環評爭訟案件行政救濟途徑之探討－以中科三期為例

ᅺγፕЎ!

Graduate Institute of Interdisciplinary Legal Studies College of Law

National Taiwan University Master Thesis

ᕉຑݾ೜ਢҹՉࡹ௱ᔮ೼৩ϐ௖૸ɡаύࣽΟයࣁٯ!

The Procedural Approach for an Administrative Litigation in Environmental Impact Assessment Cases᧶

A Case Study of the Third-Stage Construction of the Central Taiwan Science Park

ᅜ٩ಝ!

I-Ling Hsiung

ࡰᏤ௲௤Ǻܴܷ݅!റγ!

Advisor: Dr. iur. Ming-Hsin Lin

ύ๮҇୯ 102 ԃ 7 Д July, 2013^ġ

! ೭ҁፕЎǴҔа૶ۺၸѐޑ࿶ᐕǵࣽݤѤԃޑԋߏǴаϷǴ໒௴Π΋໘ࢤޑ ғࢲᆶࡷᏯǶ!

! ᖴᖴܴܷ݅ԴৣǴؒԖாǴךགྷԾρόޕၰϙሶਔংωૈֹԋፕЎǶᖴᖴா

ჹᏢғޑ஼ЈࡰᏤǴჹܭගрޑୢᚒᕴࢂόჇځྠӦ๏ϒБӛکࡌ᝼ǴΨ൧ख़Ꮲ ғ߄ၲޑόӕཀـǹགྷډாҔᅰӚᅿБݤǴ࿎ߦךזᗺֹԋፕЎǴᗋԖᜢЈᏢғ

҂ٰޑჴಞᆶғࢲǴૈԋࣁԴৣޑߐғǴڙډா೭ኬޑᜢЈکྣ៝Ǵ੿ޑࢂࡐ۩

ᅽǶ!

ᖴᖴα၂ہ঩݅ࢅఘԴৣکഡ࣓ᓉԴৣǴٿՏԴৣჹܭᏢғፕЎޑόىаϷ ᒱᅅϐೀǴᒃϪΞऐЈӦࡰ҅ѦǴ٠ගٮࡌ᝼অׯޑБӛǴᡣᏢғӵ؍ࡾ॥ǵᕇ

੻ؼӭǴΨ௴วᏢғόӕय़ӛޑࡘԵǹѝࢂӢᏢғޑૈΚԖज़ǴᅰΚঅׯࡕޑፕ ЎёૈϝคݤၲډாॺޑයࡑǴΨఈாॺـፊǶ!

! ᖴᖴ၏ࡓৣၟη₄ۊǴᖴᖴգॺޑႴᓰکྣ៝Ƕாॺ΋ޔࢂךޑᆒઓЍࢊǴ

؂྽གډЈྠཀ໶ǵݪ഼คΚਔǴགྷډգॺᕴࢂ୲הόᏮӦࣁΑᕉნǵϦကӧᏟ ର๱ǴԾρ൩ԖΑΚໆԶਁբଆٰǴΨය೚Ծρૈ୼Ⴝாॺ΋ኬǴࣁΑགྷा਍ፁ ޑሽॶԶ୲࡭ǵոΚǶ!

! ᖴᖴݿݿک༰༰Ǵ΋ޔаٰգॺᕴࢂ൧ख़ךޑ،ۓǴ๏ךࡐεޑԾҗǶӣډ ᏢਠۺਜǴΨӢࣁԖգॺӧӚБय़ޑคచҹЍ࡭ǴЀځࢂ༰༰ߏයӧѦӦѺ࡫Ǵ ᡣךૈคࡕ៝ϐኁӦӧࣽݤ܌ᏢಞǵྗഢࡓৣԵ၂ǵኗቪፕЎǹᖴᖴԴ׌Ǵӧך ᇴπਔᕴࢂΒ၉όᇥޑᔅךೀ౛೚ӭ٣௃ǶᖴᖴᒃངޑৎΓǴӧךଯᑫਔǴࣁך ໒Јǵϩ٦ךޑ഻৹ǴΨӧךեዊਔǴх৒ךޑҺ܄ᆶᚯ๠਻ǹ༰༰Ǵیёаܫ ЈଏҶӣѠ᡼ΑǴࣁΑیޑ଼நǴך཮ഉی΋ଆၮ୏Ƕ!

ૈ୼ԋࣁࣽݤ܌ R98 ޑ΋ҽηǴךࡐ۩ၮǵΨࡐ۩ᅽǴ؂ԛӣགྷӧ஑੤΢

ፐޑ៿኷ӣᏫǵྗഢ୯ԵޑᅐߏၡำǵኗቪፕЎޑྞዖၸำǴ੿ޑࡐགᖴ΋ၡ΢

ԖգॺޑഉՔǶᖴᖴγ៾Ǵ೭Ѥԃڙډգࡐӭޑྣ៝کх৒Ǵӧךขቾคշǵ஝

ውεনਔǴգᕴࢂӧךي਒ǵ๏ךΚໆǶᖴᖴ໳ണǴѝा࣮ډգǴך൩཮གډӼ ۓǴᖴᖴԖգഉךوၸനٌधޑٗࢤਔڅǶᖴᖴ 2417 უՔࠔӼǵё࿰ǵλ஀൛ǵ

҅খǵ޼⣼ǹᖴᖴྼᲹუՔεεǵ੻Ӄǹᖴᖴጎ⶿ǵۏ੿ǵٺޱǵᑊሺǵ☰ᆢǵ ճ੿ǵε஀൛ǵۓڷǵҥ۝ǵ჏ฐǵ၏εǴᗋԖࡐӭ๏ϒךЍ࡭کΚໆޑܻ϶ॺǶ ೭Ѥԃ΋ၡوٰधౡୖъǴΨමภधډ๴ғܫకޑۺᓐǴ۩ӳԖգॺႽϺ٬૓ޑ ӸӧǴךωૈࠈ๱УኖΠѐǴࡋၸቫቫᜢьԶಖܭ౥཰ΑǶ!

ᗨฅό௭ǴՠǴಖزᗋࢂाၟࣽݤғࢲၰձǹΠ΋໘ࢤޑғࢲǴ߆ௗޑࢂ׳

ӭόёႣޕޑࡷᏯǶᗨฅჹܭ҂ٰԖ٤όӼǴՠࢂך࣬ߞǴջ٬࿘ډϙሶኬޑ֚

ᜤ܈౟ᓍǴѝा྽Πᅰځ܌ૈǴόᇸܰܫకǴӵૈԖ΋ᗺᗺׯᡂǴ܈ࢂૈ୼၈ჴ Ӧय़ჹԾρ൩ӳǴයࠀȨѝݾරδȩޑΓғǴᅰځӧךǵคཎܭЈǶ!

٩ಝ!

2013.7.29 ܭࣽݤғࢲޑനࡕਔӀ

ך୯ᕉნቹៜຑ՗ڋࡋ߯ୖଜऍ୯ᕉნቹៜຑ՗ڋࡋԶࡌᄬǹᆶऍ୯ڋࡋό ӕϐೀǴନך୯߯җᕉߥЬᆅᐒᜢЬᏤᕉຑቩࢗำׇѦǴҭ፟ϒᕉຑቩࢗہ঩཮

Ȩց،៾ȩǴаᕉຑቩ่ࢗፕٰ،ۓ໒วՉࣁёց຾ՉǴբࣁڋᑽҞޑ٣཰Ьᆅ ᐒᜢϐЋࢤǶύࣽΟයਢ߯߈ԃٰ๱Ӝޑᕉຑݾ೜ਢҹǴځݾ᝼ੋϷᕉნቹៜຑ

՗ݤಃ 14 చϐှញǵҁਢນ೜ᆶኩਔ៾ճߥៈڋࡋϐᜪࠠǴаϷϦ҇ນ೜฻य़ ӛǶ

ҁЎ᏾౛ύࣽΟයਢჴ୍࣬ᜢղ،ᆶຊۓࡕǴᇡࣁύࣽΟයᕉຑݾ೜ਢϐਡ ЈୢᚒǴ߯ੋϷᕉნቹៜຑ՗ݤಃ 14 చಃ 1 ໨໒วՉࣁ೚ёคਏೕۓϐှញǴ ܭᙶమࡕǴωૈ຾΋؁൩ҁਢນ೜ᆶኩਔ៾ճߥៈڋࡋϐ᏷ڗ຾Չ૸ፕǶҁЎᇡ ࣁǴԾۈ҂࿶ᕉნቹៜຑ՗کᕉຑቩ่ࢗፕ༓ࡕᎁᄖᎍϐރݩǴ֡ឦ҂ֹԋᕉნ ቹៜຑ՗ቩࢗϐ௃׎Ǵ໒วՉࣁ೚ёϐਏΚ֡ࣁคਏǹᕉຑቩ่ࢗፕำׇᆶ໒ว Չࣁ೚ёำׇᗨ׎ԋӭ໘ࢤՉࡹำׇǴฅᕉຑቩ่ࢗፕᆶ໒วՉࣁ೚ё໔ϐਏ ΚǴϝ໪ຎᕉຑݤಃ 14 చಃ 1 ໨ϐೕۓԶᇡۓǹ୷ܭ୔ୱीฝݤ܌ਡวϐ໒ว

೚ё٠ߚ၀చೕጄϐጄᛑǴԶύࣽᆅ౛ֽଞჹቷ୘೛ቷՉࣁ܌ਡวϐࡌᑐ೚ёǴ ӢڀԖ໒วՉࣁ೚ё܄፦ǴԶԖ၀చೕۓϐ፾ҔǶ

ύࣽΟයᕉຑݾ೜ਢЬाаᄖᎍນ೜ࣁЬǴচ֋ҭԖаϦ҇ນ೜ගଆҁਢນ

೜Ƕך୯Ϧ҇ນ೜ڋࡋҭୖԵऍ୯ዅృޜ਻ݤϷዅృНݤϐϦ҇ນ೜చීԶ೛

ीǹόӕܭऍ୯ᕉຑݤೕคϦ҇ນ೜చීϐೕۓǴך୯ڙ্Γ҇ᆶϦ੻იᡏё٩ ᕉຑݤύϦ҇ນ೜చීϐೕۓǴӧЬᆅᐒᜢܭਜय़֋ޕଌၲВଆ 60 Ϻϣϝ҂٩ ݤ୺ՉਔǴޔௗӛՉࡹݤଣගଆນ೜Ƕӧᢀჸऍ୯࿶ڂᕉნਢҹύᖄٖനଯݤଣ ϐـှǴаϷکך୯ჴ୍ـှϐКၨΠǴҁЎᇡࣁǴऍ୯ݤଣ܍ᇡচ֋ё୷ܭځ

٬Ҕᕉნճ੻ڙډჴሞߟ্Զගଆນ೜ǴԶך୯ݤଣӧڙ্Γ҇ϐᇡۓǴᔈ፾ࡋ ቨᇡݤࡓ΢ճ্ᜢ߯ϐ៾ճǴ܍ᇡᕉნճ੻ࣁᕉნቹៜຑ՗ݤ܌ߥៈϐ៾ճǹӧ Ϧ੻იᡏ೽ϩǴ୷ܭ஑཰܄ᆶૈΚϐԵໆǴаϷᗉխ׫ᐒࠠນ೜υᘋϦ҇ນ೜ϐ

຾ՉǵቹៜՉࡹਏ౗ǵੁ຤љݤၗྍǴҁЎᇡࣁᔈज़ڋҗᕉნიᡏගଆϦ҇ນ೜

߯ࣁӝ౛Ƕ

ӧख़ᄬύࣽΟයਢϐҁਢນ೜೽ϩǴ൩ᕉຑቩ่ࢗፕǵխჴࡼᕉຑ೚ёаϷ ϣࡹ೽໒ว೚ёǴচ֋ᔈගଆᄖᎍນ೜ǹ൩୯ࣽ཮܌ਡวϐ໒วՉࣁ೚ёǴচ֋

ᔈගଆዴᇡՉࡹೀϩคਏນ೜ǹࡌᑐ೚ё߯ύࣽᆅ౛ֽ൩ቷ୘ϐ೛ቷՉࣁ܌ਡ วǴڀԖ໒วՉࣁ೚ёϐ܄፦Ǵচ֋ҭᔈගଆዴᇡՉࡹೀϩคਏນ೜Ƕଞჹ΢໒ ҁਢນ೜Ǵӧኩਔ៾ճߥៈڋࡋ೽ϩǴᔈ௦ଶЗ୺ՉำׇǹฅԶǴԖ᠘ܭך୯ჴ

୍൩঑೚ଶЗ୺ՉᖂፎϐਢҹǴ໻൩Չࡹೀϩϐ୺ՉຊۓଶЗǴ٠҂൩Չࡹೀϩ ܭਏΚଶЗਔǴࣁᆢ࡭౜ރԶࣁ΋ۓϐೀ࿼ǴჹܭύࣽΟයΎࢃၭ൑୷ӦϣȨଶ πόଶౢȩϐୢᚒǴচ֋ёᖂፎۓኩਔރᄊೀϩǴаዴߥځ៾ճૈᕇளԖਏߥምǶ

നࡕǴݤଣӧቩ౛ଶЗ୺Չ܈ଷೀϩϐᖂፎǴ֡ё௦ӕ΋ϐჴᡏቩࢗ኱ྗ຾

ՉᇡۓǶҁЎᇡࣁǴ௦ڗߕᒿჴᡏݤቩࢗኳԄǴݤଣё҅ዴӦӧᖂፎΓک࣬ჹΓ ໔ϩଛ॥ᓀǴ٠෧Ͽݤଣܭኩਔ៾ճߥៈϐຊۓёૈวғޑᒱᇤ॥ᓀǴჴ፬ኩਔ Зݾϐфૈک៾ճԖਏߥៈϐҞ኱ǶύࣽΟයਢӢݤଣ҂ૈջਔ൩ኩਔ៾ճߥៈ

ϐᖂፎբрຊ،ǴԶ٬ਢҹݾ᝼όᘐᘉεǵ׳ᖿፄᚇǹӢԜǴനख़ाޑࢂݤଣᔈ ջਔӦǵਏ౗Ӧଞჹኩਔ៾ճߥៈϐᖂፎբрຊۓǴаԖਏߥምᖂፎΓϐ៾ճǶ

ᜢᗖӷǺύࣽΟයǵᕉნቹៜຑ՗ݤǵᕉຑቩ่ࢗፕǵᕉຑݾ೜ǵϦ҇ນ೜ǵኩ ਔ៾ճߥៈ

!

! !

The design of Taiwan’s environmental impact assessment (the “EIA”) was modeled from the National Environmental Policy Act (the “NEPA”) of the United States. However, significantly different from the legal design of the EIA of the United States, Taiwan’s review committee (the “EIA Committee”) established by the environmental protection agencies is in charge of EIA, and EIA committee has veto power to decide whether the development activity, supported by the competent agency, can be done. The controversy surrounding the third-stage construction of the Central Taiwan Science Park (“CTSP”), which is a famous EIA case, involves article 14 of the Environmental Impact Assessment Act (the “EIA Act”), the types of administrative litigation, and the standing of citizen suit.

First, with an overview of all the court decisions of CTSP, this thesis finds out that Paragraph 1, Article 14 of the EIA Act is the most important issue, the interpretation of which affects the types of lawsuit which local residents who are influenced by the development activity may raise as the plaintiff, as well as the choice of temporary right protection mechanism in the EIA cases. This thesis argues that in cases where the review of an EIA procedure is not completed, or that a conclusion of a complete review is revoked afterwards, the development activity permission issued by the competent authority is invalid.

Second, although the EIA procedure and development permission procedure led by the competent authority together form an instance of “multi-stage administrative disposition”, the validity of the development permission still depends on whether the granting of permission conform to the EIA regulation. Except the building permit issued by the competent industry authority and can be deemed as a kind of the development permission, other kind of building permit and permission issued under the Regional Plan Act are not regulated by EIA regulations.

In addition to the revocation suit in the case of the third-stage CTSP, plaintiffs also file a citizen suit. Taiwan’s citizen suit provision of the EIA Act was also modeled from the provision of the Clean Air Act and the Clean Water Act of the United States. Compared with the citizen suit provision which not stipulated in the NEPA of the United States,the victims or public interest groups in Taiwan can file a citizen suit according to the EIA Act when the competent authorities have failed to act in accordance with the law within sixty days after receipt of a written notification from the victims or public interest groups.

Using a comparison between the classic environmental cases of the United States’

Supreme courts and the decisions of Taiwan’s Administrative Courts, this thesis argues that when the court applies the Theory of Protective Norms to review the standing of the victims, it should recognize environmental interests as the right protected by the EIA codes. Considering the specialization and capability of the public interest groups and the interests of preventing opportunistic litigation, the court should narrow the scope of the standing to the extent that only environmental groups have the standing to bring citizen suit.

Back to the cases of the third-stage CTSP, the plaintiff should file a suit to revoke the conclusion of the EIA review, the permission of exemption from EIA review, and the permission issued under the Regional Plan Act, as well as file a suit to declare that the administrative act of the issuance of the development permission by National Science Council is void. Because the building permit issued by CTSP Administration is also a development permission for the construction of a factory, the plaintiff should file actions to declare that an administrative act is void, too. The plaintiff should also file a motion for cessation of the compulsory execution during the merits. In case of emergency situations, such as violations by the proposed agency or the competent authority, the plaintiff can file a motion to obtain an injunction maintaining a temporary status quo with regard to the legal relation in dispute.

Lastly, the court can use the same review standards both in cases facing motion for cessation of the compulsory execution, and in cases facing motion for the provisional disposition. This thesis suggests that a preliminary review on the merit can help the court allocate risk correctly, minimize the error of the ruling, and cease controversy before the suit is final. The most important point is that the court should make the ruling timely andeffectively to protect the plaintiff’s rights, the absence of a ruling of such kind is the reason why the controversy of the third-stage CTSP becomes more complicated.

Keywords: the third-stage construction of the Central Taiwan Science Parkˣ Environmental Impact Assessment Actˣ the conclusion of EIA review ˣ an administrative litigation in environmental impact assessment caseˣcitizen suitˣ temporary right protection mechanism

!

!

娴嫅... i

㐀天... i

Abstract ... iii

䫔ᶨ䪈 䵺婾... 1

䫔ᶨ䭨 ⓷柴シ嬀冯䞼䨞䚖䘬... 1

䫔Ḵ䭨 䞼䨞䭬⚵冯䞼䨞㝞㥳... 3

䫔Ḵ䪈 ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇䑘姽䇕姇㟰ᷳ⥳㛓... 7

䫔ᶨ䭨 ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇ᷳ㛔㟰姜姇... 7

䫔Ḵ䭨ġ 㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟ᷳ塩⭂... 22

䫔ᶱ䭨 ⇌㰢↮㜸冯㩊妶... 34

䫔ᶱ䪈ġ ㆹ⚳䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⇞⹎冯忳ἄ䉨㱩... 45

䫔ᶨ䭨 㱽⇞㤪婾... 45

䫔Ḵ䭨 䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ㱽ᷳ夷䭬... 56

䫔ᶱ䭨 ㆹ⚳䑘姽䇕姇㟰ẞ䚖⇵朊冐ᷳ⓷柴... 71

䫔⚃䪈 ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰埴㓧䇕姇䦳⸷ᷳ慵㥳... 78

䫔ᶨ䭨ġ ℔㮹姜姇ᷳ慸㶭... 78

䫔Ḵ䭨 㛔㟰姜姇冯㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎ᷳ栆✳冯怑䓐... 95

䫔ᶱ䭨ġ ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㛔㟰姜姇冯㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎ᷳ㑯⍾... 115

䫔Ḽ䪈 䳸婾... 123

⍫侫㔯䌣... 130

旬抬... 138

!

၁Ҟ!

娴嫅... i

㐀天... i

Abstract ... iii

䫔ᶨ䪈 䵺婾... 1

䫔ᶨ䭨 ⓷柴シ嬀冯䞼䨞䚖䘬... 1

䫔Ḵ䭨 䞼䨞䭬⚵冯䞼䨞㝞㥳... 3

⢡ˣ䞼䨞䭬⚵... 3

屛ˣ䞼䨞㝞㥳... 4

䫔Ḵ䪈 ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇䑘姽䇕姇㟰ᷳ⥳㛓... 7

䫔ᶨ䭨 ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇ᷳ㛔㟰姜姇... 7

⢡ˣḳ⮎㤪天... 7

ᶨˣ䫔ᶨ㫉㛔㟰姜姇烉㑌扟䑘ᾅ会 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾ᷳ姜 ... 7

Ḵˣ䫔Ḵ㫉㛔㟰姜姇烉䡢娵⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗冯ℏ㓧悐攳 䘤姙⎗䃉㓰ᷳ姜ˣ䡢娵䑘ᾅ会℔㱽ᶲᷳ佑⊁ᷳ姜 ... 8

ᶱˣ䫔ᶱ㫉㛔㟰姜姇烉䡢娵⺈⓮㇨⍾⼿ᷳ⎬枭攳䘤姙⎗䃉㓰ᷳ姜 9 ⚃ˣ䫔⚃㫉㛔㟰姜姇烉㑌扟 99 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾冯⚳䥹㚫 99 ⸜攳䘤 埴䁢姙⎗ᷳ姜 ... 9

屛ˣ㟰ẞ䇕溆冯㱽昊夳妋... 10

ᶨˣ䫔ᶨ㫉㛔㟰姜姇 ... 10

炷ᶨ炸䦳⸷ḳ枭 ... 10

炷Ḵ炸⮎橼ḳ枭 ... 10

Ḵˣ䫔Ḵ㫉㛔㟰姜姇 ... 12

炷ᶨ炸䦳⸷ḳ枭 ... 12

炷Ḵ炸⮎橼ḳ枭 ... 13

ᶱˣ䫔ᶱ㫉㛔㟰姜姇 ... 16

炷ᶨ炸䦳⸷ḳ枭 ... 16

炷Ḵ炸⮎橼ḳ枭 ... 16

⚃ˣ䫔⚃㫉㛔㟰姜姇 ... 19

炷ᶨ炸䦳⸷ḳ枭 ... 19

炷Ḵ炸⮎橼ḳ枭 ... 19

⢡ˣ 㬊➟埴塩⭂... 22

ᶨˣ倚婳 㬊➟埴 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾 ... 22

Ḵˣ倚婳 㬊➟埴⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗ ... 23

ᶱˣ倚婳 㬊➟埴 99 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾ˣ⚳䥹㚫 99 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗ ⍲ 㬊➟埴⚳䥹㚫⍲ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨㟠䘤Ḱ⺈⓮ᷳ⎬枭➟䄏冯姙⎗ ... 25

炷ᶨ炸䔞ḳṢ怑㟤 ... 26

炷Ḵ炸 㬊➟埴天ẞᷳ⮑㞍㧁㸾冯夳妋 ... 27

屛ˣ`嗽↮塩⭂... 30

ᶨˣ倚婳␥䑘ᾅ会␥ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨ 㬊⮎㕥攳䘤埴䁢ᷳ塩⭂ ... 30

Ḵˣ倚婳␥䑘ᾅ会␥⍳忼冯㖕傥㕤㛔㟰姜姇䳪䳸⇵䩳⌛ 㬊攳䘤埴 䁢ᷳ塩⭂ ... 31

䫔ᶱ䭨 ⇌㰢↮㜸冯㩊妶... 34

⢡ˣ㛔㟰姜姇冯㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎ᷳ⮑㞍㕡⺷... 34

ᶨˣ⎠㱽⮑㞍埴㓧㨇斄⇌㕟检⛘ᷳね⼊ ... 34

Ḵˣ 㬊➟埴冯`嗽↮ᷳ⮑㞍 ... 35

屛ˣ䔞ḳṢ怑㟤ᷳ娵⭂... 36

ᶨˣ㑌扟姜姇冯䡢娵埴㓧嗽↮䃉㓰姜姇 ... 36

Ḵˣ℔㮹姜姇 ... 38

⍫ˣ⮎橼悐↮... 39

ᶨˣ䑘姽㱽䫔 14 㡅䫔 1 枭攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗䃉㓰ᷳね⼊冯䭬䔯 ... 39

Ḵˣ⃵⮎㕥䑘姽嗽↮㕤䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾怕㑌扟⼴ᷳ㓰≃⓷柴 ... 40

ᶱˣ䫔ᶨ昶㭝䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾旬≈㡅ẞᷳ旸⇞ ... 42

⚃ˣ㱽昊娵⭂埴㓧㨇斄⎗借㪲⺊㬊忽㱽埴㓧嗽↮ᷳ⓷柴 ... 43

倮ˣ⮷䳸... 43

䫔ᶱ䪈ġ ㆹ⚳䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⇞⹎冯忳ἄ䉨㱩... 45

䫔ᶨ䭨 㱽⇞㤪婾... 45

⢡ˣ伶⚳冯ㆹ⚳㱽⇞䯉ṳ... 45

ᶨˣ伶⚳䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⇞⹎ᷳṳ䳡 ... 45

Ḵˣㆹ⚳䈡㚱ᷳˬ⏎㰢㪲˭姕妰 ... 49

屛ˣ䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ㳩䦳冯ℑ昶㭝⮑㞍ᷳ姕妰... 51

䫔Ḵ䭨 䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ㱽ᷳ夷䭬... 56

⢡ˣ䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾ᷳ⭂⿏... 56

ᶨˣ⮎⊁夳妋 ... 56

Ḵˣ⬠婒夳妋 ... 57

炷ᶨ炸埴㓧嗽↮ ... 57

炷Ḵ炸奨⾝忂䞍 ... 58

ᶱˣ⮷䳸 ... 58

屛ˣ䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ䦳⸷䁢䌐䩳䦳⸷... 59

⍫ˣ䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾冯攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗攻㓰≃ᷳ斄Ὢ... 62

ᶨˣ䑘姽㱽䫔 14 㡅ᷳ夷䭬䚖䘬 ... 62

炷ᶨ炸㱽㡅㱧朑 ... 62

炷Ḵ炸䫔 1 枭夷䭬㗗⏎怑䓐冒⥳㛒䴻䑘姽⮑㞍ᷳ攳䘤埴䁢姙 ⎗烎 ... 63

Ḵˣ䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾▋⼴怕㑌扟⮵攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗ᷳ⼙枧 ... 66

炷ᶨ炸⣂昶㭝埴㓧䦳⸷ ... 66

炷Ḵ炸䚖䘬ḳ㤕ᷣ䭉㨇斄ᷳ娵⭂冯攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗ᷳ䭬䔯 ... 68

䫔ᶱ䭨 ㆹ⚳䑘姽䇕姇㟰ẞ䚖⇵朊冐ᷳ⓷柴... 71

⢡ˣ䫔ᶨ昶㭝冯䫔Ḵ昶㭝䑘姽⮑㞍ᷳ≇傥ᶵ㶭... 71

屛ˣ㚱㡅ẞ忂忶䫔ᶨ昶㭝䑘姽⮑㞍⍾ẋ䫔Ḵ昶㭝䑘姽ᷳね⼊... 73

⍫ˣ㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎ᷳ慵天⿏... 76

䫔⚃䪈 ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰埴㓧䇕姇䦳⸷ᷳ慵㥳... 78

䫔ᶨ䭨ġ ℔㮹姜姇ᷳ慸㶭... 78

⢡ˣ伶⚳䑘⠫㱽ᶲ℔㮹姜姇⍇⏲怑㟤ᷳ奨⮇... 78

ᶨˣ⺢⇞忶䦳 ... 78

Ḵˣ⍇⏲怑㟤ᷳ䴻℠㟰ἳ ... 80

炷ᶨ炸䔞ḳṢ怑㟤ᷳ㤪婾 ... 80

炷Ḵ炸䴻℠㟰ἳᷳ䯉ṳ ... 82

屛ˣㆹ⚳䉨㱩... 86

ᶨˣ⺢⇞忶䦳 ... 86

Ḵˣㆹ⚳⍇⏲怑㟤ᷳ娵⭂ ... 88

炷Ḵ炸⬠婒夳妋 ... 92

⍫ˣ冯埴㓧姜姇㱽䫔 35 㡅⛀橼姜姇ᷳ⋨⇍... 93

䫔Ḵ䭨 㛔㟰姜姇冯㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎ᷳ栆✳冯怑䓐... 95

⢡ˣ㛔㟰姜姇ᷳ栆✳... 95

屛ˣ伶⚳冯⽟⚳㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎ᷳ㤪㱩... 96

ᶨˣ伶⚳㙓㗪䤩⇞Ẍ⇞⹎ ... 96

Ḵˣ⽟⚳㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎ ... 98

炷ᶨ炸 㬊➟埴ᷳ⮎橼⮑㞍㧁㸾 ... 100

炷Ḵ炸`嗽↮ᷳ⮎橼⮑㞍㧁㸾 ... 101

⍫ˣㆹ⚳㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎ᷳ䎦㱩... 104

ᶨˣ㱽⇞㤪婾 ... 104

炷ᶨ炸 㬊➟埴䦳⸷ ... 104

炷Ḵ炸`嗽↮䦳⸷ ... 106

Ḵˣ 㬊➟埴䦳⸷冯`嗽↮䦳⸷怑䓐䭬⚵ᷳ⋨⇍ ... 107

ᶱˣ⮎橼⮑㞍㧁㸾ᷳ㑵ἄ ... 108

炷ᶨ炸⮎⊁䉨㱩 ... 108

炷Ḵ炸⬠婒夳妋 ... 111

炷ᶱ炸⮷䳸 ... 113

䫔ᶱ䭨ġ ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㛔㟰姜姇冯㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎ᷳ㑯⍾... 115

⢡ˣ䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾冯⚳䥹㚫攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗ᷳ⭂⿏... 115

屛ˣ㛔㟰姜姇栆✳ᷳ怠㑯... 118

ᶨˣ㑌扟䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾ᷳ姜 ... 118

Ḵˣ䡢娵⚳䥹㚫攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗䃉㓰ᷳ姜 ... 118

ᶱˣ℞Ṿ姙⎗ᷳ姜姇栆✳ ... 119

炷ᶨ炸㑌扟ℏ㓧悐攳䘤姙⎗ᷳ姜 ... 119

炷Ḵ炸㑌扟⺈⓮⃵⮎㕥䑘姽姙⎗ᷳ姜 ... 120

炷ᶱ炸䡢娵⺈⓮⺢䭱姙⎗䃉㓰ᷳ姜 ... 121

⍫ˣ㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎栆✳ᷳ怠㑯... 121

䫔Ḽ䪈 䳸婾... 123

⍫侫㔯䌣... 130

⢡ˣᷕ㔯㔯䌣... 130

ᶨˣ⮰㚠... 130

Ḵˣ㛇↲婾㔯冯⮰㚠婾㔯... 130

ᶱˣ⬠ỵ婾㔯... 135

⚃ˣ䩳㱽昊℔⟙... 136

屛ˣ劙㔯㔯䌣... 137

旬抬ᶨ烉ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰⣏ḳ䲨... 138

旬抬Ḵ烉ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㛔㟰姜姇⣏ḳ䲨... 143

旬抬ᶱ烉ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㛔㟰姜姇冯㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟塩⭂⣏ḳ䲨... 144

旬抬⚃烉ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㛔㟰姜姇冯㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟塩⭂㔜䎮... 145

旬抬Ḽ烉ㆹ⚳⮎⊁⇌㰢⍫侫↿堐... 153

ᶨˣℑ昶㭝䑘姽⮑㞍ᷳⶖ䔘冯旬㡅ẞ忂忶䑘姽ᷳ塩⇌... 153

Ḵˣ䑘姽䇕姇㟰ẞ⍇⏲怑㟤娵⭂ᷳ䚠斄塩⇌... 154

ᶱˣ㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟塩⭂ᷳ⮎橼⮑㞍㧁㸾䚠斄塩⭂... 155

旬抬ℕ烉伶⚳倗恎㚨檀㱽昊⇌㰢↿堐... 158

ಃ΋ക!!ᆣፕ!

ಃ΋࿯!!ୢᚒཀ᛽ᆶࣴزҞޑ!

ˬᕉߥ࿿ୋ࿿ߏߋЎࡏࡰрǴՉࡹଣ،᝼Ǵ҂ٰຬၸ 10 ሹа΢ख़ε࿶ࡌਢǴ೿

ाӃଌ୯ৎ҉ុ཮ຑ՗Ǵ٠ᗎᕉຑہ঩ୖᆶ૸ፕࡕǴගᒌ၌ཀـٮࡹଣୖԵǴऩ

ࡹଣϝᇡёՉǴωଌᕉߥ࿿ᕉຑǴа෧Ͽᜪ՟୯Ӏҡϯਢᐕ࿶ߏයᕉຑࡕǴϝ೏

Ѻӣ౻ޑ௃ݩวғ///୯Ӏҡϯ໒วਢǴᐕ࿶ࡹ۬ӭԃமΚ௢୏Ǵ໻Ӣᒧ֟ό྽Ǵ ᎁᕉߥიᡏϷ྽Ӧ҇౲மΚϸჹǴനࡕᕴ಍ଭमΐ߄ၲόЍ࡭Ǵ၀໨ीฝ֋ಖǴ ՠࡹ۬ǵ཰ޣᆶϸჹޣӭԃሼ࡭Ǵ຀઻୯ৎԋҁǴѸ໪೏҅ຎ///˭¹

ˬѠчଯ฻ՉࡹݤଣຊۓύࣽΟයکѤයѸ໪ଶπǴፂᔐΒ༜୔ၻӂϡ׫ၗ໒ว ਢǴᕉߥ࿿ǵ୯ࣽ཮೿߄Ңஒගל֋ǹՉࡹଣߏֆඩကࢄ߾ࡰрǴ܌ᒏଶπࢂࡰ

ࡹ۬ޑȬ໒วՉࣁȭଶЗǴ౜໘ࢤύࣽΟයς຾Ꭻ೛ቷғౢޑቷ୘ஒό཮ڙډቹ ៜ///˭²

役⸜Ἦ冢䀋慵⣏攳䘤㟰ẞ炻⤪喯剙檀忇℔嶗㟰ˣ⚳⃱䞛⊾攳䘤㟰䫱炻⛯⺽䘤 㮹攻⛀橼⣏夷㧉䘬⍵⮵倚㴒ˣᶲ埿忲埴炻⚈㑼⽫攳䘤㟰ᶨ㖎攳⥳忚埴炻⮯忈ㆸ䔞

⛘䑘⠫冯䓇ンᶵ⎗⚆⽑䘬㎵⭛炻侴㛇㛃䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ炷䯉䧙䑘姽炸傥ἄ䁢䑘⠫⬰

嬟侭炻ẍ⮎嶸䑘⠫㯠临ᷳ䚖㧁烊⛐䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾㕤暚㜿 BOO ✫⛦䃂⊾䆸㟰炻䴻 㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 92 ⸜⹎塩⫿䫔 519 嘇塩⭂偗娵䁢埴㓧嗽↮⼴炻⮵㕤䑘姽⮎⊁⣂ẍ 㚱㡅ẞ忂忶䫔ᶨ昶㭝䑘姽ᷳね⼊炻ㆾ憅⮵ㅱ忚埴䑘姽⌣ẍ夷性埴䁢侴㛒忚埴䑘姽

ᷳ㟰ẞ炻䔞⛘⯭㮹␴䑘⠫⛀橼Ṏ徸㻠德忶㍸崟埴㓧䇕姇ᷳ㕡⺷炻⮳㯪㓹㾇ˤ 役㛇⍿䣦㚫䞂䚖ᷳ䑘姽䇕姇㟰ẞ炻昌冢㜙伶渿䀋攳䘤㟰³⢾炻⌛䁢ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇 㟰ˤᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰Ὢ㊯ˬᷕ悐䥹⬠ⶍ㤕⚺⋨䫔ᶱ㛇䘤⯽⋨炷⎶慴➢⛘炼ᶫ㗇彚⟜悐

1 ⶍ⓮㗪⟙炷09/10/2011炸炻˨慵⣏䴻⺢㟰 ⃰復㯠临㚫姽Ộ˩炻䫔 A4 䇰ˤ

2 冒䓙㗪⟙炷08/04/2010炸炻˨⏛㍮烉ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇ᶵ 䓊 㱽昊烉ㅱℐ朊 ⶍ˩炻䫔 A01 䇰ˤ

3 冢㜙伶渿䀋攳䘤㟰ᷳ䫔ᶨ㫉㛔㟰姜姇炻Ὢ䓙℔䙲⛀橼ẍ℔㮹姜姇㡅㫦㍸崟姜姇炻䴻檀晬檀䫱埴 㓧㱽昊 96 ⸜⹎姜⫿䫔 647 嘇⇌㰢ˣ㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎⇌⫿䫔 403 嘇⇌㰢ˣ檀晬檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 99⸜⹎姜㚜ᶨ⫿䫔 8 嘇⇌㰢ˣ㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎⇌⫿䫔 1451 嘇⇌㰢ˣ檀晬檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 100

⸜⹎姜㚜Ḵ⫿䫔 36 嘇⇌㰢ˣ㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 101 ⸜⹎塩⫿䫔 1888 嘇⇌㰢炻⇌㰢冢㜙䷋㓧⹄ㅱἄㆸ

␥攳䘤╖ỵ伶渿䀋㷉`㛹偉ấ㚱旸℔⎠ 㬊攳䘤埴䁢ᷳ埴㓧嗽↮䡢⭂烊䫔Ḵ㫉㛔㟰姜姇Ὢ䓙䔞⛘

⯭㮹㍸崟㑌扟䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾ᷳ姜炻䴻檀晬檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 98 ⸜⹎姜⫿䫔 47 嘇⇌㰢ˣ㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊

↮炸攳䘤妰䔓˭炻㴱⍲䑘姽ᷣ䭉㨇斄埴㓧昊䑘⠫ᾅ嬟会炷䯉䧙䑘ᾅ会炸ˣ䚖䘬ḳ㤕

ᷣ䭉㨇斄埴㓧昊⚳⭞䥹⬠⥼⒉㚫炷䯉䧙⚳䥹㚫炸ˣ攳䘤╖ỵ埴㓧昊⚳⭞䥹⬠⥼⒉ 㚫ᷕ悐䥹⬠ⶍ㤕⚺⋨䭉䎮⯨炷䯉䧙ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨炸ˣ⋨➇妰䔓㱽ᷳᷣ䭉㨇斄ℏ㓧悐ˣ 忚楸⺈⓮⍳忼冯㖕傥䫱ᶵ⎴╖ỵ攻ᷳ㱽⼳斄Ὢ烊䔞⛘⯭㮹娵䁢ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰⮵䑘⠫

㚱慵⣏⼙枧ᷳ嘆炻⌣ẍ㚱㡅ẞ忂忶䫔ᶨ昶㭝䑘姽侴ἄㆸ 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾炻农 ἧ℞䓇␥ˣ幓橼ˣ屉䓊䫱㪲⇑⍿⇘Ὕ⭛炻Ṏ∅⤒䑘姽㱽㕤䫔Ḵ昶㭝䑘姽⮑㞍䦳⸷

岎Ḱ䔞⛘⯭㮹ᷳ䦳⸷⍫冯㪲炻⚈㬌㍸崟㑌扟 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾ᷳ姜ˤ

䃞侴炻䁢ỽ⍇⏲㕤䫔ᶨ㫉㛔㟰姜姇⍾⼿㑌扟 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾ᷳ⊅姜䡢⭂

⇌㰢⼴⁴炻ṵ䃉㱽妋㰢ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰ᷳ䇕嬘炻⯂枰㍸崟℞Ṿ㛔㟰姜姇␴倚婳 㬊➟

埴冯`嗽↮炻侴䇕姇军Ṳṵ㛒句ⷽ⁵烎䁢慸㶭ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰㇨㴱⍲ᷳ㱽⼳䇕嬘炻侴 Ὣἧ㛔㔯⮵䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ㱽⇞冯夷䭬忚埴䞼䨞炻ẍ⍲⯙ㆹ⚳䑘姽䇕姇㟰ẞ㛔㟰姜 姇⇌㰢⍲㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟塩⭂ᷳね⼊忚埴奨⮇ˤ㛔㔯㫚德忶ᶳ徘嬘柴ᷳ妶婾炻䵄奨

᷎↮㜸ㆹ⚳䑘姽䇕姇㟰ẞ埴㓧䇕姇ᷳ⮎㱩⼴炻ẍ㛇⮵㛒Ἦ⎗傥䘤䓇ᷳ䑘姽䇕姇㟰 ẞ炻㚱㇨≑䙲ˤ

ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇ᷳ㟠⽫䇕嬘炻㴱⍲䑘姽㱽䫔 14 㡅䫔 1 枭ˬҞޑ٣཰Ьᆅᐒᜢܭᕉ ნቹៜᇥܴਜ҂࿶ֹԋቩࢗ܈ຑ՗ਜ҂࿶ᇡё߻Ǵόளࣁ໒วՉࣁϐ೚ёǴځ࿶

೚ёޣǴคਏ˭ᷳ夷⭂炻⮵㕤䚖䘬ḳ㤕ᷣ䭉㨇斄㇨㟠䘤攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗ᷳ妋慳冯怑 䓐烊⌛ 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾怕㱽昊㑌扟䡢⭂⼴炻䚖䘬ḳ㤕ᷣ䭉㨇斄⚳䥹㚫㟠䘤ᷳ

攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗㗗⏎䃉㓰烎䑘姽⮑㞍䦳⸷冯攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗䦳⸷攻ᷳ㱽⼳斄Ὢ䁢 ỽ烎㗗⏎⼙枧䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾冯攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗攻㓰≃ᷳ妋慳烎ℏ㓧悐攳䘤姙⎗␴

⍳忼ˣ㖕傥㇨⍾⼿ᷳ⎬枭姙⎗㗗⏎Ṏ㚱娚㡅夷⭂ᷳ怑䓐烎⛯⼙枧⍇⏲㕤䑘姽䇕姇 㟰ᷕ炻ㅱ㍸崟ỽ䧖㛔㟰姜姇␴㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟ᷳ栆✳炻侴䁢㛔㔯䞼䨞ᷳ㟠⽫ˤ

㬌⢾炻⛐ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰ᷕ炻⍇⏲Ṏὅ䑘姽㱽䫔 23 㡅䫔 8 枭ˣ䫔 9 枭ᷳ℔㮹姜 姇㡅㫦㍸崟姜姇ˤㆹ⚳两⍿㕤伶⚳℔㮹姜姇㱽⇞炻⺢伖㕤䑘⠫㱽夷ᷕ炻冯⁛䴙ᷣ

101⸜⹎⇌⫿䫔 55 嘇⇌㰢ˣ㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 101 ⸜⹎⇌⫿䫔 860 嘇⇌㰢炻㑌扟䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾䡢⭂ˤ

4 䫔ᶨ㫉㛔㟰姜姇冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 96 ⸜⹎姜⫿䫔 1117 嘇⇌㰢㑌扟 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾炻䴻㚨 檀埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎⇌⫿䫔 30 嘇⇌㰢䵕㊩⍇⮑⇌㰢侴䡢⭂烊㛔㟰䑘ᾅ会㍸崟ℵ⮑炻怕㚨檀埴㓧㱽 昊 100 ⸜⹎⇌⫿䫔 1332 嘇⇌㰢楩⚆ˤ

5 䫔⚃㫉㛔㟰姜姇䴻㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 102 ⸜⹎⇌⫿䫔 120 嘇⇌㰢炻⺊㡬⍇⮑⇌㰢䘤⚆⼴炻䚖⇵㕤冢

⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊忚埴⮑䎮ᷕˤ

奨姜姇㚱ỽᶵ⎴烎䚠庫ℑ⚳℔㮹姜姇㱽⇞冯⎠㱽⮎⊁⮵㕤⍇⏲怑㟤ᷳ娵⭂ね

⼊炻㗗⏎㚱㇨ⶖ䔘烎Ṏ䁢㛔㔯斄㲐ᷳ慵溆ˤ

⛐慵㥳ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇埴㓧䇕姇䦳⸷⇵炻㛔㔯⯙䑘姽䇕姇㟰ẞᷳ㛔㟰姜姇⎗傥㍸崟

ᷳ姜姇栆✳忚埴妶婾炻ẍ⍲䚠ㅱ䘬㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎ᷳ怠㑯炻᷎⍫惴伶⚳冯⽟⚳

㱽⇞⼴炻㍸↢㛔㔯娵䁢⎗㍉ᷳ⮎橼⮑㞍㧁㸾ˤ⚈䑘⠫䓇ンᷳ䟜⢆⼨⼨℟ᶵ⎗⚆⽑

⿏炻侴䑘姽䇕姇㟰ẞᷳ㛔㟰姜姇⮑䎮㛇攻㻓攟炻㱽昊⛐⮑惴㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟ᷳ倚婳 㗪炻ㅱ㍉埴ỽ䧖⮎橼⮑㞍㧁㸾ẍ忼⇘㪲⇑㚱㓰ᾅ嬟ᷳ䚖㧁炻Ṏ䁢㛔㔯斄⽫ᷳ㕡

⎹ˤ㚨⼴炻ℵ忚埴ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰埴㓧䇕姇䦳⸷ᷳ慵㥳ˤ

ಃΒ࿯!!ࣴزጄൎᆶࣴزࢎᄬ

൘ǵࣴزጄൎ!

㛔㔯䞼䨞䭬⚵Ὢẍᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰㇨㴱ᷳ㱽⼳䇕嬘炻⽆䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ㱽⇞冯䑘姽 㱽䫔 14 㡅䫔 1 枭ᷳ妋慳冯怑䓐䭬䔯ˣ℔㮹姜姇⍇⏲怑㟤ᷳ娵⭂ˣ㛔㟰姜姇冯㙓 㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎ᷳ栆✳怠㑯炻ẍ⍲㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎ᷳ⮎橼⮑㞍㧁㸾䫱㕡朊炻忚 埴妶婾ˤ

䑘姽䇕姇㟰ẞᷳ姜姇㧁䘬⣂䁢䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾炻䔞⛘⯭㮹Ὢẍ⇑⭛斄ὪṢᷳ幓

↮㍸崟㑌扟姜姇ˤ⛐⇌㕟⍇⏲㗗⏎℟⍇⏲怑㟤㗪炻Ὢẍᾅ嬟夷䭬䎮婾忚埴娵⭂⁶烊

⚈⮎⊁冯⬠婒⣂偗娵䑘姽㱽䚠斄夷⭂䁢ᾅ嬟夷䭬⁷炻䔞⛘⯭㮹䁢娚ᾅ嬟夷䭬⮬䦳

㇨⍲ᷳṢ炻⚈㬌㛔㔯⯙℔㮹姜姇⍇⏲怑㟤ᷳ娵⭂忚埴㍊妶炻ᶵℵ⯙ᾅ嬟夷䭬䎮 婾≈ẍ婒㖶ˤ

6 冲ᾅ嬟夷䭬䎮婾ẍ㬟⎚ᶲ䘬䩳㱽シ㖐妋慳㱽⼳㗗⏎℟⁁ᾅ嬟ᾳṢ㪲⇑ᷳ䚖䘬炻㕘ᾅ嬟夷䭬䎮婾 ẍ⭊奨夷䭬䚖䘬ᷳ㍊㯪炻⯙夷䭬䳸㥳ˣ䭬⚵ˣ怑䓐⮵尉ᷳ⼿䈡⭂⿏⍲℞Ṿ䣦㚫⚈䳈ẍḰ㕇惴烊⎠

㱽昊慳⫿䫔 469 嘇妋慳䎮䓙㚠⌛㍉㕘ᾅ嬟夷䭬䎮婾ˤ⍫㜿㗙㠭炷2005炸炻˨✫⛦䃂⊾⺈旬役⯭㮹ᷳ

姜姇㪲傥˩炻˪㚰㖎㱽⬠㔁⭌˫炻䫔 37 㛇炻枩 25ˤ

7 䚠斄㔯䌣⎗⍫䌳㭻㬋炷2010炸炻˨ㆹ⚳䑘姽⎚ᶲ椾ἳ㑌扟⇌㰢烉䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾䴻㑌扟䃉㓰㈹ㆾ䃉 㓰䓐ᷳ⇌㰢烎/㚨檀埴 99 ⇌ 30˩炻˪冢䀋㛔⛇㱽⬠暄娴˫炻䫔 149 㛇炻枩 145-158烊㛶⺢列炷2011炸炻

˨埴㓧㱽烉䫔⋩Ḵ嫃ʇ℔㱽ᶲ㪲⇑䘬㤪⾝ˣ䎮婾冯忳䓐˩炻˪㚰㖎㱽⬠㔁⭌˫炻䫔 99 㛇炻枩 20-40烊 㛶⺢列炷2004炸炻˨䑘⠫埴㓧䦳⸷䘬㱽⇞冯⮎⊁ʇẍˬ䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ㱽˭䁢ᷕ⽫˩炻˪㚰㖎㱽⬠暄娴˫炻 䫔 104 㛇炻枩 45-67烊㜿㗙㠭炻⎴⇵姣炻枩 25-26烊‭䍚朄炷2009炸炻˨℔㮹姜姇ˣ℔䙲姜姇ˣ㮹 䛦姜姇烎炼䑘⠫㱽ᶲ℔㮹姜姇ᷳ⿏岒˩炻˪㚰㖎㱽⬠㔁⭌˫炻䫔 77 㛇炻枩 28-29烊‭䍚朄炷2008炸炻

˨䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ㱽ᷕ℔㮹姜姇ᷳ䔞ḳṢ˩炻˪㚰㖎㱽⬠㔁⭌˫炻䫔 70 㛇炻枩 22-23烊∱⤪ㄏ炷2010炸炻

˨ㆹ⚳䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ㱽⇌㰢⚆栏˩炻˪冰⣏㱽⬠˫炻䫔 7 㛇炻枩 275-308ˤ

ㆹ⚳℔㮹姜姇Ὢ⍫惴伶⚳℔㮹姜姇㱽⇞侴⺢伖⛐䑘⠫㱽夷ᷕ炻侴㛔㔯㫚德忶 伶⚳㱽⇞冯倗恎㚨檀㱽昊⮵⍇⏲怑㟤娵⭂ᷳ奨⮇炻␴ㆹ⚳⮎⊁忳ἄ冯⬠婒䚠庫烊 伶⚳㱽ᶲ埴㓧姜姇ᷳ㱽⼳橼䲣炻冯ㆹ⚳两⍿⽟⚳㱽⇞ᷳ㱽⼳橼䲣晾㚱ᶵ⎴炻䃞侴

⛐⍇⏲怑㟤ᷳ㤪⾝炻⛯Ὢ⮑惴⍇⏲㗗⏎℟⁁婳㯪㱽昊塩⇌ᷳ屯㟤炻侴⎗屯㭼庫ˤ

⛐伶⚳㱽ᶲ炻⍇⏲ᷣ⻝埴㓧埴䁢忽㱽侴㍸崟姜姇炻昌枰℟⁁䔞ḳṢ怑㟤ᷳ⢾炻枰 㺧嵛⚃枭䴙䧙䁢ˬ⎠㱽⮑㞍ᷳ㗪㨇炷timing of judicial review炸˭ᷳ䈡㬲天ẞ烉埴 㓧㨇斄ᷳ㚨䳪埴䁢炷final agency action炸ˣ䩖䚉埴㓧ℏ悐㓹㾇䦳⸷炷exhaustion of administrative remedies炸ˣ 埴 㓧 埴 䁢 ⶚ 冣 ㆸ 䅇 侴 ⼿ ⍿ ⎠ 㱽 ⮑ 㞍 炷 ripeness of administrative action for judicial review炸ˣ䫎⎰ᾳ⇍㱽⼳㇨夷⭂ᷳ崟姜㛇攻⁸烊⚈⇵

攳䈡㬲天ẞ冯⍇⏲怑㟤ᷳ娵⭂䃉⣒⣏斄忋炻⚈㬌㛔㔯旸㕤伶⚳倗恎㚨檀㱽昊⛐

䑘⠫㟰ẞᷕㅚ㱽ᶲ䔞ḳṢ怑㟤炷standing炸ᷳ䴻℠㟰ἳ忚埴奨⮇ˤ

⚈䑘姽䇕姇㟰ẞᷳ㛔㟰姜姇⮑䎮㛇攻㻓攟炻㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎⮵㕤⍇⏲㪲⇑

ᷳ㙓㗪ᾅℐ炻⮎䁢慵天ˤㆹ⚳埴㓧姜姇㱽ᶲ㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎䁢 㬊➟埴䦳⸷ˣ

`嗽↮䦳⸷ẍ⍲`㈋㉤䦳⸷炻侴⛐䑘⠫䇕姇㟰ẞᷕ炻⍰ẍ⇵ℑ侭䦳⸷䁢ᷣ炻⚈㬌 㛔㔯妶婾ᷳ慵溆ẍ 㬊➟埴䦳⸷␴`嗽↮䦳⸷䁢㟠⽫炻`㈋㉤䦳⸷⇯ᶵḰ妶婾ˤ

⚈ㆹ⚳埴㓧䇕姇㱽⇞Ὢ两⍿⽟⚳奨溆⁹炻㛔㔯㫚ẍ⽟⚳㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎炻␴伶

⚳㱽ᷕ䚠役Ụᷳˬ㙓㗪䤩⇞Ẍ炷preliminary injunctions炸˭⇞⹎忚埴㭼庫㱽䞼䨞炻 忚ᶨ㬍㍸↢ㆹ⚳⮵㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎⎗㍉⍾ᷳ⮎橼⮑㞍㧁㸾炻侴㚱斄 㬊➟埴冯

`嗽↮ᷳ⮎橼㧁㸾炻㕤ᾳ㟰ᷕㅱ⤪ỽ娵⭂炻⇯朆㛔㔯妶婾ᷳ䭬䔯ˤ

ມǵࣴزࢎᄬ!

㛔㔯⛐䞼䨞㝞㥳ᶲ炻ℙ↮䁢Ḽ䪈ˤ䫔ᶨ䪈ᷣ天婒㖶㛔㔯ᷳ⓷柴シ嬀冯䞼䨞䚖 䘬炻⌛㛔㔯䁢ỽ斄㲐ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰炻侴⽆娚㟰㴱⍲ᷳ㱽⼳⓷柴忚埴㍊妶炻ẍ⍲⯙䞼 䨞䭬⚵␴䞼䨞㝞㥳忚埴䯉ṳ炻⎗㤪䔍Ḯ妋㛔㔯䞼䨞ᷳ㕡⎹ˤ

䫔Ḵ䪈Ὢᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰㛔㟰⇌㰢冯㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟塩⭂ᷳ⚆栏ˤ德忶ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇ḳ

⮎側㘗ᷳ婒㖶ˣ⮎⊁塩⇌ᷳ㔜䎮炻ẍ↮㜸㱽昊⛐㛔㟰姜姇冯㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟倚婳㟰

8 ⏪䶗㬎炷2010炸炻˪埴㓧姜姇⍇⏲怑㟤ᷳ䞼䨞炼ẍ伶⚳㱽ᷳ㭼庫䁢ᷕ⽫˫炻⚳䩳冢䀋⣏⬠㱽⼳⬠

昊㱽⼳⬠䞼䨞㇨䡑⢓婾㔯炻枩 10ˤ

9 㜿㖶㖽炷2009炸炻˨℔⊁Ṣ⒉ᾅ晄㓹㾇䦳⸷ᷕ㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎ᷳ䞼䨞炼ẍᾅ妻㚫ᷳ 㬊➟埴䁢

ᷕ⽫˩炻℔⊁Ṣ⒉ᾅ晄㙐➡妻⥼⒉㚫 98 ⸜⹎䞼䨞妰䔓炻枩 15ˤ

ᷳ⮑㞍㕡⺷烊憅⮵㱽昊⯙㛔㟰姜姇冯℔㮹姜姇㚱斄⍇⏲怑㟤ᷳ娵⭂炻␴㛔㟰姜姇

ᷳ⮎橼悐↮炻⤪䑘姽㱽䫔 14 㡅攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗䃉㓰夷䭬ᷳね⼊冯䭬䔯ˣ➢䢶嗽↮

怕㑌扟⼴ᷳ墄㬋ˣ䫔ᶨ昶㭝䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾旬≈㡅ẞˣ埴㓧㨇斄借㪲⺊㬊忽㱽埴㓧 嗽↮䫱⓷柴炻忚埴妶婾ˤ

䫔ᶱ䪈䁢䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ㱽⇞ᷳ↮㜸冯䑘姽㱽䫔 14 㡅夷䭬ᷳ㍊妶ˤㆹ⚳Ὢ⍫

侫伶⚳䑘姽㱽⇞炻⛐䩳㱽⮑嬘ᷳ忶䦳炻㕤䑘姽㱽䫔 14 㡅岎Ḱ䑘姽ᷣ䭉㨇斄℟㚱 ˬ⏎㰢㪲˭ᷳ姕妰烊➢㕤娚㡅ᷳ夷⭂炻⯙䑘姽⮑㞍䦳⸷冯攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗䦳⸷攻ᷳ

斄Ὢˣ䚖䘬ḳ㤕ᷣ䭉㨇斄ᷳ娵⭂冯攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗ᷳ䭬䔯忚埴婾徘⼴炻ℵ奨⮇⮎⊁

⇌㰢ᷳね⼊炻ẍ↮㜸䚖⇵䑘姽䇕姇㟰ẞ㇨朊冐ᷳ⓷柴ˤ

䫔⚃䪈⇯⃰⽆℔㮹姜姇⍇⏲怑㟤忚埴奨⮇炻⚈ㆹ⚳℔㮹姜姇㡅㫦Ṏ⍫惴伶⚳

℔㮹姜姇㱽⇞炻䴻䓙㭼庫㱽ᷳ䞼䨞炻ẍ㩊夾ㆹ⚳⮎⊁⛐⍇⏲怑㟤ᷳ娵⭂㗗⏎怑

⭄ˤ℞㫉炻憅⮵䑘姽䇕姇㟰ẞ㛔㟰姜姇⍲㙓㗪㪲⇑ᾅ嬟⇞⹎栆✳炻ẍ⍲㙓㗪㪲⇑

ᾅ嬟⇞⹎ᷳ⮎橼⮑㞍㧁㸾炻忚埴奨⮇冯㍊妶烊㚨⼴炻⯙ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰埴㓧䇕姇䦳⸷

Ḱẍ慵㥳ˤ

䫔Ḽ䪈Ὢ⚆栏ᶲ攳䪈䭨ᷳ慵溆炻Ḱẍ㬠䲵⼴炻㍸↢㛔㔯䞼䨞ᷳㆸ㝄炻ᾦἧ嬨 侭⛐奨䚳㛔䪈ᷳℏ⭡炻⌛⎗㌴㎉㛔㔯ℐ尴ˤ

ಃΒക ύࣽΟයᕉຑݾ೜ਢϐۈ҃

ಃ΋࿯ ύࣽΟයϐҁਢນ೜

൘ǵ٣ჴཷा

ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰⚈㬟䴻⣂㫉㛔㟰姜姇ˣ 㬊➟埴冯`嗽↮ᷳ倚婳炻䁢㯪䯉㖶炻ẍ ᶳẍ㛔㟰姜姇䁢↮栆炻ẍ⍲㛔㟰姜姇䚠斄ᷳ塩⭂忚埴ṳ䳡ˤ

΋ǵಃ΋ԛҁਢນ೜Ǻᄖᎍᕉߥ࿿ 95 ԃᕉຑቩ่ࢗፕϐນ

⚳䥹㚫㇨Ⱄᷳᷕ悐䥹⬠ⶍ㤕⚺⋨攳䘤䯴⁁嗽¹炻䁢彎䎮ˬᷕ悐䥹⬠ⶍ㤕⚺⋨

䫔ᶱ㛇䘤⯽⋨炷⎶慴➢⛘ᶫ㗇彚⟜悐↮炸攳䘤妰䔓˭炷䯉䧙ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇炸炻⮯ᷕ䥹 ᶱ㛇䑘⠫⼙枧婒㖶㚠Ṍ䓙䚖䘬ḳ㤕ᷣ䭉㨇斄⚳䥹㚫炻䓙⚳䥹㚫廱復䑘ᾅ会⮑㞍忚 埴⮑㞍ˤ95 ⸜ 6 㚰 30 㖍䑘ᾅ会䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⮑㞍⥼⒉㚫炷䯉䧙䑘姽⥼⒉㚫炸䫔 142㫉㚫嬘㰢嬘㚱㡅ẞ忂忶䫔ᶨ昶㭝䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⮑㞍炻㕤 95 ⸜ 7 㚰 31 㖍℔⏲

䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾²炷䯉䧙 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾炸炻侴⚳䥹㚫㕤 95 ⸜ 8 㚰 3 㖍㟠䘤攳䘤 埴䁢姙⎗³炷䯉䧙⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗炸Ḱ攳䘤╖ỵᷕ悐䥹⬠ⶍ㤕⚺⋨攳䘤 䯴⁁嗽烊ℏ㓧悐㕤 95 ⸜ 10 㚰 26 㖍㟠Ⅾˬᷕ悐䥹⬠ⶍ㤕⚺⋨䫔ᶱ㛇䘤⯽⋨炷⎶

慴➢⛘—ᶫ㗇彚⟜炸攳䘤妰䔓冯䳘悐妰䔓㟰˭炻㟠䘤攳䘤姙⎗⁴炷䯉䧙ℏ㓧悐攳䘤 姙⎗炸ˤ

䔞⛘⯭㮹⚈ᶵ㚵 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾炻㕤姜栀楩⚆⼴炻ẍ䑘ᾅ会䁢塓⏲㍸崟 㑌扟ᷳ姜炻䴻冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 96 ⸜⹎姜⫿䫔 1117 嘇⇌㰢ˣ㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 99

⸜⹎⇌⫿䫔 30 嘇⇌㰢⁵炻㑌扟 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾冯姜栀㰢⭂䡢⭂ˤ⍇⏲㕤䫔ᶨ

1 埴㓧昊⚳⭞䥹⬠⥼⒉㚫ᷕ悐䥹⬠ⶍ㤕⚺⋨攳䘤䯴⁁嗽炻㕤 96 ⸜ 1 㚰 9 㖍䴻䩳㱽昊ᶱ嬨忂忶埴 㓧昊⚳⭞䥹⬠⥼⒉㚫ᷕ悐䥹⬠ⶍ㤕⚺⋨䭉䎮⯨䳬䷼㱽炻㕤 96 ⸜ 1 㚰 24 㖍䷥䴙℔ⶫ⼴炻㬋⺷㓡䁢 埴㓧昊⚳⭞䥹⬠⥼⒉㚫ᷕ悐䥹⬠ⶍ㤕⚺⋨䭉䎮⯨炻侴䁢埴㓧㨇斄ˤ

2 埴㓧昊䑘⠫ᾅ嬟会 95 ⸜ 7 㚰 31 㖍䑘会䵄⫿䫔 0950060540 嘇↥ˤ

3 埴㓧昊⚳⭞䥹⬠⥼⒉㚫 95 ⸜ 8 㚰 3 㖍⎘㚫⋼⫿䫔 0950039651 嘇↥

4 埴㓧昊ℏ㓧悐 95 ⸜ 10 㚰 26 㖍⎘ℏ䆇⫿䫔 09508063931 嘇↥ˤ

5 㛔㟰䑘ᾅ会⯙㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎⇌⫿䫔 30 嘇⇌㰢倚婳ℵ⮑炻怕㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎⇌⫿

㫉㛔㟰姜姇ᶲ姜ᷳ㛇攻炻⯙ 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾倚婳 㬊➟埴炻怕埴㓧㱽昊塩⭂

楩⚆䡢⭂⁶烊⍇⏲⽑ẍ⁝㪲Ṣᷳ幓↮炻⮯䫔ᶨ㫉㛔㟰姜姇䡢⭂⇌㰢倚婳⻟⇞➟埴炻

␥⁝⊁Ṣ䑘ᾅ会ㅱ␥攳䘤╖ỵᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨㕤慵㕘彎䎮䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⮑㞍᷎⎰㱽 忂忶⇵炻 㬊⮎㕥攳䘤埴䁢炷⊭㊔㕥ⶍ⍲䆇忳炸䫱炻Ṏ怕埴㓧㱽昊塩⭂⁷楩⚆䡢

⭂ˤ

ΒǵಃΒԛҁਢນ೜Ǻዴᇡ୯ࣽ཮ 95 ԃ໒วՉࣁ೚ёᆶϣࡹ೽໒ว

೚ёคਏϐນǵዴᇡᕉߥ࿿Ϧݤ΢ϐက୍ϐນ

95⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾怕埴㓧㱽昊㑌扟䡢⭂⼴炻99 ⸜ 8 㚰 10 㖍⚳䥹㚫冯ᷕ䥹䭉 䎮⯨⎔攳姀侭㚫炻⭋ⶫˬ ⶍᶵ 䓊˭⁸炻ἧ⶚忚楸⛐ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇➢⛘䭬⚵䘬⺈⓮

⍳忼冯㖕傥两临䆇忳ˤ䑘ᾅ会ẍ临埴ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇䫔ᶨ昶㭝䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⇅⮑㚫嬘䘬

⎵佑炻㕤 99 ⸜攻⎔攳 5 㫉⮰㟰⮷䳬⇅⮑㚫嬘⁹冯 2 㫉‍⹟桐晒姽Ộ⮰⭞㚫嬘⼴炻 㕤 99 ⸜ 8 㚰 31 㖍⎔攳䑘姽⥼⒉㚫䫔 197 㫉㚫嬘炻ℵ㫉㰢嬘ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㚱㡅ẞ忂忶 䫔ᶨ昶㭝䑘姽⮑㞍炻᷎㕤 99 ⸜ 9 㚰 2 㖍℔⏲䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾¹⁰炷䯉䧙 99 ⸜䑘姽⮑

㞍䳸婾炸烊⚳䥹㚫⺊㬊⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗⼴炻㟠䘤㕘䘬攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗¹¹炷䯉 䧙⚳䥹㚫 99 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗炸ˤ

⍇⏲䁢 㬊ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇ᷳ攳䘤埴䁢炻晐⼴ẍ⚳䥹㚫ˣℏ㓧悐ˣ䑘ᾅ会䁢塓⏲炻

㍸崟䡢娵⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗冯ℏ㓧悐攳䘤姙⎗䃉㓰ᷳ姜ˣ䡢娵䑘ᾅ会℔

㱽ᶲ佑⊁⬀⛐ᷳ姜炻䴻冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎姜⫿䫔 1179 嘇⇌㰢ˣ㚨檀埴㓧 㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎⇌⫿䫔 2263 嘇⇌㰢炻⍇⏲㓿姜䡢⭂烊䫔Ḵ㫉㛔㟰姜姇专Ⱄᷕ炻⍇

䫔 1332 嘇⇌㰢楩⚆ˤ

6 㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 98 ⸜⹎塩倚⫿䫔 146 嘇塩⭂ˤ

7 冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎➟⫿䫔 39 嘇塩⭂ˣ㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎塩⫿䫔 1552 嘇塩⭂ˤ

8 冒䓙㗪⟙炷08/11/2010炸炻˨ᷕ䥹⯨㰢嬘/ᷕ䥹ᶱˣ⚃㛇  ⶍᶵ 䓊 ⯭㮹⥼ả⼳ⷓ䖃㈡㓧⹄ 呬 シ㚚妋㱽Ẍ˩炻䫔 A01 䇰ˤ

9 ⇅⮑㚫嬘㛇攻䘤䓇旸⇞⍇⏲ 6 Ṣ冯䑘⠫ᾅ嬟⛀橼忚ℍ㚫⟜↿ⷕ䘬䇕嬘炻侴⍇⏲ 6 Ṣẍ⍲䑘ᾅ⛀

橼⎹埴㓧㱽昊`嗽↮炻⯙䑘ᾅ会⯙ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇攳䘤妰䔓䑘⠫⼙枧婒㖶㚫ᷳ䚠斄㚫嬘⛯ㅱ℔攳⮑㞍炻 ᶵ⼿⥐䣁倚婳Ṣℍ⟜㕩倥冯䘣姀䘤妨ᷳ倚㖶炻怕冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎ℐ⫿䫔 40 嘇塩⭂ˣ㚨 檀埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎塩⫿䫔 2048 嘇塩⭂楩⚆䡢⭂ˤ

10 埴㓧昊䑘ᾅ会 99 ⸜ 9 㚰 2 㖍䑘会䵄⫿䫔 0990080213 嘇↥ˤ

11 埴㓧昊⚳⭞䥹⬠⥼⒉㚫 99 ⸜ 9 㚰 6 㖍⎘㚫⋼⫿䫔 0990064454 嘇↥ˤ

⏲⯙⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗倚婳 㬊➟埴炻䴻冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎ ⫿ 䫔 54 嘇塩⭂ 㬊➟埴炻⚳䥹㚫ᶵ㚵㈿⏲炻䴻㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎塩⫿䫔 2032 嘇塩⭂楩⚆⼴䡢⭂ˤ

⍇⏲⽑ẍ⁝㪲Ṣ幓↮炻⮯冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎ ⫿䫔 54 嘇䡢⭂塩⭂倚 婳⻟⇞➟埴炻䴻埴㓧㱽昊塩⭂楩⚆⼴䡢⭂¹²烊⍇⏲Ṏ倚婳䚠⮵Ṣ䑘ᾅ会ㅱ␥⍫≈

Ṣᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨ 㬊⮎㕥攳䘤埴䁢军䑘姽⮑㞍忂忶䁢㬊炻⼴䴻冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 99⸜⹎ℐ⫿䫔 43 嘇塩⭂炻␥䑘ᾅ会㕤塩⭂復忼 7 㖍ℏ␥ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨ 㬊⮎㕥攳 䘤埴䁢炻䑘ᾅ会ᶵ㚵侴㈿⏲炻䴻㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎塩⫿䫔 2029 嘇塩⭂楩⚆⼴

䡢⭂ˤ

ΟǵಃΟԛҁਢນ೜Ǻዴᇡቷ୘܌ڗளϐӚ໨໒ว೚ёคਏϐນ

⍇⏲䁢 㬊ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇ℏ⺈⓮ᷳ䆇忳炻㍸↢塓⏲䑘ᾅ会ㅱ␥⍫≈Ṣ⍳忼冯⍫≈

Ṣ㖕傥䩳⌛ 㬊攳䘤炻᷎塩优⍳忼冯㖕傥两临䆇忳ᷳ埴䁢炻ẍ⍲䡢娵塓⏲⚳䥹㚫 冯⍫≈Ṣᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨㟠䘤䴎⍳忼冯㖕傥ᷳ⎬枭攳䘤姙⎗䁢䃉㓰炻᷎␥⍳忼⍲㖕傥

ᷳ攳䘤埴䁢䩳⌛ℐ朊 ⶍ䫱ᶱ枭倚㖶炻䴻冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎姜⫿䫔 2054 嘇⇌㰢ˣ㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 101 ⸜⹎⇌⫿䫔 178 嘇⇌㰢炻⇌㰢⍇⏲㓿姜ˤ

⍇⏲㕤䫔ᶱ㫉㛔㟰姜姇专Ⱄᷕ炻倚婳`嗽↮炻天㯪䚠⮵Ṣ䑘ᾅ会ㅱ䩳⌛␥⍳

忼㖕傥⌛㖍崟军䫔ᶱ㫉㛔㟰姜姇䡢⭂⇵炻㕤ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇䭬⚵ℏ 㬊㕥ⶍ䓇䓊䆇忳烊 Ṏ⯙⚳䥹㚫冯ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨㟠䘤䴎⍳忼冯㖕傥⎬枭姙⎗倚婳 㬊➟埴炻⛯怕埴㓧㱽 昊塩⭂楩⚆⼴䡢⭂¹³ˤ

ѤǵಃѤԛҁਢນ೜Ǻᄖᎍ 99 ԃᕉຑቩ่ࢗፕᆶ୯ࣽ཮ 99 ԃ໒วՉ ࣁ೚ёϐນ

⍇⏲⯙ 99 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾冯⚳䥹㚫 99 ⸜攳䘤姙⎗炻ẍ䑘ᾅ会⍲⚳䥹㚫䁢塓

⏲炻㍸崟㑌扟ᷳ姜炻䴻冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎姜⫿䫔 118 嘇⇌㰢⍇⏲㓿姜⼴炻

12 㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎塩⫿䫔 2032 嘇塩⭂ˤ

13 `嗽↮塩⭂䁢冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 99 ⸜⹎ℐ⫿䫔 71 嘇塩⭂ˣ㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎塩⫿䫔 1030 嘇塩⭂ˣ冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎ℐ㚜ᶨ⫿䫔 1 嘇塩⭂ˣ㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎塩⫿䫔 3073 嘇塩⭂烊 㬊➟埴塩⭂䁢⎘⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎ ⫿䫔 9 嘇塩⭂ˣ㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎塩

⫿䫔 1058 嘇塩⭂ˤ

䴻㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 102 ⸜⹎⇌⫿䫔 120 嘇⇌㰢⺊㡬䘤⚆炻䚖⇵ṵ⛐⮑䎮ᷕˤ⍇⏲⛐

䫔⚃㫉㛔㟰姜姇专Ⱄᷕ炻⯙ 99 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾ˣ⚳䥹㚫 99 ⸜攳䘤埴姙⎗⛯倚婳  㬊➟埴炻ẍ⍲⍳忼冯㖕傥⎬枭姙⎗倚婳 㬊➟埴炻䴻冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜

⹎ ⫿䫔 9 嘇塩⭂炻昌⍳忼冯㖕傥⎬枭姙⎗ 㬊➟埴ᷳ倚婳楩⚆⢾炻99 ⸜䑘姽

⮑㞍䳸婾ˣ⚳䥹㚫 99 ⸜攳䘤姙⎗⛯ 㬊➟埴ˤ

䑘ᾅ会ᶵ㚵冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎ ⫿䫔 9 嘇塩⭂侴㍸崟㈿⏲炻䴻㚨檀 埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎塩⫿䫔 1058 嘇塩⭂ˣ冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎ 㚜ᶨ⫿䫔 1 嘇塩⭂ˣ㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎塩⫿䫔 2293 嘇塩⭂ˣ冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜

⹎ 㚜Ḵ⫿䫔 2 嘇塩⭂ˣ㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 101 ⸜⹎塩⫿䫔 1200 嘇塩⭂炻ẍ楩⚆⍇

⏲倚婳⼴䡢⭂ˤ䑘ᾅ会Ṏ憅⮵冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎ ⫿䫔 9 嘇塩炻倚婳㕤

㈿⏲䡢⭂⇵ 㬊➟埴炻䴻㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊 100 ⸜⹎塩⫿䫔 1059 嘇塩⭂楩⚆倚婳⼴

䡢⭂ˤ

ມǵਢҹݾᗺᆶݤଣـှ

ẍᶳὅ㛔㟰姜姇⍲䇕溆㴱⍲䦳⸷ḳ枭ㆾ⮎橼ḳ枭ἄ䁢↮栆炻徸ᶨṳ䳡ˤ

΋ǵಃ΋ԛҁਢນ೜

Ȑ΋ȑำׇ٣໨

⛐冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊⇌㰢䎮䓙ᷕ炻䃉䦳⸷ḳ枭ᷳ䇕➟烊⛐ᶲ姜⮑㗪炻㚨檀埴 㓧㱽昊娵䁢ˬՉࡹᐒᜢ٩ᕉຑݤಃ 7 చೕۓ೯ၸᕉຑቩࢗǴԶ҂٩ᕉຑݤಃ 8 చೕۓ຾ΕಃΒ໘ࢤᕉნቹៜຑ՗Ǵջগღᕉຑݤ፟ϒۚ҇ჹ໒วՉࣁ߄Ңཀـ

฻࣬ᜢ៾ճǴ྽Ӧۚ҇៾੻ջӢԶڙߟ্ȩ炻䔞⛘⯭㮹⼿ẍ⇑⭛斄ὪṢ幓↮㍸崟 埴㓧姜姇ˤ㱽昊娵䁢㛔㟰塓ᶲ姜Ṣ↮⇍⯭ỷ⎘ᷕ䷋䤆ⱉ悱⍲⎶慴悱炻᷎攟㛇㕤娚 嗽侽ἄ炻䔞䃞℟㛔ẞ㑌扟姜姇ᷳ姜姇㪲傥烊塓ᶲ姜Ṣ晾㚱ᷣ⻝ẋ堐ˬ⎘ᷕ䷋⎶慴 悱彚㤕冯䑘⠫ᾅ嬟⋼㚫˭㍸崟姜姇炻䚖䘬Ὢ⻟婧姜姇ᶵ䁢䥩Ṣ⇑䙲炻Ṏ℟℔

䙲⿏岒炻᷎朆㌐㡬⍇ᷣ⻝ᷳ⇑⭛斄ὪṢ幓↮ˤ

ȐΒȑჴᡏ٣໨

䇕溆ᷣ天⛐ 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾⯙ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇ᷳ攳䘤埴䁢炻⛐ˬ⮵䑘⠫㚱慵⣏

⼙枧ᷳ嘆˭ᷳ娵⭂ᶲ㚱䃉忽㱽炻㗗⏎ㅱ忚ℍ䫔Ḵ昶㭝䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⮑㞍ˤ冢⊿檀

䫱埴㓧㱽昊娵䁢ˬಃ΋໘ࢤᕉნቹៜຑ՗ำׇӭ໻ࢂȬਜय़ቩࢗȭำׇǴ੿҅ޑ ᕉნቹៜຑ՗ำׇۈܭಃΒ໘ࢤǶӢԜǴಃ΋໘ࢤᕉნቹៜຑ՗ำׇჴॄԖၸᘠ ჹᕉნࢂցԖख़εቹៜϐဤޑҺ୍˭ˤ㱽昊娵䁢炻䑘姽㱽䫔 8 㡅㇨䧙ˬ⮵䑘⠫㚱 慵⣏⼙枧ᷳ嘆˭炻Ⱄ㕤ᶵ䡢⭂㱽⼳㤪⾝ᷕᷳ夷䭬㤪⾝炻枰䴻䓙䥹㈨⮰攨䞍嬀炻ㆾ

㍉⍾姽₡ᷳン⹎⥳傥≈ẍ䡢⭂烊㴱⍲ˬڀԖଯࡋϐឦΓ܄ǵ஑཰܄ǵ࿶ᡍ܄ϐ஑

཰ղᘐǴٯӵ୯ৎԵ၂ϐຑϩǵᏢғԋᕮϐຑۓǵीฝ܄ࡹ฼ϐ،ۓǵϦ୍঩ૈ

Κϐຑሽǵᐱҥ஑ৎہ঩཮ϐղᘐǵ஑ߐࣽמ٣໨ǵՉࡹ΢ϐႣෳ،ۓ܈॥ᓀຑ

՗฻ȩǴ⚈㱽昊⮑㞍傥≃㚱旸炻侴㈧娵埴㓧㨇斄㚱⇌㕟检⛘烊Ữ埴㓧㨇斄ᷳ⇌㕟

⤪㚱》シ㾓䓐⍲℞Ṿ忽㱽ねḳ炻ㅱ㈧娵㱽昊⼿ἳ⢾≈ẍ⮑㞍¹⁴ˤ

㱽昊娵䁢㛔㟰㰉㯜㌺㓦慷䓂䁢⎗奨炻ᶼ㌺㓦⋨➇⮵彚㮹㿴㸱ˣ䔞⛘⯭㮹䓐 㯜ˣ⚳㮹‍⹟⍲⬱ℐ㚱䚠䔞ᷳ⼙枧烊䑘姽⮑㞍⮷䳬ᷕ℟⁁‍⹟⌙晒姽Ộ⮰㤕䞍嬀 侭㚱␐㗱㼬⥼⒉炻℞シ夳⯙姽Ộ㛔㟰㗗⏎⮵⚳㮹‍⹟⍲⬱ℐ㚱慵⣏⼙枧炻℟㚱 㰢⭂⿏斄挝炻⚈㬌㱽昊ẍ␐㗱㼬⥼⒉㬟㫉⮰㟰⮷䳬⇅⮑㚫嬘䘤妨ᷳ姀抬炻娵䁢㛔 㟰攳䘤╖ỵ㕤䑘姽⮑㞍忶䦳ᷕ㛒㍸ὃ⬴㔜屯㕁炻⯙‍⹟桐晒姽Ộ悐↮暋娵ὅ䑘姽

⮑㞍䳸婾䁢⬴ℐᷳ墄⃭ㆾᾖ㬋¹⁵烊95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾㇨↿㡅ẞ䫔 5 枭Ὢẍ攳䘤╖

ỵㅱ㕤䆇忳⇵㍸↢‍⹟桐晒姽Ộἄ䁢㡅ẞ炻䙲娵㛔㟰䡢㚱⮵⚳㮹‍⹟⍲⬱ℐ忈ㆸ ᶵ⇑⼙枧ᷳ嘆ˤ⚈㬌㱽昊ẍ塓⏲䑘ᾅ会⛐攳䘤╖ỵ㛒㍸↢‍⹟桐晒姽Ộᷳね⼊

ᶳ炻ὅ㒂ᶵ⃭嵛ᷳ屯妲ἄㆸ㚱㡅ẞ䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộᷳ⮑㞍炻䁢塩慷㾓䓐ᷳ忽㱽炻㥳 ㆸ埴㓧㨇斄ᷳ⇌㕟Ὢ↢㕤拗婌ᷳḳ⮎娵⭂ㆾ拗婌ᷳ屯妲侴忽㱽炻侴㑌扟⍇嗽↮ẍ

⍲姜栀㰢⭂ˤ

14 ⇌㰢䎮䓙烉ˬ⤪埴㓧㨇斄ᷳ⇌㕟㚱》シ㾓䓐⍲℞Ṿ忽㱽ねḳ炻Ṏㅱ㈧娵㱽昊⼿ἳ⢾≈ẍ⮑㞍炻

℞⎗屯侫慷ᷳね⼊⊭㊔烉1.埴㓧㨇斄㇨䁢ᷳ⇌㕟炻㗗⏎↢㕤拗婌ᷳḳ⮎娵⭂ㆾ拗婌ᷳ屯妲ˤ2.埴 㓧㨇斄ᷳ⇌㕟炻㗗⏎㚱忽ᶨ凔℔娵ᷳ₡ῤ⇌㕟㧁㸾ˤ3.埴㓧㨇斄ᷳ⇌㕟炻㗗⏎忽⍵㱽⭂ᷳ㬋䔞䦳

⸷ˤ4.ἄㆸ⇌㕟ᷳ埴㓧㨇斄炻℞䳬䷼㗗⏎⎰㱽ᶼ㚱⇌㕟ᷳ㪲旸ˤ5.埴㓧㨇斄ᷳ⇌㕟炻㗗⏎↢㕤冯 ḳ䈑䃉斄ᷳ侫慷炻Ṏ⌛忽⍵ᶵ䔞忋䳸ᷳ䤩㬊ˤ6.埴㓧㨇斄ᷳ⇌㕟炻㗗⏎忽⍵⸛䫱⍇⇯炻ṵㅱ䓙㱽 昊⮑㞍ˤ˭

15 ⇌㰢䎮䓙烉ˬ㛔ẞ塓⏲ὅ䳬䷼夷䦳䫔 4 㡅䫔 1 枭夷⭂炻伖⥼⒉ 21 Ṣ…℞ᷕ℟㚱‍⹟⌙晒姽Ộ

⮰㤕䞍嬀䘬⥼⒉㚱␐㗱㼬⥼⒉ 1 Ṣ炻䁢塓⏲㇨㗗娵炻⇯␐㗱㼬⥼⒉ᷳシ夳⯙㛔㟰㗗⏎⮵⚳㮹‍

⹟⍲⬱ℐ㚱慵⣏⼙枧炻℟㚱㰢⭂⿏ᷳ斄挝ˤ…␐㗱㼬⥼⒉⶚㕤㬟㫉⮰㟰⮷䳬⇅⮑㚫嬘㍸↢岒䔹᷎

婳攳䘤╖ỵ墄⃭婒㖶ˤὅ攳䘤╖ỵᷳ䫼央婒㖶炻㈧媦⮯Ἦ䆇忳⼴炻㚫⮯㌺㓦慷㍏⇞㕤 1 ⸜ 750

℔☠ẍᶳ炻ẍ⍲㚫㊩临䚋䜋㌺㓦炻᷎㛒憅⮵␐⥼⒉ᷳ⮑㞍シ夳炻ἄ℟橼ᷳ⚆ㅱ炻⯂暋娵℞⶚ὅ⮑

㞍䳸婾䁢⬴ℐᷳ墄⃭ㆾᾖ㬋ˤ˭

㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊偗娵⍇⮑ᷳ夳妋炻᷎堐䣢䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ䦳⸷ˬಃ΋໘ࢤ໻ࢂவ ਜय़׎Ԅቩࢗ໒วൂՏԾՉගрϐႣෳϩ݋Ǵၸᘠځ໒วՉࣁჹᕉნࢂցԖख़ε ቹៜϐဤǴԾಃΒ໘ࢤ໒ۈω੿҅຾Ε΋ঁၨᑞஏǵЪ፬ՉϦӅୖᆶޑำׇȩǹ

⯙䑘姽㱽䫔 8 㡅ᷳˬ慵⣏⼙枧˭炻娵䁢ˬٯҢೕۓܭᕉຑݤࡼՉಒ߾ಃ 19 చӚීǴ ёـѝा໒วਢڀԖځύ΋ී௃׎ȬϐဤȭǴջᔈᝩុ຾ՉಃΒ໘ࢤᕉნቹៜຑ

՗ȩǴ侴朆攳䘤埴䁢⽭枰⮵㕤䑘⠫ˬ㚱慵⣏⼙枧˭㗪ㇵ忚ℍ䫔Ḵ昶㭝䑘⠫⼙枧姽 Ộˤ⯙ᶲ姜Ṣ䑘ᾅ会㊯㐀⍇⮑㛒ὅ埴㓧姜姇㱽䫔 41 㡅␥嗽↮䔞ḳṢᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨

⍫≈姜姇侴徽䁢⇌㰢炻栗䃞忽側㱽Ẍ悐↮炻㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊ẍ㛔㟰䁢埴㓧姜姇㱽䫔 42 㡅䫔 1 枭ᷳね⼊炻⍇⮑㱽昊晾㛒㛔㕤借㪲␥ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨⍫≈姜姇炻ᷕ䥹䭉䎮

⯨ṵ⼿ὅ⎴㱽䫔 284 㡅䫔 1 枭倚婳慵㕘⮑䎮炻侴朆⍇⇌㰢㚱忽側㱽Ẍᷳねḳ炻楩

⚆䑘ᾅ会ᶲ姜侴䡢⭂ˤ

ΒǵಃΒԛҁਢນ೜

Ȑ΋ȑำׇ٣໨

ᷣ天䇕溆䁢烉

1.⍇⏲䫔 3 枭倚㖶炻⽆ˬ塓⏲䑘ᾅ会ㅱ␥⍫≈Ṣᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨㕤㛔㟰慵㕘彎䎮 䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⮑㞍᷎⎰㱽忂忶⇵炻 㬊⮎㕥㛔㟰ᷳ攳䘤埴䁢炷⊭㊔㕥ⶍ⍲䆇 忳炸˭炻嬲㚜䁢ˬ婳㯪䡢娵塓⏲䑘ᾅ会㕤 99 ⸜ 3 㚰 2 㖍㓞⇘⍇⏲㍸↢ᷳ℔㮹⏲䞍 㚠⼴炻屈ㅱ㕤 60 ⣑ℏ␥⍫≈Ṣ慵㕘彎䎮䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⮑㞍᷎⎰㱽忂忶⇵ 㬊⮎

㕥㛔㟰攳䘤埴䁢炷⊭㊔㕥ⶍ⍲䆇忳炸ᷳ℔㱽ᶲ佑⊁⬀⛐˭㗗⏎⎰㱽烎 2.⍇⏲㗗⏎℟䔞ḳṢ怑㟤烎

3.⍇⏲⯙䡢娵⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗䃉㓰ˣℏ㓧悐攳䘤姙⎗䃉㓰ˣ䡢娵 䑘ᾅ会℔㱽ᶲ佑⊁⬀⛐䫱ᶱ枭倚㖶㗗⏎㚱䡢娵⇑䙲烎

冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊⯙⍇⏲姜ᷳ嬲㚜悐↮炻娵䁢⍇⏲ᷣ⻝ねḳ嬲㚜侴⮯姜ᷳ倚 㖶嬲㚜䁢䡢娵℔㱽ᶲ㱽⼳斄Ὢ⬀⛐ᷳ姜炻冯埴㓧姜姇㱽䫔 6ˣ9ˣ11 㡅⍲䑘姽㱽 䫔 23 㡅䫔 9 枭夷⭂᷎䃉ᶵ䫎炻侴Ⅾ姙嬲㚜ˤ⯙䔞ḳṢ怑㟤悐↮炻㱽昊娵䁢䑘姽 㱽䫔 23 㡅䫔 8 枭␴䫔 9 枭¹⁶炻Ⱄ埴㓧姜姇㱽䫔 9 㡅ˬ㱽⼳㚱䈡⇍夷⭂侭˭¹⁷炻⍿

16 䑘姽㱽䫔 23 㡅烉ˬ炷䫔 8 枭炸攳䘤╖ỵ忽⍵㛔㱽ㆾὅ㛔㱽㌰㪲妪⭂ᷳ䚠斄␥Ẍ侴ᷣ䭉㨇斄䔷㕤

➟埴㗪攳䘤╖ỵ忽⍵㛔㱽ㆾὅ㛔㱽㌰㪲妪⭂ᷳ䚠斄␥Ẍ侴ᷣ䭉㨇斄䔷㕤➟埴㗪炻⍿⭛Ṣ㮹ㆾ℔䙲

⛀橼⼿㔀㖶䔷㕤➟埴ᷳ℟橼ℏ⭡炻ẍ㚠朊⏲䞍ᷣ䭉㨇斄ˤ炷䫔 9 枭炸ᷣ䭉㨇斄㕤㚠朊⏲䞍復忼ᷳ

⭛⯭㮹⚈Ⱄ㪲⇑⍿Ὕ⭛ᷳṢ炻ᶵ䫎㍸崟℔䙲姜姇ᷳ天ẞ炻侴℔䙲⛀橼⼿➢㕤娚㡅 夷⭂㍸崟℔䙲姜姇ˤ㱽昊娵䁢⍇⏲ᶱ枭倚㖶Ὢ䁢䡢娵姜姇炻⛯冯䑘姽㱽䫔 23 㡅 䫔 8 枭␴䫔 9 枭⯙ᷣ䭉㨇斄⿈㕤➟埴借⊁ᷳ埴䁢㇨⼿㍸崟ᷳ䴎Ẁ姜姇ㆾ婚Ḱ佑⊁

姜姇栗㚱ᶵ⎴烊⍇⏲Ὢ⯙冒幓ᷳ‍⹟ˣ⬱ℐ䫱㪲䙲⚈䲣䇕攳䘤姙⎗⍿㚱⌙⭛炻⚈

㬌⍇⏲ᶱ枭倚㖶⛯㚱⌛⍿䡢娵⇌㰢ᷳ㱽⼳ᶲ⇑䙲ˤᶲ姜⮑㱽昊偗娵⍇⮑ᷳ夳妋ˤ

ȐΒȑჴᡏ٣໨

ᷣ天䇕溆䁢烉

1.⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗㗗⏎⚈ 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾▋⼴怕㑌扟炻侴怑䓐 䑘姽㱽䫔 14 㡅䫔 1 枭䃉㓰ᷳ夷⭂烎

2.ℏ㓧悐攳䘤姙⎗㗗⏎㚱䑘姽㱽䫔 14 㡅䫔 1 枭ᷳ怑䓐烎

3.⛐䡢娵䑘ᾅ会㓞⍿℔㮹⏲䞍㚠⼴炻㗗⏎屈㚱℔㱽ᶲ佑⊁ᷳ⬀⛐烎

⛐⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗㗗⏎䃉㓰ᷳ悐↮炻冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊娵䁢塓⏲

⚳䥹㚫㕤 99 ⸜ 9 㚰 6 㖍⶚⺊㬊⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤姙⎗炻⚈㬌ὅ埴㓧䦳⸷㱽䫔 110 㡅䫔 3 枭⍲䫔 125 㡅夷⭂炻⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤姙⎗冒 99 ⸜ 9 㚰 6 㖍崟⣙℞㓰≃侴 ᶵ⬀⛐炻⍇⏲姜婳䡢娵⭊奨ᶲ⶚ᶵ⬀⛐ᷳ埴㓧嗽↮䁢䃉㓰炻姜姇天ẞ⌛㚱㫈仢炻 䴻㱽昊斉㖶炻⍇⏲ṵ䵕㊩⍇姜姇栆✳炻栗䃞㫈仢㪲⇑ᾅ嬟天ẞ炻䃉姜ᷳ⇑䙲侴楩

⚆ˤ

⯙⍇⏲ᷣ⻝⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤姙⎗⚈ 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾怕⇌㰢㑌扟⼴炻ὅ䑘 姽㱽䫔 14 㡅䫔 1 枭夷⭂䁢䃉㓰ᷳ埴㓧嗽↮ᷳᷣ⻝炻㱽昊娵䁢Ȩᕉຑݤಃ 14 చҥ ݤҁཀǴӧܭᔈӃֹԋᕉნቹៜຑ՗ቩࢗǴҞޑ٣཰Ьᆅᐒᜢۈளࣁࡕុϐ໒ว

೚ёǴҭջਔ໔΢ԖځӃࡕ໩ׇǴЬᆅᐒᜢόளӧ҂ֹԋᕉნቹៜຑ՗ቩࢗ߻Ǵ

೵ࣁ໒ว೚ёǴց߾Ǵ၀໒ว೚ёԾۈคਏǴόࡑᄖᎍǴаߦ٬Ҟޑ٣཰Ьᆅᐒ ᜢ൧ख़ᕉߥ࿿ჹܭᕉნቹៜຑ՗ϐղᘐ˭烊⬴ㆸ䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⮑㞍⼴ἄㆸᷳ攳䘤 埴䁢姙⎗炻⚈䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾▋⼴怕㑌扟ᷳ㱽⼳㓰㝄炻㱽昊娵䁢朆䩳㱽侭㇨枸夳炻 㖍崟 60 㖍ℏṵ㛒ὅ㱽➟埴侭炻Ṣ㮹ㆾ℔䙲⛀橼⼿ẍ娚ᷣ䭉㨇斄䁢塓⏲炻⮵℞⿈㕤➟埴借⊁ᷳ埴 䁢炻䚜㍍⎹埴㓧㱽昊㍸崟姜姇炻婳㯪⇌Ẍ℞➟埴ˤ˭

17 埴㓧姜姇㱽䫔 9 㡅烉ˬṢ㮹䁢䵕嬟℔䙲炻⯙䃉斄冒⶙㪲⇑⍲㱽⼳ᶲ⇑䙲ᷳḳ枭炻⮵㕤埴㓧㨇斄

ᷳ忽㱽埴䁢炻⼿㍸崟埴㓧姜姇ˤỮẍ㱽⼳㚱䈡⇍夷⭂侭䁢旸ˤ˭

Ṏ䃉䚠ㅱᷳ夷⭂炻䃉婾ὅ㔯佑妋慳ㆾ䩳㱽妋慳炻⛯暋娵Ⱄ䑘姽㱽䫔 14 㡅䫔 1 枭 夷䭬ᷳ䭬䔯烊㱽昊⍰ẍˬך୯ݤڋ൩ՉࡹೀϩϐคਏচӢǴ߯௦ख़εܴᡉྵ౪ ᇥ///܌ᒏȬख़εܴᡉȭǴ߯ࡰځྵ౪ϐำࡋǴߚՠख़εǴЪӵӕቪӧᚐᓐ΢ǴҺ ՖΓ΋ఈջޕǴӵ݀ځྵ౪ߚख़εǴ܈ߚܴᡉǴջᜤࡰ၀Չࡹೀϩࣁคਏȩ炻⛐

➢㕤㱽⼳⬱⭂⿏⍲ᾅ嬟埴㓧嗽↮䚠⮵Ṣᾉ岜⇑䙲炻⽭娚埴㓧嗽↮㚱㖶栗慵⣏ᷳ䏽 䕝炻⥳䁢䃉㓰ᷳ埴㓧嗽↮炻⚈㬌暋ẍ䵕嬟䑘姽㱽夷䭬≇傥䁢䓙炻㒜⣏妋慳䑘姽㱽 䫔 14 㡅䫔 1 枭䃉㓰ᷳね⼊¹⁸ˤ

㱽昊娵䁢 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾怕㑌扟⼴炻⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗ㅱὅˬ↮

昶㭝埴㓧䦳⸷˭⍲ˬ㍍临埴㓧嗽↮˭ᷳ埴㓧㱽䎮娵⭂ˤ㱽昊娵䁢Ȩ٩ᕉຑݤಃ

14 చಃ 1 ໨ೕۓ...ᔈ፬ՉϐȬᕉნቹៜຑ՗ำׇȭᆶȬ໒วՉࣁ೚ёำׇȭ߯

ឦόӕϐՉࡹำׇǴځЬᆅᐒᜢόӕǴᏵаբԋ،ۓϐݤࡓ٩Ᏽҭό࣬ӕǴΞᔈ Ӄࡕ٩ׇࣁϐǴࢂȬᕉნቹៜຑ՗ำׇȭࣁȬ໒วՉࣁ೚ёำׇȭϐ߻໘ࢤำׇǴ Βޣ໔ᄬԋȬӭ໘ࢤՉࡹำׇȭǹΞᕉߥ࿿٩ځᕉნቹៜຑ՗ำׇ܌բԋϐᕉຑ ቩ่ࢗፕǴ໻߯൩ᕉნቹៜ೽ϩϐ،ۓǴᔈឦȬӃՉຊ،ȭ܈Ȭ೽ϩ೚ёȭǴҞ ޑ٣཰Ьᆅᐒᜢ٩໒วՉࣁ೚ёำׇ܌ࣁϐ໒ว೚ёǴ߾ࣁȬࡕុຊ،ȭ܈Ȭࡕ

ុ೽ϩ೚ёȭǴΒޣջԋࣁ܌ᒏϐȬௗុՉࡹೀϩȭȩǹ侴 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾䴻⇌

㰢㑌扟䡢⭂⼴炻⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤姙⎗ㅱ怑䓐㑌扟ㆾ⺊㬊ᷳ夷⭂⭡㚱妶婾䨢攻炻 Ữ朆Ⱄ䃉㓰ᷳ埴㓧嗽↮⇯䃉䔹佑ˤ

ᶲ姜⮑偗娵⍇⮑夳妋⢾炻⯙ᶲ姜Ṣ㊯㐀⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗㕤 95 ⸜䑘 姽⮑㞍䳸婾怕㱽昊⇌㰢㑌扟⼴炻ᶵ⼿ẍ⺊㬊㕡⺷嗽䎮炻䃞⍇⮑ẍ⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳 䘤埴䁢姙⎗怕⺊㬊⶚ᶵ⬀⛐炻侴娵䁢㫈仢姜姇天ẞ炻㚱⇌㰢䎮䓙ᶵ⁁⍲怑䓐㱽⼳

ᶵ䔞ᷳ忽㱽悐↮炻㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊娵䁢炻⋨⇍⺊㬊冯㑌扟Ὢᾉ岜ᾅ嬟⍇⇯ᷳ⮎䎦炻

18 ⇌㰢䎮䓙䧙烉ˬ㞍㛔ẞ塓⏲⚳䥹㚫Ὢ⛐䑘ᾅ会⬴ㆸ䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⮑㞍᷎℔⏲ 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸 婾⼴炻⥳㟠䘤 95 ⸜攳䘤姙⎗炻㬌冯䑘姽㱽䫔 14 㡅䫔 1 枭夷⭂ˮ㛒䴻⬴ㆸ䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⮑㞍˯⌛

䁢攳䘤姙⎗炻娚攳䘤姙⎗䃉㓰ᷳね炻⶚Ⱄ㚱⇍烊ᶼ塓⏲⚳䥹㚫㟠䘤 95 ⸜攳䘤姙⎗㗪炻⍇冯䑘姽 㱽䫔 14 㡅䫔 1 枭夷⭂䃉忽炻攳䘤╖ỵ⌛⍫≈Ṣᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨⽑㒂ẍ叿ㇳ忚埴䚠斄ᷳ攳䘤埴䁢炻塓

⏲䑘ᾅ会 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾Ὢḳ⼴⥳䴻㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊ẍ 99 ⸜⹎⇌⫿䫔 30 嘇⇌㰢ˮ㑌扟˯䡢⭂炻 䓙㬌䙲⽝塓⏲⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤姙⎗᷎朆冒⥳⌛䡢⭂ᶵ傥䘤䓇㱽⼳㓰≃ᷳ埴㓧嗽↮炻㓭䁢ᾅ嬟攳 䘤姙⎗䚠⮵Ṣᷳᾉ岜⇑䙲᷎䵕嬟㱽䦑⸷ᷳ⬱⭂炻冒暋ẍ䵕嬟䑘姽㱽夷䭬≇傥䁢䓙炻㒜⣏妋慳䑘姽 㱽䫔 14 㡅䫔 1 枭㇨⭂䃉㓰ᷳね⼊炻侴娵䁢⛐⬴ㆸ䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⮑㞍⼴炻⥳ἄㆸᷳ攳䘤姙⎗炻㕤 䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⮑㞍▋⼴怕㑌扟侭炻Ṏ㚱䑘姽㱽䫔 14 㡅䫔 1 枭ᷳ怑䓐炻ṵ䁢䃉㓰ᷳ埴㓧嗽↮炻农 䓇妋慳䑘姽㱽ᷳˮ䃉㓰˯炻忽側埴㓧䦳⸷㱽ˮ䃉㓰˯㱽䎮ᷳ忽側㱽Ẍ䳸㝄ˤ˭

䷙䃞埴㓧嗽↮忽㱽炻᷎䃉旸⇞埴㓧㨇斄ᶵ⼿ἧ埴㓧嗽↮⎹⼴⣙㓰炻⤪埴㓧嗽↮忽 㱽冯⏎⯂㚱䇕嬘炻劍⎰㕤⺊㬊天ẞ侭冒⼿䁢⺊㬊烊㛔㟰⚳䥹㚫 95 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢姙

⎗㗗⏎䁢⎰㱽埴㓧嗽↮炻ㅱὪ⺊㬊䔞㗪埴㓧㨇斄娵⭂ᷳ借㪲炻ᶵ婾䔞ḳṢᷣ⻝䃉 㓰ㆾ⼿㑌扟ᷳ忽㱽炻埴㓧㨇斄⛯⼿怠㑯ẍ⺊㬊⎹⼴妋㴰埴㓧嗽↮ᷳ㓰≃¹⁹ˤ

⛐ℏ㓧悐攳䘤姙⎗㗗⏎䃉㓰悐↮炻冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊娵䁢䑘姽㱽䫔 7 㡅ˣ 䫔 14 㡅㇨䧙ᷳ䚖䘬ḳ㤕ᷣ䭉㨇斄炻晾䃉㖶㔯夷⭂炻ˬฅჴ୍ၮբ΢Ǵ஼а٩΢໒

ೕۓᙯଌᕉნቹៜᇥܴਜԿЬᆅᐒᜢᕉߥ࿿ቩࢗϷೕጄ၀໒วՉࣁ࣬ᜢݤೕϐ ᐒᜢǴࣁҞޑ٣཰ЬᆅᐒᜢȐջ໒วՉࣁ೚ёᐒᜢȑ˭炻⚈㬌塓⏲⚳䥹㚫⥳䁢䑘姽 㱽䫔 7 㡅⍲䫔 14 㡅㇨㊯ᷳ䚖䘬ḳ㤕ᷣ䭉㨇斄炻℞㟠䘤ᷳ攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗⤪忽⍵䫔 14㡅䫔 1 枭夷⭂炻⥳䓇䃉㓰ᷳ⓷柴烊塓⏲ℏ㓧悐㖊朆䑘姽㱽䫔 7 㡅⍲䫔 14 㡅㇨

䧙䚖䘬ḳ㤕ᷣ䭉㨇斄炻侴ℏ㓧悐攳䘤姙⎗ὪˬୖуΓύࣽᆅ౛ֽҙፎβӦ٬Ҕϩ

୔Ϸ٬ҔӦᡂ׳ਢҹǴ೏֋ϣࡹ೽٩୔ୱीฝݤಃ 15 చϐ 1 ಃ 1 ໨ಃ 2 ීϷ

ಃ 15 చϐ 2 ೕۓਡวϐβӦ໒ว೚ёȩ炻侴冯䑘姽㱽ᷳ夷⭂䃉㴱ˤᶲ姜⮑㱽昊 㓗㊩⍇⮑夳妋ˤ

⛐䡢娵䑘ᾅ会㓞⍿℔㮹⏲䞍㚠⼴炻㗗⏎屈㚱℔㱽ᶲ佑⊁⬀⛐ᷳ姜悐↮炻⍇⏲

ᷣ⻝塓⏲䑘ᾅ会 99 ⸜ 3 㚰 2 㖍㓞⍿⍇⏲℔㮹⏲䞍㚠⼴炻屈㚱ㅱ㕤 60 ⣑ℏ␥⍫≈

Ṣ㕤㛔㟰慵㕘彎䎮䑘姽⮑㞍᷎⎰㱽忂忶⇵ㅱ 㬊㛔㟰ᷳ攳䘤埴䁢炷⊭㊔㕥ⶍ⍲䆇 忳炸ᷳ℔㱽ᶲ佑⊁⬀⛐ˤ冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊娵䁢ˬЬᆅᐒᜢܭԏڙϦ҇֋ޕਜࡕǴ ӵᇡ໒วൂՏዴԖၴϸᕉຑݤ܈࣬ᜢڮз௃٣Ǵջᔈܭ 60 Вϣ٩ݤ୺ՉǴԜࣁ

19 ⇌㰢䎮䓙䧙烉ˬ埴㓧嗽↮ᷳ㑌扟Ὢẍ埴㓧嗽↮忽㱽䁢⇵㍸炻侴⎰㱽埴㓧嗽↮ᶵ婾㗗⏎㌰冯⇑䙲炻

⛯⼿䓙⍇嗽↮㨇斄ὅ借㪲⛐ᶨ⭂㡅ẞ䁢ℐ悐ㆾᶨ悐ᷳ⺊㬊炻㗗ẍ⎰㱽埴㓧嗽↮⍇⇯ᶲὪẍ⺊㬊㕡

⺷⎹⼴妋㴰℞㓰≃炻Ữ埴㓧嗽↮⎰㱽᷎朆⺊㬊ᷳ⽭天㡅ẞ炻Ṏ⌛℟⁁⺊㬊ḳ䓙侭炻⌛ἧ娚埴㓧嗽

↮⎰㱽ㆾ忽㱽炻⯂㚱䇕嬘炻Ṏ⼿䁢⺊㬊炻味⺊㬊⇞⹎ᷳ⼊ㆸὪ⚈㌰䙲埴㓧嗽↮℟⼿⺊㬊ḳ䓙炻农

⍇⎰㱽埴㓧嗽↮℟忽㱽⿏炻⍇冯㑌扟䚠⎴嗽䎮侴㹗⍲⣙㓰炻Ữ➢㕤ᾉ岜ᾅ嬟⍇⇯炻ᷫẍ㱽⼳夷⭂

旸⇞℞⎗㑌扟⿏᷎䴎Ḱᾉ岜ᾅ嬟ᷳ墄⃇ˤ⋨⇍⺊㬊冯㑌扟炻Ὢᾉ岜ᾅ嬟⍇⇯ᷳ⮎䎦炻᷎朆ẍ㬌夷

⭂旸⇞⺊㬊ᷳ埴ἧ炻Ṏ朆⯙ἧ埴㓧嗽↮㓰≃妋㴰⋨↮䁢⺊㬊⍲㑌扟埴ἧ㕡⺷炻䷙䃞埴㓧嗽↮ㆾ䁢 忽㱽炻᷎䃉旸⇞埴㓧㨇斄ᶵ⼿ἧ埴㓧嗽↮⎹⼴⣙㓰ᷳ䎮炻㗗埴㓧嗽↮忽㱽冯⏎⯂㚱䇕嬘炻劍⎰㕤

⺊㬊天ẞ侭炻冒⼿䁢⺊㬊ˤ䈡⇍⛐忽㱽㌰䙲埴㓧嗽↮炻埴㓧㨇斄᷎䃉シ⮵⶚䴎Ẁᷳ⇑䙲⎹Ṣ㮹徥 䨞炻冒⼿怠㑯⮵Ṣ㮹㚱⇑ᷳ⺊㬊烊ℵ⤪㛔ẞね⼊炻Ṣ㮹冯埴㓧㨇斄⮵䁢姜姇⮵尉ᷳ埴㓧嗽↮炻䨞 䪇㗗⏎忽㱽䇕➟䓂⣏炻劍埴㓧㨇斄ẍ㑌扟㕡⺷䁢ᷳ侭炻栗冒娵忽㱽炻⇯⎗傥⮶农塓ὅ⚳⭞岈⃇㱽 徥⃇ㆾ⼴临䦳⸷农䓇⚘暋炻Ữ⍰⚈ねḳ嬲㚜ᶵ⼿ᶵ⮯娚埴㓧嗽↮㓰≃Ḱẍ妋㴰炻Ṏ⼿怠㑯⺊㬊㕡

⺷ẍ妋㴰娚埴㓧嗽↮㓰≃ˤ㱩㇨媪⎰㱽埴㓧嗽↮ᷳ娵⭂炻᷎朆ẍ䔞ḳṢᷣ⻝䁢㸾炻侴ㅱὪ⺊㬊䔞 㗪埴㓧㨇斄娵⭂ᷳ借㪲炻ょᶵ婾⤪ỽ炻℟㚱⼊⺷⢾奨㚱㓰ᷳ埴㓧嗽↮炻ᶵ婾䔞ḳṢᷣ⻝䃉㓰ㆾ⼿

㑌扟ᷳ忽㱽炻埴㓧㨇斄⛯⼿怠㑯ẍ⺊㬊⎹⼴妋㴰埴㓧嗽↮ᷳ㓰≃炻᷎䃉ᶵ⎗ˤ˭

ݤࡓܴۓϐက୍ǴόࡑዴᇡǹѸЬᆅᐒᜢᇡ໒วൂՏዴԖၴϸᕉຑݤ܈࣬ᜢڮз ϐ௃٣Ǵ٩ݤڮ໒วൂՏࣁ΋ۓϐՉࣁ܈όՉࣁǴ܈٩ݤೀϩࡕǴۈӧځᆶ໒ว

ൂՏ໔ബ೛Ϧݤ΢៾ճက୍ᜢ߯ǴӧԜϐ߻Ǵ٠คϦݤ΢ݤࡓᜢ߯ౢғȩǴ侴塓

⏲䑘ᾅ会㓞⇘⍇⏲㍸↢ᷳ℔㮹⏲䞍㚠炻㗗⏎⮑娵攳䘤╖ỵ㚱忽㱽ᷳḳ⮎㛒㖶炻侴 塓⏲䑘ᾅ会㗗⏎屈㚱℔㱽ᶲ佑⊁Ṏ朆㱽⼳斄Ὢ㛔幓炻朆䡢娵姜姇婳㯪䡢娵ᷳ⮵

尉炻⚈㬌⍇⏲ᷳ姜冯䡢娵姜姇天ẞᶵ⎰ˤᶲ姜⮑㱽昊㓗㊩⍇⮑夳妋ˤ

ΟǵಃΟԛҁਢນ೜

Ȑ΋ȑำׇ٣໨

䇕溆䁢⍇⏲㗗⏎䁢䑘姽㱽䫔 23 㡅䫔 8 枭ᷳ⍿⭛Ṣ㮹侴℟䔞ḳṢ怑㟤ˤ冢⊿

檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊娵䁢⍇⏲ὅ䑘姽㱽䫔 23 㡅䫔 8 枭ˣ䫔 9 枭㍸↢ˬ℔㮹⏲䞍姜姇˭炻 Ὢ⍿⭛Ṣ㮹⯙ᷣ䭉㨇斄䔷㕤➟埴䑘姽㱽ㆾὅ娚㱽㌰㪲ᷳ␥Ẍ㗪炻㕤嶸埴㚠朊⏲䞍 䦳⸷⼴炻ἧ⍿⭛Ṣ㮹⯙ᷣ䭉㨇斄ᷳᶵἄ䁢炻⍾⼿姜姇㪲傥烊侴䑘姽㱽䫔 23 㡅䫔 9枭䁢埴㓧姜姇㱽䫔 9 㡅ᷳ䈡⇍夷⭂ˤ㱽昊⽑ẍȨচ֋฻Ծᄖᎍ೏֋ᕉߥ࿿ϐȬ95 ԃᕉຑቩ่ࢗፕȭղ،ዴۓࡕǴൺ่ӝᕉຑݤಃ 23 చಃ 8 ໨Ϸಃ 9 ໨Ϧ҇ນ೜Ǵ ࣁೱՍϐௗុፎ؃Ǵϩձ࿶΢໒ҁଣϷനଯՉࡹݤଣຊղǴচ֋ନЬ஭Ьᆅᐒᜢ

࡙ܭ୺ՉѦǴҭ߯ଞჹჹᕉნϐόؼቹៜԶፎ؃ǴӢԜǴࣁҁҹճ੻៾ᑽਔǴς ό߳ज़ܭԵໆȬচ֋฻ϐғڮ៾ǵيᡏ៾Ϸ଄ౢ៾ȭ฻دΓճ੻Ǵ׳ԵໆჹȬႣ

ٛ܈෧ᇸ໒วՉࣁჹᕉნϐόؼቹៜȭϐᕉნϦӅճ੻ȩ炻侴娵䁢⍇⏲䫎⎰䑘姽 㱽䫔 23 㡅䫔 8 枭㇨䧙ᷳ⍿⭛Ṣ㮹ˤ

ȐΒȑჴᡏ٣໨

䇕溆ᷣ天ẍ⍳忼冯㖕傥ᷳ攳䘤埴䁢㗗⏎ㅱ 㬊䁢㟠⽫烉

1.⍳忼冯㖕傥ᷳ攳䘤埴䁢炷姕⺈埴䁢炸㗗⏎ㅱ⮎㕥䑘姽烎塓⏲䑘ᾅ会㗗⏎ㅱ

␥ℑ⺈⓮䩳⌛ ⶍ炻᷎ὅ䑘姽㱽䫔 22 㡅⮵⍳忼冯㖕傥⎬嗽㕘⎘⸋ 150 叔⃫优挘烎 2.塓⏲⚳䥹㚫⍲塓⏲ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨➢㕤 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾㇨㟠䘤Ḱ⍳忼冯㖕 傥ᷳ⎬枭攳䘤姙⎗炷⏓⃵⮎㕥䑘姽姙⎗炸㗗⏎ὅ䑘姽㱽䫔 14 㡅䫔 1 枭夷⭂侴䃉 㓰烎㗗⏎ㅱ␥ℑ⺈⓮㕤ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇ᷳ➢⛘䭬⚵ℏ炻䩳⌛ℐ朊 ⶍ烎

⯙⍇⏲婳㯪塓⏲䑘ᾅ会ㅱ䩳⌛␥⍫≈Ṣ⍳忼ˣ㖕傥䩳⌛ 㬊㕤ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇ℏ㇨

㚱攳䘤埴䁢炷⊭㊔㕥ⶍ⍲䆇忳炸ᷳ倚㖶炻冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊娵䁢⍇⏲Ὢ㍸崟婚Ḱ 佑⊁姜姇烊⍫≈Ṣ⍳忼冯㖕傥䓛婳㕤ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇姕⺈ᷳ攳䘤姙⎗炻Ὢ䓙塓⏲⚳䥹㚫

⥼ả℞㇨Ⱄᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨➟埴炻⚈㬌⯙⺈⓮ᷳ攳䘤姙⎗ᷳ䚖䘬ḳ㤕ᷣ䭉㨇斄䁢塓⏲

ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨ˤ塓⏲ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨㕤ℑ⺈⓮⎹℞䓛婳⃵⮎㕥䑘姽姙⎗⼴炻㕤 97 ⸜ 3 㚰 4 㖍ˣ97 ⸜ 3 㚰 27 㖍ὅˬ96 ⸜攳䘤埴䁢ㅱ⮎㕥䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ䳘䚖⍲䭬⚵娵⭂

㧁㸾˭䫔 31-1 㡅²⁰夷⭂⎹塓⏲䑘ᾅ会䓛婳⃵⮎㕥䑘姽⮑㞍²¹炻塓⏲䑘ᾅ会⮑㞍⎴

シ⼴²²炻䓙塓⏲ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨忂䞍⍳忼ˣ㖕傥⎴シ⃵⮎㕥䑘姽²³烊℞⼴㖕傥嬲㚜㟠 惵朊䧵忼 13 ℔枫炻㕤 97 ⸜ 5 㚰 23 㖍䓛婳塓⏲ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨⃵⮎㕥䑘姽炻塓⏲ᷕ

䥹䭉䎮⯨ẍ⚳䥹㚫⎵佑⎹塓⏲䑘ᾅ会䓛婳⎴シ⃵彎䑘姽²⁴炻塓⏲䑘ᾅ会⯙㰉㝻䈑

㌺㓦慷㗗⏎㚱婌婳㯪慸㶭⼴²⁵炻㕤 97 ⸜ 8 㚰 19 㖍堐䣢ˬ䎦㚱ᷳ㰉㝻䈑䷥慷⎰妰

⼴ṵ⛐娚ⶍ㤕⚺⋨㰉㝻䈑㌺㓦䷥慷ℏ˭²⁶炻侴塓⏲ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨忂䞍㖕傥⃵⮎㕥䑘 姽ˤ⚈㬌⍳忼ˣ㖕傥㕤ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇姕⺈炻⛯䴻塓⏲䑘ᾅ会ˣ塓⏲ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨姙⎗炻 䃉忽⍵䑘姽㱽䫔 7 㡅ˣ䫔 13 㡅ᷳ夷⭂ˤ

▋⼴ 95 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾怕㱽昊⇌㰢㑌扟⼴炻ᶲ徘⃵⮎㕥䑘姽ᷳ嗽↮⛯㛒㑌 扟ㆾ⺊㬊炻塓⏲䑘ᾅ会ὅ埴㓧姜姇㱽䫔 304 㡅ᷳ夷⭂慵䁢嗽↮炻㕤 99 ⸜ 9 㚰 2 㖍℔⏲ 99 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾炻㰢嬘㚱㡅ẞ忂忶䑘姽⮑㞍烊96 ⸜䑘姽娵⭂㧁㸾㕤 98

20 96⸜ 12 㚰 28 㖍℔ⶫᷳ攳䘤埴䁢ㅱ⮎㕥䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ䳘䚖⍲䭬⚵娵⭂㧁㸾䫔 31-1 㡅烉ˬ㕤䴻 䑘⠫⼙枧姽⮑㞍炷㟠炸⬴ㆸᷳ攳䘤埴䁢炷妰䔓炸ℏ炻⛐ᶵ崭↢⍇㟠⭂ᷳ㰉㝻䷥慷ᶳ炻℞ℏᷳ⎬攳 䘤埴䁢䴻ᷣ䭉㨇斄⍲䚖䘬ḳ㤕ᷣ䭉㨇斄⎴シ侭炻⃵ὅ䫔 3 㡅军䫔 32 㡅⍲㛔㱽炷㊯䑘姽㱽炸䫔 5 㡅 䫔 1 枭䫔 11 㫦℔⏲夷⭂⮎㕥䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộˤ⇵枭ᷳ攳䘤埴䁢炷妰䔓炸炻ㅱ㚱䭉䎮㨇斄炷㥳炸➟

埴㰉㝻䷥慷䭉⇞炻᷎㭷⸜⎹䔞⛘ᷣ䭉㨇斄䓛⟙㰉㝻䷥慷㟠惵ね⼊ˤ˭

21 埴㓧昊⚳䥹㚫ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨ 97 ⸜ 3 㚰 4 㖍㚫㌰ᷕ䑘⫿䫔 0970004030 嘇↥ˣ97 ⸜ 3 㚰 27 㖍㚫㌰

ᷕ䑘⫿䫔 0970005559 嘇↥ˤ

22 埴㓧昊䑘ᾅ会 97 ⸜ 5 㚰 5 㖍䑘会䵄⫿䫔 09700033101 嘇↥ˣ97 ⸜ 5 㚰 6 㖍䑘会⫿䫔 0970019935 嘇↥ˤ

23 埴㓧昊⚳䥹㚫ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨ 97 ⸜ 5 㚰 15 㖍ᷕ䑘⫿䫔 0970008564 嘇↥ˣᷕ䑘⫿䫔 0970008564A 嘇↥ˤ

24 埴㓧昊⚳䥹㚫 97 ⸜ 6 㚰 9 㖍㚫㌰ᷕ䑘⫿䫔 0970010480 嘇↥ˤ

25 埴㓧昊䑘ᾅ会 97 ⸜ 7 㚰 14 㖍䑘会䵄⫿䫔 0970052801 嘇↥ˤ

26 埴㓧昊䑘ᾅ会 97 ⸜ 8 㚰 19 㖍䑘会䵄⫿䫔 0970063267 嘇↥ˤ

⸜ 12 㚰 2 㖍ᾖ㬋²⁷炻塓⏲䑘ᾅ会娵䁢⍫≈Ṣᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨⍇㟠䘤䴎⍳忼ᷳ⃵䑘姽姙

⎗炻Ὢ䫎⎰ˬ䴻䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⮑㞍⬴ㆸᷳ攳䘤埴䁢炷妰䔓炸ℏ炻䴻攳䘤埴䁢ᷳ䭉 䎮㨇斄䡢娵㛒崭↢⍇㟠⭂㰉㝻䷥慷侴⃵⮎㕥䑘姽˭ᷳ夷⭂炻⚈娚姙⎗㛒䴻㑌扟ˣ

⺊㬊ㆾ⣙㓰炻⚈㬌䃉暨ℵὅ娵⭂㧁㸾慵㕘娵⭂ㅱ⏎⮎㕥䑘姽ˤ⚈㬌⍳忼冯㖕傥ᷳ

⃵⮎㕥䑘姽姙⎗炻㛒䴻塓⏲䑘ᾅ会㑌扟ㆾ⺊㬊炻侴塓⏲䑘ᾅ会慵䁢嗽↮ᷳ 99 ⸜ 䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾炻Ṏἧ娚䫱⃵㕥䑘姽姙⎗℟怑㱽⿏ˤᶲ姜⮑偗⭂⍇⮑夳妋炻娵䁢㛔 枭倚㖶Ⱄ婚Ḱ佑⊁姜姇炻㱽昊ㅱ⯙㗗ḳ⮎⮑妨娆彗婾ᷳḳ⮎ね㱩⮑惴炻⚈㬌⍳忼 冯㖕傥⃵⮎㕥䑘姽姙⎗炻⚈塓ᶲ姜Ṣ慵䁢嗽伖ἄㆸ 99 ⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾侴ṵⰔ㚱 㓰炻᷎℟怑㱽⿏ˤ

⛐⍇⏲婳㯪塓⏲䑘ᾅ会ㅱὅ䑘姽㱽塩优⺈⓮⎬ 150 叔⃫ᷳ倚㖶炻冢⊿檀䫱埴 㓧㱽昊娵䁢⍫≈Ṣ⍳忼ˣ㖕傥Ὢὅ塓⏲䑘ᾅ会 97 ⸜ 5 㚰 5 㖍ˣ97 ⸜ 5 㚰 6 㖍↥

⎴シ⃵⮎㕥䑘姽炻ℵ䓙塓⏲ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨ 97 ⸜ 5 㚰 15 㖍↥㟠⭂⛯⃵⮎㕥䑘姽炻娚

⃵⮎㕥䑘姽姙⎗㛒䴻㑌扟ㆾ⺊㬊炻冯䑘姽㱽䫔 22 㡅夷⭂ᷳ天ẞᶵ䫎ˤ

⛐⍇⏲婳㯪䡢娵塓⏲⚳䥹㚫⍲ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨㕤ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇➢⛘䭬⚵ℏ攳䘤埴䁢

㇨㟠䘤ᷳ⎬枭攳䘤姙⎗䃉㓰ᷳ倚㖶炻冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊娵䁢炻⺈⓮ᷳ⎬枭攳䘤姙

⎗炷⏓⺢䭱➟䄏ˣἧ䓐➟䄏ˣ暄枭➟䄏ˣ⃵㕥䑘姽ᷳ姙⎗炸炻朆塓⏲⚳䥹㚫ἄ↢炻 侴Ὢ塓⏲ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨㇨㟠䘤ˤ⺈⓮ᷳ⃵⮎㕥䑘姽姙⎗⯂㛒䴻㑌扟ㆾ⺊㬊炻冯䑘姽 㱽䫔 14 㡅䫔 1 枭夷⭂ᷳ攳䘤姙⎗ね⼊ᶵ⎴炻䁢ᾅ晄攳䘤姙⎗䚠⮵Ṣᷳᾉ岜⇑䙲炻

᷎䵕嬟㱽䦑⸷ᷳ⬱⭂炻暋ẍ䵕嬟䑘姽㱽夷䭬≇傥䁢䓙侴㒜⣏妋慳娚㡅㇨⭂䃉㓰ᷳ

ね⼊烊ᶼ䑘姽㱽䫔 14 㡅㛒⯙䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾▋⼴㑌扟⼴ᷳ攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗㓰≃䁢夷

⭂炻⚈㬌攳䘤埴䁢姙⎗ㅱὅ↮昶㭝埴㓧䦳⸷⍲㍍临埴㓧嗽↮ᷳ㱽䎮娵⭂ˤ塓⏲䑘 ᾅ会 97 ⸜ 5 㚰 5 㖍ˣ97 ⸜ 5 㚰 6 㖍↥⮵⍳忼ˣ㖕傥⃵彎䑘姽姙⎗炻᷎㛒ẍ 95 ⸜ 䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾⇌㰢㑌扟䡢⭂⼴⌛⣙㓰≃ἄ䁢⃵彎䑘姽姙⎗ᷳ妋昌㡅ẞ炻䁢塓⏲

䑘ᾅ会㍸婳⚳䥹㚫㲐シˤ⚈㬌炻㱽昊楩⚆⍇⏲㬌枭倚㖶ˤᶲ姜⮑偗娵⍇⮑ᷳ夳妋ˤ

27 98⸜ 12 㚰 2 㖍ᾖ㬋℔ⶫᷳ攳䘤埴䁢ㅱ⮎㕥䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ䳘䚖⍲䭬⚵娵⭂㧁㸾炻⍇䫔 31 㡅ᷳ

1 夷⭂ᾖ㬋䁢䫔 34 㡅䫔 1 枭ˣ䫔 2 枭烉ˬ㕤䴻䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ⮑㞍炷㟠炸⬴ㆸᷳ攳䘤埴䁢炷妰䔓炸 ℏ炻℞ℏᷳ⎬攳䘤埴䁢䫎⎰ᶳ↿⎬㫦夷⭂侭炻⃵⮎㕥䑘⠫⼙枧姽Ộ烉ᶨˣ䓊㤕栆⇍䫎⎰⍇㟠⭂ˤ Ḵˣ䴻攳䘤埴䁢炷妰䔓炸ᷳ䭉䎮㨇斄炷㥳炸䡢娵㛒崭↢⍇㟠⭂㰉㝻䷥慷ˤỮảᶨ㰉㝻䈑㌺㓦慷忼 娚枭㰉㝻䈑㟠⭂䷥慷䘦↮ᷳ 20 ẍᶲㆾ䰺䉨㰉㝻䈑ˣ㯖㯏⊾䈑ˣ䠓㯏⊾䈑⍲㎖䘤⿏㚱㨇䈑ảᶨ㌺

㓦慷忼㭷⸜ 100 ℔☠ẍᶲ侭炻ㅱ䴻ᷣ䭉㨇斄⍲䚖䘬ḳ㤕ᷣ䭉㨇斄⎴シˤ⇵枭攳䘤埴䁢炷妰䔓炸

ᷳ䭉䎮㨇斄炷㥳炸炻ㅱ➟埴㰉㝻䷥慷䭉⇞炻᷎㭷⸜⎹䔞⛘ᷣ䭉㨇斄䓛⟙㰉㝻䷥慷㟠惵ね⼊ˤ˭

⛐⍇⏲婳㯪塓⏲⚳䥹㚫⍲ᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨䩳⌛␥⍳忼ˣ㖕傥⛐ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇➢⛘䭬⚵

ℏ㇨⮎㕥ᷳ攳䘤埴䁢䩳⌛ℐ朊 ⶍ炷⊭㊔㕥ⶍ⍲䆇忳炸ᷳ倚㖶炻㱽昊ẍ➢㕤⎴ᶨ 䑘姽㱽ᷳ㱽⼳橼䲣炻⽆䑘姽㱽䫔 1 㡅ˣ䫔 2 㡅ẍ奨炻䑘姽㱽䫔 23 㡅䫔 8 枭ˣ䫔 9 枭㇨䧙ˬᷣ䭉㨇斄˭炻Ὢ䁢塓⏲䑘ᾅ会烊侴塓⏲⚳䥹㚫ˣᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨⛯朆䁢䑘⠫

ᾅ嬟䚖䘬侴姕䩳炻䁢䑘姽㱽䫔 14 㡅ˣ䫔 22 㡅㇨⭂ᷳ䚖䘬ḳ㤕ᷣ䭉㨇斄ˤ塓⏲

䑘ᾅ会⯙攳䘤╖ỵ䫎⎰䑘姽㱽䚠斄夷⭂䁢⃰埴姙⎗⼴炻ℵὅ䥹⬠ⶍ㤕⚺⋨䭉䎮㡅 ἳ夷⭂炻㍍临㰢⭂攳䘤╖ỵ㗗⏎⎗攳䘤ㆾ忚楸ⶍ㤕⚺⋨姕⺈烊㕤䑘姽ᷣ䭉㨇斄 娵䁢攳䘤╖ỵ㚱㛒ὅ䑘姽㱽䫔 7 㡅ㆾ䫔 13 㡅ᷳ夷⭂炻㕤ἄㆸ娵⎗⇵⌛䁢攳䘤埴 䁢炻ὅ⎴㱽䫔 22 㡅夷⭂䓙䑘姽ᷣ䭉㨇斄廱婳䚖䘬ḳ㤕ᷣ䭉㨇斄␥攳䘤╖ỵ 㬊

⮎㕥攳䘤埴䁢ˤ⚈㬌炻㱽昊娵䁢⍇⏲ẍ䑘姽㱽䫔 23 㡅䫔 8 枭ˣ䫔 9 枭婳㯪塓⏲

⚳䥹㚫ˣᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨␥⍳忼℔⎠ˣ㖕傥℔⎠ℐ朊 ⶍ炻⯂朆㚱㒂ˤ

ᶲ姜⮑偗娵⍇⮑夳妋炻娵䁢⺈⓮朆㛒䴻姙⎗侴忚埴攳䘤炻冯䑘姽㱽䫔 22 㡅 夷⭂天ẞᶵ⎰炻⚈㬌塓ᶲ姜Ṣ⚳䥹㚫ˣᷕ䥹䭉䎮⯨㗗⏎⎗㒜⣏妋慳䁢䑘姽㱽ᷳᷣ

䭉㨇斄炻冯⇌㰢䳸㝄⶚䃉⼙枧ˤ

ѤǵಃѤԛҁਢນ೜

Ȑ΋ȑำׇ٣໨

䇕溆Ὢ䁢⍇⏲㗗⏎䔞ḳṢ怑㟤ˣ䑘姽㱽㗗⏎䁢ᾅ嬟夷䭬ˤ冢⊿檀䫱埴㓧㱽昊 ẍ䑘姽㱽䫔 1 㡅ˣ䫔 8 㡅ˣ䫔 9 㡅ᷳ夷⭂炻偗⭂娚㱽䁢ᾅ嬟夷䭬烊侴䑘⠫⼙枧姽 ỘὪ⮵㕤攳䘤埴䁢ᷳ㉥尉桐晒㇨䁢䘬枸旚⿏姽Ộ炻ẍ枸旚⍲㷃庽攳䘤埴䁢ᷳᶵ列

⼙枧炻⚈㚨檀埴㓧㱽昊ᷳ⇌㰢ᶨℵ偗娵侴㊀㜇ᶳ䳂㱽昊炻℟⮎岒ᶲᷳ㊀㜇≃烊⍇

⏲ᷣ⻝䇕溆㓰侴䔞ḳṢ怑㟤晾Ⱄ䃉㒂炻䃞⍇⏲Ὢ⎶慴⋨彚⛘㇨㚱㪲Ṣ炻㕤㛔ẞ姜 姇㚱⍇⏲ᷳ姜姇㪲傥侴㚱䔞ḳṢ怑㟤ˤ

ȐΒȑჴᡏ٣໨

䇕溆Ὢ䁢烉

1.99⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾ἄㆸ䦳⸷㗗⏎⎰㱽烎

2.95⸜䑘姽⮑㞍䳸婾ᷳ䚠斄⇌㰢炻㗗⏎娵⭂塓⏲䑘ᾅ会⯙ᷕ䥹ᶱ㛇㟰ㅱ忚ℍ 䫔Ḵ昶㭝⮑㞍烎