. 22' 特殊教育研究學刊
工業科技教育學系主編:職場導向能力及 課程發展研討會手冊(12-25 頁)。臺北:
國立畫灣師範大學。 [Li， Lung剖leng
(1999). Competence analysis and DACUM method. In Dept. of Industrial Education, National Taiwan Normal University (Ed.), Employment orientation competence and curriculum development conference. (pp. 12-25). Taip缸， Taiwan: National Taiwan Nor-mal University.]把昭安(1997) :歐智教育初任教師專業智能
之探討。載於中華民國特殊教育學會主 編:特殊教育法的落實與展望(293-311
頁)。畫北:中華民國特殊教育學會。
[Chi,Chao-An (1997). A study on the pro-fessional intelligence of the beginning spe-cial education teachers. In Spespe-cial Education Association of the Republic of China (Ed.), The enforcement and prospects of the 1997 special education act (pp. 293-311). Taipei, Taiwan: Special Education Association of the Republic ofChina.]
沈宜純 (007) :身心障礙頓特殊教育教師評 鐘指標意見調查及其應用之研究一以高雄 縣市為例。國立臺灣師範大學特殊教育學 系碩士論文(未出版)0 [Shen, Yi-Chwun (2007). The opinion investigation and appli-cation of evaluation index for the special education teachers-An example of Kaohsi-ung city and coun秒. Unpublished Master's thesis,National Taiwan Normal University.]
洪榮昭(1997) :能力轉換，滾石生苔否?就
業與訓練，
15 (2),56-63 0 [Hung, Jung-Chao (1997). Does rolling stones gather moss? -Competence transfer. Employment andTraini嗯， 15(2),56-63.]徐超聖(1999) :九年一貫課程品質管理機制
一淺談「學力指標」之意義。教育研究與 資料，詣， 33-39 0 [Hsu, Chao-Sheng (1999). Academic attainment indicators-From the demanded quality of grade 1-9 cur-riculum.Journal of Education Research and Resources,26,33-39.]
教育部 (2010) :第八次全國教育會議大會手
冊。畫北:作者。 [Ministry
of Education (20 I0). The eighth national education con-ference. Taipei,Taiwan: Author.]莊世清(2009) :平衡計分卡觀念應用於臺北 縣國小特教班教師評鑑指標之建構。國立 臺灣師範大學特殊教育學系碩士論文(未
出版)
0 [Chuang,Shih-Ching (2009).Appli-ca的nof balance scorecard concepts on con-struction of evaluation indicators of special classroom teachers in elementary schools in Taipei coun砂. Unpublished Master's thesis, National Taiwan Normal University.]
郭美滿(1999) :敵智教育教師專業姐能之分
析研究。國立彰化師範大學特殊教育學系 博士論文(未出版)0 [Kuo, Mei-Man (1996). The study on thepr，吶ssional knowl-edge ofteachers ofmental-retarded students.
Unpublished Doctoral thesis, National Changhua University ofEducation.]
陳信憲、陳美華 (2005) :技職校院商管學群 學生財金專業能力指標建構之研究。師大
學報 '50
(2)' 121-138 0 [Chen,Hsin-Hsi凹， & Chen,Mei-Hua (2005). A study of the finance students' professional competen-cies index constructing at technological and vocational universities,colleges/ junior col-leges. Journal of National Taiwan Normal University, 50(2), 121-138.]
陳建州、陳清檳、李玲梅、劉松益、陳宏輿
( 2003 ) : r 職業調轉職頓工作分析」手
冊。臺北:行政院勞工委員會職業訓練局 委託研究專案報告。 [Ch凹， Chien-Chou, Chen, Ching-Pin, Li,Ling-Mei,Liu, Sung-Yi, & Chen, Hung-Hsing (2003). The task analysis for vocational training categories.
Taip缸， Taiwan: Bureau of Employment and Vocational Training, Council of Labor Affairs Executive Yuan.]
陳清溪 (2006) :國中小教育階段特殊教育教 面專業評鑑規準之研究。載於國立教育研 究院籌備處主編:臺灣教育研究的回顧與 展望研討會論文( 225-242 頁)。新北:國 立教育研究院籌備處。 [Chen， Ching-Hsi (2006). A study on the professional evalua-tion standards for the primary and secondary school teachers. In National Academy for Educational Research Preparatory Office (Ed.),Retrospects andpro:可peetsfor the edu-cational research in Taiwan (pp. 225-242) New Taipei City,Taiwan: National Academy for Educational Research.]
陳麗如、陳清溪、鐘梅菁、江麗草iJ (2006) :
高中職教育階段特殊教育教師專業評鑑意 見之研究。特殊教育與復健學報， 16 ' 25-44 0 [Chen, Li-Ju, Chen, Ching-His, Chung,Mei-Ching,& Chiang,Li-Li (2006).
Views of teacher evaluation for senior high schools special educators. Bulletin ofSpecial Education and Rehabilitation,16,25-44.]
彭森明 (2008) :將學生學習成果納入大學評 鑑指標項目之必要性與可行性。評鑑雙月 刊， 20 ' 46-48 0 [Peng, Sen-Mi月 (2008).
The necessity and fessibility of the inclu-sion ofstudents' outcome in the universities' evaluation items. Evaluation Bimonthly, 20
,
46-48.]
游家政(1996) :德懷術及其在課程研究上的
應用。花蓮師院學報，16 ' 1-24 0 [Yu, Chia-Cheng (1996). Delphi Technique and Its Application in Curriculum Study.Journal ofNational Hualien Teachers College,16, 1-24.]
黃政傑、李陸盛( 1996) :技職教育概論。臺
北:師大書苑。 [Hua呵，
Cheng-Chieh, &Li,Lung-Sheng (1996). The introduction on vocational education. Taipei,Taiwan: Lucky bookstore. ]
黃國榮(1991 ) :德爾菲歐智教學基本能力之
研究。特殊教育學報， 6 ' 225-246 。 [Huang,Kuo-Jung(1991).Delphi's study on the teachers' basic instruction abilities men-tally retarded. Journal of Special Education, 6,225-246.]
甄曉蘭、陳淑融、宋明娟、黃家凱、張菌穎
( 2009 ) :r 各系所學生專業能力指標應
用」說明會會議手冊。臺北:國立畫灣師 範大學教育評鑑與發展研究中心。 [Chen，
Hsiao-Lan, Chen, Shu-Min, Sung, Mi月
Chuan, Huang, Chia-Kai, & Chang, Han-Ying (2009). The instruction on the under-graduated students' professional competence indicators. Taip仇，Taiwan: National Taiwan Normal University.]
甄曉蘭、黃姿霓、許宛琪、邱于真(20 II ) :
「中等學校教師頓組專業標準及專業表現 指標相關內涵暨配套措施 J 100 年度期申 報告。臺北:國立臺灣師範大學教育學系 教育專業發展中心。 [Chen， Hsiao-Lan, Huang,Tzu-Ni,Hsu,Wan-Chi,& Chiu, Yu-Chen (2011).The report of the professional
\'tandardl' and professional performance
in-dicator，可 for secondary school teachers.
Taipei 、 Taiwan: ~ational Taiwan Normal University. ]
. 24 . 特殊教育研究學刊
蔡桂芳 (2007) :從美國資優教育學會新版教 師應備基準談資優教師培育的方向。載於 中華民國特殊教育學會主編:特殊教育的
資螺輿支握( 203-220 頁)。畫北:中華民
國特殊教育學會。 [Ts缸， Kuei-Fang (2007).The orientation to breed gifted education teachers-From American 2006's teacher preparation standards in gifted education. In Special Education Association of the Repub-lie of China (Ed.),The resource and support for special education (pp. 203-220). Taip仇，
Taiwan: Special Education Association of the Republic ofChina.]
蔡崇建(1994) :特殊教育教師專業智能發展
的需求評估。特殊教育研究學刊，10 ' 103-118 0 [Ts缸， Chung-Chien (1994). Iden-tification of the competencies needed by teachers of special education for the continu-ing professional development. Bulletin of SpecialEdi缸ation， 10,103-118.]
鄭英耀、葉麗貞、劉昆夏、莫慕貞 (2011 ) :
大學生基本能力指標之建構。測驗學刊，
58 (3),531-558 0 [Cheng,Ying- Yao,Yeh, Li-Jen, Liu, Kun-Sh間， & Mok, Mo-Ching (20 II). Constructing the indicators of under-graduate students' key competences. Psycho-logical Testing,58(3),531-558.]
蕭吉男 (2003) :製圖科畢業生專業能力標準 輿基本能力等蔽之研究。國立臺灣師範大 學工業教育學系碩士論文(未出版)。
[Hsiao,Chi-Nan (2003). A study ofgraduate students' professional competency standards and basic competency levels at the drawing department of vocational high school. Un-published Master's thesis, National Taiwan Normal University.]
蕭金土、陳瑋婷(2007) :敢智學校教師對
「特殊教育教師專業標準」意見之調查研 究。東臺灣特殊教育學報，9 ' 219-236 。 [Hsiao,Chin-Tu,&Chen,Wei-Ting (2007).
An investigation of views on the professional standards of special educators for the men-tally retarded schools special educators. Bul-letin of Eastern- Taiwan Special Education. 9, 219-236.]
Andrade, H. (200 I). The effects of instructional rubrics on learning to write. Current Issues In Education. 4(4). Retrieved November 1,2012, from http://cie.ed.asu.edulvolume4/ number4.1 Andrade, H., & Valtcbeva, A. (2009). Promoting learning and achievement through selι assessment. Theoη into practice ， 紹. 12-19 Australian Government Department,Employment,
and Workplace Relations (2011). National professionalstandards 戶rteachers. Retrieved July 24, 20 II, from http://www.
deewr.gov.aulSchoolinglPageslProfessionaISta ndardsforTteachers.aspx.
Bailey, T.,&Me由此， D. (1995). Making sense of
indust.η-basedskill standards. Macomb, IL:
WesternIllinois University. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED389897) Butler,F. (1978). The concept of competency: An
operational definition. Educational
Technol-ogy， 的，7-18.
Carnevale, A. P. (1991). America and the new economy: How competitive standards are radically changing American workplaces. San Francisco,CA: Jossey-Bass.
Cheetham, G, & Chivers, G (1996). Toward a holistic model of professional competence.
Journal of European Industrial Traini嗯，
20(5), 20-30. doi: 10.11 08/03090599610 119 692
Choa峙，L.H.,Smith,S.L.,& Spruill,D.A.(2005).
Professional development of counselor educa-tion students: An exploratory study of profes-sional performance indicators for assessment.
InternationalJournal 戶rthe Advancement of Counselling. 27(3), 383-399. doi:
10.1007/sl0447-005-8201-0
Garvin, P. (Ed.). (2003). Developing knowledge-able teachers: A framework for
standards-bωedteacher education supported by institu-tional collaboration. Washington, DC:
AACTE
Grossman, P. L.,
&
Richert, A. E. (1988). Unac-knowledged knowledge growth: A re-examination of the effects of teacher educa-tion. Teaching 正是 Teacher Education,4( I), 53-62. doi: 10.1016/0742-051 X(88)90024-8 Hoachlander,G (1999). Integrating academic andvocational curriculum-Why is theory so hard to practice?Center Point, 7. Retrieved August 25, 2010，台om http://ncrve.berkeley.edu/Cen terPoint/CP7/CP7.html.
Johns, A. (1995). Competency standards for pro-fessional accountants in Australia and New Zealand. Accounting Education, 4(1), 37-42.
doi: 10.1080/09639289500000005
Kirk ，鼠， & Gallagher, 1. (1972). Educating excep-tional children(3rd ed.). Boston,MA: Hough-ton Mifflin.
Knowl 郎， M. S. (1970). The modern practice of adult education. A systematic approach to education. New York,NY: Holt,Rinehart, &
Winston.
Legere, C. L. 1. (1978). Occupational analysis for training. Educational Technology， 的(3)， 27-35.
Lil阱， K. K., Laakso, K., & Palomki, 1. (2011).
Using theD呻hi method. Paper presented at the Technology Management in the Energy Smart World Conference,Portland,OR.
Mansfield ，旦， & Mitchell, L. (1996). Towards a competentwor，紗rce.London,UK.Gower.
Middleton,R. A.,Rolli肘，
c.
w., Sanderson,P. L., Leung,P.,Harley,D. A.,Ebener,D.,& Leal-Idrogo, A. (2000). Endorsement of profes-sional multicultural rehabilitation cpmpeten-cies and standards.Rehabilitation Counseling Bulletin. 43(4), 219-245. doi: 10.1177/003435520004300407
Raiz凹， S. A. (1989). Rφrming education 戶r
work: A cognitive science perspective.
Macomb,IL.: National Center for Research in Vocational Education Materials Distribution Service,WesternIllinois University
Schu此， D. (2003). Self-e伍cacy for reading and writing: Influence of modeling, goal-setting, and self-evaluation. Reading 正是 Writing Quar-ter秒" 1久 159-1 72. doi: 10.1080/
10573560308219
Shulman,L. S. (1987). Knowledge and teaching:
Foundations ofthe new reform.Harvard Edu-cational Review,57(1),1-22.
Tymms, P. B., & Fitz-Gibbon, C. T. (1995). S仙﹒
dents at the 企ont: Using performance indica-tors for professional development. Educa-tional Research, 37(2), 107-122. doi:
10.1080/0013188950370201
Ysseldyke.1.E.,Algozzine,B., & Thurlow,M. L.
(2000). Critical issues in special education (3rded.). Boston,MA: Houghton Mifflin.
收稿日期: 2012.01.19
接受日期: 2013.04.19
·26·
Bulletin of Special Education 2013,38(3),1-27