常數項 內部人持股率 D 1* 內部人持股 預測 EPS P/E D3*(P/E) -4.320(0.144) 0.039(0.292* ) -0.024(0.424) 0.514(0.069* ) -0.052(0.232) 0.040(0.100* )
D 4*(P/E) 產業別 承銷價 承銷規模 成長潛力 公司規模 -0.025(0.688) 0.588(0.084* ) -0.014(0.246) 0.310(0.122) 0.014(0.946)
0.047(0.056* )
()內代表顯著水準
。
*:10%顯著水準, **:5%顯著水準, ***:1%顯著水準。
6. 結論與建議
本研究目的在同時考慮內部人持股與財務預測訊息下,以二因 子模式探討新上市之折價與上市後初期異常報酬之相關性。研究結果 顯示內部人持股比例愈高,新上市折價愈低,而且內部人持股率與 新上市後之初期報酬可能呈現非線性負相關,與過去之研究結果一 致。
其次,新上市前公佈預測公司之初期報酬顯著低於新上市後公 佈預測公司之初期報酬,與國外Jog & McConomy(2003)針對加拿大 新上市自願性預測之研究結果一致。此外,強制財務預測之每股盈餘 訊息預期可作為公司價值訊息之傳遞因子,盈餘預測訊息不論以每 股預測盈餘或本益比衡量,皆顯示與上市之初期報酬呈現相關性。新 上市股票具有低本益比的價值股或高本益比的成長股的特性下,會 有較高的蜜月期報酬,投資人在評估新上市公司股票時,公司宣告 的盈餘預測值納入評價的參考資訊,支持評價攸關假說。
就新上市前宣告財務預測的新上市公司,內部人持股率與初期
報酬無顯著相關,盈餘預測訊息與內部人持股比率作為訊息傳遞因 子之比較,盈餘預測訊息取代內部人持股率為主要訊息傳遞因子,
二者不具有互補效果,研究結果與Firth(1998)一致,Firth 認為預測 EPS 是 IPO 價值的主要訊息因子,比其他訊息因子例如內部人持股 率更重要,但新上市後宣告財務預測的新上市公司,內部人持股比 率為主要訊息傳遞因子。
在選擇上市前宣告財務預測之公司特性方面,在訊息不對稱下 , 內部人持股率愈高、預測每股盈餘愈高或P/E 值高具有成長股特性的 公司,為加強投資人對公司的信心,有較高的可能性選擇提前釋放 預測盈餘訊息,以降低投資人對公司的事前不確定性,而可以較高 的價格承銷,以致在新上市後有較低的承銷價折價。
綜合上述的研究結果,在訊息不對稱下,盈餘預測訊息相對於 內部人持股率,提供給投資人較直接且攸關之訊息,可作為投資人 評估新上市公司承銷價之參考,可以降低投資人對公司的事前不確 定性。在未來實施簡易式財務預測制度下,自願性的財務預測是否具 有相同的訊息效果,可做為後續研究之方向。
參考文獻
陳安琳,1997,新上市公司股票相關之理論與實證文獻回顧,管理 學報,第14 卷第 3 期,403-436。
陳安琳、李文智、林宗源,1999,新上市公司股票之發行折價-代理 成本與公司控制之研究。
陳安琳,2001,各種衡量模型下新上市公司股票之長期報酬,中國 財務學刊,第9 卷第 3 期,535-556。
顧廣平,2003,台灣新上市股票短期與長期績效之再探討,證券市 場發展季刊15:1,1-40。
Allen, F. and G. R. Faulhaber, 1982, ‘Signalling by Underpricing in the IPO Market’, Journal of Financial Economics, 23,303-323.
Baron, D., 1982,’A Model of the Demand for Investment Banking Advising and Distrubution Services for New Issues.’ Journal of Finance, 37, 955-976.
Beatty, R. P., 1989, ‘Auditor Reputation and the Pricing of Initial Public Offerings’, Accounting Review, 64,693-709.
Carter, R., F. Dark and S. Singh,1998.’Underwritter Reputation. Initial Returns, and the Long-run Performance of IPO Stocks.’ Journal of Finance,53,285-311.
Carter, R. and S. Manaster, 1990, ‘Initial Public Offerings and
Underwriter Reputation’, Journal of Finance, 45,1045-1067.
Clarkson, P. M., A. Dontoh, G. Richardson and S.E. Sefcik,
1991.’Retained Ownership and the Valuation of Initial Public Offerings: Canaddian Evidence.’ Contemporary Accounting Research, 8,115-131.
Clarkson, P. M., A. Dontoh, G. Richardson and S.E. Sefcik, 1992, ‘The Voluntary Inclusion of Earnings Forecasts in IPO Prospectuses’, Journal of Accounting and Economics, 601-626.
Downes, D. H. and R. Heinkel,1982, ‘Signaling and the Valuation of Unseasoned New Issues’, Journal of Finance,1-10.
Firth, M., 1998, ‘PO Profit Forecasts and Their Role in Signaling Firm Value and Explaining Post-Listing Returns’, Applied Financial Economics, 8, 29-39.
Grinblatt, M. and C. Y. Hwang, 1989, Signaling and the pricing of new issues, Journal of Finance 44,393-420.
Howton, S.D., S. W. Howton and G.T. Olson, 2001,’Board Ownership and IPO Returns,’ Journal of Economics and Finance, 25, 100-114
Huang, Y. S., 1999, ‘The Price Behavior of Initial Public Offerings on the Taiwan Stock Exchange’, Applied Financial Economics 9, 201-208.
Hughes,P. 1986. ‘Signalling by Direct Disclosure under Asymmetric Information.’ Journal of Accounting and Economics 8, 119-142.
Ibbotson R. G.. and J. F. Jaffe, 1975, ‘Hot Issue Markets’, Journal of Finance 30, 1027-1042.
Ibbbotson, R.G., J. L. Sindelar and J. Ritter, 1988, Initial Public Offerings’, Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 1, 37-45.
Jog,V., and B. McConomy,2003. ‘Voluntary Disclosure of Management Earnings Forecasts in IPOs.’ Journal of Business Finance &
Accounting, 30, 125-167.
Keloharju, M., 1993, Winner’s curse, Legal Liability and the Long-run Performance of Initial Public Offerings in Finland’, Journal of Financial Economics, 34, 251-277.
Lee, C.I., S. Rosenstein, N. Rangan, and W. N. Davidson, III, 1992.
‘Board Composition and Shareholder Wealth: The Case of Management Buyouts.’ Financial Management,21,58-71.
Leland, H. and D. Pyle, 1977, ‘Information Asymmetries, Financial
Structure and Financial Intermediation’, Journal of Finance, 32,371-387.
Lev,B., and S. Penman. 1990,’Voluntary Forecast Disclosure, Nondisclosure and Stock Prices.’ Journal of Accounting Research, 28,49-76.
Loughran,T. and K. Rydqvist,1994. ‘Initial Public Offerings:International Insights.’ Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,2, 165-199.
Loughran, T., and J. Ritter, 1995,’The New Issues Puzzle’, Journal of Finance 50, 23-51.
Menon, K. and D. D. Williams,1991,’Auditior Credibility and Initial Public Offerings’, Accouonting Review,66,312-332.
Michaely,R. and W. Shaw,1994,’The Pricing of IPOs: Tests of Adverse Selection and Signalling Theories.’ Review of Financial
Studies,7,279-317.
Ritter, J., 1984, The ‘hot issue” Market of 1980’, Journal of Business 32, 215-240.
Ritter, J., 1991, The Long-run Performance of Initial Public Offerings’, Journal of Finance 46, 3-27.
Rock,K., 1986,’Why New Issues Are Underpriced?’ Journal of Financial Economics,15, 187-212.
Rosenstein,S, and J. G.. Wyatt, 1990, ‘Outside Directors, Board
Independence, and Shareholder Wealth’, Journal of Financial Economics, 26,175-191.
Rosensrein,S, and J. G.. Wyatt, 1997, ‘Inside Directors, Board
Effectiveness, and Shareholder Wealth’, Journal of financial Economics, 44,205-228.
Stern R. L. and P. Bornstein, 1985, ‘Why new issues are Lousy Investments’, Forbes 136, 152-190.
Stoughton,N. and J. Zechner,1998.’IPO-mecnanisms, Monitoring, and Ownership Structure.’ Journal of Financial Economics, 49,45-77.
Titman, S. and B. Trueman, 1986, Information Quality and the Valuation of New Issues’, Journal of Accounting and Economics 8, 159-172.
Verrecchia,R. 1983. ‘Discretionary Disclosure.’ Journal of Accounting and Economics, 5, 179-194.
Waymire,G.1985. ‘Earnings Volatility and Voluntary Management Forecast Disclosure.’ Journal of Accounting Research, 23, 268-295.
Welch, I., 1989, ‘Seasoned Offering, Imitation Costs, and the
Underpricing of Initial Public Offerings’, Journal of Finance 44, 421-449.
Yermack, D., 1996 , ‘Higher Market Valuation of Companies with a Small Board of Directors’, Journal of Financial
Economics,,40,185-211.