴزวܫӦᗺࣁѠεץ፮፮ჴ֝Ǵᆛ϶ёаӕਔᏱԖӭঁIDǴӢ ԜᗨฅҁࣴزςճҔᔠմନख़ፄIDаϷIPٰᑔᒧԖਏୢڔǴՠҗܭᆛၡԖੌ
IPޑфૈЪᆛ϶ёаճҔձѠႝတ༤เǴӢԜᗋࢂᜤаٛЗख़ፄ༤ቪޑՉ ࣁǶ
ಃѤ ҂ٰࣴزБӛ
ਥᏵҁࣴزϐࣴزวᆶ่ፕǴаϷࣴزज़ڋޑόىǴගٮаΠ൳ᗺࡌ
ࣁ҂ٰࣴزБӛϐୖԵǶ
1. ႝηαਏ݀Ӣનϐᒧ
ҁࣴز܌ගрቹៜႝηαਏ݀ޑӢનԖٰྍёߞࡋǵϣၗૻ܄ǵຑፕ ኧໆᆶϩଛǵ҅ॄय़αϷຑፕኧໆǵၗૻᙦࡋǵௗԏޣவӛᆶำ ࡋǴࡌࡕុࣴزёቚуȨޣ၌ၗૻޑԛኧȩǵȨόӕౢࠔᜪձޑቹៜȩ ᆶȨޣੋΕำࡋȩǴа׳ྗዴޑᑽໆႝηαਏ݀Ƕ
2. ޣᖼວᆶኞαޑӃࡕׇղձ
ҁࣴزଷޣჹᓓޑᆶኞαϣǴٿޣ٠คࡕׇޑৡ ౦ǴࡌࡕុࣴزёଞჹޣࢂӃӆኞαϣǴᗋࢂӃኞαӆ ѐٿБय़ѐుΕޑǴΑှޣࢂӧؒԖ٣Ӄᡏᡍၸࠔ܈୍ܺޑ
ݩΠǴ൩ΑኞޑբǴᗋࢂԾρӃᡏᡍၸǴԖΑ٬ҔᡍǴωѐ
αޑණթԜٿޣޑৡձǶ
3. ቚуኬҁޑӭኬ܄
ҁࣴزҗܭࣴزჹຝаϷวܫӦᗺޑज़ڋǴӢԜεϩޑ༤ڔޣࣁᏢғ
ဂǴӢԜࡌࡕុࣴزૈቚуځдဂޑࣴزǴӧ᎙᠐ޣङඳ׳ࣁӭኬޑѳ ѠวܫୢڔǴаᔆံҁࣴزϐόىǶ
ୖԵЎ
ύЎҞ
1. ԙ੦։ (2004)Ǵ୯λٽูவՉࣁჹ႟१ᖼວ،ቹៜϐࣴزǴШཥεᏢᢀ ӀᏢسᅺγፕЎǶ
2. Ԣ܃։ (2005)ǴαՉᎍኳԄϐ܄ࣴزǴ୯ҥᆵࣽמεᏢҾᆅࣴ
ز܌ᅺγፕЎǶ
3. ԣ௵ (2004)Ǵᆛၡαٰྍёߞࡋჹጕᖼວཀკϐቹៜɡаጕܡ፤ᆛ ઠࣁٯǴ୯ҥѠࣽמεᏢҾᆅࣴز܌ᅺγፕЎǶ
4. ֺᙼྣ (1997)ǴޗᏢ: ϖࠄკਜǶ
5. Ўզ (2002)ǴᆛၡαϐቹៜӢનࣴزǴϡඵεᏢᆅࣴز܌ᅺγፕЎǶ 6. ඁන (2000)Ǵႝηແҹ٬ҔޣޑᙯՉࣁࣴزǴԢεᏢεኞᏢࣴز
܌ᅺγፕЎǶ
7. ॕЎ (2001)ǴიᡏΚᏢ : ဂᡏΚޑፕǵჴ୍ᆶࣴز: ਦ߷Ƕ 8. ڬۑᑉ (2004)ǴႝတύϟኞჹαՉࣁޑቹៜǴܿֆεᏢҾᆅࣴز܌
ᅺγፕЎǶ
9. ݅હች (2006)Ǵख़ࡋႝηແҹᙯޣϐΓαी፦ᆶғࢲࠠᄊǴᓉەεᏢ ୯ሞҾᆅࣴز܌ᅺγፕЎǶ
10. (2006)ǴᆛၡαჹޣౢࠔᄊࡋϷᖼວཀᜫቹៜϐࣴزǴ୯ҥύ ξεᏢኞᆅࣴز܌ᅺγፕЎǶ
11. ੮లޱ (2002)ǴᆛၡαԸ࣬ૻ৲܄ϷௗڙޣՉࣁ፦ჹᄊࡋԋϐቹៜǴ ୯ҥᆵεᏢᏢࣴز܌റγፕЎǶ
12. ࡾᑫ (1991)ǴМЈᜏڂ (߃ހ): ܿрހޗǶ
13. ഡធѯ (2004)ǴႝηແҹՉᎍϐࣴز:Γॺࣁϙሶ᎙᠐ϷᙯߞǴ୯ҥѠࣽמ
εᏢၗૻᆅࣴز܌ᅺγፕЎǶ
14. ಡ܃ (2007)Ǵႝηαਏ݀ᆶᆛၡӝᖼՉࣁϐࣴزǴᆵεᏢ୯ሞҾࣴ
ز܌ᅺγፕЎǶ
15. ྷ (2002)ǴύՋԄೱᙹᓓᕉნឦ܄ჹޣϐቹៜǴШཥεᏢᢀӀࣴ
ز܌ᅺγፕЎǶ
16. ယᝬϘ (2007)ǴᔈҔᄟёૈ܄ፕኳԄ(ELM)ܭပαՉᎍਏ݀аਓ ၯပࣁٯǴ୯ҥᆵчמೌᏢଣᏢࣴز܌ᅺγፕЎǶ
17. ᄪੀғ (1999)ǴޣՉࣁ: ϖࠄკਜрހԖज़ϦљǶ
18. ቅऍ (2007)Ǵαૻ৲ჹޣᒧੀ୯ᓓޑቹៜ—аѠчѱӦੀ୯ ᓓࣁٯǴ୯ҥᆵࣽמεᏢҾᆅᏢسᅺγፕЎǶ
19. ጰЎᅺ (2003)Ǵॄय़αჹޣᖼວ،ϐቹៜǴεӕεᏢ٣ᔼࣴز
܌ᅺγፕЎǶ
20. ጰስД (2005)ǴቹៜႝηແҹჴࡼԋਏӢનϐࣴزǴ୯ҥҬ೯εᏢᆅࣽᏢ
ࣴز܌ᅺγፕЎǶ
21. ᎄඵᇬ (2008)Ǵᆛၡၗૻཛྷ൨Չࣁᆶᓓ،ϐࣴزǴύ୯ЎϯεᏢғ ࢲᔈҔࣽᏢࣴز܌ᅺγፕЎǶ
22. ᐽ׆ǵ݅Јች (2005)ǴᆛၡᔮᕉნϐᆛઠࠔจᑽໆኳԄ--៝࠼୷ᘵᢀ ᗺǴ
ႝη୍ࣴز
, Vol.2(2), p161-180Ƕ23. ᑵҏॳ (1996)Ǵך୯ᢀӀسวຑࡰࡌҥϷځਏຑϐࣴزǴύ୯ ЎϯεᏢᢀӀ٣ࣴز܌ᅺγፕЎǶ
24. TWNIC (2009)ǴΐΜΖԃࡋѠቨᓎᆛၡ٬ҔރݩፓᄔाϩǶ 25. ѭᅟහѠǴhttp://www.acnielsen.com.tw/site/index.shtml
26. ՆറљᆛၡαࣴزύЈǴhttp://www.i-buzz.com.tw/
27. Ҹ⍌ (2009)Ǵ ӄౚᆛၡ٬Ҕޣँઇ 10 ሹ! ύ୯Γኧۚ߷Ǵ http://tw.news.yahoo.com/article/url/d/a/090124/19/1djg7.html
मЎҞ
1. Allen, V. L. (1965), “Situational Factors in. Advances in Experimental and Social Psychology”, New York: Academic Press, Vol. 2, p133-175.
2. Anderson, E. W. (1998), “Customer satisfaction and word of mouth.”, J. Service Res., Vol.1, p5-7.
3. Arndt, J. (1967), “Role of product related conversations in the diffusion of a new product.”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol.4, p291-295.
4. Asch, S. E. (1952), “Effect of Group Pressure upon the Modification and Distortion of Judgments.”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol.16, p394-400.
5. Bansal, Harvis S. & Peter A. Voyer (2000), “Word-of-Mouth Processes within a Service Purchase Decision Context.”, Journal of Service Research, Vol.3(2), p166-177.
6. Barbara, B., & Robert, M. S. (2001), “Internet forums as influential sources of consumer information.”, Journal of Interactive Marketing, Vol.15(3), p31-40.
7. Bart, J. B., & Vijay, M. (2001), “Unobserved retailer behavior in multimarket data:
Joint spatial dependence in market shares and promotion variables.”, Marketing Science, Vol.20(3), p284-299
8. Berlo, D. K., James B. Lemert and Robert J. Mertz (1969), “Dimensions for evaluating the acceptability of message sources.”, Public Opinion Quarterly, Vol.33, Winter, p563-576.
9. Betsy, D. G., & Suresh, S. (2002), “Adapting to "word of mouse".”, Business Horizons, Vol.45(4), p21-25.
10. Bone, P. F. (1995), “Word-of-mouth effects on short-term and long-term product judgments.”, Journal of Business Research, Vol.32(3), p213-223.
11. Bristor, J. M. (1990), “Enhanced Explanations of Word of Mouth Communications:
The Power of Relationships.”, Research in Consumer Behavior, Vol.4, p51-83.
12. Brucks, M. (1985), “The Effect of Product Class Knowledge on Information Search Behavior.”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol.1, p1-16.
13. Charles, W. K., & John, O. S. (1970), “Overlap of opinion leadership across consumer product categories.”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol7(1), p43-50.
14. Craig, C. Samuel and John M. McCann (1978), “Assessing Communication Effects of Energy Conservation.”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 5(2), p82-88.
15. Crisci, Richard and Howard Kassinove (1973), “Effects of Perceived Expertise, Strength of Advice, and Environmental Setting on Parable Compliance.”, The Journal of Social Psychology, Vol.89(2), p245-250.
16. Dichter, E. (1966), “How Word-of-Mouth advertising Works.”, Harvard Business Review, Vol.44, p147-157.
17. Engel, J. F., Blackwell, R. D., & Miniard, P. W. (1995), Consumer Behavior (8th ed.), New York: The Dryden Press.
18. Ettenson, Richard and Kathryn Turner (1997), “An exploratory investigation of consumer decision making for selected professional and nonprofessional services.”, The Journal of Services Marketing, Vol.11(2), p91-104
19. File, K. M., Judd, B. B., & Prince, R. A. (1992), “Interactive marketing: The Influence of Participation on Pos.”, The Journal of Services Marketing, Vol.6(4), p5-14.
20. Fisk, R. P., Brown, S. W., & Bitner, M. J. (1993), “Tracking the evolution of the services marketing literature.”, Journal of Retailing, Vol.69(1), p61-103.
21. Flynn, L. R., & Goldsmith, R. E. (1993), “Application of the Personal Involvement Inventory in Marketing.”, Psychology & Marketing, Vol.10, p357-366.
22. Geok Theng, L., & Sophia, N. (2001), “Individual and situational factors
influencing negative word-of-mouth behaviour.”, Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences, Vol.18(3), p163-178.
23. George, S. D., & Robert, W. P., Jr. (1971), “Stability of appliance brand awareness.”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol.8(1), p85-89.
24. Godes, D., & Mayzlin, D. (2004), “Using Online Conversations to Study Word-of-Mouth Communication.”, Marketing Science, Vol.23(4), p545-560 25. Gregg Cebrzynski (2005), “Word of mouth's ability to spark sales has marketers
talking.”, Nation's Restaurant News, Vol.39, p15-17.
26. Gremler, D. D., Bitner, M. J., & Evans, K. R. (1994), “The internal service encounter.”, International Journal of Service Industry Management, Vol.5(2), p34-56.
27. Harmon, Robert E. and Coney, Kenneth A (1982), “The Persuasive Effect of Source Credibility in Buy and Lease Situations.”, Journal of marketing Research, Vol.19, p255-260.
28. Harrison-Walker, L. J. (2001), “The measurement of word-of-mouth
communication and an investigation of service quality and customer commitment as potential antecedents.”, Journal of Service Research, Vol.4(1), p60-75.
29. Hennig-Thurau, T., & Walsh, G. (2003), “Electronic word-of-mouth: motives for and consequence of reading customer articulation on the internet.”, International Journal of Electronic Commerce, Vol.8(2), p.51-74.
30. Herr, P. M., Kardes, F. R., & Kim, J. (1991), “Effects of Word-of-Mouth and Product-Attribute Information on Persuasion: An Accessibility-Diagnosticity Perspective.”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol.17(4), p454-462.
31. Hovland, C. I., & Weiss, W. (1951), “The influence of source credibility of communication effectiveness.”, Public Opinion Quarterly, Vol.15, p635-650.
32. Katz, E., Lazarsfeld, P. F. (1955), Banerjee, A.K., & Li, D. (2000), “Managing word-of-mouth communication: empirical evidence from India.”, International Journal of bank marketing, Vol.18(2), p75-83.
33. Kelman, M. C. (1961), “Processes of Opinion Change.”, Public Opinion Quarterly, Vol. 25, p57-78.
34. Lascu, D. N., & Zinkhan, G. (1999), “Consumer Conformity: Review and Applications for Marketing Theory and Practice.”, Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice, Vol.7, p1-12.
35. Leon G. Schiffman and Leslie L. Kanuk (2000), “Consumer Behavior”, Seventh Ed., Prentice-Hall, Inc.
36. Lin, Tom M Y, Heng-Hui Wu, Chun-Wei Liao, and Tzu-Hsin Liu (2006). “Why are some e-mails forwarded and others not?”, Internet Research, Vol.16(1), p81-93 37. Macinnis, H. (1997). “Consumer Behavior”, Boston, New York: Houghton Mifflin
Company.
38. McGuire, T., Kiesler, S., and Siegel, J. (1987), “Group and computer mediated discussion effects in risk decision making.”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Vol.52(5), p917-930.
39. Money, R. B., M. C. Gilly, and J. L. Graham (1998). “Explorations of National Culture and Word-of Mouth Referral Behavior in the Purchase of Industrial
Services in the United States and Japan.”, Journal of Marketing, Vol.62(4), p76–88.
40. Peterson, R. A. & Maria, C. M. (2003), “Consumer information search behavior and the Internet.”, Psychology & Marketing, Vol.20(2), p99-121.
41. Rezabakhsh, B., Bornemann, D., Hansen, U. & Schrader, U. (2006), “Consumer Power: A Comparison of the Old Economy and the Internet Economy.”, Journal of Consumer Policy, Vol.29(1), p3-36.
42. Richins, M. L. (1983), “Negative Word-of-Mouth by Dissatisfied Customers: A Pilot Study.”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol.47, p68-78.
43. Richins, M. L., & Root-Shaffer, T (1988). “The Role of Involvement and Opinion Leadership in Consumer Word-of-Mouth: An Implicit Model Made Explicit.”, Advances in Consumer Research, Vol.15, p32-36.
44. Schulman, Gary & Chrysoula Worrall (1970). “Salience Patterns, Source
Credibility and Sleeper Effect.”, Public Opinion Quarterly, Vol.34(3), p371-382.
45. Simpson, Edwin K. and Ruel C. Kahler (1980-1981). “A scale for source
credibility, validated in the selling context.”, The Journal of Personal Selling and Sales Management, Vol.12(Fall/Winter), p17-25.
46. Singh, J. (1990). “Voice, Exit, and Negative Word-of-Mouth Behaviors: An Investigation Across Three Service Categories.”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, Vol. 18(1), p1-15.
47. Stauss, B (2000). “Using New Media for Customer Interaction: A Challenge for Relationship Marketing.”, Relationship Marketing, In T. Hennig-Thurau & U.
Hansen(Eds.) , p.233-253.
48. Sundaram, D. S., Mitra, K., & Webster, C. (1998). “Word-of-mouth
communications: A motivational analysis.”, Advances in Consumer Research, Vol.25, p527-531.
49. Swan, J. E., Bowers, M. R. and Richardson, L. D. (1999). “Customer Trust in the Salesperson: An Integrative Review and Meta-Analysis of the Empirical
Literature.”, Journal of Business Research, Vol. 44(2), p93-107.
50. Thomas, W. G., Talai, O., & Andrew, J. C. (2005). “How e-communities extend the concept of exchange in marketing: An application of the motivation opportunity, ability (MOA) theory.”, Marketing Theory, Vol.5(1), p7-31
51. Westbrook, R. A. (1987). “Product/Consumption-Based Affective Responses and Postpurchase Processes.”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol.24(3), p258-270 52. Wilkie, W. L. (1994). “Consumer Behavior”, 3rd ed, New York: John Wiley and
Sons Inc.