Chapter 5 Experimental Results
5.2 The Performance of the Factor k
At last, the tunable factor k of suspend algorithm in equation (3-5) is evaluated in Figure 5-6. The average number of the handed-down GSM RSSI samples and the variance are illustrated in the figure. The factor k is the weighting factor about the influence of RSCP ratio.
Figure5- 6. The number of hand-down RSSI samples with different k (User = 45)
The increasing k will force the suspension goes to users who are close to the base station easily and make it harder to suspend users who are at the hand-down region. As shown in Figure 5-6, the number of RSSI measurement samples before GSM hand-down will increase
as the k increases. In other respect, high k makes the distance (or the associate RF) have bigger impacts on the selection of the suspend users. As a result, in a mobility environment, the variance of the RSSI measurement will also increase for higher k. The factor k trades off between measurement efficiency and fairness.
As shown in Figure 5-7, the relationship of the suspend probability and the strength of RSCP is illustrated. The suspend probability between the stop threshold (-104 dBW) and the start threshold (-108 dBW) is relative small. Besides this region, the larger RSCP (i.e. the RF condition is better) has higher opportunity to be suspended than the lower RSCP. With the modified factor k increasing, the RF condition is more dominated and this phenomenon is becoming obvious. It can explain in Figure 18 why the number of the hand-down samples is higher when the k is larger. The factor k can easily modify the importance of the RF influence.
Figure5- 7. The relationship of the suspend probability and RSCP with different k (User = 45)
Chapter 6 Conclusions
6.1 Contributions
In this thesis, the capacity-based compressed mode is proposed to resolve the excessive power increase during the compressed mode. To differentiate the priority users based on RF condition, number of RSSI measurement, and continuous suspension avoidance, the proposed algorithm can effectively reserve the capacity by reducing the number of simultaneous compressed mode measurements while keeping the more-than-enough measurements before a user handing-down to GSM system. Furthermore, with different choices of k factors, users with different priority in terms of the necessity of border-cell hand-down can be easily separated. The proposed capacity-based compressed mode control can apply to a general design concept for trading off the capacity and handover performance if users’ priority can be identified. The contributions of this thesis are summarized as:
1. Study and report on the detail operations of the compressed mode to execute inter-system handover.
2. The proposed capacity-based compressed mode improves the performance impacts on the capacity caused by the compressed mode.
3. The simulation platform is established for both intra-system handover and inter-system handover in UMTS system.
4. The simulation platform verifies the proposed control algorithm truly works and it can be applied to handover to other systems.
6.2 Future Works
In this thesis, the simulation only considers about the same 12.2 kbps circuited switched services. In the future, the different QoS services are occurred and it will challenge this algorithm. Since the proposed capacity-based compressed mode only considers the measurement issue. For making handover decisions, no matter what services needs the enough carriers’ information of other system. Thus, the algorithm is still work but it will add further criteria in the handover stages. Like the ideas in [33], the handover ordering is decided by the signal strength and the service profile. The next step, this algorithm can consider about the multimedia services and add new control criteria to inter-system handover.
REFERENCES
[1] Michel, Pautet, “The GSM system for mobile communications" France, 1992
[2] Andreas Springer, Robert Weigel, “UMTS: the physical layer of the universal mobile”
Springer-Verlag, 2002
[3] 3GPP, “TR 23.002 V4.8.0, Network architecture”, Jun. 2003
[4] 3GPP, “TR 25.212 V5.5.0, Multiplexing and channel coding (FDD)”, Jun. 2003
[5] Harri Holma, Antti Toskala, “WCDMA for UMTS: radio access for third generation mobile communications” 2nd ed., John Wiley & Sons, 2002
[6] Bernard Sklar, “Digital communications: fundamentals and applications” 2nd ed., Prentice Hall PTR, 2001
[7] 3GPP, “TR 25.922 V5.0.0, Radio resource management strategies”, Mar. 2002
[8] David J. Goodman, “Wireless personal communications systems”, Addison-Wesley, 1997
[9] Chih-Min Chao, Yu-Chee Tseng, Li-Chun Wang, “Reducing internal and external fragmentations of OVSF codes in WCDMA systems with multiple codes”, WCNC 2003.
2003 IEEE, Volume: 1, 16-20 March 2003
[10] Thit Minn, Kai-Yeung Siu, “Dynamic assignment of orthogonal variable-spreading-factor codes in W-CDMA”, IEEE Journal on, Volume: 18, Issue: 8, Aug. 2000
[11] Assarut, R., Kawanishi, K., Yamamoto, U., Onozato, Y., Matsushita, M., “Region division assignment of orthogonal variable-spreading-factor codes in W-CDMA”, VTC 2001 Fall. IEEE VTS 54th, Volume: 3, 7-11 Oct. 2001
[12] Sekine, Y., Kawanishi, K., Yamamoto, U., Onozato, Y., “Hybrid OVSF code assignment scheme in W-CDMA”, IEEE Pacific Rim Conference on, Volume: 1, Aug 28-30, 2003 [13] P. Krishnamurthy, A. Hatami, R. Piclma, “Handoff in Hybrid Mobile Data Networks”,
IEEE Personal Communications, Apr. 2000
[14] Forkel I., Schinnenburg M., Wouters B., “Performance evaluation of soft handover in a realistic UMTS network”, VTC 2003-Spring, Volume 3, 22-25 Apr. 2003
[15] 3GPP, “TR 25.214 V5.5.0, Physical layer procedures (FDD)”, Jun. 2003
[16] O. Lataoui, T. Rachidi, and L.G Samuel, “A QoS management architecture for packet switched 3rd generation mobile systems”, in proceedings of INTEROP, Mai 2000
[17] 3GPP, “TR 23.107 V6.2.0, Quality of Service concept and architecture”, Dec. 2004
[18] M. Gustafsson, K. Jamal, and E. Dahlman, “Compressed Mode Techniques for Inter-Frequency Measurements in a Wide-band DS-CDMA System”, The 8th IEEE International Symposium on, Volume: 1, 1-4 Sept. 1997
[19] 3GPP, “TR 25.211 V5.4.0, Physical channels and mapping of transport channels onto physical channels (FDD)”, Jun. 2003
[20] 3GPP, “TR 25.215 V5.4.0, Physical layer - Measurements (FDD)”, Jun. 2003
[21] 3GPP, “TR 25.133 V6.1.0, Requirements for Support of Radio Resource Management (FDD)”, Mar. 2003
[22] S. Hamalainen, T. Henttonen, J. Numminen, J. Vikstedt, “Network effects of WCDMA compressed mode”, VTC, The 57th IEEE Semiannual, Volume: 2, April 22 - 25, 2003 [23] 3GPP TSGR1#5(99) 633, “User Management in Compressed Mode”, Cheju, Korea
[24] United States Patent US6498933, “Method for Transmitting Data for Inter-Frequency/Inter-System Handover in Mobile Telecommunications System”, Dec.
24, 2002
[25] Wang Ying, Shang Dan, Zhang Ping, Wang Hai, “Comparison between the periodic and event-triggered compressed mode”, VTC, IEEE 55th, Volume: 3, 6-9 May 2002
[26] Zhang Zhang, ” WCDMA compressed mode triggering method for IRAT handover”, WCNC. 2004, IEEE, Volume:2, 21-25 March 2004
[27] Lugara D., Ammi L., Griguer M., Tartiere J., ”UMTS to GSM handover based on compressed mode technique” 2004 IEEE International Conference on , Volume:
5 , 20-24 June 2004
[28] 3GPP TSGR4#11(00)0243, “Downlink radio link performance in compressed mode - 1”, Ericsson, March 1999
[29] 3GPP TSGR4#14(00)0960, “Impact of compressed mode on the capacity of a WCDMA system”, Telia AB, Nov. 2000
[30] 3GPP TSGR4#17(01)0580, “Additional uplink compressed mode performance results”, Ericsson, May 2001
[31] M.Benson, H.J.Thomas, "Investigation of the UMTS to GSM handover procedure", VTC Spring 2002. IEEE 55th , Volume: 4 , 6-9 May 2002
[32] Theodore S. Rappaport, “Wireless communications: principles and practice”, 2nd ed., Prentice Hall PTR, 2002
[33] Ruay-Shiung Chang, Shing-Jiuan Leu, “Handoff ordering using signal strength for multimedia communications in wireless networks”, Wireless Communications, IEEE Transactions on Volume 3, Issue 5, Sept. 2004