iik m JdJUt - 1jLf : lfX.ioJ ~ flU! 259

--iik m

^{JdJUt -} ^{1jLf :}lfX.ioJ ~

flU! 259

~m~,~~~e~*~"~OOm§~~~$#~~M"~~~~'~~

~~ili~m~Wm~~e*0~~~,&~m~Wm~~~~~~~~o {fl~1:EJ:lfrj~f~~~~~ZPfr.p

,

~fF~~¥ti~[JMiI*5~W~~~SZJiL&rtr)({~

*~'E~.~m~~*~.~SZJ~~~.offi-$~~~~~~~

• •

~!t3:§:-~.til~fm~~@Jff!

'

JJ~Jl;t~

rmilJ (articulation)

~~~

:

~ f§~m{--\::jf*~.

'

1ff:+:I\t!t*CJ;J*~~~t1fJ5iSZJ~f~.p

, !trzm.m -tttw

r~*J

*±SZJiL&m

"*~i11

"

:)({~J:SZJ1IJ.£I~ ⁰

.m,±:r±1N

SZJmil,3:§:-~~~~A.~,*m.r*5m~~~~.J~A

• •

~' {6j~,~~,1!\~f'F.pfJ.i!¥rJtiPii~~f!I!~

r

l:.grH~A

J (mode of production)

~.om~

• •

~.~~n,~3:§:-~~*m~r~~J:~e~~~.1:.

Eff~AJ ~~.

'

:f:lGfF~}f~H~~~~.~

Eric Wolf & William Roseberry SZJflN

*~fmm~=-¥~ZP3llb ⁰

Wolf

~T~f't1ueffi1:.Ef:tlA~m~Pi-

'

^flli~~til

El 1950 iFf--\:: Julian Steward

mf~fjf~tH±1N~'J\.

(peasantry)

Wf~J;J

* '

^~~A

• •

WWf~:itt£!I!.{~Jj\.iL&mfJ.SZJ~4

'

mtMilJ5JT&til~.¥rj iL&m.~1:E~~M~~~m~Jj~~rmm~i11J~riL&m~i11JWf~o 6S~-W~~~ZPfr

'

~fF~~~*ffpSZJ1i*3ifJ ⁰

;f§~~fMiI~~~

,

,~~,~,~.1Ifi~~:r±1N.~

Wallerstein' Jl:1J'Migm

mRjf*~.SZJfJfi'~~'Mi~~

• •

~~~.2~(~~~.~I

• •

db2~fg.~iI.Ef&b

), r miS J (integrate)

@@.ffi~z.~jf*t!twe

*~ r~!)jJ ~ttHli: 0

Wallerstein

~ili2~~miS~~~

,

3:§:~~*5fM,~~

• •

~~m~1:.~Wmil'fi~~~~~~oJ5JT~,*ffp~~fr~~

tttWfil* "

l:.~flA

"

&+ilWf~~;:~rf3ifJ ⁰

§)t ,

~ZPfr

Wallerstein

~.~

& iJ

r~~1lt~zP~[J"F

:

Wallerstein

1:£:r±Wrfil*~~~ ~'1EtttW~~~~~*~

-

~: §)t~

r

~ff]\e*

J

,

rz1§1~it

"

if~

"

~fm!J~iI.t±1N.p~

Elg~~I*~~&!J-:)({~~fM~ 66flli)tJ;J~i11~* ⁰

Karl Polanyi

~~~

r

;f§lH~~

J (reciprocal economy)

~~f§m~ff]\e*~*~~t~l#li

'

1~*WJ

Eric R. Wolf, Europe and the People without History (Bericeley, CA: University of California Press, 1982) Immanuel Wallerstein, The Capitalist World-Economy: Essays by Immanuel Wallerstein (Cambridge, UK:

Cambridge University Press, 1979), p.5.

260 :i(A-it

E&fiij~18"<R:Wd~

r

0

*~lJ11f

J ( subsistence economy)

⁰

67;t:t;J;:M rtit

w'i11~

J

M~'~~ ·~&·.~,e.~.-*I~lJ11f&.m~1t*M'OOW m-M~~rtitW~lJ11fJ~*~~~'H~titWm~~.~.-~~m (~~Mrm~J)R*°titW'i11~&titW~lJ11f~fiij~rtitWR*J'OO~

1~M~~JJt1~titW*~lJ11f~fiij~

r

jVfs:±:~titWR*

J

-~1l1!l~iJJjt~+7\tit

*CJ;)JiXHtl~~JL\~*~lJ11fRn

Wallerstein

0 68

,.*±:~titWR*~~.*

• •

~~~.~~'H~OO L~lTltlliWfj!~ff<JL\' *j§~. Wj§~~*~*IM*f1J

;

x.~~H**

~r~~Jwr J~~m~~,ft~OOL~~~lJ11f~~*¥~~M*~

~~~ff£f1J~ ~m!~ooL ⁰

' ^§

+7\tit*cJ;)'*~i1'H5$~W~~~i~1t

' mt

W*~~L;fJiJL\

•

*j§~

,

Wj§[5j~*IJ0~lHB:ljiJ$~M*~

; ¥)-1J[[j ,

~~5$~~~PxJJ~titWH*m~~;F;:j(±j£~Pfi1l1!lJJj{~IJMifH*jf~~ ⁰

titW

H*W~~~fflJ~~~

, iEM Wallerstein

**JT~~tlN!t!ti

'

OOtE~fm*j§~

~*~;t:tm~tt-i&mL{i&ff<JL\Wj§~~*~

,

i%X0;fJiiL\~3Mj§

[5j~~~1J~§ftU'FlU

'

tleJl~~~3&tffJEe

r

J ; ,

*iI[5j~*W

¥)Pfi.~*.~

• •

'OO.~~~~1Jm~I.~~~;ffiU*iI[5j~~

m*~lJ11f{'P~ ,.*±:~titWR* ⁰ 69~1~H~1UVi[[j

L '

~*Bll~~~~1tt±tff-, *~

.

^{I~

^"' ^M

*& . ,

TII$IJ~lli

Wallerstein

;t·.~ti\i'X~~~J;),titWH*~

h rtt!:HlIil¥J7t1~ffij~. ~~{!]\H*fr7t • ftIlm1£fflfr~ 0 {J:lil,t.E!ll~l¥J1i:!lf1.ffij~ • "lii3'ml~~{iJ\H*

:;f~Wallerstein rl'EmJ l¥Jlm~ ⁰m~+:g!lD{"l • Jltliliffirr*Bl¥J~±ffH*=~!ll!:' ~Polanyiffi~'

*!jlfflfl'l~l¥J=f!f!m~}jKl'!iJ ; ff.Jlif1. (reciprocity • !lDm~pg2±~l¥J r/IIHlLJ ~£:x:~) , ¥})1"!'ictt (redistribution' !lD¥fH!ijrofil1al¥J;:P~m.~¥}fE~~m$mll!la(Jll1J)' &:x:W!tt (exchange' !lDJJH-I:A1±

r/J~~~;:Pf¥J:x:~ ) ⁰iW:WWanerstein~tf:lm~l)li;!:x:~l¥Jlm~ • M?::\m~Polanyifrl.E!ll~ilU

IIl'HW\1fitrJ 0 ~Karl Polanyi, "The Economy as Instituted Process, II in Karl Polanyi, et. aI., eds. Trade and Market in the Early Empires (Chicago: Henry Regnery,1957), pp.149-155; Immanuel Wallerstein, The Modern World System: Capitalist Agriculture and the Origins of the European World-Economy in the Sixteenth Centur(New York: Academic Press, 1976), p.230.

rnl Terence K. Hopkins and Immanuel Wallerstein, "Patterns of Development of the Modern World System,"in

Terence K. Hopkins, et. al., eds., World-Systems Analysis: Theory and Methodology (Beverly Hills, CA:

Sage, 1982). pp.42-43 .

. " Ankie Hoogvelt. Globalization and the Postcolonial World: The New Political Economy of Development (Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press, 1997), p.60.

a~A• •-'*:.~

•••

^MI

fi~

• 51 fIT

® t±fFL rs' ^EfJ ^mfiH*

⁰ ^70~j;J.J:

^1:]iWJ EfJtit-nM'E* 51 fIT 1& rQ] , YN

~~EfJm~~ '~fr~fiEfJ~~51~J:m~7~EfJm~m~-rtit-ne

;%J'

/F~fif5Z~

,

*~I5j~~

,

ffflfr)[{t51~J:WHH~1m5.$ ⁰

Wallerstein

i~t'et!tJ1!e~5f;~tfI5teJt&L1f

•

fiE.J.li;tiJl*~ItEfJm~

,

m~~~m~tit-ne*~~~~~~Tm~tit-ne*EfJr*~I*Jo~

~~T~. t±.~~ffiAg~~EfJm~J:o~51~t±

• •

$~~EfJ

Theda Skocpol •

fJ:t~ZFtit-ne*~~ r§7ttiHf~ft±.~-!~~f~{t

~~~~tit-nm~EfJ

• •

RMN~.EfJmnttm~~,5f;~~~~*~.

~i&J-fHt*~~~$1J

r

mm~~.] EfJfJj.iiiHiJT~~ ⁰

J

7lSkocpoll¥J5f;-f~

r {t

J •

~f~

Wallerstein

Jj~{,' ,

*jll5j , RjlI5jEfJIU51 '

JtJl~~,f1HJf~

~m~~¥~~.~~M~.EfJ~~'&fffl/F.m~~~51~~.g~~

~ij~~f[(!EfJW~ii ⁰ tcW11flt~¥~

Robert Brenner

iQmf[lj1{f~1J:t~

, ffflffJf Wallerstein

-·mB1tc~¥~~

r

Jnt~{tl¥J[§'I']31:.WWff§tt

J

⁰

72Skocpol EfJ

m=f~

r

{t*~

J

~~EfJ~~{'Ff'f!Hl

·

k§~tE~.f:tJXi*@lf

,

f~~

,

~*~t±

• •

$EfJMk§.**·~.m@lf*.MEfJ~~~f'f~~.MEfJ.~~~·

fffl~'I'~1~~EfJ±~~*&

(ruling classes)

B1fU~.\tt/F~3& ⁰ ⁷³

MtEWallersteinEfJrz.t~

, Christopher Chase-Dunn

~1Il7If~tit-ne*~

~.\tt?~f'ffIJ1?d~f~

r

{t*~

J

⁰ 74~~D~fr~J:mH~~m;F

,

llif~~£;j(t1:t±.e

*"@,*~~~

, i&{ir ' ::t{t -

f~.:r*~m ⁰

Wallerstein

Jl-~5m~~~~

, i&m.:r

*mEfJ• •

L~~rli.~.ftEfJJ·~&f'f~~ret±.~~~.(m*

m)

{tr:J~ -1¥J*~~i&Jfj ⁰

Chase-Dunn

IXtffl 31:.* • Skocpol

EfJ5f;-f~{t*~1~~ ⁰ fiE.1~telXifH

r

J

7tttjf*±~fffj.~

,

·0 Etienne Balibar and Immanuel Wallerstein, Race, Nation, Class: Ambiguous Identities (London: Verso, 1991).

Theda Skocpol. ~Wallerstein B':JJ!f;t:::tRtltWffI* : flf!~!1J;!,I~It3!:B':Jtl:ttr!(Wallerstein' s World Capitalist System: A Theoretical Critique) ⁰r&MIiWT:tj!~ , filJUtlM~ftlM : ftlMtt.~lIUI (ti' jt : §mt ' B;1!rIl74 if:), ~408 '

;; Robert Brenner, "The Social Basis of Economic Development," in John Roemer ed. Analytical Marxism (London: Cambridge University Press, 1986), pp.36-40.

Theda Skocpol, State and Social Revolutions: A Comparative Analysis of France, Russia, and China (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1979).

" Christopher Chase-Dunn. r I!rIl~H*!1J;!jf*::tRtltW*~/t!i--MjiU1U!tl1l'i!jjpjl1U1!ft ? J r&MIiWT:l!l'!

.t\ij , Ilu~~. ~379·390 c

:il:tz/f~aA r~~G*Wt[!iX~fM]J §±~titffa*z9t Skocpoll¥J~*§±⁰

~~~~~~*~±l¥JrR~~*J~m~~~r~**WtJI¥J~~offi Chase-Dunn ~~~OO @J~ Skocpol

r

~*fUfiit/f&:\~~~WtmI3~U&ffJfiitJ

I¥JElIH:i3

⁰ tzD*m~1!f*~Chase-Dunnl¥Jm~ff-JEl¥JmI.l

'

{t!!frl~~OJtJ :iEW:1~

r

JJ~*JlI5jI¥J:fJ!t~~Ft

?

tzD{ilJJE~

? J

75~p1R!~m~ Wallerstein I¥JI.I~

:il:tz*~*Jll5jti.~a*~m

• •

I¥JA'~.~~*JlI5jI¥JJE~:il:tz/fm

~ ⁰ Peter Evans:il:tzlliJ[ ffl5t~ Wallerstein

r

titffa*l¥J{lril?RJE-~~~J

1ftfB1IT1¥J1iff:JE '

ti~~JJE~fl1iff:JE3lHF1t Wallerstein iTJM~*jfl5jl¥J=

+ ^iL ^{I

'

tiP.m~;¥tr:pJ\~i~~~)L\

,

33iL~~M3I15j ⁰

.)lffltitffa*1¥J I.I1ftfB '

{~Jf®.~11J11t*I¥J~{jl.1J ⁰

* ^§

)J~~~1!fI¥J§:g:

,

:ft{f"§*?1J~'j?U{t!!{f'~ti Wallerstein ~llIl¥Jtitff a*I.I~~~~m~o®frl±.l¥Jm~'~/f~~r:pITti*jfl5j:fJ!t~I¥J/f

ii '

fffi~/fii~ Wallerstein ti3l15ji¥JJm*i~rw ⁰ Wolf ' Wallerstein

~LErm)L\I¥J~~iL\~tzD{ilJ~ffi)ll5j~mt~

,

ti~A~~1!flli~~mB!tl¥Jill5j ARI¥J&:l!!rp~m~yt/f~JJ ⁰

76FilJflI¥J '

Roseberry ~A~~1!ftititffa*

1¥J±.m~Z-,~r±~~~JI¥J~~lli~fffi:fJ!t~~r*±~~Wtitff

~~fM~l¥Jr~m ⁰

J

77~t]~3~

,

~1lr~1!ft!)/f&:timiE;E;j(~-jf*±~

titffa*I¥J:fJ!t~1t

' is

~tzD{ilJ~ill--*~~~AA~~1!fl¥Jjfl5j

,

!iX~*

±Elf:JE~1Il

'

tiP~{t!!{f'~~~ Wallerstein

/f@I¥J:ttl!1J

⁰ ff~l¥J~

,

Wolf

fa

Roseberry t!)~~T·J:tlc&.BU1~1¥J

r

±~fl~

J

:fJ!t~IT.J.!.~I[i\lIlm?Rillfi .~I¥J~mo~~IT~~®frl~fflW~.~~~±~I¥JI.I~m~zM,:ft frl*~~:.tt®JL\[Q] Wallerstein 1¥J~1!f

'

tzOfflIT,6ff~

,

!iXEBJfgmJ!tI~tlllm

?Rf§

FilJI¥J~~m 0

A~~1!f George Marcus &:~ITJJH\:;titffa* Ttzo1ilJj1frrR~~tl¥J~

R~'.~Jr~~m.~~@Jm~

• •

m~w~~JI¥J-g1J~o

~*~i11f~1!fllimffltiP~A~~1!f~/fii~l¥JtJn*J~tlt

:

~4i-fl

• •

'~rn~

" Wolf, op. cit., p. 23.

" William Roseberry, Anthropologies and Histories: Essays in Culture. History, and Political Economy (New Brunswick, NJ; Rutgers University Press, 1989), p.l52.

t

.~AM.-'~:.~

•••

^2~

~JtB"l*,~:15iEe*

'

§~~:tJtX1~'¥iJiEmlB"lllf~ ⁰ :1t~~}J!~i!J:fftzD

Benedict Anderson 1Jeffl B"l:tJit :

1E~EmlflV*f;~pxi£!J:ffff*'!lHiffJEi&JB"l~mlf~3t

r:p ,

1TJW:ffi£j::.$i&Jf~~JJjrY2.1~~ili*:SX~~T*B"lilllYJ' ⁰ ~i~~

Marcus

xM B"lIJit : 1EiEmlR*

f;~px~fI~ml'FFll5LWz3!&

ili

*~ !l7l-*a~

B"lmR

( the totality of unintended consequences)

⁰ ft!!mz.1E1mB"l:tJit~'I.''¥rJB3!fH;1t B"l~§t

.L :

!J:ff1Cf:ftf:IJ'R*B"lJE~

,

Wj;).~~

(narrative)

~~)H1.H~R

*~W~mi£*±RW~.:SX~~.B"l~$.Jtr:p,mz.~mR~mr:p.ili

~R*fiB"l~.o~®fi-RB"l@WR**:ff

• •

~i£ft!!M±M~B"l~JE

~~§t.L

'

~fJ;:~1E

Marcus r1BJt1tJ

⁰ 79i£~~Jl@WR*B"lJWJJ~*

±~JJtzDW

r;ll*'a J (linkages) ,

.~~JJ!1J§~*±

r r}$U&*lMB"lt±ll

fB~

J' r

J.&*lB"lJM§t:i&Jf~

J' r

~*1ti&Jf~

J' r

I*1ti&J~

J' r

~~1t

~f~J' ,&

r

~,,*B"lf~fEH.~~J.&ij@]~~J B"l;\**~i1Hr ~Jl@WR*⁰

*:ffi£~JE1fit.LfJj!~Wfl~@W~*±~;llB"lro'Jm

'

~1r~i£f~~~f:f'l.'Blti

OJ1t!;7::tflT

⁰ I~i£~1r~1C@]'¥iJ

Wolf

Roseberry

tzDW,t;L~~f~JtB"l~M@],f!\

114;llB"lj9IS!l1X

⁰

Wolf

Roseberry

IPJf*riJk,\jf*±~tzDlij~},.jIf5jtlllB"lro'~

;

~A 1PJ.f:f~mB"lm©Mm~~~±~:ffB"l~~.Jt~M'~II@]~.L~B"l r~;llJ ro'~ ⁰ ff::l~~ArtJit~!J:ffIN*~B"l*'t;~

,

BP1Jel~

Roseberry i£ Wolf

~~~-7::tflTjlf5jt±llji*{t~mlMB"lff!t~-~ili~~* ⁰ Ml~1r~~ Wolf ~

iEeo

Wolf 1ltiWMm,~~Jt!,±~:ffm~T,~~,'t!,B"l~~it

'

[!]lltili:tJtXm~T i£R*~$~§~B"J~~~~B"J~lIolPJ~'~~±~:ffMR*~~B"J~

~~~~.TmR!l.B"J~ffl°llt7l-'~1Er~~.JtJ~~n~

• •

rJJf!tffiUB"J rffl*¥J

⁰

8°1m'gtzDllt,

~i£~~f~JtB"J~,'t!,§gi£~~;c\B"J[!]*;f@

it~7I-J3IHM-~

, Wolf

~~1*ffl~l~ml~**JI.lm~~W~Jf!~~B¥B"J*

;g George E. Marcus, "Contemporary Problems of Ethnography in the Modem World System," in James Clifford and George E. Marcus, eds., Writing Culture: The Poetics and Politics of Ethnography (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 1986), pp.171·173.

Alvin Y. SO (§U1U§), The South ChiruJ Silk District: Local Historical Transformation and World-System Theory (Albany, NY: State University of New York Press, 1986), pp.7-9.

5" Wolf,op. cit., p.401.

~o~~~~~~~~rfr~~$~~~-~M~tl~~~°fr~~~~

~'*~.~H~IR,tt.'~.'W~~~$~~~*~~~&n

o J 81JtH§:-~~

,

Wolf~7t~~L~~~fl~~-=fI

:

*Mfr*~~

(kin

ordered) ,

*'P:J~~~

,

&~*j:\;~

;

~7t~±~~~f!rJfrtl~*~~83fr*

, ,

~~~**ffl1Ef~

,

;J\.~f~~f!IJ~t)l1n~lla~~*~~fp~

Wi:r¥m*&Mm~~tt ⁰

fr Wolf

~*t·l~!lH$

, Wolf

RXJJJ~1E~~fl~"~~7tffTm*&WfI

~~~~~~'ili~~ffl~~~~r~ili.~WM.~M~&fI~~'~

Roseberry

m~$IJ~Mf/iJlit~::~~J!t±~~~

r

~~fl~J ' ij¥f~

T

)J~fi~~ft m:tt~~~~ 'ftB~~~f~ili Wolf7tffTIR/f@~~ ⁰

Roseberry

m*~*e;f/iJ,~R:,1i§t±~~

Pierre-Philippe Rey ffl1'Ji! '

;J~~*±

~~~m~w~*±~~~mj:\;m}j~-=m~IDtt~ ^o

83Rey ,

~T'i' 4-~~m5i$U~jc~/f~~;J~~*±~~~~~~m=m~9i-

'

m}j~m -fllmmf~~t)~*~?JrU.m

(circulation)

~~M~fI~~fl~

:

;J~~*±~~

~m~~~~~~~~~&~~~~~ilia '~fr~*±~tl~R2

~'ffl~~fI~~m~~ff~~~~~~o~~~*±~tl~~~*~~

*~M&~~~~~~,~~~m-flm}j*~g~'B~~~Rh~H rJrtilll~Lt)jI&~~

; •

m}j~m-m~±~~-fllmi&m (Ji~h1JD

ifrtilll)

~f~ ^a

Roseberry

~JL\~IE~

Rey

~m-m~

•

x.m~~*±~ttf~WI

·

~j;t~±~~~jtJI ⁰

&4Roseberry

1][

Marx

~g3IDt

:

Rh1jH~~M*/f9i-~

--f19HIJ~1E9;;:f&~~~~~~ ~~~fl~~T; ~M~R~1?t~*'P:J~~

/fC&~1?t~~~~fl~

;

.9X1SlrIt~lHw~~-fl:wr~**15-

(synthesis)

⁰ ~

~L3tfF~~II~W*'P:J~~fj~T

'

~1t

Wolf

~-=fI~~fl~ili1'Ji!~@~~

, Ibid., p.75.

H:, Jane Schneider, "Introduction: The Analytic Strategies of Eric R. Wolf," in Jane Schneider and Rayna Rapp, eds., Articulating Hidden Histories: Exploring the Influence of Eric R. Wolf (Berkeley, CA:

University of California Press, 1995), p.8.

8J Roseberry,op. cit" p.163,

" Ibid" pp.l66-167.

.~A

• •

-'~:.~

• • •

.f.!!t~I¥tj;)7t;ffT~Jtl;~rrT ⁰ Roseberry jJH~g.g~

, § +f\tlt*C.tJjl

~j;)*

' tE!fi4 rm-tltwJ

t±l¥rli!ll!fIlg.g~fjr:p

'iM't,\

tHf]'fnj~ Marx

FJT

r

~if

J

g.g~~rr

'

ffiJ~~1I1I):~~'i"g.g~~Ifu*.f.!!t~1t~Jtl;

r

~if

J g.g mR "

~§Z ' ~;fpt~5V~t±~~g.g:;tm:Wf~ Roseberry :mck:g.g~1G

' JJtt

~A~~~tEiIDWbJl~t±l¥rg.gii*.:t::~m~WH1~

,

~~~ Wallerstein g.g~

~1Jl3t~ ~~ Wolf g.g-fl1:.i.Jif~j:\

,

tE~~IfuL:ms~ j;)~m~fI

r

if J '

~OJmfflwr.t±l¥r~1*3t~g.g'~Y5L ⁰

~~'fi~M7AO~ft-Jtl;~~A~~~~JI~t±l¥r.~~.' Mf%W~~~liiIDg.g&~

:

Roseberry ~ffl'i"~g.g;f~~~~Ifu~~~g.g

;

^jffi

Marcus Fl1J~fflOJj;)*±t±l¥rlIltIJ*a*g.g~e

'

Z]1tYJ'';~*±lIltIJg.gtltWe

'*

⁰ ~D*~tmFJT~~~~1~Jjjiilf%g.g'~R!iij.g.g~3

'

~~{jifJ~m~liI$l~~

g.g---~

,

~~*~~~1[ ~~ !3ltg.gMf%~

,

*f~

r

J

(cataloging) g.gI~,~JJtt~m~JI~t±l¥r~ii*.:t::~~~g.g~fI~~~'MtE~.g.g

~~Laoor~ifJg.g~~I~offiJ~~z~~~~g.g~~n~, Wolf ~ Roseberry

!3

f\O~{-~*MfJ'Er:p~HtiJl~t±l!fg.g/h!ltrm~

, if,ttE fj'&g.g$

⁰Wolf

g.gMfJ'E '

JlllHt~~¥IJ~~i&m~~~i1l~~*l¥JQ/J\.g.g~

1!t

⁰ tE*lfrjg.g:l~;H~

,

~fi1f~82f1'l~-$7t~~ftVlUt~~g.g~*&5t;ffT:;tm:

"

Wolf ¥Wl~/hW!g.gJU~

,

~r:pJjjtE7~

rjtifflY:'fif.:t::AJ

fj'&3~J*

tJjl~g.g~~,m-tltwt±l!fg.g.~1[~&.o~~~~~~~'@Mf%~

1irp~.~mg.gt7JAl!ifiP~

:

~~t±l!fr:pg.g/J\.tl1i!;j;)miL (rebellion)

&

m~*.ffi'ili~~~~~.~~@~tE.M.*.:t::Ag.g.ffi~'WtHH .$(rev~tioo)g.g~~?~m~-t7JAI!i~~~g.g,~m~TFJT~' Wolf ~.$r:pg.gtl\.f~tH 7*rJ~g.g5t;ffT

;

~m~-tJJA~ti~~1~~g.g

,

~ fflEffil~ijt~ Marx fiJTz;;~fl1:.i.Jif~j:\;f§~~

,

OJ§~tHf].g.g

r**if J R " vnJ.ifiJT& '

iE~m~~James Scott U~E~tH/J\.)I~.ill~-JE.~

. $ '

ilifm7~1j\.~~g.g rii1!*~~J

W' fJJ%tm&7

r~ifJ g.gOJ§~

t1

⁰ 85ffil¥U;\O~1~r:pJJI

'

ftf!/tliwr~rp~!J\.~filJj;);tt

r

~~g.g~~

J ' tE

James C. Scott, "Hegemony and the Peasantry," Politics and Society (US), No.7 (1977), pp.267-296;

"Revolution in the Revolution: Peasants and Commissars," Theory and Society (Netherlands), No.7 (1979), pp.97-134.

~B~~~~m~TR.*~.~~~r~~J~~m~~w~~.o%

:ft1r~)f[;;fj Wolf~!J\e1fi~EiZ,~~ff,fJT ⁰

Wolf~ffljj*~.fiA*±t±fr

' fr)f[;fim*

-*frt~ 8T§)f[;~~⁰ .frt~,m~~.**~*±t±fr~~

• •

~~~o~~~ADfrt~:U

~M~m**±AD~~,~m*~~~m~m~~fflo~~~~~FB

:

wr.LMm~~t*ji~f~~~t±frfJ;:ff~1L~

,

illa!iI~~~!h!!~InJ1fi

~~~Mffl~om~~Mffl~~mm~~~· ·ft~·&lli

• •

t±fr~jt~

• tm:l:: .

±~&1m1r~~fi1~

;

~JttAlnJtl~¥rj[¥z~~t±fr~*1f

~J~iE!ffij~~~~Atp &rmBwrJt.M"J~P (FJT~1fl

r

E13AtJ) ,

~m1fi~~

~::tJ 0 88

1£At~~*&~m{DJ ~X1t.l.~{*q~~

Atfl:l

~ E13At~m~~!J~JR .?~.~~~*~~~

• •

~t±fr~.~~~&.£li@*.ffl~M

,

ffij~Jlfr3::iii~m~1tBP~.fm'rr~~gt~~*~ft,

r

lE~~.&~

E13

At::tJ*~ffl~~.~~m~~.'&ffij~~~~A~m.*~.~1fi~

M::tJ J

⁰ 89~-{~~~~llifr{m1r~~q~x1t!i~JJ[L ⁰ Wolf 1~lli

'

~At

'

§

E13At~.~x1t,§1§T

r

LlJ~~'$~J ~~i&Jfi:l::.&t~m*t±fr~1fi

m

r~:7(

J

~*t;fj (apocalyptic) }t:H'~

,

'i'jj*~.&1~m!'t:~ImiJ*~~

~iE!At~lf-f

'

.~X1tijtt"~T~~~@::tJ 1£=*FB~&At~S"J~qx⁰ 'n::~1UlfFfflz1i' ~M*~~R~At· § E13At¥}*~~~~:k.*.~~IJ' ~

~~m@.~:7(mff~.$R±¥,t±fr~~~~.~ooo

1£.*:l::.*~t±~f~1W1~!j\At!mm

'

~3fMz7E:LmS"JIPJlf-f

'

Wolf 5m~

{m

1r~ S"J.~tlt

WW:ff:LlJ5m{m

1r~

,f';zJAVi::

{,\~

{'P ffl

⁰ ~{~~~~IT~R

illziji:ff

~tt Wolf ~il1Bt: ⁰ {mW~~E§:gf

,

{~1miJ

'

~1miJ

•

~i¥J

• pii]m&frJ!i2 .

E~ImiJt±fr~~z~~~~.~'1£~~~~lTm~~ATr~.JS"J~

8C, James C. Scott, Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1985).

" Wolf, Peasant Wars of the Twentieth Century (New York: Harper and Row, 1969), pp.280-282.

P! Wolf, "Peasant Rebellion and Revolution:' in Norman Miller and Roderick Aya eds., National Liberation:

Revolution in the Third World (New York: Free Press, 1971), p.62.

Wolf, Peasant Wars of the Twentieth Century, p.292.

" Wolf, "Peasant Rebellion and Revolution," pp.63-64.

iEX ~

AJJi" -

1fI.f- :

*

^Ji;J^ffI!^t'U!

²⁶⁷

7t: r

/h.m*J:jJ1?~r:rr~jrJf¥JP3~

:

ftf!~fD(Jj,tEr~fflf¥J~jJf.U~1~-f~

M

·M.~.f¥J~*o ,~~m&@.'~ili~.~~*~DJ 91m&-$A*,~5Di~'t±:~~:g.ffJ;l.AI~

, lffltE 1960 • 1970

~q:q-lt(')~f¥J~1II

q:r ,

1t~~Jff/F.zfl

AfillMiI!!

⁰ il&m~:g.

Scott &J:tq:rZ-

⁰

Scott

^~*}]fJHB

r

^mi!*~~

J

~*t:!I!1W*i¥Jii:!/J\RtE~§:±~A~Tf¥J

~Ro~~f¥JMmfl=:

• •

ftm~.mf¥JmM' -~.~mWD .,&~m±~f¥J~~o~_*Mmq:r'@~llimi!~~t:!I!~f¥J~*~

.0 'li.m• •*M§:@• •

~.M~@f¥JAonm~-$~±

•

tE~m~.~~.~~@~

• •

@mMM.'lffl~

• •

~m~~±,~

~ftf!f*!:~@1r~~:j:z~ ⁰ m-m.~5E~1tUJlt~

(comparable)

^flf~f¥J

W~ffl~o.-~~.f¥J:j:~.,mf¥J&rM§:~J:t~mOOfflf¥J.~~~

1Jem.frJ

⁰ .R~M §:~*~~fH!}$ti~@Z1&

'

ftf!A:;;fijg~m*tt.~ ⁰

J

am~M§:~~*~ffl&~±~m~~:j:~.*~.'lffl~5E@~.~m

f¥JfjJ!lo

r

^il!i!*~~

J

Scott 3ilfflfflffitiM

§:&:'5~~J!Hf:!

r

^~~#lrJJ!l

J ^PJ.m

.~*il!f,~m~rj ⁰ ^, 1ItliM&f*~.ft£D~f¥Jmtlf1

'

~±&:'~~~

~.f¥J~:j:~m~~/F5E~m( ~~,m~0~)o{B~'~§:±~

f¥JA~~~mffl~m~~~5E,m*~.7M§:~f*~MJ!lili~m7@~

f¥Jmt~*~~[~ ⁰ mmf¥J~U/~rJfiM §:tl~

, , /F ^/PJ1J1 Wolf' Scott

^5.$~

m~f¥JM§:~0~~~.~¥$zM'&lffl@~.tEBm:j:mq:r~.&f¥J

&tf[-ScottT

-W~fFf¥J±G-E1f?!3F1;:i~ ⁰

.~m~~W*~~5Eril!i!@~J~UJ-.~ffl*i¥Jii:!~~f¥Jm

~'m~@~q:r~*W7tili~~~~~.' rmi!~~J~nMf¥J.

" Wolf, Peasant Wars of the Twentieth Century, p.301.

92 James C. Scott, The Moral Economy of the Peasant: Rebellion and Subsistence in Southeast Asia (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1976), p.167.

Scott, "Hegemony and the Peasantry," p.279.

~JJt

(contextsensitive)'

'f::*£,/F~f'jmB"J71iffTI~ 0 94{EI~tH~~1iffJt

L:9f. ' ft r

mlit*~;1!1f J ~mt~~UB"J:EIt!jfnijtlttJ*

§ Samuel Popkin B"J ri&m

*~;1!1f J ~--ifit*i§~j;)j::t:~B"Jmlit~fOO:fWf~'H\IHr~B"Jf'j

mfi

⁰

Popkin Wd

~i±~mtfIfmI B"J~fffliif'j~ifi' 1El~-f~Jl:;JtB"J/J\.~B"J~ft

El m$ ,

;fl!m$~M 95~ ⁰

Scott

~:l:tl!.:!.:~ftmifMI!iJ1!B,SIIEl~Hr1~~~~~1;£

liI!iJn!ilB ' Popkin

BPWd~:l:tl!.:!.:R~~mttB"JMI!iJ-IJ:l:1!B,SI

,

~1!B,SI71f1X~

在文檔中政治人類學一甲子：取向與課題 (頁 23-32)

iik m JdJUt - 1jLf : lfX.ioJ ~ flU! 259

--iik m

flU! 259

,

• •

'

rmilJ (articulation)

:

'

, !trzm.m -tttw

*±SZJiL&m

"

.m*,*±:r±1N

• •

r

J (mode of production)

• •

'

Eric Wolf & William Roseberry SZJflN

Wolf

'

El 1950 iFf--\:: Julian Steward

(peasantry)

* '

• •

'

'

,

Wallerstein' Jl:1J'Migm

• •

• •

), r miS J (integrate)

Wallerstein

,

• •

tttWfil* "

"

§)t ,

Wallerstein

& iJ

:

Wallerstein

-

r

J

,

"

"

Karl Polanyi

r

J (reciprocal economy)

'

r

0

J ( subsistence economy)

67;t:t;J;:M rtit

J

r

J

Wallerstein

• •

;

' §

' mt

•

,

; ¥)-1J[[j ,

titW

, iEM Wallerstein

'

,

'

r

J ; ,

• •

L '

.

"' M

*& . ,

Wallerstein

.m,±:r±1N

' ^§

^"' ^M

® t±fFL rs' ^EfJ ^mfiH*

^1:]iWJ EfJtit-nM'E* 51 fIT 1& rQ] , YN

+ ^iL ^{I

* ^§