從胡塞爾之邏輯的現象學來看卡納普之「世界的邏輯構造

全文

(1)<.0 <.0. I. C"J C"J. 1m: ~ ~~ ~. ........ ~. i!& i!& ~. ~~. i!& -\« ~. 01::\. ....... liI. .D .,.. 40 ~. II<. ~. *. <. +. 1!iI! ~. •+. i\l In. !i;. J.l'-*. *ii~. i{~ ~~. -". ~I. ~~~ -~ -$1. ~. ~. !3:!. ~. •. -'\<-. ~. ¢. ~. ~. ~:ii$fIl\.jg~. -\t\. ~.$~'\;(.. .*~.~li!!: "fIl\.~"n!(~. ~*~+I-t;:\~. «~~*li!!:~. ~. ~. ~m\M. ~. *.~~~M. "::\!l~~~. ~+lfIl\.~::\!l.. HBr¢ili-W". ~.~~~~. ... 4.n$~*-<~. ~~. ~~-. ~~~:ii~* ~~:i-'\<-*~. ~lIIl\:..~li!!:+I \:\I\I!.,Br~~. ~~~.+I~. fIl\.l:!ir*"$'\;(.. ~.*~~~ $~~~~~ ~.~~W~. l'->$::\!l=rl~~. 0. fIl\.fIl\.$1I!'I~.. ~~~~~~. ~'\;(~. :I«., . . .. :\I1I(.o...L\~*-. i\l~. it. -m. Win' ~*. ~~"~li!!:~ iit.~~~W ~.~*~li!!:. ~. ~~""".~+I. ¥+I:lR~~ 0 "*.'l($~~. ~. ~. *'. *'. ~t ~!\l. ~. ~. Dff!I. ~. *'. ~. it. :l'J,m. +. ~. ~. .$. ~. Dff!I. 1;;. •. :If. ~.. :II\tl~. 0. ~ <~ ~ ~t .\W ~ ~,*¥: ~#\~ ~ ~ ~. ~~~ ~~~. *'""'~. e;19:g. ~S~. 1lI'~.i. {lI\IJ9~. ~. = -<. .$ ~ ~. -\(jIll ~l;Oil\I. i!& ~. ;tCl)~. i!&u~. ••. f\f. ~z~. .UIJ. ~. '*. -.III\'~~ ~~~. L. ~*o. ~-;!;o~ '-"' ..L.. i; -,.1:)... ~~:li. ~~~ ;t!i~. 1!iI!~iti;. ~~~. r-~". *i\!~. oo~;t. I. ~. €. -.III\'~1!iI!. -t><. "*. . '* ~.

(2) 34. (~..l'LiE.t.~~:k*~**la.) ~""Jl. A Critical Evaluation of Camap's The. Logical Construction ofthe World via. Husserl's Phenomenology of Logic. Wen-Sheng Wang Abstract The chief purpose of this paper is to compare and contrast Logical Positivism with Husserl's Phenomenology in respect to the issue of the meaning of logic and that of the nature of scientific world. More specifically, it is to provide a comprehensive review of Camap's The Logical Construction of the World (Der Logische Aujbau der Welt) in the light of Husserl's Phenomenology of Logic. It is discovered that even though Camap and Husser! both regard logic and scientific world as ideal objects, the two philosophers nonetheless hold distinctive views on the manner how they understand those objects. This divergent understanding may decide what and how the human beings are in the world. The divergence has its root deep in their different conceptions of the significance of the Life-Factor or the Logic-Factor involved in the meaning of logic and the construction (or constitution) of scientific world.. Keywords: Logic, Husserl, Carnap, Phenomenology, Logical Positivism, Philosophy of Science.

(3) .;:tt}j*fi~ii~eg.lJl..*-"*"*;t-t~*~ (-t!t--l'I-egii~~.lt). 35. ~'W1~. M••ma'fi•••m~~g~~~.~m-~~.~IW'~~ = ~.~~M.~~~~.ili~'~~~M. ~ ~~~+ftm~fi=+m~ ~ . '~~~M. ~ ~~*~.~~~m~~MfiID~'~m~ o @~~mw .*&~~~~mM : M~.~~.~~m.~.~~,.~g~~ m ~ ~ ~~mm~?~~~~~~~.~m~~ o. M• •. (E. Husserl). fi•••~~il¥l~37J](mf4~~ : M~tl::t§t~'* '. , ftMmlJ~' (H. Hahn) , ~~ (K.. 1&~&'t:p:cl££ (M. Schlick) *m4o/]~~~. Goedel) ~m~~* ,ffij--t*,pg~ (R. Camap) !iltEte:§t~~ , 1B~mm*~". 0. @~x~~~f4,~*~,~.~~~g~~~~,~~~mmmf4'm' .~ ~~o. •••~~m-f4~~~~~~M~~D'@M••ma~~m. ~3f'~'&'~Mm~~\~. , ~Jl;t~JPJ€:~~~:(£~-Xt:ppJT1i'N~mBjF~. ~'~.~~'~~~~~~PJ~~~m:. M• • ~~~~fi••:(£~, ~~~~~~g~~m~',~=**~ ~U ft~~ill~37~~~~~ma~fi§~f4~~~g~,~.~~~~~~. EE 50. 1f.1-t~~)]~~~~IDrm.E (A. Gurwitsch) :t~rfflJ¥5. '. ~WIm1&telt&. I¥g n~a~fif4~~~il¥l> 3{-t~~ ~ ~~~§~f4~~JJ!a~~~-~~~it: Compton, J.J. Kockelmans, P. Heelan ~Um~Jl;t~~~4ill~:(£~7G::t?;4. 0. ' J.. :(£8. .~~g1t:p~WPD~M • • ~~~5iH4~.:(£~ (scientific realism) ~~ID1ij S,. ~~~M • •. I. *,~Kraft. 2. ~.I.5( Jt. 3. 4. fi•••~ID1ijg{*~~~6. 1953: 3-11 1t~-t!!.$R*lIIegRU~.1l-~. 1997a : 64-67. Gurwitsch 1974. 0. 0. 0. 0. *'~ Embree 1992 : ix-x. 0. s *,~~..t.: xi; JHHtoi!t*:lf Gutting 1978179 ):).t}j*iH~&'#"*"'t..(£.~1L~; Reeder 1997. • __ *fi~.~.A~1L"(£'.*-~*.~M~tt~..t.'~~*I·~eg~I~~~t~ ~ ~#*,,-r1l'.~~"-r-t!t--l'I-' Jlt"f~*4'--"~.I.5(Jt 1995: 23-33, 125-134 ):).~H~i~. ~1l'..~A_*fiaa"*"~t~#*~,,*,,~.~*.;xa5(Jt 1~7bM~._*fial *~~.'t..(£..~.,aili.4'-A:lf-ttU~eg't..(£.~M~o. ..(£..f.tlfl ;;?Ii1:lf LUbbe 1972 : 43-46,55-56, Sommer 1984: XVII-XIX, 1t.-ir'lM~.~MF (E. Mach) ~ r-r}Up!'li~ (R. Avenarius) ~Jl..At}j*fi~ii~'t~.eg#~~~j.' ifiJ Embree 1992: ix. 6.

(4) 36. (I!!l jLiIti~;k. *11 * *:fa.) ~ '" AA. *3t.L-)1~liI3~~*~--t*P3~ HgJ'f-I¥J~~.~ } I¥J1JA~l11:c=~¥)jH!& ~.,.e$Zffi~~r. ••l¥Jm~~J. -~m'~~~M~m*liI3~.~. ~~Z~.·.~Z.£~&~.Z.~~W,*.~--t~~rr~.I¥J.~. ••Dnrrm~~m~l¥J.e §Mili.~ - ®~fiffi~~~7'~~~~®~l¥Jm~~~ ~ rr~ -~ ••. ~.ommM~liI3~.m~$Z~.-@'~. ~~w~~~~m~Z~~'~ili~*3tm~I¥J~~Z- o EI3*~fr'±~$~~. ••I¥J~tfHe ' M(f@~?tk~••• ~~g1fH$~l••. 1¥J~.'~$~~.*WEm~I¥JM.~~~,.~.~--t~~Z(~WI¥J .~D.)~~.~'~~~liI3.~I¥JW~~~.±~~~.~.'.~U. , ~$M1~OJl~~Z.~ '14~Wf4~~WtzDfUJf~ ~fr'Mmte=firrpJTgtfHI¥JW~~$~ r .~'fi J Wr ~YI§'fi J. 7f\Jlt=m~~¥*z/OJW~ ~I¥JW~li*tt~ ~T~~PJT~. a. , ~~~~*3tI¥J$;[J\.e. a. 3Z.*3tJJ~-~f4W!m~gt~z. ~*'.fi~~w~~-~~r~YI§~wJe§z~.~*. ••~,~~YI§. ~w~.~m~~.Dffirrl¥J~~,~rr~&.~~M~~W.~I¥J~~~ ~e~,*3tM~~Um o ~~~iliU7f\7r~YI§Jwr~~JOOI¥J~m~. ~~~*3t~.I~l¥Jm~'E~~~~~rr~~YI§~WI¥J~~$o~~W. , mff~~YI§~~ffP.el¥J r ~ffPm~ J WliI3•• I¥J~~Wf~tzDfUJ? ~ ffPm~~.~l¥Jm~?6~~3Z.WliI3 •• ~/OJ ? 1~~liI3•• fJl~~tzDfUJ~rni*~. ll:ct§~I¥J~. ffPm~w.~.~.zOO?m®~e~~.fi.~.~I¥J1J~8,~rrJltm. ••l¥Jff~~~*~1~ . ~llt*3t~fqJ~ltfj~'liI3 .~ffi£f.~• •pJTft&I¥J~.AlWrt~~tJT9 , ~~J~H~filiZ (.~mJ'C ) 3W (W ,. te~PJWJ~~fr'~*3t:fD(rr-OO. ; 1.{t.:ff Gutting 1971, Monnann 1991, Coffa 1991 ' .&.I!!l pq i;t itt,<}'#~z Shen 1995 Sf. <if -i# ~~ , {t. fl1 BiJ - &-;fr ~If..tf.;f.. 9:AEl n~ ht ~ ill J:J.~~~ (J.. 7. S. Mill) ~»)"it.1rn~·~~~.Il. :Ita:ff Mohanty, Seebohm, Sokolowski, Hintikka, Follesda1. Embree 1992 : xi fIT 1; 8. *. "':Ita Misch 1994. 0. Sf.JJt~**:::ItSf.x.J.tk<if~~. , 1] Jt. 0. ~:q;U~ ~ jL!~~1f 1.. 4p- ~11 !H~ 1~{ti. r "t;f-' '. J:J.{t.z Jt. tJl £. ~ *-AA ill tl11§l. 1..4p-BiJ*~'~M£.~m~*<if~4~1..4p-11*~ • • • •azMo. 9Marfi• •M.BiJM.A• • ~#J~ • • • ~.~ • • BiJ~« • • • • ~&..tf.~~, ~ • • 1.M~jL-M.~BiJM.,:Ita{ • • ~~)UAI~·I#~~z.~~ff~A~ -go pq ~# ~ ~~ t, ~ ~1t ~ , 1~*-fili\ -go pq ~~~ f: jf;/4 (Hyle) BiJ;f..~ .J(o{ar;t'~ {ttl! - 3V BiJ«-1..* (genetisch) ~tt;..tf. (llt:t) tf~ill rfit11'tJ (Noesis)!4 rM.J (Noema) ;t~ ~M.~.~#BiJ*.'~~.*-fi.11't4~;f..~(~#pq..tf.~M~pq..tf.~M)BiJ.~.l!. -3V.;tJ!' ..tf.JlI:.~~llllroott~ 99, 100 z~8}j?r' 1]<if~lllli1.x.~ 1995: 87-110 flTal! BiJ JJl. ~ *«-1.. * ' .&. i1. X. ~ 1996 (tJl *- ~ z r • • ~t.'i J )- 51:. •. '*.

(5) ·VU}j~~.ti~Hii·If.JJJi~**;;ij--HR-t.t (il!:~If.J~.ti\.$1!). ~) Mr~~I¥J3t,**~f!fX1r~l¥Jtt~IfF. 37. 0. =' ••1£•••mmfUa:rz.tl. .&~~~~A.tr~~.m~fi~~I¥J~~'~~m~~~.l¥Jfi: §'~I1!~~f4~1¥J. AffiH~I¥J~ifB~. '. ~~&!t1::f4~&\~J!'§-a~f!Jja. '. Jm~. , ~t~tttJ&§l. , **~~,~I¥JJt~H~¥ ' ~~-a~~~J:. ~1¥J&f-t ' X&!lJ5t7(~. ' '@J3BJt~I¥J5t7(**-g-*U~ , ffijtJ'I~1~~ (A. N. Whitehead)Wm~ (B. Russell) ~~cel¥J~JT~~~~~~~ , 1ttJ*fHIHslj:B (L. Wittgenstein) Z <~~§ifBin (Tractatus) iftiffij~~cel¥J~j§~~~m~~ , f&-fr~PJJlI~ , ~O~!¥ ' ~B~!¥Wi!!:3'f.f4!¥lIIf~~~~~f!l¥Jr",~m 10 0. fil?1r~~ft~tjjJ~I¥J~~. 0. 'pJT~~~JTjfi~~~m-~~l¥Jmfft~~mf*W1fPm~~. , 1::~~f$:Mtjfi~B"J.L-~~ ~w~tI3W' ~~B~{~Hj~~~~~IlJI¥JJI1t1!?X;~JJU ' ffij~El3=ftmtJ~I¥JJJ! (terms) *fl. p.x:I¥JIIlH* (relation) NP~~~El3~~~~IlJ~ii*1WiJE ' l2SIffijJm'.&I¥J~f*J~~ifBJJyf;~ ~f!Ufl* ~JT~~I¥J~~mi!tEl3r45m~~ , -a:rm~~I¥Jf*fFW1fPm~t~~¥u -~Wth§i=1'&I¥JBA ati 0. 0. ". ~JlI~~m-~~~~'~.~X~~~~*~I¥J~.'~~!¥Bm~~ jj£ttJ~ § ~.1&Wl~. , 1::~~~1*¥Ujfi~*Mtfl 12 WtzD~~ 2 -a:r~~~t~ ~ilF.S: rD'Wl~ f Z~~~ 2 .!l ~ll}/(~ D'fi-@ X W-@ Y , x ~~~m- y , ffij x JI~ f ' y ~D~ f ' [email protected] z ffijj§ , ~ z ~m- f ' ~fj z !?X;~~m- x !?X;~ 16J~ yo .!lJ i§:@~~l~El3~JT~~I¥J~~m~ : 1. ~~m~ - r ~ J ' 2. = 1i]Tz.i!iH~Wl~ - r WJ' r X J' r!?X; J ,r ~-~fj J ' 3. r £i- J (!?X; r.pJTfi J ) , r::f:f J ' 4. r~~ J FJT*fl.nl<1¥J 131t]..trifJki~l¥Jcp , fX1r~-a:rfljfflFJT~~I¥J~j~ I; IDfB (theory of types) M~ 1* 5t I¥J :;y J§ (contradictions) r",~ mit M~ ~ 8m: (paradoxes) r",~m ~j~f!~lflrtEW;:B@fm~m (~M:):') , @fm~z~ti (}i-:):. -) , fillto/Jz~ttz~ti (Jff::):= ) ...... ~~ , ~~:;YJ§I¥J~~JJl2SI~}i-:):. 0. 0. 0. 0. 10. Kraft 1953: 15-16 0 1.!!:Yt~*..t.*-.fl; , 1HHtoollpOf ~j'JT#i-t-if. {il!:~If.Ji!!.ti\.$1!>. tA~~.'~k~~Ai!!.ti\.~.~~o II. Kraft 1953 : 17-180. 12. Camap 1930/31 : 135 0. Il. flll..t. : 141. 0.

(6) (~.!Li!l~f; ;k*.tg**~) ~. 38. "'AA. ~mmffi~o~aWb~.~M~~OO.~;~ra~~~Jwrb~fl~J flflW~~@J.~Z~ - nw~~ 'Ij:. , EffJ~JFf~ffiUIP~ , 1El~~~:i~~ (meaningful) ; ~ r ~~~rs9'1j:~ J W r *I~~]1S J fl~rs9ttW~1S~~ = ~ ~~ti ' Eff~~~~ttEL~~~ 4:E= r a ~~rs9'Ij:W J' r~~*IJ W r~] 1S~~rs"Ij:~ J ~Eff~~JjfeE~F~#~F~ , '21r'~~]f,~~ (meaningless) ~ Eff~{j] (pseudo-sentences) , IElm~nw~mm ' [email protected]~~rn!~ g:!B-~lli!1lJ.~nw~ ~~Eff~PJT!~JJlI¥JJI'IFI~illMi:::f1?f&~~W:S ' '2 ~t)~~~B~IIj:~flH~F~~:9}~ 14 0. 0. 0. ~]f,~~Eff9{j]~fi~~*~'®fi~~~-~~~~,ft:::f~~~~ ~~lli!~IDfH. 0. ij~to/Jl¥J~;f4~1j~$t;~~~D~. $~iJ~~~$t;~til¥J. , 1Elttj~~~§~~~~JlIm. , :::f~*~~Il~pJT,~xf% ~m~f4~ Wm-~Z :::f-a:rt}]1£~~~ (fundamentum inconcussum) , ~ijz :::f'm1fH:fttzDfPJ -a:rtm~rr:t~Jl!1! 15'2~$t;~~~'Ij:W~~j:~~ (genetical) :liJ~T ' ~Z~jJjt ¥U*~~pJT~UJl~f~r.&: (constitution) ~rm ' 1f:tt!p~*~~r:p:E=*fj~f~r.&:~m ' {)J:::ffj~N5EJlIm**ft:Z § ~1j1jljJEtt 16 '. 1El'2~ff~~~. 0. 0. 0. ~1f:t-~~~fIt~~mz 1& *pg~~PJT~~~~U~]f,~. ' ~1r'f~Hi*W:fim51=>o~~~mij*fEm. 0. m~~<~mjJjtTIDfH > -xr:p§~m~mjJjtT±~~'®&~m~'~ f~m. '. ~:ffiFt:n:~1~U1Ct)~~~mj'a]~N~- ±Bq]W- 1l~~q]~EffJm~\7. fi1!1r'*~:::fffrlt~~~ID~~. , :@ij. , ~'~W¥u~~~~~rr:t~~ m*XmtetzD~F~~ ~fPJt!P3l:~7 ~1~m,~®'Ij:IDfH~~~tfH~~¥:t ::(£m*Wt~~mJ~ <~~jJjtf-' ) (Principia Mathematica) r:pt!PB~tfH~pJT~~;f$~~~~mf*~m~ftWJT ' -a:r 0. 0. ~ID~JlIm~-~.~W0~M.®m'W:::f~~ff~~~*5E~~Il~W *~BjjB~Eff~. 14. 0. 18. raLt. : 139-140 0. 15. Mormann 1991 : 740. 16. Kraft 1953 : 20 0. 17. :J'J..t... -~i!~'J1~t;1j-t-'t):),*~~ttr,ntt 7Mii~z:t~U~1~ ·ti{f.J7UOf· ~o Camap. 1930/31 : 134, 139 ·1!!.*~~tt):),-tiAtt*f~~ (mathesis universa1is) »';i!~{f.J&'tt! (Jt. Husser! LU I: A221) • ~1:.~--A~ii~"1~t;1j-t-):),i!~»';tt*{f.J&.~.:ti;l;-{f.Jq.fil~ 0 18. Russell 1924 : 32-33 0.

(7) -i:t t}J* FAt ~i!!~{(.}JJl.. ~f[*83-@. *-* *:t-t- ~ -t~ (1lt$fJI] i!!~:fJt1t). r ~:fX~U7J J (Ockham's. razor) B'9J]'1JJlH::/j~. 39. , ;1t~~ : ;g-®. ~5E~JUI (entities) ~~~B'9~f.§:J;;t1 (properties) , ffiliJl£~"f:t7-WUTI1i7Gi§:. J!:9.11I1J}*M~nB'9~f.§:*,M¥!J (Efr~E8/f~M~~)IH1B'9f(1iIPfT*flW:) PfT!lY{~ ?:Em~-1f ~m ®~~ Z f(m$Jl!]~. ;. , txfrriij ffl ~f.§:*5f¥!J!lY{~ffiJ/fWr2!x:~ !l:t$Jl!]. ZE.$~oi§:~m7 -.~~~~,~.~~f.§:~ttB'9f(11I~~*m~¥,. ffiJ'M'jflf.§:*'5;f~f£1~1f~mi§:.f(1mB'9$Jl!]/fFs¥t1E~1fB*~in~~ -®~~. ~*~!l:t*~~~~~~~. 0. ~~!lY{~¥f-t/fJ(Of(1iIB"Jm§1fB. -WUtlo ' f$MLtto/jif. 0. J. : r ~~Rifl£lJ}llgfPJ~. , ffiliJ$Jl!]PJ5e.~ , *§l8J(OJf1mB'9. 19. (matter) Jf1mi3/]=. M~~mIH1~-@~f.§:~~~;f~§C. J1t= ~'t1§)'C~fffPJ-f1Jif/fllg:tE~-~rs%~1f~-{:v:fEl. 0. ' 1t*~-f1Jif/f. n ~~-~oo~~ = /f~m~ o E~~-~f.§:BMr/fPJ.~ttJ. (impenetrability) PfT1f:Z{~. 0. ' ffiJf*#1f~f.§:8']~I~A?~~t1 '. iB;1t*/f~ -*~~$.. '8.~1$Mt...t~ 7 ~D'Ntilltto/jfj[1~ffiliJ A tIt:W~$f4mzil: (event-particles). ' tjto/jif-r)E~pfTf$B'9~f.§:~M*5*. PfT*,£l.W: '. 0. '~fr~IJ}~f¥~m~D~- /J\~~. Ii~pg '/fIJ}.~'t1B'9Jl1f.§:/f¥H'~~' @CiliTB'9to/jif~t1ffiJ1fiTB'9imf.§:~;f¥!J. 0. tlOiWpfTi3 ' Jfif.§:~;f¥!J~W:~~~7~~1f~f(1m$Jl!]Fsm§Rif*~t¥~PfT~~B'9 mft ' m**lt2fs:...t1*ffl r ~;f¥!J1f:Z{~j1HlfB J B'9~ffilfj Jl:t®:ffilfj{rp*~-®IJ}~$Jl!] i¥.Jf¥1£ ' i§:~$Jl!]~P~~f.§:~~l£tj/f*Ii!~¥UB'9Jf1ilm§1fB1~¥U!&j;'Z -rPfT M~ffiJ1~ Jl:t®:ffilUMzffl~¥f4~J(O~ , ~otE1fFs~Jfif.§:~~::tllg~W:JlIf.§:B • ' tlOf~~z$f4.iI:*,£I.w:tIt:WB"JJ(D~NP~pfTW: 20 0. 0. 0. m*tJ~JlIf.§:~~ (construction) /f~if;pj. (materials). ijtlt:Wi3"JMnX:. ~~~~ o 1$~...tB'9Jl1f.§:~§~:tEf-t.1m.m~,~f-ttlt:W.~W:~. ~. , iBE~~7~"f:t7!2§fi. 0. ~~1£~f.§:~§ ~*~ (vocabulary). 1nm ' tx{r~. mFs~.*~~~~~:t7ffiillB'9.- f(11I'ffiJ/f~.E~~~.1f~ -.o. 1£1:1]$ (syntax) ::1:J® ' txfr~m-~.&~± ' ~ , ~~~~PfT*flnX:B'9$Jl!]15]T ' .L-~~ ~-$. (fact) *§~~i§:fm$~~~ , 1I.~tV:~±§~i3"J.1mQ}.L-~83{:V:~~~~~ ~~tt*~~'~~~.1mPJU83.tt*m)E~m~o. • • ...t-®.1m/f~. E8~1:I]$~~*~~~ffiJ~*m~o~~U~f.§:BM!lY~f-t.1mB'9m~,~. ' ~7;JP;H\ ' ft{jl3'] r jj:p:jr~~{* J (two-term relation) $Jl!]IfflMl*flnX: ' Efr~8/f~~±§~~~B'9$Jl!] , ~fi'iJt5Lm~¥u .=:. ' [g , Ii.... m~M~1j£-®~7GlW1&. 19. JiJ..l. : 34. 20. JiJ..l. : 36-38. 0. 0.

(8) ~. (~~.~*.~. •••. ).~M. ~~ZH~o~~H~~~~~.~*~*~~,~m~*~W~M~~~ ~ • • ~R~~~m-.,~~ft~-R~w~~~~r.~J~w~~~ 1~~m{*~~~m - m~~'B~ PJT~~ T~jG~W·W®~JkimJJj{ Tglfli. 0. '. 21~i1R{*~glfli~- #I][Ml'". '. Mt~t1J~~. ~~.t.¥U.~~§)l~R{*I][glfli. 0. ~]i~~§)l7J. PJ1tMW·~mtlO. r - ££~~AmpJT1=f£*~~AWz~J t!11:~H5LOO+*P3~pJTt~lli~{§U~ 22. i3"J - ~2fj3fe:~'B/PJ. '. 0. Jf)({~T ±g~fi/J~~H{*fi/J~Jl!~tif~fi1D~iWF~:S:i3"J#DE m*c5l:~T {$Mti1~.1m~~!6~ ~${tf. '. 'f:11~1etrtt~~. 0. 0. ft11~JD~. ,. , t)j~~~-I2B~~~@m:/N~~[7g;tt:f¥~. IJ!~-JEtf4~m-~*1'jg~&'{~~o/JE][~ttf¥~glfB~m. ~~~~~~~~~m-~~~'M~m~mM~m~~i1.~~~W• • ~ ~R~~~. , ~~m~mM~~.~~~W• •~~~H~~.ottffi~ glfB¥fj:S:TjJ~Z~~. , M~*B~~RXEl~PJTg~~El~. (arche) ~.IHf!l~{t&. Tm~~~~~ o ®'f:~~m~~A~~~'~~**illm-~~~~.~~. ~~m*~~'®m~~.~*~m*L~m-~~~~°'f:mw • • ~? PD*'f:m~~~. , jjB~ft11~~~-ftl3Jj'**ftpg{:1{aJ-to/J~~M*~jPJt)Jji.~ ~,~~ft~~m'f:~¥~~~m.w~~.~~om~.TjJ~~ • •~ *.~,~-to/J1mm.W~~.ZB.~ • • •#~~.~M~l'"~m~~ ~ , *~-R • •f4~*PJ1~4o/.J~M~jZ~1m~WG~tt7tffflB. f-EECP*~ ~~mH\~{lz~'IfT (Teilchen; particle) B~J~t.~~ • • ' 'f:m{~~~tJWG ~1f*{iigt~M~B"J${tf~:S: 231:t~:flft11~PJJD ' f4~*tt• • ±~WM ~~~OO~.~~M~.~ • • ~~.'$#~.~&~$#MB~~~'f: 0. 0. m~~m~±~W~1mR{*lHWpJT;tt:~B1';lli*~24 g~gEJ~~~~gtt~JT~${tfff!l~M~. 0. ~m*tJm{$:*1t~±. , ~~~{$*1t~~±~~gEJJ5JT{~~~~~Z. .~W·~ttIJ!~imB~F-~~~. , ft11~Jl!§)fcMF7fJ.~W~t1~ffP~cp~~ *ftMlzWEl ~ • • ' ~§N=~FI3'~.{*ffu{lzW • • ' 1l:tf!P~§N±g~gEJpJT~~ ~-@]$. (fact) WG${tf ~Z±g~~EJfi/J~.B"~~{*fi/J~ , rtt~R{*~ 0. mJJj{)fcB~$#*~~±~li~.~,®m~*$#W$#~~.~ o m*. 21. tal 1:. : 38-40. n tal 1:. : 40-41. 0. 0. 23. tt -*- 'llh~:Sc. ~. 24. ~ 1l"J 't ;.·tPT -*-~ David Bohm ~Hc§fIJ n~~~Jt»;~H!~{£' ~ Ii. 1995: 126-128. 0. rri) ilc~ 8Jl1t.~~Jt~~ 1l~t*~ {w ~ :l:ul~. (f.J -Jtt A. - 00 iTi) e.. . .It tal J:... tf (f.J ~Jf.~ B}j 1t.{f.J~;f.I •. : 129-131. 0.

(9) .vU)j*~.:t..li~a0JJt***-;t-t#.-I'i-t.:t.. (ilt.r1-a0li~~lt). 41. .~mM~~~~ili~ • •#~~~%I~~~.*~~M~I~~~%~. ~M~~RW~m~W~li~*m.~ om &.~&*w• • •m~~oo~ miflit~~1}M5m I ffiji!il3~mlJ~1~JliJltt~{**5m-tzD{ilJ.~~J5JTmm ~M' I 0. 1m. ~J~~.#m7¥*~~~~~~I£~.~~~.*~~~~.~~~. ~~B*.mffijUB*~~M'~BK¥m.~~*~o~M~WlJ~.#. rJT91- I ~W*~NP~-~W*5m ift!iffft. z&* =tfigmmfJi1~f3t~. tEltt~~1:.. 0. I &*~~~• •®:T~ilB I. 0. -tzD*&*~fJi1~f3t~*5*Mm;!t~Jfl.tJ:m~~~ mjllj*~• • ~~~. I ;!tFs9~~~~~§li~JL. I jJ~J!iE.m52:1~§R ~. 0. ElIi52:tE <ID:ctWrg~ > -X:tp~~tEgU;ffT~ ~ J5JT~illtB"J~ID:ctffij~Frg ~ ftl!§$tJ~tef$:~,15IJ;~~m~ I ffijf$:~$~~~ (Sprache) I ~~7}~D mt (Rede) Wx:* (Schrift) I £-fr'1:.f~-#~~tl:~ §R ~ ~~~- • • I =:ffFs9~~1*WH~~ill!; (Ausdruck) ~3z!tfD~fJi (Darstellung) ~~ I 1&~ ~DgatJ®m~-1o]§3 I ~;tt£~to/J~W~3!Jft~~5E.{4 I ~fJiJ5JTftWJ~~25mf* ~5EtE~5E.{4 I ffiJ~fig¥}~UJi~£ • • ~ltt§R ~ {1=.~illtJ5JT~~~'I1:~ : 1:.fng1J~ill!; • • I :9tR 1:.ffig1J~ill!;~JT~WJ5JT1:.f~ • • tElttfig1JT ' tlPftfZ ~*m- • • R*m.~-m~lw~gm-gm=~tem~I • • •-m 'ilJrJT~ill!; -tzDfZ-fr'g12,~7 I ~TJ::.1:.f~ J' ~~ 1~1:.1:.f~J ~-t;7] 'S 1:. ~PJfi~*gmomtEM'M1:.f• • wm8~~~1:.fm*~~m,=~z~ ~# ~~*@ , #~~~JH!iJ ~25m*fl-EI~~]~ljmm§R8~*~ §25mM~ft ~~m~~ill!;~~ • • '~Mm-EI~~.~.~m.ili~~m o ~illtm~m i¥JW!53ljtlPtEltt : 1&~~~~$-ffiJ¥}m. ' WJ~~~.~1:Em~Ij~!!]fmWJm Tffij 13 SJ3 27 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. It!J]~1j~1t@! ~- ~~~x:*. '. ?. Dm$1:.f~Fs9~~]~1j. tlP~~Fs9~]~Ij".-~Fs9m~Ij. ~iflU§~~]~Ij~tlPffl}.*5m (structure). {El1:.f#~B"J*5m. 0. ~-. ' itrltt• • ili1:.f#~~*5m '. 2S. JU~..1.. 26. .j:.,4j Windelband 1980: 41 ' $.l-A ~. f\. : 131-1330. *~a0~*o 27. , X:*$1:.f~Fs9~~]~Ij , 'i'fZ-fr'fl)3. Schlick 1938 : 110-116 0. *. 0. • •. E.m52:§12,.~-~~~]~Ij ~ft§lf~§R~~jill. , §R §. lttz§~ • • ~~~§R§.~--. ift<.PIT ~3&a0 tt~ it;;!; #J PIT tt :I:: a0 -!Fa Is- ' JfJ it 1t.

(10) ~. (~~.~*. ••••• )M~M. ~,um~~m~.M~m~ • • o~~-m~~~~*~M~ • • '~~. -wm~~ • • o~W$M~ • • ~~m**~'ili~~*.~m~~~ • 281±l1:tUfr~~¥UEm~~mJ!i~XJ%~rJ~~ • • ~~W~ , • • EI3-~1IID •. 0. $.**~'*~~ • • m.oo~ • • ~tt~~~~m~~o.u~~OOE13 *i*~~~!H~~~lI35'tm, ~7~&JiW~~$Jm)7}~~~*J}~~~RB"J~$. Jm '. rm$Jm2j~~R1±~~pJT*~ • • Z~,~mfjg~~. (logically possible. verificationiO -am.~:¥. 0. Ml:Ufr%im*i*j§f$j**ill!;• • ~~W~ , BP/ffj~~a1 • •PJT. ••~*tl (Eigenschaft). 0. 31. E m~~- *mtB~g B *~~*j§f~~t3tJ~Z ~1±W)7}1±~{* : ~:tf~U ~~B~Z*tB~1±/f~$Jm~~~U~7~.~~~1±~.H~'EI3z ~ ~J[~*xJ[~ ~{*. ; {&:tf~D~~~Ji~zto/JWBr~Ws~~~m{*U~7~~J[~~)7}1±*j§f~ ' i~rm~J[~1i1~m~ 32 0. {gEm5Dt£l1:t3Z:/f:E*i*~~~~• •tEB"J1if*4. '. {iQf.1IT7¥z~?g1±~.Z)7}. ff1±-tm~l1:t*M~B"J~;f4 (Material) , B~/fm**~~. *B~B"J. 0. ,. l1:t1'Ip~?g~~m. Ufr~tJ~PfT{• • B"J~f~J;)ElC.~¥UB"J~?g~~Jt:. ' i§1'IDilirrX:fx. ~~~-mm~*~B"J~~~.oEm~&~EI3~.~gB"J~ - *m.~~ -~W:B"J.,~. , l1:t~mm.&\~.L-~-~.~A¥U§3- ~.ffi&Mm '. ~-1'ID/fi~'rm~D. 0. Em~&~l1:t%rmL*B"Jm.. 0. ~fliJ~?g~. {g{iQ{)1~?gffi&A~B:~El1Jj@. B"Jm~~o~-~~~.~A~~~mUM~m:tf'~~1±~ = A~mB"J~ ?g~El~. , rm1±f]!m~*M~~El~ J;) § Am1§U ' {iQZ~Dm- A~m~ - ~Ji~~~ , 0. ~{iQfmJ;)ff~lI.L-~)7}B"J~B~~~JL tDm-A -ft~.~*M~. 0. rm:E ~ff~tDm-A. -.~'/f~®*~~~.~~?g,w~®1±~mW~B~M~rrX:B"J~.ffi m-A%rrX:~~/f~~.WH. o Em~~U~B"J~~/f~~&~?g*J},~. ~/fm~~ - ~~~-m§.~rrX:um~*~m~-.'B~J!i~~~~. 28. ~..t.. 29. ~-t 1924: 42-43 ' IIp.t~ t!lft-~i.1dh (complex) ~~1f (fact) It-) 11'-w..k-4-:H! '. : 116-117 0. ft. f~1F-4h (simple)1t-)1Htk-1W:f: ' %r*or~..thite (asserted) ~~..t~k: (denied)' 1!*"T~..t4-. --t (named)' 30. )1. )2. ft-:t. -=-*:far1iAElJfq~. Kraft 1953: 25-26,31 0. Schlick 1938 : 118 0 ~..t.. : 122-1230. 0.

(11) ,j:U}j£!ij~~~IA.JJ!..~"'*-;;ij--idf:J-t~ (ilt"..J'I..IA~~~.it). fi~. 0. 43. 33. a~m~3~~~~a'~~~~3~~m*ft~.ZT,ft~*~~ m51.pJT~i¥J19UT : ~ r ~~~Z1JID J JfjJ~~g.1¥,J , Jl:t~~m:~3J:§1II W~~*~m*~~a'@~m:ID~J:~~~3~~i¥J • •~.-~@1J. l¥J:¥~~*fl-g-. - ~N*J:B~~.. 0. 34aJl:tftfr'~{1:~. , ~ftfr'~~@1J=f:~R]*£i. ~Z~~I¥,J~'~W1J~.~~~~~~~~i¥J~3,ft~ill~UM~i¥J~. tE~jf-a~1.*J!m~W1J. ' iR*6.W*51.X*J1m~i¥J*51. ' rnffiffiZ• •. mJ!ljmfigW:a*f1U;~JfjJJj!]i¥J~:a~.. :tE.PJT-ft(~i¥J:XJIXf!. 0. ' ftfrU~¥um*w~m~:tt[OJ~tt!::W*M.~• •*M.. ~~~~~$'{BM~Utt!::W*~~~tt!::W*5.'~~Utt!::W$~M~3W ~J:t. ' 1&~~ • •*5.~{$:~mJ~J5JT$ , ~~ai¥J:tt[OJtJUllJ ' ~ftfrt~~~. l¥J&:::,J!f~{tf:. : • • f~~~tt!::W*6 • ' SlDlItftfr'=t~g~~tt!::W @-t*fg~IE~¥m-Jt:tt[OJi¥J~m ' !mOOJtJf~ LJ.ttt!::Wi¥J~.IfF ~ftfr'J!m-t*~~t~Jl:tJli.i¥J~.*~tt!:WZ~. ' =tijJ~JlI.i¥JJ~~~ID[~~*:JJDtJWPIff ' @1&~~iliU:B~~ : tt!::W*~NP~tt!: ~'M5ff4D.~? JlI.ijilt~g{~~tt!::W*5.D,~ ? ftfr'ijilt~gm161~tmrs~rulf**M.@~ijg 0. iRJkI.aJkl.jn~~lfBJ5JT~vmi¥J-JiJ)t~.~ 0. 0. ~fl$¥J.J*'ti. ? ftfr'J5JT~~~~i¥JfM~ID~@~F ~ 3U,~ ? lt~ftfr'Bi¥\~£Jm.. {~~tt!::W*61.. '. fB~gt£~ID[.,~tfj~~'8fr'~J!M. '. ~BJj~ , @i§:~J!m"E1. , :¥Y~~3WID~rs~{l&~!&(t}]i¥J*6i1 ? xJl:t tlJ:lm~:a~~.ftfr'~$att!::W$i¥Jr!lfl ' eckJftfr'.'Jfi¥J~$£~ ? ~J!;j$¥J.J*'I:i{l&~~i¥J1f~. ~ '-"Ftffffz (i!t~~.ft'Ui) (Der logische Aufbau der Welt). ftfr,tJJl:tiJ. (1928) F.&- {~~*M:iiEJli • • ~~lfB$ • • ~tt!::Wi¥J~1.r>=l~. Qo~.MOO~.WEm~Z:X • • ~JrJkl.~~~tt!::W~.Ji¥J¥*JfjJ. 33. ~.1..: 123-129 ' 1!! Kraft ~ ~ij ili .IA 0J Z. (qualitative content) >f: Of 1lit IA.£ ~ ~ ~&:~e.. ~~Effl.~'A.~~.IA>f:Of~~o.~~I~~~M~£ttt~0Jz.~aOf~~k ~-~>f:Of~'~Kr~mA~I~.t~a~affl6~~A4 • • ~~Affl64.'~~. -*-"*f Kraft 1953 : 41-47. n:ip>f: - >t ~ ti. ' 34. ~J:. : 132-133. 0. 0. » • • a_*-.~~.'*"*fM. •• ~+~-t~.~ • • ~~>f:A.'IA~.li~.~o.

(12) «. {~~4~~.~. ••• )'~M. Jm ' j}~J!!T*Pf~l£rtt~pJT:ift1'J8/JIE~~i!t:W*5~{~~~Z~m~f~I f p36 § ft fl<; 11' ~ ¥U ii il cp Z f~ ~ (Aufbau) - ~~ , 1£ ~ cp ~~ $I xli fJl f~ m (Konstitution) W~~ (Konstruktion) =f~l~ , ---F*Pf~ijrtt =fi/Lj~tH¥Jf~Jljff~.!§ 0. ~fl<;11'pM~I¥J~f~~R. ftl1~Z1W~D{i'iJ:WJE. 0. iWiIDfl<;11'B{~ffl7~JIX:. *••. (constitution). ? ffijfDf~JIX:X~1PJ~[OJD~ ?. W~~. (construction). ~fn~. , fa:. m&*~:WJEo~~.~1Wl£-~M~~JIX:l¥Jm~n'l£~iIDfu~~. ~~&i!iIHjHl~8~f~m&m~. 0. ~~~f~ffij§. , *ifu*fg~~JIX:~~~.fJ.m~~~. ~B~cp~.I¥J~~H°ftl1~.~*B~I¥J~~~~m~I~'~~~.~ .ffll£B~~;~m~~.ffll£-HM~~iID'~~~JIX:M~I¥J~~' &tJIX:mf4~I¥J~m. ••. (logic of science) , i§:~~f4~9;D~{~~ml¥J5TfJT ffij 0. HM~~~~&~·~·~*~m~,m~m~~~~fn~~~.5Tm,W. jjjK~E11'{~.m5TfJT. 0. iW~~¥-fJEl¥Jf4~FI:l'Jm. ~*ifu*pg~[jf] j§ jjjK~fJ.f4~9;D~I¥J~m*5. ~f4~~1~W$Jml¥Jlim~~~m Jm~D{PJ1t£~-$JmWi.&*1¥J. ' 0. 0. '. f&~t!P~rg-~FI:l'Jm. '. i!&rg-~. 39ffijf4~9;D~I¥J~m*5~~~~. ~D~~-~l~~D{PJ-a-~~-@Ifn~. , ~-$. 40. ~T*pg~l£~=h&iW § cp1Wmf~rtt~I¥J{:1:~l£ ~{~fJ.t11¥J. IT'. i&~~ JJ. r ~~PJT~9;D~~][J~I¥J~l (Nachkonstruktion) IfF' ffiji§: ®9;D~B~:lLl£t~~. ~~mm~I¥J.~Z~7Jo.§Z,i§:~~.l¥Jfn~~ - ~l¥JmJE;.fn ~~~8J.j B 1tWmiii1t. '. (Explikation) I¥JIfF 41---F*pg~m~JT ~t!<;~*f~l~(Grungbegriffe) , ffij Jl it£mjJEl~~I¥J~*JC* (Grundelemente) cp*~tj(, , *JERtJj~[OJ1i!t~hl'J~l~ rtt~~*fH!iJrm{*l¥Jlim (Logik der Beziehungen) ; ---F*pg~fuJ~tJji§:~9tJffiif~ . i~f~WW*I~~PJT~WJ:tJj*8'J ' i§:~pJTg~~8J.j. 0. 0. H~~~.ili«~:~~.~. •• ~.~M_~~I~.~~.·~.tt~~~a~~·. ~~~~.fi~T~I~~#~I~fi.~~.·«tt.~~.OOA~a~~~'~Ik ~~~-~Ji !f~)dbJ. 0. ~~11"l_!l-t (1924) ~~ I~ (1938) ~~.~tt~ii.tli-"'t1t.li. -* . _ ~.*Pi. ~ t" M ~ t!t~ ~I:.ii.tli-:t -* ~ ~:~tJ~.JJt . -lto ~I:AM.t.3t/F ~ &~~~.*~·~~~fi • .tli-"'• • • _l~ti~.Il'.~~ o ii.tli-MIl'.M~. J7. J8. i1. ~ Jt 1997b: 72-76. Kraft 1953 : 22. J9. ~. J:. : 25-26. 40. ~. J:. : 26. 41. ~1:t. -. 0. 0. 0. Camap 1998 : XVII. 0. 0.

(13) ~ t}j ~ fij ~il~. BiJ J)t *- ~ *-;.fi' -t #! -t ~ (i!t ~ BiJ il~t\rt). 45. ft!!1M~~ J JJi-§~1m1*~~*5~t1*~l¥Jf-'~1fB ,jfzm~1':E~~fI1,t~~£~.Lf-f ~ §W.§~.I¥J~.'~• • Z.@g£~.~~.~I¥J-~~.~oG -t*P9~~PfT~;f~l¥JfI1~£,*MEm~~~m,* (Konstitutionssystem) , ~~ :tf1i~ r ~f-f~ a (oJf-f~ b ~ c 0' @]~A dJ (zurlickfuhren) J ' ~ r ~f-f a l¥Ja~ O'Q. 1t dJ (umformen). f1S~ b ~. C. I¥J~~J. Jlffijm~*MEI¥J£~ (Basis) ~43. 0. '. 13t~ b ~ c ~~~1~1¥J. {B~£~fflH5Hi:J[~1tM. ' 7J¥~~~ ? @]~ , ,t1t. ;~~:JiIHl~~fj~ t)~5dtiKl~ (symbolische Logik ; Logistik) PfT.f-'1¥J1m1*f-'~. ~~~ , {BpfT@]~AI¥J®Jlf$1B/fR~1m1* ' '2~[~H~*~T~ ff;t~~~*~ 0. ,. ~*P9.~~®.~.m~~~~Js~I¥J~-~.:MA*P9WM ~. Avenarius) ~JW;M (E. Mach) ~~.1:E'11~JJj{¥UpfT*iiT~I¥J.m:3::~. 0. El311t. ili~.~.m~~.m:3::.~~ • •~I¥J*5~'ffi'2~J[.(oJW~'M.(oJ ~ ~~~ffM,~ff;tW.~.~.m.I¥JWR«o~.~.m~~a'lm~ *8.~fl*~~U[:t¥pfTT~~1r!J1H[~l¥JttE1lL ' ~f1Sf4.~~I¥J~~~Z*6.* 11: (Struktureigenschaften der Gegenstiinde)45 -t*pg~ff;t~;f~~1~~~:5t*'11 0. ~. mm!;. (Eigenschaftsbeschreibung) ~ 1m 1*I¥J. mm!;. (Beziehungsbeschreibung). ~~m~~%o.~z,~m*5.~~I¥Jf4.~~B/f~1:E%~.L~*~~. :;rJ§1! '. ~~~*1&bH~,~.1:E. '. {B*5~'11;f~~2 (strukturelle Kennzeichnung). fl1i7G~~~'P.aJ~ (Gegenstandsgebiet) , ~~F@53UI¥J~1~. 1:E£~Z.LI¥J~.mlb~t).~1¥J1m1*f1S~~. 42. raJ.1. : XVIII. 43. raJ.1. : 1-20. 0. 47. , -t*pg.~-~m~~~. 0. •• 4~~ffl~~*BiJ~.4~~t\g_tr_~~ ;f,t" J)t;f J ' 1§. 1f !ti!!~f'IT% ABiJ r nH~g _ All{Jfl4" 4'/1. ~# BiJ.LfF.1. . Jt. «raJ.1.:3;~.-t#!.~a~ :. (teilweise). ~.TmA~t\.~&~BiJ.~m~.#'~~~~~.~&~BiJ£.~~~·~&~~ 4~£ • .1..4~.~%~BiJaOO~. (... )&~~&~~t\~~~tlJo~ •• ~A*-;.fi'BiJ •. ~~~4 •• ~-t#!.*-;.fi'BiJ~t\& •• ~~raJ?~*~~4~JaJ~.~~;f,t_.fflj. •. BiJ~.~?a~~~~A •• ~'~~~~~~ij.-t#!.~r~.~JBiJ~~~. '. a~.~. •• ~~fij~~ • • • • ~At;f.ffl~4.,~-t#! ••• &~4.'~~~. ~~.~_BiJ&~.~i!t~~.~_BiJ~.~o 45 ~.1. 46. ~.1.. : 11. 0. : 11-120. ~~.1. : W~I'4~~~-t#! •• ~*~ZI~~~.Mt\BiJ~.k-.BiJ'.~~~A .~~*M~._,~.~a~.a~~~kM~;f,t.ABiJ. •• ~~o.

(14) 46. <~ jL Jl.t if; .*.. '" -tg- '" '" ~). ~ /\" WI. IfJ IiJ ~ ~ ~ (zuHissige Argumente) ~ tl§ = tj ~ NT ~ z. lIiB III ~§ ~ (spharenverwand) ; If?ffBlII~§~ (spharenfremd) ff!W.I¥.H§iIT.pfT~g)(lfJlIiBlllm~ (Spharenvermengung) ~M~lfJfN1JJ 48 ~jf-1£MEYj ~~JJJfig (Aussagefunktion cptj~I¥J:9HII (Extension) ./f~IiJI{*' ' tJ ~ ~JJJfigrE'lfJg-a (lmplikation) ml 49 {*,f1P~~=1§1fJ~1I (umfangsgleich) 1iJI{*,f3t , {t!!.3Z.lf?fMIilB{~m$IfJ~~ (Konstitution) fn~JE~~ : ;sfn~ a ~:tn~ b Wc .pfT~~ , ~!J r Bj-@ a .PI 1£1fJ~~JJJfiM'~~~-@~1I1fJi3~J;}]fig , ;1tcp a ./f¥}tJjJJl ' ffijffrlt~ b!A c1£flrm J 50. ~~. 0. 0. {§. -tmlis§iWlil1£ i3 ~J;}]fig!/i'~z.~~cp jjilt~~~lfJfI{@ 15I?:¥-f./f~. , ~!6~1fJ1I{@ (Erkenntniswert). (logischer Wer(. ~!J~$U&5J. , @fu~~M~IfJ~~ {*,*5~~ill[~~H~T~m~ i'&1£{t!!.~51~~lrU7tlfJto/.J~ff~{51 ' ffijlf?fnlffi$Mml IfJtj~InJ{J'J1l!MrmlfJtj~@]~ffiff1Ps§iWlil : U~*~jjj$l¥Ji1~mWJ{J'J1l!lfJi1~* ~!6~ , Il:t~I~H3t1§~~!6~IfJl*:mti (erkenntnismaBige Primaritat)52 , ~M1§El31~ 1§ ~ tf4 ' {E!. ~ 1r, ./f fig ff!W. nl m$ IfJ l'tJ ~ ~ t:£ {" J1l! IfJ i1 ~ .PfT E' fiX (zusammensetzen) ; f1P~H~1nlm$IfJ§~""~~Htj{J,J1l!IfJ~~ffif ' .PfT{;~~ IfJff~~~~IfJ{J'H@ , ffij~!6~IfJ{J{@BP~$1Ji&53 ~tJI¥J'I~7f~fu~~~1£{J' 0. *. 0. J1l!1fJl'tJ~tt~J1l!I¥J~~@].Scp o ~~1fJ1IM~~~~*5~ffij~'~~IfJM {@~!J~ill[m*~Tffij~~ .1£f4*IfJW~6. {~3f~m~. 0. ~-t*,pglilf?f~@~tf4~UJctJto/.JJ1l!l'tJ~~£~ffif. '. ~1~. , Il:tffifill[m*~T , {E!.{ili~.92,tt*.L*I¥JW~6*~to/.JJ1l!Z.to/.Jl¥J*~Wff1£ ' ffij17Jtt (realwissenschaftlicher Gesichtspunkt). *~. £*~~*~mliJ~I¥J~J1l!£.°-tmli~ - ~rm1£~~~IfJW~. (erkenntnistheoretischer Gesichtspunkt). -fff~{J'J1l!l'tJ~{'F~*5~~UJcI¥J£.. ~fJ1£s§iWlil~{*,*5tf4i1~mt~UJclfJm~tt. 48. ~.1. :. 49. ~.1.. '. i'&-t*,pgli~1Wtl§tJj. 38-40' i!!!p,t1tJJ.rmi .l;.-f,-n~J1:~BiJjj-~;f-. : 42-43. '. : r tJ{J'J1l!~~. 0. 0. 50~.1.:47o 51. fliJI.1. : 69. 52. ~.1.. : 74. 0. 0. 51 ~.1. 76-77 ·1f~t.~MJJ~N;fh'l'BiJ4~J;);.f'J**01"J1·Ho? -1HPy:ttlltmiplT~BiJ: ifh'l'BiJpq$. ~'.~~~~·~~:ttpq1f~.A~1fM.Mpq~.~*~~·~~~~&~~ • • ~. #.J;);.BiJ~fliJI·~~B*~~&~,t~ • • BiJ • • .1.*~BiJo.

(15) tUJ3*-i1p:.. ~~lt-Jm~$*-;tT~-tZ (-tlt~It-J~fl.*.it ). ~1¥J~MC~:ct1.%.~~±:~:1J~ZfJ:~. , ¥-15jU~~tl±:~ZfJ:~lIWB'9fN* J. 54. 47. 0. 55 :tE9!f14~~B'9~ LI""F , --t~-m:1~ E=I iltB'9{A~l.;§H~ (eigenpsychische Basis) tB~. , {g~i§:~:1JffiB'9 E=I ilt±:~. (methodischer Solipsismus) f,5J*f~ff:{5J{fJ\flt. l¥J~m ' ili*&W~m-91f141&::ttef~B'9to/J~ ft~(Grundelemente). *~I¥J. m-. 0. m1.%fltB'9m,'Mj. , {,\~~mjjj$~][~. , ~~~iI%~*. (meine Erlebnisse) ~g;t1&*9!.B'9W~li. '8~ - **~mfiTB'9m.'Mi~lE (Erlebnisstrom)56 , m:tE;tt~mWMMz. ""FB'9-a.'Mi E=I J} , ~1&.x.1E?m ~~*-a,'Mj (Elementarerlebnisse)57 '8@:*~/f~gmfiTB'9 ' flt1r~~&~g~'8{$ - m ~ :B-fiT (Quasianalyse)58 ~ 1.% -a .'Mi1A'tJ& ~g * m fiT 1.% i$ mH (Quasi bestandteil) , '81r~ {-1:; ~ i= - ® tEl lli I¥J 1m ~~~ M (Verwandschaftszusammen (in ihrer Totalitat und geschlossenen Einheit) 0. 0. hange) , ~ft~tEllliB'9Im{* (Verwandschaftsbeziehung) :tEMC - r:p*:B-~~ -t~HifftJ~~§Wijj1.%~tl. ' tJ1.%. c-e-g. 0. B'9if{*1.%i$m{5} , '81r~1£~@JMc- B'9if. ~r:p0-~~ =OOif~~-@J:1J~. , flt1r~¥e~~®:1J~::t~g1£lffH~r:p1~-@Jif .~~B'9if'~~1£.*ifB'9~~ffillilm~""Ftt~@Jfi~~OO~o~~1.% • • ~.mH~/f~mm~-aB'9$H''8/f~a~B'9,~~*~~te*B'9'~ -tM.~Z/f~:B-~,~~~ft~~to/J-. :t<z-~**ft J. 0. ri$:B-~~~~7:B-~B'9~ ~~. 60. ffl *~~JiJT~.t~Z~*Im{* (Grundrelationen) ~. ~. ::t~PJT~9:t.JltIEB'9~. , $t~zQ}~~tltJBm1R{i! ' ~;JFtJ&'{?,~1R{i!1.%±:. 1i] .1. : 81 .. 84. 0. /ftJ-~{,\fJ:~:B-. 0. ~. f M.~m~~~~alt-J~d~~*-~.'~alt-J~.~~M~~m~~*-~.'fiJ J:.. : 79· 56. Ii] J:... : 86-88. 57. Ii] J:... : 92 •. 51. 1i].1. : 94 •. 59. 1i].1. : 98-99. 0. 0. r.,. i!:f!.1t-J ~-mt~$ ~ f$J' "!;t..Pf:fa tJ3 *- fJHf. ( ~fl..&1f ~ ) tf J'1i"H ~ It-J r~:lIt III I : 1lt;..&1f~) fIUf.B.~, .;:..:4r*J.A:Qt~)f,t~~ • .g~f$J'It-J~-mt '. ~~ftf J m~ (Husser I LU. 0. .TM.~u.~~r&*~~J,~~~~.~~.&*~~zr&*~.JIt-J-~'~ e. ( raJ .1.: 105)' ~tJ3~fiQ~:Qt~)f,t~;t!l1tlt-J~:Qt, :fufiJ)j\;t!l1t~-mt~.g~f$J'It-J~Aj;!' ~e.~,. M. ' #fiJ~.~~.*~~m~lt-Jr~~~M~.J*.~.~&~'.~*k~~1t-J. !tft, ftJll:.~~~t-,;/j)£5(~ 1995: 24.. 27 ' )£5(~ 1997c: 3-12 60. Camap 1998 : 104. 0.

(16) ~. (~~*~A*.*. •• )~~~. ,. fJTEf{]m § , ffi] j;)jt~Ef{]aB § *~~~ ~1j£*ft,~mfH~:,"H*Ef{]f2~p , mftJ=tfr ~~ffi' • • ~fi~mfi~~I'~ffi]£*~~~B~.~Ef{]¥. o ~~l ® it M £ * ~ 1* o~ ? '81F~ '§ t5 M £ * 1m ,~ Fa~ Ef{] :g~ 15J- fElIl'lJ '[1: (Teil gleichheit) , $ ffi fEllli tt (Teilahnlichkeit)62 , fEllli tt @] ~ (Ahnlichkeits. =. 5Sim:F.f5IjErjF.f51j~1*. erinnerungt 3 ,. .~~Erj~lli'[1:. (Reihenrelation der Intensitatsreihen) , !% (Nachbarschaft im Sinnesfeld) ~64 '81F~::(£Bt~**-7Cr:p~til 0. ~~ffiilimEf{]B~:ffill'lJ'ffilli'~~'5Sim:W~~'~~£*~~~~~ ~§~~-fl~DIf#. ' ~r:p~~~-~£*Ef{] , ~~'8Erjpfff~J1: ' ~1j~fW'l~1t ~~*JEaRif65 1EHt!~/1Wt~ili$f5J-fElIl'lJEI3:g~15J-f§llipff~J1:66 , f§llitt@]~BPPJf{ 1:ili:g~15J-f§lli67 , lI'lJ~x~-.1t~±~Ef{]~JU~1j , ::(£~~J:B:lz:7~Fa~W~F.i 0. Erjm~~'~ffillitt@].~m~£*~~~o::(£~-~~U~~~~~.I ~:lz:!~~1~aRif~1~-jfimWm~. ~~.~aRif&UI~:ff~~tij~1*. 0. '. ~~~m~ff~r45m~tijErjaB § ~Bt~~U~. Erj~fim§oB~~~ffifi~.~£*~.Erj@].,~~-ft~.Erjm~M. ttf!~~1i~£*~.ErjtJacW~tlac5m~~1i. 1W: '. ~n'l::t:t£~ftJ§~&"Erjr45m~~. 0. 0. @] ~Erj~ntt I'iJ ~7GBt~ErjfJ. {B::(£Jfi1=rB~~1.ErjJj]mr:ppM~Erj?f. a~Bf~~JE~$ljf1'~~?1RJErjaB13~~1t. ' ~/f~~t~7G~~5t~. JfItlffl ~Ef{]~m::(£.ili.W~~,~::(£~.-~ • • ~~Erje~o~~~.5Si~~ 5dC~tl /fmft~~lU~m~fl1re: ' J!~~11£ B 'W; 1:$:@(J[J~~j;)@j~W~ttm-@ 1J~B~Erjac5dC1~~'11Erj r 1&B~ J IfF 7°::(£.~Ef{]B~~1i r:p , U1FU~ 0. 0. 61. r;jJ:..: 106-107' i!.~!.T#.jljf-1J;J.if<.t~~1~~.tg."t.:t..*;F#*liJilM9r' }11f-~*;F*. • .:t..ilMIiJ~.*.~'~A.:t..&*~.~*~ili*'~i!.~M~J:...IiJ'*~~*~1 &*ft.IiJ~.~~ ? 62. r;j J:.. : 107-109. 63. r;j J:.. : 1100. 64. ~J:... 6S. r;j J:.. : 117-1118 0. 66. r;j J:.. : 109 0. 67. r;j J:.. : 11 0. 68. r;j J:.. : 116. 69. r;jJ:..: 134-1350. 70. r;j J:.. : 137 0. : 1180. 0. 0.

(17) «~.~~~.~~a**~~M.~(~~~~. ••a). ~. - .=E: '.P.---r-. Jl3Ef s 1 !,c-'r!M< >WiI;g -E tj§r h--'r!!R<ffi ¥tl-Ftrfflli J;j"Z:9'r.3!ilr:d3 -£<~~ : l:::, II DE . 1'T~/(;~'I'.El ~r::d§ , 2 . 1f'J1 'n/(;~I:d§ raJ ""I" "~ffXx:~~mt ' 3. ~1--i=5m~j3"~~~.l£iUil¥J~j3 , J;J& 4. ~)§I¥J ~~0~.ttm§'~~.HZM~~~~Z~.1£.e$I¥J • • ' U1k ~l:fj~{'FZnHW~'i1 § I¥J 71 ~ffi. ~~ 'i!,I;j. 0. ~~~K~*P3 • •jjiKf-ti!tff.I¥JJIlit~.{i'&~~ ~f'JIHI{*~1jte'iJillI¥Jj!iit{J{@: ti~1¥J. , HE ttl~.I¥J~iitt '. ' J.-~&f-t9l.PJT~~I¥J§Rj3~~{i'&7~B)j 11!ff4f1?% ' j§Jm~{ilipJT~1ll1¥J1&~.I 1'1= : ~j!cmf-t@~I¥J~.. :f'Elm:'/1:@Jtl. 72. ,. ~*7C*73. 0. : {iliff.5E~.I¥J • • '. ~~. Mzf-t9l.Zf-t~~*L~ J;J IItm~{iliOO~i:!7~IEI¥J. - EI~{AI1[f-t~ , '§.f§WJ®Ej~ ttl l¥J~*Im{*' , fi~{5JifEHl.f4 , fi~{Bif§[fiJ75 , ~Fs~~JHvr6~~ !t:::x 0. ~r:pJiI¥J~O/]:Elf-t~~.. ' ~m. J;J~1;£=7C~'::' JC l¥Jff~1t!to/Jft~Fs~~~1Jl¥U r:p Jl9l.?%MEl¥Jm~17 , 1j£ff~~~~¥Uff~~i!tff. ' ~1¥J!1tft (mein Leib) ~ ~~$l&m~ff ' '8WJ~~§cttl/f[fiJI¥J~'§{'Fm ' ftEl~I¥J{J, fJ:fi~{}j~.5C • ' @OO7~~Di!tff.&~O/]:Eli!tff.I¥J9l.$tb ' ffiJ~Af-t{ig~f-t~I¥J~.:gj3{}j 78 ~1&1£'§.-a-{ig~{J':[email protected]~I¥J~Ji~.W ' j!c~!to/Jllt!./l1:fIl¥J{ili~ ~ij!ff4 ' RH~~Im{*, (Ausdrucksbeziehung) {ig~I¥J{J'llt!.f-t~tQ,~~.if ' ffij1£fl!!~~fJ!l¥J~fj~M'&1'F§c5mtr~~ (Zeichengebung) ~fJ:m ' HZ {ili~ 1¥J1!tff.x~9l. ' ~1¥Ji!tff.W{ig~I¥Ji!tff.Fs~~Ij~ffX-5E~JUW ' ~~PJT~Ill±:ft 0. 71 Jiil.1. : 133-138. 72 Jil.1. : 150 • 73 Jiil.1. : 151 • 74 Jiil.1. : 151 • 7S Jiil.1. : 152. 76 Jil.1. : 160 . 77 Jiil.1. : 163. nJiil.1.:I~'~~a "g.:~M •• ~~~M&.ft~~.~~t~~& · ~A~~~ .M.*.~.ft'~~Jiil~a*t.ftfi.4~~~».~~~;fi~~a~~.M~' ~*.~«.ftili.*.,~~.~-~.±~a*.~~•••• ~~.1.*.4 ' fi~ e..:Ii~Y sc."Ui~~~ :Ii~fI!] J:t~~ El1ti~1t. , 1JtJtu~1t1l.f:.~*~ Th. M. Seebohrn 0. 1984 ' *sc.~~fi~;J}".

(18) 50. (@.rr.iIi)f;.k*.tn**:fa). ~~M. , :tEJl:tZ1::6ttffft~Jti~~~~I¥J-ar~~ : mff,$fi~W1Jl{ffiC9. ~i!tWI¥J~f~. 0. ~~*~M~~I¥J~~e*m:6ttI¥J~-~eI¥JM~'~~I¥JM~*~rn :tE~ef4~1¥Jt§~1'i9=J -F*pr~·9t~f4~1¥J~{J\:tE~ r ~f:l(;W~~rm15~~?6~D~ 0. ~1¥J • • ~~Jw'~~~~M~l¥Jff~~~~~S.~I¥J • • '~#~ ~. t11¥J• •. 0. Rn~:tE~f4~1¥JJ!f§::~~{'F~JJ.. £l~ffrlHE:~Jm-EllfJJ.'liWTI[jj. '. I¥JBm~m~.~~{'F~nl¥JJJ.tt~~B'~~~ili~~-g.HWJ!f§::~. &Z ' .~I¥J~.:tE~m~Htf~t££*~~~~mZ fJJ ' RnBM~~m151: ~~I¥J~~ • • mM~I¥J~~'~Rn • • m:tE£*~~z1:M~• •~1¥J1. • •. 0. ij;€H<±~§1i;:. 81. !f!.EPHJ 1f1Jr:ll:::J ct. 0. -Fm~iE~jp:~?6~1iJ~m~.w~~Jf4~Z5'}f,1;Jff~t~Ji1ID. ' {g~ffrK:6ttf2. ~Ji1ID~ ~ ft1rJ-ar~m-tlJf8111. ' ~Rn r £*1:1iff -1iJF",~~~f4~ ~ ~~ ~~@I~I¥J J 82 , ~~f~iEf~~&fi\l.J1:l¥Jf2EI.w;~m$.I¥J~-ar~~@I~ , {l:IiiiB ~&fJtJ1:17J~~ -arml¥J (denkbar) , ~1J'E{f'~ r £*1: J 17J~ -ar@]~1¥J 83 ~ {fuJti1IDtzO{§{JU~~@:'iiiEm:~ , {Bfj£;!t9=Jft{f'~~~~tU~D. ; 'E{f'~iE~WtU ~ ~~1~%l.l¥JfiJ-NW{J\gM*rt~ , {flJ!lff-ar~ ~1¥J~~~l~pJTEi~?6I¥J::t~~D. r m~~ -arl£gR1l]$~9=Jtef~Z~25JJE1¥J • • J 84'¥15~Jfj1:~~?FE8~.~ 'lil¥J$~PJT*J3.m ' ~ili~~-~~D. ' {g'EI¥Jf¥:tE~~m-F*fkJ~pJT~5E8S 0. 0. 0. 0. 79. Camap 1998 : 1850. 80. ~. 81. ~. 82. J:. : 252. 0. J:. : 252-253 ~ J:. : 254. 0. 0. ~~J:.:~4 o X~~~.~~~&~4.~A •• J:.~~~.A,~.tt_J:.~~~ · ~. *~-#. 00.' 84. ~. •• •• ~~. ~~A • • ~~~~'+~.Mm.~~~m.~~A~tt~J:.~. jUFtEl;f..J:.~I!J_. 0. J:. : 256. 0. ~~J:.:~~~,t.~~2 •••••• ~A~.4tAk£~.A~ •• ~~~.'. ~~'~~&.* •• ~J:.*~#~.~¥~&~ •• ~.~.T~.OO~~'~4~J -#.~At4U~*.Yo.

(19) ~t,ij£ii~jJ!~fI-J.fJtl.**-~+~*~ <1!t~fl-JjJ!~~it}. ~,~~. 51. ••*~<~~®.ft.~>. 13 .~~'±~t)~ , f4~ (Wissenschaften) - "6Jm~ r fiP~W~f!I!11~z . ~ J ' ~ r~Zf*~1f6*9iJLW~~~z~JH1IH.EI.~ J - ijl~~ rf4~f!I!~1f6 J (Wissenschaftstheorie) , ffiJ!l:tf.l~1f6ltTmmt7rOJg?6~D'±1;jWro~8~rf~r~1$Mt. 0. ~p. , ~Htt9iJLW~~f4~ ~IDfUmWJz r11$* J ro~~pJTI&{~ f-j.~f.I~1f6~711$~ , J!t)~1B~f-j.~ 11:lfI¥J~mW~~Zff~tl~)ttj({~{4 ~Wog-{BJ,~WT (1. Habermas) tt. ~'±*iI¥J~~§iii86~~J!"6J~tttjf!fm.~IDfU : ~*ilifff3~1*ffiJ§ , !r~IEjjjflJ~. ~ttt"6Jijg~D~11*{4zm~ (transzendental) Fo~~ 0. 0. :1J$~I¥J'I'1~87. 0. fI~J~~.t~1¥J~. , i!iJ3 ~~;HifJi.~~ilil£~=6~ ~J:.~:@G - 11$1¥J ~IDfU cp 5JU ~ -11$~I¥J%"1'i E*D.~~'±jt , ¥-J5JrH~JDjf!fm.~IDfUpJT~z11$~ff1Q]l!lli 73U ' ~~7f1tfr'tt~i!iJ3;1;mWjf!fm.~ffifB ' t):&-tfff3~zjf!fm9im~§I¥Jl:B 0. ~lfii7° ~)tflt~*~i!iJ3;1;mm.~~.~'±*iz~~o~)tI¥J.~.±jtBUI3. ~f4~~~&w. '. {Bl£*ili*fj~IIIIWI¥J,~MWruJfUfjWWT. ~g1f6Wi!iJ3~mfJi.~~~@I~~11rOJz~T~P'3. ' ~PB*!-a-7jf!fm. : r jf!f~'I'1 J W r j:$'1'i J 88 0. ffiJ~og-ffi~WTml:B:.~.±jtffi~~11$I¥J~~tt'~-1100~JL1£.B~. ~J:.I¥J*~,~Bjj~tl. '. ~m11$~Ki*l&!f4~~D~I¥J"6J~'1'i. ' ffiJ~ijgi*l&!t)~m. ff:ff!fo/J*1C- W~~~~~I¥J1BJ:.~~D~ ; :93- 1100~D~l¥Jm~~~*~,~$. ~~f.lffifB~R0]PJT1$:I¥J*1C~ , !I:t~P~pJTfffiP~~JL7ttJTtll¥J~gHi~{* ' t):&~ W.~0]W~ffifB~0].jf!fmttl¥J~~~ o ~~1100IE~.IWOOffi~l¥Jrj:$. ttJ W rjf!fm'I'1J =~T {Bf-tmMWruJfLfff3WWTffiJ§ ,r j:$ttJ ~ r~ m'l'i J ~T{J%5~{lL ' ~"6J1;ti!iJ3;1;mf1twp{fufr't)J~t*fH~~rnUlU:@Gjf:tJ~/H~ 0. 86. Habermas 1973 : 88-90 0. 87. .~ 1993 : 150. 88. *~)~:9:.Jt 1997b : 83-85' jLtil1re,J!&.~ Ltibbe 1972: 43-46,55-56, Sommer 1984:. r-r ~~ 'iii' 1IT PIT ~a~A.fl-J1!t~m~ (menschlicher Weltbegrift) tx. ill f.ti (nattirlicher Weltbegrift) 73 :fEl1t~ ill f.ti#*.p 4&J.J£fI-J tx.1:..J£* fl-J1!t~m~ , '8~. XVII-XIX 0 $,..p ~~ til fl-J1!t~m:t. .~£~B4.*fl-J1!t~m~T~~fI-J.~oA.fl-J1!t~m:t8~T.£~~.4r1:.~1!t .J'~.*~-~.41:. •• ~fl-JR~.~.~ •• '~*.41:.~~~fI-J-~o 89. Habermas 1973 : 97-98 0.

(20) ~. (~~.~A ••••• )'~.. ~1j*~JtI~f!81ffl1¥J~~ mrm~-Itl. 0. , 1~rm rJ § ~f!~~l**~Ii!~tEI¥J*rHnJtl~{~~~ tJ{iP:fr~rmf§ , JtI~jji~~AfF'~:ff1:1¥ ' §JXi*1¥I¥JI!l 90 0. WzJ§& ' tvHf'm~D{PJ~1:1I5tEWJtI~t1~-~1iJo~ ? tV3~'m~ffUif~ ~~*~J~~iV.1JDrJ*!tJS- rJ~~lE*taHzt!;I¥J*~ , {gJltMtJS-I¥JJ}]WFf~ ,1E,t*lH~ ~l*~1j , !Z9rmpJT~I¥J~~fu7f~JIEJ,*lH~~!*~IjI¥J~~ , BP~~lWm91 &'~ 0. ~'m.§~fi~lEl¥J.m~:ff~~,~.~~~~.~~.~.m~.I¥J.. , {gWZ~ § fUtl~I¥J:1J$~*51m;a~fm~. 2.~;/j$'~rtu int- [§j , fffi pJT ~.I¥J.m~.~-1~iJ.Wiml1!l~\~'IiI¥JJJl~W~m ~f§ 2. ' ~~* tV3~~ff!flfi- :1JIm ~1Ji!~'lil¥Jm 1$ ' g--:1JrnF-u E13 1:115a',~te~1JDrJ B)jm !j[ r:p. 0. 0. :¥;/j$'JtI~.m~~IJ~mff!fl~ltt11¥J-Im. ' rmj:~1:$'lim-:ii. 0. ~JXfFrf. [§j~~WtV3~'m~a~.~~2.lW~~fimte:~~~~U.~fi%~W.. ' {gtV3~~J!~HN1j£1:$*~!MLt~JtI~I¥JB)jm$mtJ ; ~D~JtI~.g~ ~:ffrJfi}~I¥J~~*~mf4~f!ffifBl¥J • • ' tJ~MtV3~m~L-~1:$*~~r:p~. ~&fi}~f!ffifB*~I¥JB)jg~te~*~m~ • • JXfF~RP1j£Ifte~tV3~~fJ!a~2. ~JtI~*~PJT-frfj1:$tt!Z9-T ' ~fi}~Wf4~titWPJT-frfj2.1:$t1WJtI~tE =!Z9Tte~ , *WJStr~*3'O&fFJtlIt.m~lfflf~~l¥Jf*.pg~ {titWI¥JJtI~.i§ > -iJo ~l¥Jml$. 0. A. ~;jf 1. i~lti ~ -f- ag JJt ~ ~ 3l~ ~-.m.MI¥JJtI~ • • *~,~~tV3~m~~JtI~~.ttl¥J-[§j,~. , l1MEIfflAI¥J1:iPW1:$ i§:r!:9 A.~~~~ JtI~I¥J~a ' rJ&JtI~~~PJT1&&I¥J1:$titWJm§ JXfF~EJ~te ' i§:~~g ;/j$'1Ji!~J~-:~2.JtI~E13~.*~,~te~l¥Jm~f!M ' Jl;tf!MRP~~¥O:g: AI¥J1:$. ~A'I!t~fJ!a~ff,~~-f!~lfflfi}~. 0. 0. £.og-:1JImJX~~~~~~.~(~~wm.JtI~)r:p@.~m~~.. ~MrPJ2.JtI~!*.. 90. Husser! LU I :. : r ~nf!~1¥J '. .JL. :f~~. ~~~nmfHl¥J~m$ J. tI:l ,~#~F"J )UPi 'i JIlT 1f 1-#1* iJ!1t. ~ IfJ ~~. 0. '. ~~-ll~D~. it-e.k~-!-1fJ. ' 1f. 1-~~,~J£*~f.JIfJ-t-"*.!..!~~~4~li~IfJi!~-t-ti~MIfJ~raJ' 1-~ Philippip 1986 :. IX· 91. 92. Husser! LU I : A208. 0. Jt Husserl Ideen I: 45·. Jtt~. : r *"*-t-tlt-t-ti.!..! .. !!p~~ffl1f#*~@'1t~ffitt!t..:&'4. .-t-IfJ·-e.ak.*~J£.IfJ~~IfJ.'~ • • ~k.~IfJ-t-ti.!..!~oJ.

(21) -1fttJJ*-fijt~~{(.JJ.lt*-**;fi--t-#lf-t (-t!t"..J'I.{(.J~~~.it). (Wissenschaftslehre) , r f~~.'I:1f4~mG~PJ~gJ. •. ~f-f-~l¥Jf4~. 0. 53. 93im~ftJtt~~jrfm!~. , ~Et~i5I~3t1tWA'tll¥J~~./f~i&!94. 0. @~~/f~• • ~~~g~B~~.~~~I¥J~~*~offi~~~~W. ~mt!m GKi~m~} ~-PJTmt. '. PJt!PMl~~~~mLt~T§I~-j!:r*~fm. :j:fi I¥JEP. ' 19.~~LtaB~ti)H~mpJTJR,cJ\ I¥J~;Wim~~*- r~reE~FffrK1&Ez .~JfiOOI¥J;I;JH~Bf4~ , X.~F t)~~n§ § l¥J~f4~pg?gI¥JI~~lfH ' 191.}\~FtE~ ~~·~~I¥J~~W.'ffi*m*.a*~~I¥J$OO~~o~x.~~~m~ ~~.n~~Jki~;~~:>Uf!~m~1ttz:t1t*IJB'lf 'L'Jl1:JiI¥J$r~'JL~. ' fN*J: BP El g?6~~*,cJ\~:1:~W& , ffi.L-~M~zfm~l¥Jm1$fD$.wmljiB;I;~1$f§l£lli53U 96 0. ffila~ll:1l¥Jim~~pmEE~n§*~.I~iH:BB*f!m '~~~~ml¥J1J~#':k7Jf1~ z~mtl-00. tl2USfJJf,iW~1¥J. '. : ~~~:15~#':k:gAftiitl¥J~n§~&!lW~n§§lo. fi97. 0. ~~~~.mM:1:~~fm~~ftttl¥J.~~~*~m~*.£~?ft (iI~m~} ~-8l:f~~m&ft~@I53Uto/JM~~$t)fm~"@:im (Ideation). 15:ctffim-~Zto/J. 93. Husser! FTL : 6. 94. Tito 1990 : xxxiii. 9S. '. JfI~;I;~~t!PEEJtt1!H~SJ3~'I:1. 0. I¥J. 98ft~1F~**'I: { JfI~m~ }. 0. 0. iutJl • • &.fHHfJ (J. St. Mill) {(.J.ii~.Lf.tilJ-'J..&.h!t-ttA{(.J.ii~*~' Ji1J;/." :t~H·ffiJ. (Bain) tJl4--=-:jf1ti-~"*". ' Jt Husser! LU I: A32-34. 0. l-:J.i!J.(; 1I 3:. A:jf;fi- flJ ~ ;.t\ JR.~ , &..(; 1I 3:. A:jf ffiJ l'" ~ J:. ~ :11.(; J! 3:. A tIJ;#It !1'i) 1l ~j1JJR.aJR.~ , !1'i)*JtflJ#'#-.ii~*4.j!..:1I{(.JlIt:tJR.~ , Jt~J:.: A164-A165 R.~Jl:t.lIt:t 1l.ft"*"t-r ;;t~.J& ' ~~-<±. r iiJ.jIj. Hti!. 96. iu tJ! *- •. 0. 0. 97. Tito 1990: xxvi,. Jt..tii iliiuJl:t.ar-<±'J.lt*-*J-'J.il~i!Jit.lI'lf-t-*-{(.JAl~·ti",.re.~fIJA.{(.J1..1p-J4. #-<±'tf.:/t~o. itfttJJ*-Ht-<±' ( ~~l1fJ'E ) 4- '" l-:J.i!J.(;J!*{(.J 8J! "&tr.Lf: ~M-*ft n #;1tHt~1t jttt{(.Jm~ , !1'i)llJ!.:t·ti{(.J Bjj5':'/"i ar l-:J.M*ttL (~J:. : A185) ;b .I>t-<±.Jt.~~ j ~~.9:. <J.ltf\;.~~{(.J _1I:f-. J > (1910111) '" ft$-.:t~Ufk : ~U," .j!..iIij • • m.~{(.J~h'*ar~.~r~~'&.t'*~:1I~.~~h'-~~{(.JAJ!~~~ 98. iu Husser! LU I: AWl, AI29 '". eAii ili. 0. .. .~1L~r*'J~:jf, M:.tJJ*-~{(.JBjj1i ·ti-l!!.k-""(£'{(.J' 1t.-I!!.M·_lI~l=l'" (matteroffact) ilt ~T'iu~~*-~W~C~At~W-.or~~1p-~J~r~~~.J~ar~,.:jfa:1l. • tJJ*-. JI4- .1I.~-.:t·ti {(.J-ff.:1I (ideates Sein) , i!ft~ .1I~;9..:1I- ~~ ~~~·~ • • ~3:..*t-"-<±':jf,.x;;tM • • ~:1I~-l'""(£'o_*JR.~~rAJ!~ • J • r -<±.~~ B~M 1I ~ {Ji.~ '" {(.J:1I ~i.'ti-' Jt J ~ ~ Ij\' ~ Ii5 ft AlI:f-. 1 {(.J lIM:1I *JI/J ~ , ;b.I >t~.A.{(.J- • • ~~.ii~*Ij\'~~~.&.~~o.J!fi;bI>t~~ • • J&m~{(.J-~~ ,. -I51Ltf.:/~~.

(22) 54. ( ~ 1Ljf.L~ *::t.fJ '" "':fa.). ~=~f!PI:iJ~¥U. 1ft '" JlJl. : ~~m1~~~~~8''];g:fN'l1: '. ~l1H1,fE~Ilttil~ttt3"J~~~~~1PJf.E~$§W 1JrOJ~1'J1¥J. 0. fN~tt8''Jlimi:fj~. , WJf;Jz§,. $:'8~1J§~E8;g:mrOJ::tm~~'~. fffl~c:p~-m~~1¥J r ~:illtWf.ER J (Ausdruck und Bedeutung. 0. Expression and Meaning) JJj;)8tt§~~A-1§U. '. ?JE~i:fj~c:pg;g:mMiID8'']m. ~.~~~::tmMiIDl¥Jmtil*.~;'8mOO7~iID~~~~~m~::tml¥Jm ~offfl~~f.ERZ~-§W.~:.~~E8-~~Zf.ERffi.~,~m -M~. WfJ.ffifu~ r f.ER~m~ZWi!~tullEt J. '. f.ERZ£*~7G$:A~A1tf.~{flj~. ~. :L1.. nh I'lEI-IdSt99. il'JilfHIQ'J1 J1lili. 0. H1tff.ER.~I¥J::t~~~l1H. ' ~fF~~¥U~-W~1im~JJ1tff.ErOJ'I1:I¥J*Mflj {t&7tffT ' ~7t 1. {flj~~f.ERZ~:illtI¥Jf.ErOJtt1'J~ (acts)' 2. f.E~, j;)& 3. pJT :j:~#Z1tf~-=-M;Jz , j;)1'JAZ~-'I1: (quality) WJIf~ (material) j]DJ::~'§'pg ~ (sensory content) #1I'l.I.~~f.E~W1tf~ tilI¥J1'J~pq~. affairs). 0. 0. 10o~7\m~11!Jllit-T ~1:rf8W;U[. , j;)Z.~~i&rff[J~~:£J1i:fj*I¥J$~J. (Sachverhalte; states of. 101. WZf§~. , *'tiQ*fj~~~~~~Z18ffilll*RI02 , i&l~~fFn~:¥U@fF~j;). ~.~I¥J~~ttffi~.I¥J~~~.~~H'fffl.*WEm~j;)~~*~~~ W~.,j;).~~#&pq~W~.*tt,~~.~~~-1tf~ZHmM~'. ' ~$~~~111@ , fffl~1Irn8?&~1I1@~~ , -Wil~'G.~.m~l1Hc:p .~l!iRz~ $'I1:Z- iID tzD*.~.§~~lfa:tfL-:J,~~*:!it~/f1:iJ§w1£1¥J£~ , {f! -~~ffP~Z~B1:rf.ER~~@!ml¥J*Ji~~Bt1-Et~MfJ.~lfa ' ~~~~il ~Jm*'I1:M:illt. 0. ~~.A~4_%A~~~$~.4~.~. •• ~~li·&~~~.1Lli.ft~~ •• ~ •• ~~.li.ft.·~~). ~#li4a~~~A'~~~~*~.~~~'6t_ 99. 100. 1-:t Husserl LU IIII. : A 95; Sokolowski 1970 : 41 •. Jt Husserl LU III1 : 1ft -. ~ 1ft li.'It Jt. '. .;it 1-:t Sokolowski 1970 : 41-65 ' 1t.~~. tI:l tJj. *. ~. 11. -t8~£~W;f'4~*J;.\ (matter and form) ~*:t~.f~~ '~~AA.~~.Aj~~.fT_~i~;.t'. ~S46T~$_.4.A~~*~-'~M~.*~.~~."'MM~MttW· 101. Jt Husser! LU. *:t~. II12:. 1ft1';-'ltJt ' 3t1-:t Skolowski 1970: 65-71 '. $,.~~. tI:l ~~!£~'$B~~. •• A'~*~*~M*~tI:la.H_~.4._-.:t~~.'~~~.~~l. ""tt 1 it} ~t . 102. 1-:t. Gutting 1971 : 212 ' $,.):)' _ tJj* iQ ~ ~a$1II ~J:."'*~ *It. ' ~ii~ ~ti~~ &.Aa. $1II~~~~~J:..*lt'~~.**.M~ft.~A~~~.1L.,~.*a.~~~. 1IIl!~~~..l."' .~¥ll· £*-..l.*~' -=-*~t~~*lt'irIW!-t;tA~~fff-~; :t:~tJj*~:t. #i/'·HJtA. (material mode) ~.A 'il~~~~:t~~~)t~ (fonnalmode) ~.A·.

(23) ,ffUJl *- ~ .:t..ii~ ff.]J.Jt *-" *-~ -t ,(!pj f-.:t.. ( i!t -l'r- fA ii~:fl.i't ). 55. ilJfjg(f]~.'[j:. ; ~~~i!if3~mtJ1:.$*~~te~~i!im~lHJl¥I~$mtJ ' t~1fP~1¥J g~ EB ~ rPJ'l:1 fJ ~W~ '§' pq ?Jpff!!it T/ , 3:§Jm MiGJJl ~ ~Jm m pff 5~ ~~ I¥J 1:. ¥5. 11. 0. tJ-~lW[Hjpff§. : fJl~~t~~Jkiml¥Jti!~'I:1PJtJ1~tjfl£WI¥J*~,~~te~*Bjj m' fJGfr~f!Hi mItfilifJl~~ ~ I¥J /f [q] ~b~:tt T.f,~~ : 1. /f ffifB~ JJl~~~ m L~1i1:.$ti~T ' ~jkim.~~ifB~:iJlm~Z1:.$t1:~T ' i!if3~mwJll~. ~iB~"'&tJ r tJ5tliiJ (Struktur) ~f§1&1¥J~~ , B~JI;t*5~l£=~X.f=f/f[q] : rrFI!t£1:.$l¥JnJ*J:.~tlG*a~~J!~ (Strukturtypik) , 1&~l£lmm~*J:.:j:j(; rim. ~J6~J. 0. 103 2.. i!if3~m1~~J'I1£1:.$M*I¥J3t*ijJl\~ (texture) te~. .~JI*I¥JJkim*5tlii (structure). 104 3.. 0. , :1::mnX:. fJl~~i!i~l£M%lm~i8W1@]i9iJl¥UlW~~. i8m3. ~~~ (prepredicative experience) 1¥J1*~~ (protological). 0. 105~~i!if3. • •!Jilll~.~~ifB~~t1*5m~~~lmf**5m ' 3t*ijJl\~~llm*5~ , l*~ tBWBIII~~mi8Pf1I¥J/f [q]mff~rj.J~ , ~PJ~t~~~f$¥U-f[Hj~~l¥Jf4~Wi!!: .w.1.fiID 106 0. 10) Tito ~r~.J. tJl*- Hi .ft..( ~ -t >t"tLE.~ tf 4;tH4$ (~#ii~) fA .i.'Jt ' 1§1..f:# ,~(l, .f;.~l=.. ~*4 .. fI/J ~ A • Jlt..i..&Jt 4·\.; f£ 91] r .~H~ J (structure) ~!. ' 1Ul:. ,~t :fl.f: At ]':J, lb.£ *'1 ~ J!- ~HJi 91] ft " :fX ~*J!.o P1fUi 9I],~~~A1!! !lr~ijttilor~*4-* fA 1.)~i!t-l'r-" iiJ *-~ .:t..#;~~ Jt Tito 1990 : xxxix 0. 0. Moustakas 1994: 34-35, 78-79 fJf~t!!J.:t..~1llm:t - texture, structure ' ],:J,M-~ ' 't#.iJi:l:.-=-m:t1t Moustakes 1;;&4-~~9I]JJt*-~~*m'J~ ,~ijttA.JItJ! ~a.~1* ~~~~& • • '~.'M.J!-~a.#;.~~'m'J-=-.I-~~.~. 104. ,/Ht.~Jfl. J.l".il!~.:t..~~J&. ••. fl/JlIA~o. 105. *~. Gurwitsch 1974 : 31. 0. ~4Jlt..ili-Jt.**~'~~~*-~J!-ii~~ • • ~~ii • .:t..A~.*.*-~~~.:t..M *.1fMft..(,;t Coffa 1991 if~~ ili r .f:.Jt Frege J!- Russell fJf~fA r i!!~9I].!I' tJl*-~P1f~~.:t.. ril!.~J bJf'A'.' ~ MeinongP1f~.:t.. r1t*-J£ti!.!I' ],1,& Wittgenstein .:t...j.ij-t! rii~fA-{q* fl/JJ • • Jt.~~~.;B~.f:~J!-+P1f • .:t..~.'.~mAl=..~J!-.~~M~~.:t...~ 0. ~~.o~~.:t..ii~~.A.:t..A~.·Jt~~~&.~I~#;.9I]~J£'m'J#.~mAX Ii) I!/Jet 1£. 0. J. (64) ~1r'.e., ;J~1l1lA~, -It ' ~ffi!.m:t~JL~ e.. Jt ~~~J& 91] i\UbJ ' m'J tt *11. '. ~S~.~~~m:t;~4~.~iiJ~mJ&l.f:~fA.~:~~.a.:t..ti~M.a~A. ~"'.t ... (67). ~~.J.tJl*-~-!f!-JJlA1-1;..i!;(;jm:t.:t..~t1.jXlli.lf... (68)' 1F~~(] Frege -~ 1i)~.~-.4.~~~~4~~~'m'JJ!-6~.~'~~-~iiJ~.a.f:~.:t..M.~~ 4iIJil!.~ , m'J.f:tfF1t-~;.t#6,ti (76). 0.

(24) ( il.tLJi ~f> .:k.:!f! ~:!f! ~. 56. B.. ta) 1It ~ JlJl. f+~~:t~~,ti~~~,ti ~( • • ~~)~-B~ • • • ~M~I¥J* • • 7m.:M'. W9;O (Wissen) fflm ' mf!z;g1¥J1j~n5lb/f)E~t5iW;gz£'u~ m:~w:xm ' 1& RA~R~ 9;otl:n5lb ' 1:1 ff~ § ~ff1f:tfu{lz:l¥Jf4~ :(£9;09= JXfr'tmffJJ.:f!{'F~-IE1ii*U~Zi1~ , {BtzDlI:t~/f~~ '~:Mz~FtJlllIE1ii*U~ , TIJ@lWJJ.:f!~§-¥)(I¥J~-$fi~z~JE:W=6JE: ' gt~~1f:t$fi~zffff~~Fff1'J I¥J9;O i§:B~~~-8J1~tl: ' 8J1B1ii~?JJXfr'~~?JI¥J*~ffff ' W(;=6JE:I¥JWiZ§ /fffff°ft~mtt~~.I¥J~$gZffff=6JE:~~~'.~• • I¥J~$g~ ffZ~~'tl{tJi(*U~ , ~z9;ol¥Jf!l;t~tMJ* 7 f4~/fffr~1'l-a~9;O ' ~~-a~1fB ~Im~~~ (Begrundungszusammenhang) 1¥J*ft- , :(£At:f11&R@l5JU~?J~I¥J~~~~ , (Wissenschaft). 0. 0. 0. 1'1 -p,,/.!J;:. -p,. ~-=-. rf;1:::;=A=;(><c6h-m-C--kR .6-.6h=A=;(><c. .v..A/X./~ IX.AE.=-ilRilillioJ )C.[PJif>J:1 p o:iilRilil'iI. 1tlfJ*ft-. 0. (/'$.#Rn.E!i)~1fIE[tm.E!i):j:ffi=8). 1~ -s LJ;IJ~1")('1I J1f't~-".:Eilllll. xi;;:. l'iJ' it-v: -", mifYL. !:~/.B. B. 107. 8J1~'I1:W~ifij~~Im~~~'I1:I¥J~:1J1ID NPOSf ff!iW1ID PJT~I¥J ~n5'I1:W~.'I1:~r. N.i!• •:(£. '. B Bm~ 7 {tMl1!zi1f4~~g\(;I¥J~@JH. ' ffiJ B iT~ ~g\(;~I¥J~aJ1~~'I1:I¥Jf!l;t~108 , l-J,R~ifij~Im~~~tzDfi.1J:(£aJ1~'tlTNH.J,{$~ (ikI.~~). 0. ~JXfr,&~m:~n5'I1:~rl¥JaJ1~'I1:Wt~f.g\(;M~pJT~* 1¥J~n5t!tWm:~gtP.X:7f4~zJJ!~~f!ffifij£m. 0. '. 1!z*iT::x~~te. fi.*lB:gtf~ili. : ~i§:1!i~. £f4~zJJ!~~f!ffifij*~Ai.t~~ a::t~JJ.:IEf4~1¥J1%f~. 0. , ~{~I¥J1%f~~1mtzD~• •m~ifijBPt)~El 109{B~• • §!fffifij~ffr~~f!M~9;o~I¥J~.*5f. ' ~. WJE:~f4~1¥JJ!i. ' i!ot81.f\tzDfOJfi~~HtB:pJT § zf1>t1fli7fJ!fo/Jf!~M~~ § m 1¥Jt§'~ , f4~~1BB/fR~-g.r:t:1t ' f4~g\(;~-$Jf (science as a fact) ~ N.i• •Rff~f4~~-r",~Jj!] (science as a problem) , NP~M~I¥J-g.a:d1:mte. 0. &'ffiJm~:(£~n5t!tW~~~~ff~ttl¥J£.o~ft*8'J!i.Jfmffifij~~ ~~m::(£f4~Wtp.x:$.TZf4~B~&fijtJ~pq$ff~t1 (technical or intrinsic. , 1f:tr",~Jj!]7J~f4~I¥JJli.*~f! ' ffiJfJ~lllf4~m:~ mmff~~tl:l¥Jr",~Jj!]~fj~jg@]f4~z~n5'I1:~' r*~f! 110. validity of science) r",~~. 0. 107. 108. Husser! LU I: A12-A14. 0. 1tm-t,ij*lija}Hi'Ii~;tftm-~MlSiJ (original)'fijJ.f,SiJ (adequate) l4~f'!.\SiJ (apodictic). ~. J5IJ ' J.:.c&. *!J1~ 1E;j.f ;/f))f( ~ ~.ft;/f ,. 109. Gurwitsch 1974 : 31-32 •. 110. t-~~.1.. : 35-37. ' 1,.~:i. ili li1\ §. It t-1lIl i.I.~ ~. 1995: 60-64. f'!.\#~J1'.1il~t,-lSiJ-=-FW,ft. 1'1'. 0. ; 1. The Period of Validation, 2..

(25) -ifttJl£ift~~~IAIJt~:'t*-;t-t~1H:. . (i!t~IA~~~.i.i). C. .tft 1.. iE tit ~ flJ. 57. *+ ~ tit ~. iiI:J~mft <Il~=}. W {Il~=> :rl ' ~1;tf¥1'f~l¥Jmffl< (ontologische Konstitution) *~~r~f4~Zmffl<rr:l~Jj!] , IZ9~EI3f8~[![Il~*~[![llf~ffl<Z W~fG~ (materiale Kategorien) cP 1'f -11~b'N* Z f¥1'f ~ ~ ±~ (ontologische Regionen) , E1r~~to/JJH1E3?'~ , ,~\%-Et-zIMmimW~1i~)d~i!tWzm)jj$ , Df£:fE£1r~I¥J¥WLtffij1'f§~f4~ , ,~\f£~WA3tf4~Zmffl< i§:ft®:)t;BJI; ~~M*I¥J=Mm~~~~~MI¥J • • W~$~jm~o~~~.~:r~ (...) _ffl<tBl¥J~~¥*~j5JIJ1'f!Jl~~zJiim -a:rif(®~mpfT;f§Blzf4~ im1'f• J IlIffij£[Jx1r~~)jj~-a:r~mM~ • • ' !&R-a:r¥:R:~ rf4~~$z®:1'f¥f'I:1J 112 ftl!~~~WWJ : r~:j'F IT':fJl1i;f4~JJ pfTml¥J ' W IT'W*JJ pfTml¥J;§ffl<J~1! ' 0. •. 0. 0. OOmti~z*.'WM~&~~~~mffl<Z~~ttl¥J)f8~z~~I¥J-a:r~. *~~PfTg*.~{:)J!iT J ~1!ZPfT1'f®:~1j. 0. J 113. gt1~~~~JJl$~1~~.~Il~l¥Ji1~-ft ~ft~I¥J~~. '. ~Mf¥ft~~W~r~f4~?fJ\. , f4~~1!EI3E1r~pfT¥:R:5E ' E~f£mIi:t~Il~'I:1i1~1¥J~1! 53U ~ {~m tiff ~ > ffif pfT § z Il ~ [![ Il W Wi [![ Il ' -4- tj, * ~ 5t tIT (Wesensanalysen)W*~tatiI1!; (Wesensbeschreibungen) ~ ~1! 114 ~~.tttgzp 7~j;):fJl~~~M~¥~ffif ' - JiJ~Jj,~~~~16J~~$ , !lPJ;)~F[![Il~$pfT 0. .'8. 0. m~~~,~J;)#~®:~~~Mmz~~;§~~~~¥~'~W0f£~M~. ~d1;ttE~16J~AI15. J12fs:JfI¥Jre'iillt '. *~,~I¥J§~f4~€i~5t!ME1~mre'iillt1!. '. ~CP1'fl/i&~~*~Il1'fJ3Z'1:1l¥Jf4~tzD1iItm~. ~tMi'$~f4~~B)j ~~ ~f4~~B)j ~~. 0. (Erklarung). 1¥J~1!. 0. 1IiEEI3[![lltB~. , t~fl~ , E1r~. 1B~*~Il1'fJ3z:l¥Jf4~tzDtmfl~. , IlIzre'iillt1!gt~ffl<~®JiWI¥J¥~116 ~1i~J~\fl~mJ3z:$tm , ~AWJ~\fl~$@:A§~!m1*cp , ~j;)*.millt~~1! ' i§:ft~11ffi1iQ 0. Science as a Fact, 3. Science as a Problem' Ji:('~~JlJlmtJl£iH~r.ll ' i1iJtJl£~3t~M&t4:'t. ~~ • • ~.*.tlM~'~fi • • t4:'t.$ • • *.tllA&.M~· III. Husserlldeen III : 20 •. 112. ~.1.. : 21 •. 113. ~.1.. : 22 •. 114. f&J.1. : 59 •. liS. f&J.1.: 60.. 116. ~.1.. : 60 •.

(26) (@.rr..iE.t~~f;.$~**.) ~:;';-j!Jj. 58. lli. (F. Brentano) pJT£~Zmillt{J\f]'!~ (deskriptive Psychologie) 1&::t~®Cj(:. ~117. 0. 4-ftf~~~~f4~f-'~ifBI¥JJLt~T. ' /f~~;fEl~f4~~lc,\f]'!~~ftm~fT. ~~~*~milltn$'@~~=M~x~/f~o. I¥J '. EI~M~UMA~M~AM~~_.l¥JmWR~~~'E~~~~. Df~EEI5?:~8(JEI¥J ' jG~/[email protected]'9JfmZ-f~~ffiJ8118 f4~*1iIEE 0. f~~tB~. ff.%§1¥J119. , {Blii~~Jlmf~[!!!]~~~f~~{i'tZmilltffiJ8 ' 0. BPt)~.~5f!Z7ttFf. tzD5f!~mf]'!~t)f~~1&imZJf~::t~~1!'I'11¥Jft(~. ~a1E1'9lc,\ (Seele ; mind) :tt/f~f~~1&Z-MJfm ~a1E1'9@:tilfV~ftm,~fI. ~lc,\{i'tZmJE. '. '. E&t~lc,\EI'9ff~*J}. ffiJEI~f4~ZmilltRm)£iff~~120. '. , #~Mlc,\f]'!~pJT. ftj7g:tE~~$lc,\f]'!~PJT. , i'&,c,\f-'~l¥Jmillt&tPJ@:ti 0. ~ • • ~0f]'!~WEl~M~ffi~~,§ft~A*J}~ff.%m~0~~EI'9~ ~~£~. , {§. E/fR~~1i·N~.EI'9millt '. ffiJ~~~m,~E1'9. 0. E~~;f.~EI'9R. .PJfJ~t1 (ideale Erlebnismoglichkeiten) z*~ffiJmillt121. 5fG7CIm~WI'1pJTgEl'9f~t~Z{lID3U1t J. '. iS5t8:ill?:~l~-$Jf. , m.~¥m.~ r - t/J 122 (Faktum) ffiJ8 ~ 0. ~m.£.zm.~~~~~.~~.~zm§'E~PJftff~~EI'9.~fBi ff~ffl -{lID r~jg1ZJ ' ~. 0. Eft. ~.~=}. $*Diffml.-:JJJlJffi$. (Geist) EI'9~§*~. 123. EE~~*'~ • • ~ffi./f~ffft~~~ZM~.~-)£EI'9W~n$' ®~n~~~UEI~M~~WEl'9m~n$'~U~~~M~~~~~EI'9n$ .~.~tt'~~E@:tiU$~*J}m~~~~'ffiJ#~-~EI'9~~ • • ~. ;!t$ , ~fu~~1i~g~PJT.~*I¥J.f~tEt=J~124 fti§Ji~.f~'IiZg~. 0. 117 M.l.. : 61 ' Jl8. M.l.. : 65 '. 119 M.l.. : 66-67 ' 120 MJ:..: 67-69' 12IMJ:.. : 69' 122 M.l.. : 69-70 ' In~&~~~ • • li#*~*~ma*~*~a~T-.IA,~~~ft~~. ~~~~~Ama*~~~'~~~*I~~tt~.ma*. •• ~*~-·ma.~~~. M.rli#.~.~~'~~AT~*~A.Tli#*~£.~~.·. 124 MJ:.. : 68; Husser! SW : 7-8,27 '. ••li#$.

(27) .f:U)3.~ ~ ~ii~agm*-**;t-t~Pl-t~ (i!t$agii~~~rt). ~"F. '. 59. -t;7]$.tiZf4~:1J$;JM:~&.~~=6kSIt83~ffijft3Zme@7tJ!:lr1:E~mt!t. W~iitlLtl¥J~\~T. 0. i;tffij1:E~±Wf~:1J1ID1tli@*z (originar) fft±wr~ , tW. ~:lL1:E§j?t,f4~1¥J:1J$;1¥J ~rpm:~I¥J~JH$. I. Mtatfft±Wf~ J. fElfJ. 0. i&=tf1&~m~I¥JJJ.. i!VHjH~tJi§:liFa9~:1J$:/f~gfF&®i~¥Um~I¥J~~. 0. 1W~Z@:~~~fft±WfJ~~. '. ~J~. , i!&.:t~. , iitJ~t~t:*ff*~~125 , i!&*ff1aHIft1t~~m~1¥J. 15$.0 f;£Mrm~1r'-aJ~D. : fEii!V3~~pJTml¥J~ mtikSIr 8fLH@m:~M1.:t1ml¥Jim,~. ifrt~. , ffij-F*P3~~~pJTml¥J~~tikSIrfNmm:fF~~*~t!tW£~I¥J£*Im{*. L '. {tl!1r'~1:E§j cl¥JpJT~bHI1£~L==tf~I*J~~ff4~ff4g\(f4~t!tWI¥JI. {'F f.S'M'-F*-P3~tJIm{**6*~l¥JtEa~~.:t ' ffij/f1&&*'I:il¥Jm~ , ffr~mff~~~ I¥1fJ{@ , /f~&3£~I¥J{I{@ , ¥-f5JU~M"{tl!fIJ&i!V3~~f~~~~I¥J1m~~1tff~ 0. *&~'W/fG~Z.~~ff4I¥J.~£~~'~=6fJM~~t!tWI¥J~~~ff4 :1J$.~~L1ID~i!V3~~Mm~l¥JfJ~? '£~1rH!~:{-f*{8~-F*P3~1tj~ff4£~I¥J~g1~. , I¥JUI-aJ ~J~*Di!V3~~J~~ ~tpl¥J-®3ifij~~~fEl{~ i!V3~~~fJ1m,~1mff!m51fJT~@] rto (Retention) , J:ij{M:iEP~ (Urimpression) WMrto (Protention) -=- @]~Fa9IftfrJ (Momente)126 ; &,Z-Fffl~L-:)Ji%1m,~¥m*/fQJ 51fJT ' ffijfJtffr~~g~~51fJT~~g\({5J ' i§:@]~ 0. $.{~:P-~P1:Ettt~~i!V3~~PJT{$:.~51fJTI¥JI{'F. 0. {fl.-F*P3~~{'F~*£*Im{*1¥J. ~EHli'ti@]'~ tp Z@] '~fu~J3i!V3~~ pJT51fJTtfjl¥J@] rto m:~ 127 g{*~*~~ 1:E851fJTI¥JIftfrJZFa9. 0. ,. tJ ~fEllli'I:i@] tl. ~D*-F*P3~3£~i§: ®IftfrJff[£~~g\({5J1¥J. , »I5MfEl~li'I:i@]'~ff[£~-li~/ijJ{*n,!!& ? -F*P3~- :1J1IDff~1mM1~1t~-/fQJ51 1¥J£*7L* ' iii§:~JM:-fJ~B~ff*4ffiji§1¥J ; g:1J1ID~-.YJffim:51fJTi&1m~ ~. .1¥J£*Im~fF~~~ff4~.Zm~'ii~~i§:~JM:-fJ~I¥JID~ffiji§1¥J. 128. 0. ~DIIt*~ , -F*,P3~PMlijJ])]LZ~51fJT ' ~g\({5J , L-~&~1r'PJTt~tfjl¥J~/ijJ{*. '. .~JM:fJ~Zff~ffiji§*/fQJ51'~W~g\(~JM:fJ~ZID~ffiji§MUI~Z£ */ijJ~I¥JMmo.~Z'M"i!V3~~U~~~I¥J:lr~1:E~~51m1m~~,~m. tfj~~Mff1:El¥Jm~U~'-F~~~1&~g\(*'ii~~.~ffillitt@].{'F~*. 12S. Husserl SW : 24. 0. ttt-Illl Husser! ZB :' 34, 100; jUtt-lllli.£.5C.Jt 1995: 88-95 1ttJl.t.~-l1. (BfMt~~) <f 1h''l -l1. of M,tH~ A ag ,It J! 126. 0. 127. Camap 1998 : 110. 128. Camap 1998 : 117. 0. 0.

(28) (@.l'LJl.t~~~"'{J"'*ta) ~~J!J!. 60. £*~~~oM • • ~n • • ¥®.~~ • • ~~.M • • ~~m@w~ e'®~~.~~.~• •~~,~~~mMm~~~$~m·.~8&!. Im{* '. ijW~mA:(£!&@~~}iUJrfJ..if~{*~;f5t®®8. xM• •ttff~~~imlJf;tfg:(£~ra9g.. 0. (das innere ZeitbewuBtsein). 11J5. ~*'~~~~~~=OO~OO=®~~fg:(£~OOg.~~.£. ~~ cognoscendi) , '&Zfg:(£~ra9~.~U~~ra9$frJ~*~£~ (ratio essendiY 29 0. ~~7G~tM • •®§. , ~ra9$®~~?2.fgfr~ra9~.~-OO~fI' ' {g~~tI ~ra9g.p~*,~~$~1ID*¥::f£ ' P):&'8&\~JJ~)ff~~£~Z~{5}~mm,~ i5il ~Mm 4E13~~~.~.ff~.if~{I{@: , t&'i'®P).if~~{**'5f~*~?2-gm ~~t;1E~ , ~1'~m~%Z~1ID~:f£ ' p):&ff~'8m1'T:lJ~~ , ~~t~pgfr~Fs9~ .~~$lDllt ; 11Sl®~t~~.® § , £*r;~H*~t§lli'I'1@1~~~~t;1EWpg1±~ rdlg.~~?2.£~ , ®~~¥mWfgfr~ra9g.~t§lli'I1@1IIJl~2js:~£~ , ~?2 .T:lJ~tt~.~.~fr~~.m~~~M~.frM • • m.~~~M*m ~ ~~~ro9~ , ~*f9.WM~.~~• •ff~U~i5i!~~mf=J ; NP~fltfr~~?2-5E =~~tj~J'f.*~iliff~mi5i!~II:i~~j. ' {El£~{tg{r~m~~~?2.T:lJfj~'I:i{~{tj=z M~~~1'~'~.¥7M • • •~~.-~1ID~.~~mW~$tl~~, 0. 0. ~- ~1ID~fjgm~tfu~flf§ltlli! ~'I:iB~fj.. £llix¥-J. 0. 130. (V Kraft) ~'5lm7WLlli (E. Kaila) fj~~.B~f!t~. : AJ~§;fij. ~£*.~~.~~~~~.~OO~m*~7'~:&'8~~fjllt~~z~~. ~Mm;®xm~*f;tffilli~@1Sm£*~~~W'~~.ffi~.~.*~ ~JmJ~§flt.,~1m~~{J;(~~r;*l{*. '. 1j~~~$rlJ. ' m@ffdX~[,§]f~8~;fltzjs::7L. *z*liiz~J¥1tW.J¥{t ~~Ii~. 0. 131. ' frllt~ATflt1r~7k~1{}1'¥Um~@A.~~*~,~ ttmtl~~ili~?2m.if.~§lfBpJTJmJ~~~. ' 1'§lfBAPJT~('B£. ~fi~'~frm.~~i5i!~fiB*~~~ o ®~~.~.~.~£2js:~('B~. = : 1. PJT~~£*7C*8~-~~pJT1{}~*6* ' 2. '8m~ - ~• • wlf(~. ~Jt~~~m. '. llt~.~*~1'*ij!~®ffdX'i'{'F~~~*,i5.®8. fr.ff~~m'I:iI2SJ-T~.ifJ~.~nt~*~~*f9.~~f¥U~*. 129. l32~fltfr~llti. ~U13t1H~£*. t-;i/ji.£:StJr 1995: 26-271tM:.n~1~1J!]i!-*M.ff 0. *. - . . ~A. ...1- »'d- #! -t 1f 4!Ji 1J;{ ~ tJj £ Mlt'tor ~ 1HlII~JJt-=-:4fIJ!]~ ~ht. 130. 0. , 131. 132. '. 0. Kraft 1953 : 102-103,1050. Shen 1995 : 2, 9. 0. ~ z.;!t ~ ~ .~t ~~ -t t~ t~Wt:t ,tHt ~ IJ!] n~ 'tl. '. Jl:U~ B'J.

(29) I,.

(30) . ~ ~~ ~. .... ~. i& ~ ~. i&. -l<. ~~. ~ .I:{ \ill. ...... N. \D. C-. ~ o. ~ ~. tH. ;1(0:1. 11110. m. :g'. I. ~~ ~ ~ ~~. mit!. ~ ~~I~. IE. ~. .t$. ~. ~. inm. .. ~. ~. •. •. ~. ~. -P\ lin ~ ~ ~. 1"><. 14. 0. 00. 0 N. N. N. ;::::. t:. bO. ::::. of!. M. =' 0 ".

(31) ~~&~~ • • ~~l.*~+~*~ ( ~~~. ••• ~ ). ~. it:1f:Rft·· R. Camap: The Did and the New Logic (1930/31). In: Logical Positivism . ed. By A. J. Ayer. Illinois: The Free Press 1959, 133-146. R. Camap: Der logische Aufbau der Welt. Hamburg: Meiner 1998 (1928).. 1. A. Coffa: The Semantic Tradition from Kant to Carnap. To the Vienna Station. ed. by L. Wessels. New YorkIPort Chester/Melbourne/Sydney: Cambridge University Press 1991. L. Embree/ L. Hardy (ed.): Phenomenology of Natural DordrechtiBoston/London: Kluwer Academic Publishers 1992.. Science .. A. Gurwitsch: Phenomenology and the Theory of Science . ed. by L. Embreem. Evanston: Northwestern University Press 1974. G. Gutting: Husser! and Logical Empiricism. In: Metaphilosophy, Vol. 2, No.3 , July 1971 , 197-226. G. Gutting: Husserl and Scientific Realism. In: Philosophy and Phenomenological. Research 39 (1978-79), 42-56.. 1. Habermas: Erkenntnis und Interesse . Frankfurt a. M.: Suhrkamp 1973 . E. Husser!: Ideen zu einer reinen Phanomenologie und phanomenologischen. Philosophie .. Erstes. Buch:. Allgemeine. Einfuhrung. in. die. reine. Phanomenologie . Hua lIllI. Hg.: K. Schuhmann. Den Haag: Nijhoff 1976. (Ideen 1) E. Husser! : Ideen zu einer reinen Phanomenologie und phanomenologischen. Philosophie . Zweites. Buch:. Phanomenologische. Untersuchungen. zur. Konstitution . Hua Bd. IV. Hg.: M. Biemel. Den Haag: Nijhoff 1953. (Ideen II). E. Husser!: Ideen zu einer reinen Phanomenologie und phanomenologischen. Philosophie. Drittes Buch: Die Phanomenologie und die Fundamente der Wissenschaften. Hua Bd. V. Hg. : M. Biemel. Den Haag: Nijhoff 1953. (Ideen III).

(32) M. (~~a~A. ••••• ).~AA. E. Husser!: Zur Phdnomenologie des ZeitbewujJtseins (1893-1917). Hua Bd. X Hrsg.: R. Boehm. Den Haag: Nijhoff 1966. (ZB) E. Husserl: Formale und transzendentale Logik. Versuch einer Kritik der Logik Hua Bd. XVII. Hg.: P. Janssen. Den Haag: Nijhoff 1974. (FTL) E. Hussed: Logische Untersuchungen l: Prolegomena zur reinen Logik. Ttibingen Niemeyer 19806 • (LU I) E. Husserl: Logische Untersuchungen Ill1: Untersuchungen zur Phdnomenolo giE und Theorie der Erkenntnis. Ttibingen: Niemeyer 19806 . (LU III 1). E. Husserl: Logische Untersuchungen 1112: Elemente einer phdnomenologischen Aujkldrung der Erkenntnis. Ttibingen: Niemeyer 19805 • (LU II12). E. Husserl: Philosophie als strenge Wissenschaft. Hg.: W. Szilasi. Frankfurt a. M.: Klostermann 1965. (SW) V. Kraft: The Vienna Circle. The Origin of the Neo-Positivism. A chapter in the. history ofrecent philosophy. Westport: Greenwood Press 1953.. E. Ltibbe: BewujJtsein in Geschichte -. Studien zur Phdnomenologie. der. Subjektivitdt (Mach, Husserl, Schapp, Wittgenstein). Freiburg: Rombach. 1972.. G. Misch: Der Aujbau der Logik auf dem Boden der Philosophie des Lebens . FreiburglMtinchen: Alber 1994.. Th. Mormann: Hussed's Philosophy of Science and the Semantic Approach. In : Philosophy ofScience, 58 (1991), 61-83.. C. . Moustakas:. Phenomenological. Research. Methods.. Thousand. Oaks/LondonlNew Delhi: International Education and Professional Publisher 1994.. B. Philippi: Protokollsatze versus Konstatieung. Ein Kemproblem des Wiener Kreises. In: M. Schlick: 1986, I-XLI.. Philosophische Logik. Frankfurt a. M.: Suhrkamr.

(33) .j:t t,il£ !lP:.. i!.tJi-{f.J l}l.. *-* *-;t -t#l-t~ (i!t~{f.J i!.tJi-*4lt). 65. H. P. Reeder: Husserl's Phenomenology and COQ.temporary Science. In: Husserl in. Contemporary Context - Prospects and Projects for Phenomenology. Ed. By B. C. Hopkins, DordrechtiBostonILondon: Kluwer Academic Publishers 1997,211-234. B. Russell: Logical Atomism (1924). In: Logical Positivism. ed. by A. J. Ayer. Illinois: The Free Press 1959,31-50. M. Schlick: Das Wesen der Wahrheit nach der modernen Logik (1910/11). In:. Philosophische Logik. Frankfurt a. M.: Suhrkamp 1986,31-109. M. Schlick: Form und Inhalt. Einfuhrung in philosophisches Denken. (1938). In:. Philosophische Logik. Frankfurt a. M.: Suhrkamp 1986, 110-222. Th. M. Seebohm: The Other in the Field of Consciousness. In: Essays in Menory. of Aron Gurwitsch. Ed. By L. Embree, Washington, D.C.: The Center for Advanced Research in Phenomenology, 1984,283-303. V. Shen: Philosophical Reflections on Carnap's Program of Construction and. Constructive Realism. In:. fo3 ' W 1-20. {~:lI.iI&m*~=§""~~¥ln. m=M ' 1995 if 11. 0. R. Sokolowski: The Formation of Husserl 's Concept of Constitution. The Hague:. Nijhoff 1970. M. Sommer: G6ttinger Lebenswelt. Einleitung in E. Husserl: Die Konstitution der. geistigen Welt. Hamburg: Meiner 1984, IX-XLII. J. M. Tito: Logic in Husserlian Context. Evanston: Northwestern University Press 1990. W. Windelband: Lehrbuch der Geschichte der Philosophie. Tiibingen: Mohr 1980 17 •. $-£ (B.. Magee):<il~ ... *±.~a!ti!A.- ~1.lf~fij(A.J. Ayer)1Hi), l/t. ~ <~t~31~a9rril.:Ui*) ($--£.UQ)':t'~: ilfj~' 1993lj=-11 ~ ,~ 1-36 i.I.x.~. : (t~£~~~tt~), 1!itfLlBY&~~ , 1995lj=. 0. 0.

(34) -,. /'-.. ~ ~. ~~. *.. t:j' #l\m( L.

(35)