非營利組織領導行為之研究

全文

(1)~Ftff*,Jmf!llU'Q~fiAz3i/f3t. 77. §I~*;f~~Jl.m~5T ~;.t.Jiff1l:*. ~. 1~. aJl. (~R~ili*.~~fi~~~m~~). i:'~. ..;/:::".. iiilfJ. -\:riJf~i1J. M~e~O.ft~*,~~$~~~tt*~• • • ,A~e • • •h ~8fl. • •OO• •. , 1~Ht11fi*.r",~m;ff~~Jffm~ , fE!.1±1±~~Jff1r1*it~ ( bureaucracy) 3'&$. , ji'jj~$;~Jff~ll ( government failure ) OO~~ Jj -~OO,~~~ • • • • ~~,~~ • • ~A~~.OO • • • • • ,%$;~.~ll( market failure) OO'tw% ' ~:J;!!4Ht~~:~UljA § OOOOfL.A%~>f!f.~' *~1II1l ' if ~~~*fmlklJifJlmUltl~JI. 0. ~.~,.~,.~,~~~,~.~,~~~*~~~~*'*~&.lktt~~~. ( nonprofit organizations ) ~ji'jj*.J!® tE~fI , [;5]~#t m!jJlj:!$~:f±.Z• • , ~ffif~~M~Z·twm. ' ~Tl$~OO-~%:Mllit;r~ , J!J!® T *Jt*~OO~~ttflj&. ' 1?7fr,31Jm TfJ.~*~~*~J!/j\~lIItt*~*~l$~" ~,ji'jj~.~Att**.~~m.mZffl.'.J!%~• • ,~.~%~• • ,~e ~~1tl1t~.J!Z*1tl: , iH±*fI~J\.;ff~*I¥J~. ' 1t~~~1lM;f±*fI~.~~. ' .?&~$;-0 ( ~Jff) , fL. ( 1f:~ ) lk~~1tfll$r~=~Il:fL~PJ<.• • • ~Z~ ffi~~~~1tflj&.ZJ!~~~ , tElt~JN~~flJtflSr';ff~~OOif~tt!;~j[[=+.. E:.WJ&.~~~~flj&.. 0. 0. OO.o~:J;!!-1lM~*ttOOif~,1?7ftm:~#t,._,tt*'fi~'~~'.~'~ $'~.lkA~.~o§.,~.$1t~&.if~l¥JfI.if~fi.~.A.~,.~. ~~*::f;ff. : ll~f}*. r ~~1tflJ&.if~.~ J. J (INDEPENDENT SECTOR) ,~~OO. ( PO N PO) ~~4!lOO. r ~~*"PIL' J. r .:fLtflSr,. (Foundation Center. )~ • • ,~*,tE.~~;ffffiHOOfl.ifM* • • ~ili.o. ffil.tl: , ~fll.t~~~fljt.di.Zif~{JJ.A.z ~ji'jj , ~%~• •1Jt~ji'jj~ , f§ ~~1tflj&.Ji)f J\.Z %~'11: , 1.t%~• •Z • •lkl.tfl~tt*;ffl\flJZ~~ , i:l';ffffl1'.t~ *OO~. ; 'Mt~~~ttflJ&.~~$; , m~J!~jfitJZ~~ , 1iJ.*~jriJ~% ' fL.tflSr,t.di .ImJ.!! , ?&~m-B- AI.t~fI~=tflSr'z~~ttflJ&.~~AZif~.f*M ~~ , *if~~ff.h:$:tE~~1tflJfilll.I¥J1Jt.rrA ' ~Im[;5]tE~~~1tfljt.di.oottl :fL,~T~~.M,tt*,~~~*tE.mf§.~.*,J!~lk• •::fOOJ.!!*J!.~ 0. 0. *. *:Jc~5Y:III:f4.. (NBC 82-0301 H 004 060) .:C'..~ft.'IlIl1UJ ' IlIJlutiM. 0. ~tii*.~:J:t:fi~ljIf~. m~±~~~~~±~,~±~.~,~±m~~~~±~ljIf~~.W~~A,~ljIf~~@~,~.~ $,*JIt~#tf{iMo.

(2) , IIP-4F:g.~Jtru.UJili::fa<J~1t \ ~JJtJ!~liJrj\;~ i*J;(£f§lta<J~1! 11.E)t~II~*~~ Ifffi , --4F~~Jta.~1itm1f~U!K~~:fC$;{9!$ , :1t1f*l!5t*a<J~~.~ , tm~JMt mJmta.A~JUlI , :t(llFtiL.j/J~~JlJL~~ , l.2AilE~ta.*~a<J;il$; Jiffl.2A , ~ tm75itA~M~ I1-4F~~Jta.zJmfPJ!J}Jtm ' ~ )t~~JJ liNiJf1E-4F ~~Jta.zlI;tA Ifo/J --4F~~Jta.z~.A~ ( ~.*!lJ(;~fi* ) a<J~1t ' l.2AbtJt~liJrj\;W.~t.t-4F 0. 0. ~~Jta.~~.. 0. ='. ijf ~ I~H(.J. ;(£IIP*JiI~tt-1lt~a<J4-;;R. ,. Eb~m1-t~rta<J~JJt.J1l. '. A~a<J~JJttIHlbtJ}J~J. ~~a<J.fi,ilE~A.~m • • B_.~,.*~.,tl*.~wm.~.~m~.. _.:It. iit;iQDIU!W r ~fL.m0 J ~0~'ti ( public ness ) a<J~1t ' ~~Jt$tlifrt:J:It!!flf!j1t A0~$$} , tEtl*DIl$} \ i§t.1~li ' ~ff)( ~\I~.J1l\ • • ~~~~~tl~.J1l\.~~!lfJ~JrtlifW._Yf!j*a<JJ}Jtm,~ 1f!lfJ~m~m1-t*±*a<J~yw \ IfJJ!A1r~a<JjfHI*Ff~ , ~bttl!#tl*a<J0~~J~ f§llt , ;UnfilJfl-4F~~Jta.*1tW*Ff~1f-1t:7ta<J.m , ~~M-4F~~Jta.tEmft 0. -4F:g.~JtiL.JYf~Az!lfJAIT*'. 0. tl*JYf&.~~~wJ}Jn,~~*~~a<J-M.att§a<JoJt~,.fl~~~R,*J. ~JJ~fl1fIl-4F:g.~JtiL.~~::fzA~~1tWtmJJ ~~-N:l1HT7*Aa<J~~. 0. 1Vf~a<J~1l. ,. \ ~~rttJ '. ~~lt~. \. bt~~~. ,*Y.m-4F~~Jta.~;lJfi~z*1t~~. , ~*J. ~~-4F~~Jta.Z~~~~~1i1f~A? ;fraJa<J~.~~H::1ilr;fraJa<J~m ? ~bt-4F. ? :fl~ , *~~tJ)\*J~M-4Fft~Ji.fi. ~;lJ::fz~~WJ}Jf1~ , btJtWi.fi.pt;j~~$ztl~ :fi~ , ~~::f*~flta.a<J{9!$~ , -lI~$.-4Fft~J!IH~)(.a<J.Y1:1t1l , *~~ii!*J7*A~MJIt-.1l llt~~ , • ~~Jta.z~;lJfi~~1ilr)jlj~i§t}(f!lJ(;{E~i.fi.. 0. 0. ~i.fi.fi~~J}-~F,.g-ta.)(~W~~f-j~zll~. 0. .flf1§fZ , *~~z § a<J;Ullr : 1..m-4F~~Jta.flll~U.z~. ; 2.~M-4F ft~ji.fi.~.fi~z*1t ' tg1iS~;lJ::fzA~!Wf1tWf1~JJ \ ~;lJrttJ \ ~.lt~ , bt ~.~~.la~~$ft~i.fi.~z~~~~~1i1f~A,;fraJa<J~;lJ~~~1i1f;f raJa<J~m, J;,{bt-4Fft~Jta.Z~~f-j~~1i1f)jIJtiti§t}(f!lJ(;{E~i.fi• •. ; 4.~M-4Fft~J. i.fi.~~::fz~~wJ}Jn. , btJtWi.fi.i*J~~$zIJRl1~ I 5. •11Iil~~::f~$~ta.)(~ W-4Fft~Jta.~.fi~ztl1~ j 6.Jl.*±'ti-4F~~Jta.z~.flj\;W1.m. ; 7.tI!~ ~1I~$$~~ta.ftJmW.1.mz • • ;&tI!~i§t}(f~fi~IJRI~+W~.z • • o tE.k.Y1~~§ a<J~~~.k. , *~~J!!JjUU1;il$;r'tl~.z~1E§ ~ : 1.Uiii : ~Eb *1Vf~7*A~M-4Fft~Jtfl.Z~1f,ti1tW.$; , tl!1~i.fi.1.m• • ::f-J1i1Jlfa<Jtfl.1Vf1Ez~.W.R, ~fP~~t:~0$F' \ fL.$F'W-4F~~Jta.~.:::. tfl.a<JAraJbt~~H~z~~,l.2A1t:.tfl.1.m.zpt;j~WilE~tfl.1.m.z~~o. 2.1flliii : -4F~*Utfl.Z*~ \ fflj/J \ Jt~.Wbttfl.ff. , #.titJt~li::fz ~1t. '. 1.m~W~~fi~~z~*Jmm. fi~a<J1VfJE. f;5lllt , *~1E~~fltit-4Fft~Ji.fi.!Wflrz~. , Mtmtl!1~-4Fft~jtfl.z~fi*!lJ(;.~. , fP~.1.mJttfl.Z• • , ~m 0.

(3) ~~1t;ftjm!fHR¥Hr~L3jlf~. D~~• •m• • ,.~~.ID~li*• •. 3.fi.iii;. 79. o. *1Vf~JJJf::l~pg1t7Xf*~~Utftt~:1JA;, ~§1W&it~lt~~~~1it~jil. .f1:-~W'/1:~~~. , :WFiJ~1;J[~~1it~jilti~~ty)t±*~J;.jJit ' QA.~-ltA~ J!1Vf~~~~~1it~jiltiZl*A~~ , Ji1ffimt~:1J~JHHt~~ntli*mtd:~ ~ty)mfID , ~:tIJi% ~~J!lH±tW1ifID ' ~jliJliU~- r ~.~1it:W- J ~iI. 4jE,Uftiii ; ~:il&*1Vf~ZJltW: , PJ.{;Jti!tmJi-:$ 7 m~~1it~Jil~~.f1: ' l-;Af1: ~mrJ1IT:ffI1Hl7*4-Wifiii.m'oo£~~~ , WH9!i!tm$r'~Ia4!fm~~1it~JiltizjJit , tltJlt:ffI 1i.jJ~f1:,QA.~li* • • ,~mQA.Mi!tm,OO£i!t~~~,~~.~~.~~~4!f 0. ~1:.mJhj{o. =-\iiJfJtn~.~. *1Vf:1tI~K~iliil~~~~1it~Jil.tQ.z*j{ :It!U!l!.~ (grounded. theory),. ,. QAWnlf14~~1it~Jil~*±'l1:z.. ijj(Kai~~l!t:1J7*~J:JJ~-U~1Vf:1t ( qualitative. .10 ; f§.K1Vf~:1Ji1J17X ,JUrlit.*4*.~Jf.t'11: , jl,1jf*~7$j{;~~ ( triangulation) ;fff1ffi~z , *1Vf~wr1*fr~1Vf~:1Ji1jmr ; l.)(lU~M : JiI~~ pg;rr:ffIrHl$J~~X ' X. ' i!tmW~~1it~Jil.*;!i;tztf.jJf1i&it , lit~~*~Jil.pg$:ffIrHlX. ' f1:l*AZ1if:i! 2./IIlVi : if~:trT~~Awr~ffiz~~*~Jil~ , Jifr1Vf~1WZfJJ:$Wi~ , l-;AJiI~. research). -=.ftf~Uri1. 0. 0. ;f~rHl.*4~$~1Vf~r,,~1!. 0. 3.lIIlVi ; ~~:trT~~*~JiltitQ71J~~jliJM~*~iltiz:ilf1: ' ;tt:*;!i;tz'L'lmM ~,tQ.fr~WtQ.:il&~~z~l!~o. 4.• lIiJf~. : ~m1W-='1I1Vf:1t:1Ji1z.m~ , IlP 1~:'Hl€ti:tMTM;fIJ!r,,~:'ffi~m- ' f.il!QA ~f14A;r,,~:'ffir+rit~~*~jiltitQ.fr Aft! rHl r,,~1! 5.~JtlVi~ : ~~Ia~l*A~"*m1Vf:1tr,,~I!~~1;J[A. ' KtIl~1Vf:1t~jIiJ~ , oFM 0. :m~~ pg:trT~F1itftJil.Jifr.:f&l*IlWilfR. 6.$-~.~. 0. : ~J!.~PJWl*IlWilfRjIiJ~Jifr ' ~Jm r $;j- J ' r $ . J ~:1JA;. ,*~~£$.:f&~.~,QA.M~:'ffitll~~WilfR~~~o. 7./II;tiJf~ All7t~~1Vf;fff. 8.1tttiJf~. : BC~l*IlWilfR ' ~W.~W)(.JiI~ , if~:.tfT~F*~Jil.f1:-f1t! , f.il!Jt:?}"*m!M'~il~ , ~f:t$1fIjj;;';ty)z~ttc?};fJT : ~tc~~*~Jil~ty) , ~F1it~JiltiWi!tm ' :ll'::~il~ty) , lit~ pg;rr~F 0. *~iltitltJltty)(tQ71Jfr~)Z.jliJo. A.'oo£J::i!1Vf:1t:1Ji1,f*fr.~-z1Vf:1t:$.o. rm " iiJf Jt~•• 1Ilt ttJ ~.£Ji-:$ • • ~.M*1Vf~wr.~:1t~.!&W§.,K1if:i!:ffIIHl)(.~f:t.. fJJ:$1;J[.WilfRz.,.~*1Vf:1tz.f14.~=o. ~=*~*1Vf~1t~QA~~W:1Ji1~~'.*4JiI~~?};fff~fr~1Vf:1tm_,~ti 1Vf:1t.~~m*~.*4,Jifr.~~.~Wl*Il~?};fff,l-;Af:t.~~~1;J[A.~~7.

(4) x. •. ,. 1/. ~ i". Mill lifj~. III. ---. 1/. ,. i'. .I. iI!llN: ti. 1/. flijr ". , .I. ft#. #-W.~/. ~f91Jli1f3!r" It~li1f3!. x.5ttfi. -. r--. ilJB\HjJf 3! $it LfU& ~. m 1;1/ ' 5t tfi. ~~. ' It r". I'. ~:F1I!. liIfQ. '--. '". '11:. ::t.,:F1I!liIfQ. ~ ~1J:F1I!liIfQ. ~. ~. 'if. ~p*~H\1i_:F1I!liIfQ. I. "it!!.. ~. '-. mfR. , :It ... ...... ~. 0. I. §tm. 'l'it!!.:F1I!liIfQ. I. V'. fi*4Ji~. I. -. /'. 5ttfi ",. li1f3!fltflil. i5!:JlOO. .~5ttfi. v. m_oo " ,. '",. tt•••. '\t:F1I!OO. tt.oo. Jj\.. 'I'. ~ptf~Jjl. ~1J:F1I!liIfQ. T ~. 0 ~a. '11:. (. ' Ilfitoo ' 1fJ!H00 ' ».t±1tOOrm~~1f~Jllfit~~.±lf!J!H lit 3Im-0;ttf£rm~:l:JtUA:ff'=:I~. : l.f$lt-flfJ* ( criteria ) ~.Jt lens) *mrm r 0~ J W r ~~~~J J ll.rmA{lli ; 2.f$}1i-:q{·fI!U~*~.~~~~JIl.rm0;tt f£ ; 3. f$}1i-1i !3 fJ I;.H~>jt ~ fHt1t *iilf~rm lijlittUrr-r : l.m~m-~.J!HlitZff4 k',.(».~ttr~:1Jnrm~~~~jllfitJ!Hlit ' ~~~~JIl.Z ~~J!HlitJtUIH~mttm~ , 12Slji'jjU:~~~.J!HlitW~~~~JllfitJ!Hlit ' .Mtmrm~8M~~ 1f~JIl.~.fi}1iW0fl.Il.Z:;fIliJr. , epMfi:ff@pZ:n 2. ffi m-*iilf~Jj.1I rg~-1iIt~~~~Jmfit~.*:I~A~rmwrml*~ , !J$u:WrmJr 1. ji'jj1iM~.-§mJli{(Jfioo. I. 0. 0. JE. ,. 0.

(5) ~~tt~Jm.4j{~ffAziJf~. 81. *_. .*4. r!liIfU ~il:1f fIjj iWr • Je1i , 111:t£ 1( ~~ $1(1'19 Jl~:1f fIjj I1P IzsLA..iJ ~~ tm II {jji'jj Jt*o 3.*1iJf9i:flftZ~~ , :t£ 'BIt 1iJf9i: ili5?:H4~ ~ T 1i~H~ II B ' • • 11 B ' lit~l!jf{JM 1HI• • m~,.~ •••$.~ 0~~~Z*1(,~&m.a~-@~.~• • .r.1'I9.:I1 ° .tltj~ , Q).~IIf£Z~~.~jm.~1iJf9i:flft ' .~~tm:@II1BZ~.iJ~ *~:ffABZiljJJff~, {.E!!Jl'I25I.tltji'jjR?lIllttTjft@:m:~Z1l!!:1f'~~F.;;f1J • • ° ~1X':t£. .•. ~~~~~*,~~flftZ~~~.~~~~~~o 4.J!1t1iJf9i:flftQ).li.E-.~. ( ¥Jtff~ ) ~~ ,. tiLtft*~~.~Jm.ZilfF*.. ' .Q).. Jt~IUE If.'lit~~.;;f1j • • I'I9.~il;!J~ °. 5.00~@]!&*~:if:~. , ~.*1iJf9i:*f1TZ*~~~~. 0. 3i,.tjfi].w.~. H~~"'''Jm. -~ji'jj~. , 1i:Jt1M~¥IJ~F.;;f1J.~ ( nonprofit organizations ) ~ , 1t~.r.rij( T: r .ugm. J (neighborhood organizations)' r tllii1i.• • J ( community organizations) , r-0~1I1l J ' r fl.A~1IJft.fL. J (private voluntary organiza tions) ,r ~*t.fL. J (philanthroic organizations) , r $ti:1L$r, J (Indepen dent Sector) , r ~~~r' J ( The Third Sector) , r ~~ J (foundation) , r ~Fl!jf{JM J ( nongovernmental) lit r ~Fitff. J (noncommercial) 1'19.*~~ , i'i.~'i&f.P}~o. ' ~ Q).:t£ tl! mf.P} Jij: 1'19 i'i • rtr ' *1iJf9i: 'ffi" Q). r ~F.~Jm. J (nonprofit organization).Z, .Q).8.Jt:ffjjlj~l!jf{JMm.~1E: • • • I'I9¥.f'~ :if:m , m:.I'I9~l!~~Z.t.It , :ff~~~J..I'I9~ • •~1m \ 1!~:fit1E , litJt¥.f1( ~ fIjj riiH.t;bu Q). A Ill¥]" ~F.;;f1Jm• • m~it:fit1E~: r A1ir!A.1* ' Q).0~JlIU9}~~1fJr ' $:ff:*.&-' ~ , :if:Q)..;;f1J~ § 1'19 m.:Ml~:if:*lfC~pg~fi',/;~ ,~A:ff tm$tij'['~1(Zm. J 125I.tlt , ~ f!Jj _:fit1E1iJf9i:fa lIJ , ~ ~it-0~ff l!jf{ 1'19 r -0 ~ J ¥.f'~ , *1iJf9i::fit1E~~ .~J • 1'191E~~: r A:ff0~!ruR~-6P, fltli1Jl:J1M±1r:tlH!l:, ~Q)..;;f1J~§I'I9Z0~r!A m. J ~m , 1t~l!jf{#tIl.l'I9m.'~1(¥.f9l , ilt:if:9UJ..*1iJf9i:Zfalll 1&• .tlt1E~ , :Jtll ~r!Z r rtrtmtlllr!A J , ~HansmannJ9fml'l9 r 1i~~ J m. , litAIllr!Z • •111 B~ A:ff1i1tlJf£1(1'19 m. ' litMIIIr!A rtr Zl!jf{JM ~~l!jf{JM IHI f*_tJJ ZM III r!A , ®'ffi"ll~~~*1iJf9i:l'I9fa(l]Zj~ ~~.~J • • {1l~ l!jf{JM ~fl. A 1E:. Z tm 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. til.. •. 0. 0. (=~.fT. itCD Virginia A. Hodgkinson, Richard W. Lyman and Associate 008., The Future of the Nonprofit Sector; Challenges, Changes, and Policy Considerations (San Francisco, CA.' Jossey-Bass ,1989) ; Dennis R. Young, Robert M. Hollister and Virginia A. Hodgkinson, eds., Governing, Leading and Managing Nonprofit Organizations ( San Francisco, CA.: Jossey-Bass,1993). it® ~m.~, IltllitA1t1l1llazA¥M (. t5-~~. , ff;!(~liff~HlJiiPIf~~!ht,. ~II!'JAT=1f). 0.

(6) *M~tirm~D~J~~~.~: r~~m~~~~§.,®~~m~.~(. , ]E~'1I~m~*.f$*' tJ~m J ®ti r m~~ J Jtut:~nrl=WJllXtJ9~ ~ , ~~Jl3t1JjJ::.~~tJ9m~~ : ap1£m~~.W.~!ft:l«~mtJ9Jl3t{lr , Ji1lt~l;..t1l. 11 ( board ) ~~~'~tJ9~~~ , tA1-T~ ( ~fif.l:Hf~ , .~.) (chief executive officer ) AtAfitttJ9m~~ ; =AmfFJ::.1t~tJ9m~~ : EEm-~~1f~Jm~~.5¥tt, A, M,. ,. ~. ) zmfF '. IWt~:i~P·f!j~~~ § .. ~~Jltm.fJJ!.~.ii.~x1ttJ9~W~:m1HHj. 0. A~~~ttW~~.mtJ9~1t~*,~~1£~.~A~~~ffJl3t~~,]Etim~A~ :l«*~ •. .fJtJ9A, • • •~:l«*m~~.~o-.®~,mm~tt• •mfFtJ9~~, ®~l;..t.M~' • • ~'tAD~'d.~~IA~.m~~,.~~-®[email protected] J::.,m~n~-WffititttJ9~~,m.m®.~m-~~tJ9MAdm.zJ::.o~®,*. M~A~m~~~£A~$l;..t~M~~D,~~~J::.~-MJllX,®l;..tA1t~~ •. .fJ z • • ~~tAfi~(M.~'.~.)AM~ti~o Jlt91- , Am~m~tJ9~. ' -tl!.~~'.fim r ~~ J J!. r ~J1I! J rHltJ914'H't Bennis WNanus~;g. r ~J1I!~:litl'E• •1Mc!if ( do things right) ; ®m~~Jtu~~titJ9.'tn ( do the right things) J @ , JJ91- ' ZaleznikJtU~A r 1fJ1l!~IU.IJL'.'tntJ9M1tJ1l!1i ;a:; ( how) ,®m~~IU.IJL'.'tnI19~. ( what) J ®WtJlt®~ , =~tJ9*~~A : m~~~.~~~:itU~:$JltJL'.fJ ; ®~J1I!~{i1£:iiDJl3t1JjliUfHI~® 1!!• • t , =~ • • ~l;..t • • • *,~Jlt*M~]E~~~m~~.1fJ1l!~A~.~tt.,1!!ID. M~~~.!ftm-• • JlOOtJ9.M,®~~.&tt.~.o~~ • • m-~~m~~tJ9 • • ,m~A~,l;..t&m~tiii.~tJ9fFm'~.W~.JlOOo 0. 0. 0. 0. *,3t.~rm ~~"'~Jii.~1fJ1l!tJ9M~. , Mm-1977~~lIlf1)tf.**tJ9~~"'~Jii.~1i*M. ( the Program on NPOs at Yale University) ,l;..t&:itfIB*.!ftJL,tJ9ffiIU.lM~ -31!JN:M ~.!}.1t~~lItJ9JfJtrtt ' ~V1f'W:et~.mtJJI19IU.11j EEm-1970~1~~i11f~:etl\::!3i!~ tt~1J.~ , 1;A&1980~~JfJtJ&tim-:f±tlilHUftJ9~~~tJ9~. , :iiI~~F"'~Jii.~*§ f±11*W1 tJ9ifUI:!3i!JfJtJ& 119M W1i&A*.~~ , m-~~F"'~J ii.~~1l fiiJ~~!ctmmm .~:!3i! 1fJlm~ , ~A:it1fJ1l!~'.IZ,~tt)t51BfltJ9r,,~. +~* ' *$**&M~¥{lrB.~F'fi'~J~.1fJ1l!tJ9~~7~A1i?:~1fJ1l! ( MBA) !lV'&~-TJfJt ( MPA ) tJ9~ '±'.tJ9-iJM:~the Mandel Center for NPOs at Case Western Reserve University l;..tlitthe Institute for Nonprofit Organization -tl!.if!#t~F"'~Jii.~1f Management at the University of San Francisco ; 0. 0. 0. 0. m®••. it® Gray A. YukI, Leadership in Organizations, 2nd ed., (Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentic-Hall Inc., 1989) p.4. it® W. G. Bennis and B. Nanus. Leaders: The Strategies for Taking Charge ( New York: Harper & Row, 1985) , p.21. it® A. ZaIeznik, • Managers and Leaders' Are They Different? • Harvard Business Review Vol. 55, No.5 ( 1977) • pp. 67-78.. it® ill'lit®, p.5.

(7) ~~ ftiflJtdlfiilHl;iJfTA LJi1f~. 83. J:!!a<J*m " Jlt7r , ill JtlH±:tmThe Foundation Center, Jossey- Bass~ , ztFt.v}t.v} illJl1i-~jtlfflm~FttllJml~a<JiaH"J Jt4t ' ~Af-t~a<J~fFff : 1984&fDavid Mason a<J Voluntary Nonprofit Enterprise ManagementAJ& ..!f!.*J~FttlljtlEL.~J:!!a<JJII~~ 0. itq{E$"~~-1a<J~fF "®1987&fJmfl.::k*~F~lIjtlEL~~jff-.JiJTillJl1ia<JThe Nonprofit. &ctor: A Research Handbook , ltUIll~ 7lff$~Fttlljmfl(~J:!!JHl~a<J:.mIm)(j): 0 Managers of Nonprofit Organi. ®1988&f!EO'Neill~YoungJiJTfMii~a<JEducating. zations , !&~7±~a<J*:if!l!.~WA±a<J.mIV.ffntru~~FttllJm.a<J~J:!!. 0. ®1990. &fINDEPENDENTSECTOR$Hr-~ju~FttllJmfl(~;lJ!l!~J:!!a<J1iJfWfr. ' .mJ~:lr. 7 <Nonprofit & Leadership >a<J.~Wlfij 7r' Peter DrukertE.:$m*lIiJi: mt. , .s1E~:lr..r~1iJfjt~F~lIJtlEL.a<J~U ' .s1E~ff (Managing the Nonprofit Orga nization) ( 1990 ) -if @ ~F~lIJmfl(~J:!!a<J1iJfjta<J~JlHlf~ , ::k3&l:IlJ?}AmWl "1980&ff-t ' IlJmA:J!it 0. 0. ~!l!.~~Jlt~~:.mIm1iJfjt~~Z~~,.s1EH~~it~*1I~OO.tta<J~~!l!4~tl. fr@1J!fj ; mJ1990&ff-t , lttJ~lI~f*ffl'fItHffm.a<J1J~~$~F~lIjm.~J:!!a<J1iJfjt " &.~Ila<J'tR~ , ~F~lIJmfl(a<J::km;flH$5G~a<J.jf;g , H¥lj19804t ' *WlJft7f1m It!l!:.m 1m ~ma<J ~ i&z 1~1J;t mJ 1lft 11:~~J:!!!l!0)t1i Jft*mWfl~FttllJt.iH'(1iJfjt a<J 11m , tE.:J! i1i_ &f;t jf;g Jft::k0 )tfi Jft1iJfjtJiJT ' Jft::k11: ~1fJ:!! 1iJfjtJiJT!l! €l'::k tl fr ~ tE.t.v}t.v}mJ ~.JlifU~~ , @f}}&ffJlllia<J .r~ 1I:HtiltlL €l'~~\ut ~F ~lIJm.1iJfjt a<J *±~~.~ , £ifJlifUm:~~F~lIJmfl(a<J1iJfjt*fft § frJa<J ±~1iJfjt)(.f}} IV.1t~*1iI )(.~$ iii pg fflff$~FttllJtifl( ~ it:lt!!.ii1i!f!W!l!~*a<JmltJ , ~n~1iI82&f!E~ 1iI)(.~*frJiJT:lr.a<Jr)(.~*fr~~frJ'~IiI~&f!EA*• • ~*frJiJT±.a<Jr 1l• • a¥::k.ffJ,IV.A!E*tlE~• •frJiJT*ma<JrtlE• •frJ ~F~lIJmfl(~JJW1fJ:!!a<J1iJfJt: , ~7 ~lIM~W~Fttlljmfl(!l!if&J1f W11:~a<JAfiij , ~ F~ lIJm.a<J Jmt fft:J!~ ~JtftMill. a<J fJf JfAfff; , 1fJ:!!:ifltlJ *JIV. fiiJlI~J1I1J W~J1I1J *1tt .~~a<JIfF1:(A~' ~F~lIJmfl(a<J § a<J~~ffJjIJ~Jt1l!!ti.~pgMlZ7r ' ftJtllm JtM~1&:J:!!a<Jttm!l!~~ , ~FttllJti.a<Jii ( J:!!.) $fra<JJtff!l!:wfm ' Jt!l!J&~~1i A~a<Jlmf*' ::(£~fiijm;flAlI.a<J~F~lIJm.a<J1f~ttJ5 , IV.A~F~lIjti.J!Jt11B$ r~a<JlHlf*W~"JljIij~.~ tta<J*~ , ~Fttlljmfl(~iiJ!1f~a<J1iJf~ , Jt±~IlJ. ~A : (I)~J:!! ( governance) : ~FttllJm.::(£.~J!it.~~l:~~~.mJ$5Ga<J ttit ' f51mJim~ff~fiija<Jii ( ~ ) $fr!l!Ai~a<JJt1flHlfjJ!~J:!!~m ; (2)A:1JJUl1f J:!! (management of human resources) : !EM rAJ :J!~F~lIJti.~:wmfFa<J± 0. J£*.. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. ~1m.,.mJ.WJt.~'.J!~.'~J1I1J~m,mii~~.aI'~fJfA~J!ii$ itt® D. E. Mason, Voluntary Nonprofit Enterprise Management ( New York: Plenum,1984 ). tt® tt®. Walter W. Powell, ed., The Nonprofit Sector: A Research Handbook (New Haven, CT.: Yale University Press, 1987 ) M. O'Neill, and D. R., Young, Educating Managers of Nonprofit OrganizatuHls (New York: Praeger, 1985 ). itt@> Peter F. Druker, Managing the Non·Profit Organization: Practices and Principles (N.Y.: Harper Collins Publishers, 1990 ).

(8) irnJ(;J4.a<J1r5:tjt!HT1Vf~. ; (3)Jijijpg:llltJlJ ( management of financial resources) : ~~ 1t;fijf.lll.1!:a:fHt1M a<J M~i&A , ~f.Ill.a<Jff.:fl~@~iif %a<J fM~ , JiJf ~ 1f~;tt a<JM~mJiJ~jJM1It!f. ; (4}.tfl.pgi!fJ!l ( management of information) : RP1Vf~ f.Ill.a<JifflfM.ftlW.fIJ.a<JYl:fL1fili ; (5}tt1t!t;ll.ppgi!fJ!l ( managingfor social chang e) : lEttllPeter DrukerJiJf1f, ~~1t;fiJta.1!tEAtJJ:li!~fR]a<J~~.tJtmJ , tt1:6it:Jfo~ :iI&fJlJtI ~Jf a~~ -I';fijta.a<J M!1fIr ' w. {IE M!;ft..£110~:ftf j2;] JIt , Ji!J1t:fl fM a<J 1Vf~ tt1;f{1 Jj:itl!.1It!f. ; (6}jIlN&1fJ!l (strategic management) : 1jJf~~~-I';fijta.tE:jt~~a<J*± 0. ~.tJt~,JiJfmm~fR]a<J1r~'I~~~~*~nJ(;:jtM!~~§.o@. l\ '\. ,{iJf 7t ~i.-it. ~.mr1!~~-I';fijta.Ji!~;lJ1Tffi4Z::t.%;fff. ,. W.btJj~TII.a<JfJJ$fifj~JL'~~. *1Vf~1jJf~IiiMf*JrJi!:l:m~:lt~ , RPtEj1MTJra<J.ft*,,·Jtt~a<JfR]~ 1r5:t,~Jj1Vf~±m~-~~mJ~Aa<J*1to. -,. , oFf*1Trp~~f.41t. .~,HiJf~mtit. (-~.1iJf~~IU~1iJf~rc'. ~~::t.a<J.mw.btJj1Vf~±ma<JfJJ$ • • 'M1t1jJf~ • • ~~=:. II='. iJ{. iJ{. ~iJ{ I $-1. 2.11. iJ. iJ{!14. ~. A~. ~tt ~J.5. m ~. It ~ J& 2. g It. iJ{~. ~iM ;JI !14&. 'UI1iJf~~.. iJ{ ~. iJ{ ~. tg. m. ~. m. lt~*llil. Dennis R. Young, op. cit., p.. ~. $t. lImA~J1{. &.lUI1!J1{. 1. iiJJiJ 2.1ftt 3.fHfflIt. 2.M~. 4.~1f1f;lJt. Jr,-,. ~®. iJ{. iJ. 4~6.. : *li1f~IV!l! '. ,. 1.'I1:fl. 3.mm 4.1ftt.

(9) ~~tt'fljf.\fL~~2J1-=r~Z 1iJf~. M1HIIl'=: , *1iJfJtWiti ~ fUfJtfflH5t ~ -r-,,) J9T:iil1UlHWi : ( ttt5). l.Vjj~~~~Jt.iijl4fi • .ifJ9T5~WitiZA~*f1t~4fi.ff~j]. 85. ,,&JtJ!~AM'-m. .~o. 2.ft(1p~~Jt.iijl4fi~.ifZ4fiiJ1i'1~:W5mliJ]UUi. , MM1p~~Jt.ii.Z4fiiJl'i:~ ; .ilEf*~. ~~l'i:~t.ii.MJ!~#~~~~4fi~l'i:~o. 3. Vii ~p ~~J~Jljl4fi~.if Z 4fi iJ.~ ,&JV(;~ Jjt.ii.ml'1;f1l til.~. Z~:W'IWm. 4.~Jt1p~~Uli.~ifJ(J{f ZlHlfj'&1p~~J~IHf~JjifJ(J{f z~lt 5.~~1p~~Jtii.4fi •. 0. 0. .if J9TllJfmlfjj]j~ rR~M , '&4fi~.ifJj.lltJl!;rR~M~;j:m~lt. 0. 6.~Jt1p~~Jtil.~ • .ifJ!~ft(~~Jl!;~~*ttt$~p~~J!.iIl.~~.Ift,. 7.VIi~p~~Jt.ii.Z~iJ.ifJ!~1IJt4fi~*f~. 8.•m1p~~Jt.iijl4fi~.ifJj4fi~Z}E~. , '&llJfmil:ii~4fi.m*. 0. 0. ~V.*~~t.iijl~iJ.if1IlHlft.·~.·.1f~lt·'&.1f • • ~.m.o 1O.V.1p~~Jtil.1IIHlt.ii.l'i:~. • !.iIl.m.:m. til.~.· '&,mjlml'1~.m. !fj,,~ , Mt:Jllltiljlj(1t:W4fiiJ • 1P~~Jtil.¥Jth*:Wjf$. • '&~ • .if~m.JV(;~ :![l'11Hl1j······~;j:~liIM , [;§~.M'~Wl·l1:rR~~t:f.lJ. , *fM'~lt~~~~:W.~tfI) 0. 7t¥}-r~~A~~Mo. (=)fVf~n$~fVf~)i@ l.fVf~~. *1iJf~zWiti.Jj.~a~ft~J9T1I*~~til• •1iJfJt• • •. , • • ~A+=~+. -A=+~B,&A+=~+=A*B7t.V~t:f~:W~~*~WMIHl,&*.~ifJ(J{f, ~Jtf£fjtm~Wz~p~~Jtil.~~ , [email protected]&~~ , ffi{]J1IJl!;.~*fmm:fjt 0. mLfl.mmI&¥U ~~~t:f iJ.~ifJ(J{f,&*.~ifJ(J{f J9T ~WZ1p~~J!.iIl. ' !IX.14Jm.:m ~~\·!IX~1I~ftml'1z~~o.~Jtt:fZ~~h.$~fm~Z~~.,W~~*1iJf. JtzA: §' , [;§.Ilt , *1iJfJtJ5~}E ~ t:f ~* A:WMlHlmA:W z~~tl:1p~~Jtil• •1iJfJt •• 0. !fj,,~ , 1&*1iJfJtJj1p~~Jt.ii.Z3il}E:. r ~1I~;JkH!l$j~~ , .~~jfgt±1t;ftlfJJ:. ,~~~~.§~Z~ft~Atil.oJ,[;§.Ilt.1iJfJtJj.}E.~~ftZ~ftt±~:WM ~~A.ft~,W~§m~r.l'i:~.:. (1)Jmt~~.. : :JlIlJlii.«1t·. I[§j~.'& S EB)iU~~.. 0. (2):![ft·I1:~.. : .Iltl'i:~.~~~~*1t~z~Jft , :Jl1l~*1t· ~~1t'&.1f1t~ (3).~1lt·I1:~ftml'1z~~~. : A.~M~~A1JOO : §mit~tfI) • ~~tfI) • M 0. ifJ(tfI)·x~tfI)·m~~·Jl~1t·~~1t,'&!li~1tm~Wz~.,*,&*tfI)7t~~ ~.eIfA:WZ.~~~IIl.. ; B.t±lIlitA1JOO : §m~Jl!;*1t;f1l1iJfJt1ttl:1lIll.· .1f. 1Il.·~• •~~.,ifJ(Mtl:IIl.,&*tfI)7t~~.~.o. (4)*lE:rtJL~IIl. ~M'it4-:WlfifrmmifitJ. ZIIl.o. : ~Jl!;1P~~Jtil.!IX~M'.*~ffXA~ ( :Jl1l3l3h*~) • !IX. ( :Jl1l~Jl!;t±1tml'1~.:Wt±fiiV~t.ii.). ,W*In]A:WMIHl~JrC..

(10) 10 WI. 86. ~m. 84 ip 10 fI. [l;J.lIt , *1i.IfJi:1* ffl :lL ~1l1J ~:Jjt! ' ~.ltUiE! ~ HI ~~F -tf ~J ~.* j{ fj{J 1m ~ II a : *tt, U-ftHlit* ' Jlt:ijtiij1dfl ' 1it)c{ttt1f~lIa ' *1iJtl\*1i.IfJi:zlllJitti~ ~111* 1i.IfJi:ti~±1f.Il1itlt§ :im~- ~:nt*1i.IfJi:tIJ~ti~z~. ' [l;Jl\~F-tf~J~.4'z .~~~~~~.~,~m*~~~~~~mA' (111)$~' (111) ,~~ .~ ( tLLH~) ~ , 11I!1,l:1iM~f1~ngA~f.I[:l.~ , :pffF-.~ , ~.lIt-IfF:i.I!:ntff; lfif~fljtffi.'Y£ , ~~*1i.IfJi:JJ~.~F-tf~Jil.4'±~z~$mM1J~, tLLfr 0. 0. ~~~~$,*1iJtl\tIJ~zti~o~7~,~[l;Jjt$~,m~'~B$~~~~f.I[:l.z. .~~~A,.~ti~~.w~1it~.~,tLLH~~.~$~~~A.o 2.rr:J~vilM (l)~.;iI~. flll~~fil\fj{J1i.IfJi::i.I!~=+~*,*$lt~.ffl~~.~.ffl:lL*.~.D.. *.wrifHIm*~. r ~~~llA1tai!ftr..~~ J. tionnaire , MfiLBDQ) , r 1f11lfil\1tai!ftr..~~ ( Supervisory Behavior Description Ques tionnaire , MfiSBDQ~SBD ) , ~f~~1i~LBDQ- xn ,. ¥t;- raJ.iiJfJ[lta;t::• • I.IR..~. l:1f;fllM It§. It If. m. f.I!j. i&. ~. !.:j::. .UJU. ml. ml. !f. !f. *1iJtA~:It~lIf;fiA~IJ':!.oL. BDQfi} ,. SBD@1itf~~~fj{JLSD. Q-xn Qj±~JJ1j r ~fI J ~ r am J m'1Im:lt~ ) fl/{A ~lIf;~fr l\~1tai!ft ; jtfm~fl~1P1~ r $ J 1!X r IA J , r f£$JfiuliJ J ~. r .I~101. J A:It~~:ltI'C.'. It f±~ IJR~ m~. 1*~. pq. )tit. ?{f. '§' :(£M~ ~~fi l\ ~1*MI! Jj(. fllf. rttlzllf~. IJ\*. z:fB II r,,~ ~. 0. ff:m.llt~:It~ fj{J. , fW.:i.I!:ntM{t~iJfil\. (Leader Behavior Description Ques. )~~~*1i.If~z § ~ , tJ{*-r. rg. MIIl7'!A 1f±1Il7'!A MIWI7'!A f±1Il7'!A MIIl7'!A f±1Il7'!A MIIl7'!A ;t.±1Il7'!A. .. 74. *. 81. 155. 43. !. 291. 4. 18. 150. 427. 639. 427. 338. 18. 577 18. 4. 1088. 1*Jflo .lIt7~. ,. ~~r..~~. 0. it@ it@. *1i.IfJi:~~~.1*fflRobert. E. Quinnfj{JJim ( competing values ) ~~ @Quinn*F~~~~~7}l\Afj : A.~J!fi~ ; B.*~A!/m ; C.j::ii~ ; D.. J. K. Hemphill, Leader Behavior Description ( Ohio: Ohio State University, 1950 ) E. A., Fleishman," The Description of Supervisory Behavior', Personnel Psychology VoL 37 ( 1953 ) , pp. 1 ~6. R. M. Stogdill, Manual for the Leader Behavior Description ( Columbus: Ohio State University, Bureau of Business Research, it@ Robert E. Quinn, Beyond Rational Management: Mastering the Demands of High Performance (San Francisco, CA. : Jossey-Bass,. it@. Questionnaire- Form XII 1963 ) Paradoxes and Competing 1988 ).

(11) ~F~l1jmIHl~fiAZJjjfrt. 87. ffilf-:t!f ; E.1th~:t!f ; F.lt"':t!f ; G.ilEii:t!f ; H.t&~:t!f Qllt-.ta~~jf£:~H1Jli!LBDQ ~.~~AH.~,M~~~*~~~m~,~llt,~~~~~.~fiB~=~AQ .~ff§jnN9:~~$;t19rd:l~iiJf3t*,JJf:l. ~.~.~~. ••~~r •• ~J'. ,. ~:lItlpmil!Ug§l'!ird:l~ZA..'. r~a~J' r_.~J,~r. QtBt , JJ:t=DIl. ••~J ••Z. .li!,~~llt~~.~.~~~B~~~~~~ • •~,~H,m~~ffi~~~.m ~~~'I'*,J1.iIl.~.~M'.. Q[;5Illt ,. mijlgT~1F't19M.'L.'. .~~~rtJ~~~-M'.?. r BIl.~+l~. , :m~1I1HfR~~'I'*,J1.iIl• .pZ Jm5§tfi.l1t19 r .ilJf. J~ r ilH.Jj J ~1SiE~.. :?f~P'l'*,J1.iIl.+lij;ZM;pjt. ? "*M'.a<J~~'I'*,J1.iIl.~~ff{E~IRJa<J+l~M'. ? ~~'I'*,Jm. • .p ~ • •~1S.~j§f{}1f~ iE:~'1lH' .p a<J +l1l ? It/, ~~ il ~~ 'I'*,J1.iIlfl(+l.I¥J*WJtM ?~1S.~~m?{Ellt$~~t19m~r,*~~JJm~T~-~~~oJtTA.iiJfi ,£:t=.~~~~It/,.~@~,H~~ • • ~~o.lltJJn.iiffH1J~I~,~~m. A+ -1f+Af:JE~~A~~llZ~~'I'*,J1.iIl• • l±lrd:l~-1H5}, @!&-=:+A~, ~I!;l# ~*'"*.M~ • • • M.~mll~taM*~+A.~,.X.p~.~~~.~~M M.,"*.MI!;l.~.$.~,~~JJ~iifi.aQM£• • t19~,.~.~*.ft .t19M*,.Jtllt~~~m • • M.~*Wtl9.ll~~.,~Hm~~~Wtl9~~~ M;pjt , ~~t:R:~~• • ij2:*r..'~ Jt T~.-{5}~:mtl9r..~~ , JJ@M~p'l'*,J1.iIl.ffi~)(~a<J~~~rm , ~~+l~ff Jttl9~.:ll!i~j1Jtk , ~.~~~t191*~~ULBDQtI9=~.M , ~I.li!~~.1I • • , ~H~=:fi'm*1iJf~Z §I tI9 , ~~fJDrucker@, Herman & Heimovics@' Wolfa, Knauft et al Q@ , Carve:r@ , Fisher & Cole®, Powell@, Gies et al@' ,~15@' ~ ._.·~)(~,It/, • • *1iJf~~OO~,llt~).~a<J~~~ • • fi.~.~- • • 0. ,@~fIl]BJf:lT~1f~~o. (2)rJj~~~. I .~ -~~----4Ji.* A;fit..4f1f. tt@ raJtt@ tt® Robert D.. Herman, and Richard D. Heimovies, Executive Leadership in Nonprofit Organizations ( San Francisco, CA.: Jossey - Bass, 1991 ) tt@ Thomas Wolf, Managing A Nonprofit Organization ( N. Y.: A Fireside Book, 1990) tt@ E. B. Knauft, Renee A. Berger and Sandra T. Gray, Profiles of Excellence: Achieving Success in the Nonprofit Sector ( San Francisco, CA.: Jossey- Bass,1991 ) itt@) John Carver, Boards That Make a Difference: A New Design for Leadership in Nonprofit and Public Organizations ( San Francisco, CA.: Jossey - Bass, 1990 ) itt® J. C. Fisher & K. M. Cole, Leadership and Management of Volunteer Programs (San Francisco, CA.: Jossey- Bass, 1993 ). tt@ raJtt@ itt@ David L. Gies, J. Steven Ott and Jay M. Shafritz, The Nonprofit Organization: Essential Readings ( Belmont, CA.: Wadsworth Inc., 1990). itt@. ,,!!5~ ( Anthony D' SouzaJi.l(*) ~fillfl/JlI.-ftIl..1J)!fI/J.m.. tt® •••. 1. ( a:ft : ~1II"m ' IO\!.IJJ\.+'=::!f:) •. a:ftrtHt.mjfIJlI"±'l1fzmi;J1:fp:wJt1fllI!I-/ftiJe.Zif~ J. 3t,IO\!.[l1::-r.1L:!f:c. 1. i&*U*:III:Iilf~JiJi'U:±M.

(12) ;. /. tE~1r'$$ B<J lIfd1:~lIItftj rf1 jtllA~J{. '. ~Jt~fi~~~'ftJll.~iHl~;f!f{m1r'~iU'4Ij -~~;f!flf. , ~ll~1r~tfJ\~Jj!~fiiJ~~~'ftJll..B<J~~;f!flfjt~fiiJB<JAm~J{ , fi'ffm~. X~.7~~ll..jt~~~B<J~~)tE~~~m~~M~~~B<J~fiiJ)~~~.7~ lIll..~f~. l?iIIlt , *1iJfJEYlJ.7tt1i1l#J1.B<JAm~J{, fiiJlJiftfJ\IlJEb1Y:tftj;f!f~:bnl;A .~)~~rf1~ili+~• • B<JAM~J{,~.~.A • • 1Y:tftj;f!f.Ilt+~~J{~l;Am It , {f*~:ltlfjtmlt!t ) atfl.>j(~~~'ftlll..~~;f!f~Ilt+~~J{~fjEilim: • •B<J 0. ,::::~~J{o. IT .~..::..~?)----4Ji.~E,JJ ( 4iJ:,. ). r~~~A.~,~A~*J\ r~~~~~A~$J)~Ilt'~7~~$~A m~J{$?twrllJmHfj~lIA~~fm}]B<J~A~r fm}]~ttJ5. , {Il1~*:bnl;A*JE. m.~-=-~?)---4Ji.IJi~. 0. ) ~fiiJB<J~~;f!ftfJ\IlJf1~~.~fiiJB<J~~. *$?tB<J~r"tjJ~~~-$?t;fl'ffiiJ. 0. ( jL~). Ilt$?tB<J$~.~Eb$~~-&oo.~~w.afi'ff*,~.tE*JE*~~ll..~ ~;f!f~~ • •~~. \ »IU1}~ \ ~~~ ,. ; I;Alk:::r~fiiJ~~~~~'ftlll..1Hj1o. ~~it~~~. ~;ff~fiiJB<J~~~ti°. *fj ). J"Hr ) ~A~+=.JtU:f£*M~~~'ftlll..§1'J ( z~ij$tt \ ll..~~.~ ~~Um~B<J~~'m% \ ~~;f!fmJfH'ltB<J'I1il£ , lktf{~mt.mlol;A{fJl~~~A~ ~ij~~. 0. IV.~ lZ!1~?)--1tJtJA- ~J.t~fJfifii ~ r..':J!. \ mmm.~ \ .lJ!t'1f ' lkm ( • ) WJ~B<Jtif~~ll ) Ilt$?tB<Jf~fJ3ta{llAO.7503 ~1i~= +m ) JtlJtE~Il~~~ 'ftJll..tf{~;f!f.jtwrllJfmiIifli;B<J*flr,,'.B<J.m~J3t~nM , tfJ\IIPJHJ~@r,,'m~JJIj.m , Ilt$?tB<JfflJ3tatRAO.8760 ~Al:~+*mrJjJijg$.~A • •ll~:bnl;A.mB<J/ir'. ' loat*1iJfJEX:bnr,,'7-=: lIruut~r,,'m : HtrIlY.tE*JE~~~'ftJll..tf{~;f!f.ill1ffB<J7!~~~J 0. 0. AM1Y:tftj;f!f.~OO.wr*alkB<JOO.:I;A.M~~~~ll..tf{~;f!fwriIifli;(.m) B<JrJjmf,l;Jlf~~@. ;. B.M1Y:tftj;f!fmilijtll..wr~ • •WJB<J/ir'm. : I;A.M~~~'ftlll.. ( tf{~;f!f ) wr~. ? c.M1Y:tftj;f!failijtll..f,l;J*5G:f!fOOm : Ilt$?tA~~~'ftlll..iEtE:bn~mrf1fi'ff~~~. ~r}].WJB<J~§lf~~@. ~A.WJ;f!f,EbIlttfJ\IlJ~Jj!*~~ll..~~.B<J~.AM)l;Alk.}]B<J~~o. v .~li.~?)--~·~·MJa.t\.r,,':J! Eb~tfF$lf~tf{~1TAB<Jr,,'.. '. ~7!~Eb~~~~IIPfm1~9;Jl. , l?iIIlt , *1iJfJEtEIlt £OOlk 7 jL'fOOjjf)1it~~. , 1;A.l*A.m~~~'ftlll..~~;f!fz~~~ , it}] \ lIAJ1. 2 ' ~mlM.Jfi , lktf{~B<Jl!J1.~nM? J"Hr ) tfJ\*JE1m1r'l;Aft.~7!*.~A~B<JIfP .~?wriIifli;B<Jtf{~m~?~jt~0~ll..It®*,lfMtf{~~~?m:{f,~.jtA tf{~r-lI~.o.

(13) ~HUljt.ll..1llJrr~z.liJt~. 89. 3.••ii~ *1M~)]!:U JH:ll.1ft~~r.mpq. rOOlW J 1f:r1:*Ji~atfl1bt;rRn~Jt*1J. ' '1tIzl~Il'I1:~~-I'~J~" • .:E , i§.mlIiff~litffl~-!t'$~lJim ' tt"8Jt!tl1m ' An ' m.Jt:&1Ifiitl1nt. • • ~~.L,n~~~~~~~~1f:r1:*~fiR~o~~,~~~.~lW~*~~ ~@.~~~,~mm$*~~~~Z~o. =-. *li1tJi.t5\ lttJJ li'H~:.Il1J\+:::'1+ Ji \)1 \ ~lt j 1f"i-\.tt1t3fJl: >it ( ~~ ) z. ~Il1fl , ~*Iill!&-s -tt=f)t , *JlmWlll* , :1t~ , fl-@rR'~[5]I* • • Bilf$jj'jj:ll~1ill ( 7'\t-A15t) iit~T~~1ifpj§ , .~fll&* ±j~m.;9~ , £ m.~~*Jfl ' ~fl:;!jl;@~~-I'~Jti,.Z f±:i1f:~IfJ~~~1i~.~ ( ¥JLfi ).mM••• ,n• • 1M~~~~~.o.~.~tt:i1f:R$*~lW.~±j~• • ~~-I'~Jti,.~mrR'~--=f~A t-Af)t. 0. ~,~=~~m~~~sf)t'~~fll&$*,~ ~lilll&=s-t-Af)t,~~ • • ~~t--f)t'. l&~~-s_t-=f)to.~=~~. • • fl.~~:='S.7'\f)t,.Iill~*.. s*ZitA~-o. =\wtr.J~~~it. r ~Il"\w~ J fj1t~1M~JflJi~Jt*4~-'M~*1f7! ,. ~~~.a9M~Blf5.ma.J. a9.m~~,~m[5]*H~:&mft~~U,jj'jj~~m~.~a9~~Jfl,~.-@ • • A. ~o*M~~~*-~m.Jfl~~.~m~.ID,~mTm~~.*~a9~~\~R ~.r'l9Hm~Hfj, ti.)(1tJl~lJ.. '. :i1i@:.t5J7!.V:&tim"~~~iEj:\;f1.l~~~.1tZ~. ~R~~a91M~,[5]~,:1t~~A.~'Rm.~lJA~fi~~\W~'Wl~~OOtiOO. a9• • • Jfl,.m~~a9~fflm~,jj'jj~\W~~IfJJfl,~~~~~~a9.$,IfJ., {liR, M~;f1.l1ftif , ~ii1fEfii!.fI'Hlt:l!!~.f4Jfl~* r ft.~.ft(participant meanings ) J a9Jt*4 0. (-lM~.~l:ftiW~ti. l.iW~.~ 1t~wr~flM-~'MM~. : ~~iE:r1:ti~:r1:\w~ ( the informal conversational in terview) , lW~mijl7! ( the interview guide approach) , ~:&fJ*1tIJij~:r1:\w ~ ( the standardized open-ended interview):8 *M~n~ r \W~mijl7! J Z M~, ~~• • Du~~M-.:E~ , ~~~1t r ~~iE:r1:ti~:r1:lW~ J ZJ11tt j N~UM1r; 0. .~lW~M~,~mfi~~~~~.~:&.Mm. ,~'M~~.~~~~,~~.~. r fJ*1t~~:r1:lW~ J ~lfI~a9JIW{J¥rtJ~\W.~rRHH~~rR'~BIf~~Z!!1f14lUJ%• • ,[5]W~~\w.~W£Am~ttRH~tto. r \W~mijl7! J ;it.t!1..wt::m:-'M~~~.'I1:a9\W~:tj":r1: ,Robert G. Burgessmm. x. '. ,-~tJ*1ta9rR'~Mff-t-~1t:&j)&JljiJ1M1E.a9.~, W.tf¥..-'Mm~:I:t!!ijl~J!~a9 MffmHJE~~\w.~-tj7:1:t!!iiJ1:~. llt@. .:£xf.4$1!.,. .~.JnJFRll. , fE!fii!.t!1.mm , :i1ifl~~~.tta9lW~ , 1JJ~mft. ( ~::It : Jlljjj:;:"Jil:. ' ~1I-t+:tLeIf) 'p.28. 0.

(14) :/. .,. ~-M~~ • • ~ • •Z~'-M.A~ft.~.h~.~o*M~~~~• • • ~ *iitttrifMi. 0. 2.ttj'~It.. *M~~*~~1*ffl. r ~F.$1tfIft J • r ;ij[lilfQ1tfIft J*ifHi , tJ)\!!P~m..~:ff~. ••• ~ft~OO~~§~ft~.M • • o*M~~~ • • • ~~.~'~.~~.~ ~:tm"F : (1)~nt*M~tint r ~F~~Jt.il. J ~JJ::~: r A:ff 0ft~[lfj}i!!!1frr ' .~ifEifMt. m~,~~~~A§~Z0M~At.il.Jo (2)ilfmlnJl~F~~Jt.il.~f$ .~'11:*. 0. (3)~ §mrt5'_:f±.il~§.~F~~Jt.il.:fb~~Im*.~A~ , tJ)\/1P~*fi~ff.. ft. ~[l!jj • lJll~iH.r1:.~)( 1tfi1f. 0. (4)~~~Im*.~~F~~Jt.il~r:pA:ff~~ • mllJh5iiL!!)tnX;1LB~ • mm~* :f±.~.JlOO**o (5lilJt.~~ , ~;ij[lilfQ.~'l1:p1Ij~~~~~~it~~:Iib~. , ti. ( t.il~ ) *~. ) • • • ~m:fft.il~~il 0. ~nt~t.il.~~*~~.~'*M~~A'.~.( ~~.m,@~.~m~~~~OO*~,il~fi~~~A~(~.~.~fi~~~~ .~') :;f~A:ffJtiE~~.h.~.m* ' JiJf~ , ~*~~~{f*A~ 0 m..mr~~iI$lj{.~~ ,*M~• • ti.~Jtt.il• • ft~J~:((Q"F (~=) :. *= it!! M. -. ff(. it!!. ~. 7J". ~. ~. 11. f± fI D ~ Jli 1* f4!j. ff(. ~. ~_tttWHHifI. '-. ~~~miJt1iUNl~~;fIJ$.l!i~fI. tp~~II~'L'~fI ~~~mJf.\\tr.fI. ~~~m* ~ ~~1f1ft,.mfI jf~l!i~fI. it. ~.~1fl!i~fI m1illl!i~fI. ~wx~~~fI. ~. fl1lwx~l!i~fI. tt®. fIlj. l!?If~~Iti*.1itp'L· +jJ.*x~l!i~fI. .A.*~1fx~l!i~fI. X. l1.i.If.R.~m.Jlti. 'f! '\1:. .A.. $;. JL. :W. 1!!. jjI:. MII'f!.A. MIII'f!.A. MII'f!.A.. *~3t* *~3t* *~3t*. MIII'f!.A. f±111 'f!.A.. *~3tt~. f±III?i.A. f±!II?i.A. MIII?i.A. M!II?i.A. M!II?i.A. MII1?i.A. MIII?i.A. MII?i.A.. *~3t*. lW~ti~. ilJfI~ ~~$. *~.~. *~.~ ~~$. it:.3t*. ~~$. Jf$~. fJt1T*~. it:.~JL. fJtfT~. it:.~JL. fJtfT~ fJtfT~ M.~. Robert G. Burgess ed., Feld Manual ( Newbury Park, CA.: Sage. 1982) P.107.

(15) 'I ~~~*,J~!'I"HJt.fi.z iJf~. 91. (=)ifj~ti:m-.ft1j~i/!~ 1.ft1j~ti:m:tEif;~ifIj~~. , RJ~EE-. r ifIj~m51 (interview guide ) J (fJf&ttt ' *~lt 1JJ~ilE.ifljliiR(fJJt*4 ' t$1ti~ r tfj~m51 J ~ , ~PRJ*JltilAJJ!:II~~jiM-TifljIiiRIft: o tt®JlmnNilf~~1!r~~~$J.(fJrJ]:ti:~ifljliiR~ff, r tfj~m51 J :1i!::ffi'l":fiE:rt~ ~FMf«1t(fJ~ttt ' ~ffijJtJj~ifIj~~Jlt~. ff~J£·I1:(fl~. ; ~Z, r tfj~m51 J (flf& ttt,:1i!::~~~lttfj~Jj~m~*~~.~~(fl~~~~~@o. *M~~*L~~.,~.~ff~~~(fJ~.~ffi~x.,~¥ilrriflj~~ttt, MIiIl~~~A -t -~-tJ3 Tm~. a JEt r ±~JfJf61 J :ilrrIUtliJc:rtiflj~ , .~ , ~ltlgUiS:rt(fl. , lUrJ]~%:rt~tttt/j r ifIj~m51 J. ,ft:Jil(;*ff-t1lllirJ]1I!(fl r ~Fif5flJil.(flf1 J ; ~l;lJltrJ]:ti:ft:~ifIj~m51 , :tEA-t -~JLJ3 JL a -wrttlr,. r fqJwxl!t~ J ft:7*fltfj~ :tEtfj~!i.jljJJl~~ , §lj!ifIj~r~~~ff:fJl-m(flflS7t ' @]*~~P:bo. .:t-rJ]~ ~1f. 0. l;l~~'~~~~:f£z~,ft:~*ff-t-tlli~1I!(fJr~~:rt~~J,~l;lJltft:~tt ~Jj~-t -1I8l~Fif5flJm.:il~-T7*fltfj~l;lJi~Jt~-t(fl. r tfj~m51 J. 0. 2.ft1j~i/!~. • •L , :tEifIj~JJI~~ , 1E~T*.:fRJ]j9a1(flJ!. ' ~~FM~:t-fm~#l1Im1l8l M~~~,ft:~tfj~f&ttt~ifIj~t$1ti,ffijiflj~Jj~ff-t£(fl~~~a,~~M~:t-(fl. .~o~ffij,.ml;lLWN~1I!,ffi~ifIj~.-.tl.!i.jljJJl~,~&.~.*~tt ,~l;l,M~:t-~T~tt~ifIj~~~~a:ll.J!z~~,£~miflj~Jj~~-1I8lrAJ. , ffij:f1l.Jt*4(fl*mt ;. ~~. , M~:t-&~1l~~~~1& , ti~~ B(fl~.,. ~.,. m. .~ • • ~ • • ,~.~,~Jlt~fm~tfjIiiRJj~a~~tt(fl!i.~,.mJt~~m~,. • • ~m1ttfj~(flJt*4,~.~~iliM~~~o ~~l;lL(fl~. ~$J1{:flIl~ . , ~~~ff~:flllfiiJ:ilrrl*fliflj~(flJt*4 ' *M~(fliflj~JJI~~t±. 0. .e.. & .... ~J:.. "'0. ~k.-. iiiIfJ. *M~~Ill.!ti~j{{Jtlt(flM~:tfr! Il~Fif5flJm.rr~z*j{{~~~ ffi~OOfr;]. , Jll!~1'!i. 0. '. Jll!.~.f!. '. Il~~~*±(fl~!.. , *§1!iii~. ~1*M(fl±i! ' jg:flT~Fif5flJm.~~rr~(fJ*1I8l. , §mf1~:t-*~ , 1l~:t-~~~~fIS~1~ , l;l~~~itI~(fJil.x1t ' milr ' MmJj~Il~F1t5flJII..(flf1~rr~1i\t-1I8lretl*li.(fJ1*~ ~~M~f&ttt 0. L±~~~rj{{J(fl1*~~~,~Jlt,Jj~WM~ttt.(fJM~A~ffij~,M~JJI~~. , RJ~$.-~tfm(flM~zht ~T§Ij;trf~ OO(fJrJ1 , M~A~$l*~tl1&II~¥IJ~Fif5flJil.(fJ0~.' milr., ~MfWmj] , m.. ~-BJ-1I8l~F1t5flJII..(fJ:ti.. i!~~. 0. iE@ John Lofland & Lyn H. Lofland, Analyzing Social Settingsa~-A Guide to Qualitative Observation and Analysis. (Belmont, CA.: Wadsworth Publishing Co, 1984 ).

(16) 1. ~?l<. fMJ/ilf!lilt III 1ft;fqlth~1& f!i1 tl9 ffJ(iIt 1f1till;! , fJ( it FJi!;fIlJffiHiiJ!l. ffIi illk. 2.Ji~~Tmsr:ffIi*(ffi~*Jtfl' JiJfJilIl~.l£ 3.1tuVf~z§(ffi&$;t;Ji1*!zJtfl. I. '. 0. J.imxitlH±ittiJtZ.~fj(. 7lHtl:BUi:t!ir",(ffiffliillkmi3l~ (interview guide) ' .. ~~sr:ffIi*~~,~~ffliillk~~&~mo. '. Z. ~~ • • ffliillk~m*~ili • • (ffi-.Mm,m$~ti,m.~M~~ • • (ffi.l£W~'~. iW. 5.~fi:ij'ffliillkIA. A~~mf-£A9 r,,'m~lIT. 0. , ftlHIIl : $: ,. illr~c*. ' jftif. ' jftift,f,. ~5lJII.'. M1#1I'. ~J;.. ,~~1tk~o. ffIi illk Z fJJ. ;g it. l.toJsr:ffIi*l&llJIffliillk(ffiIl1.~§A9;~~~~lIT.A9~fJ.l£o U~ 1it$A I6J ~ ft ~ffl ffliillklJil... 0. 3.~.f~il. ' 1Wdj!t;:;g , ~1lJI1Z'~IWfIlJ*iE,~f/iIj °. ' AJJt '. ~mlllf1... l.rnffl r ::j~][~ J (ffi:riJilJ:Jn:!: ' eHt~~~~1titfltlIT(ffir,,'m*lOrJ:l ' W~tl:~*I:iI!.(ffi'~ mr",rJ:lm ' ~j!ijj!~(ffifoJ~ 2.~~j;.~~il § B~r.a (ffiJl!IDj , ~Tsr:ffIi*1t:f{i(ffi m1JlliIWfIllJ ' tl:~jlIWfA9tt~~:ij'(ffi ffIi 3.reA1itJit rAJ *~~ , W~fI~Jtfl(ffi*7J: 4."I;l~Ji!.§~(ffi~~.~ : (I}flJi.W~1it~JIi ; (2ll6JJ.!l!JL.' , 3t~sr:fflilf(ffi~~ ; (3~*tl:;t:jJ ; (4ll6J1W ' ~~W~ 'M:ij'Jilfl!o illk 5.;ff § (ffif-£A9 r ti~ J , T msr:lOlfA9ffi~ , ~~ , 111. ' :}!tJIi ' fj(111 ' l\It;fl!'~~ , ~. miilJe.(ffiim1::° 6.11J!IWf~~sr:ffIi*(ffi1W~ , ~1Wff.(fm1t£~;fI!IfSltA9"~ 7.~MrJ:lm : Z (I)r.a r IflfO!r.am J ~.T.Z.Tm; (2)r", r ~mMm J ~ r tiMr",m J1i7~tA;fI!.SltA9Tm 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. &ffIi~_~~~sr:*Af.A~~,6~IWf;fl!r~~.~J-~ffl,~~~SA • •(ffifJ. JilJo *. ffIi illk Z flf. 9.1iffi;S~. , *1tI1!Il1llJ(ffi~U* ' EPit' JilJ1i~~1W lO.ffliillklWflllJ' _iii ' 1lJ~!ffi~~*;fI!sr:ffIi*(ffiIWfIllJ~WJE ' 0. .~f.J=/j\IWfA1r. l.1if1-f.IIlI(ffilO~El~, 7tlili.~~m.&~~, f*W1~-?pffliillk. 0. 0. (ffi illk~'& 1i~1la~ jif-£ : (I)r~ffl~riiJ:Jr~m.Msr:fflilf ; (2)~~1i~ , fflir.a• •*Jtt&A ; (3)~!ffixf'fJt*4. 2. JU!l::j~iE~ffliillki1ll£ r. 0. 3.lt~fflijfU'(*4 (ffi -. fi!!i@i~1ft~JM~{E~ti.a9!M':'/f:E. , l'§ffiHUI~F1t~Jt.iI..1iJfJ'r:z1t~'/f:E. 0. 0. ItrFRP?tJjU~. ~*1iJfJ'r:Z1iJfJ'r:•• ,~.ili~H.M• • • ,.m*$1t~ti.'~JM~~••1iJf :n:Zit-~o. - ,. ±IHi3f~.Jl. *1iJfJ'r:~~*T~W~a9~~.~N~a9n~,~T~ti~~m~a9~~L~~.

(17) , r ••• mJ~~.B.~.~ ••Mm' •• ~r ••• $J~r.~m*J. ~~qJf.fu~Jt~~~:rmL~EJ:ljJ!f&lI lI.mfJI¥tM:ttI~ ij b,jf'ijl}\lHi'f ( mllI ) ~.~.'.~~~~:rM~EJ:l •• Wrn'.N~~*•• 'HMofJI¥t_w~~~ ••1t ff~.W:stiJblir ' W'lWfdlv~~~~ .tf.wr~.fi~~~ if otr!&~ 1titY!{.wr~.fi~~tI~tr!&~qJf3tifjJ--~ 0. M~'ijJffJI~.~. .~tI~$W~~~~Wd~' rtr!&J~~~~~~~~~~#~~@1t,~~,:tt I~:?:tfJfM~W~~~~~sJl:. '. ff~.lfiM#tr!&:?~.wr~.fi~~~.¥tIffI. .lmlt .tjU'~f33l'(=) ~. o~~~wlii.J~F1J~fuM ' wlii#~&~::rA'{W-~ r #~ J ' r #Ii!!~ J .·~.'&W ' wlii~~~tr!&.wr~.fi~~~ r ~.\f1 J Mr #ifHl11 J. 'r#jJ.Jm.m~'wlii~#tr!&.w~.fi$'rn~owlii~#.*wrn'#if. .'#•• '#~~'#Ii!!~:?:r~&{W-v.~#tr!&.w~.fi~~'#~o~~~ :tfrn ' ~~~ • .m~m.fu~~_'[f~:st-ilf~~l!fu:m ' ~q-zh:~~ ff~_W.?P~~ ~~~W~'~ijr~~_J~-rnl~~MD$~ff~.W~~'ijJf.¥~ •• 'r ~.\f1J~r~~~J~-tIgij.~*!#tr!&~sJl:ff~.wm§~~'~.~:r ~~~1t~'~ijr#~mJ~~.~-rn!~Mm*. •• ~'r#jJwJm-~rn. f~.~~w~~rn~**~ij~ff~.'wlii~r*m~.J~-~rn!~§~ ~~~'.~~y1t~ ••*'wlii~rffU!&J~r •• ¥Jrn.M'~.wliijJ ~~#if!&\f1.~W ' ~~~tr!&.fj#tr!&.wr~.fi~~\f1~mI1J~ , &W~"'ill ·B~.~~~ •• tI.~,~~~.~.~ •• ,:tt I~{Wr±.J~· •• Mm~z:ttI:Ii!!.'~W~M*.wm.~~W~B. -.~W~¥N~1t~:r1i¥*~jJ!f &:tt~¥N!'~12W~M~~~.WMJ~.fjW ' r *~ J :?#if!&_Wr~.fi~~'[f. ' ~~l1~~ r :ttItr!&:tr~. 0. tIBtr!&:st.~j}~. ~WijM*~Y~1t~JMr~fJI~~:ttI~~~*~Y~JtI~#~~~$~ o~Jf~~:tf • .m.WtI~. ~'r±.~J\f1 •• ~'~.~.~m*rn'~ •• ~5.1tv'r ••• ~ •• J ~-~mb,jf'iJlt ' ~q~ ~~.fl1!M*.lfiM.~f1fijm.tI' ~WtI.*~.~.:rt Bllgrn ' .~~t!4&M'l:!3iif ' ~l1:!.M~:ltmW' r #.~¥Y J ~millf.$nlf#if ' ~w~ r Y~i~ J 1t#tr!&.wr~.fi~~~4I~:ft&lI 0. !&.wr~.~~~.¥!Il!¥f. .lmlt{f*••f33l'H :1tm~.~~¥:If!!*~.. o5~l!Y5W~¥:If!!I1q:If.:m' ~.!f~~'HMo*mif!&~. (JIoaqosso,m) ~*X*~~Jt¥:If!!.M. •• ~~fu~#-:r.~!*m~¥.:rtr!&~~B. ~~.Mif.tI.~#~~'~.~~5. •• x¥ml*m~:rtr!&l!YtI.'B~~. YM~~~r~.J~rn~~~#W~'~~Ii!!~~~~~~W.':?*~o1i~~. ~~Jt~~~ffI.~~ffI~:st'~~~:rr*mtr!&J~!Il!·~:?~.M*~~li~ fu3!m~¥:If!!~:.!Jf~jJ!f. ' ~ffI ' :.!JfmtIw:r1i¥m~:¥:If!!~¥tJ?:¥:If!!IHM ' ~q~~.

(18) ..*•• ••. I&ltit*.~/J\II.Ajt~.~:$~r.slfJz~.. , {J!~~~1tt1iJ!jf(ltitfliJ,m±~ r ~~... J.~~ ,~ ~±:$~~~± • • ~~.~~o tElllbfr,m ~OO , ~~it~JII..H'j{~;tf~iiil fIiJ ~J:IfF{J(1«~~it~ r ~tEiJtlb J ~ ~~ , *tU*II..~jt , 1tt}t1Lf~ff~~~rHH* :!iJ:5'~ , ~~it~JII..~2J;tfffil~lf1t *~~&,lrf~~Itt~fFftU~ , atJtiJtlb~~tE.fli1f1iJ-~ r $U~~iJtlb J 'WGJtJ~~*iI 1iiE~~ r lllb~ftlJ J ,ffijR~1~~~~*.l±\rHH.' m~j], '&'~i1 :!iJ:5'~ , fnit~~~.~JII..~ZJ;tff#JJUlfm.Jm~m~JI1: , ffl!1M~,m r ~2Jit~;\l ~~~Jm J ,~1l~7.~1:~.Jm, tE.~ltit1~1ilfJ1:~lbWl1J ffij~f#JJIJ~~ , ;ff@ ~iW;tf*~~Itt~Jm*ltitft~~ , I25IAffl!fr5~iA~~~il:1:fEfE~~*Wj~Mj]1!7t ~~~o~.,.~ • •fi • • ~.Jm~?~.~.;tf.,mR~##~~~*.,. 'tIt£!P~~m~ {t£iW.'PtE.it. , ~~.~11l..~iJ;tf;ffiJt5mWl1J-m1L-~1tt r A*~fit! J ,mI±\VJli~ r .~Jt{t J it~~it~JII..~l±.~{J] ~:![lfJ'I1:*~ , tff~~F.~JII..~ZJ;tfz ~lJ.~# Itt m.ltitfliJ*ftff~fllil~ t==JfJ'lf.JlE , tl~Jlt/f~{lJtJItt~IXUllJ;tfJ:fifF~~~nUi , 1!t~ ~~~Z.{t,ffij;ff~~it.~AII.• •~o 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. S1£.fIII~.IH.1.iiii II..Jt{t~~~fftE;ffi:![~II~lHIfj. fiij. ' ~~II. 0. tE~~it~lll..'P. '. I25IAII..~jtJtJfl~W.. WGJ.tIl..*§,;ff;ffiJt~~ifiij~~~. , .pfl1Q1:iiUmAWG~iJ;tf~{tfrr~~{J(1«. ' {t1'~Fit~JII../Ff!!~~.~H~~ r fiij.!f!fl J ~1I..Jt{t , ffijll tE.~.ru. m-~r.JlE~:![lfJJ~II..Jt{t,lfm:![~:![~W~~mfit!om~II..Jt{t~~~~. , 1«1'0, fl.lI.• •fl ~:5'~ , tElI..mtwr 1: , .?&~~.~JII..*~;ff-~:fC~~II..~t1t11 , fE!~tE. ~mfF1: , W*.I±\;ffi'l'~sr,I'/1:~.lfJ : ~P~fll5t~~IY3. , WGItt r {f$H~iill. J ~~ ~~. fE!.~ , tEsr,I'I1:~Ii.mtwr~fiij~ , ~P)(;ff~iW;tf~*JtIl. • .l{$IJIt{t~uif. ;m~~~. 0. 0. ,=;tf~~~;ff~Tm,1«~.pf.-~~~o. it~;lJ.ruffijl:f. , .1f;ff@~~.~JII..;;.x~~~;1J ( 21.7%) ,*~.~~~ it~lli.z~;lJ~~17},mJR~~~2J ( 45.2% ) WG**ru~~2J ( 21.7%) ; ffij~~~ ~;lJftU./FA~~it~jll..~;1J;tfJYimm ( 10.9%) (lm)1£iI• • • i"'J8IJM~1.iiii ~~it~JIi.~;lJ;tf.mm~Ii.~jt~ZlHlf* ' m~JJJfj~-m1L±.~Itt~fiij~ 0. {tfrr(~~)A~.,~~~~.JlE~ffij~~(ftJt~*~~.)o~Jlt,~lJ;tf*~. .Am:m~~iE~JJJ1ffi ;1J;tfo~Jlt,. '. .m:~ffi{f~jt. , .4i}~Aft1~tE1tB~IfFfelll ~$~-~~. • • I±\*~~~-~~.~IfF.Mo. ~.~.(.JlE).*~lHIfj,~~/F~A*.~II..zU.*(.fi*)~1tm. oJlt-• •~II:5'''z'It;m;ff~~'' ~1t~Jlt- • • ~Mf:ffiltl~·F : (ll1i1f~ti.IttIl..Z .~~;lJ;tfA± , ~ffij~~7rItU1!il:1:~.* ; (2)fl1ffftE5m~~~.~ , 1E!~jf ( .JlE) • • Hfj~ • • ~ • • o~.*~~• • =;tf~.~;ff~5t~~.~5tI,Itt.&. 0.

(19) ... ~if±~@~r€L.~!J1!. '. &+±~jHfJ!.:¥~If,iim. '. ~q:W ~ Jl!*G-I,1~,:):f0*Wi!t.f¥'J a If. ~?'nJfr~~~~L~I$!J1!' f.Yl1f~jj!G-I,1~j!:Y~4i~'fud!t' ~(gJG-I,1JiI~~*W~~4rMt: mJiIj!:3tfrmr~j(~~It~~ , j!:± JiI~~G-I,1~H~1k~* ' ~~~~fU,U~ftiHtHJH1tJ;~ , .~Qi~G-I,1~~if.~tli\fif~r~j(~~.~ : BmHnJ~:):f"*~ ( Mf,g ) JiI~tJ¥'6 0. oJl!*Z~~M~W.W~~$L.~.±~'~.G-I,1~~m.~.'~ (gJz~JiI.3t~mw' • • • Qi.wm'~.'W#G-I,1 • • ~fu~~JiI •••• ~ • • 11Hfiwr~~~~iJ. ' fil¥?!MiiG-l,1¥.f a J.k-~W~W~~G-I,1~W3t.if ' Z.?!M~G-I,1W~ , 9J~z.1Jfr~j(~~tlDW¥.f~. .W~. 0. ~JiIr,**W1fn(tlj1j{rm~wr~~~~~:W.!t~E}. .W~,~G-I,1¥~Y;f a '~M\rl. : BmHnJ.tl~.lW&f.I~~~ ( :»*.tt ) :»JiHl$'I :~~~~o.§G-I,1¥.liW~fult=. *W~(gJ~. , .w~G-I,1¥.f¥M¥.f~Ii3t:#:.wr~j(~~G-I,141±.!tr~l(iit:/:t&j!:1;fll!3t !I!\W.!I!t'M. o1fimlt±4f~HI z r )!]:j:t J M.fi• .w~~ , ;ftl.wr~~~~z r ~,Il~ J m~.fi¥:II!*~~~ , j!:± o• • &f.I~ • • • *~ •• m'.w-~-'~.m.~)!]~G-I,13tw.w~j($~W ~'z~*.~~G-I,1.~~~~'m~-~oW~G-I,1~~It~~~4f4i~~~*(gJ:):f. , M~4i:j:trll~'. (,?'{i:~g) '?f.G-I,1*~~~~'ijl- ! .¥>A!}~I4i:j:ttl ' *~G-I,14i:j:t , ~M~H4tJ~:j:t~ • •~ , ::r~}MJ~~:j:tM3t ' ~q~. ~~)}tlJ~~EJ±.wr~~~~. o.~m£~.'¥.G-I,1r.m~~± 1)#~}MJ.mr~~~~ljlf:)tM J .!tm~m'ijl-W{fsl:!1:¥:II!~IiiJg3t ~tla~.j:u~¥' G-I,1 ii~~±W~~4i~!il~}:)tM. ' ¥.f~~,~~~ , tl.~Y¥i@.!t~iI· t:/:t.~:£:1i .mr~~~~~:W.!td~ , .W.raBY~W ' raBW#i.(gJ:):f~lt ' if~liWG-I,1tRlraBW ' .3§~Im*4f*.jf;Wtm4iillW~ , ~~. ~IG-I,1?!MiffjrWl1VW.~M~~~tRl. , ~.~¥.~)jftJ.~ :$::):fJ!.:¥Ltl ' ~~MJ.wn:uJ:~~~}:)tM~ 0. 0. ,. wr~j(~~. 0. o~MJraBliG-l,1~lI. tRl.W~~$MM~~~m'~~.~.W±G-I,1:£:YW • • ;f'W.M~j!:G-I,1+~MJ W ' ~:)t .mG-l,1~~ml1~§&~WM~tlDW ' .mr~j(~~G-I,1liif~\r/~~lI~.H6.BlgQi ' Qi ( i!t ) WG-l,1JJj~7,lJ. r .~ J @:t!t.fiM~~~MI1~j!:± ' BrrJG-I,1~ 0. .11~~![~!J1!. .!t~mM~~~*¥.f~t:/:t:)t~o::rQii!t.~G-I,1M~~W:)t~'¥~lt±~~mMJWG-I,1 M~.fi.wr~j(~~.~ , WE} ~f{j:G-I,1M~~sl:!1:~J}ij[~.wr~j(~~fi!:.~ , ~~G-I,1M~ , ffjjn~~M{i:~g:):f0G-1,1w~Qi;f.wr~~~~j!:J!. ' ~!J1!~HG-I,1M~M~ 0. ~~~. om~~~MJ~~~MWm'~MJG-I,1.w r~~~~~}:)tM '~HG-I,1M~M : ~&.;ft:/:t:)t , ~:):f0M~·4i:j:t:)t?!MfMJ{ff¥m ' ~}MJ G-I,1sl:!1:~qM:Jl~~![ , ~I.}jG-l,1~.fi:mIi~j}± ' W9J~WJ}-G-I,1ff}j.wr~~~~ !l!l;l.fIII.~~ • .ft;• •~ o00' ~.:WG-I,1.WM~ifG-l,1 ~ *.W~W![~-¥:~:WI1~ , ~~~f}*fw.wr~~~~.~w~ , ~~M~)1tfi!: ( ~f!'¥i ) ~.'!t. tl.'Jfljlftl~. ~.

(20) ~If[~~it~Jil.z1:.ff. 0. 3.3C~~4l1JJUIl!&~4l1JfHlr..' B : lttr~U!!$lk=1ltlIJlIM ~~S¥:1e:~1t:E:!!!IL~z~.Imf* ) f*:J:m--ftR1e:~1t:E:!!!ttmj~. : (1)Wt$~~it~Jil.~ , tJ)\;f{I#;tf:J:JlX*~~. ?Hlr ltt- r ~$ J .fQl?&~~~J;EA#Bl$ , ff:i~P1!lriJfi~.:fujliI~~it~Jil.nltf!;i\;~~ 0. z*fl ; (2)~p~;(Enltf!;i\;~1#~1l!Hl9il• .p , tJ)\~Jf]lk~~llmJm1{htIJ~-ftR'/1:I'fJ1t:E:!!! ~~,~~m~~~I'fJ~Jf].~~~A1t:E:!!!~~Z~mo. : ;(EtIJ]f1i1f~ffl5?t!lt1Jl ' ~~it~Jil.~1#~:S:Jlml'fJ~~ ~B.Tril.m~I'fJ.~J*,~.r • • ~.I'fJ.#Jo;(E • • $?ttJ)\~$m~ .~ • • r • •~.~,::tn • • il.I'fJ.f!~flJom.fi• •~l'fJm*fQl?&n. iI~~• • •B , El.#HItf!p;j~l'fJ~fl ' ff:i@t~~it~Jil.Z5.ltIJ4!f,L\HItf!I'fJ~'/1: ' ii:;;tI'fJ~1#~' I;1lk~~.~l'fJftIrm~ , ~~ffl5?tiltMl mrm , tJ)\.1'?£~~~~it~Jil .~1#~ • • r ~'L' \ lr3Jt:A , It• • f{.*1i:J:~ J 5.~JM ( ~.M.D}]ft~~**JiIl. ~ .:tM:fHl r"'lR! : ~~it~Jil.1it ~1'fJ 1Jl~~ ,m~.Wd&A(1e:.)z • • • .D}],I;1.~.~.~~.,arm.~~~.~~ '/1: *1i1f~!lt1Jl , *$?t~F'~~Jil.~1#~:S:;tf:J:~MIt ( • • ) fl.U! , mrmm.m • • ~B~1:.I'fJ~B,~~W~~~~o 6. •~I'fJ*.ft1ti:l:l¥Jm.r"'lR! : IDiBtIlUlk , .~~~{lf:li})~~it~Jil.~~z o ff:i~ ~~A1e:1t.~I'fJ~~it~Jil.~~~ , {JJ• • filt~:liil.JlXli aEl~~1ltlIil .I'fJIfP.~, rmll, 1lt~~Jf]-.JlX*~~.*J:tllfj~:Ii, mltt, &rmriJnMt~¥IJ Ali ~ ~I'fJHItf!JL\ , fEj~ , ~~it~Jil.~~A~fi.~I'fJ~fl ' tt!.~¥lJm~ 7.iffj.fTlift~~*~fTlifHlfb'B : ~Jf ' ~~it~Jil.;(EMItI'fJ.ntr.~ El mlfIf. ~ftQ~ , ~ll~~it~Jiltill'fJit.!&AtJ)\~-NJf]~ § 1'fJ$.k ff:iltt.;(Eit~J~~~it~J fHlihff$I'fJ'IWN. , $.k~~*~~.111 .t:m. r ~!!*$.~ J 1'fJ:=f~~~~it~J 4. • • ttftjl::tfHlr"'lB. 0. it.). 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. il.~~;f{I~~,ft~~ff;(E~.~~rrd~~%~&~~~~1:.~£.~~o. =,.'ft••• (--)fi~~'''HIIl.''• •Z iI.filin-iii ~~it~Jil.~1#fjAz~~~.1'i ' riJm12tr.fi r ~~~*:!l J \ r ~1#.~ J ,l;1lkr~~~~il.p;j'*$H~J~IM~,~?tI'fJ.IJlW*om~-.I;1~ • • W!ltI'i~I;1%~'/1:.~~1'fJ. r 1ftU~~1# J ,f*11i1i%' fL.iltil¥'8l ~~ , ~.ptt!~*T~~Elm:!l~:fJlll;1m~ : l.fi~-ftR1t:E:!!!~~I'fJ~Jfj , .m~.~~~$IJ ' ~riJmltt:=f~rmWJ.T~~it~J 0. iltilz*fl~§I'fJ;. 2. • 1;15¥ '/1: I'fJ iltil fQ: wt-~:ttf ¥il.JlXli ~~ I'fJ I n~1:.I'fJ1f1*~r~~B. fPll , *. ~ ll.:. $IJ If[ ~z 1i II! ftP riJ. ;. 3.••~I'fJ.#.~~m$lJ ; fiJlXli1tIL'3Jt:AI'fJ~*~ r lii]jf J a94*~~~ , .Jl~fi• •~.l'fJm*;.

(21) 4~~~J~ru'Hl{?J1TALfijf~. 4:n-U'1!fI¥J:002:Ji!::-1I0!l~.1k~.ljl1l..* tilli El fJl¥J~1iIr~. 97. , ~~liiIlfifti~. Il..~~~m~,~~~~~.~~~~~~;. 5.!I!mmiiJil¥J!I! ~,~ , .¥.tJJ m:f1t-ll~~ 111!l€f1l1l:b I¥JmiiJi~~ 1¥J:>c~ ,. ~ ~Il.. .~~~~-lI~.I¥J.m~~~,w~~~~.I¥J.~~.~; 6.~;!J1!f~T~:fl:l!~~tlt9f..~1tMU±~I¥JWJlmt~;r. , Jj~~.ililt~I¥J$'1f (. :tm*±~.!IUlljl¥Jxtt) ,Zll'fflff:l1t~~;. 7~;!J1!fffl.~:flrMA~J~.m,d • • Il..~.I¥J.~.~;W~ • • •. • [II~#i:fll!; 8.~;!J1!f.it:ll.d.m-II~~~~,~A:fljt?fiijll{EI.~~1iIr~1¥J1l..:>C~; 9.~~1!f.~m.ilm~ftI, ~¥.tjJ~AjJ.~.Jj!~~;. lo.~~1!f.mmA. '. 1l..~,pl:m~~j1{FM.ljll¥J. r 1I!fJ J ~. '. ~.~mJ!J. mllJ,ij/Ij~I~ElfJ;. l1.~~1!f.fl.Ilfif~mI~ El fJ~jtll..* till¥J.JHtW~. , ~~ftij/lj~I~ El fJ. , x.~~,It.Il..*til ; 12.~~1!f.Ef:r#-~~Fft*,JIl..flIjl¥J~~~mt. ,. ~lk*~~~1¥J1I~. , ffI:fliJEit. ~MIl..I¥J.Wl~Ml~I¥J1Ello. (=)!HF'lf"J.U.!!UI~.t1.riii 1..mm0jt?'~I¥JW1tli~.m. ' .~;iA~l¥Jitfj~~d.~ § ,±'~l¥Jmt~ ; 2.~Jff)lH~.iE~ti1t-ff:lrMil7!~ , ~m:1Jo'±1f.rMilA~~jfilJ ' ~~)(:ttfJj~Fft*,JIl.. 1¥J4liII~~it1i;. 3AFft*,JIl.• •~ir:rlffl *lI1f:il , ~ iJEitf.&.lltl¥JmiiJi~ir~ ; 4. :1J05~~Fft*,JIl..;(£U~~ft'l1S~:ru~ , .itM~;jQI~ , mMf.6WlI ; fiijlfif , ~.~?tIEl:Zll'~H:flm~t~md1tfi;r~fi pg~'Ifi5l ; 5.~.~i!f{ti.t. , ~-lI r ~F~ttf'~ J l¥J~it , ~TIl..* till¥J• •;r ' J!ffI{ij! 0. 1l..~~Tm~~JE:Bff#-~I~I¥J1t.;fIlll{EI;. 6.~Jff~.m:1JoJj.~~M~Fft*,JIl..I¥J1mWJ;r J I~ft1l1¥J~Fft*,JIl.. ; fiijlfif ' '!t:1J05~ r Jlirlb:JJ 7.~Fft*,JIl..f.&.lltfllj.:flO!l~I¥J~1%. ' J!ffltfWJ1tr:$OOtU'~d r ~r' J ~:ru~ ' ~.~-1rUt:l&f!.fl§l~~J-~r'~1! , W 0. • • .iEn.~.~.~I¥J:I&hd~~; 8.~~.IBJ.:1Jn5~~~F**,Ji.1Il.~tiM. '. ~:fl~lillffl. r ~~ J. ,~itli~Fft*,JIl.. .~~Jffflljir~I¥J~~;. 9.• ~.li-M r ~tfrl¥J J ' r 1E~1¥J J d r ~AI¥J J ~F**,JIl.. ' W.:Jl!: r ~ ~I¥J J ~F**,JIl.. ; 1O.~:V:~f~~F**,JIl..zJl.9'nd:1JorBl9'n~ll..tIJ ' ~ IHUf~~1I~~Fft*,JIl.. ~J!~. 0. 1l.JiFff:1J05~. I¥J. r OOtitti: J ' r § ,±,~ J lk r A'~~ J J ; ~~WIH~~Fft*,JIl..zfil~& , ~~ r ~F**,JIl..Z!J~. r 0jt?tl J ' r. r ~Fft*,JIl..!J~. ~.±~ J '.

(22) J*f4tJi r ffi!it1jtitITJI¥J7i$Bo (=:}fi~Ftf *,j ifUltfJfiIf ~niii l.trJt~@A~z~F1t~ljL.f4t~MJlf*AI¥J1jJfJi:. ;. 2.:bIl5JlJtjtf!:n·~~F1t~jti.1'£.lI!~:f±~zjfj {g~~ftI3l¥J1jJfJi:. 3.1*M~F1tltjti.~iH~:f±". ;. , -0Jttt ' s.X;:f±I~Ult~~zlH1{~ , W,lk ~F 1t~jti.J!JT~JjN' I¥J -0JtJJll5 ~ftI3~ .J8!1¥J 1jJfJi: ; 4.Jt~IIJifi;(fz~F1t~JII..f4t-~lDftl1!t , w'"*m~II~F1t~jti.z.~if~Wt '. -0~Jf~. lSL; 5. • •1Jt.~~Il~F1t~jti.Z ~1.m '. AJJ Jf7Jjif~ ,. i!itJ1f~1WJ w'lk~.mzfiS~~. II!z1t.1jJfJi:o. *. *. *.

(23)