義大利政黨政治之發展及其特性

全文

(1)---. ~. 40. 0. \ *,""W~. 0. 1(\R. ,*.~,(~~"~~~'tI€~$.~·"'~*~tt·\t\,*. 0. ... 1I!iI1f:R$1$~iI-'~illii$~IlIlI() §.,,::.,tII!'~'".'''''. .-K~gf~lgf~~N~~~~~~ •~~~'~",.~~~~.~"~,,~~,~.~.~,,:"::,,,'~'>~.~~'>~.~~"';::..:$''~:""~'~'>~.~'~'>~.~'~"~'~~.~"~.~'~"~.~'~.~(. Jl!~~It\~'ft0. 0. I ~~gr*\I\~I\+-\'''' 1\+<~!II~\iiI~~~~~-tr-" -sr,,~~~;jl'tl€J (Forza Ita lia) ". r \iiI-t.:4• • J (National alliance) ". ~~ r ~.~ •• J (Northern League) \l1'tI€~ ::!-'\1(~~~ r -mr-S". J ( Freedom Alliance) ~ \m~"" gr+ gr iii 1\ ~~~~.~ o8gr~ 1\ +<!II" ..~~.~~~;}!~ (Oscar Luigi Scafalo) ~~ r ,,~~~;jl'tl€J 'tI€~IiiI\~~*~ (Silvio Berlusconi) ~*.~ ~~+!II" 1iiI\~~*~.f1~-'\1(.{C~-<~\.E~:r.(::!-'\1(\I\'tI€.~I1~ ~ ~%~.,*~~,,*t->~~ ~*-S~~ r ~.~lI!.{~'tI€ J (Christian Democratic Par ty DC) ~.\t\*~"~I1~~ " tri:~ r ,,~~~;jl'tl€ J ~~I!I\-~..\Ill~~"~~~~'tI€~~.-< \. 0. "~~$~'tI€~~!'.~~~~.~~~Ilt~" ~\.E-mr~1\ %~*~~~*" ~'tI€*'t.\ ~~~ ,*_.w~~!lJ-'\1(~"~~~~!, • • ~~~~.~ " tt-tr-·"'*~~~W~ ~*" 1iiI\~~*~~~* \.E~\¢~.~~'\t\,*~'tI€,"'.~~tt*~~~. ~"~I1~~IIl\!(~~5i~~~~'tI€~~~~~.~. .,"tfr.",mr.-& ~~.\~>. I ' _-K~~_~~N~IIIti~Q11Bt ~. t)8 .~ Monde, Ie 30 mars 1994, p.4. ~~nternational Herald Tribune, March 30, 1994, p.l. .-K~~.m$·Mfl~II!I!!~~~~.

(2) ~~~~.~~~~~~~~~~1<1(1~~~~~~m~~~~1~~~o~.~~~~~~~~~.~~~~~. 0. ~~ ~. 0. ~~~t-'-111$~~*~~ .. -l.mI I <~< I .U:t-IR I ~ 11I1.U:t--1f;l1R.gr..\J1(~1f;l.~*,~.1JN~ ~ ~~~~~~~~.m:: ~ mj.lE\lt!l{1f;lSI:I<\ ,j;tg~ , m 1 < 110~M ~ ~~~1l@N-H~~~~~.~~4fi'~ft\4i:(*'iffl-.~~.m::~~1~~~~~~~ 1 1 <. ~~~N~~. 1N*. 0. lE.t--.~~41Bm. ( Kingdom of Sardinia ). 1 <1(K~+~ ~. ~:jmt~~• • (. ~~~.$~.~~41~. 0. 0. Ji[:~. 1 ~t-'-.ijii' ~. ~~~. H::l4i:(~~.~~41~~. 1 ~ r 1t*j;tg J. ~~1+1:t" ~ ~t:~.-m:jmt~~~!lJll(*l. ~ 1~j;tg.~~~ , [M-1lE~*~t:~. ilE~~~. 0. 0. .~~:\IlI€$ ~ ~~ ~ ~~~. n). 1 $~ 1 ~Bm~. 1 <..\JO~~. 0. gr<~~ 1 <gr~~llfj[ ~ -m~*,~ (Giuseppe Mazzini) ~~lIiH~~ (Giuseppe Garibaldi) ilE~.~!!IR 1 ~~~~.'iffl-.~ Camillo Benso di Cavour) ilE~~. ~r--,.~~~~. 0. 11]~+..\Jm ~ .t--.~~Bm41~~~*W)11~( Vittorio Emanuele. Turin). 0. ~ ~ -!:i;:l.t--.~~ 1+1 Bm~*l.t-'- ~ ~r--,.~~~~~N:t" ~ ~~~~~. r .~~ll@:~Bm~~ J ~.i.\I~~~.~!!IRll~~~:::j.'iffl-.]!!i.{1i<Mr--,.~~-<lIR~lIR~~1f 1 < 1( I ~ ~~:jmt~~~t!*(. lIlIHt::~~~~"J.~lIR*l.~. 41 o@. 0. 1 ~~~~~.tS~8E 1 <gr<~111~1-Rm-m.t--.~ID1~1+1~M1ID1$!:li!t:: (Carlo Alberto). ~g~~ 1 ~m~~.~ ~. ~.1t*J;Ig~~{J:;! ~ ~~~~~~t:~!IIl4i:(~g:!a!!~. ~~~~.!lJll(~-m~1+1~~~4fi'~lE[M-.!lJll(~~-m~lIR~.~~o. 0. 1 <..\J<~~ 1 <~'Il~~. .~~~~.(. Italian Radical Party) ~:lI~~~~.. -!:i;:l~,!!J~~llfj[ ~ ~~~~. 1 .~*.-!:i;:lW~mj*l~m-m~~~-< -HHf.iI- ~ alS:w*~~KI~-< -H~ii4rr.tS~~."~l!!il~ 0. ~~~:::j ~ $!~-!:i;:l~#1\~~. 1 ~ 1 11~~ ffif\ti~"~.~ ~ ~~ 1 ~ 1111~~ ~1II1l1Ji[:~H<*l~~~lJ!l(~.N~~ :lI~~~~.~~. ( Italian Socialist Party PSI). @~~ !KlE~~~~aIIj(.~~.~~. ~,!!J$m~1mJl~. 11.mI I ~. ~~~~~~~o. 1 ~.. 0. ~~ ~. 0. 11I1.U:t-if\ I ~~Hi.U:t--.fIIll ~ I 111~WJ ~ .~~~ ...~~.~~~ -!:i;:l1 ~ 1 ~~~~.iI-]!!i.{~Im~Nl11 1 ~111 ~~ :lI~~~JIlil.( Italian Communist Party PCI) m~".iI-~~. +111~~.~~:lI~~!!IR. ~~ean-Bapti8te Duroselle,. lE~1~o-!:i;:lW~~~iI-~~r--,~~~.fIIl-m~-<-HN:t"~~.H<*l~~~~~~1~1~~~1f;l1f;llIiH~~1~~~~~~(. L'Europe de 18154 n.oe jours (Paris: PUF., 1991, 6e €!dition ) , pp.129-136.. :W§J ":!marry Hearder, Italy: A Short HiBrory (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1990), pp.164-197..

(3) I. ~ ~ili1JJ.t*IHas~~~. 0. I. ~. I. 0. ~1111l!:!-11m:::. ~ 1111l!:!-+m::: 1I +~m ~ .J;ti#l1iiI~• • '~1$. 1 ~ 1Igrl!:!-grm:::~~.+<tBm-H- ~ #l1iiI~.~~ I ~ 1ll-R~ ~ ~ili}'-~t'r. 0. 0. .J;ti~!iii'it ~ K-~~{ttI!~. 1 ~grlI1l!:!-~m:::~ mE!lili.J;ti• •. ~i'->~;ge~{~~.N~.\1t ~. 0. ( Ivanoe Bonomi ). ~ ~ ~~lIIt#l1iiI~. ~ ~1#D-H-.~l11+I-R~H!f~. Luigi St¥no ) • .f:::I~.-K*--<ISl.( Italian Popular Party""-'PPI" . . . .~.....nK#\_• • " ti* .. \~ l 0. 0. l!:!-11m:::..l..jl:l;:ig:J:iZJ:I''\~*:\mI~. (Luigi Facta) :\mI~~a(~~~l!:!-+m:::~-=!. -£H.H~IH+l~~l!¥5..g:#l1iiI~.ii1#*.P.:l'h:{~.pj I ~111 1 1$+<~~1I*N~ ~ .+<~~n.rg:#:1K-.~ o.JIII I ~111 tt~.}'-4[l ~ fE.l:l;:i~#l~~. ~~. *". .~~~~~.~~~~~}'-~~mP.:l'h:{l:l;:i~~~IH+l~~:\mI~#:1~.~~~o. 0. mE!H~mH~~_~N~ ~ ~i'->~$E~.mK-<ilI1 ~ ~~~~~-< --H~t!lr<:li ~~N1( +gr~tBmltiJ1R ~ 111~~+gr~~1$. ~1la.$~.N.~_ ~ ~~~-=!jJg1iiI~.~~~{ttI!~.N)igit ~ .+<~~~.~~lE1fE-H-.. 0. Badoglio) -33"ti:i:\mI~ ~ ~~1I*i'-> 11+*,l!:!-~1t~~~. illfff.fff~!!:m~-33*-111$+<~~§~ .'~~if.~iR~ ~~IH+l~N.~#\ltl>(~~~ ~~~Iil:~-H-il4. ~ fE-£HaJ*,lE~itIt (Pietro. (. 0. ~gr~l!:!-+11m:::l1+1Im ~ ~• • • ~~~~.jJg ~ ~~. 0. ~gr<l!:!-I. 0. ,. tBm.~~ ,. ~.~~~{ttI!~~~~N~~. I. <>. 0. 0. 0. ~.Ili:$\II!Ill~ ~ ~.~~.~~.~1:;.-j 1 ~grl il!:!-~m::: ~ aJlH+l (Ferruccio Parri) ~1:;.-j r ~.t::iit. J (Action Party) I ~gr jIll!:!- ~ .~~~1H+l Alcide de Gasperi ) ~1:;.-j r wtl.:i\it\SilI1++1. J ~.+<i;~~1I*~#l1iiI~~.~~!it ~ r ~Ilf J ~~.\lI.*.~~~~~ I ~gr K l!:!-Km::: 11m ~ .+<~illIH.t:: r ~Ilf~ ~ J -N<4il11~1fij~ ~ ~-H-*~=I:K{i.~~.lQ~~NI-R+gr~lll ~ ~~JlRr++11:;.-J.~.lQ~~Ngr +I-R~~ " .+<~:fK{i.~P.:l'h:{~1:;.-j m::: 1 mP.:ltHtl~ liKit ~ .jJg~gr+~~-H-~. I. <>@. ~ .+<~~~.~~mK:t!W-K~~.. I I ~ M+<~~M~IIN+H~IEHM~. ~*,~.4rrjJg~~~mK«$l. +<llffE111[. g:1II~ (. Gabriel Almond) mK:ftf!:aJ (Sidney Verba ) ~~-33" ~ .+<~~~~. T:t!~~~~.-.+<~~~~~-K~lE1~~~~!iii'fE.~~~~~~~~~~.~-<ilI1m\ll!lll~~.~~-<~~~~ <>. 1(-\-l. Oberdorff, us Constitutions de I'Europe des Douze (Paris: La Documentation frant;aise, 1992) ,pp.229-250.. ~$t: ~ #:1~fE~.~~.~~~mK~~tlt*if. *1><h!:;.*'N.-Kiii"UI:1~;U:;iIllHenri. ~. ~. .+<~~.~~-N~~~*«i?:tt! . h!:;!l!l2:!$Nm1><Ml1><°.

(4) ~~~oe. ~~~~~.~~~~~~~~~~~4[~~~~~.o. ~~~~1~~~~~~~~.~1~~~~o.¥~~~~~~~~~~~~#~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~. ... ~~~~~.N~~~.~~~~~~.~~~~~~~. ~l!IlE[~*.mr~. 0. ~~~~~~. ••~-3~I1~$IIT*~~1iS ~ *~~~ ~ ~~~~!lI*-R~H~. p<-m:~.~~~~O~~1~ ~ ~~*<~~.~~nR$l*~ ~ ~~~~~~. 0. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.~€~~~o.¥~.¥~H~~~~.tr~~~~~~~~ru~(. ~~~l~~O~~~~~.~.¥~~.~~~~~~~~~.~~~~~~~~~o~. 0. Lombardy ) ~1fI!~*, ( Veneto ) lfE~l!I ~ ~ii.~~.~~~*~w..!*. ~~tr~~~l!I~~W*-R~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~H~~~~*<~~.~~~~~o-m:~~~.~~~~~~~. 1~~11~~fm~-Nl1+n'$1n![J.1+\fm~-N1(+~ ~ ~~~~di£~!K!.. 1lit~~. lfEl\l!Iin-m:<4~1!ml~*Ml. 0. ~~~~~.rH~~~.~.~~~.J~~~r.~~~~~.~~~~J~~~~~o~~~~~~~¥'~~~~ IE*,~~~~ ~~l!etmttr~~~~~~:B,*-m:. 0. N~~~~~~~o~~IfE~~~~:B~~~~~~.~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o~.. U • •*ItI-NtHI-.¥~~ • .@I~~.~ ( Senate) ~.~ ( Chamber of Deputies ) 1fE~. ~~*,~~~~~~~~~~.¥~~.~N~Ro@~~*~r~~.~J~~~~~~~.~m~#¥o. ... ~o~.~~~. 0. 0. ~~•• ~1(fml1]+~ ~ ~~~~+~N 1~~~~4I1!in~~~~~~~ ~ ~~.~~~l!I ( ~$I:~11l+11~~~) .~N ~.~~~i:m\- ~ IE~~ r *~$;!~:B~~~~ J (Imperiali System) ~~~ 1 ~.~. ~ li¢~~i;tmt~~ ~ 1;JJ!1.~. 1;JJ!1l!1N"~~l~.~~~~~.;JJ!1~.~ l11E~~~N.rm ;JJ!1.~.~~N~ ~ ~~~.~~N~.~~~~;JJ!1 ~~~. .~.~~Ia'~.~.~N~~o. mj~4I1!in"~~.!iWJ~111+.~~~( ~~~gr\t-.~;JJ!1~*~.~ ~~~fm~NMr~-tJ~~m:. ~~1~.~~~.~~;JJ!1.~.~~~.~~~~K.4I1.~~o~~~~.~~~4I1!in~~~N~.~~~~~1. 1~~~~. o~*~~~.;JJ!1.~~~~~~~.~~~~~o. ~~K~-E:\~~. ¥). :W9 .:!!!Gabriel A. Almond and Sidney Verba, The Civic Culture ( Princet~n: Princeton University Press, 1963) , pp.402-403. iJj:§) .:!!!Paolo Fameti, The Italian Party System, 1945-1980 ( London: Frances Pinter, 1985) ,pp.82--86. .:!!!Sabino Cassese, "'Hypotheses on the Italian Administrative System,'" West European Politics (London), Vo1.16. No.3 (July 1993), pp.316 -328. ~.

(5) 0. ,"'.::'';'9"":,_:''~5''O:~~'''',!:~~..,.,:-v~--~''~'~. ,.."~">-'.-~:~:,,,,';:'''''~~~::7'"''""<~.-.. 0. -"':'-"''''.. -~""''''--=->-~::~''''~~' ___'. 0. •. j +~~.:ii • •~JS .. i(.~£Ir! r .f:-Xl:ti~f$. J (D'Hondt System) *~liliilit~ ~~ • ~~~it~:ii~liliil~.~~_~~~~:iio ~41Ifg111l1 ~ at~~ ,. ~~~:ii~.~t{W~lflffi:" ~~~£Ir!-N~~:!;;~~~~~~:lIW~~.-R~:iii%<_iHi¢ ~ !Erfg~ ~~J(*.p:j :&:i\!a~~ e $~:I;!;HIIIl~:i£cW ~ ~ 1 ~~grlitl11IJI:::i£I!I.~~-B:-" at~~~~:i£~.~~ ( gr~-Nl1]:i£~~-e • • *,.~~~~ ~ gr~ -N 1 :i£~~-e±r~:!;;~~~~ ~ ~W~f'-,}m~-Ngr:i£llC~~~) ~ ~cW*'_*1::j:i£ll!!H~~~t-t.~*~~~.:i£~~ ~ ~~cW*. o • • ~~.~~~_:i£~~~f'-,~~~.~~:i£~.-N~~Iffi:~~~.i%<*~~~~~.*~~$:i£~~o. t+-i%<.:§!Si~.~~~:i£~t{**~iHi¢ ( .~~~._*1lI'RP!!l1$~}m~-N 11 iliK:i£~. ~ ~~_.f::\.~~-<iilX!Er.~~~ fg~:§~~). .\i!~.~:i£1::j~. 0. 0. 0. fg~~. Depretis) ~-l1aiitllH1~ ( Giovanni. 1 ~i%<.~!Si~ 1 ~i%<~*~~~~~I1i%<~". 1E~:i£.$.~ (Agostino. ~.l?~t\Hit§ ~ ~.~lf~'~4l1~~~. ~~~.jL- ~ il>41Ii%<tlE~~.i%<~~:i£~~. 0. .. ~~ •. ill.~C(iJllII5mK.~-g~~ r il>41Ii%<tlE J mV<.~.~~i%<tlE:i£~~-N 1 .... ~ .. ~~~~~:I(I!!-&<-N~. 1 <-tJ 1 <-tJKlit~ • •~~~i%<~1i!!: ~ -e~.~~~ 1 If-t< ~ ~W:ti\. ~ ~ • •~~I!I.:i£fI>(~ ~ !Er1E.41If'-,-B:-Ii!!:W~. Olit~ ~-B:-Ii!!:4J::1~:i£:iR-R!ii~iI>41Ii%<tlE. 0. Giolitti ) ~~:\Dl~~Jli~.~~~;;tg ~\.!':S~~~l!!lflffi::i£~~mt:iR-R. .~~:ti\~_. §). 0. 0. ( Partitocrazia ). .~~1I.J~I!!I.!lH::j+l11~i%<~ ~ i%<tlE-Nj;\-:W.~~~ 1 lit. r i%<_~$ J. 0 ••. ~. ~. i%<tlE~!Si~. r i%<$~. J. ... ~~ ...~~~ 1 :ti\~~1::j-N~ ~ 1 ~\!s~f'-,~~;;tgfEiI~ 1 .~$!:i£~~" 11~l§iilX~~!!!!.~~:ti\Wll.:i£;t!~~~\.!':S .~-N~~ o!ErIE ~ ~.~$~.±r~:!;;~~mt41I~~$R:i£~iilX*ttiW.;;tg~!Si~~41Ii%<tlE 1 ~gr<lit .. ~$nI~aR++1.~ ~.~:i£~.-B:-I$~}m~-Ngr +<iIi~:i£~ ... I.!l*.:i£~~ .. ~$mt.~~~.aR++1. (Italian Social Democratic ( Italian Republicain Party PRI) ,. ~.~~mr-e. ( Italian Liberal Party-PLI). Party PSDI) ,. 0. 1 :ti\~~.p:j~-1t21~t':i£~H::j+litli!!:". 111.!ii~~41Ii%<~. .rr::r~. :i£~~. ~:i£++1~~!E1.l!Jl§mr.i%<.~-B:-1::;j;;tg.-In!!~" ~~i%<.t{:~t~:i£~. ~ ~~~~.. ( Lottizzazione ). ~. K~. 'l;I;t8 4$lliIDonald Sassoon, Contemporary Italy: Politic, Economy and Society since 1945 (London: Longman, 1991 ) , p.l65. ~J:!1$Philippe Lauvaux, Us grandes democraties contemporaines (Paris: PUF., 1990 ) , pp.562...-565. :iIi§ 4$l~offrey Pridham, Political Party and Coalitional Behaviour in Italy (New York: Routledge, 1988 ) , pp.41-61. .-Kiii;~*t~~-N~~~w.:~:t!i .

(6) ~.~~~. ~1~;;tg.1E111[ ~ ~. ~~~. ~.~*~~. 0. 0. ~{!{I!N;;tgMtf!mla'.J;g.@:!l;:i~. l$' 1 ;;tgMt.\jijt~~IlE~~~~ ~. ~1lE~m«{!{I!~R44li!IiRN.-R. ~~~. ,. :fK~1-'- ~ 1II~~l!t$.Mt~.J;g~-lEllltJK.HlJIl• • ) .;;tg~~ + gJ}~~) 0. 1 ~!It~ ~. 0. ~o. (. ,. ~. ;;tg1ll~H:l. .J;!;iilill.~1:1f:~jg ~ ~. 1II~~l!t$.Mt~~~. $~R~~;;tgmtllli:::. 1lE~f!mla'~~1:1f:!It~~~!l;:iMt~~~KW~.o~~~l$'l~~1:1f:.\jijt~~.J;!;i+~NK~-IE~'~IlE~~~IiR~.N~$~~. TA..y!l;:i (. 0. ~ • • ;;tg~4J+l1.~<+11.:&i~iP.<I ~ 1II~1l-~~~ ':!l?~. ,. ~Zl;:~.1E111[ ~ =~.;;tg~~+K.~4J+4J.jf,!£'*,~1:1f:~~.J;!;i 1 iP.<I:&i~lll!KK~-lEIII"~.~~.t;::~~N~:\t1 ~ ml.~..y 0. -IE~iii<1a~1:1f:~~.~.~N~if~~~ ~ ~..yIll~.BI~~IIJJ](":&i~;ge ~ ~~~1:1f:.~{!{I!~$:H.t;::~~:&iOO~ .1<~III~.!H.J;!;i~~~~1l-~~• • t:EiiAi\lBll!:&i~~. olll~.~~~~.~ml~~'~IlE~.~:fKIiR$iP.<I• •;;tgMt:&i~.J;g~lli:::~IiR~~~$iP.<I~lll!K:&i~.o. ~~~~~IIJJ](~N~IIJJ](.~III~K~.BI~.N~~*~~o~~~~~III"1l-~{!{I!N~IIJJ](~~IiR~~~~~.~~:&i~~. 0. 1*. ~jg[.!jL (F.. Cossiga) ~ll!l;:i~1:1f:~. ~.~~.J;!;i~~~.~TA1-'-~lljm~. 1 ~~111.l!tgrm::nJ~~~fl. ~ ~1:1f:.i;#~~~IlE. ~ ~:::I(~~*~~~~.BI ~ ~1{t>(. 1$-E-~N~~. 1 ~<O.l!t~m::l1+~m ~. ~~~~e~~~.:&i~TA~~~~~~.~;ge~~1:1f:~~~:&i~~Nl o=~~~~~.la'• •IIJJ](~.{!{I!~~~ .m:r~:ttl ~ ml~iii<1a~1:1f:1E111[ ~ ffii]m,(~~j>-.l JlIr$W:&i~~. ~~. -IE<'l~~.~ll]jml1+~.~11jmK+grlirH'l!~~~.~N~!l;:i o~lE.J;!;i 0. ~. (Bettino Craxi) , ~fii!~tJK.~wtl~~.-I.K!It. 1~illl-t;.!Ii:&i r ..~ J (Mani Pulite) {.t;::ii ~. 1 ~~J!;:\!!!::\t1. .1<~fi[i';;tg~~~~. o@. +<.~1 I jm~+4J.l(a$j>-.~1:1f:~!It~:&i ;ge~~.1-'-:&i:!i1i~~~~. 1~~ 1l.l!tllm::-lW ~. ~1l-«~:ll~tJK~:1;:~~~~~~-lW~ ~ :jnj(1l-]m,(.a1~j>-.~:ti~.~wtl~~jg[. 0. ( Giulio Andreotti) , ~~.1<~:fK~.~.~~"';;tg ( Giorgo La Malfa ) ~\IBIl!~~$~~ .J;!;i~1<lKfi~~-R~~~ IE 1 ~ll.~:&i~~~.ffii~~~~~:m~~TA~~!I~~ o~ 1 ~~gr.l!tl11m:::&iIll~1<~. ~*~1-'- ~ ~1it:&i~.~$~-lW ~. ',.;>. "." •. ,. :W§J .:!!Olivier Duhamel, Les democraties : regimes, histoire, exigences (Paris: Seuil, 1993), pp,118 -119. ~ ~ David Hine and Renato Finoc· chi, "The Italian Prime Minister," West European Politics, Vo1.14, No,2 (April 1991), pp.79-96. Mario Caciagli, " Italie 1993; vers la Seconde Republique," Revue frant;aise de science politique (Paris), Vo1.43, No.2 (Avril :W~. 1003) , pp.229...-.266..

(7) •. _. ~. ~}§$:l\!;$;'!iii.1';::j.+<~~ •. 0. .m::I/Ii1* ~ ~~l!!!&~«W;;~~~~.-J:f1~ ~. ~~.~.~~~.~~o~. 1.. 0. 0. ~ IE~I>(~. B1.:InK~~~. 11~}§++1~'!-E:-\~~~H-1!lt:S~~. 0. 1 ~~g[l!tl11o:r:~~". :InK{.il~~~~ • •~~R-4+l~fit ~ :f<:lnKIll\!{.+<~~4jIm.Q( ~fm. 0. , ~l!E~-H-~!!111 ~~~ 1 ~~ 11l!t§J:o:r:~~4jIm~.-H-~. 1 .~li!t.+<~iJ!R-§J:+<. i ~~§J:l!tlI1o:r:~R4jIm+<. ~l!E~-H-~~11+R~R+R~~~ ~. -1¢!~. 0. l!!!&~1ll\!{ r ~BJ~1IlI~.~ J 1 ~~Ol!t~li!t. ~lj2mK$~ 1l$;:;~ 1l$""~ IJl:{~~~-""m:: -\-111 \iI ~ ~f!#-1¢! 1 ~~11]l!t+ 1 o:r:lll!!:~~~~.-H-I$~ ~ ~.-N-1¢!~4jIm+<~-H-~~~~ $!1~ 1 ~~mjkI ~ .~~1(o:r:lll!!:-1¢!~\{l>(7;\g r ~~.- J (Le Monde) ~gg-H- ~ 1 ~}§*3U!!lli)ml~~_~ifJ1~mH~!t~~.~~~all(• • ~ 11~fB]HI,(~~all(i+111~}ili{I~. ~. r~~~~J.~~~o@~~~~~*~~~~.~~~~~~~-1¢!~~~~~o. 0. M~~.Il--~.oW~ 1 ~<§J:l!t§J:o:r:+ 11 rrr-8~• •.ijLljg[ ( Umberto Bossi) ~_1';::j 1 ~<~(l!t~~li!t r ~BJ~~~ J (Lombard League). 0. ( Lombard Autonomist League) ~. r =¥?~~~ J \. .~~. ~ ~.-1¢!~-PI-N~++1~Ill\!{~$1~1¢~BJ~~!t~~!f,lfHllIall(-P<~ ~ ~~~~i(ii\~~~~~~~ ~.~\iI~~~ ~ ~~~.~~~~~H. ,. 1 ~< -tJl!t~R.~.-H-~l$fm~-N~iliHq~~. ~ ~fm~-N<~<~~)m~ ~ -1¢!~. ~-H- ~ ~.$~fm~-N<~R~~)m~~~iJ!R-R ~ ~~all(.41I~~~li!t~~.-N. 0. 1 {r.;!~~.-N~ ~. :J-W~~'-\{l>(~~~"llt~~*~iii1fi)1m ~ .+<~:I!t~~~~.~iR~-$I-E~'M~\lI!!Il~~~~ +<~-H- ~ 3E~~~tIff++1. ( 1!!1&=R<~.) ~~~. ~-N 11~'K~~. ~ 1E~:!;!;H'~~fm~-N§J:~m:~. ~~tIff++1.-1¢!~.~-H-~~)mH&li!tfm~-N+'K~. 0. 0. 1 ~ all( 1 ~< -tJl!t~:IIll:l~+-~fm~~ ~. 0. 2-W~og+H.( Democratic Party of the Left-PDS) • •.L1 ~ ~.-N~~li!tl!l-&<~~~.+<~=R<~. 1 ~~ 1l!t11o:r:l11rrr ~ .+<~=R<~.h!:l'M]HI,(~li!t~~tIff++1. ~ 3E~]HI,(~.§-N~ ~ ~"llt~~• • •1{ ~ ~if1';::j~4jlmr£++1~Ml~ ,]HI,( ~.~~1f' ~~.4jIm'3tt~~~~"++1~l!!!&~ o@ 1 ~~11l!t~o:r:~rrr ~ ~~tIff++1.h!:l'M~li!tR~~4jIm• • ~~ 1 • ~~ 1 ~$~~~-< +1~1IlI~~~~~~ r ~=R<~. J (Rifondazione Comunista) ~. 1 ~~ 11l!t§J:o:r:~HI:"+<~-H- ~. ~ Le Monde, Ie 18 jilin 1994, p.6. .:!!!Tom Gallagher, "Regional Nationalism and Party System Change: Italy's Northern League,'" West European Politics, Vo1.16, No.4 (October 1993) , pp.616-621. ~. ~. "t. •. _~ ,. "'.. ~. .... ~_~. "'. ""'". .,. -. ",,,,. '". -~--~. ~. --. " - , , , . ,"",_. ~. ..-". -. ~. k. ". ..... ..,...". ~. "". ""'"' ". .. ~. _. ~(;HanfranC9""P~~,?, "~tic Renewal, and Much More: From the PCI to the PDG," West European Politics, Vo1.16, No.1 (January 1.. -. ~. "". ~.

(8) ,. T. a. 7tHw. Z )I f~ ::k 1m ., :;p. ~J. ~$tl.'l' r~ JJ:, • fr It ~ Idl. ~. ~. IftjlJ~~~. at;.. •. *-. :fIJ. iftllfRJlit.. II. ~ft~~ ~o • •. ~. ~. ,. 1t. -gga*±nl .iE:;p. fffJ z • (2) tE A EE •• •. !il'~7t1t~ ~~nX: 51! ~ lk (=.) ~ ~ it ~ ]I! Idl.fLg.~1I~tEff+~ n~~~ *fL~::k~~.~li=:3D'*r.::k. .1m~~m3D'~.Jli.~~~ ~ ~~§.$EE.~li~~U.::k.~. ~~'EE~~~'~.~-*'.~~ ~A§. tE. ~ llli. ••. ~. ••. I g(.::k. 0. ~flm~.w~o4. J& :it 1it ff&. I EE. ~. ~. z:t1JI~~. ~. .II~~ ~m~znl.~ .5I!fLtE ::k1tIUI~.a.tl.~~.~.ttfL~. 1im:-~1UI. ~. ~3D.W~z.~. ritVIIR.ffl>. Vy. ffl>~. ~~fL*l1lJ *¥~fLtt~. -. ~U. ~::k.~'7tA1t.nX:'::k~.~Im~. .~~~-~~.. is{ ~~~tE~ m±:.-~tlll~o=tlL . . . . Jt.~~~Jli • • g; ~A ' 8 z tE. ' A R ~ , .LIt iE,~1t' fl • gg f!J. iI ~ f5I f!~=f,Y{~ :rlr ~ ~ IlJ ~ Idl. ~ Jt lk ;r a tE YI g , II iffl ~..x. '1I~W*3DY5§' lI7t'l'3ft:iEE1t:l: ~R~W. , n ~ nX:~B.~ • • EE-tlLZn~~~~~ ~~Idl.~ AZEE~~'W.fLm+LU~.1I~ .II§A ~ .~W-~~*~~fL·-ldl.t~·~~ 0. ~1tmro. f{3D~~-;. §$.iI. ~~V'. *i*nl ~Jlt~fL JYiltffL ~WtI£1m. yV'C*~. ""'A1I.=:. -±:~A fLtt'~. fL f§lJ ~ Ii?J = ftjIJ fr~ 1t ~AIlJ::k. 0. ~ro ~. ::k.~.m*~~=::k-lk -~~. ~.~d~~.~~~ -aMM3DJt. J~ 'l'~:I;tll~JV'rt.fL.~ff. nAm1t.nl~tI:lA ~A~' .ati • • • iliff~::ktJlt.. 1m7t~til~~·. ~z~nX:M~. .Jli.~Vom.=fLfL~t ofL::k~nl ~ ~J J& ~. 3DA'~ .~~rm. '.\ljR:1{. ~'--z'. f£l.:;IlJjiffl. ~o. • t&Jli::k tE W IL' ~J. A '"d. Idl..g d@ * ~ 1L IJ\. 1t3D:~. ¥h.. ~~. • ~ i i ' • '1 'mf. 11 V£. • •. 1~ ~. q:t$. .. ffGNi. tlL*. '*. fL, fLl*. •. ~. g. ~S".J3.. ~:=:~~. ~§~Idl.. ~ ~ :II! • '"d. 0. _. ~P'~±:. j[;. tlL'"dlll51n '::::llt.. ~. ~. B. ~. 11.. .~~~. fLo.L~. ~+~~p~1I.:I;zfL--:l:u. flitliildl.3D +~~z 1m ftjIJ Idl. ~. 1\iIlir'. ••. fffJ-.::k J9f ::k ~J iE Jlt ~J ~. a.~AfLmA 0 li =: = 1it ~. m. ~~Jt. '-~~~. nX:. A. ~. .A~IIfRA .~IJ1Io~. 11. ,. 3D. .-~fdE~. ~. At~.LIt~ .~£'iI. • £. fi. T :t: Q. fL fL 1m ~ A ~. =fL3Dt&5I! ;mA$51n 0. jmJt7t §' A jU :l: ~ z ~ fL ¥1J lUI 1~ li • 8'a-::k S *± 7t ~ ~J P;' it z Idl. ~ g .+*~ .1m':I; ~tiJli.*f P' J[. =: ::k ~ S til lk ~J V. •. '""'. 0. • • fr. {Jj~jIJ t&,~. •• ~ W- • •. fl~~. z~.. .a~. n 7t IIfR. mz' ~+-. ~fLfL. itJlifL ,A= :I;~~ ti3D+. J!M=. ~'A. ~Nli. - It E ~ nX: ~. e: _ •. ::::.1J. (O::k 3D. 0 ~J • §-.~ ~=,. S::k. '-':I; • tE'..

(9) 0. o~tf~ ~ ~m:~~.+<~~.*~:&i$!:~*. ~. 0. 1~. :IIDII~!fl~*,.;ij'e ( polarized pluralist system ) *~~.. 1 ~~.;ij'e:&i~~.. ( Giovanni Sartori ). grl:!l-~1IJ1:!$J+ 1 ~~.W"-H-1IJ1:!~~) ~~.H*:&i~ ~ W*,.$:&i~.;ij'e~jL ~ ~1IJ1:! 1 ~~.:&i~.~.\iI~}m~N 1\+ l-8 ~ ~MmW.+<~:lfii~.mKK1~llR++1.:&i~.~cr(~~gr~}m~jj ~ ~*K1~llR+H.}m~N+~jj<:&i~.lEi'~mK~~£:&i ~~M.}m~Nl-8jj~:&i~.~~:&i.~ • .\iI~~:lfii~.o 1 ~~.~WI\I.-H-*.~*".:&i~~ ~ EBI~-m.w~~.~i1l:&il1].~~~4aM·~ '" 1\I~~i1l '" ~*f~~i1l111.Nlll!::&i~~mKMl~~II¢1IJ1:!~$m+<:&i~B!IK ~ **~4a~~mWl«I~:\t.~~~~~_ -llti~HH1. M+H~:&i.jjmW ~ EBI_.+<~1IJ1:!. <,-.. D.41Ifi11f:.sIllt~IIIM--m~~1IJ1:!. tf~ ~ ~~~. ~o. 0. 8*.III:!I!~gfi1.~1!. +<*:&i~.;ij'e~. 0. 0. 1 +111~~~~. -H-1ll[~~cr(1IJ1:!gr+1(~. 1 ~~grl:!l-l1]~+<~:&i$!:~*_~:&i. ~ 1 ~f§:4-(l '" .w~~.~4a~~:&i~~~~~*l<\ii ~. EBI~ ~ ~tl:i~~:&i~~~~\ii~1IJ1:!~lltf4ait{mj~*$l. ~'*~~~. 0. 11~f§:~. f§:.+<*~M.11.l1lB!1!~~~~IH;l • •~~:&i~~ ~ l\~f§:.+<**f~~i1l¥lmW~£• .pJ~.m:;ij'e:&i~rm< ~ ~Wl~.+<~~~ 1HE*f~~. lHfll..-Y ~. i'i!!JI!l.~:&i*~~~mK-};tgI\l~l-8~~*,.1I£!fl~:&i~.;ij'e~1IJ1:!~~N~. .~i,*¥l\ii~£4-(l.w~~:&i~~( W!llf.~-H-.w~1IJ1:!111}m1(+1(~~~~ 4-(l~1IJ1:!111m 0. ~ ~.~~11.l)m.(~. 0. ~::t: ~ <-=1~+<*,IlI(.~?it~.w~~.~K ~ tfla1~1:::1.\;ii. ~ )m.(WJJtl.-H-~B!IK.*KWlN~~~~.+<~. 1 ~~grl:!l-111~:&iI\l.+<~~.+<*:&i~.~~iI=~ 1 ~~:&i~~ ° ~~~~*"~~N~:&i~llR • .w 1 .I<\Nlll!:~_.w~. ~~). •. ~l+<.~~~~.MlN • • D.~~.+<*~ • • ~~~1lB!1!+<:&i~.mWl«I.~~~~~~~tf~~~.~• • :&i~~~~. 1 *,:&i_. o ©. ~-m0l~~IlI(tl:i <-=1I1I~t.t;:~4,g:~*~;ij'etH~~{I1Il:&i ~.Ft;.:lSs~~N1Jh~!liI~ ~ ~ ~ lEi'~~~ tf$m~~~*I\1~*i :&i~\$*. ~ ~~ ~~. Systems (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1976) , pp.131-138..

(10)