九二一震災建物毀損責任釐清與重建機制探討

全文

(1)Dq:r~if!li'ff!!~Jm:f!{GlJ~~~fM~mlOO8~fi ' ¥t~GlJgH*!!J!:wfifJl:~liitfiifjbk , lJli)fjGlJ:m:m11JfifC$f.-~ , ...... r M.ffi.!tt~lI4 J '- r ~@~ J GlJii¥tf:l@ '- r ~GlJ , ::;:JIJGlJ~~~~'i~~~!l ' !!r-GlJ¥iftf:l ~. =Ftl J GlJi!t!tt '-. r fi¥1~nli J GlJf!!~~@. ~~¥mY'i~~.~'~~~~fiW.,.*,-.~.f!{~g.Jm:¥GlJ*¥IU. '~.~.UMIit~.M~'.~Umit~~~fim.~ ,~m.mmit~GlJ~~~.~.'.~D~~~Jl:it~Jm:.'-G !f~ ~~ m! i} ~J.§ ~ ~ni~ ~. it '- it ~ M~ IfiJ ~ I&'3il Y-11¥:1 ~UI£ jn~ ~. ~.'Q~~~~~~~.U~~~it,~.~~~W~~.~~. ~it'-~~~~~. •• ~.MMIit~,*~~m~~~~.~~. m.~w*'~l¥:Io.~~~'i~m~ID,mI~~MM~~~~ ,.~it~GlJD~.~.~aIU~m'!!r¥. •• *~.it~~.. ,.m~mM.~~M'Y~.~~it!tt,~*~~~itmM'.. ~~.~~il~fi'-.~~.~.~&l¥:ImGlJ~.~.~~ilm. M.§,*~o.U.~il~.Mfi. •• ~ ••• *~.GlJ$~~. 'ili~M.~W'~m.IJGlJ~YM~it~fi.Jm:m~'¥. ••Y. GlJ~.~~~.MGlJM~¥m,~gWM~.~.¥.~~m.~. il~.'U.~~~~~v~~m.~it.M.M~W*:~. ~. ~W'lfiJ ·WlWit1nt~ 'fI. ~. ... •••• www.~ ••••• ·• !it ~ XnlI • • • • . 'j. ¥ ' if. .It+rl$.lt~. , w-. ~~. (lI). !. !. I.

(2) (I8 ). .0. ••fflffi•• ~~~.'~.e*~ ••• ffi.~~M~~~• • ffl.f:f1l71tP)J~:~~rmr~~mm ' {R!ffl.~liI~~.~~If'p~~~z.)i~ mtJ[J~~ ••~If'p~)ifi'.W.B~A=-.~.~.fi.OO&ffiUm~'m.~If'pW* J%fl~~mJb ' .il)i~f]j~.~. ' .-3F;fJtfi.~tt$llf]jfl*jtz!l ' Bi&~tJ[JP.AIE:tJi ~~~.~.~. 0. ~m~o. •• ~$~ ••ffl••~~~ •• A.?~~.R.~~fi~*1I71t.ffM. ~ •••ffi•• ~.M~.*'.~fl.fl~*~.ff1l71tfi~ •• rmtt.m~~~z m~?~.~~~.ffl•• ff~*1I71too~~~)irr.~If'p?~If'p~~~~mJb z~ •• ~.M?Wmfi.~ttM~flM~~z!l?~~~ •• ~If'pz)ifi'~ {R!~at±ttJitJjfl~**lJffl ' ~a.~If'FHj~~~mUfU.M? ~tlDMjf~t1HjzljifilJ ~.Mm~z~~?m·~.~ •• ~.fi$ffi.mW~.m~~.mofla~~,* ~~~.~t1.~.~m ••fflz~~tJ[JP.A7.Hfi ' WHj~1I71tf~rm.ffIM. ' P.A*IJ~~z m~,)iWjf~~.~~•• ~zffirm.~~ljM' ••• ~~A~mmJi ••• ~~ ••~If'p , {R!~1iI*.fjgt!Hm.~~~ *x~~.~~,~~-~oo~~'~=~.~•• ffl~~~~'~.~t1~~ mz~.~~.~~~~*)ifi~~,m~~.~ •• ffl.ff1l71t~~~!I~m~~ "'M~t1~~~~.ffl~~.W~.~m~~~'~~~m~ •• ~.m~H' •• ~m~1iI.~~.~mm~~&mflljM~~z!l'mli~Mjf~*~~t1~~ •• ~ Z~ ••JlU ' ~~.t1H!zlj*1J ':Rt•• ~rna ~. 0. 0. 921 *~.t1~$$~~t$~1iI~.f~.~.~~t!. ' .~m 921. *~.?Jl~.1¥J. ••ffl~~~~~ •• ~'~.$~m~~m~~~~.Ifi~~$~.t1~.~~ ~z.i!f)ifi~jff, .~~f'pmEl •• fJT~:tJl~~ef!.:!jl~~mIfi~r:tJt~•• ~. 3~~~~~~'~~~~ffl.~~ •• 1¥J~~: ~. 0. -·2*mlli~~Bm~~M.' ~~~.~.*~~m~. •• ~~ •• ~m~~w. •• ~ili'~~~m~~~m:Rt.~.'~ffl~ •• ~. • 4,500 ~ , f~~$~ffl~m~~ 53% ' ~~.Ei'$~~ 2,800 ~ , f~~$~t.ft~~~ ~ 32% ' WEi'~t~~m~~JlU~f~ 300 ~. 0. fi9:1~4if}j~ii~~.. '. ¥~IiE.ffij~. ,. Ei'~tQ. •• ~m'.~.~.~~~~*.~'Ei'~t~~m~m•• ,g~ .fi~~~~mili.*~ili~fi•• '~.~.~8~~Hj~ •• 'm•• ~.~*. ~rJIm ' fl~)i-jj11171t Hj~.fl~~I¥J~. 0. ='~~m~~N*.~~M.'A~.*mUW~m~. ~.~fi~W~'~Mm~fi~.~~~a.$~m~,~a.$~~~'~. -2.

(3) ~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~. .•. ~n. (19 ). ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ~.~*'~ ~~~m.z~~wam.~~~ma ~~ff~~~m~g'.~ffl.~~ft ~m~~~a~~'~~W~~.~~~' ;jt*~ • •~. 0 :¥~a~t~" 1B~~J!ur)@~~.~~ 'OJY!~~w~~m§~Wlffi. ••. ••• ••. •• ~~~m:fltEla*~;lf* ~·~~~&U~m. •• o. 0. •• R.M'~W~.~~~M •• ~n~m.~§~~§. ~IJ~!!ti~ ~ffl~~W~a~t~~a~trnr). ~~W~ffl.~. 4-6 Jj~~~wm.~~9}, ~a*5ir) 1-3 ~~. •••• '~~~~~.~8~,~m~±•• "*~"~&.B~. •• ~~wZa~~~&~~mHm.-.Am~ m'~•• h~~o~9}'OJ.~.~wmffl~.~M~B~~~~.'.~~~~w ~Jllt.ftm~.7fj.::V · f.§.?tf\'fj ®~m (f9lI~Di:I~t~ ) ~~~ 72-78 ~.B~~~wm m••&~~~79~~• •::Vo~a~g·~$~~~~~63~~~~~~.~Wffl .ft~ · ~~t$~liiIjJWj.:)~~~3W 10 ~~JjJm~Jut.ft •• ~ ~~ EI3~~~~z~ ~~~~w~a*.H.M·~~~ffl.~.~~.~w~ ••~.~w~.~~m~ ~~~~.m~~%'Bm~~ 4. 0. ~fMU1ljm~~-?V~~~. •. 0. .,m.~m.ff. •• ~M.~~m~. R.m~wmmz.ff~.~.~wmfflz.~~fi~.'~.~B~~~wm. m~.~~ROJ~~~'.-.~~.~.~~.B.~.~W"~a~$mR*~ • • ~~,.=.~~~wza~~tt·5~Ma~z~.~~"~7fj.#,,±_tt.,, r)&~~flIfiJj.~~~§ .-=..RU~.~w*:!it~a. · ~:t5.~w~m.mH (~M •• mH~~7· ••w•• ~-.g.~*m.~~~li.m.".~Jj~~ ~ff~li ~F~:mJllIO "r)&mH~!it) "DfgImB ( ~MDfgI~.~f! .~m I~nI. 12) .. j.:)&~mffJ!i! (~M~J!.~•• ~~m . ~J!.fl.~~ti&~:m . j.:)&1J[lji~. ) ~~~~~.!itfil a*~·.-.li.~~~·.= •• ~A •• ~·.=.M.~a~~~~. #·mW.~A~OJ.~R."mm~$~·a.ffli~~~~~A •• ~zM·~. 0 6. 8 ". 9 ... II. 0. ~JjllI~z~~ff*BlRJl;nfi~~~. 0. -·.~m.~m~ff~_e(I~-). (-)~M~{Jl~4hfJftf.Jt~#!t:Jl*"'~*1.fA~Jt ~~.~~.Jj~~~W~ffl.~~~~·m~.~. •••~?tf\.~.~m. ti".~~~,,~&~~~7fjJj~.~~~*~~~flm~~o§~~~~~. ~~. , ~.~~$\j'tli[ijzJlJ~OJ~.1\~ , ft5~?!~~~~1t1JD3!~it 250gal j;)~. ~1\~~.·~m~~~~.n~m.B~~M~~"JjJm~."~JjIfi~"~ 3.

(4) I. (20 ). iWD~jlUm&it~~Sli1l:l!l~Jl~. , li:li!ft!!1t®59tJ3t~~J/:bl:iit~~ , ~Uit~~ .~JUjUD:i1l:l!l~U:t£M.~ ffi:t£ 921 ft!!1t~~ t ~;ttJU7}ili-l:::i~ , :ft59tr.U®:m 400gaJ p).....t®Iglt ' ~.f(Arr:f£~III?UP).f(.$ft(jf;&rrJh ' $7}it~~~Uf: mltl:~j!J;Ij} , ~Jj!PJTff~{~W*Wi~{V:ijJG~~ft!!iW t m9}~UOJB~tlJMft!!~ , It 0. $Jt.aIl'ft!!rft~i1l:l!lo. ~*.~.1£~~ • • *ft!!ItPJT.~®ItJ3t • • *ft!!.~.~'OJ.iliit~ ~m~.ff®W~JU7}o~~'m.-OJ~lli,~ft!!m®ItJ3t~.It*®ffi.ff ~.*®g~'ffi:li!~g.~#@~t.w.~mft!!m®~~~~~~~m'.. tlD~{tfi®jl**.~ffi • •*11fiff 27.65 011. • ffi;ttItI3t11fiff 5 *& • ~t1fi®*ftm ~ffi• •*ili 95.49 011 • ffilt~W~JU 6 *& ' l&1£*UI1~;JUft!!mit~~®~m .. ffm¥ • &:,~J{fft4t®wHiSfi1JB~JE. 0. ;f(.- 1f; 1f; *j*-~~.i.-t-)J~9&)JHl.t..~Ji2tit*j*-;f(.lJoiiJi 1.t II i.E!. ~. 135.19 86.74 172.41 144.17 148.09 153.13 155.83 158.23 95.49 101.32 63.00 77.37 78.12 86.30 5.31 9.66 13.43 15.33 15.35 19.58 21.53 26.30 28.45 45.25 46.88 47.71 35.51 35.82 39.31 38.17 27.65 31.94 39.74 54.50 68.02. 39.72 94.32 17.76 57.36 33.92 28.24 28.78 46.78 250.80 65.62 90.38 353.08 81.94 261.04 171.00 311.76 344.96 415.54 275.38 270.18 274.66 257.80 230.58 173.28 76.20 519.42 153.30 129.26 193.98 109.70 116.28 335.50 211.02 79.86 41.92. -4. It.:J 146.6 168.32 32.6 112.16 97.20 69.08 87.74 91.46 684.52 122.14 162.94 511.72 207.98 399.38 302.48 422.82 610.76 639.00 420.02 368.40 370.50 563.22 312.66 168.98 157.38 361.94 208.16 182.50 438.68 230.70 187.52 749.90 351.46 186.20 207.20. i!!i'". 134.16 194.88 37.02 108.26 110.66 106.82 135.96 138.24 366.54 128.12 141.04 463.32 247.52 291.66 439.70 989. 983. 517.82 340.10 585.94 465.30 774.42 488.86 298.36 248.58 501.60 256.90 221.08 348.66 156.84 178.24 624.16 348.00 142.66 148.10.

(5) g. "¥flff~1ilfi¥~ ttll?fiil-l_ rlt(~) o wlJ.~~~'! flY-i ' ~3:f~ ~~ •• ~ ••• ~~·~±~~M~3:f~~ ••mwlJ.~~ •• ~~~·~ 3:f 8L .. 3:f IL " 3:f £9 rfler~flfHHFJ~~~ ) LElJ~:l:~~wlJ.. ~!I±M. (. 98 ... ~~ • • ~rnJ~mf~Jt#:f.~~$. , i6iS. 0. iiI1W.~~ru~~flY-i:m.g:~WW.. ~.~~W~~~.~.~¥~'iiI1lJ.W~~±~~:m~OO~~,:m~OO~~. . :m= . :m2- . :m~-~.g::m.miil1w.~~rfl'W~.~¥IZ6~ ..¥f+1-lt lY?f /}IJ ':tJ-:if ~i!1t' ~ 'iff~Jj<! f# i!~:on( -=-). OZ).

(6) (22). ~~$~ • • ~3.ft.Mm ••3. ••• ~&.* •• ~~.'~~~N. B~~~~m••m,~~~~~mM~*~~~~.~~.~~o. (tm)~"#~~4h~~itr.Ji§ll~J.t*. ' ~xnt.At~4h~~itr.J1t~J$l!l. .~~~~~ ••• ~~.~m~.mfi•• I'~*~~~~ •• M~~ ~ffM~m~~~~~~g·m~~~~~ •• ti~~~M~~~~.~~ffi~' ~~~~~. .. ~5tt~f~%*~Elf!!!m~fj~ , JlU.~~fflH)}~A~il1ri~. 0. 1f£~~. ~5t~~~~~$'~~m~~~~.~~~.~'~1f£~~~~~~~~~~. ='. ~lli.W.I~£~'1f£~~m~~~m~ .. ~w-~'~~m~il1ri~.ffo. lt~~tfiitllz.~ ~.~~~~mz~~'M~~m~~~~~~m~~&~~~~*~~,~~. .~~~~.mw-~'~.~.T~~~: (A.=) ~~-:B~~~mz~.~.~~'1f£~~~m.~~~'~*.~~.~A •• ~-x~-m~ru5t~p~~'~~~7~~o m~. : ."~ •• ~~B~~~~~~~.Mz~.~. · _§J:t~~~g~t~z~~1JDJ;)' ~~'~~~.~A •• ~'~M~M~~~.~.ff.~.x~'~~~N~ M~m~. • :j:~ru~NEHT~tt'. ~~JlIj~7~~. 0. ~~-:B~~~mz~.~.~~,m1f£~~~m.~~.~~.~A.il1ri~-~. : ••. ~+A.-.ff~ ••M•• ~.~~.m~-m~ru.ffA~tt'~~.ffi ru~P~tt'~~~7~~o. ~~. H~.~. ~~B~~~~~~~.Mz~.~.. · ml:t~~~.t~z~~1JD. ~~~'~.~~.~A.il1ri~'~A~x~~'~~A.~~~~~~~m~. 1JDm'~M~~~~~m~,:j:~ru.ffA~tt'~~.ffiru~N~tt·~~~ 7~~o. ~~~:B~~~mz~.~.~~,m1f£~~~m.~~.~~.~A~il1ri~-~. ~+A.-.ff~~ ••".~~~~.m~-.~~.§-m~ru~~~~ ~.ffli~tt. ' ~~.f)}JlUru5t~Pittt ' ~~~7~~. 0. ~~: Hf&"~. •• 5ti13tB~~~~~~~.Mz~.~.' flH:t~~~~t~z~~1JD ~~~'~.~~.~A.il1ri~'~A.x~~'~~A.~~~~~~~m~ 1JD~,~~ru~.ff~$•• M.~~~~.m~'~M~.~~.§*•• ~~.~~ru~~lIJ~~.ffli~tt.ffi~. '. , ~~.ffiJlrjru5t~p~ffi ' ~~~. 7~~o. ~~~:*~~~mz~.~.~~~-Am-.ff~ ••M•• ~.~~.m~-ffl ~ru~. m~:.~. •• ffA~tto. •• ~~*~~~~~~~.Mz~.~.·m~~~w.~•• ~~~m. ~'~~~.~A •• ~'~M~~~~~.~,~ru.~li*~tt,¥~~. 15~.~13tJlU.~~.15~m~. 0. ~~E:*~~$mz~.~.~~~-Am-.ff~$ ••M.~~~~.m~-~ 6.

(7) .... I. Ii. i i. -- L . °Y~~MI~~~~~~~~,~mm~~~.~~B~~#'~.~ .~~~~~~~'Mm~~m~Hm~~W,~~Y~&.~~.m~~~q~0~. V~.W~.~'~~~Wm~~.'8.¥~.W~~~ti~~~&·~WBW~~ .~¥m~~~~~ID,~~~~~~.~~~~~~m~~~&~~~~~~§o~ ~Yg'~~f~1$ r .~n~~. J. ' ~~'trDqnM1&~ ' nM1&*~~W.EE}¥#}m~j} , ~~W-0~wFr. ~tt~E1JY*}H~$~fbfb.Wti~l!~ID. &,H~:slz0~.~ij.WfE}¥~*. o. &'nnl~ Jif;:E}. ¥~~$nM¥~4=~-}qIllID!~~~~ID 'lW~Yij;g~$~Jilm~~~, ¥m~;g. ~~~_~'¥.~.Y~~¥'_Jilm.m~~~~B~.m~~.~.~.:~. o.~Jif;~¥~~~~~$¥m-~.$~~-~~~m$.#. .~.W~.B¥-WY-Jilm.m~~~~-m~M.~.~~.~~~*:V~~. °lW~ *Y¥~$,~~~m~.~,¥m~;g~H~_~'¥.~.Y~~¥'_JiI. m.m~~~~B~.m~~.~.~~ID·~U~~.m~.~·.M*.~:~. °lW~YB¥~m$¥m-~~~m~.fu ~.~.WfuB¥-WY-Jilm.m~~~~-m~M.~.~~.~~~*:~~~ o¥~~~~~~,~~~~~"~~~,~~. ~~¥~M~.m~W'¥.~.Y~~~*'~E~.m~~~~.m~~.. ~.~~~'Ufu~~ •• m~WB.~~~.~*~'.M*.~'~~~~:~N lW~~~~$¥m-~¥-~Jilm.m~~~-m~M.~.~~.~~~*:~~~. olU~*Jif;~.~~nt~~$nM¥mWti §*,~~~~~m~.~.~,¥m~;g~H~.~'¥. •• Y~B~~~'~. ~.WMm~~.~~.~ID'.~.~~_.~~~.~~~*JiI. •• ~~.:~N. o¥~Jif;B¥~~~~$$¥m-~.~~ (£Z).

(8) (24). f---+----.--+----j-----t---j----+------r--\----I. x. o. o. o. o 111. t:l5. ~. 8. o. x. (. o. o. x. x. x.

(9) n=-.~~~~~m.ff.~~~~.~~~. (. (25 ). ~'~~!i~~1m~~ J. a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,. ffi.~I~Wm*~~~~m~,.~.~mAm. •• 'Dffimff.~~~m~*~~. ~'H~ • • $~.wnm.~W.'~~~Nmm~.fi~~.~~RMft~,m~. ~~~m.m~m~*.'0~~Hm~,~~.~tt~m~M~MM.W~5li~I. fF. 0. n~JJHT~. •• ~f§;;$fJ~M~~-=. *-=JJl.1=r$~. 921 ~J. ±:. Jl!. 0. JJlAt!J( 1& -£ ~~EIlbj ,:i;-4--#k-tt ~. J7'3. ~. *. Z. ~. 1.~l'!:tt!!*l:tt!!tI I. ~5IUUdl.~ g~HI~UIH.1mH fi!J ~ Ptbm 5E 2.1iUnllrfjJ!fTm5E!Ii!mt~ 2.$mf~Ff:~~ , ~A!:E-N 3.~111fl'!U\t.Mz=1'-5E~~ Iffi H: .tf(lU£fj1=r~ 3.llX t!HI~Jl m:tt!! 4.=1' 1IJ ~ ~.Jlt~HJII JJrt ~ ~ • ~ ij~ 1f IlN ( f.I JJrt l'! :tt!! fl !Ii! .1Bl$mf!f!~ ) H~Ptb.§:\ra'~!Ii!03:l<~J1i 5.tt~tf(.§:\~m.m~~ , I'!!!t 5.f.ljiJEJ0;1tI~5Inf~tf('§:\~B9l'!!!tjp!li!~li ' Mz1m jJjJf)Ut*~li $1f~mJllJ.1[iIl*~. 1..1[ fT m B}HIl1=r !1t JlIJ m5E!Ii! 921 tf( ~ft~.1[iIl~. .1[iIlmt~. 2. ill :l'zJili ~ t;!ItiHft! ~ ~ 3.m fill JlIJ ii. "J. 1J1J~. 4.mID!l.1[iIl~ft. tf( f3t~ 1I.1[iIlllt i&ii Iitt!llUlmllffi. l.mJllJ~tf(~jiii~mi 2.~tf(~lIitm~~ 3.m JlIJ t*;\~~J.!Il.1!li 4.~~~tf(~jilUlm 5.~~fiM~tf(~.. 1.f.l9J~*&~'$.IIl~ ,.~fiti~1m~ij~{ij!~, ~ 0ffi1JlIl~ 2.fBtllJrn5E1W~ , 1m±:Ii:J:$fEl 3.f.l1J; rllJ~J 1m$1!&51.§:\ra'iIltm~OO~!Ii! 4.1m$1f~~5Itt r~fiJ ,j1~t±./lt* 5.fj~ff1J.~m~=1'JE 6.fj~ 13 iW !JilE.1[iIl~ftB9.1["Ji-- r 3:l<~llUr~1llG J fJEj! ~ij~i~. I. f.Iji.1[~ tf( 2.f.Iji.1[~tf(~. ,. 3.D~ 1:Jj~'$~. 6.!ilHf;j~i;;$: rfjiJi 3( ~. ffij~~~OOmifi~:fI. EI ~J.!Il.t!lIUl~~ ,. ffij~~~~mIDII. 7.[5fRl.tf( ~1f ±:tt!!~~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _ .. -. i!i*4*~:*liff~~J!I!. R~~a~.~ffig$fJ~~M.~fi,*m~~mff~ ~m~~~.m~,~m~~&$~~.~~~ lIt~*~~~,grr:tJ(;I±\~j7g$m~. ~~b'/! -. •• ~I~~~.$.. •• ~,M~a~~~*~~,~m.. 0. Jlt t\.f!R-*,~ : B,@ N.$~:lL~~~~J.H~ ,. ~l\'5lf~~~. , Jm.~ifBaJfJ '. ~i'mW. .$.~m~,~~~~.~,.$l\'5lm~~~~o. l.'@N.*J.H~: $f7J.~Af1~~~' '@N~'@it~:*$~a~~~ftpfT~~' ~1JDj;J.~. ,. Jt;~~J.H~*~. 0. -9. /f.

(10) (26 ). 2.'@~*Jl.~Qt~. : :J:tg.1J.f~WJ '. f±liiUJl.bi{*~slH~-. , ft~f±liiUI:l.ftfi${ ,. 1!W~lE~5If'F. ; ~~fiEl3prz~H'-,,~1KtEM£1lf ' 1!W~ft~*~rzf±Wl~~~;j 3. ~ :lUJl... ;j~Jf:lz: : -il*± Wl tpOJfj~~ fl ~1} ~ *1I1f:f!l!fl¥19l1 Pfi~:lz: 2. r *±Ii 1f:f!l!~~~J "~1J.f~m~~fifl¥~Pfi~:lz:2.rf±Wl1J.f~m~m~~~*J .. ~ 0. f±Wlmrn~~fl¥~Pfi~:lz:2.rf±Wlmrn~~*J~&~~§fi~.2.§~.W~ m~a'~&~ • • ~A;j~~-. ...m~.fl~~~'M~ • •f±Wlm~~m. ~.2.~o. 4JJl.1!Wft~;g:. : f±liI~.OJfj~EI3przAre1lf ' Wi&Jfif .. ilrm ... ~lIIa~tlJ~~ 5[~~§afl;fU1Jrtu ' iITi*~rz'@~~OJfj~~ielRJ ' !i¥:JJJ.~~mruU1i:~ @ s.~m.~~~2.&mfi~'~~.@~.~~~~• • • ~.~rm~n.'~ .i&Jfif1Ti&• • PfifjM~_~ A ' mruU1i:~~mOJfj~Jfmililfi1!W"W1 ' OJfj~il 0. M1~ft~tljml5t. 0. 5.jty\~~f¥j : *Jl.tpPm:A±~.~rm~tU 6.pm:.@~mm. '. *~rz'@~.ME~7m~fj. 0. : -f±Wltp.@~~mml5t&~;ffi1RJ ' Prz'@~OJfj~1Z91i1A~~miSl. ~~bi{*~.~w~ ... bi{'@~B.~.A.~m~ • • ~~iITimmf±Wlm.. milo ~~~. ~~~~~~:Jf~$~wm~~~~z~~,~~mil®m-M1m.~M ~o. l.~zJfDl¥l{ji:il1Tm~~fjtp¥:1"~&:J:tg1Ji&Jfif(1}Pfi). ... tp~.:J:tg1Ji&:J:tgi&. .~Pfi. .. mrn~~~Il~~~ .. mm~ • • U.l¥l{ji'tE.m1!W~~-ml5tr' ~i&Jfif~fj~~:lz: r l¥l-li1D J ''@~M~~Ajl~~$ 2.;ffi;Il¥l{jiJf~~1!W~~ : mrn~ffibi{*~~&il1T ' M1J11J::J:tg.~ilf1lift~~f1 m'1it!! ' t§n1}~A~Jfllt1Ti&~~I)j3~ , §j}~.HBm~~llw:milIf'F 3.:mil~~~~fl. : j;).mrn~~.mf9lJ ' ~fr.iJ.m1}lt!fI .. m-•• jU·~ .. m-•• ~ Em~~.' • • • A~m.~h'fr.iJl5t~f±liIWl~oa*m~~~~*bi{:J:tg. ~ .. bi{:J:tg:m~ .. ~~ft~ .. ~~~w~ . ~.j} ... j}:J:tg~~.&m~~'.@~ ~j}~mbltlD{aJjH~Jf § $tm:fl;fU1J~ 0. 0. 0. ~~~. ~~~.~.*M~:.bi{~rm2.~~~.~.f±Wl.@~.tp~h.bi{~rm. ~~,m-1!WPfi.o. l.bi{~rmB:itt~. : bi{~rm~ JB~-~1} a]. , ~fj~-1! BmmciITi fUll A B~:itt~. .. Ami. m~~Jj}U'i. ' !!P~~~tlJl*~1J.f'@~H~;IJlgfl ' &JlrmB1!Wltt~~mf#~~ 2.bi{ilrm1!Whjtit : nl~51mi~~JI • • ~:JfJ.I~.$t 'M1JD.J:m~~~rfl~~1m 0. bi{*~~~~.~M~MW.f'Fil1T~.'~~~rmB1!W.hf'Fft{aJ.flo 3.bi{~rm1!W~.~.Il:±.2.~Il~mtEr~1J.fJ.rA.J2.~Il',@~~. ~• • 2..~~~~~~rA.Jie~Pfi~m~'.~~rm~rz.m'm~.~. • •~ilrm2.~~.§~Pfi~m~fl • • IZ9.U.'~Ru.@~.~rm.mM.~ ~~~ftt(WlJ3.~1ijjtit~$Wlm.ffl. 013. 10 .

(11) ...... n=-.~~m~~~.ff.~~.m.~~~. (27). ~"-lZ9 l.If~ij :::FjJU~A. : tzO*mt~fmB~~ .. ~1J~~iU:lt". ' ~Um~;l:tftB~fmt~tA , m§iW;l:tftB~fm~AZ~.f}!di!:t§'I'f,g;~ l.~fmli : tt!!.~~f& ' ~Wlmtt!!~1JmB~*J\rim~ , ~~J:mtl0m 1999 .~~• •~.'W~~~.~.~n~,m~fi~.mm~• • ~'~8~& tbhijM~~f±~It~. ~aitlrf. 0. ' ~.1f&.91~~:ilA. 2.~~A ~~. :. 0. ~~:tH±liI#*i5t~1RJ. '. ~~tbhWJZ~fm~~Qj;)fnJftm):\w~~~B:. {gZ~~WJi5*~.B:.o 3.J~~1m.B$¥:fI~. : ~~cp$~fm~Jlt~tt!!.~~cp$¥:m '. &,~tt~tf;l:t~:t7.. W1m.:ilfiftf&m.I~'~*;I:t~~~ffin~.'~~~.~J:W~ • • •J: .~$jt~o. 4.jIlj fS~~QtzOfnJf)t~. :. ~ /Jtf~~~fmlY-JjIlj fSf)t~f6~O~-. t±flm.~~~Ij~fU~? fi~~Ul~t±flm. ~R. '. ,. ~Jl~~fmlY-JjIljfS~. ~U~~fm~fl.1JW~~U6bfj~~. : fi5EUl~fu~~rJ~ , ~U~~~RXtf5'l:~*~~:k:J1MZtf.lrEfJ~. 0. ~"-K ~~~~M~~m~:~mlimm.~mm~&~~~mA~It~IY-J~~CP. ~1t~lY-JtbhWJ~m'W~Mlimtbh~~.~M~~RXIt~m1Jo l.iNfirdl.~/J):\~-3&. : ;t.ttfJj1L=-.~It~f1fi~WIJ~1i+-=1~m~:. r ~1iI. Ji5*~~~~~~mlimZIRJ~'~;I:t.~~mW~~mW65EZm~&;I:t±tt!!' mm~1t~fI.. '. ~M~m~5'l:~m~w±tt!!···. ... J. ;l:tCPfiti~tl~li9~'Ji~~~. ~m~m.~/J):\~-'~~~~1m.~-.'~~~~~M~~o 2.7!P&~m~m~~. : ~-1m~~t±WlCP , 7!P&~~ZiNfi.f1Ujl$U+.*j;)J: '. ~~*W~*~m~m~8tbh~'~M~~~~o : Ji5*j;X1'.~:ilfi~~ , ~~~~-ItUl. 3.WiNfira'~flfift. ... t!?Q]'fj~~~=1t. Ul~~~=EUl'mm~~IY-J#*i5t~-'~fi~m~~~fI.~.t!?~~.o ~"-;\. ~~ jf~*iJ.f, : ~~fiH£fnJ/J.lY-Jmw. ... tbh~~.jJF~. , ~1t~.f&~~fJj~m. ~~~.~IY-J~tl·m.~~ww*?~fnJ~/J~W~.?~.~.R.It~. IY-Jn.. o. l.Ji5*~1Jw.: It~W~*1~~J:~Rm-=B1i+.' -=B1i+.~~~~? .ERiB~~If'Ffj~1JJjl(;I~fj~1J~1J\l. ' ~~~fj~1Jjtjj~rj~~fU,~, .. *~WlI~ , 1iti14#~ ? 2.Ji5*~IiW. : Ji5*~.~CPB;iiE*1J\l~ , Jlt$f711J\l~~fit~:WJfJ: ' 1F1:Q~ ~$f7}. iL'~JlOO' B~m~~~w.' ~RX~~Ji5*~JiOOf;j 3.~II}i{M.,.1t~f~pt; Ji5*.Sf\~~. ,. :. 0. ~m5ElI~~Q]'Iil]mt~h5I:~m~~:!k:fi".fli!~~. fIlJ~~QtzDfnJfljffl. ,. 0. 4.fi~Jih51:~:Xf&Ji5*Q]'~~~.,.m.,m~~OO~~iNfi~tt!! • • h5I:~. ~IY-J~j;l. , tzD*~fm~$n14~~R1,g;fUIY-J.~m~ , ~1J~.~RX*~~ltiUr~~. 1J~~If~. 0. -. 11.

(12) (28). tE~}f,J1JHj IUIHI iJiIJ B9 ~lit. r ' *liff~f6m § ftI~ ~z B9~iJiIJ -§m~llfiiJ IJ& 5I?!lim. • • ~~.ft~~m?!l~'~fiiJ.fi.~*Z~m~.,tE~.~.OO~fiiJ~~.~. ili ' i'*~~OfiiJ.Mtt\fJ ' J;).&~llfiiJs f.~ra'W.A±~1i:rJi *liff~f6mm?!l~iJiIJZ~ itJJ!J;)mJ!UIl.• • •m~lY3ftml:H»1i • .§.tEmMH~fitpJJ!ltlts fAW• • ~mtp. ' ~lft:fJ!~~~J;)sl.~rdj • • • ft~~m?!l ~!lt • *liff~Htl:Hmft ~~J;)~1~~ • • * ' m?!lIfF.JfffM"JJ!jqI~.fJ ( J!/Il=) '?!l:lz:.~.m1lJ}lJ;)~f~.m'?!lll: ~:;UfIg• • IIJ~J;)~:PirD ,Ht#t.~*,jJ!f~fZ:;IJ;)lJ&sf~rdj • •m?!l '?!l~~fjJ!lfjtlt f~l!Um~Fffi~' ~:ttBm?!l~1i:.me~:It, Ht~~~~mB9m.mtfi~~~1j , MlHtI:HJj J!lZm.f~lIm~iJiIJ ' ~1jHlm.If'FfIga~IJ:flJh • ~~*liff~m.~itiU~:lz:Z~~1j , m .~itiUm~~~[9 : 0. 0. m{. ~iJ. f;f. Ifj. fI. fI. i/llJ. i/llJ. Ii. lI!6. h!~m.~€ifli/llJ. h!~m•• ~~'~n~~tbb~~R. _m{i!l1'JitbbWlffli/llJ. .~~1i!G~.'~.~~ • • ~W~Ii~. 3.1l*1~~I1\.ir. Ii! ~ tbbil1}.fffflifli/llJ. ~~~~fffflih!~tbb~~~1}.,~tbb. ~~~IR~f!Jj. 4.~~#J~fiD~III~~R. fiD~m.i!lRfli/llJ. 5.~IUJi~1'Ji~A. ~i!lim~Afli/llJ. 6.~7~im1lm. lImmf;!tfli/llJ. ~7 • • ~~'lIm~.'m.~~. ~11f1i/llJ. ~7.rtMPo. 1.1l*1~ tbb WIf 1i!G *. 2. :JHENJ.~Ii~I 1'1' slflll(}!. 11=). 7.#J~~11~JHJfjij;. , ~jij;E*tt. fl1i!G*. ~€ii!l.~~, ~~~m, ~~, ~m.. €iw.1i!G"~/J\m~AfiD~ iI~fl • • i!l1'Ji'slfl~Rm.~~'~7. 11m:. '. 1JD*1IJ&\M~. ffi~~~~~~~-~Ii!~~~,m~w. 8.a~Ii~~-BiJ.!l!. a~lii!lfllliU. 9.m~;ffi~i)Ulii. ffU.. fI i/llJ Bi J.!I! Vit~. i'IHil(l1l. - 12 . i!lRBiJ.!l!$t.lI~~Ff:.

(13) B. £1. o. / itfi. \/ 1. it mJl?!r. I....·------'. I. 1 (6Z).

(14) J3ilJt 1iIJEii. iJIhi:.. (30) . fjFfI. 8. ·1. J&~MU~fjFf. +. fjFf 2 1t~~ff~UmZ¥. MI. t. ~. ~:ru. !. fgFf3. ~ l¥Ff4. J~]l1mMblt/lj. ffil!1mZ¥A. fjFf. fjFf. I. t. I. 1I1f- 1 : It; !Ull.-.lIlf-iiLll. fjpf;. 1-1 . ilMMHcfjpf;:. ~~~eiH5-. '. 3i~D~ 921 S'l:~.15"{1~:IHcS'l:~1t751~m. .~751'~~~~15"{1~zil.~~'~OO~rr~~o~~ft.15"{1~~~ ~il.1J;f. • ~U~fjpf;. 1-2 Ll3!J!. 0. - 14.

(15) - SI . LSE: ---<. ojft. .H~g.'~ ••••••• '~.~L~WH •• ~~~-.' •• E1 ~fi*$fq: i.f~Y4l<r7~. ' :;Uf{ein!U1~~ , !lJtlii~0if~~~MiS:tljHlmm '~ ••• ~'~0!1Jtlii~~~•• ~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R ••• ~~' ••••••• ~~~'~ ••~~~~E~:~iS:t!lJtlii~0. ~I~M. o.mM~~~~~~m~MW±~W.U~.~'~. W~.~~. ••@m~0.' •• ~*.5~••~~.~~~~E~~.. ~~~~~~*~.~~~~o$~. ••. ~~~~'.~~~. ••. ~.~.. ~ y~~-•• ~~~mfitf ' -±Yjft~ r 4\~!lft!liE=t!J ~ r 4\V~ fP,Iif• •~ntrE~J ~ r 4\V~if.E~J *~~;f}~.-: ~iS:t ••~~ ifiiff £-1 ~i§'!tUfitf ' 11~~.1inm~~~ij fu~~~ • • ~.'~ • • • W~~E~-~.lii~.~.~o~~W~ • •• ~ •• '.~~~mm~m'4\¥~~~a~m,w 0. •. £-1 ~M. ~;f}~.~~*. 0~.U~~W~.~~,~;f}~.M~~. •• ~~~.~:~iS:t•• ~m. ~1~M. (If:).

(16) (32). ~Vf 2 : ~4'-tt 11 ~.filj.if.~.Jt.ft.. 2-3 ij!:lz:?tJl.~Wmfi.f:ii '. mft; 2-1. 1..-tp9i!:.f:iifjiij~~fi*~JlUB9*,JJE. '. .lSfl~ij!:lz:.~~*ij. *~.". , ""~~?tJl~*,J. 2.EB tE~mij!ffib~m;jJ!J\~~fi3tN:U*~ • !iIIHl.~A ±~RlZij!~fiV!ij,. f~flWm. ij!lS~" lS~~A~ffibilW~iI!~f1j~~ij~gij.~1t, ~lTt§glS~fff~m1&. tB.~A~. • ilRlZ.~/J\~. 'tie. 0. 3.~.~RlZ~""iI!~~, ~zjJ:.I:3tlaj~RlZ" fJJ~ij!m~.~1tz:f$WA~~O~. li'ooan.*~wz:f$w'mti • • ~am~.~:f$~'M@ • • a~.·~ ~~~~.~~ij!ti~~~~~""~M~~RlZ~o. ~fJ~}JU.~* @.vt~. ~~I~!t@i$m. ~. ~. &*w~~±*.. @••. *~*mg. f4* &*w~~~~*,~~m.. ., l' lIJ IK 'lfJ!Uf! fi tEl 11M f4 *. ~. IK. W.. mm*. ±*vtflifiiHf.. ~mvtflifi1}*.. fi. ~1iiJ~1}*. @.ilt~~IiiJ~1}*. l'JJJIK{tflir 1iiJ~1}*, l'JJJIKEfJlliiJ~1}*. i$f$i\I!lmm~. &*W~~i$f$tElIIMf4*. WHfi*, t!flifi1}t'. 16;IilFr:IlO. &*W~~16;.,M'lfmllMf4*. IHjliiJ~:at'. fjft; 2-4 . W.. mij!t§r;UIll~: m~JH~~tE~mij!t§glS~mft;. ,. :Ii.m:~B9:1i!:a:f$trIlA~M. m_R.'~M~.f:ii~lS~tpm.,.~.m:ij!:Ii.~~"mij!$~fff~.. ""1:gtlff1JJ~RlZ. :. U~!r15W~t§ ruJ~ruJ. 2.•~A~. 0. 0. 3.t±WifJl.H\,;~. 0. 4.*mtElr;m~$3~iI!A~. 0. 5.~W~"'mij!zij!~~~~*W~~.im 0. mft; 2-5 . .~/J\ilj:l1JtJR3IEj,l(;ii~~~: EB~.ffit±"'B~lmtlilt§R.m:ij!3JfF. ~~iJjWRlZ~. • .~!j\~""~,l:) rB9~JlUrtJRjI : 1..m:ij!ff-$9il~ ". 2.*.~txj:I1J~.~~ (ffib~ti • • • >::). 0. 3.t±"'*1l~~~~~. 0. 0. 4.mij!~IJUlm131&~~. 0. - 16. ' aiO.

(17) n=-.~~~~~m.ff. ••~.~M~~~. (33). ~Jt;-:~t.if)cWWfii~m.Vff~. fjFf= 2-1. ,i. {t~m:~tbb. i/lf'fUlb'J\i!. t. fjFf= 2-2 :f;1J ttg ]JUiu ~ '@'. t. fjFf= 2-3 i!R1Gfifi~'J\i!. t. f.!j!Ff= 2-4 m:~~1i: IDI[~. t. fjFf= 2-5 ~~~~~::t11J. w:H!. ~iJf. 3 : ~~~i!fjt':;iJil~iJf. fjFf 3-1. • .m~7tWJJ.it9tJHHtHjmi! • fifiD ~'J\il:t£?iRlJ;jrdl1m$OO9t1mWm ~jj$;:1t1i • JllJfiD.'J'ilJifllI!Ps[ fflfjFf flfftmi!9ti!:. 3-2. fjFf 3-2. ~rr. flfftm~f§lU1m.9t.. 0. tftii .ttWlJ 19c JE:. ~m-:§ • • 9t.$E~~rr'~ • • • e~~.$E~m~~$;,a~m:t£. $~.ill~offi~7t~JE:ili~~~'OO.9tE~~$;o~~.e~~~ .$.fjFf~$;.~rr~m~Mo.~-.ffl~ • • JJ.it9t.,.~-,. _ '. [l3J1IJ.ffl~tfi~.9t!JlG~~.9t. - 17 . a. ~f§;;.~m~~~A. 0.

(18) (34). m. ~. ~,EIH.m.. ilJfj~"'WI±l.~. ~~-. 8flil1o/J }.g'!£;'illm. m~=. jfiM<ltil. }.g,!£;'illm'*~. ••. ~. iii. 8fl.il1o/J'il1o/J~M~~~_ ••• M'~~ :(fil1o/Jtg¥l'£ftffia1'JE *~ •• M~_ •• ~'.~~I±l~'* ••• mEil1o/J~~~¥I'.~ •• ~'ili.~Amillm W}.g~~~~.~A'~illm~}.g'!£;~.ff~~ lil~~':j1IJAJI!J!.~Ao. * ••• ~Im • • • ~~-=. jfiM<IUl }.g'!£;'illm'i&}f,f. ,~.~~~:j1IJ~~I±l~' i&}f,f.~oili-.~Eil1o/J~~¥I'·.~Amil 1m~}.g'!£;~~~.~A'~illm~}.g'!£;~.ff~. ~lil~~'i&}f,f~lil~~.~A*mo. ~~gg. }.g,!£; , _ ' i&}f,f , jfiM<liil *~••. ~~~~~~~ ... ~'mEil1o/J~~¥I".~A ~illm~}.g'!£;~~~.~A'~ilImW}.g~~. ff~~~~~'i&}f,fW*~ •• ~~~~.~A. *ot o. ~~=:rumh~~~m~:~~~~~A'~W~~W~~~flM~A'~~ a~~,~~~.~oom~o~~~~~~~~~,~. ~UJJj~A;ttftB~~~WJ~WiJl:~. - 18 . 0. ~n~.,.

(19) 61. o ~~~i'fM~iif.EIWinlrm=tt~HWY;1 ' .Ef¥JlttMm! : 1lJ4:13*'rl1fi.@f~. ~~Ir:rY;1*=!fJ4:~Wm!~M~~rJ.2}~ff~m'rl1fi.$. ~-v if~!. o~. ~~iif<rl~Y;1. '. ~~-l=i!fi~ID~~W*HiW o. m!~~~~.~'. '. mJ~~~j.:z;I:ii. : mJtsJ;~:z;I:ii V-V if~. q~ijfJr~MjJ~!Y~ '.~Y~. • • Y~m!~~~~~~,~ • • • @f~:.~M.~~ o;r.*Wif§,f(e. ~if~. ~Y.ID.~~Mm~• • I.~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~'MI~. Gtfm:m~Y.m!~m~Y;1.m~i;!~~1P*Y;1. '. ;:lmm!n!~~. : 1fi~lil~~m. z-v if~. om!~IlJ4:.~m! ~M r m!~~~ J. '. r ~~~~~~~ J. i?2lJ18 ~ifm¥~ : m!~~~lifm. I -v if~. ~.Gtfmm!~~.~w'm!~~~~~~:m#Gtfm:~§. '(if !8!. ~-!tt : V -!In. )-------.. C~ r. ."'----8 ..

(20) (36). flIP:'J;i§ rm~li m~fJl m~fJl. $. ~m.lJ4§. iIE~Lm~ft*&_~. if it ~ ItO lEi t'j. ~:n._. ~~if. iIE~~~ft*&. _19IJ. ~t\_. 1Sl-.t. m~fJl m~fJl. 1m~1fiB. 1m. N:j(:jJU~. ~iI~4tIfj. N:j(:fg;~. ~iI~4tIfj. A::tif!1f1Jt m m:ji:fg;~. ~iI~3:l<Ifj. 1Sl-.t !I!J~~t;tj(m. !I.~~if. iIE~~~ft*&_19IJ t;tj(~g1i~ ~-t:;_. ilm:ji$1. ~!H.fJl~±~ ZP:~~lfUli19lJ~± ~ lJffJUf~ i1!lli$mrHI~JE. fJl. if~fJl j(iiJl)l~. II;f Lm. fJl. if~N$. 921 .~m:~!1rr fI*~. § rr.r ~ JU~ ~illUttell. )l!l:*. N:j{:fg;~. -iG:ttN:j( §rr.rfl~m~~. ~11. • *tI*3?J~t€t~lIll. ~~tmz~~m:j(~~. ~.lJ4NM~1I1f, ~~iltJlISl~ 1m(~~iI~~.j(*II;f~~·1m~. it( nlfilJ ~ LI ~ 11. ~~fJlM~M. fJl*. fm::rJJfJg ,. fllliUi:. flJ*flll. ~il18~o ~~?@JmJlllN:lIlo. mFf;4-1. •. jI~fI.m.ij!rm. •. mFf;4-2 m.mfl1M~UJ. •. mFf;4-3. iJM:m: ~ !JiU~Uili. •. mFf;4-4. ij!:ll 11U4,.. +. fjFf; 4-5 ~iUjft~/J\*,!:J>UI. - 20. ).

(21) .... n=-.~~.~~~.ff.~~. ~IIf. 5 : -v.H!~IIf. §~:.~a.w~. ~~~ . (37). •• ,~.m~~.~.~.mm~o. WMm~.~:~~~. §~5~. ~~~~ •• ~:.~.~M~~~fi~.,.~a.~~~~* ~Llr31Umflt§lf!!!fl~. 1..:fi.~. fJ~~,fE. ,~. , ~f~tlB~~~~~~ , ~U~7'C~LlJ]Ut!3~~ : El3i&:J&.:fiji\tlPfifl.m.m-~Jtf91J ' J1t1J~.:fifl~ , {§. ~fJ~51 !ttJf~~~~ 2.rdl:fi.~. ••. •• ~M~'~*~ •• ~0~ ••••~~. §~~1. :. .ttw.umf!!!. 0. 0. El3i&:J&ji\tI.~.m. '. .tJf~m~~~ft~*Jt!m. '. {§~(5f~. 0. ~f¥.li. : f~fii~f¥. f!". 5-]. Mi fti PJT l'IlH~iHi i. ~" 5-2. ~f\1 ~1'1~tiUb. i. 8. ~IIf. 6 : ~Jt-:EJt~IIf. §~ 6-1 . m~m~WM: EI3*D./J\il~'@Mm~~~1i)jtl~~. $~m~!JiHtHIWm. J!if~fU~ 0 tf'@M~~WmJ!if ' ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~: WmJ!if~~~~~[E!J , ~flJtfrj~ , JJj~'@Mm~ , ~ .~~~m~. , ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ , m:f!~1V\ - 21 . 0.

(22) (38). tl. ~. tl~-. VIt:N l.ilmJUfi* - i&1FJ. 2.ilmj!~*-.~1I11 3.ilmj!~*-if~. 4.ilmj!~*-;ttftllli!~. *J. ~. Ii! ~ tJ~ l{!( fit ~ il EI. ilmj!~*&Hft~ tJ~ ~ ~ J3.. ~ tJ~ lJ il ' ~JlU:r:~~fit. ~1iJ]. ri1ilmj!~*.~:§.. EI iIii Jii& 1FJ,. .:&if~.. *~ rAllI. 1:::1.. tl~=. l.ilmj!~*-i&1FJ 2.ilmj!~*-.~1I11 3.• ~III1-if~. 4.ilmj!~*-;ttftllli! ~. W~ ~ - :r: 1'0 lI!.s11i:(f .~IIIU~Wif~ ~if~.ri1.~11111 .l{!(m~~l'fG~ ~~. ~~=. l.ilmj!~*-i&1FJ 2.ilmj!~*-.~1I1t1 3.• ~III1-if~.. _tl~=:r:I'O:(fW;tt .~lIl1tJ~*.~. ftllli!~i1/J;ii;J\ri1.~. IIIUUf. 4.• ~II.-;ttftllm:~ ~~119. fi~~3. ;ii. ~ 1111 &:;, ~li tJ~ l{!(. •. ~~rr~~i1/J ~1i!~fEHf. I.ilmj!~*- .~1I1t1. ilmj!~*RlItl1;. .~~~jJRtfflj. 2.• ~1I.-i&1FJ 3.• ~III1-if~. 4.• ~III1-;ttftllm:~. ~lIa,;tt~. [~. lI!ai£.~.. .m~~fi~:~~I~.~~m.~. il m j!~ * ill JHli iIiiJiff.;Z:i1/J;iiVlt :N. .~II •. ilfit*W.~1I1t1. ••••@.go. f~~ 6-4 ~.m.·lig~.W$~l'l: ~ 921 ~.~~m.~ • • • •fjt1Jfg :ttBtf:fjrl:lljJf.!'i:iY(;1iU~:fj*.7E{jJtIj£\~Jiij [ffl ~:ttBm.1JAII!;g. Gp. fll'* 6-3. fJl,* 6-4. JJi ttll7.ltl1@ fJm@~Bf - 22. .mlJ*'. J3. Ii! ~ &:;, f.l( f:t IH ~. 0. ,. {B.~W-:ttB.

(23) t-L~m. £-L~m. ~-L ~~:J. Iii:r ~j1 ¥iLij: ~. ~$~{ilm. ii£~.yij~{iI. t. J$Ir~~:mii£mt. l-L ~~:J. t. ~. Sf:. t. fi~~gijE1~;$. 0. o if~g ij OM ' fill:ii fill:~fill:Y-1g~fill:-=F~~¥Ii.ij:lilifnt : fill:-=F~~¥U.ij:lifJ!2Qr tliSi?UfiM ' fill:ti~~;$ Iif~ o. if~ £-L. £-L tl~. 0. fill:~fill:~E1Nm'~~R~g~'fill:tim2Qr*~m~~~Mif~m~~.ii. 4!i! '. 1- L tl~. ' OM!f( ~.~flJ.lli.ij:!f(.lilbk: Y-1W. : fill: -=Fjgfif. 'l,-L tl~. ' fill:ii~ EI fill:iiHifill:ti$:E};$ : tliSi~~~M tlm?ufiM ' fill:ti~fill:-=F.ij:~;$. fPf~~-:&tfill:-=F~~~OM. o. l fill: -=F.ij: ~~ Sl1:: iIfi¥ ~:I:?i. if~ 'l,-L. Ifl1~~.f- 'ij}f ~ :. L iflf. (6£).

(24) (40). ••••• A.~~'~~~.~.~Bm ••R•• M~ .m~ •• ~•• ~,~ft.~~ •• ~ •• ~mB~'~D •••• ~ffi.*$ffi. ~l*~.ad~m~. ~~~mad,ftM~~.~~~~.ff#~*W~.~~ft~~o~W'~~~~~. •• ~W~m~.~~•••A.~~.S~'~M~.a~~. ~~~~~~B.' ••• ~~M~~'*~~~I~~I~~'~&~.~~~~m .~.o~ft' •• ~ •• ~~.~~'~~~.A.'~.m •• ~mad'~R. ffM.W~~~•• '~ •• ~0~,e~~S~*~~.M'W.~ ••••• ff~ .~~.~$ID~A. W5~ffUlJJruj{.0& 1:1 ~W~lIlm*W5~. 0. ~~'~.~m.~~~.~.ma.~.~~'tttt ~~~. •• ~~~~~ftm.,. ••~m~••~ ••mfi.,~@adn ••• ~~m~.'~~n.~0~. .lE.1m~~~{$~. , ~ • •~~~JL'*.~if~fI~.m;• •~~ifll;J:l~1::N<JL'.. ~ao*~~W5.'~.m.~S~~~~ffi.~~~•• ·~.~~~~~ ••M' ~WtmtJ~~m~. 0. §WJ~.m.31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~.~#~' ~m.w<t. .~W5~'.Jlt.m;~~*m,~.m;~~A,.~~~. ••m;~B,.~m •• ~*. • • t\~o §WJ~~1~fi.R.~m~m.~.,a*~~ft~.0#IS.fI~·@~M. •• m;~Am.I~~~~~~fi·@ru~~mm~~mw. ~~~'~.18~#~.~~.'x.~ •• ~~~~~~, ••• ~••m;~.~. m.~•• ~.o*~~ •• ~~n~~~~~fim.I~o '.ffM•• m.I~~~:Jlt*ru~n~A~fi~~m.·~.ffB~.Mfi .~tt~m.'~.~fI. ~jJ!:Plm.~fi~~~' @ru~.m;*~~IL'.~fI:At. ~~W.~. ••f:um., ox••ru. ••~filll~fiffi.m.·~~~.~~A'~.ffAB~.Mfi. fI~o. ='•••• •••••. tJ~11.fI~JltffU. ~. : Htft~11*~~~~~:fi~~Iib:~fflU ' ~.ij~18tt •••fi.wadM*n••• ~~.o. JltffU'~~~m. -'.~~~.M~m.~:~~18~m.'~.M.~~~~~,~:p.m;d. * ' tJ~um.If'P~~fi. 0. 1m ':fi~~~~~~~1J&51~r~'m. : tJmmfll! '~.fll\.~~1J&5[~ra'~. ~.m.'M~mmm~~,.~m.m$'~&.~.~.~~.~~~. f~.m;~.~Wim.~d*. 0. n,~~m.~~m~.:~.~.~~:fi~~~m.ffl~'~~18~.£~~ffl itE,adll;J:l~-~~.o. - 24.

(25) .... n=-.~mm~~~.ff.~~.m.~~~. (41). ~~3t1lX J. (. l.pqi&l'!Ii( 1999) • :ft= -1lJJ<.JU@!lBlI*01J 2.pqi&l'!Ii(1999) • ;It=-JJ<.~{Zl{5Ii:M!.!J1:i* 3.pqi&$(1999) • ;It=-MU~*ifullJJ<.~Ii:M!jf.(itM!*"JD 4.pqi&l'!Ii(I999) • JJ.f~tl:illi:M!jf.pqi~r&fF*mfB 5.pqi&l'!Ii(I999) • ;It=-IlJJ.fJJ.filM!~1f$.fF*mJE 6. pq i&l'!Ii( 1999) , ;It -*ifull.ZtlM!~f!JJIi:M!~I'J~!II.5 7.pqi&l'!Ii(1999)' JJ.f~UOt.i).(.rtJ)&tl:illi:M!mlJJ~A*~II'~1!i 8.Bi&~(1999) , M!:ttf*jmftUf:1M!~f!JJz.i1llmJEr.\l~'¥oom-. ' Bi&~JJ.f~Ii:M!mlJJ~A.itM!m • 9.pqi&l'!Ii(l999) , ~IU~:IlJJ.f ilIrtJl\1jJJ.fltl1fiJf~~i!i- ' pqi&l'!IiM!~iJf~Pfi • lO.pqi&$(t999),921 ~~*ifullM!~f!JJIl§ItI1f ' pqi&l'!IiM!~iJf~Pfi • 11.~3ii:W( 1997), (miful1H!tll~~~7}tfi--3':!!!~~.~) • m=1'iIii ' .~.r.ullil'ilii · pp651-6 12.iftRJIt(2000) • ~ra'~~ilIrtJJ!~JJ.filli:M!-.~:3fJ~I'Jz.~!M.• i&*ifui&l¥Tlii±~Jt • 0. 0. 0. 0. =. 0. 0. 0. (it. 'l. J. I*Jt• • ~pqi&l'!IiitM!W~RiJf~r~IJJ.f~M!~mW~z.~"~~*Jz.$re~. 2 ·i&ra*¥ifui&~~f5f "l1B#jImpflJJi.lU!l!itfll.l!IJl'!I!~f5f·":a-Jt:tt1*i¥~Mm~MIli!i ' i&*ifui&l¥Tm±JHiJf~ .':t. 3~1tI1f~~ • •rtJ• • ~'~ItI1fil~~7}.18.7}iI'ItI~~§7}.~*w~,m§W~'&~~M~.m ~~-=$re ' Mi~~mM!~f!JJfl.'<w'(Bi&iI~Z~ , mMZU • fR~,8U • M!~fF.ft,8U ' FIHU~ • ZJiwHfJlI;I;:,8U ' :li:wHfj lI;I;:Zg~~§~B*Ut7}tfi· .~f!JJPJ. • • • ~' 3t-JlPjlW' i!I!.~.tS{Zl{5Z.iH~*lIW~91J.-*W~·" =5~Ik. 8773(.)* ' JltfllijfJJ1:i5t~P)"IUIM!~f!JJ1Iit.HJJz.:fJ~ , W-f!t.61;~rg~tt:l r {Zl{5.~J :;r-1a.J • 4 ;lpqM!~i1Il~jfz.mJE~.61;;I 63 fF.pJ.ft::tlE5tmJE1&M!~:ttfimllIJrp , Z.ft:(£.61;;1 71 fF.1t1lit~*tMtt:l~ ~ , :(£.61;;1 78 fF.3t-1t1lit~!j\tM~~ , iilrJU~;I 86 fF.::t:£:fj*tMtt:l!l1lJ ' McM!~iJf~Pfitt:lItl1f~M!~f!JJm.z. mIDPJ.~~ • .m:~tt:lif:ft~UIJ7} 0. 5-~oo~'M!~f!JJ:(£~fi~.Im~JlP~~f:1M!~f!JJI¥T~~z.~ifu~tt~filtl1f·@;lpq-~~~M!~f!JJM!~. W*~*~Bifu • •~'Mc.~~~~ifu~.tt:l~tt·oo~MM!~:(£m.~jf~~.fl.'<mJE~~m~ifu • •~ ~i!i-'@W~:fj:;r-~~.W:;r-~~~Z..,Jlt:(£~fR~1f~~rp:;r-~~~R~'~W~.~fR~jfZ.*~tto. 6 :(£*ifullrpIlJjMWi61U'!it*iI.':t.*tMtt:l~~f:171'tJ:lJ ' ~~~~M!f!JJtt:l~. ' 0lJt!D***~.tj:I:£.m:*JJ.fmtt:litimU ~~·~M,itimrtJ,.~,~rpUtt:l • • '*ZJi,~~,~.&~tj:lrtJtt:l*~~~~.R~IIJjM~~~'oo itimUtt:l.~'~5,rp.,~&~rp~tt:l.~'~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~· • • M!~Pfitt:l~~M.D )F , :(£.R~IIJjMWifll~1\i}1!ifuiltt:lM!~f!JJ~.lU.lll.jlJ~~1ft!.tt:l1\~ , D)f,IIJjM~~~M!~f!JJ1.!)JlIItt:lIi:~. ~o. 7 • •M!~Pfitt:lItl~M.D)F'~m.~f!JJrp.61;~~.~~M!~.~~~'~~MfF..71if:.~.~=~,Jlt ~.~~~.mM!~tt:lmll.*~ • • ~1*i:;r-~«ffig~jf~I~m~*:;r-&§.tt:lm.*~·~~mll.ti :fjrm· 8 l3'M!~~z.~M.iim~it~~jf , :jt.m.~:jtL$mM.~ , !Jf{!IJ~~%i~~~f:1:jtfl!!mJiJ.!j\ , %i?'!~ifu .~~M~.':t.*!lIDW~.·~~'-m~~.~~~OO~~~~.~~m-JiJ~mtt~#'~~.$M~m $ra'mllllmtt~B~~f!J~ • 9~.~T.OO~m~tt:l~.~.,~~ttz'.:fjm~mtt:l:fj~~~~m'.~Il*g~,tt~~~~*.~ti oo~Jg~•• 10 EB~-~:(£1iQ.~M~'. Mi*:.ij.~F~fR.l¥TiI.':t.tt:l~., ~mM!~~§1ffl.IJJZ.:i!lm, ~.Bt.~~VJ~jf. - 25 .

(26) (42). ~.~¥*~~'M~~~.m~~.~fi~~fim~~.~o l1~m.~m~n~~~.,.~~~.±~ ~~~~~~~,~.±~.oo*m~m~~.~'~.±B f!:fJJ.{l3?f.H~m fI~~fl PA.~~/J\tI mit~ ta±.~*1f.::t:ki6.II*~~ie.U'¥lc.~··· ~lf*. '. l5il. •• ••. ,. .... o. 12~mmI.~~.~~'@.~~'.~~~mI~~.~~**.~~. ••I~~m~o. 13 1E.1Et:jJ1t!ln~~~$tlJ~1\+1\~~m*m='Il!E::: 1::;lt.~~$tlJ~1\+1\~~m*m='1\oJ\lt ' ~i'tl~ n=-*1t!l.~~1t!l~~.mE*~.'w~~~~~mo 14W~~~m1t!l~ft.~~'~~~$~~.~T.~~.$~.·m~~~.~~~fl~@~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI!~~sm:.-.S~.~.~~,IM,. - 26. 0.

(27) n=-.~~~~~~.tt.~~.~.~~~. (43). A Discussion on Building Damage Re sponsibility and Reconstruction Mechan ism of the 921 Earthquake Chin-Oh Chang. Chien-Wen Peng. Ding-Shuan Chang'. Keyword : 921 Earthquake, Building Damage Responsibility, Recon struction Mechanism. Abstract. This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of building damage in the 921 earthquake. We found that most buildings' damages were cause by natural disaster, but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design, construction, or usage. Besides, since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encour age the speed of reconstruction, we also establish some principles and in accordance mech anisms of reconstruction.. *The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University; Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce; Department of Public Finance, Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy. - 27.

(28)