資訊著作的著作性與合理使用-事理 學理 及法制面研究
80
0
0
全文
(2) ~*~.~it. 184. ~"'+ AM. ~~~ma~~~~~~M~fl~o. ~.~~W,*~.~. a~~~;. ••• •• ~~. •• «#~.~~ •• **.~. ••• ••• ~*. ~~~.~~. ~.~~.. ~o.~L'.~*.~~~mm~.~.£*. ••. ~4. ... ~~~~M~'. we •• #~~~¥'~~.-~~A~~'*~~#~.~&~~. ••. ~~,. ••. ••. ... ... ~.~~~m~o*~. ~~.~~.&~. we~.~.~~,~.*~w~m~,~~~-~~m. ~~*~.~~.~,~~. ~. m. •• #~~. ~&*~~~~£~o~*. ~~M~~~'~ • • ~.~.*.~~.*&~-~.*~~., ~~*~M.~~~I~o. ... .... M•• : ••• ~'.~~'~.~m'.~~~m,.~.~,. ~.,. ,.~. ~.,#~.~.~.~~.,. .L~.~~. ~-:::. - " au. ••. a. .#~.4B~. .•. •• ~~WWM.~~ .•. ~. W~~. ~~~~~~~~~~~. ~.#~.~~~~~.~~m&~. ~. #~.~~.~.~.#,.~&. •. ~o~.~.,. 'B.A.~~*'~~A. •••• ~~.~.M~~.~*;. ~S'*.&~~~A~~~.~,~m~~~~. 1l~J1~.sp..R ~ff i.*.~-OOA~!l,1tJJl. ~.#~1tf.~~ilii't1. I. ~. •. ••. *~. . 0. *rp~J(~-1Ji*~2o f3.I~. Trotter Hardy, Project Looking Forward, Sketching the Future of. Copyright in a Networked World, Final Report, May 1998 0 .ff:mtfHftJfffFf~f:f{iiJ ~~~~'ff~~hl.~~~~ffi~A~~lli~~~~~~~nAo 2wm.~~~m~~~~&~lli.m~~~oott~~,,~~~~~ft, .mlrifk~tt~~t-f- tj~~tt~t:p{.,. , ~*tt~flitui ' v.64 ' .a:ifI 891f. 12.
(3) .m~~~~~ttw~~~m-$~·~~&$MOOM~. l~. l,*84.~.~*~8~ •• AB.~~.*Wfi.Affa lfffi!.;r-'f'#].~' ~il.~~;f111!)dI9!*. w*~!1tt.l!tl1 • •. 0. ~-f}]f§~ft-];lt,. " 1:btJ!8a~iift-]1Ta~l~3 ,.,. t¥Al {t It {± .. ft-] fff¥ rJf It ~ ft-] M~ 11 ft-] .. j!. ~t 5'~. 0. 4. 0. ~. .'.. A ' pps.297-341 : Jt~ p.305-306 , ~IJI Bezansm f!tHJ;).Fa.f*&lIU~1t&f.Mr; A~~~&I~~*o~-~M~~m®ft~.~~~~*~·~ffi~~~. ~~~~.~~*.·lli~~a~~~~~.~·~w. •••. ~m.~~~. ~~m~-.o~.~fi'WJ.~'ffi,~m~~OO~&I.~~~n-W&. *~~l!t~1fKii ~~r~~:f Simitis fj!~.~f-'H*~i~$ft~~~fj8!j:)."~~~fj"m~ , ~ Legislation and Data Protection' Council of Europe, , 1982, p.20 ' Simitis 1t 0. ". ,. ~H*~~. •• o~~~~~fj~,~m~~,.~e.,~.~&m.~. 1$' o~f'F.nOO' ~tH~rlA~W~ffEJlm~~f'Ffli~' J! Jessica Litman, Symposium: Innovation and the Information Environment: Revising Copyright Law for the Information Age, Oregon Law Review, v.75,1996, pps.190. •.. ·~m~~~~Mtt*~mtt~~~~fj~'8!~R~m~~n.~-,~. B~~tt*ft~~~'$$W~~~mM~~H~~~~~'~Wtt.~~ W~~£.*.m~£w~~~~~~~~o~$W~~~.m~@~roA. ~'ffi~~wwm~~~~~~~ft~~~~$A~~JlL&.~L~~~ ~~.n~o~¥ • • mH~ft~~ • • ~mo~~roffl~~.*~.~~ l:tJfIU¥!li:!~bti&m¥fj{Jurisprudence. and Social Policy Program) ,. lWffflfflE. '. ·tt*.'~~¥&i&fu¥~M±,.mW•• $¥~m~*¥&~~. flfT!¥fj , ~1Iifif.fJ.f.J~HI~~$~fj~-~ilj. J! California Law Review, v.79,1991112,pps.3903- , !1ft~A~- Sanford Kadish f!{ff~~1*~. ; 0. 7}' ~mfJ.f.lfgm~~¥ • • ~ft~W**' ~Linda. R. Crane, Inter Disciplinary Combined-degree and Graduate Law Degree Programs: History and Trends, John. Marshall Law Review, v.33,pps.4 7- ~ ~mj[[~~~ 711~~$ *.& $f$~~ 0. flfT,~.~~tt~$$~~m&*• • ¥Q~.~.ro,~~.~*¥~¥. ~~~~~a~.~~mM~m~~~$A~~~'~~~~~-~~A~ ~~ • • o.~Em.'*¥~¥• •8!M~W.ftA~~.OO~-~¥..
(4) ....., 186 i6t*~¥j!Jl~. ~t\+ AM. , PI IV. ~ =-71 W.. ~ : - " .iRf-1-{tt W' IiI ~f.¥j ~~~(Internet).&.ifjLI1ft t-~ (tq .xfttt~ ~I ' t- ~ 1t ~ ~ ~ IiI 1f. ~ , ~ J.t PI ~ mp3 ;1t 1lt 111 • f.;t§ 1lt 1ft t-t(Hg §. ~~~~(tq~gtt~~-;~'IiI •• (tq~~"~'-71W l: 1lt~*~ fj. mp3s*1t~~. 6. 0. ~~.~t-~~~~£~~(tq~~~'&~~.~L(tq~~~~;. ~71W~~~~~~t-~~~.~.~~,.~~~~~~~. (business. models)llth~J&' 1ti.m:;j;ft-~tl:L~.• ~. t-~L.'T. •. .&~m,_.&* • • ~. ... ; =-" Jk1i. ~.A.a. ~~. o. ~MAPIIV.. ili.. • •~'.~ili.~E(tq.~,~~m:. ~.". '&~~(tq.~~~«n~o~~m;j;f~~(tq~~~~f'. ;1t.K#tt •• ~T,~*£«(tq~J&o~*~ •• ili'II (tq~.,~*~ •••• (tq~~#~*.*~~ •• o~~.% wrrr.~~®&.j~*~~~.~·~*~. 10 J9. ~il88 5. • pps.179-213. •• ~·m~~,m-M·. 0. MP3 ~ Moving Picture Experts Group (MPEG) 1 Layer3 ~*l1.if' ~m*lif~. ~ifiitltJf*j • ;tt:~JC.'f!-lJiiiiUf~(algorithin) • tjmf.t.:.p~.:J!IVj7lt&.PtffM gctll!~rdJ • ~fl1ll{ti1f~E8~7:HI1Iif 1000sX5tlli&*l¥.;tt: 10 WL.ti1rUmm1lifIlifrm~ffij~:'p. 1 .". " :#-~ National Research Council, The Digital. Dilemma, Intellectual Property in the Information Age, National Academy. • r ~*.1:m~ m;W$f-t.~t$~'1m~~~ j 6Jf~* ~.*±~.~&t m23 M· 2001 fF: 6 . J9 • pps.53-1l6; N:~tI*, f,:£ mp3 ~$~ • •ilJWi~{tllf*Mf~**' foHl. ~.~~ , m74 M • 2001 if: 7 J9 ' pps.1l5-139" *::st:>F.N:~${tf:~~'g1l Press,2000,p.77 " ilpg~H mp3 $f-t.~M.· :#-~Ji~~~. ·. ·. ~IE1ttl:~fL'm " 2 IJ\IIif~tlUl~1Iif~tg 5000 OOsX5tlli' §WItJ&~w.::(£~~~WiJ:lfi~' fat. 6. :>Fiifff" 1. J! National Research Council WIfI::st ' p.77 ". 'PI18 mp3. :(£pg~m:{lli1f~&*l.~~m~N:WT"ilJ~i1f~i!1tl~HRrm:l:mA. OO.~~~'~~~-lJim~~~$~m'R~*X:>F~~A~.~~o.
(5) .m.w~.WttW~~~ffl-.~·.~&~~OO~ft. •.. l~. ~~~,~~m*~A~~~m.,~~~#~~~~.~~~. ~A*~.*.~~.,~~*.~~.~. ~o~K_'.. A~~~mfflR#~'~~~~m.'~.~~~~~~Wffl~. .... flJ f :f13 lDI ~ ~ • .Jl ~ JJl. t'lt 11' ' ;r-: ~ ~ ~ 8. .~.-.~**~~~. 0. ~.AM~~A •• A.~. ~·~.~#~A~~~m~n90~~.~.~~'*~A~~. ~~~m~~#«~'.~.~.~.~.A.A. ~~.. '. ~.~~~~~ •• ~~~~W~~~~~.O~ • • • ~~. r$~~M.~.~~'~. ~~'~~~m~~.~.~~~. ~~~*~O~~~#~~~.~r'~. ... •• ~.A.A.~#. ... ~1~~4 •• 'X~~.~~C~i.Om~~~#~~~. ~~WX.$_.~. :ftffiJ*~. '.~~~.~.~. ~~.~. x Thomas Bruce fj!militruWlifnEr!$W~(f:Jfilllj;j!~~~i&;jt~~(f:J-{i~ ~. 0. J!a~. Conference: The Development and Practice of Law in the Age of the. Internet, April, 12, 1996,American University Law Review, v.46, I 996, pps.327 - ,. jt:ft p.378 ' m;Pif-t~~~~(f:J{j}f~mlliif.*fRjffi~f:fI ' j;).I~:lri&m**~ f§IJ ' i~$**~~ or j;j~~il1i~Wtf3.(.1itrJ!(niJf~pfi. '. t!rr:iJ~~J!I!~Wtj{Ylf3.(.. o~$$*{j}f~m.zm#.m~$$**~~ • •trmo *~HtJ ;~;.H~H~~trm ~M Pill!::f!t~ iliJJl. Bruce pfijJI {,,$$ W~w.:iE: 8UNJ(f:J~'. ~;~~'~~**$$*m~.(f:J$$***~'.±&"±m$~~~. M~~~~m~.ili(f:J$$W~A±rr*mm~,&tt~W~~~:iE:lliOO(f:J. ~~'~~~*~~~~m~(f:J~~~m,f-t1i(f:J~.~j;j!XM~rojffi~~. {tilt-~II1¥J~f:fI. 0. : r ~f*Il$:tf1'FA~1'FtI~ , ~ffijfd:.:Z}jt.flj~ ,. , ~l1rJtIl:iE:*$ a *$*m:iE::a ' ~J'fUtf!f!.$f4!2m:iE: a J. i1t~' • • ~• • ~'~~ • • • $.~-:tf~tI$(f:JJJl.ft • • ,~.~a. , :)({l:#l*'T.iffi~~~ , :tf1'Ffi$~~~ , pps.I5-43 ; & Jessica Litman, 9. n:&glH'Fffim-~m:iE:. ~&g~~'()(11::~~. The Public Domain, Emory Law Journal, v.39,1990,965-. a.
(6) 188 ~*~*~:t. ~~+J\M. *X~~~~~~*~~~M~~~o~~~~-~,.~ ~~~~~.~~.~~,#~*mm'~* ~~1t~It~1I. 0. •• ~f~M •• ~. *X~~'~it~,l#]~~#{tJt~tJ~~*.~. *~~~~~~~~.'M~M.~Jt.~-~#]#{t~,l,W. ~**xM.~~~.~~~OO'~~~~~~Z'£*~~~. ••. .m~~#{t~~,. ,.#,.~&*m~~~o~~.~. ~~~,~~*~*x~~M*~~~#~~~~~.~~;~. J! 9t if. M1 Ml MIt pJT. *.. [!f lit. ~ ~ f:t {t ~ ~,l pJT ~I ~ ~ ~ ~ I: rl3,. ~,~~.*~,~~~&~.9t. *X •••. ••. ~~$'~M*z.o. ,~~,~~&~~~~*.~~. ••• ~.,. ~~W*~W~~'~lliw~~W*.~~#{t~¥~~*~*. J". 11J11g;i~~II1(low. authorship)' t§,liiJi'J~(co-authorship)8'!J. ~~&~~~~*~~~~#{t[!f.o~.m&'~~~~.~. ~~~~~I~~~~.*W&~~~~.~~Z~~.~~ .'.~.~*A.~MIt#~~#{t. •• ~.~~~&.~_. ~~~'$Jit~.3Ll1J1iEtfl.~~~o ~.~.~~J\.dgt~ ~~. 1tm (use)'::'.. ,. *Xil#ft.~'I1(authorship)&i. ' :it - ~~ ~. 0. :i!**~ ~-i-,l. , ~ &~ jlJ jf. ~#{t~.¥~'*~~~~~-i-,l.~,Jt*X~~~~~~' §~~7it.~.AWIt.~.~. lli**~1f.~1~iE~9tif.. •• ~~~$.~~'~~ • •. 0. lo~~.,~m~~tt~~Lr~~J~m~~~.-~wm~~~~~~. {'FIH'-*JJ.iU{JJ • .IWm.~ · v.50.· ~m 84 Sf: 2 Ji • pps.72-76 ; ~IIE~' .TWiIR~{'Fft/t'mZ~t-t ' .~ • v20 • ~m 83 Sf: 4 Ji ' pps.18-31 11 ~~.~~ • ~~~~.rR'U!J~JJ~ • WilR7*f9H!;t)T , ~m 85 Sf: 7 ~ , 0. pps.24~43 ; 'M'7(~' ~~~~tllmmtl;tJT-*~~m~W:Tm~~{'F.7*~. ~~~'-1&lWfBB. '. v.5 ' no.2 • ~m 88 ~ 9 Ji ' pps.IlO-124 ". ,.
(7) wm.~~.~tt.~.Rm-. *~~. •• ·~.&~.oom~. ~9. ••- •• ~'~#.* •• ilift~14~~~~~. _.! ••. •• ~~~o .~~~ ~~~ ••• 4~~ •• ~'~~~ ••• ~ •• ~ •• M~. ~i~~~.. ~~~~.~ ~I.'. .... *~§~~. ~~.o~M.~.~'. ... ~*~~.. •• ~~~~~ff~.~.***'.ili ••. o. ~,~~#ft~~~~~~*-~~~~~~ ~~.~.*~. •••. • • ~~¥,~~.~.*~-~#.o~~.,r*.,. m#. IV'.«'.~.'. t. #~~ • • ~~~ff'-~X-~*. ~ ,~,;;if , • • 11= •. ••• * m... ••• '~ili~' •• *.~. .:r. ft ~ ~ ~ !:. 12. it iff - iK. 0. ~~. tR *4 ~ ~ ~. ••• ~~.~ ••• ~.u,m •• M.~.&~*~-. ,~. ii,. IJ 1975 $' ~1~JJ~~8!~EfJ.&1It.llfi!.f~f'FflPlTm*Eflfti., ~JjrJ~lL7 the National Commission on New Technological Uses of Copyrighted Works, Mfilf. CONTU. 0. 1978 .1f. ' ~JHi*tJ!lllm~¥IHs. 0. ~~fIH5'~ 15 ~ , ~jl1rI@.. 1~~.W.~~.1f..*~~Efl~~fI~Efl;. 1802. N:Bt, .~J&6!fl~J(Designs. engravings, and etchings). 1831. {f~~IH!(Musical. compositions). 1856. /ti.f1181J{'F(Dramatic compositions). 1865. 00 it &~ it (Photographs and negatives). 1870. • •& +lm!(Statuary and models). 1909. Pfff'f~1!fEfl~{'F(AII. 1912. 1!~Motion. the writings of an author). pictures). 1972. iiRif~{'F(Sound. 1976. ~DjUlfl''liEfl~f'F(Original works of authorship). recordings). ~pgf'fM1tIJaf~A~~.f*M(ltimEflJt.~~ , :jt~~rfri¥i&~f-tJt:ffiiiJf , IltMHf' Wm~$(fJmg.iJf~-p)~~~$W~8!fXa1lfrj&~{'Ffi F<l'Jii~cp{..~, iI&*~¥i¥fi~ , v.56,1996, pps.239-257 ; j!jfiJl.!Hf ' United States Il. Computer Software Copyright Cases Analysis ' iI& * ~ ~ i¥fi ~ , v.47,1993,.
(8) 190 lI&*i*~Wli~. .~. ••. m~+J\WI. ~.~~A. M.tl~'~~.~m~Q. ~ •• ili~*'~.~~ •• ~.I~~.~. ~«~~~~*f~~W~~'~~~. JlJ it .'f PJf ~I ~ ~ ~ f- PJf 1[{ 11:. l! it sA • Q. ~. eE~~~. ~~~~MA~~. » ff M- ti ~1 A~ 1~ Jf1 A jQj. ~,~~~~~~~*~~~az~~~~Q~~-~~.,~. 1#*~t-' ~~:M-*$A. ~*~. ••. ~.*~JfLM1l~1t Witmark ~I:j:t,. Q. ~*~.~.~~~M.~~. .••. *. •• '~*.e~~ •. • 1: 13' 1ft ~ , ;f fi!&. ~ rfiJ ~ j'J. ili ' ~ J1l:. ;f ~ lk ~ 1t ti it .t F." J! .~#~~. ~'~;f ••. ~. ~. ••• 13'.ili~~~,. W m~~~.ft~~.~;~~~t-'~$~MA.~ ~~. ••• 13'ff*••. 'W~RM~~;f. *'~A~~rfiJ~~Ql! *jflk1~Jf1,R.Jt. ~ ~ ~J. ~~~. -. I. .A« •• ~~. ~~~~~~A~~.fli. ~~!rJ~:H!' *$A~1i~1~ili~j[1~ Witmark. * ' 1t 1# **J!-*. ~. @1 Jj[ 15. Q. *. 4i5tfft¥HHfi ' Mf~:?qaUI~ , reHlI~tx.f*~ Z m.t5Vji~ *= f1 , I~Jf;t;mffifJiffl~ , 87 if: 2 F.I ' pps.l3-39 ;fUt.-:tx.~f'Ffir,mm1!!. pps.285-310 " ~1I~. 14 0. 0. ~wmW~~~~ffiOO.~-$·~~m~.~~~±~~&~~~-~~ Wfl~-.~~~~~,~.~~~. •• &.&.~m~~~.~wmw~. ~.~~m&,~~*x~MreH~.~~±"~~'*~~~lI~~~~~. ffi~M*.~fJif*xm-6.~~~~fim3'~.**~iliA'R~ff. ~reHm fJif,HfiJrfHJf¥J: x~ Z 14. ~. ". ~'g~-M~m~1&1f~~tIHI:H*~mjJHi!il:1f~~ItBHft&f(~ '.flWJ~:ft!&. , i'&~1~im"lIflj"(for profit) , ~ Witmark & Sons v. Bamberger & Co.,291. Fed.776(D.C.N.J. 1923)" ~*,Hft~1&1itffElJ ' ~ Remick & Co., v. American Automobile Accessories Co., 5 Fed. (2d) 411 (C.C.A 6 th , 1925) •. 51 E1. Davis, Copyright and Radio, Virginia Law Review, v.16, pps.40-53, 1929 IS. ~~:?q. Jefferson 0. David Nimmer, A Riff on Fair Use in the Digital Millennium Copyright. Act, University of Pennsylvania Law Review, v.148,2000,pps.673- " ~111{r:Tm. if:~f'FfI¥*1* 1998.tt: 10 JI 28 B~*~~~ttt;f;, ~t~jfmf3}~~~f'F.fI1Jj.
(9) jfl!R¥f1FItJ¥{'FfiWir~OOm -.~ '*J1E&$mrIltiif~ 191. ~1~~.A~~mAZ*'w~. ~.~~~~~~~~. ••• ~.A*~~~#~~~~~~~~.'*. ~ I*~~-~ •• '~*~#~M#~R.~'&~.~~ •• ®'~M. ff.Jt~ ,\fj ~iW*. 0 it4f~lli. *~M~m~,~~ o~m~~.ftl~. ff.J i. 1t ms ~ ,. t •••. ~. ~~~~~~~;. •••. 0. '. {t ~ ~I )f]. lli JJl.. #~fi~.~~)f],~~~~~.. ••. ~.ft~~lJ.. ,. ~~.~ • • • • ~. ~.Jfj~.. "'~1~~~lt, 3t~F.. ,¥~)f]-.. ~.'~M~~~)f].. 0. ~~mA~~. ~. •••. W~tf {i15- ~ ~ m. $11. ~~~. paradigmic)Jtt!' ~#. 0. ~.ft~~.~~. ;.ft~~~,~~~~~.~~ ••• ~~.~.*. ~.o~~.. iit. o •• ,. ~'sX~J(*~. * ~ ~ ~ ~ §J W~. ~I mffii {t 1-' ~ ~ ~ ~ if. it. 1ft:lli m (access). ff.J.~*17. ,~.m.!'lJ. ... ~ ~ t: ~ ~. .~,.~&. ~'Hardy ~tf~lli ''t,l~IiiI~~*. )f]. ~ ~ ~l(programmable) ,. {t 1-'. ft it. ~. '3t~~*~ • • M~o.~{iA~~. •• ~.~.~~ ••• _'fi~~)f]A~m W,~~~*o~ *~.~{i •• ~~-.~~,~~*~~ i~tM~.'. ~H. ftJ'~.z-. 0. .~-~~.~ft~~~o~H~~.~~~~M,.~.*m,. 19". l:ffxf\l1tTm$~f'FfI~~Hm~. 0. , .m~. ' No.107 ' 1999, pps.25-42 Jessica Litman, The Public Domain, Emory Law Review, v.39,1990,. 16. pps.96511. 0. ,!. Jessica Litman, Innovation and the Infonnation Environment: Revising for the Infonnation Age, Oregon Law Review, v.75,1996,. pps.19- ;. ».. Jane Ginsburg, Authors and Users in Copyright, Journal of the. Copyright Society ofthe U.S.A., v.45,n.l,1997, pps.I-20. I~. Trotter Hardy Mflf1H5'. 0. 0.
(10) mt\+ Am. 192 &*i*.~!t. *.I*~.. ~. Ginsburg ~tfl;J.it. •• m••••. ~.~.~~.~lo. ~11.(low authorship)~~.. '1;1.'f. *f~J.l11:.~ , ~ JjtlM-/j'i!~rei.~~(high authorship)~ &r. 0. ~. ~J.l ~ ~if I~' ~ (romanticism)~.' ~7} 5:1 ~ -0011 (personali ty). •••• ••• ••. ~~.~.~. ~'~~~f*hx.~~~*~~~,~**. ~.A. ~. ~~~. • ~ (collaboration );tHt: ~ :!p f} Jl ~.~.*~~~. .£* ••. ,~. 0. awo*~~. ~~. l' •. ~. J.l~.~11. •. :tHt: ~;( ~ ~ J1. •• ~L~~~~Z~'~~ •• ~R*~~. %{,~20. 0. 2.1.fpJ~~ ~f}~. W'A~~Ett.~~~~~~. ~~~~~~. £~. .£ ~ l{ jfJf fJf it 21. 19. ~. 0. ~~~~. -.£~ffi*o~~~£~,. {t {I 1t L. ' *X 11 ~ ~j ~. EfH~. f}~~~. J!t ~ NJl. ; f,1. Jane Ginsburg, Creation and Commercial Value: Copyright Protection of. Works ofInformation, Columbia Law Review, v.90,1990, pps.186520. ~,. 0. ~~~~~ff' Multimedia and Its Copyright Implications,ll~df:~WfI~U!f.I&f{. tf~f;HIJ.LHJt.~)(J'f.!. '. ~l'-Mimm~~~fk~ , 1997, pps.251-278. 0. ~.. lI(multimedia);IE: !f.MtlHi*fi 3t $(hypertext)(fJf~*,~ 1iik ' mji*fi 3t$ Ai .!f!.~" ~,. B~hM±,~;IE:~7~mtB~~A~S~IWm~(fJ~h1. .&.' 21. ....J-'-"-'- ....... 90 1f:l-t ' fftt«JlI1. " .tf~.iPl.(fJtkj!fIA.1I. o~Wm~~'~~~W.~S~.W(fJS~£~ ,~~~~A~~o~~~*W(fJ~-~M~o. ~#~~~~ff' ~1!II~WHffft£~(fJt8'1fi' I~MimmJ.!.~' ~m 82 ff. 7 foj , pps.80-97 !f.M~Ii!.flJ~EI3miht~ili 'l~EI3.i~H!HIJN:(fJ~~~K& 0. (fJ~mg~.~o~~~~~~~®Wf~-~~M~~~.~o~~*~~ l~' ~~.f~Ai ~~~Wf~8Ttf~.flJffl]~ili jc:g,"IJ\.frj"®~~".jt-'FJJi". ~(fJ*~~oml~21f:~~.~~~ft~~~'~~.~£.EI3X • • ~&.
(11) wm~~~~~~W~~Rm-$~·.~&~.OOfi~. , Jift & ' fX K.. {tl FiJ 1* ~ ~ til l{. *•*'11 f61f-. ~ jf ~ {lif. M-f} ~. l~. 22. 0. M~,~~~FiJ.~1*~~~-~~~~~ •• M.~FiJ~fi.. t. ~~~.*.~~'~fi~.FiJ~.~ftft~~.4FiJ~.'. ~IA~*.~. !f.Jt.J-. 23. •• *.~~~~'~~~l •• ~.~~~.. 0. 1:. ~~~.'~.~.M~FiJ~~'~~ ••. !1h:t r. ' ~ it it IT. -~A.~'. ••. Woodmansee ~ ttl ' tt~. 0. OR ~ 1M. ~«.~ ~ ilj ~. ~. FiJ.N~£~'M~ •• 1:~.~~.~'.. »1~.,aM'I.,*.,#.a~.#.~.,e~~ rEJ ( co 11 a bo r a ti 0 n ) ~. /~. 0. ff N ~ £. ~ 24 0 ~. JJl. 4'-. «. tt tf ~ -J;o it ~ -. -f}. ;[~"t.¥4"r)dJt1#:~l!Mf)c*(hypertext).t.ra' '.:t~11:t. ~1-"_"(keystroke).t.1iii. 0. M~' lf11.ftFiJI!~W{7jf.f(j~-OO. ~~.~#g~~m'~.A.~M~~ft.~.~~.~,~mtt~.fi $~~~~~W~~Im~~.~~lli~~o. , 1£~~~mlliQlJl~.fIH*~.~¥tJWMHf:fH.~1* ~~ft$R.~m~.~$tf.J.~,ft~¥~ •• &.~OOft~.~~Uiff. 12. ~~'tilItf.Jiff~fi1§-. ~,~~m. •• ~~~.~m.$Mn.~~~tf.Jm~ftm • • ,.~.National Research Council, the Digital Dilemma, mrmX ' p228 '. Allen Newell, the Models are Broken, University of Pittsburg Law Review, 1986, pps.l023-35 , &~~fj, ~i!~f!.~' 1966-1991 ' ***' 2002 ~ 2~. Ji Martha. Woodmansee. Peter Jaszi .Jifili ' the Construction of Authorship, ~If~. 80. A X&fd.1tf4*tf.J*=tf~~JJ[1{~f'Ftt(llUthorship )rQ, 11 '. ~. Textual Appropriation in Law and Literature, 1997, Introduction, p.9 § $~ ,. tEH~m:~1'F.mwrJE'\~. 0. 0. ~}jj{B1Jtf.Jf'F&(original works of authorship)~~~~. fnit!~ 102 ~~~1'FfiHItf.Jm1'FfI!U8ttm~ !I~..t, &\~j'H!1'F&(works of gt~ 0. authorship) ~. ;fft ~~~fi}jj{SlEltt(originality)&B1H'Ftt(creativity)'rQ,a. 0. W~~tt&~f'Ftttf.J.H'~.~.~.'~~~$.'~~U~'~~fi; pps.135-. 0.
(12) mf\+ AM. 194 i&*~~fnt. A8M.~~~.m.'«.~ • • ~ • • Am.8~~ili' •. •. ~~ Jl :I~btt ffl1 ~2S. 0. Woodmansee .. ~ flJ ~ nA4 {t ~ ~ Jl i" iJp j{:t~ 11: ~ ti tiiJ ~. .. JliE1ii. 0. -~Aji;tflJ ~!tm(multimedia)v'1:t~ ~f!'l1. *' '. Ii]". ~Jlm~~'.~'IW'~*~~~~f!~~~~~'~*~. ;t j~ ~ !t g ~ ~ L 1* t.¥J ~ (network) ffl1 ~~ Jf ;;: (hi erarchi cal) M ~'~~~~~~M~~~~,~.~~~~~1i]"~~o. Dreier 1J!~ ili ' ~!t ftit 7f ~.J;JJ if. *~ Ilkl ~)fJ .*~m~~*f1l'. 1i~:tll~~~. 0. ~!t ft fJf. : (l)1'~ :fltt.f'lt. (sequential Hit f:f ~ M1f ~ ~ ~ , :ft ~~ ~ 11 (non-l i near) fY'J M:f#: ~{~, 1!1!f~.1lt)f])c~,*, 1i]"~ 8rr-W-JtJ{M.~JfiJf; (2}~. ~~ ~. .. it 1!f ~. it.ffl A ~ lftr .i lJt ~ ~ .t ; (3)lftr ~ JJf ~ -Jk ~ Jk ~!t ftJllJt ~.t. ~ ~ j§. (Internet) ~. (democratization){t-J »l.~. §.~'ti(interactivity)' ;r:1l~.fflAitJ!.*1lt~~4{1#.' ~m. A,* J;f -tt!;iif ~ \El ~ ~ ~ , 8 G~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 4{ 1#. .27. 0. ~~#~~4{1#l.§.~11{t-J~~.~'~.Ati~~f1::~ "~.W~M?.~~~lJt'§. 25. j! Woodmansee. •• ~~11:.~ •••• '.8. Mmx.,l3;;mlf on the Author Effect: Recovering Collectivity,. pps.lS-28 ; &. Jaszi. mm ' on the Author Effect: Contemporary CopYright and. Collective Creativity, pps.29-56 ". ~ Jt~~rr 1.7. '. Multimedia and Its Copyright Implications'. mrmX ". j! Thomas Dreier, Developments and Prospectives of Copyright :from. Gutenberg to Data Highways,!&~ns- Klaus Brunnstein &. Peter Paul Sint ?fiii'. ,. Intellectual Property Rights and New Technologies, Proceedings of the Know Right :95 Conference, 1995,pps.31-50" 1:&.~.~ lli:*5l:¥IJ~?!~g;t~(fJ~1Jl. ~~&.~~~~~.~,ttmH(fJ~~W~nOO'~*X~~mg;t~(fJ~~. tI&'.JMMWJ(fJtbbliill!IH'FffH".
(13) .m.~®.~tt.ft~~m-.~·.~&~~OO~~. M#.~*. •• ~~ •• *~'~. .... 1%. E• • ~~.~~~~u'R. ll~.*~~~~.~.~.~~'. ~o~~~~,~. ~~~~**A~*~~~~~~~no. .~~.#*#~.~~~.~.,. 4~.*.~._.. &~~~*'W~$~~r'**~~~. ~'m*~~~. ~J.tthhraJr3t~-.»x;fft~1m~.t.~*. ft~~~*~~. ... ••. ~~~'~~#*$~'. .... ~~~*~#**~~~A.o~. .~.~.h,. i.~ ~. 0. x~3t~. ~. ?&f+*'. x~ I~.%r'~. •• ~~1. ~'~~.~ft • • • ~ • • ~,*. o~. ••. ~~~. f~~~. (authorship)~?. {£ X~ jj 1t ~w.. •. .z r ' Pennock =m ~ f-t • ~ fI.J ti Jiil j~ ft. ~. JJl.1t:t Jt 1:[ Jfit f ~ fI.J lit 1t ~ ~ ~ # fI.J I~t % 1994 ~ fI.J 1;}. %=m tB ' ~ .1r1. ~ # *I¥J Mfll ~ , #. 37 ,I» x. 100 1:[ ~ ~ fI.J 1t ~ ; M.1f ' #J 11 MflJ ~ 1:1 140 .. » x ~ JJL 100 1ft ~ ~ fI.J ~ ~ :i! i 0. *. ,g. 0. Mario Biagioli, Rights or Rewards? Changing Contexts and Definitions. of Scientific Authorship, Journal of College and University Law, v.27, no.l, 2000, pps,83-107 ; Susan C. Borkowski and Mary Jeanne Welsh, Ethics and the Accounting Publishing Process: Author, Reviewer, and Editor Issues, Journal of Business EtItics, v.17, 1998, pps.1785-1803 ; S. Krimsky, L.S. Rothenberg, P. Stott and G. Kyle, Financial Interests of Authors in Scientific Journals: A Pilot Study of 14 Puhlications, Science and Engineering Ethics, v.2, no.4, 1996,pps.395-410 ;. J. Greco, J. Brooke Hamilton III, and John R. Tanner, Professional Standards for Joint Authorship and the Assigning of Credit for Joint Publications, Professional Ethics, v.5,no,3, 1996,pps.37-n; lit Robert T. Pennock, Inappropriate Authorship: Collaborative Science Research, Public Affairs Qurterly,v.lO,no.4, 1996,pps.379-393 .. n authorship. -*~fl=.'. ~--~~U~{lfft~. , ~it-=ff'F~!tMlllF.¥ '. ,.en~=aWH~ J:~-ftf~f'p ; ~,~jHit~f'F~fttr{lLIF.¥ff!~faJr*~. 0.
(14) 196 iI&*~.~&. ~ 1f.. ' Jllj ~ -. mf\+ J\WJ. tr J;1 1. ~ ~:t m500 1.!I J;1 1. ~ 1t:t I- ~. JO. 0. :l! ~ 11= t. ~~~.~~~1t:t~~ft,~~~-~~~o' .~-~t~1.'~~~~~-ft~1t:t,~~~ft1t:t,. ~~~~~~~~ft'$~~~1t:t,~~*~~1t:t~ft~~ ~~~r,,~;t!. 0. ~~~j(.:t(contributorship)~~1t:t,. *It. .~~~'M ••• A~ •• ~:t~ • • • • ,~~.,~.". 7t. .. ft::l;l " " .. " jf ~ iIf •. :f ~ ,. 31 0. ~ fJf 1M ~. , If 1t •. * 11 }J. ~1t~*1.~~~~~~~7t°~;ljf~~~J;1~~*~W~ ~,~.~~.*}J~~~,~~~.*~~~~~7t~:t.~ :t#~Ma1t:t'~#~M ••• :t'~~~~:f.~.o~. ~.*'~4~~ •• ~~1t,.~~1tR~~.+a~~.i. ••• ~1t~*1.~£*~.o.M,.~~1t~._1*$' ~ If 11= 'fi r,,~ ;t! ~ :t # Greco •• % 1-. r,,~~~~~ M*':it. r,,~~~~# Iii] ~ft: ~~~I~~~.W~o~m~-fJf**~.A~~, •• ~t .~fi~~ ~ ~*.~ ~.~mJ;1 •• M.~~ ~.ilinoJ;1 ... ~~a$.@4:t~:it.~~.~,~~m~1 0. •• •••. ••. ~~~*~A~A1t:t~~~~~~~'~:f-~o*~A~A. 11=:t1l '. .~#~ ~ ~:t. 15. 1:.. ~. tQ. :t. ~. jt .t1t~~:t fJf f1fi ~. 92.8% ; ~. it. ~. 1.. ~. "it • (conceptual. JO. ~. 31. J! Robert T. Pennock,ifrjtl:st ' &. Mario Biagioli ifrjm)(. Robert T. Pennock,ifrjtl)( , pps.379-380. MflJtm. Fa' 25%3}11 50%:t '. 0. , p95-. 0. ±jl!(flg~. the Journal of the American Medical Association, Lancet, Annals of. Internal Medicine, British Medical Journal, &. American Journal of Public Health. JSj ~ ~~ mt)::f IIlJ ~ J3it (fl jf II: ~ (contributorship) ~ {~{t ~ (authorship) (fl-n ~ 32. , J! Mario Biagioli ifrjm:st ' p.96 J! Anthory J. Greco ~ifrjtl:st ' p.41 0. 0.
(15) .1R~f'F(t-J~f'Ff:l:W~3!i!flm -$3!i! '¥3!i!liU*fiiJiliHvf~. 197. butions)' 1591.7%0 Jit.*-' ~Jl-#~~~#:~_5fl.:WIJ' 7t~L~jf~jt.(15 87.1%)'" _fHift(data manipulation)(15 81. ' &)t-#:t1l (15 78.4%) o~.f #~ ~ ~ #: ~lj7i- 'lit: .i fl!jj~,t(ma'jor editorial revision)(15 67.4%)'" j{'t7t~»)(f)f ~~M 25W) T(15 66.9%)'" bt)(.~ifiJ(15 59.0%)33 0 l!Jjifm~~ ~~~. ••• a.' •• *K~.~~~ •• ~~.'.~+7i-. ~lo. • • _~#~.m.bt' •• ~ •• ~.~*B i.~'~~~~.Aili4~4 • • ~.~.ft • • ,*• • • ~.~~,. ~@~M*'~*BA~~0.4.~.~.~~bt.~~~. ~·~~~~~~~.~.~I~Aog.~%~.~*~,~ ~~.~~~~.~.~,.#~~.~.. :W~~~'~A.. 1~~~~.o.~.*~.~~~.*~l!Jji~.~N~. •. •. «~~~.~~'~~*)(T-.:WI.~~bt.ft.*~#. Al!.7i-it.. ~f~~7i-~fm~.~.7i-.40£*~,*)(. ~I~.~bt •• ~.~.-~#~.h~.o. ~.~ttAfLl:~il. 2.2 ~. *.~~~~-~#~~*.. ~~~~~~.~~. ... ~o~~$~.,it)t-~#~.~.A~~*~ili~~~~~bt. ~~*~. ~~.,~~*)(-~~#~~. ~ntt~ft~it.. *•••. ;K. ~.Jit. •• ~-.o.~~~. ttf*f Privacy Enhancing Technologies' ~~~. r",. '.. AA"~ PET)it_~lltfJ,... •• ~-.Mol~ •• ~.~_~#~~~.A'~0.. 11. 5! Anthory J. Greco ~iW#t)(: ' pps.58-59. J4. ~~~~fT ' iURlIlfktlri;Jlf"Uq-- P)'~lJilHliir:p{., • i&:ki*¥lJiil". 0. ffJ.
(16) 198 i&*7!*ft\~. m~+ AM. ~~*~nz4'E~~~~,~~§~.q •• ~~A~~*o .m*~«. ••. ~.#OO. ••••. A~ •• o~ • • ~@1. ... .a~M~~~*#~«.~~&o~.4.ft~~~~o/'m. ~.m.~~M*'~.~*.~.~~. •• •• *.~. ~.~~~~.~. '~~4 • • ft.~~«.*~.~*.o~1. ~~'~~~~~$.~*~~*~~~~*~. ~-~~~. .,~~.~.«.~.~.~~~~*~«.o.~~'fi~. .~.Am~*~.~.~.. (circumvent). «.~~~~~~. 0. ... ~I.~.**. 1998 ~tr;t~.1ft~f-t.~.~1t$!. tr 1. (Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998)35, :!t! .fi~~. 1201. ~.«.J~~.;t'~lA~~.£~*ft. (interoperabi 1ity ) fJf 1tk ~ ~ JtiJ.:r. {i (reverse engineering) , ~ l«.~~~$.'~.*~i. •• , ••• a •••• A~~. •• ft.~~~.*~-&.~.~*·'.m~~MA~*~~ ~ ttt£$lHltm (access)~.~.« • • 1f ~~.#f~J7. 0. ~.m~'~~.~.~.~.«.J~~.~.m'~1 ~*~~.~.A.~mA~~~~~~;fi~~#~~~~. M'#~~ff~o~~tr~~I.~.*~~~*~II~~t. M' ~1iJ 89 ~ 12 fo.l • pps.297-, jtJt~)(ffMj(~f3.j.ttiIDf*liI.f.Uf]~:tJ· ' JIjfL'em ' ~1l1998 ~flW:1l:::'fm1f?§1'Ffi7!~Im1f ' • [il7!~ , no,107,19991f 10 fo.l ' 19991f 10 J1 ' pps.25-42. 64 3S. ~7!$)(fDj1f. 0. • iWJI 17. uses. 1201(d)-(i). a. ~~~.m.U!!mA{J)mJtjIBf*~2mJE. ' :ttm. ~1E~:aJl1t"f9t.!9tffli5t ' 1.I;FJtt:TJimJE*~1'~1I JI Marshall Leaffer, The Uncertain Future of Fair Use in a Global Infonnation Marketplace, Ohio State 0. Law Journal, v.62, pps.849- , jtJt p.857-858 37. 0. "No person shall circumvent it technological measure that effectively controls. access to a work protected under the title. 0. ... JI 17 uses 1201 (a)(I )(A). 0.
(17) .m.~~.~a~~~~m-.~·.~&~.oo.~ l~. ~ fri -tt (librarian) 1'£ t,t~fM.k~. *#] 1t. ... ~.:t. r ' 4t -=-1f ~. ill #C. •• ~.~.J.~~. #].~~mA#]. 110 {t ffii. #~~ • • • ,~.~~ • • ~{t#].~~m~f •• ·o*~r. -1~1 ••• ~ •• ~~m#].~,.~ •• *~-'ti.,. ,.#].. *1~~~~ •• ~.~.J.'~-~~'~l'£~~~-'~ ~t 1~;f11o{lAlt~. r.. ~£1l. 0. AA ~ (encryption) :Jt 11:. ~3J- ~ t: t: ~ ~ • • --lJ. ~ #;: gorithm) 0/ #] -1l1 t: t: 1Jt § £ * .1 :Jt Li1 - -00 r~ A • ~ pri vatekey )39, ~ -1l1 r~ A. ~li -1l1 #. ~ (pUbl ic key)40 , ~#AA~#].ft.~- •• A-1l1.~#]lJ..#;:'*~ •• ~#] Ifi.~.*o.~m •• ~~'~Li1~- • • lilJ.~#;: •• o .~~.~ •• ~.~.~.#]£1lo.~tt.#].m.m~. f~'~ •• ~~~.'_~.~*.'_~~#~.~~ 0. *.·~.;»~~. ••. li.~.,~m*MNo. ;f~{tfiJf1l:.(copyright. ..'. management information)"?§". .~a*~$.~.~.~.,mLi1~:Jtaft1l:.~~t:~.~. &'~Af~.ft~~.1f.~.#;:~~~.G'~.-'l.#] ~lo;f~.T~1I:.~ •• ~.~'~.li~~~1I:.'.~. 18. ~~ 5't. 17 USCS 1201 (a)(l)(B)-(E). 0. ~HiI$If;t~f'Fiim~}fHfJlR~. , t1Jm..t. ,.~m.Mfi~m~f'F,a~ftaS~m~~.~·~.iim~. m~~rr~.~~§~~.~~~~.~,m. ••~~.~.o.~~-~. ~~~0:f!I!~m~iMMu '. &.. Marshall Leaffer , frIm3t • -{OOM~~1itEH~{m=f:e.1: • ~=f:~iliiffijpx ' ~jqJ'M'J!~A.~~kIt~f; ~(password)o .Ut*!t~i*f;~J! ' ttttifJ\ml~{iJ.; ~ J! National Research 0. Council r,fjf~~~ , appendix E. 0. ", 1t-T~lit.(electronic signature)f!p!*m-{l~A ' -fl0::tHI~~il1t{iJ.;J7J.t 'I. " 17. National Research Council. uses 1202. 0. frItlfIli!f ' p.283-284. 0. 0.
(18) 200 a*~*fli~. .A&~~~ m.~. ~~. mf::+ AWl. ••. ,~&.~~m~·#···~~··&~t. ••oofi~~~M#t&tm~~* '~~~4~~ofi~ ••• ~~mw~~~~'~mt. ... ~t.~I~~4. ~.*~.~~~~. ~&~.~;f~.ft~l~. ~.~~~«~%,~~~W~~~~. 0. ;f~.~._.~~.ti. *". **. ••. ~,§.~£*~ml~.:. (1)llCm~~;k:~*(centralized source of access)' ~P1~JfJA. .R ~ {£. 1J ~#l{ ti (connected) MI Z. r ' ;f ~ 1~JfJ t. ~ ; (2).ft!#J1t-(digital object)~ jj~~'1Jb'I~·.~~J!t~~~1t. -~.~*ft~.~_M~,.~m • • g~A~M~~!~#. .1 Pjf ffi" • it- Z (proprietarY. 1t m_ M I*J ~ .•• ; (3) ~ {Ill ~ A viewer) J/lj:It - :!V ~ ~j M ~ 1i ~ • • ' !W Jl:. 00 ~:t ~. , ;f. ltffi:. fltlt. Jt ~ 1~m jj ~. ~. , ~ 3tll1'l!Md~ .::. ~. ; (4) /}( ~p (watermark). ~{£ • • • ~.l~.-~~.g~~~,~~.~. $Y*,;f~~A~~~~. .~flt~~. •• ~M{£~fi~~mA~M~~~o. 2.3/}Jt" Goldstein ~ffti tl:l ' 1: T ~ #](electronic contract)45Ji!~. 1ft ~ ~ (encryption).,I" 1f~:It. *. ~ ~. ~. & ~ ~ (l:ftJ Z 1~ ~. uses 1202(c)" ffJ! Trotter Hardy, iWmfliH!:r ' pps.13-14 " 4~~iW~~m~~~fl ••• AttmL~ • • ~~~,,~~.~~m~ilim IHhHfJ'*M~f.J'(shrinkWTap contract) , ~~~h!:(£~Jln~\~$'G~~::tm.p"l m:m(access)~~f'F~1I " ~f'F.1fjljjlm.1'~*fl!mA$'G['iiJ~::tmt~m~ .~W'ffi~mA~B~m~W'~~wm~~®.w~1fjlj.m~® •• ~~*~mA'~ • • ~.~~f.J®-~'~~~®~m~:(£~~~~fl~. 43. 17. 44. m.~W.~zd'&~.®~*~~".
(19) ... .mit:f'Ftf-J~f'Ff.£Jii~m1l!m -$m ,~m&i£t1JiIiHiJf~ 201. _~~~~«~~. ~~~. •• ~.~o~.~~~. ~m. .,~. ~~~~~~~~.~.~-.~.*?~. ~~$. $,~~~~Am~~~~#~.~~~. ~m~~~;~«~. * it (expression) *11 M-lt ~ ~t. ~ it,R ,!,!!!, (idea);f. :t 1* ~,. ~.~OO~.~.. ~~oaft.~~~~~~.ftllt~.o. - • • k~.:t.~.1* •• fr~~.1* ••. ~Q~'~*. 1,~*.~;f.k;f:tlt~.1* •• ~~~~1*.~.o~. t~. ~~#~~.*~.~~;~-fiW**~.~~~.~. ,.r rp~~ ~~,. Goldstein :;t'ttf~~.lt. ~ ~ ~ ~ aft. ~i{itli3(~~*(transaction cost), 3t;f)t. ~:t:f«'. ~~*. 'iii. 13 IiJ {~. 0. 0. ~£~~M-.+~~~~'.~.. Fh ~JL ~ Frl7 W- Jt ~. *4 '#. .i. j)[ 46. aS~*m~~~. 0. ..•• ••. • • #~fi • • • • • M~~~,~.m~o~~~. ,~.*.~~*~~.~.~*.~.,~*. ;.~.*. ~.~*'*~~.*'.*.*.~~~~~ l~I*J-~.~~~. ~. o~. ~'~M-~ •• ~~lt~~.~,~. ~M.~.~~~.:t*.~~~£*.1*.'~*~~~~. ~~.~.*1*~~. ~,~~*~~~. *~.l~.~~.~o~1 M~3t~~~lt~ -1~ 1~ ~ ~. ~ ~. 46. •. ~. ~ 47. *.~~~. f*~.~~~. ~.~ •• #,lt«~~. ~~. ~~«ll*J. 0. 5i Paul Goldstein, Copyright and its Substitutes, the Kastenmeier Lecture,. Wisconsin Law Review, 1997, pps.86547. ~~~. •• ••. 0. 5i Religious Technology Center v. Netcom On-line Communication Service,. Inc., 923 F. Supp.1231(• •1$1N.tA.~~~.~.ffJ)Cftft!Vl.N(f~)i6~~~, .nft~. .l)J1t~j , i*~1Jl7jClttff~il&~.~{'Ff.I ' "=f P)3iru~). 0. .nft~~~~ Tiffany. Trunko, Note:. Remedies for Copyright Infringement: Respecting the First.
(20) 202. D&*l't.~. m"'+ AWJ. ~~.-~~. •• ~.~'.~~-~.H'~~$*~i. _.I'~.~-~.AH.o*~~-.*. 1t 11 (authorship) It 1} J! 1t)fJ r,,~ _ J: ' J! ";)!ff~lJt', ~lt')fiiJ~~m.. ~. -. •• ~._.~.. ~ ~:ffr:It. iii. ~. f. 0. -=- ' )f lIt.:i-1t 69 :i-ff:'li. ~~~ 1t m W*~~~.~fr~,~~~)fJ~_#~~_,~#lt~~. tft~~.~~~ ~~~. •. .. ••• ' •• ~.J!' ••. 1t)fJJ:~~~~. A~*~~.~~~o*~.~.~.;)!~.~. •••. .. ~.~,.~~~:It~~.~.~.~.~~.~.~~~. £_M~'.A.. :~. • • _.~~.~11~_ol*-. ... ~~.-~~.~.~.I-.~~~.~~~'~.-.~. ~1}J!1t)fJ~_0:It~.~_~~:ffr~*.~ ~-.*J!iiJ~~:ffr'Mffi~. ••. o. .~~~_#~. Amendment, Columbia Law Review, v.89, 1989,. ~~~. pps.1940-,(::t5ii*}EffW.~. ~1J;f , ll!l!::mti1P{l!lfOWJt(non-injunctive relief)(fJ1fm ' J:J.~i"~"'~1*1ij (fJ~~gHEl!:~:f:IHtt!fi: ,jt:.t(::(fI*~';fHI~(necessity)' f1X1!r!iffl(misuse):1f {'F.:!OCl$'&:S~frj~(fJmff3;zT). ; Alfred Yen, Internet Service Provider. Liability for Subscriber Copyright Infringement, Enterprise Liability, and the First Amendment, Georgetown Law Journal, v.88, 2000, pps.1833-; Yochai Benkler, Free as the Air to Common Use: First Amendment Constraints on Enclosure of the Public Domain, New York University Law Review, v.74,1999,pps.354- ; Mark Lemley .& Eugene Volokh, J;reedom of Speech and Injunction in Intellectual Property Cases, Duke Law Journal, vA8, 1998, pps.147- : Note :Clarifying the Copyright Misuse Defense: the Role of Antirust Standards and First Amendment values, Harvard Law Review,v.1 04, 1991,pps.1289- ; lk. Stephen Zimmermann, A Regulatory Theory of Copyright: Avoiding a First Amendment Conflict, Emory Law Journal, v.35, 1986,pps.163-. o·.
(21) .m.~~.~tt.~.~m-. •.·•.. ~,~'W4*~#.o •• ~£* ••• ~~~.»~~~.~~~. ... 0. ~ it ~ ~ ~ ~ .. ~. t!1. *•• -~ •• ~.'. .'o,~~~.~~~~. ~~~~.*;~.~'. it ~Hf. ~§~~A~.'~. , it:J ~ r,,~ H! Bi '# ~. ~'~K~'~~~.~.~.fr*~'~.A ;%. 091*". 0. l!.rJi r,,~ H! '!~ ~ ~. ~,~~~~;flit. &~.oo~~ ~3. *. ~P;f f!J3. •• *. •••• ~ 8 ~. Jf. ~W~.~.. lit ~. ~ 'ti (authorship) ~. ~~oW~.~.~~~*~.~o/'~~. mA~~~m~K~XM~?~.~'.~.~.~~!- •• ~~m'~Jf~~~~H!~' -~~±'t-*~~~~, 1FiiJ!J!,W~. *~~. ••. •• ~.~~.~.~OOo. 0. '~.~.~A.W~~~~.~~'~.~~. ~~~o*~~~*~~~~.~~A~'~~*~.~H!~~. tt 09 j.lJl. ; T' -. ,~.::1f. 00 It. ;%~~~~-~.~'W~ ••• OO~~~~~~Z~'~. ~. *••• I. ~ ~IJ!if. • JfJ ~ {law maki ng) ffJ ~ ~ ,. ~~~~.~*~. ~.~~~m~H!'~~~A~.. *~&.~~~j{.?. 3.1 ;f~1t *~~*. ~~.,w.~.. A.M~~~~'WA. 4f49 ,. ~ .·1)~ ~J 'ti- ~P ~~. a~ • •mm~~~. ili'.~~~A~.~~~. fl~~*lJl.~~ • • ~~.#~ffJ.~. #'. ~;ft ~~A gt~ ffJ .'!f ; 2) A ~.;fIt!. •• m;.~m~#'~~~~'$•• 'M~mm.. T~#tt~,~~~®~~~~~~~m~~~ff®li~~lli~.o 49. §UM~f.:F •• ~{'F.$MaJ. • 1992,P.21 lItJli ' 0. llIH'F~~f'F{I1.lJ!Ml1'~jJ[J. '~~.W~~Ml~mfi~r~WJ.~.~.$~mM~r~WJo.. =M~W'. ••• ~'~ •• ~;1'~~~m~~fi~·lIt=.~~*~~. °H~~W.$.~. ••- ••-.W~.W.:. ".~~¥,~~,.
(22) 204 i&*7*.1ll~. ~Hf. ; }k 3»)iL t;,{. jJ~+ AWl. *JJl11:. 4f11~Hi}k ~#=tt. =-. .~~;f 11: ~.t l. a. :liljftjtll~~~;f~:t' ~J!.1t I)~~Jtt;. 2).t-ft1tz-;t 7f*~; 3)JlM-J~>" rt:f' f$ti~,t;tt1i:ftJfe:tIl ~H¥;}k 4)tJ, ~f ;f ~ 1* ~ Z ~ 11: SO a ,ll~JH! # !* llt. IN l-14 ' ;r l! ~~ ~ :J{ Jj t 11: 'f*. l-14 £*J:. ' ;f11:tt(authorship)1±~ ~;f~{ljidt#t"f ' :ttfl. ~ ;$'~ (originality)}k ~J 1f: 11 (creati vity )52; ~ ~;if 11: {I '* ff;J tf. .~«;f1f:.Jj.AA.z.~, •• :J{.A~"°llt.*,*~J:. 1~:f4f.;f~11~~~~~ •• ft'~~~11:~;f1f:~ff;J.~ ~. 51. a. ~:f:t~~.#.Z.o~.tt'-.~.~~~~11:'.#1 1iA'~AJ!.1t.~~~~1f:~£oW~~~~~*.~~ff;J~. .1i:ijlC1tff!!~~~lIIzJltlf'r·. ". !J1'~ P).¥1iielllruUi:::J!!i!i3C1it '. ~.{L:.{Pl. fi~ • • ~~~Q~~'*~~ • • ~~~.:J!!~Q~~'~.~*~~. 1¥J~~o. SO 51. 52. ~ilUI"(#. , ~~fI~~ , 2001 ' pps.83-86 ". ~.fl)Hm ' .~fI~~ , 1999, m':::'n& ' pps.135-165 ". J1tBl{~.~.W'J~~~*'f ' ~lfWIfI. ' pps.136-137 0. "~H~m_I¥J~~&AMl¥Jfi~~.~~.~~~~.~'.~.~.'. 1996, pps.22-23 ; &g~ijb , .~fI*"l¥Jz. lUfJi: ' ~IJ 75 if:" ~1J~IjP)'~~~:lJf£±*H ' ~.~fI~nUt~fI¥ttU ' M$. ~liI.~flt!t;If*,Wc~ifJi:'. ~~I~mg~tt~~~.fffi~:ijlCfi.M~,~&~m*~mA"mz.. *~~~~.~.~M~fll'~"m®~mI¥JMtt,=.~.~.o.2M. ~flt!ffilJl¥J § l¥J!!ntE~*=.".H~EItJ*,jL1:.l¥Jm{!'li(optimal. point) " .~ Paul. Goldstein' Cases and Materials on the Law of Intellectual Property' 3rd ed. '. 1990, pps.I-2 " tE~~~I¥J.~fI{'Rift~ , ~~.fftlt!~*~1m.ffAm. fll¥J ~;ft: , ® f~ Pl1t ff!! ~ tr1f*!!tit • ff A MIi ' • ~ Goldstein iW fl. '. pps.742-759 ~j8t$~~*~Ri5ft~liI&t!~I¥J-D11l ' ~.~IJ.ffttff.~. 0. l¥J~liI".
(23) .m.~~.~tt~ft~~m-.~·~~&~.OOfi~ W5. 3E.lI.JlJl1t4f1mAfiGJ;Jj#fi4f S4o. 1fit1i~, _ff~A~Ji~:fiP11=m,. .~mM~'. $11. tf.j~.. •• ~.~~~A •• ~~~~11= • • *' •••. '. /F 1f.(" *'1 {izti -f ~\ MU!ll!At~. 'jf .~ss. 0. fftlt. 1f • • ~K.~~~.'~~~~*~.~.'I*lt1t{i*. IOO~4~z.'*.£W.o • • 11=.*• • ~.I~lt1t. 1. :t ~ ... ' :!w;ft ,!.• it ~ .::. ~ (the dichotomy of idea and. *. *. expression)J;1alt1t.1f:~~.. ~ ~ It ,t ;y I. *. Learned Hand. *. ~ fa'. 0. ttl ' • ,!.• It ~ ::. ft' ~~~~~-1m#~(ad hoc)1m~~j}c~S6o Jaszi ~I!-~fa' tB ' ~ m:lt 1'1=:. ~ ~ /F (incoherent)Zit ' ~.1iS1 M-.lt if tl ~ ~~'.fl ~ -It 11= fi (authorship) , ~~ JC (,f-lJ. MJt;t ft PJf. .iLl.. ~. '-IfiJXiijc54HtJf-~IJ~fa'~. Ii.,. *. *. o. 5~ ~~~~fF~wIf!~. , p.21. &2WHmOOm. ' pps.139-141 ' fl'Hfjj{EfJttz. ~~~~.Z~ijo*x~m~~M~~~m&~~~W~~~~~~'.~ ~·m~. •• ~.&.mk'0~MM~~m., • •fjj{~tt• • Att~~. ~·~.~m+~~~~~.5~&X~ • • o~.~*x~.~~fio 55. P~UJ~~i5r. r ~!¥~~mfjj{~1J J. ~"~m~. , ~.tEm~-, ~=P~1'FfI£*~. ~~~~~1'Fti0fgMft. ' 1im~l~H~ffi' 1997 fF: 12 fJ *xMi51 Ei2WBm 'p.I37-141 ~~~::g*~ll Holmes' fr 1903 fF: Bleistein v. Donaldson 0. 0. Lithographing Co., (1&8 U.S. 239)-~,*,1J!~~~llLlfr,!Jj{EUf1~J!lfl:~ EifJG. W~~ •• 'ffWR~~.~.~A'fr1'FW-.~ • • ~&.~X~~~ JJ~j~rl'f1rQ'I'Dmfii~~~~JIim¥' ~m1tlft~/h§.~IYHm~RJJt(the narrowest. and most obvious limits)J~HLH~~~. 0. ~-It~/h§'~lJlifi~~fjj{ElJttR.z. ~~'~.~fJG~~1'F.~m9~ml~m3~:~~&~mZ~~,::g~,. 'fl~,~m'f!Jfffi~m¥Mo '6. jl Nichols v. Universal Pictures Corp.,45 F.2d 119, 121(1930) 'Mm.~.~B, ~~. 0. ~~f.f~~'m. ••• ,m+li.o. Peter Jaszi. Toward a Theory of Copyright: the Metamorphoses of. "Authorship", Duke Law Journal, 1991, pps,455-448. 0.
(24) 206 J.f*~.~&. •••. ~:f\+ AM. ~.*~-.~t ~.~#~~*~. •• ~*.'.AA •• ~.~.t~. ••. oM4.~B~.~.~~~*,. ~~+~~~~~t~~o-~W'#*~~~~-~~~~. (discovery)ill..t. ' ffii ~F t~ ~ ~ tHt ~ #.if j!t ; jj - ~ W '. 'tit tf #;It. i!t.w.~tq~4t(author of the world) , A~~*A'AJt.t~~jJ ~~4f' J.f#~~(enlightenment).t.f!{, t~1iJtW:580. ~ffii'~~. A~~M •• #ffii~~~~g'~~A.~.. ~~~~~~~*~~.t.~o~~~~.r. ••• #~~4t~~. •••••. -.~.W~~.'~~~E~.4~~E~A~o. ~. J71t t (genius) ~ {OO A PJf t~:it ~ itt jf:t. (romanticism) I~'~' ~ .. tf. A ~. (possessi ve indi vidualism) Iii] ~. At ' ~ Iii]:fl if .1~-.*~~.~.~. •• o~~l*~*.~~~fi~'. .~.~~~.A.~#~~~~~~~~'ill~l~~L£* ill.J5~kJ.o. *.-~Mm~_~. i'J it ~ I~' ~. ;. •• ~.~"*L§.l~A**.. 1£1. • .t. #I [£ lit ~. ~t~.«o~if..£*. ..... (communal )60. *~~~.~.~. 0. •• ~1iJtW:,.~~.~~£* OO~.~~~~.*ffii •• ~~. 4 ' ,R ~.1t 11* ~ 9)f;e~, ~ ~«t-t~ Jk 58. ~~. {I if. ' # a. .~~~.11:.~~~#.~~~. ~'.A.**~A~~.'~ ~ ff ~. 1:. fiT ~ (der i vat i ve ) •. ~ ~ J.. 0. Yen 'fltlJ ill. *. Martha Woodmansee, the Genius and the Copyright: Economic and Legal. Conditions of the Emergence of the "Author", Eighteen-Century Studies, v.17,. No.4, 1984, pps.425-448 ". ~ Woodmansee ~iEm~!il18 ' 19 t!t*cff~XA ,f§'AJk.fIj*f,IHf:l3lf~~~. ~ffiH~f§'~,§~ • • ~~n.~.~§.~.Qgn,~rem.M_xo 60. ~~Jessica Litm~. M_x ' Public Domain' Jk Peter Jaszi M_x. 0.
(25) wm~f'F(fJ~l'FM:Wft}ljHl!m -$m! '*m!Hd~lfjIJOOjijf~ 207. *'~.*~~~.~#. ••. +~~~A~~o~.*~-~M.. ... ; JktA.~Af*~ I~rt.*~ ••• ~.~# +~~lt~ . . . . . . . ~. ~o ~*~-~ ~«~ •••• '~.~.~K.lt •• H mp3'. tit*~. ... ~~lt.iR#4t'::'jjiii!.$~?~. ••. 11'ffl*$jlt.~. 0. ;f ~1t (authorship)iiJ ~ tit;ij ~ iii!.$. 0. -. ~. iii!;t {t 1'f ~ *. ~ili.'.~.~-~.H.~~~~~.~~.~;t~Jkto». - 17 tm '. *. ;f 1'f 11-tl!. liT ~ cl1 ~~ ~ I~' ~ PJf ISft;f (fixation) ~ ~ B. (tangible objects)«$~. 0. ~.. 1f~$iL::t*rhJ*m.;f1f'li. '. ~~~~~'ffi~~~~~~~~.o~%~,;f~11~~~~. ~,::t*~~~~~o.cl1~~. .. ~*~;t~~~~~f~;f~,. .. ... •• ~~~ •• QoJkt.~~~ili;f~11;t;f~.*~.~~£ .~ •• '~8~.A~f*H'~.f~*.~# •• ~ •• o J~.~~~iii! •• ~.~~.~a ~ 11_.*;f~. ~. ~~~IE:Jt°. ~*~.A.iR#4t~~~iii!_+~.~~fAftM;f~. ~1~.~ •••• ,~ •• ~~.*~.jj~~IiT~.~~~. ffli ~F tk~, $;. 0. -,.!. J;).. r. it #. ~;f 1f (joint authorship) ~. tilt '. ~~~. 0. .i.l #~;f~. Alfred Yen, the Interdisciplinary Future of Copyright Theory, J&~tt. rfT£iUfHle ' pps.159(,2 ~".i¥J~mt~!ltfh~mfllJl ' *)(::fti~A~m ., ::f~ , ~~l!!!~ifr ' ~ fiJII¥~~1!t1t-J Dworkin itl!!!~ , tt.E\: 19861f:JiJT~ Law's Empire ' 1J!j;) Woodmansee"& Jaszi. 0. [if'{interpretation)jH14~~~HI~. 0. Dworkin ~~~ff~-1j{lB::"It-J$~". m~~~It-JIW.~~~~.lB::"~.ffi~mD~!lt'~~ • • It-J.m.~. m.111 ~~ ',~l$~ IlJJiElt W~ l! JiE~.lB::"It-JJt~l! ffiJ1l!~m ., ~~ Dworkin, Law's Empire, 1986, ~=Iit. 0.
(26) 208 i3c*:i!.iW~. ... m~+ AM. ~l.-.~.#. fl.~~.~~~. ... *' ••••. ~~.~.~mBA.~'.~.M~~~~ili«;~*'.~. *••. ~H.lo.W.~.*~~~.*'#M.~~~.BM. ~~o.W'-fl~~~.~~~~~~~~~o/'~~~.l ~~.~W;~fl~'#~.~~~~ ••• ~~.$L~~~. *.-~. ••. .. ... '~W#~~~~. ~.~.~-o*~. ~. ••• ~.~.o/'~*.~~ § • • ~L~.H~-~~;~. •• ~~~.~I*T- •• ~.Ho ~~.~.~~8~~~:r~A~L#M%~~.~'~~. A~.~,~~~.~m.'A~~.~oJ~~». ••ffA'. .~A.~A.~~*~~~ho~A#M%~.~'~~11 .~#M%~.~~'~+.~. •• ?- •• A~~.~No~~. •• #M.~~~~A'.~~.~*.. ~*~~~~~.~. ~A-~.~~~~?#M%~~~MM~,~q~#M.~A. ~~~~?#~.~A~.~.~~fi**I#M.~~mL~. ~~~~~M.ff~~.~,~~*.~om~~~~~~.~l. o~A~~wmtt~~~&m*~.2~~.~~~~llE~~~~~~~ ~~e·.~~~.·~rfta~fl.J.K~. ••~~~m-••~••. • • ~ • • • • • • • • 2.ff· • • ~*~~.+-M,1~.. pps.213-227 • jt~ pps.217-21S fta~ flJ.~mpqYl!lfllm~• .t..l'FfJ~. iW • *:>Cf-fI'i ff,)tfCm~ ,HJT N .~.EfJjjft, ",HI., p.231 J1t9f.. mj9j~~ S61f:a.t.~. 763 ~*,mc'. 0. 0. 0. mW~~.~~.~ff~:.=A~.t.~~m~;.m~2~ff~~N~;. &•• ~~.-2.~'B.~MmAm~.~~~~Moo~m~2~mo .~.~jft,n~.,~w·JIt~~~.~w~~• • • ~ • • m~w·m. N~~m~-~~~.~2.~,~.*xJlt~~.K~~m.~~~~.. ~~m 65. ' Jifiilmflft. 0. I. J1tI!pn-fl'i.t-tmlJilttIH'F~~ij j!t~ EJ ~«*Mffl.x~.M.rl:l'm. ~ fXliIlH'F~~. 19 f5i~IE~~.~Am~2rr~. 0. :•. 40 ~2 1 ~1E~liiJ.
(27) .m~~~~~ttW~~~ffl-$~·.~&~.oo~~ W9. ~~~~~~.~m,~~~~~~~~o. ~~~~~*~~#~~~~:r#~~~~m~ft~Lz~ ~~~~~~~~~.~~~~*~.~~X*# 67. 0. ffm. ~ m~ jt. P.i 1i: l! flJ •. J0. ~- ~~~. ~ft~~~. 11 ~ , ~;&:# ~ ~ it. A~#~.~~.~P.i~M.~,.aL~.~~-a~o.~#. ~~~~-~~~W#~~~*~~~o~~.fim..~~~~. r~~~f111.*. ' -t~:t~ (). 3.2 ~Jf 1tJtl ~~~m~~-~~~.*~~~W~~~~~~~~~o. ~~~~~.~.~.~~~~~-~~.*£*~~~~~ _'~.-~.~~;~*'~~Ma~~~a. •• w~~~~,. ~~~~m~~~£~'ili~~~~~~a.~aZ~~~*~ ~-*~~~X~,~~.~~ft~~w~~~~~~~.*~. lfl1.Jo -.fi~~~.m.~M'.~~~~.~.~~~~.Z ~. •• ~.~~~~~~~.m~:#«~~~A '·~iL1±lt.tjHf~ £1lL~ rJfrsttw mtt;f~#ti~~.. ~.;M~~. ~iJ1t. ~~M. 0. •• ~ff~;.~ • •~~~.~M •• ~M.,mm~.~mfiM. ~f$i~~.~ttf})\mfiM~fJlo 67 17 USC 101, " ... A "joint work" is a work prepared by two or more authors with the intention that their contributions be merged into inseparable or interdependent parts of a unitary whole ... " 68. ~:!q. 0. Rochelle Cooper Dreyfuss, Collaborative Research: Conflicts on. Authorship, Ownership, and Accountability, Vanderbilt Law Review, v.53, 2000, pps.1l62';; &. Mary LaFrance, Authorship, Dominance, and the Captive. Collaborator: Preserving the Rights of Joint Authors, Emory Law Review, v.50, 2001 ,pps. 193·. 0.
(28) 210 i31:*iE*iW~. m~+ AJIJl. *.~~+~~m~~~~ili .~.,~.~+~~m.~ ~.;#.~~~~~~. ••. .. .... •• ~.£.o#.~~~ •• * ~.~~. ~~I."l. ,~~.«*m.m~m~.~,. .~~~.m.~~.M.~'. ••• •• ~. ~~~#.~~~. .M~~.~o~~+~~m~~~.~~.~~m#~.&,. ..•• .... .-~M~~~~$~~~~o .~a~~. ~.,.~. *1~~.&~.~. ~-.~*. '4~.~.. ••. ~~.,. ~.~~~.~.~M. ~.~~~o~~~~~~~T".~~~~~~~~~~n~ W~&~#. •• ~.ff·,~ •••• ~ ••. o.~~.A~m,. x~&~A~$~~~'.~.A~~~~ff~~M~.mo~~. 69. ~1i~f'FfI$~ 61 1~Htii:". : r .tt~iflJlJ~ ,. fiE~ffHi&m ' ~~§'x:fd:fr. L~.~mZ~~,~m~~~IJlJ~'fiE~Mtt§.X:m.~~~~0~~~o ffi~itlYrf~gf.tt~:fr~~~1:W ' ~1fJltIIR. 0. J. 0. ~ 62 f~m)E. : r i&m§.X:ffi:ft. L~0~ • • ·.~~~&~*§.X:~n~H0~~~'ff~A~~m~offi. • •M)EA~ • • ~~~'~~~~~~W1:W'~~~WMBflA~~.oJ Jlt=.~m~m~m)EWft • • • h~ID~&~~.~ffH'~W.-~~. fl!.5&LI¥J.~&iff~. 0. Jlt9l- ' ~m~m-M~U~UmL.PJT~Jt®~f'F11m ' ifF. ~~ • • ~WIDft • • • h.~~.~~H~o.~~~.~~H~I¥J. ~. ,. ~.~~. Neil Weinstock Netanel, Copyright and a Democratic Civil Society, .. Yale LawJournal,v.l06, 1996,pps.283-: Jlt9l-' i))\ff~1:Wm~~§m~0~~ :JI:l±\ff • ~~~f'FtI$D!.t)JI*rJ(regulatory)I¥J$fl!~~ , rm~F-.lJi*,U$M Bftif¥lIal¥JfL.$ 0 ~~ Stephen Zimmermann, A Regulatory Theory of Copyright: Avoiding A First Amendment Conflict, Emory Law Journal, v.35, 1986, pps,16370. ~~. 0. Dirk Visser .~ftpi;J~J:'!f.fmz~M' ~.fX:..PJT~, Copyright Exemption. Old and New: Learning from Old Media Experiences,J&il~ Bernt Hugenholtz pIT ~. , The Future of Copyright in a Digital Environment, 1995, pps.49-56,. pps.49.50 -t§1i~WfI.§t§~$~" ' 1955 ~~tII~fB.$$~fl!f'Fl±\fIA 0. {Wi ffl ifF~JH1.l¥JtlJi*. 0. 1965 ~TI:$m)Em J:'!NWl~~11f~pi;Jft AETB 5t.lt.
(29) fllR~f'F{rtJ~f'FtiW~Jl1fm -$JI '~JI&~ftlIJWif~ 211. ~i~~~~MA~A~~~AzOO~~~~~~~~~~~~ X~+~~lo.~.~~.~~~~~.~&.~.,. •• ~. ~.A~~~A~&=*OO~~.'~.~.~o.~~~.~ $~~ • • ~.~~&~~~~~~~~w~~o~*e~IM. *ftJ =f 1f. r.. ~ ~ J! 1~ ~ ' ;!I! , ~. wIt #. 71. 0. Ginsburg ttit*.~~~~1t~=1I1~~; -~~)fJA-'~ 5~. f 'ti ~ 1~~ (consumpti ve use) ; -. ~ 1~~. Ajtl ~ ltfii tt.:t. t:p J'JT ~. .z.. :tIl ~ ':, ~~*1t ~~ (transformative use)72 hi It 1M NJ ~ 11 ~ , #It " 't ~ " Ii JIll ~ ~ ;It ~ f ~ 11k ~ ~ it A • ~ , Jl f'&. tl,. ~q~m~. 0. -. •• «1MB.~.~~ •• ~ •• '.fi.«~~~. it: 51 }f] ~ ~~~- 1tf41t~)fJ. 0. f41t11~)fJ. -. hi~:(f It. 1M t~ ~ ltfii. "{t 'ti ~Jf] 1~ q!J.it A~ ~ ~ ~1t ~ ~ ml ' t(.,~jtj~*.~~-~1;} *x~;f Ginsburg ~it~1t~ ,. l~. 0/ ~!m fl!!.A~ ~ ~ tt ~ ,. 0. *~~~)fJ~. •• m~~~~~Jf] ••. '1tm.Ho.f'&'.~. • .:t.oo~~. -.~~~~X.~~-~~~~1t,m~~~m~. ~ml1tJ!.~#~11' 1t;.:r~~jt~ ffJ~{'F • • flJ~ ~. 0. 1985 if:J!~.ttt~JlJE.*3&~BS'ft- ' S~~~~Jattl Davies, Gillian, Copyright and the Public Interest, 1994, 1t~ pps.llS-132 0. 0. 0. .~~H.{'F.ft.Rm~~{'F,~.~.~g,.{'F.~~ft.Rm. ~IJ;zliifJe. '. 'Itlli!iri:r*¥~~liifJeJiJTtt±~)(. m~{'F.~ft_Rm;z~!1E. ;l;1I!~~. '. , ~118S if: 7 fj. , no.102 , 1998 if: 12 fj , pps.S7-8S ;. ;Mi"i3f3J.jt@~f.fft.Rm~fJa:'W** ' ~fI fj flJ. 10 WI 12. '. pps.539-S70. ; ~.~ , ~. ' mSI If ~ m. 0. J! Jane Ginsburg" Authors and Users in Copyright, Journal of the Copyright. Society of-the U.S.A., v.4S, no.l, 1997, pps.I-20 .{tRm(transformative use) 0. ~W. •• ~.&&;Z~m, • • ~., • •~)(,~n, • • • •ftRmo. *)(f:£~11~. , ••• {tRm. ' .~.~ , ft.RmwH1!)(. ~-M~llt1mll!mlJl;zliil~@~ r:t~¥. '. m18 Jf}J , pps.223-249. 0. 0. ~.;jj. , ~M~. 0. .t. ~I'~.j{fjf*~. ,r ~I~.J ;zliifJe '.
(30) 212 a*~.'Ht. m~+f\~. 3.2.1 ~tt~~ftt1'tJfJ mftt1'tJfJ~A~tt'~~~~R1'tmA~~tt.~1'tm~. ••• ~ •• ~-~.H.~_~ ~1'tJfJ,~~~~.~o~ttt1'tmm •• ~,~~~~~ttA ~ {t ~ .1'tJfl ~ 1'tJfJ ~ ~# ~J ~. J: o.rB ~ tt JiJf it jt t± 't j;a ~ •• ~~~.~,~mA~~1'tJfJ~A tt~~~.t,~~~ .~~1'tmA.~.~RK4~~~ •. o~*,~.~~tt~~ tt~~~~~~.~~~.'. ~~~~'~~.~~lli~~~tt*~~~~J~~~~A§~ ~J. m~ jfS ~. ; iJlJ:!t11 ~ tt ~ -1# I~'. ... ~. tt JiJf •• ~ •• . R ~ tt 5! i!. E1 m~jm ~~#4Ji~(pub1ic domain)jfS~7J .~.tt{t*~E1.*~.~ •• ,a~tt{t*.~»~§ f& * 1:fc II-' ~ {t ~J ' ~F 3L * iif 1'£ ;t f~ ~ E1 1960 5f.1~ I;l. *- ~ pt if .~~*~R ••• ft~ • • ~'~A-~W~~,ttA~tt. § 1#~~. 0. * ,. A.~.~.~Jfluo.l~a1'tJflA.~~tt~~~1'tmx.£. *~~-1J!tr~(equity)~~~1tJer. 1'f ~ 'it. .. if m~ 1( •. 1976. 5f..I~tt{t*. 'm. •• ,~1'tm~m~.~ ... ~1't J: I;l. R1't mff ~ 1'f jf ~ rjr ~ Jj 1175. .~~~.~lli~1J!~~~~. m. 0. *. 0. ~~~tt{t*.65~'£*~.~.I*~~£'~~.65~. •• JiJftt~.~'~.~~3L*~~ • • O~M.1#~~1'tJfJ~er~A~.~~*~'-1~.tt •• · 1;l..#ff4.~~1'tm. ~~~-jdtit. 0. .1.tt•• ~~~~£,I;l.*~~~~~~I;l.R*~1'tJfl =~.~. Om~*~£*~~AWK~tt.*~~~£,~~. 14. J! Jessica Litman, Public Domain iWtI::i:: J! Davis, Gillian iWmIJ ' pps.1l5-132. 75. 17 U.S.C 107 ,,~~~f'l:tli!m 65 U~Jl1fm ffl!A~f'F((;]~JIlfitP.*mf'F((.J. 73. 0. 0. 0. ~~,~m~~o~~~~.~'~~~f'I:.i!~Jl1fmzm~'iWm::i::°.
(31) JnRlff'Faglff'F11Wil~~m -.~ '.~&~*'1iMif~ 213. ~~*.*. ••. ~*~~~~~.~.~~~~~~m~.~. ~'ffifflj;r-:ltft1r~1tm~~{t#£~7t{Jf' It-~~lt16o Leval. *'t t£ *~. 1990 ~ 1~ ~ Jllli ~ f41t ~m (transformati ve use) *'1. ••. ~.~~~M~. ,#• • •. *. 77 ,. ,~~-~.*~-~7t. m~$.~ft*~~g~~@~'~~$ • • ft*,.~,a~&~~~. ®~*~m ~m. •• ,.~mWH~o~~$.~m&$~OO~@.'~.~~. rt••~(law economics)&$.t¥J.~7Hff(economic analysis oflaw)fl~. $~~.~&$.~$tt$.&.~.ft~mftt¥J~.o$ • • ~t¥J$.~ ~rr~~~~$~.~~~-~Z~'ill~~~~$~~~t¥Jm~'$ • •. ~~r)lt*BiIi Posner $'g.$~.••~~f5l DWorkin zfmt¥JiBllt ' itff.£{-t~. 0. Ronald Dworkin, Is wealth a Value, Journal of Legal Studies, v.9, no.2, pps.191-226 &~~1&~~ Coleman, Jules. Lange, Jeffrey ,1ifTi; Law and Economlcs,I992, rai)(.m1&~t¥JIUM$.J[ti(fJ~~iBt¥JpfH-t~f'F ~liI$ 0. ~~.~~~~~~.t¥JM~~~,m~~~~ft'.~~~.~liI~k. ~$(fJm~ilIim. pps.35-7S. 0. '. 1&~~~~ft ' $~px.$!t41t-$.iflRfiff~ , 1999 '. gtifmlff'Fflft~~mt¥J.~ , $.~.~(fJiB~1J;tt~t±~m. ~:Rif(market faiJure)~~.:lL~1Hi;~1Iffij~ft~~mt¥J~.. 0. t±illRlff'F. .~m.~&~~~.ffij • • m.~.~~~,ft~~m~~~~~tt?~. ::if David Nimmer, A Riff on Fair Use in the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, University of Pennsylvania Law Review, v.148, 2000, pps.673- ; Mathew Africa, Comment: The Misuse of Licensing Evidence in Fair Use Analysis: New Technologies, New Markets, and the Courts, California Law Review, v.88, 2000, pps.114S- ; Maureen Ryan, Fair Use and Academic Expression: Rhetoric, Reality, and Restriction on Academic Freedom, Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy, v.8, 1999, ppsS41- ; Stephen Mcjohn, Fair Use and Privatization in Copyright, San Di('go Law Review, v,3S, 1998, pps.61-. 0. *)(~Hlff'F.ft~fl!mt¥J$.~~. ~ftm,~~#~~,~m.fi~~lff'Fzft~~m-~mrm.~~~.J. !Ji! 77. rm.~.J z~fni. ' .!MJfd:f4.~. , v.14, 2000, pps.87-130. 0. .w. Pierre Leval, Toward a Fair Use Standard, Harvard Law Review, v.103, 1990,. pps.1l0S-. 0. fi~lJIfJrjmfni)( • P)'&~2"~. Mt~)(',' i])\~~.. 0. , fniWT~f'FfI$ft~~mzm~ •.
(32) ~t\+ i\.JIJJ. 214 St7i::~¥If.. ~o. •• ~.~.~k~~.~ •• '#.'•• o A~~ ~~m~ •• '#~ • • fi~k~ft~. ~ • • ~~~M~, ~. ~~.~oft~.~.~k~ ~~,. ••. «~~~.~. •• ~.~ •• 3.~~~:r.. s~m~m.~.'~k~ft.IM. ~~m.~,.~mA.*~fi. .... .'~~~ft.M~. ~m.. ~,~.~~~~~~z~*~n~~m*M~.~oJo. .~.~~.-.~~'A~ .~~,~. •• m#~.~~~~~.M.~~~m'~~M~. •• oR.~E~4~*. ~. ~~.~I~.~~~. ~#~~.&~9~~.ft.~·a. g~m~x~w~'~.#~. M• • • ~*~'~. •••. ~~~. ~~m*. ~.~~. .~.~.~~~.~~'*RA~I~~. 7S. ~~. •• ~fiw~~&. ••. ••••. ~~m. ~~. •• N,~. Martin Schippan, Purchase and Licensing of Digital Rights; the VERDI. Project and the Clearing of Multimedia Rights in Europe, European Intellectual Property Review,. 2000~. Issue I, pps.24-29; '& Herman Cohen Jehoram, The. Future of Copyright CoUecting Societies, European Intellectual Property Review, 2{)Ol~. Issue 3, pps.134-139 ; Thomas Hoeren, An Assessment of long-term. Solutions in the Context of Copyright and Electronic Delivery Services and Multimedia Products, 1995; '& Charles Clark, An Investigation of Current Practices with Contractual Arrangements and Copyright Clearing Services, 1995 ~:iJjlmltft.1tp fl'lIIflt'fJiM&' ~~ Micheal Rutner, Note: the ASCAP 0. Licensing Model and the Internet: A Potential Solution to High-Tech Copyright Infringement, Boston College Law Review, v.39, 1998, pps.I061-; '& Alan Kabat,. '. Proposal for a Worldwide tntemet Collecting Society. =. Mark Twain and Samuel. Johnson Licenses, Journal of the Copyright Society of the U.S.A., vAS, no.3, 1998, pps.329-353 ftil.HmAifHtpftflIfttf.Jmi!.f.f**it*$M.~~~ ff~~~. 79. 0. ,. 11:;f6 ~$~.±(t;Jif1i:f'J:W1lf1tUUJ ". ~~ Mark Stefik, lbe Internet Edge, Social, Technical, and Legal Challenges.
(33) j!URlf1'F!'f:Jlff'FttJ!~~~m -$~ '.~&$$fHiHiJf~ 215. ~M~~~m~. •...•. •• om.A.Ae~~~~~~~m.~,~. ~*.~~~~m.~. A£_'#~ •• ~M~~~. ~~~~~~~~.~.'~~~~~lli#~ •• ~~~$~~. m«~~**~~W.~A. 3.2.2 . •• W~~~'.~.«o. f1::~*1t'tt~m. ••• ~.1 *,~~~m_~~~~_,.~m~$~~f1::_~f1:: •• ~. .~~m~m~_~mf~~m'~_~1~. m'. 5/. ~ftg.A~if;t1. '. ~lf~i- J:.~~.~ , ~1t~~~~. 1m ~ It ~ , ~ 1 ~I mA~ 1f ff: ~ :ft ~I m$ ft£ ~ lit M,itt rl2~.* ~I A.$1t ttA ra, # ~~ ~~n-tM ~~, ~E. ; iTO til M ,t. ~. ' m. ~~lo~~~*1t*~m.~.~~I*~m$~'~N. •• '. ~~JJ.~;ft1io. $It,,_1M ' "1tft~m (transformative use)~~.;t-~~ [@ Leva! )i ~ .~lf ft£ 11 ~ it!: ~ ~ ~ 1~'1.!t , t ~ 1990 ~ ~'1)i. t¥~(Harvard. l. ~ :I!~~m80. Law Review)J:.~;ft. -f};ft{t, j(.~.;t-:f1!!:ft~1I. 0. , ~tt~ ~ 11 flL~fo.,t:l! ~Jl A ~I mIlo. ll?& Leval. ~f~~1i~m~~~~m.~~)i~1fM~~~~m~.J:.~ ~~ {7}~ -t1l. 12 , *~.A Leval. )i ~ "1tft~m ~},f: J'llj. , .*~. for a Networked World, 1999, jt~ p.97 0 f'F~Mc~iM~f1f!~~:tm~mfJtP.«(fair use license)(f-J1:flt ' 80. pps.79-106. 0. Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music Inc., 114 S.Ct.l164(1994). 1W±~x 81. J!ffrHI. '. ' pps.248-253. 5e. Jeremy Kudon,. 0. ~;JjJf~1JJ. ' iJrUI. 0. Note: Form over Function: Explaining the Transformative. Use Test for Fair Use, Boston University Law Review, v.80, 2000, pps.579- , pps. 597 ' JX~~m~~jfiJfn'{ttE{l!mil1iM1:fltffif ' :t:~mltft &2. .:1t:Jt. 0. ~ 7 Kudon M.xii-,~;Jj Lloyd L. Weinreb, Fair's Fair. A Comment on the. Fair Use Doctrine, Harvard Law Review, v.103, 1990, pps.1 I37-,("ft~mM.fiM ~~1'JiJOOif ' 13.f{::tj·:ltJJJflj(utilitarian)~* ' ~1§1tftf!.1Ji!1flfF&x1tmll(f-J.
(34) .,.. ~*it-~~&. 216. -~. MR+AM. -~~~~~-~~~~,~~. :l!j~. ~.~~-. ~. ' 1t{~lt-~~A. Leval ~. t. ~ J.t. r}f ~ t' ~;ttl:it Yfi th (intellectual. acti vity )$-t-~ {ij' 1. (deri vati ve) ~:fflS7t 't.l1l ~~~;~. ... ~,. creative. ~ ~ jlj ~ I~' 1!!,. ~~Yfith~~~~~~~~'ll_~.'~~"~ ~.# • • ~~~ • • H.~~_.~o~.~~t'l. ~,». M•••• ~~~~~.:itYfitho+~~m~~.J*~ •• ~ 11 ~ J: ~ t:- ~ ~IJ : 1).11:. ~f 11 .& ik Jt ' ~.& ~ {~L~, ; & 2) .~~m~~. ... *. :fflS7t,~~.~1I*. :it 'Ii Yfi jJp.~.1( ~ *l Jt ~. 1f;. +. 1~. ~ ~ J: ~ 1m 1m ~... ~,~~.&.. :. 1) ~ m~ § ~ •. *. 11:~'1i1(; 3)1~m~1(.I:'& 4){~}fJ~tt1~Jfl.. it it ~ rtf.<r& J: ~ ~ • 0/ ' Le val ~",~. •• OO. 0. m~J J}f J: -. 2)tt1~}fJ. *. ~. t. ~ J.t 1t Jfl ~. 13 ~ •. ~ 'K ~ ~ I~'. -~.ttA.«o.~~~m~#.~Jfl~1f~-~. ~~"~~;~~Z'~~~~~'~*++~~Jfl~t:-. • it. ~. (quote) ~. 1tJl(*-~1~Jfl ~ ~ ~ ~ (productive) , ~. ~. (repackage) ~ ~jJtHit.. 0. +. *. & § {Ig r}f j. JJl. ~ fiil ~ ~ • (Ig ~ -t- 11 ~ * ill AA. (republish) ~. IiA ~ it 11 ~ i!. ~ it 1~}fJ 0. ~1~Jfl~'J.ft~iJl11tit(value added)' ~~.:fflS7tr*J. ~ 11: J.t .. tt (raw material) , #~!iJ 1~ .. .. mA (Ig :trJ11: ~ it ~ if j- iR "~,. if~~(new aesthetics)" if5f.iI. Jt (insights) '~if understandings) ~ $ 7t ' ~ ~ t 11 i- {Ig )( it ~ MiSS o::lt ~. 0)0 Leval ~'§ §. 1997. pps.1449-. ". M-(new ~11-t~. I ='. cr-JJiM' ~~ Fair Use, Rescued. UCLA Law Review. v.44,. 0. ~. Ji Pierre Levat, Toward a Fair Use Standard, ",H»x ' p.1I09. 84. fQliJrjtt. pps.1l1l-l1l7. 85. & ~I Jfl. 0. 0. .'1.
(35) jnR=I=f"Ff-J=I=f'Ftl:~~J:!IHlm -$]1 ,.]I.&$l!iImiHijf~ 217. , ~Hf:Ii! {i'& jll fF fit 1.~Mo+~~m~~~'~M~~.A •• rfI •• ~~~.fF ~~*~o.~**m~.~'E~~ •• ,~~*.fitA~~ ~ Hubniann. ft ttl jlJif ~ ~ M~ , rfI ~~ fF ~ ~. lifF*~~£~~+~*m~.~*o. ••• R, •• Leval :Ii: 't f~ ttl ' tlp *~ + t41t 'ti ~:f * ' ftm 4f ~ ~ {ff •• •• ~~_~.~**m.~~~8.-'~.. ~. 0. -9J1. ~~*m. ;~'&*m. fFA.~~~'~.~. 1,~.*mA*.tifF~. ifF~~~fF*. .fF~.. •• 4f,~~.fit.~**mvo ••. •• ~.~*'~~~'&~M.rfI~~**m~. ~m,*.ttl+~*m~~~,~~#~-'*.o**~. A. .~**m~4~~.*.RA.fF.:Ii:+~*m~.'~~A !fi~;!~~jt.. 3.3. 0. IJ' ~ .fF*'&+~*m.*a~.fF.:li:L~_~~.~'~.. •• ~*~m.o ••• ifF~A,*mA'&~#~a_.~lo •• fF*~.~*.' *~E~.~M# ••• M~W.~fF4f~ft_~.*~~.o m#tt~ • • ~'X~.1~.fF*~. ~t~~,&~~#ttEa*~'&~'&'~~~~~~.~IfF~. ~~.~'~~. ••••• ~.fF#tt~~.~u'fF4f~.fF~. ~g¥~'.~~~~fi~'~~~~o 87. !OJ iWtto. 88. l[1m•. .lVJthb~arH'F(Computer Supported C~llaborated .Work,. ~ ~~gt.IHbHt(Association. .liHt't-J!M~. ,. of Computing Machinery, ACM)fl. 5;EM~m*~fi~fr. proceedings/s~ries/cscw. 0. t1Ilf¥1 CSCW). '. miJf~1Il. m~~ www.acm.org/pubslcontents/.
(36) 218 J!l*~*lW~. ~~+J\WJ. •• ~.**~.~~~-~I~ ••• ,a •• 4~oM~, ;?iiLffF1!(authorship)j:.~~--OO •• JE~~*~"~;. t!:.**. .00m~~~~~fF~~~~~~~~~'~~~*~.~*.. *. 11 *JJtt: ~ Jfj ~ , :t 1!J-1;A J{Ij *90. Ginsburg. ~Uf!lj}~f11~)fJ.*,{tt1~. Wi jJ 00 IiiJ IJf- j]rJ 5~ 1i1f ~ lk. W ' .1f it1}~1tmffr11f'. ... ... 0. m,q.~~~~~~j}~'Mffr1.~~~'IiiJ~~OO~.~~. .~11~~-~~.~'.~*~*~~*.Wo~~~~-. ~~~~~. ~~A.~#~~~~~.~. ~~?~~4. q*.-OOA.~X.~1}~~mW?~.~.~1}~~m~., ~.~ •• ~~1}~~~.~.~ •• n'.~~.A~«o. ~~~~~*~~~-m.*~.~~~M~~~,~~~.ft~~W~ft. ~li~.~~'~~~-~N.*~.~~'fi.ili~~~~'.~.W·. ili~~&~m~~·tt~§M~g~o. ••~M~~~~m@~~~~m~~~,~*~~~~. *•••~.$~.~.$ •••ft••~~~m~m,&.ili$$Afttt ~mLfl£~~&~~.'.~~m~$$,.~W$~ •• ~~$.m~ 9O*xM~~~~. fllifd:fr'§MflJtE~niIijo. Kabat OO&f.:t~~~~~.{'Ftiftjlft!l[m ASCAP & BMI Jtl!iMf1t':='W:fjj;\. tr.~1f.t§l • •(licensing fee)ilflm{J£~.Jf~.{'F~t§lfifl*rJ ' }it:±~f[;. ~~mA••~~~m~~*'~~~~fl-*.Mfi • • ~~.W~~ .. • Ji.Ef:.PIT.MtlX ' :1tJt p.334 & p.345. 92 Franklin 'H1T~if1*gfj{f-tf.l~.~fi$$&~lRij{f-t~r~.f*~m4i f& ' .&:!tlJtlRi!t~MI:f:H1Jfi~ 1J m~px~j{f-t~~.:r-~l1fjfifrJ(sui generis right) , 1JJ1~Hi!~:rJHIf!lslE1'!H:EfuJ{§lf1Ji- ' HP1i~f.fIN;f;t E! 0;f:t:fi~~jff4~1F rB.i~L(f-Jf[jm Franklin ~1E~m:lJ{m~.~ll:*:fIfljm(extraction).Mfrlffl 91. 0. 0. (reutilization)t¥Jm~";tt1JlJIN~0;f:t:fi~jfm~~*, jft.:t~.~~~,~jitt~. .M•• ,mm1JlJ.~~~;~*,~~~ •••••~j{m~~~~m:fj :tt!Jlf'F '. ~fili. • ~7*.fllm~1Ji- ' ~nMR*1m~INf4 ~ftil1*:fIflJm0;f:t: 0. fi~j{mffif:l!ifd:frpx~ ~~jC~1mWlli:m~sf:tj{m "0:Jt:frJf.itL~'t~Htt. *'. 1'~1':mm. 0. ~~. .J1:PIT. ' Facing Facts: the Database Protection Dilemma,.
(37) 'ilm~f'F£t-J~f'Ftt~€i"~ffJ'IJ-$~ '.~'&i!8iI1mH'f~ 219. _it 'it 1t}fj rB. ~ Le val. *1'.$ J!- *J! X. It if *. ••• J!-• •. ,i{ 1;. ~:it 1ft. •• ~£ ~o~g • • ~.«~.~.*W~fl7~*~A.M •• ~M~ ,~~~'~'*~. «.7mW.l~~. ~~~~~7~~W~O~~~~7#~W~~~'.~~*~ ~'*fA~~&~#~~&~~~~~~~~~Q~~ft~~ ~~~~~.~~~~~~~~~&~+. tf. ,{!!~#~~>jt~. Gasaway ~~~ ill. ~~~~W~,~.. 0. ' it Je ~. ~~ijill1!itJe~*#ft,. *~ &;:.. -00 $ ~ {t{§ 1m #] rll'~ : 1). 1ttt*1!l£ 0/ [1:l!" .it(perform)94JX;~. mii '. Laura Gasaway Growing Pains: Adapting Copyright for Libraries, Educatio~, and Society, 1997, pps.85-108, 7t~ p.91 JJz.. pps.94-95 " Iltr~~atj:r)( ~.'. ••~~.~'.M.~$.~~,~~~rem.' ••M••£*. , 1999, pps.65-169 " ••~~ftmfi.M~~~M~:~.$ ••M•••~~'.~$ •. rQ'~iifF~. •. M.~~a'~JJz...W.~.M0~'.W~~~JJz...~ • • ~~$.". c+.n.~~~~. •• M~~-*m.'~B'0~~~.*~ • • •. ~·.R.~.M.~~.ft.mffl~**~.~.+.M.*.,m~. ~.M.~W~.~~~a,~ft~.~0~~~~~~.~" Ilt~i-,.:lf mmH~t¥J¥!f3Lt¥!1f:.te~U~. Lexis $ • •+ fi*4.ifflW.d:U. .~~~)(.*$.Mfl'~~$ • • M.-H~~.1f:M.m.~m~~ l:UJHJ7i~-Ifl.{tf:. ' :ff/f*,UJ~~{:f{iiJ~~W.d:mfl ' /fJi.~Bi:mftOOi~#!t$ Lexis .~.M.' ~$'Cmj;)"~I~t¥J.*$.Mfll' lJ)\/flIff~" ¥!Bi:.\l'i {llfEll3.~,Ilt1~~ , -HfIlA~1Bf1.~.M~~~~..tt¥Jmjft¥Jr~~a, Bf& (~m. ~~~m.o.~fI~g~m$gJJz..$.t¥J.A~~'.M/f3.". f:&t1I'Laura Gasaway' ~1:iIQi!llI!fJ¥!1:t 1995 ¥ll19981f:~rmJiX~ 72%, j[£{fJ 1,700 *~~~~~ 54,000 ~..t(online)~~ , ~~t¥J¥!1:.~ft 160 14A Jif. ,Impasse: Distance Learning and Copyright, Ohio State Law Journal, v.62, 2001, l>ps~783- , 7t~ p.784 tIG~i!llI!fJ*t¥J~~lf7;:i5C ' &if.:?5l*fffifflfi ' PJc~1~llI!fJ*~rRr<l~Ji'lH~iM ' W;& , ~m 89 6 F1 ' no.396 94 1lt.~~.~.$m 101 f~~)Eil : To "perform" a work means to recite, g3. 0. *w.. 0. 0.
(38) "" 220 i&*1*~Wli~. Mf\+ AM. ;;F(display)'ftAt:1f: ; 2)7t-f}ft# ~2Jt*~*1. ; lk. 3)1Il:f tr; Jt it Ie ft * * I ~ lIt ~ 1999 if ~ {i! ~ 1f: ;f( foJ 1t it ~ 1ft "7. JR.. ~. 95. 0. 1f:;f(*~~~,~it~~*~1f:;f(.~~ff~~~~lli~. .,m~~~~~~~~~~.-~o~~~Jt~1f:~~~lli~ ~.*;;F~~%'~~it~ft*~*1.~w~ ~~1f:~~~~~~~ ~~~~. ~m~#,~~~. t:1f:M~;f(o. 1f:;f(~.lk.. 1f:;f(A~~~~~~~~.ft~~. ~~mr~~'~~.~~~. ~ft*t:1f:~~~~m~~2Jt~. .~~ft*'~~&~*1.~~~~w~L~#*I~~~2Jt~ .~~~~o~~.. ••. o.. .~*1.;A.1.~~~itle2Jt. ~. ~~m~~~~ft~M~*.~. ~ft*~*1.~ ••• L. ~.A ••• ~k**~m.ft2Jt. *~g~~m.ft~ft#o. #~ • • ;~*'.left*M~m~~*~. ~~~W'ftA~1f:. render, play, dance, or act it, either directly or by means of any device or process or, in the case of a motion picture or other audiovisual work, to show its images in any sequence or to make the sounds accompanying it audible 112 f~mJEf;f{¥Lt¥J-&tll~m. '. ffH:'::f-&t~li. '. 0. j! Gasaway. ~!I'~1'Ffiit.m. wHI:.tZ5Hff '. "& Ryan Craig, The Development of Internet Education and the Role of Copyright Law, Journal of the Copyright Society of the U.S.A., vA7, 2000, pps.75-116; Robert O'Neil, Campus Database Issues, Journal of College and University Law, v.27, no.l, 2000, pps.109-117; Georgia Harper, Developing a Comprehensive Copyright Policy to Facilitate Online Learning, Journal of College and University Law, v.27, no.l, 2000, pps.5-14; Kenneth Crews, Distance Education and Copyright Law: the Limits and Meaning of Copyright Policy, Journal of College and University Law, v.27, no.l, 2000, pps.15-51 95 %. j! Laura Gasaway Mtl:.t, p.784. 0. 0. The Copyright office Report or Copyright and Digital Distance Education,. Hearing Before the Committee on the Judiciary United States Senate, May 25,. 1999, Serial no. J-I06-539 ' "& Gasaway Mm:.t. 0.
(39) flm*1'F(f]*f'F'!iWiillftffl-$~ '¥lI&~1ffilooliJf~ 221. ~~,~~~~*~~o/m~m~A~~~'~~~~~. ~i~~~*m,~~~~.~~.~.~~.o~.~~~*. jj it. '. *_. ft.1t'ti*m ' W~f mf'ti {~m98 Leval )i: 't ~ ilrJ"tt :tt * mti '( W-g , .i['{ m- ~ $ifj ~ ~ fft 1'1 .. ~I U. f~ m~ A~. ffl ' ~ J. *. 0. ~;~~~~A~~A~_'.ff~.'.~.A~~A~~~. ••• $ifj*~.~~*m' •• ~~m- ••• .i['{*~.. MM~;. ~1r)i:.i['{r!J.ittt.A~~99. 0. ~;~~~)i:~m-~.~§~~~*m~~~~~~~~~ t~.m. •• ~~.~m%o~~. ~.)i:#.~~§~m.~. 1r~~m~~'~~~~~M~,~m~.~~.~m~o£* ~,~~. ~.)i:~~. ll/;~;f;f~~~{~m. ~ ~ ~ ~ ti. 0. )i: ~. ~*~A'~.~~. 1*. 9. .... 46. {!ft ~ ~ :. •• 4'~. ~*m.~~~#. *. r )i: ~ ir.. ~ itt •. J. 0. [GJ Witt. 0. ~~~~. ttR Jt iii 11. ~.~~~*.~~AE~I. ~~oJo~ • • 2~~~~r~m~m~~~. &~.~~~~ ~UR 100. •• L~. .... m_. ~)i:,~.m-~~M~.A~~~.'~~. ~ it J1J. ~~• ~ § ~ ,. *. {!ft rJf ~ •. ~ ~ •• 4 ~ M. 0. :$: ;(Ji~*J::~'g~~Hffiff~'*Jjt ifFlI-~i!irH'F. 0. ~nm~-~OO~OOOff~~~&~~rr~o~~~*~'~Hffiff~~~. ~~oo~OO~~m~Hffim,~&~*~~~~m~~.~.~'~M~~. -~~m. ••~o~oom~&~~.'~.fi~~.~mli~$~~g~W'. U,IH~1;P&~{'Ftlf.fwr..'m. I",. J!t~f.. 0. • !6Jitm 47 f~m 3lJlnl:tE. : r 1tttt~ll.~~k&*~~~ffMm ' fiU&. ~8~~~~'ff~.~~~'~~~M~~AE~~~~~~WoJft~ m~~~.~J::~~.Rm,1tt~.m4lJlnl:tE,ftmA~M~Wftm~m ~~~WM.tlA'~~M~m.~o~Rm.~$1tt~.$m~~~r.
(40) ., mt\+ J\!f}l. 222 a*7:t*lf!Ii~. ~~~M~~~*'~~o~~~*~~~~~%%.. *~. •. ~~~~~~~**,~~.~~~~&. %~~~~~. ~m~~~.~o~~,~~~~~~~~~. ~J' t£~*{~M-~,*Jij[}1;.$.~1W1t. ~~~. ~~.~~. 0. %~.~~#.~~~~~~#*~~~~m,~~~~~. *~~~.47~o£*x'~~M~m*~~~~~ff*~~. ~. ~#m. '~~~ff*~~~~~~~#m.,~. ~OO~'~~~'~~~~~~A~~~~*~ ~~~~#. ~~,~m. o~~. ~. ~ {t MAtt A ~ X it {t Jf1 ~ Jl. ~. ' {t. m~ Jl $. ~~*~~%,.~~~#. ~o~~~~,. ~~~#~. ~#.*~~.o~A~~.4.~~~mA. tiT ~. t£~~ ~m~l. *~m.%.~. *tm tr ~. ~~~~#~~. 101 0. ~*~~t. ~~I'~1~.~~~~~m~OO~~m~A.~*'~%. ~. {10M AttAltX 1t~ftItl ~ ~~. '~iltm ~~JIf. ••. Leval. *. t~1t. $. 1W11l1. 0. #ft~.~.~.~~m~~~.~. ~~,~~.**~~. ~. ~,~~~~~lt~~*~~~~£*. ~.A.Ho*~~-.*H.~Mti1*_~~~. ~~~~x'~.ili~ ~~*~&** t!9 ". ~,~. ~,t£~JIf{tm~~.~*, ~. ~~~.~. ~a~.'. 0. ~'~.A*.. ~~J~~~t. ~~~.~.*m.. 0. :fm~1'F.i!-1M~!A469~jt ~ {t ti. *. ~J. t£ II ~ ~ ~ JtiJ $. ~. *_(li. vi ng law) I02J!. ,.l:. W.$~47~~4~Z~m~~$J~~o 101. g"~~WItt. ~. , fJ. 102. m$ffif.tilNtt:i.$:J:f'f]$ft(paper law). '. ' M!t~ , .WJ¥f{f;fz:tff'F.rQ~m~. :i1[~~~~~ , ~.fJt. s $!4!.~ , ~ 65 1m '. 2000/10,pps.99·113 0. 0.
(41) .m~~~~~~.~~~ffl-.~·.~&$.oom~ ~3. •• ~ •• '~.*~.~.~lo*M*~~.'~~~ *~~ •• ~.~*.m.~o*.~~.~~N •• ~'~M ~~. ~.~.~.~ • • • ~~ffi.M~o. ••~. m~~~M~~~~~~~~#~~~ ,*~.~. ~~. ••• *•••. ~~A.'~~*. 4.1 ~.~. •••. ff~J-~ • •. ;M. $'~~. * 1t)f] fZSJ. * J1 ~~~~N.J~18.~* 11 1f *tJ M• 't -f. %~ ~ 0/. -~.H.o. f'J.. :t1lJ1 flJ ~ ~ ~ ~ 11. f}f. *~~~M*M*~m. •• *A.«~~~.~~~~~ ••• #~~~ • • - .. I~~«~'#. I\..'. .m.,-... ~ ~ 83. ~. JfJL "M ;t 11 J]. fU J. '. ~ ~ pJf ~11t ~ WF~I03 0. !f.. r ~ rt%~ (:1f) I {X ~'~~M1t*~~~~$~.o/ 1$ %~ r 0/ ill fdJ6 J 0 :ft % ~! -f ~ !f. % IiiJ ;t , ~ {i ~ ~ ~ 83 • 11 J1.&. 84 1. *. ~.. 20 8 ~ ~ {i pJf ill ~. *. ~~ft~~~~~~~e&~~~,*~~~~: 1.~~:e. '. 2001 iF 10 ~ 158m. § http://mail.tyaLtyc.edu.tw/-s814114/cs.htm;. 2.841f:ltfff¥m 5185 ~iJ'~iJ'~t~1Jt!IrfC.~~~~~'gi.ewH' Jj~:ffi ' 1995 iF 11 ~ , pps.20-29;. ' Jllmt!. 3 .84 iFlt~*m 2341 ~iJ'.iJ' ~t!t!!1Jt!lrfC.jffJ$*,J~' Jllmt!Jj~:ffi' 1996 iF 9 ~ , pps.28~29; 4.85 iFltL~*m 4501 5I1EiJ'.if1jWt!lrfC.jffJ$*,h~' 2001. 3~ 6. a t~§. http=lIwjirs.judicial.gov.tw/~~IrfC.~¥1l~JjfI;. 5.85 fF:!lm:~*m 1412 ~iJ'.iJ'~tjt!DJt!Wf£~$*,Jj~ , ~f'FflJflJ$~m ,2001 iF 10 ~ 15 §http://www.tien-liipr.com.tw, 7i:3H!$W$. am.. JjJ5JTI1M:& 6.86 iFltiJ'L *m 7267 5I1Elil if1j~lrfC.jffl$*,ji;k; , 2001 iF 10 http://www.crime.org.tw/data02-04.html. 0. ~ 15. B.
(42) 224 i&*#?¥W~. :if- 1fJ Fa' 7f;1~'::'. mt\+J\M. *r!11l' tf • #f f.¥j ••. ~~.~,.*t. ~ ~ ~ -f 1$". %~ 0/ T ~ (download). (~.)~.%~~83:if-12fJ&~.2. fJili~.*ff~r.~~.fJ~J.~M&.AM. Jt.1t r>g ~ ~ .):f r>g. IIW. 0. *J.%~~.'~* •• ~.*.~.~. •••• ~~. .... ~~.. ~~~fflo.%.~Jt.~~.~.*.49.m~~~rJt.~~*J r~~ • • ~J,~m§*. ~~*&~~~.~;. .~~X~#~~.~,~. rr~~~. ~.*.61.~~~~ffl~#o. ~K.%~ •• ~'~*A'.'~'~'~~*.*~'#~ ~.*.64~~~ili~~~~of.¥j~~~~. ~.~~OO~,. .. ... ~.~**~4~~~~'.~M**.~.~~~~'.~, .~f*. •••• oi~~~~f.¥j~~.. ~&.~.*~~~ffl. IIW. j!wHI5"~~~i:tWfC*,Ji*)(. 105. ~{'F*ii:t~ 49 {~;t1~. W'.%~R~~~. ~~,.%~.~. ~.~. ~o. C>. : r PJJJffl ' tlij , it~ , rJTtmktt.!iX:~fi!r1Ji:t.m~$. •• ~·rr •• ~~~.~~·~Mm~.~~.$m.~~~~oJ~~ i:t~ 64 t~~;t1~ • .m 49 t~i;J!&!mM= ' ff!an~t±H~ <> 106. ~~fii:t~ 61 f~;t1~. : rm'X;7~rJTllfJ*It'. *,fU.t:fi~U;!zm, ~~.!iX:~r:tffJ:~. $~m~~ill·~ffi~@rJTllfJ*It,~~.ft~ffi.~~mm0~.~o&~. ttan~ff.ft~0~.~~,~rr~~<>J. ~. •• ~~.5" •• ~i:tWfC~~)(c>* ••• i:tWfC~~~.5~m.J!m. ~:. ..... r ' J:WfA~5tii{1P:'~~rJTllfJ~jJ (!!P Netnews ' .!iX:m Ne~s ' ~~.'ffWA'ffW.m·~~~~~ •• tt.~~.~~~. USENet). ~·. ~~~m~$ •• m.~~'m$mi:t~m •• <>-'Wili~.ff~rMM fta~flJa •• ~~~ ••• ~~.m~~~$.'~~~mJ:~AW.. ' i))\1!WmMftl r ~f& 1n:t J ~Ifi!f.m~ ••~3~R~.fi~~flft~.ft$ ~~~.~~-'~~-.rJTllfJm,~~~.ft •• 'm&!-~M~w.m lZSI.~~&:\J!~i;J!.!I1~fljm~rQ'm. .~~3,.~~~o~'J:fiAm.
(43)
(44) 226 jSC*l!.WJi~. ~. •• ~~. mt\+ AM. *~,~~m.~fi~«~. ~~ ••• L'~~~~~.~ ~. ••• ~. ~*~. ~~.M~. '~~~~~Lt~. ~~~A$~~m~~~~~~~~~'~~~~m~m# 'M~~A.~I. •• ~.~~~~ •• ~.om~~.~~. ~*~~~~~~~.A~~,~~~.~~a~~~~~~~ ~o. ~.A~~ff-~~~~~.z~.fi~.m. ~~~~~~~~z~~'~~~~~. •• I~'~. ~~.A~~~~~~. ~~.zi~;~~~.A.m~~~*. ~~~~~~~~~. Z~~'~~~~~.~~~~*~~M~.z. ~A'~x~. ~~~~~*~~~Z~$'~~*~~~~~*~~~Z§~ .~lt~o. .... ••• ~~~m ••• ~ •• tM.~z~.'A m.~ ~ Zmo*# •• iOO*~'M~~. ~*,t ~f~m. t ••• ~~~.(~1f-t:~).WFA.~~~tt. •• ~~.#~,*m~ •• ~~'~~.~. ~l!~1f' jf. Ma.z~tt. ~*~A'~~K.WFA~~t ••• ~~~*. ~. *i~~. ~~ •• ~~~fi~.~.z~~'§I¥J~~~. ~~~.. f.fj.~~Z §. ~-.~t. I¥J. ••. '~!!1,:ft~. ~~~.~. ~.Z. ~IIO. 0. ~.~.~.Z~~~~~_-.. ~~~~.~~k~*.~~.A~.~~i~~m~~~o. ~~~~r~~Z~~fi~~J~~~Z;~*.. it' ~~Im~~~. if J. r1}iffifl1~J. ~.~.52. ~$Ij olll~~Z r~~J ~ r~. fi ~ , l1i *~ ~ tt ~. 65 1~ 112" ~ *lJfi'f. 0. .., 110. 111. ~ 112. ~iWtt". =lfFffir!~ 52 .1;ljE : r E.UfI~ , iW~ , $&* ' fitf~1OC;Jtft!!iEtt § tr-JZ£'. , t£-ftJ!i!~:lIIp<;J , ~ij[ fflE0!mj1~z:tff'F • J". :tffFlir!~ 651~~JljE : r:tff'Fz-ftJ!i!fiffl ' 1'tJfJiJG:tff'FMJmffiz~i!" 0. ......
(45) ,..... .m.~~.~ttw~g~m-.g·.g&~.oom~. 2~. ~~~~*~~~~~~m~~z~oo*~~~~.~~~. 1ft • z .!$ , !! ~ '*" '" ~ z ~ !$ ( r e po r t ) & fft ~ :!lX. ~j ;1ilU1G /f71I1r;)ftl!:!lX.~~jiiji--$,I!«.';fLt~r.!$J'. f;jt , J?7 ~ ~~J-$ f~A. ••. ~,m.~. o~~~~. ••. M••• ~A. ~~~~.~~.~. •• ~.Afl,r;)~.~MM • • ~. M• • • , .. IA~.I~z • • *~m~'~.~~!$z~J-:!lX.~~.OO~ r,,~~; ~.r;)M~ r~~jj*J ~,* • • !$ZiiI~lI3o. flJm. ••. 4.1.2 ,*~J5f. ~.~fl 1m yf II~. 0. '*.. *M.~~.'~'~~~~*.~~. I.k ft ,Il ii ~t it ~ til *! ' •. t~,~~. ~~. ~~. i: •. ~ ~;t. 0. ~~~M~r~~~~~;~*. ~ & fij 1Jf ~. M. ~. ~~~. ,~.~.~~.o*~~.*z~;t'i:.J?7Nr~%. i: t 1~. ~ J. lIS. 0. !i€:>t ~ 11: tl -f ~ ~ ,Ui (copyright) , iiI ~ i:.. ~ff;Lfflm:JE::afoft:m 44 f~¥m 63 f!lmJE:i!,t!:tfi1!~lIfY!ftL~f~ff3. ' E!iift:J. '~E!~.~~• • ,~.~~;L~.:. -·~m;L§~&tt.,~m~. ••• §~.~.~• • §~". , ~1'F;Ltt. a .::. ' PJTfrjm;L.ji&:!tt£~MI~1'FPJTfti;L1t~" ~,"mM •• ~WMt£m • • ~t£ • •;LBV"J 111. J1t~-Et.ifIj~¥:tIffC.~~Unfi1J1l1S~~W*I¥:tm 64 f~IJjVG:!ttf:H~. 1tr1R~fi~ftf!A~1'FfI;L• •. ~~~~jt~ ,. a. J!MtI-Et,ilJifIj~¥:tIffC.*,Jr*)(. , iJF1!ltM. ". J ¥tf~iml::~~1'Fflrtl'm-*~~imlM~ ' *ffi1¥:t¥iJf~m II WJ ' 1996 1f. 12 FJ ' pps.213-227: tim. ' ftlilFJ flJ¥~~J!" ' fV~Mif.fl1illF1 flJ ' 1996 1f. 7 fi ' pps.29-31 ; Iftj$~' ~im~1'F'fnJJ:m1' jfm7:t~j!#T' 1996 1f. 7 FJ 'pps.24- ; f:£ r ftlilFJ. f~Ut~='M!lUlll::IM~.='M ;LJfff. '.n~±m.m.~-~~~~~~,m~.,.*~.m.~~. , 19981f.. 0. !lt9i- '. fitEJtlilJ=JflJD~' 115. ~f'Ffi~:m 3. *¥Wi1Sfif~ftft:ftiflj¥:tIffC.*,Jr*llfflE~&. Aft: rftlilFJflJJ ¥ '. J!~f!l p.128~129". '. ft;: 19981f. 3. .m 1 .m 5 ~x~l)E :r ~J't : f§.L'Jt:fJjj , ~t:fJ ~ iff!' ' if.
(46) """"II. mt\+ AM. 228 i61::kit~Wf~. it 11 JJL t: ~ ~ I\.'. ~. 0. ti ~ ~ '* X lltr i! *;ff Li tman. ~. 1±l '. j:!l1. ~._~m,.;ff~~.'W •• ~~~+~'it.~.§~.. it {i t: fI] 0J ~ ~ m':ft.. t: lJJ 71- ~ 1t m. ll6. if •. 0. .'it ::f. *7F • :t it. •••• ;~.~ •• ' •• ~m~~~~~.o ~ YL ' ~ -1ji + it l!J. ~;if ~ YL ~ ;tIj ~ ;;i ~ 1I ~J * x:m. m::f~~-~~. Li tman. 0. 1±l''*•• it~#m .~. •• ~~.,~+. ~~;;iJA*_. ._.;fIlA. ••• ~§~,~. ~&AM.I~. ••. ... t:fI]0J~~m.~.'#.~m.r~. ~.o~. § ~W1tJfJ1J%.itll7. 1±l'*.~.lI~.%tl~. 0. 7I-'I.,*.~ • • %.~;ff'~.~.~A~~~~~ A~. ' • • iA*«~~.~M.~.~~.~o£~~. '.%-.~i!I. fit 1±l •. ~ 118. ~;;i~;A~.~*M~*4~.'0A. '* X it '* ~ • ;t * M YL M -t 1t ' 1ft ~ ~ • • $t! r,,~ _ ~ it ,I. ~ l& 71- tJr ~. Wi. ~. '. 0. A it ~ ~i:-. ~ •. 119. *_. 0. 120 •. 0. '_.~.~ • • ::f* • • ;ff~YLM;W**~_~iti!~~ MW$.&~.. *. ,=;ff*.~. .. ...... AO.~. •• ~i. .·m.' • • • ~~~$~m~ • • ~~o~~*'W~.~.~M.a .~.w. ~~~~. :.~~.m~~.~.m~.a~.~. ~. ,. 116. j[ Jessica Litman, Innovation and the Information Environment :Revising. ifJ\.~. 0. J. Copyright Law for the Information Age, Oregon Law Review,v.75,1996,pps.19111. t),jfij~~fIJW~Fjfij~ftfrH'F~WiJjrJ~:a.~.f'F~f;J:lIH~m. '. 0. -f1,,::/o,W;;fl!. ~ • • ~&$ • • OO~ • • '~.M.W~~m~~~.*,m~~.ifJ\~ ~Ii:~. 0. ~ p.1673. §WJ•• u!{Jj,.;t:g~~8t. ~.~~. 0. ,. William Fisher III '. WJ11:.>t • :;ft. 118. £*J: ' .~~~frj$ll~~*t)'&{Ii'i!AKi1&~~ • • ~W~'li j[1if3tft ' WJfl:.>t. 119. j[~~fI7!m. 9. 120. j[~Wfi$m. 611a!. 0. 0. 1 ~m 4 ~ 0. 0. 0.
(47) ... .m.~~.~~.~~~m-.~·.~&~~OO~~ 2~. ~.~~*~.~. ~,~~~~m;~~m*.~. ~~1~ •• ~~~~*' ~-. *a~~.~~.~~~o. •• ~.~ •• ~.~.-. 1~.~o~.~a. ~.. ~~~~~m-.,~~. ••••• •• ••• ~M. ~. ~~~~.~. !.tMo*~~~~Nili~-.dd.A~«~.m,~.~. ~~~~. .~. M.~~,*.*a*. •• ~~.~.*.Afl. •• ~I •• #~.~ffo.~. ~M.ff~~~'ddI. JJl;f.JcMM ~ ~ ~Jll2l, i£1tJf}1! # 0/ ~ ~.~ 1t.JtIj fll tr? ~ PJf ~~.~~ff~~~m,.~~.«om~. ~~1~~. ~~~~ili~~Jlo. ~.. •• ~g~a.~. ~~. ~~~~~£. *§~,~~~~~~~.#~~~. ~~ff'~~~~. ~;~. • • *~~~,~~. ~.. *ra,. ~A'#~. ~~#. ~~. •. {1ff rJ] ~ Jtj! (dialog) 1tM N~'*.~.~AI4A~~ •• ~~Jtj!,~. ~~-~~~~.o* •• *~. ~*W~~~'~~e •• %~.#K~~.o~.*~~ff~ M• • *m,~~.%. t~~ t~ . ' m1t.M~. o.*~.M .~~# fJl,~. .... ~i~'. ~a~.~ ~. • • • • ~~.*.~Afl'~. ~ft.$*~~. 121. •• -~.#~~.*. •• wo.M~ •• ,~~~.~*t~.~,. ~~~~*)(~IJI~{'FttEt-Jffl)7t. 2001. 0. ". if: 10 jj 15 614 §~Jlhttp://www.tien-liipr.com.tw/home_tienli. /iprjudge/hopeneti.htm. ~~7I1'iti¥jjfiltlMi)(ft~~. , http://www.esouth.org ,. 7t~fJ~mmH5·EfJ.-T-*:\l([*1~$lj1Jt~l¥JthUt.7 P1Ef'Ftfjl¥J~f'Ffl1Fj$~1ij'f~.~H~$l~m. 0. " ~~f$ if: 5 J=J 12 6 :L1f!1J~. A::~i¥j1Jtm~. :{£l!ii~ 86. ' ,*~~*fI. 700 ~~ , ~1fJC~J)1:. mM~.~:{£~m~.~~'.~M.:L1f!1J~IfJC~f'F.~.~1ij'f~.~~ ~o. ••. ~ • • • *.~~mm~*m~1Jt~l¥Jm~"~~ •• ~~m~~. M~®~~~:L1f!~~'.fl~-~~~l¥J~~".
Outline
相關文件
Wang, Solving pseudomonotone variational inequalities and pseudocon- vex optimization problems using the projection neural network, IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks 17
volume suppressed mass: (TeV) 2 /M P ∼ 10 −4 eV → mm range can be experimentally tested for any number of extra dimensions - Light U(1) gauge bosons: no derivative couplings. =>
For pedagogical purposes, let us start consideration from a simple one-dimensional (1D) system, where electrons are confined to a chain parallel to the x axis. As it is well known
Define instead the imaginary.. potential, magnetic field, lattice…) Dirac-BdG Hamiltonian:. with small, and matrix
incapable to extract any quantities from QCD, nor to tackle the most interesting physics, namely, the spontaneously chiral symmetry breaking and the color confinement..
• Formation of massive primordial stars as origin of objects in the early universe. • Supernova explosions might be visible to the most
Master Taixu has always thought of Buddhist arts as important, the need to protect Buddhist arts, and using different forms of method to propagate the Buddha's teachings.. However,
Continue to serve as statements of curriculum intentions setting out more precisely student achievement as a result of the curriculum.
