GOOD PRACTICES ON LANGUAGE ACROSS THE CURRICULUM (LAC) IN
SECONDARY SCHOOLS
DISSEMINATION SEMINAR
Yuen Yi Lo, Simon Chan & Research Team
Outline
I. Introduction and overview of the Study II. Key findings of the Study
III. Professional sharing by participating school teachers IV. Recommendations
2
I. INTRODUCTION & OVERVIEW
3
I. Introduction & Overview
Bilingual education programmes and their effectiveness
- Use of students’ second/foreign/additional language (L2) as the medium of instruction of non-language content subjects (e.g. Mathematics,
Science, History)
- Aims: “additive bilingualism” – students learn L2 more effectively without sacrifice in L1 or academic achievement
YET
EMI students in Hong Kong enjoyed some advantages in English learning, but they suffered in their achievement in such content subjects as Science and History
(e.g. Marsh et al., 2000, 2002; Lo & Lo, 2014)4
Difficulties encountering EMI in Hong Kong
- Difficulties caused by subject-specific academic language - Students’ readiness (English proficiency level)
- Teachers’ training (content subject teachers incorporating language scaffolding in their lessons)
5
Language across the
curriculum through teacher collaboration
• Different forms/ways of collaboration
• Contributing and hindering factors of teacher
collaboration
6
(Lo, 2015, p. 458)
1. How is LAC implemented in Hong Kong secondary schools with different MOI arrangements?
2. To what extent does LAC affect classroom practices and students’ learning?
3. What may be some contributing factors to effective LAC in secondary schools?
Guiding questions:
7
The Study
- Multiple-case study, with 12 cases (schools) with different characteristics
- Informants: Principal, Vice-principals, curriculum leaders, English teachers, content subject teachers, students, parents
- 12 cases could be categorised into 3 types, based on their MOI arrangements:
Type 1: English as the MOI for most curriculum time and students
Type 2: Students streamed into different classes with different MOI arrangements
Type 3: Mainly with allocation of time to subjects and/or Extended Learning Activities (ELAs)
8
Summary of data collected
Individual interviews (Administrators &
Teachers)
Focus group interviews (Students)
Questionnaires Lesson observations
School documents
57 hours 19.5 hours • Administrators &
Teachers: 186
• Students: 3296
• Parents: 2550
72 lessons e.g.
• LAC/MOI
committee plans
• schemes of work of different
subjects
• lesson plans &
teaching materials
• student work samples
9
II. KEY FINDINGS
10
1. Landscape of LAC practices
(a) Formal collaboration: LAC/MOI Committee
Setting up an LAC/MOI committee or task force: an academic head (e.g. the Vice- Principal) or an LAC coordinator, some English and content subject teachers
- Responsibilities:
Co-planning LAC curriculum and teaching materials
Conducting lesson observations
Professional development (PD) opportunities
11
(b) Informal collaboration among teachers
Usually ad-hoc collaboration between English and content subject teachers and of smaller-scale, e.g.
content subject teachers seeking ad hoc advice or assistance from English teachers on language issues (e.g. grammar or sentence patterns)
English teachers consult content subject teachers and subject textbooks for the LAC worksheet design
casual in nature yet complementary to formal collaboration, nurturing a sustainable cross-departmental collaborative culture in schools
12
(c) An English-rich environment with LAC/English-related activities
to provide a whole-school English learning environment and to increase students’
exposure to English
English-related activities: English language-oriented activities with English as the medium of delivery
e.g.,hall assembly class presentation, Spelling King and Queens (content subject vocabulary spelling competition), job hunting, drama performance & joint-school oral practice
LAC activities: incorporating cross disciplinary elements in a more all-rounded manner e.g. English presentation based on content subject topics; Science Fair; Reading across the curriculum; LAC Festival
Complementary to formal LAC curriculum
13
(d) Developmental stages of LAC
No noticeable differences in LAC practices among Types 1, 2 and 3 schools
Diverse scopes and modes of LAC according to schools’ strategic goals, resources allocation, students’ needs and teachers’ professional
expertise subject to regular review
14
A continuum of three developmental stages of LAC
a) whether LAC is well planned and implemented;
b) subject-specific or integrated across the English and
content subject curricula;
c) level-confined or connecting between different key stages of education; and
d) LAC in the formal curriculum only, or extending to the informal curriculum/extra- curricular activities
15
2. Potential impact of LAC on classroom practices and student learning
Questionnaire items n Mean SD
Content subject teachers always incorporate language objectives when
planning lessons 85 3.55 .84
Content subject teachers always highlight difficult words during
teaching 85 4.12 .64
Content subject teachers always highlight language features during
teaching 85 3.47 .83
Content subject teachers always evaluate both content and language
learning 85 3.39 .76
English teachers always incorporate academic language objectives
when planning lessons 76 3.38 1.05
English teachers always highlight vocabulary that may appear in
content subjects 76 3.68 .93
English teachers always highlight grammar items that may appear in
content subjects 76 3.86 .95
16
(a) Macro-level analysis of curriculum and lesson design
(i) Curriculum mapping
Cross-curricular collaboration with unit co-planning, lesson and materials design - by identifying content and language objectives across the curriculum
- by identifying common “knowledge structures” (e.g. “cause and effect”, “problem and solution”, “definition”, “classification”)
- by identifying a common theme (e.g. “Water”)
- by integrating language goals into content subject curriculum and lesson plans
17
(ii) Design of teaching materials with LAC scaffolding strategies
e.g. vocabulary learning support (L1 equivalents, glossary, vocabulary log), “Language Corner” with language support (e.g. useful connectives, sentence patterns)
(iii) Lesson design with generic and transferable skills
e.g. a reading strategy “Persuade, Inform, Entertain” (PIE); writing introduction and conclusion
(iv) Learner diversity is catered for with tiered worksheets (with different levels of support)
(v) Facilitating students’ transition from primary education to junior secondary education
e.g. pre-S1 summer bridging courses/programme, focusing on instructional language, common question words, self-regulated learning
18
(b) Micro-level analysis of classroom practices
English and content subject teachers incorporate LAC practices in their daily teaching (i) Content subject teachers
Vocabulary instruction: syllabification, word formation knowledge, explaining with synonyms, everyday language and/or daily life examples
Grammar instruction: teaching of nominalisation, passive voice, modal verbs
Sentence construction: provision of sentence patterns
Paragraph/text construction: using connectives as cohesive devices, demonstrating paragraph structure
19
(ii) English teachers
Vocabulary instruction: pre-teaching or recycling subject-specific vocabulary,
demonstrating vocabulary building strategies (e.g. syllabification, linking to familiar words)
Grammar instruction: making students aware of the use of grammar items in other content subjects (e.g. comparatives, passive voice)
Sentence construction: with connectives, using the context or knowledge of content subjects
More illustrative examples from the sharing of the two schools
20
(c) Impact on student learning
n Mean SD
School administrators & teachers
1. LAC practices help students learn content subjects through English
184 3.56 .88
2. LAC practices are effective in enhancing students’ English proficiency
*25 3.72 .74
3. LAC practices facilitate students’ transition between key stages 184 3.52 .93 4. LAC practices help cater for the needs of students with diverse
academic abilities
185 3.39 .96
5. There are no problems arising from practising LAC 185 2.98 .98
6. Overall effectiveness of LAC 184 3.48 .80
Students
7. Students’ recognition of English teachers’ teaching of academic language
3289 3.41 .91
8. Students’ recognition of subject teachers’ provision of language support
3284 3.44 .85
9. Students’ capability to apply English knowledge and skills to other subjects
3285 3.32 .89
*only administrators were asked this question 21
III. PROFESSIONAL SHARING BY
PARTICIPATING SCHOOL TEACHERS
22
Sincere thanks to colleagues from …
TWGHs Mrs Wu York Yu Memorial College (東華三院伍若瑜 夫人紀念中學)
Ma On Shan St. Joseph’s Secondary School (馬鞍山聖若瑟中 學)
23
IV. RECOMMENDATIONS
24
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS TO EFFECTIVE LAC
25
(a) Collaboration between content subject teachers and English teachers
“more collaboration from other departments is also a facilitator to the whole school approach for the LAC practices” (45ADQ2)
Benefits of collaboration:
- teachers achieve a shared understanding of the nature and purpose of LAC and share their experience
- English teachers and content subject teachers are willing to open their classes and have professional exchange
Possible factors to facilitate more collaboration:
- a student-oriented mindset
- teachers’ personality and attributes (e.g. being open-minded) - a collaborative culture in schools
- content subject teachers’ language awareness
26
(b) Leadership/involvement of senior management
provide a blueprint or some general direction for LAC development
provide administrative support/arrangement (e.g. collaborative lesson planning, peer observation)
manpower support: additional teachers to reduce teachers’ workload
organise information exchange and sharing seminars
psychological preparation: help teachers understand the significance and purposes of LAC as well as the school’s expectations and requirements
school leaders’ attributes: a strong belief in the benefits and importance of LAC for students; being supportive, open-minded & flexible
27
(c) External support for LAC practices
professional development and training provided by the EDB and universities (e.g.
workshops, intensive course)
28
Overall recommendations from the Study
1. Schools should plan and implement LAC practices according to their MOI
arrangements, school context, student intake, teachers’ expertise and resources available.
2. The Study observed the important role played by the LAC committee/task force to coordinate a school’s LAC practices. It is important for the LAC committee to involve teachers of different departments who understand the curriculum and needs of
different content subjects.
3. Schools should consider how to extend LAC to the informal curriculum.
4. Through providing bridging courses and tailor-made teaching and learning materials, LAC is considered to be effective in facilitating transition between different key
stages.
29
5. School administrators should provide necessary support to facilitate teachers to collaborate to promote LAC.
6. Teachers are the key agents in any educational initiatives. Teachers can attend professional development workshops from time to time to update their knowledge about pedagogical theories and practices.
7. Considering huge learner diversity, LAC may be an effective way to enhance the effectiveness of EMI teaching for different groups of students. It is recommended that the Government should provide continuous resources to support LAC.
8. The Government may consider stipulating a percentage range that extended learning activities (ELA) could take up in the curriculum. This may provide more flexibility for schools to have more holistic vertical and horizontal curriculum planning, especially for schools with huge learner diversity.
Schools should be reminded to continue with their efforts in promoting LAC and supporting both teachers and students to overcome the challenges involved in EMI education.
30
Good Practices on
Language across the Curriculum (LAC) in Secondary Schools
TWGHs Mrs. Wu York Yu Memorial College Dissemination Seminars
18 and 25 June 2021
School Background
According to the fine-tuned MOI arrangements, English can be used as the
medium of
instruction for non-
language subjects
in most classes.
Phase I Phase II Phase III KLAs Preparing LAC Team Forming LAC team Expanding LAC team
Administration Vice Principal Vice Principal Vice Principal
English 2 resource persons Panel heads &
1 member Panel heads &
all members Humanities
(Geog, Econ & Hist)
Panel heads Panel heads &
all members Panel heads &
all members Science
(IS, Phy, Chem, Bio)
1 Science KLA coordinator
&
IS Panel head Panel heads & all members
Maths Panel head & all
members
TOTAL 4 12 32
(65% of the teaching staff)
LAC Team Members
Our Beliefs
Whole-School Approach
Each teacher is a piece of the puzzle
Cross-curricular Writing & Curriculum Mapping
Form Term English Geography History Int. Science
Cross-Curricular WritingF1
1st Chp 1 A Fresh start
Chp 5 Out and about Chp 1 Using urban space wisely
Introduction to history
study Scientists
(Nobel Prize winners)
Geog + English Common topic:
Urban land use 2nd Chp 6 Hong Kong
Stories Chp 9 Taming the sand Topic 2 Traditional rural
life of HK Food labeling
History + English Common topic:
Traditional rural life of HK
F2
1st
Chp 2 Arts for all Chp 4 Incredible
people
Chp 3 The trouble with water
Chp 4 Scramble for energy
Topic 1 The
Renaissance Air pollution index
History + English Common topic:
the Renaissance
2nd
Chp 8 Going green
Chp 7 Extreme nature Chp 5 Living with Natural hazard
Topic 5 Growth and development of HK up to the early 20th century
Acids and alkalis
Geog + English Common topic:
Energy resources
F3
1st
Chp 2 Healthy body, healthy mind Chp 3 The best jobs in the world
Chp 2 Food problem Chp 11 Changing climate,
changing environment
Topic 2 HK in the 20thcentury
Food (Bio) Digestion (Bio)
Bio + English Common topic:
Food & nutrition 2nd
Chp 7 Our beautiful planet Chp 8 The world of
the future
Chp 5 Living with natural hazard
Topic 1 Major
achievement in the 20thcentury
Geog + English Common topic:
Global warming
Cross-curricular Writing
English English
History Geography
Biology
Cross-curricular Writing
F.2 (History + English)
“ If I could travel back in time to Europe in the Renaissance… ”
Sample of student work
Good morning Principal, teachers and fellow schoolmates,
I’m the chairwoman of the History Club. This week is our school’s History Week, so now I am going to give a speech on an interesting topic in history.
Have you ever wondered how people’s life was like in the past? Have you ever wondered about how art developed over time? Have you ever imagined that you may meet the famous artists in the past? If I could travel back in time to Europe in the Renaissance, I would want to meet Leonardo da Vinci most. Leonardo da Vinci was a “Renaissance man” and he drew the Mona Lisa, the painting that was so famous. I would ask him why he was interested in painting and which painting he liked most.
Of course I would show him smartphones, a camera and modern paintings so he may know more about our life nowadays. Lastly, I would watch his paintings, ask him to draw a picture of me and also take photos with him.
Learning history is useful since you may know about the interesting life in the past. Are you interested in history? Want to know more about history? The long-awaited history week is held this week! What are you waiting for? Let’s have fun and learn more about history through the activities in the History Week!
That’s the end of my speech. Thanks for your attention.
“If I could travel back in time to Europe in the Renaissance.. ”
Sample of student work
Good morning Principal, teachers and fellow students,
I’m the chairman of the History Club. This week is our school’s History Week, so now I’m going to give a speech on an interesting topic in history. The topic is ‘If someone from the Renaissance could travel to Hong Kong...’ Of all people in the Renaissance, I would like to meet Columbus most. This is because he discovered America during his voyages around the world.
If I could meet him, I would like to ask him a few questions. The first question that I want to ask him is: why did he have the courage to travel around the world? Had anyone encouraged him? The second question that I would like to ask him is : what was his first feeling when he discovered America? Was it exciting or touching and why? These are the questions that I would like to ask him if I could meet him.
If he could travel to Hong Kong, I would probably take him to a shopping center and buy him some clothes that he likes. Second, I would have a Star Ferry trip with him because I want to let him know the design of the modern ships.
Lastly, I would take him to my home and have a party to celebrate Columbus’ arrival.
Also, I would show one of the modern inventions, the mobile phone, to Columbus. This is because the mobile phone is very important to our daily life. I would like to let him know the importance of the mobile phone and tell him about the functions of the mobile phone.
This is the end of my presentation. Hopefully more people will join the activities during the History Week. Thank you!
Cross-curricular Writing
F.3 (Biology + English)
As chairman of the Student Association, give a presentation As chairman of the Student Association, give a presentation on how to improve the food in the school canteen.
Sample of student work
Good morning, principal and teachers. Today I’d like to talk about the importance of healthy eating and how to improve the food in the school canteen.
First of all, there’s a great variety of food we can buy in our tuck shop, such as rice, noodles, burgers, meatballs and snacks. However, some of these choices are unhealthy. For example, instant noodles, luncheon meat and potato chips are highly rich in fat. Although they have high energy value and can release more energy in our bodies, taking in too much fat will cause us to be overweight and have high blood pressure, heart disease and diabetes. Besides, ham, sausages and potato chips are all processed foods. Colourings, flavouring and preservatives are added in these foods, thus they havelow nutritional values and may cause health problems too!
Therefore, we should improve the food in order to make students healthier. I think the canteen should sell wholemeal bread and corn for breakfast, since they can provide enoughcarbohydrates for our bodies and contain less fat.
Next, vitamins and dietary fibre are the most important substances for our metabolism and maintaining our body functions. I have observed that we have vegetables and fruits for sale in our canteen, but I don’t think it’s enough.
For example, carrots are rich in vitamin A and can help us to prevent night blindness. Kiwi fruits and strawberries are rich in vitamin C, which can keep our gums and teeth healthy. I also highly recommend the canteen to sell these vegetables and fruits. Finally, we all know soft drinks are unhealthy. I think it should sell some fresh fruit juice. It’s healthier and even more delicious.
To conclude, we should sell less food that contains a large amount of fat. Instead, we can sell more vegetables and fruits to students. That’s all I want to say. Thank you.
TWGHWYYMS
Cross-curricular Writing
F.2 (Geography + English)
fossil fuels are going to kill us! Help!
Energy resources - fossil fuels are going to kill us! Help!
Sample of student work
Nowadays, fossil fuels such as petroleum and coal are used in many countries. However, there are many
disadvantages in using fossil fuels. In this essay, I am going to talk about the disadvantages of using fossil fuels, and then I will suggest one alternative energy resource that can best replace fossil fuels in Hong Kong in the future.
The first disadvantage of fossils fuels is that fossil fuels cause air pollution. When fossil fuels are burnt, pollutants such as sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides will be emitted. These pollutants can do a lot of harm to our health. For example, we will have respiratory problems, poor lung functions and coughing. Acid rain also makes the quality of land and water worse. It makes the soil and the water become too acidic for plants and animals.
Another disadvantage of fossil fuels is global warming. When fossil fuels are burned, a large amount of carbon dioxide is emitted. Carbon dioxide is a kind of greenhouse gas. It absorbs energy and keeps the earth warm. It will stay in the atmosphere for decades. Therefore, an increase in carbon dioxide results in global warming.
The third disadvantage of fossil fuels is water pollution. Sometimes accidents may occur when extracting or
transporting oil. This may cause hazards to the environment. The serious oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010 is a case in point. Huge amounts of oil were spilled into the ocean. It caused serious damage to the environment.
On the other hand, wind power has a number of advantages compared to fossil fuels. The first advantage of wind power is that it is clean. Wind energy does not pollute the air like power plants that rely on combustion of fossil fuels, such as coal or natural gas. Wind turbines do not produce atmospheric emissions that cause acid rain or greenhouse gases.
Another advantage of wind power is that it is cheap. Wind power is cost-efficient. It is one of the lowest-priced renewable energy technologies available today, costing between four and six cents per kilowatt-hour, depending upon the wind resource and project financing of the particular project.
In addition, wind power is renewable. The wind will never run out, unlike reserves of fossil fuels , such as coal, oil and gas. This makes it a good choice of energy for a sustainable power supply.
Wind power can be used to replace fossil fuels. It is suitable for Hong Kong in the future. The government may consider building some wind turbines on the surface of the sea.
Apart from causing air pollution, global warming and water pollution, fossil fuels will be used up one day. Conversely, wind power is more environmentally friendly since it is cleaner, cheaper and renewable. Therefore, I suggest using wind power instead of fossil fuels.
Enhancing students’ reading skills
• Short attention span
• Too many distractions
Reading
programmes
LAC Morning Reading
• Once a month
• Reading worksheets for senior forms
Objectives:
• More exposure
• Connect subject knowledge with
language learning
LAC Morning Reading Day 1 Morning Reading
• F.1 – 6
• Different themes
• Different genres
• Comprehension questions
F1 Arresting an Artist
A new school Facts and Fiction Board games are fun! How to be happy Cash ‘wasted’ on new coal
plants Dear Future Generations
Sorry
Fun for the whole family Pokemon to the Rescue The invention of the
Computer Nature vs. Nurture
China named biggest IP
thief Essential Creativity
Longevity Pepper keeps customers
in line F2
Life on the Seine Return to River Town The story of the Aral Sea The first year of life Wild weather
Siberia’s medical train The Easter Island Statues
F3
Summer outside, winter inside
Visitors flock to local diners Climate change attracts smog
Waste bag scheme
Whale hunters face new weapon
Walking for organ donation
“Meal on one plate” too
salty
LAC Morning Reading
Senior form sample
Free Lesson Videos
Criteria of choosing videos:
• Length: 3 mins – 15mins
• Subtitles preferred
(not auto-generated)
• Clear narration
• Suitable level of difficulty
• Moderate pace
Spelling King & Queen Competition
LAC Vocabulary Logbook
LAC Vocabulary Logbook
Word Form Transformation
LAC Vocabulary Logbook
LAC Vocabulary Logbook
LAC Vocabulary Logbook
English iZone
Recorded by the NET
Picked by subject teachers
Encourage subject teachers
to use iZone
Skills Building:
Graph description & Writing definition
Skills Building:
Graph description & Writing definition
Skills Building:
Graph description & Writing definition
F.1 English Bridging Programme
• To equip students with the ability to learn
content subjects
(Integrated Science,
History, Geography)
through English
Class-based Drama Production
Date Day Class Subject Ts Eng Ts
1 1/3 D6 3A Geog Lai KW Ng CY
2 9/3 D6 3B Bio Ng BC Lee YH
3 20/3 D6 3C Hist Wong NC Cheung CK
4 28/3 D6 3D Phy Ng SL Yeung TL
5
13/
3 D2
2A Hist Lam SL Lyons
6 2B IS Chan KY Wong KM
7 2C L&S Wong YY Wong KH
8 2D Math Wong YT Lyons
9 2/5 D6 1A Hist Chan TL Ng YK
10 10/5 D6 1B Geog Leung HP Sum KW 11 21/5 D6 1C Math Li HC Shum PS
12 30/5 D6 1D IS Lam KT Chu LY