118 j[1if3tft ' WJfl:.>t 0 - 資訊著作的著作性與合理使用-事理學理及法制面研究

119 j[~~fI7!m 9 1 ~m4 ~⁰

120 j[~Wfi$m611a! ⁰

.m.~~.~~.~~~m-.~·.~&~~OO~~ 2~

~.~~*~.~

. .

~,~~~~m;~~m*.~ ~.

~~1~ • • ~~' a..~o

••

^~.~

••

^~.~.- ~~~~~m-.,~~

1~.~o~.~a

•••••

^~M

••

•••

^~~~~.~

!.tMo*~~~~Nili~-.dd.A~«~.m,~.~

~~~~. M.~~,*.*a*

••

~~.~.*.Afl .~

••

#~.~ffo.~ ~M.ff~~~'ddI

JJl;f.JcMM

~ ~ ~Jll2l,

i£1tJf}1! # 0/

~ ~.~

1t.JtIj

fll

tr?

PJf

~~.~~ff~~~m,.~~.«om~

••

^~g~a.~

~~1~~ ~~~~ili~~Jlo ~. ~~ ~~~~~£

*§~,~~~~~~~.#~~~ ~~ff'~~~~ ~~

~;~ ~. ~A'#~ ~~#

• •

*~~~,~~

•

fJl,~

... * ^ra,

^{~a~.~ ~}

^{1ff ^rJ]

^Jtj! ^(dialog)

⁰

1tM

N~'*.~.~AI4A~~

••

~~Jtj!,~.

-~~.o* •• ~. ~W~'e ••

%~.#K~~.o~.*~~ff~

M• •

*m,~~.%.

t~~ t~ . ' m1t.M~. o.*~.M .~~#

~i~'

• • • •

~~.*.~Afl'~

••

^-~.#~~.*

~ft.$*~~

• •

^wo.M~

^••

,~~~.~*t~.~,

121 ~~~~*)(~IJI~{'FttEt-Jffl)7t

"

2001

if:

10 jj 15

614

§~Jlhttp://www.tien-liipr.com.tw/home_tienli

/iprjudge/hopeneti.htm.

~~7I1'iti¥jjfiltlMi)(ft~~

,

http://www.esouth.org , A::~i¥j1Jtm~

"

~~f$

7t~fJ~mmH5·EfJ.-T-*:\l([*1~$lj1Jt~l¥JthUt.7 ⁰:{£l!ii~ 86

if:

5 J=J 12

6

:L1f!1J~

P1Ef'Ftfjl¥J~f'Ffl1Fj$~1ij'f~.~H~$l~m

'

,*~~*fI 700 ~~ , ~1fJC~J)1:

mM~.~:{£~m~.~~'.~M.:L1f!1J~IfJC~f'F.~.~1ij'f~.~~

~o ^{• •}~^{• • •}*.~~mm~*m~1Jt~l¥Jm~"~~

• •

~~m~~

M~®~~~:L1f!~~'.fl~-~~~l¥J~~"

• • •

eJ

~ ~ .H=1 \IiK ~ :t$ ~ ~ ~ $2 ~

•

~ :; , ~ ~ #': :!ir I!l1 ~,:&; -H1 ~ ~~ ~ ~'\ I*-

:\it

Jt1 ~ l~ 4,n ~ ~ l?J 0 ~U\ ~.

it

t><

~ ~ -.l!lS ~ ~

..

~ :&; fii "<:-~ ~ ~ ~ ~ nJ ~

IE

~ ~ ~

tr:

~0 ~~~

• -<

~ ~ ~ I*-~ ~ ~

.. +1

:g;

0tIll!(

\t1'

~ ~ ~ ~~ \;ill{

$

~2 ~ ~ -33 1Il~ ~

WI

~ ~:#= l~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

*' •

~ -\:1m [If:~ ~ ~ ~ IIiJ. \

If m::

~ ~

m::

• :g;

~ ~ ~ ~ ~

-<

~ 1W

t::\

~ l~ <~

$

-\:1m

:g;

11«

:g;

~ -\+\ 00

¥

~ ~ ~

¥

~ ~

lI\n

~ ~ '.l!lS lI\iil'

.. :g;

~ l~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ::em <~-.l!lS ~-£l:-

:g;

*

•

l~ ~ ~ 11« $ ~ ~ ~ ~

•

~ -:lH ~ ~ -33 0 ~ ~ iii ~

'M

H ~U\

¥

:\tm ~

$!!

\$ ~ IE~ ~ ~iii\{ ~

*

ik\i' ~ ~ ~ ~

:#=

~ ~~ ~

•

~ ->.:l ~

-<

~ 1m\( -.l!lS ~ ~ ~~ ~ <~ ~ -.l!lS {nn ~ ~ W; ~ il:E: :roI: 1-\ ~ ~ $11

lI\n

~ ~ ~ ~ ~

:t:

~ 51

!fi

*

:&; ~

*

~ ~ ~ ~ '~2 ~ \iii' ~~ § :&;

..

4,0 ~ ~ ~

.. •

.wr

::em ~

:\it * :\it

-<

*'

\ tIl ~ ~

-< .wr

-< •

~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ :§ ~ If)

:It

+ • :g;

~ ~ ~

-<

:ti \lilt

:g;

~ ~ ~K ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

- ¥

•

~ ~ ~!

-<

illit *

~ ~ ~

iW

~ ~ eo ~

tir •

:#=

~ ~

..

~ ~ ~

* 4\

~ ~ l!fi ~ ~ ~:AI I.'ffi:

"

~ l~

•

-R: 'i." ~ lEI ~ .~~ ~~ mU\

* • :g;

I: eo

t:t

~ '" I*-

'"""

eo ~

:$

\in W;

•

~U\ I*-I!l!& ~

It

Itt

\t1'

m •

\in -\:1m ....

•

:\tm ~ ~~ ~ !f1 \ ~ ~

* * .. -K *

*

\!tI

lll~ ~

•

:&; -Bl I*-~

4\

~ ~ -t.tl ~ -~ 11\ 1\111 ~ ~ Ti:;f

=4l: ti&

-£l:--33 ~ -\:1m lEI :roI:, l~ mU\

tir

=t

~ ~ , '" C':l ~ ([C\l -t.tl ..q< ~ ~

..

~ I!l!&

• ¥

1\ I*

"* -*

,;t::. {r;.. ~~~

=

![:~I

~

~:IB< -::.::' ffltliii'<

-K

lI!~- ~ ~NOJ 1 • ~ "iT r--

.;W

M N ~ ~~~~m:: .)\QI~ftCiRRr-~

. ~*J:It

~ ~ ~ 1

OQ

:IB~OQ ~~ .!ooI~

~=Iii!

lt€ 48 ~ Q ~ fflt~.

~tm lI!;:)tr

.~. ,

-... .

~~Ml

~::)~ _.Ii

:lB OJ• ~ii; .)\QI :!$ ,. ~ a9;!(~V'I. lt€

m:: 40

~EfEiB I!'OQjIi

40

• J:It -<

.~~ ~:. .~1Ii .utlfil~ ~~~ ~g£i*I i*I~~ .)\QI ~.~~~

-p<!~m~~ma9;!(~ $(~.~.~!

~.tr8trtr ~(~~:~-P<~

!:j:IBE

iRR!!:l

6

""""

.m~f'Fl¥J:tHFttJ!€iJl~m-$JI '~JI:&'i:*tlJiHHiJf~ 231

m~~.~M

••

'~i.m.,~~£.~

•• ,.*

~~~~.~~.o~~M*

••

~»*'~~~

••

•• A

A~~'~~~~I-~~fftl~~M.~~~M.~.~a r9J ~

.:;t JfJ

⁰ ¹²⁸

~~.1tli~' ti1~-f~~5f.t..f(unclean hands).m.:~.

11: ti)fJ JfJ (copyright misuse)

Jl

~IJ

' :,J: m.11: li

•• ff a

:i1

Jt:. 0/ - :rJ! 1i-- *

^~^i;t^~¹²⁹⁰ ^~

^I*J ^'W-

^Il~^•

^{fl it} ^It ^1t ^m•• ^rJf ^jj

~i1t.*~.'#.~~.1t.:,J:m~~~.«o~.*~m 1~~.'~~.~.~A~~m.~~.o.1t.~~~~~

•••

^1t~~Am,

••

^~*~.#~jj.~

••

^rno~:rJ!m

.~**~.~.~~.o/,~m.ft~.R.~.o

• • •

~#~~

• •

m.:~A

••

~.~m~~.~Mjj'm

~&~.1t.~.&

••

~~.oM~*~m~~,*~~~~

~~.~.1tW~~.1t~.~»~~.~'~~W~.1t

~i1t*~1i--~~m~.It~I.~'~.*~.*

••

^~#.

'~~*~~#~.1i--;~~8.~.Mt.~.£

••

^~~ft

'o~*.#MM~~~~W~~.~jj'~M*A~.~£.

~i~.~.*.~

•••

~~.~-.~~,~~.~.1t~

~Ht

It 1tJfJ. iiI

~~ ~~

-t-

~ ~ ~ -ft~.:r

' Li tman

tt~t:.t*

*i1fti*.I~~.(sensible)' ./I~A~Jt

i.5&

⁰ *~

~~-~.M.'~.#.~-t:.t'.M~_~~jj~~.~

*!

12R

129 ~~Paul Goldstein, Copyright, v. II, 1998, pps.177-186; :& Note: Clarifying the Copyright Misuse Defense: the Role of Antitrust Standards and 'First Amendment Values, Harvard Law Review, v.I04, 1991, pps.1289-⁰

~~#~fi7ktt

' a]$&¥tfJtE&¥ '

1998 ~ ⁰

232 ~*~¥W¥~ 11If\+AM

4.3

.ft::.~.J:

••

^M~

*

~~ M~.~.~.~.~.~~ #tt~~~.m

~l ~ ~ ~

- 1m r..

^{~ ~,}

^i!t

^{~(. ~}^f@^~

^r& l!

~Jji

t4 tt

~11} ~ ~

if

~,~

#! il

~t4**~(science court)~:ti\;Mj}t, ~*~:rJJ ⁰

Wessel

ill ;it

~ ~J;/] ~

,J r& 1±:.m-

~,J

, 1t

#J 1L

'jf ~ ~

ifF wl-

rr

, :i! JfltU

~ ~

Jk

t4 tt * * r..

^{~ ~.z:.}

^Mj}t

¹³¹⁰ ^{~ ~}

^r!

^{~ ~ ~}

t '*

.~~~~~~~WF*R~# ~~.£~o,J%~1t%#J~~

ffij-'~~~~"'!h-Jf}~~i\;, *.4-~r!;fIlVf~.im ⁰

Fuller tt

ff

~ ~ ~ ~I\,'

(po

ce,n t ric) -* ^Jf}

^1!

^~Ji

^m ^t.

⁰

^M' %.z:. '

^{~ ~}^I\.'^fi]

**~~~.~~,J'.%~WF~~*.~.~:t~Mj}tmo

Fuller

~ill 'i!Y:t*~J1±:mj}t~~~fJf1}J&ill ~~*~~jN.'

'.if 1±:.m-

J!lit

t ,J , 1t % tit ill

(proof s and reasoned arguments)

~~ ,~~~~~~_~*.~m'~ill~j}to ~ ~~~

~~~, S~~~ill**~~~£~om;it~ ~ m~~

mj}t~~4~~~- «N.A~.U# .~#~~fi'

• •

~A ~'~~~~~r!~~~;f~;ffij**~MR;it~1}J&*

131 ~~ Milton R. Wessel , forum: Alternative Dispute Resolution for the Socioscientific Dispute, Journal of Law and Technology, 1981 v.1, pps.l-⁰ Wessel

if

if 11 *'l-

f1g J!l!

m

^f9j^~

^fI

(Association of Data Processing Services Organization , ADAPSO) ,

1'&]I!

~ ~ ~

if

M\ ~J!l!

f4 tt

fI

(Information Technology Association of America, ITAA)t¥J$$.Ilfh~' 1Jm~~flBrJ~~mJi J!l!rpJc"~1if;ttJ!l!jt ⁰~:::1S~refJ

'

Academic Software Arbitration ' J&~1t.B2Pff

~, ~m~.Wflj~,1966-1991, .l:!p~tBll& ⁰

llt)ji- '

Wessel ;ttftf!!Ylff)j;tt~~bi J!l!J!l!jtt¥J~f'F '

:ff

The Rule of Reason: A New Approach to Corporate Litigation, 1976 ; "& Science, Technology and the Law in America: A plea for Credibility in Dispute Resolution; Jurismetrics, v.22, 1981, pps.245-⁰

132 Lon Fuller, the Forms and Limits of Adiudication, Harvard Law Review, v.92, 1978, pss.353-⁰

wm~f1F8'1~f1F11Wilit~m -$it ,.it&i*!/ifJi1iHiJf~ 233

1$ #L

,

~;f 1~

!;L M

1~ ^IJJ⁰

:t ^Ji;r ^{f {f.J}

^mt

^11: ^tt

^r~~;!!

^{, aJ1}

^{,~Ji ~}

••

bt1!~~~,~~jt

• •

bt1!~~~"{f.J~.,~

I~~~#~~

• • • ' • •

• •

f.A{f.Jf~~ o~

M&~. ~.{f.J.~,!;L .~.{f.J~~,~ ~

t 1*

l¥J

Wes sel

f

~ ~

jt 1!

, jtJ

-fiLA. 't]l.

bt 1!

~ I~' ⁰

£ *

~*~~

~,*.&~.~;!!

••••

^a*~

••

#.ili~A~~rn~.

~.*{f.J~~~.~

• • #a.*

^.~

••

^~{f.J~

^•

~,~~~~.~~~{f.J~~~,~ 8~~~~~~{f.J ~

ri '

^.1~t.:fl ^{.~~ ~~}⁰

-It ,-+ f1f.rm

^Wessel

{f.J

~'~~BM~M

••

~m{f.J+8'~1~*{f.J~mt~.~ 0

~mM~M.&

••

^*.#~

••

#a{f.J*fi'E~~~~

~*~~.«,~~

••

~{f.J~~~E~.'-

• •

A.~.

M~ (online dispute resolution) ^IJS⁰ f.¥!~f.:!l!

• •

~~1fMf*

13~ ~ Bride, Edward, Fence Mending; ADAPSO's Alternative Dispute Resolution program intended to reduce litigation, Sofrware Magazine, July, 1991, v.ll, ·no.9, p.6 ; "& Calderbank, Alison, ADAPSO sets PC arbitration center, Computer Reseller News, February 4, 1991, p.20 ⁰

Frank Cona, Application of Online Systems in Alternative Dispute Resolution, B~ffalo Law Review, v.4S, 1997, pps.99S- ; Demand Henry Perritt, Resolution in Cyberspace, v.IS, 2000, pps. 67S- ; Joel Eisen, Are We for Mediation in Cyberspace?, Brigham Young University Law Review,

\998, pps.l30S- ; Jack Sabtino, ADR as "Litigation Lite": Procedural and Evidentiary Norms Embedded within Alternative Dispute Resolution, Emory Law Journal, v.47, 1998, pps.1289- ; Casey Lide, ADR and Cyberspace: The Role of Alternative Dispute Resolution in Online Commerce, Intellectual Property and Defamation, Ohio state Journal on Dispute Resolution, v.12, 1996, pps.193- ; "&

Robert Bordo~e, Electronic Online Dispute Resolution: A System Approach

234 ~*7t*Ml~

mR+AWJ

~~~~~'~~M~~A~~~~~~~~&~~~~~~ro

~.~.~.M.;.M'M-~'~~~ •• ^~

~~ff,~.~~o~~~*

•••

~~~~'.~~~ff*.

,.~.t •• ,~~~~~~~.._

X~o

• • •

~~~~~~M~

• • • • •

~W~~.'#

••

m~lli~'.~W.~~~£~o~~~~'~m

••

m~~~~~*.,~~~.&~~.~~#~,~~&#

A~A.$.~ •• 'fi~~M'~A8.~*&

~L'~~~~.*.~~~~o

~~~!M~.*~~~~~*~

••

^~~'~~~~~~

136 0 ~

! M

ti • •

~ ~ ~

& If. :t

~ ~

,

*

^{~. ~}

^{1£ 1£} ^#. * ^5l ^t

~'.~#

• •

~._-~M~.~o~.'*~m.M~.~

.~.~.'~Ilf..~.'.~.ff~~ •• ^~

~~.~,~~~.o.~.~~.~A.~mA~&~.*~'

~~~.-.A~~.AI~~.~~.K~o~~~~,~.

~.~.~~~~~mK~~~'~~A*.~~M.L~~~

.~'.~.~~~~ffi.'~.~.~.*

1Jt~~1ti-Jl~* ~ ⁰

Crews

{tilt.

~.1t {i*~J

i-JlLM

~ ~~~ ~~ ~~

1!Jf1

Potential, Problem, and a Proposal, Harvard Negotiation Law Review, v.3, 1998, pps.175-,

.1.-).&

Katsh

&

Rifkin, Online Dispute Resolution, 2001 ⁰

~.~.~M~~H~WmW~M.~~m~~.3~~~'~.~.' v.40 ' !X~ 84 ~ 11 fJ ' pps.6-12 ; ~W~J{;f.flf!ft.(t-J~m~!II

'

I~J{;f.

fi~HJH:1!

'

!X~ 84 ~6 J=J ' pps.I-13 ; f!ft.~~tt(t-J~M

' 1!ft. '

v.56 ' B:~

89 ~2 fJ ' pps.62-73 0

Ilt9i- '

:(£rri5l:~WmI~mIJJ/J\m~1Jr

' Et=JWmI

•••

*.~$.!X~~.~

•••

,~~g*rH~rWm~~~.~~

••

*J,~mlJJ~~r#.AA~.Jo~~M~'W~M

••

^~~~m#

Bfi ' jff;.r~H!f!. ' v.40 ' !Xii 84

1f:

11 fJ ' pps.13-26 ⁰

.m.~~.~ft.~.~m-

..·..

&$.OO.~ 2~

4!~lj(fair use guidelines)~' ~tB ~4!N1Jt{1J\:*!t:l1k1tJ!{!

m *Jt

tJI;]:l

..

~f;;J fj (illusion)'J7 0 1£{iiJ~! ~

*

^ti~lt!1X.^tJI;]

^{£)f]

I~W.~'.$~.,~~

••

~.*1tJ!~mtJl;]~

• •

~;~.~~mA~.*~)f].~~,~.~)f]~t.~.-~

~~~~~.~~~~

••

o*.~.HtJI;].~.~

•..

^~.

~~J!~~'~J~~~*A~~~

• •

~~.~.~~

• •

*;~~~~!~~.~.~.~

...

a.M~~.~.'_

~~g~*!1X.-~~~*~~~J!~tJI;].~~)f]~.o

Dreyfuss

t£.

.1t ti * ^$IJ

^fu ^ti ^IiiJ

^{~ ~}(collaborati ve research)~~Jt!~' t{tB~IiiJ.1t~.f~:t~w,fAA~.1~tB

;

t~ ~ ~!1X. ~

, JiIJ J.! 51 $Ij if

~(compulsory arbi tration

)1J8

⁰ ~

liE!.

~1*.82

••

^-~.-a#~~

•••

^a~~§.

t ' • •

~~~I~n~~~~§~~m~A.~ ~m.~$

t;LR.1t .1f 1r-1I .rJf n

{£m.J1 $139

⁰ ^{~ ~}

88

^jp

8 A

g

i'.I~.~~~~lr.~.#1r-II.z~m.J1$Z

• •

IJ7 ~~ Kenneth Crews, the Law of Fair Use and the Illusion of Fair·Use Guidelines, Ohio State Law Journal, v.62, 2001, pps.599 ⁰

Il8 Rochelle Cooper Dreyfuss, Collaborative Research: Conflicts on Authorship, Ownership, and Accountability, Vanderbilt Law Review, v.53, 2000, pps.1 162-⁰

1)9 ~~~f'Fti¥ftm 82 f~m)£

: r

±1f~Rtf!~iI~f'Ffljfm&~M~j1I.

'

.~~~.~:-,m~+~.m~~.)£&~f'FfI#ft~mmn)£~m.

~$~~mo='~f'FfI#ft~mfi~mA~,~~m.~~m~~.o_,

~f'F~~~~fI~m~~Mo~·~~fi~~f'FfI~m&~.~~~oM~

=ftm)£~m~~M'~.&M

••

'~~fi~.~.~

..

^o~*,

w.~ft.~m~.m~~~.)£:±.~R

••

~ft~m~~~~.M'

~~OOm.~$m2.f'FfI.~&~M~.*.moJ.#ft~mmn)£oo ffl~~$~jfm$~,e~~.~~.f'Fm¥ft~~.'

••

^~*~M.~~

~A51!il 0

236 J&*7E*~~

mf\+ AWl

a*&

~m.~.~~re~~ ~~J~ff.o~~ An~ .

.

•••

,&~re~M~tt.~~i.'~.#.A*~~~.~

JlIJ r:i! ^fT140

⁰

^*:t

^~~

^A

^Dreyfuss

^ftff

^rJdJt~{L.

^A ^fib

^{~;r.: ~}

^Ill" ^5s

~#.~.~'.A..o8.~ ••• ^~#~~.'

'f9tJ ~

11,

^til ^It ^r)f ^{iT If} 1t{l

^{~m

.III.}J{

^{~!. ~ ~}

^{*! Jt} ¹⁴¹

^¢

* ^{tri ffr}

~~~lf~~M~*~.~~~~~'~~~~mt.&.~~

~~~~~~~.'#.~:i!-~~~o

lf~~~.~~.' ~~~.82.~~~:t*!Jt~olf~

~~.83.~~*£~~I~Jt~~.~I~m.*!~&~.m

~'§.~fT~~~Jt.~#~:l'~~~~~{l

• •

&~.~

••

m.*!~:&2'.~.~.~

••

^~¢*.~ff

•• ^m••

~~M ~~*~.~~~.~~~~~.~{lM

* ••

~.~'~~.#.'~..~'R}J{~ •• ^~ft

••

~~'~l~.M.*J.~ .*,~ ._~

••

~~o._*J

••

^~~.*.~

••

~~~#.A.~~.1

~o~~*.~~.~

••

~.~0M'*~fT~ ~~~~*, R~*~~~#.A.~&~~.~~~ ~~*,~~~.~

.~~~~m.I&~~._'

»* ••

^M~~01~~

^•

10 0

140 J!~,*fl1ntrliUc~ ⁰

w J!tp~ffif¥lit

'

20011f: 1O.Ff 28 8lf13http://ctrews.yam.com.tw/news/

200110!26!196252.html

oWflff'Ffi$i3fij

911f: 1 J1~~tft0:ffl:i ⁰

142

J! M

laPfT

ijIf~)( ⁰

143

fi.i&fiFf$~ 44 fl~Hl~

: r ' fJ.i&fllH1#Hj&f¥'Wzjfm '

J;)0:lmffl~

'.M.M*;~0:Im&.M'~*$.~.~'~~$.nzo=·M

JJjPfTfijij[m,

{~HtHT.i&flIH1PfT~~~f*'W

Z)(if' III Jt

,*C~, ~Jt ~~~(1f) •

•

~Jt·t~~~j[M~,~m~,m·M

•••

~W~lf~.m~~.~

)(if~.&o_·~HfJ.i&.Hj[m0:Im&~.Mz$.,~fij*$0:ffl:i-.M.~~.~tt.~.~m-

•• ·••

&~~OO~~ ~7

Ji,MjIq

~~~~50.~.g#~~

• • •

~*'A~~~'I~»

.f;f±i-ft.J!~'{~fi*~1t ⁰ ~JlJ(

• •

it·~~5il!' 1{{!f~*t:

%~~_~~J(m

• • •

~'~*~~~~~~~~ff'~&A AA£5~.~I.,

••

~~J(m.JI~

••

;~~~.JI*~

S~~$~'~AA~A.JI~~~'X*'~W'~~'

••

~.ft~~'.-~~E

• •

•••

^m~M&o~

• •

tt.~

• •

^~.~

• • •

^~~,~*~~.g~

••

^~~.~

T' •

.f~~~M-~~.o**A~~~'I~».f;f±.~.

#.l

M7~1t, 1if~ffiWJ~o

*xm~~~.g.~.'

••

~.~~~~4'~~~~

-&m.~~.g#~

• • • •

• •

,.g.~»NJ(m.g

#tt~~,.~~~~~.~o

• • •

~#.~_~.M'~§

~U~~8~~$~.~.~.~*'~~~*~~.o~~,

f~.~.x'.f- •• ^~.~I~~.o

*x~.~W

••

'N~.g.~.~~~.~~,.»~

'fl

& .it

m

.1*

• # 'tf '

^~.

g.

^1*

^{~ ~ r~'}

^_

^~I^1}^~

~~.o*x*~.~.ffW,~.~.g.~~.~~.~~

~m~o*.~*.~~.~~

••••

W'.~~1o~~.

~~;f±i-*WW'~~~~~

• •

~~.~MI'*x~*.~

4pqjGpx:i'1:~ ~jGpxllr*WJ' 1'Ti&~D!fllOJ*IlijH!IJljUU1Jft~.fitq;z ⁰ ⁰J.

{?i

m~~m~,fti&~~~~90$2~21B~~fti&~~~~1Jft~o{?i~~

¥}j$r~m 8 {~;ZtI~:

r

1'Ti&.~z1:IfJ~~' ~i*1$~~Mi~9}' !t1J~~"f

:

'fl.~i&R~H~.~!t@lli~&o=,~m.m~

••

~~!t~1J~

m~~.~.~o_,.m~~oo.'~.'~$'.fi'.~

..

^~o~.

m1Si'~'::~.RtJr , ~fJJ1f1 0 li ' !t~,@tj{j!~~m~;Z1JA 0 J ⁰

"

238 i9:*1t~~.

mt;;+ AJJJ

.J~~~ft~M;~~~~~-~O/'*lli~~~~L~~~

~~,~~~~~~~~~r*~~*~L~~~o*X.~,

••

~~~.O/~~-~.~.*.*'.lli.~o

5.1 J! • • • • iii /9l Jl!:l J!

*Xo/.~~~~~*~~M'~~~~~.~~~;*$

~**~~.~mflW'~~~'*~~.ro 5.1.1

*~r,,'l!

.~flW'.~~~

••

^~#

••

~~*.~~~~~~

.~*o

•.•

~.~ ~~.~~.o

•.

^#~.-.~.$

~ ~

iii '

~:f

th ^l' if

.

^fUll

^{fl it}

⁰ ^Mp3^1~

ⁱ

.~if.~

..

^~~~.*~~o

.•

^m~'k4it4.~

^••

••

·.it~.;.~.~

••

^~~

••

~#~xtho/'~~

•

^o~~~*~#~~

••

•••

^it~I.'.~

••

^lli~~

~.~~.~.~~,~#tt.~~~~~~if.#.~

..

., ••

^~X*. ^~.~~~.

'

^~*.th*~x*

••

;~.~.ma ~x~

••

~§.'~x~~I~ ~ .**~~~,

••

,a~~t*~~~~.~*~~

•• lli.

~It! ~ ~

J/IJ 0

.~~~~1'W

••

~.*~~£*~~o.~~~~~~

M~.m

••

lli~~ ;.~M~~~' ~#~.~o/~m.

~?~~~~ .A~~.*it~.~;

••

^~.~.~lli«

~f ~ ~ ~ty~, ~fi.·~ I flP ~~* r.ijl! ,~ ~

~~.~.*~~*~.~q~,~~~*.~*~~~~~~

*~~;~~. ~~,~~~~~~~o

if..

~.~ ~~.ft~~-~*.~

•••

^o/~.~~

11il!{i

⁰ f!!~1~~.~~.jpM~M MJZJt?~~*~1%jfL

.m~~~~~tt~ft~~m-.~·.~&~.oo~~ ~9

~~~

••

~M?~~~W4~.~*

••

^{oA~. ~~}

••

~~.~~.~~~~~~~~~~. ~m.~#~ ~ ~

~.,~~~~g£.~.~.~~.~~~'~k~~-.

*~~'~~MA~*~.~~~~~mt~ .~

••

^~~~

~«

••

~o~.~,~~~~~~~~.~

..

^~~~,*~~

~«.$

••

~ .m;~*~.~«

••

^~m~

••

tR

1Jfj ,~ ~

fiif

~~ ~J

• tl

«1ft

^jp

1±:

~ ~

it • • •

1t z.l ?

~ ;~

-*

!~~jp.l

• •

~.~~~~~~~~~.~

• •

^~~'~M

A~~~

• •

~.o

..

^.l'R~*~~~~

^{• •}

^*~».**

~n.~ .~~~~~

...

^~;

..

~M'. *~.~

• .

^~.«~~~~.~~»-.+~~~.A~~At~*~~

..

^~M-*o

• •

^~~~~.o

*x~-~fr~1$~#*~~~+.~~~~~~~~~~.

R~m_o4~~.~~~

••

^1±:.~#~~

•• z

^,.~.

~&llio~A~I1±:**.I~'~

* ••

~~M1±:°.~~~A~~*.M~A~.~~~

••

~ X~.~.'A~~~AI~oA~ ~*~£_~ ~~

~,~~~

••

~.~~~~~.~~.~£~~~£~,~«

it 't!

~ ~

it • £ *-

^{~ ~ ~}

i* ^A

^{~ ~}

^,

^~.

*

^{JiJf if;}

^{I~' ~}

^it ^{i

~~~~,~~~z~ ~~. ~~~~

••

^{I'~~ ~}

~,~.~~ ~~.~ M~~~A~.o

%~~mjJffij ,

Ginsburg

~~*f!}fl-=-jf~m f*~"1t/~!

lRJfJ

'~Bblitrr>'.lt-jY~~ ⁰ ~t*1!m.l'

Litman

~~~~

2!z ~

im l:

~~ jt}f

l: 't! f!}fl , 1t

£ - ^1& ^{jf ,}*

^{~ ~ ~}

^Y!

^(copy)^~

:t

*~~~.~-~A~lit~.~~~,~~*~~o~1±:~~

l~~ 'No person shall circumvent a technological measure that effectively controls

access fo a work protected under this title.'. Ji~$ § 120(a)(1)(A) ()

ta':&;'

..

~ ~~ ~~

m::

te~ ~~ :E; l~ ~ ,:til(

• • •

·m.w~.w~.~~~m-.~·.~&$~OOM~ Ul

. %Mi.~.~&«~.~.~~~~~.~ff»

~~.R~~.*.~~._~

..

^~~

.. ••• ' ••

^o~~.,.

~*~~~ff~.~~~~~~*

•••

*~~~~*~A~o .~

••

~&.~~I.ft.~#~~.m*~~IM~~

~L~w'**~~~'~M.om~.~MM'~~

1:

^EY-J~

I •

~ ~ ~;tl

, ftJi

~ ~,:f.

; •

• • ' 111 't

.t.

tf ill iJL

⁰

..'N.~~.m~.~ .. ~A~'-AW~.~

;~ ,~,,;

l.:t:f. t- '

~. ~ ~ ~:fl

i" ^.t.

^rEI'

Jt 1f

{7j

M

^:(t^~

t-

At '

~ .~~o~~«.~~*

••

~~~~~A~~~~~L

••

~ •• ^,~~m.ff~ •••• ^~ •• ^*'.~ ••• ^ff~

,x..,:f. ⁰ ,).1.3

IJ"

~.t-~~~i"#.~.:f.*~~i"~.~.~~~

•• '

~~.~~.~.~.~.~~8.~~

..

^{o - • •}^{~ ~.}

A.~mA~~.g~~~,~.~~~.«,~.~

••

^~~

~~~.~~~.~~*

..

~~~~'§~~~.:f..~o~

~~fl8It ' tlt~rr:~IJ$B 7t;Lli~t.;LflJ/~ ⁰ *14~i5-Ji1~ft1~H~11i

~~~~m~~'R~~~ft~~OO~$~~~~;L~~m,~m~~~w

~~~Aft.mffl~mfl.ffoB~~R.m~~~.~

••

~~A+~rr:

+~+8.~~.k~~X.ft.*~~~rMMM.~~.-~=~

*J'.*.~fi~.~~~~~'MM;L~W~A~M.fi~.~m.~~

.~ff~o~~i5-~~~i5-.~;Lttm(~~.)'~i5-~.mm.~.~m -~ffl~z~~oill~i5-.m~~mm;.~~~X.W7t'~~~i5-.ft 7t~,.F3fIJ~fffizi\.7t;L-,

£l.1If*tJ.JEfli\ . =ffitltw

,~ttm~t.~

~~.m.+~~o~~~.~a.~X

••

fflS~'*~~.~~i5-~S W-~=Ax.z1tm (~Ut.), ~~t~~Ilff!~~tW:tk, ~~~ff!.m7tJjfjm m~~~Az~.~~xm-~ffl~~~.oJo$~.~~~~Wtt?~~

l'fU~:*~,.F3 f!J~~IfUIOOB!

242 i&*~*Mi~ m~+J\M

~.**~ .MT~t

~o*~~-~~~I~~.~~£*~~o~~~~~~mt

~.~~~8,.m~~.~.m.~

•. ^{» •••}*

^~~.

$j , ~ !:U~.l~~.~

1

⁰

5.2 ****I¥JJttf.,

~ ~ ~I!l

J.I! *

^{~ fJf ~t}

*

^~^t:}

^tt ^{It Jl} fl. ^1f ^II ^:it

^{~ ~}

^{:ffj ¥ '}

⁸⁴

~«.~~~~o~l*e*m##~:ffj¥*,.~

•••

^~~

J-~

1M" • • • (World Intellectual Property Organjzation, W I PO )

~ ~

• 11 *'

It Jl

{g!

ti

1f!.

jJ - ~

:t :J

~;;ty '" [f

-!

⁰ ¹⁴⁷

5.2.1

.1f.*,1~*'th~j

~ ~

90 10 fJ 25 8 ir *'

~.::. tl1!~.1f11*,~~~ ~ ~1~

iE

1411 0 •

*

^~^fJf^{~ ~t ~}

^r:J ^$l-

^JJ

^it

^~^{149 :}

146 ~~~~tmfU3fiMJm}i~HtJ~f'FfirtdlIHH~)(f~lE1j!~(m=~),

RYI

1f.

f:I '

*)(fjj 90

If

f:I

1 81~

IS

fU3fiMJmlEJ~Jlt; ⁰

147 WIPO

fi1:RII 85lf

¹²f:llit.im~

r

t!H'·fU3fiMil:fim.~1'Ffi{~~J

"& ^{r 1!t}

WfUlU:fJm.m.~iJ{"&ttk%1o/J1~~ J ~ilW!JiIl~~~

"

*)(1ft-/J\&nffl~

H.~.~~~fi~~m."&~~

• •

~.M~.~~"&MR0~

••

.

'±J!~~HI!!

' j$JJ!

^WIPOYI~~~~.JEffg ⁰

1411 ~lL~WC 90

If

10 f:I 25

8

.::.m.im~~f'Ffi~gIHH~)(JfWf~·"&~1IJI

"

149 :.lttt~lEpq~~fi!i

;

l.m=~,:t:.tlg&.m~~$:

2.m.::.+tm1~

,

1IIJffifi~f*~!UJ:mm~0!m~~~

50

^lf~.JEII~

,

~ :.lt~~-~~~A~ffMOO"&~~~50lf~~~MOO:

3·M-t::;+-1(i'

%~~~flmH~trJfffimtMJ!m~;Z~lE

:

4.MJ\+-1~

,

.lIff.;z~ffIiAlj)\1~:1JnA~f'Ffif!f1ft\ll1l

;

5.MtL+~;z-

•

#jH:lfmfiJf;z~lE

"

~rrUIl\'f'Ffi$7t~)(~lEJfOO~

"

~m~~~~~tt~~~~m-$~'.~&~~OO~~ 2~

- ..

37

~1=1t.ft.Z

*.iE

~.-.M.~~ .. ^1=~ ^{• • •}* ~~.~.' ~.~

371:.

6 Jj;hP!;A ~"'jn1

r: :

r.~.~~~.~.~~~ff.~~,~mA~m~~~

#~.~~.~

..

1t,~.m.~.~~o~.~.1t.#~

~ft~~Z.~.~,~~~~oJ~~~.37*.6~£*L

•••

~~%~#~~.*~~~~mA~.~;fi~*~A

#~OOft*~ _t#~lft*~

• • • _•••

~,#1t,*~.~m.~~~~~.~m.

• •

~m.~.~~.~

..

^~,

-t 11

¹⁵⁰⁰

=".82*.~.~

• • •

A~.~

.••

~ 1t.#~lftm

~T Jt1~m.iIl

z ••

^{~ ~l~151}⁰

~1~~~~90~10A258~~~~~~~~.~.~~

'~mn.fi~.~mm~~~~.~,n~

••

m=fi~mli.oHM~

~.m37

••

~.~m-.~mli.~~~~,m~.m~*~:r~~M

iltI~fffiftn:.AfIJm~f'F

'

jttf~fllm~f!P:~

, mlfb' ,

P1~

,

ffjm1f$!iX~

•• ' •••

.A~~~;jt~~~~~.~,m~D*ff.o

M.mfi.0m.A~~0m

••

'~~~~M.fi.A~.Mjt~~M

••

mW!iX{I}Df5Ui

^ffiB~:~'⁰

~W~ff.~.ff

•

.A~

••

~M.~.A~.'~MMjt.~W~.~{I}

f5tWm=.Af

jm

⁰

w.f5tm~.~m.Arr.f5t.~~P1'~~~~M

••

.A~f!P:ffifi~.

"p.~M

••.Arr••

f5t.~~P1'~Mfi~m~o

m=.~m~.m~'~*$.~~fiMmD~~.'1'~m~oJ

*f~.~p)JkiWmttJifi'1lm 81 fll~.~I1A~

••

f5ttl~1f1im~.A(fJ$1*J.1!1

~~f5t.Bm.~(fJ.m~~~~'~~A.ft;~*'~

••

~~~

~$.~~.$M(fJH~'~#.M~mo

lSI .~~~jj*~M-ftr'j.m~f'F~ii1Hi-~m.Jm-/j\fij'jtf.1.§jt~mfIHtlfl*Ef.Jtt

244 &*~*I¥. mi\+AM

~~~~~~*'~~~~r-~~ ~~*~~~~,~*X

;ff IJ

~ ~ ~

tt ;ff

^{152 :}

=-'~~-0-M~tffti

;if it:ft * 1l

~n ~ 23 {~.t. 1 :

r

it A .. ;ff -0- Miff ti jt:

it .t.

.~,~

• •

~~~*~*~~~~.t.oJ-0-M~tff~*~;ff~

-0-Mtff*.~.*'~A§.(~ti'.-0-~.~4jt:~~tio

~~~,ffJIJ1lfff~~~~;ff:

1.~ 3 ~~ 1 JJl~ 6 1 ~:

r-0-M1ffti:

~£M-0~*t&t1\

4A§~,~;ff.«4

• •

«~-0-~~.;if~~~'~~-0-I.

~,§.(~tff'.0~.~4jt:~~.oJ;

2. fpJ

JJl

~ 7

.t.

1 :

r X • ( iff ti : fa'

^@1

R! -0-

M- jt: 1!

Z

*~4~~ ~*,~.~.jt:~.;if~~~oJ;

3.fpJftJJ[~ 7 2~: r.~~.~: fa'.~~tf~~,

19!.-0

~O/.t.~ft~M-jt:m~~l! .t.*~4~~'~;ff.«4

• •

~it*_ J ⁰

1m ..

k

ill!

~ ~

1t ifdi #T

-*

^{~ ~}

• ; ^{e. ...}

^{f< 1ft} it -f :ft 1f-

it li *

^(Digital

~il1ennium Copyright Act)' mtJ!lJ.l~k1:r1iifA~lill!~it~1*~

~~o~;~~*~~;ff~~~~;~fpJ ~,~~ o~~

~~;.~~~ ~.*~,ffJ.ft~~r:

1..~ ~=-1!f,~-JJ[~+ 1i~~~'

rf+tt1*

#r~: ~~

.AA~kjt::ft~~~~m~m.t.#tt~*oJ;

~fpJ1!f,' ~+~~~~: ~~~tf~*~. :~m.

M-~tfmt~4 ~~~4M-~tf~-0-~~timm~X~q ~

~"~~~A'4~m

;ftf

.~4**

• •

~.~,~~

IS2 ~ff!!~iEl{l'i:±~~0M1WilfI&~ltmlE~fif*jfllJl

'

flijt'i¥~-ti7i1f~

&lI~WJt=-m

'

tti*:)(t11'~~ 0

.M.~~.~tt.~~Rm-.~·.~&~~oom~

us

AAffiM • •

~~.*~.~oJ;

1.~n.~.~

...

^~W~

^••

^~.A+~

..-..

~~&.=.~.:r~'~~~ffA*.~.~.A.~~~

~,~~ro~~~~~~~~.~

••

~*~~~~;$~~.

~~*~$

• •

~~~~~.~

• •

~*$.~~

••

^~~.

~'~~~.'~A.~.A'~~M •• ^*.~.~.A

1~~.W'1~A~~,~~oJ;

,.~n.~+=*~-:r.i~~W.~.~.~~.%

~-~'~-~~~.M~~'~~#~~~+~~~~~*:

-' ••

'.A~.*.~~m~~~#~*~~~ ~

~~~~#o

=,~~.~~m~~~#~*~~~~M~~.~oJ;

~.~n.~+=*~=:rA.~~§~~.m~~~#~

*~~~~'~-~~r.M~~'~~#~~~+~~~~~

~J m 0

5.2.2

*jc~1t~

~*jc~~~.~~~#~.~.~¥*~W~~~,.~

1~~.~.~&~mmw.1t. •• ^'~A

~~.m~~~m~~~~*~~#,*X~~~~.~.*~

~.ili~~~.'.~~~~~.~o

- , . I # • • • • • ~.~.~.~a~'~-~.=~

I~ft*'

• •

n~.~m~fi~§w.~~~~

••

ff,#ft.~.no

~A.m~§W~~.~~.;-H~

••

ff#~.fi.~~§W.~~ff

!%~~7frJ.fM~ ~1f~~RfjmttpfTij!.f'Ffi.IE1j[~, *)(~.~-~~~⁰ ⁰

~.m.~~~m~.f'F.#ft~m~.ili

••

^~A

••

^ftH~

•• ,.*

••

~*,*)(

• •

~.~IEOO

••

,R~-.~B~~*~*~~o

tt• •~*~~ftmRfj.)(fi~.m~H.o

••• ~- ~.*~. ~~~ ~. .~

-~ ~ •• ~ • • $ ~.~~~ ~.~w ~ ~~ ~~¥~~ ~~ ~.~~* ~~~~ ~~~

• ••

~~~~

••

~ ~~*~. ~,~~ ~

•••

~~ .~.~~ ~. ~~~--~~~_ W~~~ W~ ~~~.~ ~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~o~.*. ~

W _

••

lin" ~ ~ ~.

-N ...

~ ~.:m ~

,\11

~? ~W ~ ~ ~ ~~~~ ~~ ~ ~m~~~.~~.

.. -. .. ~ ~~~.~ ~ ~EW ~.. ~W~ ~ W~.~~~~ .~ ~

• ijB-\

..p\ W ~ ~

tJi(

~ ~. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ * * ~ ~ I~~* ~ .~$~ .~~~~~~~

.~ .~tJi(~m ~. ~ ~~~. ~~.~~~_~~

*-

.~.~~ ~~ ~.~W ~~~~

••

~.~

$~ ~~~~ ~. E.~.~ .. o.~~ .~ ~~ •• ~_W«* • . ~.~~~-. ~. ..~ .. ~. _ •• ~.~~ ~. _~e.~~~~ o.~.~.~ ••• ~.~~. ~. ~~*~ •• ~.~. ._I. .~_~. .. ._ ~W~~~~~ ~ !~ .~.~~~I

~.~~~.~~o;_ ~.*~~.~.~~~

.. .. ~·~~···N~ ~.~~~*~.~.~

W.W~~~W

••

OO~ .. ~tiilt~.~W~~~~~~.:tli

.:t: .. , •••

~ ~-m·N«.~_ ~ ~ ~~~.~~_life.~

• ~'tl ~ II ~ ~ •. ~ ;\i ~ ~ $

1: •

Bf2 •• ~ N ~ 1~

•

~ M ~

* 'M

.~~ ~-•• ~ ~~ ~~~.~ ~~.Bf2

* •• ~ •• ~ ~~~ ~5~~ ~.~

248 i&*i:ti*W~ ~f\+AM

~mA

• •

~."X~.M~,~m.~

• •

,~*

.~ 0~ ~$ffi.'~*~.~~~~~~'~~m~~

~~ ~*~~#~~Z~~~~~o

t#~~

• •

~mA~.~m.~ '~.~m~

•

W~Y'~W~~~~'~fiww~~

~~ ,~w~~Z.~.X~'~~~

OJo .11= it m .IJII

^{-t lA}

^{~ IIJIt}

^{i' •} ^A ^{i. tt} ¹¹

~ ~ ~I ~ ~ jf ft.~'~.~~*~~0#~.I~~.'~ ~*~.M~

W~.~

••

_'~.~.~~~~.~

••

'~.R~~~~, w~8.~f~.~~~.~~ili~o#.Ai.

• • •

~fX~

~mA ~*'OO~~~.;#~~i.tt

• •

~~~ .~1Im w~~iliA*' ~~±-t~,W

• • •

~~ ~W~~~~

.~~~ o*~ .'.R*~i..~.# ~ ,.~~

4

~MA~-~.*z~o~l~~#. ~

ft «~ ' .M~R~.~.~.-t

~~~ ~~

~'~I.~01

• • •

~~.'*~

WR

.~.

A~. ~,*~.tW~I

••

^~~~

_._._

~ml~'

• •

_._.~~~~m~~~.~w,.#~~

~#;m*~#~q~~§W~~~~_'.~J ~.~,~

M_M ••

^~~mK~,ft~

^•.

^4~I~.o~~. ^~~.

*~~.~~M.~ml~

••

~«.?*~'~~~*~«~

z ••

M~' ~ ~~*~.~~i.?*.'~ wM~?

~.~M ,~~.~q~ili?~~ft*.i§~~~D

' _ ••

ili~~,.~~m~~~ ~~~~

I • •

'X~~ ~Rff0~~~'~~~~~~ ?~

*-t.~~~ '.~W~.**~ ~

1lm~f'FEt:1~f'Ftt~~JI~ffl-$J! '*J!'&~l!iIJiRHijf~ 249

1.~

• • •

~~m~~&.~~'I~~.A'~~.~~_

d • • •

,~~*~a~~~~ ~.~o~.~4~~~~~

~ 1~* ~

Jt '

1jAfW-/~, ⁰

~'~~~~~M~~~ ~~~~~~~~~,*X~-1]\ ~ ~

itt lli

1f.l

:if

, f!P

*;{

-It ^{If it} 11

~ ~

it

lJ{

^~Jl.Jt

^'

^~IJ

~~~ftlf~.~~~.~,~~.~~.~~~oM~~.~

~-It~~~«~~~.~~

••

~~Jt~ ~.~.~ ~~~

#

~ ⁰ ~

1Ji

r,,~ ~

-It it tlif l! •

~ ~ ~

it

~:f ~ J.!J! 154 ;

-It lW l! Jk U

it

f,;

,it + .::. i!f-

.::.

~IJ

-t it M:t

⁰

~.ft~f

• •

lf~.~;{~$lJ{A.~.~~*~ ~

••

^~~

••

~ .m;~A.~.~~if.l~ m.lf~

~m:f#~~~lJ{~Jt~~,~~*~~~-It_~~.~~~

*o~ft.Jk~U~.,it+.::..~.::.~~ r~.~§~J~~~

il!tfT~~fr1~£~ ⁰

~~~m.~#~~~~~.fT~'.E~~M~~.~~

f1

^{0 ,}^Jftj^~^"^{~ jl~L~}

l!

^1@

A • t+ 1*

~ ~ ~

.&. • it 11

; iiJ

~~ ~ ~ ~

~~_'~~~.~~4'~~~~.~~~4o~~~~.fT

~~.l!$.~,~.~ml~~*.l!'&'

• • • h

.,~

~~~.,~~:t4'~$

•• -It*

^m~.A.H.o*

a

.~.~w.~m.~#~.:t~.lf~.~~.~.' ~E

••••

*.~it~;A~~I.~-It~~.~~~~lf~.

A.~~M.'~:f-lt~;{~A.~~§~o

••

^~~~.~~

It

~ ~

A 1f

~ ~f ~

fu

^jfJ

If it ' R! it 1:

* ^{M •}

^fJ

^f,,'

^{, •}

~~ml~~ ;~K_'*~~~~lf~.A.~ M.'~

~+~

•••

$lf~;~.M'~.~*~.~~.~~~i~

m ~f'Ffi~J!f{m::t~tW&~f'Fti$W&$ra'm;11~mit!OO&~Jlit!§t'Jf,Jra' ijJfJ~t'Jf,JfIJ~

,

*)(~*~~ ⁰

250 &*~¥WH"

mt\+ AWl

*

^,~#

^{• •}

^~om

^••

^~.~~~'~0~

^{• •}

^'~.ffa

1iJ

.. ,t1

^ISS⁰~ ~ ?~

-1-.. Jt J!

$I.! fI.J 1t

-i- Jl '

~ ~

r..

• fI.J

~~,~*,~*~~ ~~~

••

fI.J $~~*.'

••• I

~o~m~~#ftM~*$~£'~~*$~.~~~~~fl.JM

*'1f.~*$A#fpJ~fJ:t.Jto

ISS ~ilJiiW\fflJj:tf(t§l Ulrich Sieber {I!:JtHBJiiW\1fIJ7:tti!:~fflm!~ffAl¥Jff'BflJ

"f+'.A:l!\o-!:!'I\..<,+"

J!.ff:.Pfffi '

the International Emergence of Criminal Information Law,

1991,p.15," ...All over the world, the new legislation in the field of intangibles is still characterized by the lack of a general theory on the criminal protection of information .... " "

PI

J!fii1.il:JiiJnH'Ftl7:t~ffijfL'mflffi7:t.J:f4~~r5"I¥J~

tJl

ifm~f'F{(.J~f'Ftt~€;~1lm -.~ '~Jk·$:t1fOOliJf1l 251

t-~x*+

~~i.

I .

Africa, Mathew, Comment :

The

Misuse of Licensing Evidence in Fair Use Analysis: New Technologies, New Markets, and the Courts, California Law Review, v.88, 2000, pps.1145-.

2.AHson, Calderbank, ADAPSO Sets PC Arbitration Center, Computer Reseller News, February 4, 1991, p.20.

3.Benkler, • Yochai, Free as the Air to Common Use: First Amendment Constraints on Enclosure of the Public Domain, New York University Law Review, v.74,1999,pps.354-.

4.Biagioli, Mario, Rights or Rewards? Changing Contexts and

在文檔中資訊著作的著作性與合理使用-事理學理及法制面研究 (頁 46-69)

118 j[1if3tft ' WJfl:.>t 0

. .

~~1~ • • ~~~~*' *a~~.~~.~~~o

••

••

•••••

••

•••

••

••

••

JJl;f.JcMM

i£1tJf}1! # 0/

1t.JtIj

tr?

PJf

••

• •

•

... * ra,

{1ff rJ]

Jtj! (dialog)

1tM

••

~~-~~~~.o* •• *~. ~*W~~~'~~e ••

M• •

t~~ t~ . ' m1t.M~. o.*~.M .~~#

• • • •

••

• •

••

"

if:

614

,

"

if:

6

'

• •

• • •

eJ

•

:\it

it

t><

..

IE

tr:

• -<

.. +1

:g;

\t1'

$

WI

*' •

If m::

m::

• :g;

-<

t::\

$

:g;

:g;

¥

¥

lI\n

.. :g;

:g;

*

•

•

'M

¥

$!!

*

:#=

:#=

•

-<

~~1~ • • ~~' a..~o

... * ^ra,

^{1ff ^rJ]

^Jtj! ^(dialog)

-~~.o* •• ~. ~W~'e ••

^••

6