ѿѕఀىᏰѐ! έΪΞ! 3122ԑ9Т! ॲ64.85! !
ऋޥོϛޟϴҕኈᇄఀى!
!྆ࢸݘ!
ҳᄲࠒሬσᏰ፞แఀᏰᇄऋंـܚ zsyang@ncnu.edu.tw ! !ᄢ! ौ!
! ! ! ࿋фޥོϐငএଽ࡙ีޟऋޥོȂԃդஉᎴΡঈӵऋޥོϛޟϴҕኈ ȂоᑖྃӴᆰ៖ᇄቨ໌ӒΡޥོޟӓӣցઉȂऋޥོีޟ१ौដᚠȂζԙ ࣏ϴҕఀىޟ१ौ፞ᚠȄҏМ։კၐо౩፣ϷݙПԒȂលភऋޥོϛϴҕኈЅڏ ఀىϱొȄॶӑ൷ऋᇄϴҕኈϞᜰ߽ୈΙᐣѬܒޟӱ྅क़Ȃڏԩ൷౪фऋޥ ོϞ੫፴հΙϷݙȂശࡣඪюӵ७ᄇऋޥོپᖝܚџЕีϞᆍᆍ୰ᚠȂϴҕۣԤ ϞኈЅڏఀىϞ౩܈Ȃհ࣏࡚ដՃȄ! ! ᜰᗤຠȈऋޥོȃϴҕኈȃϴҕఀى! !!
Kpvsobm!pg!Fevdbujpo!pg!Ubjqfj!Nvojdjqbm!Vojwfstjuz!pg!Fevdbujpo! Bvh-!3122-Wpm!4:!!qq/64.85!
!
Citizen Virtues and Education in a
Technological Society
!
Chou-Sung Yang
Associate Professor, Graduate Institute of Curriculum Instruction and Technology, National Chi Nan University
zsyang@ncnu.edu.tw !
!
Abstract
! ! Through theoretical approach, this paper aims at analyzing the citizen virtues in a technological society and its implications for citizenship education. Firstly, from historical perspectives this paper lays bare the relationship between technological society and citizenship. Then, it describes the characteristics and critiques of modern techn ological society. Next, it mentions probable issues and problems that modern citizenship education faces in a technological society. Finally, it presents some implications for citizenship education in a technological society.
!
Keywords: technological society, citizen virtues, citizenship education
ΡᇄᐠᏢശσޟϚӣȂ൷ӵܻΡЖޟΨ໔Ȅ! ..!Kpio!Dpoops!)311:*/!UfsnjobupsȋTbmwbujpo/!
൦ȃࠉِ!
! ! ऋᇄΡՌ٘ᐣѬӣڏѠՂȂՃᄆऋѬޟีһџᑛΡีϞ७ᇼȄՄ ᓍऋϚᘞ۽ժޟኄ࡙ȃ࡙ᇄ࡙Ȃ౪фޟऋඁнϐငӒ७ܒޟᅤആՍᇄΡ ҡԆޟ፝ኺᄘȂٽԃȈΡሬޟҺ܁ȃ࣏ޟԒȃҬޟᒵᐅȃޥོޟ๖ᄺȃࢇݽޟ לԒȃҡᄘޟڼၼ้้ȂඁнၭऋಳϚΟᜰ߽ȄџоᇳȂ౪фऋӵϬРϐငԙ ࣏ΙএฒܚϚӵޟΨ໔Ȃζ౪фМϽுо࡚ҳޟஅᙃȄՄӵࣺ࿋แ࡙ΰȂΡМϽ ޟҐپฒᅸӴȂऋζོᅋΙএߨல१ौޟؚۡܒُՓȄ! ! ! ऋΙП७࣏ΡளپΟהఖȂԤڏғөޟΨ໔ȂΡ೨ӻޟ३ڙϛ၌ܹю پȄKbdrvft!Fmmvm൷ᇯ࣏Ȉ! ၸࣽמǴΓॺவமуܭځޑਔޜज़ڋύှܫрٰǹவବᎧǵሉපǵ ᝄൣǵۑࡓᆶࡉསϐڹှܫрٰǹ೯ၸᆶӹۖޑҬ۳ǴΓᜪவࢌ ٤ޗ״ᑛύှܫрٰǴ೯ၸჹૻ৲ޑಕᑈǴவඵΚޑ߳ज़ύှܫр ٰ)Fmmvm-!2:94-!q/!:2*Ƕ! ! ! ณՄȂऋࠓζளپӻޟ३ڙᇄॳᓎȂиџШо܁ёᝒሗᇄᔆȄоᄇΡ ޟᔆՄِȂҥܻऋ౩ܒᇄਝᄂ፺ޟᐌᡝȂӣਢζપוȃԒᇄᐠడޟӫ ᡝȂ൷ོߒ౪юΙᆍौؑ҆ณޟપוᇄጂۡޟᐣแȄӰԪޥོϛޟऋีቨёޟ ູӻȂΡޟՌкܒᇄкଢ଼ܒζ൷ёڧ३ȂӰ࣏ȶ҆ณȃྥጂᇄਝޟऋᡒᒮฒݲ ϰ೨ՌҥȃጙȃϚڷᒙ้ޟᅤΣȷ)Fmmvm-!2:94-!q/:2*ȄՄष൷ॳᓎᇄ३ڙՄِȂ ऋีູቨߝȂڏܚளپޟॳᓎζ൷ູଽȄٽԃȈσೣྒྞܒݡᏢלԙޟॖٱݡ Ψৼҁᒋȃਯऋளپޟਯኀਟညޟ୰ᚠ2 ȃፒᇧऋᏲमޟၾኈগ౩ޟތដ3 ȃ1 2009 ⸜ 3 㚰 18 㖍䴻㾇悐℔⏲⎘㜙䷋忼ṩ悱冯㼶㷾䷋㛃⬱悱ℑ嗽炻ἄ䁢Ỷ㓦⮬⿏⺊㡬䈑㚨䳪嗽伖⟜䘬⺢嬘῁ 怠⟜⛨炻忁ṃ⛘溆ᶵ㗗暊Ⲟ⯙㗗ῷ怈⛘⋨炻≈ᶲᷳ⇵䘬嗕ⵤ㟠⺊㕁⃚⬀⟜炻℞ᷕ晙⏓Ḯ⮵悱㛹冯⍇ỷ㮹㕷䘬 㬏夾シ嬀ˤ侴㓧⹄䁢枮⇑嗽䎮㟠⺊㕁炻ḇ䶐↿Ḯ⣏䫮䘬ˬ⚆棳慹˭炻ẍ⋼≑䘤⯽䣦⋨䁢⎵炻㓞䶐娚⛘⋨䘬⍵⮵ シ夳ˤ 2 1999 ⸜⽟⚳⿅゛⭞ Peter Sloterdijk 䘤堐Ḯᶨ䭯˪Ṣ栆楜梲⟜墉䘬夷⇯˫㺼嫃炻Ṿᷣ⻝䧵㤝⛘⮑夾➢⚈ⶍ䦳⛐ Ṣ幓ᶲ䘬忳䓐炻䓐㸾䡢䘬➢⚈䈡⿏ẍẋ㚧䃉夷⇯䘬Ṣ栆䷩㬾炻娎⚾⽆庫⣏䘬㝞㥳ᷕ⍣䡢⭂➢⚈ⶍ䦳⛐Ṣ栆䷩ 埵ᷕ忳䓐䘬ΐ䎮⬠ὅ㒂ˤSloterijk ᷣ⻝ㅱ娚㍸Έ⒚⬠⭞冯➢⚈䥹⬠⭞䘬⎰ἄ炻⇞妪ᶨᾳ䎦ẋ Plato ⺷䘬ˬṢ栆
ଉऋџഅԙឌᄆࡔޟᅸኌ้Ȃζџளپଽ࡙ޟॳᓎȂиᆍॳᓎӵӒ౨ ϽޟΨϞήџᏲमࣺ࿋ኄݿՄሉޟኇȂՄպ݈ٲॳᓎѫܐູپູ֨ ᜲȄFmmvm։ِȂȶΡঈΙԩ७ᄇӴ౨ΰӒഋҡڼོྞ๘ޟџܒȂӰ࣏Ρঈϐင ԤΟᄂ౪ѺޟПݲȷ)Fmmvm-!2:94-!q/:2*Ȅ! ! ! ྥԪȂԃդ౩РઉቨߝޟऋڙȂϐငএਢфᆧफ़ޟ୰ᚠȄ౪фΡభؑ ҡԆȂ҆ᄇԪ୰ᚠ໌ӱᔖȄȶՄఀىሯᜰЖԪΙ୰ᚠȂӰ࣏Ρঈᕕுդᆍᜰܻ ऋޟ౩၌ᇄᄘ࡙ȂᄇΡܒޟఖՍ࣏ᜰᗤȄȷ)Cpoofu-!2::9-!q/479*ȄѯၗᇳȂ Ԥᜰऋޟ୰ᚠȂᗙ҆ӱڗΡޟҏ٘Ϟΰپ໌ࡦՃȄՙੲбᏰড়Kptf!Psufhb! z!Hbttfu൷ᇯ࣏ȂऋΡܒޟΙএҏ፴ौશȂΡႆऋΙଢ଼فಛȂΨყᄂ౪ Ρҏ٘ኺΙᆍ຺ՌณޟೣგȂӰϞऋ࣏ΟΡޟ࢚ᆍ౩དՄ໌ޟΙᆍސ፴ࣀଢ଼ )Hbttfu-!2:94-!q/3:3*ȄHbttfuདौސ፴ี݂ᇄҡ࡚ҳܻΙᆍᆠડี݂ޟஅ ᙃϞΰȂᇯ࣏ڏਲ਼ྛ൷ӵܻΡޟ࢚ᆍ౩དޟՌרഺഅܖཎȂՄᙤҥऋޟΨ໔پᄂ ౪Ȅ! ! ! ७ᄇऋีܚբᓍՄپޟϚጂۡॳᓎȂগ౩ӰશޟՃ໔ၿӵऋޟ೩ॎᇄี ϛ҆ौᅋ१ौޟُՓȄѓࢂȈџڧޟॳᓎแ࡙ԃդؚۡȉҢդྥؚۡȉҥ ።پጂۡٲྥȉऋᄂ፺ϛ҆ࡦՃޟ୰ᚠȂζਖ਼ЅΟऋޥོϛΙ՝ي ԁϴҕᔖ၎ڎര࢚ٲኈՄёоӰᔖȄྥԪȂΙএऋޥོϛޟϴҕԃդЅᔖ၎ ᇄڗԤᜰऋޟؚ๊ϞϛȂ༖҆ԙ࣏ҐپϴҕܚᔖڎരޟΨᇄ੫፴ȄՄԃդஉᎴ ΡঈӵऋޥོϛޟϴҕኈȂоᑖྃӴᆰ៖ᇄቨ໌ӒΡޥོޟӓӣցઉȂऋ ޥོีޟ१ौដᚠȂζԙ࣏ϴҕఀىޟ१ौ፞ᚠȄ! ! ! அܻΰक़ȂҏМკၐо౩፣ϷݙПԒȂ௴ҢՙПޥོޟऋंـᢎᘈȂលភऋ ޥོϛϴҕኈЅڏఀىϱొȄॶӑ൷ऋᇄϴҕኈϞᜰ߽ୈΙᐣѬܒޟӱ྅ क़Ȃڏԩ൷౪фऋޥོϞ੫፴հΙϷݙȂശࡣඪюӵ७ᄇऋޥོپᖝܚџЕี Ϟᆍᆍ୰ᚠȂϴҕۣԤϞኈЅڏఀىϞ౩܈ᇄհݲȂհ࣏࡚ដՃȄ! !
楜梲⟜䘬夷⇯˭ˤṾ娵䁢炻怢⁛➢⚈ⶍ䦳䘬彭忇䘤⯽㗗䔞ẋ䘬䘬䈡⽝炻℞ⷞἮ䘬⼙枧⊊暋性ˤṾ⚈㬌ᷣ⻝ ㅱ娚䧵㤝⛘忳䓐➢⚈ⶍ䦳炻⇞妪ᶨ䧖Ṣ栆ⶍ䦳⬠䘬ℙ嬀冯㱽夷ˤSloterijk 㬌㔯ᶨ↢炻⛐⽟⚳⬠䓴⺽崟姙⣂䇕 婾炻姙⣂ΐ䎮⬠⭞ˣ➢⚈ⶍ䦳⬠侭ˣ㔁做⬠侭䫱悥⍫冯Ḯ忁⟜婾㇘炻⊭㊔䔞ẋ㚨慵天䘬㱽嗕䤷⬠㳦⍲℞柀 ⮶Ṣ Jürgen Habermasˤ娛䳘婾彗忶䦳⎗⍫夳烉劫㌟⸛(2003)ˤṢ栆怢⁛➢⚈ⶍ䦳—Ṣ㔯ᷣ佑Ṣ㔯㔁做䘬䳪 䳸烎庱㕤⽟⚳㔁做⿅゛㤪婾 (165-191 枩)ˤᶲ㴟烉ᶲ㴟嬗㔯↢䇰䣦ˤ
ຯȃऋᇄϴҕኈ!
! ! ऋᇄϴҕኈޟᜰ߽Ȃऋଔྛޟהᛸડၗ࢈ٱϛȂ։џߑَᆒকȈ! Ϻઓۖථ)[fvt*ബғނࡕǴࢴᇾදᛥԯঅථ)QspnfuifvtǴԖȨӃޕȩ ϐ ཀ * ϩ ଛ Ӛ ᅿ ω ૈ ๏ ނ Ƕ ද ᛥ ԯ অ ථ ޑ Ҳ ԯ অ ථ )FqjnfuifvtǴԖȨࡕޕȩϐཀ*ԾᏟ߿ᔅঢঢжമǶҲԯঅථ όཎࡕޕࡕޣϐӜǴՉ٣డคीฝǴӃډޣӃ๏ǴܭࢂྰηԖΑ߿ ǵചٽԖΑԳЛǵԴ߁ԖΑПη…ނӚᕇځ܄ϐωૈǶՠΓᜪ ۇۇٰᒨǴനࡕډਔςคωૈёϩଛǴΓᜪၱኪ៛ܭނϐύԶԖ ྐᅿϐဤǶදᛥԯঅථԖགρϐೢҺǴၱԿڂি)Buifob*Ϸᇲථ )IfqibftuvtǴࣽמϐઓ*ೀୂளОᅿϷᇙբᏔڀϐࣽמ௲ϒΓᜪǴ ڐշځғӸǶΓᜪԖΑОϷࣽמࡕǴளа໒рΓᜪЎܴǶΓᜪԖ ΑࣽמϐࡕǴҗܭલЮ҅ကᆶಚ৭ЈǴၱᔲҔࣽמא٬ԾฅނǴࣗ ЪӣᏘΓᜪҁيǴԋଯࡋόዴۓޑ྄ྐ॥ᓀǴΓᜪኬᎁڙྐᅿϐ ဤǶۖථၱࢴ٬ઓԯථ)Ifsnft*ଌ๏܌ԖΓᜪٿᘶނǺ৭གᆶ҅ က)ЇԾླྀు֞Ǵ2::8Ǵ।223*Ƕ! ! ! ҥΰϞડၗζᡗҰюΟऋᇄΡኈϞޟᜰ4 ȄऋΙП७࣏Ρளپה ఖȂࣥи໌ՍϬȂΡԤהఖഺഅҡڼȂڥфഅސкϞӴ՝ȄณՄȂѪΙП७Ȃऋ ϚᘞีϞ๖ݎȂһ࣏Ρжࣨளپଽ࡙ޟϚጂۡܒॳᓎȄڏᄂȂऋϞڍ७ܒȂ ࠉक़הᛸડၗϞऋϞડሀ੫Ϟഅ։џࣼюȄሀ੫࣏ЈડۤᇄЈӭה ܜ)Ifsb*ϞυȂЈࣨശछτડߡ߁ᡎအ)Bqispejuf*࣏ێȂԪᡗҰюऋԤڏડ ܒਲ਼ྛᇄछޟ੫፴Ȅծሀ੫ҏ٘ࠓໂٗՄϚيܻȂڏێάܣြЕፆȃϚԊܻ ࡉȂࣥՍЕଔ੫ࣄӀᏽތȂഅԙྒྞȄζᡗҰюऋҏ٘ԤڏીഞȂиৠܾྖю3 㬌䤆娙Ṏ栗䣢↢Ḯ冯㔁做䚠斄ᷳシ佑ˤ椾⃰炻Ṣ栆䓙㕤℞㛔傥ᷳᶵ嵛䘬仢星炻忪暨天䥹㈨䘤㖶ᷳˬẋ℟˭ (prothese)ἄ䁢℞⿅゛冯幓橼ᷳ⺞Ỡ炻ẍ⋼≑℞䓇⬀᷎攳⯽㔯㖶炻䥹㈨䁢Ṣ栆䓇⬀冯㔯㖶ⷞἮⶴ㛃烊℞㫉炻䥹 ㈨㚱℞桐晒炻㮓䃉䭨⇞ˣ仢᷷」デ冯㬋佑ᷳ䥹㈨䘤⯽㇉⣑⼡䈑Ṏ㚫ⷞἮ䃉⎗㋥㓹ᷳ㭨㹭烊䫔ᶱˣ䥹㈨ᶵ㗗冒 䃞䘬炻㗗㛔傥䘬㚧ẋ⑩炻⚈䁢ᶵ㗗㛔傥炻ẍᶵ㗗塓㰢⭂䘬炻侴⎗ẍᶵ㕟⛘䘤㖶ˣ⮎䎦冯∝忈烊䫔⚃炻䥹㈨ ᷎朆Ṣ栆㛔℟ᷳ㛔傥炻侴㚱岜㕤⬠佺䌚⼿炻㔁做㳣≽㚱℞⽭天⿏ˤ䫔ᶱ冯䫔⚃溆⇯溆↢Ḯ㔁做㳣≽冯䥹㈨ᷳ 斄Ὢˤ䓙㕤䥹㈨ᶵ㗗㛔傥炻㓭暨天⬠佺烊⍰⚈䥹㈨㛒Ἦ㛒塓㰢⭂炻℟㚱䃉旸⎗傥⿏炻侴㚱⼭德忶㔁做㳣≽侴 ≈ẍ攳⯽ˤ㔜橼侴妨炻䥹㈨⮵Ṣ栆⎗傥䓊䓇䘬媠䧖䳸㝄Ṏ䁢㔁做㳣≽ᷕ⽭枰≈ẍ㶙⿅䅇ㄖᷳ慵天嬘柴ˤ
ڙϞѴՄלԙॳᓎ)྆֬Ȃ2::8Ȃॲ224*ȄѯၗᇳȂయฒڙϞऋีའЈמ ސһོளپฒџਗϞྒྞȂՄԤᒦΡ৻ཐᇄғဎϞኈޟีථПுоᗗջȄ! ! ! ऋᇄϴҕኈޟᜰ߽һԞ࣏ѠהᛸਢфΡঈܚࡦЅȄԞၾኈᇄࢇݽᏰ ऋຜ࣏॒७ޟȂTpdsbuftȃQmbupᇄBsjtupumfमΨܻଆȃғဎȃޣᜋȃ ޥོȃϴҕ้ȂࠓᄇԤᜰऋޟሴܲࡻྃσޟᛄᅸᇄקЖȄQmbupޟᢎᘈࣼپȂ )ufdioè*܁܁ԤኈȂӰ࣏ڏᜰݧޟސ፴ޟ౪ຫࣨȂٮϚցܻଡؑശଽ ޟ౩܈ȄӵȶරኈᛳȷጕϛтζࡾΟМԅၷϞᏹོࡄޣᜋӱᏹޟᏹȂ ၷܒޟᏹོԤࣞԴΟӱᏹܒᏹϞӠᓎȂоमڏྒྞȄѯၗᇳȂᙤօΟਪቸ ޟऋȂΡᏹڧڗࡄȄQmbupᇯ࣏ȂࢇݽޟҬޟӵ࡚ᄺΙএᛧۡՄԤೣࡡޟ ޥོપוٮ٩Хڏҡ༄ᇄ૾ଝȂӰԪӵтޟདݲϛȂ౩܈)fjept*ೝԊညܻ౩܈ ࣨȂ౩ܒޟΡौўଡ൶ޟҬޟȂώӞޟᇧհސࠌӵ౪ຫࣨȂڏ౩܈ࣨনޟ ϚׇӒፒᇧސՄϐȂٮϚڎԤўଡ൶ޟቋȄ! ! ! BsjtupumfࠌΡҡڼࣀଢ଼Ϸ࣏ȶ౩፣ޟȷ)uifpjb*ȃȶᄂ፺ޟȷ)qsbyjt*ᇄȶᇧ അޟȷ)qpjtfjt*ȂΡٷڏٱҡڼࣀଢ଼ϞϚӣȂܚᕕमϞȶȷ)hppe*ζԤଽճ ϞտȄΡശଽ౩ܒ࣏ȶ౩፣౩ܒȷȂଡؑ౩፣ؕࡦϞΡҡޟȇڏԩȂࢇݽᄂ፺ ϞȂڏԤᜰܻΡঈၾኈܖࢇݽޟࣀଢ଼ȇശήቹࠌऋᇧഅޟΡҡϞȄՄࡸྱ BsjtupumfޟᢎᘈȂऋᇧഅᗶณڎԤᄂ፺౩ܒȂծڏҬޟѴӵޟࠢȂڟູٮߨ ϱӵܻএΡȂӰԪቹճܻᄂ፺ᇄ౩፣)Lojhiu-!3118*ȄஅҏΰȂᄇтՄِȂऋ։ Ιᆍȶᇧഅȷࣀଢ଼Ȃࢇݽٱࠌȶᄂ፺ȷޟࣀଢ଼ȄΡঈོўȶᇧഅȷହȃᓏȃ ܘࡐȂࠓўȶᄂ፺ȷࢇݽܖᏰȄᇧഅޟҬΙএϚӣܻᇧഅࣀଢ଼ޟᄇຫȂଢ଼ ޟҬࠓ༫ᅖޟଢ଼ҏ٘ȂՄөശଽޟᄂ౪!)Njudibn-!2:91*ȄBsjtupumf ᇯ࣏ȂȶΡࢇݽޟଢ଼ސȷȂΡҏ፴ΰ൷ᎌӫҡࣀܻ࠲٤ϞϛȄՄ࠲٤ޟҡࣀҥՌҥ ΡޟᆹȄؐএΡՌҥޟȂ൷ཎڨؠԤΡџоўࡾථտΡޟଢ଼ȄؐএΡ ҁ้ޟȂӵݲࡡӴ՝ȃϴӓٱȃЅᄇࢇݽٱސีߒِ፣ޟ᠌Ψҁ้ޟȄࢇݽҡ ࣀܚᜰЖޟٱސᄇܚԤϴҕՄِΙኺޟȄӵϴӓሴϛȂؐএΡཎყौў຺ູ এΡܖড়৳ցઉՄўଡؑᐌᡝޥတޟȄؐএϴҕϚӣܻڏтϴҕȂծࢁޥတ ܚԤϴҕޟӓӣώհȄϴҕ٘Ӌ፡ᄇܻϴӓҡࣀޟᑖྃᇄȂٮᅖٗؐএΡޟശ ଽዖȄоኺޟПԒۡဎࢇݽȂBsjtupumf៉ўଆϴҕޟُՓᇄኈȂтᇯ࣏ ౩དޟ࠲٤ϴҕ҆ѓࢂಛݽޱᇄೝಛݽޱڍᆍ٘ӋȈ!
ٿޣޑڑຫ٠ό࣬ӕǴՠࢂӳޑϦ҇ᔈ၀ԖૈΚٿޣࢂǴдѸޕ ၰӵՖႽঁԾҗΓѐݯǴаϷӵՖႽঁԾҗΓޑѐᒥӺݯ—೭ ٤ࢂϦ҇ޑڑຫϐೀ)Bsjtupumf-!2:95*Ƕ! ! ! Bsjtupumfٮᖂ๖ᇳȂΙএԁޟڙ࡙ौஊᡱϴҕᎈࢺᇄϴӓٱՄӵᄂ፺ ࣀଢ଼ϛଡؑڟູᇄኈȄᄇтՄِȂѷᗵᇄώӞᄇܻ࠲٤҆ޟȂծтঈٮϚϴ ҕȂΙএԁޟ࠲٤ϚϴҕၥਿᘗڗѷᗵᇄώӞȂӰ࣏тঈޟᇧഅҡࣀٮϚў ଡؑᄂ፺ޟڟູȄBsjtupumf໌Ι؏кȂϴҕ҆ᗗջᏰಬऋȂӰ࣏٥ོ६ճЫ ྥȂиོੑଶΟкΡᇄѷᗵޟୢႤ)Bsjtupumf-!2:95*ȄѯၗᇳȂтᇯ࣏ऋޟٱ ᇄѷᗵЅڠ፮ޟ഼ώԤᜰȂಛݽޟΡঈौўᗗջȄBsjtupumfᄇܻऋᇄϴ ҕኈޟདݲஅҏΰϫณ۽៉ΟQmbupоپޟࣼݲȄ! ! ! ϛжकஅఀᄇܻऋٷณ௴ڥΟϚ߬ӈޟᄘ࡙ȄᄇϛжकޟΡঈՄِȂϱӵܒ ޟᙽᡐሉഽܻѴӵޟж߹ϞސȂӰԪᇧഅސࠢޟӴ՝ϫณճܻᄂ፺ଢ଼Ȅ! ! ! ծڗΟGsbodjt!Cbdpo)2675.2737*ਢȂࠉक़ຶऋޟᄘ࡙ԤΟᙽᡐȄCbdpo коᘪઽݲ)joevdujpo*հཱི࣏ंـώڎоڥфBsjtupumfᅋᛰݲޟᙟंـώڎȄ Cbdpoᇯ࣏ȂᙤҥཱིޟώڎџоੑଶᡱΡഞܻᙲᇲᇯᜋޟѲᆍୋ)jepmt*Ȉᆍఊȃࢾ ҲȃѿൟЅቑൟȂՄᕕுઍғޟޣᜋȄആႆᘪઽݲޟंـȂоᄂᡛᇄᢎᄆਟ࣏அ ᙃȂငҥϷݙȃШၶȃᒵᐅȃܢҌ้ȂџоଡؑՌณٱސޟনӰᇄೣࡡȂ໌Մџо܂ ݈ՌณٮᘗΡޟ᠌Ψ—ޣᜋ൷Ψ໔ȄѯၗᇳȂᙤҥऋᏰޣᜋޟΨ໔ȂΡঈϚ Ӕհ࣏ೝଢ଼ޟᢎᄆޱپࣼՌณȂՄᔖ࿋ցҢՌϏޟऋᇄᚖЙȂफ़ٺՌณᚔ ڏՌณޑᄘȂᄇڏ໌ᔆᄵᇄ༭അȂӰ࣏ٱސޟҏܒӵऋޟࢅᢐήौШӵڏЈณޟ Ռҥޑᄘϛৠܾኸ៩юپ)Xjoofs-!2::6-!q/81*Ȅ! ! ! CbdpoӰՄܷЀΟऋᏰᇄऋؑޟᓺӑܒȂ፭ϠΟऋᏰᇄऋ८ޱଽޟӴ ՝ȂӰ࣏ऋᏰี౪ᇄऋഺཱིޟցઉџоߝδӴЅܻܚԤΡȂӈդࢇ᠌ȃӈդ ឩࣂȃӈդറюΡސᄇΡٱཾޟኇϚᇄϞШᔣޟ)Cbdpo-!2:71*ȄӵȮཱིٳ ੫៌ඪȯ)Ofx!Bumboujt-!2738*ϛȂCbdpo൷ජक़ΟΙএȶܚᛳߞȷ)Tpmpnpo!ipvtf* ޟंـᐠᄺȂڏϛԤᄂᡛࡉȃේސ༪ȃଢ଼ސ༪ȃώኅȃኁܘ้ȂऋᏰড়ঈӵڏϛϚٱ ҡӴȃฒࡣϞޟΣऋᏰंـώհȂڏҬޟ൷ӵܻଆٱސޟҏনЅڏၼફ ȂоᘗσΡޣᜋȂٺΙϸ౩དޟᄂ౪ԙ࣏џȄܚᛳߞζԙ࣏ϞࡣӨড়
ंـᐠᄺԙҳޟԒȄ! ! ! ՌCbdpoඪюऋᏰऋޟཱིώڎо܂݈ՌณޟᢎᘈоپȂΡംᅚᄺ࡚юΙᐌৈ ຟቋՌณȃҡސоЅΡҏ፴ޟޣᜋȂ໌ՄџоளሴΡᑸ۷ᆋҡࣀޟ੩Ԝ٤жࣨȄ CbdpoޟདݲϞࡣζថுΟ೨ӻޟଡᓍޱȂ29жकݲంᇌၼଢ଼ࡦདড়൷ࣺ࿋१ຜώ ԙ൷ȂEjefspuளᓞܚጡϞȮԻऋӒਪȯ)Fodzdmpqfejb*൷ҢΟྃσޟጕൽўఄक़ ऋี݂Ȅ! ! ! ᓍᄇܻऋᄘ࡙ޟᙽᡐȂΡঈᄇܻՌרցઉ༊өޟ୦ཾᏢސᇄސ፴ଡؑζᡐޟ ё१ौȄЎڏӵ28ȃ29жकޟՌҥкဎࢇݽ፣क़ϛȂ൷ዅᢎӴᇯ࣏এΡငᔼցઉޟ ଡؑᄇܻငᔼቨߝԤઉޟȄࡸྱኺޟᢎᘈȂଡؑȶՌרցઉȷ)tfmg.joufsftut* এϴҕछኈȂϚ༉Ӱ࣏ڏོளپސ፴ΰޟցઉȂиҥܻᄇցઉޟଡؑџою ԁޟಛݽޱᇄٹޟϴҕȄ! ! ! ԤᜰՌרցઉᏲөޟငᔼࣀଢ଼ӵKpio!MpdlfȮࢇۺ፣Πᖿȯ)Uif!Tfdpoe!Usfbujtf! pg!Hpwfsonfou*ϛԤΟӻޟលភȄтᇯ࣏ȂΡঈོདौ܂݈Ռณоຜ࣏ϏԤȄ࿋Ρ ᕣ၌ڗтঈޟԤސԤೝჴϞӠᓎਢȂΡ߯ᚔΟȶՌณޑᄘȷ)tubuf!pg! obuvsf*ՄלԙΟޥོٮಢᙑࢇۺȂٮۏଊڏ࡚ҳೣࠌо߳ራএΡޟؽԤ᠌Ȅࡸ ྱMpdlfޟᢎᘈȂࢇۺޟђ൷ӵܻ߳៖এΡջڧ߭ȂՄषࢇۺฒݲႀԙኺޟ ޟҬȂΡҕ߯Ԥ᠌ցڏ௰ᙚȄӰԪȂMpdlfޟᢎᘈࣼپȂΡޟናؑΙᆍᑖ ྃܒޟΨ໔Ȃ࿋Ρঈӵଡؑސ፴ޟቨߝਢȂтঈོё౩ܒȃҁڷӴўᒳԈݲࡡȂ ӰԪᇄѿൟޥོЅၥҏкဎࣺڳᔖޟএΡኈџоў࡚ҳΙএᛧۡޟࢇݽપוȄྥ ԪȂӵڞօ࡚ҳيԁޥོޟࣀଢ଼ϛȂีऋоଡؑސ፴ቨߝޟӴ՝൷ೝᄔᡗюپȄ ᄇMpdlfՄِȂࢇۺϚڎԤϱӵቋȂڏُՓӵܻ߳៖ҡڼȃՌҥᇄޟ᠌ցȂհ ࣏Ԥᜰٲٱଔތដਢޟຘրȇऋᡐ᎐ࠌೝۡ՝࣏ȶ໌؏ޟȷȂӵ౪фᐣѬϛ ೝᇯ࣏҆ณོีҡޟȂӰ࣏Ρঈ࣏ΟଡؑএΡցઉᇄؽΡၥՄོў໌Ι؏ี ޟଢ଼)Xjoofs-!2::6!-!q/83*Ȅ! ! ! ᆣΰܚक़ȂԤᜰऋޟᢎᘈȂѠהᛸਢᄇܻऋޟ॒७ᢎᘈംᅚᙽԙዥϛ ܻऋޟ໌ȄޢՍϬРȂंـऋȃีऋȃၼҢऋޟแ࡙ଽճࣥՍԙ࣏րۡ ޥོড়М݂໌؏ᇄ֏ޟٷᐃᇄຫȄ୲ӵኺޟᑖྃዅᢎޟᄘ࡙ϞϛȂऋٷณӵ এΡؽΡሴᇄϴӓሴԤܚୢႤȄϴҕོೝჂᓾўၼҢӨԒӨኺޟऋࠢо໌ ՌרശσցઉޟଡؑȂծऋंـᇄऋีࠌ឴ܻடড়ޟٱཾሴȂऋޟដᚠ
ӵၾኈတᡝܖϴӓሴϛٮؠԤϴҕџоབࡦ݂ᒱȃ፣क़៝፣ᇄϷٴଢ଼ޟުȄ! !
ȃ౪фޥོϛޟऋ੫፴!
! ! բᓍCbdpoȃԻऋӒਪࣂᇄMpdlf้ΡᄇܻऋޟᢎᘈȂԙ࣏ΟՙПంᇌၼଢ଼ࡦ ད࣏ྃ१ौޟࡦՃၯኵȄࡦདড়ঈᇯ࣏ȂΡᙤҥऋᏰޣᜋᇄऋഺഅȂџо܂݈ ՌณȂٺΡԙ࣏ՌϏࣥՍԇۤޟкȄӵኺޟ౩܈ήȂऋԙ࣏ΡڙՌณᇄ Ռ٘ޟώڎȄณՄȂԪᆍऋࡦᆰᗶณڞօΟΡўඡණՌณȃڙՌณȂࠓζӱႆ ᓞ پ ڙ Ο Ρ Ռ Ϗ Ȅ Ipslifjnfs ᇄ Bepsop ӵ Ȯ ం ᇌ ޟ ៝ ᜌ ȯ )Ejbmfdujd! pg! Fomjhiufonfou*Ιਪϛ൷ࡾюȂంᇌ౩ܒϚᘞޟଽᅛȂΡЅڏܚҡࣀϞҡࣀжࣨ സນ࣏аࢲоП߯ॎᆗȃႱกᇄԤਝڙȂϐငׯԢΟΡҏܒᇄҡࣀжࣨȂ๖ݎం ᇌনཎӵ၌ଶડၗȂծശತంᇌՌ٘ࠓάלԙѪΙএડၗ )Ipslifjnfs!'!Bepsop-! 2:83*Ȅζ൷ᇳȂంᇌ౩ܒন࣏ڞօΡಳᚔཌྷฒޣޑᄘоԙ൷ᐿҳՌкࡦՃϞ кᡝȂծႆ࡙፡ᇄ१ຜޟ๖ݎȂฒݲٷᐃऋᡒᒮौؑϞೝ໔ϽȃႱกޟ࣏ᇄҡ ࣀ൷҆ೝඳణȂ៧ӴᗍଶΟΡЅڏҡࣀޟଢ଼ᄘܒȃޥོܒȃᐣѬܒᇄࣺϣкᡝ ܒȄΙϸ༉ٷඉ౩ܒᇄࡊᢎޟݲࠌȂΡತـೝϽ࣏ސȂޥོԙ࣏Ϛڎתដᖐॱޟ өޥོȄ! ! ! ։ԃNbsdvtfܚࡾюޟȂऋϐငᙽᡐ࣏ΙᆍڙᡒᒮȂऋন࣏Ιᆍ၌ܹΨ໔Ȃ ٱސ հώڎϽϞ ౩ȂࠓІ ՄᡐԙΙᆍ ၌ܹޟᑩ Ȃӱႆᓞپ ٺΡԙ࣏ ώڎ )Nbsdvtf-!2:75*ȄѯၗᇳȂऋন࣏җሉԤਝӴڙՌณȂζҥആႆڙՌณඪ ټΟᄇΡޟڙޟԤਝᢎ܈ᇄώڎȄӰՄȂڙҏ٘ϞᘗᇄࡻδϐငϚӔ༉ആႆ ऋپႀԙȂڏҏ٘൷ऋȄҢFmmvmޟၗپᇳȂऋϐငএȶՌкޟفಛȷ )bvupopnpvt!tztufn*Ȃڏ຺юΟΡޟڙՄԤΟՌϏޟၼհᡒᒮȄGffocfshࡾюȂ ᆍऋفಛ։ԃIfjefhhfsޟᢎᘈȈ! ᄬԋᅿཥޑЎϯᡏسǴ೭ᅿཥޑЎϯᡏسஒঁޗШࣚख़ཥᄬࡌ ԋঁڋޑჹຝǶ೭ᅿᡏسڀԖᅿᘉࢲΚޑᗺǴѬஒനಖߟ Εঁࣽמݮ٠༟ޗғࢲޑᡏǶӢԜǴᕴᡏޑπڀϯ൩ԋΑᅿڮၮ5 ǴךॺନΑଏࠅаѦؒԖձޑрၡǶѝԖӣᘜ܈ቀᐆω ૈගٮᅿჹޑޓҞࡨޑඹжԄ !)Gffocfsh-!311303116-! q/7*Ƕ! ! ! Մᄇܻऋ໌؏ԃԪޟޡҬதࡶȂҥܻऋ၌ܹΟΡনԤਢުϞ३ڙȂΡ ଢ଼ୢޟȶᘗቨȷ)nbhojgjdbujpo*ܚளپޟՌҥЅ፭᠌ཐȂృؠΟΡঈᄇܻऋ ޟ׳րȂиᡱΡঈןΟи҆ўܛၷऋܚளپޟȶᕻωȷ)sfevdujpo*Ȅ6 ऋΙП ७ԙ࣏ΡঈՌרޟ۽ժᇄޥོжࣨޟӔ౪ȇѪΙП७ȂΡঈޟՌרߒႀᇄӔ౪жࣨਢ ܚٺҢޟಒጆȂࠓ҆ᎌᔖܻϛϭऋޟ࢜ᄺȄྥԪȂΡঈܾྃഞΣΟҥऋܚ ёޟΙ՛ᐇհࡾхᇄࡦᆰПԒϛȂи࡞פ൷ོӣཎೝȶ೩ۡȷ)qsphsbnnfe*ԙ࣏ȶแ ԒΡȷ)qsphsbnnfe!qfstpo*ȂٮฒݲၼҢདΨپ೩དՌ٘ޟџܒȂלԙΙᆍߨ லᜲоඡණޟᕻωלԒȄ! ! ! ኺޟऋڙȂӵNby!XfcfsᆎϞ࣏ȶ១᠖ȷ)jspo!dbhf*ȂNbsujo!Ifjefhhfs ᆎϞ࣏ȶ࢜ȷ)fogsbnjoh*)Hftufmm*ȄᄇIfjefhhfsՄِȂऋޟҏ፴൷ԆԤޟ ၌ጶ)Vowfscpshfoifju-!vodpodfbmnfou*ȂΡޟڼၼ൷ԆԤޟ၌ጶȂԆԤޟ၌ጶ ༉ีҡܻၭжࣨޟՌҥᇄܹޟжࣨᜰ߽Ȅ౪фΡՌרཎס߭ΣڗԆԤȂऋ—ᆗ ॎޟоΙᆍᓽԆᇄȶ࢜ȷޟПԒӔ౪жࣨȂٺுސԙ࣏ᓽԆސՄࣱ࣏ΡܚҢȂᗶ ณζΙᆍ၌ጶȄ౪фΡޟ၌ጶΙᆍڼၼȂӰ࣏Ѻయฒ౩ҥӴؑՌณȂᗴጶՄ ߨ၌ጶԆԤȄྥԪȂ༉࿋Ρঈ१ཱིൔଔΡޟՌרཎסٮՌ٘ॎหΣઍ౩ޟีҡ о຺պȶ࢜ȷޟऋᄘ࡙ਢϗுȂζϗ१ཱིᇯᜋڗԆԤȄؠԤऋ൷ؠԤ၌ ጶོีҡȂо୰ᚠٮϚୄӵऋȂՄϚӣޟၼҢऋȂӰԪ҆ӱᘪڗऋޟ ੫ȂӱڗᇭِᇄၑϞϛȂആႆᄇᇭِᇄၑޟࡦՃȂ१ཱིี౪ԆԤᒦоԊ٘ҳڼ ޟжࣨ)྆ࢸݘȂ3122*7 Ȅ! !
4 ⍇㔯䁢”Geschick”炻⍇嬗䁢ˬ⣑␥˭炻㖻冯ᷕ⚳⒚⬠ᷕᷳˬ⣑␥˭㶟㵮炻㬌㓡䁢ˬ␥忳˭ˤ 5
㬌⌛⤪ Ihde(1990, p.74)㊯↢䘬炻Ṣ冯䥹㈨⍲ᶾ䓴攻䘬ˬ橼䎦斄Ὢ˭(embodiment relations)炻⬀⛐叿℟㚱ᶨ䧖 ⽭䃞䘬ˬ㒜⡆/䷖⮷˭(magnification/reduction)㝞㥳(Ihde, 1990, p.74)ˤ橼䎦斄Ὢ㚫⎴㗪㓦⣏ˣ㒜⣏ㆾ㗗䷖⮷ˣ 䦣昌(旣㑳)ᶨṃ德忶⬫侴䴻槿⇘䘬㜙大ˤἳ⤪炻ṢᾹ德忶㛃怈掉奨⮇⇘䘬㚰䎫炻⿏岒㚫ᶵ⎴㕤倱䛤䚳⇘䘬 㚰Ṗ烊德忶暣娙䘬倗专炻ṢᾹ⎗ẍ䴻槿⇘态怈嶅暊ᷳ⢾䘬ṢᾹ炻Ữ㗗ẋ₡㗗㬌䴻槿㚫塓旸䷖㕤倚枛ˤIhde ẍ 䎦尉⬠䘬㕡㱽⍾⎹㍊妶ˬṢ—䥹㈨—ᶾ䓴˭䘬斄Ὢ炻侴㍸↢烉橼䎦斄Ὢ(embodiment relations)ˣ娖慳斄Ὢ (hermeneutic relations)ˣ⬫䔘斄Ὢ(alterity relations)ˣ側㘗斄Ὢ(background relations)䫱⚃䧖✳ンˤ
6
! ! ୲ Ifjefhhfs ΰ क़ ᄇ ܻ ऋ ޟ ଡ ୰ Ȃ ೝ Gffocfsh ׳ ຟ Ι ᆍ ȶ ᄂ ᡝ ፣ ȷ )Tvctuboujwjtn*ޟᢎᘈȂڏϐငᗴ֤ܻXfcfs౩ܒϽȶ១᠖ȷޟඍᢎ྅܈ϞϛȄтঈ ᇯ࣏ȂऋϚᙏޟЙࢲȂՄϐငᡐԙΙᆍᕗცڷҡࣀПԒȂԪ࣏ऋޟᄂ፴ ܒ)tvctuboujwf*ኇȄྥԪȂΡঈݧۡܖޱऋөȶІ੩Ԝ٤ȷ)Eztupqjb*ޟ Пө௰໌Ȃܖ໐པ)Optubmhjb*ԒӴଝӱڗনۖޟҡࣀПԒϞϛȄӵӈդלήȂ ऋϚོᡐȂڏΡޟڼၼȂΡฒΨўওғܖϓႱ!)ᗺኊȃఔᢎݲឍȂ 3116*ȄՄխኺޟᢎᘈζџӵݲऋᏰড়FmmvmࣼڗȄ! ! ! Fmvmmᇯ࣏ȂऋϐငڥфΟՌณᕗცՄԙ࣏Ρ҆ҡࣀڏޟཱིޟȃ੫ۡޟ ᕗცȄኺޟᕗცԤоήޟ੫Ȉ2/ѺΡώޟȇ3/ѺՌкޟȇ4/ѺᐿҳܻΡ ϓႱՄՌרؚۡޟȇ5/ѺࡸྱΙᆍӰݎՄߨҬޟᏲөޟႆแีȇ6/ѺႆЙࢲ ᑖಣՄپȂЙࢲӑܻҬޟȇ7/ѺޟܚԤഋϷޭៈӵΙଔȂϚџϷȂฒݲᐿ၌ ؚӈդΙএऋ୰ᚠȄӰԪܚᒝএտڎᡝޟऋีՌࣺҭࣽޟ౪ຫȄՄࢋณऋ ϐငԙཱི࣏ޟᕗცȂܚԤޟޥོ౪ຫ൷ည٘ڏϛȂᇳငᔼȃࢇݽȃМϽ้ڧڗऋ ޟኇܖᡐϚᄇޟȂٲࣀଢ଼ညܻ٘ऋϞϛ)Fmmvm-!2:94-!q/97*ȄྥԪȂ ؠԤܚᒝޟΡЛऋޟٱȂѫԤΡў݈ᇄᎌᔖऋᕗცޟᡐ᎐ȂӰ࣏ܚԤ Ρޟᢎ܈ȃ߬Ӊȃրᘞᇄડၗ้ϐငೝऋܚ༭ՄԙޟᕗცഅΟȄ! ! ! FmmvmޟཎࡦȂऋׇӒএՌкޟفಛȂڏٮߨҥ़டড়ܚڙܖᆓ౩Ȃ ՄؠԤΡઍғಛݽܖڙȄЎڏ౪фऋفಛޟፒᚕܒȂԤڏՌ٘ٱސᇄೣ ࠌȂོЕᏲؐএΡᇄސٷڏೣࠌ࣏Ȃٮആႆᎌ࿋ೣࠌپׇԙȄѯၗᇳȂσޟऋ فಛོࡸྱڏՌ٘ޟೣࠌၼȂٮϚོڧڗড়ȃࢇۺȃंـᐠᄺܖடড়Ᏸޱܚ ڙȄٱᄂΰȂடড়ᏰޱଶΟՌϏᆠޟऋѴȂਲ਼ҏ൷ፙϚΰџоڙڏтӈդΙ ऋȄ! ! ! Fmmvmᖂ๖ᇳȈ2/ܚԤऋ໌؏ԤфቋȄ࿋ऋ໌؏ΙП७ቨёΟΙٲݍՙਢȂ ѪП७ࠓζ҆ณЍΟΙٲݍՙ8 Ȅٽԃऋф഼ٺுΡঈ഼ଢ଼॒ᐊሆΟȂծᓍϞՄ پޟᆠડΰޟᆧȃ഼ᇄዛІՄቨёΟȄӰԪȂܚԤऋ໌؏ԤڏфቋȂϚ ࣺ߬ᇳऋࣥቄϚளΡঈȂࠓζϚᔖ၎ᇯ࣏ѺջາளپޟȄ3/ऋЕଔޟ୰ᚠ Ш၌ؚޟ୰ᚠӻȄؐΙԩޟऋ໌Ͻ၌ؚΟ࢚ٲΡঈܚ७ᖝޟ୰ᚠȂࠓζᇧഅΟཱི
7 㬌⌛栆Ụ⇵徘 Ihde ㍸ᷳˬ㒜⡆—䷖⮷˭(magnification/reduction)㓰ㅱˤ
ޟ୰ᚠȄٽԃȂᚂีႀ६ճΟᔉڋޟЋȂζளپΟΡჰڼޟ۽ߝȂณՄࠓζ לԙΟΡοႆ഻ޟ୰ᚠȄ4/ԤޟڷԤઉޟࡣݎϚџϷᚔȄٽԃՌଢ଼ϽளپΟ഼ଢ଼Ψ ޟ၌ܹȂӣਢࠓζഅԙΟѶཾՄॊҡԙޥོ୰ᚠ9 ȇ5/ܚԤऋᗴ֤ΟϚџႱَޟࡣ ݎ)Fmmvm-!2:94-!qq/:8.:9*Ȅٽԃ࣏Οσೣᆍේෝ߆ᇄҝԽȂऄӃිݓоቨёે Ӵ७ᑖᎌ࿋ޟհݲȂሳ࣏ಒӫငᔼਝઉζߒ౪юऋޟ໌؏ȄծҐෆਟڗޟȂ ҝԽᇄෝ߆ٺπዱȂࣥՍੑ၌ΟπȂငႆघѲΪԑેհࡣȂπೝકᚽԙ࣏ᗻ ಖȂॳ֚ႆȂӴߒ൷༉഻ήᇦ៩ޟۭүΟȄ! ! ! ՄӵኺޟऋفಛϞϛȂऋޟቨߝЛΟӒഋޟΡΨ໔ȃᐭȃසΨоЅ ኈȄоमܻདौў൶ײᇄี౪ڟູޟΡኈȂӵᄂ፺ΰߖнϚџȂࣥՍҥܻ౪ фऋفಛޟፒᚕܒȂٺுौӈᘪӰܻӈդএΡޟ๖ݎζູپູ֨ᜲȂΡޟޟ ၾኈӈོೝใភܖ܇ȄٽԃȈઽᆞۢFjdinbooᇯ࣏т༉ᅾтޟӈᇄॎหࡾ ҰӖٙ၆ᅖนЊΡٮଚ܁ϛᕊȂтѫୈтᔖ၎ୈޟώհ: Ȅடཾগ౩پࣼȂOb{j ޟடཾΡষȂᚂৱȃώแৱȃॖۢȃρռ้ȂᇯઍޟஈΟтܚ၎ୈޟӈȂณՄ ๖ݎࠓΙൟσք)Evtfl-!3117!-!q/21:*Ȅ! ! ! FmmvmԪᆍҥऋՌк፣໌ՄᏲөऋؚۡ፣ޟᢎᘈȂھณԤڏᐿڗَ၌Ȃ୲ڏ ζЕଔϚЍ፴ᅸȄЎڏՌ2:61ԑфоپȂ೨ӻࣺᜰऋޟޥོȃࢇݽᇄগ౩ដᚠ ۖџоആႆၮሴޟΡϗȂоၮሴޟӫհПԒپёоଆٮၐყ၌ؚȂՄהఖऋ ܚளپޟџॳᓎᇄኇࡣݎୈӒ७ޟՃ໔ȄٽԃȂΡஅӰಢॎหȂีႆแ ϛϐԤ೨ӻޟϴӓ፣क़ਖ਼ΣีᖐȄ౪Ϭ೨ӻ१σϴӓώแ࡚೩Ȃӵೣგ೩ॎϞਢζོ ёΣϴҕღᡝޟଆ፣Ȃоᡱᇄቹ७ኄȂࣺᜰ୰ᚠޟՃኌџоёں۽Ȅ!
ဓȃऋޥོϛޟϴҕఀى!
8 劙⚳⛐ 18 ᶾ䲨㛓 19 ᶾ䲨⇅㗪䓙㕤⺽忚㨇㡘䷼ⶫ冯䳉䷼ⶍ⺈炻忈ㆸ⭞⹕ㇳⶍ喅㰺句炻⮶农姙⣂ㇳⶍⶍṢ⣙㤕炻 䚏⽟⮯幵(General Ned Ludd)忪ⷞ柀ⶍṢ㍉⍾㽨忚ㇳ㭝䟜⢆Ḯ䲬悉冯媦ᶩ㻊悉䘬ⶍ⺈姕⁁ˤṾᾹ㚨⼴Ẁ↢Ḯ 塓嗽㬣䘬ẋ₡炻Ữᷳ⼴䚏⽟ấ⫸(Luddites)ㆸ䁢⍵䥹㈨侭䘬ẋ⎵娆炻䎦ẋ䘬⍵䥹㈨侭⇯塓䧙䁢㗗㕘䚏⽟ấ⫸ (Neo-Luddites)ˤ㕘䚏⽟ấ⫸⍵䥹㈨䘬⍇⚈᷎朆㗗➢㕤⣙㤕炻㚜⣂䘬㗗㉝⇞䎦ẋ䥹㈨ⷞἮ䘬䔷暊冯⅟㻈ˤ Chellis Glendinning ⌛㕤 1990 ⸜䘤堐˨㕘䚏⽟ᷣ佑⭋妨˩(Neo-Luddite manifesto)ẍ斄↯䔞ẋ䥹㈨⮵㕤䓇㳣冯 䘬⦩傭ˤ⎎⢾⁷ Wendel Berry˪䁢ỽㆹᶵㇻ䬿屟暣儎˫(Why I am not going to buy a computer)ḇ屔暋Ḯ㕘 䥹㈨ⷞἮ䘬⭛嗽ˤNeil Postman ⇯㊯↢㕘䥹㈨炻⯌℞㗗暣夾炻忈ㆸḮˬ䪍⸜䘬㴰必˭炻䥹㈨ᶲ䘖㚫ˬ㬉ケ军 㬣˭ˤ侴㚨㽨䁰䘬⎗傥㗗⁷ Dr. Theodore Kaczynski 䫱ˬ悝⊭䁠⻰⭊˭(Unabomber)ˤKaczynski 㗗伶⚳≈ⶆ⣏ ⬠㝷厲↮㟉㔠⬠䲣㔁㌰炻冒 1979 ⸜崟炻➢㕤⍵⮵㕘䥹㈨䘬䩳⟜炻Ṿὧẍ悝⊭䁠⻰䁢㬎☐炻㱧叿刦㢖尒℔嶗 䁠念㱧嶗ⶆ䩳⣏⬠炻⊭㊔≈⣏䘬 Davis ↮㟉ˣ渥㷾❶䘬䋟Ṿ⣏⬠⍲㆟Ὤ㖶⣏⬠䫱ˤKaczynski ḳ䘤⼴晙⯭呁⣏ ㊧ⶆ⣂⸜炻䚜⇘⛐⟙䳁ᶲ䘤堐⍵䥹㈨⭋妨ㇵ塓㩊冱句䵚ˤ
! ! ਲ਼ ᐃ Bsjtupumf ޟ ᢎ ᘈ Ȃ ኈ )wjsuvf* ࡾ ޟ Ι ᆍ ಬ ᄛ Ꮄ ԙ ޟ ፴ ܒ )ejtqptjujpo*ȂтܚඪϞኈগ౩Ᏸ)wjsuvf!fuijdt*ौў୰ޟ୰ᚠ։Ȉȶרौԙ ࣏ΙএࡩኺޟΡȉȷ)Xibu!tibmm!J!cfȉ*ȄषЕժӵϬРऋޥོϛȂԤᜰϴҕޟ ኈौў୰ޟ൷Ȉȶӵऋޥོϛרौԙ࣏ΙএࡩኺޟΡȉȷ)Xibu!tibmm!J!cf!jo! ufdiopmphjdbm!tpdjfuzȉ*Մӵ७ᄇΡঈᇄऋࣺϣҺៈȂऋ࣏Ρܚี݂ȂΡζೝ ऋܚ१༭ϞϚџଛᙽȃฒџଟᗗޟऋޥོϛȂΡঈौԙ࣏ޟᔖ၎ஊ࡙ࣸࡦ ऋџளپޟ୰ᚠᇄॳᓎȂٮᑖྃϭΣऋ೩ॎȃंـᇄีႆแȂԃIfjefhhfs ܚᒝᇄऋԤȶՌҥᜰ߽ȷ)gsff!sfmbujpot*ޟΡȄ! ! ! ྥԪȂஅܻࠉक़ȂҏМᔣඪюȈ)2*ᇄЅᄇၗޟϴҕఀىȇ)3*ӈগ౩ޟ ϴҕఀىȂհ࣏ऋޥོϛيԁϴҕܚۣԤϞϴҕኈᇄϴҕఀىޟ၄шᇄՃȈ!
ΙȃᇄЅᄇၗޟϴҕఀى!
! ! ౪фϽऋհ࣏оਝᡒᒮ௮ࡕޟፒᚕفಛȂӵΡঈҡࣀںᎏޟऋࠢᇄفಛ ӵϚᘞଡؑਝޟႆแϛȂΡޟଢ଼லೝຜ࣏Ϛጂۡޟᡐଢ଼ӰશՄ҆ёо௶ ଶȂ೨ӻऋ೩ॎᇄࢇؚ๊ۡӰԪོөቋϛҳᇄӫ౩Ͻޟনࠌў໌ࡦՃȂᅾ ໔ ᗗ Ρ ޟ Ռ к ܒ ȃ ഺ അ ܒ ᇄ ၾ ኈ ӈ ཐ Ȅ ٽ ԃ Ȃ ഫ ࿋ ഼ Ͻ ন ࠌ Ȉ ਝ )fggjdjfodz*ȃџॎᆗܒ)dbdvmbcjmjuz*ȃџႱกܒ)qsfejdubcjmjuz*ЅߨΡऋޟ ڙ)dpouspm!uispvhi!opoivnbo!ufdiopmphz*!)ݓէထȃဨݠܑឍȂ3113*Ȃ։ ኺޟऋᡒᒮȄݽடড়кဎ)ufdiopdsbdz*அܻኺޟᢎᘈȂкऋंـȃี ᇄؚ๊டড়ᏰޱޟٱȂΙૡϴҕฒޣζϚᔖԤ᠌ᇄȄӰԪԤᜰऋޟࣺᜰؚ ๊ȂငலીмΟϴҕᑖྃᇄޟᐠོᇄުȄ! ! ! ծ୰ᚠȂऋޟ๖ݎ҆ณོᜰнএΡᇄӒᡝΡޟڼၼȂڏϚᔖ༉ೝຜ࣏Ѝ ኵடড়़ܖ᠌ΨΡρޟ㞽ȂՄۣೝຜ࣏ΙএϴӓሴȄӨএሴޟடড়ᏰޱȂ ࣥՍѓࢂӨӨཾޟΡρȂӵϴಀޟᅿڷڙήώհȂо࡚ҳΙᆍҕкޟȃᇄ Ԓޟȃϴޟऋؚ๊ϴӓሴȄӵኺޟϴӓሴϞϛȂϴҕޟབࡦᇄᑖྃᇄོ १ौޟኈȄ։ԃXjoofsܚࡾюȈ! ! ӳޑϦ҇ाޕၰӵՖୖᆶόӕᜪᜪࠠϐࣽמޑࠠ༟ၸำǴӕਔΨाޕ ၰ ӵ Ֆ ѐ ௗ ڙ ࣽ מ ё ૈ у ፏ ܭ ي ޑ ࠠ ༟ Κ ໆ )Xjoofs-! 2::6-!q/92*Ƕ! ! ! ѯၗᇳȂऋޥོϛޟيԁϴҕᔖ၎ौᑖྃкଢ଼Ӵᇄऋޟ೩ॎȃؚ๊ᇄ ஈႆแՄڞօלԙऋપוȄ։ԃGffocfshܚкޟȂ҆ᘗσᄇܻऋޟҕк ϴӓᇄȄтᇯ࣏Ȃऋفಛএࢇݽ׳րڷଢ଼ޟࡊᡝȂ౪фޥོޟ੫᠌࡚ҳӵ ऋܻۨڏϛޟӨᆍޥོࣀଢ଼ޟஅᙃϞΰȂѓࢂҡȃᚂᕛȃఀىᇄॖٱ้ሴȄӰ ՄࣺᄇޟȂޥོޟҕкϽሯौஅҏޟऋᇄࢇݽޟᡐϽȄଶߨҕкೝᘗڗ༈ಛޟ ࣨጣϞѴȂζ൷ᘗڗऋޟሴȂ֏ࠌҕкޟٺҢቋོή६Ȃҕкڙོ࡙ ംᅚੑѶ)ᗺኊȃఔᢎݲឍȂ3116Ȃॲ33*ȄGffocfshӰԪкΡঈᔖ၎кଢ଼ᇄٮ Ᏸོ௴ڥӻᆍלԒܰתڎᡝޟऋ੫᠌Ȃоᄂ౪ऋሴޟҕкϽȄ! ! ! ԃԪΙپȂऋ೩ॎԙ࣏Ιᆍ॒ၷΟࢇݽࡣݎޟ೩ॎȂՄޥོӻኵΡ௶ଶӵԪ ᆍ೩ॎϞѴϚҕкޟȂӰ࣏ΡঈԤܚᒝޟȶᇄޱցઉȷ)qbsujdjqbou!joufsftut*Ȅ ։ԃGffocfshࡾюȂΡঈΙҍΣڗऋᆩϛȂ൷ڎԤΟ࢚ٲޟ੫ցઉȂٲց ઉᇄᆍᇄܚբᓍޟܖԁܖᚽޟዖࣺᄇᔖȄ౪Ԇޟऋೣგငல݈ܻٲ ցઉȂծٮߨΙೱԃԪȂڏζџёоᗗջȄӵኺޟޑݷήȂএΡۖཎᜋڗҥܻڏ ᇄऋޟᜰՄೝ܇ຜȃᔆफ़ܖࡄڗтঈޟҡԆȄՄ࿋тঈџо఼ཿӴߒႀڏց ઉਢȂ൷Ԥᐠོਲ਼ᐃΡሯौᇄΨϞኄݿޟጒ൜پ१ཱི࡚ᄺऋᡝف)ᗺኊȃ ఔᢎݲឍȂ3116Ȃॲ33*Ȅ! ! ! Gffocfshᇯ࣏ȂԤᜰऋޟᏰࡦՃғौўᄇܻΡঈՌ٘ޟഺഅސᇄଢ଼ޟ๖ ݎ॒Ȅऋޥོᆹ࣏ΙএᐌᡝޟॎหȂആႆኄݿᇄࢇݽϭΣȂΡᄇܻऋ ޟҐپԤڏগ౩ӈȄтӰԪкȶऋҕкϽȷ)efnpdsbuj{joh!ufdiopmphz*Ȅ ऋלԒ࡞ЍԤҕкᇄޟഋϷȂGffocfshᇯ࣏Ȃ҆ആႆఀىȃ൬ᡝȃݲࡡЅऋ டཾ้پёо८ȄኺޟᢎᘈкौپՌܻNbsyᇄEfxfzȄNbsyࣺ߬ώΡџоӵऋ ޟஅᙃΰўᙽಋ౪фޥོȇEfxfzࠌהఖӵऋޟؚ๊ΰџоԤӻޟϴҕᇄȄ Gffocfshᇯ࣏ȂҥऋޟٺҢޱᇄڧޱҕкϽӴϭΣڗऋҡϞϛȂོԤ࡞Ϛӣ ܻऋடড়ᏰޱޟᢎᘈȄ፝ԃԪޟҕкϭΣȂӵᕗ߳ដᚠоЅᚂដᚠΰ७ϐငԤ Οԙݎ)Gffocfsh-!3118-!q/69*Ȅ! ! ! ՄӵኺޟҕкᇄϛȂϴҕ܄ԪϞޟᄇၗ҆ौޟώհȄCpshnbo൷ࡾюȈ! ࣁࣽמޗύޑঁϦ҇ǴᜅԋѸჹࣽמࢲՉ٤ϦӅ
ࡼǹԶࣁޣǴΓॺࠅۙܺܭཥᕉნޑΓᎶΚǵចόӼᆶᜤ аਆᄗޑ៥ΚǶ೭ኬޑҟ࣯ޟ่кᅈΑᅪቾᆶόӼǴऩाှ،೭ኬޑ ᆣ൩Ѹၸ҅ޑჹ၉ǴѸӧϦፕᏝՉྎ೯Ǵፕٗ٤Ԗ ،ۓཀကޑ٣аϷӵՖ٬೭٤٣ӧғࢲύૈ՞ԖዴۓԶЬाՏ ޑӅӕࡼ!)ۏቼਔǴ3114Ǵ।24:*Ƕ! ! ! ҥIbcfsnbt้ܚีޟȶቷដԒҕкȷ)efmjcfsbufmz!efnpdsbdz*։џୈ࣏ϴҕ ྜᄇၗޟڎᡝᄂ፺ПԒȄܚᒝޟቷដԒҕкȂ߽ࡾϴҕആႆ౩ܒ፣៝)ejtdpvstf* ޟПԒӵԤތដޟࢇݽȃݲࡡᇄၾኈ୰ᚠΰלԙӓᜋȇиོཎᜋڗӓᜋਢиџᒿ ޟȄҥܻؐএΡџқᒿȂӰԪ҆Ᏸಬ᠙ڥтΡޟϚӣཎَȂζ୲Ԥ᠙ڥܚԤཎ َڷϚᔆڙӈդΡȂϗўᔮᡛٲٱސᄇܚԤΡՄِԁޟȄٮጂ߳ؠԤӈդΡ ೝ௶ଶܖጢϽޟྜПԒȂи߳ᜌ৵༖ޱӣ้ޟࢇݽՃ໔)็жᗿឍȂ3114*Ȅѯ ၗᇳȂആႆቷដԒҕкޟแוȂএΡԁџоՄиζᔖ၎ႆᄇܻϴӓցઉޟ౩ܒՄ ϴޟଆ፣ՄೝᡐȂڏΙএѓৠܚԤΡάϚᔆफ़ܖ௶ଶӈդΡޟࢇݽϞᢎ܈לԙ ᇄཎסלԙޟᐇհПԒȄ! ! ! ՄӵቷដԒҕк࿋ϛȂ҆ौ߳ᜌ፣៝ޟܹо٩Х๊ܒޟ࣏ܖӓᒗȂӰԪ Ιএ౩དܒޟቷដԒҕкޥတᔖ၎џоՌҥӴᇄȂиᇄԙষঈᓍਢႱരӵ፣ ៝ႆแϛᡐڏᢎᘈȄӵΙএቷដԒޟ፣៝ႆแϞϛȂӓᜋᇄؚۡޟႀԙϚ༉ᇄ ޱϞࠉ։ڎԤϞցઉܖཎَޟІࢎȂζڏӵӱᔖΟ፣ᜌϞࡣܚήޟրᘞ)Njmmfs-! 3111*ȄӰԪӵቷដԒޟ፣៝ႆแϛȂఖሯؑȃ৯ᇯޣܖওғሯؑޟ౩၌ौೝ ՃኌȄѯၗᇳȂቷដԒҕкܚႀԙޟҬٮϚΙᆍޣᜋΰޟӓᜋȂՄौ֕౪ю ଆ፣ႆแᇄϱৠϛϚӣᢎᘈޟϴғҁᒋ)Njmmfs-!3111*ȄՄആႆቷដԒҕкޟПԒȂ ϴҕџоᑖྃӴᇄڗऋޥོޟفಛϞϛȂٮඪଽӨऋٱؚ๊ႆแޟแוӫ ݲܒȄ! ! ! ᆣΰܚक़Ȃऋޥོϛޟϴҕོᕣ၌ڗΙএཱིऋفಛޟ೩ॎҐپтौҡࣀܻ ڏϛޟުȂт҆ӱᔖڗBsjtupumfᄇܻيԁϴҕኈޟᢎᘈȂζ൷ौ౩၌ڗԃ դӣਢհ࣏Ιএݽ౩Ρᇄೝݽ౩ΡȄՄӵऋޥོϛȂԁޟϴҕ։ौўޣၾԃդ ᇄڗϚӣϞऋޟ༭ႆแȂӣਢζौޣၾԃդўڧऋџོёܻ፝٘ΰޟ ༭Ψ໔Ȃζϗᅋԁӣਢୈ࣏ݽ౩Ρᇄೝݽ౩ΡޟُՓȄ!
Πȃӈগ౩ޟϴҕఀى!
! ! Njudibn)2::5*ෆငࡾюȂ༈ಛޟগ౩Ᏸ፡ޟΡሬᜰ߽Ȃฒ፣ਝઉ፣ܖ ဎ፣গ౩ᏰȂஅҏΰݧ१ΡၭΡϞᔖ၎ԃդࣺϣҺ܁ޟ୰ᚠȄณՄȂՙПՌ ౪фϽоپȂҥܻऋޟีЅڏϠΡޟ१σኇȂগ౩Ᏸҏ٘ޟጒ൜ϐငᘗσ ڗΟѓࢂΡᇄߨΡޟжࣨȂԃଢ଼ސȃՌณᇄΡώᇧࠢޟᜰ߽Ȅӵ౪фऋޟᔆΨήȂ Njudibnᇯ࣏ȂӨᆍלԒޟӈϚᘞᘗσᇄᡐϽȂቨߝޟऋΨ໔Ѕڏᅤആሴϐင ٺுᇄӨᆍऋࣀଢ଼ࣺᜰޟݲࡡȃࢇݽȃငᔼȃޥོȃ۠ఀȃၾኈ้ӈζϚᘞᓍ ϞቨߝȄٲᡐϽѓ֤ԤϤএП७Ȉ2/ԤᜰӈޟݲࡡלԒޟ၌ភȂ҆ᘗڗᄇܻ ࠢޟӈᇄᕗცҡᄘޟӈȄ3/ቨёऋᏰড়ঈᄇܻޥོӈ୰ᚠޟఃཐ࡙Ȅ4/ี ᙛཾ࣏ྥࠌᇄޥོӈগ౩ᏰޟଆȄ5/൷அఀधශϛӈᇄऋᜰ߽ඪюࢅ ᏽ Ȅ 6/ ᄇ ऋ ޥ ོ ϛ ޟ ӈ ୰ ᚠ ໌ Ᏸ Ϸ ݙ )Njudibn-! 2::5* Ȅȶ ӈ ȷ )sftqpotjcjmjuz*҆ԙ࣏ऋޥོϛ१ौޟኈϞΙȄ!! ! Nbsujo! Ifjefhhfs ޟ Ᏸ ҡ Ȃ Ibot! Kpobt:
ӵ Ȳ ऋ ᇄ ӈ ȳ )Ufdiopmphz! boe! Sftqpotjcjmjuz*)Kpobt-!3115*ΙМϛ൷ࡾюȂ࿋фऋϐငᡐΟ೨ӻΡଢ଼ޟ ܒ፴ȂՄগ౩ᏰᜰЖޟ൷Ρޟଢ଼ȂӰԪগ౩Ᏸζ҆ौԤܚᡐȄ༈ಛޟগ౩ Ᏸ౩፣ۡΟΡଢ଼ޟѲএ੫፴Ȉ2/ᄇܻߨΡٱސޟଢ଼—ׇӒऋޟሴ—ӵ গ౩Ᏸΰϛҳޟȇ3/গ౩ᏰΡϛЖȂڏ༉ᜰЖΡᜰ߽ȇ4/ΡܒϚོೝऋܚ ᡐȇ5/গ౩ᏰܚᜰЖޟӵΙএ३ۡޟਢުᕗცϞϛȄՄ൷ԃӣKpobtܚࡾюޟȂ ࿋фऋϐငᡐΟܚԤޟٱȂኇӒ౨ޟཱིΨ໔ΟΙএࠉܚҐԤޟཱིޟӈ ७ ө Ȃ গ ౩ Ᏸ ҆ ԙ ߝ ڗ џ о ѓ ֤ এ ཱི ޟ ७ ө Ȅ Kpobt ၿ ඪ ю Ο ȶ ӈ ন ࠌ ȷ )qsjodjqmf!pg!sftqpotjcjmjuz*հ࣏ऋޥོϛগ౩Ᏸޟ੫ȂоဴѢΡঈ॒ଔ ުࠉޟၾኈဎȄ! ! ! ӵ2:8:ԑ)़Мގ2:95ԑ*ѐշޟȮӈন౩Ȉ൶ײऋਢфޟগ౩ᏰȯΙਪϛȂ
9
Hans Jonas(1903-1993)䁢 Heidegger ⚃⣏䋞⣒⻇⫸ᷳᶨ炻℞ṾᶱṢ↮⇍㗗 Emmanuel Levinasˣ Hannah Arendt 冯 Herbart MarcuseˤJonas1903 ⸜䓇㕤⽟⚳炻1933 ⸜䓙㕤䲵䱡䘬従⭛徫⇘劙⚳炻㇘⼴⭂⯭≺㕗✎᷎ả㔁㕤 ⶴỗἮ⣏⬠ˤ1950 ⸜䦣⯭≈㊧⣏炻1955 ⸜䦣⯭䲸䲬炻1976 ⸜徨ẹ炻1993 ⸜必㕤䲸䲬ˤJonas 斄㲐䥹㈨䘬ΐ䎮 ⬠炻㍸↢屔ảΐ䎮⬠䘬奨溆ˤᷣ天叿ἄ㚱烉˪䓇␥䎦尉—崘⎹⒚⬠䓇䈑⬠˫(The Phenomenon of Life: Toward a Philosophical Biology, 1966)ˣ˪屔ả⍇䎮—⮳㈦䥹㈨㗪ẋ䘬ΐ䎮⬠˫(The Imperative of Responsibility: In Search of Ethics for the Technological Age, 1979)ˣ˪婾䥹㈨ˣ慓⬠冯ΐ䎮⬠˫(Technik, Medizin und Ethik-Zur Praxis des Prinzips Verantwortung, 1985)䫱ˤ
Kpobt፵៉ΟIfjefhhfsᄇܻ౪фऋޟԆԤ፣ࡦՃȂࡾюΟȶ٥ٲᗵ឴ܻΡׇᐌܒ ޟσኇΨᇄၥྛޟ࢝ᆑȂٺΡΨ໔ޟᘗቨբᓍՌר྅܈ᇄԆӵϞޟҭࣽȄȷ )Kpobt-!2:95*ȄKpobtॶӑ൷ᄇܻ༈ಛগ౩ᏰޟΡϛЖкဎ)Bouspqpdfousjtn*໌ Ο׳րȂтࡾюᐌএ༈ಛޟগ౩Ᏸ൷ΙᆍΡϛЖ፣ޟগ౩ᏰȂฒ፣Bsjtupumf ޟኈ፣ȂᗙஅఀޟيЖ፣ȂࣥܖJnn/!Lbouޟဎ፣ȃK/!T/!Njmmޟਝઉ፣ȃ ᗙӨᆍၾኈࣺᄇкဎȂܚԤٲগ౩ᏰΙᆍΡϛЖкဎޟগ౩ᏰȂٲগ౩ ӵҏ፴ΰΙᆍȶߖຽᚔޟগ౩ȷ)Obfditufo.Fuijl*Ȃ։Ԥ৯้ϞདྷȄȶߖຽᚔ ޟগ౩ȷӵҏ፴ΰΙᆍкᡝΰܖкᡝՌࡡܖтࡡޟগ౩ᏰȂᄇΡᇄΡϞޟၾ ኈᜰ߽ඪюޟೣጒڷघȄՄฒ፣ၾኈޟҬӵܻՌҥȂᗙӵܻኈȂζฒ፣ၾ ኈޟྥএΡ࣏ޟϱӵྥࠌȂᗙޥོ࠶घޟғဎڷѴӵೣጒȂٲগ౩Ᏸޟᄂ ፴ΰڏᄂᄇΡϞᇄ᠌ցޟᜰݧȄ! ! ! ณՄኺޟΡϛЖ፣ޟগ౩ᏰȂӵऋୈ࣏кᡒᒮޟ౪фޥོϛȂϐငᡗ៩ юѺঈޟмڷฒ࣏ΨȂӰ࣏ѺঈӵऋޟฒҬޟܒޟᛁσΨ໔७ࠉЙฒ๊ȂҐ ඪ ю Ι ᆍ ऋ ਢ ф ޟ ၾ ኈ ӈ ন ࠌ Ȅ Kpobt Ӱ Մ к Ι ᆍ ȶ ሉ ຽ ᚔ ޟ গ ౩ ȷ )Fuijl efs Gfsof*Ȅᆍȶሉຽᚔޟগ౩ȷ७ᄇޟϚӔΡᆠડܒޟၾኈ֨ცȂՄ ӵऋಛݽޟࡄήȂΡܚᔖ࿋ܛᐊޟӈȄᆍӈޟҏ፴ᄇՌณޟᜰݧޟ ဎȂՄϚᄇΡޟᜰϸȄȶሉຽᚔޟগ౩ȷ౪ӵޟΡᄇܻϐငԆӵޟՌณڷ ҐپҡڼޟӈюีޟȂӰԪڏ߽࣏ΙᆍᜰݧΡᇄՌณҡԆኺᄘޟԆԤ፣ȄՄኺ ޟӈন౩षҢLbouޟِۡхԒپᇳޟၗȂ൷Ȉȶձޟ࣏ޟࡣݎौᇄઍғΡҡ ࣀޟࡻδܒ߳ࡻঙৠȷ)Bdu!tp!uibu!uif!fggfdut!pg!zpvs!bdujpo!bsf!dpnqbujcmf! xjui!uif!qfsnbofodf!pg!hfovjof!ivnbo!mjgf/*Ȃڏ֏ۡޟߒႀלԒࠌȈȶձޟ ࣏ޟࡣݎϚકᚽᆍҡࣀޟҐپџܒȄȷ)Bdu!tp!uibu!uif!fggfdut!pg!zpvs! bdujpo!bsf!opu!eftusvdujwf!pg!uif!gvuvsf!qpttjcjmjujft!pg!tvdi!mjgf/*!)Kpobt-! 2:95*Ȅ! ! ! ᄇܻKpobtՄِȂӈগ౩ޟনࠌ։ӵܻौؑΡଢ଼ޟࡣݎौᄇՌณޟҐپڷ ΡޟҐپ॒ȂܛᐊଔΡհ࣏ԇۤ୲ΙڎԤ॒ΨϞԆԤޟဎȄኺΙᆍ ӈন౩ޟΨȂкौࠌپՌܻᄇܻऋџளپϞॳᓎޟႱȄҥܻΡџоႱ ऋΨ໔ོளپ࢚ᆍแ࡙ޟ༌ᇄࡄȂ໌ՄЖ౩ΰོҡৼាϞཐՄԤܚంีȂ Ԫ։Kpobtܚᒝޟȶৼាంีݲȷ)ifvsjtujdt!pg!gfbs*!)Kpobt-!2:95*Ȅһ։Ȃᙤ
ҥᄇܻऋܚџளپϞॳᓎᇄӠᐠޟৼាȂΡ॒҆ଔӈȂବᄇ٥ٲৠܾڧ༌ ޟȃޟЅৠܾԥᚽޟтޱȂѓࢂΟՌณᇄΡՌ॒٘ଔӈȄՄ॒ଔӈޟΡ ᇄೝ߳៖ޟᄇຫࠌΙᆍȶЮҔӈȷ)qbsfoubm!sftqpotjcjmjuz*ޟלԒȄ ኺޟΙᆍЮҔᄇυτޟӈȂ࣏ΙᆍϚџଛޟᜰ߽ȂӰ࣏ЮҔᄇтޟࡆυڎԤϚџ௰ ڣޟဎȄӵԪᆍϚџଛޟᜰ߽ϞϛȂौؑז៖ޟ৵ޱȂՄܛᐊז៖ӈޟࠌԤ ଢ଼ΨޟޱȄྥԪȂࣺᄇܻΡՄِȂՌณڷҐپޟҡڼ৵ޱȂЎڏӵऋಛ ݽޟσΨ໔७ࠉȂհ࣏৵ޱޟՌณڷҐپޟҡڼሯौ࿋фΡܛᐊଔՌϏޟӈ ᇄဎȂՄζ൷ᏰޟҐپȂζՌณڷҡڼޟҐپ)Kpobt-!2:95*Ȅ! ! ! KpobtоЮҔᄇυτޟלԒौؑΡᄇܻՌณᇄҐپ॒ଔӈȂھณතҰΟհ ࣏ސϞޟΡฒџᗗջȃϚџ௰ڣՄ҆ܛᐊޟগ౩ӈȄณՄȂԃԪޟᢎᘈڏ ᄂٮҐၰಳڏܚ׳րޟȶΡϛЖкဎȷȂζФી࣏ᢎޟҡᄘຜഏȄ࿋ф࡙ ҡᄘᏰ)effq!fdpmphz*։໌Ι؏Ӵᇯ࣏Ȃၾኈဎޟौؑ҆ᘗЅڗܚԤޟҡᄘ ࣨȇ࡙ҡᄘᏰၼଢ଼)effq!fdpmphz!npwfnfou*ζौؑΡ҆ඳణΡୈ࣏ԇۤϛЖ ޟࡦՃԒȂᙽ࣏оҡᄘ࣏ϛЖ)fdpdfousjd*ޟᕗცগ౩ᏰࡦՃԒȄਘࡄᏰড় Bsof!ObfttЅڏЛࡻޱܻ2:95ԑ൷ඪю࡙ҡᄘᏰޟΤᘈᆪሴоհ࣏ଢ଼ྥࠌ)ЕՌ ഌᄂฃȂ3113Ȃॲ233*Ȉ! Ӧౚ܌ԖΓᜪϷߚΓᜪғڮޑғӸᆶวԖځሽॶ)ӕကӷǺϣӧ ሽॶǵ܍ޑሽॶ*Ƕ೭٤ሽॶᐱҥܭࣁΓᜪޑҞޑޑπڀሽॶǶ! 2/!ᙦᆶӭኬޑғڮԄૈᡏ೭٤ሽॶǴӭኬ܄ҁيΨڀԖϣӧሽ ॶǶ! 3/!ΓᜪؒԖΚߺ෧೭ᅿᙦᆶӭኬ܄ǴନߚࢂӢࣁױᜢғӸ܌ሡǶ! 4/!ΓᜪғڮϷЎϯޑᕷᄪࢂҗϿኧΓวᆶᐱ՞ޑǴߚΓᜪғڮޑᕷ ᄪΨा೭٤ϿኧΓޑոΚǶ! 5/!ӧΓᜪࢂၸҽߺ෧ߚΓᜪШࣚǴݩВᅌൾϯǶ! 6/!ࡹѸঅׯǶ೭٤ࡹቹៜډ୷ҁᔮǵࣽמϷཀࠠᄊޑ่ ᄬǶനࡕ่݀ஒόӕܭӧޑݩǶ! 7/!ཀࠠᄊޑׯᡂԋΓᜪғࢲࠔ፦ޑׯᡂ)ᖿӛڀᆒઓϣӧሽ፦ޑ ғࢲύ*Զόࢂѝӧाނ፦ғࢲޑНѳޑගϲԶςǶ!
8/!ЬॊӚᗺޑΓॺԖޔௗ܈໔ௗޑက୍ѐჴ፬೭٤ѸाޑׯᡂǶ! ! ! ࡙ҡᄘᏰᇯ࣏ՌณՌԆȂϚ࣏ΡԆȂԤڏϱӵҏ፴Ȅ࡙ҡᄘᏰюีȂȶҗ ៉ีȷ)tvtubjobcjmjuz*ԙ࣏ᄇऋߒႀҡᄘᜰᛄޟ१ौ྅܈Ȅ2:98ԑᖒӫȶж ࣨᕗცᇄีۏষོȷ)XDFE*ีߒCsvoeumboeൢ֙ਪȂڼӪ࣏ȮרঈӓӣޟҐپȯ)Pvs! Dpnnpo!Gvuvsf*ȂғԒත㎄ȶҗ៉ีȷޟ౩܈ᇄۡဎȈࢋᅖٗ࿋фΡϞሯؑȂάϚ ӠЅήΙфΡᅖٗڏሯؑΨϞีȄᆧ2::3ԑᖒӫӵБՙ٨घѢȶӴ౨ଽ ৫ོȷ)Fbsui!Tvnnju*ȂีߒȮΠΪΙжकដแȯ)Bhfoeb!32*ȂζೣგΟӒ౨ӓ ӣஈҗ៉ีޟώհᙢყȄ! ! ! ᆣΰܚक़ȂऋีܚளپޟџӒ౨ॳᓎᇄΡخᜲ้Ȃफ़ٺΡঈ҆ўཎ ᜋڗᄇএжࣨᇄήΙфΡޟϴҕӈޟ୰ᚠȂΡঈ୲ԤᄇՌ٘ᇄтΡޟცߒ౪ юଽޟϴҕӈগ౩ȂΡޥོϗџᛧۡᆰࡻᇄҗ៉ีȄӰԪȂऋޥོϛޟ ϴҕኈȂϚӔ༉࡚ҳӵȶ࣏ϏՄԆȷՄϐȂՄ҆ߝሉӴўࡦՃᇄܛᐊΙᆍᄇ ܻтޱޟӈᇄဎϞΰޟȶ࣏тޱԆȷޟϴҕޥོȄ! !
ӂȃ๖ᇭ!
! ! ࿋фޥོϐငএଽ࡙ีޟऋޥོȂԃդஉᎴΡঈӵऋޥོϛޟϴҕኈ ȂоᑖྃӴᆰ៖ᇄቨ໌ӒΡޥོޟӓӣցઉȂऋޥོีޟ१ौដᚠȂζԙ ࣏ϴҕఀىޟ१ौ፞ᚠȄٱᄂΰȂऋᔖ၎հ࣏ႀڗΡҬޟޟЙࢲᇄհҢȂϚᔖ Іႆپԙ࣏ڙΡܒޟώڎᡝفȄྥԪȂҏМ፡҆ᝒӴࣼΡМϽϛऋޟ ፒᚕُՓȂкऋޥོϛ҆Ϡऋӵϴҕኈᇄϴҕఀىϛޟ१ौ՝ညȄࡸྱ ኺޟᢎᘈȂऋࠢ҆ೝຜ࣏ڎԤϴӓܒՄԤᒦ೩ॎޱᇄٺҢޱޟҕкᇄȂҥ ೩ॎޱȃٺҢޱᇄऋࠢέПҺៈϣଢ଼Մל༭ࣺᜰޟϴҕኈȄѪѴȂऋีܚ џளپϞॳᓎᇄ୰ᚠȂζඪᒺΟӓӣҡࣀܻԪऋޥོϛޟܚԤΡўݧཎڗ࣏Ο тޱޟӓӣցઉᇄ҆ӓӣܛᐊޟӈগ౩ȇоϚӣܻΡϛЖᇳޟߖຽᚔগ౩Ȃ ፡հ࣏тޱޟՌณސȃҐپжфϞҡڼઽΣӈՃ໔ޟሉຽᚔগ౩Ȃζऋޥ ོϛۦҐׇӒೝஅӰώแᐇיᇄڙϞ౩ܒΡޟ१σӈȂϴҕఀىޟ१ौϱ ొដᚠȄ!!
ՃМᝦ!
ኊਢ)ឍ*)3114*Ȅၮູࡣ౪фޟϷࣨጣ)নհޱȈCpshnbo*ȄѕٵȈ୦ӟਪᓢȄ! ݓઝထȃဨݠܑ)ឍ*)3113*Ȅޥོޟഫ࿋഼Ͻ)নհޱȈSju{fs*ȄᇃѕȈ҄සȄ! ഌᄂฃ)3113*Ȅଆ࡙ҡᄘᏰୈ࣏ᕗცఀىϞᏰஅᙃȄၷܻឃҗ݂)кጡ*ȂȮऋ ᄇఀىޟፐᔞȯ)212.251ॲ*ȄᇃѕȈϤࠒȄ! ็жᗿ)ឍ*)3114*ȄӵٱᄂᇄೣጒϞ)নհޱȈIbcfsnbt*ȄѕٵȈέᖒਪ۹Ȅ! ྆֬)2::8*Ȅྜ౩ܒȃҡڼᛄᇄఀىႆแȋࠤղᅴޟྜ౩ܒᇄఀىȄᇃѕȈ ৱσਪीȄ! ྆ࢸݘ)3122*ȄNbsujo!Ifjefhhfs፣ऋЅڏఀىཎဎȄఀىᏰᇬȂ36ȄᇃࠒȈᇃࠒ σᏰȄ! ᗺኊȃఔᢎݲ)ឍ*)3116*Ȅऋ׳ր౩፣)নհޱȈGffocfsh*ȄѕٵȈѕٵσᏰȄ! Bsjtupumf!)2:95*/!Qpmjujdt!)C/!Kpxfuu!Usbot/*/!Jo!K/!Cbsoft!)Fe/*-!Uif!Dpnqmfuf! Xpslt!pg!Bsjtupumf!Wpm/!JJ*/!Qsjodfupo-!OK;!Qsjodfupo!Vojwfstjuz!Qsftt/!! Cbdpo-!G/!)2:71*/!Uif!Hsfbu!Jotubvsbujpo/!Jo!G/!Boefstpo!)Fe/*-!Uif!Ofx!Pshopo! boe!Sfmbufe!Xsjujoht/!Joejbobqpmjt-!JO;!Cpcct.Nfssjmm!Dp/! Cpoofu!)2::9*/!Fevdbujpo!jo!b!eftujuvuf!ujnf;!B!Ifjefhhfsjbo!bqqspbdi!up!uif! qspcmfn!pg!fevdbujpo!jo!uif!bhf!pg!npefso!ufdiopmphz/!Jo!Q/!Ijstu!'!Q/! Xijuf! )Fet/*! -!Qijmptpqiz! pg! fevdbujpo;! Nbkps! uifnft! jo! uif! bobmzujd! usbejujpo/!Mpoepo-!Fohmboe;!Spvumfehf/!Evtfl-!W/!)3117*/!Qijmptpqiz!pg!Ufdiopmphz/!Pygpse-!Fohmboe;!Cmbdlxfmm/! Fmmvm!K/!)2:94*/!Uif!ufdiopmphjdbm!psefs/!Jo!D/!Njudibn!'!S/!Nbdlfz!)Fet/*-!
Qijmptpqiz! boe! Ufdiopmphz-! Sfbejoht! jo! uif! Qijmptpqijdbm! Qspcmfnt! pg! Ufdiopmphz/!Ofx!Zpsl-!OZ;!Uif!Gsff!Qsftt/!
Gffocfsh-!B/!)3118*/!Upxbse!b!Efnpdsbujd!Qijmptpqiz!pg!Ufdiopmphz/!Jo!K/L/! Cfsh! Pmtfo! '! F/! Tfmjohfs! )Fet/*-!Qijmptpqiz! pg! Ufdiopmphz/! Bvupnbujd! Qsftt/!
)Fet/*-!Qijmptpqiz!boe!Ufdiopmphz-!Sfbejoht!jo!uif!Qijmptpqijdbm!Qspcmfnt! pg!Ufdiopmphz/!Ofx!Zpsl-!OZ;!Uif!Gsff!Qsftt/!
Ipslifjnfs-!N/!'!Bepsop-!U/!)2:83*/!Ejbmfdujd!pg!Fomjhiufonfou/!Ofx!Zpsl-!OZ;! Dpoujovn/!
Jief-! E/! )2::1*/!Ufdiopmphz! boe! uif! Mjgfxpsme/! Cmppnjohupo-! JO;! Joejbob! Vojwfstjuz!Qsftt/ġ Lojhiu-!L/!)3118*/!Bsjtupufmjbo!qijmptpqiz;!Fuijdt!boe!qpmjujdt!gspn!Bsjtupumf! up!NbdJouzsf/!ńŢŮţųŪťŨŦ-!Fohmboe;!Qpmjuz!Qsftt/! Nbsdvtf-!I/!)2:75*/!Pof!Ejnfotjpobm!Nbo/!Mpoepo-!Fohmboe;!Spvumfehf/! Njmmfs-!E/!)3111*/!Djuj{fotijq!boe!Obujpobm!Jefoujuz/!Dbncsjehf-!Fohmboe;! Qpmjuz/! Njudibn-!D/!)2:91*/!Qijmptpqiz!pg!ufdiopmphz/!Jo!Q/!U/!Evscjo!)Fe/*-!B!Hvjef! up!uif!Dvmuvsf!pg!Tdjfodf-!Ufdiopmphz-!boe!Nfejdjof/!Ofx!Zpsl-!OZ;!Uif! Gsff!Qsftt/! Njudibn-!D/!)2::5*/!Uijoljoh!Uispvhi!Ufdiopmphz;!uif!Qbui!cfuxffo!Fohjoffsjoh! boe!Qijmptpqiz/!Dijdbhp-JM;!Uif!Vojwfstjuz!pg!Dijdbhp!Qsftt/! Kpobt-!I/!)2:95*/!Uif!Jnqfsbujwf!pg!Sftqpotjcjmjuz;!Jo!Tfbsdi!pg!Fuijdt!gps! uif!Ufdiopmphjdbm!Bhf/!Q/51/!Dijdbhp-!JM;!Dijdbhp!Vojwfstjuz!Qsftt/! Kpobt-!I/!)3115*/!Ufdiopmphz!boe!Sftqpotjcjmjuz/!Jo!E/!Lbqmbo!)Fe/*-!Sfbejoht! jo!uif!Qijmptpqiz!pg!Ufdiopmphz/!Pygpse-!Fohmboe;!Spxnbo!'!Mjuumfgjfme! Qvcmjtifst-!Jod/! Xjoofs-!M/!)2::6*/!Djuj{fo!wjsuvft!jo!b!ufdiopmphjdbm!psefs/!Jo!B/!Gffocfsh! '! B/! Iboobz! )Fet/*-! Uif! Qpmjujdt! pg! Lopxmfehf/! Cmppnjohupo! boe! Joejbobqpmjt-JO;!Joejbob!Vojwfstjuz!Qsftt/!
! ! !