• 沒有找到結果。

Bulletin of Educational Psychology

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Bulletin of Educational Psychology"

Copied!
21
0
0

加載中.... (立即查看全文)

全文

(1)

൏ᕇྋՙൺഇᏙથ̚ᙯᔣયή۞ྻϡᄃ

༊ְˠͅᑕ̶̝ژࡁտ

Ŏ

׹ Ϝ ৌ

ϛई̂ጯ

ᑕϡ͕நጯր

ώࡁտଣ੅Ꮩથरдᑕϡ൏ᕇྋՙൺഇᏙથሀёॡĂྻϡЧᙷᙯᔣયήĞ୏ኘ݈ƝมԼតય ήăּγયήă઄నયήăณ͎યήğ۞ᄬήਔඛĂͽ̈́༊ְˠ၆఺ֱયή۞ͅᑕĂͽਕ׍ វᒢྋ׎ม̢જ۞፟טࠎңĄώࡁտפ଀αҜՐӄ̚ొߙۤડᏙથ፟ၹ۞јѐ༊ְˠТຍણ ᄃĂᄃ˟Ҝჟሢ SFBC ሀё۞Ꮩથर̶ҾซҖαҌ̱Ѩ۞ᏙથĂ֭ٺՏѨᏙથඕՁޢତצణ ኘĂͽᒢྋ༊ְˠдᏙથ࿅඀̚۞̰дͅᑕĄ̶ژ 21 ЊᏙથుфቇĂͽ̈́ 17 Њణኘుфቇ۞ ̰टֽаඍࡁտયᗟĄࡁտඕڍ̶ҾౘࢗЧᙷᙯᔣયή۞ྻϡĂͽ̈́༊ְˠͅᑕ۞ଐԛĂ֭ ੫၆၁ચᑕϡ̈́Ϗֽࡁտ೩΍ޙᛉĄ ᙯᔣෟĈ൏ᕇྋՙൺഇᏙથăᏙથԫμăᏙથ።඀ă༊ְˠͅᑕ ܕ˟˩ѐֽĂЯᑕ၁ચ̍ү˯۞ˠ˧ă༊ְˠ۞Րӄݭၗ두ࢋĂͽ̈́གྷᑻड़ৈඈયᗟĂൺഇᏙ થᑕྻ҃ϠĂ֭ు႙צזࢦෛĞ׹ϜৌĂϔ 85 ć Basile, 1996; Lee, 1997ğćଂధкጯ۰೩΍Ч჌ൺഇ ۞ᑕϡሀёĂՀΞពϯൺഇᏙથдᏙથ૞ຽ۞ᅳા̏ҫѣ˘य̝гĂ҃ͷ૟޺ᜈצזڦຍĞWell & Phelps, 1990ğĄ ൺ ഇ Ꮩ થ ј ࠎ ᔌ ๕ Ă ̙ ่ Ч ࣎ ந ኢ ጯ ࠁ ൴ ण ΍ ͽ ྵ ᖎ ൺ ۞ ॡ ม ֽ ఍ ந ༊ ְ ˠ ય ᗟ ۞ ሀ ё ĞMcLeod, 1993ğĂధкጯ۰ϺͽԶਾ۞͞ёֽޙၹൺഇᏙથć׎̚ de Shazer ᄃ׎Тဈצז Milton

Ericksonă MRI ൺഇڼᒚăඉரפШăᄮۢҖࠎඈЧ჌நኢ៍ᕇ۞ᇆᜩĂд Brief Family Therapy

Center൴ण΍൏ᕇྋՙൺഇᏙથĞSolution-Focused Brief Counseling, ᖎჍ SFBCğĂ҃ޢᐌ඾ de Shazer Ğ1985, 1988, 1991ğώˠౙᜈгଂ׎၁ચགྷរ̚ඕะтңᑕϡ۞ኢࢗĂͽ̈́ధкጯ۰૟൏ᕇྋՙ۞ໄ ه׶఍ந͞ёᑕϡдЧ჌̙Т၆෪˯۞ଣ੅ĞּтĈ Berg, 1994; Berg & Miller, 1992; Corcoran, 1997;

Weiner-Davis, de Shazer, & Gingerich, 1987ğĂ SFBC ̏൒јࠎ͕நᏙથࠧ̚౵າ۞ᑕϡሀё̝˘

ĞCorcoran, 1997ğĄ ൏ᕇྋՙĂٕߏͽྋՙࠎ൏ᕇĂߏൺഇᏙથ۞͹ࢋপᇈ̝˘ĞLittrell, 1998ğĄᔵ൒ᇃཌྷгֽᄲĂ ઼ ϲ ᄂ ៉ र ቑ ̂ ጯ ି ֈ ͕ ந ᄃ ᅃ ጱ ጯ ր ିֈ͕நጯಡĂϔ 94 Ă 36 סĂ 4 ഇĂ 335 Ǖ 355 ࢱ ොĈώࡁտࠎ઼ࡊົྃӄ̝૞ᗟࡁտĂࢍ൪በཱིࠎ NSC 89-2413-H-018-030 Ą ώࡁտ̝ԆјĂপҾຏᔁڒ༮ૅАϠ׶ᗞࢢ͕̈ؓдࡁտ̈́Җ߆૷ચ˯۞םӄĄ

(2)

ٙѣ۞Ꮩથሀёౌߏͽྋՙ༊ְˠ۞યᗟࠎ൏ᕇĂ൒҃ SFBC ٙ൴ण΍ֽ۞ྋՙඉரѣ׎পѣ۞ࣰጯ ׶ܫهૄᖂĂтڍϏྋ׎ࣧ̚நĂಶޝᙱડᏰͽྋՙࠎ൏ᕇĞsolution-focusedğ׶ͽયᗟࠎ൏ᕇ Ğproblem-focusedğ˟۰۞मளࠎңĄ צז Erickson ۞ᇆᜩĂ SFBC ࠹ܫՏ࣎ˠౌѣྋՙҋ̎યᗟ۞ྤ໚׶ਕ˧Ăஎܫଂ༊ְˠٙӔன ۞યᗟٕҖࠎাېĂಶΞͽԱ΍ྋՙ׶Լត۞ბࣔć Erickson ˵ᄮࠎ˘࣎̈̈۞Լតυ൒ົ͔൴׎΁ Հ̂۞ԼតĂᏙથಶଂୁજ఺̈Լត۞൴ϠฟؕĄੵ˞఺჌࠹ܫˠѣਕ˧ྋՙҋ̎યᗟĂ֭ࢦෛ࣎ˠ ۞Ξਕّ̈́ᐹܜ۞ˠώܫه̝γĂޙၹ͹ཌྷĞconstructivismğߏ׎Ω˘࣎ࢦࢋ۞ࣰጯૄᖂĄޙၹ͹ཌྷ ᄮࠎĂՏ࣎ˠౌдޙၹҋ̎۞གྷរ׶͵ࠧćԧࣇ۞ۢᛇಶߏԧࣇ۞ன၁Ğour perception is our realityğ ĞWebb, 1999ğĂˠ۞ӧᕘٕયᗟĂӈдٺҋ̎ߏтңޙၹ࣎ˠ͵ࠧĂͽ̈́׎၆યᗟᑕѣтңྋՙᏱڱ ۞ᄮۢĞңົјăѦԠૻĂϔ 88ğĄЯѩĂдᏙથࣣฟؕॡĂᒢྋ༊ְˠٙᄮࠎ۞યᗟߏ̦ᆃĂͽ̈́ ྍтңྋՙ۞࠻ڱߏ࠹༊ࢦࢋ۞Ąдᒢྋ༊ְˠтңޙၹયᗟ׶ྋՙ͞ڱޢĂ༊ਕѣड़ăԣిг̟ͽ ྋၹ̈́ࢦາޙၹĄ યᗟ۞ன၁Ğproblem realityğߏ࣎ˠ͹៍۞ޙၹĂᄬ֏݋ߏޙၹܑ̈́ࢗன၁̙Ξٕ৿۞̍׍ ĞWebb, 1999ğć༊ְˠ၆યᗟ۞ᄮۢӈߏצז׎тңኘኢયᗟ۞ᇆᜩĞLawson, 1994ğĄᄬ֏טࡗன ၁Ă˵ޙၹ΍༊ְˠ၆̎֗યᗟٕӧᕘ۞ᄮۢć͕நᏙથĞڼᒚğ݋ߏЋဦםӄ༊ְˠĂଂԼត׎࣎ ˠ۞ۢᛇĂ౵௣྿јયᗟྋՙٕᆧૻ࣎ˠЯᑕਕ˧۞˘჌ˠᅫ၆ྖ࿅඀ĞMartin, 1994ğĄ

͕நᏙથߏ˘჌ኘྖĂ SFBC Հ૟̝ෛࠎ˘჌ᄬ֏ྼᑚĞa language gameğĞde Shazer, 1991ğć ۡତԯᄬ֏༊ј˘࣎Լត۞̍׍ĄྋՙפШ۞ጯ۰૟Ꮩથर׶༊ְˠдᏙથ࿅඀̚۞ᄬ֏̢જෛࠎ˘ ాҚۢᛇԼត۞ְІĞperception-altering eventsğĞWebb, 1999ğćᏙથरϤ༊ְˠ۞ೡֽࢗᒢྋ׎ޙ ၹ۞͵ࠧĂϺ౅࿅ᄬ֏۞ྻϡֽםӄ༊ְˠฟ౹Ω˘჌ۢᛇ׶ன၁ĂͽਕԣిྋՙયᗟĄ Webb Ğ1999ğૻአĂࢋਕѣड़ᑕϡྋՙפШ۞ᏙથሀёĂੵ˞ܫه˯۞ڇᓕ̝γĂጯ௫̈́ޙϲ׎পѣ۞ᄬ

֏ϡڱĞbuilding blocks of languageğ˵ߏࢦࢋ۞ᙯᔣĄ

SFBCߏםӄ༊ְˠд౵͌Ѩ۞୏ኘॡม̰൴னྋՙયᗟ۞͞ڱĂᄃ˘ਠᏙથሀё౵̂۞̙ТĂ

дٺι̙͉Νኘኢયᗟ൴Ϡ۞ࣧЯĂ҃ߏ౅࿅˘ֱᙯᔣ۞યήĞkey questionsğֽםӄ༊ְˠԱ΍ྋ ՙ̝྽ĞңົјăѦԠૻĂϔ 88 ć Johnson & Miller, 1994; Lee, 1997ğć҃఺ֱયήĂಶߏϡֽᇆᜩ ༊ְˠഈྋՙ͞Шޥ҂׶ኘኢ۞ඉர׶ԫμĞO’Hanlan & Weiner-Davis, 1989ğĄ

၆ٺтң͔ᅳ༊ְˠഈྋՙጱШֽฟणᏙથ࿅඀Ă SFBC ൴ण΍୏ኘ݈׶୏ኘมԼតયή Ğpretreatment/ between-session change questionsğăּγયήĞexception questionsğă઄నયή Ğhypothetical questionsğ׶ณ͎યήĞscaling questionsğඈᄬຍ̰ट̙Т۞ฟٸёયήć఺ֱયήк ͽܳј༊ְˠਕྻϡҋ̎ߊѣ۞ྤ໚׶གྷរֽྋՙયᗟࠎϫ۞Ąдᑕϡ˯Ă˜ߏ౅࿅າ۞ᄬ֏ϡڱĂ ֽࡎ৔ٕአፋ༊ְˠࣧѣ۞ຐڱă៍ه׶ҖࠎćአፋᄃԼត༊ְˠА݈ߊѣ۞ۢᛇĂଂ҃ᆧซ༊ְˠ ၆યᗟྋՙਕѣ˘ሄ៍۞ഇޞĂ֭ΐిдҖજ˯۞ဘྏ׶វរĄ

ૄٺયή۞ֹϡߏࢋםӄ༊ְˠԼតߊѣ۞યᗟۢᛇĂഈྋՙ۞͞Ш݈ซĂ Berg ׶ MillerĞ1992ğ

૟୏ኘ݈Լតăּγયήă؈ᖹયήăณ͎યή׶ЯᑕયήͽĶ̣௡ѣϡયήķĞfive useful questionsğ

Ⴭ̝Ğp.70ğĂώࡁտ૟୏ኘ݈Լតΐˢྙય׌Ѩ୏ኘ̝มԼត۞યήćଣ੅୏ኘ݈ƝมԼតăּγ યήă؈ᖹયή׶ณ͎યήඈαᙷયή۞ֹϡᄃड़ϡĂ֭ͽᙯᔣયήჍ̝Ąͽ˭̶Ҿ੫၆Чᙷᙯᔣય ή۞ᑕϡࣧநઇซ˘Վଣ੅Ą Ğ˘ğົኘ݈Ɲม۞Լតયή ྙય༊ְˠଂତ९୏ኘĞintakeğ̝ޢזϒё୏ኘ̝݈Ăયᗟѣ̦ᆃԼචĂࡶѣĂߏЯࠎ΁ઇ˞ ̦ᆃٕ൴Ϡ˞̦ᆃְଐֹ҃଀યᗟ̙˘ᇹĄΩγĂ༊ְˠΞਕЯࠎઇछलүຽٕҋҖဘྏྋՙ͞ڱĂ ҃д׌Ѩ୏ኘ̝มѣֱԼត൴ϠĂᏙથर˵ΞͽΐͽྙયĂଂ̚Ա΍༊ְˠ۞ּγٕјΑЯᑕ۞གྷរ

(3)

ֽΐͽᕖ̂Ą Ğ˟ğּγયή ּγགྷរߏ޽યᗟ̙ӔனĂٕߏયᗟᚑࢦّൾ຋ഴҲ۞ॡ࣏Ąྙયּγགྷរ۞ϫ۞ĂߏࢋϤયᗟ ՟ѣ൴Ϡٕ̙֤ᆃᚑࢦ۞ॡגĂԱ΍༊ְˠ͔൴ּγགྷរ۞ҖࠎĂ׎ޢခᐽ༊ְˠГѨᑕϡĂЯֹ҃ યᗟ΍ன۞፟ົഴ͌Ăٕӧᕘ۞඀ޘഴҲĄଣ੅༊ְˠ࿅Ν۞јΑགྷរĂΞͽֹ༊ְˠ·႕˧ณĂ֭ ೩ᏹҋ̎׍ѣྋՙયᗟ۞ਕ˧Ą Ğˬğ઄నયή ˫Ⴭ؈ᖹયήĞmiracle questionsğĂϫ۞дםӄሏ୻༊ְˠ۞ഇޞ׶ϫᇾĂ֭ͷ͔ጱ༊ְˠଣ੅ યᗟă኏ࡎٕӧᕘ̙Гᇆᜩ΁ॡ۞ଐဩĂ҃༊ְˠΞͽઇ۞Ӆ˧׶Լචߏ̦ᆃć͔ጱ༊ְˠഈШϏֽ ۞ϫᇾӅ˧Ă֭ᖣѩฟण༊ְˠ۞ෛ౎ᄃᄮۢĄ Ğαğณ͎યή ͽ 1 ז 10 ۞˩ᕇณ͎ࠎૄᖂĂณ̼༊ְˠٙഇޞ۞ϫᇾăซՎ۞ېڶăྋՙયᗟ۞જ፟׶ܫ͕ă ࣎ˠଐჰېၗăᄃ΁ˠ۞ᙯܼă࿰ഇϏֽ۞ซणඈĂͽ׍វ̼༊ְˠٙೡࢗ۞̰टĄ఼૱ 1 ΃ܑ౵̙ рĂ 10 ΃ܑ౵р۞ېڶĄ༊ְˠ۞͹៍ෞҤĂ˵Ξͽͅߍ΍׎࣎ˠ۞ۢᛇགྷរĄ д˯ࢗЧᙷᙯᔣયή۞ྻϡ˯Ă SkidmoreĞ1993ğࡁտ൴னĂ̂кᇴ۞Ꮩથरᄮࠎ઄నયή౵׍ ڼᒚड़ϡĂณ͎યή౵૱జֹϡĂ҃ͷߏෞҤ༊ְˠซՎ۞౵р͞ڱĂּγયήቁ၁ਕ͔ጱ༊ְˠຐ זયᗟ՟ѣ൴Ϡ۞གྷរĂ֭ਕϤѩฟؕயϠԼតĂҌٺ୏ኘ݈۞ԼតĂ݋ߏ౵ᙱֹϡă౵͌ड़ϡ۞ય ڱĄ Weiner-Davis ඈˠĞ1987ğ۞ࡁտ݋൴னĂдௐ˘Ѩ୏ኘ̚ࡗѣ 66% ۞༊ְˠܑϯѣ୏ኘ݈۞Լ តĂ LawsonĞ1994ğ݋൴னѣ 59.7% ۞ּͧĂ҃ͷͧ՟ѣ୏ኘ݈Լត൴Ϡ۞༊ְˠĂ׎Ꮩથϫᇾቁ ၁ਕྵԣ྿јĄ Nau ׶ ShiltsĞ2000ğдଣ੅؈ᖹયήֹϡॡ፟۞ࡁտ̚൴னĂᏙથरࢋਕᄃ༊ְˠ ޙϲ։р۞ᏙથᙯܼĂ̖ਕםӄ༊ְˠึӀซˢ؈ᖹયή۞ѣड़̢જ࿅඀Ă҃ͷᅮࢋдּγયή۞ਔ ඛֹ̚ϡ͞ਕயϠᑕѣ۞ड़ϡćೱ֏̝Ăтڍ༊ְˠ൑ڱԱז࿅Ν۞ּγགྷរĂ˵ྵᙱຐည΍Ϗֽય ᗟ̙Г൴Ϡ۞ଐဩĄ Nau ׶ ShiltsĞ2000ğЯѩޙᛉĂᏙથरᑕ༊ΐࢺӅ˧гซˢ༊ְˠ۞ۢᛇன ၁ăଣ੅༊ְˠ۞ᄬ֏௫ၚĂ֭ฟୁ࿅Νּγགྷរхд۞ຍ෪Ăͽਕ͔ጱ༊ְˠഈϏֽયᗟྋՙ۞͞ ШᔙซĄѣᙯЧᙷયή۞ֹϡᄃड़ϡĂጯ۰ࣇкߏͽᏙથर۞֎ޘֽኢࢗĂ൒҃၆༊ְˠயϠтң۞ ᇆᜩĂ݋إϏѣࡁտ˯۞ଣ੅׶ᒢྋĞRita, 1996ğĄᏙથߏᏙથरᄃ༊ְˠ˟ˠ۞̢જ࿅඀Ă༊ְˠ ၆Чᙯᔣયή۞ͅᑕтңĂҋ൒˵ߏଣߤ۞ࢦᕇĂͽਕ၆ SFBC યή۞ड़ϡѣՀᖳ၁۞ᒢྋĄ ტЪ˯ࢗĂώࡁտ͹ࢋଣ੅ SFBC ۞ᙯᔣયή၆༊ְˠ۞ᇆᜩࠎңĂྏဦᒢྋдԆፋ۞ SFBC ࿅ ඀̚ĂᏙથरྻϡЧᙷᙯᔣયήĂͽ̈́༊ְˠ˾ᄬͅᑕ۞ਔඛĂ֭ͽְޢణኘ۞͞ёĂྙય༊ְˠ၆ ఺ֱયή۞̰дͅᑕ׶ຏצĂઇࠎᒢྋ఺ֱયήயϠтңड़ϡֶ̝ፂĄֶѩĂώࡁտຐଣ੅Ꮩથरд ᑕϡ൏ᕇྋՙൺഇᏙથሀёॡĂֹϡЧᙯᔣયή۞ਔඛࠎңĉͽ̈́༊ְˠ၆Чᙯᔣયή۞ͅᑕࠎңĉ ׌͞ࢬ۞યᗟĄ౅࿅၁ᅫ̶ژᏙથरྻϡᙯᔣયήĂͽ̈́༊ְˠͅᑕ˟۰̝ม۞ᙯܼĂ၆൏ᕇྋՙൺ ഇᏙથሀё۞Լត̰உਕѣՀྎ၁۞ᒢྋĂϺΞ೩ֻᏙથरିֈ੊ቚ̝׍វણ҂Ą ˘ăЩෟྋᛖ Ğ˘ğᙯᔣયή ώࡁտٙ޽ᙯᔣયήĂߏᏙથरֹϡ SFBC ۞পѣયήĂΒ߁୏ኘ݈ƝมԼតયήăּγયήă ઄నયή׶ณ͎યήඈαᙷયήĄ Ğ˟ğ༊ְˠͅᑕ ώࡁտٙ޽༊ְˠͅᑕĂߏ޽༊ְˠдͽЧᙯᔣયήࠎ͹ค۞݈ޢԆፋᄬຍ߱ར۞˾ᄬͅᑕ̰ टĂͽ̈́дᏙથ̝ޢ۞ణኘܑٙࢗ̚۞̰дຐڱ׶ຏצĂϡͽᒢྋྍયή၆༊ְˠ۞ᇆᜩࠎңĄ

(4)

͞ ā ā ڱ

˘ăࡁտ၆෪ Ğ˘ğᏙથर ҂ᇋᑕϡ SFBC ਕ˧۞યᗟĂਬᔛኛ˟ҜͽൺഇᏙથࠎ͹ࢋᏙથפШ۞Ꮩથ͕நጯ౾̀ፉЇĂͽ ਕдᏙથଐဩ̚ቁ၁ፆү SFBC ࿅඀̈́׎̚۞ᙯᔣયήĄ˟ҜᏙથर࠰д̂૞७ੰᏙથ࠹ᙯࡊրଂְ Ꮩથ૞ຽࡊϫ̝ିጯĂܕѐֽ၆ൺഇᏙથкٙ២ࡁĂੵ˞дᏙથ၁ચ̍ү̚ᑕϡ SFBC ሀё̝γĂϺ ̶ҾѣкѨనࢍၱ૲ᅳ SFBC ̍үӪٕဥវ۞གྷរĂ၆ٺ SFBC ۞ྻϡ࠹༊ჟሢĄ Ğ˟ğ༊ְˠ ώࡁտਬͽՐӄ̚ొߙۤડ͕நᏙથ፟ၹ̝༊ְˠࠎ၆෪Ăפ଀αҜ༊ְˠТຍણᄃώࡁտ۞ซ ҖĂ̶Ҿᄃ˟ҜᏙથरซҖαҌ̱Ѩ۞ԆፋᏙથĄ̣Ҝ༊ְˠ۞ࡦഀྤफ़тܑ 1 Ĉ ܑ1 ༊ְˠࡦഀྤफ़ CL΃ཱི ّҾ ѐ᛬ ጯ። ᖚຽ ૓ބ ͹ࢋયᗟ CO΃ཱི ȋ ̃ 34 ੼̚ ̍ ̏૓ Ꮠ̄ିዳ ȋĞշğ Ȍ ̃ 44 ̂ጯ छგ ̏૓ Ꮠ̄ିዳ ȋ ȍ շ 26 ੼ᖚ ̍ ᗓ૓ ᗓ૓ְІ ȌĞ̃ğ Ȏ ̃ 36 ੼ᖚ થ ᗓ૓ ຏଐᄃᏐ̄ ȋ ˯ࢗ༊ְˠ۞ᏴפĂ˜҂ᇋ˭Е׌ᕇĈ 1. ణኘ۞ซҖĂੵ˞ᅮࢋ༊ְˠ۞ॡมਕૉ੨Ъ̝γĂϺᅮࢋѣᙸຍฟٸҋ̎дᏙથ࿅඀̚۞གྷ រ׶ۢᛇăᙸຍତצᐂࢰĂͽ̈́ਕૉϡ˾ᄬܑ྿࣎ˠགྷរඈ୧ІĄ 2. ࠎഴ͌Я༊ְˠՐӄયᗟ̈́఍࿃͞ё̝मளٙயϠ۞஄஑ĂਬͽವՐ࣎ҾᏙથ̝ 18 ໐ͽ˯ј ѐ༊ְˠࠎᔛኛ၆෪Ą ˟ăࡁտ̍׍ Ğ˘ğᙯᔣયή߹඀੃ᐂ̰̈́टၡࢋܑ ࠎ͞ܮణࣶ៍၅੃ᐂĂਬనࢍ˘੃ᐂֻܑ׎ֹϡĄ੃ᐂܑॾёၡᐂтܑ 2 Ĉ ܑ 2 ᙯᔣયή̈́༊ְˠͅᑕၡࢋ੃ᐂܑ ॡม યήᙷҾ Ꮩથरᄬή ༊ְˠ˾ᄬͅᑕ ś ୏ኘ݈Ɲม۞Լត ś ּγ ś ઄న ś ณ͎ Ğ˟ğణኘ̂ჩ ༊ְˠ̰дͅᑕ۞ྤफ़ߏϤణኘפ଀Ăణኘ̂ჩ۞̰टࠎĈ 1. னдຐ੓ֽĂд˯Ѩ׶ȼҁरซҖ۞ኘྖ̚Ăѣ՟ѣ̦ᆃឰଋО෪எג۞г͞ĉ 2. д˯Ѩ۞Ꮩથ࿅඀̚ĂȼҁरયଋŤŤĞયή̰टğĂଋ۞аඍߏŤŤĞ༊ְˠ༊ॡ۞˾ᄬ̰

(5)

टğĄдᏙથरયଋ఺ήྖ۞ॡ࣏Ăଋ۞ຏᛇߏ̦ᆃĉѣѩຏᛇ۞நϤߏ̦ᆃĉĞֶયή΍ன۞ॡԔ ֽྙયĂтڍ༊ְˠ၆ߙֱયήᛇ଀О෪எגĂణࣶ˵ΞֶѩणฟયήǕͅᑕ۞ྙયĄğ 3. ፋវ҃֏Ă˯Ѩ۞Ꮩથ၆ଋ۞ᇆᜩߏ̦ᆃĉ Ğˬğ៍၅ၱణኘˠࣶ ੵ˞ణኘ̂ჩ̝γĂణኘˠࣶ၆Ꮩથ࿅඀۞៍၅ᄃ̶ژߏӎ׍វྎ၁Ăͽ̈́ణኘॡ۞ၗޘ׶ԫ μĂౌߏᇆᜩ༊ְˠтң೩ֻགྷរྤफ़۞ࢦࢋᇆᜩЯ৵Ąώࡁտᇈ଀ˬҜ၆ൺഇᏙથ׶ SFBC ѣٙጯ ௫۞ᏙથᅃጱჇă౾̀঱ࡁտϠፉЇణࣶĄࠎޙϲ։р۞ణኘᙯܼĂՏҜ༊ְˠౌߏᄃТ˘Ҝణࣶซ ҖణኘĄдซҖྤफ़ᄓะ̝݈Ăણᄃ˟Ѩ۞ణࣶ੊ቚĂ੊ቚ۞̰टΒ߁Ĉ 1. ᒢྋᄃሢଉ SFBC ֹٙϡ۞ᙯᔣયήĂͽ̈́Чᙷᙯᔣયή۞̙Т˾ᄬݭёĄѩొЊ˜೩ֻణࣶ ࠹ᙯྤफ़ĂགྷϤዦ᝝३ࢬྤफ़Ăͽ̈́ଂ࿰౯ّᏙથٙ଀ז۞Ꮩથ၆ྖుфቇֽΐͽ੅ኢᄃᒢྋĂͽਕ ᆧซ៍၅ᄃᄬή̶ژਕ˧Ą 2. ሢଉᐂᇆ̈́ᐂࢰన౯۞ፆүĂ֭ઇ၁г۞៍၅ᄃ੃ᐂĄ 3. ሢଉణኘ̂ჩ̈́ሀᑢణኘ߹඀Ą ˬă၁߉඀ԔᄃՎូ ώࡁտેҖ࿅඀ĂֶԔт˭Ĉ Ğ˘ğפ଀Ꮩથ፟ၹТຍࡁտ̝ซҖĂ೩ֻࡁտಞг̈́࣎९Ą Ğ˟ğ͛ᚥᄓะᄃ̶ژĂፋந΍Чᙯᔣયήֹϡࣧநඈ३ࢬྤफ़Ą Ğˬğበᑢ࠹ᙯ̍׍ĞࡁտᄲځᄃТຍבăణኘ̂ჩăణࣶ੊ቚྤफ़ඈğĄ ĞαğซҖ࿰౯ّᏙથ̈́ణኘĂԛјణࣶ੊ቚՄफ़ăቁϲణኘ̂ჩᄃ߹඀Ą Ğ̣ğΡ๒៍၅ၱణኘˠࣶĂซҖణࣶ੊ቚĄ Ğ̱ğᔛኛ༊ְˠТຍણᄃĄ Ğ˛ğ၁гซҖ SFBC ᏙથĂణࣶ֭ٺ៍၅ވ̚ซҖ៍၅੃ᐂĄ ĞˣğᔂᆷᏙથ࿅඀ుфቇĄ Ğ˝ğ̶ژᏙથ࿅඀ుфቇĄϤࡁտ۰ᄃణ̶ࣶҾෞژుфቇ̚Ꮩથֹࣶٙϡ۞ᙯᔣયήᙷҾĂ ҃ޢซҖ੅ኢĂ଀ז˘࡭۞ᕩᙷĄ Ğ˩ğซҖణኘĄణ̶ֶࣶژుфቇٙ଀۞ᙯᔣયήᄬຍ߱རు˘ྙયĄ ˯ࢗՎូĞ˛ğҌĞ˩ğĂֶĶௐ˘ѨᏙથƖణኘŮௐ˟ѨᏙથƖąąąƖణኘŮ౵ޢ˘ѨᏙથķ ۞߹඀ซҖĂ༊ְˠдՏ˘Ѩ۞ణኘඕՁޢൾүЃिĂГซҖྍѨ۞ᏙથĂ׌ѨᏙથ۞ม࿣ࠎ˘࣎ߐ ഇĄֶѩనࢍĂВซҖ 21 Ѩ۞Ꮩથ̈́ 17 Ѩ۞ణኘĄ౵ޢ˘Ѩ۞ణኘĂЯ൑ڱפ଀׎̚׌Ҝ༊ְˠТ ຍдᏙથඕՁޢ˘ߐഇ΍यણᄃĞ˘ҜЯ̳̳ҝੰâҜЯְຽ΍઼ğĂٙͽ˘࡭Νੵ౵ޢ˘ѨᏙથ ۞ణኘĄ Ğ˩˘ğᔂᆷణኘుфቇĄ Ğ˩˟ğྤफ̶़ژĄ αăྤफ̶़ژ ώࡁտߏͽᙯᔣયήࠎ͹ค۞Ԇፋᄬຍ߱རઇࠎ̶ژ۞̰टĂϤᏙથ࿅඀ుфቇ̚Աז၆ᑕ۞߱ རĂଂ̚ᒢྋᏙથरдᑕϡ SFBC ሀёॡֹϡ̙ТᙷݭᙯᔣયήĂͽ̈́༊ְˠ˾ᄬͅᑕ۞̢જਔඛĄ ѣᙯۢᛇ۞ϒቁᄃӎĂ݋ͽ༊ְˠдᏙથ࿅඀̚ਕӎྫྷᐌᏙથर۞યήֽаᑕઇҿҾĄ ྤफ़۞˘࡭̶ّژొ̶ĂᏙથుфቇߏдፋ࣎ࡁտԆј̝ޢĂࡁտ۰Ωᄃ˘ሢଉ SFBC ۞౾̀Ϡ ̶ҾซҖበቅĂଂ౵݈ˬЊ۞ుфቇ̶ژ̚଀ז۞ፋវ˘࡭ّܼᇴࠎ.86 Ă׎̚˫ͽณ͎યή۞˘࡭

(6)

ّࠎ౵੼Ă୏ኘ݈Ɲม۞યή݋кЯྙય۞ᄬή̰टдॡมᕇ˯ѣ̙ځቁ఍Ăд˘࡭̶ّژ˯ѣྵк ڡள۞ҿᕝĄдԛјВᙊޢĂࡁտ۰ᄃםТበቅ۰ВТԆјٙѣుфቇ۞̶ژĂ֭ಶ̶ژ̰ट׶ඕڍ ుЊ੅ኢĄ д༊ְˠ̰дͅᑕొ̶Ăਬͽణኘుфቇ̚Ă༊ְˠ੫၆˾ᄬͅᑕ̚۞Ķѣă൑ķ۞аඍٙͅᑕ ΍ֽ۞̰дຐڱ׶ຏצࠎ̶ژࢦᕇĂߏϤࡁտ۰ֶᏙથుфቇ̚۞ЧયήਔඛĂԱז࠹၆ᑕ۞༊ְˠ ͅᑕֽઇྤफ़۞ፋநĄ

ඕ ā ā ڍ

˘ăЧᙯᔣયή۞ፋវֹϡଐԛ གྷ̶ژαҜ༊ְˠВ 21 Њ۞Ꮩથుфቇ̰टĂЧᙯᔣયήֹϡᇴณ۞ଐԛтܑ 3 Ĉ ܑ 3 ЧᙯᔣયήֹϡѨᇴּ̈́ͧ CL ୏ኘѨᇴ ୏ኘ݈Ɲม ּγયή ઄నયή ณ͎યή યήᓁࢍ ȋ 4 1Ğ3.2%ğ 6Ğ19.4%ğ 15Ğ48.4%ğ 9Ğ29%ğ 31 Ȍ 6 5Ğ10%ğ 13Ğ26%ğ 21Ğ42%ğ 11Ğ22%ğ 50 ȍ 6 4Ğ13.8%ğ 7Ğ24.1%ğ 2Ğ6.9%ğ 16Ğ55.2%ğ 29 Ȏ 5 4Ğ14.8%ğ 6Ğ22.2%ğ 14Ğ51.9%ğ 3Ğ11.1%ğ 27 ᓁࢍ 21 14 32 52 39 137 Ѻ̶ͧ 10.2 23.4 38.0 28.5 Ϥܑ 3 ̰टΞ଀ͽ˭ඕڍĈ Ğ˘ğЧᙷᙯᔣયήд̙Т༊ְˠ۞Ꮩથ࿅඀ֹٙ̚ϡ۞ּͧЧѣ̙ТĂҭ̂кะ̚д઄న Ğ38%ğăณ͎Ğ28.5%ğ׶ּγĞ23.4%ğඈˬᙷĂ࠹၆ֽ࠻Ă୏ኘ݈׶୏ኘม۞ྙય݋ព඾ഴ͌Ą Ğ˟ğд 21 Ѩ۞୏ኘѨᇴ༊̚ĂᑕҌ͌ѣ 21 Ѩ۞୏ኘ݈׶୏ኘมԼតયήĂ൒҃၁ᅫ̶ژΪѣ 14ήĂ׎̚˫ͽ CO-A ׶ CL-A ۞ 1 Ѩࠎ౵͌Ą Ğˬğ׌ҜᏙથरдયήᙷҾ۞ֹϡᇴณ˯ӔனमளćϺӈĂ CO-A дᄃ A ă B ă D ˬҜ༊ְˠ۞ Ꮩથ༊̚Ăౌߏ઄నયήֹϡ۞ּͧ౵੼ĂֶѨҫᓁયή۞ 48.4%, 42% ׶ 51.9% Ăд CO-B ᄃ CL-C ۞Ꮩથ̚݋ͽณ͎યή۞ֹϡּͧ 55.2% ౵੼Ă઄నયήΪҫ 6.9% Ą ĞαğЧᙷᙯᔣયήдಏѨᏙથ̈́ፋ࣎Ꮩથ።඀۞ֹϡ֭՟ѣ႙Ѩᆧкٕഴ͌Ăયήᓁᇴ˵՟ѣ Яࠎ୏ኘѨᇴ۞ᆧΐ҃˘࡭ᆧΐ۞ଐԛĂͽ̈́˟ҜᏙથरᄃαҜ༊ְˠ۞Ꮩથ࿅඀֭՟ѣ˘࡭ֹϡય ήᙷݭ۞ଐԛֽ࠻ĂЧᙷᙯᔣયή۞ֹϡົצזᏙથरă༊ְˠĂͽ̈́યᗟ൏ᕇඈЯ৵۞ᇆᜩ҃ѣ࣎ Ҿमள۞ଐԛĄ ˟ăᏙથरֹϡЧᙯᔣયήᄃ༊ְˠ۞ͅᑕ ώࡁտ̶Ҿ૟ЧᙷᙯᔣયήĂֶ CO ฟֹؕϡયή۞݈ޢ၆ྖ̰टԱ΍ֹϡॡ፟Ă֭૟࠹ܕ۞ֹ ϡॡ̶፟ј˘࣎ਔඛĄགྷ̶ژαᙷă 137 ή۞ᙯᔣયήĂВΞ̶ј 20 ࣎યήਔඛĄϤٺቔ಼ࢨטĂͽ ˭˜̶Ҿ੫၆ЧᙷયήĂАӔன CO ׶ CL ˾ᄬ̢જ۞ਔඛĂ҃ޢд༊ְˠͅᑕొ̶Ă݋ۡତᕩৼӔ ன 21 Ѩ۞Ꮩથుфቇ׶ 17 Ѩణኘుфቇ۞̶ژඕڍĂ̙Ωᓝࢗ CL ۞˾ᄬ̈́ణኘ̰टĄ

(7)

Ğ˘ğ୏ኘ݈ƝมԼតયή 1. Ꮩથरֹϡਔඛ གྷ̶ژ 14 ή୏ኘ݈Ɲม۞ԼតયήĂΞ̶ࠎˬ჌̙Т۞ਔඛĂͽ˭̶ҾౘࢗĂ֭Ӕன၆ྖ̰ट ઇࠎᒢྋĄᄬή۞΃ཱིĂͽ COA-D1-03 ࠎּĂߏ޽Ꮩથर A дᄃ༊ְˠ D ۞ௐ˘Ѩ୏ኘ۞ௐˬ߱၆ ྖĂ B2-06 ݋ߏ޽༊ְˠ B дௐ˟Ѩ୏ኘ۞ௐ̱߱၆ྖĄ Ğ1ğಏѨ୏ኘࣣฟؕॡĂ CL ͹જ೩זଂତ९Ğintakeğٕ˯Ѩ୏ኘזனдĂҋ̎۞ଐჰѣٙᖼ តĂ CO ͽ୏ኘ݈ƝมԼតયήྙયԼត۞ࣧЯĂּтĈ ĶҰࣣࣣ೩זҰֽ̫͇ଐჰ̏གྷͧྵᘦؠ˞Č֤ԧனдͧྵຐᒢྋ۞ಶߏĂҰଂ˯ѨĞintakeğ ۞ͧྵ̙ᘦؠĂזֽ̫͇ҰᄲͧྵᘦؠĂ൴Ϡ˞̦ᆃְଐ˞ĉķĞCOA-D1-03ğ Ğ2ğдௐ˟ѨĂͽ̝̈́ޢ۞୏ኘࣣฟؕॡĂ CO ͽ୏ኘมԼតયήྙયેҖछलүຽॡѣ൑р۞ གྷរĂͽ̈́д׶݈Ѩ୏ኘ̝มѣ՟ѣ൴Ϡр۞ېڶĂ༊ CL ೩זѣр۞གྷរ൴ϠॡĂ CO ᚶᜈྙય CL ઇ˞̦ᆃֹ҃଀ېڶ̙ТĂ֭ͷԯԼតᕩЯٺ CL ώ֗۞ԼតĂٕߏۡତග̟ CL ခᐽ׶͚޺ćтڍ CLܑϯ֭՟ѣԼត൴ϠĂ CO ݋ܑ྿Тநᄃତৼ CL ༊˭۞஄ใଐჰĂּтĈ a. ĶČČԧࣇ˯Ѩኘ˞˘ѨဗĂ̫͇ߏֽௐ˟ѨĂ˯а۞ΑኝаΝޢިᆃᇹĉķĞCOA-B2-06ğ Ķԧᛇ଀ԧߏѣ໰఺ᇹ̄ൾ຋ගι၁Җ˘˭Ăඕڍޅ̄۞ͅᑕᔘ̙᏾ધĂ΁̙ົᄲޝĂ Ğ৯ğĂಶߏතঈިᆃត଀ͧྵрĂົྫྷҰྫྷҰ఺ᇹѣᄲѣ৯఺ᇹ̄ĄķĞB2-06ğ Ķؙઇ˞̦ᆃĉٙͽҰ̫͇ົᓾ఺ᇹ۞ྖĉķĞCOA-B2-07ğ Ķԧᛇ଀рညᄲĂԧႽณಶߏ᝘΁ྫྷԧᓾĂᓾᄲࢋەᔘߏ̦ᆃ۞ĂࢋАە۞ྖĂԧಶᄲр બĂ֤ҰಶߏАᆷ̦ᆃڌҘᆷԆĂ൒ޢ๽๽ГౖҰە̶̣࣎ᛗă˩̶ᛗĂ఺ᇹ̄Ă΁ಶົ ޝ੼ᎸĂಶߏҋ̎ಶົᆷ଀ޝрĄķĞB2-07ğ b.ĶČ఺˘࣎ᖃ޵྆ࢬĂѣ՟ѣ൴Ϡ̦ᆃр۞ְଐĉ̙˘ᇹ۞ְଐĉķĞCOB-C2-06ğ Ķ՟ѣࡠĊҰΨԧࢋԱ˘͇рჂ˘ᕇĂৌ۞ԧΝྏĂ዁඾ౌჂ̙඾ĂĞCOB Ĉ఺ᇹಊğ ๢Ăৌ۞̙ۢ྽ࢋިᆃᏱĉķĞC2-07ğ c.ĶČČѣ՟ѣĂ఺࣎ᖃ޵ѣ՟ѣઇ˘ֱ̦ᆃְଐឰҋ̎р˘ᕇĉķĞCOB-C4-05ğ ĶѣબĊķĞC4-05ğ Ķߏ̦ᆃĉķĞCOB-C4-06ğ ĶޝкબĂညԧ੧ԧ˵ˬ͇՟ಅ˞ĄķĞC4-06ğ ĶݝಊĊޝрޝрĄķĞCOB-C4-07ğ Ķ၆બĂౌдछౖ̈ޅĂ఺ˬ͇Ă׶̈ޅ˵ᛇ଀៌ѣ኷۞ĄķĞC4-06ğ Ğ3ğд̚มѨᇴ۞୏ኘ׶౵ޢ˘Ѩ۞୏ኘ̚Ă CO ͽ୏ኘมԼតયήĂ͹જྙય CL кѨ୏ኘͽ ֽ۞ќᘥ׶ጯ௫Ą CL к೩זҋ̎дᏙથ݈ޢ۞ҖࠎԼតćࡶ CL аᑕ۞ߏຏצ۞̙ТĂ CO ົซ˘Վ ྙયߏЯࠎ CL ઇ˞̦ᆃ҃ឰຏצ̙ТĄ၆ٺ CL ۞ԼតĂ CO ٕߏۺؠгͅߍ CL ۞ҖࠎमளĂٕߏ ͽᙯܼયήྙયѣኡ൴ன CL ̏ѣ۞ԼតĂּтĈ a.ĶČČԧࣇ݈ࢬኘ˞ˬѨĂˬѨಊĂؙΞ̙ΞͽАᄲᄲ࠻Ăؙѣ՟ѣ̦ᆃ̙˘ᇹĉķ ĞCOA-A4-01ğ ĶČ఺̂ໄѣ˘࣎͡۞ॡมĂԧᛇ଀ֽྫྷҰኘ˞ͽޢĂԧ۞ଐჰ˯ѣᑒӄĂಶߏԧົԯְ ଐ࠻ၙ˘ᕇĂ՟ѣ֤ᆃާĂಶߏČĄķĞA4-01ğ b.ĶČд఺࣎ᖃ޵྆ࢬĂΒ߁݈׌࣎ᖃ޵Ăؙᛇ଀дԧࣇኘྖͽޢĂؙ౵̂۞˘࣎ќᘥĂд Ꮠ̄ᙯܼ྆ࢬ౵̂۞˘࣎ќᘥߏ̦ᆃĉķĞCOA-B3-27ğ ĶΞਕߏྫྷ΁໛఼˯۞˾ঈČČĂԧனдౌͧྵĂಶߏ΁ᓾ̦ᆃԧಶА᝘΁ᓾԆĂ൒ޢԧ

(8)

Гྫྷ΁໛఼఺ᇹ̄Ă൒ޢд˾ঈ˯Ă̙ࢋᄲĂ̙ࢋϡ˘ֱͅࢬ۞ĄķĞB3-27ğ 2. ༊ְˠͅᑕ Ğ1ğ˾ᄬͅᑕ д ABCD αҜ CL ۞Ꮩથ࿅඀̚Ăੵ˞ CL-D ѣ˟Ѩ՟ѣϒቁۢᛇᏙથरયή۞˾ᄬͅᑕ̝γĂ CL-DдௐˬѨ̝ޢĂͽ̈́׎΁ˬҜ CL ౌΞͽѣϒቁ۞ۢᛇĂ˾ᄬͅᑕ۞̰ट݋кߏ೩΍ҋ̎ઇ˞̦ ᆃ҃ឰଐԛѣ̙ٙТĂٕߏ೩זҋ̎അဘྏઇ̦ᆃҭ̙֭јΑĄ၆ٺ݈۰Ă CO ົͅߍ CL ݈ޢҖࠎ ۞मள׶Լតăᕖ̂̈́ۺؠЯ CL ۞Ӆ˧҃଀۞рགྷរć၆ٺᛇ଀ҋ̎ઇ଀̙рă՟ѣԼត۞ͅᑕĂ CO݋к̟ͽТந׶ଐჰ఍நĄ Ğ2ğ̰дຐڱ׶ຏצ ༊ CL ೩זҋ̎ѣઇ˞̦ᆃ҃ឰְଐѣᕇ̙Т۞ୃࢗॡĂ CL ҋ̎ົᛇ଀ޝ੼ᎸćЯࠎҋ̎۞Լត ҃ឰޅ̄ѣᕇԼតĂᛇ଀ޝ჏͕ĞB6ğĄ҃༊Լត۞࿰ഇར۩ॡĂ CL ٽᛇ଀ε୕ĞC2, E2ğĄ CL-C д ௐ˟Ѩ׶ௐαѨᏙથॡ۞˾ᄬͅᑕ̙ТĂ׎̰д۞ຏצ˵ѣޝ̂۞मளćௐ˟ѨॡЯ՟ѣซण҃ᛇ଀ ҋయĂௐαѨॡ݋Яࠎѣр۞གྷរ൴Ϡ҃ᛇ଀ҋ̎ѣซՎĂᛇ଀ፋ࣎ߐഇֽ࿅଀ͧྵѣຍཌྷĄְ၁ ˯Ă CL-C дௐ̣Ѩ׶ௐ̱Ѩ୏ኘĂ၆ٺ CO-B ྙય׌ฉ̝มѣ̦ᆃ̙ТॡĂ˵ౌ޺ᜈ۞ͅᑕ΍ѣϒ Ш۞ԼតĂ˵ܑϯҋ̎۞͕ଐດֽດᅅᗫĄ Ğ˟ğּγયή 1. Ꮩથरֹϡਔඛ གྷ̶ژ 32 ήּγયήĂΞ̶ࠎ̱჌̙Т۞ਔඛĂ̶ࢗт˭Ĉ Ğ1ğ༊ CL ͽĶՏ͇ķăĶᓁߏķăĶౌ՟ѣķ۞фீֽୃࢗયᗟॡĂ CO ົึ඾ CL ۞˾ᄬ௫ၚĂ ͽБొӎؠ۞યή͞ёྙય CL ࿅Νѣ൑ּγགྷរĂྏဦԱ΍ּγ۞ېڶĄ CL Ξਕۡତ೩΍ּγགྷ រĂ CO ᚶ҃ଣ੅ѩּγགྷរ൴Ϡ۞ࣧЯć CL ˵Ξਕаᑕ՟ѣּγĂѩॡ CO ԼͽϒШ͞ёྙયѣ൑ ּγགྷរĂ CO ܑ̪ϯຐ̙΍ѣּγགྷរĄּтĈ a.Ķٙͽ఺ᖃ޵ĂҰᄲĂ఺ᖃ޵ౌ՟ѣ˘͇՟ಅ੧۞ĉķĞCOB-C2-27ğ ĶѣબĄķĞC2-28ğ Ķ๢Ăߏࣹ˘͇՟ಅ੧ĉķĞCOB-C2-28ğ Ķߑ͇୎˯બĄķĞC2-28ğ b.ĶČؙᄲؙౌ՟ѣ֤჌ČޝਕૉΒटâۡౌߏ఺ᇹ̄۞๜ĉķĞCOA-A1-11ğ ĶᆛᆛᆛĂٙͽԧಶᛇ଀఺ᇹ̄၆Čԧۢ྽ԧޅ̄൑ԛ̚ԧ๋च΁ޝஎĂԧ఺ᇹ̄ົᇆᜩ ז΁۞ˠᅫᙯܼĞᓏࢰࣽݟğĂٙͽԧ̖ຐᄲԧົֽז఺྆Ă఺ᇹ̄ĄķĞA1-11ğ ĶČؙٙᏜ۞˘ۡ఺ᇹ۞Ăд఺ᇹ۞˘ۡ྆ࢬĂົ̙ົѣ̦ᆃॡ࣏Ă׎၁Ăؙဘྏ඾Νઇ ˘ֱΒट۞ְଐĂѣ՟ѣĂᄲᄲ࠻р̙рĉķĞCOA-A1-12ğ Ķ๢ĂČޝ͌ĂԧΞͽᓾᄲޝ͌ĂᆛĂѣ˘ѨČČĂೀͼрည՟ѣĂԧனд˘ॡ̝ม˵ຐ ̙͉΍ֽĂԧ˘ॡČČҰ఺ᇹયԧĂԧ˘ॡ̝มᔘ՟ᏱڱຐזĄķĞA1-12ğ Ğ2ğCO ۡତͽּγયήྙય CL ၁߉छलүຽ۞ଐԛĂࡶ CL ೩΍ѣϒШ۞ּγགྷរ൴ϠĂ CO ົᚶ҃ᕖ̂఺࣎ϒШགྷរĂּтĈ Ķ఺ᖃ޵ѣࣹ˘͇՟ѣಅ੧๜ĉķĞCOB-C3-08ğ ĶѣĄķĞC3-08ğ Ķ֤͇ߏ൴Ϡ˞̦ᆃрְଐ˞ĉķĞCOB-C3-09ğ Ķ՟ѣબĂ֤͇ԧಶ˵௢௢۞Ăޅ̄˫ࢋ׶ԧ˘੓ჂĂબԧಶΨсࣇᓾ߇ְĞCO ĈΨсࣇᓾ ߇ְගҰ᝘ࣺğĂᆛĂ၆Ąсࣇ׌࣎ޝົᓾĂޝົበĂᓾᓾĂ֤୎ৌ۞ޝрჂĂрჂޝкĂ ͧྵᅅᗫĂᆛબĄķĞC3-09ğ

(9)

Ğ3ğଂ̝݈۞୏ኘ̏̚ቁؠયᗟ̏ѣԼតĂ൒҃ CL ݒ˫ᄮࠎ՟ѣ͉кԼតॡĂ CO ͽּγયή ͔ጱ CL ۢᛇ׎ม۞मளĂּтĈ Ķᛇ଀኏ࡎ۞͞ёྫྷͽ݈ᔘߏ˘࣎ᇹ̄۞๜ĉķĞCOA-B5-08ğ Ķͧྵ͌Ăۋેົͧྵ͌Ăҭߏѣۋે۞ྖĂಶតј΁ͧྵ׽ે̎֍Ăಶߏԧᄲ఺ᇹಶ఺ ᇹĂ΁ᄮࠎ఺ᇹಶ఺ᇹĂČČĂķĞB5-08ğ ĶٙͽĂ఺჌ଐԛͽ݈ѣ൴Ϡ၆̙၆ĞB Ĉ၆ğĂҭߏؙ఍ந۞͞ёனдྫྷͽ݈ົѣֱ̙˘ ᇹĉķĞCOA-B5-09ğ Ķԧಶͧྵ໰΁۞ຍޥČČĂԧߏனдಶߏͧྵឰĂА᝘΁ᓾԆધĂ൒ޢГྫྷ΁ᓾᄲ̙Ξͽ ఺ᇹĂČČķĞB5-09ğ Ğ4ğ༊ CL ྙય CO ࢋтңઇĂವՐ CO ۞ޙᛉॡĂ CO ͽۺؠ CL ࿅Νഅѣּγ۞јΑ఍நགྷរֽ ྙયĂ CL ೩΍ּγགྷរĂּтĈ Ķ֤˭˘ࢋިᆃઇ׸ĉķĞA2-24ğ ĶČԧࣇଂ࿅Ν۞Ϡ߿གྷរֽԱඍ९р˞Č˵ధؙ࿅Νౌѣઇ࿅˘ְֱଐĂޝͯᕝ۞Ăޝઊ Ⴌ۞˘ְ࣎ଐĂ֤఺ְֱଐົֹ଀ؙ༊ॡ఍நޅ̄۞યᗟଐڶត଀ͧྵрĄԧ̙ፍ଀ؙѣ՟ ѣ఺ᇹ۞གྷរĂԧࣇႽ˧ֽаຐĄķĞCOA-A2-25ğ Ķ๢ĂҰߏᄲԧ၆ޅ̄ČČĉķĞA2-25ğ Ķಶߏ࿅ΝĂؙѣॡ࣏༥זᙷҬ۞ଐဩĂͧ͞ᄲΑኝ՟ѣઇрબĂᇅൣ̙ᄮৌબĂٕ۰ӱ੺ ଡ଼ӱ଀֤ᆃ˳બĂည఺ְֱଐĂؙ۞ͅᑕౌߏޝϠঈĉķĞCOA-A2-26ğ Ķઊ̙҃ົĂѣॡ࣏ĂͧтᄲČČĂ׎၁ԧౌߏѝ˯၆΁ࣇপҾрĂѝ˯΁ࣇࢋ΍ܝ˞Ăԧ Ν˯঱΁ࣇΝ˯ጯĂԧಶߏ֤ॡ࣏Ăԧಶົ၆΁ࣇޝрĂಶົആ΁ࣇ৭д΁ࣇ۞ϲಞĂԧົ ྫྷ΁ࣇᄲԧۢ྽ጯൣޝ֙ࡴČČĄķĞA2-25ğ Ğ5ğ༊ CO ۡତ޽ጱ CL тңઇĂ CL ˵Тຍଳৼ CO ۞ޙᛉॡĂ CO ତ඾ͽּγયήྙય CL ࿅Ν ѣ൑ଳϡᙷҬ͞ڱ۞јΑགྷរĂ CL ˵ਕ೩΍ҋ̎۞ּγགྷរĂּтĈ Ķͽؙ݈ѣ՟ѣ࿅ᙷҬ఺ᇹ۞གྷរ࿅ĉķĞCOA-B3-74ğ CL-Bаඍ࿅Ν۞јΑགྷរ̝ޢĂ ĶČČ఺ಶߏϒࢬ۞ྖĂؙͽ݈ڍ൒˵ᄲ࿅ĞB Ĉ၆ğĂٙͽ᝘੓ֽ׎၁ؙ˵ᄲ࿅఺჌ྖĂҰ ˵൴னιޝѣड़ϡĄķĞCOA-B3-77ğ Ğ6ğCO Аֹ݈ϡ઄నયήྙય CL Ξਕ൴Ϡ۞ېڶĂ CL ˵ܑϯтڍྍېڶ൴Ϡົѣң̙ТĂ CO ᚶ҃ͽּγયήྙય࿅Νѣ൑ᙷҬ۞ېڶ൴ϠĂ CL ܑϯ࿅Ν՟ѣ఺჌ּγ۞གྷរĂּтĈ Ķ၆બĂтڍ΁ڈֽ̓Ă࠻ז΁఺ᆃใ۞ྖĂݣĂтڍ༊ࢬ఺ᇹ̄ග΁৯Ăᔘߏިᇹ۞ྖĂ ΁ΞਕಶົѣԼតĞ৯ğĄķĞB2-84ğ ĶࣺĂ఺˵ߏĂ఺࣎Ăည఺჌ְଐͽ݈൴Ϡ࿅๜ĉķĞCOA-B2-85ğ Ķ՟ѣબĄķĞB2-85ğ 2. ༊ְˠͅᑕ Ğ1ğ˾ᄬͅᑕ ੵ˞ CL-D дௐ˘ѨᏙથॡ՟ѣϒቁۢᛇ۞˾ᄬͅᑕ̝γĂ׎ዶ CL Ӯਕઇ΍ϒቁۢᛇ۞ͅᑕĄ ༊ CL ѣ೩΍ּγགྷរॡĂ CO ົᚶͽଣ੅ּγགྷរ൴Ϡ۞ࣧЯĂ֭ͷۺؠ̈́ခᐽ CL Ξͽᕖ̂఺ּ࣎ γགྷរć༊ CL ܑϯ՟ѣּγགྷរॡĂ CO ΞਕົԼೱྙય۞͞ёĂрឰ CL Հ୻຾યᗟĂٕߏඕՁּ γયή۞ֹϡĄࣃ଀ڦຍ۞ߏĂ CL ၆ּγયή۞˾ᄬ̰ट˯Ăѣ˭Еྵк࣎Ҿमள۞ېڶĈ a. ༊ CL-A ͽБొӎؠ۞͞ёдୃࢗયᗟॡĂΞਕЯࠎஎౝҋయ۞ଐჰ༊҃̚൑ڱ͔൴׎ּγགྷ រ۞ౘࢗĂ׎аඍౌߏۺؠ۞՟ѣĂ̙൒ಶߏдᖎൺೡࢗഅགྷѣ۞ּγགྷរ̝ޢĂ੺˯ҋҖྋᛖࣧ

(10)

ЯĂٕΐͽĶΞߏķ۞̴ܜୃࢗĂ CO-A ݋ЯТந׎ຏצ҃εݒ݈ࢗ˘̈ొ̶ּγགྷរ۞ྤੈĄ b. CL-C၆ٺБొӎؠё۞ּγયήѣྵϒቁۢᛇ۞ͅᑕĂᑕߏᄃ׎௫ၚϡӎؠ۞͞ёֽౘࢗҋ ̎ϫ݈۞֏ҖѣᙯĂ҃༊ COB ͽྒૺ۞Бొӎؠ͞ёྙયॡĂΞѣड़͔൴׎ͅᅺ۞ͅᑕĂϤѩԱ΍ ׎႙ซ۞ԼតਔඛĄ c. COAЯᑕ D ۞̴ܜୃࢗ۞ͅᑕপّĂԼͽދౕёયή۞ήݭֽྙયĂቁ၁Ξѣड़ഴൺ CL-D۞൑ϒቁۢᛇ۞ౘࢗĂ˵Ξםӄ CL-D ჸ൏д༊ॡ୏ኘ۞͹ᗟ˯Ą Ğ2ğ̰дຐڱ׶ຏצ CL၆ּγયή۞ͅᑕӔன΍ྵк࣎ҾमளଐԛĂ˭ࢬ̶ࢗ࣎Ҿ CL ۞ېڶĈ a. ༊ CL-A аඍ΍ּγགྷរॡĂົᛇ଀ޝ੼ᎸăޝᅅᗫĂᛇ଀ྫྷҋ̎۞߄ጼјΑćҭߏ༊аඍ̙ ΍ֽ۞ॡ࣏Ă˫ົᛇ଀ޝঈድăҋయĄଐჰͅᑕӔன׌ໂ۞ଐԛĄ b. CL-BкѨజྙયޅ̄۞ּγҖࠎĂᔵ൒ CL-B кܑϯޅ̄ѣܑனྵр۞ॡ࣏Ăҭߏд͕྆˯ᄮ ࠎ΁ઇ଀рߏᑕྍ۞ăϒ૱۞Ăયᗟಶдٺ΁ࠎ̦ᆃົઇ̙рćѩ˘̰д۞ͅᑕᄃ CO ຐ౅࿅ּγય ήԱ΍༊ॡޅ̄ࠎ̦ᆃΞͽઇ଀̙᏾۞ᄬή࠹νĂ˵Я҃ഴຫ˞༊ॡֹϡּγયή۞ड़ϡĄ c. CL-Cд݈ޢ˟Ѩ̙Т۞Ꮩથ࿅඀̚Ă၆ٺּγયή۞˾ᄬ׶̰дͅᑕౌ̙࠹ТĄд݈˘Ѩ۞ Ꮩથ̚Ă CL-C ܑϯҋ̎՟ѣ˘͇̙ಅ੧Ă׎̰д۞ຐڱߏӈֹߏѣ̙ಅĂ˵̙ߏЯࠎҋ̎Ӆ˧۞ᙯ ܼĂٙͽᛇ଀ѣֱҋయĂ᝘ז CO ᄲ΁ޝ̙᏾ॡĂຏᛇ̙рຍޥĂᛇ଀ҋ̎՟ѣ CO ຐ଀֤ᆃрć҃ дޢ˘Ѩ۞Ꮩથ̚ĂЯࠎѣቁ၁ઇזҋԧଠט׶ԼតĂٙͽаඍ੓ֽ˵ྵѣܫ͕Ăຏᛇ˵̙᏾Ą CL-C˵дణኘܑ̚ϯĂ CO ݈˘Ѩ۞ͅᑕឰ΁ᛇ଀ҋ̎ࢋઇזҁर۞ഇޞĂٙͽ˵Ӆ˧࠻ҋ̎ਕ̙ਕጐ ณѣࣹ˘͇ਕ̙ಅಶ̙ࢋಅ֤჌ຐڱĄ d. CL-DдаඍּγયήॡĂ̂кߏдϏѣϒቁۢᛇ۞ېၗ˭Ăֶ׎дణኘ̚۞ྤफ़ֽᒢྋΞਕ ࣧЯĂ CL-D ܑϯ՟ѣˠય࿅఺ᇹ۞યᗟĂٙͽ༊˭ࢋޝӅ˧۞ຐăҋ̎༊ॡຐ඾ҋ̎ᙯ͕۞ְଐă ༊аຐ੓ͽ݈۞གྷរॡĂົѣ˘ֱ࡚р۞аጸ΍னĂଐჰົצזྵ̂۞኏ᑝඈĄ Ğˬğ઄నયή 1. Ꮩથरֹϡਔඛ གྷ̶ژ 52 ή઄నયήĂ̶ࠎ̣჌̙Т۞ਔඛĂ̶ࢗт˭Ĉ Ğ1ğдಏѨ୏ኘࣣฟؕॡĂ CO ͽ઄నયήֽྙયᏙથϫᇾĂٕߏд CL ౘࢗߙ࣎ᛉᗟ̝ޢĂ CO ͽ઄నયήֽྙય CL ၆ѩᛉᗟ۞఍நഇޞࠎңĂּтĈ a.ĶČČԧࣣࣣኛିؙ۞ߏĂؙԓ୕ԧࣇ఺࣎ኘྖඕՁͽޢĂؙ۞યᗟົតј˘̦࣎ᆃᇹ ̄ĉķĞCOA-D1-09ğ Ķ˵ಶߏᄲؙගؙҋ̎ϏֽĂдତצԧࣇ఺ᇹ۞˘࣎ኘྖ̝ޢĂؙ֤͕̚۞˘ֱႷೊĂٕ ߏؙ۞ຐڱĂιਕૉតј˘̦࣎ᆃᇹ̄ĉķĞCOA-D1-10ğ b.Ķؙ֤ഇޞؙ׶΁۞ᙯܼ૟ֽਕૉଂனдྭז˘̦࣎ᆃᇹ۞ଐဩ྆ࢬΝĉԧࣇАᄲ౵ޢĂ ̙გ̚ม൴Ϡ̦ᆃְĂؙ֤ഇޞ౵ޢົ΍ன˘̦࣎ᆃᇹ۞ඕԊ׸ĉķĞCOA-D2-21ğ ĶČČٙͽؙࣣ̖ົᓾؙࢋΝຐ୻຾ĂČČؙԓ୕౵ޢҰࣇ׌࣎۞ඕԊߏĂؙഇޞިᇹ۞ ඕԊ΍ன׸ĉķĞCOA-D2-24ğ Ğ2ğд CL ኘ΍ٙഇޞ۞ඕڍٕϫᇾ̝ޢĂ CO ͽ઄నયήྙય CL дٙഇޞ۞ଐԛ൴ϠॡĂߏЯ ࠎ CL ઇ˞̦ᆃԼតٙ࡭Ă CL Ξਕۡତаᑕ΍ҋ̎ઇ˞̦ᆃ҃࡭ֹ઄నଐԛ൴ϠĂ˵Ξਕᅮࢋ CO ޺ ᜈͽ઄నયήྙય͞ਕаᑕ΍ֽĂ༊ CL ܑϯຐ̙΍ֽॡĂΞਕವՐ CO םӄĂ˵Ξਕͽ࿅Ν۞ּγ གྷរֽаඍĂּтĈ a.ĶČČԧдछሄ჊࠻זҰࣇˬ࣎ӱд֤྆ĂҰົިᆃઇ҃ឰԧᛇ଀Ұࣇᔵ൒ᗓ૓˞ĂΞߏ ᔘߏޝр۞ڈ̓఺ᇹĉҰᛇ଀Ұࢋިᆃઇԧ̖ົ࠻ז఺ᇹ۞ഀ෪ĉķĞCOB-C2-133ğ

(11)

ĶԧຐࢋАឰԧҋ̎۞Ϡ߿̏གྷ࿅଀ޝԣሄબĂԧ̙ົ˘ۡΝຐזᄲČĄķĞC2-134ğ b.ĶČČЇң˘Ѩؙ༥זᙷҬ۞યᗟĂؙ͕྆˵ధΞͽ΍ன఺ᇹ̄۞˘࣎ҋ̎યҋ̎۞ຐڱ ĞA Ĉ࣮ğĂᛊтؙᄲؙ׌࣎ޅ̄ົѣ௫ၚّ۞੽ᆜĂؙ֤ᄲԧΞͽઇ̦ᆃְଐ΁ࣇ̙ົ੽ ᆜĉԧΞͽઇ̦ᆃְଐĂٕߏԧΞͽឰ΁ࣇдЫԆฺĂΈ؏࠹఍۞֤࣎ଐဩĂΞͽѣިᇹ ۞˘࣎ត̼Ăֹ΁ࣇ̙υֶያ੽ᆜĂ˵ਕૉޝ೚ԣ۞д˘੓ĉķĞCOA-A4-56ğ ĶҰਕ̙ਕᑒԧຐĉķĞA4-56ğ c.ĶČČԧࣇ઄నؙઇ˞̦ᆃְଐĂඕڍົֹؙޅ̄ޝᙸຍ᝘๽๽۞ྖĂ΁˵ޝᙸຍԯΑኝ ઇрăࡍҗڇЫฺĂČČٙͽԧࣇૻአ۞ߏĂ๽๽זغઇ˞̦ᆃĂٙͽޅ̄ົ΍ன˘ؙ࣎ ٙಈᝌ۞Җࠎĉҭ̙ߏؙึ඾΁Ă̙ߏึ඾΁ĄķĞCOA-B2-22ğ Ķԧۢ྽ČĞᓏࢰ຋ऴğĞઃ࿲˛ࡋğĂԧᛇ଀ߏтڍౖ඾΁ەĂౖ඾΁ە۞ྖĞ৯ğĂە ˘ە΁ಶົޝϡΑĂ၆ĄķĞB2-22ğ Ğ3ğ༊ CO ֹϡּγયήĂ CL ൑ڱ೩΍ּγགྷរॡĂ CO ົᖼ҃ྻϡ઄నયήྙયְଐтڍਕѣ ̙Т۞ΞਕࣧЯĂ CL Ξਕౘࢗҋ̎Ξͽઇ̦ᆃְଐֹ҃଀ְଐѣ̙ٙТĂ˵Ξਕౘࢗ࿅Ν۞јΑགྷ រĂּтĈ a.Ķ֤̙൒ԧࣇͅ࿅ֽᒢྋ˘˭р˞Ăтڍؙᛇ଀ྫྷؙ̃׊д˘੓ົត۞ͧྵҋдĂČČĂ ઄тѣ˘ؙ͇ਕૉຏצזྫྷ̃׊࠹఍΍ன˘჌ઇ๽๽۞֤჌ຏᛇâ჌р๽๽۞ຏᛇĂ֤ ѣΞਕߏЯࠎؙઇ˞̦ᆃĉ֤჌р๽๽۞ຏᛇಶ΍ன˞ĄķĞCOA-D3-60ğ b.ĶрĂ՟ᙯܼĂ֤ԧࣇೱ˘࣎͞ёֽຐĂтڍ΁ਕૉٸጯаֽČĂਕૉԯٗมፋந઀ஐĂ тڍ۞ྖĂтڍĂ΁аֽਕૉ఺ᇹઇрĂ֤ߏЯࠎؙд΁֗˯ٕдؙ֗˯൴Ϡ˞̦ᆃԼ តĉķĞCOA-B2-78ğ Ķ֤ԧࣇ఺ᇹֽ̄ຐĂтڍѣ˘͇Ă˭ࢬԧࣇଂ˘࣎ܧ૱؈ᖹ۞֎ޘֽ࠻Ăѣ˘͇΁ٸጯ аछĂؙ̦ᆃྖ˵̙ᄲĂ؈ᖹ൴Ϡ˞ĂҰ۞ޅ̄ا൒ົԯҗڇଭ੓ֽĂؙᛇ଀ߏ΍ன˞̦ ᆃְĂឰ΁ົԯҗڇଭ੓ֽĉķĞCOA-B2-81ğ Ğ4ğགྷϤณ͎યήྙય΍ CL ෞҤ۞ϫᇾ̶ᇴ̝ޢĂ CO ౅࿅઄నયήֽྙયΞͽ྿јϫᇾ̶ᇴ ۞ઇڱĂ CL Ξਕаᑕ΍ΞҖ͞ڱĂ˵Ξਕаᑕ΍࿅Ν۞఍ந͞ёĂּтĈ Ķٙͽனд઄నؙ̏ซՎז̶̱Ăम̙кĂ֤ԧࣇᔘߏѣֱĂᔘߏѣซՎ۞۩มဗĂٙͽؙ ࢋ̙ࢋຐ࠻࠻ᄲĂтڍԧࣇ̫͇аΝԧࣇΞͽឰޅ̄Լត۞ՀрĂז྿ؙ˯Ѩᄲ۞ˣ̶۞Ҝ ཉĂѣ̦ᆃᔘΞͽઇ۞ĉķĞCOA-B6-11ğ Ķѣ̦ᆃᔘΞͽઇ۞Ăࢋͧྵ׍វ۞ረᐽ΁ĂٕߏჍ៙΁Ă΁̖ົຏᛇזĄķĞB6-11ğ Ķ֤ੵ˞఺࣎͞ڱ̝γĂؙᔘѣຐז̦ᆃᏱڱĂΞͽଂ̶̱זˣ̶۞ĉķĞCOA-B6-17ğ Ğ5ğCO АҖ೩΍ೈᒖ̢જ۞ྋᛖĂ̝ޢ݋ͽ઄నયήྙય CL Ξͽઇֱ̦ᆃְଐֽχ৔ࣧА۞ೈ ᒖĂּтĈ ĶČČĂтڍ఺ᇹ˘ј̙ត۞ᑚቅՏ͇ౌυื˯ႊ˘ѨĂௐ˘࣎ĂЇኡౌົᛇ଀఺ᇹ۞˘࣎ Ϡ߿ߏ൑ड़۞Ăߏޝ௢۞Ăߏ̙ߏĞA Ĉ๢࣮ğĂௐ˟࣎Ăؙѣ՟ѣຐ࿅఺ᇹ˘̙࣎ត۞ԛ ёĂߏౄјؙયᗟ۞ֽ໚Ă֤тڍ̙ϡ఺ᇹ̄۞˘࣎Ϡ߿͞ёĂͧ͞ᄲԧࣇઇ˘ֱԼតČ ČĂтڍҰࣇ۞Ϡ߿͞ёਕૉઇ˘ֱԼតĂઇ˘ֱྫྷͽ݈̙˘ᇹ۞Ăؙᛇ଀ົѣ̦ᆃᇹ۞ត ̼ĉķĞCOA-A2-31ğ 2. ༊ְˠͅᑕ Ğ1ğ˾ᄬͅᑕ a. CL-A,CL-B׶ CL-D ౌѣͽּγјΑགྷរֽͅᑕ CO ઄నયή۞ଐԛĂֹ҃଀ CO ГԼͽּγགྷ រֽྙયĂٕߏ੫၆ CL ٙ೩јΑགྷរઇૻ̼۞ͅᑕĄ

(12)

b. CL-A׶ CL-B ၆઄నયήѣᙷҬ۞ͅᑕĂໄ׌ˠ۞યᗟ࠰ࠎᏐ̄ିዳĂ҃ܜഇᄃޅ̢̄જٙԛ ј۞ೈᒖሀёֹ଀сࣇྵᙱྯ௲યᗟଐဩĂ˵ޝᙱຐညϏֽଐဩົѣΞਕ̙ТĂϺᄃ׎࣎ˠপኳѣ ᙯĄ CL-A ൑ڱຐည׊̄ົѣΞਕԼតĂ˵̙೷ဘྏ̙Т۞ઇڱĂ̂кᇴ۞ͅᑕ˵ͧྵߏຐ̙΍ֽ֤ ࣎઄నඕڍтң൴ϠĂ֭ົᖼ҃ವՐ CO ۞޽ጱᄃޙᛉĄ CL-B кͽ௫ၚّ۞̢જ͞ё׶࿅඀ֽຐည ଐဩ۞ඕڍĂޝᙱѣ׎΁Ξਕّ۞ޥ҂Ă COA ˵ዋॡ۞ϯቑтң׶ޅ̢̄જ۞͞ёĂ׍វିጱ CL-B тңઇ˘̈Վ̙˘ᇹ۞ԼតĄ Ğ2ğ̰дຐڱ׶ຏצ a. ༊ CO ٙ೩۞઄నଐဩ̙జ CL ᄮࠎΞҖٕΞਕॡĂ CL ͕྆кߏຐ඾၆͞ިᆃΞਕԼតĂҭߏ Яࠎ˫̙ᛇ଀၆͞ΞͽԼតĂٙͽ˫ೈᒖаז̙Ξਕ۞ຐڱ˯Ăᙱٺࡎ৔ᖞѣགྷរ۞ࢨטĂдۢᛇ˯ ˵ᙱٺᖼតĄ b. ༊ CO ྙય CL Ξͽѣ̦ᆃԼត҃Ξͽֹ଀၆̙͞˘ᇹॡĂ CL-A ׶ CL-B ົЯࠎᛇ଀՟ѣᏱڱ ઇז҃ᛇ଀ҋ̎ޝᒷᎣĄ CL-B ܑϯҋ̎᝘଀ᑖĂҭ˫̙ۢ྽ࢋᄲ̦ᆃĂ༊ॡཝఠ۩۩۞ĂЯ҃ຏז ̙рຍޥĄ Ğαğณ͎યή 1. Ꮩથरֹϡਔඛ གྷ̶ژ 39 ή઄నયήĂ̶ࠎ̱჌̙Т۞ਔඛĂ̶ࢗт˭Ĉ Ğ1ğдௐ˘Ѩ୏ኘ༊̚Ă CO ੫၆ CL ٙ೩΍۞યᗟĂͽณ͎યήྙય୏ኘ۞൏ᕇٕϫᇾĂ CL а ᑕ΍̶ᇴĂ CO Гͽณ͎યή׍វ̼ CL ٙᄲഇ୕ېڶ۞̶ᇴࠎңĂּтĈ a.ĶČČٙͽĂ᝘זனд఺ᇹ̄Ăԧ᝘ז۞ߏČĂ̂ໄΒ߁఺ˬ࣎͹ᗟĂ֤ԧ̙ፍ଀ࣹ˘࣎ યᗟؙᛇ଀၆ؙᇆᜩͧྵ̂۞ĂČČĂ֤тڍؙගιࣇχ̶ᇴр˞Ă̶ؙҾගιࣇ˘̶࣎ ᇴâז˩Ă˩̶ߏޝ႕ຍâ̶ߏܧ૱̙႕ຍĂؙົ̶Ҿගк̶͌ĉķĞCOA-A1-21ğ Ķԧ̂ໄౌගα̶ĄķĞA1-21ğ b.ĶČČனдԧࣇᔘѣ˩̶Ξͽಆि۞˧ঈĂબԧࣇԓ୕ົೇࣧဗĂΞͽၙၙ۞݈ซĞC Ĉ ၆બĂԧಶߏޝԓ୕ᄲ֤ᇹğĂ၆બĂˠϠ۞གྷ።̙Ξਕ੺˯ಶ˘Ѻ̶ĂબҰԓ୕ᄲҰົ ซՎזೀ̶ĉķĞCOB-C1-62ğ Ķ఺࣎Ăԧ՟ᏱڱྫྷؙᄲĂԧΪߏČĞೡࢗܕֽ۞Ϡ߿ېڶğČķĞC1-62ğ Ķ༊൒ԧߏԓ୕Ăԧ౵ԓ୕۞ಶߏԧѣᏱڱҋ̎৭੓ֽĄķĞC1-74ğ ĶߏબĂ৭੓ֽम̙кѣೀ̶ĉҰᛇ଀ೀ̶ΞͽឰҰ৭଀ͧྵۡĉķĞCOB-C1-74ğ Ķ60 ̶ზ̈́ॾဗĂČČĂ֤༊൒˵ߏࢋ֕ז̈́ॾĄķĞC1-75ğ Ķٙͽԧࣇனдѣ˘࣎ϫᇾĂΞͽឰԧࣇၙၙΝຏᛇҋ̎ߏ̙ߏՀѣ˧ณ˘ᕇĂ၆̙၆ĉķ ĞCOB-C1-75ğ Ğ2ğ༊ CL ܑ྿΍࢑ШҋԧୃٕࢗଐჰېၗॡĂ CO ͽณ͎યήณ̼ CL ٙഇޞ۞ϫᇾ̶ᇴٕனд ۞ଐڶĂּтĈ a.ĶČࠎ̦ᆃԧౌ՟ѣᏱڱΝΒटԧ۞ޅ̄Ăᔘѣԧ૱૱ϡ֤჌ČķĞA2-41ğ ĶČČԧࣇனд˘੓ֽຐĂ઄నனдؙ݈ࢬѣ˘ԯณ͎â̶ז˩̶â̶ܑϯޝ̙рĂ ֤˩̶ಶߏޝр۞˘࣎ېڶĂؙගؙҋ̎χ̶࣎ᇴĂ၆ٺֱؙ֤ຐԼචҋ̎۞ڌҘĂχ˘ ̶࣎ᇴĂ̂ໄົߏೀ̶ĉķĞCOA-A2-42ğ b.ĶČČ֤ԧ˯ѨયҰᄲҰࢋซՎזೀ̶Ұ̖႕ຍဗĂ˯Ѩԧࣇѣᄲז̈́ॾĂ֤̙გѣ՟ѣ ̈́ॾĂனдҰᛇ଀Ұҋ̎ೀ̶Ăдፋ࣎ᗓ૓ޢ۞ଐჰېڶֽᓾĉķĞCOB-C3-37ğ ĶČČԧᛇ଀ԧᔘߏ̶֤࣎ᇴĂԧ̙೷ᄲҋ̦̎ᆃ̶ᇴĂזனд఺ᇹĂрည՟ѣซण۞ຏ ᛇĂЯࠎԧᔘົ˘ۡдͼČČĞኘ̈́၆͉͉೩ᗓ૓˘ְ۞ᇙޤğĄķĞC1-37ğ

(13)

Ğ3ğCO ଂּγགྷរ̚Ăͽณ͎યήྙય CL ົГѨဘྏ఺࣎࿅ΝјΑઇڱ۞ΞਕّĂּтĈ a.ĶČтڍΝྏྏ࠻఺ᇹ̄۞˘࣎ઇڱĂҰ۞Ξਕّߏк͌ĉѣк͌Ѻ̶ͧΞͽઇ଀זĉķ ĞCOA-B1-48ğ ĶѺ̶̝˛˩ĄČČЯࠎԧ˵ᛇ଀Ă΁˵ᛇ଀ԧՏѨಶߏԱ΁᏾۞г͞Ăબԧౌ՟ѣԱ΁ ၆۞г͞ĂԧຐԧΞͽଂ఺ᙝઇ੓ĄķĞB1-48ğ b.ĶČԯ఺࣎࿅ΝјΑ۞གྷរĂдனдГࢦາઇ˘࿆Ăؙᛇ଀ؙޅ̄ົ̙ົͧྵಈᝌĉ ĞB ĈᑕྍߏົğĂᑕྍົĂٙͽؙࢋ̙ࢋྏྏ࠻ĉΞ̙Ξͽઇઇ࠻ĉĞB ĈΞΞͽબğĂਕ ઇזѺ̶̝к͌ĉķĞCOA-B2-71ğ ĶѺ̶̝̣˩ӐĂᑕྍߏΞͽધĂԧтڍ˘࣎ᖃ޵٩۩Ă٩࣎ॡมČČĄķĞB2-71ğ Ğ4ğCO ͽณ͎યήྙય CL ̏ѣ۞ซՎĂ CO ˵ົซ˘Վྙય̶ᇴम෼۞ϒШԼតࠎңĂ̟֭ခ ᐽ׶ۺؠĂּтĈ a.ĶČԧࣇኘ˞ˬѨזனдĂ̙გިᆃᇹĂؙࢋ̙ࢋᄲᄲ࠻Ăؙனд̂ໄдೀ̶۞Ҝ̄˞ĉ ˩̶ߏ౵႕ຍ۞â̶ߏ౵ᒷᎣ۞ĄķĞCOA-A3-37ğ Ķ̂ໄ̣ă̶̱ĄķĞA3-38ğ Ķனд̏གྷѣ̣ă̶̱˞Ăдؙௐ˘Ѩֽኘॡߏೀ̶ĉķĞCOA-A3-38ğ Ķ๢Ă׌ˬ̶ӐĄķĞA3-39ğ ĶČؙ֤ᛇ଀ԧࣇଂ˟ăˬ̶Ăனд̏གྷྭז̣ă̶̱Ăؙ֤ҋ̎౵̂۞Լតߏ̦ᆃĉķ ĞCOA-A3-39ğ b.ĶČҰд༊یی۞֎Ғ˯â̶ྫྷ˩̶ֽᓾĂώֽԧ̙ۢ྽Ұົχೀ̶Ă֤Ұᛇ଀னд఺ ࣎یی۞֎Ғߏೀ̶ĉķĞCOB-C3-139ğ Ķ˘̶ז˩̶ಊĂྵѝߏ˘̶ĞέᄬğĂબனд׌̶҃̏ĄķĞC2-139ğ ĶಊĂซՎ˘̶ಶត̼఺ᆃ̂ӞĊķĞCOB-C3-141ğ c .ĶČ˯Ѩԧયؙ̂ໄଂ˘ז˩ؙдࣹ࣎ҜཉĂؙ̂ໄӘ෦ԧрညߏαᔘߏˬ۞Ҝཉ ĞCL Ĉ๢ğĂрĂؙ֤༊ॡߏдαٕˬĂؙᛇ଀ؙனд۞Ҝཉдࣹ྆ĉķĞCOA-D3-29ğ ĶԧಊĂᑕྍд̱ٕ˛Ăᑕྍ՟યᗟӐĊķĞD3-29ğ Ğ5ğд CL ೩זҋ̎ѣซՎ̝ޢĂ CO ົซ˘Վͽณ͎યήࢋ CL ࿰ҤϏֽΞ྿ז۞̶ᇴĂ֭ྙય ΞͽซՎ۞ઇڱࠎңĂּтĈ a.Ķٙͽ఺̣ă̶̱ߏؙҋ̎ਕૉઇ˘ֱ̙˘ᇹ۞ְĂᛊтᄲਕૉٸᅅᗫĞA Ĉ࣮࣮ğĂԧᛇ ଀ܧ૱рĂČČତ˭ֽĂ઄నᄲтڍؙࢋࡎ৔఺̣ă̶̱ז˛ăˣ̶ಊĂؙຐࢋٸ˘ֱ̦ ᆃڌҘซΝĉķĞCOA-A4-29ğ b.Ķٙͽ᝘੓ֽؙߏซՎז̶̱˞Ă༊൒ؙޝ႕ຍဗĂ၆̙၆ĉ֤тڍԧࣇᔘΞͽซՎĂ֤ ఺࣎ซՎؙຐࢋซՎזೀ̶ĉķĞCOA-D3-40ğ ĶԧಊĂҌ͌ࢋˣ˝̶఺ᇹ̄ĄķĞD3-26ğ Ğ6ğCL ྙયᏙથ௣ඕ۞યᗟĂ CO ͽณ͎યήྙય CL ۞࠻ڱĂ׍វෞҤ୏ኘΞͽඕՁ۞ॡ፟Ă ּтĈ Ķ֤ࢋ࠻Ұ̂ໄᛇ଀̦ᆃᇹ۞ېڶĂࡗரೀ̶ߏዋЪඕՁົኘ۞ĉķĞCOB-C4-101ğ Ķૄώ˯Ăम̙к̣ă̶̱֤྆Ăԧᛇ଀ᑕྍम̙кԣତܕ˞ĄķĞC4-101ğ Ķ๢Ăϫᇾಶд݈ࢬ၆̙၆ĊČČ̶֤̣۞ॡ࣏ົߏ̦ᆃᇹ̄׸ĉķĞCOB-C4-104ğ 2. ༊ְˠͅᑕ Ğ1ğ˾ᄬͅᑕ ੵ˞ CL-C ၆ٺณ͎યήѣᙱٺග̟ᇴф۞аᑕ̝γĂ׎ዶ CL ౌΞͽۡତаඍ΍ᇴфĂ֭ᄃ CO

(14)

ઇ ซ ˘ Վ ۞ ੅ ኢ Ą д C O B ᄃ C L - C ۞ ̱ Ѩ Ꮩ થ ࿅ ඀ ̚ Ă В ྻ ϡ ˞ 1 6 Ѩ ณ ͎ ય ή Ă Ϊ д 4 Ѩ ĞC1,C3,C4,C5 Ч˘Ѩğ۞ྙય̚ CL аඍ΍ᇴфĂ׎ዶ۞ͅᑕ̙ߏᖼொྖᗟĂಶߏۡତܑϯඍ̙΍ ֽă˭ᖃ޵ГᄲඈĄ ༊ CL-C дௐαѨᏙથ̚ೡࢗ΍̶̣۞ϫᇾ̰உॡĂ CL-C ۞ҋԧۢᛇ׶ຏצѣϒШᖼតĂ CL ᛇ ଀ҋ̎௣տົ֕΍ֽĂЯࠎฉዎѣధкˠග΁˧ณĂ˵ഇధҋ̎ޝԣг֕΍ֽćЯࠎҋ̎АઇрԼ តĂ̖ਕ૲જޅ̄Լត׶ዋᑕĄ CL-C ֭дѩѨྙયᏙથ௣ඕ۞࠹ᙯયᗟĄ Ğ2ğ̰дຐڱ׶ຏצ д̰д۞ຐڱ׶ຏצ˯Ăଂณ̶͎ᇴ۞ொજΞ׍វ࠻΍ҋ̎۞Ӆ˧Ă҃༊ CL ࠻זҋ̎۞ซՎĂ ֭צז CO ۞ۺؠॡĂົᆧૻ CL ࢋᚶᜈӅ˧Լត۞ຐڱ׶Җજ˧Ă˵ᆧซ CL ۞ҋԧۢᛇĂ၆ҋ̎۞ ԼតՀѣܫ͕Ą̙࿅ĂдෞҤϏֽΞѣ۞ซणĂͽ̈́ CO ྙયΞͽઇ̦ᆃֽ྿ז఺࣎ϫᇾॡĂ CL-A ׶ CL-B ܑϯҋ̎ᔘߏޝᙱຐזΞͽઇ̦ᆃĂᅮࢋ CO ۞ିጱ׶ຍ֍Ă CL-D ݋ፉ͕ҋ̎ᓾ͉к̶Ăᛇ ଀̙рຍޥĂ˵ፉ͕ҋ̎Ξਕઇ̙זĄҌٺ CL-C ۞ͅᑕ݋ߏЯࠎᛇ଀ҋ̎Ӆ˧̙ૉăᔘ྿̙זҋ̎ ۞ᇾ໤ăፉ͕ҋ̎ᄲזઇ̙זă̙೷ቁؠҋ̎ΞͽઇזඈࣧЯĂ҃൑ڱග̟ᇴф۞аᑕĂ൒҃ଂˬѨ ĞC3,C4,C5ğ୏ኘ̚Ă CL-C Ξͽаᑕ΍ᇴф۞ਔඛĂពϯ CL-C ၆ҋ̎Ӆ˧҃ѣ۞Լតਕૉྵѣܫ ͕ĂЯ҃˵ͧྵਕૉۡତͅᑕĄѩ჌аᑕ۞मளٕΞពϯ΍ҋԧड़ਕຏ۞ᖼតĂٕ˵ᄃ CL-C ۞ّҾ ׶পኳѣᙯĄ

੅ ā ā ኢ

˘ăᏙથरֹϡᙯᔣયή۞ፋវଐԛ Ϥࡁտ۞ඕڍֽ࠻Ăੵ˞୏ኘ݈ƝมԼតયήкߏд୏ኘࣣฟ̙ؕ˳ॡֹϡ̝γĂ׎΁ᙯᔣયή ֭՟ѣপؠลֹ߱ϡ۞ଐԛĄᙯٺ୏ኘ݈ƝมԼតયήҲٺ၁ᅫ୏ኘѨᇴĂពϯ׎֭ܧдՏ˘Ѩ۞୏ ኘֹ̚ϡĂ̙௑ѩયή۞ϲຍĂѩٕᄃ SkidmoreĞ1993ğ൴ன୏ኘ݈Լតયή౵ᙱֹϡ۞ඕڍ࠹௑Ą տ׎ࣧЯĂΒ߁ CL д୏ኘࣣฟؕॡӈ͹જгౘࢗયᗟĂ҃ࡶ CO ྫྷᐌ CL ۞ౘࢗĂໂٽεݒֹϡ୏ኘ ݈ƝมԼតયή۞ॡ፟ĄГ۰Ăтڍ CO дયή˯Ϗਕځቁᄲ΍ᙷҬĶѣ̦ᆃр۞ଐԛ൴Ϡķ۞ф ήĂ่̙Ϗਕ็྿΍୏ኘ݈ƝมԼតયή۞ϡຍĂ˵ྵᙱ͔ጱ΍ CL ѣ൑Լត۞ͅᑕĄЯѩĂтڍ CO ਕдᄬήϡф˯ՀࠎჟቁĂٕధ˵ͧྵटٽ͔ጱ CL ྯ௲˘ۡдୃࢗયᗟ௟༼۞௫ၚ͞ёĂ҃ซˢ၆ Լតགྷរ۞ଣ੅Ą ˟Ҝ CO ׶αҜ CL дּγă઄న׶ณ͎યή۞ѨᇴּͧѣٙमளĂ׎̚˫ͽ˟Ҝ CO д઄న׶ณ ͎યή۞ֹϡ˯ѣໂځព۞̙ТĂϤٺώࡁտ֭൑੫၆ CO ֹϡયή۞ຍဦ׶̰дͅᑕઇᒢྋĂٙͽ ൑ڱቁ̷ଣ੅׎ࣧ̚ϤĂҭࡶଂ CO-B ᄃ CL-C ۞၆ྖ̚ѣྵ੼ּͧ۞ณ͎યήֽ࠻Ă CL-C ܐॡ၆ٺ ณ͎યή۞ͅᑕкߏܑϯ൑ڱаඍĂٕధ఺˵ֹ଀ CO-B ົࢦኑֹϡณ͎યήĂͽਕ׍វᒢྋ CL-C ۞Րӄϫᇾ̈́ҋԧෞҤࠎңĄ ˟ăᏙથरֹϡᙯᔣયήᄃ༊ְˠ۞ͅᑕ Ğ˘ğ୏ኘ݈ƝมԼតયή ୏ኘ݈ƝมયήдಏѨ୏ኘࣣฟؕॡֹϡ౵кĂдֹϡᄬڱ˯Ă CO кߏͽϒШ࿰న۞͞ёֽྙ ય CLĶઇ˞̦ᆃķֹ҃଀ଐڶត଀̙˘ᇹĂ҃׎̚˵ΞਕЯࠎ CL А೩זְଐٕҋ̎۞ຏצѣ̙ٙ ТĂ͔҃൴ CO ྙયĄΩ۰Ă݋ߏдᇴѨᏙથ̝ޢĂ CO ͽቁؠᏙથ݈ޢѣٙमளֽྙય୏ኘม۞Լ តĂ҃Ϥٺ CL ̏ۢᛇҋ̎ѣٙԼតĂٙͽдͅᑕ۞ᄬή˯˵ਕϲӈೡࢗҋ̎дᏙથ݈ޢ۞मளᄃќ

(15)

ᘥĄ ༊ CL ͅᑕҋ̎۞ԼតĂ CO ົ̟ͽͅߍٕۺؠᄃᆧૻĂ༊ CL ۢᛇזЯࠎҋ̎۞Ӆ˧҃ឰયᗟѣ ̙ٙТॡĂ࣎ˠ˵ົຏצזϒШ۞ଐჰ׶˧ณĂ࠹၆۞Ăд CL аඍ՟ѣԼត۞ТॡĂ͕྆˵ົຏצ זҋ̎۞̙֖׶൑˧ຏĂ CO ᅮࢋڦຍ׶఍ந CL ѩॡ۞ଐჰͅᑕĄੵ˞ͅᑕѣ൑Լត̝γĂ CL ˵Ξ ਕѣ൑ڱϒቁۢᛇ CO યή۞ͅᑕĂּт CL-D Я௫ၚٺୃְࢗІ۞௟༼Ăӈܮҋ̎̏А೩זଐڶѣ ̙ٙТĂҭ̪൑ڱྫྷᐌ CO ۞યήĂ൑ڱ૟ͅᑕ൏ᕇٸд̏ѣ۞Լតొ̶Ąໄ࣎ˠ၆યᗟ۞ۢᛇ׶ᄬ ࢗ௫ၚౌ̙ߏΞͽ੺˯አፋ׶Լត۞Ă CL ˵ᅮࢋՀк۞ॡมֽጯ௫៍၅̏ѣ۞˘̈ՎԼតĂ൒҃ CO ˵ᅮࢋڦຍᄬή۞ֹϡߏӎჟቁĂ de ShazerĞ1996ğಶᄮࠎĂ൑ڱពϯ΍ԫμѣड़۞ࣧЯĂѣΞਕߏ CO՟ѣዋ̷۞ֹϡ SFBC ԫμֽޙၹд׌Ѩ୏ኘ̝ม̏ѣ۞Լតٙ࡭Ąдྤफ̶़ژॡ˵൴னĂ CO д ֹϡ୏ኘมԼតયή۞ॡ࣏Ăѣॡд઄న̏ѣԼត۞ᄬή˯̙֭˩̶୻຾Ăٕధ˵ົЯѩഴ͌ CL ၆ Լត۞ۢᛇᄃྫྷซ۞аᑕĂ఺ߏ CO дֹϡ SFBC યήॡᑕྍڦຍ۞г͞Ą Ğ˟ğּγયή ּγયή͹ࢋдॏ॓ CL ࿅ΝјΑ఍நયᗟ۞གྷរĂӈܮΪߏ˘̈ొ̶۞̙ТĂ˵ߏୁજϏֽԼ ត̈́ᆧૻ CL Լតܫ͕۞ࢦࢋགྷរĄд̱჌ּγયή۞ֹϡਔඛ̚Ă CL-A, B ׶ C Ҭͼౌ௫ၚͽĶᓁ ߏтѩķ۞͞ёֽୃࢗયᗟĂְ၁˯Ă఺˵ߏ̂кᇴˠኘࢗયᗟ۞௫ၚ͞ёĂ൒҃тڍ CO ਕૉ௟տ ׎̚ѣ൑ּγགྷរ൴ϠĂ˵ధਕૉѣड़ᖼೱ CL ۞ᄬ֏ၚّĂ҃Ν၅ᛇזഅགྷѣ̙˘ᇹ۞གྷរĂт CL-B׶ C Ă̙࿅Ă CL-A Ҭͼྵ̙ٽགྷϤ CO ۞ּγયή҃Լតۢᛇયᗟ۞͞ёĂ͍׎ CL-A ௫ၚͽ Ķߏ۞ČΞߏČķ۞ᄬڱઇаᑕĂពϯ CL Ϗԯۢᛇ൏ᕇٸд˘ᕇᕇ۞̈ԼតĂٕ˵ͅߍ΍ CL-A ၆˘ ̈ՎԼត۞៍ᕇ̙֭௫ၚٕ̙ТຍĂ఺˵ధߏЯࠎ CL-A ၆Ꮩથٱ޺੼ޘ۞ഇ୕Ăԓ୕ਕૉ࠻זࠤ̂ Լត۞ቡ߇Ăٕ˵ߏצזᄬ֏௫ၚ۞ࢨטٙ࡭Ą Ϥ˾ᄬͅᑕពϯ΍ CL ᙱٺӈגᖼត၆યᗟ۞ۢᛇ௫ၚĂ CL-A ׶ D ౌܑϯҋ̎˘ॡ̝ม൑ڱຐז ࿅Νѣ̦ᆃ̙Т۞ּγགྷរĂ҃൑ڱຐזּγ˵ឰ CL ព଀൏ާć CL-A ׶ B ౌഅЯ൑ڱаᑕ΍ּγགྷ រ҃ವՐ CO ೩ֻ޽ጱٕޙᛉĂ CO ᔵ൒ѣ೩ֻ CL-B ޽ጱĂҭᐌӈͽּγયήྙય B ࿅Νѣ൑ଳϡᙷ Ҭ͞ڱ۞јΑགྷរĂ֭ͷ͔ጱ B ೩זҋ̎࿅Νഅѣ۞ּγགྷរĂѩᄃ˘ਠᏙથ༊̚۞޽ጱٕޙᛉ͞ё ̙Ⴝ࠹Тć CO ೩΍޽ጱᄃޙᛉĂٕధΪߏྫྷᐌ CL ۞ࢋՐĂଂ҃ቤ׶ CL Яࠎຐ̙΍ּγགྷរ҃ព଀ ღૺ۞ଐჰĂ൒҃ CO ̪ԯ൏ᕇٸдଣྙ CL ѣ൑ᙷҬ۞ּγགྷរĂ˵ቁ၁ਕѣड़͔ጱ CL аזҋּ̎ γགྷរ۞൴ன׶ኘኢĂଂ̚ᆧซ CL ၆યᗟྋՙ۞ܫ͕Ą ༊ CL аᑕ΍ѣּγགྷរ۞ೡࢗॡĂ CO ົତ඾૟׎ּγགྷរઇซ˘Վ۞ͅᑕ׶఍நĂΒ߁ଣտ ּγགྷរயϠ۞ࣧЯăଂּγགྷរ̚Աזѣड़۞̢જሀёăခᐽ CL ਕГѨဘྏăۺؠ׶ᆧૻ CL дѩ ּγགྷរ̚۞ઇڱ׶Ӆ˧ඈĄтڍ CL ܑϯ࿅Ν՟ѣјΑ఍நĂϺӈּγયή൑ڱ͔൴ CL ኘࢗјΑགྷ រॡĂ CO ΞਕົᚶᜈଳϡּγયήĂયή̰ट݋ߏԼͽՀ׍វ۞ॡมᕇֽྙયĂٕߏᖼ҃ాඕᑕϡ ઄నયήĂЋဦ૟ CL ۞ۢᛇᖼೱזϏֽΞѣтңԼត۞ຐည۩มĂЯ҃дඕڍ۞̶ژ˯Ξͽ൴னּ γયήాҚֹϡĂͽ̈́׶઄నયή࠹̢ࠎϡ۞ଐԛĄ αҜ༊ְˠ၆ٺּγયή۞̰дͅᑕౌѣ׎পঅ̝఍Ăߏ˘ࣃ଀ᙯڦ۞൏ᕇĄ CL-A ׶ B ۞Րӄ યᗟౌߏԓ୕Լតޅ̄۞ҖࠎયᗟĂ൒҃˟Ҝ CL ၆ٺ̙Νଣ੅ޅ̄Җࠎયᗟ۞ࣧЯĂ҃૟Լត۞൏ ᕇٸдҋ̎֗˯ĂҬͼౌ̙ߏ͉ᄮΞĂ҃၆ٺฟୁ˘̈ՎԼត۞ໄه˵Ҭѣ̙̟ᄮТ۞ႷೊĂЯ҃൑ ڱЯࠎ̏ѣ˘̈ొ̶۞Լត҃ѣྵϒШ۞ଐჰᖼតĄ CL-C јࠎᗓ૓۰ᄃಏᏐ۞ᛉᗟĂ၆׎࣎ˠ҃֏ ߏາ۞ְІĂ͌ѣՐӄ̝݈۞ּγགྷរΞͽણ໰ᄃଣ੅Ă҃Ϥ CL-C ၆ٺѣ൑ּγགྷរ۞аᑕֽ࠻Ă ᄃ׎࣎ˠ͹៍ෞؠѣᙯć CL-C Яࠎᄮࠎּγགྷរ۞யϠ̙֭ߏЯࠎ΁࣎ˠ۞Ӆ˧ٙ࡭Ăٙͽаඍ΍ ՟ѣּγ۞ͅᑕĂ҃ࡶߏϤҋ̎ೠ೪ֽ҃۞ԼតĂ݋ߏ࠹༊ѣܫ͕۞аᑕ΍ѣּγ۞̙ТĄ CL-D ၆ ٺ՟ѣྫྷᐌ CO ۞ּγયήઇаᑕĂ೩זҋ̎༊˭̰дᖳಱ۞གྷរ׶ຏצĂ CO-A ٺ࿅඀̚кѨԼͽ

(16)

ދౕё۞યڱֽྙયĂቁ၁Ξͽѣड़͔ጱ CL-D ૟ڦຍ˧ཉٺּγགྷរ۞ۢᛇ׶ଣ੅Ą˯ࢗЧҜ༊ְ ˠ۞̙Тېڶ׶ͅᑕĂౌߏ೩ֻ CO ޥ৶тңѣड़ֹϡּγયή۞׍វણ҂Ą Ğˬğ઄నયή ઄నયήϡֽྙય CL ٙഇޞ۞ඕڍࠎңĂ֭ͽഇޞ۞ඕڍࠎϫᇾĂֹܳ CL ਕဘྏӅ˧ـѩϫᇾ ᔙซĄᔵ൒ SkidmoreĞ1993ğܑϯ઄నયή౵׍ड़ϡĂ൒҃ଂ઄నયή۞̣࣎ਔඛ̚Ξͽ࠻΍Ă CL ၆઄నયή۞ۢᛇ׶ͅᑕѣྵк۞ӧᙱĂ CO ఼૱˵ᅮࢋࢦኑྙય׶ሏ୻યή̰टĂЯѩĂ઄నયή кѣాҚֹϡ۞ଐԛĄ CO кߏд CL ܑϯ̙ߏޝᒢྋયή۞ຍޥĂٕߏܑϯإ൑ڱຐည̝ޢĂుՎ ࣒Լфή۞̰ट׶઄న۞ଐဩĂٕՀ෭ܕ CL ۞ΞਕགྷរĂٕߏౘࢗ۞ଐဩՀ׍វ୻೽Ăͽֹ CL ਕૉ ୻຾યή۞ຍஉĄ CLᙱٺࡎ৔࿅Νགྷរ۞ࢨט҃൑ڱຐညϏֽΞѣԼត۞ଐԛĂ˵Ξͽଂѣ CL кߏͽּγགྷរֽ аᑕ CO ۞઄నયήֽᒢྋĄѩٕтТ Nau ׶ ShiltsĞ2000ğ۞൴னĂࡶ CL ൑ڱԱז࿅Ν۞ּγགྷ រĂ˵ྵᙱѣड़аᑕ΍Ϗֽયᗟ̙дٕӧᕘഴ͌۞ຐညଐဩĄ఺჌၆યᗟΞͽྋՙ۞࡚рຐညĂٕధ ᄃ CL ౝٺયᗟ༊̚۞னېѣ͉̂རमĂ࡭ֹ CL ྵᙱྯ௲࿅Νགྷរ۞ࢨטĄ RitaĞ1996ğ݋ᄮࠎĂ઄ నયήᔵ൒జෛࠎߏѣड़۞ԫμĂҭ၆༊ְˠ҃֏Ă˵ѣ͉࿅٩෪׶৿ͻ͞Ш۞યᗟĂ҃ͷ CL ຐည ۞઄న̰टགྷ૱ߏӣѣధкొ̶Ăព଀࿅ٺኑᗔ׶̷̙၁ᅫĄϤ CL ۞̰дͅᑕགྷរ˵ពϯ΍Ăӈֹ CLਕаᑕ΍Ϗֽ઄న۞ېڶĂҭ׎̰͕ࡶ၆ѩ઄నଐԛ՟ѣТॡயϠᄮΞٕ၆ԼតயϠԓ୕ຏॡĂ ޝᙱቁ၁͔൴ۢᛇ˯۞ᖼតĂ˵ഴ͌˞ഈШ઄నଐڶӅ˧۞Җજ˧Ą RitaĞ1996ğ೩̈́ CO дֹϡ઄ నયήॡĂព͌ᒢྋྍтңѣड़гֹܳ CL аᑕ΍ѣड़۞ͅᑕĂధкጯ۰ᄮࠎ઄నયήѣ׎ड़ϡĂҭ ˵кϏགྷ၁ᇈّ۞ଣ੅ĂϤώࡁտ۞ඕڍពϯĂ CO тңឰ઄నયήਕ൴೭ৌϒ۞ड़ϡĂםӄ CL ᖼ ೱၚّۢᛇ۞ሀёĂቁ၁ࣃ଀၁ચ̍ү۰׶ࡁտ۰ΐͽᒢྋᄃଣ੅Ą Ğαğณ͎યή ଂ̱࣎ณ͎યή۞ਔඛΞͽ࠻΍Ăณ͎યήΞͽдᏙથ۞Ч࣎ลֹ߱ϡćଂᏙથฟؕॡቁؠᏙથ ϫᇾăᏙથ࿅඀̚ෞҤ CL ۞ҋԧ׶ଐჰېၗăဘྏԼតઇڱ۞ܫ͕Ăͽ̈́Ϥனд۞ซՎ࿰ҤϏֽᔘ ΞͽՀр۞ϫᇾ̶ᇴඈĂࣘ׍ᏰᙊᏙથϫᇾăᑭ८ CL னې̈́ԼតଐԛĂͽ̈́םӄ CL ఢထԼតඉரٕ ࢍ൪۞ΑਕĄ ณ͎યή۞ᑕϡĂᄃ SFBC ۞࣎ˠ͹៍ޙၹன၁۞ۢᛇ៍ᕇ࠹༊˘࡭Ă CL ˵Ξͽଂҋ̎۞аඍ ̚Ă׍វ࠻זҋ̎ϒд൴Ϡ۞ԼតĄ CL даᑕ˯Ă̂ొ̶ౌਕϲӈග̟ᇴфĂܑ྿࣎ˠ͹៍۞ෞҤ ׶࠻ڱĂ͍׎д၆̏൴Ϡ۞Լតېڶઇᇴф۞ෞҤॡĂౌព଀ྵࠎۺؠĂҭߏд၆Ϗֽ۞࿰ഇ݋ព଀ ྵࠎӧᙱĂᇴф̙ߏ֤ᆃ۞ቁ၁̝γĂ၆ٺтң྿ј۞͞ڱ˵ྵᙱຐညć CL-A ׶ B ၆઄నયή۞ͅ ᑕ˯кٙӧᙱ۞ଐԛĂ˵ពϯд၆Ϗֽซण۞ณ͎યή˯Ă CL-D ˵ፉ͕ҋ̎ົ྿̙זҋ̎ٙаᑕ۞ ̶ᇴଐԛĄҌٺ CL-C Яࠎ̙႕ຍҋ̎۞ېڶ҃кѨܑϯҋ̎൑ڱග̟ᇴфĂ˵дҋ̎ѣ̙˘ᇹ۞གྷ រ൴Ϡ̝ޢĂ̖ᙸຍаᑕ΍ᇴф۞ͅᑕĂѩ࠰ពϯ΍̙Т CL ၆ٺԼត۞࠻ڱ׶ҋԧࢋՐѣٙमளĂ ҃၆໰ CL-C даᑕ΍ᇴфॡ۞ଐჰߏ࠹༊ϒШăᅅᗫ۞ຏצĂ˵ពன΍ CL ۞͹៍ෞҤ၆׎࣎ˠҋԧ ड़ਕຏѣໂ̂۞ᇆᜩĄ ଂ CL дௐ˘Ѩ׶౵ޢ˘Ѩ۞ณ͎म෼ֽෞҤፋ࣎Ꮩથ۞ड़ڍĂ ABCD αҜ CL ౌѣ̙᏾۞ซՎᄃ јड़Ă׎ҋԧۢᛇ˵Ϥܐॡ۞࢑ШᖼតјྵࠎϒШĂ࣎ˠ۞ଐჰགྷរ׶ҋԧड़ਕຏ˵ౌਕᐌ඾Ꮩથ۞ ซण҃ѣ႙Ѩ۞೩̿ĄϤ˯ࢗЧᙯᔣયή۞ֹϡĂͽ̈́ CL ۞ͅᑕଐԛĂΞͽ࠻ז CO གྷϤᙯᔣયή ֽםӄ CL Լត۞ਔඛ׶࿅඀ćଂ 20 ࣎યή̢જਔඛ̚ĂΞͽ࠻ז CL ۞ۢᛇགྷរтңצז CO ֹϡ SFBC࠹ᙯໄه׶ඉர۞ᇆᜩ҃ԼតĄ൒҃ଂణኘ۞ྤफ़̚˵ᒢྋזĂ CL ᄮࠎಏѨᏙથ၆ҋ̎౵̂ ۞ᇆᜩͽ̈́О෪౵எג۞ొ̶Ăᅲкߏд CO ᄲ˞ߙ˘ήྖĂͽ̈́ CO ၆ҋ̎۞ۺؠ׶ခᐽĂពϯ CO ౅࿅ᄬ֏ܑٙ྿΍ֽ၆યᗟྋՙ۞ϒШၗޘĂͽ̈́ۺؠ CL ࣎ˠ׍ѣྋՙયᗟਕ˧׶ྤ໚۞ͅᑕĂ၆

(17)

CLѣ࠹༊ϒШ۞ᇆᜩĂٕ˵Ξਕߏֹܳયή׍ѣड़ϡ۞ࢦࢋЯ৵ĄϏֽࡁտΞͽՀᇃھ۞ࢬШ׶Я ৵ֽଣ੅ SFBC ᏙથԼត࿅඀۞ྻү፟טĂ၆ٺ SFBC тңుՎޙၹ΍ϒШᏙથड़ڍ۞࿅඀૟ਕѣՀ ୻຾۞ᒢྋĄ ˬă၆ SFBC д၁ચᑕϡ˯۞ޙᛉ Ğ˘ğCO дᑕϡЧᙷᙯᔣયήॡĂᅮਕჟቁֹϡࢦࢋфήĂͽਕϒቁ็྿΍ SFBC ۞યήჟৠĂ ͔ጱ CL ྋՙયᗟ۞ϒШۢᛇĄ Ϥ̶ژ୏ኘ݈ƝมԼតયήॡ൴னĂ CO ֹϡѨᇴ࿅͌۞ࣧЯ̝˘Ăдٺ CO ۞ᄬή֭՟ѣ୻຾ ۞ͅᑕٕᇾϯ΍ྍયή۞͹វ̰உĂѩٕ˵Ξਕᇆᜩ CL ၆ྍયή۞ۢᛇ׶ͅᑕĂ CO ᑕ̟ͽপҾ۞ ڦຍĄΩγĂдᏙથ༊̚˵ॡ҃΍ன CO ాҚֹϡ઄న׶ּγયή۞ଐԛć CO кд CL ൑ڱᒢྋٕͅ ᑕયή۞ॡ࣏Ăు႙࣒࿹ᄬή۞ᑕϡĂͽ෭ܕ CL ༊ॡΞͽநྋ۞͞ёԼតયڱٕфήĂͽਕᑒӄ CL ϒቁۢᛇĂଂ҃ઇ΍࠹ᑕ۞аඍĄЯѩĂ CO ᑕд׍౯ჟሢયήᄬήྻϡ۞ТॡĂ˵ᜪ̈́યή۞˾ᄬ ̼Ăͽਕ͔ጱ CL ۞ϒШۢᛇĂጐԣฟୁ˘̈ՎԼតĂ఺˵ߏдᑕϡᙯᔣયήॡ۞౵̂ϫ۞׶જ˧Ă ߏ CO ᅮࢋΐͽൟ᎐۞ਕ˧Ą Ğ˟ğSFBC ᙯᔣયή۞ड़ϡĂ̙ࡶநኢ˯ٙᄲ۞ৠ؈ᄃϲӈĂᅮ҂ᇋ CL ۞યᗟۢᛇ௫ၚઇአፋ ߏᅮࢋॡม۞Ă CO ᑕᔖҺ૟̝ෛࠎ CL ਕ˧̙֖ٙ࡭Ą ᔵ൒ѣధкኢࢗ࠰ܑϯ SFBC ۞ᙯᔣયήѣ׎ड़ϡĂ൒҃ଂώࡁտଣ੅ᙯᔣયή၆༊ְˠᇆᜩ۞ ඕڍΞۢĂд၁ᅫᑕϡ˯̙֭टٽѣϲӈѣड़۞ͅᑕĂ̙ࡶኢࢗٙ̚ᄲ۞நٙ༊൒Ąໄ༊ְˠ۞ۢᛇ ׶˾ᄬͅᑕ௫ၚ۞ጯ௫׶አፋᅮࢋॡมĂ҃༊ְˠ۞̰дͅᑕ˵̙ٽྫྷ඾˾ᄬͅᑕ۞ᐌ̝ᖼតĂѩٕ ˵ᄃ̙Т۞Րӄ̼͛ѣᙯĂ CO дᑕϡॡࢋՀڦຍ CL ۞̼͛׶࣎Ҿमள۞ଐԛĂ˵ࢋᔖҺ૟ CL ൑ڱ ϒቁۢᛇ۞ͅᑕෛࠎ CL ࣎ˠਕ˧Я৵ٙ࡭Ą ĞˬğCL ၆ᙯᔣયή۞ͅᑕĂܐॡព଀ࢪϠ҃൑ڱѣड़аᑕĂ൒҃ CL ၆Чᙷયήົѣ႙Ѩሢଉ ۞ጯ௫ड़ڍĂ CO дྻϡॡᅮࢋѣѩᄮۢĂ˵ࢋдͅᑕ۞ၗޘ˯Հΐ׶ቤᄃ࡝͕Ą дௐ˘ă˟ѨᏙથॡĂЯࠎ̙ሢଉયήĂ҃ົᅮࢋ CO ࢦٕࢗซ˘Վሏ୻Ăд׎ޢ۞Ꮩથ࿅඀̚ ݋ྵ͌ѣ఺ᇹ۞ͅᑕĂ CL ࠤҌдޢࢬ۞Ꮩથ̚ѣ౯ֽ҃ĂЯࠎ΁Ğࣇğۢ྽ CO ˘ؠົ఺ᇹયćѩ ពϯ CL ၆યή۞ۢᛇѣቚ௫үϡĂົϤܐॡ۞̙ࠤ୻຾זЯࠎ CO ۞кѨֹϡ҃ሢଉ׎ᄬຍĄ CO ᅮ ࢋ঻͕۞ߏĂ CL ၆ٺҋ̙̎୻຾યᗟă൑ڱаᑕયᗟ۞ଐԛົѣ࢑Ш۞ҋԧຏצĂ҃఺ᄃ SFBC ߏ ࢋᆧซ CL ҋԧड़ਕຏ۞ϫ۞ߏ̢࠹ٛԵ۞ĂЯѩĂ CO дઇซ˘Վ۞ሏ୻׶ࢦኑྙયॡĂၗޘ׶ᄬ ঈᑕणன໢׶гତৼĂͽᔖҺΐࢦ CL ၆ҋ̎۞̙႕ຍĄ ĞαğSFBC ၆Լត۞ໄه׶៍ᕇ၆ CL ѣϒШ۞ᇆᜩĂтڍਕૉдᏙથࣣฟؕॡ೩ֻ CL ᒢྋĂ ᑕѣӄٺ CL ۢᛇ௫ၚ˯۞ᖼೱĂдаᑕᙯᔣયή۞ྙયॡĂ˵ົͧྵѣϒቁ۞ۢᛇĄ ଂ CL ၆ٺᏙથ̚౵எגᇆᜩ۞аᑕ̚ΞͽᒢྋĂ SFBC ۞ధкૄώໄهĂּтĈԼតଂ˘̈Վ ઇ੓ă࠹ܫયᗟߏਕྋՙ۞ăྋՙયᗟࢋـϏֽ࠻ඈĂགྷϤ CO дᏙથ࿅඀̚۞ۡତౘࢗĂ၆ CL ߏ ѣໂ̂ᇆᜩ۞Ă҃఺ֱໄه˵ߏ SFBC ඉர̈́ᙯᔣયή۞ჟৠĂдᜪ̈́ CL Яࠎ၆યήᄬຍࢪϠ҃ய Ϡ۞࢑Ш̰дͅᑕĂٕధд CO ֹϡ SFBC ॡĂਕАԆፋ೩ֻ CL ᒢྋѩᏙથሀё۞ૄώໄه̈́ྋՙય ᗟ۞៍ᕇâ݋Ξͽ͔൴ CL ۞ഇޞ׶જ፟Ă˵Ξͽഴ͌ CL Яࠎ၆ᄬή۞ࢪϠ҃யϠ۞࢑ШຏצĂ၆ ٺୁજ˘̈Վ۞Լត׶ࡎ৔ CL ᖞѣ۞ۢᛇ௫ၚ˵ᑕѣٙᑒӄĄ Ğ̣ğCL ၆ѣ൑Լត۞ͅᑕĂົᇆᜩ׎࣎ˠ༊˭۞ଐჰĂ CO ͍׎ᅮࢋڦຍ༊ CL ܑϯ՟ѣр۞གྷ រ൴Ϡॡ۞̰д࢑ШຏצĄ ώࡁտ൴னĂ CL ၆ CO યή۞˾ᄬͅᑕ̰टྵࠎϒШॡĂ CO ົ૟׎ϒШ۞൴ன׶གྷរΐͽᕖ̂ ׶ૻ̼Ă၆ٺ CL ۞Լតѣޝ̂۞ӄৈć൒҃༊ CL ۞ͅᑕߏᛳٺ՟ѣּγགྷរă൑ڱຐညϏֽ۞ј

(18)

Αăҋ̎۞఍ந͞ё൑ड़Ăͽ̈́ᛇ଀ҋ̎՟ѣ̦ᆃซՎඈĂ৿ͻϒШͅᑕ۞ౘ̰ࢗटॡĂ༊˭ົѣҋ యă̙рຍޥăᘃႷҋ̎ਕ˧ඈ࢑ШຏצĂЯѩĂ CO ࢋਕڦຍז CL ˾ᄬࡦޢ۞ଐჰᄬ֏Ă֭ઇዋ ༊۞Тநăତৼ׶఍நĂ҃ CO тң͔ጱ CL ֕΍࢑Шଐჰ۞஝טĂវរ׶ຏצ˘̈Վ۞̙ТĂ˵ߏ COᅮࢋڦຍ۞ొ̶Ą Ğ̱ğCO ᅮࢋڦຍ CL ۢᛇăޥ҂׶ͅᑕݭၗ۞࣎ҾमளĂ֭࡭˧ٺтңֹܳՏҜ CL ਕѣड़ͅᑕ ۞ᄬήֹϡ͞ёĄ ଂαҜ CL дᏙથ̚۞˾ᄬͅᑕពϯĂ̙Т CL ۞ͅᑕ͞ё̙ТĂЧѣ׎পѣ۞ݭၗĂּтĈ CL-Aޝ௫ၚϡĶߏ۞ČΞߏČĞyes, butğķ۞ᄬڱֽౘࢗĂ҃׎ଐჰົઃ঻дĶΞߏķ۞ొ̶Ăᓁߏд ᄲҋ̎׶ޅ̄ࣇ۞ܑனޝᒷᎣĂ҃˵̙೷ဘྏ˘̈Վ۞ԼតĂЯࠎс၆ඕڍᓁߏխᙱ࿰ഇć CL-A ௫ ၚّгنர̏൴Ϡ۞˘̈ՎԼតĂߏ CO ΞͽপҾ඾˧۞ࢦᕇĄ CL-B צࢨٺҋ̎۞གྷរĂ၆ٺΞͽ ܑன΍̦ᆃ̙˘ᇹ۞Җࠎ׶ઇڱព଀Ձ͘൑ඉĂٙͽ˵૱ߏଂ࿅Ν۞གྷរֽаඍ઄నયήĄ࠹၆ٺˬ Ҝّ̃ CL Ă C ۞၆ྖͧྵᖎൺĂ၆ٺҋ̎ઇ̙ז۞ăᔘ՟ઇז۞Ă้Шͽ൑ڱаᑕֽͅᑕĂ CL-D݋ߏགྷ૱൑ڱϒቁۢᛇ CO ۞યᗟĂӈֹѣٙаᑕĂ˵кົ̴ܜгౘࢗ׎΁ְଐĂ҃ᐌ඾ CL-D ۞ౘ ࢗĂ CO ॡ҃ົԯ൏ᕇᖼҌ CL ޢֽٙౘࢗ۞ְଐĂεΝ̝݈۞યήਔඛ׶൏ᕇĂ CO-A ޢֽкѨԼϡ ދౕё۞યڱֽឰ CL-D ᖎൺаඍĂͽᔖҺ̙̠ۢٙ۞၆ྖ΍னĄЯѩĂ CO дᑕϡ SFBC ॡĂтңѣ ड़Яᑕ̙Т CL ۞̙ТͅᑕপّĂ˵ߏᅮࢋ඾˧̝఍Ą αă၆Ϗֽࡁտ۞ޙᛉ Ğ˘ğֶώࡁտ൴னĂ CL ၆ᙯᔣયή۞ۢᛇ׶ͅᑕĂΞਕົצז׎࣎ˠّҾăّॾĂͽ̈́યᗟᙷ ݭඈЯ৵۞ᇆᜩĂϏֽдࡁտ၆෪˯ĂΞͽᕖ̂ CL ၆෪̈́યᗟ۞मளᙷҾĂ֭૟ CL ࡦഀតีăˠॾ পኳ׶Րӄયᗟᙷݭඈΐͽ̶ᙷĂซҖ၆໰׶ͧྵĂᖣͽᒢྋ SFBC дᑕϡ၆෪˯۞к̮ᄃࢨטĄ Ğ˟ğώࡁտགྷϤαҜ CL ă 21 ѨᏙથ୏ኘĂ̶ژ΍ 20 ࣎ᙯᔣયή̢જਔඛĂϏֽࡁտΞͽଳϡ Тᇹ۞͞ڱă࿅඀׶ྤफ̶़ژ͞ёซҖĂᕖ·ᒢྋЧᙯᔣયήᑕϡਔඛ۞׎΁ېڶĄ Ğˬğώࡁտ඾ࢦд CL ͅᑕ۞ଣ੅Ă၆ٺ CO ֹϡЧᙷᙯᔣયή۞ॡ፟׶ਔඛĂߏͽᏙથ၆ྖֽ ઇᒢྋĂ൒҃Ꮩથߏ࣎ CO ׶ CL ࠹̢ۢᛇ۞࿅඀ĂϏֽࡁտٕΞ੫၆ CO ֹϡЧᙯᔣયή۞ຍဦઇ၁ г۞ଣ੅Ă၆ٺтңѣड़ྻϡ SFBC યήĂ༊ѣՀᖳಱ۞ᒢྋĄ Ğαğώࡁտд࿰౯ّᏙથ׶ణኘ۞నࢍ̚Ăࣧώߏࢋ CL дତצԆᏙથ̝ޢൾүЃिĂ҃ޢӈϤ ణࣶᄃ̝ซҖణኘĂ൒҃ଂેҖ̚ݒ൴னѩ˘၁߉͞ёѣኜк۞ӧᙱĂΒ߁Ĉ CL ۞ଐჰΞਕ̪ઃ঻ дᏙથ༊̚Ăྵᙱડ̶Ꮩથᄃణኘ۞मளĂдణኘ̚ॡ҃ྙયణࣶѣᙯҋ̎дᏙથٙ̚ኘኢ۞ᛉᗟć Г۰Ă CL ۞ჟৠېڶ˵Яࠎ̝݈ԸڦдᏙથ࿅඀҃̚даᑕణࣶયᗟ˯ព଀˧̙ଂ͕Ăᙱٺаጸд Ꮩથ̚۞གྷរĄϤٺᏙથޢ۞ϲӈణኘѣ˯ࢗ۞ӧᙱĂٺߏԼࠎᔛኛ CL ٺ˭ѨᏙથ݈ĂҌ፟ၹତצ ణኘĂ൒҃ CL ݒܑϯЯࠎ˯঱҃ᙱͽ੨ЪĂ҂ณ఺ᑕߏ̂кᇴۤડᏙથ፟ၹ࣎९۞ଐڶĂЯ҃౵ޢ ̖Լតјд˭˘ѨᏙથ݈˘̈ॡซҖణኘĄణኘॡม۞щଵѣ఺ᇹ۞តೱĂ˵ଂ̝ޢ۞གྷរ̚൴னĂ CLдణኘ̪̚ਕаጸזҋ̎д̝݈Ꮩથ༊̚۞̰дགྷរĂ҃Ϥٺణࣶߏֶፂుфቇ̚۞યήֶԔྙ યĂ˵ਕᄓะז࠹༊Ԇፋ۞યῄᑕྤफ़Ą Ϗֽࡁտࡶߏͽۤડ࣎९ࠎࡁտ၆෪ĂٕΞଳϡώࡁտ۞నࢍĂٕ˵Ξဘྏͽˠᅫ࿅඀аጸ۞͞ ёĂٺᏙથޢ۞ 24 ̈ॡ̰ซҖణኘĂଘтңפ଀ CL Ъү۞ຍᙸ׶ਕ˧Ă̪ߏ҂ᇋ۞ࢦᕇĄ Ğ̣ğЯᑕ˯ࢗࡁտనࢍ۞តՀĂώࡁտనࢍѣĶ୏ኘຏצ੃ᐂܑķֻ CL ੃ᐂдՏѨᏙથ̚۞វ រĂ൒҃ଂ CL ๱ᆷ۞ଐԛֽ࠻Ăѩ੃ᐂܑ̙֭ዋЪઇࠎྤफ̶़ژ۞ֶፂĂ่ਕઇࠎణࣶణኘॡ۞ણ ҂Ą CL ՟ѣ๱ᆷٕ๱ᆷфᇴޝ͌۞ࣧЯĂΒ߁ĈаΝಶѓ඾ధкְଐĂ՟ѣॡมᆷă̙ۢ྽ިᆃ ᆷă CL ܑϯҋ̎ᆷфޝၙޝᔟĂϡᓾ۞ͧྵԣඈĂଂ̚˵ΞͽᒢྋĂдͽۤડϔிࠎ၆෪۞Ꮩથࡁ

(19)

տ̚Ăтңనࢍዋ༊۞ࡁտ̍׍Ăᅮࢋ҂ᇋࡁտ၆෪۞३ᆷਕ˧׶௫ၚĂ˵ߏϏֽͽۤડ࣎९ࠎ၆෪ ۞ࡁտᅮࢋкΐޥ৶۞ొ̶Ą Ğ̱ğдࡁտ۰ᄃణࣶ੅ኢ࿅඀̚൴னĂణࣶଂय़៍၅ፋ࣎Ꮩથ࿅඀۞ซҖĂѣӄٺೠ೪Ꮩથ߹ ඀̈́ CL ٺᏙથ࿅඀̚۞ଐჰགྷរĂдణኘॡਕՀᒢྋ CL ٙೡࢗ۞̰உĂ˵ਕдυࢋॡઇซ˘Վ۞ሏ ୻ĄҌٺдтңഴҲణኘ၆Ꮩથ۞ᇆᜩొ̶Ă˜ࢋՐణࣶ̙၆ CL ೩ֻᄃᏙથ͹ᗟѣᙯ۞ੈि׶ຍ ֍Ă֭୻຾ࠧؠణኘ׶Ꮩથ۞̶౎Ąᔵ൒дࡁտ̚൑ڱԆБଠטٕᔖҺణኘ၆̝ޢ۞ᏙથѣٙᇆᜩĂ ଂణࣶ۞གྷរពϯĂణኘٕѣΐஎ CL ၆ CO યή۞நྋ׶ሢଉ۞ड़ᑕĂҭ̙ҌٺѣயϠ࢑Ш۞ᇆ ᜩĄ

ણ ҂ ͛ ᚥ

ңົјăѦԠૻĞϔ 88ğĈವྋጱШڼᒚĈٺۤົ̍ү۞ᑕϡĄ NJ Ĉ Global Publishing Co. Inc.έ ΔĈˣ͞Ą

׹ϜৌĞϔ 85ğĈൺഇᏙથ۞൴णᄃໄهሀёĄᅃጱ؞ΏĂ 32 סĂ 4 ഇĂ 34-43 ࢱĄ

Basile, S. K. (1996). A guide to solution-focused brief therapy.Counseling and Human Development, 29(4),

1-10.

Berg, I. K. (1994). Family based services: A solution-focused approach. New York: Norton.

Berg, I. K., & Miller, S. D. (1992). Working with the problem drinker: A solution-focused approach. New York: Norton.

Corcoran, J. (1997). A solution oriented approach to working with juvenile offenders. Child and Adolescent

Social Work Journal, 14(4), 277-288.

de Shazer, S. (1985). Keys to solution in brief therapy. New York: Norton.

de Shazer, S. (1988). Clues: Investigating solutions in brief therapy. New York: Norton. de Shazer, S. (1991). Putting difference to work. New York: Norton.

de Shazer, S. (1996). Words were originally magic. New York: Norton.

Johnson, L. D., & Miller, S. D. (1994). Modification of depression risk factors: A solution-focused approach.

Psychotherapy, 31(2), 244-252.

Lawson, D. (1994). Identifying pretreatment change. Journal of Counseling and Development, 72, 244-248. Lee, M. Y. (1997). A study of solution-focused brief family therapy: Outcome and issues. The American

Journal of Family Therapy, 25(1), 3-17.

Littrell, J. M. (1998). Brief counseling in action. New York: Norton.

Martin, J. (1994). The construction and understanding of psychotherapeutic change: Conversations,

memories, and theories. New York: Teachers College, Columbia University.

McLeod, J. (1993). An introduction to counseling. Buckingham: Open University Press.

Nau, D. S., & Shilts, L. (2000). When to use the miracle question: Clues from a qualitative study of four SFBT practiontioners. Journal of Systemic Therapies, 19(1), 129-135.

O’Hanlon, W. H., & Weiner-Davis, M. (1989). In search of solutions: A new direction in psychotherapy. New York: Norton.

Rita, E. S. (1996). The miracle question therapy with college students. (Eric Documents Reproduction Service No. ED392004)

(20)

model. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of South Dakota, Vermillion.

Webb, W. (1999). Solutioning: Solution-focused interventions for counselors. Philadelphia: Accelerated Development.

Weiner-Davis, M., de Shazer, S., & Gingerich, W. J. (1987). Building on pretreatment change to construct the therapeutic solution: An exploratory study. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 13(4), 359-363. Wells, R. A., & Phelps, P. A. (1990). The brief psychotherapies: A selective overview. In R. Wells & V. J.

Giannetti (Eds.), Handbook of the brief psychotherapies (pp.3-54). New York : Plenum Press.

ќ ቇ ͟ ഇĈ 2003 ѐ 09 ͡ 17 ͟ ˘ቇ࣒ࢎ͟ഇĈ 2005 ѐ 02 ͡ 21 ͟ ˟ቇ࣒ࢎ͟ഇĈ 2005 ѐ 04 ͡ 08 ͟ ତצΏ൳͟ഇĈ 2005 ѐ 04 ͡ 11 ͟

(21)

The Relationships of Key Questions on Clients’ Responses

in Solution-Focused Brief Counseling Process

Y

U

-C

HEN

C

HOU

Department of Applied Psychology

Hsuan Chuang University

The purpose of this study was to explore the use of key questions by counselors ( e.g. pretreatment/between-session change questions, exception questions, hypothetical questions, and scaling questions), and the relationships between key questions and clients’ responses. Subjects included four clients recruited from a Community Counseling Center in central Taiwan and two counselors trained in SFBC. After counseling, clients were interviewed about their responses to key questions. Audiotapes were used to record data from both the counseling session and the interview. 21 counseling transcripts and 17 interview transcripts were used to analyze and answer the research questions of this study. The results are presented by category of key questions and clients’ responses. Further recommedations are proposed.

KEY WORDS: solution-focused brief counseling, counseling skills, counseling process, clients’ responses

Bulletin of Educational Psychology, 2005, 36(4), 335-355 National Taiwan Normal University, Taipei, Taiwan, R.O.C.

參考文獻

相關文件

• Learn strategies to answer different types of questions.. • Manage the use of time

Time constrain - separation from the presentation Focus on students’ application and integration of their knowledge. (Set of questions for written report is used to subsidize

Based on historical documents and archeological evidence, this thesis provides an analysis of, raises some worth-noting questions on, the development of Western Qin Buddhism

We try to explore category and association rules of customer questions by applying customer analysis and the combination of data mining and rough set theory.. We use customer

This study aimed to explore the effectiveness of the classroom management of the homeroom teacher by analyzing the process of the formation of the classroom management and

This study was conducted using the key factor from Technology Acceptance Model (TAM), Theory of Reasoned Action, Diffusion of Innovation, and Involve Theory to explore the

This paper aims to study three questions (1) whether there is interaction between stock selection and timing, (2) to explore the performance of "timing and stock

The volumes in the School Mathematics series contain brief review notes, selected questions with detailed solutions, and test questions with answers.. We hope you