台北都會區住宅品質標準之研究

(1)

Arch

i

tect

u

re

.

A

.I.

R

.O

Dec

.

,1992

re D

is

tr

ic

t

s and

ung Uni versjry.

Cheng Kung University.

of urban developmem,

By using multiple re

m the type and size o~

From the view point of

trip characteristics havr

ngs of (1) and (2), we ~.~.m~¥.rm~¥fiJMtM PP.21 ~38, 1992.$12i1

te-~1i~~~';;~Z~Jf~*

~

it {-"

~ ~ ~~

...

~ tt~~.,ft~~

• •

~,~~~~,ti~~~,tt~~.~m

•

*X§~~~m~tt~®~Z$m~-~~,~~~tt~®~~~Z~~ o *~~~ ~.$~&®~~Z~~~~tt~®~~~~-~~~:~~~m~$~tt~£~~~'~ l{t.Pj!tt.t~gJJ =~Mi¥J~{*.Mz~tI:l mJJHl3I~(hypo-

thes is

)pj~~m: (1 )~~JJ~~Wtt~

,

p.~~*

:

(2)ttFM~~ttt1JD

'

mtt~JlQ~~7t~tt~~:ff~{.!£PJ~g 0

1It)'f. ,

:fIHIl±IT~

~.~PJ~~ztt~®~m~,~~m~$~~tt&~A~~R~*.~&

• •

£~~~.Mz

~.

'

mpj~1iIUWl:t.tJ~t.w1fm:$tJ~t'*

'

mlli:+-.{f.rdltt~JlQ~i¥J~ItJ:tkDt

'

.Mz~~~

".&.J.&tJ~tmi¥JJlmFfJ\:m~~mlWjzjt{l3l~

,

&RWt~\I~~n~Z~* m:1&mte~~.Mz0

aB.~FfJ\:n~tt~£~~~zffi~$m,~m7ttt~®~ o

-, Mia

.~~~ffi~*~i¥Jm~'-~*~R ~&pg)'f.$*Ei:ff4z*liB{

: (3)

J5ttf~{tf:zllN~U

.~m~~.zi¥J~~'8~~m~~m '~HMgz~~.=*~§~~~~o*&

1.*~l¥J~7t 0 ?&ffij~~i¥J~

,

¥~tt~ ~§i¥J~R~~~~i¥JJ5tt£~,ttt~~~i¥J

-~§®g '~~~~W~-~*~ill~ iflilflJ 0

1.*~mtt~M:ff.i¥J~~&~~tt~m *l~tt~£~~~W$mi¥J~m'.~

~~.,oott~®~~~*~~~~

• •

~i¥J,~~&pg~~-~~'.Mztt~~~.~

'

I

tt

0 ~Dt ° ~~lPJ~'~~JlR~z-~m~tt

&.~)'f.~~'B.~~~.,~m~ ~~.&fft®~i¥J$mo~~R~~~~A

l~~fi+~m~'ffi~W~~~~~~m Fi¥J~~8:ff-~$mm~~~~~tt~~~

~" tt~tfQ1f~~"

(Housing Standard)

£Wi¥J~~' -~ttFi¥Jtt~&OO&:ff$~~

}jqJ..~tt~i¥J" Aifl£®~~~"

(Minimum

~'~~~~~~i¥J~%~&FfJ\:~~-~.

S

tandard)&"

• •

Q"1~~~"

(Preferred

m~~~tt~JlQ~~~i¥J~~.1'I'1 0

S

tandard

)*1iIUtt~ff.(Hous

i

ng

S

to

ck) i¥J

*XPj-Ef~t~1f~

(tt

2 )

~FfJ\:~!II'

i.:~~-#n~M~i¥J"tt~®~$m ~~E$~~fiM~,m=$~~tt~£~~

• (Bous ing Code

),

~~W£~ttFZ~ ~zffi~FfJ\::m~$ffi~tt~£~~~Z.

t

,

• •

WlJiffrII: '

~~~~m(po1

ice pow

11. : m[g$ffi~-Ef~t~1fm:tt~®~Zlf¥$W

er

)

(ttl) i¥Jfi~

,

gj"~(l )m-~Z~~W m~JlmFfJ\::.1&~~~W.~o

I. '~~~'.m'~~&

••

~.~,

EB~*, fOj~.~~~~

:

(2)

*llltt~¥

='

_{1i.;Z~§IHI~~}

m

&XmM~.'fl'

•• 'BA

·*iIJt~.!l.~

•••

iII,ut.~»JJ(NSC 81-0301-1I004-03)ZS,yill~RUl

"~i&~.iM:ilUil± . "II:llam~"jj!ja~l1li

(2)

~ 1 ~!l=;~.;ffi1ll5tmZ.t±~

'$; ±lI!l~jjHH!; ft.'$;~ {1~.Ib.'$;~ {1~~ti'i ; ~jft.lbfi _lm_!i!_{1~it.II_.!l,_tr

~ !f~~ilU ; QlIt.lb1f.~[tt 1) .!.\@ '$;1J/,

~ (Zon ing Ord i nan ce) (Build ing Code ) (Hous i ng Co de; (H ous i ng Gu idelin e (Pu bl it Dousi ng

m W

• .

~ i!

..

Pl ~ tt~~lI!JIijt tt~'iiJ~i*III~Ht!JI ijtjjijllJE , :K±lI!l:&

,

••

~~~m, -1' ~ :fl".fii}tt~.fI'~ ~:&Ii1:(tIlmttll '$; § 34) ° 1 , t1F~~,ffi~~~m :&rr.[~3) ° 2 . m~.A.Dltll~. .ltll[tt4) ° , ~$jUI!~ W1IIIiIUl'!fll( , .L'). Mt itli}~~~' i}~1i 1::&Itl!!m~• • ( lUI'$; § 1) ; liI~i! ~ff.:&mt:.J!,ff o 1f~J;). -FJl El : UI!~iI1ill 2JU~i!ii~ ' .&$ ''$;JE~lI!l 3 ·IUI ' iliff ' iIi:iII: 4. 81(ijJ!~1't 5.Jtfjit 6.•~J#i!!tW*~1IIl 7 Jtfj;k:&mJtfjNti ' Rliffi ('~j!• •~itm.ilU) Minimum Standard) {1~Plllll ltt1.1tt~ff.<jJ " lIt ~.!.\@.L')' Ttt~"( Sub standard Hou s -ing ) ~lt., ~ffJ!t .tt~~Jl,1f7.l-;J, '!f ~, .L'). l1ll*ttpa~ *!.\@~.Jt!N~~; JilitI1Hitt~il&J.If ° 'l'i1iIJ.l-;J, TP!ijJl : 1 . tt~Pl$~&HI!i!!t Iiffi~N.~:fl"~O MtlllJtl:l5t 2. tt~Pl~R~~ll ;Preferred Stand -srd ) tt~Plllll ('FlU,* tt~.IbJ!!a!{ l!!~il.lI:1Uj. , lIIIiI& ~M:t.J ~iJ1ifi:&lI!l!i! m~~iIli~'i±@"~ • •a:&:lt{tw.JlU lJ'i~ o.muitt~ iI&!'If o ~I!l J;).T =-Jl : 1. tt~Pl$~i!!t.!N i!!tfli 2. tt ~Pl~R~~ll 3. ttp f.mtt~~a jtBf:t.J Code) lmm{1~~II!&M lIl1llJll lt2 J i*"<jJ ' ii~AJS~ tt~IiI~.».~ilt) .lbti.1e · !fi1ilJ.L')'TJlEl : 1. tt~~Ii!. ' Rit ' N. 2 . i±llPl~~~1!UIi ' IIUUUilU i f! i!!tBfi*1tl , l!~tIi

.:&AI.~1111

(if~1Il~1I;I,Q1! :&tt~RIHlUW)

II Pl

W WBfi<jJ W.<jJ * W . * WIiffi W Ii,*,

Bfi Jtl: l5t

ttl :filJi1tt~lIJ!:fi (reDel's I )~I!lJE'--", iJl;li£-.a~.Ib• •-"·

ittut~lmPl~II!l~m.JlJNtt~ilU~WBfi'-~jjij;iE °

i!J:3 :iU~ f tllmltl!l'$;BfiftlalilU J ,(~:jtm: § 11 ) ; (~:jt. : § 16) °

tt4:i$jL ; tJ:jtm±lI!l~m7}-'il'I'~~ilU J , § 4° .~*D:*if3\:~ll( ° ~®~,±~~tt~tt~£*~.~~." (-):5c~@I.Wi ~~~M&~~~tt~~~~R~ ' ~RA~ ~~mW~'~~fl~tt~~W~~.~ {@YtW3i:~~Jl El fi5E~fi£~e~ 7P)~.( fJJMl~1892~ , ili¥lJl936~~ , :::t~lEfl~m

Wexler & Peck,1975)

o.Ilt5'l-

'

f;J1t.

¥PXf

j!fftt~ff:.~W~ff,jJ~(Baer, 1976) ; E3~

tt~(Subst- andard Housing) • •I¥Jfi!i~j6

-mmft~1949~\lfJ5Ett~$ (The Hous i ng

_{*'~T~~~~i&Jff~m~~}

_'.~

_~~

_~

Act of 1949)Z1&' i&Jfftt~tt~~fi~{tj.

_{~~~~.Z5'I-,~nU~m}

_~

_ff:

_.B.

'1H\!!W$m~\lfJ5EJ!mmi!(Goodman ,

_{~j!~~~~,~m~*i&Jff}

_.

_~~~

1978;Wexler & Peck;1975) 0

jIDljf{~tIFlI(Clemmer & Simonson ,1983) 0

(3)

1II!\!f£~itl(o!/," $;\l (Publ ic Housing Code) 1II!\!f£~PlllflAUI j§'IIIlJt[tt2J iJi[1IQr:p' i;.i&AJSrn {1,;tiIIl!t.U~-1i6t) ,\l,!'f.~ o '!'~lJ;..cf:IJi§ • 1. {1!tZ~1Zl ' rUt '112: 2 .iia:pq il!J~~ , RUUlUU.!ill il2:1iI'Ii*.;ar&tJj .AiW*~/II!

CiIU.III~iUINlI!

Ai{1!tI!tItJiilU) W "!(f r:p

J;;*ifi_

B9 R'il

1i

'

II

~!!7\DL~

,

~:&A~ l£B9~~7PJ-iliH~(

t5i-

'

JJ~.~J;).r i

ng)

.

1iI:a9

#i[tt:i!i

~~~

,

1tUl!~1R1tt. ~~pg{±~f¥Jt £:'ft C

JfJIt

5E

.&

~~{3:sf;

monson

,

1 983)

0

:

~ lJ~ fie~.&

$1

.w~~&&·~~'~~{±~~~B9~~:& ~n5E~Tffi{±~~~B9~~~~~5E~ if.\!I!.L&~{±~Z{J{~1U~ (~J3'T::st{r.

.iJ:.1fOOB9~!.I)

(Ratc1iff,1952) :

{±~

• •

•

~V5E~.~A.mB9

• •:&A::st.

(

Stern

1 i e b , 1976) :

{±~ ~.B9t~,~:&~t\!!

• • •

~~~mB9.*.~®~5E'®.

~f4.~.B9~rdlFf:YiJtJ-ff:l:~.B9~1r.

~.J1tV5E~~

(Baer

,1

976;C1emmer

&

IlOn50

n,1983)

0 ~.g-®§ 'ill@~~1JJ~~

~db

• •

~~~'

• •

~B9 0

~~.~~~~JJtt~~.~$:&$m~

~~~g.o~~fi~~~~U~.~$B9.

J!I!»(the

theory of the f i rm):&l!l!.tt:ifHt

tr

f.i

Jl

»(the theory of consumer be

av

ior under

rationing)m~.' ~m{±~

i.~mB9.~~~~m~~~{±p.tttt~

• •

~.G{±~~.'£~~~~.~~B9.

1:(

li11er,1973;Walden, 1987;Rava11 ion,

I~)o m~~x.~B9~.~.~£~{±~ i.$mWffl.DL*~JmW(Walden,

1987)

,~ &~rfHI~f'F5&$B9~ji(

Mi Iler, 1973) ,

1~~~~B9{±~~.$m%~~.~n~* 1~~.*'R~*Mn~~~'~~~~A

p

fl*

_

$ittt(Rava 11 ion, 1989)

0 ~llt

'

~ *Lm$&ti~~1JJ~ft~~ffi~~~~tt~

db

• •

¥:&$~J1.B9&,~·jj: 0 ~~~pgti~{±~~.B9ffiH~~'~* 1.~@tt~~~.B9~.:&~.m~~$n $L~M~,~~{±~~.~t\!!B9~~~~~

o *?wi&(61~ )tt~'if~~P'1~~~n

'

*JE

ADmd'*~

• •

nh~~m~~5E{±~OO .~.~IU~ ~B~(62~)RX~::st$~5E0 tt~~• •~B9m.tt,~m~.*t\!!~.B9

· ~~.~'e~.~~~~,~.

'j(ft:?(flt®n ' ~&'_~~IIlI~rdl~.®~ .~.11 0 _ttf~(74~)tt~~W!,*.m~PJ-~ ~~.~~~~{±p%ttJJm{±~oo*.B9. *.~'m~R~~~{±~OO*.B9~~o*

if

~1J!JijB9jn1:&meW5l:1iZ:'W' tt~.(80

.)~if1ef§m ' {fUI:J;:B9~~R~*~~R

n;.t:fJHPIlt5E@Jt~t\!! ' ~J..)'60:&80~~~:m:

-~:&~~tt~~~~.;tt.&RX~~$~

fljffl ~

M?tfff$ (AHP)

'*

te

~tlii~rdl

f§WB9:fi

M(we ight):J;:/J\

,

~*~-~~~~$B9il11l~

o

Rgn::st~

$ ,

fTJ&~*!H~.~{±~

(75

~)ttJJ~~$:&~~{±~~5E~~B9~~{±

~:&m{±~.~.'~.fTW~B9~fTtt?tfff

o

m::st $$*mte

B9~$

(ffiDe Iph

i

$~

t±l )

~~,wmDL~~'J&~~.nn~fT1JJM~ lito W~~ffi~~T'~P'1JJtt~~.~.:& $mB9~~1JJ~~~'~~Y~~M~B9?tfff o (=)~~~E1 ~WJffi~'J&~n5Ett~~~~.B9§B9 '~Tm~~~~{±PB9~~~&~~W~~ '£~~~~~{±~~.B9ffl.om~~$B9 V5E~~.Mt±l~mB9o.§~'RXE.~ ~~T,~~nB9~~,~.~n.B9~*~ ~il1Il'~P'1~~JJ~tt~~.~t\!!W~*zM B9~~

(lff3)

0

*::stPJ-

TOO~@llll~M~{± ~~lJ.~$W~*r~B9lijjf* 0 R~l $'~~~~{±~~.'~~~~ ~*0 fftJ~ll {-t~~.tt~~ff~jf~~* ~

(tt4)

oAB~~~~{±~£ff~.(mini

mum standard) , llt

ffiJ&~n5EPJ-~~ttpa

~*$B9~~W~~;CD~~~{±~~.~t\!!

(preferred standard)'

lltmJ&~~~{±~

~.B9J&m§~oE1Fl m~~AP.~{±~

~.~~*~:E'F'~-~~AP.~{±~~ .~~*~om~~m~oo~.!!7\~~~'~

!112:&[I!3ffi~ 0

R!il2$ ,

1¥i~EF m~~AP.~{±~~

.B9~*'®~*~.~B9tt~£.moa

'

;sJ&~~Q~~.~$m~~A1Bl ,~~,~~ ~AP~$.~obB9~.ollt~J&~fi~$JJ

QR

~rdl B9~JIE~{jj;fliiWJ

(s u bs i d

y) tJ-m~~ ~APB9.~ngn~E1Fl '~~AP~1fi.mtlD .X.~{±~~.B9~*,m~~~~~~B9 .~om~~~WJ~::st~$~@~~&W~~ {±~£.$mB9JJf-:~~-o R1II3$'1¥i~E'F'm-~~APW~{±

23

(4)

i I l __ - --- ----A

c

l'

m2t-'

E'---·---~--- -__ __ EI---J- __~-

q___

~

_____ _

_

___ ~---

FI E -- -- - - -p - -- ---- --- -- -~--- - - -F r : R i&1f.f 'iiliWJ 01 ~

1 b

1c )

{tto"b~ B D

.1

.~*iI:B . O. EI ias, "A COllprehensive Model for Housing Standards: Theoretical analysis and appli cation to in the Sudan", Elistics, No.2l6, 1973.

*~~B~'liT.a!r' ft~~.~~,ftp~.,ft~~.~ *.:2.III~1II A AI c r'

~

*

-__ EI ___ j ___~___ ____ _____ ___ ~---FI E ---j---P

-

--

---

-

--.J---

F r R 0 1

fa

Tb

Tc )

{ttJl,~ B BI D

1112

fi~.~W~~AP.:2.III~1II ~&.~~~~*,x~~m~mm~~: 1. ~~-~~AF~.~m~~~~~~ ~~~~~*,~m~~~~~ttF& *tt~&~~~D~~o~tt~~~( ~.)~m~~~g~mB~.rom~ m~~tt~&~~~(H5) 'H~~ ~~~N~*~m~r'-~~AF~ ~n~~.W~~.M~&Wtt~&~ ,~Jlttt~&~~EBIII$~oa~Tt-¥ A C C_I

1'

.1

l' ~*

E

;

-

J---

-l

---

--

---Z---

-

/-

-

1 -]

----

-

F;

EI -- ---, ----.---- - ________FI rI 1 0

·c ·

a

T

b

I

~

tt:tci" B D DI

1113

~~*~~-~~AP.:2..~~

ob 0 Jltm1i&:J?1~~~~ittt1:; &bJi

~EB CD ~~¥C1Dl •

tEir3!:.

§

ltt

m

*~i%~tt~£fio

2. ~JW5lIt~~ztjJ , m~~H!i\tj~WJ~tt Fztt~&~m*o m~~m~~ffi~ ~ftMOO~~~~. ' ttF~ffi~.w .~,tt~&~~*~&~~.&~, r.~~no m@~~~*m~~~~ ~&tct~~~~&~

:

(1) EB~ilnpft.~~.' i$-m!1MI~ mjfu~~~ , ~tt~jHt

(:tEl

)

~.1JD~N*~ttFffi~jf.IJD ~~N

'

~RP1!U~7ttFltte~

fjg~ , ~3&tt~Jl~fi*I!IJfi~i8

1JD~m* 0 (2) :tigtttF~~~~IUl*~ ' 83~ 1V±1l~~~&~

,

~i1Jit!nl;J'~ ~~fIx: § ~~.1JD ' :ffF rs)dJ ::f~~m~r' ~~7{:E~P:l~ M~1f!* Jlt~ 0

,

{£jtfi.ft.~ji ~$ , ~~A~T:;c~BlI~fl!! at ' Jffi.~~M~.*$Ilit~ 0

~Jlttt~&~*

l!l

m

f**

:1JDffiil

Tt-o

*m~~~$,~mjfu

~~

~~~

.

M~

a

*'3$,m

~

~~

~.~

~~m

jfuliill&1!f&~zjl~~*aI

I'

rPJ

lI:8~

hI;'

• JIlt£

J"i

)Ht~

~# E'F' Z$

c 0

it<fti~~:flIJtI 1I1l~ (hypot l I.-ft(.IW~~ l:~.{i~ 1!tW~liLJ.S 2.

-El

~t1W.ij m~'

ttf

f{tlTt-ri~ ~*,

jli®""

, JIl{i!t&fU

IfJ

Jli£.&{iF

~

=

"1±~~j

(

-)

t£!t~P'l!j {t~fflpft ~

:r-

H

U'

hDPJ.{i;

l:t£!t&fi

!

~.m.'&~ .iL.ItJ5{i~

;IMit (~~

..

n*{i!t~p~

,

*iF~flgtF

.

0 ~'lVf

It

11 !f.tjJ ~:m: ~ 'Mtpr~lJi~~ 'f'.~~: ~m ~."' ) '1&~

z••

o '¥~1JD.Jil t'{aggrega t e) °l'~m.(f. (It 6) 0 B~ tit1t{AHP )" ,

nt1t '

De 1- phi mltl~Jlt1Jt!*

(5)

: C C1

(

,I

f

--/

T-

J---

· -

--

r;

~

-

-l

---

--_

rl 1"--:> a rb J~ ttu"J" D DI lApZ.~ 1lJJjtf~38tt~£Jt DI

'

1f

iftdfUHJ

..t

m

[ 0 ffl fij.

B<J

~i\l~WJ ~tt • 0 @

1f

~'Hp:l1B

m:

em

:

\1 '

ttF~m~ftI:j!f 7tB<JJ!I~.Ul~~~ ~~'§.

"*

lij.jfu

1199

jQj

.

•

:

B<J

~.

•

~

rP

ffll

iIa<J

, {ttt

f{';

1\

it

UE

t

!It*~ttFm~ilhD !:!p ~rr ~

7 ttFi

~Jta<J [1

f{'; J'b

ff

*

g RT

fi i8 ~B<J~rJB~fi

'

fE~

&. '

$$jtgm:'J'~

vJt1Jo '

1f

Fi

P9A

[J

F '

~97ttf{;pg?t:

t

5'f. ' 1f

i\iti

ti

1tI'l9 jj: '-~T:9:~BIl~ff!! ~

Fdl

B<J

11 *

!Jj\ I~d~ 0

f

~J!ffl ~~

11 0rm ~

~{I~tIl89~.MiE ~

tll

B<J

~

W

IIf

{g!

~

rf.

:II'rE.Jtc~~ hll' e~~·B<J~*Jt~o.§~,tt?~

#

E

'

F'

~~*, tt~JlrlffJjtfEE

oa

~m ~$~~~~~B<J~~,*~~~lli~~ .tI~

(hypothesis)

t)f,!j~-?P~m : 1.{t(.!W~~1 1!iB<J~EA' -mB<J~~tJ ~~.tt~~ffB<J~~~~o~~1lJEE

1!t:W~

Iil

.FeEl

fIt!lli

m:

B<J W*,+

rp

~

m

0

2.il~t~*m:

'

:::tt~~-Er~tm

'

~Dm2 15

m~'tt?B<Jm~.~Jt~,@tt~~ f{~7t.ttli¥~~fI£B<J1lJng 0

~~,~~!W~~%B<JM~1lJ~~-@~ .~tt~~fi~~¥9~~~~~!llitt~~ .atJ~~.&ttF B<J~~ngtJffij1liUn 0

='

1t..:z.}t1L

-) ttf{'; Jlrlff

nH~ ~~

l&EdJO

m

tt~~fi~-@~~B<J~~'~~~.lli

ff

fmltlJDt)tff

•

.&~:m(Goodman ,1978) 0 ~Ltt~J'bfim~mm-~tt.m~,~~ 1~.m.'&~.~~N®~~tt~J'bff;tt ~i

••

~tt~~M*L1lJ~m?·~·~m

=1111

.

(*~. ~ tf~.

'

80fF) 0 EE~ .M.ttf{';~fi.~.&$mill~tt~~$m~ ·~~~~~F·~m@M~.~tt~J'bffm , ₀ ~9\-

'

*~~t)~~~1f~m68¥78fF;tt Itll~tj:l~E:B<Jtt~~~W*'+:m~ 0 EE~JJf(Ml .Mtj:l~~B<JmM,{t?·~m@M~B<Jm~

'"A

:1i5

~

;

~

m

B<J:Ii *'+

¥,t73U

::f

JE

({Ii~

1lJ

.&

'

11:

~.~) ,a::f~A~.o.2m*~~{tm o

tm.

£~1JD.If{(we

ight )B<Jf'Fm '

~~1f~~

€i(aggregate)

~~m~, t)~:m~fttt~~ .0~~m.B<J~m~~1f.EWill*~~~

(tt6)

o.~§!W-.~~~~m"~M~ fi"t!(AHP)" '~i&J.W~U",~~~E: (HP~.~ "Jjt!. Del-

ph i

method)~~~~lli1JomWi' iJ!1t!~JIt~$ft~.tJ, .a~WB<JW*f'F~

-82

tt~~.ffi~·~*~~~~Z~~

...

bD. liI.lJ(§

•

~

•

100 tt 't: 6/, 1( fS 0. 2 ft,A.1o!:IUll!l (tt't:.iil!ll J"~,A.O.) IOil' l;.lJ: SJiII . 10il'

•

SJiII 80

SJII' - 8i1' lit •

SJII' 60 SJII'J;n

• •

0. 2 ftllll~m,A.. (J"I'!,A.OItI ~mmllll.) I 05,A.J;(r 100 O.S,A. . , ,A.

•

I,A. 80 I,A. -2,A.

• •

2,A. 60

2,A. -. ,A. lit •

.,A. 0

0.2 J8 , lIt'JI IH:r1IIltI

J8li-. ' lIt!!!=. ' JlIfi: : . 100

J813-. ' lIt!!!-. ' JlIfi = . 80

J8li-W ,lIt!!!-. ' JlIfi-JJ 60

;)I;<l>lf=IHII' 'lttll!#lfIIUl 40 'It<l>lf-IO'Il·;lttll!#fl'*a 20 ::"'lfa 0 0.2 tt't:Jllit tt._JII 60 11• •15. 40 ttllt.;lttil! JIIU! tt• •

I.

20 20 0. 2 S:ttlllltl a1'il1l11~ 60 W-I"1'; tt (16" I / H:n) . 0 '/1' ::: J" S: 11 (16"1 / 4 -112) 20 W::J'lJlI. J:ftl1 (16 112J.;lJ: ) 0

•

I 1 3 all 2'1' JlI.r 100 :1'1' 80 4 -18'1' 60 19 -28'1' 40 11111129'1' 20 I 1 3

••

..IUUI± 80 bD.iUj 60 ;ltflll(* ' 'i'l' ,± ';C , lUi) 30 I 1 3 • • • I!! lIR>t ' WIII>t 100 ,~.J;(J:£>. 80 • •>t 70 l i .t.H£> . 60 n: 1.M:.Zl1't:dl.1(lIt1.l'Ii"'W.ZoIb1( ••!Ugdl.1(tt*~JA

2 .~.<l>1fi1ll r • •J 7'1li1J;(F'l;J!!J;!fJt1l!l1ll~' 1I!lIllft,A.li!l1iiil!l9 .S"'''·.~

tlF'l~!J; • jfJtfIJ"'9S~ '

3. • 68' 69'1'?I-• ;It.~'I'.*'I<l>9'Jtt'''.iiil!l1!!8j1J.lI-siiil!l

4.S:tttll~ 68' 69'1'l!:tlJtfOlllf".

s.allra~.*'1· ft'l'Z.~'f'fJiI' J;(78'1'Z • • • • • .!I;lt"'~• •IlI"ltl 3 Ifi;j::

(6)

~ 3 ~iflJtz~fi~,H~~~

~~~m:/f'~~w~m~"f (H7) '*~J'C

f1iP)S1m~~" ~lJo,fllf' (equa I we i ght)

~fi~m,~rom~~~~.~~~.2ffi~

°

(=)tt~&.ma~~.~~&~.~W. ~~m~~~~~~'~-.mm~"R m:" (Sea Ie) ° *~J'Cj::~~MEJ~t~*m:tt ~~.a• • •~~,~*~tt~~fi~.~ m-Wtt~nUiH(norm) (ifi1!!~ , 77~) ,~

~E13ffr±1t~flif@j!UIT( va Iue judgement) ffii~

~,~~tt~~.a.~~~~~~tt~~.

tlTiJ:f*~~-{lQj.JlU(eriter ia)' ~fP)~~J'C

1J1t9JMTm~~.Rm: (ordinal scale) o,&"

~'~~~.~~/f'~~.~~m.9J~~a

.~~.~,~m¥®e*/f'~~~~~~~

fjg~il-®r"ijM(Rossi & Gi Imartio , 1980)

;ffiie.tttt.~~~~~ffii.~'~~~~ .~~~~"f,~~~ti¥®~.~m&m. ~~~iID~. (Baer, 1976) ° m~m{lQj%3m:* m,aB~a.~.-.e.~m~

••

~f* ~~ff,~~~ru~/f'~~~m~"f' ~~~ ~W~~~/f'0o~~£*~*~J'Cilltitt~ ~fi

•

ill1ij1EiID~1to ~"f~~p'~mM~ ,~.tt~£.m i5r. ' m~1tm&-~miHiMIDfSEJ~t~.m:~tt

~~.a. ' ti~-m:fi£a.~ y60~ , .*~

mi5r.~.*."f ~&~~ ; ~~e.JlU~T80

~ ( H8) o~W~~~~Tn~~-.~~ 9;U ,~.W5JU~*o 1 .p~1W. ~~~W~'*~J'Cf1i~wA~ttiID~' WM~mA~'~m~@~m~,tt~m~' -&lttm~*lJtM~RH~.~IT~

°

(1 )wAJl!}ttiIDm If-II: II!' ~ 68 69 70 71 72 73 7. 75 76 77 18

20 ~ liill!l 35.11' liill!l 36 l1' lIIlI!I 37l1' lIIlI!I2 2.11' oIII.i!l234' oIIIlI!I WI' III lI!I25'" ffUi!l2 64' IlIl1!127'" III lI!I 284' 1II.i!1 ~ 40 ~ 19- 34 '1' 20 35 '" 21-36'1' , 18 - 'l7'1' 19-~ 60 ~ 4 -184' 4 - 19l1' 4 - 204' • -214' • -22 -'" , - 23l1' • -24l1' • - 25'" • - 26'" 3 • 17'1' ~ - 18'" 80~ 34' 3-'1' 3.11' 34' 3'" 3'" 3lI' _3'" 3.11' 3l1' 100 ~ 2lJ: 24' 2!J: 2'1' 2l1' 24' 2'" 2'" 24' 2'" 211< w{lQjtt~~.~.,&"~M.&@ttRtt~ m~~.*,~,tt~fi' .' ~.&+r₄₄ :;;o'J Qc, o/f'~~m~• • •~WA• • •~~5~! rdJe . ' 1§!~*~~~ffl1J~&Xft~lIilD~ /f'~ (~~.~tt~ , 75~) 0

Jlt5'f.

'

-tUT

_k ~~_A~ttiIDm~Sfi£e.&~.e~~. -tl!&H~

•

.&tt~~.~~i5r. ° ~!€!tt~tt~tt~~~75~@:3m.fJ1fi

~ (Dwelling Unit )iID~ (~pg1IiHft )

z

!\l

{l

e.ff!~30ft!i ' l3.jij!~U~A~~!t~rm!1~ Q

~~.q~~p~4.7A~.' ~Amttoo~

(~pgiIDm) ~a:fi£7Jd"¥:J. 6.4* olit9j.,

~.~~ml1l&iri~mJlUm37.~JUe: ' ~~~

M~/J\iIDfflE13 Ef!tmtt~m:iit~ 25 . 71W.¥T

tt~m:fi£~14 . 88ft!i 0 ~~fiEJ~tt~tB~1H

tM$m6f~9JEf! '

z:. '

P3 ' Tlmlitt~B9*11

ADg-f-jf , wA~ttiIDm ( ~pgiIDfft ) ~t£4

3?: 5~~1YJ ° ~ P)~pgootlm. ' ~Amttffii

m~e:fi£~.~IT~5ftp °

~5'l- ' -f.&.*~J'Cg-f-ll78~-5'~~P ,

Wi

A~ttOOm(Bm~~EJiIDm ) ~~B~~~

~~* 'fi£~ 8ftp&10~~B~ltf91j~¥-J~80\

&90% ° ;sP)~~p:i:4A~. ' 4iJ5{if{;OOfft

~~32ftp&40~' WEJiII~m:~~4ijpOOI

30. 54ftp&~~wpl!l!~iID{W39 . 5* (~8ro

~~EJiIDm ) ~~/f'*o~~~~~A@ttOO

fft~~~e~IT~8ftp, a:~~~~10j)jij;).t

o (2) WM~ffJA. W~~~wA~ttiIDm~.~~~ffi~· wlYJ~mA.~.~tt~~$~m~~.·Q ~~~ffii~' r -.P-tt~

,

-A-@~.J ~m~&~.tt~~iri~§~(~.*~tt. , 78~ ; ~@1t~~~7\~g-f-1!I ' BO&f ) 0 ~ ~' -A-~~'~wM~mA• • I Amn • •• $80~ atilp;j~Ji5 ~ft~~'JI:b • (UiI)(~r:tz; ~rI~fi!i~i¥.

AIJ

•

• ~-~

~~4ij1Ul1?A AiiJ*~-n 00 ~ :

ti=_r&l

"I

EAI

f.L.

~

tl

3 )Jf

m-

lliJ

!3

~'

'

ffJ'

m~

fl.

it ' IJ pg

1:

p)..t (fi9 !

••

:f!IIp;jtt~ o

it-t!t*Ji!

IfiBtJ~m~~ ..jt-.~

,

i£~.f.U~~ 3-M# '&P)l: &~*N' ';G~Jfi9JfI {t~'B!lIm

,

tt

' fa!3

~It* ~N. ( ~D~~

I

litiZ-e

ILi

tifF~-~i¥. (4)1t~ffHt ~.j::~.

H. :

tt*~ i 1t • •

lt1:::1f.

~.M{~B9m~

fr

o

~~ff~~ tffi

JjlGJRHffttfi

~}iIt~60~~ )-a-1t1ft~

P).-OO.i

jl.15~ffla • fk\!tt~fi£ ' JI!!\I.~ttr .55% (ttll )

(7)

17 78 BlA 28 jJ! _IUII_29J¥. 8-21l/' 19-28~ 171!' ~ - 18'" ~

-

2lf 24' ~~FdJW~~11~tt,Ei fj , ff .. ~~~*~t

~A~

1j*I!Z

Q

/J

'~

m:1J

~.&)(1t,3~!

fI

ffiilj

75.1f.)

0

i1t

9J.

•

tEU~ a;~~.&~38e1\!! 1F.¥

'

Ji

Dr.

0 ~r!lJ 75.1f.ilta~¥trL{!

1ft

(~pqffiHft ) ~m1! ~Altz~.ffijtt~t

,-IT. '

~A~ttJIjj ffl !!k8m 6. 4~ 0

Jtt5'i- '

Um37~m5E

•

~pq~

iil1lif¥J 2

5 _

71liJS~Tf!R i~r!lJ ~tt~tfj ~tlHa

.

..

T[gfltt~~*~ ft (~pg

iiiftt)

t-ltE4

ftO~~

•

~A5fiiID o

· JJ78.1f.

t:1

:1ta

..

i'/Hi

rnHIf) ~gfs~lt~i

f¥J

13 ?ttt

~J4H~1.£80:\

IT. •

~J5tt~oom

, 1t!flilI ~:Ie] fi p 00 fI1

mfi139.

5~

(

~B1lJ

~

JIt PJ

~1jAJi5fiOO

ijj1e~mlO f)f P)'..t rf¥J~~U~~f§~

,

"J$f.L.l!'M:B9~iI 0 t~

·

-A-J&~J

3.tJ

(¥-!!~*~ttJS <=:IT~

, 80

.iF)

0 ~

J...m A~m

1 A

PIfI

.

••t\@80?t

0

••

~~J&tt~m*~'~~T~~W~ .e-~'iIt~£~~~~fuPJn~.-~

.

(llm)l.~T~.1f.ti~~rm~~5jU 0 ;fi~JiiJlt ~.-E~f¥Jm~'PJ~~~~mA~m2

AI1

•

{l;.~60?t 0 ~~fiirm~mAIH1r:t£O.5

A

PJ

r '

~~ ~m*~-~@~~L'PJ~7~jj1~~ 100 ~ : tifiiFdj~mAfi:t£4 APJ L ' ~~~

illJe.~mttPJ~

, ~JItmo?t

0

3).m~l3~m~

.

M

..

m~"~ffi~~pqtt~~.~~. ~

•

,~~tt~z~

..

m"~§~$~:t£ 981 P)'1:.

(tt9)

0 ~JIt

'

~

.. m ..

~~~-1.~.~tt~ft¥*f¥J~*,~ma~f¥J~ o .-~~~~ffl~

..

m"~f¥J~*rm~' m~~m~*5~,m~~~,mma~o

•

~-.~'H~m

..

m~-~"~ffi~~ ~~.m~jj1f¥J~~:R~mm-~,m

..

i~

•

.&~Lf¥Jtt~~.~~f¥J.tJ~o &~*~,~

..

m..

~=~~.~m~~ I,~=~~m~-~,~~~=~~.~~ tt~,~.a~.tJ~~rztt~o~~,~ ·~"~I3~~Dr.~~~~~~.~~fi'~ m~~(~~~~m~.) .mE.m

.. m..

~.za~~f¥J~~'ffi*~~~~~~~ .tltfJ:if!-?p-f¥J~~ 0 (4)1t~miti ~.±rr.f¥J?t~:1J~,tt~ffl~?tm~

1'4. :

tt*$Jffl ..

tt~~J6

• ..

tt~~Iw&

&

1t._ltBffliztf (alO)

0 tt~Wffl*~tt ~.li~~ffl~

, Jf!~tt~P'1fif¥Jm:~.tJ~60

fro~~ff~~~J6."IW&&~Bffl~ti~ ~P~.~ttpf¥J@tt~fi~~~OO~.'. -Yfi~60?tzms?t 0 (5}~1t1ft~ ~-OO~~*~'~~W~B*~~tt~ 8~*~~mf¥J~mtto~ttf¥J~~~§a~ '~~tta~

,

J&ttJ'pfifua~ 0 ~~78.1f.t:1

'~a.~ttp~§@ttf¥Jtt~~~fttt~f¥J

93_55%

(fill)

,m§Z'

m6.45%

ztt~~

- 27

~tt~Dr. ° ffiJltPJ~~~~tt~~ztt~ma ~f¥J~fi~$,~~~~tt~~Ztt~~T~ ~60?tZms?t 0 2 .. **a9lI~ ~.~'ffi~~~~~'*~~mn~m ~

..

~.&~m~~=~~m~fi~$f¥Jn~ o (1 )~ti ~mL':t£~~~~Dr.Zr'mti~il1Iif¥J tt~,~m~~Wtt~.~~.~ttp~ffl~ ~f¥J~~rm.m'~~fi~~:&z'm~a ~f¥Jtt~'~~fi~il1Iio*~~£*L~~~ fflllt-1N~rtJl%~~U**f¥J ~fi 0 ffi~±IT.f¥J~~m~~~I~~'~~ ~.?t~-(~.3ffi~)

'¥-!! • • •

f¥J~~ ~~.Rng~JIt~~.~~~ 0 W,~UL

'

*~~ PJ~~:t£4~18 .1f.zFdjf¥Jtt~~~fima~~ ~

, ~tim3.1f. f¥Jtt~~~fim~jj1~~

0 (2)~. ~~±IT.Z~?t:1J~,~.~mf¥Jtt~ ~.~?tmmEm~±~

..

~.~~

..

~~& *"n"±"E~'~B~A~ott~~.f¥J W~rtJl%~~tt~f¥Jm~&*~tt'~JIt~. ?Jj\~E:lttt~~fif¥J!l~z-o ~.ffilmlit~ffil2~..t

'

::jt$ffilmx.~ ~~~

,

ffi.L-~~::jt1m1tmf¥Jtt~~.Jf!PJlfUt &&~~m~~ o -~rm§,;fi~~I.~f¥J MDr.~~ 'MEm~±~f¥Jtt~~lfUt.&~~ ~*a~,~~m~.~~,~~~~.&*" n"±"E~f¥Jm~lfUt.&~~~*~~oJlt ~

,

;f!HtJ±IT.78.1f.Ntt~1lf~f¥Jji~U~

,

~.~~WME.~±~f¥Jtt~~~.~~tt ~f¥J7l.

42% '

~M{(j.!t~J~~~1.JD

'

~~~iiII ~&*"n"±"E~f¥Jtt~8~~~~~~ o £~..t~.ffi'*~~~~_iiII~a9tt~ ~m~~f¥J~fi~~:MEm~±~f¥Jtt~m ~jj1~fi.tJ~:~~&*"*"n"±"E~ f¥Jtt~m~~~o (3)~m~~ ~.ffil~ztt~~m~~'~~±IT.f¥J ?t~~~~~&~~~~~

..

~m~

..

~**~

(8)

-: 'li~~~0~&n~~L0~~o~~~tt ~Umtt&~tt~~~~fi~

• •

fi~m., 1I~Jt

'

~mJt&~~JtEl3~jMm~m1lF~1I ~Jtm.'Umtt.~~~tt~@~li~~~ &A~~L0~m~:~~tt~fi§a~.~ ~

,

3i:~tE~i% 0 m~~~~~~m~mtt&mm(~~~ ±~~*)~~*'~~Jt~.~~~tt~: A~~L~0~~m~mtt&~~mm~.li ~~~0~~~o~~~tt.~.Z~'1I~ Jt&~mJttt~~.a~e.:n~~L0~ ~.~e.:li.~~0.~ft~~.:~~ Jttt~Z6b1UUfr~n~j.;)'L&1i.j.;). ~0~ ZF~ 0 ~&*~~~mztt~6b.m~ '~~M ~*~Lill.%.,~~~m~~fl~~~' ~~tt~~~m&~*~~'~~~~'~. ~~m~~(~.~~~) '*~m~~~w ~~~mzg~~.$~~-~~~~o~~ Jtf~rpj~.~U.~~

,

~~D~~~~~~mfi ~(~.I'~.~~Bh.~A~~tt~) '~~~.~~~.'~~0~~~~~m~ ~(~

• •

OO'*~'~~~~)~.Rfl~ ~~~o~m~.~m~~,*~~m~.~ ~~t1m51fIil$~~tt~db. 0

1m '

.g-

~t

15 •

~

11

~ ~

it

.:z.

wp

{is

W

~n~

..

mm~~

(-)

~~t1m51tmtt~Jlrl.z~fi5~* f1jmh~~±rr~~~iJ68~¥.78~ffi{'F ztt~~5t~1i~fl

(H12)

'M!:~~lW-1P ~~~~.&~m~~~~,.~~.*~~ tt~rl'b1f~. ~*~~rp 0 , ~~tm~~h~

liI1i& ~ ~t~ ~~m~.~

db.

~Illj.;).

rp

~Ill

(

Median)~7F : ~~tm&~~'

IImlii

(H13

) " ~~t~&~~ (~) ~m

'

~.~ftl¥J

ffb

.~~~~h~liI~m~.ffb.~~~~~~

(Average)ft~ 0 Mz.L-:J.:tm.~(Stand- ard

Deviation)iil!7F~flZFI'Il~~UE~*/J\ 0 1 ' ~~ffb1f 64 63 62 61 (1 )~~tm~4Zrp , ~h~Wi~~

-J

if.tl)j;,. 78 Year ~~

•

• ill

~~~~ ~ _r-;;;-. I 57 .• i 1f~'Ut ~m1* (ff14) '*3&ill~~L7tI¥J.~. 60 I _III

J

_I_lr_<_~_/ 59 ~ 58 u 57 VJ 56 55 54 53 52 51

1

I I I I I I I I I Db 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77

0: fiml& t : ~J[ml& 0: i:i:itiiJ

111 4 ft~tm}'zfIf.mWi? atJ~.g

~!t~1Il

~~~~~~~~~.~~U7F~fi

.~.~m~~·~rp~fimlil.m~.o ~il1ll 4 ~~~m~*~

·

~7~i168if.rr.

liI1i~~i%~~mlil1i~'~~~~~m~~~~ fim~

·

mj£~~*~/J\ 0 lIt-:m."5JM.~

•

~~68if.ZmI~~m~~~.~lIrPWtt

•

~~~.~fi&~~ill• •~**~~~zr ·~~db~.Bmlil1i~omQ~~*AD~~ A·~mlil1i~~mAD8~~~ '~tt~~. ~·ffi• •~fi~~tt.~~~~~rPW~~ :fim~~~lIt~ffim~~lliW.~*~tt~ ·~lIt~~ffb.~.mlil~~ o ~~~ ,.m ~~~Jlrl

• •

:Q~tfU~60~~il$ , JltijG~~;F ~~~tm m~mir6~Z ~ • -ti:ffi~~~f;m ~~ffb1fc&'lHJlN~* 0 (2)-EJ~t~ ~~5&.5Zrp. ~ (~) gm~&1 ~~~~~72~j.;).lW~~i%~~.

'

1f

lJlItt

il

~~~~*~/J\ £*L7k~ 0

,

r:jJ $J , fT);!i'

l\W~m~~~tmZ~£~m

•

~

tm~

~.

~

_·_~'~ffij_l

~Lm

'

L~~~ffi

0

1m

~~tm

z

BB

U

HI·*

±.~

••

ii

AD~aA.~~~(~)ftm

~~~

AD~

_·._jlf~M

(

~rp~~~m¥~m~U.~

~

A~,

~~A

I

• • •

~I!

~~~oo~*~m'ffb

.

~.~.

~

• • {If,fj). Ill · 61 68 69 70 0: ,*(-'tl) ~

Is

~~tl

.'Ht

bDo~• •

(9)

l

Mf5. ..

I I

75 76 77 ?8 Y~ar

0: Eiitm

~a<J db.!I~jJ.iI

r

i&

~IHI9

Jb

ff

~

lU

I

UJLl:

ff-

(J9.

~

,

ill

j\U7f-~ffi&WB9db

'm

li

lU

i

m

IY3

Ai

0 ;f§

, ~7~il681f1lrr.

~ ~

if.

~

ifni

~ fI~

)

lIt-ffl.'(DJ~"m ~~~~ambiHt

'

UJt*~~!JlHmz~

al!.l!

lf?l-

*A

DB9fj

Uf!l~ , mt£lI:lf1 t~~a9*TrtniJ5tt

E

tfj filSIU~*a<J

tt

~ ~~ a ::f~ff

"

.

If

t~iit ' lIt~~~ffi

, -~ijT~~%tf;jM

~ (~)

.

m

a<J

£

li~~.

'

ffiJ

.i!

1l

1

(~ " $~ " ff!i5~ J' a~tmm~.g l~tmzD~,&9l-* .ma9~{iA[]~ ~~~Aml '

;ff4:i

A

a9 ~Qf{

?t

It~JjHt

•

~ 1t~trf'H~tl68~78~-!-DiEij;P~dbft?tfi -.~ ,-

..,.

68 69 70 71 72 73

ft.

· ,..

_"~IJ 57.50 59.00 58 .00 59.00 61 .00 62 . 00 *RIJ 58.50 60 .00 58.00 b'( .00 64 .00 63 .00

'i;".

.6 .00 61.00 59.00 52 . 00 60.00 59.00 I

•••

57 .50 56.00 52 .00 52 .00 53.00 :'5. 00 " " aw. 59 .,0 ,1 00 54.00 50 . 00 60 .00 58 .50 :1

.

"'.

02 .00 ,. 00 ,., .00 53 .•0 60 .00 58.00 I

•••

\ 53 .00 50 .50 41.00 \ 54 . 00 I

•••

50 .00 \ 49 .00 54.00 58.00 58 .00

*"

.

53 ,00 , 1. 00 49 .00 51.00 56 .00 56 .00 "' ~. ;5.00 58 .00 60 .00 57 . 00 62.00 61.00

j

".'.

55.44 ,5 .89 54 .65 ,3.25 59.33 58 .•5

••

•

3.02 3 .60 4.05 3 .• 6 3 .09 2.80

"

.

50 .00 \ ,2.00 52. CO 65 .00 66.50 " ..alf 48 .00 ;0 .00 55 .00 57.00 61 .00 \

'.

•••

\ 5' .50 51 .50 58.50 62.00 62 ,00 il

"'

..

SO .50 61 . 00 64 .00 .3 . 00 59.00 62.00 1:• • 54 .00 ,4.00 54 .00 51. 00 61 .00 61.00 ta. 55 .00 58 . 00 58.00 57.00 61.00 62 .00

••••

51 .50 55 .70 55.75 54.75 61 .50 62 .70

••

•

2 .38 3.39 3 .94 2.64 1.67 1. 77

11 ..

· · ' 5 4 0 4 33 .82 55 .06 53.81 60 .20 59 .87 I • • • 3 .45 3 .64 4.16 3.33 2.86 3 . 24 H 75 63 .00 62 . 00 63.00 63 .00 60 .00 60 . 00 56 .00 57. 00 64 .00 61 .00 \ \ 56 .00 \ 60 .00 \ 58 .00 55 .00 61 .00 ' 6• .00 60 , II 60 .29 2.81 3 .01 66 .00 \ \ 61 . 00 62 .00 64 .00 63 .00 62 .00 60 .00 61 .00 61.00 62 .00 62 .40 62 . 00 1.88 1.00 60 .93 61.00 2.79 2 . 55 76 77 78 .lI''!1 ~

••

•

62 .00 64 . 00 64. 00 61. 05 2 .22 IttlJlI 64 .00 62.00 68 ,00 61.86 3 .08 j;: 'le\l 62 .00 64.00 60 . 00 59 .36 2. 99 _{i ' i "} 58 .00 ,8.00 62 .00 56 .05 2.8, !I_II 61.00 61.00 68 .00 58 ,91 5. 13 II tlJ lIr 64 .00 64 . 00 62 .00 58 .28 4. 28 1Il "'1Ir 58 .00 58 .00 62 .00 :;~ .81 4. 43 IUlII[ \ \ 67.00 56 . 57 5 .75 1l'l'1I[ 61 .50 58 .00 62 .00 56.27 4. 65 j;: ffli 62 .00 64 . 00 62 .00 61.27 4 .20 "'11111 61.39 61 .44 63 .70 2.05 2 .63 2.76 \ 63 . 00 63.00 59.69 6 .60 1'l.1I[ 62.00 65 .00 \ 57.38 5.63 11111 11[ 6•. 00 65 .00 64 .00 60 .85 4. 15 * _11[ 62 .00 62 . 00 \ 59 .85 4. 27 • •11[ 62 .00 58.50 63 .00 58 . 14 3. 92

"'

'1'

.

62 .00 62 . 00 64 .00 60 . 18 2.62 ~tlill[ 62 .• 0 62 . 58 63 .50 0.73 2 . 04 0 .45 61.75 61 .90 63 . 6~ 1.78 2.53 2. 35 I

,,,,

.

:

*III!1eltff

~TI---~ ₆₄ 62· 63 62 .. I ~{~~.$ 61 60 73 74 76 ~...".,..L:;r -r I fi}f~~ij!\ 59 ~ 58 0 ~ 57 56 55 54 53 52 49 I I j I I I I I , j ₅₁ 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 Year I I 68 69 70 71 72 77 78 Year 0: ,*(tfa)¥lrli t: mm 0: i::!t~ 0: Eitrli t: E;itll% • 5 '8'~t.}1m'., UP~db.g~~.

III

6

.g.~tB' mp~db.jg~~.ill:t~1II

."lt~1II

(3)-Ei'~t~" mZ.tt~ .roO~

••

~M~~~tt~~~OOPa9dbf{

El31116

"ilJ~tfj , ~iJ68~78if.+-if.OO

.

~'~OO.tt~T~~"~K"

±.~

.

~~a9.~,~• • ~£~?t~1Y3 -Ei'~t~ " mZ£ft?tWl~f-J.1JDIO?t ' II'U~-Ei'

~tm~-Ei'~tl\Wz£fiW a

lIt-ffl.*IW13'

lf

P ~

·~~~g(~)

.

m~?t

~

o~oom~~*

£f{~l\lImfij.~~7tOO~~ ; -Ei'~tm~ijTfij. (

.fI*

!UI:~.¥60?t~~

,

.7F

~lJtt~~V\

~ifttJ ) ~-Ei'~t~~ , ~OO £f{fu~~ a

· $~'~A~tt~OO.~.N~*o

- 29 +---~;JE:d,v: , 35

'"

S3 52 51 SO

(10)

t

f

I

~

5

.g.~tU~il68~78.$~m.Up B9~it ~fi-.~ If-IJ: 68 l'Htli: =-tili 52 .00

•

lIlllili 57.00 ( 1'J tHEiIi \ ) It fi15i1i 57 .00 iff _"'«1m 61.00 <l' «IiIi 59 .00 1tli:'I'~ 57.20 81$)!f 2 .99 .*1<_ ₄₉_.₀₀ tI.x:_ 57 .00 =-11* 50 .00 ~*- 47 . 50

•

lS' .tl::_ \

-

±tiR. \ .~. 53 .00 nil!. \ .~. \ *1<0. 54.00 .~. 45 .00 :elii'. 46 .00 li!'*I<. \ =-~. 47.00 el"l. 47 .50 1\lit. 45 .50 iIIU!. 51.00 1tli:'I'~ 49 .38 .$JlI! 3 .58 -a 1tli:'I'~ 51.68 ~t

•

.$l?l 4 .94

."'*_

:

"'!i!'!UI:lt 69 70 54 . 00 56 .00 60.00 57.00 59.00 55 .00 59.00 58 .00 63 . 00 59 .00 59.00 57.00 59.00 57.00 2.65 1.29 49 .00 54 .00 49 .00 \ 51.00 56 .00 \ 54 .00 51.00 53 .00 \ 58.00 \ \ 50.50 48 .00 58.00 55.50 61.00 \ 52.00 \ \ \ \ 49 .50 55.00 \ 45.00 \ \ \ 56.00 \. 52.50 53 .50 4.37 3. 11 54.79 55.00 4.95 3.04 71 72 73 74 75 53.00 56.00 56 .00 59 .00 59.00 58 . 00 60 .00 60 .00 60 .00 60.00 54 .00 58.00 58.00 56.00 59.50 60 .00 61 .00 61 00 64 .00 64. 00 60 .00 61 .00 61 00 61 .00 62.00 58 . 00 60 .00 60.00 62 .50 61.00 57.1"1 59.33 59.33 60.42 60 .92 2.'/3 1.80 1.80 2.56 1.69 51.00 \ \ 56 .50 56.00 \ 60 .00 60 .00 58 .50 \ 54.00 \ \ \ 55.50 55.00 61.00 61.00 66 .00 64.00 54. 00 57.00 57.00 61.50 63. 00 53 .00 57. 50 57 . 50 \ 64.00 56.00 60 .00 60 .00 \ \ 60 .50 60 .50 60.50 61 .00 61 .00 55 .50 50.50 50.50 59 .00 60 .00 52.50 \ \ 60.50 59 .50 \ \ \ \ 61.00 \ 63 .00 63.00 57.50 55.00 51.00 \ \ , \ 60 . 50 \ 59.00 59.00 56.00 61 .00 50 .00 \ \ 58.00 58.00 53 .00 54.50 54 . 50 58 .00 60 .00 54 .00 65.50 65.50 63.50 \ 53 .81 58.95 58.95 59.67 59 . 89 2.59 3.88 3 .88 2.83 2.80 54.87 59.09 59 .09 59.92 60 . 20 3.06 3.30 3.30 2.77 2 . 56 76 77 78 IIJF'I'l!¥ 81$l?l 60 .00 58 . 00 57 .00 56 . 36 2.46 =.tili 62 .00 61.00 61.00 59 .64 1.55 lIl llili 60 .00 59 . 50 63 .00 58 . 20 2. 51 f i b 63 .00 62 .00 66 .00 61 36 2.64 fiPiill 62 .00 62 .00 64 .00 61 . 45 1. 30 "'«Iff; 62 .00 62 .00 62 .00 60 . 23 1. 75 <l'«IiIi 61. 50 60 .75 62. 17 1.1 2 1. 52 2.79 \ 60 .00 62 .00 54.69 4.55 .*1<_ \ 58.00 62.00 ~7.79 3.89 tI.x: _ 62 .00 64 . 00 64 .00 ~7 . 06 5.25 _=-11* I 62 .00 63.00 61.00 59.45 5.31 _~*_. 65 .00 59 .00 65 .00 58 .55 4.75 lS'.tl::_ 64 .00 63 .00 64 .00 60 . 13 3 .91 ±tiR. 62.00 61 .00 61.00 59 .00 3.02 .~. 61 .00 60 .50 \ 58 . 17 4.81 nil!. 63 .00 62 . 00 55 .00 56 .90 4. 10 .~. 56 .50 58 . 00 64 .00 58 . 25 3.56 *1<0. 65 .00 \ \ 55 .75 7.79 .~. 60 .00 60.00 60.00 58.06 5.19 eR. 62 .00 \ \ 55.75 5.55 li!'*I<. 59 .00 61.50 \ 57 . 19 4. 37 =-~. 58 .00 61 . 00 \ 53.93 5 . 81 el"l. 60 .00 60 .00 63.00 56 .50 4.97 I\!I!.. 62.00 63 .00 62 .00 60 .28 4. 97 iII ~. 61.43 60 .93 61.92 2.34 1.78 2.53 61.45 60 . 88 62.00 2.07 I. 71 2.62

2 ,

@I't9!Prlfi

(1)

t:r

~t

$

Ef3

~

6 Edll7 OJ

tJ

M

ffl. ' @1't9

5b

fi

~

IIIiii

~

~pl't95bfiffi~¥ffl.~~I't9~m$'~&~~ ~OO®~~UI't9~~5b~'~~ffi~~fll't9~ ttffi~~o±~~I't9~fl*~~~~~ff~(

housing stock

)f.U!IHmj/tI't9~~' ~~ff

~~,a~7 $'fi$ldI~ ~$m'~Y~7f-fi$lilh~~I't9 o

(2)

ti'~tl1W ~5b.~~~ ~~~m.1 ~7&1Il8Lr:p

,

5b1l0-~{t(~1'mf$' ~ Ef3~ruffi~oa~,~r:pOJ~.*lli~.~~

fi~~~~

,

~0-I'i~a60?ttJ ~ ,

mll.a

• 6 ~~tm~ _II, 68

•

66.00 I ~ 63.001 63 .00 63 .00

"'IJ

.

66 .00

I

• ••

•

64 .33 2.05

•••

66 .00 • • • , 63 .601 2.24 64 .07 1 2. 15

I I

I I I 6b 69 70 71 0: E'm~ 7 ~~tmJ.

:M:

Jifl:l& 1\.1't9

JlfY lJl~

IUD

m

~

ilIJ

{J£

ffi

~

fN

1\. ;

.Ei4ij~~~mt.(housing flow)jl~tt1JD

'

~ ~~.I't95bfi~~~.~1\.o~~a~.~

*'Ll'

~

ldIl't9

5b1l0-I'i~HE?Jj\1\. 0 ~)jU~@1't9

5b • •&7mti'~®~ffl.ili.{J£~~~m~ 1't9~1IJ

'

~?Jj\~7f-t:r ~tW~lilh~~ff:.

r:p@1't9

!Prl.lfl~*~lIJm13t~1\.

(1\.f-J

a50-li:;fi~ IIJ) 0 ru~p~5bfir:pWxtt~,mOJ~~~~AC ~8'~.A*~~OO~~®

•

~M.o (3)t:r~tl1W' $L~~ jl~m~~lIJm~~z~u~

•

~(~

!119ffi7f-)

,m1\.3&...tti'~t$@~5bfiillil~

ti'~tl1W

0

ti'~t$pgjly

afii

rm

~J!Ji

l't9itHliI '

mlli~*7\.tJ...t0~ ( __

*11)

?Jj\.~'7@1't95b~;

$~~

@~·

aJOlt..

.~.£J!rg

1:.

,

ma9~~ 'lI:~~tI

.€itJ...t.A

,uu:!!

J51't9

~ t.~ffi~i!JJ 0 I

(11)

6 ~~tm ~9168~~78~'1HJ~oo;,*((,] Q~ .;tll-.~ E.tI'i!J iii lUi tiill'ili til5'i!J ""tl'i!J

~

I .,~a tle:a .=..a lJl*a lS'.il:a

I

±~. aH. liR. .llJ. ~D. !lilt. 'lJ~. lI!I~. .=.z. 'lJ1"l.

i:?T

68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75

"

a.

-r

.IJ

.

66.00 60 . 00 60.00 60 . 00 66 .00 66 .00 '13 .00 66.00 ....:t... 66 .00 60 .00 60 .00 66.00 66.00 66 .00 63 .00 66 .00 r;;•• 66 .00 60 . 00 66.00 60 .00 60.00 60.00 66.00 66.00

· ;-

,

..

60 .00 66 . 00 60 .00 63 . 00 ,3 .00 ;0 . 00 63 .00 63 .00 , :-'1:1. 66 .00 60 .00 56.00 60.00 60 .00 63 .00 66 .00 66 . 00

• r.",

.

63 .00 60 .00 60 .00 60.00 53 .00 66 .00 \ \ r • • • \ ;0 . ~o 50 .00 50.00 \ 40 .00 40 .00 \ ~Il• • 63.00 \ 56 .00 50 . 00 50.00 50 .00 50.00 \

r

*

_

.

63 .00 ;6 . 00 56 .00 60 .00 63 .00 66 . 00 40 .00 50 . 00 , "'~J• 66 .00 60 .00 ;6.00 60 .00 60 .00 53.00 60 .00 66 . 00 I • •• 64 .33 ;9 . " 58 .00 58.90 ;'9 .00 58 .00 5'1. 89 63 .29 I • •• 2.0, 4.0 1 4.00 4 .83 5.48 8 .73 11.15 5 .52

1 "

•

60 .00 \ ,0.00 5UO 63.00 66 . 00 66 .00 \

,

_•••

63 .00 60 .00 60 .00 66.00 60 .00 \ \ 66 .00

• r

•••

\ 63.00 66 .00 73.00 63 .00 66 . 00 60 .00 66 .00 Ir ",• • 66 .00 66 . 00 66 .00 53 . 00 60 .00 66 .00 66 .00 66.00 H t:. 63 .00 60 .00 60 .00 63 . 00 60 .00 63 .00 63 .00 60 . 00 r ~It. 66 .00 60 . 00 63.00 66 . 00 6J .50 66 . 00 60.00 66 . 00 I· ..• 63 .60 61.80 60 .83 62 .08 61.25 65 . 40 63 .00 64.80

•••

2.24 2.40 5.43 7.59 1.35 I. 20 2 .68 2 .40

=1

..

"

...

••

64 2 .. 07 15 60 3 . . 0'15 7 54 9 ..79 06 60 6.21 . 09 59 4 .47 .90 60 "1 . .94'1 7 59 9 .7 .41 1 63.924 .55 1"• • :*iI!ltlut , 76 17 78 a ll''I'l!!I a•• 66 .00 66 . 00 60.00 64 . 4' 2.22 tJl llJli 66 .00 60.00 66 .00 64 .09 3 .08 * 1<1i 60 .00 60 . 00 60 .00 62 . 18 2 . 99 i!i.1l 63.00 ,8.00 60.00 59 . 91 2 .85

".

Ii

63 .00 61. 50 66 .00 62 .50 5.13 Ill liJ ll 60.00 60 .00 60 . 00 60 . 22 4 .28 ~4'1l 63 .00 53.00 60 .00 50 ."15 4.43 IIIlitIi \ \ 53.00 53 . 14 5 .75 It'l'li 46 .00 53 .00 60 . 00 55 .73 4. 65 xlillli 60 .00 60 .00 60 .00 60 . 09 4.20 'l'liJll 60.78 59. 06 60 . 50 5 .67 3.83 3.44 \ 60.00 66 .00 60 . 31 6 .00 PlIMIl 60 .00 56 .00 \ 61.38 3.20 iii litII 66 .00 66.00 60 .00 64 .90 3 .56 *1!1l 66.00 50 . 00 \ 62 .50 ;. 82 _*Ii 63 .00 56.00 60 .00 61 .00 2. 13 ±#Ii 60 .00 66 . 00 66 .00 63 .66 2.67 ~ttltli 63. 00 59.00 63.00 2. 68 5 .74 3. 00 61. 57 59.03 61.21 4 .94 4 . 69 3.51 68 allJ. ₆₇

~

66 65 64 ., 63 (; J:; 62 61 ImT4[~~Il~.~~~ l&f~~~ ₆₀ _taf~~4'l

Ik {±Ef:;~J!

iT3!~.1I

59

58

57 I I I I I I I I I I

{?t.~~~YH$' ~ _6~ ₆₉ ₇₀ ₇₁ ₇₂ ₇₃ ₇₄ ₇₅ ₇₆ ₇₇ ₇₈_Year 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 Year

pOJIY3U~tfH'.~~ 0: W-f,(cml¢lm +: ~~m 0: i:;.:ititf.

(j: E'm~ + : f;'im§ 0: i:; .:itm

III 8 .g.~tQ~m·.· .~((']~.IJ!~

••

E60?t ~J.l'

'

iEHIJ_tt

₁

₇

_{8~m~~·.m~~((.]~.~~}

_{• •}

o '

~OJfjIH~.p

P3J-.P

.'Ut~1Il ilJ1jlt~1II

'1JDrm~~a9~t* 0

~B~m*m~~~~~~m~,x~~~~

~·~~£J!~~~~~&'JI~~OO~Wo~

~

Z

IY3lrH~

i!UI

~

(

llf

_Jtli

_{• m~~~ OJfjg:ff~fi~?:k~'&~~!j1JD}

!jro~rfbfi~.~&U.'~~~~-#~~

~tm**a9£ JI{1J1i9if) _lI11_~~ttQ

m

o

~o/{±~af0mH~J:1i _~_.g.~J.Lijf~

_{, ~~t!\W}

_•

_{mZP •}

_~~Ilfi (~)~.~~D~~*zm#.~~~

lL0;!t

(

m

.

;;*;:II)

_'~m_._{p~rfbfi,q~~~M~rmm*'~} ~~ijf~'~RD~{±~&~.~~@~

Jrfb'JI ;

$?t{£~~.

_*

_.~m

_{.*~rm~.~OJ~o~-~OO'rfb}

~R.fiR.~~~

•

.&.~{±~rfb'JI~~§

(12)

II! III !II II

•

'If !i! III II 00 ~ ~ '"" <0 ~ '" ~ ~ M ~ N ~ ;: 0 ~ '" <0 ~ <0 IE

..

111 ~ ~

-&l ~ g 0 <0 g 0 <0 0 0 0 <0 0 0 0 <0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 <0 g 0 <0 0 0 0 <0 0 0 0 <0 0 0 <0 <0 0 0 M <0 r.o III

..

ill III It

;

IE ~ r.o F.; Ij;! Ii Ii III Wi Wi ~ -II ~ ~ ~ ~ <0 N M ~ N N a: 0 <0 '" ;;; M M ;;; ;;; 0 ;;; ;;; <0 g 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 g <0 ~ ~ <0 0 0 g 0 g 0 0 0 <0 0 <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 0 0 ' 0 0 0 ~ , 0, 0 0 0 ~ M <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 M 0 0 <0 <0 '" <0 <0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 M 0 M ~ <0 <0 '" ~ 0 0 0 g 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 0 0 0 0 g 0 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 ~ <0 <0 <0 g 0 0 0 g 0 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 <0 <0 <0 <0 0 0 0 g 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 0 g 0 0 g 0 0 0 <0 M <0 <0 <0 <0 ~ <0 <0 <0 0 0 g /' 0 <0 M M M <0 <0 <0 <0 jE jE jE jE jE

•

Ii! !'!! Ii Ii \III Wi Wi ..If -II .-l' -a jE

•

:It

-

_..

"*

""

..

j;

•

II( III ~ t> -+i

•

:0: ~ N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ <0 N M ~ ..: M N ~ on ~ ~ ::!: ~ 8 ~ 8 M ~ ~ <0 ~ '" ~ '" '" ~ 0 '" '" ~ ~ ~ ~ <0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 g 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 <0 <0 0 <0 <0 ~ ~ ~ ~ <0 '" ~ 0 M g 0 g 0 g 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 ~ N <0 0 0 <0 0 <0 0 <0 <0 '" <0 '" '" <0 <0 0 '" 0 g 0 0 0 '" <0 /' /' 0 0 0 0 ~ N M M 0 <0 0 '" <0 <0 <0 <0 M <0 0 0 g 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 /' /' 00 N ~ <0 M M <0 '" '" <0 <0 <0 M ~ g 0 0 0 M 0 0 0 0 /' /' /' '" M M M 0 0 '" , " . 0 <0 <0 g 0 0 0 0 g 0 0 0 0 0 0 /' /' 0 0 ~ 0 0 M 0 <0 <0 <0 '" <0 0 0 0 0 0 g 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 g /' /' 0 0 0 0 M 0 '" <0 <0 '" <0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 g 0 0 /' 0 0 0 <0 <0 ~ ~ <0 '" 0 g 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 /' /' g 0 M M <0 M 0 <0 <0 '" '" <0 ~ 0 0 0 g ~ 0 0 '" /' /' /' ~ N M 0 ~ 0 <0 <0 ~ '" 0 ~ 0 g 0 0 0 <0 0 0 0 /' /' M

-M M M <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 '" <0 'A' ~

•

!i!

•

:It

• ..

"*

""

..

Ii III

•

II( 111 ~ t> -+i

•

~

•

QI -3 0 ~ 11/ :It IN C aI -3 iii

•

:It II ~ t-III ~ <

•

M ;;; ~ '" 0 0 '"" ~ '" M '" ~ M 0 <0 M ~ ~ ~ N M .,; M Q N ~ N M <J. ° 8 ° ~ 8 ~ '" ::l 8 <0 '" ~ ~ ~ ;;; 0 0 0 ;;; N ;;; N <0 <0 <0 ~ <0 <0 0 g 0 0 g ~ ~

=

~ 0 0 ~ /' <0 <0 /' <0 /' /' /' :g g 0 M <0 <0 ' " ~ ~ <0 0 0 0 0 0 g 0 M ~ ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 '" M ~ /' /' ;;; <0 <0 <0 <0 M M ~ ., ' " 0 '" <0 <0 '" '" '" <0 ,0 <0 0 0 0 0 g 0 0 0 0

·

g:

=

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ N 0 ~ 0 <0 <0 0 <0 M 00 0 ~ ~ g ~ <0 <0 <0 '" '" '" <0 '" <0 0 0 0 0 0 0 g 0 N '" C; 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ /' ~ <0 0 <0 M 0 0 M 0 '" ~ '" '" <0 <0 <0 <0 ~ '" <0 <0 '" '" 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ :2 N ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N '" M <0 M /' M /' 0 M M M '" '" '" ~ '" <0 <0 <0 '" <0 <0 <0 '" '" g 0 0 g g ;;; '" '" ~ 0 /' /' 0 /' 0 /' 0 N M M :6 0 M M ~ '" '" ~ <0 <0 '" <0 <0 '" '" 0 0 0 0 0 0 '" '" '" ~ 0 0 /' 0 0 0 0 0 N /' /' /' M M M ~ M M 00 '" '" ~ <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 '" '" 0 0 0 0 0 0 M N M 0 0 0 0 '" 0 0 ~ '" ., ~ M <0 0 /' /' 0 /' M M '" ~ '" M <0 <0 <0 '" ;;; <0 <0 '" '" 0 0 0 '" M M <0 0 /' /' . 0 /' /' /' /' N <0 ~ ~ M 0 0 ~ ~ 00 M '" <0 '" '" '"

...

'"

.,

>- 00 r-l" 'D r-OJ) r '(!.. r 0 0 g 0 0 g 0 ~ ~ 0 0 0 /' /' 0 /' 0 ~ ~ 0 0 M ~ 0 M 0 '" ~ N ~ ~ ~ '" ~ <0 ~ ~ <0 ;::: 0 0 0 0 g 0 0 M 00 0 ~ /' /' 0 0 0 /' 0 0 0 M ~ ~ ~ 0 0 M 0 M :6 <0 ;;; '" N ~ <0 <0 <0 '" ~ '" <0

•

tI' $I tI' II! QI -3 0 ~ 11/ :It IN C ill -3 !i!

•

!i!

•

iii

•

:It II ~ SI III ~ <

•

III

•

III

•

~ ~ $ "" OJ) .;1#.

-•

~ ~ ~ ~ t,;

a

'II

~t

aw

:\fg ~

•

-R

..

II

tit ~ ~ mt ag n~~ ~ ~a ~ ~ ~-;. -tE ~ t,; otc.

fI-r-.>..J~ T\Tl"

Ita

~~

4[1.

~ C>

K

0'> 0 II

IlB

(13)

III!(

li

§ ~

-N

~ ~ 4J( P-:l

• a

mI

a

~

..

~ QQ

*'

0 -< g: Q I I + It bE ~ ll ~ I I + -<ll \liN It bE ~ ~ 1-. I Q ~

•

(14)

I

~9 tt~~.*~~~~~Z~~.U~~ ~~ _j.~9?J!!~JJ

Ill • • ~

•

It iI!

•

as

•

fl!:J'l.i!f. iiiA'I'I!! l!ilf lilA'fI!!l!ilf PI'lAolt 1II.1Jl _i'_tI F tA D-I tI .~It

(111J (*n:) Z'I'1511 (AI!" )

IiIMIIIIA. -0.000 15 5. 68£-9 0.30 0.86 0.42 28.64 1.52 125

(A I lit) (-3 .18)" ( 1.99)' (4 .34)" (2 .21)'

a ~t iii fll"'I'l!!l!ilf 1iIJ5 '1"l!!l!ilf J"' PlA O Il (112J (fiil"') Z'f }jlJl (AI!" ) F" e!h!/,t(j}. 0.049 -3.47£-5 -3 .'15 61 .27

.I

0.53 49 .57"1 1.49 128 (S .32)" ( ·3. 78)" (-~ .;7) " (13 .86)" flA!i! ItIiIII 0.0 15 -8 .58£-6 -1.26 6.;1 0.51 39 .96"1 1.83 113 (II!' /A) (3 82) " (-2 .23)" (-3 .60 )" (3 .H)" fllIllil-BfAIl -0.002 1. 12£ -6 0.36 0.6'1 0.33 18 .99"1 1.70 11 3 (A/Ill) (-2.04)' ( 1. 35)' (4.81) " ( 1.6;)'

• •

atr.-t-flj

.p).~~~~~

e

n

'

~JlU~~B

tl

•

l . • • •(pol ic (inherent )1 -· ' I! B.O .OSZ • •

*

.

:

·,, ·ttB.O.OIZ • •

*.·

(11 IJJU'!~.DI989'1'ZlItlJiili'll"( cro..'"ct ;0. data) , 'II"~.D"2i.Z r tt'!:~rt• •) • M131989l!'1fl1iiii j:~ 'EE;Jtilt Z;;I;:!I:Sl'I:t:.,

1112J'II"~.lIa~tiliI6j1ffili:1I['I"l!!tI!IIli!iIl;8~78'l"Z§f;'II"(poll in. data)· mtl '0~ 'II"*.:~9f!le.tf·

)dl

fIJ

-y

P),1lJ:

~10 tt~~.~~Z.~l§i13 (tl) : ~~~L*l¥JM~,~~.pl¥J£.~.m~t _.Gifis,"Law IS r1'J

"

Ii II r1'J

"

"&j

IJl El !Ii

• •

IJl EI !Ii

• •

tt'!:F'!Z~ III-m -II i!f'l'f-. ~:t:l't IL.. IU~ltJZ(t

I'lla II.Z IIlit 1Il»!1Ii(')

•

m -IIZIl • • •• Ii

••

lUI -.~

1Il&• •~ (') Z",:t:(')

Ii ~(')

It lIt* -lItll lilt"• •Ii IIF'!Z~. 1I1'l1lo'lt1l! .11III1If1!S

Z~R(') (') 11.(') .Z(tJ!j~ j} MI 'l'l-*

'!:

.!E- ••

R(m.1I 1If• •~~

• • -IiRJ¥. _·_a.~"". 1Il'*~ (')

rlIr IIiii' (') • • -!III;)!; )(')

t( (')

.'aw

'I!.'

''•

• •!!(') tlF'!lIlf;1l

.I_

-

1Il

•

(')

..

. wa/ll'!l _III_".!.:('₎ _&X-eff

(') _flA(')

•

-'l!l't :1:1'1 • • • fl Ali!ttli 6. lit fllIllil-MA

•

'f'~tt'!:2i .2itt~~ tt~~ ' tt'!:lIlll! IU!WIIl

tI! tt'!:f'lZ~ III-m-II tr'/l'-.J;.( I!fIJ~(') tlPlff*1n ff*lnZ. !Ilia lIaZ!llIt J:: Z!llIt(') El(')

•

tt'!:I'!!I!!! !Ef.If!!lIl • • •ZI! 1if1l• • ll'l1&11 l!I!15 (')

tt 1II!.1l'J f<11m lIt~!!!IIII oItM.IfIi'1J (') 'il; (')

12".(') Mrf!!III ' (')

'!: II<m!!lII11J ;;I; 1111 liZ

rlIr (')

..

(') ! t(

J

•

{l£.~607J-~~ , t=l~trPl¥JtE~£.-tP.~iI$~

•

t=l~t~ 0 ~~.m~~7Ft=l~tl\W

"

rtHI9tt~6b. ~~JH~f5JU1J[]5!R 0 4. ~~M1ID.fiflrf~

,

m~3t*.m1f7Jdl' lQ:*.m~M~(.p~AD~) m~.tt~~ fi*~&e~n~Z~* 0

ltt

7l-

?JJ-D

iji

tl'~tm l¥JtE~JlQ1f251:~~wx~l¥JM~

,

tJ~tr!Jl¥J~m

• •

(~~~~ADm~BW. ) ,S~~~ .S._~~l¥J~~'~®~ill.~-~~.

fifo

~7~~~~~~Wlrf~n~tt~~fi. ~zffi~1!m7l-'*lrf~?J)\~~~r.~~A ~a:

l.1lN~1ifll¥J~JE'*lrf~ti~.P '~&

~l¥Jm.slU:*~~~~,~a.±~~~~~~ § Lijg1J[]A~10fnJllzJJi § ; ~~~m~89' ~?J)\~~-~M~oltt7l-,.mnOO~~89~ ~?J)\~~5!R'~7tE~m0~.~~~&tt& ~~'~*~~Z7l-,~m~fim~~~.1 'W~~15l'~~~.~15l.~~ro~~~o

tt :(')I!~*9f~~~."'f'~*.ff.~r1'JE~; tI!.tt'!:~• • •B~•• ~. 2.'±M~l¥J1ifl~~tE~~AM~.~f

flt}1Jl13 •

'II1'I*. :*9f~.1I W~'W~m~l¥JtE~~.£~?J)\.~-~f

tE~Jb1fe~o ,~ltt~M~

• • •

~l¥JtE~£fi~~M~n

3 .*~~'±J!*YltE~Jb1f~15l' ~~1!

_*Ylo

mm~lQ:tE.p~*.J!( bas i c need )l¥J~. 3.

lrf~tE~£~.m15llQ:~

flf.

H

Ji.m~

,

7J-5JU~~t=l~t~1tl!Ul~lQ:~j~l¥J£'1HJ~

.m~~~l¥J£1fe~ill~m~

· ~~

ru~n

,

slU:P),60lQ:807J-~7F

'

~ltt~7Ft=l~t~.liiliM

~

••

Z~~,**

•

• ••

~~,

~

.m~

~l¥JtE~£~~~~15lo~l¥JJb1fB~~~fl M~lQ:ffd:~X1t~jt.~ff~-1W~7Hff 0 ~g~.®~~~~~~~~~''pl¥J£1fW 4 _

**~~n~tE~£1ftJ

.

~1f\¥

'

~*

Educational 1t2.JIt.#~t~"8 .tI9~.o~ ~H{]~7~tll '!f~"M. o 3.•

~.'

#:P

~

• •m£j

1981~1~~ IU. ~lIIjj~tM~

tt

ffi

~

lIN

fUll '

ilLtI9.iJt£fi

)'(111

tfJ l¥J

I I ' 15.It-tt~l~~

..tfJ

"A~ cient)ff!{P). , 1ipjH"ijg~ 1 6.(iossi &: Gi ,1981) , (Goo

1T

1i

'

71~ ) .~1J[]tl1Jp.: .~o 17. fl'1IIt1l1$)j

#*)'(

"

;tam"

':II

Wfl/.

orB

fffr

(15)

~p

I¥.J

!PJ:lff~.fI~.

p

I¥.J

(:t ~fib

ft

i!z

Ii!

f.fj ~

:l'itl1W "

m~tt~~,

e '

fJJ?J7

5i: 1ii

m

~

7jO,

\.DIIi ) m~.fi~~

~ 0 1lt1l-vJ\DlJ..~~tm

JJ!I~ , t1~tmB<J~1I

~!El~~)

"U1

:ttktla9

~

rm

~

ill

~j'Hm

-

~

itHlt

H~f~IT;@{:t~Jbfie ~w\~tHtJ.

r

. I

H

'FI

*if~tt~F

'

~& ~.j:ttJlt~~:a:Jj i§ ; .¥~4Hiee91

. ,

~.mjJW.~e9~

i}

~ ~1JIIi

I¥.J

OJ

l?di&

mJ

lII~jM~~liUt.

Dt~~Q}1JD5!i~1t 0 {:t~ff:t~?£.mJ]i :A:

£ ff

vJ\H!{'F-~f {:t~ J:I~ f{

1!

1t

If,J DJ

f'F

JJl

Dt N: m;

:¥.i

~:.m

m

5:E gtm~

,

~OOJruj!jm ~ ~

l1g h "

j{jfU1ifiX IT~-M~?:t~ o ~ff~~zlJf • ~~ J.~~~~~:¥.i~~I¥.J£ff~~ffi~;~

• • •

~~~~~I¥.J£ff~~'~T~&1¥.J ~~~aBI¥.JM~nhN:~~Apl¥.Jft~

1J'

~JlUaBN:il£~Ap~ft~::f~

0

•

l. • • •

(pol ice

power)~rf!*a~m;~1¥.J

(inherent)lIh

,jMm~1ltllhlfitT!1!!jJ

~~ 'ru~£~~*N:~~~~"~~"

m. "i}.-.~~Z~.~ru,tt~u

AAI*UT tJ.llNftlj 0

~WlI¥.JM'-'llW~~S . H

.Gifis,·'Law Dictionary", Barron's

Educational Series Inc., 1984,P

.

350 .

1£2 .JltJjt1itil51tmiI¥.JWlllH~:~.rra~~~

t'(!(Jm.

0

~7

'§.-2;-Eiitm1l- ' t1itl1W$

~m~7~W"~.m"~E" ~~"~* "~~~M~.'~~A.~l1WI¥.J&w~ o 3.~ii.

"

*~.

' "

~~~ffctlMil¥.Jlfc!it& *~.~£ffl¥.J~~"'~.M~~' 1981~1.~ ~

, 13---

17Jt

0

1

4.

-ft(.:I:l~~!J!l¥.Jlm$

,

~jjl!PJ:lffl¥.J~~~ ~~I¥.JIlNM'~¥-~~.'.~~-. m~.~£~~~.~~.~I¥.J~*'* 3t1llrf!~ I I' RH~~D~1lt&~mHt

0 Jt

S.JIt-

.tt~JQ}m~tEp

ftifil1gh '

~fiW~

~.rf! "~M-.1*Iil"(Engle ' s

coeff

i

cient)ffift) ,

~tXf~~VF

:

tEpftifi(~Jt)

{!p

Jl. tttg h

tEpJ5JT~

it6 .(Rossi &

Gilmartin ,1980)" (Carley

,1981) " (Goodman, 1978)"

(Dffi~MtN:.

iTlI '

71~)

"

(~7\:;, 72~) ~~ttm .~~.jJ~N:~~~~~tH::f~.UI¥.J iJ~o 1t7.~HtlJI$jJ$~ffl~l¥.Jff~$Jj{, ~~

#.- ''' ••

$tt~W~M?:tfijJ$ ~.ffl" ,~~

• •

~~~~ft#N:.~ .~

(m3f!!j-)

'rf!¥~~Ifi.lIjjl~*

-

35

~(:p,

PP

.

III

-

2 -

1---III-2-22 0

a8.

ru~2rf! Q)~ tH~Jj{fli1~

rf!

~~~I¥.J~?:t ::f~-~o£*L*if~~~~il£N:~~

• •

~~W~.~~l¥.Jffitttt~,~1lt~ ~U""f~?:t~::f%~-~

0

a9.rra~j:~at

' "

-Ei1ll!1!!lMitE~~Dt~lt

¥&'*"

,~1jJ78~'

P. 11

0

al0."

tE*~~'8miti" ~m~m¥JJ~~tE

*~fflZ1l-'~~~~M0~J5JT"~J5JT

"M~W:E~~mo all.~a9'

P

.

15 0

a 12

.1lt-~fl*~~tJ.a31I-Ei.!1!!li\[~~P

~M .m5JU*1tgf~flm~:flI3.ffHI

'

~~

M

.mZiI5m

{l:fi.&N:~*~.

' ?:t-Ei1ll

!fi~24M :

-Eiitm4M :

~Mtm5M

0

~ ~ r?:tM=~~~:flI3~$J 'm-~. *.~~M.m;m=~«*.~~P'

ffE-EiM!1!!lMi7 ,365MM.m rf! ' :flI3ml502M

M.m~~*M.moM~.-~*M.m. P~rf!:flI3ml.*pf-J18,600p

0

ru~~ 1\l!~fE!l.

'

-EiitmW-Eiitl1W$l¥.JrralMi

.m~.~fl.~~OJn~~.~.o

a 13.

if "

fnplil~m-Eiitm~~~56~*M ~mr~miW.l¥.Jrram~o

a 14.

ru~j:gfat~I\I~:flI3.jJ~~lt

'

.~ ~~m:fll3~I¥.J.*~f-J::f~,~1lt~ lMiZp~£fi?:t~~~~rf!~n~~* l¥.J~jgo

a 15

.

tlOBurns~G

re

b 1

e r ( 1976)

fJJ~ l!&mtE~ ~~l¥.Jf§tt*~(H

IDN

)W2fi~.A~Ps ~~=gM

(GDPC)

~~

-"

1l1JU~"

I¥.J

~~H

1* ;

Chang(l986)~JtmifJ!G$W6~tE~ ~~~~.~~~~~tE~ff:.M~~ ~~~*.J5JT~0

a 16.

GAnnez~Wheaton(

1984

)fJJ~W6~tE~1I mU~m$'.~l¥.JtE~~Dt::f~~~

*0

~;1Jxit 1.

ji{ma ' 1972 '

< <

-Ei1ll!1!!liIfr5tEMDtZ

~~N:fr5tE*~Z~.»'rf!ftil5ifJ5JT

(16)

-m~fu 0 2.ms1:l '1973' «{i~~~:/~wHM#H"S9 W?¥~~>> ' ~*1'l1HilfmmIDfS 0 3.1$m~' 1985' «-EJ.~Wim{i~rdi7..k ~Z~~»'$jl~~?fTmIDfSo 4.51~'!1' tW~. , 1991' «-EJ~tm{i~ £.m~Z~~»,«~mWff~M flJ> >m+!\~

,

m-M 0 5. Jii!t~ , 1988 ' < <~mjlA~{i~~~ z~~»'rr~~~W~~~~~o 6. rr~~~lil~~{i~ , 1986 ' < < {i~:& m{i~flW1¥P5E~~Z~~> > 0 7 .1l)H~£~tt§:'75~W~~CPJL\~EP , 1982 '«§:'75*fiM1IDz~~---wf~~IDfS Jt.(1»> 0 8.Rossi,R.J.:&Gilmartin,K.J.mtlf' $~ ,mJtl$.g.~ , 1981 ' < <ffd:~t~H~~IDfS

- ~ta' ¥,t'~:&7.HfT> >IYH~£~~M

rr o 9.Downing, P.B. lJj{lf' Ji*~~.g.~, 1989 '«~~~~*W~~»,~~~~ ffd: tfj ~ 0 10 . cp¥~~Ifi}JI:!Jl*tt~EP , 1988 ' < < lll~~.IIl{t~~~tf:&~~~fl(m

=

ffiT » > 0 11. 51~~ ,

#9" '

1982 ' < < t:£~~il1i1ilI S9~~a~~~~£.S9~~»'« lilmflili J=j flJ > > 0 12. ~*

'

1983 ' < <7ZmIt~il1i~t~~m* zlil.rr> > ' «$~*1tITfH~» '21 ~ 8M 0 13 . rr~lI%~lil*~{i~ '1989' < < -ElfJ!tit!! m:~~{t~lil~ (~1jJ59SfJ.l.¥78SfJ.l) >

>

0 14.rr~II%~Ut*, 1991' «IjJ*lil~t\Sf ffJ!J(~1jJ80Sf.¥85Sf )Zmp:gffiT~1t 1jJ~§:'75~fl.> > 0 15.rr~lI%±ff~' 1989, «-EJ.it!!m:{i~ ~15lWliJ~~1S-»0 16.~.g.ljJz r{im*1tff~~J ,

mEl

1989 Sftfj~z*~sf4:i:.(~Jt~) 0 17.-EI~tm~R'f±IT~~EP' 1979-89' «-EI ~tm*'&V&:SZ::Wffi~?t~~1Eit~!M~)

>

0

18.Annez,P. and Wheaton,W.C.(1984),"Eco_ nomic Development and Hous ing Sector: A Cross-national Model" ,Economic De velopment and Cultural Change ,Vol.32. 19 . Baer,W . C.(1976),"The Evolut ion

0:

Housing Indicators and Housing Stan dards :Some Lessons for the Future. Public Policy,Vol.24, No .3.

20.Burns,L.S. and Grebler, L.(1976), "Re' source Allocation to Ho usi ng Invest. ment: A Comparative I nterna tional Study",-u2;Economic Development and Cultural Change,Vol .25 .

21 .Chang , C.O . (1986),"Exp l anat i on and Forecasting of National Hous ing In vestment: A Comparative Study in Tai

wan(ROC),Korea(South),Japan, and the USA" ,Ph.D. Dissertation, Unlversity of Pennsylvania.

22 .Car ley ,M. (1981), "Soc ia I Measu rement and Social Indicators: Issues of Pol

icy and Theory ", George Al len

&

Unwit LTD.

23.Clemmer,R.B . and Simonson,J C. (1983) Trends in Substandard Ho using: 1940-1980",J. of AREUEA( Ame ri can Rea l

Estate and Urban Economi cs Associa tion),Vol.10,No.4 .

24.Elias,B.O.(1973),"A Comprehensive Model for Housing Standards: theoret

ical analysis and applicat ion to the Sudan",Ekistics, No.216.

25.Goodman,J.L.,Jr.(1978), "Causes and Indicators of Housing Quality", Social

Indicators Research,Vol.5 .

26.Gifis,S.H. ,(1984), "Law DictJonary', Barron's Educational Series, Inc .. 27 .Mi 11 er, L. C. ,J r. ,(1973), "The Economics

of Housing Code Enforcemen t" , Land Economics, Vo I. 49 ,No.1 8.tatcIiff, dards and Economics, 29.Ravall ion , of Housin) AppI icatio Econom i cs , 1 30. St ern lie Statistic! Housing (I976),"H( AKS Press,t JJ.falden,M .L. Codes on L of AREUEA, 32.fexler ,H. J. and Local Books .

(17)

~ 7tIfC ~

:i:

irf3t

~1!;' )

on, W.C. (1 984) , "Eco

and Ho us ing Sector: odel",EconOlll ic De lfa I Change ,VaI. 32 . "The Evoluti on oj and Hou s i ng Stan ; for the Future' 24, No. 3. bler, L. (1 976 ) , "Re_ to Hous ing [nvest ve I nte rnat i ana! c Deve l opmen t and

1.25.

"Expl ana ti on and ional Housi ng In t i ve Study in rai

:h) ,Japan , and the tion,Un ivers i tyof ocial Me asur ement rs: Issues of Pol

rge All en &I Unwin

U1onson,J. C (1983)"

ndard Hous ing :

~UEA(Amer ican Real conomics Associa "A Compr ehe nsive

andards: theoret )plicatio n t o the .216. 178), "Causes and ( Quality", Social ,Vo 1.5. Law Dict ionary ", Series, [nc .. 3), "The Economies orcement ", Land .1

.latcliff,R.L . (l952),"Housing Stan dards and Housing Research" ,Land Economics, Vo I. 28.

29.la va [lion,M.(1989),"The Welfare Cost

of Housing Standards: Theory with Application to Jakarta",J . of Urban Econooics,Vol.26, No.2 .

30. Sternlieb,G.,"The Sociology of Statistics: Measuring Substandard

Housing" in Sternlieb,G . (ed.) (1976) , "Hous i ng (1973 -1974)" ,Vo I .3, AlS Press ,New York.

31.'alden,M.L. (1987), "Effects of Housing Codes on Local Housing Markets", J. of AREUEA,Vol . 15,No . 2.

32.'exler,H.J .and Peck,R. (1975), "Housing

and Local Government"jLexington Books.

台北都會區住宅品質標準之研究

Arch

i

tect

u

re

.

A

.I.

R

.O

Dec

.

re D

is

tr

ic

t

s and

~~t~~e-~1i~~~';;~Z~Jf~*

it {-"

...

• •

•

thes is

:

'

1It)'f. ,

• •

'

'

'

,

-, Mia

: (3)

,

• •

'

I

tt

(Housing Standard)

(Minimum

S

tandard)&"

• •

(Preferred

S

tandard

i

ng

S

to

ck) i¥J

(tt

2

)

•

(Bous ing Code

),

t

,

• •

WlJiffrII: '

ice pow­

er

)

,

••

:

(2)

='

1i~~.~~;Z~§IHI~~

m

&XmM~~~.'~~fl'

•• 'BA

•••

•

.­

..

,

te-~1i~~~';;~Z~Jf~*

ice pow

_{1i.;Z~§IHI~~}

&XmM~.'fl'

.

_{*'~T~~~~i&Jff~m~~}

_'.~

_~~

_~

_{~~~~.Z5'I-,~nU~m}

_~

_~

_~

_ff:

_.B.

_{~j!~~~~,~m~*i&Jff}

_.

_~~~

_~~~

»(the theo- ry of consumer be