本研究的主要目的在於應用評量傳送模式所輸出的「面積」單元測驗來進行 實徵研究，並利用國小學童在「面積」單元測驗所產生的作答反應來進行貝氏網 路模式的修正與分析，以探討其分類精確度與其分類時其決斷值的設定，將這些 在研究中所發現的資訊，加以歸納總結，並在文末提出未來的研究結論與建議。
根據本研究之主要設計，可知：
1. 根據文獻探討去釐清以證據中心的評量設計為基礎的設計原則與步驟，再以 貝氏網路為基礎，建構以概念性的評量架構為主的評量傳送模式，發現欲利 用貝氏網路有效診斷學生之錯誤類型與子技能，需仰賴良好的試題來得到欲 測節點之證據，才能得到滿意的辨識率。以本研究為例，在建立題庫時，每 一個試題的設計需詳細考慮如何將錯誤類型設計在試題的選項中，以達到精 準的分類結果。
2. 貝氏網路模式應用於診斷國小四年級學童「面積」錯誤類型具有可行性，可 達到不錯的診斷結果，其中以二元資料輸入值在錯誤類型與子技能的辨識率 較佳。
3. 由於本研究之施測工具為診斷測驗，根據錯誤類型來設計選項，因此不同的 作答資料輸入值在本研究中對貝氏網路辨識率造成影響。本研究發現試題選 項設計不佳造成該選項未能具有該錯誤類型之代表性，將對辨識結果造成影 響。未來可使用根據本次診斷測驗之錯誤類型的選項設計，進行更進一步的 探討。
4. 不同的分類決斷值會對貝氏網路辨識率造成影響，至於該取哪一個決斷值較 好，在本研究中發現將所有的錯誤類型與子技能的決斷值固定，並不能得到 最好的辨識結果，若採以「動態決斷值選取法」來選取錯誤類型或子技能的 決斷值，其辨識結果較佳。因此可知傳統的固定決斷值選取法來選取錯誤類
型或子技能的決斷值，整體之辨識率較不穩定且較差，而動態決斷值選取法 的方式將能有效提高整體之辨識率。
5. 本研究先進行文獻探討建立面積貝氏網路，再利用預試結果與施測結果進行 資料分析，並結合使用 backward variable selection 的刪去法，找出最佳之面 積貝氏網路，可知貝氏網路模式架構的建立較為主觀，需經過多次的實驗才 能獲得一較為滿意的架構。
6. 未來在進行相關研究時，可先參考國內外相關文獻，建立具代表性之貝氏網 路之節點，在編製試題時需根據其節點內容進行試題選項的設計，亦可將所 設計的試題電腦化進行施測，將更為省時省力。
7. 以證據中心為主的評量傳送模式，涉及到組裝測驗，此部分需要需要大量的 試題來整合為題庫。
8. 此研究之結果可成為未來發展電腦適性測驗之參考。
時至今日，測驗領域面臨著家長對學科的要求與教師對學生的了解需求，將 評量設計及其標準程序實際地程序化地組卷並以電腦化的方式呈現或輸出，將使 教學職場的教師在實際應用上更為省時省力。電腦可在短時間內進行複雜的推論 來了解學生的能力與錯誤所在，更能即時的讓教學者了解學生其迷思之所在，並 即時提供補救教學，對於受試者亦是有相當大的助益。在心理計量學與統計學的 結合之下，電腦化測驗的進步可以提供更豐富的例子來印證其需求。利用知識所 蘊含的關係及概念，將需要專家設計其貝氏網路之架構來表示其關係。因此，吾 人相信了解特定知識的基本組成概念及其相互關係，佐以證據化的推理，將可設 計出符合評量目的的作業並進而運用在測驗中。在這之前，設計者需要能探索在 作業模式中的變數所代表的意義再來建構作業，以明確的證據來組合評量，並將 能力特徵化，以及傳達在作業表現與學生能力之間的關係。只有建構出一個完整 的評量架構，才能成功地設計一個複雜的評量，並且能精確診斷出研究者或教師 欲知的訊息，這些訊息將能提供教師補救教學之用，亦為未來研究之重點。
參考文獻
一、中文部分
王興家、吳曉蓉、林玫伶、莊凱安、陳冠州、江永明、趙曉燕、黃偉琪（民 94）。
第十單元面積。康軒第八冊教學指引，p169-p177。
施淑娟（民 86）。認知網路評量模式及其實例應用之研究－以「分數的加法」單 元為例，國立臺東師範學院國民教育研究所碩士論文，未出版，台中。
施淑娟（民 94）。應用貝氏網路進行國小五年級「小數」單元學習診斷之研究，
國立台灣師範大學教育心理與輔導學系博士學位論文計畫，未出版，台北。
高敬文、黃金鐘、朱進財(民 77)。我國國小學童測量概念之研究（Ⅱ）。國科會專 題研究，p14-p60。
莊維展（民 90）。國小兒童估量能力之分析研究－以高屏三縣市五年級學童為例。
國立屏東師範學院數理教育研究所碩士論文，p11-p34。
陳建誠（民 87），面積表徵的轉換。台北：國立台灣師範大學數學研究所碩士論 文，p23-p44。
陳鉪逸（民 85）。我國國小高年級學生平面圖形面積概念的研究。八十五學年度 師範學院教育學術論文發表會論文集，p235-p298。臺東：國立臺東師範學院。
戴政吉（民 90）。國小四年級學童長度與面積概念之研究。國立屏東師範學院數 理教育研究所碩士論文，p34-p58。
譚寧君（民 84）。面積概念探討。國民教育，35 卷 7、8 期，P.14-p19。
譚寧君（民 84）。國小兒童面積概念探討。台北師院學報，4 月/35 卷，7、8 期，
p14-p19。
譚寧君（民 87）。國小兒童面積迷思概念分析研究。11，p573-p602。台北師院學 報。
二、外文部分
Almond R. G., Mislevy R. J.(1999). Graphical models and computerized adaptive testing. Applied Psychological Measurement, 23(3), 223-237.
Corbett, A. T., Anderson, J. R., & O'Brien, A. T.(1995). Student modeling in the act
programming tutor. In Paul D. Nichols, Susan F. Chipman, & Robert L. Brennan(Eds.), Cognitively Diagnostic Assessment, 19-41.
Gitomer, D. H., Steinberg, L. S., & Mislevy, R. J.(1995). Diagnostic assessment of troubleshooting skill in an intelligent tutoring system. In Paul D. Nichols, Susan F.
Chipman, & Robert L. Brennan(Eds.), Cognitively Diagnostic Assessment, 73-101.
Hildreth, D. (1983). The Use of Strategies in Estimating Measurements Arithmetic Teacher, 30(5), 50-54.
Huang,Y.(1999).Learning bayesian networks guided by decomposable markov networks. Unpublished MSc, The University of Regina (Canda). 3-54.
Langley, P., Wogulis, J., & Ohlsson, S.(1990). Rules and principles in cognitive diagnosis. In N. Frederiksen, R. Glaser, A. Lesgold, & M. G. Shafto (Eds.),
Diagnostic monitoring of skill and knowledge acquisition . Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum, 217-250.
Lee, J. (2003). Diagnosis of bugs in multi-column subtraction using Bayesian networks.
Unpublished ph.D., Columbia University, 5-48.
Mislevy, R. J., Almond, R. G., Lukas, J. F. (2003). A brief introduction to evidence-centered design, 8-19.
Mislevy, R. J., Steinberg, L. S., & Almond, R. G. (1998). On the roles of task model variables in assessment design. Generating items for cognitive tests: theory and practice, 12-35.
Pearl,J.(1988).Probabilistic reasoning in intelligence systems. San Mateo, CA:Morgan Kaufmann, 2-21.
Russell G. Almond, R. G., Steinberg, L. S., & Mislevy R. J.(2003).A four-process architecture for assessment delivery with connections to assessment design.
National center for study of evaluation, standards, and student testing (CRESST), 5-13.
Russell,S., & Norvig,P.(1995). Artificial Inteligence. A modern approach. Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice Hall Inc. 1-23.
Snow, R.E. & Lohman, D.F..(1989). Implications of cognitive psychology for educational measurement. In R.L. Linn(Ed.) Educational Measurement,263-331.
Tierney, C., Boyd, C., & Davis, G.(1990). Prospective primary teachers’ conceptions of area. In G. Booker, P. Cobb, & T. N. deMendicuti (Eds.). Proceedings: 14th PME conference, 2, 307-315.
Vomlel, J.(2003). Bayesian networks in educational testing. http://utia.cas.cz/vomlel/.
1-4
Yan, D., Almond, R.G., & Mislevy, R. J.(2003).Unpublished draft empirical
comparisons of cognitive diagnostic models. Educational testing service, 12-13.
1
附錄一
給老師的話
親愛的老師：
您好！我們正在進行一項有關國小數學領域診斷性評量的研究
，此次測驗的內容為九年一貫數學課程四年級小數的部分。試題共有18 題，作 答時間沒有限制，以學生能做完為主。
十分感謝您在百忙之中惠允協助此次的施測工作，為求資料之真實性，煩請 您在施測前務必要提醒學生認真做答，每一題都要詳細思考計算再選出答案。試 卷收回後，麻煩您直接交回貴校負責的老師，我們會負責批改，若您需要批改後 的結果作為教學上之參考，請告知貴校負責的老師，我們會將批改後的試卷送回 給您。
至於測驗的結果將僅提供學術研究之用途，請您放心。由於您的協助與支持，
將對本研究及改進教育現況有極大的助益。最後，謹此致上最誠摯的謝意。
敬祝 教安
國立台中師範學院教育測驗統計研究所 郭伯臣
台中市立賴厝國民小學 許雅菱 敬啟 中華民國 九十三年 十二月
69
70
附錄三
試卷參考解答
1. f 2. e 3. d 4. e 5. c 6. f 7. f 8. d 9. e 10. f 11. f 12. e 13. d 14. d 15. c 16. c 17. e 18. f
71
72
附錄五
表 6-1 第一次修正之二元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b 1 79.23% 76.15% 77.69% 76.92% 74.62% 85.39% 86.92% 92.31% 87.69%
b 2 74.62% 74.62% 72.31% 87.69% 87.69% 85.39% 82.31% 84.62% 87.69%
b 3 64.62% 51.54% 48.46% 56.15% 64.62% 60.77% 58.46% 50.00% 61.54%
b 4 76.15% 80.00% 76.92% 77.69% 79.23% 86.15% 84.62% 83.85% 86.15%
b 5 78.46% 75.39% 74.62% 85.39% 87.69% 86.15% 79.23% 83.85% 88.46%
平均 74.62% 71.54% 70.00% 76.77% 78.77% 80.77% 78.31% 78.92% *82.31%
sk 1 72.31% 66.15% 73.08% 65.39% 70.00% 73.08% 78.46% 70.77% 22.31%
sk 2 66.15% 67.69% 73.85% 66.92% 76.15% 80.77% 39.23% 41.54% 36.15%
sk 3 47.69% 42.31% 40.77% 50.77% 64.62% 57.69% 59.23% 57.69% 78.46%
sk 4 75.39% 80.77% 75.39% 72.31% 76.15% 84.62% 80.77% 26.15% 23.08%
sk 5 58.46% 62.31% 73.08% 50.00% 65.39% 63.08% 73.08% 68.46% 59.23%
平均 64.00% 63.85% 67.23% 61.08% 70.46% *71.85% 66.15% 52.92% 43.85%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
表 6-2 第一次修正之多元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b 1 67.69% 66.92% 69.23% 76.92% 73.08% 73.08% 73.85% 79.23% 84.62%
b 2 41.54% 55.39% 63.08% 63.08% 65.39% 62.31% 66.15% 66.92% 73.08%
b 3 50.00% 73.08% 74.62% 66.15% 72.31% 66.15% 68.46% 64.62% 70.77%
b 4 73.08% 68.46% 73.85% 65.39% 70.77% 70.00% 73.08% 76.15% 70.00%
b 5 79.23% 94.62% 95.39% 90.00% 88.46% 87.69% 83.85% 85.39% 75.39%
平均 62.31% 71.69% *75.23% 72.31% 74.00% 71.85% 73.08% 74.46% 74.77%
sk 1 78.46% 64.62% 72.31% 70.77% 77.69% 69.23% 63.85% 66.15% 20.00%
sk 2 59.23% 50.00% 76.15% 68.46% 66.92% 53.85% 61.54% 40.77% 40.00%
sk 3 47.69% 67.69% 67.69% 70.77% 77.69% 78.46% 80.77% 67.69% 63.08%
sk 4 74.62% 70.77% 70.77% 85.39% 73.08% 71.54% 75.39% 73.85% 68.46%
sk 5 35.39% 86.15% 80.00% 85.39% 81.54% 86.92% 83.08% 83.08% 62.31%
平均 59.08% 67.85% 73.38% *76.15% 75.38% 72.00% 72.92% 66.31% 50.77%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
73
74
附錄七
表 6-3 刪第一題修正作業模式二元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 70.00% 80.00% 80.77% 83.08% 80.77% 80.00% 76.15% 92.31% 92.31%
b2 57.69% 65.39% 66.15% 65.39% 71.54% 70.00% 70.00% 78.46% 80.00%
b3 48.46% 52.31% 43.08% 50.00% 49.23% 53.85% 51.54% 43.08% 50.00%
b4 81.54% 82.31% 80.77% 86.15% 83.08% 81.54% 83.85% 79.23% 86.15%
b5 58.46% 67.69% 66.92% 65.39% 70.00% 68.46% 69.23% 75.39% 79.23%
平均 63.23% 69.54% 67.54% 70.00% 70.92% 70.77% 70.15% 73.69% *77.54%
sk 1 76.92% 75.39% 76.92% 80.00% 74.62% 75.39% 73.85% 76.15% 13.85%
sk 2 70.00% 66.15% 79.23% 76.92% 76.92% 72.31% 71.54% 37.69% 40.00%
sk 3 38.46% 41.54% 35.39% 43.08% 43.08% 47.69% 45.39% 90.00% 66.92%
sk 4 76.15% 73.85% 76.15% 76.92% 79.23% 74.62% 76.15% 40.77% 28.46%
sk 5 73.08% 80.77% 88.46% 69.23% 74.62% 69.23% 72.31% 72.31% 69.23%
平均 66.92% 67.54% 71.23% 69.23% *69.69% 67.85% 67.85% 63.38% 43.69%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
表 6-4 刪第一題修正作業模式多元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 71.54% 70.77% 64.62% 70.77% 81.54% 78.46% 76.15% 83.08% 77.69%
b2 41.54% 43.85% 67.69% 56.92% 60.77% 57.69% 66.92% 61.54% 66.92%
b3 58.46% 73.85% 76.15% 68.46% 60.00% 57.69% 68.46% 65.39% 61.54%
b4 71.54% 79.23% 72.31% 70.00% 70.77% 76.92% 74.62% 76.15% 76.92%
b5 79.23% 76.15% 82.31% 90.00% 93.85% 87.69% 89.23% 96.15% 87.69%
平均 64.46% 68.77% 72.62% 71.23% 73.38% 71.69% 75.08% *76.46% 74.15%
sk 1 84.62% 86.92% 80.00% 78.46% 80.77% 73.08% 69.23% 71.54% 71.54%
sk 2 65.39% 68.46% 67.69% 70.00% 66.92% 57.69% 63.85% 43.08% 34.62%
sk 3 35.39% 40.77% 83.85% 67.69% 76.92% 80.77% 83.08% 86.92% 60.00%
sk 4 67.69% 75.39% 73.85% 77.69% 82.31% 78.46% 85.39% 72.31% 74.62%
sk 5 74.62% 81.54% 77.69% 85.39% 86.92% 85.39% 71.54% 68.46% 62.31%
平均 65.54% 70.62% 76.62% 75.85% *78.77% 75.08% 74.62% 68.46% 60.62%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
75
表 6-5 刪第二題修正作業模式二元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 70.77% 79.23% 83.08% 81.54% 79.23% 77.69% 76.92% 84.62% 89.23%
b2 58.46% 70.00% 70.77% 76.92% 86.92% 86.15% 72.31% 73.08% 73.08%
b3 51.54% 50.00% 49.23% 55.39% 53.85% 57.69% 51.54% 47.69% 50.00%
b4 83.08% 83.08% 83.08% 83.08% 82.31% 80.77% 78.46% 81.54% 84.62%
b5 59.23% 70.00% 67.69% 77.69% 86.92% 83.08% 70.77% 73.08% 70.00%
平均 64.62% 70.46% 70.77% 74.92% *77.85% 77.08% 70.00% 72.00% 73.38%
sk 1 67.69% 75.39% 76.92% 75.39% 70.77% 65.39% 66.15% 64.62% 18.46%
sk 2 68.46% 66.92% 74.62% 73.85% 73.08% 78.46% 73.08% 39.23% 36.15%
sk 3 36.92% 46.15% 39.23% 44.62% 45.39% 53.85% 50.00% 89.23% 60.77%
sk 4 76.15% 75.39% 82.31% 80.00% 77.69% 77.69% 70.00% 42.31% 29.23%
sk 5 71.54% 83.85% 83.85% 65.39% 72.31% 69.23% 63.85% 68.46% 61.54%
平均 64.15% 69.54% *71.38% 67.85% 67.85% 68.92% 64.62% 60.77% 41.23%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
表 6-6 刪第二題修正作業模式多元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 70.77% 72.31% 72.31% 66.15% 78.46% 73.08% 77.69% 76.15% 83.08%
b2 39.23% 29.23% 63.08% 64.62% 58.46% 60.77% 66.15% 60.77% 60.00%
b3 63.85% 69.23% 76.15% 60.00% 63.08% 63.08% 54.62% 80.77% 54.62%
b4 71.54% 70.00% 73.08% 76.15% 73.08% 68.46% 81.54% 73.08% 67.69%
b5 80.00% 73.85% 91.54% 96.92% 90.77% 93.08% 92.31% 92.31% 93.85%
平均 65.08% 62.92% 75.23% 72.77% 72.77% 71.69% 74.46% *76.62% 71.85%
sk 1 75.39% 72.31% 74.62% 65.39% 69.23% 68.46% 67.69% 63.08% 23.08%
sk 2 65.39% 66.92% 76.92% 76.92% 70.00% 68.46% 58.46% 56.92% 43.08%
sk 3 36.92% 46.15% 39.23% 67.69% 80.00% 85.39% 84.62% 85.39% 68.46%
sk 4 73.85% 78.46% 78.46% 73.08% 78.46% 74.62% 83.85% 68.46% 71.54%
sk 5 84.62% 85.39% 85.39% 89.23% 82.31% 85.39% 65.39% 75.39% 70.00%
平均 67.23% 69.85% 70.92% 74.46% 76.00% *76.46% 72.00% 69.85% 55.23%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
76
表 6-7 刪第三題修正作業模式二元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 72.31% 76.15% 76.92% 83.85% 80.77% 77.69% 82.31% 87.69% 89.23%
b2 87.69% 86.15% 93.08% 89.23% 88.46% 90.00% 88.46% 90.77% 87.69%
b3 71.54% 63.08% 66.92% 54.62% 49.23% 50.00% 54.62% 54.62% 59.23%
b4 84.62% 85.39% 79.23% 84.62% 81.54% 76.15% 82.31% 82.31% 82.31%
b5 88.46% 87.69% 90.77% 89.23% 87.69% 88.46% 89.23% 90.00% 86.92%
平均 80.92% 79.69% *81.38% 80.31% 77.54% 76.46% 79.38% 81.08% 81.08%
sk 1 76.15% 73.08% 74.62% 70.00% 66.92% 73.08% 71.54% 77.69% 18.46%
sk 2 67.69% 69.23% 72.31% 82.31% 76.92% 76.92% 78.46% 37.69% 33.85%
sk 3 43.08% 42.31% 46.15% 59.23% 49.23% 53.85% 83.08% 83.08% 55.39%
sk 4 73.08% 76.15% 71.54% 83.08% 78.46% 76.15% 76.92% 74.62% 24.62%
sk 5 61.54% 65.39% 65.39% 81.54% 76.15% 63.85% 58.46% 57.69% 56.92%
平均 64.31% 65.23% 66.00% *75.23% 69.54% 68.77% 73.69% 66.15% 37.85%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
表 6-8 刪第三題修正作業模式多元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 63.85% 64.62% 66.15% 75.39% 72.31% 76.15% 78.46% 77.69% 82.31%
b2 49.23% 54.62% 70.00% 67.69% 70.00% 66.15% 68.46% 65.39% 60.00%
b3 56.15% 50.77% 58.46% 66.92% 67.69% 73.08% 66.15% 68.46% 56.92%
b4 66.92% 70.00% 70.77% 77.69% 80.00% 73.08% 80.00% 77.69% 76.92%
b5 76.92% 82.31% 83.85% 87.69% 90.00% 91.54% 85.39% 83.08% 87.69%
平均 62.62% 64.46% 69.85% 75.08% *76.00% *76.00% 75.69% 74.46% 72.77%
sk 1 67.69% 70.00% 72.31% 73.85% 68.46% 63.85% 68.46% 64.62% 17.69%
sk 2 54.62% 60.77% 62.31% 77.69% 76.15% 66.92% 70.00% 53.85% 34.62%
sk 3 41.54% 44.62% 50.00% 61.54% 83.08% 83.85% 72.31% 78.46% 59.23%
sk 4 66.15% 70.77% 75.39% 77.69% 83.08% 76.92% 83.08% 74.62% 64.62%
sk 5 55.39% 74.62% 70.77% 77.69% 76.92% 80.77% 73.85% 64.62% 59.23%
平均 57.08% 64.15% 66.15% 73.69% *77.54% 74.46% 73.54% 67.23% 47.08%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
77
表 6-9 刪第四題修正作業模式二元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 66.92% 73.08% 85.39% 80.00% 80.00% 76.15% 82.31% 88.46% 90.77%
b2 77.69% 85.39% 85.39% 85.39% 86.92% 89.23% 86.15% 89.23% 89.23%
b3 70.00% 63.85% 64.62% 57.69% 63.85% 53.85% 46.15% 51.54% 58.46%
b4 85.39% 83.08% 88.46% 86.92% 83.85% 82.31% 80.77% 87.69% 84.62%
b5 77.69% 85.39% 87.69% 83.08% 87.69% 86.92% 82.31% 88.46% 88.46%
平均 75.54% 78.15% *82.31% 78.62% 80.46% 77.69% 75.54% 81.08% *82.31%
sk 1 72.31% 73.08% 77.69% 67.69% 70.77% 70.00% 70.00% 70.00% 22.31%
sk 2 70.77% 76.92% 75.39% 78.46% 75.39% 81.54% 81.54% 40.00% 36.15%
sk 3 43.08% 48.46% 47.69% 49.23% 56.15% 56.15% 65.39% 86.92% 60.00%
sk 4 65.39% 63.85% 66.92% 63.08% 66.15% 68.46% 46.15% 47.69% 43.85%
sk 5 62.31% 71.54% 77.69% 76.15% 69.23% 73.08% 73.08% 69.23% 62.31%
平均 62.77% 66.77% 69.08% 66.92% 67.54% *69.85% 67.23% 62.77% 44.92%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
表 6-10 刪第四題修正作業模式多元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 66.15% 71.54% 70.00% 64.62% 73.08% 83.08% 78.46% 79.23% 81.54%
b2 50.00% 57.69% 70.77% 66.92% 66.92% 72.31% 66.92% 65.39% 60.00%
b3 63.85% 69.23% 66.15% 63.08% 65.39% 63.08% 56.92% 63.08% 63.85%
b4 60.00% 61.54% 55.39% 61.54% 52.31% 56.92% 50.00% 55.39% 60.77%
b5 81.54% 82.31% 89.23% 93.08% 89.23% 93.85% 81.54% 86.92% 93.08%
平均 64.31% 68.46% 70.31% 69.85% 69.38% *73.85% 66.77% 70.00% 71.85%
sk 1 73.85% 72.31% 74.62% 70.00% 66.92% 73.08% 73.08% 67.69% 20.77%
sk 2 60.77% 63.85% 76.15% 76.15% 73.85% 78.46% 46.92% 50.00% 36.92%
sk 3 35.39% 35.39% 53.08% 72.31% 73.85% 83.08% 83.08% 83.08% 66.92%
sk 4 64.62% 61.54% 59.23% 63.85% 54.62% 59.23% 50.00% 46.92% 43.85%
sk 5 76.15% 83.85% 82.31% 77.69% 83.85% 87.69% 85.39% 69.23% 68.46%
平均 62.15% 63.38% 69.08% 72.00% 70.62% *76.31% 67.69% 63.38% 47.38%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
78
表 6-11 刪第五題修正作業模式二元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 66.92% 82.31% 85.39% 79.23% 86.92% 83.85% 84.62% 80.00% 83.85%
b2 73.08% 83.08% 83.85% 89.23% 84.62% 85.39% 90.00% 88.46% 85.39%
b3 75.39% 57.69% 58.46% 52.31% 54.62% 64.62% 61.54% 44.62% 61.54%
b4 80.00% 86.92% 91.54% 90.00% 92.31% 82.31% 89.23% 85.39% 79.23%
b5 76.15% 84.62% 82.31% 86.15% 83.08% 82.31% 86.92% 87.69% 84.62%
平均 74.31% 78.92% 80.31% 79.38% 80.31% 79.69% *82.46% 77.23% 78.92%
sk 1 77.69% 73.08% 78.46% 74.62% 75.39% 73.85% 63.08% 73.08% 19.23%
sk 2 66.92% 72.31% 75.39% 80.00% 85.39% 78.46% 85.39% 40.00% 40.00%
sk 3 61.54% 43.85% 50.77% 47.69% 52.31% 67.69% 69.23% 66.92% 63.85%
sk 4 71.54% 83.08% 80.77% 83.85% 89.23% 82.31% 83.08% 27.69% 30.00%
sk 5 82.31% 62.31% 73.08% 63.08% 63.08% 64.62% 65.39% 70.77% 65.39%
平均 72.00% 66.92% 71.69% 69.85% 73.08% *73.38% 73.23% 55.69% 43.69%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
表 6-12 刪第五題修正作業模式多元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 67.69% 66.15% 70.77% 73.08% 70.00% 82.31% 80.77% 77.69% 78.46%
b2 62.31% 54.62% 61.54% 65.39% 73.85% 64.62% 70.00% 63.08% 62.31%
b3 72.31% 73.08% 65.39% 68.46% 60.77% 72.31% 67.69% 60.77% 63.08%
b4 66.15% 67.69% 75.39% 71.54% 73.85% 73.85% 77.69% 64.62% 74.62%
b5 83.85% 80.00% 84.62% 86.15% 88.46% 86.92% 88.46% 79.23% 69.23%
平均 70.46% 68.31% 71.54% 72.92% 73.38% 76.00% *76.92% 69.08% 69.54%
sk 1 68.46% 68.46% 76.92% 73.85% 66.92% 70.00% 68.46% 66.92% 20.00%
sk 2 60.00% 59.23% 68.46% 73.85% 77.69% 69.23% 60.77% 39.23% 40.77%
sk 3 27.69% 37.69% 51.54% 74.62% 60.00% 80.77% 81.54% 85.39% 66.15%
sk 4 70.77% 70.77% 71.54% 75.39% 74.62% 76.92% 79.23% 71.54% 70.00%
sk 5 55.39% 80.77% 81.54% 81.54% 83.85% 81.54% 82.31% 66.92% 65.39%
平均 56.46% 63.38% 70.00% *75.85% 72.62% 75.69% 74.46% 66.00% 52.46%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
79
表 6-13 刪第六題修正作業模式二元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 75.39% 77.69% 76.15% 79.23% 89.23% 86.15% 85.39% 85.39% 89.23%
b2 76.92% 90.77% 87.69% 93.85% 90.77% 93.08% 90.77% 90.00% 90.00%
b3 59.23% 63.85% 66.15% 50.77% 56.15% 53.08% 50.77% 52.31% 53.08%
b4 72.31% 83.08% 80.77% 76.92% 79.23% 81.54% 81.54% 83.85% 86.15%
b5 80.77% 91.54% 90.00% 90.00% 92.31% 90.77% 91.54% 90.00% 89.23%
平均 72.92% 81.38% 80.15% 78.15% *81.54% 80.92% 80.00% 80.31% *81.54%
sk 1 68.46% 67.69% 70.00% 67.69% 77.69% 80.77% 66.92% 69.23% 19.23%
sk 2 72.31% 72.31% 67.69% 76.92% 79.23% 80.77% 75.39% 35.39% 36.15%
sk 3 30.77% 56.15% 52.31% 44.62% 49.23% 47.69% 53.85% 78.46% 63.85%
sk 4 66.92% 63.85% 63.85% 67.69% 66.92% 70.00% 40.77% 43.08% 42.31%
sk 5 49.23% 68.46% 73.85% 66.15% 63.08% 66.15% 70.77% 66.92% 63.85%
平均 57.54% 65.69% 65.54% 64.62% 67.23% *69.08% 61.54% 58.62% 45.08%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
表 6-14 刪第六題修正作業模式多元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 67.69% 70.77% 70.00% 70.77% 80.00% 71.54% 83.08% 79.23% 85.39%
b2 59.23% 53.08% 61.54% 61.54% 73.08% 70.00% 68.46% 69.23% 63.85%
b3 70.77% 66.92% 63.85% 66.15% 66.92% 63.85% 63.85% 63.08% 53.08%
b4 62.31% 63.85% 67.69% 65.39% 66.15% 75.39% 70.00% 72.31% 73.85%
b5 84.62% 90.77% 86.92% 90.77% 90.77% 85.39% 91.54% 83.08% 59.23%
平均 68.92% 69.08% 70.00% 70.92% *75.38% 73.23% *75.38% 73.38% 67.08%
sk 1 66.92% 70.77% 69.23% 70.00% 70.00% 73.08% 70.00% 67.69% 20.00%
sk 2 60.00% 59.23% 72.31% 69.23% 77.69% 80.00% 60.00% 38.46% 26.92%
sk 3 50.00% 32.31% 48.46% 62.31% 83.08% 80.77% 82.31% 82.31% 66.92%
sk 4 63.85% 73.85% 72.31% 67.69% 62.31% 73.08% 66.15% 45.39% 31.54%
sk 5 53.85% 79.23% 80.00% 90.00% 84.62% 80.77% 85.39% 71.54% 66.92%
平均 58.92% 63.08% 68.46% 71.85% 75.54% *77.54% 72.77% 61.08% 42.46%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
80
表 6-15 刪第七題修正作業模式二元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 78.46% 74.62% 80.00% 83.85% 82.31% 88.46% 89.23% 83.85% 90.00%
b2 88.46% 89.23% 89.23% 86.15% 90.77% 90.00% 93.08% 93.85% 90.77%
b3 64.62% 73.08% 66.15% 60.77% 55.39% 50.77% 54.62% 53.08% 50.00%
b4 82.31% 81.54% 82.31% 81.54% 82.31% 81.54% 85.39% 79.23% 78.46%
b5 87.69% 90.00% 92.31% 86.15% 86.92% 88.46% 91.54% 93.85% 89.23%
平均 80.31% 81.69% 82.00% 79.69% 79.54% 79.85% *82.77% 80.77% 79.69%
sk 1 75.39% 73.85% 70.00% 78.46% 78.46% 79.23% 64.62% 66.15% 21.54%
sk 2 72.31% 73.85% 74.62% 76.92% 83.08% 83.85% 81.54% 35.39% 37.69%
sk 3 38.46% 51.54% 56.92% 50.77% 45.39% 42.31% 63.08% 80.77% 65.39%
sk 4 68.46% 64.62% 63.08% 73.08% 78.46% 70.00% 40.00% 44.62% 44.62%
sk 5 43.08% 60.00% 88.46% 66.15% 71.54% 66.15% 63.85% 66.15% 66.92%
平均 59.54% 64.77% 70.62% 69.08% *71.38% 68.31% 62.62% 58.62% 47.23%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
表 6-16 刪第七題修正作業模式多元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 64.62% 63.08% 66.15% 75.39% 74.62% 73.85% 75.39% 80.77% 87.69%
b2 56.15% 52.31% 62.31% 63.85% 66.92% 63.85% 65.39% 62.31% 60.77%
b3 66.92% 65.39% 66.92% 64.62% 60.77% 60.00% 67.69% 66.15% 59.23%
b4 60.77% 62.31% 60.77% 60.77% 70.00% 66.92% 69.23% 55.39% 70.00%
b5 75.39% 90.00% 92.31% 91.54% 92.31% 88.46% 87.69% 83.85% 79.23%
平均 64.77% 66.62% 69.69% 71.23% 72.92% 70.62% *73.08% 69.69% 71.38%
sk 1 70.00% 69.23% 66.15% 70.77% 73.85% 63.08% 71.54% 60.77% 17.69%
sk 2 60.77% 62.31% 58.46% 70.77% 80.77% 73.85% 60.77% 31.54% 36.15%
sk 3 35.39% 30.77% 40.00% 55.39% 70.77% 89.23% 83.85% 76.92% 71.54%
sk 4 69.23% 73.08% 71.54% 67.69% 66.92% 69.23% 66.92% 40.00% 44.62%
sk 5 64.62% 85.39% 83.85% 80.00% 83.85% 89.23% 84.62% 64.62% 70.00%
平均 60.00% 64.15% 64.00% 68.92% 75.23% *76.92% 73.54% 54.77% 48.00%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
81
表 6-17 刪第八題修正作業模式二元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 74.62% 69.23% 76.15% 85.39% 96.92% 93.08% 98.46% 95.39% 98.46%
b2 76.92% 86.92% 80.77% 82.31% 86.15% 85.39% 86.15% 90.00% 89.23%
b3 73.08% 60.00% 56.92% 58.46% 59.23% 68.46% 57.69% 60.00% 52.31%
b4 81.54% 79.23% 89.23% 75.39% 74.62% 85.39% 83.85% 81.54% 80.00%
b5 88.46% 89.23% 83.08% 83.85% 86.92% 88.46% 87.69% 86.15% 85.39%
平均 78.92% 76.92% 77.23% 77.08% 80.77% *84.15% 82.77% 82.62% 81.08%
sk 1 91.54% 88.46% 80.00% 86.15% 80.77% 76.92% 73.08% 67.69% 10.77%
sk 2 74.62% 76.15% 79.23% 73.08% 78.46% 81.54% 84.62% 40.77% 40.77%
sk 3 53.85% 44.62% 50.77% 53.85% 53.08% 67.69% 59.23% 79.23% 60.77%
sk 4 83.85% 83.85% 84.62% 77.69% 76.15% 81.54% 84.62% 28.46% 35.39%
sk 5 60.77% 60.00% 63.08% 65.39% 70.00% 65.39% 73.08% 69.23% 63.85%
平均 72.92% 70.62% 71.54% 71.23% 71.69% 74.62% *74.92% 57.08% 42.31%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
表 6-18 刪第八題修正作業模式多元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 76.92% 66.92% 75.39% 73.08% 73.08% 70.77% 76.15% 83.85% 91.54%
b2 46.15% 46.15% 58.46% 65.39% 71.54% 65.39% 67.69% 59.23% 63.85%
b3 62.31% 66.15% 71.54% 66.15% 58.46% 70.77% 65.39% 66.92% 58.46%
b4 56.15% 63.08% 54.62% 60.77% 77.69% 73.08% 72.31% 73.08% 67.69%
b5 81.54% 93.85% 93.85% 93.85% 93.08% 97.69% 93.08% 88.46% 90.00%
平均 64.62% 67.23% 70.77% 71.85% 74.77% *75.54% 74.92% 74.31% 74.31%
sk 1 86.15% 86.15% 85.39% 82.31% 75.39% 70.00% 70.00% 71.54% 19.23%
sk 2 69.23% 57.69% 72.31% 70.77% 82.31% 77.69% 78.46% 46.92% 37.69%
sk 3 30.77% 30.00% 54.62% 73.85% 69.23% 91.54% 86.15% 81.54% 66.15%
sk 4 77.69% 70.00% 58.46% 70.77% 83.85% 70.00% 74.62% 73.85% 66.15%
sk 5 63.08% 81.54% 82.31% 86.92% 87.69% 90.77% 87.69% 67.69% 68.46%
平均 65.38% 65.08% 70.62% 76.92% 79.69% *80.00% 79.38% 68.31% 51.54%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
82
表 6-19 刪第九題修正作業模式二元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 77.69% 83.08% 83.08% 84.62% 79.23% 77.69% 82.31% 87.69% 91.54%
b2 67.69% 82.31% 84.62% 85.39% 80.77% 89.23% 87.69% 93.85% 89.23%
b3 70.00% 63.08% 78.46% 58.46% 64.62% 60.00% 59.23% 97.31% 50.77%
b4 73.08% 77.69% 76.15% 91.54% 70.77% 73.85% 75.39% 91.54% 83.85%
b5 88.46% 86.15% 88.46% 85.39% 88.46% 85.39% 89.23% 95.00% 87.69%
平均 75.38% 78.46% 82.15% 81.08% 76.77% 77.23% 78.77% *93.08% 80.62%
sk 1 75.39% 67.69% 70.77% 71.54% 70.00% 70.77% 65.39% 73.85% 18.46%
sk 2 79.23% 72.31% 75.39% 86.15% 70.00% 77.69% 79.23% 76.92% 28.46%
sk 3 53.08% 44.62% 45.39% 45.39% 56.92% 65.39% 73.08% 78.46% 53.85%
sk 4 80.77% 71.54% 75.39% 84.62% 70.77% 74.62% 73.08% 25.39% 23.08%
sk 5 46.92% 61.54% 74.62% 67.69% 68.46% 56.92% 57.69% 47.69% 56.92%
平均 67.08% 63.54% 68.31% *71.08% 67.23% 69.08% 69.69% 60.46% 36.15%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
表 6-20 刪第九題修正作業模式多元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 74.62% 65.39% 71.54% 67.69% 75.39% 76.15% 75.39% 78.46% 82.31%
b2 43.85% 48.46% 58.46% 60.77% 68.46% 66.15% 60.77% 68.46% 62.31%
b3 66.92% 73.85% 67.69% 66.15% 63.08% 66.92% 66.15% 65.39% 61.54%
b4 67.69% 53.85% 72.31% 73.08% 67.69% 74.62% 70.77% 81.54% 72.31%
b5 79.23% 76.92% 75.39% 73.08% 70.00% 72.31% 66.92% 57.69% 71.54%
平均 66.46% 63.69% 69.08% 68.15% 68.92% *71.23% 68.00% 70.31% 70.00%
sk 1 76.92% 71.54% 70.00% 73.08% 64.62% 67.69% 63.08% 73.08% 27.69%
sk 2 73.85% 71.54% 68.46% 66.15% 77.69% 74.62% 70.00% 54.62% 34.62%
sk 3 50.00% 44.62% 44.62% 51.54% 51.54% 68.46% 70.77% 87.69% 56.15%
sk 4 75.39% 74.62% 76.15% 78.46% 71.54% 76.15% 67.69% 72.31% 65.39%
sk 5 53.08% 75.39% 71.54% 85.39% 82.31% 82.31% 68.46% 54.62% 59.23%
平均 65.85% 67.54% 66.15% 70.92% 69.54% *73.85% 68.00% 68.46% 48.62%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
83
表 6-21 刪第十題修正作業模式二元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 64.62% 80.00% 83.08% 81.54% 79.23% 78.46% 76.92% 81.54% 81.54%
b2 86.15% 86.92% 91.54% 88.46% 90.77% 89.23% 87.69% 92.31% 92.31%
b3 65.39% 56.15% 56.92% 58.46% 60.77% 55.39% 52.31% 50.77% 50.77%
b4 86.92% 79.23% 79.23% 85.39% 82.31% 79.23% 81.54% 83.85% 83.85%
b5 86.15% 85.39% 88.46% 89.23% 90.00% 90.00% 85.39% 93.08% 93.08%
平均 77.85% 77.54% 79.85% *80.62% *80.62% 78.46% 76.77% 80.31% 80.31%
sk 1 65.39% 71.54% 76.92% 75.39% 70.77% 65.39% 64.62% 64.62% 64.62%
sk 2 74.62% 81.54% 83.08% 81.54% 82.31% 78.46% 75.39% 78.46% 78.46%
sk 3 39.23% 45.39% 44.62% 51.54% 53.85% 62.31% 51.54% 79.23% 79.23%
sk 4 78.46% 80.00% 82.31% 83.08% 78.46% 78.46% 76.92% 30.77% 30.77%
sk 5 42.31% 62.31% 69.23% 61.54% 70.77% 66.15% 62.31% 67.69% 67.69%
平均 60.00% 68.15% *71.23% 70.62% 71.23% 70.15% 66.15% 64.15% 64.15%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
表 6-22 刪第十題修正作業模式多元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 66.15% 70.77% 71.54% 76.92% 66.15% 82.31% 73.08% 79.23% 83.85%
b2 50.77% 54.62% 53.08% 62.31% 73.08% 65.39% 60.77% 71.54% 65.39%
b3 70.00% 63.08% 60.77% 65.39% 70.00% 68.46% 71.54% 53.85% 62.31%
b4 55.39% 60.77% 70.00% 66.15% 68.46% 54.62% 58.46% 79.23% 70.00%
b5 79.23% 72.31% 70.77% 63.08% 66.15% 58.46% 47.69% 50.00% 51.54%
平均 64.31% 64.31% 65.23% 66.77% *68.77% 65.85% 62.31% 66.77% 66.62%
sk 1 80.00% 75.39% 73.08% 73.08% 59.23% 70.77% 67.69% 67.69% 23.08%
sk 2 70.00% 73.08% 75.39% 81.54% 72.31% 60.77% 61.54% 49.23% 35.39%
sk 3 33.08% 39.23% 50.77% 47.69% 61.54% 71.54% 80.77% 73.08% 66.92%
sk 4 68.46% 73.85% 76.15% 78.46% 74.62% 50.77% 58.46% 73.08% 58.46%
sk 5 53.08% 68.46% 70.00% 70.77% 81.54% 76.15% 81.54% 64.62% 68.46%
平均 60.92% 66.00% 69.08% *70.31% 69.85% 66.00% 70.00% 65.54% 50.46%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
84
表 6-23 刪第十一題修正作業模式二元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 74.62% 85.39% 79.23% 79.23% 82.31% 76.92% 90.00% 86.15% 92.31%
b2 91.54% 81.54% 93.08% 90.00% 83.08% 88.46% 93.08% 92.31% 88.46%
b3 60.00% 56.15% 73.08% 53.85% 61.54% 63.85% 51.54% 54.62% 53.85%
b4 85.39% 86.15% 83.85% 86.15% 80.77% 84.62% 79.23% 78.46% 77.69%
b5 93.08% 83.08% 92.31% 90.00% 80.77% 88.46% 92.31% 92.31% 86.92%
平均 80.92% 78.46% *84.31% 79.85% 77.69% 80.46% 81.23% 80.77% 79.85%
sk 1 71.54% 83.08% 75.39% 76.92% 71.54% 66.92% 66.92% 69.23% 18.46%
sk 2 76.92% 85.39% 75.39% 80.00% 75.39% 84.62% 77.69% 80.00% 33.85%
sk 3 37.69% 39.23% 52.31% 44.62% 55.39% 64.62% 49.23% 86.92% 70.00%
sk 4 77.69% 85.39% 75.39% 80.00% 77.69% 83.85% 74.62% 28.46% 28.46%
sk 5 40.00% 63.08% 68.46% 63.85% 60.77% 68.46% 70.77% 62.31% 73.08%
平均 60.77% 71.23% 69.39% 69.08% 68.15% *73.69% 67.85% 65.38% 44.77%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
表 6-24 刪第十一題修正作業模式多元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 b1 67.69% 67.69% 69.23% 68.46% 73.85% 74.62% 70.77% 79.23% 85.39%
b2 36.92% 49.23% 62.31% 67.69% 69.23% 74.62% 62.31% 70.77% 76.15%
b3 61.54% 63.85% 63.85% 56.92% 62.31% 56.92% 58.46% 53.08% 53.08%
b4 69.23% 73.08% 81.54% 68.46% 73.85% 74.62% 72.31% 76.15% 71.54%
b5 79.23% 93.08% 97.69% 95.39% 93.08% 93.08% 93.08% 90.00% 96.15%
平均 62.92% 69.38% 74.92% 71.38% 74.46% 74.77% 71.38% 73.85% *76.46%
sk 1 73.85% 73.85% 75.39% 64.62% 69.23% 70.00% 69.23% 61.54% 20.00%
sk 2 69.23% 70.77% 70.00% 78.46% 75.39% 79.23% 62.31% 50.00% 33.08%
sk 3 33.08% 36.15% 36.92% 43.08% 63.85% 75.39% 87.69% 86.15% 65.39%
sk 4 69.23% 74.62% 70.00% 75.39% 80.77% 76.92% 71.54% 71.54% 66.92%
sk 5 54.62% 84.62% 82.31% 88.46% 82.31% 87.69% 86.92% 70.00% 67.69%
平均 60.00% 68.00% 66.92% 70.00% 74.31% *77.85% 75.54% 67.85% 50.62%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
85
表 6-25 刪第十二題修正作業模式二元計分之辨識率
分類決斷值
辨識率 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 B1 74.62% 75.39% 78.46% 80.00% 80.00% 83.85% 82.31% 84.62% 89.23%
B2 90.00% 77.69% 86.92% 86.15% 90.00% 87.69% 90.00% 87.69% 87.69%
b3 71.54% 58.46% 56.15% 59.23% 56.15% 45.39% 45.39% 56.15% 47.69%
b4 92.31% 73.85% 80.77% 80.77% 91.54% 86.15% 85.39% 82.31% 81.54%
b5 92.31% 74.62% 86.92% 85.39% 87.69% 84.62% 87.69% 87.69% 83.85%
平均 *84.15% 72.00% 77.85% 78.31% 81.08% 77.54% 78.15% 79.69% 78.00%
sk 1 73.08% 78.46% 71.54% 74.62% 77.69% 72.31% 67.69% 70.00% 18.46%
sk 2 75.39% 74.62% 64.62% 72.31% 81.54% 80.77% 80.77% 41.54% 37.69%
sk 3 50.00% 46.92% 43.08% 50.77% 53.08% 48.46% 60.00% 88.46% 66.15%
sk 4 84.62% 80.77% 71.54% 80.00% 84.62% 84.62% 82.31% 30.77% 25.39%
sk 5 52.31% 76.15% 63.08% 64.62% 62.31% 66.92% 68.46% 72.31% 66.92%
平均 67.08% 71.38% 62.77% 68.46% *71.85% 70.62% *71.85% 60.62% 42.92%
*表示最高的平均辨識率
*表示最高的平均辨識率