• 沒有找到結果。

社會基本權與憲法上工作權之保障

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "社會基本權與憲法上工作權之保障"

Copied!
15
0
0

加載中.... (立即查看全文)

全文

(1)j±11f"~;;c$:;fIW.~J::I{'F;JI;t1*:1!$. 19921f:5GfJ. i±1t£. **fl $it ~ it; J:.-=r. 11= *fl z 1* ~ J _Social. Rights and the Constitutional l1uarantee of the Right to Work. £,t*t Wang Hud-Ling. !iii. ~. A~.A...*liPtr"'.' F.it~~~i~;}a ~ w;i1Hl- ' r.\J~*if.."". £*-'Hl.:i!::.-!f,.jS.f::. 0. f~if..""£*-£~M-.:i!::.*~.t.i.~a.n ••~ • •. r"':R!. . , .{£~ M-Jt .\k:.#I'AJt.;tf *1:.:te.4'J Jlul] , ffiI~;tf .tftM-#Jt .\k:..:i!::.Jt.It.1't:. o~~.A~*£*-~.:i!::.~~~m'~~A...±#~~~~.:i!::.­. , mf\!.:iit1:lf.#tllf$~~ l h . ' Jl:tA.• .3H·~ 11=:flt.:i!::.*1:.~F.it:i M- 1ft. + lL~tl- '. 0. ~1iI:i*~;tfIWl~. J!.*-III j(1ft -alL + ~.I'A r;;l!. *1:.~~~-!f,. • • .tt.~tt1t • YA21~.itI,$iII.l.itJl·J. 0. tt±#:flt ' ~. ff:;ij( , Jl:tA.;fff-=:.::It lUI 1t. ili7 -& ' .It I'A !!,:#.,IS,~ i*i~ JlIJ itI, 1,JJ Jl:tA.;ij( ~~~:flto±# • • ~ff:;ij(Jt.;tf • .tt.-~~'21~.~~'~~. ff:;ij( - :;t ili11tJ-jE Jl:tA.;ij(1@. • .:i!::.... -$ , ~AJl:t A..:i!::.+a.. 7ItJ ~Ji. 0. '"It~ 1II~ff: •. 0. jJ -:;t ·ifil.{£:fA".a. ~ ... J:..J!tJ. ,IS,. .:i!::.Jt.It.'frm.{£m.fTM-*1:. ~ JI'lllJ# ','.. ABSTRACT It has been recognized. that life with human dignity needs not only. civil rights and political freedoms, but also the economic, social and cul­ tural rights (generallly. social rights). The scope and extent of social right are difficult to be clearly defined. Therefore the social rights are hardly justiciable as the rights graranteed in costitution. Their application usually needs detailed regulations. The most important subject in social rights is the right to work. In the modern constitutional theory it combines with political freedoms and property rights to become "trilogy" of the constitutional state. Together with the right of existence and the property rights. the Article 15 of the. ••itMU*liB.~~~~i\9± • Jjf:tti&?tO\:~~IlVf~fftIUt5ct3!!. -77­.

(2) m-. W!ltIJ~W. M. Constitution of ROC (Taiwan) gral-antees the right to work. and within the "Basic National Policies" includes also principles for labour law and industrial relation. Lg_ labour protection principle, full employment, and cooperative industrial relations (Art_ 152 tT_)_ It schould be noticed. that the right of existence harmonizes the. ~;. 'f. t. connict between the right to work and the property rights_ In this respect, the right to work is defined and complemented through the right of exis­ tence. It not only modifies the concept of property rights. but also creates property to some extent. However. it is necessary for Taiwan to make more effort in law-making in order to protect the right to work guaran­ teed in Constitution.. -:I:'. 'lL. •. ~~~w$tl*1!!m~~I¥JRlG~W~~. ~~. F]lJ. €r. °M~J:7*W:..t.ZEJEi3ZJS~'~3& ~~..t.~1=:..~Z=1'EJEi3W=1'ZP:$f-. :tE~*;f:fi~UI¥J~JBi:~~ rp ~!P!JIXri3 EJ. Ei3;fifi. , rtJ. (Buergerliche. politische Freiheiten,Civil Rights) ,. ~Pt!i :!1I:!-1¥J~*;f:fi (Klassische drechte). ,. ,. und. :ifF. Grull­. ft1f!.;Im~$Utii*l¥Jm.ff~. ~m+j\.1!t*c.*~±.JIX~1m~. ;1m , 7:1tJ.~1ttl:W1tUJIXJffz;fifi.1J ' ~. *JIXJfftJD~~~Z~~*~' ~OO At~tJ.~~~-ez"g1Jm*Q*1¥J ¥i1i.¥'J ' mJIXri3~ifJl¥J.:f::.~ § I¥J ' ~. fffi1WlAEJ Ei3l¥Jtiig.~ , ~*"g~ *jfd:iWZ~1IDt&~ , &j'ffi1!fRlGM1i{ ~g.rp~Yi!kA=¥rp'*~i!kA 1¥J1=:.?I5~~~lHm~;;tt*.1J~1'.i-' tJ.3&. *11J1J~~~*'MRlG~1Jm~' *!lW1~1tf:1E:rE. 0. lltli!Jjl~PJTtM*1¥J. F",'jJm~;}J::R1[1~AI¥JJitm fi5*~. '. , ~t~jfd:~m~$u ' tJE*-f~*EJ Ei3 ;f.fi1fz =1'JEtJ. ~~OOAZ1=:. ff lSt;;tt A t!:#M' ~fffi~~~~tfj "jfd:~¥ ,*;f:ji" (soziale Grundrechte, Social Rights) Zf.ft~ , ~mA~t~~*-f1~ A#MWA~ EJ Ei3~~PJT£'~Z~ ~ , jfd:"frlSt:>Cft~;fifi~lJ ' 'WU~DI1'F , ~W ' ~B1l ' jfd:"fr~W1" .~~ ;;tt rp I 1'F:fii~1~A1=:.ff=::k3tttZ - , fffi~l!.II~H.r*m+1i1~~mJE : .. A~Z1=:.ff;ff( . . 11'F;fifilStMlfilfl , ~7~~ utE~~k"1.lltpJT1'Fz llifQ~fiU=1'~.w. ' *x~P~~I1'F;f:fi Zg~ , pg?@: , tJ.lStI1'FffiW.r* ..t.~ftg~*ffiZ;f§rmt!:tJDtJ.~fl ' 0". ~Jj.tJjlf.f*i1Jr*m*D~I1'FffiW. fiU_§:~.. ~1¥J~~rJL' tJ.WJ~*ifJ4fllt:r:][~*. , ~W . . m~fij!.····· .$f-jfd:. .~Uz7m*-fpJTWJ~. iWF",'JJm ; fJ5.]~m."g.1JI¥JIS1f!{E: ' iE.. WJjl - 78­. ~!'. 0. 0. ,. ~1JE;;tt7iS?t.

(3) Ii.:tir£*:fi:WlniU:I1'F;fIZ1*~. 19921¥5GFI. *1ftzmlig, ?f.FRJJJil!YJ*fflttJZ/$!. i\ " ;f±-t-£.*~Zm* ,. 1Z§J1:t~.mIf'F.z. r~. :t.EJIt;fliJ~t~cp. El3n!illJz~. 0. £F.ZffE~J(.7*.B~jj'd:.~*;f:II. P97i§ • ::ff ~\~tijjtt*~*.llIl!fF~i1d. Z ~liffiJ ( ) , ffi.Mz.*~f~ JfJ::ff !':mlltifiW. 0 -{--fL-I:lt*i:.z ".7*" ~a~ .J{IJJIt{ttl';l;ijIiBzfqJ~~l'!J ' ffij;lt~/L\. ;iljJ;:. - '-. f*~MA.:&'fd:.. , 7*1!YJ--t:;/\iL £F.zA.1ft~~ (Declaration des droits de l'homme et du citoyen):&.--t:;tL.=.. EI3~If'F;f¥i.mjj'd:*~*.zm ~~EJz-. 1M '. ~±.1t.4.*~fl:.t.ftJAl. :tE~rtJ~.WJlt{tt?l§mo. I~¥$zf&' OO:jji±~Zimf'F. (Grundrechte) ~A;f:II ( Mcnschenrechte. Human Rights):tE;It. %~~ifill§EI3·~'rml!YJ*Zff!1.J. "®:.l!8i:reJ::.lF!':mAi~~A.~J-im~. S'l:~~~r~:;1Jlig, ;tt~*~3&. *Zltff.;f¥i(Abwehrrechte) , ;It EI!':m. :ftM~:f;$]:&.Jiil±F1~~Zjfrl:*I"","JQ. :tE~OO:~~A::fff.&*'tt.Z;f:ll;fIJ-=Y. ~ffij*~ltA.. ~"ffij~*I!il!.I*zf1t. ~*;f:II. J;j,$:Jt1t '. Mz.~:!n~W:~JW::X. ~f'F~. ' WIJ. 0. (jtt-). iliU~jj'd:.JIt{~. 0~lE~Zjj'd:~~JUlia. pj,lii:rril!.l*mJ-i~f~.H5HB~~1l::Z. fmAtr.m!fii!n!iIlJIiBIE. ,. m. !1~mfJ*zjfj1!r.. -fJ}::ffrmA.!':mJtftf:~'mw&~~­. JJmf*z~J!I,. =-li£F.~iI!.I!':m. ~~. EI3*W:. (Magna charta libertatum) , ;ltP9~fli!:fi~ :.:tW~mZ%<;f¥i • ~ffij;ltcppJTm~ !':mA. ffiJi~J. ~ • J{U:t.EltEf ~1&1fJf~ ~ ftt§~r*W:Fm'tt7$:tH-~H!I!~cp , ffJ. pj,"®:J.m:$:.m~ili!':m ' ~~!':mA.;f:II. 0 (tt=). tJ zltfff4\J;f¥i. ; fqJlJ~Mz.lii~J& • ~*!':m:::r-1lJ1~. jji±.~*.;fIJ". 0. ffi.mr~U-fL-fL. £F.~mfJZJi!!(;~.7*. of rights). ~g~~M~I!!l!J*1Iiffl;f¥i 0. ~*~~mfJ*zf'F~. • ~:tE~~~iiI±.~~tI1f~ligz lE'mimiP8 • ffij13.~MAm*::ffz ... -t:;-t:;A£F.~I!YJZMilJL~",,'ffij§(!~. ,. • J;j,:&'MA.W~*. ~. A;f.ffi§~I±\!~:iljIj(ftmU~­. 'pJT~~~. • J;j,*~13 El3J1:tffit;¥j!*. fm:tE~1iffifWdmA!:tI!il!.l*zJjEi:t:EW~,. *. ~~1'I'liliU~z;f¥i;fIJ7*~ (Bills. ,. 0. '. 1itlJi<!i JEj EI3±ftz~~. jEais1Ji!*.mjji±"~!fii!JL~' ~iliUff. JIt{.:&' .~;fWl , SJttMilJL • J;j,:&.:fil ~MAWjtt*~~~*=Fi!Pz •• JEj mltlB1'i!D" 0 ffij :lfl1&-~!lJJ.m!5Yt!~. • fd:~~*.~ :t.E:il7*tf:(ij~f~-~z:t& 0 :tEJIt-:iI 7*CP.7UZjj'd:.~*.~ts : Y~~1!5I , *~:&.£l'tt;z.:r*~(l19) • ;}fY~~ .:r-3<:Zff!;f1J (121) • ~W;f¥i (145, 146) • f*fi"413:p.~#,liiZ~n!i(151) • tt~. (155) • If'F.:&.~~sJ&1ff ( 157,159,163) • iji-l:*f*~(161)";~~ o '11i1Z§*P3ff3::~~® • Ji!!(;;;~.7*z Jlfl.~Mz.*lig3E:$t.!YL. -79­. a. ~=::xtlt:fil*~Cp "iiH:*~~.

(4) m. ~IJJ~¥i ". (Soziale Sicherheit, social security). J!J.MztJHI:i '. PJ.l5t*g§~.~cpffi. 1&~zl!Y*. EE-m1l11§EE"gJe,. EE'!ie~~m.!I@.!ie~IIfZ~§EE. , tEg§:n ~.:EI!iJ*:§i1~~~?'JHjglW • J!tE.~I!iJ-j1.I!Y/\1f:~=1f.i~ r t!t W-A:fIlErs J PJ.l5t-n"A"A1f: r~ ~ " Jfd:~ " ::}(1't:fll~IjI!iJ~~*"1 J ijJ3 ::}(*mA~ZI.1"F " ~lf " Jfd:~$( WJ" " •••.• ~Jfd:~~*. 0. (~Il9).¥.llt·*~1!i:I!iJ*~1Ii~. M. f*-ilm5:E5i- ' ~f~.:E~.~ljz1-i$l! , ffil~*~8,t;1t+7!J;fj$~.~Z , 17tl~D~~§El3Zfj$l!~I!iI*+ 7!J;1f-¥ ' t~rE.J~~~iH.1B~E.Z7*~ ~~~.*~*+7!J;. ffilfji&l5t1L7* ftlD1~J.Uit;1tfj$mte~.ZmijJ3. ffilJfd:1i££*.JlU.&:Z ' ~5:E~lJtj!t1"F$~!inj~ ,. 0. ~$I!iJ*jjt ~Jl:t~1"F~. .~zpg~!If!fili§tltl~ii:l:.1i£~*. .*~5:E.Z=1'ijJ3l1i. 1't '. '. ~Jf~;ho~ft. ::aJlU~IJ~~.PJ.rE.J~~.:E5N.;1t. .~fj. ~~t!l~~*.mf*~z§. w,.l5t~Mzpg~~'~aJt~~mm. 1!iJ*~{:f:!9f~1J!~ra~·. ,~. 0. 17lltlIJJfd:.f*~$Un£. ( .7*~. ffilRl 1:Y.=r51JfH'i!itirJ~Z~~!I@.jtl::~~~ ;. •. 155 {t¥) fii:!tz~ 13. ~Mz~~. '. 7*lJ!f*~3]Z Ag.tM:pJTfM~~~ff. 1iiB~~fl..rtl£f@1A~31<z-a:rll!g,. ~$;ffilt:E~-:nOO*~'§EE.. ~~ft1'tZ;fd:~~*.:ML~ "7*m. J;}Jll!gZ~sU. '$~~.1~~n£~ii:I:.. 1iiB~jj". *. , 7*~$1AA~~$U;1t~fj. f*~,,~w.7:!.¥.~~m~.Zm. , {iH~~1L7*.g~fji&1JJt~~, f.&fflt:t.J 7.}1L1J.i(JlU, tJ.~.~W!ie~ -=¥.Ji)tfj$l!i&rat?:!$U (politische· Kon­. ~,l;t~.~~·§t=1'~~I!iJ*Z. troll). ~~~. 1"F. ". 0. :£Jlf\::;~.:Ej±~t:p. ~mB~. ". ,. ~.$(!JiJ. ~IHJI.. ". j±~. (ltt"A). Jfd:~~*ffiZ~ .W:£JlfElllt3.JI. 1li~ff~' ~~'~$U5:Elfl3lJSi&m:7* ~PJ.{IE;1t.:£Jl. 0. ~I':9Uf'.::I:Um. 0. :. 1. jtf:1i£~*.pg~~*;fj!:m1ffi~. .=.. " ~±.~~tE.z...... 1I1.crite.. ,. xlli*7*ZlY311itt'Wm~ff.' W~"I.1"F.' :ML*flijJ311i~pg~. 'r.i.. ~fimg. ,. J3.~ff.~I.1"F.~RI. rE.J~.:E5N.~~*~·J'Lllt~~tE. !l@.t!l~¥*.lfl3.' g§:n~if ;i,iiIDt::a~.7*t:p~IHlJfd:~~*.Z. .7*t:p~MmMtllJ. m5:E7:!A.BM~.PJ..:E~~. ~~*.~fl.tiitt' m-qjfd:~. ,. :ML~EE7*. 0. flJifEE~Jfd:. (. ~Mffilr&.' 17lltllJ~ff.~P3~. (ltt. El3:mdg;~m~,.' 7Jii.$~~Z. ~*A;f&z.7*f*~~m~1!iJ. ~m7J<.~' ¥4'-J!:i1tffil$m~~. *z~ff$·I3~:tE~.af@1A§. m~ff,tkffil1:Y.f;5J;Jt~.~Z~. El3mJ!JJz~~· fElJl:t~.7*J::JJU~. 31< '. ~.1ft;tt.¥;L~ffz "~~J::.~Ij". subjektiv-oeffentliche Rechte). ). 0. - 80­. 7*z~5:Ett (Rechtssichel'heit).

(5) j-11l~!!t!.7*J:.::r.1'F"~f*1If. 19921'f·jCF.! IZ9z;1J'~!M~.. - :J.flIii 1Z9~~~lil!ffij~FfTWl!I~ ,. (fit). 0. 2. ~D::E5~jfd:1!r~*;Mm1lJWFMi~~. ~-:J.n.mjlljmm*M~j!t~fagjJ. Z ".:.fU" 'Ef3~ J::Mt?f~ rV:Hi'itt , 3&UJ:!?,~~~J!i)njfd:.~;<$:;Mz.P9. fffi~' lZ9.tltlitl:*~~.lJl.z.;f-~. ?l§1JIJP).!f.~' .tlt.1mA~~¥.. jfd:.z.~f"11fgjJm~~. ~~ftfJI1nitUIT' :M!.~m1L~;fti. mJ~m~ti~*A;ffIWjfd:.~*. ~R. .5!1i*llttz.~~;1$ilH4 Jf.. (fij\.) ~Dw::tE.7* cp~jfd:. lJlm-1lJ:m~~JlP).!.tm~~~~1St. 1*' m~~R*tl~*.jJW~*~ *.~f1=m ' =-1ffftE:tR*J::~ ~~, jfd:*~*;M~ffl<:.WJ::z. 'Wtl • 765tJii;t~~~f.d~jf~~m. ~. ".I.*~JJt~m"AjJ~m,,~. JtUUJ:!.7*~~. '. ~~• • '..fiJt.~~=1'Ifi~Jl!.'. ijJJtU~JlP)'~.fJiF¥mz, P)'.~. mm*:tR**7*ztt.~=1'~. ·~m1St.7*z!i&fi3o. 3. jfd:~£*.W 13 Ef3;MIZ9Jt.;<$::itJ:: z~A. '. ~~~~fjjg"~Uff!~~1iIJ. 7*1$i*W'l (Gesetzesvorbehalt) ,. j-J:... 0. 0. w~m. ~B~H~HstA 13 Ef3;ff1zi*iliiB~. ~Z.;fI311]!iGi3' ~ffij-1riIfi*.I.. P).j±~~*;M=1'Ifi.5B!z~*. ,. " it* ". fiIij:i!j[~"AtJ*SmZ."~~·1Z9. .tlt fj3J tlJ5Rftiti 7 I:iJfag'~. ~mm*~m~A~.I.f1=z.Bi :M!.5!1i*tl::Li::~JiHf.j ~Z~W. '. ,. ~ffl<:!1~:fiM. !t:H~Affij <=itkffij1lJfag. ...m ".I.f1=.~'·. 0. 4. ~-).Ji~ji:Jtumjfd:*~;<$:.Z~ i~H~jfijttt. '. jfd:*~*;ftitl:ti:~1St. jgjSJ*z.~f~H'Tm. '. ~~f1z.P9~. 0. jfd:.~*;fiIz. jfffI. (ltl:+-). jfd:1\J£*.lSl~fftEJ::~~r",1] ~. , ntE'Hld1=:m£*~ramiiB(poli­ tische Ordnung) , w.::ctJ::ftEf3Jt. « ~.. Z.~mifffi~:fim.ttJ;bfag, f4 f1=m~~tiJlTm*fi:mlE.i3~!Jij. :az.~jJ,l;. • •J::JtuP).:tI..m=¥~ • .Ef3~.~:±.z:1.f5:~ , :Mffl<::M!.~ :'tL~~J&?'ii~~J::z;!t., P)'f.!Effl<:. 81\. ~-:J.riIfi~7;tf.. • 'Wtl~DI!il~~ra " ~~NUJ!J " 1X. , 3&P).jfd:*~~lifiWJ 13 Ef3:«1765t ~'TUJ:!z*~~%~~~ 0 (lttJ-L ) 'Wll~D765tJii;t~ZJi!*~DilJimm JtljliEJ*~Jl*fffi:fi~Uz:*P:1A*m. ,. •. m.tJf,§~~~~:M!.~FI!il*PJTfag~*tl. W1~:a1lJfag~3&r3 Ef3.z!lf~. ,. ~7;tf~m~~Jt.ii>c..,. 1I~:fiPJTfjj~. '. =1'~51®~1Il' =1'1fiJi!*~*T. ,\1. " :J!{f,!W~m " ~Ml~m···. T1L~-1ftE~*jfd:*~*.Z.. P)'3&51® 13 Ef3;M~~Z.iIJ ;. " 1"--1. .tlt~Ef3. • 'Wll~D Iit?JtlA.i}~ (Europaeische Men­ schenrechtskonvention) Wl&PJ~~ ~P]7*w.rt.~z.5!1i*tl=¥~· fffiJli::?JtI (Europaesche Sozialcharta) jlUP)'~M¥IH!r.~m BJE. (ltt+) 5. jfd:1!r~*.z..ffIjJf.d~1St1!l!.l* !tJllli*.P9~z... ~~5tfagjJ ( P)..I.f1=~ Verfuegungsmacht). 0. ~~*;M~ft1t.. ··'"f. ,. I. I. I. \.

(6) m*z~*S'. :lE~~-g-::w1i~ (inte­. grative Funktion). tE~·'7C1t;~~jfd:.. 0. .WH!!\~~).1±~59i~iiDL. 1!trcp ,. -. ~. *!WJ~n ~*J)j(Jm. 0. 100. .lltlm~;E:~~~~Z~. ~'!tJ~*iVJ• • W~~.$:~~~ {ilJlmg~. ,. ~,~5t:fJDP)'Jmm. 0. 83~tE~~~~ZJll!l~i1iiCP:Mz*. ~*1Wf@D~~jfd:.1!tr~*~~ (Ba­ siskonsens) Z::w1i~'. ~)'~:9B~~7C. tJEte~kz~~ilitll3tM~' ~.llt~).. 1t;ffil~3&jfd:.1!tr:$j-~. Ctt:+=) tiD. ~~~~f'F~~lffml/iBZ1~~J)j(ftU. 0. ,. '!M~t:::'.~~~~jtraJ11Ifitirn~z~. J]i ,. tiDjfd:.~~*;f.I:. ,. BI~Hfij=1' ~. , ftU. ~W:r-f-g-~~Z1JifitiIJHIi.!~*i(tru. ,. llJ1i~~.W~~~lE~tt (Legit­. imitaet). 0. (tt+. ). '!M~~~militlz~~. ,. ~1if*k. ~13tZCPJLtE (Neutralitaet). CPJLtt:Mz~F7§.~~ilitl ~zjl*~~. ,. f&;!t. 0. ' ~ti Ef E8~. ~%~::akfJ,.1ifM. {§'1JWllJ~ o=i '. iItkilitlzjtiItkm-IfIJ~~ilitll3t. , ,. ~~Z*.=1';f§~. '. W~~. bindlichkcit) , {§.~)..lltliH~~pJT*~. , J&J&tiDWfi~ ~~~ilitll3t ' ftUJE3A!. 0 (tt+1?:!3 ) ~tE.llt=tii~Zf79 ' ~*1~=1'~ *k~lffilitl13tZ~* ' ij'~.~~~ W1T=1'raJZJ&m ' 3&Jf.H~~Zm~. z0~!M~*:MIJili7J~1if~;E:~*. wmtn&'. .1J. ~. .Wzjfd:.1!tr~-g-::W1i~ ~Z~m.lJi~~{tj::. ¥*ffliZ~;E:. ,. i7J~J;l~)'~f79 i'&'!M~jfd:.1!tr. tE.i*M~--'c~=1'. ~fMjMmzWm~*.1J (Rechtsver­. (~~--r:7U4§-lin. JLW':&1TJ&=¥~. ,i@~~*~).. , tEWf1I!:--.C.:&ilitll3t. J::1*~A~z--'cJ]i~*;fCfU. 0. 0. tijfd:.1!trW~7j!f:fJDP).-g-l!I!m. E8mitiB~mffil s. ' m*~.llt~"g­. *I1JW~lff11lj][~.1:E' 1if~~ilitl k*_::r:JA!~~J&m.:&JLW. 0. ­. ffilm*'!M*!W':&~lffz.{:f:~. ~. '\. ~11=~-z~~&fi'J i~. ~83-==-~~~':JL;lt:lE~~~~Z JlI[~'U:;y.;~.W--'cZ~'~+1i f~~)..:&~*~mZ;f§lHlf~::stJ!:fJD~).. -'.~.J:.WIiJ1!.~~?If. • • z..~*~1A. 59i1t; , .~ilG~z~lffW*ih.:tt o (tt+1i) ~+1if~zm;E: "A ~Z~ff. " If'F;f.I:':&M~fff ' H!!\ 71*~" '7J-ilGm*ihW~lff• • Z*,~J{UtEmk; ffiltt1!tr~*;f.I: cP W. *I1J~Z1*a1ifrm~' *tI£=1'te~. 1if1Jil*!Ww~~ • • z~m,. *f~1*~iliBlmz~. -§" 5t~'im~WilG~.WCP-J]i*~. , NP. .i* cP I¥.J :;y.;~). ~ ;E:AzJjSI,~::t. ~iH'F~JL.ft(:JJ.l -f~Zmk~. ,. 0. . it'. '\. 1. ~1Z9;ltk~~. ~flH~'f79~~~~tz,i'&Ui~~. *~m~-==-lP. ~.WM o=t.:&~. ". ~[glPcp7UI¥lm~. ~lff':&jfd:.1!tr~~z~J]i. ~~-B[g+=. ,. ~~*!W. .:ttW~7j!f.~z~m~mo. f~mk~)'~~~iif'F~~~~~z ~tR::. ,. - 82­.

(7) jfrl:~~*;tI!ffl:.i'!J:I.f'F;tIz~1i$. 1992:if-5GFl. (4)f*,~. ~. , .:r:.1'1=~fl2:.:t A.~pq ~. ... J!J!~.pHM. 1*1F.ij;).&..:::c1'F~OOz-g­ 0. 4.~wj,j.\Gm~.:::c*zffI~IJ&.n.:::c •. • j'[5ffii <=t. '. A~~1{};lt.~ffm. .z!fo/JJff~1Cf::. '. *Fl:f::[[i~M~. , NfJW m:*WJ ' :1LP)' "*Wl' z~M' 1i'£. m~~J{U1i'£I~}JtlJ!J!$* (Europarat,. ~*tJ,:I,t~~fl:R*&.~ift£.:::c~~. Council of Europe) m:-JL~-1¥~. MP)'*~~z=¥~. ~ziX}JtIjfcl:*• • (European Social. 0. !-1I 1'Fffl1'Fft1i'£1it17z.El.lWBz. 1Z9.tl:~~E8MAI3. E83H=m~$.:::c 1'F' P)'*1~-g-::tm~M!. ,. *1£t~MA&.;lt.*.Z~fr5. '. ~fM~~Mjfcl:1!irift£~:m*~.. charter). &..:::c1'F. ' 19j'[5: (tt+ j\ ) 1. ~$.:::c1'FZ lIV¥IJ :. 0. (1 )3T;7}U~j}j(mZmfi. ,. "13 E8ffjJliI!·~·~;f:¥f1*~" (Freiheits­ und Eigentun1sklauscl) , mliiBl!l!!J*W ~ ~r",,'jzIHI1* ; ffiiJ~f~.Slikl1l!~J{U M~~1i'£ : 13 E8:fti . . M~ • ... .:::c1'F. ':=:'7C~. (3)IM~:fr*B. (4).~m~ ... ~~WII**W1fi\!~:m:. ~ 2.-g-;FJn~*mlJf~ftt-. 1'F~~~~.t1.d*Mtz~*:tfktiI. 0. (2)~j;f#1J!1&.1F.i. :f£!:f:J'~*R!G1i'£.~iliRMt!:f:J~1iJj,j.\G. B. 3. :ti:~f$j~Z.:::c1'Ff~ftf (1):ti:~~i~~~z0ffp. 0. I 1'FfflD~*tJ, :l,t1!i!rJ*fi!TlJ:Bi& Z**:fti:if1J ' ~;;l'tmii§~z$Bl1!I4§­. tM'1iiEz~W.. 4. -g-~*iWJ¥&MI. ~~~z "~j)!f .... 5.M1*5;ft1. 1fi±1!ir'" :>C1t.iflJ. , *J1HI.:::c1'F:ftiztflH}* ( ). ¥2:1g:fl5~;9U4§-lJ{:. 6. ~mx1W;fffi 7.*.:::c1*.~. l.3H~~~ZI3. (I )~jt&.1¥i9?-1=f:1*.1Hf. 2.~~11~U~WWIl~. (2 )fEIl:tc*WJ~1*.li:fi. 3. 0-IEW.m.tfr-~.:::c1'Ff~fCf:: ' 19j'[5 : (I )~ :tc[EJ.:::c [EJ M! 0 (2 )~:(!?i&-g-:Jm~ fr5 z.:r. 1'F¥~M! 0 (3)*~~j~z.:::c1'Ff~fCf::. ... 1iiEfi. (2)J!ii±&'*ih~Im!Hl~3i:~~~. 1!l!!J~*J~~' t£D{&.-g-I!l!!J-j-L~~. f!iIQ~0-~". :. (1 )-g-;FJn~.:::c1'F~OO. (ltt-l-~) I1'F.:tEJ!J!~lfijZftJ!it~. ~ . 6. (2) 13 E8~~.:::c1'F.. (Triologie) ,. ~z~*ffI:if1J. ~:g~+fLf~*JlHIjfi±*. ~*.~IJZm~!:f:J~fl[[g?tZ=7J..P. ~­. fL il!:*c..7*l1I!~P)'13 E8.WM~:fti ~lftt~~1t-Jz=*~~. ,:fE. 8.~~g§gtg.. 9.1fi\!~m(~;fffi. 10. ,.~~*1fi\!~~ff!Ii.!~~:m:~ 11.~Ji5*i/J*Lf*~. 0. -83­.

(8) ~i€\$ili5Jtg. i1'~H ~ ~~. Nljgi'~:!K. '$o~~i( iit. I iW :!K ~ jg $.~ID!I:!K~ ~1i:ffi~~:!K. $'a'~~N~~ ··~/L-nJ~.. iit~~w{a~. ~1l~iG~1l\D N~ I ~~iit ~/W~iq!. fit. ~~~i~~N~~.~~~~~~~*. N~~~. ¢Ht~~~~~~'~~~~*~~N ~~~I.~.~~~~I~·II~' N¢!-~~~~~f!H~~lti'.. ••. ~~1~8'~!~~~~*.~. '**~~~DNI~I~~~"IH ~ H~~.~~~~~I~w.~H~.~. iI«lm". ·1~il~~~j~lti'I~H~~ljg. ~. 1~~~~jg~~N° ~ "~Ntr~~~. ~~~N!,;~~~~!$fEiI$li!::. ... ~~ I lE! f .. ~~~~~*~~~wr~il t;~tt~~tt~~~+mIIi'N:tH. ~~. 1'~f~I.$N~~iq!#~&~~O ~Ni!~·~I~~NH~~~~H'~. 1~~~~~o~~~~~_~~ii!~N~~~~'~ _'l1il~·~. ~ ~ -\¢$ ~~. ~~ ,~. W~. , ~. I. {t{. t'. l. ~~ ~ ~. tt­. H. ~. ~. If ~ ~ ~. wa. ~. I. I. l* ~ I. '1' 00 I.

(9) Jftt1~r~*;t.I'~.~J:I{'F;t.IZ.f*~. 19921f-5Gfl. ;ffl "' M~;ffl:Mz.71J • iiJi:m~51U1Jil:lr~ ~~z;ftlt~IJ· t&I Jtt::l:.~§:':f¥;f#l~)\. ,§Mn~~~l1g1J~ t q~!EJiU*~*~. t. 1115 ;. 1&m~n~JiX:jft1:*l&J'f{!A!~?;!fl&. mz;f.fi~'~:b1-~:f¥*Yiz1*~o. *~mJ5JTfljfz"~Ij· ;ttpg~il;R!EJ~ fm1:!?*IiH.::*1*~'&if:11!~nl&WJi{Hj!Ipg. Z$JJi. (tt-t-fL). ~11IAZ~:f¥. ~PJ~fir;;. , §:.:f¥;ftIt1.f\tlDIEfJJ5JTfl. ifd:*¥*.~§:.;ttpg~=1'I¥3~zm. (. :tJt t fElJtt=1'~~VB~;tt3t*!i!P~jE ;tt.:m0t;*J::z "*Yi~Ij" t ffilP)Jftj-z. ~D;ttgfliHMifim~:b1-m*flf1*. iiJi~P3~f;lft~:f:I!lfiizEJi¥J~7.J"~15. 0. 1:Q.fI5J5JTfl~.:w;mJi$J::Z.*'. titr). P)'~P.lGJr.J::zp.~~WzPJ. :j1fttfg. .. ~§:.&, ~mfjt .. (Daseinsvorsorge) t ~ •• ~ ~1*~" (Auffanggarantie) t ~!i!P:tE. ~1*~1tJ.if&:m~1I. .:-:1:1'F"!n~'~ifM*l1gi'iii9~z1JiR~P)'. .J:1~~jlJ*$~:i1{1'm¥Jvf.rz*Yi~IJ. ~:f¥1WH.ftfl51*~z. 1~'d't{~:±:~FF}~JiX:0~. ~~jft1:1it~WB~~J5JT:mz. t. Jttlm~M1tJ.~. (. ). ~umfl.jf-I!f*m*1*~;tt~1¥z ;fti~Ij". ,. A ... ~JttJJi"ifM~IJ":Mz.:3-F~$~~. t. • ifij. ~*1L~. Wfil&~IDl~~~A~§:':f¥Z:lr~. ~~~o. EI3~~. 0. "' jftcWr"'. 3t1!::;.~lJm~. 0~zF.f~CP~PJ~m.. t. -€1.:s:p.A~#.Z§:.m. &'~0~J:!. t. ~DW::*fl'. !Jt!~ttfg. 0. tlD:fiJ:tm~~+ l i1*~ftifij~ifii. t ~:f¥:ftIm~If'F.&M~.zJ:: ' ~P).I1"F*Yi~MJ!'I[«iz1*~ , :I:$]:m ~jH~~ffZ"T~ t I2§Jtt ' ~:f¥:ftIz 1*~~;Jt:m:~EJI¥.J t ¥~JttI1bI1'F. l&tiH3 EI3;ft1:Wifd:*"' ~~&3t1!::;J:: ;f.fi~ljz1*~:Mz.:m t ~Jtt "if:**~ .. 1Iiu]j{!iltt:m.m~:f¥;ftIzm~-=¥~ • m.1!PJ*~jfH~§:.mz1*~;9'f- t tl:t :b1-1:E:f¥"Zf§'!f-~~!nA~.. ( Menschenwuerde) P).&~:±:JlSt~ ( Demokratie ):a:f§Mi-€11JDP)'~lM jft1:**~~jjim~IJ\il?l*zl!l[~ t. ;9'f- • p)'=1'mJilEfI1lAZ§:'ff*Yi~~~ t ~fl·~jEI1'F.WM~.fB~z J;/J1ig , :Mz.tl:tI1'FifMWM·~;ftItrd1z00 ~1.JDP).ilJijJW 0 tl:tM~;ftiffil~ t ~~. ;It.!Ji.IE.~fl!fijl:b1-11IA:tEflliA1~~. *mmcpflHM~.~'&1IiUzW51um. " 3t1t.&ifrtll?t$JJiJ::zi;kJflJt::fflW ~J::z~!A!" • MAtlD1m~~~tk m • ~1J1.f\~Dt~m8!lG:E1.!H.~1P&~.IE Jrm • fElJtt~:f¥;f.I:1*~zHi! t·:ff. ~~~ "' ifrt* "' 3t1t.~mziA!:m~. ~?f.. (~1431*¥.~ 1451* ). !A!:fIi°:m~ye*~IkA~fEl~~:i!k. WHf:HMJt.1·~;ftljfi~. 0. UlZ 1J:S~ •. *YiWM~:ftI~S't"'§H¥*;f.I:zruJ!1IiU. .:mM~;ftIz-JN:~*1*~. meine Bindungsklausel) ,. ?i~!dmii}E;tt:~n'irJ::·~HIiI!.. ;. m- ~. t fl-tJD.I;.tm'fB&,. o~itE~=1'-€1:f!1!&=1'-€1:p.~1J'.f~. ~ZM~1Y!ffl. 1~IEW~J::~W:zp.~. ~*(Sozialbindung). ta:tii:m~fi. '. ffijfl~R.z~·:W~8. Zfi~·I!l!.l*fl~~~~~:f¥.t. ,. ¥~tS~·. ~ifij~§:.g-i~M~:ftIzm* ~~fI1lA:ftI~. t ~ff (allge­. -85­. t. ~~M~:ftIzitC1!r. t MA*YiflJzfT.

(10) 11. ~. ~!lUJ~¥~ fi!!~1~'t-:f!j~~iftl:-e:, ~FIlI1M..A.~~. jftifit3!f!~lm1~' tM~"nljfti-e::ertfl. ~1~ffl;2?dtB..A.Z~:fj;f.l:.f1j. f:E '. 0. nm. J.V,.~ :fj;ffllf'Fi1\Ur!l~Zmf;11MW ( Auslegungsmaxcime) , :1F~Jfj\-y_I f'F;ftIl~~:l;t!iUz ' *00J::. "*ill' ~ ~zf*~tt (tt=) ~Jlt~~ :1F IlI1I!iJ*~:t.I1'F;ftIl:!1A!Mi!fHCZ1*~~ 1lJflFJT~m ' i!&mpJ 11$l±I *jifhi,Wrn -g-1'FZW-JW ' ffiHii~Z§B9JWtE~ 0. ~*IJjg(~.oo~Z~Ji!'i!&~:fj;ffll~. flZJS-iti.I 1'F.~M~;ffllzJJJfi15. 0. Wltt.r;!;~*I!iJ~P3zmjEffij. ~. , •. .~mfiiJ*!ii±~:st1tzJJ&~ 13. ?&.~J::.zrC;':MmJt.''M'~~~. '. ffijflFJT~~. ,. i!&JJ&J&1iflia:~~~jE. ~5t:;n~J¥:. '. ffijflt~z1Ji:lt~~~ljm. ~:fj.. ~:fj;ffi:f:~~t!p~I!iJ*"~1Z9~.. ~1Wml:k;jE~*JJ&~. ,. 0. ~m~~). ('Wtl~D.1*'". vJ-~ztMMJ:ri;fttzi*~o. MJ:ri.Zi*_.~*5m'~w-~u. (Strukturprinzip) , Z~*m~. 0. ~~W~1Jr. '. ~~$l:?<:.P3~Z.5!lo. OO..A.M~J::.Zfti~ OO~·. • 7tlli[lJ::.z P.Jl:?<:.;ffi:tJW1£~rJjzoo~ •. ttt.:.l:~3&~:t!ii±l1i1r~mZffi;~. 0. •. ' 1*ll!IiZ. fit!~Dl:?<:.1};tJ.;:.fJj:Q:·. 1.fE~..A.:tJ. (lEti::t[9) ~. lItftJL~J::.5liHt;jFM J:ri• (*!WJ~'. fHiit..A.'. ftM-~lIiz[ttfitJjJfi15. .=... " J{:t& ~. tion). 0. ..A.ziIBUz. ~@~). ,~. (soziale Funk­. (ltI:t1-li). ?&ffij~-jj1ID. *mb~Z{Vil~~.If'F.z1*~~. '. :Mi:i<JJ. 15 ' ;1t:~~lJl±I~ "1£." (Gerechti­ gkeit) J.V,.l:?<:.iftl:fiti@'i¥1Z~;;t m~ !le.~-g-.:sp.~~;;&:Q: (unoekonomisch) , 73'~~~-g-llI'! ' ~-g-.:sp.1£~ (un­ gerecht)ZJ!:1-J:rifif;!ffl ' J:ri~fa:t5"i1t1:-e: ti~ (allgemeine Sozialverpflichtung) Z-=t~ • W5mFJTfl;fi~1~~ , ;1t:1T. :st1t. 0. :tE.it;r:p*flf9i.i~~1Jl. 0. tMMJ:ri.Z~}jiU l±I~~~;;&*J::.tm. ,:Ut~D~m~~~~;:ft;7t~~ jilJlli:zr.m~tlij.~ffl. ~.i*~lj}J~:w.:J. B9 .:tEJV:jl1::i'J*~H:L.flM~Zi5!~ , ffi~flM..A.mfi15 (Personale Funktion ) ; :tE.it;~Wt~~ r:p. :tEMJ:ri;ftt jjooJ:ri~=~m~· -mjfti1!!r:fW* (Sozialbindung)Zt1ftJO • ~-~Umf*. ~~~*z:erti1llfi15:tJ. JJ&mv}\fl!{i1k!-g- ~~JJ&m: '. 0. jf~M~;ffIlm 13 rE{VilZ-fji' ;llt §. ,-jj001~1Ji:lt.~~. IZ9Jlt*.I1*li!fW-~Ul'. ~rE'U;!;J::.~MJ:ri.. rErtJ:I;fi;~~m$tl. P.JmtDOO..A.Z~ffWI!iJ*i£~Z~. ff. 0. 73'~*~~$tl1Jr. z1*~' iinilg:.fL.flM~$tl1JrP.Jl:?<:.13. ~DJlt. ~!Ji;!jfti1!t X*mp.Jl:?<:.MJJ&:ertilifi15:tJ. ,. (Inter­ essenverbundenheit zwischen Kapital. und Arbeit)' (tti::t':::::') ~MJ:rivJ­. ~_If'F;ffiff:tEZ1lJfi15 ' ~lIt.it;r:p. -jjoofif;!~*~1~~if~fllm..A.~. ~:fjZ~P3~'. 1t13. ji*W*BVJZ:.fiJ~;f§lm·~". B9~5t:;'~,. :Utltt;1€(:JJ&m5¥'t1:.~~z;ffi~. -. '. Mi~H.Zf*~. ~f1i.5~~PJTfl ~~V1f1llf(jZ;fL.fl. {g£~ ". J J. - 86­. ).

(11) jjfl~i!i!iq!Ji:!il~l:I1'F;fIz.f*~. 19921FltJ1. ;fIi5f1J. (vern1Oegenswertell. .T.i"Fif§~.g.. -§.1I5!MJiIPJ:MiIUJI (W1"F. Recht) •. ••. wJ:JP.tlftimRX.Z..1!iI'M~~ffi]oW. privatell. ~~tifF.T.i"F.WM~.E..~I:;f§J;t. , :1C;jt.~ifd:1!iI~J:Z.:ijg1ll '. :iLz..5f1J ' iTIfi*if§trBif§RX. ' ~f!1!J~ tg~~.g.~ A~.MZ.§::'1¥Jll:f:jtoW. Mf~Difd:1!iI~i'.t~*. • ~tt1!r~M zM~ffi (~1*:s'iZ). (ittit1'\). 0. 1~14z.=*3Z.:tt. I'llll:)' ~f!1!J~:FI5.~~~z.Jl!.mm'Wtl. ,. 0. g;f!mJ:~0~J:IDff*.1*~E81im. ~z.~itfJ::tJ~. 11 (Arbeit. ( IfifrdJ~1fz:~J:). und Leistung) mmRX.~. 11i :. ~. ,. 1liIlH:;l!:(q~J;ttte-1¥~~1'.tZ.~:B-;fIi. .L it:ff{ ~J!.1t ~ J-t. (Teilhaberecht) , i!&ffi]ii£mm:~lfM>.K. .T.1"F.z. "n!G3t1t" oW "Jlm it" , ~m~!.IGIU~.T.1z:~P),btfi. .q~*:fifMi!f£;ffj1¥~. JJ&~Jl~bt 1'ij~*U~z.JjtJjl. .lH:; ,. 0. ~itfJ. 0. ~~~. WM~E..~I:B.:if§J;t:iL' ffi]~if§§::'if§. .IfifM~~JJ&r-§~~oWifd:~r¥z. RX.Zm~*o. ~.It, .~J:::Mz*J;t.T.1"F;fIF:fPJ,:~. .. ~itfJ" - :noomM~.I~.EU!iU ZJf'§J-1~* ' ~-:nOOJ{IJ~DJ:pJTD. ooti~. 7I"B':JmM~mRX.z.~=:F-.JWl. 14t&~~~fFJl'MI. Chance der Vermoegenllbildung). (reale 0. :. :t£~11f J: E8~P)'JJfH.~::tJ. 1"Fm.T.~~mtz.1~14. E8. iflfl'. •. '. IliIJlt~iVJ1~. ~.T.r~m!~ju;ts\. iTIf~-1:ftmJJ&J&J;t.T..~~. ~~JitOO*;g'M~.~7Jm::!:~. l!:(.~~I!l:,~J.l::D.T.~.T.'~~. if'E~ifti;:t£Jt~if1!f~.f5Hpg·. 1fJ~~~i"Fm I~UJltt;h im~~Z.~m. Jm::!:J;t1tJmA :fif1~1111~~;ffj ; ~:6tt ifd:1!iIooffi]~ , J!ii::!:J;t~fJiiA:sl1Hllt~.. :B-~"oWifd:e-3Z.:Ifr:!;fIi ffi] I'lIJ~M~ .AZ.~~3Z.:re.#-~.n1t.I f"F*MZ ~fUM ' d6,~~-v~.T.1¥gz.m~·. .'~.~:n~ooB':J-8"iM'.~J:. ~~~itfJ~J;t1E:~~if.:fif~oW~. .~~~.*-4~' 1~P),-~~~$. ~.,. 1if!IUH~~z., iTIffiJJ&J:~.::r::.~~fii. ~~J&1i'*Ur~.~.z.m:t£1tz.. *a*. 0. [l§TI1fift!15%jUf!1!J*J-1~itfJrfj:lii;. ffllt'WtlZ.m~). 0. 0. E8~1iiI73 :if-0:ffl1ftTifi~iVJ~~. m.E8M~m. i1.i;z~, ~.T.r~m!~~$1:jUff!!:fifB':J I!fflf! ' ffi]~raJ:z.§ E81t~::!:1t '. RX.Z.l!i!6tfj~. • M.Z.mRX.bt~1J[] ~*~ft:Wj!~~il!JJ::tJ z.19:A. • 1liIlH:;. P),bt~~RX.~WIiiI*MJJ&tg::tJZ.t&. PJT~1fil~B':JMi!f£JJ&m (positive Eigen­. tumllpolitik) JJ!3&JJ~IiiI.BMJ!q~.. iTIf~l$m~~a.t:riWz.$. .~pgJJ&B9-/J\:gI):B-. 'IliIJlt.T.i"F.:W~. ::Mz~.R*UM~.Z.lfi81!jJ. 0. m • ::Mz1!MJttii1z:i* ' It:J3.j;), fi~$ ~l!:(t~~l$z:ijg1ll • pJ7*J:J;t~.T.. =ffflf1J1ftTiZ.~. ('Wtl~D~~A.iiJm. ,. :I:S]:fif*IJ~.T.1"F;tflZ.Jlm.m,. ~f!1!J 76:if-RX.1z:n-JJ&~~.::r::.~.!!t.. -87­. \!;:. ~fJimm~~l$.5f1J. Z1¥g'iTIf'§'Jl:fif1i!l~~fto:t£lH:;. ~ijE];fIi~1m1HnMi!f£.) ~iL&. 1.rS0~. ,. '.

(12) ~. %jlJ~¥I. -. WJ. ~~~:c.~z.:t::~M/HJ~M.¥.:gB. tE;15:1}:st~:iI&m1JOO'.JlJ:::Ml*. *JWl%& • ~1~~~z~:c:il&mf5;lt ~IOtktiL • =1'fl}7iS~1:t<Iij;f~jft*:iI&. Hl!tf:Ffir:1Jz~:C:il&m.:t::~. m:ijlG~?J!fjljl(mzcf:l;ffij:tz:~1Joo~. 12§11tfrJ!Je:.~:C:il&m:m~-J.Rz;15. ~~m.Z~~f~lE. :I}U~:iI&J';'rl'"~tim~?J!fjljl(m:zlij;f. ' (itI:-I:r-b) ~ilW1J~'01lif*ffU1t£if~m ~~~*, miiP~~*ilW1J!I{!:.'" A' '" Z=1'1lJ:I}tt IZ:;ltt:iEStt4Uli~1J. •. ~O~ilJ~~~. " :c*~ " *:c~I!iS!fl¥i9U " gt~ij~ ~~ " ...... ~ , ¥.?J.7J":CfF.z~ ~'B~itT~.'~::tE~~zillBIIJ ,&~J::. ' J{U{}Jf5pfi=1'JE.. 0. :iE"':C~31J00'~fj~m.cf:I. , ::tEi®.$:. ~+:1f:*' 1lfEf55&ft~?J!fz:~~'. 0. 00'. .~;§~!I{!:.~~P)'&.~1r~. 'W:CfF '. W-1N:1Ii~zfl:jl1r~~:Ml. '. f5H~ltJf~fCfZm.~· .~J::{}J~. ~::t:*~:J4. ~~m.~cf:lZ~~~;f§.~I€' ~. A~". :iE¥Aff J::*1ig.-w: ' ~{}J~Ilfk~3& Z ~~m.~ , i9JJ~Df5H:Cm.1zm.~ , 1!iJ~~:C~. (ILO) :1f:NIJf5~3lmIm+/J\m.11}~ • P).~~ :CfFlm+d\m.1mlJi(J{U • ::tE~--A. ~T1¥~lm:'W'WIZ:;l~,:tE.~1r~.. ~@m.cf:I(-1LA=:1f:~:P':Cm.1. @aW) ,. J!!mEf3tt~. ,. p)'~iIJ~mm~lI6z. JL.,1:!l" .~tm1J" **.~. ;fMcf:I:Ml*1igmtJt:;155J-ii'im" j}:f1T'& 1£Dii • ffij J::illk~MM*~$~~~3& Z~43-:hIlP)'~.~1:!l. 0. :tE1k~rHm. J::!ill~BfJHMtttfl1:!l1k~f*~. , mm ~ttzPfif~fiI1ififiJ:t.M;15tt. ' ~{}J~P)'iIim~1k~~:p}m:St~, frJ!. Im+ j\ /J\~Z~3lm1E-m :c~m.*J::~.m. •. 1k~rHm:W~~'r:tSt~ij~~z.~. ~*jil~:MlH.l~itT~:P':Cm.1,~ffij. 8;t~~~z. .¥.~:iE~~~cf:I{}J[g]~Im-t- jVJ\m.1. jfij:iE*ii'i1tbft-8r1"F1J00' w~ ~W!!1JJl1JzmM ' P)',&.~IJlt ~B9l1fJ5t '~Ji/HJ1¥B.5!m "fIE A" rH "lWIfl1" ~ "1WIt1" rH "iii! II" zVi:{tJ, rH:iI&.r&z1:t<i!iiUn1ill>.t< 1E;f§W~:P' ' IZ:;lttjljl(Wi zPiliS~~. 1L-1L:1f::C~1}~Zm.~,. 1M •. ~~~~Ji{ffl{ : ~~~pfi~rs. =1' JE..P). f*~pfi~ *iJJ~ 0 rsJm.1:st~)jU:f:r~z:c~ J:: !jf.¥~~3&::,~$M~M~O • i9tl~oiM B9fi~)jU$~:P". ~ o. ,.t.r! '. :P}~D.3(. t&.H~tP)''&.lIil~f''F~. ". *iIW~zf*3. wrl~~nttJai;f§~-8r. Je.:itW~1f:.. " ~~~ ' $.f5~fIik: ' NIJP).. ~1ig.lE~$U. ~o. 3J7tETI!!1.f.?.::r-m.ffij:tz:~1tbWJW~jjfy. z:lt!!tiL°:iE:tz:~J::~~~*iIW~Z. ~3(~iJJ~ffijl=l''¥'~~*f52JS~. *Jl~;f.I,&,~Dii.. f-fj:3Az:tz:~. 1J §. ,. •. P). f*~3(ttz:c1"F:fI. , ~ ~*~ZA:1Jii'iTl5t*1igJB:I}~1j fflo. *U~. ". X1~;f.I. , ifEiVG!!. .~1tbfm:Ml*un~ji~.J1zt3!l!. ,. frJ!1};f.I1Jzf"Fffl~fjIi~~ii'i. ~.w~~m.1~rr;z*ft~'. - 88­. rm'1f:!i![.

(13) jj±-Q'~*.!'1!.fiU:IfFflz.f*.. 1992~5I;~. ~1rA.~'l.a'i$Bi. 0. ~fIi*7*Z~~tt!llJ~1imtt,it£;s~. ~EllWl\G~*j'i. €fr~11!:f:!f!.1MJjffJ1:Jt~J¥~*tll!f!~fS. 7*~~]'[~~~~z.fflG),(it;. ~.. il:::. . .. :ffHI.**Ji8Z]'[7*?I.F*1m1i5. . . :Jtll. ~1'.!1!.7*.)'(~:Jt~~ffij~. PJ.3&~lJ;fm?~iiH~~. 7tf*~1lIJ*5.ZfT1'.!1!· WJiit::tZ~. ..J::3'&1J '. it.f*~W*!ftfJ~.~ZMJ~~tlD. .Ei~.g3.7*z.1'JIfi!mM. fi:iJ1JoPJ.1Uwm· fJ1m*j'iINl~J::ZJI:. PX&fj-JIi!{J1:J.¥. ~ 7*.INIZtflf!il"Fm • mf.i:• •7*1*:~m::>f'1'iJ:ij\GfIi*. ~~eo. ,. ~J/t]'[~. 0. 0. t5jfd:*~~ !:f:!;fiim 1i~:I1P;Ul.. ~ I~. " \""0 ~::I:-i~ . ~:ff.MZimii&· J1:JA*~,~&A. ZI.l"F;f.fi • tEl\G~.7*J::.:ff~),( f*~ , ~t£;tt::Jt lI'J(mJ:: • JltlfJ1:ff ;f§.~1IIi • PJ.~* EllWZ~tM-i151J &;tt.1&~UfllfH~ffiji§"· m!.;fiiJ¥*. mmij$z.~J.J£~mr. t&~. 1'.!1!.7*:f:!f!.~:m.tE7*f$Jff~~. "(TIl. ~jfd:*~*.z.~~WWA~. • pJ..7*Jff~m. 1~.1iI. ~ifd:*~*. • l*{l:E1'.!1!~~&±JIi!{ ~~ZmiJi;i. • ~ffijEl:rl;S-tt.~*.. •. ~3&fflGm:Jt),(. , JJtlE1*:~I.l"F.. , tloJ/tltai15. 0. Ii • Leobenstein,Soziale Grundrechte und die Frage­ ihrer lustitiabilitaet;in FS Floretta,Arbeitsrecht und Soziale. (l)~~~~Edwin. Grundrechte, 1983, 209~. 0. (2)A;f.fiZ.~Hl~~Oestreich,Geschichte. der Menschenurechte. und. Grundfreiheiten in Umriss, 2.Aufl. 1978. (3)7*~Aif.Ii~=m7EHJ~f.Il/i}~~WJ.mJ&~:ml.5f.' pJ.&mm~WJ ~WJ~. '. ~~. ; ft4l-J[.~Jltl:OOE:rd:.m!~.:yA~I.l"Flit11WI1"Ffl151J~Z~. ~o. (4)1!t:fi!.A.~j;&~tM-. mli:~~7*~*),(l~. ... ifd:.- .... :)(l1:::..~Ij~~~;f§HP9~J!. :. £i~~. ,. 0. (5)tlDKorinek,Dirschmied,Tomandl,Cerny,Ohlinger, van der. Ven~~J/t. ~mo. (6)T. Tomandl,Der Einbau sozialer Grundrechte in das positive. Recht/in Recht und Staat, H337/8, S.37,1967.. (7)Edwin Leobenstein,a.a.O -89-. '\.

(14) *Bt1J¥!~. M. ~. (S)Walter, in Water-Schnorr, die Grundrechte mit Areitsrechtbezi­ ehungen und die Neufassung des osterreichischen Grundrechtska­ taloges, 1967,~7~t).l'"" l~jfUfR~' rmr rjfd:it~*-;fJ1J ,J! r.l*~ **i;flj : ~*$rmrJ '.l=ffil, ~95~t).l'" ' ¥-l]JU:;Il!1l6, 117~" (9)WJ!Tomandl ' IWm23~t).l'"" (1O)~J!I(YtLA..0*9~=-ti'i&mlm1f.jfllnJim&:0*9~~ j i -§tiiii&l.W(?JHi*~. ;;::::J¥J¥.l=M!;e: , l-:'J.&ItYt/iittit.~~lmtlB7} (m211*p).l'") zM!;e:" Ermacora ,Rechtsque I len zu den Grundfreiheiten und Menschenre­ chten in Oesterreich, Wien,1988 81,86. UDRupert Dollinger, Das Recht auf Arbeit in Wirtschaftlichen and politischen Wandel, in FS Floretta, Arbeitsrecht und soziale Grundrechte, Wien,1983,S. 131 ff. (l2)Theo Oe hlinger, Soziale Grundrechte,in FS Floretta; S.271 ff wisb 280ff. UIDJ.P. Mueller, Soziale Grundrechte in der Verfassung? 2 AntI. 1981 S.2 Horner, Die Sozialer Grundrechte 1974. (l4lt~liIJlJlnJ Soz ia lstaatspr inz i pZ€Jf~ , d.F~fj~~liIJp).~~-=t.f'Fm~m­ ~*DjU'UZ11lm;f§!1§i , 1lJf§1LJ1~ '~~O.E.Kempen, Grundgezetz und Arbeitsmarkt; in "Arbeitsmarkt-oekonomische, soziale und rechtliche Grundlagen:eine Einfuehrung/Mihael Kittner(Hrsg) 1982. S.129 ff.insb s. 143 ff. (15)lJH~1f;f¥i. ... Jt 1t;fl.dFJiljfd:-§t£*~JfiBIE ' flSl=1' .*JtlM~1JiBIJlli!&T. Jitlf~o. (lQP. Haeberle,Vielfait der Property Rights und der verfassungsr­ echtliche Eigentumsbegriff, in AoeR, 1984 S. 36ff. (I7)~~ ... itl.:-§t ... Jt1t.;fJJIiIJ~0*9mj;;;11li::¥.m/\'11ii (l8l~J!~Ytljfd:t!r• • ' m=:gB:S}m-1~#m+il.11ii 0 (l9rw~t£D~~ ... li:m.~ . . §i:dri:Jit ... ~.~~~Jlt~ ,0. (20lJ!;f;f\*aJfi! .... t:p.~IiIJ.l*~1~~H. '. m240~p)'l'" ". (2])J!*Jtm~!pzlM"&" 1ilJP9~~;f;f\*a*lJ&:J1BJ! .l*~1~.H240. 241~. 0. - 90­. ". ' ~.ooCP.~li?J. '.

(15) 19921f.5G.F.i. itW1~*-tI~.fl.d:I1'F;fIZ.t~d~tit. (22)Wi*~15{~P),I1~;ftItEM~;ftIL:$t;. ,. ffil~143{~~ -J1ii~l!l. "±:ltBfJrfmi:;J¥. f:§1itJiP),~ JJjtf2fs::ffil *jJ[]~ • ~Ef3I!m*1fl.i&±it!J;*fmi:m, DA~:tI:l?-Z". • ?Jj"\lI/J*J¥jWi*J::t1 "~!lfJ:JJ" Jli\:T~ "Mlt£" ~LfJlfil (23)Nell-Breuning • i51§Peter Haeberle, "Vielfal t dor Property Rights und der verfassungsrechtliche Eigentumsbegriff",AoeR, 0. 1984.S.48 ff. (24)~$W7*~153{~m4lJi. 0. (25)P. Haeberle a.a.O (26)Martin Wolff,Reichsverfassung und Eigentum,Festgabe fuer W. Kahl,1923,S. 2 ff;G. During,Der Staat und die vermoegenswerten oeffenlich-rechtlichen Berechtigungen seiner Buerger, in FS W. Apelt,1958 S.13,B.Verf GE.58,81 109 ff, B.Verf GE 50,290/339; 53,257/299. (2VWang Huei-Ling,Gesetzgebung zur Verwirklichung der Vollbeschaeftigung,eine Rechtsvergleichung zwischen Taiwan und Oesterreich,(Diss. Universitat Wien) 1990, S, 16 ff.. ,. -91.

(16)

參考文獻

相關文件

Estimated resident population by age and sex in statistical local areas, New South Wales, June 1990 (No. Canberra, Australian Capital

Under the pressure of the modern era is often busy with work and financial resources, and sometimes not in fact do not want to clean up the environment, but in a full day of hard

For goods in transit, fill in the means of transport in this column and the code in the upper right corner of the box (refer to the “Customs Clearance Operations and

• To the right of the Draw mode buttons you find push buttons through which you can access all the functions that you need to define and solve the PDE problem: define

 Promote project learning, mathematical modeling, and problem-based learning to strengthen the ability to integrate and apply knowledge and skills, and make. calculated

Teachers may consider the school’s aims and conditions or even the language environment to select the most appropriate approach according to students’ need and ability; or develop

Now, nearly all of the current flows through wire S since it has a much lower resistance than the light bulb. The light bulb does not glow because the current flowing through it

Using this formalism we derive an exact differential equation for the partition function of two-dimensional gravity as a function of the string coupling constant that governs the