mfffiB1mJi: 0 - 政治人類學一甲子：取向與課題

, • •

m~.~~ji*±~~~~Aiffi.,@~~.m~.

*1C::X:{t**l~fl~ ⁰ fm1r'5!li~~~~5fo/J~~?!!iB1'Jr~~~

, litrijflj§ em

1~B1M.J;)~SJ3fmfr~.~~~1rf1ffrJ2f~B1~wrr a FJTJ;)~JT~~fJ;JtcpB1

• •

~*&

'

4§.~.*1CmMcp~iflj~iEll{teJ]tB1$7tJ;)f*~§ eB1iflj~ ⁰ Scott tEm~cp£H~'3Tt Popkin B1~.~1NSJ3MB1 tE~~h~~~~⁰

%~~~ji*±~.ill!~~~~'fffi~~~.W*~B1S~aka'::f~B1~

R&BP;t§

~ B1m~~.*1CmM**l~- eB1iflj~ ⁰ iflj~~tB1*~~

AlIlft-%A

§BS

⁰ @~J!~Ji~B1

'

Scott B1~~itt1§Xf'f: Wolf 1M.~~L~'J\.&:m .ffim.B1a~'iliB~B1~.l±\tEmB~~mJt~.~, r~ftJI±\B1

~*&

0 -5FY=ffB1.;t§

⁰ Scott ::fwz,~ Sedaka

B1**ft'!Wi5t(lJffg:t4i:z '

**~~Ilm

'

~I1tfm!tIl~'J\.B1m~3tm!T

r?l,fmJ

⁰ lOo~1&

'

Scott ::fM~'Jrm

T

Marcus

FJT § :

:fEj.§mfm~~m§]fW~~fm'tfft.5t~~rj.PTB1

" Scott, Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Forms ofPeasant Resistance, pp.43-45.

9S Ibid., p.305.

Ibid., p.220.

100 Ibid., p.350.

nm. '

l!tt~1E~fmffE*m.px~fflHllt~?5rJ151:~I±L*zJl9Ha*t8~a

0 llitft Scott

tEitBt8~~~fif4r:p

,

~l±Ifi/.$:±~a*tE

Sedaka t8Jft&iii'F (

3!~=~ifjlJ

'

JE~m

' iJf

A~IJfS~

,

&Im~mt&) J¥xtiJ1I~

0

JJ]t8~

, Marcus

tf1J~$tJ

' iiffl

ftE.)5JTm~nm.lITtfEt8~fPJJitt~

r

}j~§·Sl,li!'!,±~=1jt8a*

lilf~

J '

tJ2Jitt~1::~~:rt:fllli! ⁰ lOJ

tft@.~~t8mff2~a*'H~.mttt8~ffl1::~~:rt:.~'M~

iTfi1::~~:rt:2mr-t8/J\.WfJ'E

'

/.$:NiH~T~1r§

1970

fFi-(r:pM~iEet¥J

~~~±~~~A.~~~z~,~-± ~tE.OOlli-~~~n~m

,

~S't~~*Gm:r:}]fJ~±~~.t8a*&~fj~rl:t] rf:jE~J

t8!lllmf tJ2lfF

⁰

~1F~tiJ t)J'~~J~,±~m~m.t81£&trm~glfi

' *;gffl@JW 1990 fF{-(z n '

~~A.~tE*{~m*Cr:p

,

=MlfX~t8?9Ht~f~

0

¥Mt8a*.=1j~~§W'~~.Jl~~ftE.~1£a~~t8WfJ'EI~z )5JTtJtiJ~

,

Jitt@IZ;j~itB1F~e-*~~~~fi/.$:±~~51rFt8IDt1¥t:frj:6it=1j ⁰

]021£

Asad '

jJ!nl*GtPJ{1Lrn:1£@a*.=1jJlijllU~lflH~~t8*~ ⁰

m

t)tE~

,

,~mft*#~z.,ftE.~tiJurn:M~m~~±.t8~H~.~~.' 001E±.tl.m.px-M§@t8,~n~~t8,~~~tEt8ft~~~.~

t8 ra*J 01£ Gluckman

mAfjJ~fml6t8i&lfjftiffrzf3t, ~1F~;g$IJ~flwr M~~t8~=1j,tEMa~~ff~t8ft~k'~.T

• •

t8~.m~tl.

IJIJ '

^~ti&

'

^~~m~⁰

Turner t8 r

~Ji:I:.!iX_J~ij!J

,& Cohen

~ti&t8:;g:

IHt ' 1£&'1t '

&1$M1t-=.~fj

,

~{S~m~T~tHj*Gm~at8ff1£it1¥t Mat8li~i&l~tiJ.~M'lli~.~tJ2~lil*~tr.fmt8ft~ft~ffi~fm t8a*ft~offi~i&l~lfX~~=1jt8~n,u.~t8.~ZOO;g*,.~

Scott ftiffr Sedaka r

~=1jt8J1t~

J ;;t.f¥tl±l4J-A?jJlt8G

⁰ llt~lZ;j~n :ffWallerstein&*Gm,~ ~}~t:t~=1jt8~it

' 1E § @t8/.$:± r a* J

~~$Il 7rnil~~

,

~=1jf&

r

1::~tl:rt:

J )5JTlfX{-( ; 13t:ff Marcus

tE~~~WfJ'Ekt8

~m'~JE/.$:±1::~~:rt:t8~mlITt@U~~M~~fiW.fmt8~ffl~~o

." Marcus, "Contemporary Problems of Ethnography in the Modem World System," p.173.

Talal Asad, "Two European Images of Non-European Rule," in Talal Asad, ed., Anthropology and the Colonial Encounter (Atlantic Highlands, NJ: Humanities, 1973), pp.I05-1IL

... --- ...

~~A• •-'~:_~• • • TIl

~~~fF~::tg~~f&.

Scott

~1r*~I¥J~1fJl

0

103~JlrJ

' :ilA 1990

1ff~l¥Jl&m )J~~

¥PM ?tzo *

^{Scott I¥J}

^~1r*~t:V:T

⁷ ^$JT

,ti~l&m)d~fi

¥1iffJtI¥Jii!* '

:ftE.~'8tE.i1i{i~l~pgllft-l¥Jflii! ⁰

1980" 1990

1f1-\:;Jtft!t)\J~~¥11fi!t~~

7~~l&mAM¥I¥J~~~1iff~'~~~~'frTOOI¥J~~-®&9'~

fF~9g~g1~n~jBf&I¥J~~ 0 ^lO4

m'~.~A-.~A ••

~~~.~.~~~~~

H~;:F~~jBf&(state fonnation)I¥J1iffJt~~

,

19781fOJtJ~-fiJ1ji3-1¥J

'"' ~*~1l'~U 1¥Jm\1Jt*.£!t!mJi~5iJ~,ffl§ , ~ft:'E~t~A)(~IIifj:jJti~~~:'E r $j(i;- J I¥Jftlf i£ ' J3[l~;;f;::ftI!i&m.AJlft*il'~ff!:fUJT~I¥J~>C ' tilj:jJ J:J~1H.~ml¥J!<IJinj¥H~*.ti1H±1'!JAllA1'E B fJI ' 1illlI.1A'1¥J r 9iiR;~.1j': J '*' ' ~~:±l!Mi&ml¥J r **i;- .£!t!m ⁰ ^,seizin (

B.m

^ri&m J ' ~

'§'seizi(t;lilfUlt) fj!1'!J!lAJ:JJtWJ*1tI¥J>cftllllli (~AIlI ' hanido r~"1$Jill, &=il'ijl :±l1¥J.::::ftfl

n~%).£!t!mMR;~ff~'~~~~l¥Jr~l¥Jtl~~~~_J°1'E~-r**~JI¥J~_,*,'1'!JAllA

- nl!ilJ:Jfil¥JffVJIlI*~ftlilllllA'l¥Jf4IifefffJJ (fflJ:Jm~ft$IJ*,I!l*1tI¥J'§'IWf.fi&§ftiil5fj!::r::1t~B'l riii

§ J) , ~-ni1iitil!ifi.!lIijmjfHE.::::ftflJJ~{,*'*'B'lishnoXf11!}}jl]!IJ (J:JfI!\lAfi~JJ~lijJf11!~J.lIjA~:i(m B'lB'l~{*) !JH~ft.m--ft r m~:ftI!ntJf:.!Ji~fliIJJ.EtlJ ~';Jfln 0 r >cftJ pqffiSB'lmt;'j!ifi.!"~ , iil51'E;;f;:)(

,*,jj!.lMl!M1'!J!lAftWIB'lliffRffriJ:J~.I¥J{JfJiill~JJI.:±l* 0 ~~ff!:W' rifizmJ !ifi.!>Cft : *.!itlt±1'!JAllA I¥JwFf ' ts.iI3{)g'fU ' ~31t1l (R;1illlI87:L:j.O) , N 115-193 ⁰

~tui'ltilil¥J.!I!!;f!~ffjlj , fl<1fH~~::r:m~;w1f A~*liffRR;tl*±~B'l>C~ , {£lll! ' EI 1983 il'J-:L:j.O~

{\LA~*il'Benedict Anderson~Ernest Gellner:±lK&: 7 R;tl*±~B'l~fFJ:J* ' !Ilci;-7M:~ , ffiWT1iL7<:

~nm*J3. ' '*'2 ' Bm~R;tl*±~B'll9ll.te~~ , A~*il'.~J::J'¥1IJ7 ;\O:L:j.Of~J:J*B'lR;~±~liff R~i1Wl 0 Anderson ( 1998) L&~Tft!l87 :L:j.OJ:J*fflf.;nf~R;~±~ffJ~)( ; Gellner1'E 95 :L:j.O!i:'l;=*t!tL t:t ' Hall ( 1998) Pfi'kj*c~~>c~ , fjJJ1iLJl!GeJJnerB'lR;tl*±~mfi~~~~Jl..I¥J~J!! ⁰J:JJ:=t!'f.1(

£R 7 .l\5iJl!I¥J~ f.1(tlIII JI.lii B\~±~f!I!~ ⁰ t:Et:tfJl. f.1(IlI!!1M1tiWAnderson~GellnerffJj:jJ ~;gDuara

( 1995) , ffriEley and SunyB'l~* ( 1996) , ~IJ~~il'ffl!l:rlf.1(£R!MR;tl*±~l¥JliffR ' lE1;'EfJl.f.1(Il111iJ.iJ

j:t!Jl.f.1(.lMlili:)'Fmfl.imB'l~~ 0 fl~Anersion~GeI1nerJJI!~B'l,*,>C~'Jifr ' j:jJ ~n~~

(

1994) , Z[11l:

f' (

1998) ⁰ ~Benedict Anderson, Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism (London: Verso, 1991 [1983]); The Spectre of Comparisons : Nationalism, Southeast Asia and World. (London: Verso, 1998); Prasenjit Duara, Rescuing History from the Nation: Questioning Narratives of Modern China (Chicago: The Univerisity of Chicago Press, 1995); Geoff Eley and Ronald Grigor Suny, eds., Becoming National: A Reader (New York: Oxford University Press, 1996); Ernest Gellner, Nations and Nationalism (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1983); John A. Hall ed., The State of the Nation: Ernest Gellner and the Theory of Nationalism (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1998); n~~' r MR;:ftI!R;tl*±~~ 1920 :L:j.Of.1(B'l Bmi:l'at J ' ~~Utft"~ , ~ 3 WI, (R;

1illlI83 :L:j.O 3 J=l), N 161-197; u11l:f" 5i!El3::t::.' ~Bli:::t::.WIf:llil!1!jJ1i!!J (i:l'jt : ~fJi'~1"l] , R;1illlI 87 :L:j.O) ⁰

tl:I~mli ⁰ -1:fOO~fri&1€:tA.~~E8f.t~~

,

.~F1HIi&)~a~-~f~tl:IU~

~~U~~tl.E8~*ft~z.~m-m)'A~¥~~~tl:Im=~~g 1fI.tiJj1~~~tl:I~M~lE1ifI1t~~E8m~ ⁰

lOsg-1:fOOfr\Q]-4 ' ltfXi&m

¥~

O'Donnell

ittttm-=tttwE8i&*I£~~

,

f~tl:Ht!?:m~l¥J~mi5LE8J5X~~f~

~-f4M&12f:1i&ft(bureaucratic-authoritarianism

' fmffil BA i&fl) ,

tQfr~4 iJlJEefleM~ ⁰ I05U~lEeiJ/~~ffl1fiJl~A~~~

,

JJ~tl.~~

, fr;\O

4{~ttt1~~Jf5J5XZ~~MOO(semiotics)E8~~

,

~1Mj;JM~

Clifford Geertz

& Philip Corrigan and Derek Sayer

E81ffF1~{~~

;

I07.Mz.~&1990 4{~A~

~~tirU~E8~~A~¥J~rm~tl.JE8~Mo®~ftE8~'

rm

~t±.

J

tQlE~

1990

4{~l¥JltfXi&m¥~frf~lli rt±.~8"J~*J

(state

in-society)

8"J.@~~mz~

,

~~fiffJ'EE8Ii!!H3 ~1B q±.~E8~*J⁰ ~

m,

fltj~frBAi&:mH~~Z1&' ¥~ti 19804{~mm r/t!km~*}E1iLJ

~E8&:~ I08j;JT~fr~~ft(i&mA~¥~ltfXi&m¥E8JifHfiMID.ia.e ⁰

'

5tJ1IJ~i

~1~~Jf5J5XI¥J~Nli ⁰ ~fr~.~mM~lj

,

m-::::.tttwfElIm1Bm~t±.z'@~

, ill

~&ffitlM

'

~f¥I¥J.!tt;:fiffJ'E

'

OJfi~J5X~fr~f;1(1t

'

~~{tfti.T

' i&¥trA

~~~WltfXi&m¥~ti~I¥J~l5o

i&mA~¥~fr1~84lli~7~*~gn~~IEeI¥J~~~o~~re

Morton Fried

~Mj§J5X1~~

, WElman Service

ft$,§,f§h~IJj§~*I¥Jn:~

,

mfJl'1~;jFmrn~ ⁰ ~~WJ~

Fried

^£~

,

n~~~*l~-}EI¥Jt±.:;;·FZP~

®~1::8"J*E~

,

tQJl~~~/f';: \Q]~M(~ Ilt~/f';: \Q]:III&myjt~8"J~.)8"Jf¥

if '

~1~~Jf5J5X8"J&::\~f~{*

;

~~-fl~*&fti~~8"J'@~ ⁰

109® Service flrJ

Ronald Cohen. "Introduction," in Ronald Cohen and Elman R. Services, eds., Origins of the State: Th, Anthropology ofPolitical Evolution (Philadelphia: Institute for the Study of Human Issues, 1978). pp. 1-20 Henri J. M.Claessen and Peter Skalnik. "The Early State: Theories and Hypotheses," in Henri J. M Claessen and Peter Skalnik, eds., The Early State (The Hague: Mouton Publishers, 1978). pp. 3-29.

10" David Collier. "Overview of the Bureaucratic-Authoritarian Model," in David Collier. ed., The Ne.

Authoritarianism in Latin America (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1979).

Clifford Geertz. Negara: The Theatre State in Nineteenth-Century Bali (Princeton: Princeton Universit Press, 1980); Philip Corrigan and Derek Sayer. The Great Arch: English State Formation as Culture Revolution (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1985).

Peter B. Evans, et. aI., eds .• Bringing the State Back In (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Pres 1985).

'" Henri J. M.Claessen and Peter Skalnik. "The Early State." p. 16 ; Ronald Cohen, "Introduction." p.7 .

... _---

*~A.*-'~:*~.

TI3

±~~J{~'§~ftI&f!tAR~~1lJ-jjf!tIE~ti-z~EU~~*

'

ffk'il]~li~~

*E!AR~~~~~~~$*i&fI!1{tEfr~~1:.$~flj

,

ITO~fl$7tIlM'lffpx

BkJ r

:f±wr~¥JJ : 0 llOD~~*~)(~ ,7tJJrj~

~~~~~!1U~ff~~~~llix~~&!1~~.'

.'~~~&~~E!~~'~*~~~~£~~~~~~o $~

~f~lli~~M~IE~1f.:J;}7f.~~~Jl~~

: AD!!1J '

,

~~W ⁰ lll~

J =£f. ' Henri Claessen

Peter Skalnik

fI}~~lU1f.15~~~

)(~~'D~A.~~.~M~~*%px~~~~~,m~ffl~~Bm,

~1U1~*B10~m:~};B~"'fg, ⁰

112 , Cohen

ft{tE~i\i.ij~~)(~$

,

B*£]tJl:¥IJ~-{~~a1HtA.~

~~mg.

J :

~~ffpx~u£~:f$~1r:

(sacralization) Fp,a

⁰

~aft 1980

£f.ft$f!t¥rj Geertz & Corrigan and Sayer

~§1~ Mwf~¥rJ ⁰

' Geertz

~W**1C1f.:{tEm~Rtmtt;~-¥Yti

'

&fffi{mE!J;}nHif!l~Jj\dD)(lliZ ⁰ ft:ftfr~7ttfT{m0~f.I5~Jt~~Ifit51:.Rtm~t-Negara ~~)Z

M '

~:ftfr~1cft£{m~!j\dD$~0{tE!1

r JI¥:fi'S

(thick

description){~~Rtm t&m~1Jyti~&~ ⁰

Geertz

^{§:Ii '}^{tE~

r

^Jft¥t~WIPJ~rg~*

Paul Ricoeur

r

^~tlJ^J

(inscription) , r @]JEJ

⁰ 114Jt~~!l*~lJ};

:

~:~.~!1aE!rliwr~.~~~J ;§~E!H~~~ (~

"said" )

^fe.~~~^;

^§

^,

~i.~I1J{'F&::,{t';ift~ml~M;::X~3.!fi ⁰ il5Jt;::X{tEf~$IJ

'

J\lM'l~~~z-~afl

'

f~~E!1lJ.I;U~l.Xft¥t~~Jt~~ff

IHJ Henri J. M.Claessen and Peter Skalnik, Ibid., p. 17 ; Ronald Cohen, Ibid., p.7.

Henri J. M. Claessen and Peter Skalnik, "Limits: Beginning and End of the Early State," in Henri J. M.

Claessen and Peter Skalnik, eds., The Early State (The Hague: Mouton Publishers, 1978), p.625 ; Ronald Cohen, "Introduction," p.8.

112 Henri J. M. Claessen and Peter Skalnik, "Ubi sumus? The Study of the State: Conference in Retrospect," in

Henri J. M. Claessen and Peter Skalnik, eds., The Study of the State (The Hague: Mouton Publishers, 1981), p.484.

1Ll Ronald Cohen, "Introduction," p.16.

'" Clifford Geertz. Local Knowledge: Further Essays in Interpretive Anthropology (New York: Basic Books, 1983), p.3!.

113 Clifford Geertz, The Interpretation of Cultures: Selected Essays (New York: Basic Books, 1973). pp. 20-21.

Mti

$J. ,

iffiili- ti

$J. ~fHH~~

JJ! Jr B9

fjH~1 ~fjJifHfJ

iiJ

1t.n~ ~ 0

116t!l1itttE

~,a.B9~.-nmM.ffiti~ti.mAAB9~m,~-nma.t!liiJ.

1fJ!RXj:)Jt~m

'

.~C&~

,

^~mftti.

^{A;[} :}

ili~]jIH~B9tE*~nmB9a .iffi~o.~~*~a.B9.~iffi~'B~._M~m:

' • •

~~~~mmrA~~~iffi~JB9ffi~;~ffl.~'B~~.~iffi~~B9

~~~fl:

;

~lll~~

,

'2~~'flt~5~~.Bl:~3ltffB9'@m ⁰ 117~D*~~mtJJ

Geertz

B9}!J1a'inY*~

,

Jl~Mft!!

Negara

B9~~tt:~§:'*;f~M~1Jrr7ili1~n

?

Geertz

1W11li5~ Negara

B9:±:

I=t~DT

:

^ll8

~Q9 ]j-*/f-~00 ... k~/¥dt

T -:f1r :

iLiltR.Q9 $.J1. Mi H:tSt£!Il

.'II·I~~·**-a~#.·.a'

• •

·k_'.-*.~~.~~

.-.#.4~~.Q9.~.~ak.~a·.~'~.·~4.Q91r~~.~

Q9#••

~:~4iltMt~~#~ilt~'~.~~~kA~ilt~Q9

• •

^·~~

•

^~~#~.~Q9

• •-••kaa.Q9 • •

,~k#~.~Q9.~-~~-

••

1!l~J,t.

T

;f!."Q9.~ 0 }j-~OO...

aa;l1f;f:.;:r::;; kJit't

^{~ ~~~*}

ElII.f

⁰

*Q9.;f:.~~'~~~k~~4~*at4a~~Q9-J·~~~k~~~~Q9

•••

^~·~a

• •

^~a*ftQ9~t

••

*;f:.~~,~~~a.,~~~~~;

~k~a

• •

Q9.*ht.#T4.Q9~ruot4Q94~a.~~a;f:.~.~*

~;f~

't;llJi ...

1t.[~!!4~ ]~

• •

~ ⁰ (J&~~.fJf~)

.~~~M

• •

*~Thbmm~mrn~ili.B9~*.ft'~M~$~

(sedahm)

1&~~iI!Ht]*lfrttJjrmMl

'

~~ffl*mt*~mpqB9~-IIIiW '~~~B9.~.~~~rrm~.-*~~~~~M~.M~'*RXti .~pt;-B9~ 'GeertzB9~~~.fIj ffHli~~ ⁰ 119{g~~fr'fl:1~

Geertz~Negara$B9}!JmE*~!f rfY.&.M;;xB9~~J ~/Ffii

;

~§&:B9 ,~

o Ibid., pp.91-94.

Ibid., pp.100-107.

liS Geertz, Local Knowledge, pp.29-30.

I" Clifford Geertz, Negara: The Theatre State in Nineteenth-Century Bali (Princeton, NY: Princeton University Press. 1980). pp.77-82.

~~A• •-'~:~~• • • 2~

m-$.~~~.~~,®wr.mJwm~

• •

g~a.~M'.-~

m~B~~~~~~M*o®.m~~$~~~Ww.~~~wm~.w r*.lliwttJ~mft~.,ftm~~~r~mw~~J~r~.JOO

a 1201f£$1!al1i~ffifm~~*4~~

,

p}fm~

Geertz

~1~~m~±E§ 0

~~E§§~M~~'a~~.~~~®ffiftmWm.*ft

• •

rr~~~, ffiMif~

,

&m1!!t~~~~

,

¥rJ~~~tlT~~~~i¥:~~~ ⁰

~JltzPi-

' Geertz

~1tff&

T

{tP.?fi~j!l

• •

~~;f'!'t~fl~

(a model of)

~JJ!Jl~fliH(a

model

for)~±~

,

~~~iID~~f

'

A:~~jJD~**~$

ft ' Wytp}

Tm

⁰ ]1!1f!~~

, ftgJ;J Negara

~1f!Im*rr'g~:It!!{1L

(status) ,

w_x±a ^(pomp)

^~~£UJ!

^'

mHi®W3&~1j5!flXfffi~i&m~~-1t5!li~~

Im*~mm

(governance) J}]fm ;

{tP.Mzt~W:It!!{1L

' x±a '

^mm=~**~

r Im* J ( state)

-gPJrr~.g~~5tia~=*±~ ⁰

121

~* ~ ~ff~ ~ iID~ffi~~~5'~~ ~~ ~~

Corrigan and Sayer

lM~ El-f--tit*clffi~1iEij~J;J*

'

~~lliT£fz~~10~

~~~om*.ti~~~A®~,~mW~~¥.~

• •

'E§§~~W~

ffl~ftg~~.~~~m~~~'ffi~¥m~JlEm~m~r~&J~W~

J

~:It!!~ ⁰ ~~1mfr~mW rm9=~~10~§X1t1fL$~a~J' BP~W

Geertz

~ifz,l~ §1tJ1f~~~~il10~&:\~Jtt~§X1t1fL$ ⁰

? E§§

~~B.lliT£f~~~~,.~~rM£.JW.~m.m~~r

J

~ilWTrr$m~{~ltr\~5C1irf

' :m¥rJWrI ;

®£mw*C14t~mrI~fj

, WJx.

~¥U$m*~~m!ilHtW1~A1t~*g. 123ftt!~Z' ~~10~1!J>13-=*~⁰

f j , ®~1f!~~~ r~~1t-=f~

(PJr:tiRtrJ

'1-tilii&m~10A

'&*ft)

~~~~fjJ' 124~wyt~~M1zr:tim~m!i~1tW{iA1t a

il*m~Ela~~1t~-=f~~MT~.m~~~N'~~~~~~*

§OC~~.~

rX1t10AJ

⁰ mJf:t10A1Jt!1~il*1~J;Jji1T rm~:gtrJJ' ~Wyt

Ibid., pp.5-6.

I"

Geertz, Negara, pp.121-123.

122 Corrigan and Sayer, The Great Arch, p.ll.

Ibid., p. 3 & p.12.

124 Ibid., p.lO.

~r~M~R~~~ll.~~m~ft~*H~&~.~~m,~~~

it ' §

~it

'

J:!P~px w**~!~¥lJ ~~t. 0

J

125ffi~tzl]fijJllHTi§:~~jg~

~~? ~.B~.*~M.~.~~~PX -Mr~~.*J

(nation) ,

x.tzofijJ~.H~~~ib1¥J~f~5:HI~m~

(citizen)

~rr.:l~1m ⁰

*~~Jm~ijijm<.rPJ~1:'rf~HWJz&f& 'fE!~E~.it~t±1£

W

Negara

~,~ftn.~px~~~~'~ff~.~**~.*~~ll.~~¥lz~

~MOO ffiJ~ ⁰

r

iEl\!~~f#iJ

J

1!t~~1MI±l

'

;{UJ!ji-ti7~fW

1970 4i-ttJ

*~~~~~

Antonio Gramsci raflJ

!l:l[~ijij~mt

'

12E!i$~m{.lrff~ft~~

~~-&f&mjlJafl ⁰

Gramsci

raflJ'

1~~~.*tJXitmW§~~Wz

~~~rm~ll.J'~~.~~fE!~ft~~'ffiJH~jgm~~a

• • Z

~~ ⁰

Gramsci JJi,ttzo

Corrigan and Sayer '

~*~fJjaJlft~?1t[~

~~~Jfl~Ffi~!§J rm~ll.

J'

~i§~~ft~-tttw~IDft*~~f~Jfl-i§:~

19904{-t~~~ft~A~~~lix~ltifiSZft~~1!'f~~jiJ~rr.:l'~

,

fjHr~iIfif

在文檔中政治人類學一甲子：取向與課題 (頁 33-40)

mfffiB1mJi: 0

, • •

, litrijflj§ em

• •

'

R&BP;t§

AlIlft-%A

§BS

'

0 -5FY=ffB1.;t§

B1**ft'!Wi5t(lJffg:t4i:z '

'

r?l,fmJ

'

T

FJT § :

nm. '

0 llitft Scott

,

Sedaka t8Jft&iii'F (

'

' iJf

,

0

, Marcus

' iiffl

r

J '

'

1970

,

t8!lllmf tJ2lfF

' *;gffl@JW 1990 fF{-(z n '

,

0

,

]021£

Asad '

m

,

t8 ra*J 01£ Gluckman

• •

IJIJ '

'

Turner t8 r

,& Cohen

IHt ' 1£&'1t '

,

Scott ftiffr Sedaka r

J ;;t.f¥tl±l4J-A?jJlt8*G*

' 1E § @t8/.$:± r a* J

,

r

J )5JTlfX{-( ; 13t:ff Marcus

... --- ...

Scott

0

' :ilA 1990

¥PM ?tzo *

Scott I¥J

7 $JT

¥1iffJtI¥Jii!* '

1980" 1990

m'~.~A-.~A ••

~~~.~.~~~~~

,

B.m

(

f' (

,

lOsg-1:fOOfr\Q]-4 ' ltfXi&m

O'Donnell

,

' fmffil BA i&fl) ,

,

, fr;\O

,

Clifford Geertz

& Philip Corrigan and Derek Sayer

;

J ;;t.f¥tl±l4J-A?jJlt8G

^{Scott I¥J}

⁷ ^$JT

(state

... _---

^§

^,

^{A;[} :}