mpchen@ntnu.edu.tw
! " # $ %& ' ()*+ ,- . + /01 2 3 # $ 4 5 6 7 8 9 :; <4 ; = ) > ? @A )B 7 8 9 : 0C D 4 E F )2 3 7 8 9 : 4 G <)H > ? H I )J K ,- . + / LM 2 3 4 7 8 9 :6N O P Q R 4 <S 0! " )T 4 U P VQ R WB X Y Z1.
[ \ ] & ^ 4 %_ ) ` a b c d e 2 f 4 & ^ g h (Paris,Colineau, Lu & Linden, 2005) i j k l)
C D- . + /m N n o [ p p 4 q r * + r sp t u)v w r sxy z { 4 | (> } ~, 1997; Sweller, 1988) P ! 4 x)0C D @ Dn o *+ 4 + /)m C D j e " 4 (Z r g } g h ) 4 *+ ) { r & ( ¡ Z¢ £ ¤)1995) ¥¦) O P §¨ © - . + / l ª « ¬ 4 " Q )1 ® F ¯ { 4 G 4 x) °*+ , - . + /± °J K ,- . + /±$ ² ³ ´ )D 4 & u) ` µ ¶ ·
4 ¸" (Schunk, 1983; Whipp & Chiarelli, 2004;
Zimmerman, 2000))¥¦) ¹ $ l º » ub ¼ 4 ½ s¾ D 4 M ¿ 4 7 8 )¥¦ ¹ À 7 8 9 :Á <S
2.
2.1
 ` k Ã Ä k l 0<lÅ Æ Ç È É Ê ' , Å Æ z ~DÅ Æ Ë Ì 4 ¸" H Í l(Schunk, 1996) 0~D Å Æ Î Ï 4 ¸" )C ¦Ð r ] lÑ Ò )Ó Ô Õ Ö × ) l Ø × K 4 Ù (Bandura,1977) Fisher Baird(2005)k lÚ Û Ü & Ý2 f
Å Æ Î Ï *+ Ì Þ 4 ß ` )m à á â 4 ã ä ~ å Yi Davis(2003)¹ k læ . xç è 4 ' | ? z é ê *+ )m Á lÌ Þ )1 ¸" ë ç ì $ Ç È z ¸" l) í l4 î ï z ð ñ ò e Í 4 l Ç È ó ¿ 4 Ç È ~å ô õ k l ? z ~åö ÷ ¿ ø 4 & )ù ú ~å 4 ¿ û V)ü ý N ~åu )¥¦2 þ u (Learning by doing)) a e {4 ~å E F ) G 4 ~å X )i 0$ l @ 4 ( , 2001) MajorTaylor (2003) ë ) u{ 4 ~ å) ç è Pratt(1998)¹ 2 ë ª 4 & u). Ð 4 [ ; <) u2 f \ ï 4 . )m { 4 Ç È ~å) ? i · ` [ ¿ û 4 & ^ 1 Û L*Ð ~å 4 ¿ û V
Schnotz Rasch(2005) z k lÇ È Å Æ ! {Ô " # ) $ ,K (Ç È )à 2 f % ù & )¥lK ¸" ë ' Q () * | ¸ 4 K )/Ñ c+ 4 é ê , - 4 . Ý) ! Á ¯ j 4 k à / 1 0 Á 6Ì 1 ,K (Å Æ )2 f 0 Á & )K e 2 f 4 " 2 Ì 1 03 4 5 6 :7 Ì 1 ) 8 9 %: $ ; è 4
2.2
z [ Ï â O P 6 4 < =(Ma & Liu, 2005; Tsai & Tsai, 2003) JooZBongChoi(2000)! "
º » u) 4 ¸" $ X > ) ? T ) @ A 4 ¸" ? è Ren(1999) 1 @ A %)! " ? T ) O P B 5 WB C ) @ A $ ? è Ren ½ Ý 2 T D O P 4 )ª z 2 3 4 0' | [ )¥lE M xF 4 Á ) e ÝG H 4 x¹ I J E ¯ ] ) Wù 4 ñ µ Wù 4 K ß )W ` ¼ K L ë ] 4 xF e M Margolis McCabe(2006)k lª N 01 P Ç È O . R (Ç È ) P Q ~å(Å Æ )@ 2 3 R Ç È O . R (Enactive
mastery)S Ð r â $ & 4 & R ª N 0
1 T [ G Í 4 U )H V m W G X U {[ # Y Z V)m â $ & · # $ X U ) C DX $ & ~å@2 3 4 P Q ~å(Vicarious experiences)S Å Æ Î Ï $ 4 & l â 4 Ù ª N 01 C D[ \ Ë Ì 4 *+ E F ] l^ _ w 4 :7 Ì )m ` a Ð r Ñ Ò )b B Á 4 c d)2 3 4
3.
e P f å | ) g \ l 1 - . + /ª Ù [ p p # $ h i )cj ' , [ ) 0Ó <l°J K ,- . + /±°*+ , - . + /± k À â O P Á ! \ 4 6 l m )z [ Ê â 6 4 < n <ø cj l ¸G < f <§) f <§ o p l°T ø ±)Ô q lB ø cg \ l # $ %& Z 7 8 9 : O P Q R # $ %& S # $ h i e r s §)t u P ! \ 4 %: 7 8 9 :S 7 8 h i Á 4 9 :& R O P Q R 4 A | 4 2 l! v w ª x y )E ß z {30| l {)}120|) å Ó E ß <T ~°J K ,- . + /ø ±°*+ ,- . + /ø ±) å× cj 4 f <§Ó <l°T ø ± °B ø ± 4 G t u R ¸Z 7 8 9 :¸Z O P Q R ¸)} \ ! G < g h Ñ R
3.1
¸P 1 Ð r Á h i 6 9 : f )¸9 R ~« ; [ 5 V å)Cronbach’s α = .96)« ; [ 5 Vk § ¸« ¬ <l Y R R 6 Z 7 8 P ) Y R s ! { 4 s)}
12s)e P Likert Scale4 # ) s1~5
<)<§? T Q ¸ S R ? T 7 8 9 :<¸P 1 Ð r â 7 8 4 9 : 7 8 9 :¸ l ¸u4 7 8 Y R ) ¸u4 [ ; < å e G u) 7 8 Y R 4 G < l 7 8 $ ) åç × ´
1 7 8 Y R [ s Á ) l 7 8 × $ 7 8 9 R ~ « ; [ 5 V å )Cronbach’s α = .90) 7 8 × 9 R ~« ; [ 5 V å) Cronbach’s α = .94)« ; [ 5 Vk §
3.2
u) r Á h i h i z ! w ª x y Q ¸(1 l )J Ó w X # · ¡ ¢ ~Ú Û £ 4 l® F u)à { 5 4 h i Ó X ¡ ¢ ~Ú Û £ ) 2 f ° ±) lª Ù h i ¤ F ª ¥ Á h i 4 & u¦ § ¨ © %)0ª « e r û 4 )C D e 2 f 4 - . + /)[ p [ p G h i 4 À ' ,4 [ ) 0<l°*+ ,- . + /±°J K ,- . + /±)1 < ¬ Ô « ¬ R (1) *+ ,- . + / *+ ,- . + /C D¾p p Ì 1 )*+ K m Å ® Ñ (1e *)*+ ,- . + / 1 r g ¯ ¿ # } 2 * p t 4 ¿ # )´1 K Ì 1 *+ K )Ñ ¦° p · q r *+ )m Á 01 E % # ª ° [ p ±^°Û [ p ±± ² 1 ³ [ p t 4 *+ )^z # ª °¿ ´ X [ p ±± ² µ 4 p t (2) J K ,- . + / J K ,- . + / M ¿ m K ¶ . h i ) cj p t 2 * K ¶ ). Ñ Ò Á h i Ñ ( 2 e *)J K ,- . + / 1 r g ¯ ¿ # } 2 * p t 4 ¿ # )· × I J ¸ E -. + /2 *Á ) r X ¹ Á º [ p t ) ` G » ¼ ½ ´ )Ç Í X )Ñ ¦° p · . p t K (1 *+ ,- . + / () *+ ¾ X ¿ À p t (2 J K ,- . + / () r . ¾ X ¿ À K3.3
O P Q R ¸P 1 Ð r 4 S R )¸9 R ~« ; [ 5 V å) Cronbach’s α = .98)« ; [ 5 Vk § ¸« ¬ t Á RU P V S V) (Y s !
{3s)}6s)e P Likert Scale4 # )
s1~5<)<§? T Q ¸ S R ? T U P V
k l ¬ U O P 4 & R )E F V
k le O P h i
4 E F & R
4.1 ! "
!
!
!
"
"
"
# $ %& 1  [ ¡ º à )Ä ~# $ e Å 4 s §Æ Ç )t u P ! \ 4 %: )! ø È # $ %& Ñ ¸1e *)Ô g ³ §< S L*) É J P ü LM f 6 ü LM f (F(1,116) = 5.394)p = .022))L *J K ,- . + /ø # $ e r %: W*+ , - . + /ø Ê4.2
7 8 9 :z # $ 9 lË r ! ø 7 8 9 :z ð {e 2 3 ) À 7 8 9 : × G <Á $ {tÌ ï ! ø Á × 7 8 È §Z f ² ZtÌ ï Ñ ¸2e *)T × 7 8 9 : * LM ² ³ V) z B 7 8 9 : {LM 2 3 6? H I )J K ,- . + /ø 7 8 9 : {LM 2 3 ) *+ ,- . + /ø × 7 8 9 : * LM ö g4.3
O P Q R e O P 4 S R )< N °U P V±°E F V± Y R Á <S U P V4 È §Z f ² Ï §Ñ ¸3e *)Ô g ³ §<S L*) É J P ü LM f 6 ü LM f (F(1,116) = 24.781)p < .001))L * 4 U P V' ()T W B Í µ M WX Y 4 Q R ¸1R! ø # $ %& È §Z f ² Ï § J K ,- . + / 11.70 8.995 30 T *+ ,- . + / 9.83 6.988 30 J K ,- . + / 14.30 7.818 30 B *+ ,- . + / 9.50 7.505 30 J K ,- . + / 13.00 8.457 60 Î Æ *+ ,- . + / 9.67 7.191 60 ¸2R! ø 7 8 9 :È §Z f ² ZÏ §tÌ ï Ï û ¸ t df 4.5722 .47969 60 T ø × 4.5611 .58381 60 .121 59 .904 3.6500 .63905 60 B ø × 3.8056 .66749 60 -2.175 59 .034 4.0500 .73088 60 J K ,- . + /ø × 4.2833 .70731 60 -3.033 59 .004 4.1722 .72743 60 *+ ,- . + /ø × 4.0833 .74567 60 1.061 59 .293 ¸3R! ø U P VÈ §Z f ² Ï § J K ,- . + / 4.5222 .55144 30 T *+ ,- . + / 4.3556 .81618 30 J K ,- . + / 3.7222 .87574 30 B *+ ,- . + / 3.8000 .69811 30 J K ,- . + / 4.1222 .83014 60 Î Æ *+ ,- . + / 4.0778 .80340 60
¸4R! ø E F VÈ §Z f ² Ï § J K ,- . + / 4.6444 .45430 30 T *+ ,- . + / 4.3000 .81814 30 J K ,- . + / 3.6889 .81148 30 B *+ ,- . + / 3.8556 .66484 30 J K ,- . + / 4.1667 .81071 60 Î Æ *+ ,- . + / 4.0778 .77232 60 (3R E F VÉ J P ( E F V4 È §Z f ² Ï §Ñ ¸4)Ô g ³ §<S L*) É J P L M f (F(1,116) = 3.966)p = .049))Ô É J P (Ñ (3e * ~Ð × ÑW! " ) ) lT %) k lJ K ,- . + /W{ F ® F â (F(1,59) = 4.064)p = .048)6 lB %) E F V4 Ò Ó * LM ² ³ (F(1,59) =.757)p = .388) ) O P J K ,- . + / %)T WB Ô ï â 4 E F V(F(1,59) =.31.672)p < .001)6 O P *+ ,- . + /%)T WB Ô ï â 4 E F V(F(1,59) = 5.332)p = .025)
5.
"
"
"
"
#
#
#
#
$
$
$
$
%
%
%
%
N # $ %& <S 0! " ) 1 *+ ,- . + /4 ' ,Á ) 0W9 4 %: u# $ )L* P *+ ,- . + /01 2 3 # $ 4 5 z # $ %& t u 4 %: )1 P 4 %: )¥¦ ½ Õ × 4 01 Ó ¦É Ê %: < Æ Ç )Á ¯ Ö × 4 <S 7 8 9 :; <4 ; = )0! " T × 7 8 9 :G <* LM ² ³ )ÝØ z Ø Ù Ú ? 7 8 Á R )¥H {X {4 6 z B 7 8 9 : H I )Ø Ù 0C D Û Û Ð r Ñ Ò 7 8 Á Ü )¥¦ 7 8 9 :G <{LM 2 3 ? H I )O P J K ,- . + /LM 2 3 4 7 8 9 :)0z J K ,- . + /2 f . 4 ß ` )C D. 4 $ & ~åm Ò Ó Í â 7 8 4 )¥¦2 3 Ð 4 7 8 9 :6*+ ,- . + /2 f 4 *+ ) ~DÅ ® × ) [ ï ] Ý · )¥¦*+ ,- . + / 7 8 9 :2 3 W* LM N O P Q R 4 <S 0! " )T 4 U P VQ R ÑB X Y E F V' () {É J P )T k lJ K ,- . + / 4 E F VW*+ ,- . + /T B k lÉ Ê 4 E F V Þ 1 Û )01 ! " J K ,- . + /{F 7 8 9 :4 2 3 ) G T WT 4 < n )ß k lO P J K ,- . + / l )Ý01 2 3 4 K ß ¥¦)à · J K ,- . + /0` m Å á Wj
4 %: # $ ) â ½ §¨ º » u
Ý2 f J K ,- . + / l
6.
&
&
&
&
'
'
'
'
¡ Z¢ ã ¤ (1995) x Ù Y 4 j
ä Æ !!!! """" #### $$$$ %%%%22)
10-15
> } ~ (1997) ä Æ © o ª 4 0V<
= &&&& '''' (((( )))) **** ++++ %%%%39(2))1-13
(2001) $ Ï 4 ~å , ,,, (((( %%%%59)
2-11
Bandura, A. (1977). Social Learning Theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Fisher, M., & Baird, D. E. (2005). Online learning
design that fosters student support, self-regulation, and retention. Campus - Wide
Information System, 22(2), 88-107.
Joo, Y. J., Bong, M., & Choi, H. J. (2000). Self-efficacy for self-regulated learning, academic self-efficacy, and internet self-efficacy in Web-based instruction.
Educational Technology, Research and Development, 48(2), 5-17.
Ma, Q., & Liu, L.(2005). The role of internet self-efficacy in the acceptance of web-based electronic medical records. Journal of
Organizational and End User Computing, 17(1), 38-57.
Major, H., & Taylor, D. (2003). Teaching for learning: Design and delivery of community college courses. The Community College Enterprise,
9(2), 85-102.
Margolis, H., & McCabe, P. P. (2006). Improving self-efficacy and motivation: What to do, what to say. Intervention in School and Clinic,
41(4), 218-227.
Paris, C., Colineau, N., Lu, S., & Linden, K. V. (2005). Automatically generating effective online help. International Journal on
ELearning, 4, 83-103.
Pratt, J. A. (1998). Where is the instruction in online help systems? Technical Communication, 45, 33-37.
Ren, W-H. (1999). Self-efficacy and the search for government information. Reference & User
Services Quarterly, 38(3), 283-291.
Schnotz, W., & Rasch, T. (2005). Enabling, facilitating, and inhibiting effects of animations in multimedia learning: Why reduction of cognitive load can have negative results on learning. Educational Technology,
Research and Development, 53(3), 47-58.
Schunk, D. H. (1983). Progress self-monitoring: Effects on children's self-efficacy and achievement. Journal of Experimental
Education, 57(2), 89-93.
Schunk, D. H. (1996). Learning Theories: An
Educational Perspective. (2nd ed.). Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice Hall.
Sweller, J. (1988.) Cognitive load during problem solving: Effects on learning. Cognitive
Science, 12, 257-285.
Tsai, M.-J., & Tsai, C.-C. (2003). Information searching strategies in web-based science learning: The role of internet self-efficacy.
Innovations in Education and Teaching International, 40, 43-50.
Tuovinen, J. E., & Sweller, J. (1999.) A comparison of cognitive load associcated with discovery learning and worked examples. Journal of
Educational Psychology, 91(2), 334-341.
Waldmann, M. R., & Hagmayer, Y. (2005). Seeing versus doing: Two models of accessing causal knowledge. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 31, 216-227.
Whipp, J.L., & Chiarelli, S. (2004). Self-regulation in a web-based course: A case study.
Educational Technology, Research and Development, 52(4), 5-22.
Yi, M. Y., & Davis, F. D. (2003). Developing and validating an observational learning model of computer software training and skill acquisition. Information Systems Research,
14(2), 146-169.
Zimmerman, B. J. (2000). Attaining self-regulation: A social cognitive perspective. In M. Boekaerts, P. R. Pintrich, & Moshe Zeidner (Eds.), Handbook of self-regulation (pp. 13-39). New York: Academic Press.
