臺灣的綠色創新組織初探 - 政大學術集成

全文

(1)t *-if J!i.t: 8(2) , 1\ 86 ' 9 j]. 99-124. :. 99. een. ~ ~~~ a~ ,*Jfr. ~ ~111Jf #Jl ~~ ~J} J~. r* ~ afJ **. ~1i ~ At *. climate on. ~. ;Jrij. es on the. nal ethical marketing. ~ fe 4~:fi J!1~ *~ "t ~t ~ m.. ;r}] .*ft.. e. ilJ ~if bi] -. ft ' JlIJ. 't -+ Ji 1: ~ ~}i ;F T5~ 1'JJ bi] ~IJ. tiring the. I h'~**~~~e.~.~~+.~~t¥a't.Ji¥ff~~~*~-o~. te that the. ~~ ~~~k~~*±~,*~~~~.~~~r~*~~J~t-+~~,~*. late, and. . ~ ~ tHif 4~ 1J1. ~ J! i1 f\lHi] n~ 1:¥:. 0. rance, [he climates:. ~ ~ ~r:fi n~ r .*~~. e. ~ -t J. e.:fi :r-~' , 1£ i1! ~Jf %r;UJI. ~ ~t m.. bi] .li ;r~ -J- -! : ~.±. it. $~ r ~Hif 'if if J bi] ~Jf % l~ 3t,j£t ~. !11t BJ] ,t'k e. tHif fIT ;t -J- bi] .~JI. t~ Ji{ it JlIJ ~. ~'. 0. *. ·1 ·m~·~W·*~*'«~~+'N@~.li~.:fi~*~.~~ •• ~.. 6j eJT ~. ,. t\ it tJ:. m~ -* *:it:#- ,~~ e. iHif bi] §:3,. 1~ - :fJ] ., bf] 4*. 1.. an, 710.. Dlm~~. : 1"'k e. tlJ ~if. Jf Jt if Jf. ilJ jif 111 ~. Taiwan, lLWJ. ifrJ\.~WH~~fftitf~ pJT ~ljf~ t§t. ··ffJ1:Ii JJ CP ' L' f4t~TI;ff*~ff. J-i{ 1~ *~ :f. H. 0.

(2) 100. ~~~M&~.~~.,~ft~~~~~m~~.ffi~m~~~m'~ 11 5M~~1f[j~M~!flf1i{H1~ftfm'.1~. 0. B ;§t i:J ~ ~ ~ ]I fl~ ,. PJ ~ iii ftj ~ 19. ff @] ~~. gr.5j ~ ~ 1}. mrnt. it( Carnegie-Mellon *~~{~~t ' ~~ § 0. ~ * ~ ~ D.Navin·. Chandra(l995)J!~ '47CftfrH~~-=iiB~IU~~ 'ff=i:JWI ~ fJX~Ifl'. ¥U:L} =i[.. 2005 4l:t*~1% 1 : 1 ' m!itt~ftfr,~~~g~~@]~~~i!E)}ffD~~S'Ji!E!l - tJ. J. ,:e;:f'l1Jf4~~Jb~If4~jhlfJX1%iTS'J~~WiF±~rQ~~. EHtt. 1987 4~~~f~~%tmJ:*~~~. 1. 0. •. ft{rHt~~** J. l.-J& 1992 if:tfl. *~l~MfJ!.:g/jfjt~f*~~~~'H&' 1 7j(*I~mJ: J 8~ft~& 121 ttt*c.~f~ J ~~i:i*. ... ~~~~o~~~~~.m~~~~~~.·m.~·.~~~- ~ S'J~.. o ~-=. ~.~~'-.~~.~~~ffi~.~m,.~m.m~~~. tt'~~.ff~~~~OO~~.'~iTJ. ,~m~s~~.~.~o. u. *~. Porter & Linde(l995) j~t±1~~.f*W~Ji~:1J~:lrS'J~~W~~~~i¥J. 0. T. ~~afi·~.*~~~A±'~R~~.~$m~~~.~$Mm*~~ *1 .'$.k~.~~~~S'J.~~e.,~m~~~~iT,~~~e~~· ~ ~ffi' :lr$~~~ li~!thz~*~ff-. ,. J!ff~ti!!flJmmCM. e.:1J ' M. *~. ,. ' l.-j 1 tHjggfjif J. (offset). PfTt).;g:~gl.-j~~S'Jf~~~~i]I~~~aljfi. ~g~~~fii@ • ~{i£fJX*. /jfj.~we.1.J~flffl:j. {~8~&tJt:~fJl l.-Jt~1~. .. 0. f~f*3tt±1. '. 0. t~1JD. .. m~~Di:lD{Jfg{. ~1j~gf~~~J!: fi. {-t!!fr,~t~=+1L*8 . 1iffi~1J*~~ifffi~IWi·· 1. ~7j~~1.J. t~~f~AgfjiT!'t':JlirJj. /jfjgfjif~mJ<f1ilil'h~~(differentiation). ,. J (resource productivity) OJ ,. jJ!~l.-jW:~~QQ1f)l1~~ f\?jfU. :;fu.¥!1Eii§:!tJJlt{*~vrqWmH,£. E~~.~~m~A+=4+=~-Bm/jfj~m~=~ •. E4=~ 8ffE +-t*~~pJHmi&J$gg. o Jt~]I~;f§;~~~ff+ -=* '. ,. ,. •. 0. S'J$~'¥ A+. ~ ~t=sE+7\f4~~D ~f~mIi~ ~*. m~;f§rmi1:Di:lDff7\+1L{4. ;g:t~ ta ff.1*~~~1% fJXJ}]W: ~glj ~ ~-fI. h,~~~mwa@.~~~~.4* • •. '. '. ~ PfT{~l:t$t§M'*. ~fj ~ ~~. m ~ ~ 7 f§'i'®gIJ~ lig. &• •. ~.ffm~~*z - o~@ 1.

(3) ~.::..'. fn't If.) .~ e. i,J;tJf #.11. t.':'HJJ 4* . 101. ~~ ~~~~~~~,*~~.m~.~~~.~~.~.~0~'~*~.~ ~iJiT WMi • • ~rs'~fUJ{* ~ E*'i::fY. i:Jtil 1*'i t; lavin-. I:L}. I. .. 0. Wrgrj~~!J.J. {El. Jl;-*~SA~®.~grj~PJT~~~*J3.~~~51iJr.16Y. et~ t)JJ3.*IfHMpx~E.J1i~*. ''j (technology). : ffd:~~~. 1£ ~ {ttx@ $. ~~~9~X 0. ~lIt. (social structure) , EH~ (goals). '~W:t3 (participants). E~ m*'i~ {~f~~ ~. .VJ?frB"Jf*gi. ~~9H~frm r.~1£~ J. '$~ (environment) ~=F. '. *. 'ti. . 1tt~ P'l. ~~ ~ · ~~ )jtUJ3. ~~*1tt~~ ~Erj iT ~f}~ W{ttx. 0. - ff~. 5f&JJ ~ ~~ cB'~ ~. ,~Jt ~ ~lJ #Jf a~ 5t ~ ffit. -?7Jf 1E ~ {l. i\ '. ~:ff l. *m~ffiMr.~~~ J. ... .~~r~*E~ m. J ~r~~~~aM J ~ft. *m#C.{~FtJ~~~if€~o~~fEgljiT. 0. - liR'rJT1i'i!1. r .~glj~JT J. PJ §1'E~illt.:::fI. iID :. v ~ 0. ~* *l ~ glJ. t J!R ~j§ffl. ) liT fiffj. 1. if ~ !IJ $fT A. iiJiM (incremental) ~~ r i~.~ J (shallow green) • m~~~tffif€~o~. ii~~~~.,~.~~m ft '~M,~.'m~ftreW~~*M·~~ 9J~t!i~!J.A*i10JI.H)WJ~EiPPJ o. 19~~D. :. . ::f~{ttx jd~N~~!J . ~fjglj~~~~¥!J[. cYx:"ff~±~1.JD ii:~[J!§ .. @lW~~~~o~§~*H4. '. !§~ 1,* ~!f.J'11. ~. r *,&e?;JioJ J. ~~~t&1P:H~~~ftW¥. '. 0. B. f'&*~~M(radical) ~~ r 7~.M J. .. ~.{~~~. •. J. (deeper greening) • '8l.-~ r {J' lI mi~. .m~JE~~~9:H~~~~o. 0. fZ9tifiliJ&ft{J'. ~j\ _! '. ~gifi!l~iU~!~~ ~ l7J. l .~. R~~.~~~~.~.,~~~~,m~ftreW~~~·~m~~ff.. r*. IJ[. J ~~. ~~ m 0~·ff~.~px • • ·~~~.~.'ffi~~.m.mo. ,Jtl: ".. 0. .. ~ Tushman, Newman & Romanelli (1986) ~~$. i~UiJ1Mglj~m/Z9Jtt~ 2!x:~1£*tt'l~{J'{'I{11. '. if€cTh;fOffi~~IB~. ·. , ij 1it8 ~.

(4) Sarkis (1995) B'J r ~~1t ~~~~ J (Environmental Conscious Manufactu ring. ECM) D.~~rs~ ECM §-a-1t. '. i7fj~5fit ~fflfffJfq. ,. 7~Y~ * m~~. , ~Ut. • • 'm~~.~~'~&m~~~@~~~~ • • ' . '~fflB'J ~~: o Jj\ND$ffl~~Q~\lfj~WH5f{ti(life-cycle assessment) i¥JfI!J{~ ,~ ~ ~ (reduction) ,. 1l!~. (remanufacturing) ,. 1J§I~~ffl(recycling. and reuse) ~ E. M. i¥J.~Ij!.o. 3. @] ~1l i lJ iiT ~~@~~~B'J.nWM~ff~i¥JB~,§m.~m~~~W.~' 1. ~~~~~m'~~@~'~.'~~M~B'Jm.'U&@~~~affi ~~. .n. o. ~§. Z ' ill ~.lHj giJ ~ :gIH~1: 1fJ ~ ~ ~ 6'1 ~ @j r ~ \lfj ~ WHJ§ ~ J. @J~ , ~ ~ 11* ~t)1J§Ia{~ffl. '. {i11L!I[ :f9~t~t~ 9~1:E~J~. 0. jf~ fJ.tM i:fJ B'1. 1:E 'f1Lt'. mt m :f ~n. ~ ~~*I~i¥JW~' 1:E ~~~B~~~.mm~~.w,~~mmr.~. J. ~ {4-' :tt:~ . W~@.glJ~'. ffl. r ~ 11*~iI::1JJ. '. rJc,\ 1t 1i1W~ J ~ r**1t~. ~Ji¥JD.~'*~~.~~@'i¥J~&o. ~ ~~ giJ~*JlJi~*i¥JtiJBi:m:fY. Richard Scott ~ - A. ,. E~. Thomas J. Peters '. ,~Jt.piT~K@B'J*JI.~dlHMfJ.t~ * &II~i1A~. EI3 ~ Scott i¥J ~ifH ~li 5fi1:$: tiJfJi:.PiT ~t ~ i¥J jt HV~ T (l:). 0. gt. '. I W~::t-. ~BJ3~D~. 1:. ~ ~ Wff firq lJ ijU5f l;} ~. .PiT J,):$:tiJfJi:~Jt~~ t) Scott( 1992) i¥J1ifltJl.*i~*~~A r **@.!'§'II J & r alj. ~'lKII. J. i¥Jfl!Jt~. ,. *~*W**@'EIJ~;f§fJ$J*JI.*,I;mi¥J~*. 0. Gladwin( 1994) i:l2 ~ m t±J t)*JI.*,II ~ifH* fult.f$1t. i¥J ~ 11:. i¥J~f~. L '. , W.. B~. B11JJ:t '. 0. tt*JI.~~JiJs1. Porter(1995) mt±J1:E$4- fi iiiL*~ T 1t.giJwr~ra' , t)rtJJ~tJ::1J ~f~1t.t~At]i{*. '. ~ ~f1B11JJ:t. 0. 1:E*Jl.m; §. ~L. ' -=. .. Hutchinson( 1992) ,.

(5) ~4~ '='M. ;'f ag !* e.:M Rlf #.n. ~ flJ 4*- .. 103. .8Jj Ilffi(1995) , YM~*(96) :acturing.. ;l llii..t~. ,~. Roy(1994) ~mt±!~*M. ~, ~ ftt. ~nU*'T!¥J~m1r.fffi~iIH. ~~& ~. ,~ f~lU~~Jt~)d~.. ;:',Iil,~. lLlI!Y /l1lI, ". .~. EeM. It~itti I @) ij~. '. ~~. 8m¥'Jf..!J<f3 r i l!Jt J. 0. '. 1±*JH~px~...t. '. m~M. Chatterji(1995) ~?6~'. '. r f..!J<f3~Jt~ J I¥J~. , jfj(JffWfil!1;'f:lIla~1'F ; Thierry ~(1995) ftlJt~~-@1}PJ~~.l't1±ii:. 0. ~~. v.± ,.-fx'=+'+. '':iR',[1I, ~R ~f:EA =Am {-'± .A. Y.!I. R, {f!;:,:(EA fIlll!;'Jm:;: ~:(!R ,'1/ =A'=j/l'("Mt'; \V!lOtt t=l ij'.lJ( § .1'.30 .... ,4:1 ?I'll IS ->.30rl] ii l!f!iiREl)(, [oijJll7\. '1';~'iI'r:1~ii)t,' JElJj.5!.ffit1if~ :3:'.al!f!~If;1:I 0. ~llJt. '. e::.. *~Jtj'C1MEl38f*~ ~ ES~iJlffT . {5IJBj1}PJ. -I.:~ ai::f-t ~iJlffTW~ES~f.ll!'&*Jl.*:QUM~FI3~I¥J~~{*. '. *- 1.. &m ~B'~ {'F~. rJI. ~~ l1ry. *J3.*l B"J f14 PX ~ ~at~(Structure). Thomas J. Peters/. *. I'~·mIi Fp~1}~J (1977). <7~' mif~~. ~Jt~?lt@t~~D liIl l. 0. ' jl. 0. *.;& -t- "*" ~ifti ~ W1f~. "*. , r.ftCSystem) , JgM~ (Style) , ~ I(Staft) , ~fijtJ(Skill) , * me (Strategy) , ~ roJ1l! (][15i(Shared Value). I~ r *~ t!:.. r. , *~lf~~§. 1}PJI¥J~jll'~:l:~i)~~W; Elkington(1994)~,g~iE: ~ ~fD. , "' j/~·¥U ilH~...t8'J~Jtj'C. ~m JJnJ. px~~M8~ ft ~. 0. ill -p, -y / \1i1: 1.><'. xttM ~. '. 1±li. 0. g: fffi...t J5X: J)] , £, ~Jr~ W:tt.1il!. 1} 15] ~ 1'1" f.fUJi ~ P'J *g; mtli.! ~ ES ElfJlffT I¥J ruJ 1* ft iJ. ~d, [. ~fft. ft1£~iOtErJfiH~l¥Jm~tt. I. ~ lj'i::f~liJt.~mt±l~~me~c~~1} E'] ~5~. , iffi~ ~ fF&~cx1fi{'F~JJ$ ,. *J~-*,ll X 1r. W1Ji m W 2. f~t±l1} 15J B"J ~~Hf!~-- r :f IJi~U¥ff 0. J. 'Hi. -OO~E']~~:fIJi ~~ ~~ =~~.. , ~ ~~~2X~ , ~~ 0 E] B"J JJ Hfu , :f ~ {ii~ 1m ~ ~ iI: 6"p ~D~miHh fiij ~ z ' {1g{r~B"JJZ1r.~;t ~ tJU*ff ,~ .lJIHHFoJ ~ 0. 0. W~ :t -·(1993). px ~. ,. ~~. m~W lfflU~. nl. -, w.. , ,. m~e. '. ~ FPJ im. ••. ~~~,~ . ~~~*,~mu~ ~~ ftmma ,~ . ~lj'i:o~ ~~~~ Mm. !¥J ~ • •• ' ~~ ~~ • • ' ~. ~~~B~~m.'~H~ ~ . t±lr~. mffd: . J !¥J• •W• • ' ~~.~~ · U~ ~~. ,& r~'J. w. Richard. ffd: fHMM ' *J3.*l PX. IScott( 1992). ,. EH~. ,. ~vrq. , ~~. Scott(1992) 5~ jjr.Jtt f5lfi B"Jt!tW~ ,. *J3.t.a'i. ~~ M~ . m~tt~ ~W ,ttUtt~K o *J3. ~ ftJH~iJ ~ ffl F~ , ~ /J\ , tE: *J:l ~ S"J gj3 f5-)J}j~g9H~!. @5JUB"J*J:lt~F,Mitl~) r ~lil& 0. ~. 1' I. 992) .. '.M~ JJ~ ,m* -@~ ~m ~§ Jlt9~ , .m :ffi :li~J1UJ:l *l ~ * Zr1~ li!liJrmJ 8 ' #px 1% *J3. ~ B"J~ ~ Z - " J. lKt :lfV. 0.

(6) 104. ........ .... ...... ... ~. ~± 1ff ;f.6. ....... ~m. ~. /. rt4. I. r\ , ·· · .~. I. ~" " EH~. /. px:~. ,...... ..... t~l$j. ~ ~. ". au *fi !. ~ ............ ". ". J;. -. .......... 11 *tiff~8~fiH~~f~cp $~. , !IJlH18~~9~ttJ;Jlf!~~r,§Jlli'F~t¥J~* ' ~D l! , ~ptjH~H,*0*~m~:w. "r,§J$UiHm"ijH~ Scott pJTm8~"ffr±@*,Ejffli"(Socia l 0. Structure) ,. ~ 7 Jl:l.¥ ~Jr1~8~ 1EH~'. Leavitt( 1965) l¥J JE ~ ,. , 1£;'( cP 1--:.1. rJHJli7'J l¥J~± fHEif~"*f¥}Uf II. ~± fHEitff6J 1--:.1. 5t gt;liJ[ i'G *,Eim(Normative. *Eim( Behavioral Structure) ,. lW~§fi5*Ji~8~flfj. 0. fti~. Structure) ~Hr. , miGWftEJ§. ; 1&~m iH*ll. ~ A l¥Jm~Wli~ ,m~~m'ili ~~~ff~~.l¥J~mo tJH~gtj~H~l¥J~fHl3.~8~~i'F W*i~:ffIUl~~~(Barnard, 1938;. o I. W~:t:-( 1993) v)\~K'&gtiE3iUJi~ffij§ ,. Mz/f ~.R1:fa72 rfi£. Simon, 19161 '. &~Jf)(JjJ *fY:J. A~ ~ m.l¥J~ A 'm.gt . §~~~'~~~'8~,tt*mff~m~~ ~ *Ji~ ~ flJ ~ ~m{*. '. ~m{J\. '. ~~~8~A(S takeholders). , t\t{F~ vHA:Ufl Jlt-fJl!L~ , tJt. .~I~l¥Jm~'£~~W0~M~ffi~~.ZOOl¥J~~Wli~oa~~ .m1 .M~ml¥J~.'ffij~§fi5~ff I ~M~l¥Ja~~~.,§~~~a.w . ~~. ffi ' 1£*tiff~cpMz~X* tiff~~~Z~~~ @~ ~'~7M~~ffi ~ ~t¥J ~!.

(7) 1~(~~~~~~~ . ¥m~) m ~~m~-~.hl~~ = +V~~E ~N ·. [g\!tWl~ . ~ ii @2g ~ ~¥~~~DM El ~nM'WlnfHjf~. : -~ [g \!tWl~~Cta~~ r iM.. ~~ij J ~.Hffi ( Yd3) £ *Hif~~fijHl.~lff-~-J~::m ~ ~m::lUdJ~::lY Ge~ ~ ~ \!t~. DM El ~HJ M' Wlffll!, it~ :. I. I. ~ \!t ~- ~4&}~,(112~Y~~m-. [g \!t Ele. I. *. ~¥ *} ~ J Wl~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Mff £. ~ - ~~~~~H '. I. Y. [g\!tWl~~Cta¥ !tff:t. *Hlf ~ kl! fH~Hn ~ .. ~~ ~ 31 [g \!t~I ~ J.~~~ [g \!t~¥'~~W'~.~~J~~~W o. I. ~~ .~. I. ~ii4~if J ~~*n~~~~. ~~~~~+g~~m~. 0. rW@~~!:f#n~ I. I. W8 1T~U~). 'Wl~~ ~~ J f-~~nMlJlHl!'. I. .. . iHfs .. (9L. *~~~~~~~~fHn,. · L{j:1M ¥tc;v ~ l&~~~~~M~Ef3. \'J,~!?gi~'itH0~±£~I§ EIlHiri£m~ ~~f~~. CW:~~Ef. ~. \{. : )o1fDtf f.. ~. CW:~~ ». 9. CW:iflMf41. r.JI. ~i~ ~ t. .1.zr4~~. NHifE(1lHI. 1M¥ W~. .'. ~~~f1M~~D:t~~~ Y~}~nfH~ . [g'. ~~¥~~~~~ft1~$8W~~J.~g. ~~Hif~~ft1~$~C?45f*~*m::f~m~~,(1 (v I 'Z 'S 8 :. ~~,~W. 4V:~~"" : "'. Ef. #= . •. tlJ~-};~ s:)d:). t:gJ ~-J ~ s:) .:D t:gJ~J.~ s:)d:). ~hl . Y! '. tlJ+}g} s:)d:). t. -~~Hl'qV.t. o ' '/~.. ~¥. ~. Wl~~Y W I. tltl t:1. ~. W. §ff. e£l. z fii:. :. D~. I. J!. fil!?iJ~Jl:~~ ri1f3i. t:gJ~~m±.oC?~\!t~V.·~ • • ~m*~fu~Ug~~$X,~m ~ W. ~~~~ID·~.~~·~*U~~~I~M~~.~t:gJ~~~~~~~ ~~~ o. ~ ~~ ~m~l~ ~l'1. i11:ffM. · Y! n~~:k ~m Y! n~ t:gJ;fI Ql jj'~:i'~ -. ~~ t:gJ;ff Cta i=~*i lit· . I4n}~ ~ :. ~~¥~~UYJi+~~'i!M~~ :)d:) ,(1lli£mfjbLUU~D}. 0. ft}~t±~~:k~~tlJ~. . ~a#!f; : ~1f*ii~ng.g&B~~$~t:gJ~':Hf~. I. .. ~!!*. ~~·m¥.@.w~~~·m~M·H~~·m::f • • :~El~~~~1. •. ~.~$~~8~~~~m±.~I~m~$ • • ~.a~.~~y.W.

(8) 106. ~~~~ = ~~~~B~~$~~IfFmftft~~,xft.~~~~~ .~~ ° m~~ ~~~m~.~~~~~.~~fi~~fi.~~~o. r.~~~J . ~~M$·*m~~mm~~~.~*~.~~·~ .ffi l ~~~ - ~lI$imo1<~ r.1*~~·J ~~ft~~ ~~~~.$ir.~~.J~~ • ~ ~lI f~. .. f&~9!iJ~~~ El J1~~. ~~p ~ ilt ~~~f~~ f;(q ~ ~~1t It ~Jjffi@]~z~~. •. oM~~~.~~m~~~*$ffi~ ~S_. . El J1 El ~~. * . ~. . §.~~9!iJ~m-*i: ~91J. 0. .~~~§rzg~ffi* non-CFC. [Zgffij))ffij. ffiU. rn 1~1ti{~lE:~~~ ~ ~ 1JT~DfiiI. 0. 4. ~mffiA~.fimrm.rzg.JWr~~~fiJMz~~~~~~·ffi ft~. 5.. ~ ~ m~~~fi.~~·~~W~~~~tt~~orr . ~*~·~.E$·. *~~m·~~ . ~ft~·~~~~r~mJm~~~~e·~~.m~ ~. • . ~lf ~T :91j rd] Jm : - ·*~ § .W~~~ffi~ ~ ~-~z~~?~lE:~~~n~X~~~~ ~i f~. ?. = · ~.~. ~. ••. ~~~xm.~~~~? ~ ~ ~ •. •. ~r.~ . mJA. 6.. *1. ~?~~~ ~ ~~m.$~~m~~?~ . ~~m.~~#~~ ~ ?. - ·#m@r.W~J.W.~~fi?~~~T~.W~fi.~#M.m ~?_. fr'~I fF¥-Ht~1il]. ?. ' ::t~~1¥.~EiJ*JT? §M1* m ~~i@i)lID! Ji~~ 7fIJ 81~iJfi*~ ? t~:fJ~J~"'~filJDJ ~JPX:JJJ ? Ii . f.* ~ ~Il fi ft: ~ ~ m¥U i:l fF ~ mil ? t:: ~~ ffJ3. ¥~ pg 9~ a1 lW· 1}'z PO {il] ~ *5 . pJT ~ r ~ Mffi J ~~~5J~~~~ii:~pB~f[t!m~ ;I~%~D1ilJ? [9 . lE: ~ tn#fil]f!l m{J\A~it. ~r~~J~r~ffiJ~.~fF~w~~a' ~ -ffi~ . ~o*~~.~ ~ w~ m*~~'lE: ~ ~~ ~ @M~~~~~~~~~ ~ x~~~m~M , ml. flj ::f ~ mJi: r~ mil. 0. mBJi ~O l'. :. UL ..

(9) m~ ~J] 4*. . ~A" ~ ':'. ~ ;t t1J .t! e.;f1j ~1T. tf 1; H~ II i9j. I. :$:liJf~)t~fj~0 P]ft* f( ~j;. 107. , )t~fj~fl1'f +A ' FlY fi'&5tfJTfj ~)t@ lJU 0 P] ~. t~ ~l¥J~e,~~*~1'f~~-#*~o. t=J iIlt'lT' ~~*, 71J. 71ffiJtHJ£ ~FC. FlYt) 1:E. IJT~D fiiJ~. , 1£:L}PJ§~~~~tf)tt:~ , ffiLEi -][1£~fijij¥111IfF , ElM inlHt 1f &t ~ $ p~ :l: ~ , {fl, EE ~ 15t 1'f 1£ lJU l¥J ¥ flllfU~ 3® , f-j r ~ Ilt[ J. : ,tW5 ~~~ij[I1f ~. ~~ ~~~fj~Mi. 0. 3. t: liJf ~ &fj ~t f-j @l ~ :L} PJ ~ ~ :l: ~ {i'& W~fj ,. th 1~ ffg ~fj r~~ fr ~~ W~ ~ ~ i'3~ 11'. 1. ~M~f-j~@.~~~~B3@~l¥J 8 $'.m~Wgw=~.ml¥J.. i '~~~rn~~.~~~~~,~@ ~e *WJi:l¥J~~o. t .$: !itt ~ B~ f~ ~ ~ II. r ~. ~ J. ~ 6'P'. r iT 3i tC J EU ~ , EE ~ 1~ ffg. ~a 1jllJ ~~ r~~~J ~f9U ,f-j~ rEIj~. !l '. fffilHf. ~1i~' ~ ~l¥J1e: ~~. U~ 8'J fflsa. !'Ci mltJf) 'filJ!f=ifiS , lr.O ?•. l~lJ _",LJ.A. UI; II!.:. ~ ill ~~~. J. mfIj ¥U. f:I §!l1il¥JfP~~~~{J11'fFlYfi~. 5. :$: liJf ~ FlY ~ gj l¥J ~ rQ] • ~ j£: 6'P l¥J EU ~ , 1~ fj ~ gj r ~ ~~ EU ~. J. r. 0. W r @] ~~ EU. f J~*~'f-j~.~~~l¥J~gj{J1~~~~,mm~~~~~ .m m.. f5 gU*'T l¥J f~ 7* mi~ wt~. 0. ~ )feBJ. 1£. r. 0. *. 6. liff ~ ffijJ ~N 1£ *JH~ l¥J E f~ ~ ~ 13EIj $iT l¥J'~W. ~. m~ j: iI: cp {J\. *Z. Fs~ l¥J ~ ~. J. l¥J;t f9iJ cp , OJ illl3i ff ¥U ill 1i. *. , OJ ffg ~ ~ ff~ T Jt 12: EU ~ ~ f-j. 0. " '1m ~ ~ ~ a Jt Ji ~ Ji 1%1t -;f. ~~fj.~.ml¥J = @)t~:L}PJcp'~~~Tl¥J=~m3i ~ ~K ~l¥J~ ~. ~'~ m:l:~~m~~~~'m][WrQ]~~~~Bo*~:L} PJl¥J.~~ ~~1'f K. ' ~ r ~1:. ~iJWIMl¥J=IA~t:;A. ' ~ ~ jtl¥J:l:ff~ ~ ~*~I ~ ~l¥J~Jfd&~ , 75%B~. f~~ ~~m o§ ftl¥J.~~~ . ~mKtC~~'th&fj~~l¥J I ~A ~ o~T. Wk~ ~{i'&$tf)m~.~.IMAfttrm.cpl¥J~m~~'~=~l¥J~~EE ~j£: $ ~T'~ .m~~j:~$~l¥J~0~~m . m '~~.~ I ~l¥Jm~ o* . 0 PJ. Ji:f§af filJ ' 1B.". IJMm& f1Hl71UtU~ 8"J liIiHs i'3~ i';j ~ F~ Jt l¥J Ii f~)J~, f3i: ' ( e$ PD~ 3). 0. ~ ~ IJ {* ,~ (ll ~:lr 8*1 FJ:!. *.:y.

(10) 108. t:lillf~T. 9 .~5J. B::~ 52 ~. ~1l 25 ~. 1050A. 5893 A. 3650 A. 625m. lOOm:. 306~. 176 i1. ~. 955~. 520~. 2,7%. 2.3%. *IOJ~~. *~tlU~. flfjjjlUIH&l. fJX:lz: B;¥ r~~. ~~7~. ~~65~. ~[lJ. ~IA~. 35000 A·. 3217 A. 1f~m. 408 fl··. ~. ~. ( 1995). 117~. ~1f~m/A / :tf~m. liff~. 1943. 3,5%. ~1ll. 5%. 373 m:. 266f!. 1:~~~o. ~~fi'. *11 , @IAmH&l. ~§.~~o. OJ< ffi '. ilU~. ~f*.ijl13L. !If*~~fI. ". flI f* ¥ 1ll ~:lz:fK¥ r~~. 83 ~. @AiilU~ I ~ I f9j$ ·. 7Fl. -. I. 73 ~. -. 88 fI. *~cm!..~&l. *. 484 ~. I. 2,7% I I. 86 $ ~.. ~HCm!.lIU&l 1 iJJ<ffi'6tRfI OJ<ffi ' 6t~1II , lIf*rtHm~ ~~tffi !Jf*~ ftt 82 ~ 2 Ji I 84 ~ 4 Fl. ~ ;f4*7@: (1)!j[,$U1Hz' ~~85~6Fl: (2)~litf~. • A1IU~$r~ (1'gm:T»1li~jt:fttr~ni~8h ' ~oi't5F~) flff ~I*11500 A .. 83 ~fl~ a]tt~m~ 39,9% ' NP 149,6 f!~~~fi~~o~1ll (gi€i5F~W~ 1tt! 11U~~jf~~!;l). Star ) ~. ~$~ f. ~ i;1f. rI ~1. ii1'F ~[. Im ~. .ro9lHi. 0. ~ @*0PJ~~Aa~Ma.0PJ~$~I~~.~~~,u&a.~~ ~~. (. ~£~W*~JIA'li*0~.~~~7+A'~~~+@A~~m'~R~1. &JJiIfl1l<4 Ji '. ~O. :~4. 0. ' tt. .. (= ty~. ~ ~JJ ~. *fI:00PJ. ~. WI. 1I~i§j~~~~~ I~~H~~. ~~~HfAU~~. mU!41i 204 164 124. JJi~4Jl ~tr:. ~ ~ ~~. ~~ffl)W~. 154. ~tr:. fffif. m 11. gr~. ~~tm~JI. ~tr:. {:J. i!fl. "T. 84 204 144 194 204 15 4. 34 84 15 4. ${~ t1HjHfH~JI. o1<*§~~~~ ${~~~~~~~. ~ . 0. PJ ' ~{~*~tiffi~~5H~JI. II~~9:Hg~*~J-'. c= t" if.! ¥j. n:. f~. CFC. ~tr:. (Q. ,.

(11) .," t-1f; .:..111. f; ;rf If.) tlf;. @. ilJ -alf jll. ~ 17] ~~. 109. - , @A ~W~~~!;1*~~~fiE n'~ 6] ~/jJ. 25 $. 3650A. -~~=~~~=+-B,~~.~~~m~~ffa$~~*~na~~A 1]iJ1}'H~ , W1*~tlJr-J~ EPA (~~!if:jH~~~) pfTm~1¥J r ~g1jz£ J. (Energy. •• ,ft~. 176ft. ~)~.~.ao~~A~+tB~g.ff~&~.~.m~£~. 484~. i~ '~M~*0~fi~~~.z~o~~~~~~mA*.m~£lliD~'~. 2.7% 86{j. * 11. fij ,. 7)t ~ .. f*~~ t. 25f 2 ~ 500 A ' ~W~{t!!. ~ ~ ~~~'.~~.~'ma~~£~m~~~*fi~g@Wm - ,W~~~ _$ ~~~~_~.~I¥J~~,~~.~~~~~m*l¥Jn . 'K¥~~~*~. . ~o~~~$'!i~~w.m.~~~~'~~I¥J.a~~~~~nr$. _~ ~~.~m.~.J*~~~-m~'m~.~n~~-~~,~~~.~. ~ ~~~~mo~~~.I¥J~a~8~ffm~~@~a'~~~~~~~ffm l .o~~~.I¥J.~~~W~~&~~-.,~u~~m~m~~-&~~. ~ ~ 'fu~*m~~~~~I¥J~~z-o. I¥J 5E~1?r ~ ~w:f§ ~ , -~fffi § ~ *1m~~iJ ~ ~:1J rdJ : ~IH"J~gy~: ~ ~ ~ ~ EPA ~fN*I¥J~* ' 'i21Hfi~ ~ ,}]§m g~~. ~ ruJ MJc ~ f~J~. ~~ ~~ ij~~if l. -;:2';. -.!i'!,. ¥ 4. (-). , fff~.~~*15t~.tJI¥JWHtiiflS.1R 30W (= ) ~ ~. aj eFe. lli tt : ~ ~ ~ ~ flS. ~M ~j. 0. , ffij ~ ~ f~ $1~ ~ ~. lli ~ tJ ~ ~ IiW. 0. (=)~.~~:~~ffl~~~~I¥JM~,~~:~m~ffl~*.~~~~~ ffl ~~~m'U.p~~~&ml¥J~mo. ([Z]) ~~*y1H~~. : g~H ~?~P ~ f*~ §. ,. .pm:1i '. t)WJ~~ .. 0. f.~U,El1[:t). .~. ~~OO'~.~~~ ~ '*&W~~,~~~~.p~1jI¥J~n'fffi~~ '-t &H~'~*. 0. =' ~;7.k*§i¥~!;1* ~~ ~m . ~ml¥J ~ . w~~I¥J~*~m&AD~.~-5E~g~'~.§M~~~ W ,* ~ , = #,~~,~ftW.~~t~0 ~ ~~~ffl~mo~~~~~. ~g~ R $ r'§J ~i 98% '. -:it ~ [9 ~ I¥J ffi~ 1§::!!: tt M -. ~ ~ ffi: I 0.2 % ' {Elj~ 1§:. 19 f5X f~.

(12) llO. 18.05%. EE~~pgm~px~~rsr1'*. 0. *m~~7~~¥Ur:p*~~lii ~~.~ . ~~ •. •. '. Ii JtijW ~~ ij~ft E3 ~1t{j~ ~~. , IT 8. 0. ~~~~~ W ,ft~afi~~~~-ftft~~- ~. OJ< ffl Ed~ (~fH§ ~ ~ ~ ffl-a- ~!! ~ ~)I ~ $i!\ 1t@R 1t ~m ~ i@J:frlitftirt 11 ' in-ftftE!if.t:fj ire~pg~Jtij§JRW~ non-CFC ~f~ , Mz~~t~ij£~ imtry ire '. ~ 11:. 0. OJ<~§~ ~ CFC ~1~~J!ii~~-~5t~.=.f~~fH~. 30% ' m=mt~~ CFC ~~&VltJ~J!ii {~ 1~~)&~ 1tU~(GWP) &fijtJ~J!ii W¥'HNtJl~1I1 . mB)j~DT. '. ' m-. ,. m - jl&~t~~ eFe '. ~~~~fj~ .~ ~iif~tJ m ~(ODP). *ntf~?JT~ ~ill~m=mt~. 0. mOJ<m ~'~. :. 7~~§ Y!H~ PX ~ ~ ~1J ~ RJ~ y;. ---; t~ft: ~~~;f;H4 ~ ~ 1ft:. ~ t1Ul&~IJ~~" ~ mJl&~iI~t Jl ~r:l ~ ¥H~~& i~IJ~Jt ~ §~A.I$. 0. ~f~r:p "~~&~~Y;" jl&~f~~~~ffl*itEt:J1t~mi5t)'!f~&* ' ?fTl-J-~ ~1 *~~'~~OJ<ffl~~I ~ W~~~*.JI~'.JI*~~M~~~~~' t~~{iEE*:;;AC~~~~m.m:rt:. :!§} lZ9 ~l$~JLt~m CFC ~~ng~~ t~ E EE HCFC-141 b TtJ~1~ &~£!~jfU±A.~~. ). ~9¥. s~f[j ~. ' 0. ,. ,. '. ~U-aJt)j~:d17j(~~. , 1@t:fJ~. 0. .. "tJr70~~f.H4" ~. CFC ~u~UJ~ tJ *~ 1tJ. tJ~jr1t ~$i.II ~!! m~. 0. '. lZ9Jtt :(f~. ~~C~t~~,El-8' l!. Jffi:~~~m~~~JlJ!¥\IIMz~~ ¥:r:¥:)&~8"J eFe (R· I ~. :t±*mt~ml-J- HCFC (R-134a) ~9l*1JDtJ~1~. , l-J-*ii~{~JtttlD ..

(13) ~A. 4. ~. .:.*.,. ~ ~ 9~.t!. e. flJ -.vr #11. ~A114*. !f "-llJf Jt: 1f J~ ~ 4t iI! 41i 1~t. ~, n ~G. ¥-,E3- B ~ ~ iffj a':J t1. 111. -, @~i1~B~ ~ 1*f~ntgtt ,~. ~~15Bi;J]. 1m~~ ~ JI1*4if~- ~ *-. *-5.. -. *~ 0. E~. 0. 0. ~ f~~r~. 0. 0. ilgMiJf~. 0. 0. i~~m~. CFC ~I ~(ODP) ~fij~ ~ ~n. @]~~Wi~~. ¥5~1:J. '. 0~. 0. 0. I. 0. ~*~!@:~. 0. ISO-14000. ~*4*7ml. ~.. tlT 0 0 0 0 0 0. flfUm 0 0. 0 0 0 0 0. : *tiff~. U~4~~.~~fim~*fi'~ ~ ~T~.~m~ A ~.~'OO )15 ~~s: 5~ o ~~. 3}" ~ ~. ;]ltt:fr* ig ~~1. FC (R-J2 ~~ f-j1l!l. im lTli ~ JI itW7t~. ,. fj£~A~ 24. A '. #~~j£~~7tt. 14000 l:.m.R1H~0 P]!3JHi~JEt!:lH . $~~ BM. 0. -:jl¥J~ J~ r~j§f;5fig7mtt¥Jffl1*'J. 0. ~1P-j1±m ll.J ISO. flfUm0P]~f~~ JJl JJH31-~. p;iJ\ ' 1*,[29~~0P]fPjjlU1IU~f&~~c~f~~5'I,tJDIfJT~ . *mH5H~~1£§~*Jt*fijt¥J@]~~~flJffl '. 0. •• ~.. 0. "0". ~0P]~@]~~~JJlI1'F. 1-~R.¥Jft0~HJt'*t¥J£m~ffl. ~ J1f tl T~ §t3&ZtfL*~@]~fEJflJffl. '. '. @*~0. 1± @] ~~W~. ~ . $~@ * 0~OO~~~~t¥J~~ o * ~ ·~TW .ft . ~ . ~ . m' ~M. .. !ifj(J'~Ii1*maffiPD. :. @]~~W 7~~. 'E!!H3i1JfpfiH~~. ,. 7.i:~9i~flfUml£ ~ *~. ~ *~!@:~. .. ISO-14000 ~mifiX~i5rtA.i€. , !i!1E1~~$~.1lL '. 111~f;!HJl1~. .. 0. ill. ~' fig. I'tt~,&~~.~.~.m~~o. =' ~m~ @ ~ w~;**~ @~ B~1:t'~ 1* 0 P] .~~~~0 P] '~ffi~~t¥J~~m~~~~t¥J ~ £'@1± . ~W. .. nH~;t ~ , ill ~j£ ~t¥J¥,j 'liWiI: ~ B'J~fJ3] , n:~A tt~PD : ~ 6. 0.

(14) 112. -. _- ,. @"":::0l. ULEt •. ~*m~~~m~.' . ~fim~. • • ~ ~ ~ ~~,. ~§ ~~o ®R = *~~tt ~ m ~. ~D, ®R~~m ~~m , ~~~. lli~ *~~~1. Mtt~'W~~~0~o ~.m ~ ~~ ~ *~,*m2~&$ *m~ ~ &a~m~~~.o. o. J.lf:ff '8~ ~. ... "~ ff 1f. ,~~*~~n~ . ~~o. ~ ~~~~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~*~ ~~~ ~~~~~~ ~~~~W~~*·. , ®R~mtJmt±:l k$J< ~~UfJT~~* ~. a. 0. .R ~ ~M~ il$ ~ nUEflPQ}. 0. jlj~ ~ ~ .~tR~~1r:' J;J&lxfII . OJ<m~a ~~~ ~ * ~1t, @ilf ~~* ~r?paWi~ffP il§lM ~ 1:R ~ 1f-~~ CFC ~~trJ ' tx~H~lQ ~WfDpjtf.~ fi~fNm~~ ~ * fI~ ]I! *JT ' t~ j)t~ ~~ ~ ~ & ~ o CFC ,, ~~ HCFC '!JH~&tt f¥. '. 0. mm!il. ~Ij. Wi - 'El fl. .g. 1'y J!ltJo ~ ~~~ffPil§lM~'~¥Ma~~~ ~* ~r?pJjJ~~1'If]I!fJT ' tJ iIlli. •. '. p,1j~~ff ~ I~~~g~~~N~~t1E~ ~ ~ .g~~§~H ~ cptt~gl1H-~. H'. ffiJ1iHfj~-§~tfR~@]~. ~tt±:lffl;f&~ii ~ e~~. 1~. f¥.. rm. , lliJlt ~ ~& ffJ. ~UWi . cptt~~ '.l~HI &~~ ~ffl. I11*oi<rfii ~ 1m D tt ~ ~p!JJflg _blE yj ~fN*~ ~ 1r:. )f[;~~.g~~Ha~. o. ~ ;f~. :1:1;. 0. , ~~ ljt ttUli 0. * J;J E!. ~ §,IE IUra m~ o.I<1ii I't]'L .1t ~ IHm.~ :f§ IDl ~ffl tx Wj , F.l. *,A!\t ~~Hg,u~1:~g;t7tpx7* f. '. fP.j '11 111 ~'11 ~/f [i3J. , m *"§'1~~ , EE 1n fl *ffii~trLtJ,. ~tiR~~~a~'®R .*. @ 0. ,~ ~~m .~: @] ~w . ~ ·. ISO-1 4000 ~mi1J ~ ~ ~f1Wi \ 0. ~!j. (Hj =. fhlH r'i'D~ Ijiji'; - ~~. f~ fJ --~. !f11 ' Wi 1 --~. 0. i!ij~I~ ~ ~~ . ~~§~m:$1*!i!I11 'lt 17J<~fii@ ~OOlH~5G~ ~~ ~.~ ,{g~~.~~~~Wi,~:~ m. -= '. 0. , J;J[i3J*If~~J3A~fiWi~ tTl fP.j T ~ tt -!!£ ' fD wu~ l1U~$J1. ~f#j~o. ~ ~~. 2trfr. 0. WfD¥{ll~l/J~gtt*il. ~ ' {g~fiWi WfB. l/J~gttfJ3. *i ' ~ BII~*i ~~~ B ff.¥,pxn!1ff.¥tt~w ~1II ff.¥ ' pxTI:f#j D~ ~ ~ , *~~~ mlF' ~ . *~il/f[i3JW~~ W T~[i3J~ D ~ [i3J f#j B ' 1El. ~ ~ ~ fiX: j{S-{fr" ~pt:1p. -::. . af* tfJ:g. , ~~ifrE~. . ~g * ~3]: J!t IUJ. .~ *..§. 1~~)f[;~a~. *..§. ~. ~ r?p ~ ifPil§l Wl ~ ~. CPU &fmf51~ ~.~ I~ ~~ :9~* ~fflWi~tl (HCFC) ~ JI!~tl3 jfi (~f¥. ' ®Jtt ~ ~ I~lE~#(k 'H~ fiIl :9~ Id~ B! ' ~ ~ ~ fJ3. 141lrflJ rJAl. ttl/J~g~ ~ I~. Wf B. Mi<@. jr '. -- -. /J\ ~. 1i '~.

(15) fRUrHIf I!#f. ~U!4 ~ @. [g0 .~. X. X. X. X. 0. X. X. X. X. 0. 0. X. X. x. x. 0 0 0 0. 0. ©. X. X. x x. x. 0 0 0. x. 0. 0. I. 0. 0 X. 0. x. oj X. X. lC. ltm ~if' Y ~ 13W7):Hi ~ M~~~[MHI. x. 0 0. 0 0 x. x. W:!II~#. 0 0. j;!1I. x. ~;f!(oDJf§J. l0tymmf. +QXE.lW;f EVE ". x. X. x. 0 x. 0. =FfJ -. M4Y M~ t=l ~ ' :=. X. 0 0 0. 0 0. X. fmJ ~WJr ~ t9l§~. 0. ytn~t1JI!. 0. f~?f.f. X. \d~!r , tlI. ;;;Jl;~. 9iHIDfiAt ~ fiU~nili ' Ea. I. 0 ©. 0 x. ytn~6:f:fiij. 0. X. X. X. i~ ;t. ~IHH5 bJW ~. m*< ~. .* ~ lfM. 'J'[te~ fu.~ l'! U~~. ~ ::n~. ~~ 0. ' -:. r~ ~1!. lII Hfm~t9~ m !if!IDt9l§~. X. ~El. ~g~1l~. [g0[gj¥. *. §"]. ,-. yt @. !ifif,t rli' § fJ3. sHI~f1l!t ~El}. I. . * ~:. o. a~ ~~~E::M: ± {~L X" : a~t1M: ~E:uf$ ,," ... : & ~~¥~J~t~E:fl~~!I'~[g0~~M*~ytn~~~*"©,,. L *D~if%i3 #1lY'. 0. itfjHj~l: 1. ~fti!~. 4l/. lliJ ~. fu~~I~~~.~[g0*W~~E:yt~t9~ ~ M:'*~w~~ . m$~m.

(16) 114. lm. '$~m ~)j m.~5~U~~lifi oo . w . r~.MJ~*fi,m.~ffi1I¥J~M' &16. ·~71¥J~~,a~~U.~.!1XUTI¥J$e:. 5:. 1:~. ~_ ~~ wr ~a6. J w~ a~r m~§. J. r5i~~ JJ'" J. ,mWI!. 0. f£*Pff~ffig~ = @.B0~oo~~~m'~m~~~ •• § ~i ~:ff ~~ I¥J~$W.$'R~~~I¥J~~~~*~WI¥J$ ~ ~* o ~ ~l. U!1X~~~~~m.)t ~ ~I¥J~ ~ o~* m OJ<ffl0~ili~:ff~~Z~' P ft$~I¥J~jg~T. ' ~~. $ffffi ' pff L-JM~~~~. non-CFC ~~f}lIJ&'~Ji~~. , 19.:ff~fiti ~~ :1. 0. 2:~¥M ~Wa ~W ~~~ ~a~~ ~ ~ M~~o ~@0~ •. •. 8. ~~~~~.~M m .~~*~'~M.~~ .Bft. J. it:*: ' ~f?g~~ , D~~f?gf£)t , ~~1!iff/c.'Ito.f£~1IrJJf?Lt Iilltt ' :(f ~.mMfiA. tlU~~ , ffi1.m:g,Pff ~ ~Fa~ f§&~iJillfi(f!M §.i. ~ mt WN:ff non-CFC l¥J~fijgfjgimt ' ~1tt~~1}~W1E7*-1 80-90 A. 4 I¥J Mf fill , ~EBj~$l¥Jtt~~., ' :;tjG!1X~§OJ<fflI¥JEIj*fiI f'F 0. 0. 0. -=-~mmM0 ~WY9.:ffWJjlU 'ilI ~t&:fe6t~ttfi/q :ff~mwr~l'?l,rtll. 3I!1XEIj*fi1¥J § ~. . *firft~l,l¥J~fiI'q. , -* m OJ<~§I lI ih lr;, , fgrr~:j~Jf.~tbbWJ1JD~ E1 c81~jJ Wrt ~. 0. OO.~.§~~*fi:ff~~$~~~I¥J~~'~~~8ID!1X~ ~~ ~ ~.'W~.§ m ~ffi.~OJ<mf£~£~~~~~~:ff:g,:*:I¥J~ ~ ' I~. L.

(17) ~~ fll) t~ tj'HH1l.~;f7J~. 115. ~-~~'±~~*o~*.B0~~~~~'±.N~~m~M~~·.~~. t·. &~ 6. ~~~I~;&~~.O.i<m~@.$~~ ~ .~.WR.~m*~M~o. 5: r~ ~~ J~&~-m~ ~~ tiMm~ ~M . ~m ~ W o. ,tm11 :fSiIa1l. OO*~~$~0~~~~m.pg~~ . ~m~ w ~.om~~~~· r~.MJ~~ff:f-~~~~fim.pg~~ . ~.~~o. 6 : lm ~~ MOA~ mmM ~ ~m 'W~U$'~~a ~Mm. B m*~ M Mo. fi1Zirt z.rf li*~.~~~~w~.m. : BJ3 • R:Ii! [ fiILj~ ?J~. •• $·m~~~:f~~m~~tiA~I. ~·~~m - OOA~~~~~M o .~~~·~~tt~~.a~~~~~k ~D. Jain & Triandis ( 1990) PJT~: r ~ ~~UJi . $Bl-{lLpx~ ~Jf!;~"~m. A~". . "~mA¥JJ"~~~;I;~ · fffl:f~{9U)7~~P3~J. 0. 7:m 3 fi ~~ a~m B ** M M'W~ M~ ~~ eg. ' mm ~~ itUifd~. ~ ft m~* m~ ~ o. IItt . tE~ ; 0 l'f] ~* ~ 9if ra,. .. ~g~~W{~ff.!~~gJjff~mWJ. Peters(I983). .. *trJf~~*a*:fD Marquis(1969) ,. l--:J.& Quinn(I985) ~trJf~~Uff~~~~$-¥~. 0. fX~~~*1=. ~Mm~r~~~n~ffJ~*trJf~$ili~~ • • ·ffi~W V . ~m~~~ ~ ~M*tt·m~~~~O.i<m~~H~~$. •• liffi ~ ~·. = ~ m B0~W. ~ ~ ~ m~~m~~*ttiliW~~AA~ o. ili tlf.; nim oJ~~ ~. ~. 8:*~U ~ ~ ~ *~hfiM~~ ~ a~M ~B.Mo ·~~~.~~~·B~~~*~.*$ffi. •• ~~~~·OO.$~. § 0~~~~~.~~~~·.~M.~m*~~~~~~*mM~~m~ ~. rs' *1~JE.~~ $~. · W15-~Jf~1r~* § .~~mt~w*tL n. pull) }~jt£ln~fS~~gfjff~ - @~j*n ;l:. 0. m0.i<1§@ ~ l--:J.pg~Fr~.±. El. ~~ N;1. 'fj .... I .. n IOJJ '}. . Wl' ..·. (marketing. . )1~U3. m .ili~~~~~~~~ . ~~~m~&$~~m·~7*~~~~~ffi. *t11J .. ~~:1t~~~~Qgljffkili_~~~mf ~. 0. •.

(18) 116. 9: iim jijR1a!JmtJO!~) * ~ fl *~. plI JI& B!J Jlt8 !iii ' ?Il.;Hi Pi r ~i~ ~ J. iliff. 0. m~S"J. m.~.m~~~.~T~ * ~ ~, ~~. ~ m ~ . ~~ ~ ~ .f ~ [QJ H~. 0. ~ lj. 2,. fEl. t~HM lJ ~ S"J 2J ~ , ~Jl ~ 1£ III "[QJ ID "S"J 3@J f~ c:p , ~ tr i§ ~ *Jl tl r. e.m i@J+ k Z ra~ 3m. ~~ ~ ~tJS"Jm.,*m~c:pM~MS"JM*~0w~r~~~J~ lr'. 7H~~ 1'F. MU ~ 0~W~ U ~M'ill~~~S"J.**~ A ~' 1£ . ~$ 6 g ® Mt,. {t~ c ~. fu.~*.~~~a ~ l£~~. .§~~S"J ~ . 7 °. ~@@DW~u~~ . ~m~~ - $.~*. E1t~ ~1~. •• ~ ~ . ~ .m. , ~. 1t~ * !%. -~~~@~~@@e~~~~ M ~T,~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~c:p m~~ ft~~. 3.. It:. ~S"J.§*~& ~ aS"JlJ~~*~W - @ ~~o. ~lHI. Jtt~IJA1i. UkM.*E:} R~ m. f,1. , ~1~ ~19. ~ r *".Us lji~ J ' r ~€S ~ ~ ~ JS"J~~T'~~.W@ ~r ~ .J ~ U~~ • • o @ l£~ ~ $ -~~m ~A. f'F~S"J OEM/OOM ~fH~ , ~fij~ --$ ~ rtD § IJr:f1IJ~S"J O BM iJl'~~~ !!lilt [ !f- 8i Wl ~A r i~.J S"JF;U~ , HW§cIJEU83.§.J1fr:f11J Ham 1 & Prahal ad r 1".J 1989 ) ~lS~ , l£~~\~Y1j;im ;lt/G§ ;i: :1JS"J!J{J\ , r:mfJl~\ImB3 r *~ .IiI J W r fij! J . ' frl 0~LT~ 1jB~ :1J ' f~ ~ I ~1jl1J :ffpfT~*j1 , ~ ff l£ ~~ . ff W!~~iJ r y~~~ J S"JgU~ ~ ~ El3 OEM ~A OOM S"J~f~c:p'. ' 1.;. WI 1Jx JJJ ~. ~!¥Jf,i ~ j. U&7R: . i!1Uiil. 0. 0. U'f.R'Jit. tEWl. t. MHlJ " (. 199 ~. 0. $ 't! L '. •• J. ~D. B 1/ ' tl"-F ' NEe. ~ , m =f iI * L>~ 7t~0 I§'] ' ~~ E fM5E. '~~~ ~ I~lJm~.L~~:1JS"J ~ ~ o. ~. A' (flWl ~ ISO-140(. tr.J[& - - ,.

(19) o. fPil}~~~ ni~~~ *if ~IY~fi{lID. '. ~42f. ~±I¥ M~ ~~ 2r} , $ili~G);lill ~~f~ , ~~!ID ~(:'1 ' m* Im~lftr!dGtS 000171 , ~~ g: G);l1f~ 0i ~ ~} mt G);l cP . Ef*:F):~} "II*Hff +.f ~ , c£(; bHtl;l ~ Eff~;2 *~ ~ J) [g ZHi ~ ~ WHIi bJHM ' :p:~ §{:~IHta :;jHlfHf+ If ~ ~ tt1f:.;w C£l ~ (:,1 ' \fl ~ illf m (1766 1 ) MIG);l ~m gt if:81~~[(j~}f~t~ , mmtGtacP ~m I. .. 0. ~ ~am ( 2:661 )uosu!4:)lnH. *. 1. 0. :F): ~+.f~~~,m . ~. G);l ~.~~8 ~~ ·~¥~ o. ~n~ifDq. [gj §i ~ ¥. '1. ,. ~~' cP~ ~~mE. ~lhg~lHf~jUQm¥f~ ~~ G);l~D~Im ~ :w ~fif~. , ~~l, ~ r [f;~R ~ J ill r ~ ffi!~ 1;3 J. ± fi ~ !i1Ul¥ 13* G);l W"f:r Di '. ~ ~*. JG);l • :m ~ ~iMW. ~. r i€ID J. .. .:u ~~ 2fl. 0. !fl 'i1J *'* J. ' infflfG);l~¥~ :;j} ii3t:B}' :1t} ~J ~ 0iGtaC{lWYHG. ,. 3,tHi~~IIl' r/2(!!M~G);la~ !rJ ~. ~~~:m ~ ~~~ m. '. ~ifj G);l ~ 13* ~D qY1. '. ~·~ti·. y. .G);l . ~~~MM '~M oIDaG);l ~.~.~ ~&.~.mfu~~ ~Y mW 0. r !l. , ~~~~3tr. G);l l:f~£f ?f¥m~~(:'1 fuillU~Jj!!BJ. '-ri!J][. ~ 111 iii WG);l "} cP ~ llIf ili,* oJ;t! (:'1 [g \} ~~ tg '(1. ~ ~' r ~.W. JG);l a~~.[g0.a o - ~~~*.~f. •. r brJ&8 J. 'i&~ ~ ±fi ~~IIl ~ ~ 13*~ 1;3 , .m ~Ht:~. o. r. -+g r ~ ~§fIq~ J YOq¥Yfig. ~r~~H§!'ifI~}' ~a. ~~ r~~~~ijJ l.f(f ~ ,. , Ehii~~ fib¥.l ¥ * (:'1 Yg' ,. ~ JOO ~~;@g4:l! lI1~ fi~ ~*- ~Y fig~~ 1f ~. 3J f:i ~ ~ G);l. o ~~f G);l ~n~'i&~~ m '. #JJ! ~ij OO $t'i& ~G);l {i~~~~. !. f,!: ,. ]~~. ~~~'.~ . ~N~~' ~. ' ~. ~ ~~ ~~'~$t~ ~ ~~ . M ~.~. illf. ri±a~~@ICfJ~J. ~?tn}~~. ,. '. r ~~~W~HlfJ. tfil~BWNG);l~~~}. ,. ,. '. r.tfh!~ W !.¥f~~~;f!J. [g0 m Ej3»2* ifID¥Ui(t~"&~ m. G);l liiE M: "&~*D~ , f~- ~m .a m~ \.14 :F):~~~Y;1 Yg'. 0. '. ~ff::~Q! [f¥ r~~~ ~~. 0. M: 2~~t··. ~ N3t} ~~t*). J. • ::;J IHill j'!i. r. , yt n~G);l. ~iID~eJ2 ~. #JJ!~#f:WNGa,,:;jy lIni¥ "Di"if~ ~~ ,, §t:tf8 ~~ ~n1~ ,~+@}m. :L J ~ Ef*~ ! ~. iff WH~t Di 111. .~~~ .~~~~~~~~ W~' ~.~WGa~~IY.~~~~NG);l~ ..

(20) 118. ~$etWA~~M,ft~~mE*@ . 0~WD~&m~~W~W~ ~~. $~~~~.~o@~.~~~Zffi~~~~~.r~~~~J~.~~ffi .~ ~~'~. 1:. 0. IJJ '. ••. ¥lfr inf~:. ~~*~~~~~~. ( 1994). ••. ~£~@~Wg,W@~~~~~ ~~~. ~fttf~fumi~~~R~~~. , ~~~5t~fHii~@]~~I1'F- B'9n. ~fhj1i!HQ~mg,gj- * 0~1NJi~El~lz:@~~~£*.mV. '. Thierry (1995) ~~. 4,. g,gjm@.M~~5t.~.,~ . ~~~@~~mm~~o. !~. "lf t't $ i. rq r~mz£J. .. r.~ .~ ~ . J. '. r.~. ~~:. •• j~~~.~~.~fi lffl. ' f.f~1Rji1£~~~~irj~*~B)Hi!~F}fl;~~~ o1ll!;) r 1iE7~Z£ J j;)& r ~¥-f.§1iktf J ~~~i&J1& ' *~~'~IUIill8'] mllJ. ~PJT~3§t±l*~~~lI±ft r~tU~~:f.&{9Ij,. ~ ~ ~~ D , ~~~m.~ . ff~~~~il~~.~a~'~.~~* m ~ ~~ :ii6~~ jlj~. 0. Porter & Linde ( 1995 ) t:Ji:!E1J r §)tH~#2~ii. J Blm~#~B tu;J. 5, ft. ~~,~w1£~.m®~m~~&&:iiMOO'~1£.~fttf~~~~§~~'~ f ~ ~~7~ •. •. ~~a,*m~~~~. 6m . ~M~n$ o§ M~WB~ ~~. WJ1£~*1JJ ISO-14000 ' ~~-.7}c m iJj~81mlJm' ~/J\~J3.. J 2~~ r 7j(*:rt~~/J\*J3. J. Bl r /iii ftujd'l ~ ~ m@ J. ,~{J;l,~~~. ' ~~fu*~~~. .;u:. '. r ~f*~ ~. r ~~1bk kl~ Jm~ ~ fJ J &tJO$1\. 0. r\lf4 ~ liJf. ·~ ~tJ. ·8ylinsl r ~E71*';z£ J ~g~H~~ ~ B"J~~~. ,. fo~m~f~a!M~*81t~U~:1J ;li ff~. , ft'. ~~~~~~*~ffl~m~*~~.:1J . ' *:f.&ft~~r~~ •• J3§~ o ~* ,.~. • • ~m~~~~~~m*, - noom~~~~~w . ~m~.~~~ ~. Jfj ~ , 53 - noo~!J~1Jo~m~!M~.~f*~. 0. "~~1*. ~r -=t-~. rTJ tt?'~~. • !!lZ 13 1=1..

(21) o~ ~ ~ @ tim~ ~ ~ ~ - ~~ •• ±.~» ~fu ~~' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ . ~ ~.~~r± . J~ ~ ~ :~.timM~~ ~ ~~ ~~ m. m• •. ~~ ~~o~@~~.~~ ~~ ID~-~~~~.~~ ~ ·.~ . ±. ~ ~~~·m.~m~gH~m~.WB~~~ . m.~.mWo~~~ ID~ .. -. ~ ~4Y •. . ~tl~G-aID ~. r ~H!1itil~[g]. J. G-OtlJ1~~M ~. ~~Y! n~~.~~ ~qf5. ~f. 0. ¥t~ r ~. . fffj Ii :r!J ~ ~M'. : 'hl1~ (~66 [)A'ISU!l h8 .. ~ ~ mmm~.~· m ~~ ~ $ ~~~±. ill . ~$o~~y~~. ~ @~ ~ · li~ ~ ~ = m M :mnf£ % fW. . WHl~1 ~ m[~'!;VJ'cjJ ~!I ~~~ I!~£nfi~f . ,rJ'cjJci.Hf!!itti . ID : D~ ~:z;i:: ~Ff~:l 5J,lf . ~ !4:)Bl!H • :::>30 • Y\lSJ : D~.~~~~illl . b1Jlff-t[fa~~@]ClJ ~ 4.. ~ ~ N ~~. ~* ~mH ~m~·cjJ~~·~. *~ ~MI~~~~.·. V. mfu~~· ~W ~ mMI~.me . ~.~~~~-¥MI~r~~~~J. y * oq~ r . ~. Jt intf~ J ~. m ~ tt?:8~29!D!f. ±YJ1 . f1Jl~~IY. ~~~. * *. :~nf¥ G-a. Ga~'bt:: I¥. .. •.. o. ~3i'~.~~* ~ lf!&~~m ~. ·~fuBm:z;i::~~~ W. ~~.~·~m~5J,lf~g~-~~0.~g·~~ ~. ~.J~. ~ ·~~~&~~m.M~illlo~ . ~~. • • ~~~~~ .~. ~ ~ ti. rti ~~~ffll.~ •.. r:1 B}. 0. ~~li~~. W ~M~fHW~f~ ~. ~~~~ ~ W4Y~~·~~~~.~~~M~W±ID~IDW~~· ~ ~~ ~~ ~. •• ~ M ~~·. ~~ ~~ ~. •• ~~~~~~~·~~~~~~~.$~ ~~. £@:1?J.i}f ijff .¥: ~li ~~~.E([l ~~ • ?R~ ~ ~?f;~+~ ~~ ~~. .. ~~53~~.~(,~~.?R~. ~ ~ ( ~66 [ ) AJJ~! o ~. B~@.m~il~EM~·~~o.~~~~~ •. •. ~ ~m W.~~.· f. ~B~·~~~~~W~@W~@~·w~oo~m~~.~0 . §o. ~ m. ~ * ~±@·¥~~~.~~~~.ti~·~~mm~~mfu.~~~ .~. if~MI4H@J~W. i. ±p.! fgJ ~ ~ [iJfff 4~. fXI';§*lin!#~~ r i~ 4J;l ±~ f1~ ~ 11l W~. 611.

(22) t~1: '~A~~':'''I *~ /t.J.~ ~;tHJf~1l.~4JJJ~. 119. 3. ~JI1Jtt.~f!!.ilj~ff~ Ri ~. 1J! rJj W1HHIHf 8':J 9~. J i¥JmffiU~;f§;i(fJ Wx: ~ (Itt} i¥J ~ f§] tiff i tiii~@]~~I {'f(fJ1t. ~R~~m.m~~~mffl.~'~Ba~~~m.tt~~*,~~~~~ ffim~ .o§ . 0~.~~mmoo~~·~mJ~mwa~*~~M~'~.i¥J. ~ ~ '.~~~~ •• ~$a~~~i¥J •• o~~'i&fi~~n$m.M~. ~o. J!I. ierry ( J 995). 4. t!l . ~f!!.5~.~. , iIJ ~ ~f!!.m t~ W# * t~1J. 0. m ~~w~~. ~ i¥J~ni'~JJ~~~.~ . B, m ~.§~ .~ ~ ~ MrJj ~~ ~sa§~~i¥J~~JJ,a~~M~m~. •• ~~i¥J~.'i&fi ft ~.fW~. 1. i¥JJJ . '~~M.~@~.~ . ~a~.~~~~, ft W~g . ~~~a. •••. ••. jf ~ ~if~ f'JiHfj. ~. ~~~i¥J~ . a~~ . ~ o ffii&fi.ffi~~m~~~,. ~Fm-~)&i¥J. _~ ~~'~1t.0&~-H~~W~rn~'ma~~.m~i¥Jm~ m Bm~,. 0. 1ElJ~. , a~1IU~i¥Jm liJ. i!J 1t ~ lJdfFf IT B9. J. 8'] tJDE v]\ ~E1i~ ,,~. lfT. a ES ~ fifty. , jTff 1. 3 mJi&J?1' 8 1R JJ: jg ~~ r. iE fjHIHl. ~ ~ fW J. &1Jo ftA. ?!\I~ ~::E ~ J!U!J<. § f€ J1r1. 0. 5. jt iJJ~f!!.~ ~~a{jM IB3~9 r~~Z £ J i¥JIW~-~M~;a~ . Bm.i¥JIW~ ~ m a ,~~mm. 1~ '.§~~i¥JIW~ ~~ .i¥J'~~~'*~~ B mli *~.~~ ~~~ .~ ~Ib@J ~~8']t5dl~J. ~~~4~ 1itf~~{J\. ' ffi~)7~1t~M. : IBM • DEC,. Hi tachi ~ , W E m ~~ ~O. :•. . f~t~l~~ ~6b .~If~ ~{J\8'J~ ~. f~ , ffi ::g 35ut\t j'f5¥r=:.~n\. -m ~~ . '~~Ammo~~ . m.~~~~ $~M~ m ,~ .~ ~~ m~ ~. , Bylinsky(J 995) ~§5t : ~ :f4~~rrr1i¥J ~flJ?iJJ m:~ ~. l:il J. .t ill §. ~ra~. ~~. 0. , 1; ~H'~. im~ a €S ~Ij $1T(f.J. 1 ~~ ~ ~~o~m.~. r IJIlJm~~:to/J J fe: ~i¥J1l2~ , fW ~~ -r. ••• ~m ~ .~a~~~ .R8'J. ~. M 'W~ ~.. • •• ~M@tiii°~?!\ *.~ ~~. ~m ~. m~' . M~.~~i¥J-r - ~.~~. 0tt ~D ~m ~ 8'J ~ W~B.*; ~~ ~r . ~J~~'~~~ ~~~ 8'J ~ ~tt. ·~~ ~ffi ~rn.~ ~.~~ - m ~~ i¥J~B @ ~ a ~ o.

(23) Thierry ~() 995) tiff~ CopyMagic ' IBM ' BMW. -=-*0 ~i¥J@]!&m1~} "'". . m~~&i¥J@]t1E*/J\~1'flJE . @]l&rtd~ , @]i&j~filtj~fu 1' :;ttti:iE ti'f ~ l{ fill 0 p A- it . j( ~ & filtH~Hfl. ' ~ [OJ ~ ~ IJ~Bl ~ ~Q l' fJUiJ t)JJU'iE)j, ~ , ~. 0. •. I. 1.. .~~ ~.~w.~mm@~·rr@]l&.~i¥JBn~~~~fi o ~~, . ~ m~ ~.~~~~~ . ·~~~. •• •. ~[OJBrr~. e ~·~.aa fi. w. m~[OJ .W·~T-~ .B &* . m&m~i¥J.*~~i¥J ~ ~·g~ ~~. ,. J.. m :l"~8'JB J1. .. ,~fF{§I1' 9i¥J ~~. 0. .J .. s. 6.. I.. '). ,. J.. 5..

(24) ~A~~":' ~. -i; ~ IJ~ ~. E. ;tlj -,1Jf 1.H. ~ ~7J 4*. 121. ~;1f. §l. l ~~ a iM& m. UiJE:. 0. :~ IJiUi. '[29 Jlt. .. E fi~. . ffij. *. ~ ~tfJf!x:Jff. . ~~::x ~&. - , Jt:I)( I. ~CJj. . i':fJ.,G'. '. Wtl1=* ~ ,&:fJ.~Wf~pfT. '. ~~ 82 -if: 2. 2. *6'ffFt ' ~:f;lt1a{~);J<r§ no n-CFC ~f~~{~~J.i¥N~ ~ [J]M. : 42-49. t ~ BJ3rlM. ~ut~)( iliH:I:lIf&Jij±. '. ~lM }~J,. igmw: ·. '. ~~$j:~HpHJi ~. ·. !! liff~~. ,. fU '. ' 1994 -if: 3 F.l ·. ~ JEfJJ. m [z] @iI~ rg: J.fUH~i Wf -- a l!1jl ~iH~ ~ Jj. F.l. 5B. 0. " !W fl Mli:fJ.Wit~!Wf~~ me ~~:f)J~ ". ftff~i~, ~ :lIJ&¥i:l*~,. 6. illa¥jf[. 1im~~ ~ m !t F.l. 0. ~ . ~:lICPLlJ *~it: '&~ ' 84 -if: II. 5. . 0. 0. 3. ~ B~rlM • Jlil f* ?;t [OJ8"J;U:: ~1f J.f ' jt&-fjru. ,. F.l. 85 -if: 5 F.l 16-17 B. . m - @ it:~)( 1~W;U::~~t~. 0. " fi,t!JI '&J.!8"J~~ W-- ~HifHit ~ 8"J%3~W m fff' ~= @ lft iJ!#(~W ~. ,. ~.n: CPLlJ*~'. 81. if 10 F.l 16-17. a. 0. =,~)( I. Abe rnath y,William J. and James M. Utterback.Patterns of Industria l Innovati on.. Tech nQlo"y Review. Ju n.-J u1.l978 : 40-47. 2. Bylinsky,Ge ne .Manufacturing for Reuse. Fortune Feb.6 1995 : 102- 112.. J. Chandler,M .K . & L. R. Sayles. Manag in g Large Systems .New York. Harper. and Row,1 97 1. t Chatterji ,Deb .Achieving Lead ersh ip in. Environmental R&D. Researc h Technology Manage ment. Mar.-Apr.199 5 : 37-42.. 5. Elkington , LTowards the Su stai nable Co rporation : Win- Win- Win Business "trategies for Sustainable Deve lopmen t. Cali fo rnia Managem ent Review. Winter 1994 : 90-100 ..

(25) 122. 6. Gladwin,Thomas N. The Meaning of Greening: A Plea for Organizational Theory. Environmental Strategies for Industry.1994 : 37-62.. 19.T. V. C 7. Hamel,Gary & C.K.Prahalad. Strategic Intent. Harvard Business Review. June 1989 : 63-76.. M B) '. 20. V. 1: 8. Huber,George P. Organizational Learning: The Contributing Processes and the Literatures. Organization Science .2 1991 : 88-109.. 21. V. C 9. Hutchinson,Colin.Corporate Strategy and the Environment. Planning.vol.25.No.4.1992 : 9-21. 10. Jain,R,k.& H.C. Triandis. Management of Research Organizations. John Wiley & Sons,lnc., 1990.. and. Long. Development. II . Porter,Michael E. and Claas van der Linde. Green and Competitiveness Endi ng the Stalemate. Har:v:ard Busine~s Review .Sep.- Oct. 1995;120-134. 12. Quinn,James Brian . Managing innovation: controlled chaos. Harvard Business Review. May-June 1985 : 73-84. 13. Roy,Robin.The evolution of ecodesign. Technovation .vo1.14 No.6 1994: 363· 380. 14. Sarkis,Joseph .Manufacturing Strategy and Technovation .vol. 15 No.2 1995 : 79-97.. Environmental. 15 . Schon,D.A .. Champions for Radical Review .vol.41 1963 : 77-86 .. Inventions.. New. Consciousness.. Harvard. Busi ness. 16. Scott, W. Richard.Organization : Rational,Natural,and Open System.3rd edition. Prentice Hall.1992 . 17. Th ierry,Martij n et al. Strategic Issues in Product Recovery Management. California Management Review .voI.37,No.2 Winter 1995 : 114-135. 18. Tushman,Michael L.& Philip Anderson. Technological Discontinuities and Organization.} '1 Environments. Administrative Science Quarterl),.31 (1986) : 439-465..

(26) e. jlJ ;j1f jll. . . ~J1 J~. 123. , 1f; -=-AlJ. i; )If I!q.*fk. lational. 19. Tushman,Michael' L ~ , Wailliam H. Newman & Romanelli. Convergence & Vpheavel : Managing the Unsteady Pace of Organizational EvollUtion. California Manaaement Reyiew.VoI.29,No . l, 1986.. t . May-. 20. Wen,Chao-tung. lntearatina Enyironmental Manaaement into Product Deyelopment, Ph.D. Dissertation ' Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute,Aug.1994 . and the , I. Winsemius,Pieter and Ulrich Guntram . Responding to the Environmental. Challenge. Business Horizons . Mar.-Apr. 1992 : 12-20 .. . Rani opment. Ending. usiness. . : 363. IU sness.. Ll.S..llllli. :dition.. ement.. :s and. :6 ) :.

(27) 124. A n In quiry of Gre e n In nova tio n Organ ization in Taiwan. Chao-tung Wen*. Tim T .M .Chen **. Abstrac t Electro nlc industry has shown it ability in innovation, Green computer & Eco-refrigerator are two eminent products during the last few years. Product that obtain eco-Iabel certi ficates can be regarded as a form of green innovati n. This paper investigates companies that produce Green computer & Eeo refrigerator to see the processes of green innovations & characteristics of thes organizations. Green business/management & innovation management/organization are two intens ive researched top ics recentl y. However, the organizational element that enable green innovation have not been explored deliberately. Based on fi\ e eco-label products companies, we look into five organizational attribute : objective, technology, participant, social structure and environment to explofl! how they influence green innovations.. Keywords :. * **. IA LlSF. 1. Green Innovation 2. Environmental Management 3. Innovative Organization 4. Eco-Iabel. Associate Professor, Nationa l Chengchi University, Graduate In stitute of Technology and 'Innovation Management. Techno'iogy Management Man ager, China Productivity Center. • r', iJ.

(28)