俄羅斯與美國在喬治亞的戰略競逐 - 政大學術集成
151
0
0
全文
(2) ᓵ֮ټጠΚᢅཎፖભഏڇएࠅऱᖏฃᤁດʳ ீߓΰࢬαิܑΚഏمਙएՕᖂᢅཎઔߒࢬጚՓఄʳ ฅᄐழၴ֗༼ܑΚԼԶᖂڣ৫รԲᖂཚጚՓᖂۯᓵ֮༼ʳ ઔߒسΚ׆ቯᅜʳ ᓵ֮༼փ୲Κʳ ՂધأᤕᜤऱഽᑭᨃएࠅऱچᒴਙएขسԱࢤءऱᔆ᧢ΔएࠅڇᑛࠅՕ ຬऱچᒴਙए֒༼ۯچΔለᤕᜤழཚچڶࠠޓᒴਙएᏝଖΖመװऱएࠅਢᤕᜤፂᥨ ഏ୮ܓ墿ፖഏڜ٤ऱᣂഏ୮Δ،ਢᤕᜤڇ႕௧ऱ॰֪ΔףፖխࠅऱၞנՑ၉ ࣐ຟؘႊመቼएࠅΔٵழ،ՈਢᤕᜤፖקપհၴऱૹᢰΖྥۖΔᢅཎፖ एࠅ۞ٺᗑمհ৵Δࠟഏऱ܂ٽᣂএլ༚ڇژΔᠨֱڂቤञᤜΕගᆢᓢડΕ૨ࠃഗ چംᠲᎼֲᏺΔዬ۩ዬΖԫֱ૿Δભഏٍࠐࠩ㠪௧چञኆ౨ᄭܓ墿Δए ࠅऱຏሐۯᆜፖᖏฃᏝଖ֧ܮԱભഏऱᣂࣹΔएࠅ࣍ਢګભΕࠟൎၞ۩چᒴᖏ ฃᤁດऱፘΖʳ چא֮ءᒴਙएᖂፖഏᎾᣂএऱኔᆠᓵઔߒຜஉΔᨠኘΕભࠟഏڇ एࠅऱᖏฃᤁດΖृଈ٣៶چڃطᒴਙएᖂᓵፖഏᎾᣂএኔᆠᓵΔ൶ಘ एࠅऱچᒴਙएᏝଖΕچᒴਙएై֗אएࠅኙ࣍ΕભࠟഏऱᖏฃრᆠΖ֮إڇ ऱຝ։Δृ։ܑಘᓵԱᢅཎፖભഏڇएࠅऱچᒴਙए೯Δچאᒴܓ墿Εچᒴ ਙएౡΕچᒴਙएኔᔌԿଡ૿ٻԵ։࣫ΕભऱᠨᢰᣂএΖڕΕભፖ एࠅऱ܂ٽᣂএΙΕભڇ㠪௧౨ᄭܓ墿ऱञኆΙΕભኙ࣍एࠅףԵקપऱمΙ Εભኙफጇࡎऱم֗אΕભፖ ˅˃˃ˋ ᓢડऱᣂএΖʳ ່৵Δ֮ءऱઔߒ࿇ലΕભڇएࠅऱᖏฃᤁດ։ԿଡழཚΔรԫଡழཚ ਢᢅཎ༳༽ႚอᐙԺΔભഏၞԵ㠪௧౨ᄭᏆΰ˄ˌˌ˄Д˄ˌˌˉ ڣα ΙรԲଡழཚਢ ભഏᗨᄕᆖᛜΔᢅཎ࣍೯ΰ˄ˌˌˊД˅˃˃ˆ ڣα ΙรԿଡழཚਢભഏ༳൳೯ᦞΔ ᢅཎۻᖲ֘ᚰΰ˅˃˃ˇД˅˃˃ˌ ڣα ΖڇຍԿଡழཚΔᢅཎፖભഏڇएࠅऱچᒴਙ एᐙԺܧڼ९ऱኪႨΔᢅཎྤԺॴַભഏڇएࠅ૨ࠃΕᆖᛎΕਙएՂऱ ᗨᄕؒݝΔᢅཎޡޡಯᨃΔດዬໜ؈ڇएࠅऱچᒴਙएᐙԺΖྥۖΔ˅˃˃ˋ ڣ ऱᓢડথڶԱᚭᏣ֏ऱ࿇୶ΔΕભڇएࠅऱႨԺૹᄅੑྨΔભഏࠉ៱ᖑ༼ڶ ֺߺཎਙᦞऱ֭Δፖएࠅၞԫ܂ٽޡΔᤉᥛፂᥨભഏڇएࠅऱچᒴܓ墿Ζᢅ ཎឈྥፖ༼ֺߺཎऱᣂএࠩ܅٧រאՀΔ܀থࠩ։ᠦچॳؒশ౿ፖতႾඪࠅऱ ֭Δᢅཎຘመፖॳؒশ౿ࡉতႾඪࠅऱ܂ٽᣂএ൳ࠫࠟچΔൕۖፂᢀڇएࠅ ऱچᒴܓ墿ፖ؆ףऱچᒴਙए़ၴΖࠐآΔएࠅቃறսലچࠡڂᒴਙएऱૹ ࢤΔᥛᢅཎፖભഏچᒴᖏฃᤁດऱૹፘΖʳ. 立. 政 治 大. ‧. ‧ 國. 學. n. er. io. sit. y. Nat. al. Ch. engchi. i Un. v. ʳ ᣂڗΚچᒴਙएΕएࠅΕભᣂএΕफጇࡎΕ˅˃˃ˋ ڣᓢડʳ.
(3) Abstract: The collapse of Soviet Union in the last century fundamentally changed the geopolitics of Georgia. Its geopolitical values in the Eurasian continent have been improved after the Soviet Union era. In the past, Georgia was a key country that Soviet Union utilized to maintain its country interest and defense security. It served as an entrance to the Black Sea for Soviet Union, as the import and export trading between Caucasus and Middle East relied on it. Meanwhile, it was also the critical sector between the Soviet Union and NATO. However, Russia and Georgia have stopped cooperation since their respective independence; both parties had ceased partnership due to issues of border demarcation, ethnic conflicts, military bases, etc. On the other hand, the United States also competed for its energy interest in the Caspian Sea region, and the passage and strategic values of Georgia has drawn attention of the United States. Georgia, therefore, has become a stage of geostrategic competition for the two superpowers that are the United States and Russia. This study utilizes the geopolitics and realism theory of the international relations as an approach to observe the strategic competition of the United States and Russia in the Georgia. First, I reviewed the geopolitics and realism theory of the international relations and discuss the geopolitical values and elements of Georgia, as well as its strategic meanings for the United States and Russia. In the thesis, the geopolitical activities of the United States and Russia are discussed respectively. The bilateral relations between Russia and Georgia, as well as the United States and Georgia are deeply analyzed in terms of geo-economic benefits, geopolitical threats and geopolitical practices, including the cooperative relations for Georgia with Russia and the United States; the competition for energy interest in the Caspian Sea region between the United States and Russia; the positions of the United States and Russia on joining NATO for Georgia; the positions of the United States and Russia on the Rose Revolution; and the conflict relations between Russia and the United States on the 2008 Russia-Georgia Conflict (South Ossetia War). Finally, the findings of this study divide the strategic competition of the United States and Russia in Georgia into three periods: The first period is that Russia had traditional power and the United States meddled in the Caspian Sea region for energy (1991~1996); the second period is that the United States operated actively while Russia operated passively (1997~2003); and the third period is during which the United States took the initiative while Russia waited for the opportune moment to counterattack (2004~2009). The geopolitical influences of the United States and Russia on Georgia have been constantly changed through these three periods. Russia was unable to strategically stop the military, political, economic plans of the United States in Georgia and had gradually lost its geopolitical influence on it. However, the conflicts between Russia and Georgia in 2008 had a dramatic development. The influences on Georgia of the United States and Russia have been changed again. While the United States have gained Tbilisi’s support to continue cooperation with Georgia to maintain the geo-economic benefits in Georgia, and while Russia has a bad relationship with Tbilisi, Russia has gained support from the two breakaway regions, Abkhazia and South Ossetia. Russia controls these two regions by cooperating with them to maintain the geopolitical interest in Georgia and the geopolitical space in South Caucasus. Due to its geopolitical significance, it is expected that Georgia will continue to serve as a critical stage of the geostrategic competition between the United States and Russia.. 立. 政 治 大. ‧. ‧ 國. 學. n. er. io. sit. y. Nat. al. Ch. engchi. i Un. v. Keywords: Geopolitics, Georgia, Relation between Russia and the United States, Rose Revolution, 2008 Russia-Georgia Conflict.
(4) ؾᙕ รԫີ ፃᓵ ......................................................................................................................... 1 รԫᆏ ઔߒ೯ᖲፖઔߒؾऱ ......................................................................................... 1 รԲᆏ ઔߒຜஉፖઔߒֱऄ ......................................................................................... 3 รԿᆏ ઔߒᒤፖઔߒૻࠫ ......................................................................................... 4 รᆏ ֮ ڃ............................................................................................................. 9 รնᆏ ີᆏڜඈ ........................................................................................................... 24. 政 治 大. รԲີ एࠅऱچᒴਙए ............................................................................................... 27. 立. รԫᆏ چᒴਙएᖂᓵ ............................................................................................... 28. ‧ 國. 學. Ε چᒴਙएᖂऱࡳᆠፖऎ ............................................................................. 28. ‧. ၁Ε چᒴਙएᖂᓵ ............................................................................................. 30 รԲᆏ ഏᎾᣂএኔᆠᓵ ....................................................................................... 40. y. Nat. io. sit. Ε ኔᆠᓵऱࡳᆠፖܑ ............................................................................. 40. al. er. ၁Ε ኔᆠ֮ءڇऱᚨ ش................................................................................. 42. n. iv n C รԿᆏ एࠅऱچᒴਙएైh ................................................................................... 44 engchi U Ε एࠅऱچై ......................................................................................... 44. ၁Ε एࠅፖΕભऱچᒴᣂএ ......................................................................... 47 Ε एࠅچᒴਙएኙፖ٤ऱᐙ ......................................................... 55 รᆏ ՛ ................................................................................................................... 58 รԿີ ᢅཎڇएࠅऱچᒴᖏฃᤁດ ....................................................................... 59 รԫᆏ ᢅཎڇएࠅऱچᒴܓ墿 ........................................................................... 60 Ε ᢅཎڇएࠅऱᆖᛎܓ墿 ......................................................................... 60 ၁Ε ؆ףኙᢅཎऱچᒴਙएრᆠ ............................................................. 62.
(5) รԲᆏ ᢅཎڇएࠅऱچᒴਙएౡ ................................................................... 64 Ε ᢅཎፖएࠅऱᢰቼംᠲ ......................................................................... 65 ၁Ε ᢅཎ֘ኙएࠅףԵקપ ......................................................................... 69 Ε ิࡥॳײ៣ ..................................................................................................... 73 ᆥΕ फጇࡎኙᢅཎऱᓢᚰ ............................................................................. 75 รԿᆏ ᢅཎڇएࠅऱچᒴਙएኔᔌ ................................................................... 80 Ε ףൎፖ؆چףऱ܂ٽᣂএ ................................................................. 81 ၁Ε ᢅཎኙएࠅऱᆖᛎࠫဪ ......................................................................... 83 Ε 2008 ڣᓢડ ............................................................................................ 85. 政 治 大. ᆥΕ ᢅཎڇएࠅऱᕋ૨ ................................................................................. 93. 立. รᆏ ՛ ................................................................................................................... 97. ‧ 國. 學. รີ ભഏڇएࠅऱچᒴᖏฃᤁດ ........................................................................... 99. ‧. รԫᆏ ભഏڇएࠅऱچᒴܓ墿 ............................................................................. 100. sit. y. Nat. Ε ભഏڇएࠅऱᆖᛎܓ墿 ........................................................................... 100. io. al. er. ၁Ε एࠅኙભഏऱچᒴਙएრᆠ ................................................................... 102 รԲᆏ ભഏڇएࠅऱچᒴਙएౡ ..................................................................... 104. n. iv n C h e........................................................................... ભഏڇएࠅऱ౨ᄭౡ 105 ngchi U. Ε. รԿᆏ ભഏڇएࠅऱچᒴਙएኔᔌ ..................................................................... 113 Ε ભഏං೯फጇࡎ ....................................................................................... 113 ၁Ε ભഏԺআएࠅףԵקપ ........................................................................... 117 Ε ભഏፖ 2008 ڣᓢડ ............................................................................. 122 รᆏ ՛ ................................................................................................................. 129 รնີ ᓵ ..................................................................................................................... 132 ֮ە……………………………………………………………………………........140.
(6) ቹ । ؾᙕ ቹؾᙕΚ ቹ 1Ё1Κएࠅچۯᆜቹ……………………………………………………………4 ቹ 1Ё2Κएࠅፖᢅཎᜤ߶……………………………………………………᧯7 ቹ 1Ё3Κᑛࠅ֣ዿი………………………………………....……………………..…10 ቹ 1Ё4ΚᢅཎڇچףऱԿᐋᗶᢰ…………………………………..…20 ቹ 2Ё1Κຽ८ᐚऱ…………………………………………………………..…33 ቹ 2Ё2ΚΕᢰݮچቹ…………………………………………………………..46. 政 治 大. ቹ 2Ё3Κભഏኙएࠅऱ૨ࠃࡉᆖᛎག…………………………………………ܗ..52. 立. ቹ 4Ё1Κ㠪௧چऱ౨ᄭሎᙁጥᒵ…………………………………………………108. ‧ 國. 學. ।ؾᙕΚ. ‧. । 1Ё1Κᢅཎᜤ߶᧯ፖएࠅऱᢰ९৫………………………………………6. n. al. er. io. sit. y. Nat. । 1Ё2ΚΕભڇएࠅᖏฃᤁດऱԿଡழཚ……………………………………..26. Ch. engchi. i Un. v.
(7) ᖴᜏ! !!!!ѤঁൣපၸѐΑǴӧࡹεװ᠐ᅺγᏢՏޑВηࡽऍ֮ΞᖑٌǴҭ੮Πӭόёᑃ ྐޑॉၞǴᜐπբᜐ᠐ਜޑғࢲٌࡐޑधǴၡٰوǴၶډӭᔅշޑךΓॺǴ๏ ךႴᓰ٠ЍֹךԋᅺγᏢՏǶ२ӃǴགᖴੵངޑךР҆ᒃǴԖգॺޑਭǴךω ૈՊ१คဤֹޑԋεᏢᏢǴ٠ᝩុװ᠐ᅺγᏢՏǴයఈ೭ҽᅺγЎᏧૈಖғڙ ҔǴаൔเР҆ᒃޑᎦػϐৱǶ! !!!!ӧࡹεޑᏢಞाགᖴԴৣॺٌ༇ޑ௲ᏤǴགᖴ݅҉ޱ௲ჹፕЎᆶၗԵࡰޑ ᏤǴЦۓγǵԭكԴৣޑᜢᚶᆶ௲ᇧǴ܌ԴৣޑҔЈᡣᏢғሎӧЈǶٰԾဃ۶. 政 治 大 ߮ޑᇟፐзךӵࡾ؍॥Ǵךӳ׆ఈૈᝩុӧፐௗڙாࡰޑᏤǶќѦǴΨाགᖴ߮ 立. ளൕޑ׆ԴৣǴா፪ښᐉғ߮ޑᇟ௲ᏢᡣךӣښคጁǶ፦ऍζယ࣬݅Դৣǹா. ‧ 國. 學. ᛥථࣴ܌زշ௲✎ӵǴգᒃϪ୍ܺޑᄊࡋࢂϦ୍ΓڂޑጄǶ! !!!!നࡕǴགᖴᙦךᏢಞғࢲޑӕᏢॺǴࠧຬǵۏᑼǵځᑣڐޑշᆶഉՔǴόፕࢂ. ‧. ӧፐϣ܈ፐѦࢲǴԖգॺޑВηωᡉளࢲዃԖ፪ǶᏢٜ࣬Ǵգ၅፪قޑፋ. sit. y. Nat. ᕴࢂࣁεৎٰӭ፪ǶࡐϿрޑৎᇯǵࠫӹǴᗨฅᆶգॺ࣬ೀޑਔ໔όӭǴՠ. n. al. er. io. ךϝᚶۺԖգॺޑፐǴգॺᕴࢂࣁፐٰཀགྷόޑډᡋ഻Ƕ࠻϶ Ebwje!ȿ!. v. KptfǴᖴᖴգॺᡣךԖᐒግಞमЎ၉Ǵ٠ᇡ౦୯ЎϯǶךኑޑᇡࣁૈख़ӣ. Ch. engchi. ࡹεਠ༜ࢂךΓғύനғЪόёલЮޑ।Ƕ!. i Un. !!!!ᅺγᏢՏಖֹܭԋǴᏢғఱΨኩࢤပǴࡑ״่אܺךǴѸஒख़ӣ௲ᙍǴଅ ܌ᏢǴයૈӆԛࡾ॥ϯߘܭፐϐǴ٠ஒԴৣॺޑፌፌ௲ᇧаϷזޑᏢಞғ ࢲǴϩ٦ϒޑךᏢғǶനࡕӆԛགᖴ೭Ѥԃπ᠐ғࢲύၶ܌ޑډԖΓǴόж߄ ϩᚆǴգॺஒ҉ӸޑךᏫǴךᚶܤགᖴޑЈǴᖴᖴᆶӆـǴ୯ҥࡹݯεᏢǶ! ! ᙣϒךനᚶߓޑۺϦ! 3121 ԃ : Д 39 В!.
(8) รԫີ ፃᓵ. รԫᆏʳ ઔߒ೯ᖲፖઔߒؾऱʳ ࣍ۯᢅཎতֱऱچףΔچ࣍طႨസኜፖຏሐऱߨ༔ۯᆜທګᇠاچගᠧ ᲧΕࡲඒٌᘜΔᖵՂڍ࣍։ါणኪΔൄ֧ࠐࡌᢰ٨ൎऱञኆΔឫլឰΖվֲ چףऱچᒴਙएΔچڂޓ२㠪௧ขईΔڍڶය౨ᄭጥᒵᆖመΔ᠆দऱ౨ᄭܓ墿. 政 治 大. ֧ࠐ٨ൎᝍᘤΔڇףၞ۩چᒴᖏฃᤁດΖʳ. 立. ʳ. ‧ 國. 學. ˅˃ ધ ˌ˃ זڣᤕᜤᇞ᧯৵ΔᤕᜤףᅩഏᗑمΔچף։ါᢅཎΕ एࠅΕࠅႾਈྥፖࠅભࠅ؍ଡഏ୮Δچᒴਙए᧩ޓᓤᠧΖ᥆࣍ᢅཎऱק. ‧. چףڶքଡ۞ए٥ࡉഏΔຝ։۞ए٥ࡉഏڶᗑمႜٻΔམᡨ࿇փᖏΙࠅႾਈ. y. Nat. io. sit. ྥڂᔣ२㠪௧ईضΔ౨ᄭܓ墿࠹ࠩᨫؾΔਢֱ۫ᗨᄕ࿇୶֖ړᣂএऱഏ୮Ιࠅભ؍. n. al. er. ࠅፖࠅႾਈྥڶᏆՒिΔࠟഏམᆖՕ೯ե֩ΔݝႨԫᤛܛ࿇Ιएࠅឈ᠆༄ऱ. Ch. i Un. v. ۞ྥᇷᄭΔٌڶࠠڂ܀ຏߨ༔ऱᚌႨΔګ㠪௧فईሎᑛऱᣂഏ୮Ζ؆ף. engchi. ԿഏհխΔएࠅਢፖᢅཎຬچᢰ່९ऱഏ୮Δࠟഏऱᣂএ࣍طएࠅቼփऱ։ ါംᠲΔ᧩೪լឰΔᝫ႖Ζʳ ʳ एࠅᗑم৵Δࠡਙݝ٣៱ط٥᤻ߓࢬނΔ؆ٌਙႜٻխمΔլႜٍ լႜֱ۫ΖྥۖΔ˅˃˃ˆ ڣएࠅᡨ࿇फጇࡎΔભֱႨԺၞएࠅΔᦞԺႜٻ ֱ۫ऱ؆ٌਙֲ墿ࣔ᧩Ζભഏᕁࡐڇ؆ףऱ౨ᄭܓ墿ፖچᒴਙएठቹΔሑᗨ ᄕࢮᡚएࠅףԵקપΔڼᜰᨃᢅཎՕ٠־Δڻڍ।ሒᣤૹݼᤜΔࠀ֭אए ࠅቼփऱ։ါچࠫएࠅऱ֫ΔॴᡶएࠅऱԵપၞ࿓Ζʳ ʳ 1.
(9) ˅˃˃ˋ ڣሎཚၴΔएࠅፖᢅཎึڂ९ՆऱլᅬᣂএΔᡨ࿇૨ࠃᓢડΖए ࠅႣೈቼփऱֱچ։ᠦႨԺΔኙতႾඪࠅ۞ए٥ࡉഏ࿇೯૨ࠃސᚰΔᇢቹ൳ࠫত ႾඪࠅΖᢅཎঞאতႾඪࠅڶڍᢅཎഏاطΔנঅᥨতႾඪࠅΖΕ հၴऱᖏञᥛնֲΔएࠅլᑅᢅཎऱෳ௺ސႨΔڇנতႾඪࠅऱ۾Ꮖ Δ᠏ۖ༈ޣഏᎾ֭ΖڻڼᓢડΔᖏഏឈྥڶΕࠟഏΔࠡ܀હ৵ኔᎾՂথ ਢΕભհၴऱՕഏለၦΔΕભڇ؆چףऱܓ墿ᓢડၴ൷ᖄીԱຍᓢડΖ ᢅཎΕભഏΕएࠅڇףऱᖏฃԿߡᣂএΔࠠڶ৫ऱچᒴਙएრොΔࠠઔ ߒ൶ಘհᏝଖΖʳ ʳ. 政 治 大. ءڇઔߒխΔृچאߓፖઔߒऱᖂહནΔࠌچشᒴਙएᖂ֗אഏᎾᣂ. 立. এᓵऱઔߒຜஉΔಘᓵएࠅچڇᒴਙएՂऱૹࢤΙ։࣫ܐᖏ৵Εભኙ. ‧ 國. 學. एࠅ؆ٌਙऱዝ᧢Ι൶ಘΕભࠟՕൎᦞڕ۶ڇएࠅၞ۩چᒴᖏฃᤁດΙएࠅ. ‧. ۶ൕԫଡ৵٥ഏ୮᠏᧢ᘣֱ۫ऱഏ୮Λࠀᐙᢅཎڇچףऱᖏฃ܉. y. Nat. ݝΙᢅཎ۶ؚאధመװፖएࠅऱٵᅩᣂএΔࠟഏՕ೯ե֩ΖۖભഏԾ۶ࠐࠩ. er. io. sit. एࠅፖᢅཎၞ۩ᖏฃᤁດΛભഏڕ۶ሎࠡشਙᆖᐙԺΔലएࠅԵભഏऱچᒴ ਙएठቹΛ֮࣫ءᓵΕભڇएࠅऱچᒴਙए೯ΔאᛵᇞΕભڕ۶ຘመچᒴᖏ. n. al. Ch. i Un. v. ฃऱᖙ܂Δञ࠷ഏ୮ዊᤌΕ૾܅ഏ୮எ᥈ፖঅᎽഏ୮ܓ墿Ζʳ ʳ. engchi. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ. 2.
(10) รԲᆏʳ ઔߒຜஉፖઔߒֱऄʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ א֮ءψچᒴਙएᖂωઔߒຜஉΔ࣫ᓵᤕᜤᇞ᧯৵Δᢅཎፖભഏڇएࠅऱ ᖏฃᤁດΔᨠኘΕભڇएࠅऱچᒴਙएؒࠟ֗אݝഏڕ۶ሎشኔᎾऱ؆ٌ۩೯ᕁ ࡐࠡڇएࠅऱچᒴਙएܓ墿Ζڼ؆Δٍ֮ءຘመഏᎾᣂএᖂऱψኔᆠᓵωઔߒ ΕભΕԿֱڇഏᎾਙएՂऱᤁञࢨ܂ٽΔࠀאഏ୮۩೯ᖲऱዊᤌΕܓ墿Εஎ᥈ Կଡᐋ૿ΔᎅࣔΕભڇएࠅၞ۩ᖏฃᤁດऱ೯ᖲΖʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ش֧֮ءऱچᒴਙएᖂᓵױ։ࠢײፖچזᒴਙएᖂᓵΔृٺ٨ᜰԿଡ. 政 治 大. ז।ࢤऱᓵءᓵ֮ऱઔߒຜஉΔփ୲ᇡߠรԲີรԫᆏΖۖԫଡઔߒຜஉψ. 立. ኔᆠᓵω Δ֮ࠡءڇऱᚨٻֱشঞױᇡߠรԲີรԲᆏΖኔᆠਢԲᖏ৵ഏᎾᣂ. ‧ 國. 學. এऱઔߒੌΔᢅཎፖભഏऱኙ؆ਙઃ࠹ࠩኔᆠᓵऱᐙΖኔᆠृᎁ. ‧. اගഏ୮ਢഏᎾᣂএऱፖृΔۖԫଡഏ୮ऱഏᎾ࣍ެ࠷ۯچഏԺፖਙΔڼڂ اٺගഏ୮ྤլᗨᄕچಳᦞޣԺΖڼ؆ΔഏᎾၴڂܧྤਙࢌणኪΔᖄીഏᎾᓢડ. y. Nat. io. sit. ګྥؘհ࣠ΔኔᆠृᎁഏᎾऄࢨഏᎾิ៣ࠀլ౨ڶயࠫލഏᎾᓢડΔڼڂ. n. al. er. ਙए୮ଚؘႊૠԫࠫ৫Δᝩ܍ഏᎾᓢડΔۖᦞԺؓᘝإਢࠫڼ৫ऱᣂរΖʳ ʳ. Ch. engchi. i Un. v. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ֮ءऱઔߒֱऄאψ֮։࣫ऄωΔ᎖אଡԳᨠរΔ፦ႃᢅཎፖભഏڇ एࠅऱ؆ٌ೯ᇷறΔࠎא։࣫ܐᖏ৵ᢅཎፖભഏڇएࠅऱᖏฃᤁດΖઔߒऱᇷ றܶץറᓵထΕີழࠃΕཚעᓵ֮Εጻሁ֮Δ֮א֮Εխ֮ᇷறΔ ֮֮᎖Δྥڂृլᘲ֮ፖएࠅ֮Δਚ֮֮אڍ᠏ᇷறΖᇷற ࠐᄭঞො።ΕխഏՕຬΕભഏΕഏΕᢅཎΕएࠅፖ܌ᥞഏΖʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ. 3.
(11) รԿᆏʳ ઔߒᒤፖઔߒૻࠫʳ ֮ءऱઔߒᠲਢᢅཎፖભഏڇψएࠅωऱᖏฃᤁດΔઔߒᒤࡳ࣍ף چऱएࠅ٥ࡉഏΖΰቹ ˄Ё˄αچף࣍ۯᑛࠅٌΔױ։؆ף ፖփףΔٍڶጠհতףፖקףΖएࠅ࣍ۯ؆چףΔഏՒ૿ᗨ քᆄՏԮֱؓۍֆߺΔપऱࠟՕΔԳՑ ˇˇˆ ᆄΔࠡխएࠅග٤ഏԳՑ ˋˇʸΔࠡ塒اගঞࠅܶץႾਈྥԳʻˉˁˈʸʼΕࠅભࠅ؍ԳʻˈˁˊʸʼΕᢅཎԳʻ˄ˁˈʸʼॳ֗א ؒশ౿ԳፖႾඪࠅԳΕဎԳΕྫ֜ԳΕՒۘࠡԳΕࠅ૪ԳΕݦᢊԳΖʳ ʳ. 政 治 大. ቹ 1Ё1 एࠅچۯᆜቹ. 立. ‧. ‧ 國. 學. n. er. io. sit. y. Nat. al. Ch. engchi. i Un. v. ᇷறࠐᄭΚhttps://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/gg.html. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ 4. ʳ.
(12) एࠅ٤ഏ٥։ ˉ˅ ଡ۩ਙΔܶץԿଡऴᝤؑΕԲଡ۞ए٥ࡉഏΕԫଡ۞ए ֗אڠଡڠΖ ˄ ؾছएࠅቼփऱॳؒশ౿ፖতႾඪࠅΔኔᎾՂᗑمणኪΔլ ࠹༼ֺߺཎऱխ؇ਙࢌ൳ࠫΖ˅˃˃ˋ ڣᓢડࠃٙ৵Δॳؒশ౿ፖতႾඪࠅڇ ᢅཎऱ֭ՀؒᗑمΔؾছ٤ႛڶᢅཎΕذࢮף؍ΰˡ˼˶˴̅˴˺̈˴αΕࡡփᅗࢮ ΰ˩˸́˸̍̈˸˿˴αΕᘭᕙΰˡ˴̈̅̈αഏࢭᎁࠡᗑۯچمΖʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ. 立. ʳ. 政 治 大. ‧ 國. 學. ˄. ʳ एࠅऱ۩ਙቤᇡ٨ڕՀΚʳ. ‧. ԫΕ۞ए٥ࡉഏΚʳ ʳ. ॳؒশ౿۞ए٥ࡉഏʻ˔˵˾˻˴̍˼˴ʼΔଈࢌΚᤕࡅۏʻ˦̈˾˻̈̀˼ʼʳ. ˅ˁ. ॳ֬ዿ۞ए٥ࡉഏʻ˔˷˽˴̅˴ʼΔଈࢌΚ֣อʻ˕˴̇̈̀˼ʼʳ. y. sit er. তႾඪࠅΰ˦̂̈̇˻ʳˢ̆̆˸̇˼˴αΔଈࢌΚಅࣲܓرΰ˧̆˾˻˼́̉˴˿˼αʳ ʳ. al. n. ˄ˁ. io. ԲΕ۞एڠʳ. Nat. ˄ˁ. ԿΕڠΚʳ. Ch. engchi. i Un. v. ˄ˁ. ៳ම٨ᢅˀՂཎࠅࡱ௳رʻ˦˴̀˸˺̅˸˿̂ˀ˭˸̀̂ʳ˦̉˴́˸̇˼ʼΔଈࢌΚల૭૭ʻ˭̈˺˷˼˷˼ʼʳ. ˅ˁ. ࠅܓײʻ˚̈̅˼˴ʼΔଈࢌΚలዿ።ᆳΰˢ̍̈̅˺˸̇˼αʳ ʳ. ˆˁ. ࢮ৾Ё٨ࠡࡅࡉۏՀཎࠅࡱ௳رʻ˥˴˶˻˴ˀ˟˸˶˻˾˻̈̀˼ʳ˴́˷ʳ˞̉˸̀̂ʳ˦̉˴́˸̇˼ʼΔଈࢌΚؒڜᢅ໎ߺ ΰ˔̀˵̅̂˿˴̈̅˼αʳ ʳ. ˇˁ. ْම٨ࡱʻ˜̀˸̅˸̇˼ʼΔଈࢌΚჃْ۫ΰ˞̈̇˴˼̆˼αʳ ʳ. ˈˁ. ៳ࡥಅ᎒Ё֬ر᎒ࡱʻ˦˴̀̇̆˾˻˸ˀ˝˴̉˴˾˻˸̇˼ʼΔଈࢌΚॳশዿᏘ᎒ΰ˔˾˻˴˿̇̆˼˾˻˸αʳ ʳ. ˉˁ. չሒЁܓʻ˦˻˼˷˴ʳ˞˴̅̇˿˼ʼΔଈࢌΚୂߺʻ˚̂̅˼ʼʳ ʳ. ˊˁ. ࡥಅ᎒ჃЁࡥࡱॳ௳ࡱʻˠ̇̆˾˻˸̇˴ˀˠ̇˼˴́˸̇˼ʼΔଈࢌΚࡥಅ᎒Ⴣΰˠ̇̆˾˻˸̇˴αʳ. ˋˁ. ܌ፂ๕Ёܓʻ˞̉˸̀̂ʳ˞˴̅̇˿˼ʼΔଈࢌΚᕙཎჃፂʻ˥̈̆̇˴̉˼ʼʳ ʳ. ˌˁ. ᎒ࡱʻ˞˴˾˻˸̇˼ʼΔଈࢌΚࢮፂʻ˧˸˿˴̉˼ʼʳ ʳ. ΕऴᝤؑΚʳ ˄ˁ. ༼ֺߺཎʻ˧˵˼˿˼̆˼ʼʳ. ˅ˁ. Ⴣْ۫ʻ˞̈̇˴˼̆˼ʼʳ. 3.. ंࡱʻˣ̂̇˼ʼ 5.
(13) ʳ ʳ چאۯᆜۖߢΔएࠅ࣍ۯ؆ֱקףΔ۫ೡ ˃˄ˆ ڶֆߺऱ႕௧௧ࡾᒵΔ۫ তֱፖՒۘࠡᔣΔত൷ࠅႾਈྥፖࠅભࠅ؍Δ່ۖૹऱᔣഏᅝ᥆קᢰऱᢅཎΔ एࠅፖᢅཎᜤ߶ڶ९ሒ ˊ˅ˆֆߺऱᢰΔΰ। ˄Ё˄αᇠ᥆࣍ᢅཎऱקף ᜤ߶Δࣟ۟۫ط։ܑΚࢮ܌ཎᘭሒዿᜤ߶ʻ˞̅˴̆́̂˷˴̅ʼΕْ৾ࢮЁ֊ዿ܌ཎ٥ ࡉഏʻ˞˴̅˴˶˻˴̌ˀ˖˻˸̅˾˸̆̆˼˴ʼΕ֣ዿሒЁ֣ዿዿ٥ࡉഏʻ˞˴˵˴̅˷˼́̂ˀ˕˴˿˾˴̅˼˴ʼΕקႾඪ ࠅ٥ࡉഏʻˡ̂̅̇˻ʳˢ̆̆˸̇˼˴ˀ˔˿˴́˼˴ʼΕײٱչ٥ࡉഏʻ˜́˺̈̆˻˸̇˼˴ʼΕ߫٥ࡉഏʻ˖˻˸˶˻́̌˴ʼΕሒ ٳཎࡖ٥ࡉഏʻ˗˴˺˸̆̇˴́ʼΔ ΰቹ ˄Ё˅αࠡխקႾඪࠅΕ߫ΕሒٳཎࡖΕײٱչઃམ ፖ๕ཎઝᅝݝ࿇سᐰᚴΔ۟ᨈګ૨ࠃᓢડΔՈڼڂچףऱچᒴਙएԫऴࠐא ຟਢ๕ཎઝᅝݝᣂࣹऱྡྷរΖʳ. 立. 政 ʳ治 大. । 1Ё1 ᢅཎᜤ߶᧯ፖएࠅऱᢰ९৫. ‧ 國. 學. ሒٳཎࡖ٥ࡉഏʳ. ˄ˈ˄ʳ. ߫٥ࡉഏʳ. ˋ˄ʳ. al. n. קႾඪࠅ٥ࡉഏʳ. y. sit. ˄ˇˁˈʳ. Ch. ֣ዿሒˀ֣ዿዿ٥ࡉഏʳ. ˄ˊ˄ˁˉʳ. e n g c˄ˆ˃ˁˉʳ hi. ْ৾ࢮˀ֊ዿ܌ཎ܌٥ࡉഏʳ. ˅˄˃ˁˈʳ. ࢮ܌ཎᘭሒዿᢰᡲʳ. ˋ˅ʳ. er. io. ײٱչ٥ࡉഏʳ. ‧. ፖएࠅऱᢰ९৫ʻֆߺʼʳ. Nat. ᢅཎᜤ߶᧯ʳ. i Un. v. ᇷறࠐᄭΚݳદΔཏࠇ߶ڜհሐΚᢅཎ२ᔣ؆ٌΰࠇקΚխഏषᄎઝᖂנठषΔ2006 ڣ11 ִαΔ 200Ζ. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ 6.
(14) ቹ 1-2 एࠅፖᢅཎᜤ߶᧯. 政 治 大. ʳ. 立 ᇷறࠐᄭΚhttp://iguide.travel/illustrations/North_Caucasus-1.png. ‧ 國. 學. ʳʳʳʳʳ. ʳ ʳ ֮ءઔߒऱழၴរΔದ۞ ˄ˌˌ˄ ֲ ˌ ִ ˇ ڣएࠅᗑمΔึ࣍ ˅˃˃ˌ ֲ ˋ˄ ִ ˋ ڣ. ‧. एࠅಯנᗑمഏ୮ഏ࠰Ζएࠅףִ ˅˄ ڣ ˆˌˌ˄ ڇԵᗑمഏ୮ഏ࠰Δዿ৵Δ˅˃˃ˋ קڣ. y. Nat. sit. ࠇሎཚၴΔएࠅፖᢅཎᡨ࿇૨ࠃᓢડΔएࠅנᓢડچΔא؈װԿ։հԫ. n. al. er. io. ऱᏆՒګᖏञऱᙁ୮Δᐬۖ࣍ ˅˃˃ˌ ڣಯנᗑمഏ୮ഏ࠰Ζءઔߒऱழၴᒤאױ. i Un. v. ˅˃˃ˆ ڣएࠅफጇࡎ։រΔफጇࡎছΔएࠅආ۩ለխمऱ؆ٌਙΔ. Ch. engchi. ԫ৫ᇢቹଥ༚ፖᢅཎऱ؆ٌᣂএΔ᧩ࣔڶآೣٻભഏࢨקપऱ؆ٌႜٻΖफጇࡎ ৵Δᙟထᢅཎൎ֏ፖएࠅ։ᠦႨԺऱຑΔᠨֱࣴߠֲΔएࠅ؆ٌฃሑ᠏ ۖႜٻભഏፖקપΔᕧඨᛧֱ֭۫ΔݼאᘝᢅཎऱᐙԺΖʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ 7.
(15) ֮ءەऱ֮ᇷறאխΕ֮Δא֮ᐷᐊऱֱ۫ᨠរΔڇഏփቹ塢ࢨ ጻᎾጻሁઃ౨࠷᠆༄ऱ֮ᇷறΔ֠ࠡڇᓢડࠃٙԫڣ৵Δઌᣂ֮ᄐբຬᥛ נठΖྥۖΔऱᖂࢨנठথڼאᤜᠲለܐ॰ΔઔߒԳթࢨנठრᣋΔ נठऱઌᣂխ֮֮ઌᅝΖ࠹ૻ࣍एࠅઔߒᏆऱຆΔڼڂृ ౨ەለڍऱՕຬ֮ᇷறΔۖխഏՕຬᖂኙ࣍Εભᣂএ᧩ڶޓઔߒრᣋ ፖઔߒԳթΔ֠ࠡਢקࣟڇऱഏᎾᣂএᖂࢨࠇקऱਙएᖂΔઌᣂઔߒፖ֮ຟ᧩ ޓ༄৫ΖլመΔ֮ءऱઔߒૻࠫսਢृኙ֮࣍ፖएࠅ֮ऱߢሶᎶΔ ृڇٍᣄ࠷אएࠅֱऱรԫ֫ᇷறΔ࠷ࠌܛՈڂլ␓एࠅ֮ۖྤऄᔹ ᦰΖॺߓฅᄐऱृΔኙ֮֮࣍ऱᔹᦰਢԫՕᎽᡶΔࢉڇഏփऱቹ塢ױ. 政 治 大. ࠷ऱཚີ֮עΔ˥̈̆̆˼˴́ʳˣ̂˿˼̇˼˶̆ʳ˴́˷ʳ˟˴̊ ཚ˿̂˩ עˁˇˊʿ́̂ˁˆʿʳˠ˴̌ˀ˝̈́˸ʳ˅˃˃ˌ ༼ࠎ. 立. ԱڍᢅཎΕ܌ᥞΕएࠅᖂृऱထ܂Δឈྥਢ᠏֮Δ܀ኙ࣍լ␓֮ऱݺΔ. ‧ 國. 學. բ᥆ᣄ౨ױ၆ऱᇷறࠐᄭΖʳ. ‧. ʳ. y. Nat. ່৵ΔᕣጥृઔߒऱਢΕભڇएࠅऱچᒴਙए೯Δ᥆࣍ઔߒऱᖂઝ. er. io. sit. ᏆΔ܀ਢڇृچᖂፖઔߒऱറᄐᎁवխΔಡᦰڶᆄ࠴ۖլ۩ᆄߺሁऱሐ Δृྤऄᘣ۞ࠩएࠅം࠴ᓳࢨᘣߪ᧯᧭ᅝچऱاঋଅൣΔਢृᎁ່Օ. n. al. Ch. i Un. v. ऱઔߒૻࠫΖݦඨڶཛԫֲΔएࠅਙݝࡳհழΔृՈ౨ࠩएࠅԫΔԫᗭຍ ଡഏԳཏሙઃլᑵᢝऱएࠅΖʳ. engchi. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ. 8.
(16) รᆏʳ ֮ڃʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ֮ءऱઔߒຜஉਢچᒴਙएᖂፖഏᎾᣂএኔᆠᓵΔઔߒᒤᡱܶץભᣂএፖ Εભڇएࠅऱ؆ٌ೯Ζءᆏല٣چڃᒴਙएᖂ֗אኔᆠᓵऱઌᣂᓵထΔ ٦ڃፖઔߒᒤᡱઌᣂऱխΕ؆֮֮Δ༼נছԳ֮ኙءઔߒऱඔ࿇ፖەᏝଖΖʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ˄ˌˌˊ ߬ߺؒطڣཎഗʻ˭˵˼˺́˼˸̊ʳ˕̅̍˸̍˼́̆˾˼ʼᐷᐊऱπՕཪᒌρʻ˧˻˸ʳ˚̅˴́˷ʳ˖˻˸̆̆˵̂˴̅˷ʼ ԫਢ ˅˃ ધچأᒴਙएᓵထऱᄑΔּؒא壄ऱᨠរᓵ૪ܐᖏ৵ᑛࠅՕຬऱچ ᒴਙएݝΔլᓵਢ൶ಘچᒴਙएᓵࢨ։࣫چףऱچᒴᖏฃຟᄕࠠەᏝ. 政 治 大 ˅. ଖΖּؒലᢅཎऱতֱࡳᆠᑛࠅ֣ዿიΔ ΰቹ ˄ˀˆαᒤᦖਔԱףፖխ. 立. ࠅچΔהਐנᇠࠠڶᣂऱچۯᆜΕ᠆༄ऱ֚ྥᇷᄭΕᓤᠧऱጟගፖᙑᆜऱᖵ. ‧ 國. 學. હནΔຍࠄᒴګࠡࠌطՕഏႨԺߡດऱᖏΖʳ. ‧. ʳ. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ּؒאছભഏഏ୮ڜ٤ംऱᇷᖵΔ༼נભഏᚨፖऄΕᐚᜤ֫ᕁࡐࠀឩՕاਙ. y. Nat. io. sit. एऱठቹΔലקપऱ૨ࠃԺၦ۟ۼխᑛፖࣟᑛΔ۟ਢ؆ףΔ৬ዌԫଡޓՕऱ. n. al. er. ႃ᧯ڜ٤᧯Ζ۟࣍ᢅཎΔֱ۫ঞᚨ༼ࠎᇷ८གܗᢅཎ৬ທᄅऱֆሁፖᥳሁጻΔല. Ch. i Un. v. ᢅཎፖᑛޓጹയچຑ൷ದࠐΔআࠌᢅཎᘣ२ᑛࠀፖᑛၞԫޡᖞٽΖભഏᚨ. engchi. ˆ. ៶طอٽፖᡚऱ؆ٌ֫Δೈႚอऱ֨ᆮՕ൛ᢅཎΖ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ 2. ψᑛࠅ֣ዿიωԫဲএ߬ߺؒطཎഗڇπՕཪᒌρԫխࢬ༼נΔᒤො።ॳ༄ۀΕࠅભࠅ؍Εࠅ. ႾਈྥΕएࠅΕশ៳܌ΕٳዿٳཎΕჃ܌ٳΕՒΕ౿ܑ܌ 9 ଡഏ୮Ζᑛࠅ֣ዿიࠠڶ৫ ऱچᒴਙएრᆠΔጟගᓢડΕࡲඒञΕ౨ᄭܓ墿Εٌຏۯچైڂᖄીᇠᓢડ᙮Δࠐ֧٨ൎ ऱᝍᘤΔೈԱࡌऱᢅཎΕՒۘࠡΕْிհ؆Δխഏፖભഏٍᗨᄕ௫Եڼऱࠃ೭Δञኆڇᑛࠅ֣ ዿიऱഏ୮ܓ墿Ζ 3. ຫؘᅃΔ ψભഏڕ۶ڇՂनຍԫᒌཪΛω Δࣥ࣍گ၆πՕཪᒌρʻ˧˻˸ʳ˚̅˴́˷ʳ˖˻˸̆̆˵̂˴̅˷ʼݧΰ. קᗼᄅࢋؑΚمፃ֮֏Δ ا96αΔ 6Ζ 9.
(17) ቹ 1Ё3 ᑛࠅ֣ዿი. 立. 政 治 大. ‧. ‧ 國. 學. Nat. y. Ӧጔࡹݯፂ!ڈ ኻ٥Ѓᅟ༸! όᛙۓୱ! ፂँᗺ!. ʳ. n. al. er. io. sit. ᇷறࠐᄭΚZbigniew Brzezinski ထΔࣥ၆ΔՕཪᒌΰፕקᗼᄅࢋؑΚمፃ֮֏Δ ا96 ڣα Δ 163Ζ. v. ʳ ʳ ˌ˃ ॣזڣཚΔᢅཎऱՕ۫ᆠ؆ٌਙ؈ܓΔመ৫ႜֱ۫ٻऱ؆ٌਙΔ. Ch. engchi. i Un. ࠀآኙᢅཎࠐٚ۶ഏ୮ܓ墿Δ२ᔣᚌ٣ᓵ ˇ ດዬګՕ۫ᆠ؆ٌਙऱཙז ֱூΖ۫ց ˅˃˃˃ ڣ༳ᦞऱཏࠇച۩٤ֱۯ؆ٌਙΔࠀآ൷࠹ભഏऱႃ᧯ڜ٤ਙΔ ᢅཎૹႂ֨ডডऱچᒴਙएؾᑑΔլᝩᘨऱֆྥጠԱᢅཎऱഏ୮ڜ٤ܓ 墿Δᗑمഏ࠰ഏ୮ᚨࠡႨԺᒤΖʳ ʳ ʳ 4. २ᔣᚌ٣ᓵ(near abroad)Κᢅཎਙए୮ڇ്ছᤕᜤᖕڶऱچᒴਙए़ၴΔ৬مԫଡא๕ཎઝެ. խ֨ऱࢤ۩ױਮዌΔהଚᎁᗑمഏ୮ഏ࠰אױዝ᧢א๕ཎઝଈऱᣊᑛᅩิ៣Δᢅཎؘႊൎ ֏ፖছᤕᜤףᅩ٥ࡉഏऱᣂএΔ֠ࠡਢຘመᆖᛎઌյࠉژऱ᧿หΔፖছᤕᜤഏ୮ጹയچڇٽԫದΔ ڼڕലኙᢅཎऱᆖᛎፖچᒴਙएࠐഏ୮ܓ墿Ζ 10.
(18) ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ּؒګڣ ˊˌˌ˄ ڇழΔᓵ૪ᢅཎ֘ኙקપࣟឩऱمፖվࠀྤ֜ՕฆΔ ܀ኙ؆ףऱچᒴਙएΔؒߺ߬ཎഗࣹრࠩᤖ៲᠆༄౨ᄭऱࠅႾਈྥΔೋ༼آڗ एࠅፖΕભऱچᒴᖏฃᣂএΔຍፖᅝழएࠅࠀآ࿇سᠱࡎۥΕսآ࿇ س૨ࠃᓢડऱழ़હནڶᣂΖʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ഏփچᒴਙएᖂृຫاౝاڇഏ ˇˈ נڣठऱψچᒴਙएᖂωԫΔऴࠩاഏ ˉˈ ڣբᆖ٦ठԿڻΔਢृڇՕᖂଥਙएچᖂழࢬشհඒઝΔڼګឈڰΔ܀ խലچᒴਙएᖂຫ૪ऱ؎าᣇᙊΔຫاౝ٣אسഏ୮ਢڶᖲऱسढ᧯ᎅࣔഏ୮چڇ ़ၴፖഏᎾᣂএՂऱژسᑓڤΖխऱรԫଡຝ։Δהൕഏ୮ऱګݮΕഏ୮ऱᢰᡲΕ. 政 治 大. ഏԺऱ९֗אഏ୮ऱଈຟֱ૿Δ൶ಘഏ୮ڶᖲ᧯ऱᘋՋฐಐΖรԲଡຝ։Δঞൕ. 立. ԳՑΕഏᎾਙएΕཷاਙΕጟගᒤᡱΔᤉᥛ൶ಘഏ୮ڶᖲ᧯ऱᘋՋฐಐΖຍءထ. ‧ 國. 學. ܂ኙ࣍ृچᒴਙएᨠ࢚ऱګݮΔፖᛵᇞچᒴਙए࢚ഗ៕༼ࠎৰڍऱᚥܗΖʳ. ‧. ʳ. y. Nat. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ Ꮨزઝ֛Η֣ፂዿΗॳऄ۫ળፂ࡛ΰ
(19) αᒳထऱπᅝ. er. io. sit. זᢅཎഏᎾᣂএᖂρፖر٨ߺΗ٨࣓ڍ؍ፂ࡛Ηᢅ֛ထ܂ऱπᢅཎچᒴਙए ༚ᘋᝫਢᄰՋρࠟءറΔृ܂ઃਢ๕ཎઝՕᖂထټऱഏᎾᣂএᖂृΔृࢬᔹᦰऱ. n. al. Ch. i Un. v. ਢխഏᖂृࢬऱ១᧯ڗठءΔࠡխπᅝזᢅཎഏᎾᣂএᖂρ༼ࠎԱᢅཎᨠរ. engchi. ऱഏᎾᣂএီມΔխտฯԱؾছᢅཎഏᎾᣂএᖂፖچᒴਙएᖂऱ࿇୶उΔᢅ ཎထټऱഏᎾംᠲറ୮༉ᢅཎኔᆠऱរΕഏᎾᣂএ։࣫խ್܌৸ᆠֱऄऱ णΕڜ٤ംᠲઔߒΕഏᎾᓫܒΕاගᓢડԫߓ٨ംᠲ࿇।Ա۞աऱრߠΖπᢅ ཎچᒴਙए༚ᘋᝫਢᄰՋρԫঞտฯԱڍᢅཎᨠរऱچᒴਙएΔխಘᓵԱ ᢅཎᨠរऱՕຬΕ௧֮ࣔچᒴਙएΕࣟإඒᨠរऱچᒴਙएΕᢅཎऱᑛࠅՕຬچ ᒴਙए֗אᢅཎऱچᒴਙए֖ࣛ֗אᑅԳΖຍࠟء᠏֮Δኙ࣍ृᛵᇞᢅཎ ᨠរऱഏᎾᣂএᖂፖچᒴਙएᖂΔ༼ࠎԱڍᓵᏝଖፖऄΖʳ ʳ ʳ 11.
(20) ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ طնতנठषנठऱࠟءഏᎾᣂএᖂᓵထΔټຟਢπഏᎾᣂএρΰ˜́̇˸̅́˴̇˼̂́˴˿ʳ. ˥˸˿˴̇˼̂́̆α Δԫਢإࣔޕطᖂृ٥ٵᐷᐊΔԲঞਢطભഏഏᎾᣂএᖂृ ˙̅˸˷˸̅˼˶ʳ˦ˁʳ ˣ˸˴̅̆̂́ ፖ ˝ˁʳ ˠ˴̅̇˼́ʳ ˥̂˶˻˸̆̇˸̅ ٽထΖࠟຟኙഏᎾᣂএᖂऱᓵፖኔᔌԱ؎าᣇᙊ ऱ૪ΔࠡխΔطᖂृᒳထऱψഏᎾᣂএωΔխٍಘᓵԱچᒴਙएऱ࿇୶ፖآ ࠐΔ᧩ߠഏᎾᣂএᖂፖچᒴਙएᖂᓵՂऱຑࢤΔࢬٵ֮ءאழچאᒴਙएᖂፖഏ ᎾᣂএኔᆠઔߒຜஉΖ؆ΔխՈ༼ࠩקપऱመװΕڇፖࠐآΔृ܂ຘመ ٨ᜰิ៣ऱኔᎾᒤࠏΔᎅࣔഏᎾᣂএ࿇୶Հऱิ៣܂ٽΔۖקՕ۫ֆપิ៣إ ਢءઔߒ֮إຝ։ࢬಘᓵऱૹᤜᠲΔΖʳ ʳ. 政 治 大. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ πኔᆠፖഏᎾᣂএρʻ˥˸˴˿˼̆̀ʳ ˴́˷ʳ ˜́̇˸̅́˴̇˼̂́˴˿ʳ ˥˸˿˴̇˼̂́̆ʼԫطψᏦᖯՕᖂנ. 立. ठषω۫ڇցԲՏנڣठΔृ܂ਢᏅ༄ฐټऱկ۵Օᖂඒ ˝˴˶˾ʳ˗̂́́˸˿˿̌Δխृ܂. ‧ 國. 學. ࢤܒޅאऱᨠរΔԵ։࣫ഏᎾᣂএᓵխऱਙएኔᆠΔٵ܀ழΔՈ༼נڶڍ. ‧. ࣍ܓኔᆠऱᨠរፖऄΔृ܂ᛀီԱԳࢤፖഏ୮೯ᖲऱᣂএΔृش֧ܛԱխ. y. Nat. ࢬ༼ࠩऱഏ୮೯ᖲءઔߒ֮إຝ։ऱᓵਮዌΔՈ༉ਢഏ୮ऱዊᤌΕஎ᥈ፖܓ. er. io. sit. 墿ΔृشܓຍԿଡᐋ૿։࣫Աᢅཎፖભഏڇएࠅၞ۩ᖏฃᤁດऱഏ୮۩೯ ᖲΖڼ؆Δխኙ࣍ഏᎾྤਙࢌणኪΕߓอዌᓵፖᦞԺؓᘝΕഏᎾࠫ৫֗אሐᐚᨠ. n. al. Ch. i Un. v. ࢚ڇ؆ٌਙխࢬފዝऱߡۥᤜᠲຟڶৰऱထᕠΖᖞ᧯ۖߢΔຍء༼ࠎԱഏᎾ. engchi. ᣂএኔᆠᓵऱᇡጐտฯΔኙءᓵ֮ऱઔߒਮዌಥߜڍΖʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ψભഏਙए֮֏խऱኔᆠωԫਢխഏᤄᖂृ୪٘ࢬထΔृ܂ൕխഏ֮֏ऱ ᨠរנ࿇Δᇢቹᇞᤩભഏਙए֮֏խऱኔᆠΔ֮ີԫၲࡨش֧ܛশ۵Օᖂࣜݪቅ ΰ˦˴̀̈˸˿ʳ ˣˁʳ ˛̈́̇˼́˺̇̂́αඒऱ֮ࣔᓢડᓵΔൕሀ֮֏ऱီມᨠኘભഏኔᆠਙए ֮֏Ζխรԫຝ։൶ಘऱਢભഏփਙխऱኔᆠΔรԲຝ։ঞፋྡྷ࣍ભഏ؆ٌᏆ ऱኔᆠΔรԿຝ։ਢψᢞ৸ەΚփፖ؆Δኔፖუω ΖڇรԲຝ։Δृ܂ ༼ࠩભഏڂഏ୮ܓ墿ऱᏁޣΔۖڇ٤ឩ്ભഏऱਙएᐙԺፖ૨ࠃԺၦΔਢࠢ ীኔᆠऱ।Ζ܀ભഏاאނΕ۞ؑطᆖᛎΕഏᎾऄഗ៕ऱ٤ഏᎾ఼ݧ 12.
(21) ီᅝྥΔঞਢუᆠऱ।Ζृ܂უ૪ऱਢભഏऱ؆ٌ۩೯᜔ਢො።Աუ ᆠፖኔᆠΖኙڼΔृᎁࠐشאױᇞᤩભഏڇᗑ࠰چࢬං೯ऱᠱࡎۥΔ। ૿ՂਢԱ࠰ܗᗑ࠰ഏ୮اޓΔ܀ኔᎾՂথឆܶထ౨ᄭܓ墿ፖچᒴਙएऱەၦΔ ભഏاڤՈլԫࡳᔞ࣍شՂࢬڶഏ୮ΖྥۖΔאृ܂խഏԳᦞլ۞طऱᨠរࠐᓵ ૪ભഏਙए֮֏խऱኔᆠΔڍᨠរսߠೣᏅΔᖄીءऱەᏝଖૻڶΖʳ ʳʳʳʳʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ছ૿ࢬ༼ऱ֮ڃਢچᒴਙएᖂࢨഏᎾᣂএᖂऱઌᣂᓵထΔ൷Հࠐृല ڃፖءઔߒ֮إຝ։ઌᣂऱറࢨᒧີΔտฯܐᖏ৵Εભڇएࠅऱ؆ٌ೯ࢨ ΕભᣂএऱᓵထΔຍࠄᤄኙ֮ء൶ಘΕભڇएࠅऱᖏฃᤁດ༼ࠎԱ᠆ڍ༄ ऱรԲ֫ᇷறΖʳ. 立. ʳ. 政 治 大. ‧ 國. 學. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ πफጇࡎ৵ऱएࠅΚچᒴਙएऱܺቼፖኙભഏऱრොρ ΰGeorgia after the Rose. ‧. Revolution:Geopolitical Predicament and Implications for U.S. Policyαਢભഏຬ૨Օᖂ. y. Nat. ᖏฃઔߒᖲዌ࣍ ˅˃˃ˊ ڣԲִנठऱ֮ີΔृ܂ਢ ˦̉˴́̇˸ʳ ˘ˁʳ ˖̂̅́˸˿˿Δזױ֮ڼ।ભഏ. er. io. sit. ڇएࠅᖏฃᤁດऱભֱᨠរΖ֮խਐڇנছᤕᜤףᅩ٥ࡉഏխΔएࠅԫऴڶൎ௺ ऱඈႜٻΔ،ਢ່৵ԫଡףԵᗑمഏ୮ഏ࠰ऱഏ୮Ζ˅˃˃ˆ ڣफጇࡎ৵Δएࠅ. n. al. Ch. i Un. v. ޓፖᢅཎऱᗑ࠰ਙહሐۖቍΔएࠅ᧢اޓΔࠀެ֨ᇞެഏ୮։ါऱംᠲΔ ٵழՈᗨᄕ༈ףޣԵקપΖʳ. engchi. ृ܂ᎁᕁࡐڇएࠅऱچᒴਙएኙֱ۫ഏ୮ॺൄૹΔܑਢኙભഏۖߢΔ एࠅऱफጇࡎז।Աছᤕᜤഏ୮ፖऑխࣟچ֏اऱפګΔएࠅऱچۯᆜᨃ ،ګᖏฃᑐోΔਢᑛࠅՕຬ౨ᄭሎᙁऱሁஉֱ۫֗אഏ୮ၞԵխࠅፖॳ༄ۀऱ ሐΖᢅཎॣזڣ ˃ˌ ڇΔڂഏ୮ڜ٤ܓ墿ऱەၦΔࢴڇנएࠅቼփऱ૨ࠃ ഗچΔࠀຘመᇷܗएࠅቼփऱ։ᠦႨԺΔధᡏएࠅፖ։ᠦچऱኙᇩΔ༼ᠨֱ ૨ࠃᓢડऱױ౨ࢤΔᢅཎشܓ౨ᄭࠎᚨΕ၉࣐ࠫဪΕᆃሎΕᦀᠦᢅཎቼփए ࠅԳ֫Δᇢቹեឫएࠅऱޏاၞ࿓Δྥᢅཎࡨึآ౨פګΖʳ ʳ 13.
(22) ૿ኙᢅཎڇएࠅऱ؆ٌᖏฃΔભഏᚨᇠࠫࡳٽࠠছ៓ࢤऱਙΔۖ լਢ೯ऱᚨኙΖભഏଈ٣ૹᄅေ۷ፖᢅཎऱ؆ٌᣂএΔڇլ႞୭ࠟഏ؆ٌᣂ এऱছ༼ՀΔᥛ֭एࠅऱޏΖۖಾኙएࠅऱቼփᓢડΔঞؘᏁᖄԵഏᎾࢤ ऱፂࡉ۩೯ፖࡉؓ࠰ᓳิ៣Ζᆖᛎֱ૿Δᏺףኙएࠅऱ၉࣐གܗΔ༼ࠎएࠅڍޓ ऱ၉࣐ؑΖભഏࡴֱႊւᘭएࠅףԵקપΔףൎएࠅፖᑛኃ۴ഏऱ܂ٽΔᏺ ܂ٽᖲዌΔࠀދԵڍޓᇷᄭᣂ֊एࠅऱઌᣂᤜᠲΖ ˈʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ π˅˄ ધॣऱᑛਙएठቹρΰ ˧˻̂̈˺˻̇̆ʳ ̂́ʳ ̇˻˸ʳ ˣ̂˿˼̇˼˶˴˿ʳ ˠ˴̃ʳ ̂˹ʳ ˘̈̅̂̃˸ʳ ˴̇ʳ ̇˻˸ʳ. ˕˸˺˼́́˼́˺ʳ̂˹ʳ̇˻˸ʳ˧̊˸́̇̌ˀ˙˼̅̆̇ʳ˖˸́̇̈̅̌αԫ֮ኴᙕ࣍ཚ́˴˼̆̆̈˥ עʳˣ̂˿˼̇˼˶̆ʳ˴́˷ʳ˟˴̊Δਢ֮ ऱ᠏֮ີΔृ܂ਢᢅཎᤄऱ ˞˼̅˼˿˿ʳ˦̂˿̂̉˸̉Δהଈ٣༼ࠩԱ৵ᤕᜤழזΔመװऱ۞. 政 治 大. ए٥ࡉഏڇഏ୮ۯچՂऱञᤜΔࠀᜰࠏᎅࣔᐰዿرڍམᆖڂᆖᛎەۖైڂᐞףԵᢅ. 立. ್ࠅ؍Δ֗אएࠅቼփॳؒশ౿ࡉতႾඪࠅऱ։ါംᠲΖएࠅቼփऱ։ါംᠲ. ‧ 國. 學. ᄭ࣍ ˄ˌ˄ˋ ڣऱᖆऄΔᅝழ༉آലॳؒশ౿ፖতႾඪࠅជ᥆࣍एࠅऱጥᝤհ. y. Nat. Ζʳ. ‧. ՀΔۖਢലהଚជ᥆࣍ᤕᜤհՀऱਙए᧯Δຍທֲګ৵ࠟ۞ए٥ࡉഏڇഏ୮ۯچՂऱ. er. io. sit. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ˃˅ ࠩ༼ृ܂ધխᄐழΔՂ༉اڶග۞ެֆދऱ٣ࠏΔ܀չᏖॳؒশ౿ ፖতႾඪࠅ༉ڶຍᑌऱᦞࡋܓΛאڇऱൣႨۖߢΔॳؒশ౿ፖতႾඪࠅս. n. al. Ch. i Un. v. ྥլ֜ױ౨ᜰ۩اග۞ެऱֆދΖ܀ኙຍࠟଡਙएኔ᧯ۖߢΔڶչᏖࠡٽהऄऱᗑم. engchi. ֫ࡋΛতႾඪࠅګڣ ˅˅ˌ˄ ڇएࠅ٥ࡉഏऱ۞एڠΔᤕᜤழཚऱઊቤ։ࠀ ݔآەچᐞࠩᏆՒፖاගऱิګΔᖄીႾඪࠅ։ሶতΕקႾඪࠅࠟଡਙए ኔ᧯ΖᖕຍଡᒴطΔႾඪࠅԳڇഏᎾऄՂऱอԫۯچᚨਢٽऄऱΔ༉ٵڕᐚഏΕ ཏ೬ཎΕឌഏഏ୮Ζृ܂ᎁڇᢅཎፖᝨᓵऱ֭ՀΔতႾඪࠅৰݶ༉ ᄎᜰ۩ֆދΔᨃࠡፖקႾඪࠅۖٽԫΔᝨᓵᚨᇠᄎ֭ࠟഏمګԫଡᄅऱ ႾඪࠅഏΔۖլਢףԵᢅཎᜤ߶ΖؾছতႾඪࠅˈˌ ڶʸऱԳՑᖑڶᢅཎֆا ᦞΔۖऄ৳ፖඒᄎᙊፃ֗אᅝچऱᢅཎԳലᄎފዝഏ୮อԫऱૹߡۥΖʳ 5. Svante E. Cornell,“Georgia after the Rose Revolution:Geopolitical Predicament and Implications for U.S.. Policy,”ȐNY:Strategic studies institute, February 2007ȑ, pp.v~vi. 14.
(23) ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ॳؒশ౿ऱᏆᖄԳܘԺቫᇢᨃഏ୮ᗑمᛧഏᎾࢭᎁΔִ ˅ ڣ ˃˄ˋ˄ ڇڰΔॳؒ শ౿༉ਢᢅཎऱԫຝ։Δ˄ˌˋ ࠐڣൕآ։ᠦመΖᤕᜤمګ৵Δॳؒশ౿٣ਢګף ᅩ٥ࡉഏΔ৵ࠐګ؆ףऱ٥ࡉഏհԫΔፖएࠅΕࠅႾਈྥΕࠅભࠅ؍Կഏؓ ದ݄ؓΖྥۖΔ˄ˌˆ˃ ֲ ˊ˄ ִ ˇ ڣথޏជएࠅհՀऱ۞ए٥ࡉഏΖˉ ຍࠄᖵైڂ ऱिᆼΔګԱएࠅᗑم৵Δॳؒশ౿ፖতႾඪࠅլᣋრലอएᦞٌ༼ֺߺཎऱ ڂΖؾছऱᢅཎᚨᇠᄎւᘭॳؒশ౿ऱᗑۯچمΔ๕ཎઝᄎᤩנڍᆖᛎܓ墿Ι ڕᣂ࿔ٵᅩΕᆖᛎ८ᘜ࠰ࡳΖؒॳڇশ౿ˈˊ ڶʸऱࡺاᖑڶᢅཎֆᦞاΔॳؒশ౿ ፖᢅཎࠓٽਢ᧤ٽᙀऱΔؒॳ࣠ڕ܀শ౿ᙇᖗᗑمΔࠟഏലᄎࡳ࠰પΔյઌࢭ ᎁᠨૹഏᤄΖঞՂ༼ֺߺཎࠡኔՈڶᖲᄎᨃॳؒশ౿ఎڇएࠅΔؘ܀ႊፖᢅཎ. 政 治 大. ؒॳ֗אশ౿ਙࢌᓫ࠰ܒΔڇຍᑌऱൣउՀΔॳؒশ౿ױ౨ᄎګቝڜሐዿຍᣊഏ. 立. ୮Δॳؒশ౿ऱᏆᖄԳᄎٚଈઌΔףڕஞՕΕᖾΕో۫ᥞऱࠏΖएࠅؘႊ. ‧ 國. 學. قխمऱۯچΔᏆᖄၸᐋؘႊԱᇞהଚ ˌ˃ ॣזڣऱਙएᙑᎄנבᡓՕזᏝΔۖ. ‧. ᣄڃگא؈ՒΖᕣጥᑛՈڶৰڍ։ᠦႨԺΔה܀ଚཏሙᎁຍࠄᏆՒञᤜፖ৵ᤕ. y. sit. io. er. ʳ. Nat. ᜤچਢլچٵΔڂֱ۫լᄎւᤕᜤऱႨԺ༚ሌΖʳ. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ एࠅቼփऱ։ါംᠲਐנᢅཎ࠹ࢭإထ ˌ˃ זڣऱਙएᙑᎄΔኙֱ۫ࠐᎅΔ. n. al. Ch. i Un. v. הଚऱᑨრᢝࡨึإࣟڶඒፖഗᅮஈऱܑΔᢅཎऱٚ೭ᚨᇠਢ㩀ඵߪᑛԫ. engchi. ऱუऄΔ᠏ፖࣟإඒஈऱছᤕᜤچጹയຑΔլહধຍࠄመװऱ֖߶Δה܍א ଚףԵᑛᖞٽΖ֣ዿიፖছᤕᜤچऱᓢડຟፖᤕᜤऱرᇞڶᣂΔڼڂڇऱᢅ ཎᏆᖄԳᚨᇠ୶۞ࠫΕਙएཕᐝΔࠀࢭᖜᢅཎኙ࣍ᗑ࠰ᏆՒञᤜऱຂٚΔԺআছ ᤕᜤچمګᑛࠅᜤᅩΔᨃመװऱᅩ֖ंڕᢅऱ௧ԿഏઌॾຍଡਙएൣႨΖতཎࢮ֛ ऱرᇞயᚨױ౨ᄎឩཋ۟ᗑ࠰چࢨᢅཎΔᐰዿرڍΕएࠅΕ܌ᥞΕࠅႾਈྥ ຟᚨᇠ᠃შ༼ΔᢅཎՈਢΔլᚨ٦መ৫۞ॾ۞የΔᎁຍլᄎᐙࠩᢅཎऱഏ փፖԳاΖʳ. 6. Kirill Solovev, “Thoughts on the Political Map of Europe at the Beginning of the Twenty-First Century,” Russian Politics and Law, Vol.47, No.3(2009), pp. 14. 15.
(24) ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ˞˼̅˼˿˿ʳ˦̂˿̂̉˸̉ ឈྥਢഏᤄᖂृΔڇ܀ຍᒧ֮ີᇙΔս౨אለড়ᨠऱኪ৫૪৵ ᤕᜤழཚऱاගञΔॳؒশ౿ፖতႾඪࠅ։ါംᠲऱࠐطԱᇡኔᎅࣔΔࠀ༼ נԫࠄױ౨נऱᇞެֱऄፖནΔݙृ܂܀ᒚऱழၴរਢڣ ˋ˃˃˅ ڇᓢડհ ছΔࢬृ܂אᅝழᚨՈ౨უࠩΔᢅཎᄎڂতႾඪࠅऱ։ါംᠲፖएࠅե֩ઌ ٻΔᨃ։ါംᠲྤऄࡉؓᇞެΖʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ πऴ൷૿ኙભഏЁॺڇᑅኙፖᤁٽၴρΰ˙˴˶˸ʳ ̇̂ʳ ˙˴˶˸ʳ ̊˼̇˻ʳ ˔̀˸̅˼˶˴ʳ ˀʳ ˕˸̇̊˸˸́ʳ ˡ̂́˶̂́˹̅̂́̇˴̇˼̂́ʳ ˴́˷ʳ ˖̂́̉˸̅˺˸́˶˸αՈਢԫᒧ֮ऱ᠏֮Δृ܂ਢഏᤄऱ ˦˸̅˺˸˼ʳ ˟˴̉̅̂̉Ζຍᒧ֮ີִ ˃˄ ڣ ˋ˃˃˅ ࣍ګݙΔਢԫᒧԵಘᓵᓢડऱ֮ີΔ֮ີԫၲ. 政 治 大. ࡨऱ֧ߢΔܛृ܂ൎᓳܐڇᖏ৵ऱվֲΔڶԳᄎܡᎁ৵ܐᖏழזऱݝႨֺԼն. 立. ڣছࢬუऱᓤᠧڍΔהᎁվֲݺଚإڇഏᎾ᧯ߓ᠏ীऱૹၸΖ؆ף. ‧ 國. 學. ऱٲᖲᐙထᢅཎΕભഏΕᑛፖ٤Δຍຟؘႊូࡏ࣍एࠅ᜔อآᆖ৸ᑵ. ‧. ᐞऱ૨ࠃ۩೯ΖڻڼᓢડՈᨃഏᎾᣂএࣔி֏Δˌ˄˄ ࠃٙ৵Δ٤ᚨᇠᄎቸ. y. Nat. ԫીኙڶࢬݼऱਗᖏፖஎࢠᆠΔᢅཎፖભഏॳڇ༄୶ۀၲ܂ٽڼऱᣂএΖ܀. er. io. sit. ਢΔࠡڇ৵ऱْࢮ܌ᖏञΔᢅཎথؾᅯԱભഏऱ۞ՕΔᢅཎऱᣋඨࠀڶኔΔ ՈլवሐչᏖΛ˅˃˃ˋ ڣऱᓢડᑊԱߓ᧯Εᑛڜ٤᧯ߓፖભᣂএऱ. n. al. Ch. ᝲ༞టኔ૿ΔՂךየಮ৸Εွፖ۞ུݺᣑΖʳ. engchi. i Un. v. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ۞ൕएࠅڣ ˇ˃˃˅ ڇ֚ᇢቹࣳאԺࡹࣚতႾඪࠅΔᢅཎ༉լឰཚඨए ࠅ౨ജૹᄅ৸ࣳאەԺᇞެംᠲऱֱڤΔᕣጥᓢડᡨ࿇৵լױ౨נܐᖏΔᓢડՈլ ᄎዝ᧢ګՕᑓᖏञΖᖕऄഏ᜔อ៳ઝٳΰˡ˼˶̂˿˴̆ʳ ˦˴̅˾̂̍̌αऱᎅऄΔٲڻڼᖲ ڶທڍګց֏ΔᄕՈլڇژΖᖵࡻएࠅ᜔อ᜔ਢ࢙ီࠌؓࡉشኙᇩऱֱ ࠐڤᇞެംᠲΔ˅ˌˌ˄ ڇЁ˄ˌˌˇ ڣཚၴנऱᖏञՑᇆψएࠅԳऱएࠅω Δଶ៳ ૭ࠅΰ˭̉˼˴˷ʳ˚˴̀̆˴˾˻̈̅˷˼˴α۞աৰؿએچሔહഏ୮ᏆՒऱݙᖞࢤΖᢅཎאԳߪڜ٤ ፖঅᥨᢅཎԳऱᆠ೭Δഗ࣍ഏᎾऄۖ૰ፖᖏञΔᢅཎࠀॺ೯࿇ದᖏࠃृΖ ᢅཎᎁ࣠ڕएࠅऱਙᦞ౨ٌطቝر౿ΰ˭̈̅˴˵ʳ˭˻̉˴́˼˴αຍᑌױᔾࣔऱ ԳΔ߷Ꮦᢅཎኙएࠅऱࠀاլᄎףڍե௫Δ࣠ڕ܀एࠅऱ༳ਙृਢᗑဪृࢨ 16.
(25) ࣶੌڶႜٻΔاঞਢڶრᆠऱΖ٦ृΔભഏኙ࣍एࠅऱ૨ࠃགܗΔࠀլ౨ך։ ڶچய൳ࠫ៳ݦፂܓΰˠ˼˾˻˸˼˿ʳ˦˴˴˾˴̆˻̉˼˿˼αਙࢌΔࠃኔՂΔ֘ۖቔᚐԱԫଡլױᔾ լױቃྒྷऱਙᦞߨٲٻᙠऱሐሁΖ ˊʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ˼˸˺̅˸˦ ृ܂ʳ ˟˴̉̅̂̉ ਢᢅཎऱ؆ٌຝ९Δڼڂຍᒧ֮ີזאױ।ഏऱࡴֱᨠ រΔה।قֱऱ۩೯ݙ٤ฤٽഏᎾऄΔֱ۫ऱլኔᖄڴށԱֱऱ۩೯Δ˅˃˃ˋ ڣᓢડऱᐙ၌መچףΔהᎅࠩژऱݧ఼ਢྤயऱΔאભഏ ଈऱᄕਢಮ৸ڶࠠᑨࢤڇऱٲᙠΔֲ৵ભഏലᄎດዬໜ؈ᚌ။ۯچΖ᜔ה ༼ࠩ ˅˃˃ˋ ڣᓢડലᄎᨃᰳբՆᏁ᧢ޏऱᑛڜ٤᧯ߓૹิΔՈലᨃ ᧢ऱڜޓ٤Ζאृ܂ᢅཎऱᨠរΔඖ૪Ա ˅˃˃ˋ ڣᓢડऱছڂ৵࣠Δຏᒧ֮ີ. 政 治 大. սլࠩߠ܍ለೣᏅऱඖ૪ֱڤΔ܀ຍᑌऱᨠរսءઔߒ༼ࠎԱլ֟ױऱᢅཎ. 立. უऄΔኙءઔߒࠠڶ৫ऱەᏝଖΖʳ. ‧ 國. 學. ʳ. ‧. ʳ ʳ π৵៳ݦፂܓΚܓ墿ፖᏝଖρ ΰ˔˹̇˸̅ʳ˧̆˾˻˼́̉˴˿˼ˍ˜́̇˸̅˸̆̇̆ʳ˴́˷ʳ˩˴˿̈˸̆αٵृ܂ᑌՈ. y. Nat. ਢഏᤄऱ˔˿˸˾̆˴́˷̅ʳ ˗̈˺˼́Ζຍᒧ֮ີፖ؆ٌຝ९ऱᨠរሼٵΔܧנᢅཎاග. er. io. sit. ᆠृऱᨠរΔהᎁ ˅˃˃ˋ ڣऱᓢડᑊנભഏല۞ߪऱܓ墿ီ٤ऱᏝଖ ᨠΔۖطભഏ୬ऱழזբᆖޔԱΖृ܂ᎁऱᏝଖᨠࠀॺࠐ۞۫ᑛࢨקભΔ. n. al. Ch. i Un. v. ᢅཎՈլਢᑛഏ୮Δڂ،ז।ऱᗑऱᑛࠅ֮ࣔΖ˅˃˃ˋ ڣᓢડאױᨃ. engchi. ᢅཎऱ۫֏ᆠृլཊ٦༼֏۫נऱޣΔڂຍᑌ࣍ٵહܒԱᢅཎऱᏝଖፖܓ ˋ. 墿Ζ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ 7. Sergei Lavrov, “Face to Face with America - Between Nonconfrontation and Convergence,” Russian Politics and Law, Vol.47, No.3(2009), pp. 50. 8 Aleksandr Dugin, “After Tskhinvali:Interests and Values,” Russian Politics and Law, Vol.47, No.3(2009), pp. 6. 17.
(26) ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ π ն ֲ ᖏ ञ ऱ ᄭ ֗ א طᐙ ρΰ ˧˻˸ʳ ˙˼̉˸ˀ˗˴̌ʳ ˪˴̅ˍʳ ˣ̅˸˿˼̀˼́˴̅̌ʳ ˖˴̈̆˸̆ʳ ˴́˷ʳ ˖̂́̆˸̄̈˸́˶˸̆αԫ֮ऱृ܂ਢ˦˸̅˺˸˼ʳˠ˴̅˾˸˷̂́̂̉ΔהൎᓳᖵऱైڂᨈګԱᓢડΔ ᤕᜤᙊፃऱᐙڇ໌ףທԱլࢭᎁऱ۞ए٥ࡉഏΔഏᎾᛩቼॴᡶԱהଚऱᗑ مΔٍྤऄࡉؓچᇞެچࢤऱञጤΖፖࠡהՕڍᑇऱေᓵ୮ઌٵΔהᎁຍଡᓢડ լᄎਢᄅܐᖏऱၲጤΔᓢડ।قထԲڻՕᖏ࣍ႁዿሒ֗ंࡖڻ৬مऱഏᎾڜ٤᧯ ߓբᆖرڤإޔᇞΔڇઝֱ۫ڍഏ୮ࢭᎁፖॳؒশ౿ΕতႾඪࠅ ᢅཎࢭᎁऱൣउՀΔഏᎾਙए؈װԱ٥ڶऱঞፖᑑᄷΔൎᦞഏ୮ऱਙएߏܓലފዝ ૹऱެߡۥΖ ˌʳ ʳ. 政 治 大. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ᢅཎᤄऱृ܂ᕣጥאլٵऱߡ৫ࠐᇞᤩᓢડΔה܀ଚথຟࠩԫࠄᣊۿऱ. 立. ᓵΔהଚܑᣂࣹᢅཎڇᓢડխऱ۩֗אኙഏᎾڜ٤ፖભഏᦞԺऱ૿ᐙΖ. ‧ 國. 學. ઌኙچΔएࠅፖ܌ᥞऱࠀृ܂լ֭ᢅཎᖂृऱᨠរΔڇഏՠ܂ऱएࠅᖂ. ‧. ृ ˚˸̂̅˺˸ʳ˞˻˸˿˴̆˻̉˼˿˼ ᎁᢅཎڇएࠅऱᖏञലᖄીᢅཎഏᎾषᄎࡰمΔהᎁ. y. Nat. ᢅཎشܓ᧯ࠐዻ೯ᖏञΔࠀղᢅཎտԵᓢડऱطΔᢅཎ࣠ڕᤉᥛቫᇢ. er. io. sit. ౡ૰२ᔣഏ୮ࢨࢴൕएࠅऱᏆՒ૨Δֱ۫ഏ୮ലᄎඈ؞ᢅཎΔࠀቫᇢؓࡉא ऱ֫ࠐআࠌᢅཎਙᦞऱޓ૯Ζʳ. n. al. ʳ. Ch. engchi. i Un. v. ʳ ʳ խഏᤄᖂृᔤ壅ᒳऱψਝॺᅩ֖ΔՈॺᑅԳЁᤕᜤᇞ᧯৵ऱભᣂএΰ˄ˌˌ˄ Ё˅˃˃ˈαω٥։ՂΕՀࠟ࠴Δᔤ壅ਢխഏՕຬᢅཎઔߒऱૹၦ్ᖂृΔڇഏփאױ ࠩބהطڍᒳထऱᢅཎઔߒထ܂ΖءՂ࠴ऱรԫີଈ٣ڃᤕᜤऱ؆ٌᙊขΔ ᎅࣔ ˄ˌˋˈ ۟ ˄ˌˌ˄ ڣऱᤕભᣂএΔ൷ထृ܂ಘᓵԱᤕᜤᇞ᧯৵Δኙભ؆ٌਙऱዝ ᧢ፖભኙ؆ٌਙऱዝ᧢Δࠡխٍ൶ಘԱݦؒ۔ΕਲࣥቅΕ՛ؒݦԿۯભഏ᜔อڇ ٚཚփኙᢅཎਙऱዝ᧢Ζ؆ΔխՈ։ີᎅࣔԱભᆖ၉ᣂএΕுڜ٤ᤜᠲΕ קપࣟឩΕᗑ࠰چऱભᤁञΕ֘எᤜᠲ֗אխભԿߡᣂএΖʳ. 9. Sergei Markedonov, “The Five-Day War: Preliminary Causes and Consequences,” Russian Politics and Law, Vol.47, No.3(2009), pp. 7. 18.
(27) ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ᒧີᇙኙءઔߒ່ࠠەᏝଖऱᅝ᥆ભڇতףऱञኆԫᆏΔאृ܂ᇡาऱ ֮ᇷறΔඖ૪ԱڰཚΕભڇएࠅऱ؆ٌਙፖᖏฃᤁດΔױ൦ຍءऱழၴ រႛ۟ ˅˃˃ˈ ڣΔኙءઔߒऱழၴᒤս࿑լߩΖψཏࠇԶڣΚᢅཎ༚ᘋհሁΚ ˅˃˃˃̑˅˃˃ˋ ؆ٌ࠴ωਢ᠆ဎፖᔤ壅נִ ˈ ڣ ˋ˃˃˅ ڇठऱറΔٵᑌਢطᔤ壅ፖ ᒳऱᢅཎઔߒထ܂Δຍءऱழڣ ˋ˃˃˅ ۟ۼݧΔխኙཏࠇചਙԶڣխ؆ٌᖏ ฃऱዝ᧢ޓڶຑᥛࢤऱᎅࣔΔೈԱኙભᆖᛎᣂএΕᖄᐘᗧᤜᠲΕקપࣟឩΕᠱۥ ࡎΕ֘எᤜᠲݙޓڶᖞऱտฯΔ؆Δृ܂Ո༼ࠩԱᢅཎኙᗑ࠰چΕᑛΕࠅ ΕࢮԭભΕॺऱ؆ٌฃ֗א౨ᄭ؆ٌᤜᠲΖʳ ʳ. 政 治 大. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ݳદࢬထψཏࠇ߶ڜհሐΚᢅཎ२ᔣ؆ٌωԫΔנठ࣍ ˅˃˃ˉ ִ ˄˄ ڣΔ. 立. խรԫີኙᢅཎ२ᔣچऱچᒴਙएॺڶൄᇡኔऱտฯΔנ༼ृ܂ᤕᜤᇞ᧯৵ᢅ. ‧ 國. 學. ཎچᒴਙएᛩቼऱքរ᧢֏Κ˄ˁధᡏԱא๕ཎઝխ֨ऱᑛࠅچᒴਙएՕ़ၴΖ˅ˁ. ‧. ᢅཎΕ܌ᥞΕػᢅཎኙᤕᜤࣳᇘԺၦऱ։໊ΔؚధԱխࣟᑛچൄࣳᇘԺၦ. y. Nat. ऱؓᘝΖˆˁᢅཎऱࡌᢰڜ٤ᛩቼ༞֏Ζຍਢਐקપࣟឩኙᢅཎࠐऱڜ٤. er. io. sit. ౡΖˇˁᢅཎࡌᢰچऱႨԺᒤլឰ݀ჅΔᑛᅩऱԫ᧯֏ᑪኙᗑ࠰ഏ୮ขسԱൎ Օऱ֧ܮԺΔᤕᜤچլ٦ਢอԫऱچᒴਙए़ၴΖˈˁᢅཎچᒴਙएխ֨ऱ. n. al. Ch. i Un. v. ഏᎾڇࡉۯچഏᎾࠃ೭խऱ։ၦࣔ᧩Հ૾Ζˉˁᢅཎսྥڶඈೈፖֱ֮۫ࣔհၴऱ. engchi. ሶᎶΔՂऱբၲ࿇ഏ୮ኙᢅཎսྥڶژጊᐞΔᠨֱڇᏝଖᨠՂऱ։ࣴᣄאᚦ ٽΖ ˄˃ ڇཏࠇ᜔อૹ༼Օഏ؆ٌΔᕁࡐ៱ڶႨԺठቹऱ؆ٌਙՀΔאՂքរᚊរ ᅪऱਐנᢅཎچᒴਙएࢬ૿ᜯࠩऱܺቼΖڼ؆Δृ܂ൕ֮֏ΕᆖᛎΕᖏฃᜤᅩΕቤ ञᤜΕֱچᓢડק֗אપࣟឩᐋ૿Δኙཏࠇ᜔อழཚᢅཎऱ२ᔣ؆ٌԱԫߓ ٨։࣫ಘᓵΖຍءထ֧ܮ່܂ृऱֱچΔԯਢچאृ܂ᒴਙएऱߡ৫֊ԵΔԵ נऱᎅࣔԱᢅཎፖएࠅ։ܑᗑم৵ऱ؆ٌᣂএΖʳ ʳ ʳ 10. ʳ ݳદΔཏࠇ߶ڜհሐΚᢅཎ२ᔣ؆ٌΰࠇקΚխഏषᄎઝᖂנठषΔ˅˃˃ˉ ִ ˄˄ ڣα Δ ˅ДˊΖ 19.
(28) ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ྉᛑڇψᢅཎ֗ࠡࡌᢰൣႨհઔߒωԫխΔኙ࣍ᤕᜤرᇞ৵Δᢅཎፖࡌ ᢰᔣഏऱچᒴਙएԱԫߓ٨ऱ૪ΖխലᢅཎፖףΕ㠪௧چऱᢰΔ։ ԿᐋᗶᢰΔ ΰቹ ˄ЁˇαรԫᐋփᔣΔܶץᢅཎᜤ߶ቼփऱሒٳཎࡖ٥ࡉഏΕ ߫٥ࡉഏΕײٱչ٥ࡉഏΕקႾඪࠅˀॳᥞࠅ؍٥ࡉഏΕ֣ዿሒЁ֣ዿዿ٥ ࡉഏΕْ৾ࢮЁ֊ዿ܌ཎ٥ࡉഏΕॳ૭٥ࡉഏΰ˔˷̌˺˸̌˴αࢮ܌֗אཎᘭሒዿᢰ ΖรԲᐋ२ᔣΔܶץएࠅΕࠅႾਈྥΕࠅભࠅ؍Կଡছᤕᜤףᅩ٥ࡉഏΖร ԿᐋঞᔣΔ۞ܶץ০ழཚࠐאऱႚอᔣഏΔՒۘࠡፖْிΖ ˄˄ʳ ʳ ቹ 1Ё4 ᢅཎڇچףऱԿᐋᗶᢰ. 學. ‧ 國. 立. 政 治 大 ๕ཎઝ. փᔣΚሒٳཎࡖΕ߫ΕײٱչΕקႾඪࠅΕ֣ዿሒЁ ֣ዿዿΕْ৾ࢮЁ֊ዿ܌ཎΕࢮ܌ཎᘭሒዿΕॳ૭. y. Nat. er. io. sit. ᔣΚՒۘࠡΕْி. al. ‧. २ᔣΚࠅႾਈྥΕएࠅΕࠅભࠅ؍. ʳ. v. n. ᇷறࠐᄭΚྉᛑΔᢅཎ֗ࠡࡌᢰൣႨհઔߒΰፕؑקΚߐᇷಛઝݾΔ2008 ڣ2 ִαΔ 103Ζ. ʳ. Ch. engchi. i Un. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ փᔣਐऱਢקچףΔᢅཎගፖᅝچऱጟගΕࡲඒΕᖵΕ֮֏ᣂএለ ᜳஇΔ๕ཎઝྤᓵਢڇ০ࢨᤕᜤழཚຟᣄݙא٤൳ࠫᇠΔקףԾڂ㠪௧ऱई ᇷᄭፖفईጥᒵऱመቼΔچᒴᆖᛎܓ墿᧩ထΔࠌޓᅝچឫլឰΖ߫ംᠲਢק چף່ཟ֫ऱਙएᣄᠲΔࠟڻऱ߫ᖏञፖᢅཎቼփऱஎࢠސᚰᨃ๕ཎઝᅝ ݝ႞ຘᆰΖʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ २ᔣܛতچףΔٍጠ؆ףΔڇԲԼԫધছΔᢅཎፖएࠅऱᒔ ࡳᢰᠨֱഏᒵ ˇ˃ʸΖڇᤕᜤழཚΔᢅཎፖएࠅאസኜጿऱࡳࠐݮچ ᆠഏᒵΔᅝழएࠅऱᏆᖄԳਢܘԺऱ൳ࠫഏփऱᏆՒΔۖڤإڶޣፖ 11. ྉᛑΔᢅཎ֗ࠡࡌᢰൣႨհઔߒΰፕؑקΚߐᇷಛઝݾΔ2008 ڣ2 ִα Δ 104Ζ 20.
(29) ᢅཎቤ։ࣔᒔऱഏᒵΔࠟഏڇഏᒵՂऱञᤜࠀآᨈګՕጞΖ˅˃ ધ ˌ˃ ࠟזڣഏ ᗑم৵Δቤञᤜᙟܛ௬Ղឺ૿Ζڼ؆Δॳؒশ౿ፖতႾඪࠅऱֱچ։ᠦႨԺٍ֧ ದᢅཎፖएࠅऱᎼΔᖄીࠟഏམᆖᡨ࿇ࣳᇘᓢડΖ˄ˌˌ˅ ۟ ˄ˌˌˆ ڣཚၴΔᢅ ཎ૨ၷڇᢅཎਙࢌڤإآᦞऱणउՀΔ࠰ؒॳܗশ౿ऱ։ᠦႨԺᚰඓएࠅਙࢌ ૨Δڼ৵ᢅཎԾؒॳشܓশ౿ऱ։ါᤜᠲٻएࠅᅝݝਜᚘΔޣएࠅףԵᗑم ഏ୮ഏ࠰ࠀᆟႃ᧯ڜ٤යપΔԫֱ૿ΔᢅཎথԾٵழࢴഏփاගᆠޣ ൷ॳؒশ౿ףԵᢅཎᜤ߶ऱࡅᩃΖྥۖΔ๕ཎઝࠀآല૨ࠃՂऱפګ᠏९Նऱ ᖏฃפګΔ๕ཎઝྤऄᇞެएࠅቼփऱ։ါംᠲΔՈ؈װ༼ֺߺཎፖᤕࡅۏᓳ ೖृऱॾױ৫Δ࣠ᢅཎլ܀ᖿᚐԱקףऱ։ᠦᆠृΔՈ༞֏Աएࠅፖ ᢅཎऱ؆ٌᣂএΖ ˄˅ʳ. 立. 政 治 大. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ڇতႾඪࠅΔ๕ཎઝፖקႾඪࠅਙࢌආ࠷ለᄵࡉऱمΔ˄ˌˌ˅ ڣᢅཎऱ. ‧ 國. 學. ֆاᓤެࠟޣଡႾඪࠅૹᄅอԫΔ܀থൕآᎁటەᐞΖতႾඪࠅቼփڶڍ. ‧. ऱएࠅԳΔፖॳؒশ౿լٵऱਢהଚࠀآՕᑓᦀດΖᕋฮڇতႾඪࠅપڶԫ. y. Nat. ᛜ૨Ժऱ૨ΔټᆠՂਢፂࡉؓΔ܀๕ཎઝऱؾऱথਢݦඨאױຘመ૨ࠃڇژঅڶ. n. ʳ. al. er. io. ીࠟഏᣂএֲዬ༞֏Ζʳ. sit. ኙতႾඪࠅऱᐙԺΔᢅཎፖएࠅڂගᆢ։ါᤜᠲۖขسऱᎼፖෲݲΔᖄ. Ch. engchi. i Un. v. ʳ ʳ ʳ ʳ ψૹᢅཎЁཏࠇऱኙ؆ᖏฃፖ؆ٌਙωਢխഏᤄᖂृؐᏕዊ˄˄ ڣ ˋ˃˃˅ ڇ ִנठऱറΔؐᏕዊڇխኙ࣍ཏࠇऱ؆ٌਙፖભᣂএڶৰऱထᕠΔࠩ༼ڔ ᢅཎਢຬՂऱխ֨ΔۖભഏڇԲڻՕᖏ৵ګ௧Ղ֮ࣔऱխ֨Δഗ࣍ຬᦞ ፖ௧ᦞءڇᔆՂऱฆΔࠟഏةՆࢤऱኙݼലլᄎ؈ΔࠟഏऱഏᎾܓ墿ലਢةᓢ ˄ˆ ડऱΔৰᣄሒګԫીࢤऱ܂ٽፖߠᇞΖ ႛጥ ˌ˄˄ ࠃٙ৵Δᠨֱଈڻ༉߫ംᠲᒷᙬΔ. ٥ٵኙݼஎࢠᆠΖ܀ભഏՈࠃ ˄˄ˌ شܓٙ৵ؚᚰஎࢠᆠऱߜᖲΔኙᢅཎᔣ߶ऱ ਙᆖࠃ೭ףጹዶຘΔࠡࠠ᧯ࠃኔאױ।࣍ᗑ࠰Կଡഏ୮ઌᤉ࿇سᠱࡎۥΔ˅˃˃ˆ ˄˅. ྉᛑΔᢅཎ֗ࠡࡌᢰൣႨհઔߒΰፕؑקΚߐᇷಛઝݾΔ2008 ڣ2 ִα Δ 115~116Ζ. ˄ˆ. ؐᏕዊΔૹᢅཎЁཏࠇऱኙ؆ᖏฃፖ؆ٌਙΰࠇקΚ೭ٱ塢Δ2008 ڣαΔ 17Ζ 21.
Outline
相關文件
Incorporated Management Committees should comply with the terms in this Code of Aid and abide by such requirements as promulgated in circulars and instructions issued by the
Students are asked to collect information (including materials from books, pamphlet from Environmental Protection Department...etc.) of the possible effects of pollution on our
Wang, Solving pseudomonotone variational inequalities and pseudocon- vex optimization problems using the projection neural network, IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks 17
Define instead the imaginary.. potential, magnetic field, lattice…) Dirac-BdG Hamiltonian:. with small, and matrix
Attributable to increasing rent of housing and expenses of house maintenance, rising prices in summer clothing and footwear, as well as fresh vegetables, the indices of Clothing
Having regard to the above vision, the potential of IT in education and the barriers, as well as the views of experts, academics, school heads, teachers, students,
Microphone and 600 ohm line conduits shall be mechanically and electrically connected to receptacle boxes and electrically grounded to the audio system ground point.. Lines in
Therefore, this paper bases on the sangha of Kai Yuan Monastery to have a look at the exchange of Buddhist sangha between Taiwan and Fukien since 19th century as well as the
