臺灣新郎 : 「編導式攝影」中的記錄思維

全文

(1)i&1a*~ II1 ~eg 01563486. 111111111111 11111 11111 11111 1111111111111111111 1111. \ -.:1. ' ~. '.:-'. "'" 3"S ............ ~ tEa"'. .ttl* n.J. ~. 11'1a:. ~. fr---,. ~~. !t t:\. ~f,. ~. L-. ~. ~. ~. • •........ 4IJ. :l. > CO.I. c:. :0. ----. e o. ~. 0 J.. QJ ~. J.. .~. ~ QJ. ~. Q. Q.. =. ~ QJ. ,.c. E-.

(2)

(3) ~.~~ r.S~.~J~~~~~*. 1936 if 11 J'j 29 B ' .l)~~ a:t ' * It&TIfi ~. B~J5g 'F. ". ;!tf U>.. iiRU. ~(lut fr it. t2ir:pB~~J)J. 1989 iflmftElft£~ m ll!3 ~~~ , t(£if~ * ' ijj* ' itt* '. Y:.* '. -rn~tW. , f!i:lli1!f1JU!ff ~ifHtt4i. ~;~~r*~ ~ aJW~~® ~ 'W~ R~~ *- R .~~.M o. ~m~ g ~~~3*~,~ ~ ~m ~ .~. ~ * ~m~~ m ~~~UM'. B ~~~~ ~ ft ~ .~ D1' .~ ~ ~ o ~~' ~ .'~ Q ~ *~oo .~m~ 7~ tB ~ r:p. , &}!it. ~Mi. " ~F rY~[" ~B(~ t:H~iBi~1ftI :g.. ,. ~a . mr:p~a.1'~~*.ft~*Y:. ID. ~ Rm. ~ '~.~~ ~ ~lli~ ~i5. 0. fiiT6Cfr ~ ~Jl. kiijn~oJtt.~~4-32. '. ~.i. ~OJ .l)iit&~ ~JfIH§~ijBi kiij~r:p. ,. t&~~ ~:g. *W~ft.~ . o @ ~ M. ~"m .~ * Y:. ~~ •. • ~ ~~. ff ' ttttm~~~~ m M ft~~ * . $;R .~ @1'~~~~~~m~ • • 'Am ~~~w , ~. ~ ~mffi~" :g. ~~ ~.®~~ B ~" ' 8 ~ ~ ~ m . ~ ~ ft ~tt~w.~~,m~£~ .~ ~ ~ ~w w m~1' ~ ~ o. ~ * m5t~ ~ ~~W'ili8~~.ft ~ ~r:p~m. ~ .a*m.M~m . tt ,. ,. ~1Rl.)ll3 *o fibl~ giJf'F~W fi~ (jjJ £~. ; ~$~WR~. ft~m~~.w~~~m* . ~ ~ *~ ~, .it. UOJ~"~ ~ ~"ft£ $~ .~ W a ~ ~'.~frm.~ ~ ~WM'fi ~ •. • *~ftm • • • ~ ~K~HM. ~ ; w~ .m . ~ n ~~~~.~ o e. ~,am ~ ~~ e ~A W *1' • • • ~ ~mftM,~ ~ ~~ ft~. ~~ ~~fi ~ M ~~. ? ~*~ 5t .it. ~ B . ~~" ~ ~ * m.W* . fim- H,ft ~ " . ~ ~ :g. ,~ m ~ ~ " * [@J~ f-t ~~~HH~Wr-;~. ~5t ~. ~ m •. .. ~i!!! rY J!.. ~~. o. (John Baldessari) §'dE §' ; 1' W .~Ij,g,. • '~fi M .~ ~.M~ ~ ~ . ~ ~'W~~R ~. t4i~m~. ~ * MM8 ~~ . k .7 o R~~~ :g.~Att D ~'.~ ~ . ffi~~r. ~ J R ~ ~ ?p. ~r:p~ - gIHt. *1CM itt J!U il. '. iITi(i!!{f£t:IJ ffr !l1! fflBi~¥, ~ ;I;l!: fJJllm ~W ~. 0. ... ~ ~ ~. t *. A . ~ ~~~t.ff' ~*. ~ ~~~ . ~~~~. ~;;T.J~. iImII ~ :t\ 1JIIJ)j''?. mOJ (HansDieter Junker) fr. J. «~~ t1if~Oi~ mt. '. -@J . {{ ~ vrqI'li~"~i ». r:p~ a ; a ~*1C ~. ~ m. m ~' ~.£ ~~ ~ID ~ 'ili1'~ ~ ft ~ .~~, rfflR. ~J8A~A~rt. R ~ill. · lli*ili~m. ~ .~~. ~M mg.~ ~ ,i'q l!l!!1iJJ 1=f r ~~tHfq J' r~ ~ti Vij J. ' Commentl &. I!~IDili3ill1f ~Hi~Wj 9=t B"Jm~ 'Ii. rVJ5;t1~tnw. fi.e., iill-X. rHlil f§ ~1~::t~ J ' rw~tli1fq J. r~ l!I f1Hifq J. ' rt'k~ ~ vltf J ' Art of Social. r.{{8~~ffr± ~ §j fflaJ ( New. '. r~ W Jw. ~1A J ~. 0. ft£I~~j~{'F ~ OO *;g. ,. flIi ~ l~F1'{jlff! n. %' ~.'MM,. m~ "~tt D ~" ~ ~ .,mU~ OOili~~~I ~ .M .. mm $ .~M'~. & ~fffiiT~ D ~ ~ffi'~ Ua~ ~ m~. ~~ w~~. {t ' ~ (~m & f(ff ~ H~tl~B~J * l~ if {tfli tt5TI * ~1fg ~~ *~~t5l Arthur C. Danto fl!~~ , ~ ~ ~ - fi&' ~~ ~~J!I!~ :tt1gfffr~. jJ] , r~ ff!Hfii8I;JJ:I1fum ' "!Hg" R1'~ ~ "' ~ M Hhl 7 ~O(frJU~ - N)l:AWtafi~Bi~m ' {(£trH~Bif.t~ ~l~I~~ ~ ~ r~.m f0 J (fine art photography) I ~ lf0 {~ ~ ~ ? i~Jlf! fH~. ~ ~Ij{f O ZJit ~ j}j( ~~ , ~ iITi f.!~ 'Frt {.IE /1X Wi~ ~ 1ifii PX~ ~ ~ ON r.jl ~ "j~- Ji. "'I{{ f4 ~ t¥ 1ifii ~ ". 0. 0. ~£r:p'~~ •. • • AAm ~~* a ~ .~ffB o m ~ 'fi~~ ~~fi ~ W ~ ~. ~ M'M~ ~ n ~8AR ~ ~~'~~ ' 32 :tW ~ OOo"~~@ ~~~W,ft£M. * ~ ~~ * * ti ,~m~ * ImB~ ~ ~~M;AAtBOJ~H~~M'8~'~. ••. ~ ~i1IJilli ~~U!ir:p. ,. "~F fI}JJl" 'M ~ A~J;)a ~ .QJJ ~n {H'] il:?: f\'lI,. f#l ~c. " 1}rt ~AJJl" 8~*~Hj!111 ;fJ!. , t± tU&!t:\H~~ f*9'. 0. ~1fIl. , ~Jtt ' m ' If£N!{ffl l1i1ix A. m~ ft. * ti 'ffOOr • • J~.fi*~ m ~~~~ • • ,.~ ~ m~ *~~ m ~J&,tB.~ ~ ~~~~ft°OJ~rmft. ~ Jr:pMM~t4i~m~W % • •. nM~m. 'Rfrm~ ~~ ~~ 2 ~ m*~ftA~:g. ~ @e o tr~mm ~T '. ®~t O ~ R~*'OO ~ -HmWmfW*1CrmftfllitiJ~ ~~~ . 1' ~~~. J&ft7 ~f :g. (fjf.HHltrIDiI~ffr ~fj ~M. :R ; IEF1~ g'J~ J;)~1!2 ~ . ~WT ii~x3Z ?I~ . 2 ~ MW A r~ Im 64 ~1W1 J (f / 64 group ) ~~{~~'L' : (t~~ .w. B r~n~tiljf;'0J ~f;f ~ ffl~ ? ili/f~ lm ~m tl~. ~, ~ m *~* ~~~ fi 7*.IDM'~#~ * ~frRtt~' ~ OO ~ , tI ~ .. .m ~ ~r~~tt.OOJ~ ~ . 'iITi~rW~ 8~J~g ~ '~ ~ ~ m ft 'ID. ~~* .m ,~. {if.. . !1t ~. ~ ~ o R~'*W~ffl~m-H A ~~OO • • ~ $ W .~. , f1f ~{t~f4f~ I Ji'! '. ~rft?!.\ miJ. '. I~UJ!l!.a W omiliKfr rnE ~~* m * ~a 7'~*$ 5t ~~.~~~fi. ~ ::t ~jHn ~ijtti 1ifq ~ -·-nI. 1'~ ~ a ~B~ M · ~ ~~ ~ ,. " *fi"~mm~~~~ ~ /1X'.~~~W. mode ) ~um' ~illif~:tfJSi fJfi(;}; ~*6. r• • JID~ ~ ~7"~W~~. ~ . " ~ , :¥: ~flIi )l!~ ~JUIJ~~fr'~f!~ 4. 8A I1x 7 tii ~ £. 0. Hft I2SJ fiiT it ?. '. ID~ - fdl~{J;.( " fj;T~ =tf 8'JJM\~" 0. (the directorial ~1t ~ m~ fj1(li~.~mr:p , ~m. , ~ ~,.~tttt ~~ ~ .~~~.. 0. . ~ * ~r:p~~.~.~~Y:.* . ~n*~~ • • m.'.~ ~ M ~ m~. ~~ ~r ~ ~m~J.~wr.m.~J - .efr* * ~~r:pftm:g.if' {§jl.5t1'ffl ~jtjj ~ . f;}j. o am~ @~ ~~~~~ ~OOttMB o. .~~'~ ~~ ~~*~~B~~W a~ ?ft£.~~~OO* ~ '.*1C * ~*W. ~ ~~~aB~I~~ Ba~ ~m B'ili~ ~ ~ * 8 ~ m,ft£m~3M8. ,. ••~ ~ ~ .~. 0. rtlttj;ll-flAA wmtB"J**~g J. m~. *~ :g.~ ~fr ~ ~ Ui ~r:p8A/1X7. ' a l!i*. ~w~.m ~ ~~ ~~ ' ~ ~ ~~ ~fiM~~- . ~ ~ " M~ ~~ *"~~. 0. "~~~ - fmAA OJ J;) ~fW. ' fiWJ .l),~~Mt!!m ~. .~.ffl ¥ ~ ~m~ ~ . ,"~~~~~. g ~~~ K ~ ~OO .~ H , m~~ ~ lm mi ~. {J:) ~a m 7 ;. ~8i** M~J '{f{frJ ~ i~ii ~~ ~ lli @J " ~m W' ~EIj{'f~M. ~ • • ~ D ~ M M ~ M~~m .m . ;~ • • ~Y:. * *mijj · . ~*M~ ~~. 0. '. rf' ~i2 - flJlAA~. ~ ffi ~ ~'~M.~"*m ti ~W~~ffi o ~~~*ffi~ ~~ W i '~~~~. * g~5tB';J ~~1=.. ~. :. -'fIIH oJtt,. 0. ~~~ m ~~-.,. (~~1' $2l! Y:. * "U[ t~W mr ~~Yi! 'I'i. ~ ~t~tfT !'l3. 0. ~.r:p~ m~ '~OO'M~~~ ~~g 'RAm~Wm~~frm W ~~ m ~.. 1M . (j;.t2i» ~7fI. { i.tli» ~tnt fr~I!IiJ ~ 1T. , W**ofW. ~m~ffifi~* 8 ~;~Sm~r:p~ ~ M~1'~Afi E .~~ ~~ c ~~ .m. 1.J3ZFt. . {~ft~ (Anne H, Hoy ) ® -g. ' J:_~(f':JHm ~t~~ (Fabricating ph otographs) 1'f.§13ti5 "{f{iiJ~F-t4!f¥tB~Bi *c~ ~ (~ " ; Mi~O; rmo.~ ti~ J f01~ JJHtft-J r ~ l1J\\J1U; . J '1fz J;) r ~o m {J;.(~iiJJ A ~ iffi J (tableau) ,. fifT lt Px8i r~. J (lens-based image) *6. '. r~.J. I . * mm W~ MmMm~~,@m 1' .mY:. ~~.mm~~;~.~ffi m ~ ~~~ Nfi!I~. , ili1'~tlfi )l!~*B9~ffiX OJ J! ' ~~WH§~ffi~~ "* 0 ?~ " 1'~ 0. ~ ~ !E _t 8A r~ ~ ~..n B9 ¥ ji. ,. Ml IJ''' ~ ~fIli ~ B~mm F;;3. , i.E! fr W~. RI!.§~Kr:p~m~lJH§< ~ "*~ ~ ijJ'I'i " ~~a. * o HM~"~mft , .~m.*~ . ~&~m~m~,~m 1' ~m~~~~. .{f ' m1' ~Im Jf, /1X.Bi.I~ ~~:K*~~t~H~!~~W~Wd9;O • OJ J! ' 1!P{ferm.J J&ft7 ~.RU ~~~'R . ffl.ffi.~Afi~~.M*.~ D~ ~ ~,mR 1f{f~f4tIUJl ~ .m~ {'F£OitMfq 1·i. ;*. i§Bi~.. 0. '. ~fJJ XW ~J!tft 1!t *~{t. 8f4~~ "§~ ~ ~". '1' ~m ~: ~~. jifli ~ .3'& {I-M1Jlj JI 1t~1ifij ~Z1iUf ? If£~M'iiB9 ~ ti *~. , f/ffiM;ffl (Camille , t16~ * ~IJ~O Fi'lJ ~~ . R~ , iiW~ fi §it IlN~~m " IlN JE$ ~IJB~~r,:f' 3IdUJl § vrij ~: ~ ) ~.Mffi~~ m m "~ ~~ ~ " *~~~MMMttM~,mffi • • • ~W~~ eW. ~ · OJJ!,tlfi~ *1'm . tt • • ~. m ~fiiTW~~AD I~ ~~' ~ ~ • ~ - . ~m I~ ~~ . ;aft • • m~? S ~~~~ K r:p~~ ~ ffl a ~~ Rech t)~ ttlljjlj. ,. 'J \m~ * {~OO 'i~lU~1* ~O~J1:E ~c B(J I ltl!w'! i§tf:l 'iif tlnlH~. 0. * ? - ~ ~ c ~m~~'W~A&n~~tt~ i mo. m,. ,rB~Jmr.m~.J W. M*~, 5t m7~ft li + A ffi fik ~. !I .~fi~ ~ ~*. (Fabrication, Stage , Altered , and Appropri ated 3ZFt. . 1~ {-& !1 r:p r~g~tJk·~J O{J Jm~ Hl*r~ * ' ;f(~ ~:'@ lli{-~ ~14~ ~~ 13lI ~ lJl~ @lAt&~ , lli{{ r~ m -:tt lii~ J (Fabricated Photography ) ~t ~iBi !JOE ~'L'IH~~ ~ :m ~ : .l) r Ml~ ~ti1ifii J ~ * j,i , WH~ rm {{m~ J fJJWl r ~1if¥lilfi Ji!; J (straight photography) :f11 r m@iIiWi ';jljJ (rnanipulated photography ) oi5tMY ' -fffi~ijffUi r£JH~ ~ tfii~J tlhlJ;m)B/J hiIJ jJ tf:l ~ mrJA@tL WI' . lliiJ~ t~ (Darsie Alexander) ffi~: r 'M rtlilfi IDh1 1Hru(1'J m~i! ~ ' MU~ =tf *6-@J ' . !lQ~ " W "glj{f" ~ - ~ , ~ Ji!; (~fQ itJJ £UJltf:l ?f1i t!1 D9~xll1J~ , ITli 1' ~ fw ~Jt IS ~¥. ~ fli( 1' Hfl @ lliH~Ht ~ tBi J W! 'nJ ~1!i F.~ , if.HUifk r~ r:p OZ] " ~t1I " ~ 0. photographs' 1987 ). ~~ ,. 0. a'J. 0. ~ .6 M.tf:l * ~;1' ~* ~m a ~ ~ $ ~~ ~ ~ ~ om~~~ ~ ~.~7 ; S ft~. m. 1' ~~ R m ~ ~fiiTmrn~A; ~ ~. " g ~ ~" ffi.illitf:l * ~ ~ a; ~ ~ w w . ~ ~ m .~~~~~ · ~ .w .~r ~ ~ H~ *J ' 1' ~.. "~~~~~m ~ ~.~.ftM~IDrt m. '®~ H~ ~.± .~rft~ ~ • ~lj ~ 1ifqBt.I *~. ?J. 5.

(4)

(5) & , " § Jti~fj~20 02{ nJl 7\31IiiXJ1f1HSouthern. r ~fti Wrt tM r~ Jj,2- fiR ~.ft tt (1'1&illi ~!DJ rt ' ~ ·fill 1J i-Milli ' IOJ tit ~ iI jfn foE;?; ~ !l1 Y4 fl{~ f1!i (19 "il !Hjfq H(4g- " H!i' ' 11 U)~) ~ ~lt tm ;1'1 '}Htlri'i ? I L! fj~ fli'U .. GiiI (19~ f1 1i1if!; {~ ~. Alleghenic :; Muse um of Art fiJT ~VflUI'Jlb'J ~'11 <~ )( {tmmf) ~Mi lPi. ~ (~~~~rr~~) W ( ~R m M)m ~ ~ffl ~~rt~~ .'ffiU.~M~. I11iiPJTIBMI~]A ltoona , Johnstown , and Ligonier Vall ey= {[~~ Jl'illiili£!g)MIH'I~ q,- , ( ~. ttt~ ,. ~ & 'U~W fl ~ R .~~~m~~aao U T ~ - H A ft~~ rt~~~wm. ~Ufr f!~ ) fD{[~IA !J1-jt,}n~ J'19 (it~~~rJ'- tE i1 ifol! » ( 1997-1 999). ~~. rt I1J H~ (1'-.1 Jid, oPt ji!!J,f¥ I/.iJ. WiJ B9 flJI ~ ' 7tjJIJif mff£;l~ $ttlil lifi ~ n t-Jr~ (19¥JJf~~ ' r it~jilinflj .g if"J n~1t.f T J ' rfr i£IJ tI:l [1 ¥Ij ~~ (19:(i1~IS~A al~rJ 'WTIi'J;L f~ ' pjIl1!!G I t-ililTIl~o/Jff[: @ ~. 0. 1~IJ~ J;;tUU! fRjf;. -~!i A jjj tt~~ AJl}j fl B"J ,~\~~ Ii fM~riiT ~)Jf:!lH~qllf!J. ~ t5ia:m t~II>B9~IH'F~tJ~ 19994 £. , t)Itt * illi ~~~ )( {UN t(~\U~.fI&I AH''.i ~~. '. \1(rt-E~~ lf\q. ,til):) r li!il~ ~. r ~< J- % 1~ 11 ,HI ' tE::kffiE)( {t r[ltF·]1i , irt t:~~ f%~jjlj~:fUff tN flt.I A'ITI ~ «i1 .-}:Wf &II» ((Jpq~ , 'f l!ll;r~!!l~:JjJqEfJ I~EsHtl!1lriE ~UJ 8':j BH& ~H~ , 1(jj;iiif~ f~ jffi (I':j 'fl'tmiE " 'JljllJi- jM!;,!~ ro!" qr ~ ttH\[I ; if;J:\.l[fL'itl:' 1E;r ill) fiw'BftJijc~Jffili-~R' mu) r ff; ;i'\.± ~ J O(JB;fj ~ , J~ I-IJ Afr\f.\EfrJH (:~!'tiIJ~,W0 [l1 %~~!.!:~ ~ .. M1 lllki)(r9~ JlX 0. M~~~~~~~~~~~~rr~~#~? r. WrtR ~ J fi r~" &~ Jwr~~mti J~~ .ft~ ~). iJj f~j~( )(~lJfiIIt:J~~ftl!.(f~1jo/Jn ?. ( t1'i5iftHJtlf1 ~H~J£r.,9M\'i ). ( :H. r *cUtMll~ J fI9f1J'rW~ ~ ffl!FHHi t¥vrq ~F;i! [ll! n1 ll'Jr:#iN. ' " ~MMrt" ~~. W.. t)~o/j ~r[I {:I]':j iJ*{UJUll ~fflJil ' ~l ljJf:. rifi. 89 ~N tfh\". mlIMA .. fLn ~~Jl!i. 0. B9WtllT1' jUiliAf[QlA. nHH_HltiJ. r{,' t7l~ {~J *CJ~(:I'-J ~rh. 0. ~ ~ r ~ ~. ~ J~~ k ~~~. ~ ~$ ~~~~ ~ru~~~'~£llir.. II~H~H't1jijJixtllJ\~(ilCi1:L1'l,' l~\Vtmf'F blr:j:Ju'o)5l:#- " 3! nrjil~ r ijt {l~U 1iIl! .~ ft. W = * .fflm ~~, .~tI:l M ~ ~~ 0K ~r~ ~ 8 ~Jw~ ~n ~ ' ~M & ~J. '. ~ fliSl. A~ 4 ?I~ ,fa 3'~ 19fJ )l: {t -Er: illhi'J9!~f~. ' filli lt r l0l~tHrci J $ ilff r $ilf~J 1\tl :t {tU9*R*'L~. '. JfrIlliH·'! ( rJf; rtJ ' r ~J>u & r~ ~ J tM!i1;W 31 Jf:~W?J' *m rm{t§!J rtrl'0 r{.' W~ It§!J ~1m.U\]~~f~~? W n9 * 'm W 1'~ , j! 0. J. J±}i~$I;JJA r 1i\t~~ VftI iii ~ rttM~ IJ''.i*cJ"'kKi/. '. IT.~f~~ij[. 0. , t)l:Ht ~. tI:l «.gifdHrrQ~). fi r ~~~ ~~ J ~. Vfii ~m· ~ ~, ( k ~~ ~)~~W ~ . ~Mi'lfftaU. t 2 ~ ~' S . ~ .M;r~ ~ rm~ H ~J~ G~. ~~ 'M .~8~*. :. It ~ mT'! J - irttllif-t. ~~ is: 13- fflil 1J»:;l:(19 ~H4'q1!ft t~ , ~IJ i§ J ~ ;c. r m ftffHM~ J. r.H:'l-;JU ~\ '. f~. is: tr,l!. rm 9!MMi fr~ J. aJ'J- fifl. rJ}HUJ~!;t~ J. :jy) AA:r~. 0. ~r. r~ ?n;r\.f3li l:l~ J. ~. rrJ 1\ ITJi ~c ~ tl:\~ , mlli #!: iN. Jfi\li¥R rtlliJ. rn'Yl ~ tilH'J J. Rna B'~ ~ Vfif ~I~ It ' ,Hz mtIIlJ J. r~U'HiWit~ J ~ r ~am~'diJilJ J -=-~-)-Hl:;Ug - ~i'lUE. '. IfIi ~g, ;C~f1W0~t5 I~1jIWF fi1f. .. j1iJ. ft~~~~~,~~n~rt~.n~ m~ rm ~~8~ J~~~' ~ ~<~.. r M,\Pl fM~ J9~ B<J ~~ f~~ @ >r.f ]Jlj Ira m ~nH{~!:!5 JWJ I~I ~ f'ilj{'f ii'l1 ' ;@ ~ tilli jill 7 r ~r W rt~W J~ n. '~fi'm~&V M ~W**Wm~ .~ mm~~o. -fillMHiLt(I\)~r~qJi&w~tJ~:tJ:-. : ~fmY*l1lj~jJ(I"Jff{jli;tl!<\! i11Ji!: ' 0. 1: ' dO tt.~R It. *ffl~/filMI9UR. :f- '. 2 £19 {n]; , ~ ~lHL \1;: ttfl9 til] f'H'i j~ fiX. gs ~~ pic ~Q 0 1m alrn ~ rl',n:n~ > {glj ~D;t llfH-,'j! J'lj , /",lj:: e 7'\ +1Y t;£ ' f.MJ ~ r Jm 1'1'1 tlHfiJ!'? j;'i:J ( Ca I Art s )(I'J r.~ ~l . ~5l:i!l! iYItt ' ·f f£!:!e '~ { ~EHfq * $ il~ 'V-I!i!m ~~l fH]]I)fJ a~)7t ~!Jx "¥Jx S(, 'ili~ ·~{ t.: ~"f ~ (f'J ~IWJ~ jifq~UJnffi;L- , tH!l! m m ~IY0 !;;! ~~ It§!::k 1ft.j . iy r.1~ ( David Salle ) ' I~. -f-g'J ... " -t i!" (t>]1'F #)- I~ ) - ~ 1t r# ~i -1.,Ht'T J <tl: t.ji Ri7 -t '. ;f 11 ~ - iH'l1'F §J it : 1~ 1'F J'p Jt,;5?- J18 A "# ~t §J pM1-" 60 ~ ~~ ,. e,~~U~--#~HfJDhLJ!-§J t f.'#cHt67 :2 -tit1i 0. t~. rt ~. :. «f; /~ 4fT 17~ ». {i/lrtl: ' rnii£ < r !f-WJ rJJH{tMfJ J B"J~~~1-. !131~ M'\. -II;. r~1if~J. IJHC~1i~f~ U'0 rff;j:\ 3:~ taH~ J. J ff~ *€i :JH'I:E11 !#1 {f. ~:lH111#f-\: Riit&\, 1j!~ ~fi[rg~. IMl > )Up ,. , U=:1f(:I'·)II'tro' , tt tif 'i'I'[ J:iln~I~~~Attlt~/f. )l:Q~m ~~X~~ u W a ~ ~~~ M , ~ ~~m a. r*c $SHilHt5 J ii!/ ' -tl!srrdt T. - ~~ r~m At;r!i ~~ J H~f. m~ a~~~ M m · ~ ~' * ~ Q~ U«ft " ~M ) m.Mm~~m> )l: • ~filj{'~B''.i @ YfHl!fJM ' pq 'tf~f'HHrr .. M :r:\.J!.n12: ¥JlHI:IIMiI~~ " ~ lfif!f.1V[!f ~~. 60 .<g. M i. . r1LMIillHM !lI3 J W '. .. L~ f~ 'ct'l1 k ~{lc!ff i}(u Y.!!r.lz). ~Ij ~ tt ~!Q. *.w:wrm fYl. M~ m, ~ * ~.~~~~ g. ~m'ili . ~~~ ~ 8~ ~W ~ ~~ A.*o. ( rJ.fl. ~ . ~ Jw s ~rmK 8 ~J~~~ffili~~, ~.~~~~~ rm K.~ Ja. = r tnt. .. '® ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ - H~~A ~$ ~ ~~~fim.'~~: fi ~ W ::k. ~~~± ~~,~~ ~. 5~,tE<~tiOO~>$,~~~w~mg~~ ~. ~~ m~.E& ~.. i'lf ~ill~1",!; {t.:H~ ~ thill rI9 t% jfq~"(~ nrnH[lt!i:i1+[I~liftftlj. 0. ~~ J. ~'-iIi-;i~ r i~ ~ ;jlHJ J tf60 *jf~* JlA. mue. ' :¥t f:Ij{'vl!l:r:t81J k:tIW]/jnHt iE. ~~'~ RW~~Nffl m~~~~ ~ , aOO ~ U M ®tm~ .~ $ ~r ~~ ~. rit 1~ 1(. ~ JJUiUJ J fi0·(; f',f ~yt l't. it ' 1{) .u~ iGJffo: 1li ' 1m ~J,. rit {~ J BtJ ~G~ {.iQH Jl± ' ~{).~~~faJ r -fjY~$ ,g,-j,k J. ® 1f Iff1Y1\~~~ t£f!l!~ " tHM*<¥~fljf' 't)gc EI9{t£* f(fUL!tt ~~Vfii fIU. $ a1 ffllifVFf ~ Hj I'-'J : it!!{Ilfj ~fr. T tE f,~ }it l:j:! fi~ ;;-;L j} , -tl! m~ " flj ~" '1m it ~ ~ $ (n r;5 j JI! -Jt ;\~ 1~ fllI!lt~. ffiffir~ (.g~lrrr!ll ) EI\] !;~ f~Jfh\l~ fn ll!~h\. ~' ~Mr~«. ~ J~~#r ~~ J a. 0. n. f!~ » f){iiJ~ mn. *A7t@~~~m.,~~,*a k~ W~~* ~ ~~ ' ~0 «~ ~~ ~)~. ~~~$'~ .R~ .~m ~ ~m~m ~ ~mm, tlft ~** w ~tr m ~ k ~n {F;. MtQfrlIJJX1~ i!j:t al~ t!i V!tT'?a'(. . w;j( !~* f:IJ~EfrJ~ ~${k . !Ii[;\! ' LHH1J'~ rme J!Hililr~ J ffr &,.!~ a<] -~ '&I !~, <{liII fL r $§Ui{U B"J~cU ~ {fq>~*ii r *c;i{Htfnf,J J "'~.rfIff''.1y.7~'' ~illiiili ' !l! ~~?br~ l~J rt~d~J *c fr~!~Wi ~Ijt!!II\JEJ'.Jtj'LtL! ' J~ f:H il[f "~ tH~ Ja"hL ~r", ' *iliflIJ f\ C jl~ {t 1f fi.'U.... :fL fi .~~m.~s~,~r~~~ ~ • • J~~a ~~ o ~ ~~ . ( & ~~. .r ~ ~. ~ J ~.~u ~~ w~ ~ ~ ' m$~m Qm~ .~~r ~~rt .. 0. ~W ~.Mrr r ~~. VfiiJ~k'~~Ur~a~ ~ J~ ffl ~' r mm rtm ~ J. - n~O,I!I ~~ *~illijill. fill!JWi: f-1-[*f.ml it'l ~f1)O\)f~~:l!oiZ. <tB~lil~cU>Hlj~ffUc$fHlIi ~~(J\)1~{'Pt::t.HlH'~. WiJ. '1:1 '. oo ~~ .~ ~a~a r A~ M*~~'&~JlX ~~~~ ~ - ~~ . ~~¥ ffi ~. ~~Hq$lWti'lrI9gl;71* QfllWr4f fl~LA. tJ9if~li\i!:. 0. ~ ~ ~n·~~WID rt ~ ~M . ~rm~rt ~ ~ J. f ;). «EritijmH~» jIHf~i~. R~l~~(f rtt :t,if,6iH~ 4=' tl! !'iT ;ft IJH ~ if'!*rr&ll » !H fj~ r ~UW.AtMi~0 J ffiHtJ0'; 1±lEl&. rt' ffiu~ <m~~~r.~fi~J>$'@A~lli = ,,~r~ *, r ~~8. «tr if!~ f!11) if- )ifj U1J..1 #. : 1»'(11-,11 2002. . ~ s~. ~JI!t, ~f>t {I!'~ AI*J tE U(J~IJ1fx, CJTH~rl'tf-H~89 f1ljfl. 2 8 ~.JU .ID a I~ ' ~nM . ~m~*~ffl~~S@A ~ ~~ M ~~. ). a~.~.+~.~~.®~~.ili~W~.~? ~ I~il. 0. JflfilT F.!!It'fJ rpq{EJ5xJj~J. pq ~wIDrt~ ~~ O~ ~;L~' ( k A~M)~."~ ~~~ " ~ hliM ~'. mI :tfMi~ J ~ ~ iilli ~JijfITiE ~WUg. ~~.ft~~~~w~~?~~~~?p~* m?. ~rt(QM~m. ~ * u ~ ~r~ ~m~ J s~m , ~~ ~.mDft. .~~· M ~ ~~rt ~~ .~~~~'U &miliW "*OOW~~ rt~ ,m. (. ~'*~j~ Mti)C=f: [IJ'.i r ii\1 ~ t!HillTJ. !. Izg Jl:t< rlfU~ :;:\-tUJifMWJ ~{)fNJl!I!Y>. ·FJ1 jrWl! II\] (I'J fLf J1P. t-J[rill. 0. (~ A :mM »M ~# ~ ®m~n~M~~ "i1~A ~ " '~ .ffi ~ ~ ~ ~ ~. ?. r£~f~J tt!:Wfill jiPR fl9IABI;J ~ i(q 1UJl '. r ~u¥. , tI:l ll& ~ -Er'i'~! ~ f!rl-- r ~~ 1t J q:rH'·] ~e tu~ *In '1fi g! e ft!: ~~ {i§.! f'I:: i'r1r ,fa ~ fiICi JTJLtt rnMJ'{C! lm : I(ij /j~ ft ~ hMwr a~» t!lJ:I~ t-'FXtEQc uUU:mWHI(J ~IJ )!. rt.. * ~m~'~ /f£ •• V!tTm~~~ff D. 0. =**~M~'~0~ ~ ~~urM n. ~ J~ .Ii!il~MS~ ' ffi~ ~~. 7.

(6)

(7) ~~~ OO~t~~h. ~~~ff. mti ¥s/;J-~~Jt r* ~ ~ 'K~ J. R~J:l:l!ft~ ? ~Jt •. ~ ~~~.~ m$~ ,m~.~M&~7~~~~(m ~E M) · ~ag. ~ ~ M'A.~ Dm ·~ ~~ E~m~ ~~ .IDrt*~M~ . &.~m.om .~.~~M'A~ .~. m·~~W .m ID~,am.W~.$~ft~~~. gMom ~ ~.~ ~ ~'~~* *~ .*~.~7mRAreRmW .~ ~n ~. 0. * $ ftE "'tm" 81Yft1iJli • -. w "R ::t:e':J~j(q". ~m)f~~ f~*iltEJ(WTli!i ~f:lli~*·it§.~~~. *:!itmJ~. • @lAB/;JJi!~f:§!l1tg:W~ct~ . ,ffl. a•• ~.ft~ffi~®~~~B~~:*~~.,~Jt$~m. •. w. ' t)&~jillifflffifFnB1ilg -g ~iitlfJ4 * ~ 19891f ' ~ • ~ jijjjf1!! ~ j;fqlm~~A Daniel Wolf, Mike Weaver and Norman Ro s enthal= .A:t£~*B1rtiH~~j;fq-f:t 18391f¥!J 1989J (The Art of Photography 1839-1989) ~$' flHJBN r~?,Jt~ fHf? J ~@mtJJ Tf9IJ~;\l1l : 0. (-)~~~-.u ~~m~. (Heliograph). 0. f:tJtt ' • "'tm". ~ Illf [fd* ;&. ,. ~Jt.~r - *.~3g~tij;fq~w'YCHMLffi.m~ ¥@~ .J o~* .ffq. • ••~.~. 9. (Erwin Panofsky) ffim ' ~- fll!~~ ffi ~ ~!~Ii*. ' ~ ~M~r:5~i1'~nrr~!t&L' ;jfr'§'~ li rr/J\~~~S1 r~. ~I:IHij)j!3j;fq J. (daguerreotype) lfij j§ ff1J~11H't'l *B%~1m! ~~rjjjj~.~m;J;E-~ -·~~~.'~ . M~'tm~,~gm@l.~ - • • ~mm~.*7~~~ · $t ~~fO~WB~ rtiiJ¥tHij)j!3{iflfJ (Calotype) ~1&~~ffiC!z~ f:t~r(lif&' Ffffi S/;J "~:rclmJt " 10 ~f.[;! ~ ",!i1" 7 ' Mgfilfjt~Zf~Affi~jQJt}iH4 0. 0. 0. 1!l1HH4~~~ ~~$'J~~. , ~o/Jft :;iG~(f]nrtlli B~ jH'~ lmJt L ' 0. , t1~~!t&~.~n.lil'Jj;fq (photogravure) !iX.~~. 0. )lf3f~B/;Ji*,lfjxmf:t 1~ ~~. ,. ~f"tAJ!g. E.~*~~~nrt·~. ~ m~~sWm~n~·@lA~~W~~·M~~. m~.~~ft.Mm~~$~" • • rt~."~*,.~.~·emftm. f$$'J i'~Hf'*JtS1t8 :i'If~' ~~~IIHH~ffl~* /J\B/;J r*~n~J ,J;)&~~Jtf-t!ffi~. fi~ ~~fi~·~ .~. ~*~· Aft ~~~.R~Wh@l~~n~'*m~. ~. ~. ~rmR~.~tiJ'~&.RB~$,m~·~ . mmm2~. fILI~J!!t&fI}IM!A~HM2$. !&Wt£t:Ht~ft$B1~~. B/;J:9JJJJlmfHi 1l!~ mtffi'i ~ ~. 7. ,. jftgf$r~t>J~Jt~~{iflfl1~ Mi. 0. 0. :t£~'OOJtffim.~".~"~~~'~~ffle~gft ~. ••. *~~;~. ffl~~~~Jt.~M~M ~ • • ~'%.E~0m.~~~ § ~,~#~ j;fqj§~. !j\fnU iPhotography J. 0. (~)~~~-.m~~~m~w~m. ~H~~l±lft~~r ~ *~ffq*~J~* ill ~~ • .Aill~ ·xM*~. (William Henry Fox Talbot) 71;;~fl#~Jt !m af~ rf' jffit)lijUU~ ( ~) (nitrate of silver) 1.Mw7l:MH' ~ffi r7l:~~fBH'~J (photogenic drawing) f*ff~1@'tm lim a~nl±l o~ IDJ a~HfqB-9$~- @ ¥iJ 1839 1f ' ~ ffi ifijll9frjIH~ ~ (Sir John Herschel) t) photo fO graphy **~ "7I:S/;Jm ~" (light- writing) ~Wii ' M~~~~ff~~jjJPhotography , $~~'Jln~'!iX.fI 18341f '. ~~~±±{ffBM. (Lady Elizabeth Eastlake) ,. ' J!~~ ~ r 7I:*rt ~ aJ (optical. Tffi :@ -fift1tj§5!~~ rl'l'B/;J~gi3. '. 0. ~ ~~. ,. lw.Jtfll~~~ :il. g~'lli~~~.~~;~tr*.~~~~j;fqm~M~.$' .~ • • 1±l ~.H~lIf. J. 0. .~~ M.m~*B-9"M~tl"~a,jffi~~m.·~~&~7C.m.,~~. If! ff tl}Jft ~iHl~ ~ A ~JHJt ~ j(q ili! r.l. .j;fq*~,~.~Jt~~*1l!ftE~.~~ ,m~ ~.§~,U&~.~.~W. 0. ~7C&~W ~~ ~UMffi.~~ ~ .o~~~.~-~m~~Jt~ - ."~~. ~ ."5 'R~mrr~~M~~.$ml±lm~~.M'~A~~~~:m~~. 0. r~?-JtM:{tltt ?. 0. *~mWI.!l~~.ft.m.Q o ~~'~~~MRWm~~~ ~w~~-~~. J;it f"t.Ailif fttiill'~ f(J~~9;DM ~ f4~ 81;3l ~i)j; ~ltfjti!l~ft ' :7t~:tf ~ m. .~. Jt,mm ~ ~~ R~ ilitttt~.m~~ o oo~ooJtn~ • • ~~.~.~·.. ti·*m2~'*~~~.~~M~B~.'M g~ ~~$~m~7fi~ oH. ~.·M 8 .·m.~3~*~.,* •. ~L. i!3~~j(qll!Jj~M8~~:!1t$$. '. * ~ flJ f~*~ml :Jl! {tP PmU'0. ; IlPffefI:J~Ji!3~'~~ , ~~rr.li!.!Jl.Ih¥J1!JjHI~ rtJ/liJJfJJ -~ijj:t£$~fm~~ 7 !ljJ&llJfO. imtlf&m {:l ~%,[q(J.lli ;fi§J~ " wjJ~w'''. .~ o ~~~·~ • • ~~ft ti~ *'~~~MR~rfltiJ-~:t£R~L~. ~ ~. '@fiftr ~ Jt ~ ~:t£~*UHLffi.~~ftm ~ .J '.fi~~~~ ~o. • ftE5!M~Bm~~mm_,~~~. 0. 0. ~~~ .~ '.R ~ ~ili~~~ ~~ ~.~~ftB.· ~® ~IDrtml±l~g~. W~6U~.?,JtB/;J mfJ!. .. */J\.~mID~.E~~!!!'!J2-. , jffi~1li. 0. ' rr.!f.~JlB/;JliiC!z ~ 7~~$~~a~~m~~:!1t~a~~wo@.~m.ft • • ~W~ffqM' .fiOOJt~¥fi@lAM • • • ~*. o W~rr.~j;fqffiffi.&~~,m~A~ fflmfi~ffi • • !iX.~n~*~.~~~~~~H~OOJt'~M,m.~~~R '. ~Jtili Ji!:- fiMA~t ffi B/;J~5mt. 0. tnA)jiJj;fqB1~BA. ~M~ ~ m~, .~ ~ ~ :~Jt~~-fiA~I~.~~!iX..H.o. -fl "R:±~ifq" 18881fF~~~ rfiiJ~t§.J. (Kodak) & 19001f rtwllJtt§8J (Brownie) ,. ~ ~m~~W.·S~M~'~~~AAfi~0~W~~ . ~~°ftE~-H~. m~.'~~~RmRAft~~mW.~m~B-9*ft~mID~ o * 2 ~OO·.. J B1gt~~i:lf~:'l%~l1&~Y-~~mWNi (Beaumont Newhalll 86U'li : r~Jt~-tm:t{~ ~*~Afr~m9;Ji1 ' f.i!j€;7t~fOft~H~.~Y~fflJ 6 : ~ ~*. ~rlI . jlIif (Stephen Shore) tf.~tlil3*fi8{j:;&;J\ : -5M.?,Jt~zp.B/;J . ~~w.fOi'itrmB/;J 7 :!B-fIL~~~~:1Htl! . ¥*t.I~ (Pe ter Tuner) 8/;J1.!l!,-~~'J~ : r ~Jt~fl:)ft*~ . ~~rI'lHOMra' J 8 ~ , 1i~.mH:tfq*-* {(:!1ill~ (Vilem Flusser) rr ~ fiU~~fq&:,! ,£tfJf» $ffimI±lB/;Jti~ -=- fl~H~~f~$ : f4~ • ~!ztflfO. image ) B1&:,~f,*f* f&Aft~ft~fliHt - fl~fllJf'F~Wmm~ffqaljf'F~fqJ!~Jf1l: ~~ • f§tl~D : ili:f"t ~ ~!+}~'ti.'jtMIj . xf'JWT (Ainslie Ellis) 1l!~.~ : fI\li~~. ~o/Jftj:nrm. ~~'jffi~ - ~AfiA~~"~~~~~m~";~Jt~ ~~ ~·mA' lli~ ~I~f!t. ,. ,~5Hf~f1H~ LB/;J "W~Jt " x~~f$!*:!1t~ 1f(. rlw.JtffifllJ~~~~ ;!U!i j;fqili~~mjillU1. m~m~~·fI~ - ~,~~~* ~ ,~ft.M~AM~M'~"7I:"rrfl~ j;fq$81ftlit!3~~0~fi'fill:.ft~mm*8/;J?5if. 'Mf"t~m$. *=1:ts/;JW ~ *3.~,@. (=)~~~ -.tt~.~~M~~.Wm~~~. Mg. 0. 0. .,#m.~ • • ID~,*mLM~B~,~~~ft1MA~.j;fq * m o @~. ~~WM~~ffi.'ffWAWfi~~ffl~.* ~ . ~2 ~~~,*m@A~ill. Wft tj!~M~~~iJJftt§. ' ~.7 -W ~ *.~~ JJH'ft~fr5 ; fH:l ffi • M 0. R~~.ffqID~'**illili:~mfJ4.ffq~~Mo~Jtm~mRmtt~~~.~ rr . j;fqmOOL~~~,~jffi,ftEA.il • • ~Ii*~,mw~mw~~ - .% Af~HiB/;J*\1m. 0. II. @A~',5ftlfHI~W~Ct.~ .tiMm~~.~.*~m~*.'ili~~ ~ ~ft - ~~~~N'~~. 1),1; • ~~~B1~~MO M As/;J~Jt 1i1. (John Szarkowski ' 1999) ~*.A~fi-~ ~0~ .~ 2~gAA~~·~A~!&Jt&mnft' • • L'~ ~ ~ •• ~ fJ4~R B/;J~ iHl¥ ~Wd:. J}JijtB1liJf 3i: 0. 12. 0. - , "!/o/J". ~. fiX ftf.j. 18261f ' it;~~A ~~J1fr (H.N.Niepce ) ffiffi rB'Ui'iJ (camera obscura) , t):IQj i/\./j\B{j:U5JYC8ifrcil ' t~* ~ ~1R~m~~nrrM~7CHf4J-. ' t8f~ 7mWLJ5l.ff. 1999"fliJ=l ' ;%~[riiJga~~ ~ ~ m~lf6J ;iiJ.~1H ' j§!iX.[g+t\@lAJEt:fOf ' 7(~ffitft/t~~ R~~ IDs/;J~t ~ , 1l! ft 1mJf~B!]~cte 'Ili' f1!!/J\~ ~fIIJ~,n • • $~h~ttI±l3 • • m~~Jt'fIlm~.J!~~~RM* m A~~fi1JJffl8if. 0. 9.

(8)

(9) M ' ~~~ ~ M ~ ~~ ~ : r m ~ tt n~m~m~ ~~ J ' U m~A~ ~ 'M ~ IItH~. , Ilf£j l-j:lllfr i? J)l O~ f!~ (~ .. K~ *. ill) 51 %: 1~:Jn~j i-I ' • liT ~ , i)i 11 J!~ Jj- !itt 1-1 hl. ~ ~~m A ~ ~ · rrOO~A * ~~ m m ' .~~*~ W .&.r M A fflR ~~ . Wmg 'ill ~~~R~~" ~ ~ A~~ ~H rrW ~ W ~ ~ o ~noo~ , *~. A {lQ 1m it (iI!u;(. • lJXj r~fj~ ~~Ut 111 D'~ yt- p,;j A. ~~',l~ ml~~:;ft! PU!1J~;j~n~ ;m , MU7J~ tj( ~ , iAHEiHff(J~~~-U • IE! :(Cxlill ~~ 5I( ~'it~n':J U;'f f~r:p • jE~ -j!j! 41 u~*J ~I,":1Ii-1 ' a1t&~A 1r~ T M!JPE~O~ :m ').Hi:! IJ ffij 1969 'Cf: ' ~ - iJlH~)7t- * " tt[l l-!Hlf~ !iliJ>J( !KVI ' reJ~ :l1Jlt " f~ !~!~ n" jflJ~IJfM~ 0. < ~ * !U! flP'~U6»fSl iLlj 1Hn~..t 1Mt] ti\! l.ll.~. 0. 0. , ~~\~r *IIJ.'!l,~ , ~tri5111~U~H~Fw flH*. • ·.! I~IIj)({U;tB!P¥·t~ ~IHi > J!Wo'l-' JtJGQWrIWOOi-l'. ;HH~ n :Jt \'Il *,Q. t\' fm! A1l~6W~!P~ ~M! ~ ' W:& ~-( Edw ard S t e i chen)~!(tr.~ 1-J tZ&JHI!!A;Hflco~)r~~Ut. 0. :. r! ~-! K U':JflEGn ~ Wf.f.~ AWA'. J (1':JJlI1;l'J! , ff!:tLI !!fJ H~' lJIi~j-&')(JH~it; ~ ~ (Hl~:t~. ' IZSiJJt • tMm** . {*f;i,l liit:2 ( Lee Friedlander) ffi:! mU\ : !V-ti-l ;\f:. ' J{r:p u'~ "-I:=_ 'JE"'F#~~! ·,:r;~ A)N - (I&IDH~ (I'·) ~ctrJ. tH~ltiij""'~fll k~ AftiHJ['PH~(gIJT-*{i . A O'f.tnj nql~ ~ {~H~)Jct.t! ' lilt~JJmi );!j ("i*fH'j~?'!! • r~ ~t. l\f!{'f'(I~) ff'n. ~ ~ n ffl* ~ , ~n~ ~ ~ ~. ·~ AAW.ff ~mMAM~~ N~~hlnrto. . ' ~~ #~ R ' ~i-I£n hl R~ nft WillW~.~mA · ~ m R ~ ~ ' ~i-I. Tm :tjjJ it~ pJ tE ~/BJ fJtIMi~WJ -- M~H~U-HIJPx}gil1R [ljJf2;r,- Jfht. {£:E~ilhl'·)j~. 1m'. '. @{E'~~~l~ Z1 /K Htr:I H~ ;a~ (~,L M. M~:III '. . Jtf:A{IIIJUf i:L~~{;!W£I*. fl'~1itf1::r H fLA j)!H& ~'!( [liE.. '. '. JH& ' I3iBi! (fl'ltJa fI t.lnill WIIft8~)( ftlt l;t. : !¥.UnOllH>1 ill WJH~. 0. ~ JE1i~al'f 1'8m jJ ~f.C }]fl;[!rl:t , im[{b~jJti1~ -(f IiIiI A:sz{r.ff'iflillmHI'Ht ~- , I1!E-. r 1.!'t~H¥ ~ f,j J (Farm Security Administration) :(£ r ~i~ )(f~t-:rt J j\) r=: 4-J ~~f8 T H~5fl --:' -I -Li.ij~ 5!H~ (~ , ·i E M~E fr'J 'A: ~Uk!m*0i1!t'HJem ' tJ.~ jHIOt)itM ~Mt O'~. w-$nt~fl~~lpR~fM];!j vr~*:,}*tl tXntlili. :. 0. ( hpot o ·e ~say). R_xR3 f'n~' t))7i.S':J. 19S5~' ~t'2 ~ ' ,£:!~ 1'nHJWJ r J>l{-t~Hijf)g J. 1i'rt,. :I~*§ 68 11~1~ * 503 *w.{~. r- a~ ~.I ,* 3~ ~ ~k~M~ . ~A. ' A . ili~*~. tJ. rmti-lMnt J. .~ ~u. , ~~~~~k ~ M ~ ff~.~tt~J. § WF.S~tJ&~ it A ~JEU6fOj!;llil1'rH&\n'~ M ~J : « A~ft - ~O. JdQ ~~ W i 1l! IIJJ rifT ' ;\:fi l fa: ~.H;u:aHo ifH!1 f@1 1* ~:,'i {T T. '. 0. fr:tifi~ 1J~;t. *§. ?~ it!b. n~ffl · ~ r a~ *. ~ ~ J M. ~ ~M~h'~ Y ili ~~oo m.tt~mn ~. "*. tHt .f - *M !1!: fi ~ D'~ EH~ ~ }Jl Lf! " frnJ¥!Hi± ~~ tHllr L}~ PiC 1m JUiH~ . JJ) yilJ (Roger de Grey ) f:£ J~ {~A !lJ!1MR t±l : jJ1i ~j tIOP:;l).t r.~ jt(J'~*nl 4=J (mechanical sketchbook ) : - lilltti Vlii * ~EH£U: Fl r.~/hWlf6'j(,\Helj!fIi1UcnU~) Jc '~ flftiR1i-:rt · J:~~AEI()~nuili~dnf -- ff~* -UHcs(J i:HJ:i ' ti1Jili - -I~ JtJ~ {-t §r~J!ll\{jl 0. r:n ,jiHU n R~O~J'IJ:t. ~fljljl,(4J -,' ~ - ~-U;J All r~ -liPJl. 1i T-UI~:f!.IlQ:. z l& . \~r*-HHUm. '. 183 9"LHJH'0J~ llHI'~~ ~ij;l1f ~. nl'·J!rl$ ~J :. r .. ·· .. ill i@!f.!;\J-\· , ~fr¥D~II~t. Bi • t: fiJi it ~'r- _\JJ b'iHntl\J;\;1 , 'Hi l1f.t~E ii5 1 PU1ftE ltt {D ~re }J£ (JH -IIQ];iiHJ~ J A " J:~Zltt;t ll6j~t~ I~ II·fJt.!I*J#flJ,i~~O fl}#M il~ , m!1~JtF~ "t!tWZ~ " : -WH·i 0. I&M/jjfJ1t'! t!tj'f(I'·) il nnc$!k J!f;lJt tIJ Hi ltUt N fHI~f'l! 2 ' fJEfJe!l?i-I)11F.\ifftt0H ~? ' !lx~ ~r.J 4~ ~l:!~Hf;m flI ~H'~lWJ(I'T'~¥l! I f! Ul?Z ' 'bli ft~i~,)( Wljj -. I~ 1'f jl} J),,!" II~ , fIIJ ~ Jili A5:\ - -{ill iffi j! m}~. ~'i~ Wi~ [liLU-H ' Ki~ itt- iTIr ftIH't 0. liJ f lt:D~ill '!1! ~ f'f. 0. illW~~[~{n TI ~ . m~ ~n ~iliMo. • 1!,l mm~ Mi. { ~ fl~fit[.~H i. • f:n mmj [{lj iTii ~ ~r.H!J. • wr~Ut. Ir¥i~~rY1J fIJ - f~ --!f.UJ ftE. ~~ 8 L~~n,~~n ~ A~ ~ ~W ' * ~ T -. A~~W · ~ ~ ~.~ lli~ n.H~! ttl n& ~..1 D~ )ttt ' * ll t o~[tl[ ~. 0. B~M ~ ~m~~~~*~~F ' illMA~®~* ft ~~ M ,~m~ U R ~ m F~J:(J'·) IillHl!. 0. ~ -;J~ ~4l! Mi. • f~U~ . *NHPiit£fS. tib.Jm~~~!J~i-I*~ IFVJ A Ii ~ - friW~ , 1:111. ,.. {E!,!:E: , tt1R ~ lH~A ITIT ~". « A 1!l - ~O ~ ftl!f1'H1!A ~ Hqf)gB'~. , f~ t:; {{ ~!H'.H' 'r I:: i:j:l itL= f- 15HTF ~ !irJilll i.+. m~ ~ff ~ ~~~~ ~W ~ A·m ~r:p* ~~ ~~ ~~W H ~hl~ * ~ ~ ~a Y~' dfl t ~.* m~ ~ m ww~ ·. ~lU~~IY-J~1-\(;~ Ii j ij: ft U~ ILEi Ril fIE E *~U-. dj , i';l1 f& TIiil )JI_11J ~ j;}j fg~ (I~ :f:: 1m • ,\c~ .?ii fllJ t'l { )( {UM~~~ l~mH~ 1!I.'I r:pB'0~1 ~ ~·ft~ ,-; I ~iil'l~:(£ 1!: 1*1Hii i~ , ~ -ffU~I!ibIl-~ , -t ~. :h'. n'. , ht }j fffl ili**tt!ltJi!~fiQ~ 1HK~Jt :i ;&U'·) FI ~11 ' ~t] ~i~J~t ' *IH*J!~ Fh1tiN!O~i'=Tl&IJ;1 ;t , ~- ill! ~13J,jf~ txNlj , ~l t tr ' :sz {r.:& Iii ~ 8~:SZ 1M ' :;Jut:(£ r yit !tHl5 ;;~ J r:p m@ JSdl~ ~ I~ ~~ ~itl • w: J:E: ~ .y !}W& Th~ ~ 1H§ I$M : *~ ~ t. · H ~ f~Afl~UiTI*IJ :;:E fLl J!TI ~J.!8z)IKl iHlJ ' !tortt- %: ' L~ f~hVL ~O ~ ~ f;'j If: IjH$ 89 ·ttll )) U_t}~. h't\ ~VJ ~ I HIO'~m~ 1ilffi rtot~ Jej!2illll~f ' A Jt,,u® tILl f&t~ Il*Mftf fn In] ftfflll: . IJ~J ~tJ tm m3 ' fffifjJUmWHI~ ,HtXtt!I~Jf~f(ii ft,L r~.?'i-I JfPJU sf.JfTfi'.}!1ft ' iE =. ":' tl:- I~H J1I1~nJlR") r W;\hf!l~ J 11ij;~nt ~ J1l'i~ rl~:SZfr. ' fIJj\/) lf fUiJ ~ If ""5J~ ~JTBf.J;;!J (~fxf~~" (renewable image-technology) &r.-hl ftf l'rfflt&Ji!H fiTI fl:'trrit'l lmB~*1'1. ~~U~~~jI'8W¥; V ~ ~A® ~ · ~~.~M ~ - m ~ ~J:~~~~ , . m~~ ~ ~~m~. -!M:~ ·lt'ifllrr!l!lJ~=fjfii.\f,\lu'~WlJt. 0. fJij~o : -JH8\fJ:if!!u':JK~MT '. [I'llH;¥- g cA1J. « oo~ ·- m W ~ ~~ ~*fl~a ~~~:~~~~~ ~~~~~~~ , - ~ ir W4 .Q-~ -~II ," J ~HN. '. ':~ --IJHf.~ fimhlUlll& -H\\l~. 0. 0. m OOfim*nt~ - .~ ~mm fttl ~Nm·~~ ~~. mrm.J. r. (si mul ation) 'fbi' JWrM1 z:l AA~it IIJJ/iitilifl¥rll ' II:l ji J,'t,lHtr Jt rpO'~fUl:m " Imo ' ~ fft1!t7.1 (simulacrum ).:e ~J {~fJrL"t M fJt~ nMJ! ffMiJ.ffi!rt ' jtJYI. trWj1JJ~~Q']!JlI~~ , ~ ~ - M ff~0 n ~ ~W~ ~nW~ o ~~'ili~jE~~~M~ m W~~ ~~. tJi '. ~(1j FUI~ rr(~nu~tJrf4rH~ ift!iX i& J~Uf~rt tg-JfHi. Ulf>1 l1Ef]II:'Htr:p , ~. '. ffij~ ;W;t :tf{I ~ I~. )dii'lf.t m~O~t\~llifijH>1~T-T1~S~ !i4ft FJe*l. '. , l<'WlH. - Ti'-HJH~~ IINJf':l. ~~~Mm ~ ~illW W' ~~~~M,m~·~ ~ ~*~"~@~"g. :tdl& lfiE jJ fHl\! d37t:'~,!. ' fr. q~rfTm~~t±lB~ rS;U"~ J tttW o;!£.?ii ' fJlJtA&;' ~!~ lm ~a ffl '~ ~ f~ 7f~ N hl :!.tum If,ij g~ Ff w[ , E t2 a; ~ a(J~ m "a:& n O'·)~VJ f.~r 0. IJ\. {frj. 0. J\'. mm. m,~~tt *Q ~ L ~ ~WW m mm~ ~ 1t ' ~ffi m~A~~H ~~~ ~~ '. ~ ~ ~ ~~ . · ffi~~'~~~~Mti*~~~~~ § ~" ~~~ ~ M"~ m. 1905 'rf ~Bl ( 1~ ~( !iliJ!TI fft~> rr~1A t±lW1lYJ~ rm lIJ 'fix- ;\;I lllli ~!Wtt. 0. «A~ri - ~(} " rn ~i'I " AJi!l :sz {to'~f'fit;. ~m~:±1HHt-.Hjc~WfNi~n~. jt\ r ~ ~ru fM l;/HILi J. , *JlfiX - H~1. (The Family of Man) o ~}( JL~ r.t tlllif,1l/JtiE : ';jH~l A:sz t:m ' A'118~ i';i IH(( i~ ff Hi hlTl¥i ~ R ~ITl ' AfO r;1c u~$: A' *rl Afl-I}~ 8~ ,e.: ~~ tl"l -:.1f t12 UJ 1-:1- 51 ::9.= B~ ;J[) 71 1 ;1,1rtt • 7f~ [I'll :sz f U 1l~{ 8f.J A fr~ , ~I; ~HJ LI:l'~. ' I f'f ' tit ~ frWtc~~ ;;tJ 5} JJ.i 1M If -k!;l ~ 'd: 1k M~~ liffi iii EB ~Iil i-I n'T ~tIi ~I ft.l (mH1 ' ti illi-=;x:;le i~Ht* if: A ~Jj.frl/l: no 0%'\ .c} .~J i).'~ 1111. ~~~nmM~ W~ H'fflm K~ ~A~ o. 0. InJ ~ \'I'I.'1. *it IT ~ ~~ ~~~~~a o ~ ~ ~ ~* %:~~ m ~~fflU'~8*@ . $ ~. ¥* ~~Q~~~ill~o~~:(£ rR ~ 8 ~Jr:pMm~ ~ma~: ~ m~~ w. 1:::'. A h!&JI~.:L f?ZtH thiX~T~{t. Ii,. 0. . ~ ~~ -ffi lli~ &g~~~m · oo~~ ~~ ro . flfi m U illW~ - M W . ft. I~J. 0. fa'imt k 0 r&IY-JnA. r}!~f~~JiI~ Ii[Lj J ~l![lJltf ,L-JE~llfi. t1 ];!j ~-dt!~:1J. 0. .k 1~ {E ri} - ;x 11.!: W*~~xliJ , Rnfr!!~ .ktJt -!: J-( iI~ ;J+Iij""'.I&.\ 1~rfIJ ' fQ i)l fi (f. a~rffi.U~W. ~~JlIViHR. ri fi 11& ~ 5HiVJilWI f t!H~ fJt {~ A ),.J) ~ p~ -I:: ~ li!XI * fll m~?, i-I"* ifH i If!.! ifl .:L ~~ E fH§ I;:tu~,tf.~~ fl~t!111!1! :(£ ~:t~ * W ' if'.:lI{'flll! fHW.1Jt u'~(glj fQ); ~ 'i-l\ "5J J! • ~ ~. "~~. ooo ~~m rr ~ ~ ~ ~ U ~,tl ~ * ~ w m ~r~~~m ~m Qtt,. 0. f}n~Af.tmJ ~a~);~ (~t!tW~f$J11 fijT ·m ~ I:H:WTfl~ J!~ut. ;~:i lSi 8%)(, R. 0. :!r1Y}- {,H1Hllili ";iar'. (n~. M m m, ~~ .~ w ~oo~. m m M m,m .~ft~ & MM ~ t±l°. ~~3 Mm ~~ ~ *,~~,~*~~~*. tl ~ '~~ ~ ~ Rm ~ R A. Bg I-L J=".' 1 h~ Itm U1: IU rY,-t "n n iE /\.rJl ~J.8 U-l WJ ~ EA E~ OO~~ ~ ~ •. •. ,,0=:. '!'f.t' Yo].f1:, " ~ J;=l. .A ~'(. · itt - m~~tt ~tlm ~~ ~~ ~~ '~ - ~. fl H IJ&~11]B']2.7~. , NfIJi1AfIB1A M i;i1dl':JI~;jj~. m l?1)lm~~{J:J.U;J. 1~ ~ H~ Q ~JSZj'm.llY,f~ mJ. ,. f..%IH~ ~ VN !i'~ 'j!1lR~ gB )} {I!t !l'1 'rrA9 i!~ U~ III ;f:i\l ~ " mLG ~1t (IZJ )U4H~Hl~ ". ' ~ ~~f!ilLr. '. n 1/i J;¥j (~)7i.~~fU. R[Jf~ltlH . it JJlI (Peter Tuner) iV.!. (theart ofreal l I - °fE[ 1} tLt !!~J ',Mffi 0. *@1: "«'!1'f. , ~ !(tHI'~Ml.e.". 'fjHF+fm\);~}& (~. ~rrffl?m.M e ff" 8~ W fJt"~ft~o"5Jn '~W~ Q .~i:L*,~ m~. A ~ 1!!~ W~ Il'JIit ~Hn 11 fir! ' mjnJ II.'t ili.rtf: A f'ji fL1jg~ (g~ o() !l1 VI ~! Y.J fix lUI 'Iili:J-i; fiJT 1-1 $L(lJMti1 fDltlNE, re~~~ u1 1UI~ ijfUml(tiWElH-!t(1 0. II.

(10)

(11) 11. 1!',\4 (~ ):t r0 (~ J (photographic image) 11 'i}; ~ efJJi;i;eJ.~ :I-e - .oo ~rilJ;JJj~ ~ !l! B'~ ~f/JU~ 16 US?t;, John Berger) '},.JJlt::.~~jQ f ·n~ "J£ttHI1 !!lft'" * -M' f-t)j~ !lfI !fret 1;r; tlfl'H1i ill U ax 1i!ti1i!'~ ~ J: ~ ~ ftJ fF.jj,~ , tr: ~ vltj ~ m~~] W ;l r:p Wf.~ tl:l*tlil' ' B']~fJE(l1! !HFci,UOj~J:~) !Q ( U demateriali z eqO)r--tmf;tft wnm ' tEti. • '8~ -fi i~HU:!H~ ' f<] fw~IIl T~ " ) t7;1/f': M • Rl;rlJ~ ru Iillill § J3t ~(U3. f-U~ § 2. iffi ~ lilf lf.J • ~ ~ ;!:2 §j l~o"JfJ:tjjHD a1,* ; f -Wrf{ Ef!. ~1*' (Constantin Castoriadis ) [;e~ • ~1E(),:)~ Uliffi'l JE ~~- ~jjffHi • '881~ffi y.!!fllf:'~*if;IU!H~ ~ lll)J ii1 &f~ W:lo ; ~:fi A 1H1i ~ vrq. ~ 'W~~IJ r.rU5}~L(I'J*C7crp. ~ - .ffl* ~ ~mA a ~~~ ~~ · . vrq * ~ . arr0 Wm ®~~.~~(~. ft *Da ~~~$ * · ~ ffjj'~~ffi~~~.in~~~m~ - @~~~M' ~. ~*. ~~~~ 7 W~ m atl:l~ 8 ~~~~ o. 0. 0. , ~ tt f.f ~Ht. 'JlI~(ll ft~~. • 1~; f-ttzo ~~ PJT J~Rg"~. cr ~ ~" ili~R~~ m ~~.~EDili~~· A . ~~~ . B~ B~ ~m ft. ~fX: ~~ ~~ !1-~*:i1HT ;1'P 1IHtHfllftj. (Michele. . Val erio Adami). 0. ~s~ ~m ~ ~w ~'~~:.~ffi~~~~m.~~~ ~o R~'.~. D. DCl11oulin ){:E r~. J-_~1IE !? ~~B'~;\RU;ill1ffi)jffJI f ~ fjfq'.~01 ~@ 1~E. 0. ~PHII. . :,tdW1'± «aiIDtiti!3» (On Photography) rt1PJT -g • tJ:l:..t6t*i~.@ f.tIY'J~ '/l?l • l~~ 1M~~1iXilf~ ~~ 8':J !m H~~l.:JJ~A ' ~ 17q~('F~alffl{,' l¥.fJtlwj ii ftl l6I~a':J ~ !\\~PJrr .I-. }.E - fl!~HWi'lWlFfrJ 1!lt1ll~ [11f1:~~ , !M!1iUli *Ml olfiJ~tttE* § :It~~*Df'f'il 0. ~'~ .~~MmS W~ - ~~~ ~ m ·~ ~ ~ - w ~ m.~?~~~Affi~. , }j;H~ !e ~t~.trt(11 ~rI5lfr~ fl~)111 ~ - ~ ,. jJ11±l*8Z]Kn15 '~ ~. 17. • ~ r,ifU ~5NtltW {'lfJJl 811Jrt ' !¥Vfql$('f'. ~~ !wjt trm4 )(ft!:\J(I"J Mi ~:rj]tj~. WU' D. ~ ~.m .'ffi . ~fim~~ ~ ~W· ft W ~ . ~ WA '~ ~W~. xfifil . i!!J± JJlm (Ellen Dissanayake) ~ {E UHI!i ~ ~~nijj:, ?» ( What is Art For'i) - 11ql ~J~i~f~!1I:e~lf~ n::?1 ' 'Ei,1i5 : -;flMD~B El W ~~M tE/j~ *lIt~liJ\: i~ : -fill2.7!Jl(t)~IJ ifi ; -;f!lHN~fUD ~ Mii1B']I~m tw ; - fmf.f ~\ !\f; , ~~. - till m * ~fH;~Wi~f!i fjfq. m,~~,~~ * . ~.~; - g Vm.~~~~ ~ ff ; - ~~~ m ~ ~ ~&. ~ Fd']~ p.~. ~ = ~ OO·~~~7 ~ m mW~~ ~& ~ ~ . ~~~~n·ili- ~ . ~ A~~. ~ ~ * ~;- mf.f #~ * ~~~~; - .~ ~; - M UA. ~~ .U ' ~W ~~~ a ~ ~~~·~ fi OO~~R~ ~. ' ~. ID~mW.)(. 1=ifu~R':J r;S!llJJ. n!ft m~. , ilrl *i hl ~ ' f~Hili~# ffifJl\\i! B9I;~~ (%\)(ft. ~ EbIfl1 I!l.'VlfT iffilJX: (J9. 1)( ftrr;(~J r.M:H!'. f?!{iJ ~fr ~~. (image culture) r.\~:m ; ili8.X , 'itt 11!ii ~ ~fi1r;u1 1li}1~mll'niJ. ~ID ~. ~·ti~Amm~~ ~ ~hoo~~~~~?"~~~loTW~~~ trrl}]~w':J~t ~ :& )(1t%Jf!:!~)r}. • ~fifli'111~}1nlj~J\::. ; -H~f{ 8 f;lHll(iliAB15mfU'F ffl ¥. -F 91J ~ Jj~ JJJ~~. : jlii ~. ' ~J~ , ~ ft!z~~i]if4 (J;'Jftfi. ~~,~ ~. vrq~ ~ ~~,.w ~ ~. •• ~;-. fi §~. EE Jtt~ t)*%t~ t±l!Hfi( :'f ' Whf,)t' ~cJ*' iEl!Q ' 1'H !l1n 81 02 1. • • ,m•• ~ * m,mm~••• ~~. 0. ~=ftlJ. • , I);]Jtt '. f:ffllJ5f!,lltr.llft8':J~ tUfl ffi5U~:JiI;!iiIffl9Xf;~. 0. , BJ! @j -F'r(,W ~~ 1i!'Li~U7~(lg rViHR. 0. N'i-~~!:H~ rp. J! . - fill ~r: 14.t}! , i~nij B9 ~ Vftiwg ~'Ilif '. ~~ a tE,® ~mM~~ g ~~ n tr o. .fifli. ~ ~ ~~ ffl . ~~ . '.~~U.~~~.~·~MM~ ~~~~. ~ ' ~M@ ~ • • ~ ~ ~ - .m~~~ * o~.8~~~~~ rr ~w*~~~ .'ili~Qm~n~~ ~ ~m.·~ * ~~-~&M'~W~~~~ .g lli~ EHJtt~ 5i. '. l.)T7f: tI4JjX:~ VfijH~~~ ~ B':J'ilJfj~jftdil!.. 0. 1:Jtii '. P-I~wtt~z r~. .H~~rp~"~a " m~m' S ~~B~ *~ n~~~ ~° if! ~. ~' ~.~'8WID'f!:!'U~, a ~ ~ mQ1f}rt.~~r*ffl~~J-~· ~ ~.. (Joshua C. Taylor ) '". 0. ~DJtt-*. '. .. til1i;?j~IH'Frp. , 1:: N!lt(I':J~~1~. ~.m~~~~~.m·m~~' ~~' ~ ~~ in~.~~~:R~'8 ~fi . ~ *~. 0. ,. A rr 01:if 1Iil' f.t ~ fjfq filll1i,!\ a'~ ~1i -L' * ~ 1£ rp ~i:. tlff:: a':J 1 ~ in ji if! ~ f!:! t~!~ ~~ fili ~U~1f}rt fi-~!;): ":if01" ' ;M~B':J ~ fjfq~izJ*~,iIl -g , ~ fIii 0. m ~ ~@g~~AW~~rp'ili ~ $T.:lt naa ~oili~~,~ a ~~rp~ A~mW,mtt~.*~ :It ®~1f}rt~~~.~D. ~.~ F1 ~ B''1~ffq llHW fififli*rrmITm ~m~~ ~rp,~m@A%~~1Jrt~gmeU'~~ w. m l:l3~Jf;~ #- t~. , ~illJrii!~9XtilJiID ' ~WtlffU&8Iri;?,.~-~ttID *n* ~ ~B':J~!;J~ ~ ~ 1~ li~] , ~ Wi 1m r~ IiollflJJ:tili lit ff;:It ~ ;J~H-b 1~ , UfI :ff ~Jli rn Mm:tijE ~ IiEfl ft!.! A 11: i: . ~ffjj p7U:.~~~ • !Iift~t!5fjf(iBl(t'1fffiitI:1i~;1~t±l (Bill Mitchell ) 12 , if!!1!ii~rpB9 0. 8 Vfiitt ~ ~m ~~.u ~~ 'in ~ ~ - M @~~ti88~~m~~~;w ~ .. gl5IDl~irq. 0. :~Ni D1,[I, ~. .. ~ ~ ~ fll:: ffi :ldiiHit. 8g~iffi~J. Vfii A: 1dno "AiiJ ~" f'l ~m ' f(ri .El- W: ~ fiJ 1ft ~ ~ Wi J ':t ~MElf1Z ~ J'i - fiJl "~F~!;J"u':JMr~ff~~ flnf~~DJtt ' J:!iX1HI1 ~ 1~q~lU31J1JJM. itiP1i ?,!iU.ilp:.t(tJUi rfijtB ' El ffi FJ ~ 81 tli VtiJ IJ)UitJ 9.t ti .ft ' in lEI ~t ")( ft" - ~ilJl5[ I(jut "~i fjfq" If! ~~ m;ill A ~n illW BIJj§~iJJ • ffjjff£Wi r~ Bg f~ Ii*~ r~~ ~)(ftJ -f;iiJlf.J~ :h! /nIVf!)7x1iJ~. m - M~m *i ~~,m~~w~·~um~W~~Q~~~~~~~ · . m ~. 0. (content). m~~.'~EE~~~rt ~ ~~~R.·~® ~~~m .~~~@ttmM~~. ~W ~~~%SH *@ ~~~ ~ ' M.R .,m g ~ ft ffl IR '@~~ . tlllffl tlll 'I~:B'W!H}. 1~ *i . W~~~~ (k U ) W~rttt ~ ~~~ ~ ~Ilif·:t8~Em)(*. ~~~*'ffMffi~~.W,mtl ft" '011E.Wm~~mAm.*m ~ '8. 0. 'II '. ~~~~·-H ~~ iliHtt~ - @~m~mA~ o fi~,.mxJt!T ¥ m~:. N~ffl~~IW~·~~:fi~,.gA'8. 0. ~~J:tE8~1~jttmfnJ ?. -,. ~. (tJ(x*,* ) ;t§!lHili' 1~~rJit~vrqJ ~IJ~ - fill[i\Ji~B':J. 0. • f'f' 6b:±: -9li tE ~:>1< ~ ~ tt8g £' ijUAi,@ , - H fj~'if! Wi~ IiEfl- M!;): 11 8':J li , m: ~HII @~t-frZ]~9; ; f;lf ttfM ft B':J 143H=t ~~a:s'L' ~ lHilll}] • ~ ffq~ ~':Ui ~DJttal. 1. ~$~ . vrq~m ~ ~ m •. ~;a ~ I'f~ - filL~, ~J:! I. ~~ o ~m~ . vrq~ffiU~ffjj~~·~ ~~ m~~ a~ ~~*m~ - .~;~. ~~.~'fi atl ~~~~~~ . ~W o. ~ f-rjf)(A ~ fll ~~~=F- rp. ~j'i " ffHHJ~" ~Htr :iill l.p * ~. 1ti l.l'Et ti Jtli Vfij it mfMt ~ ~JU~, at) ~J It;¥ , t f ~..t ili ~iEfl llaHN ~ (J'~mI Wfi'iJ. ~ *fi ~W~ft~m~ft o ~vrq~~~if!&~W*W~~g~'~ffl:&~0' inrrW ~~ *A m ~~ .· @ [email protected] .Vfii~ ~~ m~W ) ' ll~~T®A ~n¥f'F ~ ~l(q ~~I B'J~H~. . ~ ~~ ~~ a. j:,~~~1Joo,~~:m@Am ft ~.w~~~.f'l. ~; "~~a~~~~M . ;EE ~~ ffi.~~ ~m~ ~: * ft'm.'B~m ~.~~ R~o ~~~n,mffi~~~WM~tt~~~. ~ . 'ili~m~fi~. rp~~~~~~ . ~ hlo ~~~~~I*m~ w J~u*ga:s.~ * ~ W~A M,~~'m~'9X~rt.W~@~·if!ti. ~ a ~ ~ ~ tttt ~. m~~~.. ' ffjjH;ff~WFiflll~~EH% k~~~k ' am, f.I; ~- , (gfm ' lij1~ , )( ft ~ ~ ff€ ~.Bl a}f lJ:'PYl ~ ff41 ffjj ~ ~, "tiUHN~" ffiA ~ H\1 F'I- q:1 81 11HJl ~ t$EXm±fl'fJlf{x~J-.. 0. ~J. 0. ·®~em~~ ~ ~~~~ ~~ a~~I~~o. ~ lfci &I ':PB':J~ fI tt: 'iU>l~ W~- fl1Hl\~ litt ~~D1~. ~*:;lF 't?; ~~ fil1~ ~*fJ[!lX,1;'/J~ 1i (\QJAi'i3ti'fU':J ~ TJ. '. Bg I-L K-::xlJ.t. '7 ~ W,{w rfu AI;: ? ,Iu"n HJ IIIJ~ •. ~ ~IJtiR~)r}~~1f}~t5t. 2. *A~~I.ID.\~JiJT~ff4Et>rgIiEZ~. .~ . ~S· ~ a~ Mmm ~ mm A~S · ffiU'8~~~ ~ - .ff ~m0~. fi.*~'.U'm~'.M,~tl * m , w~ ~ ~ & ·~&MA ~ ~~~~. 131J1'f' fj DrpB'~~fjfq~~ 'l;nIijB9 1f:K:§.J1 • 1IJIt~ ' 1I!~ &x g;H~ , 1§-Nifi~ ~ I~ £' fJ'~ WIJ i?1l ' iffi ® i~ ~ 'L' fm ' %J tXi£ J5Z },1mff tj - fill ~ 1{~ AAt ~ lilIUIl ~ :fn~ 'iHO 1: 1fn • ffi~ ~ ;f<J. cI3 ~ 1(q*tQ ~ U1+~fUD!~'tj!i~Ar&-;1-ij~.Jf; l~lJtt • tJi1~;* ftt1~. (J'~ f,IJiffi Ht1. *~ N, ~ *& vrq~W ~~.5 ~M *7 ~¥ ~ W # ~~® m ~ tt ~fia,~. .~W.~:&IDrt~.m·.ml ~ ~~ ~fi Vfii W. ~~~~ o .~ 8 ~~ID. ~m~ - ~ MM~~~ * ~·m~ffi~~·· ~~~~ "~ ~D ~~ m~rt ~ .. rt,~mUM~Ma:s&ffl~~~* , ~~ ~~~ &.~·~~:~~a~,.. ttX • 1(jj~ fl~rA)(fUr1(lliitI1 11j1f:. f!:! '. 0 M~ ·- ~m~ - ~ft W R . ~ ~ OO·~ m. U g ~~ID~~ ~ ~~ti~m. iillli.H UJl .. :!'l; cl:t Mi Wa~j.fiiRl~lt~t~fSiWi. '. )JtlLglJlr>J l!J~ li. 0. 1*IJtt • f!n(IHHLA ~~1 '. (Nelson Goodman). r1T ~ :. :'i'l(~(ll!;fl: Zc. l ~ ffcid-b rr M~. TflffM. '. , 191J .!l.J W1H5Hn}]~~ 1< J ~~n1!l!~!!\Wi !J2** rIIHrixJt!T ¥ (E rwi n Panofsky ) In ri': 1!¥ ~rJil.JH[lt.{q~ 1(q[i})~(11 Px,'ib ' J 1:J(IJtt ' ~ Wi &h ~ - ft] 71~ HIi~. Q. .. ~m ~ M ¥ ~ ~ m~fiVfii~~ ~ *~ ~ ~:1f}~ '~ .'m~3 · *~m ~tl ~ (Michale 1. Parsons) ~IJ 1~ 1~y::'~;J}~ JJlIHHtr H:llf~ , F,;g ~ ~ Vfij ~% * § :. 0. 0. 0. n~B':J I m f~J ~~ ()i( i~z ' m~ , *}t-=f flHlH ~) "~ \ 1f} rt " 7c~~. 0. ffjj "*. 13.

(12)

(13) ID:c\ ... ~~~ ii ~@I!j \ Jf; AtIl IL t~Wf*Bl ~ ~ lj ({9Ij ~D. : !J!~, , &ru. ' ~Ht ~). fO~. ~ * ( ffl~m ~) ° fifi m~M m'*TM~K~rea~~~B~~.~~' ~m ~ft'8 ~~ ff ~ ffl~'*~~~~~~fflB~~m~.~§~m~·. ~ ~ ~. 1tr1ltl~8~J. 5f7 ~¥. !PM. :. ( ~ )~ ~flM~~&~;~~ r ft~BWiJ~r~tt~. ~J; (E )ti~W'~~~~~'~&±~~~ • • ~M~:R1trm~. rfJtf~tI'jJ ~~*¥ r~Jtf~J. IJi. .~J. r~ ~tH.R. .:t)jU. ' r.rl.lt'BRJ *0. •. rl'JH~ ~ f~qJ. S9HUfIfWi U[n] aiffu. ~~0 ~ M»~'ffl~ : ~mfflJ1X~'M~~~(.~ ' ~R ) '~ ~* ~ ~ o ~ft;:L*'~1£~~~~~,~m~,m~,~~·gm, ~ ~,*m. ~ J~t!H!II ~ vrLT ~ ~fT'ft~t. *~too~. +Ir.H ~. /~ 1f!. ;1'1=1 liRa. i-t 5 ~ J. ~+ m~rffl~8WiJft ~. ~~~ ~ :~@ 8 WiOO~fi ~ . ~ ~.M " D Wi OO Jt"tzulfYl'F *ff!j \ ~ r:prMai~B%7~~l!. '. + 1I4f(~ f~~*13 ~Bl~. ,*&1rutHJifr~;DHtJilt5·. (Ad Reinhardt). 27. fMm;~ -.:.. l-m*c:fJJWl '. J;) r~r¥~. ~±WT~ ~~?;( !lJJII. .. ~~.'Q". (Diana Crane). il?'J~. : - 1~ ~Nfq :UE ~~*;j;'c{. ~.rM.J~U~'~(.~.~W~ H ~*ftWM~,~m~ lfi ~~. ~PX* ' IlIj>E tMf!J*!'~M ' ~~B9 *c~ , !1Hi!Lif5~~iilla9~~li ' ~:f]f~ 'J\~ • 19IH iI[ ft.1t~3( . 1WJ1JJiji (Diane Arbus) F;r F-'i' , r -fiitiffif~ {'F,~idl!lfmu~ --ftQlfl'. fiJ.~*'~lli r .~m~J~~'. • •. ::h.m*cr ~%Ptqm~ J (Art. ,r iHHil1i~J ( P ictorial. m ~~ - MM*' U OOJt~~U'~ ' ~.fi~a~m~.~ · Jr m~ B ~. ~~}Iffl~*.M. -V: ' JcJ&T~t3lfU9IJl. i-t it · * ~,m I'31~ ~ ~ r l'.R.I-ttlHI~ J. m1JOO'M. 8 Wifu~~ lli ~W~M.ff~'. ~U :l~IT~Jtf'F m~ f;j[j~H ' 1!~ ' ID ~ , ,tIi;f~ ~ Ptqr:pDl ~1~ J1.UU ~ f~q fl~ J • '«i ft" !HlqOOJt" Sl (,kj ~ f~Ij i@~1.HJ0f~ ~~ ~ffii!"1 ' l' IJ:l. q~;Wiilfr 3!. J.R.~ ~ , t·:t1x ' ~/W~ '';IF'X'' B9 W~all~~ ,~~*~ rLl!E m@i j(qJ Bl?ct ~ ~@ , ftH;'f , !!?Jt. ~ = +m~M*w~ r IDrt~ ~.W J. :(flttw<q,tH~~' y~~,~,.ri:,U~:1tJ..)A(1fTW~~Vlq~WM~ifiW!)o. * ~;H). tiI1i~0 J. TiJ Iffl ~ Jtl:1f;Z~ , t;£li!JI~£UJtIDrtfo~WrEJ9 ' ~ 1HA rM.J ' rlJH~itJ SZ]J1X* •. E Rm~%~~A ff~ W ·- R 2~h ~ ~~Jt " m* = ~~~Mm~~r@. ~ ~~ ,~&w*~~ ~~m~ ~ *ft ·. A(lltv l~ f!~~JilCm, J. r~~ .M ~ ~ ~ti~ J. '. Photography). ' r ~G~ J m~, m ~.* r .w *0;\:\,'rJHt:S9IiMilf. ' fJl ttl : fiIJiLl!J:tfIJi. i-t it r:jl/f fUi:~;z . j'[ B9 !¥Uf!~H Mi..§. f&A1£;jfiU~~¥.H~ U# ' 1j\~~ n[:c1~tE{ilTWi!Jt~ll3" fil~~11H pictorial). ):1] ;:L 9~. ,. , fi~ fi)[ it!l' ft ~ mlfT ; Mi..fi{j: fj rf~,~M'·J~f'f~~ ~~ • • ~1m&~~"*ft ·. ~ tLt fg ~ fj~Pjt ·-fWf s9M €r O=H~~jf)[ if:! ,'E, ~. Wfi::I·~j.W~i~~it. '. ij~N~j(q~f1Wf.!tttlHt;\1i~:{F. ~*t1!i ~ t¥.Vlq {£ -.:. l'm*cf)J~. ' r 'JgimJJJH1(I\]gc~Mi!m~1J i~ J ' r ft&l AnUM'i!~~;iiliJ '. ' rn ft .~~B~~J*m. (David Plowden ) u9W~li: rooJt1WWBl~ £ rr0 . ~ -B~~ ~~U'®1' . ~~~fi~~~J • :tl~ j£aif. iF=\' ,. Photography). M~~m~ ~. ~m~ ; *m+. (Robert Atkins, 1990) , 5E!l1t r Mtlfi J Mf!lJ:{£ r1Ji.. if! 89 tili i11: •. '. r ~.DD ~ ~~ J. ~ -etM~ :I:t!![B]fflE7 ~~1l. ~=i!p. ~- ruJ. IIJl f-'ttlJ,; J B'g I M!*¥fIJ,; J II.. IIJl f~ ~1ftj J. rm~~~J~.~8Wimt::h.m~r~~.~ J '. r ms .~ J ~m. ' 1N1}~. • - .+tlHCf)J , _~iI.~HJH~ftW 1il jif ' 11;:~ r ~ID:itl I~1H~fi~J (form follows function ) i¥J ".W" Ilt!~' :9d~f~*mU~IjBl rMfltiJ ~ ~,. ~ .ffi~Wffi~I .If'F · M~'I .~.D ~m~1}.~ m ~m~,~~. ~.~&.~8~ *~~ M~~. ·ffl~ ~~mrffl~M . J 1£~~ ~~.. M~M.~~~W~m,~~~af'F,mW m m'~~~~ ~~ M ft. RT'ffim~~(r~~~J~1ItIa . Vfii'®~ BW 'Mffl~ ~ ~I~ ~~. rIJI. f-t. T hlIimJ II fI~; 1£Jl:t~il1! if! .fi'1 ~ttht~ ttl : ~!!i1} ~ ;fl~,* f*W~Jt 89tii~m :lL til ' :,~:I@~;lF~ ·.l i~!;tal "~tl1d;!J " (pure photography) f~ J;)~}3J1. i-t iU(J£!.. +::h.m~ • • ~'~~M'm~w .w~~~ ttl ~m'S~ttAm~~ ifi !}1s'~I:efff~'g~O~px~~ i!tj~. (Scott McGuire). 28. ,. 0. mi1Hglj I~1ftffi¥fiU:r"* ::tli~jj~R. I~f~ J'l ~P:%!j'trOJfi~~ rA9 J:!n iliISl~,~*O~;:L .wt~·. ~~ J~~m~~~2 - ~'~~~~~.8~*~~'A.J1X.M~-~. 71' '. ~ ~ fu !~W~ ~ ri ~ri'~ f,c'. 0. IJlf-t A JK* i~ T ~ ffi .1. t!i fO. f!! it ·. 8\J ~~~n. 0. ;j:§ • 'l!.'. rJJH-t::t'l& J (Modernism) 6 Vfq~j!}]~~1t 1860¥lj 1970~1~9 ' ~Vlq~ ~8"J r 1JH-t~~Vfq J (Modern Art)):i!fl~H;£E]J~7JN ' f&En~ iJl~ , 17. ~ im ' ;f.Eft4 ' W1Jl. ' ii~ , ~lJl. tr ' 1ItI~:!&lJl. ' :~n¥f ¥lj fti~~IlNj=: ~~ • (Robert Atkins, 1990) UJi. i-t ~ Vfii J ' El:Lfj~ ! Hfq * ~ 1m J;) 11 it< W~ i!i 1m ' ~~ sZ] tJ;J~ , ®. , J..)Jit#tl r m ~tMi~ J m :1:~ B'~ r tM~5t ~iJRJ (Photo-Secession) • ~3ip*t1*,jl~'1 (Sadakichi Hartmann) t:Hr: (-@1m r*'l! f¥:ft!~ J ~A);i$i) (A Plea for Straight Photography) ~ g:rfBi ~ : 1191 A§'tffi1i', llj1. ~~~~nTI3~~'~~I~¥tffim~M~~m&.'~~~~ ••M.. ~ o ~ft'~~ - *fJlttl,m~~~~~ ~ • • Wi'~~ ~ ffi., ~m, ~. '*. *. ~~~'0~ ' fiWi*~m~~.~ ~ ~~~MW1J$,~~~rM.J. (avant-garde). 29. 8\711 ~ •. ± .J'. r ~ ~m~J~.~~a~~if!~ - ='@&~~Wm.~aM*.~~. JtfOfUJti'$ , 1'fl!Ff ~ r*'l!~HtHt;J (straight photography) fibifiJ • '~If1f ' ~% r' ~jilfr\~f.tJl:t1]IL~f~HoTslll*ill :. ((.JJ1XI~T- it~:t. ( -)fiM~~M. *ffi~.·.~,~#~a~~~&~ . ,~ ~ ~·~. ·_$ ~A~. ( = ) .fflM.~~ : ~mr~.. .·~ •• #·~~~~MI~~ ~.·M .,~~~~,#~~t,~. rm~ 8 ~J~kM~ 8 ~~~W.~ • • ~ ~N~ :. M:R1tr*,*~J~~~~m~*~:. 1904~. :(i: ~ ~TIn~ wH.e. r~ ~B Vfii J ~r . ~~M~a~J;. ( = ) 1ItI.M~~~~:~. ~~~~~~~. •• a ili~I~Ma~'~#.*M ·. 15.

(14)