௦ίٿޠ࢈๋ᙾึȂӤኻྜՍܼ࢈ឪᎉࡤަཽΩ໕ᑺକޠུ
؛ᘉȄ2000 Ԓޠ࢈ឪᎉȂҖໍឪпхߓЇᄈ༗Ωޠ࠽ᄙஉ࢈Ȃቩޠ࢈
ݾೱӉࠔ८ᖞЎ࢈ۻޠᏵ࢈֩ძȂঐਣޠҖໍឪ࢈ۻ࣐ΠϾҖ ཏȂηᡲަᆌ๊Җւઊყᡞ᐀ԥၷτޠឋโښ᠍ȂԚ࣐ѫΚঐུя౫ ޠښ࡚؛ᘉȄഷӫޠ߰ 2002 Ԓ 5 УޠӓަཽᆌւཽឋȂӼঐަ
ᆌყᡞಣԚޠȶҖަཽᆌւ௱ϊಣȷȂၑშᏘᆺӔᜌȂՅӶԫࡤޠ Ԓߝ࢈๋ႇโϜᅌ२्ޠ؛ِՔȄஆܼ።ަཽӔᔽޠ౪܉ȂȶҖ
ަཽᆌւ௱ϊಣȷлަཽߴᓏ࣐ଓྜ௪ޠРԓȂՅসЇᄈ
࿌ਣ࢈ଲ឵ཏޠᓾߴښȞڨ 004Ȃ005Ȃ009ȟȄЏڐቔ߱ܣӉᖃಜ ۻ๋ୱםԚޠᗗ፤ᔇΩȂय़ٻചЬࡶ࿌८ܜᒜࡹྲަᆌყᡞޠຨؒȂ
්ӪަߴښდҖԒߝȄঐᔜቒܓޠ࢈๋ᙾȂٻூ࢈ଲϛூϛ२
ུાΤަཽߴᓏޠᒶȂდᒳȶϊҖԒߝߴᓏȷోᇑґђڐуԒ ߝߴᓏޠҖȄկȂԄӤݔ݃Ȟ2001Ȉ157ȟࡿяȂѯᢋަཽၽყ ᡞુЎኅހޠᡞಣᙒஆᙄȂၷᜳӶΚঐᅟߞޠ࢈๋ႇโϜࡼ៊ึҢ ኈΩȄ܂܂Ӷ੬ۢឋᚡᏳЖίȂϛӤყᡞϟ๋ܓޠ๗࿘ܗᖓӬঐ րҴېӶឋཽϜึᖑȂᘉӶԒߝ࢈๋ႇโϜٸᙠԄԫȄစႇ 2002 Ԓޠ ӓަᆌཽឋࡤȂΚഌϸަᆌყᡞᡞᇰژಣᙒᖓӬЖᏳឋᚡޠ्҇Ȃܼ
2003 ԒϜӬಣȶހ๚ᖓ࿘ȷȂוగ࡛ҴକϵҖަཽޠΩ໕Ȃᇅަཽစᔽ ޠឋᚡȄӶԒߝ࢈๋Р८Ȃހ๚ᖓ࿘ණяᚗቺԒߝᡞقޠлȂוగѯ ᢋԒߝᡞقᐍӬ࣐ஆᙄԒߝᇅߤђԒߝȂኻޠಣᙒসηӕԪםԚ࢈๋
ښۢޠᔇΩȞހ๚ᖓ࿘Ȃ2003ȟȄ
ԫਣϲ࢈ഌٸᐄ࢈ଲစᔽ࡛೪ېসཽܛණȶҖԒߝښ࡚დȷ
ൣ֚І؛ۢ௵ަཽߴᓏښۢȄ13ښ࡚࢝ᄻᆱࡼࠊΚࢳȶཿଡ଼ϸҴȷ ϊᐍӬРȂϲ࢈ഌٯܼ 2003 Ԓ 6 УԚҖԒߝߴᓏݳ૪ଛՎҴݳ ଲቸឋȂӶ࢈ۻԥҖԒߝښ࡚დϟஆᙄαȂ၏๗፤ᆡઢાΤ
ҖԒߝݳ૪Ȅᗷด࢈ଲႇҖԒߝݳ૪ȂկҴݳଲһрΡឪ ყڟ୧ȂԫਣଷΠঐޏҐѵȂӤਣηя౫ҖឪޏІؖ൳ېসޠڎঐ ޏҐȂЖକഽϏᇅަᆌყᡞޠᜱݨȞቔҞ៍ȃചҔҖȂ2005Ȉ86-90ȟȄ14
13 ࿌ਣᇰ࣐ҖԒߝښ࡚пަཽߴᓏዂԓ࣐ۤȂٯᔗщϸՄ໕࢈ۻᔗߴሬҖஆ ҐҢࣁϟᙜೱȃзхϵ҂ܓȃॴᓏϸᐋȃᐍᡞަཽଓ࢈ܜᐋΩȃஆҐҢࣁߴ ሬЬྦȃπՃϾϟፑᔟ๊ӱષȂпښ࡚ϟҘ៊ึ࣐ࠍȄ
14 ϲ࢈ഌߞն࢈Ᏽхߓϲ࢈ഌᇴ݃ҖԒߝȂስޠԒߝߝ 7900 ϰȇҖឪ ყ።уউܛᛵޠߴຳၷЎȂٯйђጇႇࡤٻԒߝስژ 8900 ϰȇؖ൳ࠍ
።ϛཽ༇φޠঐவЙښȂпစᔽᏱޠᢏᘉ።Սϐ॓ೱՃϾޠୱᚡȂп
࿌ਣӶҴଲཽ๗ޠਣᔇΩίȂҴېᄈܼҖԒߝޠښ࡚ᒶᐆณ ݳҴ֊ႁԚӔᜌȂҴݳϏձӕ࡚ଞӲ࢈ഌߟȄήᆎޏҐޠя౫ᇅ ҴݳႇโޠፑȂᡘұЎ࢈ۻޠ࢈ഌߟᇅЇᄈឪජඬޠҴݳഌߟҦ
ܼࣻϤඡهՅᏳयޠ࢈๋ᒷᅘ౫ຬȂӶөՍࡼϛӤޠݳҴൠם ίȂݳ८ᖞᔥဋȂ२ѫѵΚঐࢳ࢈ۻᇅަཽყᡞᇅޠԒߝ࢈๋
ႇโȄ
2005 ԒߒӶ࢈ଲߞᗃߞיࡿұίȂҦᏱяٙޠരҴဩ࢈ଡ଼ېস॓
ೱდҖԒߝښ࡚ȂԄԫᄈܼԒߝ࢈๋ښۢႇโҢᡑϾȂםԚΚঐԥ րܼп܂пစཽ࡛࣐л्ڟ።ᐡᄻޠ؛๋ዂԓȄҦܼര࢈ېᇅަཽყᡞޠ ߞӬձᜱ߾ȂпڐяӉ࢈ଡ଼ېস॓ೱდȂΚР८хߓᏱޠِՔ࣐
ӭ२ȂѫΚР८η࣐ަᆌყᡞః࣐ޣ௦ᇅኈԒߝ࢈๋ޠึᖑᐡ
ཽȄ࿌ਣޠަᆌყᡞϟᗷดϬดԇԥݣُȂկлໆϑစۢ՞ܼпใԞ ښ࣐лޠஆቺԒߝȃህϟпښ࡚τᐍӬޠಒΡቺߤђԒߝዂԓȞпഽߴᘘ τાߴРԓȟȂٯй࣐࢈ឪᝰࣻђጇޠིՃࢼຯॐίဤСȞеᄹይȃ
༂ు߈ȃାੵዯȂ2007ȟȄര࢈ېᇅަᆌყᡞ৵ፚᕤ၍ٯᕖூཏُࡤȂӕ ᗝࣻᜱ࢈ഌߟໍྜྷڟ።࢈๋ޠѠܓȄଲཽႇпަཽߴᓏښ࣐
лໆȂٸȶҖԒߝϏձȷდРӪ೪ॏԒߝݳȂҦަᆌყᡞȃ්ഐ ڎឪІ࢈ഌߟӔӤः୧םԚڏԥӔᜌޠޏҐȄӶ௦ίٿޠഌཽڟ୧ႇโ ϜȂര࢈ېࠔٸด᎐ႅࣻᜱഌߟޠ፵ᅹȂЏڐᘘτഽߴޠឋᚡΚޣณݳ ᕖூഽېཽޠॷȞڨ 003Ȃ007ȟȄӕђα 2004 ԒϑႇഽϏଞӅུ
ښпІөԓޠིՃࢼຯȂϑစ४ᕼ௦ίٿޠ࢈๋ᒶȂѬ഼ίഽߴپᇅ
ռኈঢ়ଓ࢈ȄήᆎϛӤޠޏҐٯചܼҴݳଲϜȂӏᜋϜޠѢࣃژѿࣃ
ࣲӶ࢈ഌߟϜණȂᡘ౫࢈ഌߟޠ౪܉ીݣȄҴݳଲಒϥཽ۪ϜȂ්ഐ
࢈ឪޠڟ୧ཏُϬดґႁԚӔᜌȂήޏޠ࢝ᄻϛΚȂณݳഃڂଇ፤Ȃέӕ
࡚ଞӲ࢈ഌߟȄ
ҖԒߝሡ௦ޠୱᚡȂءԥޫᐍӬܓԒߝښ࡚ޠᄃࢋȞڨ 013ȇ ѫѵЩၷভНኌȃဩਫྕȂ2006ȟȄӶစႇଇ፤ࡤȂര࢈ې࡛ឋпަཽߴ ᓏ࣐࢝ᄻȂՃԒрࠍᆓຝϛӤݸпڎᆎϵԓॏᆘȈߴԒၦ X Уߴ ߝ X1.2%Ȃܗ 3000 ϰɮߴԒၦ X Уߴߝ X0.6%Ȃӕᐆᓻ፝ስ Ȟڨ 012ȇϜ๊݃Ȃ2007Ȉ21-24ȟȄկҦܼҖყᡞϬดԥϛ ӤཏُȂђαង॒݀ϲረظ௦ᗃߞיϲረαӉȂུӉረටࡿұኸਣᔥဋ ԫ࢈๋РȄ
ԫࡤϛεȂݔቈఁ௳௦ӉരҴဩޠ࢈ېᙜ՞Ȃ२ུۗᇅަᆌყᡞ ڟ୧ҖԒߝޠ࢈๋Ȅӕђαሬᖓ࿘яٙᐋӉҖໍឪಒϳ۪Ҵېޠеᄹ ይȂпІစӶυഀጤٲஐၽޠ༂ుऽҴېȂηӶҴݳଲڴᔗݔ࢈ې ޠ࢈๋ښۢևΩȄپԄеېসӶҴݳଲණঔҔȶഽϏߴᓏپȷᇅණ яȶҖԒߝ૪ȷȂᗷดٯءԥூژ්ഐҴېޠМࡼȂҭޠࠔӶᏳЖᗗ
፤ݨཏژᘘτഽߴᇅߴᜍԒߝޠឋᚡȞڨ 005ȟȄᏒᆔݔ࢈ېӶӉϲഃ
ᅛᇅަᆌყᡞםԚӔᜌȂӶڟ።ࣻᜱഌཽޠྜྷႇโϜࠔΚኻ᎐ႅഽېཽ
ޠܣȂณݳڐЇᄈᘘτഽߴાߴጓ൝ޠᄙ࡚ȄЏڐഽېཽᇰ࣐ᐍ Ӭཽኈژഽߴޠଓଡ଼ୱᚡȂҼԥѠഀழܵ࠴ҖԒߝޠଓଡ଼Ȃӕђ пՄ໕Ԓၦȃߴᖡၦ๊ᐍӬαޠ֩ᜳȂӱԫࡼϸҴޠҴൠȞڨ
003Ȃ007ȟȄ࿌ਣޠԥᜌഎఽྀҖԒߝᘫ឵ܼഽېཽܗሠఅഌ࣐л ᆔᐡᜱٯϛ࿌Ȃկߴᇅഽߴᐍڂᘫ឵ϲ࢈ഌȂέႅژഽېཽޠЇᄈ ᇅࡼȂഽߴᇅၼߴᜳпପӬᐍӬԓޠԒߝᡞښȞڨ 001Ȃ002Ȃ003Ȃ 007Ȃ008Ȃ011ȟȄԫηᡘұяп࢈ଡ଼ېসлᏳޠ࢈๋ڟ୧ዂԓ४ȈҦ
ܼ࢈ଲߞ༊Ӫᖃಜ॓ೱޠᄎߞȂӶҖໍឪஉ࢈ޠΥԒϟϜέඳႇ
ϳԪ࢈ॷߞȂђα්ഐᜱ߾ޠᆨȂᜳпϡ࢈ଡ଼ېসۢޠМࡼ༺
නȄӱԫҖԒߝ࢈๋ณݳΩՅԥਞޠҦαՎί௱ȂηณΩ҉ખ࢈
ഌߟϟӶڟ።ਣᡘ౫ޠҐ՞лဏȄ
ӶҖԒߝޠپφϜȂҖໍឪЎ࢈ۻޠ࢈՞᠍ΩೞಁӼښ࡚
؛ᘉ४ᕼȂߣᛥҖԒߝᇅഽߴᐍӬޠѠܓȂίϸҴԓަཽߴᓏ ᡞښޠӆ์ȄึՎԫȂݔ࢈ېηѬଞՅؒڐԪȂᙾՅ೪ॏᇅരҴဩ ޏҐծޠ࢈๋РȂη൸ϊޠҖԒߝߴᓏȂѬోᇑၼҖІڐу
ۧґೞॗϵఁܗഽߴߴሬޠထȄଷΠܛூх౦ϊԥᡑѵȂл्४ ښስႇڐуަཽߴᓏՃԒрȂϛூӕђΤҖԒߝߴᓏȂٯйԥ
ӈޠ೪ۢөིՃࢼຯޠဤСȄᓎ 2006 Ԓ 7 УޠȶѯᢋစᔽҘ៊ึ
ཽឋȷҖԒߝӗ࣐ަཽԋӓಣᚡᆫϟΚȂӶ๗፤Ϝ࣐ٻҖԒߝ ႁژΫΡӔӤཏُޠҭޠȂϲ࢈ഌᔤॐȶ௱ҖԒߝښ࡚ॏฬȷા
࣐ȶ2015 ԒစᔽึෂϟτྤཹަཽᆌւಒΚࢳήԒፑڗॏฬȷ ϟΫΡஉॏდϟΚȂѣཽឋȃϵཽኅાөࣩཏُȄ2007 Ԓ࢈
ଲή࡚ႇଲཽଇ፤ȂٯӶӤԒ 7 УܼҴݳଲήႇȂ2008 Ԓ 10 У
ۗࢋȄ
ҖԒߝݳႇࡤޠލឋၼҖાΤߴሬπϟӗȂᘉࠔЖକ ၼҖყᡞޠឋȇӱ࣐ӒޠၼҖߴᓏϜȂ࢈ۻ॓ᐋ 90%ߴຳȂٯйᗚє
֥ڐуҖԒߝܛءԥޠрȂӤਣѠпؑУڿۢስڦՃၼࢼຯ 6000 ϰȄ ᄈܼၼҖՅّȂђΤҖԒߝᡞق๊ܼΚᆎᡑࣻޠᆌւࠉȂӱՅԥၼ ҖᇅҖԒߝႚޠ्ؒя౫Ȅᓎ 2008 ԒᖃಜτᒶޠٿᖞȂၼҖڸ
ҖԒߝႚޠ्ؒץӶҖឪ२ུஉ࢈ϟࡤᕖூ२ຝȂᓎ֊Ӷஉ࢈ឪխ ΠήϸϟΡৱԪޠҴݳଲႇҖԒߝޠঔҔݳȄՎԫጃۢҖԒߝޠ
ᒳ௷ଷၼҖȂࡤٸดስڦпၼҖߴᓏ࣐лޠՃၼࢼຯȄԄԫΚٿȂ
ҖԒߝԚ࣐ӫಓڐᄃޠ৶༗ԒߝߴᓏȂѷџަཽߴᓏϜҐٿᔗ၏ϲ֥
ޠτݳࠍॴᓏϸᐋཏဏȂᘉѐᡘԒߝ࢈๋ښۢႇโϜ८ᄈޠ؛
ᘉӼϰ੬ܓȂၷܿᏳयښ࡚ᡑ᎑ޠϛᛨۢȄ
ѳȃϊ๗
ഇႇα८ޠϸݚȂשউᇰ࣐Ӷ 2000 Ԓ࢈ឪᎉϟࡤȂѯᢋ࢈ݾښ࡚
Ϝޠ؛ᘉ੬ܓ߰ᡘяٿȄӶ 1988 ԒՎ 1995 Ԓ८ᖞҖлऐખޠᙾࢆ
Ȃ࢈ឪᝰލ௱ҖԒߝޠึѠܓȂկ༊ѬܼโזαޠҖлȂ
༊Ӷ࢈ଲഌཽᇅҴݳଲޠණϟၾٗȄ1996 ԒՎ 1999 ԒࠍቩђӼ ණޠѠܓȂ࢈ۻഌߟηϛᘟޠःឋȃდȂԫਣஉ࢈ᗷߩା࡚ޠ᠍
ΩϜȂկҦܼஉ࢈ឪӶҴݳଲϜڏႇљӼȂӱԫϬၷ་Ӫ᠍ΩϜޠ ዂԓȄӶঐݸίȂҖឪᗷดڏԥା࡚ޠಜܓȂڐᄈަཽ࢈๋ޠᏆ ΩηѠӶ 1995 ԒӓҖୋߴޠᄃࢋϜᑜُȂկڐᄈܼҖԒߝ࢈๋ޠ؛ᘟ ΩࠔϛԄӓҖୋߴȂђпӓҖୋߴޠࢋڸΟΡΚτӵᎫޠѵӱȂҖԒ ߝޠᄃࢋೞᔥဋȞڨ 001Ȃ005Ȃ012ȟȄשউདྷࡿя᠍ΩϜޠښ࡚་
ӪܼೱӉϜȂ᠍ΩޠϜᗷดቩ࢈ۻႁژ࢈๋ҭዀޠΩȂկηђτ
࢈ۻޠॴᓏȂуউ࣐҇Ѡϛڨߕޠ࢈๋ᄈϵಁ॓ೱȂٯйܤयӶᒶ ᖟϜڨژᛄᆵޠ๗ݏȞPierson, 1994: 33; Weaver & Rockman, 1993: 15ȟȄܿ
ّϟȂΚঐ࢈ۻԄݏӶΚঐ᠍ΩϜޠښ࡚ᕘძϜၽձȂᐈᖄ࢈๋ޠΩ ѠཽȂկѻηђՄኍڐ࣐ӶᒶᖟਣആԚޠࡤݏȂӶ؛ᘉၷЎ й᠍ΩϜޠӤਣȂηђೱӉޠϜȄӱԫӶ᠍ΩᇅೱӉޠᒌϟϜȂ ٻᖃᡞޠҖԒߝ࢈๋๗ݏڏԥϛጃۢܓȄ
ࣻၷϟίȂ2000 ԒՎ 2008 ԒޠѯᢋȂߩկᐤစҖлϾᙾȂӶஉ
࢈ឪᎉȃЎ࢈ۻޠݸίȂ֖౫᠍Ωା࡚ϸයޠݸȄ᠍Ωϸයښ࡚
Ϝၽձޠ࢈ۻȂ҇ᇅѵഌւઊყᡞፚցڟ୧९௪ࢋȂٯйяᡲؐȂ ڐ๗ݏႁϛژуউ࢈๋९ޠߒȂӱ࣐ښ࡚ܓޠ᠍ΩϸයቩМࡼᆌ ւښ࡚ᖓ࿘ޠΩ໕ȞBonoli, 2000: 43-51, 2001: 239ȟȄӶ 2000 ԒՎ 2008 Ԓ ϟȂҦܼЎ࢈ۻޠஉ࢈֩ძȂםԚ᠍Ωା࡚ϸයޠ८ȂೱӉޠᘫ឵
ηା࡚ϛ݃ጃȄ࿌ښ࡚ණٽ؛ᘉਣȂ൸ཽᄈ࢈ۻښ؛๋ႇโڸጃߴ
ႇ੬ۢ࢈๋๗ݏޠΩᄻԚ४ښȂٳ੬ኊᄈ࢈ۻΩԥኈȞڨ
003Ȃ004Ȃ012ȟȄښ࡚ޠِ࡚ࣽȂӶڏԥ᠍Ωϸය੬ᘉޠ࢈ݾښ࡚ϜȂ Ў࢈ۻੀϜޠښ࡚؛ᘉቩђȂ᠍Ωႇ࡚ϸයȂٻ࢈๋ዂڨ४Ȃ
࢈๋ॐۢਣηཽ۾ᰏȄ
ดՅȂӶ᠍Ωϸයޠښ࡚Ϝၽձޠ࢈ۻȂႇ௵ڦાΤѵഌყᡞ
ޠ؛๋๋Ȃණା࢈ഌߟޠឋቌΩȄӱ࣐ҖлϾࡤޠѯᢋ࢈ݾ ښ࡚ϜȂϱ೩ѵഌყᡞ഻ആᐡཽпኈ࢈๋ޠҴݳȂܛп࢈ۻηΚޣӍშ ױٳყᡞ֝Ԟໍ؛๋ႇโϜȂᙥԫᘘτ܅ԫޠኈΩȄӶҖԒߝߴᓏ ޠښۢႇโϜȂࡶ࢈ۻ߰ႇӓަཽᆌւཽឋІစᔽҘ៊ึཽឋȂ
ѵഌყᡞђпાΤښ࡚ϟϜȂпණ݈ᐍᡞޠ࢈ۻၽձΩȄӶঐݸ ίȂւઊყᡞѠпٻңᇅ࢈๋ښۢႇโϜޠᐡཽȂႁژߣЦ੬ۢ࢈๋Р ӪޠਞݏȄӶኻޠݸίȂ࢈ۻৡܿ௦ڨፚցȃя࢈๋؛ឋޠᡲؐȂ ٯϡᜱᗥΚۢޠ၅ᓼȞBonoli, 2001: 238ȟȄѯᢋӶҖлऐખਣ
ȂӤኻഇႇւઊყᡞϘٻூҖԒߝޠឋᚡԚ࣐Ҵݳଲଇ፤ޠឋโȄҔ ӱ࣐؛ᘉޠቩђȂߵٻ࢈ۻདژᔇΩȂᄈܼҖԒߝޠ࢈๋ښۢ༗҇
яӲᔗᇅᄈ๋Ȅ
ᙐّϟȂשউޠϸݚࡿяӶҖлϾϾޠႇโϜȂ࢈ݾښ࡚ޠᡑ Ͼ࣐ҖԒߝޠ࢈๋௱ђ፞ΠӼ२ޠ؛ᘉȂᏳयϸҴԓޠԒߝߴᓏښ
࡚ȄӶϸݚϜשউึ౫ҖлϾޠႇโϜȂ࢈๋ឋโޠښԟޠ
ۣлᏳഃؐᙾඳՎӼϰަཽᇅޠዂԓȄ൸ԫՅّȂҖлϾࡤޠ؛ᘉ ӼϰϾȂ࢈ഌߟᇅۣٸดᅌΫϸᜱᗥޠِՔȂկѻউϛӕ
୳Κޠ२्؛ᘉȄЏڐӶ࢈ឪᎉϟࡤȂΚР८ڨښܼЎ࢈ۻᇅ්ഐ ᆨޠੀȂѫΚР८ηఃަᆌყᡞᇅ؛๋ޠᐡཽȄঐښ࡚؛ᘉ םᄙޠᡑϾਞݏȂӶ 2002 ԒޠӓަᆌཽឋࠊࡤึදூిᅎᅿयȂԚѓ
ଜᙾ࢈ഌߟཏమ௱ޠᓾᇌঐவЙښȄดՅ࢈ឪᝰލཏѵЖึޠིՃ ࢼຯښ࡚ᡓᒯȂђαԥަཽߴᓏлᆔᐡᜱޠւઊࡼȂпІഽଞུښޠ ᄃࢋȂτൾ४ަᆌყᡞᇅܛЖึޠښ࡚ᘘਞᔗȂҖԒߝߴᓏܼ
ٗӪᑀޠϊߴᓏዂԓȄ
Ӄȃ๗፤
؛ᘉޠ࢈ݾښ࡚፤п࢈ݾښ࡚ޠᢏᘉȂᇴ݃࢈ݾႇโϜޠښ࡚ᐡ ښԄեኈ࢈๋Ȃᙥԫᕤ၍ᄙޠϵӔ࢈๋؛๋ႇโȄҦԫѠп၍ម࢈๋
ᄙᡑ᎑ڸၦྜڟ୧ޠႇโȂȶښ࡚ȷණٽ࢈๋ښۢޠၾᔜࠍȂ࢈ݾښ
࡚ڸᒶᖟᔇΩٻ࢈๋ם༮ڨژኈȂӱԫ࢈๋؛๋ޠл्ΩႇโϜޠ ȶ࢈ݾȷӱષȞImmergut & Anderson, 2007: 7ȟȄѯᢋࡅ᠍ᡞښٗӪҖл ϾȂҦ᠍ΩϜٗӪା࡚ϸයޠႇโȂשউѠпُࣽϛӤޠ؛ᘉҭ ᓎϟቩђȄႇЎޠ؛ᘉȂٻ᠍Ωା࡚ϜȂٯйٸྲЎܗΚ
ޠ౪܉ໍ࢈๋؛ឋȇՅႇӼޠ؛ᘉȂࠍٻ᠍Ωା࡚ϸයȂٯйٸྲ
ϛӤᒶҖԂ࣐࢈๋؛๋ޠРӪȄ
ҖԒߝښ࡚ޠښۢႇโ϶ߞຳਣȃ࢈๋РӪϛΚयȂϛӤޏҐޠ૪
ਜ਼αᘩ८ȂഷࡤႇϊᐍӬԓޠϸҴҖԒߝߴᓏȂᡞ౫яҖлϾႇโ Ϝ࢈๋؛ឋϸයӼϰϾޠ੬ܓȄשউ௵ң ImmergutȞ1992ȟпІ Bonoli Ȟ2000, 2001ȟޠᢏᘉȂ።࢈ݾښ࡚Ϝޠ᠍ΩϤࠍኈ؛๋ൠޠ ၽձȂ᠍Ωϛᄈ๊ޠ࢈๋؛ឋႇโѠҦښ࡚Ϝޠ؛ᘉٿ௱ᙛᇅښᒌȄѯ ᢋޠԒߝ९ႇโϜȂᇅӼϰϾȂٯйӶ؛๋ൠϜِഃ࢈ݾᐡ
ཽȇӤਣӕђαښ࡚؛ᘉޠቩӼȂٻூԒߝښ࡚࡛ҴႇโΫϸ᛫Ȅש উᇰ࣐ҖлϾޠΩ໕Ȃ༮ആ࢈ݾښ࡚Ϝޠ؛ᘉȂߵٻҖԒߝ࢈්๋Ӫ
ᇅࡅ᠍ਣᄡดϛӤޠښ࡚ᡓᒯึȄӶҖлऐખਣȂӶഐឪޠึᖑණ ٽԥΩޠΩȂߵٻ࢈ۻഌߟ࡛ҴःឋܗϊಣȂ௱ҖԒߝޠ
დȄژΠҖлᎰڿਣȂҖԒߝდϜഃؐ௱я࢈๋ቸឋᇅःفൣ֚๗ ݏȂկ࿌ਣ࢈ۻٯґױඬਣᐡႇ࢈๋Ȃٻூڐࡤޠ؛๋ႇโםፓᚖ ϾȄҖлϾਣਣȂҖໍឪ࢈ۻ२ུდҖԒߝޠᄻདྷȂήᆎᄡดϛ ӤޠޏҐਜ਼αҴݳଲ؛ឋޠᘩ८ȄկӶЎ࢈ۻښ࡚ښङίȂ૪ၾٗ
ܼ࢈ȃҴݳഌߟϟȂђαөᆎࢼຯޠࢋȂпІަᆌყᡞޠึᖑȂആ
൸Ӽ२؛ᘉޠൠ८Ȅঐښ࡚ښङҖԒߝ࢈๋ޠึȂࣦՎΚ࡚
םԚ࢈ݾޫᙾޠҖл֩ძȈ࢈ឪᝰލᏳयޠࢼຯᘘװԣԥޠԒߝ࢈๋
დȂђαښ࡚؛ᘉޠቩђȂٻ࢈ۻޠឋ؛Ωڨ४ȂആԚԒߝ९ޠ ᖠ֩ึȄ
ҖԒߝ࢈๋ښۢႇโޠϸݚѠпࣽяȂ᠍ΩϜЩၷৡܿጃߴ࢈
๋ޠѠႲܓȂԫਣޠᜱᗥӱષ؛ܼۢஉ࢈ޠ߭܉Ȅᓎ᠍Ωޠϸය ϾȂښ࡚؛ᘉޠቩђЁା࢈๋ښۢႇโޠϛጃۢܓȂၷৡܿя౫ϛӤޠ ၰ৸Ȅ൸שউϸݚѯᢋԒߝښ࡚࡛ᄻޠစᡜᡘұȂѯᢋޠҖлϾᄈܼަཽ
࢈๋ޠኈڏᚗ८ܓȈΚР८ȂၗԄ೩Ӽݎٴަཽ࢈๋ޠःفࡿяȂҖл Ͼޠጃழٿᆌւᘘޠᗎ༗Ȃᡲ೩ӼަཽᜟጣყᡞηߧְᓒȄѫΚР ८ȂҐНଭᄈѯᢋԒߝ९ޠϸݚӍშࡿяȂᆌւᘘٸᙠཽڨژ࢈ݾښ
࡚ޠၽձᡓᒯښङȇЏڐښ࡚؛ᘉᇅ؛ޠፓᚖϾȂԂѠᡲᆌ ւᘘޠਞݏ҉ԛȂࣦՎѠ॓८ޠኈȞپԄིՃࢼຯޠђጇȟȄ
൸ᘉՅّȂשউޠϸݚ๗ݏڸࠊख़ःفݎٴަཽ࢈๋ޠНᝧԥΚٳৰ
Ȃл्ϛӤᘉӶܼשউᄈܼҖлϾޠኈЩၷߴȂᇰ࣐ѻܛЖึޠᆌ ւᘘȂഷಥᗚᆓຝ࢈ݾښ࡚ޠᄙ؛ۢ࢈๋ޠ๗ݏȞݔቈȂ1994;
Haggard & Kaufman, 2008; Ku, 2001; Peng & Wong, 2008; Wong, 2004ȟȄܿ
ّϟȂҖлϾᄈܼަཽ࢈๋ޠኈȶЬၸՒȂҼѠ᙮ՒȷȂᜱᗥӶ
ܼ࢈ݾښ࡚Ԅեጓᇅϟޠ᠍Ωᜱ߾ȂпІښ࡚ϜԥӼЎ؛
ᘉཽښङ؛๋ޠึႇโȄ
ᘉณᅹґٿݎٴޠԒߝЩၷःفޠໍΚؐ፟ᚡȂЏڐӶݎٴҖл ޠึϜঢ়ȂҖлښ࡚ҐٙηܼᄦસᏱಭᇅښ࡚።ᎍޠႇโȂᆎ࢈
ݾښ࡚ޠᡑ᎑Ȃη౫Ӷᄈަཽ࢈๋ޠኈᡑϾαȄЏڐӶҖлϾആԚ
؛ᘉቩђޠݸίȂϨቅ࢈ݾΩആԚϛӤޠԒߝ࢈๋๗ݏȉ15՚Р
ঢ়ޠःفࡿя࢈ឪᝰލΚঐ२्ޠӱᡑȂՅኈөӶϛӤਣ
ޠᆌւ९๗ݏȞHuber & Stephens, 2001; Kitschelt, 2001; Lynch, 2006ȟȄ կঐӱષӶѯᢋޠԒߝ९စᡜϜծоءԥࡼ៊ܓޠኈΩȈѻѬӶ 1990 ԒхҖлऐખਣϜԥ݃ᡘޠձңȂӶࡤ៊ޠึϜࠔѬ࣐Չఞԓ ޠђጇ࢈ݾȂءԥఽޠ࢈ឪཏᜌᄙৰȄӤኻޠםηึҢӶަཽყ ᡞޠΩ໕ϸݣȈϏཽпІϛӤޠަᆌყᡞϟޠ๋ᖓ࿘ٯґ֖౫Κय ܓȂЇՅӶөঐࢳԥᘜޠ౫ຬȂӱՅኈަཽΩ໕ѿѢԒߝ࢈ݾޠ
ΩȄᘉӤኻԥրܼ՚Рᆌւঢ়Ϝޠၯ઼ᖓ࿘౫ຬȂࡤ܂܂ӶԒߝ
९ႇโ၈ึදᜱᗥΩ໕ȞEbbinghaus, 2006; Häusermann, 2010; Mares, 2003ȟȄӶѯᢋҖлϾޠႇโϜȂ࢈ݾښ࡚ޠᡑ᎑пІঢ়ᐡᜱᇅަཽყ ᡞΩ໕ޠϤᗚӶϛᘟޠြᡑȂቩђᆌւښ࡚ޠ࡛Ҵᇅᡑ᎑ႇโϜޠᡑ
Ȃሰ्Ӷ࢈๋ঐܗၯЩၷϜಡᑷޠϸݚȄ
կηҔӱԄԫȂҐНᄈܼҖԒߝ࢈๋ޠϸݚȂѠᇴ݃࢈ݾښ࡚
፤ΫϸᎍӬໍΚؐޠЩၷःفȄᄈܼѯᢋޠަཽᆌւःفՅّȂҖлϾໍ
โܛЖକޠ࢈ݾښ࡚ᇅ᠍Ωᜱ߾ᙾᡑȂณᅹᄈґٿޠᆌւ࢈๋ښۢԥᜱ ᗥޠኈȄΚঐѠпໍΚؐᢏᄇޠࡿዀپߞྲៗߴᓏȈҖໍឪஉ
15 ձདᗃຠቸණᒻঐୱᚡ८ӪȂկ४ܼൾȂርЩၷޠ౪፤ᇅԒߝ९ စᡜϸݚ҇ӶуНϜѫ౪ȂԫѬ൸ѯᢋޠ९စᡜණٽߒؐޠࡧ ՄᘉȄ
࢈ਣ߰ۗറȂژΠ 2008 ԒҖឪஉ࢈ϟࡤέѫକᝦحȂ२ུۗ
დຠզȄΚঐུޠަཽߴᓏښ࡚࡛ҴȂ҇ดூစᐤ౫Җл࢈ݾښ࡚Ϝ ޠၾᔜࠍȂӶ࢈ȂҴݳႇโϜڨژᙣᆧِΩȃࣻᜱւઊყᡞึᖑᝧ๋
๊ಣӬޠΩ໕ܝȄཽԄӤҖԒߝߴᓏΚኻȂژഷࡤяѯޠ
࢈๋щᅗ׃ڟޠ౸ၭȂۧࡠᢏᄇȄҐНϸݚᢏᘉޠِ࡚ٿࣽȂ؛๋Ї᙮
۾ᰏϬดΚঐ྄ѠึҢޠᡑȂЏڐߞྲៗߴᓏଷΠଓྜ௪ޠୱ ᚡѵȂηਗ਼ژྲණٽȃпІڐᇅӓҖୋߴϟޠ᠍ೱᜱ߾๊८ӪȄӶ ୱᚡፓᚖ࡚ϛႉӼᡲޠםίȂߞྲߴᓏޠҴݳႇโϬดѠึҢΚݱή
ޠםȂঐឋᚡηԚ࣐ґٿໍΚؐ࢈ݾښ࡚፤ᢏᘉᔯᜍҖлϾᇅ
ަཽ࢈๋ᜱ߾ޠጓپȄ
ՄНᝧ
еҔȞ2003ȟȄȲစᔽึᇅަཽᆌւȈུΩ໕ᇅᙠቌঅޠ֩ძȳȂȮަୣ
ึ۠ёȯȂ102: 21-32Ȅ
еᄹይȃ༂ు߈ȃାੵዯȞ2007ȟȄȲѯᢋሰ्ޠҖԒߝښ࡚ȳȂȮަୣ
ึ۠ёȯȂ116: 25-49Ȅ
࢈ଲစᔽ࡛೪ېসཽȞ1998ȟȄȮҖԒߝښ࡚ېଋःفൣ֚ཋጢȯȄѯ іȈ࢈ଲစᔽ࡛೪ېসཽȄ
եߝ١ȃڻᝌ߀Ȟ1999 Ԓ 4 УȟȄȲҖԒߝᇅᖃᡞစᔽȳȂȶঢ়৴ȃަཽ࢈
๋Іڐଓଡ଼๋ርᏱःଇཽȷ፤НȄპဏȈϜҖަཽᆌւᏱཽȄ
ܿᘀȞ2005ȟȄȲѯᢋӵୣҖԒߝდϟଇȈུަཽॴᓏᢏᘉޠߒؐ
ϸݚȳȂȮНІަཽऌᏱёȯȂ17(4): 715-760Ȅ
ܿᘀȃѡϱНȞ2003ȟȄȲѫΚঐᆌւзࣩȉݎٴึᆌւᡞښߒȳȂ ȮѯᢋަཽᏱёȯȂ31: 189-241Ȅ
ज፲Ȟ1989ȟȄȮϜҖቩҴݳېস࢈ݾِՔϟःفȯȄҴ࢈ݾτ ᏱήҖлဏःفܛᆉς፤НȄ
ݔቈȞ1994ȟȄȮᆌւঢ়˕ᐤѭЩၷޠϸݚȯȄѯіȈѽࢻȄ ݔቈȃ༂ޚȞ2000ȟȄȲ፤שҖԒߝښ࡚ޠდȳȂȮަୣึ۠
ёȯȂ91: 16-29Ȅ
ݔ݃Ȟ2001ȟȄȲҖлϾᇅަཽ࢈๋ޠϵӔᇅȈӓҖୋߴޠ࢈๋םԚȳȂ ᒄུྶȃݔ݃ȞጢȟȂȮѯᢋޠަཽᆌւၽȯȂॳ 135-175ȄѯіȈ ѽࢻȄ
ހ๚ᖓ࿘Ȟ2003ȟȄȮހ๚лȯȄѯіȈހ๚ᖓ࿘Ȅ
ڻᝌ߀ȃᛴखᛞȃѽࡅȃചϊकȃڻᆓȞ2001ȟȄȮҖԒߝᄈ࢈ۻଓ ଡ଼ІҖ᠍ઊኈϟःفȯȄѯіȈ࢈ଲစᔽ࡛೪ېসཽȄ
ভНኌȃဩਫྕȞ2006ȟȄȲҖԒߝІഽଞུښҴݳႇโϟЩၷȈ࢈ᡞϜ ЗޠᢏᘉȳȂȮःفѯᢋȯȂ1: 59-107Ȅ
Ϝ݃ȃࡃඐНȃ᎓ີȞ2007ȟȄȲשҖԒߝϟდᐤโȳȂȮަୣ
ึ۠ёȯȂ116: 11-27Ȅ
݃ึȞ2001ȟȄȲҖԒߝᄃࢋ๋ϟЩၷᇅຠզȳȂȮᏱൣȯȂ68: 195-208Ȅ
༂ؿᆓȞ2003ȟȄȲЎ࢈ۻӶཽޠ֩ძȳȂȮѯᢋ࢈ݾᏱёȯȂ7(2): 3-49Ȅ
༂ވݎȞ2008ȟȄȮᏵ࢈ࡧᒲȈשϜѶ࢈ۻᡞښึРӪϟःفȯȂѯіȈ ϥࠓȄ
ച≊ඐȞ2007ȟȄȲѯᢋҖԒߝښ࡚დޠึᇅࢆȈΚᖠ႟ަཽϏ โޠᄻᑟȳȂȮަୣึ۠ёȯȂ116: 85-97Ȅ
೩ϮᡤȞ1989ȟȄȮ࢈ឪ࢈ݾޠફזᇅঘ౪ȯȂѯіȈঢ়࢈๋ःفϜЗȄ ೩ਐ݃ȃڻᝌ߀ȃեߝ١ȃݔ࡛ظȞ2001ȟȄȲҖԒߝᇅ࢈ۻଓ࢈॓ᐋȳȂ
ȮѯᢋစᔽႲขᇅ࢈๋ȯȂ31(2): 67-90Ȅ
രҴဩȞ1994ȟȄȲѯᢋަཽᆌւᡞقޠቺϾਞݏߒȳȂӁኋࢍȞጢȟȂ ȮѯᢋަཽޠҖಁཏӪȈަཽऌᏱޠϸݚȯȂॳ 285-310ȄѯіȈϜѶः
فଲȄ
രҴဩȞ2000ȟȄȲՃԒԒߝȃ࢈ឪᝰލᇅᒶᖟȳȂᒄུྶȃݔ݃ȞጢȟȂ ȮѯᢋޠަཽᆌւၽȯȂॳ 232-256ȄѯіȈѽࢻȄ
രൊȞ2005ȟȄȮѯᢋӵୣՃစᔽԋӓРᇅՃစᔽၦྜџঢ়৴Ͼϟϸ ݚȯȂ࢈ଲঢ়ऌᏱېসཽᚡःفȄԚݏൣ֚Ȟൣ֚ጢဵȈNSC93- 2412-H-194-008ȟȂґяޏȄ
രൊȞ2007ȟȄȲᙾঢ়ᇅึϜঢ়Ԓߝ९စᡜ፤ѯᢋԒߝᡞق ޠ࡛ᄻȳȂȮѯᢋަཽᆌւᏱёȯȂ5(2): 31-66Ȅ
ဩპྂȞ2005ȟȄȲ࢈ݾښ࡚ᄈשଓ࢈ٖԆޠኈȳȂȮϜНަཽᏱ
ൣȯȂ2: 84-110Ȅ
ጿۤᑮȞ2008ȟȄȲ౪܉ȃւઊᇅښ࡚ȈѯᢋҖԒߝდޠ࢈ݾϸݚȳȄ
ҴᇄᢋτᏱަཽᏱःفܛᆉς፤НȄ
᎓ఽᗹȃ᎓НᎄȞ2005ȟȄȲשަཽߴᓏೞߴᓏଓଡ଼॓ᐋᇅ࢈ۻ၅ֆϟ
ଇȳȂȮѯᢋަཽᆌւᏱёȯȂ4(1): 51-94Ȅ
ᑌ࢈ࢍȞ2004ȟȄȮѯᢋަཽԋӓᡞقϟୱᚡᇅᄈ๋ȯȄѯіȈ࢈ଲစᔽ ȮѯᢋစᔽႲขᇅ࢈๋ȯȂ33(2): 61-95Ȅ
Amenta, E. (2005). Institutionalist and state-centric theories of political sociology. In T. Janoski, R.Alford, A. Hicks & M. A. Schwartz (Eds.), The handbook of politi-cal sociology: States, civil societies, and globalization (pp. 96-114). Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
Aspalter, C. (2001). Conservative welfare state systems in East Asia. Westport, CT:
Praeger.
Bonoli, G. (2000). The politics of pension reform: Institutions and policy change in Western Europe. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
Bonoli, G. (2001). Political institutions, veto points, and the process of welfare state adaptation. In P. Pierson (Ed.), The new politics of the welfare state (pp. 238- 264). Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
Bonoli, G., & Shinkawa, T. (2005). Ageing and pension reform around the world:
Evidence from eleven countries. Cheltenham, England: Edward Elgar.
Chen, H. H. (2005). Universal values versus political ideology: The virtual reform experience of Taiwan’s national pension plan. In J. Doling, C. J. Finer & T.
Malt (Eds.), Ageing matters: European policy lessons from the East (pp. 96- 122). Aldershot, England: Ashgate.
Chow, N. W. S. (1987). Western and Chinese ideas of social welfare. International Social Work, 30, 31-41.
DiMaggio, P., & Powell, W. W. (1991). The iron cage revisited: Institutional iso-morphism and collective rationality. In W. W. Powell & P. J. DiMaggio (Eds.), The new institutionalism in organizational analysis (pp. 63-82). Chicago, IL: The Chicago University Press.
Ebbinghaus, B. (2006). Reforming early retirement in Europe, Japan and the USA.
Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
Fu, T. H., & Hughes, R. (Eds.) (2009). Ageing in East Asia: Challenges and policies for the twenty-first century. London, England: Routledge.
Haggard, S., & Kaufman, R. R. (2008). Development, democracy, and welfare states:
Latin America, East Asia, and Eastern Europe. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Hall, P. A., & Taylor, R. C. R. (1996). Political science and the three new institutionalisms.
Political Studies, 29, 936-957.
Häusermann, S. (2010). The politics of welfare state reform in continental Europe:
Modernization in hard times. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
Holliday, I. (2000). Productivist welfare capitalism: Social policy in East Asia. Political Studies, 48, 706-723.
Holliday, I. (2005). East Asian social policy in the wake of the financial crisis: Farewell to productivism? Policy and Politics, 33(1), 145-162.
Holliday, I., & Wilding, P. (Eds.) (2003). Welfare capitalism in East Asia: Social policy in the tiger economies. Basingstoke, England: Palgrave Macmillan.
Huber, E., & Stephens, J. (2001). Development and crisis of the welfare state: Parties and policies in global markets. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Immergut, E. M. (1992). Health politics: Interests and institutions in Western Europe.
Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
Immergut, E. M. (1998). The theoretical core of the new institutionalism. Politics and Society, 26(1), 5-34.
Immergut, E. M., & Anderson, K. M. (2007). Editors’ introduction: The dynamic of pension politics. In E. M. Immergut, K. M. Anderson & I. Schulze (Eds.), The handbook of Western European pension politics (pp. 1-45). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Jones, C. (1990). Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea and Taiwan: Oikonomic welfare states. Government and Opposition, 25, 446-462.
Jones, C. (1993). The pacific challenge: Confucian welfare states. In C. Jones (Ed.), New perspectives on the welfare state in Europe. London, England: Routledge.
Kitschelt, H. (2001). Partisan competition and welfare state retrenchment: When do politicians choose unpopular policies? In P. Pierson (Ed.), The new politics of the welfare state (pp. 265-302). Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
Ko, C. F., Oh, K. M., & Ogawa, T. (2007). Aging population in East Asia: Impacts on social protection and social policy reforms in Japan, Korea, and Taiwan. In J. Lee
& K. W. Chan (Eds.), The crisis of welfare in East Asia (pp. 43-70). Lanham, MD:
Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
Koelble, T. A. (1995). The new institutionalism in political science and sociology.
Comparative Politics, 27(2), 231-243.
Kranser, S. D. (1984). Approaches to the state: Alternative conceptions and historical dynamics. Comparative Politics, 16, 223-246.
Ku, Y. W. (2001). To be or not to be a Taiwanese welfare state: Lessons from recent experience. In C. J. Finer (Ed.), Comparing the social policy experience of Britain and Taiwan (pp. 27-48). Aldershot, England: Ashgate.
Ku, Y. W., & Finer, C. J. (2007). Developments in East Asian welfare studies. Social Policy and Administration, 41(2), 115-131.
Kwon, H. J. (1999). The welfare state in Korea: The politics of legitimation. Basingstoke, England: Macmillan.
Kwon, H. J. (2005). Transforming the developmental welfare state in East Asia. De-velopment and Change, 36(3), 477-497.
Lin, C. W. (2005). Pension reform in Taiwan: The old and the new politics of welfare.
In G. Bonoli & T. Shinkawa (Eds.), Ageing and pension reform around the world:
Evidence from eleven countries (pp. 182-207). Cheltenham, England: Edward Elgar.
Lin, K. (1999). Confucian welfare cluster: A cultural interpretation of social wel-fare. Unpublished dissertation. Tampere, Finland: University of Tampere.
Lynch, J. (2006). Age in the welfare state: The origins of social spending on pensioners, workers, and children. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
Mares, I. (2003). The politics of social risk: Business and welfare state development.
Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
Peng, I., & Wong, J. (2008). Institutions and institutional purpose: Continuity and change in East Asian social policy. Politics and Society, 36(1), 61-88.
Peters, B. G. (2005). Institutional theory in political science: The new institutionalism (2nd ed.). New York, NY: Continuum.
Pierson, P. (1994). Dismantling the welfare state? Reagan, Thatcher and the politics of retrenchment. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
Pontusson, J. (1995). Book review of structuring politics. Comparative Political Studies, 28, 117-47.
Scharpf, F. W. (1997). Games real actors play: Actor-centered institutionalism in po- licy research. Oxford, England: Westview Press.
Shi, S. J. (2010). The fragmentation of the old-age security system: The politics of pension reform in Taiwan. In K. H. Mok & Y. W. Ku (Eds.), Social cohesion in greater China: Challenges for social policy and governance (pp. 339-371).
Singapore: World Scientific.
Steinmo, S., & Tolbert, C. J. (1998). Do institutions really matter? Taxation in indus-trialized democracies. Comparative Political Studies, 31(2), 165-187.
Tang, K. L. (1998). Colonial state and social policy: Social welfare development in Hong Kong 1842-1997. Lanham, MD: University Press of America.
Thelen, K., & Steinmo, S. (1992). Historical institutionalism in comparative politics.
In S. Steinmo, K. Thelen & F. Longstreth (Eds.), Structuring politics: Historical institutionalism in comparative analysis (pp. 1-32). Cambridge, England: Cam-bridge University Press.
Tsebelis, G. (2002). Veto players: How political institutions work. Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University Press.
Weaver, R. K., & Rockman, B. (1993). Assessing the effect of institution. In K. Weaver
& B. Rockman (Eds.), Do institutions matter? Government capabilities in the United States and abroad (pp. 1-41). Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.
White, G., & Goodman, R. (1998). Welfare orientalism and the search for an East Asian welfare model. In R. Goodman, G. White & H. J. Kwon (Eds.), G.White, The East Asian welfare model: Welfare orientalism and the state (pp. 3-24). London, England: Routledge.
Wong, J. (2004). Healthy democracies: Welfare politics in Taiwan and South Korea.
Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
ߤᓄΚ
ߤᓄΚȞ៊ȟ