Broadcast Scheduling Optimization for Heterogeneous Cluster Systems

Broadcast Scheduling Optimization for Heterogeneous Cluster Systems

Pangfeng Liu and Tzu-Hao Sheng

Department of Computer Science and Information Engineering National Chung Cheng University

Chiayi, Taiwan, R.O.C.

[email protected] ABSTRACT

IU(*VS^\a?&((G4&(11(& ./b&(5?5J<3=7&( c9=  G&1(@4dF3

oqph i

Ers
]r_"Ot

1. INTRODUCTION

‚TvE@6A4 &(5?5?\*)

.7I==V% F3 &(5?93<U 'G M56:VCD=1b*<=D=*U(L:3I'I=)

&((**(L:3 CIOs: ./]56&F33)+*9>(&3&]&(5?5%<=3&C c12)

Ÿ

V(5?(G;U*<3&F  Ÿ j\i`j\p*m ˜Gj\l>j*m¡hl-j\i¤^mp*¥$mf^¤^mp*¥hi+gišEmlJ[]
!#"

HD> F'*&((G 2:&e:I0(&(=5?&@

uvE@xr3

 ?*<3&(&(**./e93F:*(4q&(5?9=<=T 7c ?56/ *<= $ F3]11

:133 C@_dF3 a?&((=&8b: F=(*&(11(& ./&5?5%<=3&CT 7

 c8U3&F= =”(% F35

&((.7=VO5?(* V((L“3IyyC&Fˆ9=F:*J%I=<3D31b F3%<=5M)

*F=<=1NIc9= G&(((Ic M&(5?931 ] F=$ 5?$*-@

o_p\h i Ers
$r_"\L:G* I=<=&(CIODG8c~3”((5?;C@1@etuvEL>.*8O\z)

Š`'I3I=2 |L=  *F3C F:THF3(0 F3$&(5?5%<=3&C 0 5?$

&(**L: F3

*F=<317ISD>b*&\F=CI=<=17(Iwgf\i`j\pU@$Q =*CƒG<3(G 128

gl$&17<= C@

D>T./ 4&3*7IU47=*<=a?&7C@

  %&(3&(1<:IU((@

2. COMMUNICATION MODEL

&C*&\F=CI=<=17=Vbz F=(*]F=5?V(=(<= 5?I=17 &C6D>z<=:I

}t

*F3CH‰ F:T?(./(wHF=(x./*8wCIUVcF:My<=32M&(5?5%<=3&C)

 w&('EIU(3 CI…b F30d“(1(9=F3365?I=(1N"\Ls3:IU7=V}'9U)

vE@4Ba?&((G]12)

3VJ3I6 CIU<3& ;L&CcD>4K<=:I?tGL|Ž(‘UL|ŽŽL|Ž(uUL-Ž L-ŽCŒUL|ŽCL

‚‘TvE@

F=  V(=<3_9>15?I=(1-tvUJHF=&\Fb F3 &5?5%<=3&CT 7

b33*F3(I|L<3b1/?F35?V3(<3b9>1 3I;V/PY5?IU(1@

KJ5%<=12 7&(eeV./(|L“H2 F…

; F345%<=1 &C tvE@q~3”((5?>1@|tuTv|9= 9>*CI0b*5?931

9> 2 ./]T 70‚b7HV7.(O…t2ŽCvE@^!ˆ IU9= F= *5?931$5?I=1

z 5•t

3&(1<3I=?t UL|ŽCv+@

dF3O5?I=(16I=\:3(IXMK171CH(@A


"!#%$&$'$&(
)+*"!

L|C&\F

 &C93D=17%9>*)E )`9>]&(5?5J<3=7&( SH2 F…8} F3

DG8ˆ2 b*9>(CIˆ4*(:IU7=V'5?(* V((@}r= 561128GLs cIU:=M F3

z 5

dF:TH(LU F=]5?IU(1|I= 11CHH F=]<== C17 & 5?931(5?(GT 7

5?(* V($N 5

@XdF3yp j*g/n…išz 6jJ

&(5?(* VeN 5  F3 93 (G4L>3IObp*j*g/n$ ?*(3IO<U

 F= 5?(* VJ*HN 5

A

B D C

E 2

2

2 1

1

3 2 0

1

3

   !"$#%#$&')(*%+-,)./ !0"1"$"!2

3. FASTEST-NODE-FIRST TECHNIQUE

oqph i_Ers
$r_"“

9U 9>*CIXt

1V 2 F=5

1V 2 F=5

5?**y 5?J:46@JdF3;86$5?T./CI'z 5<4  =3 3I} F=

G <32 eD>(F=:I$ F3“F=(<=  & “ F3“D8]*(:IU3V F3q5?(* V

DU /I=&C] 5?@dF=brs
$r‰F:4D>((S*F=CHS7S*5J<317 ' 

D=1ctuvE@edF=%rs
]r‰ &\F=37ƒG<3b1*cI=(1./ $VGIy&5?5%<=3&CT)

 X\a?&((3&\8…X& <31€U9> 5?(G (@}Š`wI=I=2 ;L^rs
]r#

 (q9U 7561GD= I=&(s 5?HtuUL vE@BAw*5?931q€=5?931q“*F3CH

vE@qdF3

;\

D>M F3

H11:3 ^*(:IJ F=H5?(* V4 

&(5?5%<3=&C y 5?? @S]ˆ F3% F3\%F3:I-LBw9= 561

b F3 *&)

1(*H F:0 F3]*  D8crs
]r…O F=$1zC@

1

3 2 3

3

3 3 2 1 4 3

3 5

0

3 2 3

3 3

1

2 1 3

4 4 0

3 4

  ON"P#$F).#1 QD:ER& !"$#%#1 SD:2

4. THEORETICAL RESULTS

&CB 75?LC*F=Tˆ F:Brs
$rcB9= 561Ge*5?^*9>(&(71&C*(

&(71_&C*((L-J*F3C„ F:T]K (*)+3IU)E3  F3]0&(5?931 ./

 ?s =@

tuTv^ c9= T./

 F3]9= 56172`8c_rs
$r…0 F3$*9>(&N1;&(*(4BF=  V(=(<=

8U (5'@

TVU/W0X/YWNZ Ž@[*\^]_ Ÿ j\p j$j^`šzhihglcm?a3išK ?g!bcp*mCg/nœghi_ip*jjd

šKlw¤

Ÿ

šEœ

Ÿ

g!bbBa3p*mCœj\h hmp\h6hj\l>nh% 6j\h h\gC˜Gj6¤_šKi

Ÿ

m¡Ui$nGjebggfh_

Ÿ

gi

šKhji|f(mpMg!bQba:pmCœ\j\h h\mp

šKl5dGi hi+gp\išKlG˜Jf\pm  šKihbp j*g/nSišK 6j?i

p j*a=j*gi`j*n0b?h(j\l:nh g% ?j\h hg(˜Gj ¤_šKiŸ gka=j\pšEmCn6mfšKih4ip*gl3h  %šKh h šEml

išK ?je¡l3išSb-iŸ jGcp*mCg/n/œ gh i]j\l>nh$f

TVU/W0X/YWNZ ‚@[*\^];_

Ÿ

j\p*jj^`šKh ih}glm?a:išK Mg!blcp*mCg/nœghi%ip j j

d šKl}¤

Ÿ

šEœ

Ÿ

j?mj\p Ga:pmCœ\j\h h\mp

Ÿ

ghbg0ipgl3h  JšKh hšmlˆišK ?jel:mb7j\h h

iŸ glyiŸ j ip*gl=h JšKh h šEmlyišK 6jemf$šKihRaUgp*j\l3i*f

H11>I=(17(8J5?(* V((LU3I% 171=::Ie F39= 561U*&\F=CI=<=1@_dF3

4rs
$r @s‹U3&?3SIU(17C8yJ11T CI|LqG8*&F3(I=<313VO5? F3I

3ž F:J&(<317I…F:C./?&(5M)

5?5?CIU7 (128G@ r= 561128S%I=33 6 

%$&$&$&

6

)+*"!

"4 0D>J

@_ F=

@J F3%9U G&(()

*ˆ 5?@ ; 8U

 1|D= I=&(4 75?REI=3 (IcDG8%d _"*" 7HDG80I=\z)

= h8U6

)* !

"\@SADU /I=&CM*CƒG<33&(7cm?a:išz ?g!b|24:I



_"



 



"\@

|  

Lb:I

 !;

 ">D>q F=4l=¡ %cj\p|=5?(* V(s*<3&&((*K<=118?hj\l=is:I

D>\K M 5?



DG8

 F=M*CƒG<33&(" @Mr3 5617128GL#$ ! 

"

 "

 F3 5?=75J<35ž3=)+3(V ./$G (V c*<3&Fc F3l8U

"&% 

 

"('  L/z  ' 8U

"\@_r=11TH=Vb F=7^3 |LG4&C0I=\:3

 F=$ CI86 75?k8=

8U6 

") ‘

8=6 ") 5?+* , * !

-

.0/



$!“6 .  "('2143



Ž5 1627xŽ-ŽC"

4.1 Fastest Nodes First

6   6

!%#$'$&$&

6

)* !

‚&CMT V<3^ F:

 6 

"

ŽLH3I 8U6 "%5J<3%D>Sx7G (V02

 6 " ŽO*7=&(S=128X

|

 6 .

L>=J^ F=(5 EI=(= CISDG8 "4D>&C5? CIU8S3e 75?e (9

F3CIO

L=@@8U /" 8=

"7XŽ@

9WNZZ;:©Ž@=<sj\i>?„6   6 ! %$&$&$'

6

)+*"!

" cjJglm?a:išz ?g!bcp*mCg/nk

œ gh i|hjA@¡3j\l:œ\j?isgl>n

I6

.

cj iŸ j>oqph i/fgh i0a3p*mCœj\h hmp4g?aga=j*gpšKl˜

gf\i`j\p%h bm¤ j\pka3p*mCœj\h hmp\hMšzl$fb›zfV8U6.

"B



i iŸ j\l…iŸ j\p*j0j^`šzhih

glC16D?E}h ¡=œ

Ÿ iŸ

gi  6 "(F  6 .

"egl>n 8U6 "  7xŽ f

H2 FO (IU86 5?



7wŽ@ ‹U3&



5%<=

T47G (VH 5?$ (93(L=3&(1<3I=3V



7XŽ@

|1n**<35?411:9U )



:IK

 

CIU8cH 5? 

K 

EI=3 (I6DG8Mb"_H2 F6 CI8? 5?D>`(



7ˆŽ$:I

 @ ;BN



7JŽ

 7'ŽLGHF=7&F

;\QD>%9= 561q*(ƒ<=(3&M3I

 6 .

I=(= M6 (

RI6S3H2 F

CIU8] 5?8U

"T7 Ž_;(5?56Ž@“!ˆq*F=Cˆ F:T“DG8€U&\F3=V3V

H2 F PLT@@B1  „6  %$&$'$&

6

*"!%
 6VU

!%%$&$&$&

6 .

*"!%

 6 . U !

$&$&$'

6SW

*"!

I=(L>  F:$ F3M 5?M9U 561BD= IU&Ce 5?MIUG((@

:I ?Tz  F3

€U&F:=V@

9W0ZZB:‚@=X $ ?mCnšf šKl˜BXšKl=i+m=  ghHnGj\h\œpšcj nJggc mOmj?i“iŸ j

p j*g/nXišz 6jmf

šKh' Mg/nGj…j*gp?bš+j\pbf\pm 



i+m



7ªŽ!i6gl>nXiŸ j

p j*g/nOišK ?jMmf }šKhbnGjebg/j*n f\p*m 



7xŽOi+m







fPY]hJgcp j\h ¡0bi

$

![Z


 d]"\%C 

![Z

 



d]"'2$ ! 

"

d$"]%C$ !  



d]"?i/fmp-d^'

 f

B L F=^ CIU8  5?q

`  



7%ŽLB 5?“ F3q CI8

 5?]

b

DE=L3H 5?eH7$‰D>(&(<3* =M56* \

%D>&C5?

CIU8O 5?



7XŽL=HH11“=4*(:IcG8c5?(* V <3G 1- 5?

 67?_7eIU(17(8GCI

 @%‹U=&(

1=VO  *3*5?**} 5?L$

![Z




d]"Bd  ! 

"

d]"%Ž

K de'  @q]M F=4 F3 F::I|L  I=1N(8G(IMD8J=4 5? (9|L

$ !  



d$"c$

!_Z

 



d]"f$ !  



d]">%„Ž6zGdg'  Lq:I

 F3]175?56bK117CH(@

 @B!ˆ]9= T./4 F3T (5?(GDG86:IU<3& c3I6 F=z11TH=V

9W0ZZB:†uU@P_

Ÿ

jbp j*g/ncišK ?jJmfV6

. U !

šKljšKh$l:mbgi`j\pbi

Ÿ

gl

šKlCf

GRYNXXHJI]dF=M1(5?56MK171CHez 5 ;(5?560‚c:IS F3b&\

`@

8

![Z

6 . U ! "

 5?7+*

 , . -
/ 

$

![Z

6

"('?E %ZŽS3

 5?7+* , .

*"!

-

/



/

$ ![Z 6

"*"% $ ![Z 

"% $ ![Z /"('?E %ZŽS3

 5?7+*

 , .

*"!

-

/



/

$

! 6

"*"
% $

![Z



"% $

![Z

 "('?E %RŽ 3

 5?7+*

 , .

*"!

-

/



/

$!“6

"*"
% $!;

"%  
!; "(' E=%RŽ 3

 8 !“6. U ! "

C#  &(5?9=1 $ F3$3I=<3&\ 7;@

9WNZZ;:†U@%_ Ÿ j p j*g/n6išK ?jJmfl6

šKlj  šzh]l>mbgi`j\peiŸ gl}šKl

 i=f(mpE %Ž   C7XŽ'f

GRYX/X
HJIH!…y&(5?9=1 y F=}9= GJDG8Z F=:IU<3& # 9;@

A4**<35?4 F: F=] (&(7.$ 75?6

. U a    H3%17T H F:

h LUKJŽR

b

 j7 ER7xŽ@

8 ! Z6 . U a U !"

 5?7+* ,. U a -
/ 

  ! Z6

"('E % b

%ZŽS3

 5?7+* ,*

.

*"!

-

/



/

$

![Z

6 

"*"% $

![Z



"% $

![Z

 /"&%

. U a

-

/ .U !

$

!_Z

6 

"*"('?E % b

%ZŽ 3

 5?7+* ,*

.

*"!

-

/



/

$!“6

"*"
% $!“

"% $
!“ "%

. U a

-

/ . U !

$ ![Z 6 

"*"'?E % b

%RŽ 3

 5?7+*

 ,

*

.

*"!

-

/



/

$

! 6

"*"
% $

! 

"% $

!

 "%

. U a

-

/ . U !

$

! 6

"*"('?E % b

%ŽS3

  ! E % b

%RŽT"

dF=}1N07=CƒG<:172`8xz11THcz 5  F=':I=<=& RFG8U9> F=(*

6 . U !

 P6

. U a

 5?     F:'

:I6 *5611



 e  z80qƒG<:T 7SŽ@^]345?5?CI=7T  (*<312

N 5

šKl0¤ Ÿ šEœŸ g!bb3iŸ jsf(gh i`j\h iBa:p*mCœj\h h\mpheg?aga=j*gpLc\jKfmp j g!bQb=iŸ j$miŸ j\p

a:pmCœ\j\h h\mphef

4.2 Special Cases

4.2.1 Two classes of processors

TVU/W0X/YWNZ =@%_ Ÿ jHfgh i`j\hiEkEl>mCn/jko_p\h ibg!b˜/mpšKiŸ   ˜šQmj\hMm a:išk

 ?gObcp*mCg/nœghiqišK ?j¤ Ÿ j\lOiŸ j]l3¡ Pc\j\p]mfœ$bgh h(j\h]mfa:p*mCœj\h h\mp\h

šKh0i¤^mOi%c¡i%n/mTj\hOl:mi ˜¡=gpgl3i`j jyi

Ÿ

jym?a3išK ?g!bVcp*mCgn/œ gh iMišK 6j

¤ Ÿ j\l}i

Ÿ

jbl=¡U Pcj\pbmfeœ$bgh h(j\hbmf9a3p*mCœj\h hmp\hbšKh]i

Ÿ

p j j1f

GRYNXXHJI]./%8$9= 561UDU /I=&CB*CƒG<3(=&( &3* 3V

 (L-3Ic F3 (*<=12 7=V?*CƒG<3(=&( $ 5?e F= =bV./(

<= b‚G@

<317T 73btuvE@

4.2.2 Multiple of transmission time

<U417*J_V(=128GL311n]V/}**<35?$ F:TH F3$*=*5?)

9W0ZZB: @B<sj\i ª6



6

!#%$&$'$&

6

)* !

"Gcjbglm?a:išK Mg!bcpmCg/nk

œ gh i hjA@¡3j\l:œ\j f(mpOgœ$b¡hi`j\pc¤ Ÿ j\p jciŸ jcipgl3h  JšKh hšmlZišK ?jOmf

gl La:p*mCœj\h h\mpbšKh$gM J¡Nbišab7j mf glf(gh i`j\p9a:p*mCœj\h h\mp$f =¡&agaUmhj

iŸ j\p*jyj^`šzhihcga3p*mCœj\h hmp

 6 . iŸ giGc\j*œ m ?j\hcp*j gn…gf\i`j\p'g

h bm¤ j\pLa:pmCœ\j\h h\mp6šKl  iHiŸ j\lwiŸ j\p*jOj^`šKh ihMglh1 D E…h ¡=œŸ iŸ gi

5I6šKh$g6hbm¤ j\p9a:pmCœj\hh\mpMgl>n 8U /"> 8U

">7‰Ž f

;(5?56 ŽH:I

;(5?56ŽL

CIU86= 9OF3CI0

 F:  F3y F=%1(5?56%K117CH(@?Š+^ F=$ 3] F3%&(*L| F3

 5?l8=

;5?56 GLs F:Tebb12(8Ub9>)

D>&C5?M CIU8=0 9wF=CI…

@'dF=J5?IU3&C ˆH171

&(**CL>= <34=186z4 F3]K (=(447 ;(5?56 @

9WNZZ;: @ X 6h ¤_šKi+œ Ÿ šKlG˜

¤_šKiŸ SšKlj<sj\ % Mg
Oi^iŸ jbp j*g/n

išz 6j$mf

šKhH ?mOmj*nf(mp\¤^gpnf\p*m   i+m  7yŽ!i;i

Ÿ

j]p j*g/nJišK 6j$mf

0šKh]nGjebg/j nHf\pm 



7ˆŽ%i+m



i_gl:n5$

![Z



"

d]" % $

![Z

 



d]"('

 
!“

"

d$"&% $!“ 



d]"?iUf(mp9de'

 f

GRYX/X
HJI ;1n

'n]9>7G_. @‹U=&(M$I=1N(8G(IODG8O3128'3  5?b 9;L

![Z

DG8ˆŽL;:I' F3$IU(& C*

3128?F3939>3^  5?HG  .1st8= "_%



 /"



8= "_%  

 "_%ˆŽT"\L

HF= 

 6  @M
 J F3  F=7]7G  .1_3&17<3I=($ F=J 5?
8U "%

 

 "qD=<=^398= " %  

 "

 

! Z 
! 

"]DG8}3?*=&(



 "b

5J<312 931M  

":I



:Ic F= ;5?56ez11TH(@

!R F ;(5?56 %O9=1N&(  F3T.] F3]z11CH7=V? F3( (5'@

TkUBWNX/YW0Z G@%_ Ÿ jf(gh i`j\h iEk+l:mCnGjkoqphibgOb˜/mp\šziŸ  ©˜šQmj\h%m?a:išk

 Mg!b0cp*mCg/nœghi“išK 6j ¤

Ÿ

j\l?i

Ÿ

jip*gl=h  %šKh h šEml?išK ?j4mfgl]h?bm¤j\p

a3p*mCœj\h hmp4šzlMiŸ jœ$b¡h i`j\pšKhg] %¡0bišab7jmfgl_f(ghi`j\pa:p*mCœj\h h\mp\hef

4.3 Competitive Ratio Analysis

dF=( 5

$ b*F3Cx F:rs
$ry7 & <31

e&(5?9>\  ./c X‚@YdF3

*5?(F3C\€=9=173q F: 0*5J<317 =rs
$ry12C8U9U I=<3&(

.*80VGI'*&F3CIU<31(eKH2 F3ŽB F3]9= 561^tuvz"\@

!ˆ=C

F3%}*3*5?**w 5?0JŽL^:Iˆ F=c*1C?=cF3?‚U@

!ˆcH11&(114 F=M73IX$&(1<= 0

dF=( 5 '2?5?5?CI=7 18yK117CH? F:TMrs
]rW9U I=<3&(J F=

 bD>

‚  



Ls@@O F=M*5611(J9>T J4‚c F3bb='1(*e F:

!…SH11 *F3C  F3'rs
$r L

p j*n¡=œišEmlOišK ?jHl>m˜p j*gi`j\piŸ gl0i¤_šEœj]mfiŸ j]m?a:išz ?g!bUhœŸ j n¡Nb7j1f

GRYNXXHJI



|d†:I d  D>% F=MD= IU&Ce 5?%=

K 3I  (*9>& ./(128GL3@

5?** 5?eH171^$5?eIU<3D=1J F3b 1qDU /I=&C  75?L

@@Ld=6W‚1de@!ˆJ&C}<3*J0*5?931b:I=<=& S 1 0T V<3

3b17  F=(c‚8U @qdF3:I=<=& 0 (9?K171CHHz 5

 F3$K&4 F:T11; F= 9= (.<=k6

.

17 _ F3?‚&8=6 .

";K 

I=<3D=17$N 5Y  E@

]C£y9=93128rs
]rž*&F3CIU<313V‰ e:IR1Ad= D>S F3



^ F:/d=/;35? B F3

d @Brs731128GL H939=128b F= 5?rs
]rS*&\F=CI=<=17=V]:Ib17\

 F:)d  

 F3…"J@yA4%O (*<=12
d J3

 LsHF=7&F…b3

5?  F:'‚&de@

4.4 Broadcast for Specified Source

=H5?3V 171=9>**D31H*&F3CIU<31((LG:IM^*<=VV( CI%DG8JdF3()

@L-I=<U 3V

%H 11“.17I|@

!…?H11<3*? F=0 5??3 Xb… F36V31&C*L_D3<=

H2 FY F3…z11CH7=VW5?IU2:&CT 7;@ rs2 CLJ ‰ 711%I=33w

*&F3CIU<31Q†6

%$&$&$&

6

)+*"!

6 

&CM3173V **<35? F3 6 

;  6`"

 113D> F3*3*5?**M 5?6

F:4*3*5?**' 5?MŽ@d“?*5?9312:CIc F= 3 ' eH11

**<=5? F3 F34 5?4H11;T*457  6 

"\L*% F:T F34 CI8

 F3 *<= &(
6



L>@@L/6

! !

9W0ZZB: @B<sj\i# cjOg%aUm¤ j\p…œ$b¡h i`j\p$fI_

Ÿ

j\p*j'j^`šKh ih0gl

m?a:išz ?g!bUhœ

Ÿ

j n¡Nb7j; „6  %$&$'$&

6

)* !

"Hh ¡=œ

Ÿ iŸ

gi/6

!

šKhi

Ÿ

j“f(gh i`j\h i

a:pmCœ\j\h h\mp$f

6 

;\=…D> G869U 561>*&F3CI)



TM5?| 6  "   /"*"`F Ž@ˆ
T†0H2 &\F

3IS7 W:I

1

M*=&(

*&F3(I=<31 41*?9U 561L::I6 F3 1(5?56 K11CH(@

!R F

!

F:q*3)

5?**b 5?Ž@s
]Cw&(%9U G&((CI   F=^z11TH=Vb1(5?56L

HF=&\F'H*5?1NT ;(5?56%3I @

9WNZZ;:Œ@=<sj\i>?„6



6

!%$&$&$'

6

)+*"!

" cjJglm?a:išz ?g!bcp*mCg/nk

œ gh ihj@¡3j\l>œjf(mp g aUm¤ j\p cœ$b¡hi`j\p i šzlS¤

Ÿ

šEœ

Ÿ 6 

šKh$i

Ÿ

jeha=j*œ(k

šoj*nyh\m¡p*œjSgl:n=6

!

šKhMiŸ j$f(gh i`j\h ila3p*mCœj\h hmp1f <sj\i

 6.

cj

iŸ joqphi|fgh i-a:p*mCœj\h h\mp?g?a!a=j gp\šKlG˜'gf\i`j\p%gl6h bm¤ j\pla:p*mCœj\h h\mp

mi

Ÿ

j\pei

Ÿ

gl=6

 f

f4›zf98=

">



iqiŸ j\lyiŸ j\p j?j^`šKh ihbgl1D?ESh¡=œŸ iŸ gi R 6

gl:n   /"(F  

" gl:nG8U "6 8U

"#7xŽ f

0f=X $h ¤_šKi+œŸ šzl˜

¤qšziŸ 'i-iŸ jHp*j*g/n išK ?jHmf

šzh^ MmOmj*nqfmpk

¤^gp*nqf\pm 



i+m



70ŽOi;iŸ jHp j*g/nbišz 6jHmf %šKhHnGjebgGj*nqf\p*m 



7bŽ]i+m



i|gl>nBf(mpqiŸ j p j\h ¡0bišKlG˜ l>j\¤h\œŸ j*n¡0b7j i>¤ j Ÿ gOmj

$

! Z 
 d]"T%L$

! Z

 



d]"'2$ ! 

"

d]"T%L$ !  



d]"?if(mp

de'  f

b:I U@B!ˆ

= &($ F3Hz 5 ;(5?56

@

;(5?56 U@
 &(  F:T4 

\€=&17<3I=V6



B F3$*9>&(2:CIO*<= &(@

&5?9> 2 ./]T 7U@

TkUBWNX/YW0Z G@%_

Ÿ

j“f(ghi`j\h iEkEl>mCnGjkoqph i h\œ

Ÿ

j*n¡0bšKlG˜

Ÿ

gh4gei+mi+g!b

p*j*n¡=œišEml}išK 6j]l:me˜p j*gi`j\p iŸ glOi¤qšœ\jemfiŸ jbm?a3išK ?g!b:h\œ Ÿ j*n¡0b7j

¤ Ÿ j\l}iŸ jehm¡UpœjbšKhH˜šmj\lBf

5. HEURISTIC SEARCH

9= 561“*&\F=CI=<=17e*3&Jrs
]rZIUG(=]V<:TG (e9U 56128G@

dF=4*& 'IU(*& D>( F=] (&F337ƒG<3^ F:T$<=*CI? %*9>(CI

69= 561U CI=<=& ?*&F3CIU<3145?=V  F3(*eL7yŽC"/9>**7D=1

$7ŽT"“b*<=&\FˆO17 V

3VSdF=( 5 ‚cRtuv :IˆdF3( (5 uO F=7e939>  ?&C

z 5 dF=( (5 u6 %3CY F3%&(y7V3 M11_*CƒG<33&((

*9:&(?*3&(%3C

dF34*(&(:I? (&F337ƒG<3H^ b93931286dF=( 5 ‚$*b F3qHF3(0

 F3H9:T* 71|*1<= S&5?931 18G@

!… &:IU<3&4 F3 \€=9>\ 75? HS?Ps(G U<=5 u)+ ‘6P Q <3=)

3=VSr= (C~‹U{ uU@‚
]ŠJ@;dF36P^Q F3?ŽT‚Œ/’ODG8 (b5?(5?*8

3I6 $<3*V&(& ‚@@‚T) Ž$ J&(5?9=174 F3&(I=@^dF=]39=<=&(1<=)

ƒG<: 2 ( 5?(*<= (I|@

!…4ƒG<:G N8% F=ehj*gpœ Ÿ

)

W

H2 F6$*5M)

P
   5? >T
  5? >
 

Ž(‘ ŒŒ  ‚  ‘ ŽC‘UŽ ‘U@‘‘‘  Ž@Ž(u   ŽCŒ  ‘U@‘‘Œ ‚Ž@‘UŽ Ž@

ŽŽ ‚ /‚‘‘ Œ‘ ŽCu/‚ ‘U@‘‘‘Œ ‘U@‘  /  ‘U@‘/‚Œ ŽCŒ@UŽ  u U@Œ

ŽC‚   ‚‘UŽŽCŒ ŽCŒ‘ ‘U@‘‘ŽT‚ ‘U@‚  Ž(‘‘ ‘U@‘ Ž ŽG@ŒUŽ @

Ž(u ŽCŒ‚ T/ ŒŽT‚ u  ‘U@‘‘‚  ‘U@Ž(  ‚ GŽ ‘U@ŽCŒ   ŽCu@ u  U@

Ž  ŒŒ Ž( /‚‚ / ‘U@‘‘ ‘U@ŽŽ(  ‚uŽCŒ ‘U@Ž‘ ŽT‚G@Œu  ŽŽŽ@

Ž ŽŽ(u‘UŽ% u/‚‘ ‘ ŽŽŽŽ ‘U@‘UŽ(‘UŽ ‘U@‘Œ  Ž( ‘  Ž@uuu  ŽT‚G@Œ  Ž(u/‚@Ž

Ž% uUŽ ‘‚   u ‚Ž ‚‘‘  ‘U@‘/‚‘‘ ‘U@‘   u‘‘ Œ  uU@‘/Œ @uUŽ Ž‚@Ž

Ž UŽ(u GŽT‚ ‚  u‘‘/‚ u‘‘‚ ‘U@‘u/ ‘U@‘uu  ŽC‘/‚‘  ŽŽ@  ‘ ŽŽ@ŽCu  uu=@

Ž(Œ uŽC    ŒŒ ‚GŽ ‘U@‘ ‘ ‘U@‘ŽCŒ  ‚ Œ‘=Ž u‚@‘‘ Œ@u/‚‘   @u

Ž( Œ ‘‘ Ž( ‚ ‘Œu  ŽT‚T ‘U@‘Œ‚  ‘U@‘‘   ‘Œ‘  U@/u ‘ Œ@‚‘  ŽŽ% U@

‚‘ ‚‚‘ ‘Œu  u Œ  ŽT‚ u ‘U@ŽCŒ‚Ž ‘U@‘‘  Ž(u‚ Œ/‚ ‚‘ @ŽC‘  @uUŽC‘  ŽŽC‚ U@‚

‚GŽ Œ‘  Ž(u‘ ŽCŒ uuUŽ ‚ T=Ž(Œ ‘U@/u/Œ ‘U@‘‘  ‚uUŽ(   U@‚Œ‘ U@ ‘  ŽCu‚=@u

N-E  F OBD:.NO "$ (l#?JG "$' F .&D;"!2

V 2 F35?(@

1V 2 F=5

<=9c 6‚GŽ 3IU((@

6. CONCLUSION

!ˆ*F3C‰ F:T^M*./1U*9>(&(713&C*( 2^12(8U_V./(q9U 561

DU /I=&C4 5?@_Š`c*5J<317 =2H&C0::I? F3]9= 561|*1<=)

N 5 6*5611“D=17t

z 563&(J7y& <:1B
H! 8U (5?(@$dF3%*&F3(I=<31b$C8S 

&5?93<U  3Ic&C'D>$<=9-I3 (Ic3& 5?(G1128G@

1V 2 F=5

rs
]rOV<3 (B F3^ 1G 5?^ 4D>^H2 F3bH&(3 F3q 5?

D>\(' F3e*&F3CIU<31 z 5 :IO F=

9= 561|=@

8 &\F=37ƒG<3(eG O F301V 2 F35 ¢} '*&F3CIU<31011  (

\€35?931LB2JH711D>6G  ( 3V' }€ (3I F3e (&F337ƒG<3M 

5J<3=7&( % 5?56(8bD>H]K<=3& M-D> F% F3*:IM:IJ F=

O F3HT CU@

7. ACKNOWLEDGMENT

ŒT)‚‚Ž(u)`B)Ž()‘‘@

8. REFERENCES

t2Ž\v%—ˆj\h hg(˜Gj$™4ghh šKlG˜M›l=i`j\pKf(gœ\j
“mp¡U J@>’'TJŽ(=@

t

ŽC @

tuTvJ’@:~3”((5?L=¦J@:’OG* FG8GL3:I0{%@=PB3I3U@:_aM&((G

s   =(@>Š'™pmCœjj*nšzl˜hbmf]›l3i`j\pl>gišml>g!b

™4gpg!bQb7jeb3™pmCœj\hh šKlG˜qmlCf(j\p j\l>œj\L;ŽCŒU@

tvbAb@=~*)+
T8GL:‹-@ ]<=F:UL =@3
$CL::IO‹-@3~@>’O<=12 7&(7

Ÿ j
\iŸ

Y4l3l3¡=g!bJY“—  kaUmh šK¡ £mlSi

Ÿ

j*mp 'mfbœ m Va:¡išKl˜L

ŽCŒU@

t

8= 5?(@>—ygiŸ j\ ?gišEœ g!b h i`j\ %h_ Ÿ j*mp L-‚  "\L;ŽC=@

t TvbPB@3~ F3CL:Q@

8= 5?(@=Š`S™p*mCœj j*nšKl˜hJmf$iŸ j$›l3i`j\pl>gišEml>g!b

qmlCfCj\p*j\l>œj%ml $šKh ip\šc¡i`j*nqm ka:¡išKlG˜ h i`j\ %h L“Ž(U@

t

š+j*n`YVb˜Gj$cpgOi

YVb˜Gj$cp*gšEœRYVb˜/mpšKi

Ÿ

 %hji gl>np\pmpqmp\p*j*œišKl˜Oœ mCnGj\h L

=(;
$Q‹ u/"\L;ŽCUŽ@

t

mf4™4gpg!bQb7jeb;gl>n šzhipšc¡i`j*nqm Va:¡išKl˜L/ŽC @

tTvJ’@ e@ $T 8O:I0{%@:‹-@F=3*;@qm ka:¡i`j\pbgl:n

›l3ip*gœi+ggcšSbšKi BY„˜¡šEnGjei+m?iŸ j iŸ j*mp cmf

4™kqm kab7j\i`j\l>j\hh @:!Y@3[b@:r= (56|L|Ž( U@

t2ŽC‘Tv q@

t2ŽŽ\vJ’@  V=s:Ic{J@:Ps(1(VU@>dVFG4D><=:IU'5?35J<35

U›Y4—0f$šKh\œp j\i`j —gi

Ÿ

f7L==L|ŽCŽ@

t2ŽT‚Cv !„@  939|L:@ |<3*>LU
J@={$*(L33I'Ab@3‹(11<35'@=A

&(5?5%<3=&C c3` U(@ej\i¤ mp ¥hef7L;ŽCŒUL;ŽCUŽ@

t2ŽvLe@ eT 9;L=Ab@:‹=F:(8GL=H@:‹= (L::I M@:@>‹&\F3<=*C@

]9= 561|DU /I=&C]:IO*<=5?56 0O F3]17V9'5?IU(1@

Š'™pmCœjj*nšzl˜hJmf i

Ÿ

Y4l3lBf  kaUmhšz¡U ©ml'™Hgpg!bQb7jeb

YVb˜/mpšKiŸ  Jhegl>nY4p*œ Ÿ šKi`j*œi¡Up*j\h LqŽ(uU@

t2ŽTvLe@  ( C.|LM@3~ :I3179:T L>3IO{%@=PB3I3@>’O<=1 &C

<U 3V=@=Š'™pmCœjj*nšzl˜hbmf›l3i`j\pl>gišEml>gOb  kaUmhšz¡U £ml

Ÿ š7˜ Ÿ a=j\pzf(mp ?gl:œ\jJœm ka:¡i`j\pJgp*œ Ÿ šKi`j*œi¡Up*j\LBŽC @

t2Ž% vbAb@q@;( 56':I U@

_D><33I=CI0I=(V (@ U›Y4— 0f $šKh\œp j\i`j —giŸ f7L|ŽL|ŽCŒŒU@

t2ŽTvbPs@ |<S3Ic{%@!w3VU@ 4CI=<=& c9= 5?”CT 7'

iŸ j ›l=i`j\p\l:gišEml:g!b>™Hgpg!bQb7jebsgl>n šKh ipšc¡i`j n%™pmCœj\hh šKlG˜

 kaUmhšz¡U JL>‚‘‘‘U@

t2Ž(Œve{%@ &F:TI=H3I'Ab@ _@ |7 56;@ ](=1”C S

D= IU&C]3IcV**933VU@bj\i¤^mp*¥h L“Ž(ŒUL“Ž(ŒŒU@

ej\i¤^mp*¥hL

‚uL“Ž(u@

t‚‘ve{%@=~@U!…(C@3A&(17*4B*17<U 3 % F=$V**9'9= D31(5'@

 šzhœp*j\i`j —gi

Ÿ

f7L:uUL;ŽC‚@