高階主管的管理藝術

全文

(1)'f"lIffn.· 'f"f.l\IIIl.+=-1f-td') • .1-15 J{. ~~. ± ft ag ft JJI!. f;fij * ... Mm.~*. ~**. -¥. :tii ~.m. i<.. ••~21m~~m.,~.~.~ ••~~.~~m., •••~~ : (excellence) ; 2)alJ*fi (innovation) ; 3)ThlIi (intuition) 1)Ji!~. 0. lIt~ 7 ~IJ!~3I1*~~ijltm. '. 1$ME~ltfjjUEl..~~~fflGIL\IU13... 0. ~. ~~~±.. ( chief executive officer) it.Jl:t.f.:fI~fijfilij , ::tff~.~~~~m~i5Cll ff~iUf J] ~~. 0. frlll9f.6Jf~~JH!J;f§~:t.f~~~IIl~. (Warren Bennis) mfBWT~~~ts~. mfflGm~~~.'.~~~~.~~,~~~~&mo. R.~:~.m~,~.tt.g~m,~~±.,~~*.,~tt.:fI. Abstract To manage a. 21. st. century organization - be it a profiting one or a non-profiting. one, we can't do without the following three important things: 1) excellence, 2) innovation, 3) intuition. As our environments keep changing at an amazing pace and the traditional mechanic organization gradually turns into the minding organization, it won't be likely for a chief executive to operate on the edge of chaos unless he learned the art of management.. Warren Bennis, the U.S. scholar renowned for his study of. leadership, believes a successful leader is the result of learning from Zen - that's something we have to think about.. ... * t 4t- ;~U't 2002/11129 ft;lt::.;p iltJf.t *fJIf€r!J·-:;:I Tl!.-~-tlt ii!.m..Jil~h €r!J ~Jt ;t.-'Jt1t .. iltJ;..i}#rrilt~~ft. 1.

(2) •••• ~n ••• ~·~.~~&.~M~. ili~~~~.D.M~ •• ~Rn~.m~fi$:OO~~ •• ~~R.n .~ ~,~.~ .*m.**'~~~~.~~~~.D •• ~ •• ~'Rna. )£~.~1'1T$ ; {E1~~ • • m~ (chaos) ~it*~&fti~ ~?f6~~::t~ (chief ffw-oo~~n~m.·$. 0. • •. executive officer) ~ffij CEO ' ~~ CEO ~.~~nIG.fj~~mt~~~m~~Jlfjg~ JJ~~ (to Qperate on the ~dge of £haos) ,. pff tJ~nIG OEC. .n~m.~~.~.~~.~&~.m.~ ~!!~~~~jtHjLWTtflffi1!. '. nj3b1ft~~~OiaJrmftllttt!fflJ. ~f!4~ 11 % '. '. ?f6m::t~~~5. 0. '. ~ffX. •• ,~**~g~~§.o • •. B rlJfii'I¥;1t~. 60. ~tt.~~;!t~l!l!~~V1tjT. 0. $~frJPJJB¥Ji. 0. (IJm~¥~. ,. 2002 ' 11. fo:l 13 B ). ~. ••• ~m21m~~m.'~~m.~~~.~~m., •• ~m~oo •. • 129* : [1]. !f!~. ffi~.M~~.m. [2] 1iU~ (innovation) [3]. (excellence). iEfU. (intuition). 0. •••• tt!~~.~ • • ttm.,~m~a.T •• ~.)£Jl. ~lHlj~~~.~ffiHf~~{,'.*fi.. 0. . HtrL5ia < IiJJBa~1-t~*~. >. ~l!l!*grp1El1~. -.*ttmili'm.n~m.~~.)£.~1'~~g~ ~j.~ &'~JlJ\l~!fJ~,.~ID~:EjJ~'.~fjg~. 0. ••• ~~n~-o.4. lIt{.,IUfi• • J\lWitJ l' ~~ii~'11. ( Rubinstein & Firstenberg, 1999) : I.CEO ~::t.r}]ffg.,,~~. OEC' rsJ~::t~~¥Ji1T~.fjg~tmm~. JJ 2. • • ~.J\l~1iU:i§&~Ij~fjg~. R it!. ·. .~~ • •1t. 50%t:iti ' 1\I~.~~~~'~tit~~. 3. • ~r~~~H~F¥1I.~~1t. 4,• • ~.~.&:~/W~. 0. '. {9U~O. 0. 1Z9.*fi• • )£§tflJ~. ffg~. §.. 0. ZPfti1(i~W.~~IJ~. 0. : &:~ , ~~I!Jit!. t§&:v)\ffM§nIG ; oo~m 0. 2.

(3) ii;j!f1-ftfJ-fJ.!I-.fif zffl,iJ]~*fflo. 5.tg~ ~1f~lltlJllfTn~jJ llij~*~-aI¥JA::t IU1i~. '. ~"t~U1i~J~xJ~1f.ml¥J{l\. 0. 6.~ffl =1'W~'!j:I¥J~jfmm~wHf§I!{tl¥J"~~. 3! I. 7 .~Il00pfT1ffIJW!HI {*Al¥JflJ~. ef. 9 .3'C7t~~Ji I {'F~;;[J~ltU[J1X filtj. 1ft ~ ~. t4 1. [. 0. 8.ft1¥fil.pg)i.I¥J~~I1'F~-mntt~:. lt. 0. 0. , JJ1n* *JmM.:y~~ I¥J fjltr1J ~t w~m.. o. 10.~~~ ~1fiv.Hltl¥J~Il. ' ~ttOJ!:tEifil!ln** 1\ji~1t~~~iH~·" (paradigm shift) I¥J~. (ilJtE~fi ' 2000) l1j~1iJfi;f[J. ; f1!ttW~lll!!it ; IIM~&l.~jJl¥Jpg~ 12.~ffl~1l ' ~7C;f[J~:?ejfHEHlm ' ~{'F*1i~I¥J~Pm 13.~1ffEl1Lffi{£;f[J~ml¥JmffrEfl ' ~mffi{£ij~"t&~IJ~jJ;f[J~IJ~nEjJl¥Jmn~ , 0. 0. 0. 0. Mtij~f!~A5cmliiEfl. 0. (Intel) ~~ (Andrew S.Grove) :tEftgpfTm~1¥J < +{it. =1')..zM~~5€~.. ~~{-t > CPtl!tH. '. :tE1i::~~~i@!fjcpOO=1'IlfTITfi~PfT~ r ~Pm"tfi~ J. infection points) I¥J~~. tfi!!!li J. ,. ~{'F~1f;f!i*rJm1*. i. @].tttWl:~~;;a~1i::~l¥Jm~. (1¥f±. ' 2001). 0. , ~:p.iS;f[J. (strategy r ~Pm". ~!ltBJ&~~?J~1¥J OEC n~jJ. 0. ~'«~~J1i1J-*"~*4. .... r. E. f. 1f{.iLfmtH$~*~f1!A f6Jf!~;lt~:E!RI¥J~:tj!. '. rt!J~~~:E!R.~*Mif±fB'~ (Peter Drucker) ~~ ,. ? f~¥UI¥J~~J1;?&~ : r ~~ill/J\m:~OB !. J. tm. jiiJ] P)J~HjH'*. 1t&1¥J:EJ! {-t 1} ~ a.1¥J 1£ ~ Wfg- Vj1f{.iL ltillA \m:~ I¥J. $~ '" ... ~'t 5cffMt ~ 11f. f±.~I¥J • • @~'~* • • • ~:E!RI¥J~*,~ • • ~.gA5c~filtjz~'::t" f#j.:tl~~I¥JJiJn~$lD~'!j:Z~l¥JmjJ (.~fII!l ' 2002b) ~11f.~11IITfirt!J*~"~?J 0. 0. 0. ~I¥J*.:. - , cr:~ vs.ti rJs1 3.

(4) ~B~M.~gtt'M.'~.~m'~~~.~~.;OO~B~Mft~~ tt'~.'#~.'~~~~~~.(~~)·0B.~~~~B~. r *~g§~ ~ J ~$~. , -l/J}1mfl~ J. • 1WJEfHltU~lf~Hf~Hi'&$. , PJfJmIDIi;. • 0B.1IDf10~m.1f (citizen-consumer) ,. •• B'~~. r N~.~. , rflJfiiff ~fJIFfIfHi~tl::\~ , ~. •• ~~~B~~~~.m~.'~.~.lf~B~~.~m~~ ~m~~.o~~g.B~~~~m,.m~.~fi~~ •• ~·~.~*~~. m~~nB'. .m~.~.M'~M~g~I~iliff.I~,m.~m~(~~m).~=~ ~~,mEW~E$,~~tl::\~KW~$o y,. ='. E it vs. I. it. ~~~~~E~~a~·iBE~~~~.M1ID~*g§·. WU. l.~DEU~ (Innovation): 1'£m.*~V!ffk!j1~. ~.~~. , f(~~EU~fJg~ , Vf.il:~PJL:JJf~,~. ; ~.~~~D*~~ 7EU~fJg~ , 1!t;k.ff~t¥JtkOO~~9~I~ ·f§tl2. ~o~1t.~ (Imagination) : ~1f:~~tj~M~1'F1f.~~m~1t.~. :3z:ttil!~t3Fff~q:tm-~. 0. ~flfl1U.&~'. .~ (Intuition) : .~:m7JtU~. , ~11l!,~.~iitW. · .fJMJiPf·~1t.~~~.. 0. WI] 3. w:. , ~D~~~~~.B1'£=+I\1f:iW ' ~fk!j~*~ml. ~~.~m0~~ • • • • 7=+.m1f:.~~~~,.*~mM=+~'~~. ~'B*.ft~~.'~~~~~~.V!f~1IDoK~~.~M~:**~~~1f' ~~~~:m~M.~MA&m.oM.~~!. ,. ItF~1t vs.~. (~j'E)r11) M~B~~~·*~m.~~.~·*~~OO~~I~~~~'~~~'~. m.'~m~,&~~. M(>C.\II~L61. ·. •• o~~0B.ft~~I~~~.·.~~.gtt·~. ~~M0B. WfJg#.)jUAf¥1'£~flml' ~tl::\~MAB"J*. (Guru) ...... JC.\.~1'£.Sffl~mijl. '. .ijiI~~~1'£~1iHi. '. OO~~~1'£~¥~!ifH. 0. .~.ffi~~~~~~.m.~$~~I~'~~.I~~~ •• ~~.ft·~. ~~~.*±.~.~·~~0B.ft~I~~~~'.~~flfl1*~~&U.. Z~. • 1fil:~I ~~1tW~::t~1t '. ~~m. ~ffiHf:E~ • • 1t~JC.\1rn. '. ~~*~~~.'Jf. •• ~ftE'.~m••*~$~,.~~~• • ~,ngm*~~gr~ 4.

(5) jfij ~~ i£.. ~. ~~:tt~. , ~U5m:tt:9E. 0. **. J,f i-~dtf. f.fJ. J. ~g. 1m ' IQ vs. EQ (Emotional Quotient). m. I~~~~. A~~~~fi.~R~2~'X®~*~. ~. ·.ft·fi.~.·. tJ. A~tR0' ~ili5~A:,\II~~ijg:1J. fg. 1¥.7~_.~·®~~mW~~ft·m.~EQ·ill~.~~.-m~~I¥.7M.:tt·. 8"J. ~. 12. (Goleman' 2001) ~d:xtRV5. 0. it~.f¥J~. ~Or: ~pJT7U. 0. [t;jllt IQI60 ~Am. ~~. Self-awareness. fjff~l} .ffiI Ilf ~{)'/"'" ",., ~ ~. ~. m~. c ~'\ JL,J'1J!j. FJ '". 1.J\l~ ~ fa{,'. M'FJ. 2.• ~~1¥.7 ~ :fx~{i5 ' ~D~ ~. . m:1JJ;J&JjUAI¥.7~.fm. 1¥.711~W~~$U 3.(3~~1ti~~~~. ~. (3$U Self-regulation. 1.1ifH~mf~WMft~I¥.71B~. _.. ~ ~~ W~ ~ fiiJifJ W,v[fi 1¥.7 ijg. . 2. f;t fJH&: ~ fin~ ~ ~ 1£ 1¥.7 ffI!. :1J ' ~ 1& tv 1fT 1¥.7 {l;Ji raJ -- ::: ,~,!. f;t. '". 3.r~llf,&{,\~fi:W:~:iJ. rmf&rJ. ,"". ' m:nft. 'ft-:1J IW~. Motivation. I 1'F ~M:t1¥.7 3]! FE MU~ 7 sE ~ WtiBflt: ; f[mtJW~Mfi:t;~. *. § ~1¥.71tJiraJ. l.5m*~m:1J:t;~~§H~'. ~J.!lc". Empathy. ffd: X tRV5 Social Skill. J\l. ~If'F~M:t. 2.15fH'!f ~ IH1!P& 1¥.7~ ~. 3.*Jl~Jl(m. 1.M!:lL& Wi. iItJ·. ~. ~J'A:,\W. r::Iif_. ~:. -*. A ~ rm 1*WM!:lL~ ~1¥.7~3]! ijg:1J ; ~~II¥.7'[fi~&:~Jti JJI!l¥.7tRV5. l:;]. ~. •. EQ 1¥.71i mf¥J~_*~. ~. ~. ifJ~. :. i![. ~. 0. EQ l¥.71im_*~Ff~ EHf: • ~ ~J .. W. fffi. IQIOO I¥.7AI{'F EQ ~~Ji~. *~ ll!i 1n ~ 3]! A ~ 1m f* WM!:lL .A~~~;f5t:EJij:l;;ll!iI¥.7~~. I tl.15 W:sz: fi 1¥.7 ijg:1J 5. A:t-~. 2.~JG)(fta"J~:W::1J. **. ' ~)(1t. ~f;t~3. 3. m:1Jt U ~ W1¢J Jt:tt1¥.7 mH:?i 4Jtt JitI1'F ~ ~R f§ 7 ~ l.ij [M~:iJI¥.7~ijg 2.~~~:1J. 3.M!:lL&51. if. ~I¥.7W**.

(6) 1'*1C1'B IQ W1Xfittrf;t~5mfIjJl'B~~{JJ~m~1'B ' {S:fi¥ltJOL EQ ~1j~Ji~I'B1f ~.~~~~~.7o~~~. .~~~~.I'BI~'~~~~~.~.~I'B.. , 1f\~r.!jl~f'Biiiifl~.{J' (Meditation) f'Bw~ , ~~ OJ t)JJ!~.~ , ~fjMz7F~~ , ~~~IL.'19:A ftfI~~1'B EQ f;t~~:±:1f~16'~Ji~MfjI'B*. 0. ~F*J.R}l1:tJJ~5t:fJT. ( nonlinear dynamical analysis) ~* ~ ~. (Chaos Theory) I'B.~ fi!fliliffl~~Jl~5t:fJT. '. 0. 0. ?&t4~ t:p 1iffi~ffif6. t:§.If:t*Jl~l£*WL~~-ml1Jt~a'9~F*J.R}I1:~*1C. '. ~lttm. ,. ~.~~~*1C~1l8 (systems paradigm) , -m1fm~t48'9~. ~~ • • 'Um~M~mffil'B • • ~.o. ffi~#.~~*1C'. ~*1C~t:pI'B~~~~I'B~~~fIl1J~7Ff;tMf'BW~o. .. ..... J. fgtl~D. : ~0~I'BAjJ~$ifillF~~~~R1J~~lfijt:pl'B-lCt:§*~ffif6 (f*~-~JtJ t:§ ) t)&0ZP~ffif6 ' t)BJfp~~I'Bi&JfiMH~~Il'BilillJ$ f,£ 1990:¥. 1997 M~fp~.~~~~*.un~~~I'B~~.m'Afp*-~~ I'B ZP¥-:]ilillJ$MU~l£ 94%ft:;t1( ft{~m 1992 fpl'B 92.7%' ft~~tj~ 1996 fpl'B 95.1 %)0 ~:¥. 1998 fpf}] , ~fillF~fJ1~ttfgUm{~~fpl'B~~*.illl~J5E7 ~II'B~~~mm ' $~:¥.-r-fp~~~fW ' {JJ~g~~Il'BilillJ$Mtr~l£~$I'B*. ~ffij , :¥. 1998 fpfp~~~~'W.~$W • • '~IZP¥-:]BJ l'BilillJ$~:¥.8~ft:~0~f;t~ -iliAm;fS!.I'BM:i\l5t ' AjJ~$ifillF~t)&0~1'B1f~~JI~iI~~rr ' Wm7F¥UflUf I'B~ ~U • • ~-~.o • •llifp*• • ~~~.m.,~¥~ •• ~~~~ ~&!~0~1'B • • 1f\~~7lli+fp*§ml'B~~~'~~I$.~~-r (1999 fp )/f~~~7J<. 0~~, AjJ~~fillr~m1~~fpm0~l¥JilillJ~~.tt. 1998 0. 0. ~~o. ,ftlli~0~.~~fp~~~!W.~~.~*fpm. tf:Uit~Jt~. 96.3% ! ~0P] 1990 fpt)*l'Bif~''''''. ULI'B~~OJ~~#.tt~*1CI'BWWo. ~I'BZP¥-:]. '.~~*1Ct:pm~I'B~M.~X. ~Y~~I'B~~~fI~~Wf;tMI'BW~o~~'~X~~-~~~I'B.~'Y1f\. .1Ii~~t1D (B)(;~:Jr) ~*1C~P~F~D.If:t. '. fI~{~. ~tt.fgUI'B.' ~~~~J!l?ii19:~1*. X ~tJJ Y 7F-~~tJJ '. Y~~B)(;~:Jrf'B.mWX.I1JI'B1f.7F~~~o. 6. Y=f (X). 0. {S~~F*J.R'11:. Y l'B~tJJ~zfl5E}11: '. .~P. t.

(7) ~ f~ :£ if ftJ T J! f. .f,ltf. ~I¥J~. ;JF~JIi~UfE1~lJ§tmm#Rt~. I¥J~. :. 1.#:J~j. 2.fI)i::I¥JfRUI : 1£-- JEiH III Vg ;fD$/l1 m: t:p fit ra 3.::ffl)i::;f01:l~ttl¥Jmra : ~flJE~A::ffl)i::I¥JI¥'&~~. *~I¥J ~.o. 4.tJ&~~8~#~15t. : ;JF~JIi~UfEl¥J1fi$M. oottm. •• I¥J#~tt~~~~ •••• 'ili~~~~~ ~~.ffi.~'ill~~mm~Zt:p~~~I¥J¥~ •• '.Ml£~)i::l¥JiHlIl~.m: Ztpo ~#~tt~mOO~~wm •• I¥J~m.ooo~~~~~ •• ~~m. f3./-l¥J~. ~15$.&'1( 1tl¥J~ffTfj~:1J (Kiel, 1996). ~~J!.I¥J.~mili,.ft. ~J!~. 0. 1\ ' II'li vs.][fi. ~tto. _It!. J!'[j:~~l¥JrmIllWIfiOOiW~ (Herbert A. Simon). :f:E. 1987 ~f!ili~~IE8~.~6. >7~'. ~7J!J[j:1:R:~j}fEJ~;JFJ!J[j: (~D~tt&@.) I¥J.J!~~ (Simon, 1997). I¥J i.1%)o iMm: ·. ~:5:tT{I~I¥JJ!tt ' OOGl::flil)i::'Ii~. 0. '. R~~D. ~ 1998. , .1t~m:tR:I¥J$.f;Jt , ~D±lL:!"Edlf~J:t (Garbage CmM~cl)~-~~~.&.~15*~-M.W~&.m •• 'ffili_ra'fi. :1J::f~JL\ ~.~J!::f-JEfE:J!!l~~ , ~m~B'iffl~*:t~¥IJ~~J!~j\j::fm ~fiilf!¥UI¥J~::f~J!lIftu (irrational) , JJit.~m@.&*ZP:Jr;J::15:tfj~tm~tif-~ , ~. ~tWtt. ~0~0~J!'.~.~J!'. ~Ulllfff. 3~.*~J!AI¥J~ffT:td$15r;~. rl3:§t¥U. ~.mftiH~_'.~@./*ZP:~.:t"f&:JjJo~~~E*~ftJ!.~ffmf&:. ~. 0. 0. rmw.~~~.JoWJE~.~I¥J&.~~~. , *ff£f~f&:JjJ1I;fiJ?fj\ff~M. 0. Rffl£Y~~::fSAZ~~. , fj~. 1998. •• 7M~~~I¥J.~'~~.fi~.f&:JjJ o~ ~I¥J tpgOOi~~~~·M·®·~I¥J15$.'15"~~ •• mm'=~ffR~~IZ~o. ~ZP:#:J. ~*~ftJ!.~~m,~.JJit~~~~M~a~~mo~~~m.~ttfrml¥J~. -~m: ~. '. .. .(. JjJI¥J~.~~:~~. :r.8.W::f~W,~ft. X. Y?fj\ :*~t~E. jiRP. ::f~D~~fll1JM.~~. t,. jJ.. ••• ~.,.*~re.~~'Wl£~~B+~oJ. ? ~.~tluJ\f!~I¥J~.f;Jtif1H~:fjBffPtu. 0. vs. • ~. *$~l¥Jffa~ftmftJ!~~m~WM.J:t~::15'HP~WJEfff~.,~tt. ~~~::f~I¥J.~. affi~.m.mW~l£~.I¥J~~I~~ftU~~. 7. •• ~1¥J.

(8) fi. 1it. 73 ,jiJl. M~~~E,~mM~Em~~~£0~~~-mm~~o. *$~~0~~m*fi~~.mm~-oo •• £m~mfi~~W~W*~~. l. ¥-~.~.m·~~.£~:r~~~M~ffim®~~.~~~*.~~~W§ tru~~W1JJt?. J. :. r~D{iiJfUffi~~f/r.j*{f&®~Jtru7G~1~lHf&~s~~?. J. r. 0. B. ~~IW~£eD~'OO£W~~fi~'£~ffl~~~.~~*.~~fi~ §.o~~IW.ffi.~$~~~. ~~~. ~. 0. 1. 1950 :q:.f\;;1&Wl~~,EHtEIJf!. '. .OO-:WfIHltfj-m~ IBM '. is IBM. IT m~ ~,~ 1t1& ~ JE1&~ , ~lc.U~ NP{!l!!£ ~ ~ lT3Z 1-\;; f£ ~ *J£5fD;ft {-(g f£ EP ~ ~j~ m. w;'~*{)Jm$rm!&o. !Jf{jl$JlU (Say's Law): {~~~IJ~.* lIt~~~Wi¥nAfr~m.L-jJnfi¥-*I!§Z ~'A~{)J~mm~~ •• ffM*I!§'~.'~~*~.~&fiE~.$~mD mW;~~A. ~~~.~~~ztru~~m.~ •• ffMa~~ma£& 0. fi~*ffl.~,~.~a~~mammztru'®~ti~~.~~~{)J~~~mfi. pq. ~mij~a~ffi. reference). Z 9}. '~~IE. ffi~9£iil1!1!£~tfj. ~~~m (frame of. 0. .*m.~-.£~~A~m~M~~ffM£m~~mm.,~~.tt~. ftU£~U~tfjAfr~fF~fum~¥U~-PJ~gmD~1TD 19~-:. 19IJ= :. 0. (teleconference) iJHT&f!A.W~gtA.mJ:'JWif£'t$!j~ (database) ~~ffimJ:'JIPJ~m{~.*JTji*4Mt~[5Jf~ffi~. 0. 0. •• ~ •• fiM.&.~~~,ti~fifi~~~.W.ffi,.~~m;ft** ~.~1J~. , ~DJ1t::t~Em{'FmflJW~!tf (Hamer & Champy, 1993). .~~mA~~=*~*£* pfTJ:'J{1gfi=**~1JlJ:Z{'F. .~o~~,~~.m.w.~. •• D. ' ~55U£M!n~'f~tttt*1J . Jn~~tHtt*U . &*UIf~tIt*1J. 0. OO~If~~~~~JE~.~&&~~If~~gDm~f£'~~~mm*~~~~.. , A;;ft£&~,S~*U.~Z.*P3~E~---1)t.mS~~{t1EEMf&~~.~ ~1&:t~{-\;; ~~1JlJ:ffi~~~M*'~~fi&~~~.~,::t~* •• ~~'.~*.1JlJ:ffi~. ~. ~H~. !;. ••~~~fi~~~~m~mA~~~~~o. 19t1- : IBM ~{fimA.n~1JOO~rlH& f§JJ= : Xeron. 6. D. , .}ji;t~E,gXJJJ ". 8. )". .f,. 5. ~. il 3. ~. :{. :;;.

(9) iIi!lf.3:.f-~f-ll!i-#r. i\ '. 5}BU/~\. (.mum). VS.. IJZm/~\. 1978 ~M~~~ ~~MI¥J~$~. ¥fRi:it' 1£?w:~~~ §fffif~fimliJlii 75 ~.M~ o.~m.®~m~ I¥J. m~~~~*I¥J~~~M,~nm¥~.-~$.~.. IlR~I¥JM*1:. '. ~~.'~fi. *:rl£.~~M*. 1¥J~~M~'¥~.M~~l¥Jtim.-.g'~~~M?mm®-.~~*, ~-*~¥um. 0. ~~~*. '. ftt!f~ffeIG\ffi$~r1:l£ n'. .g ~ z1: '. ffij~F n' ~. ~*~1:°J¥~.~~~§~~~~M~I¥J~m'~~~M*~I¥J~~'m m®~~~*~~ • • l¥Jo~~~~~~m~1¥J ~§. §. ,. ~~.gzffif' IG\ffi$ti~$:~r1:~~~*. 9d& ~. m'l£¥~:it.M • • ~~. 0. :EJil£~~1:PlTID\j1¥J (Wallenda Factor). , ~~MUIG<1J~ff:~'M"~1¥J -r J ·.. ·.. zp:m-IG\m~, ~frBm. _ ' ~Ji ~. '. ~ ~ ~. r ¥~~~* J '. ® e 71: 5E. tim~fmfl. ~~'Iiij~:tili~~,lI**1¥J. rm. , tzo jlfplT ~ : r ~~~~Jt§4!.Z. 4l~~~Jt,Jt*Jl. :tf ~O filJ ijg ~ $ •. 1'£~ fr~Ht?Hi $. 0. J. : lf~tlr!. I¥J § fX fflG ti m gf. ~ EI. (meta-motivation) , i§:ti.~.~~:tfI¥J"ffJ!~~~. 0. ~. II 1[11¥J. ti:ffr.rg~*§:.mJtJf~tt. (384-322 B.C) vJ\mlli~ftJ,f~*I¥J$jlfZ3!!l¥Jm~ (The Model of "All in Good '';. Iyteasure") B~m-f.i~~~. ,. (CEO) pfi~mwl¥J §. m. 0. fr~~HifF~~~f§'M"1=i::g~I¥J~~~:tf Warren Bennis ~2m-{llfflGJtJI¥J~Ji~. :tf'~ • • ~$Mm~I¥JM.~-.'~.M.'ffi • • ~:it~r=. JI¥J. .m,ti~M.I¥JA'MI¥J~&M.z.'~$~ffijm-'~ffij~Ar£ttJ. ~n~~mf.i~~,mti~mm.*.I¥J~~:tf°.W.fi~~*.~H.· ~n~~m~*I¥J~.~?M~~~~fio .lli=~.#~~.~*I¥JM.~§,.~mWW1=i~A • • l¥JfflG.~?~ ~~fr~ijgTm;ttWII**I¥J~fi. I¥Jwll**F7fjMl '. '. § ~ti~ ~ ffijuiilT. 1~wll**¥U~~filij8"J.~*ZP:ffif. 9. '. 0. m~ili~1ftf3f~~filijM*. l£~~~1ff4'¥U.~.

(10) , 1ttl:t~~~JL\.l¥JglIJ ' ~Ajl$U r f~jFf' J I¥J:ttW ~D.llt:t~ii .~ •• I¥JM.'_~~~BI¥J~.'~~~ •• M.~ ••~~~W$ •• 7jl~m.I¥J§.'.~~~~.I¥J.~'~~~~1¥J ••~~~=m~.:~~·$.&_ql¥J.:tt,~q~.®~'&~-~I¥J~ 0. '~~ffl~.~I¥J~~ ®.~r~ttJ. •• o~~~I¥J•• '~M~.~~~I¥J••. •• ,a~~~o.I¥J ••• fi.~~~,% • • ~~mrA.J '. ~A~*®lli~~'~.m~~~·~· ~.. '~. ' ~M:ttE~~.BtI¥J~~~~ , Nf$it'L\ , •• ~M~~~~~'~~W~~I¥J~. '~~A~~$I¥J*m~*. r J.' ,~~~~.m~~~~I¥J~'. ,mmfi~~~'&~fi~ffl@tiI¥JAW.~'~~~.~I¥J.:tt,®~. ••. ·~*.mn •• I¥J~~-~.~M~I¥J~*,mn~~~~I¥J.:tt°. r ZP:m-'L\~~ J ' ~~miGfi{r~~O*~'L\.M~ , ~~1fBfUJq{UJi~ , {1]1 ~mtJM~ {1]I1¥J-a-~ , -.-i=--~JE ' ~~~mf~l¥Jfiffijl¥J ; .R~IDiX'L\IDiX. ' 3'::liI$Jt~~~{iNI¥JI{tJ: ' ~~.w~rr~-J:1 ' M~NP~U:fJ!~ ~~{1]I?fdiNl¥J I {t ' $~*/J\*13.*IE • ~~ .. gf.iU 1" ; .~m?f.j\B ' ~~j , 1}1G~!t*~ .~-.'~~~ •• I¥JM~.ffo&.*~·~.·~~~-~~~M~D~ *'L\*.,~ , ~fI~.IL\~f~ . ~~ , ~~~J:mf~ . {~ff ffr~H~Mz~p~lSIj@wif* ff~l¥Jm~ 0. _*rui .. 0. 0. ~Ui!jH~~. iG7. , I{'P~jRJI¥JAFs~B~~~.ffr'l¥Jg~ll\!iiJ!. (1izJlJU*~) ~. r ?JT~{~$~. (~*M' 1992). , Nn~H~$ , ~~{~$J. I¥J.~. 0. ~fuAi). 0. •• ~~~~~~~'~n&~w*ff~*~'®~~~.n&~n@~.' ~.~m.I¥J§.o® •• ~M.MAI¥J.R&~~n'~.I¥JR~,.~*tt. ~~. I¥J. 0. , .R.fIg1l&~. r**@ § J '. ~ ~~ffM5H'lli*. ' Mz~P~~1&7(l¥Jwll.fjg1~*. II:c~.~~fD.~ (Herbert A. Simon) 1}1G*ZP:JiSt~.*~tt~ (Edward de Bono). J ~~~mM®~;®.l¥Ju~~r.~8.J'.R~~.m,.~*tt,~~•• 1¥J~$~~~l¥Jo~~~. I¥JR~'~nti~.Rnl¥J~W~mr.~8. • RI¥Jt!n (.ttffiiJ ' 2001). 0. Shi].

(11) ~ f~ ~ {- aq {-l£ i-4,iq. :f;~~. 5&1¥J 1¥J[J!l] ,~. 1i.'1i~~*'f - ,. rli}~2~tt r 8~8F.H~ J. (.ft\~,. 2002a). =+~*,g_~.~tt~~~,~tr~~~.~,mM~~I¥JB~'~~. !t. r.!oJ. :lJ!cP. 1¥J~~*~'.W.Mg_~~&.~~l¥Ja.~m~~~°ftO~rtl¥Ja.~ .1¥J~_.rq.~l¥Ja.J'iliUJu~~r~~~l¥Ja.J'K~~~m~U. I¥J~. r ~'Ii ' ~~I¥J~][. J ' ~~i@lM~~~~1¥J ' ::f~lij!'1i1¥J g_trml($gffiffl Jlr~nH~~1tl¥J~][."T ' ep~~m-q.~ , ~~~ , ~'Ii. !.~Jltt~. Iw.t,~,. 0. l¥Ja.'::f~~~~'~~ili~,m.a.~~~m~l¥Ja.o. ~ft~.~~@*~,rN~~~I¥J~~J~ft~I¥J~~'~®~~.~@'. , {1]\ ~~. ,. OOEUI9'~'§~*~. , tU~ililii.~W:~1¥J. 0. {g;fi~c)(~A:1i. ' c)(~A/L.\ , ~~7\:;~tU. {i'&1¥J. ~~::f~I¥J,mU~M(~@~.~~)tr~tr~~.w~mm~l¥Jm_,~.. *~. 'L.\l!l¥JlJ$--9t:lr-{@l.~'Ii*fl~ftm~1¥J. o. tzD. Llif* :ti~J~. ~,. ' ~m~~5mIDWl*fl~W:~15UEl,. (~. ' P91ti1 ' P9 D ' &1tiI) I¥Jfig~ ~Tmm.l¥J~lJ •• '::f~~~~.~~~'B~~.~~~~m~,ft 0. .~~A~'~~A~mmorr~mmm::f~~'Am~M~.,*mmM~; ®g_~BUJUm*A&m~ml¥J~~,~~g_z~trr~~~J-_~~~. ~ib. '. *'Ii. ill~m~*tt'iliJltt~ml($Wm~IDWll¥JrAI¥J~~~~J. ~*I¥J~*m~~: r~~~"T'~~~~. •• J. 0. ,m-MAW~.-.='. , 1"T;;r-:. :dr. #m•• '.UJ.~I¥J°m~g_A,ft~*'~~~~~~.~~-M~.*. :ono). ~~-M~~~,®~trg_~BI¥J~mW~~~I¥J'W~~~.~.m,~~. ,~a. J. UJ. ~t!I!. Jltt~.m*~~~~I¥JD~*~,g_~#mUJ.l¥Jo. , ~Ai:1~P9/L.\~-Mifff~ , ~fig$:~ml($gffim~1¥J r A 1¥J~~Dl~jm J' ~A~¥UAtiB"J7\:;#'> miliJltt~~{r~:fj%tr@lfmr ~$'M~·" J (Paradigm *¥Ug_~Bcp. Shift) PJTW:~I¥J~-TZ/L.\~EU~l¥Jfig~. 0. A~~T~m~~~U~,~~*~~~~o*~~~trg_mM**ecp,. UJ~~ti*.~,~~**~sm~~~mw:,m-MAW~.~~aW:~'K. 11. IJ. llil.

(12) ~~. ... A~~.~H.~~~.~~a. m.~.~~(~~g~~~)~. •. ••• ft~'~~~A~.~ft~.~fi. ·~W~~M~$'~.M~$,m~.~m*R~~-~~.~fia~~. ~ij 11N~ A:t~Amf~[I].. ' fre:1~-Efl'U:E~M*~~~Jm~~~r:p--~j}AJ¥JEP~. ~a~z.·~~~.mM.--ffi.fi@-.a. ~~~-f~. ~~fFm1i.!f;f~. r ~~ J a. (effective) ~~Ji~=if. · J;)*:fU3i: m~iA~~~*~ , ~. m1i.!f;f~~ffili~iJ;ia€iW~~Ji~A. '. ~Ji~~~*~.. , ~~5=J,~~Ji~-M$r~ , ~-f~/J\lJ\~[I]~ · m1iJJ;)~m. '. r:p/J\~. ff:. 0. ' ~-'¥m~fl*~~$ (great ideas) • llt®~$5gHffl ~~'1iJ~~.mWaW~a~~$ •• ~'~~~TR.~~M±'~~~.· ~ • • ,~&~a~ • • 7.~~ •• ~~~'~#.~.~~A.W'~.~ ~~~~~fff:*~~Ji~=if. ~.7iitWo. ~=,~.:g~~~~o. -ftftO~R*~,m~A. ••. r.~Jwr~~Jaa.M~*'fifre:a~. *mgZM'*.M.~.~,~~~~~~am~~,~~m~1i-%~AmW -.~~,a~~m~~ma~*m.,a~~.~-M~~=if·®~-M~~. ••r:pa ~~~~ . , •••• ~.,~fre:~# •• m.,.~.A~~*a , ~.~1~~¥jt~f~dfl a~f~A.J;)~~. (courage) ~~ (brave)' ff~A~OOW~.~M~' •• ~~.~'M5~·~.·MAOOW~.M~' a~m~~~m.~-m~OO'~~Allt.~. m.~¥Uf~dfl. a. ®~.'~.~1iJ~W~~~~m,~~ ~t±L.~'I'B. '. {S~~~~WII** ,t±LJ;)lItfflG~~. ~ a.~JT)(~~1TiJJ. 0. 12. •• ~ftDa-M.*A'~A* 'fiMI1~W~~. ,. ~~m, ~Dili.

(13) jtj ~tf .£ If {{.J If tt ,,~. iL--2.1& ' ~. att!/}i;:~T1rf~~JHlIl¥JM~' ;gtt~¥U~1•• ~{,\. , m~. .~l¥Jm'®~~T'~~.m®~~l¥JM~'.~~*l¥J.*,,~m~.~o. [Zg lIt. ®.~£~~*.l¥J~~~~'~~a M~.~~.iL--l¥J.,a~'. EP~. •• £ttB'OOtiBo~A~a.~. ••®~~~.~'~.~M®~m~~~.. l¥JmWo~A.~.a~,~~~m,a~.Mm*,~~~o:t£m.~~.~ ~~._o. m= ' ~Ji?J:!f~li~1i. 0. •• ~~.,~ ••• ,~~ a.~~ffM' •• ffMoa:t£.ffm~m .2.M,tim~m~ •• m~mm'.~~~T-~*l¥J~~'~ •• W~~~. '$. IJ ,:11::. {:1:. 0. ®mm~~l¥J. •• '~~.T- ••• l¥J~~'ill~~m.~~'~iL--. [tUo. 2..l¥J.Mfi.m~.~om.~~~~~.mm~mti.M.~l¥J~.fi.'. s(fHffi. tt.~o~ftJIt~:r:~E. i*" .. '. Ml&~.~~~Wl¥J. •• ' [ZgJ1t~fr~m:rrT.~.{tfJ1!~tFIL\. 0. m:rr2.W1rf~Am~,~m&~~.·~m~~'{B~a~~'.~~.T. ~*'®mm~m.~.'~. ~IE. •• ~ ••• &.·~W&.·~&~~~l¥J~.o. mll9 ' ~.:!f~1If3~.~. 0. m.~~~.*~'**.'-MWl¥J •• ~·~.~~•••• *~M~'. •••• ,®~.:t£~•• °ti• • l¥J.~~.m,. m:t£.~TffM.o.~~m. ~:t£. ill•• ~iB~;fJ'H*~M®fr~ °. :f~l±I. mE ' ~.:!f~1If3111~td'f:. 1'JE~. 0. ~~-.m.'-~~-M~~:t£~~' al¥J.J1!~j~15. ve) ,. •• ~ •• ~~'MlR~~~~~. 0. -iLiL~~a~ffm~m.'m~mOO~T1rf~M.~eo~~. 1JC. '. ••~m~. B·~~m.~M·M~a~.~'~~1'JEm.m.~~~m.·~m#~mmo m~ill~~~~~l¥J. :AX. •• '~~-+=.~~l¥Jm.~~·~.·mR'~~.. ~l¥JA~o. 1:D~. .m.a*~'.J1!~.~l¥J~~~~ ,. ~. 0. 13. •• '®~l¥JI~~~:t£ •• m®~.

(14) ~7 • • ~~~E'.fiM.~~~E·.mA~fi~a~m~,a~am '~1N~. , ~~{tl!fgt~J1:~U~WJ$ , ~fiiifut{J' • a~WJf]!fDa3:PJ+ }\!if:* ' l&m. f/&~~. , gt~QLfa'~-~ti '. fiiifut{J\-~ti. •. ~ • • ~~~~~'OO~~.7.~~a'7.. a~~~E~a~.M~'. ~*~a-mfi.~~.·~.a~~.fi~~~~~'. ••••• · ••• '. ~*.m.~~.ffi,.m-~.~E~.ffi'~~.~'M~M~·. ~tE~i!f(2000) , [~f]!fjl5~iftlt*,cl. '. s~t. ' 5R"T3tft. '§'tlN.lf(2002)' r Mmr-l$~*flJ:9:~ : ~~~~1iJJiJJjU~!J J' [5R"Tftiitl' 6, §[ 46-48. ' #H~t:i:~siz:* ~'f±lfl(ioOl) , [a{3\~~f]!tlfi! 1 ' s~t ' 5R"T3tft •. ~*lIf(1993) , [ I {'F~{J' 1 ' if~t. Q. ifitfll1] (200 1) , r AjJ~1fjW9;D~~f]!J' [mImJm~W~f]!D1i!tj1iffB*~3t~l' ~t. '. .1t:k~. if~tfiil(2002a). ,. s. .. [0f!1lfIjf]!1 '. s~t. ' ~Jm •. if~tfiil(2002b)' r~f]!~D1i!tj-~tv:/j\m:~~~~~1~J' [0~HI¥Iil~1' voLlOI·. Bennis, W. & B.Nanus. (1985), Leaders: The Strategies Taking Change. San Francisco: Jessey-Bass Publishers. Hammer, M. & James Champy. (1993), Reengineering the Corporation. New York: Harper Collins Publishers, Inc. Goleman, Daniel. (2001), r What Makes a Leader? J In Henry Jane (ed.) Creative Management. London: Sage Publications Kiel, L.D (1996), r Nonlinear Dynamical Analysis: Assessing Systems Concepts in a Government Agency J In Jay M. Shafritz and J. Steven Ott (eds.), Classics of Organization Theory 4thed.New York: Harcourt Brace & Company. 592-606 Robinson, K. (2001), Out of Our Minds: Learning to Be Creative. Oxford: Capstone Publishing. Rubinstein, M F. & Iris R. Firstenberg. (1999), The Minding Organization: Bring the. 14.

(15) ~pt.3:.f'lf:Jf'J!.*#t. Future to the Present and Turn Creative Ideas into Business Solutions. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Simon, Herbert A. (1997), Administrative Behavior: A Study of Decision-making Process in Administrative Organization, 4thed. New York: Free Press. Syrett, M. & Jean Lammiman. (2002), Creativity. Oxford: Capstone Publishing.. 8. .... 1. .:. a f. G. ". e. 15.

(16)