Thermophysical
properties
of
room
temperature
ionic
liquids
with
oligomeric
formate
and
hydrogen
sulfate
Tzi-Yi
Wu
a,b,
I.-Wen
Sun
a,
Ming-Wei
Lin
a,
Bor-Kuan
Chen
b,
Chung-Wen
Kuo
c,
H.
Paul
Wang
d,
Yu-Yuan
Chen
a,
Shyh-Gang
Su
a,*
a
DepartmentofChemistry,NationalChengKungUniversity,Tainan701,Taiwan
b
DepartmentofMaterialsEngineering,KunShanUniversity,Tainan710,Taiwan
c
DepartmentofChemicalandMaterialsEngineering,NationalKaohsiungUniversityofAppliedSciences,Kaohsiung807,Taiwan
dDepartmentofEnvironmentalEngineering,NationalChengKungUniversity,Tainan701,Taiwan
1.
Introduction
Reducing
the
amount
of
volatile
organic
compounds
in
chemical
and
industrial
processes
is
challenging.
Room-tempera-ture
ionic
liquids
(RTILs)
have
been
used
as
solvents
in
many
academic
and
industrial
research
areas
due
to
their
unique
properties,
such
as
a
wide
liquid
range,
negligible
vapor
pressure,
good
thermal
stability,
excellent
solvent
power
for
organic,
inorganic,
and
polymeric
compounds,
suitable
viscosity,
and
non-flammability
[1]
.
Owing
to
their
nonvolatile
nature
and
favorable
solvation
properties,
RTILs
have
been
suggested
as
green
and
benign
replacements
for
traditional
volatile
organic
solvents,
and
are
expected
by
both
industrial
and
scientific
communities
to
have
a
broad
range
of
applications,
including
as
electrolytes
in
lithium
or
lithium-ion
batteries
[2,3]
,
solar
cells
[4–7]
,
electrode-position
[8–10]
,
reaction
media
in
nanoscience
[11,12]
,
electro-analysis
[13]
,
and
physical
chemistry
[14–28]
.
ILs
can
be
tuned
by
varying
the
combination
of
cations
and
anions
[29]
.
When
designing
industrial
processes
and
products
that
involve
ILs,
it
is
necessary
to
determine
their
thermophysical
properties
including
viscosity,
density,
and
conductivity.
A
thermophysical
study
of
compounds
enables
an
understanding
of
their
properties
that
depend
on
fundamental
factors
such
as
ionic
structure
and
intermolecular
interactions.
Such
information
allows
the
design
of
RTILs
with
the
desired
properties.
The
application
of
RTILs
is
limited
by
their
relatively
high
viscosity.
Therefore,
if
the
relationships
between
the
viscosity
and
the
molecular
structure
of
RTILs
are
quantitatively
determined,
the
design
of
low-viscosity
RTILs
will
become
possible.
ILs
can
be
divided
into
two
distinct
groups:
aprotic
ILs
and
protic
ILs.
Protic
ionic
liquids
(PILs)
have
received
increasing
attention
as
a
protic
solvent.
They
are
easily
produced
via
the
combination
of
a
Brønsted
acid
and
a
Brønsted
base
[30]
.
As
the
ions
of
PILs
can
both
accept
and
donate
protons,
PILs
have
characteristics
of
an
amphoteric
solvent.
PILs
are
expected
to
be
candidates
for
fuel
cell
electrolytes
due
to
their
excess
of
electrochemically
available
protons
[31]
.
A
number
of
studies
have
shown
that
the
formation
of
dimeric
anions
is
possible
in
the
IL
system
and
that
they
may
be
weaker
bases
than
monomeric
anions
due
to
solvation
by
an
additional
acid
molecule.
For
example,
the
HF
2anion
has
been
extensively
studied
by
Hagiwara
et
al.
[32]
.
The
formation
of
dimeric
anions
occurs
strongly
at
a
2:1
composition,
which
exhibits
the
highest
conductivity
and
which
is
thought
to
be
of
potential
use
in
fuel
cell
applications.
In
the
present
study,
we
report
two
series
of
ionic
liquids
that
use
pyrrolidinium
as
cations,
and
oligomeric
formate
JournaloftheTaiwanInstituteofChemicalEngineers43(2012)58–66
ARTICLE INFO
Articlehistory:
Received26February2011 Receivedinrevisedform9May2011 Accepted5June2011
Availableonline4August2011
Keywords: Ionicliquid Thermophysicalproperties Density Viscosity Conductivity Waldenrule ABSTRACT
Brønstedacidroomtemperatureionicliquids(RTILs)comprisedofoligomericformate(orhydrogen sulfate)anionsandpyrrolidinium-basedcationsareprepared.Itisfoundthationidentitygreatlyaffects thethermophysicalproperties.AllRTILsstudiedhereareliquidandhaveahighionicconductivity(upto 55.4mS/cm)and alowviscosity (downto 6.42mPas) atroom temperature. Theincorporation of oligomericanionsinILssignificantlyincreasesthedensityandconductivity,anddecreasestheviscosity. Thecorrelationbetweenionic conductivityandviscosity isbased ontheclassicalWalden rule; a relativelylargedeviation oftheplotsfromtheidealWaldenlineisobservedforformate-basedILs synthesizedusingequimolaramountsofacidandbase,whereasthedeviationdecreasessignificantly whentheformate-basedILscontainoligomericanions.TheStokes–EinsteinplotofDT1vs.
h
1forferrocenceinILsshowsthathydrodynamicradiusofdiffusingspeciesisindependentoftemperature. ß2011TaiwanInstituteofChemicalEngineers.PublishedbyElsevierB.V.Allrightsreserved.
*Correspondingauthor.Tel.:+88662757575x65330. E-mailaddress:z7902010@email.ncku.edu.tw(S.-G.Su).
Contents
lists
available
at
ScienceDirect
Journal
of
the
Taiwan
Institute
of
Chemical
Engineers
j o u
r
n a l
h
o
m e p
a g e :
w
w w . e l s
e v i e r
. c o
m / l o
c
a t e / j t i c
e
1876-1070/$–seefrontmatterß2011TaiwanInstituteofChemicalEngineers.PublishedbyElsevierB.V.Allrightsreserved.
and
hydrogen
sulfate
as
anions.
Their
thermophysical
properties,
such
as
viscosity,
density,
conductivity,
and
diffusion
coefficient
of
ferrocene,
are
evaluated
and
studied
in
detail.
The
conductivity
and
viscosity
data
are
plotted
under
Walden’s
rule,
where
ion
association
plays
a
major
role.
It
is
expected
that
the
incorporation
of
oligomeric
formate
(hydrogen
sulfate)
containing
ILs
into
the
ionic
liquid
family
may
facilitate
the
use
of
ionic
liquids
and
open
up
a
new
field
of
ionic
liquid
chemistry.
2.
Experimental
2.1.
Materials
and
measurement
All
starting
materials
were
purchased
from
Aldrich,
Alfa
Aesar,
TCI,
or
Acros
and
used
as
received.
Solvents
were
freshly
distilled
prior
to
use.
The
conductivity
(
s
)
of
the
ILs
was
systematically
measured
with
a
conductivity
meter
(LF
340)
and
a
standard
conductivity
cell
(TetraCon
325,
Wissenschaftlich-Technische
Werksta¨tten
GmbH,
Germany).
The
cell
constant
was
determined
by
calibration
after
each
sample
measurement
using
an
aqueous
0.01
M
KCl
solution.
The
densities
of
the
ILs
were
measured
gravimetrically
with
a
1
ml
volumetric
flask.
Values
for
the
densities
are
given
as
0.0001
g/ml.
The
dynamic
viscosities
(
h
)
of
the
ILs
were
measured
using
a
calibrated
modified
Ostwald
viscometer
(Cannon-Fenske
glass
capillary
viscometers,
CFRU,
9721-A50)
with
inner
diameters
of
1.2
2%
mm.
The
viscometer
was
placed
in
a
thermostatic
water
bath
(TV-4000,
TAMSON)
whose
temperature
was
regulated
to
within
0.01
K.
The
flow
time
was
measured
using
a
stop
watch
with
a
time
resolution
of
0.01
s.
For
each
IL,
the
experimental
viscosity
was
obtained
by
averaging
three
to
five
flow
time
measurements.
The
melting
point
of
each
IL
was
analyzed
using
a
differential
scanning
calorimeter
(DSC,
Perkin–Elmer
Pyris
1)
in
the
temperature
range
of
140
8C
to
a
predetermined
temperature.
The
sample
was
sealed
in
an
aluminum
pan,
and
then
heated
at
a
scan
rate
of
10
8C/min
under
a
flow
of
nitrogen.
The
thermal
data
were
collected
during
heating
in
the
second
heating–cooling
scan.
The
thermal
stabilities
were
measured
with
thermogravimetric
analysis
(TGA)
(Perkin–Elmer,
7
series
thermal
analysis
system).
The
sample
was
heated
at
10
8C/min
from
room
temperature
to
800
8C
under
nitrogen.
The
water
content
of
the
dried
ILs
was
measured
with
a
moisture
titrator
(Metrohm
73KF
coulometer)
using
the
Karl–Fischer
method;
the
content
was
less
than
300
ppm.
The
cyclic
voltammetry
was
performed
using
an
electrochemical
workstation
(CH
instruments
Inc.,
CHI,
model
750A).
The
working
electrode
was
a
glassy
carbon
electrode,
the
counter
electrode
was
a
Pt
wire,
and
the
quasi-reference
electrode
was
a
Pt
wire.
All
electrochemical
experiments
were
performed
under
a
dry
argon
atmosphere
to
remove
oxygen
and
air
humidity.
2.2.
Synthetic
procedure
of
cyclic
amine-based
Brønsted
acid
ionic
liquids
Amine
compounds
were
placed
in
a
three-necked
glass
flask
equipped
with
a
reflux
condenser
and
a
dropping
funnel.
The
flask
was
mounted
in
an
ice
bath.
Formic
acid
was
added
dropwise
to
the
flask
under
stirring
with
a
magnetic
bar
at
room
temperature
(25
3
8C).
Stirring
was
continued
for
24
h
at
ambient
temperature
in
order
to
obtain
a
final
viscous
liquid.
The
produced
ILs
were
washed
repeatedly
with
diethyl
ether
to
remove
unreacted
materials.
The
same
general
process
was
used
for
the
synthesis
of
all
ILs.
The
product
was
then
dried
at
80
8C
for
12
h
in
a
vacuum
oven
(0.5
mmHg)
containing
phosphorus
pentoxide
(P
2O
5)
to
remove
any
excess
water.
The
synthetic
reactions
were
carried
out
without
any
solvent.
The
structure
of
each
protic
IL
was
identified
using
nuclear
magnetic
resonance
(NMR)
spectroscopy.
The
ionic
liquid
samples
were
kept
sealed
in
vials
using
thick
layers
of
paraffin
and
stored
in
an
argon
atmosphere
glovebox
(VAC,
O
2<
1
ppm,
H
2O
<
1
ppm)
before
use.
2.2.1.
[MePyr][HCOO]
Feed
ratio
of
N-methylpyrrolidine:formic
acid
=
1:1.
Yield:
76%.
1H
NMR
(400
MHz,
DMSO-d
6,
ppm):
9.92
(br,
1H,
N–H),
8.30
(s,
1H,
HCOO–),
3.08
(m,
4H,
N–CH
2–),
2.67
(s,
3H,
N–CH
3),
1.90–1.85
(m,
4H,
N–CH
2–CH
2).
1H
NMR
(400
MHz,
D
2O,
ppm):
8.18
(s,
1H,
HCOO–),
3.47–3.31
(t,
2H,
N–CH
2–CH
2),
2.88–2.80
(t,
2H,
N–CH
2–
CH
2),
2.71
(s,
3H,
N–CH
3),
1.95–1.79
(m,
4H,
N–CH
2–CH
2).
2.2.2.
[MePyr][2HCOO]
Feed
ratio
of
N-methylpyrrolidine:formic
acid
=
1:2.
Yield:
72%.
1H
NMR
(400
MHz,
D
2
O,
ppm):
8.21
(s,
1H,
HCOO–),
3.50
(t,
2H,
N–
CH
2–CH
2),
2.91
(t,
2H,
N–CH
2–CH
2),
2.77
(s,
3H,
N–CH
3),
2.04–1.93
(m,
2H,
N–CH
2–CH
2),
1.91–1.83
(m,
4H,
N–CH
2–CH
2).
2.2.3.
[MePyr][4HCOO]
Feed
ratio
of
N-methylpyrrolidine:formic
acid
=
1:4.
Yield:
75%.
1H
NMR
(400
MHz,
D
2
O,
ppm):
8.19
(s,
1H,
HCOO–),
3.50
(t,
2H,
N–
CH
2–),
2.91
(t,
2H,
N–CH
2–),
2.78
(s,
3H,
N–CH
3),
2.05–2.00
(m,
2H,
N–CH
2–CH
2),
1.91–1.85
(m,
4H,
N–CH
2–CH
2).
2.2.4.
[MePyr][HSO
4]
Feed
ratio
of
N-methylpyrrolidine:sulfuric
acid
=
1:1.
Yield:
92%.
1H
NMR
(400
MHz,
DMSO-d
6,
ppm):
7.51
(br,
1H,
N–H),
3.16
(m,
4H,
N–CH
2–),
2.73
(s,
3H,
N–CH
3),
1.86
(m,
4H,
N–CH
2–CH
2).
1H
NMR
(400
MHz,
D
2O,
ppm):
8.68
(br,
1H,
N–H),
3.36
(t,
2H,
N–CH
2–
CH
2),
2.76
(t,
2H,
N–CH
2–CH
2),
2.62
(s,
3H,
N–CH
3),
1.85–1.73
(m,
4H,
N–CH
2–CH
2).
2.2.5.
[MePyr][2HSO
4]
Feed
ratio
of
N-methylpyrrolidine:sulfuric
acid
=
1:2.
Yield:
87%.
1H
NMR
(400
MHz,
D
2O,
ppm):
3.38
(t,
2H,
N–CH
2–CH
2),
2.79
(t,
2H,
N–CH
2–CH
2),
2.66
(s,
3H,
N–CH
3),
1.89
(m,
2H,
N–CH
2–CH
2–
),
1.77–1.76
(m,
3H,
N–CH
2–CH
2–
and
HSO
4).
2.2.6.
[MePyr][4HSO
4]
Feed
ratio
of
N-methylpyrrolidine:sulfuric
acid
=
1:4.
Yield:
83%.
1H
NMR
(400
MHz,
D
2O,
ppm):
3.33
(t,
2H,
N–CH
2–CH
2),
2.73
(t,
2H,
N–CH
2–CH
2),
2.60
(s,
3H,
N–CH
3),
1.83
(m,
2H,
N–CH
2–CH
2–
),
1.73–1.68
(m,
3H,
N–CH
2–CH
2–
and
HSO
4).
O
H
O
H
O
H
O
O
H
O
H
O
H
O
H
O
H
O
N
H
3C
H
N
H
3C
H
(a)
(b)
Fig.1.Possibleformationof(a)dimericand(b)higher-orderoligomericformicacid. T.-Y.Wuetal./JournaloftheTaiwanInstituteofChemicalEngineers43(2012)58–66 59
3.7.
Stokes–Einstein
relationship
The
classical
Stokes–Einstein
equation
[53]
relates
the
viscosity
of
an
incompressible
medium
to
the
diffusion
coefficient,
D,
of
a
spherical
particle
with
a
hydrodynamic
radius,
a
,
moving
through
the
medium
D
¼
kBT
6
pha
(9)
where
k
Bis
the
Boltzmann
constant,
T
is
the
temperature,
and
h
is
the
viscosity
of
the
solution.
The
Stokes–Einstein
product,
D
h
/T,
where
D
is
derived
from
electrochemical
mass
transport
data,
is
often
used
to
make
temperature-independent
comparisons
of
the
relative
value
of
a
.
Fig.
9
shows
a
graph
of
DT
1vs.
h
1resulting
from
experiments
conducted
in
[MePyr][HCOO]
at
temperatures
ranging
from
303
to
333
K.
The
results
clearly
demonstrate
the
applicability
of
the
relationship
between
D
and
h
1for
the
diffusion
of
ferrocenium
in
[MePyr][HCOO],
and
they
indicate
that
a
is
independent
of
the
viscosity
of
the
IL
and
temperature.
4.
Conclusions
Brønsted
acid
ionic
liquids
containing
oligomeric
formate
and
hydrogen
sulfate
anions
were
synthesized.
The
density,
viscosity,
ionic
conductivity,
and
diffusion
coefficient
of
ferrocene
in
the
ionic
liquids
were
characterized
as
a
function
of
temperature
over
the
range
from
303
to
353
K.
Brønsted
acid
ILs
contains
oligomeric
anions
have
lower
viscosity,
higher
density,
and
higher
conductiv-ity
compared
to
those
of
ILs
prepared
using
equimolar
amounts
of
acid
and
base.
The
temperature-dependent
electrolyte
viscosity
is
correlated
with
molar
conductivity
via
an
empirical
Walden’s
rule.
The
a
values
of
ILs
calculated
from
the
slopes
of
the
Walden
plots
were
compared
to
those
calculated
from
the
ratio
of
activation
energies
for
viscosity
and
molar
conductivity
(E
a,L/E
a,h).
The
diffusion
coefficients
of
ferrocene
in
ILs
were
calculated
from
the
cyclic
voltammetry.
The
hydrodynamic
radius
of
the
diffusing
species
calculated
from
the
diffusion
coefficients
using
the
traditional
Stokes–Einstein
equation
was
found
to
be
independent
of
the
viscosity
of
the
IL
and
temperature.
Acknowledgements
The
authors
would
like
to
thank
the
National
Science
Council
of
the
Republic
of
China
for
financially
supporting
this
project.
The
authors
also
gratefully
acknowledge
the
contributions
of
Chao-anx
Lai,
Department
of
chemistry,
National
Cheng
Kung
University,
for
helping
with
the
laboratory
work.
References
[1]RogersRD,SeddonKR.Ionicliquids:industrialapplicationsforgreen chemis-try.Washington,DC:AmericanChemicalSociety;2003.
[2]LewandowskiA,S´widerska-MocekA,AcznikI.Synthesisandcharacterization ofhighlystableopticallypassiveCeO2–ZrO2counterelectrode.Electrochim
Acta2010;55:1990.
[3]SunXG,DaiS.Electrochemicalinvestigationsofionicliquidswithvinylene carbonateforapplicationsinrechargeablelithiumionbatteries.Electrochim Acta2010;55:4618.
[4]WuTY,TsaoMH,ChenFL,SuS-G,ChangCW,WangHP,etal.Synthesisand characterizationoforganicdyescontainingvariousdonorsandacceptors.IntJ MolSci2010;11:329.
[5]TsaoMH,WuTY,WangHP,SunIW,SuSG,LinYC,etal.Anefficientmetalfree sensitizerfordye-sensitizedsolarcells.MaterLett2011;65:583.
[6]WuTY,TsaoMH,ChenFL,SuS-G,ChangCW,WangHP,etal.Synthesisand characterizationofthreeorganicdyeswithvariousdonorsandrhodaninering acceptorforuseindye-sensitizedsolarcells.JIranChemSoc2010;7:707. [7]WuTY,TsaoMH,SuSG,WangHP,LinYC,ChenFL,etal.Synthesis,
characteri-zationandphotovoltaicpropertiesofdi-anchoringorganicdyes.JBrazChem Soc2011;22:780.
[8]ChenPY,DengMJ,ZhuangDX.Electrochemicalcodepositionofcopperand manganesefromroom-temperatureN-butyl-N-methylpyrrolidinium bis(tri-fluoromethylsulfonyl)imideionicliquid.ElectrochimActa2009;54:6935. [9]TsaiMC,ZhuangDX,ChenPY.Electrodepositionofmacroporoussilverfilms
from ionic liquids and assessment of thesefilms in the electrocatalytic reductionofnitrate.ElectrochimActa2010;55:1019.
[10]ElAbedinSZ,GiridharP,SchwabP,EndresF.Electrodepositionof nanocrystal-linealuminiumfromachloroaluminateionicliquid.ElectrochemCommun 2010;12:1084.
[11]YangJM,GouSP,SunIW.Single-steplarge-scaleandtemplate-free electro-chemicalgrowthofNi–Znalloyfilamentarraysfromazincchloridebased ionicliquid.ChemCommun2010;46:2686.
[12]HsiehYT,LeongTI,HuangCC,YehCS,SunIW.Directtemplate-free electro-chemicalgrowthofhexagonalCuSntubesfromanionicliquid.Chem Com-mum2010;46:484.
[13]BarnesEO,O’MahonyAM,AldousL,HardacreC,ComptonRG.The electro-chemical oxidationof catecholand dopamineonplatinumin 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazoliumbis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide ([C2mim][NTf2]) and
1-butyl-3-methylimidazoliumtetrafluoroborate([C4mim][BF4]):Adsorption
effectsinionicliquidvoltammetry.JElectroanalChem2010;646:11. [14]LeBideauJ,ViauL,ViouxA.Ionogels,ionicliquidbasedhybridmaterials.Chem
SocRev2011;40:907.
[15]XieZL,TaubertA.Thermomorphicbehavioroftheionicliquids[C4mim][FeCl4]
and[C12mim][FeCl4].ChemPhysChem2011;12:364.
[16]Lazzu´sJA.
r
–T–Ppredictionforionicliquidsusingneuralnetworks.JTaiwan InstChemEngrs2009;40:213.[17]WuTY,WangHC,SuS-G,GungST,LinMW,LinCB.Characterizationofionic conductivity,viscosity,density,andself-diffusioncoefficientforbinary mix-turesofpolyethyleneglycol(orpolyethyleneimine)organicsolventwithroom temperature ionic liquidBMIBF4 (or BMIPF6). JTaiwan Inst ChemEngrs
2010;41:315.
[18]TienCP,TengH.Efficientiontransportinactivatedcarboncapacitors assem-bledwithgelledpolymerelectrolytesbasedonpoly(ethyleneoxide)cured withpoly(propyleneoxide)diamines.JTaiwanInstChemEngrs2009;40:452. [19]WuTY,SuSG,GungST,LinMW,LinYC,LaiCA,etal.Ionicliquidscontainingan alkylsulfategroupaspotentialelectrolytes.ElectrochimActa2010;55:4475. [20]SorianoAN,DomaBT,LiMH.Carbondioxidesolubilityinsomeionicliquidsat
moderatepressures.JTaiwanInstChemEngrs2009;40:387.
[21]SorianoAN,AgapitoAM,Lagumbay LJLI,CaparangaAR,LiMH.Asimple approachtopredictmolarheatcapacityofionicliquidsusinggroup-additivity method.JTaiwanInstChemEngrs2010;41:307.
[22]WuTY,WangHC,SuSG,GungST,LinMW,LinCB.Aggregationinfluenceof polyethyleneglycolorganicsolventswithionicliquidsBMIBF4andBMIPF6.J
ChinChemSoc2010;57:44.
[23]SorianoAN,DomaBT,LiMH.Densityandrefractiveindexmeasurementsof 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium-basedionicliquids.JTaiwanInstChemEngrs 2010;41:115.
[24]SorianoAN,AgapitoAM, LagumbayLJLI, CaparangaAR,LiMH.Diffusion coefficientsofaqueousionicliquidsolutionsatinfinitedilutiondetermined from electrolytic conductivity measurements. J Taiwan Inst Chem Engrs 2011;42:258.
[25]WongC-L,SorianoAN,LiMH.Infinitedilutiondiffusioncoefficientsof [Bmim]-basedionicliquidsinwateranditsmolarconductivities.JTaiwanInstChem Engrs2009;40:77.
[26]WuTY,SuSG,WangHP,LinYC,GungST,LinMW,etal.Electrochemicalstudies andselfdiffusioncoefficientsincyclicammoniumbasedionicliquidswith allylsubstituents.ElectrochimActa2011;56:3209.
[27]Wang M-H, SorianoAN, Caparanga AR, Li MH. Binarymutual diffusion coefficientofaqueoussolutionsofpropyleneglycolanddipropyleneglycol. JTaiwanInstChemEngrs2010;41:279.
η
-1/ cP
-1 0.20 0.15 0.10 0.05 0.0010
10D T
-1 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140Fig.9.Stokes–EinsteinplotofDT1
vs.1/viscosity(
h
1)forFcin[MePyr][HCOO].
[28]Yu Y-H,SorianoAN,Li MH.Heatcapacityandelectrical conductivityof aqueousmixturesof[Bmim][BF4]and[Bmim][PF6].JTaiwanInstChemEngrs
2009;40:205.
[29]WuTY,SuSG,WangHP,SunIW.Glycine-basedionicliquidsaspotential electrolyteforelectrochemicalstudiesoforganometallicandorganicredox couples.ElectrochemCommun2011;13:237.
[30]AngellCA,ByrneN,BelieresJP.Paralleldevelopmentsinaproticandprotic ionic liquids: physical chemistry and applications. Acc Chem Res 2007;40:1228.
[31]Nakamoto H,WatanabeM.Bronstedacid–base ionicliquidsfor fuelcell electrolytes.ChemCommun2007;24:2539.
[32]HagiwaraR,NakamoriY,MatsumotoK,ItoY.Theeffectoftheanionfractionon thephysicochemicalpropertiesofEMIm(HF)nF(n=1.0–2.6).JPhysChemB
2005;109:5445.
[33]JohanssonKM,IzgorodinaEI,ForsythM,MacFarlaneDR,SeddonKR.Protic ionicliquidsbasedonthedimericandoligomericanions:[(AcO)xHx1].Phys
ChemChemPhys2008;10:2972.
[34]CasesAM,MariglianoACG,BonattiCM,So´limoHN.Density,viscosity,and refractiveindexofformamide,threecarboxylicacids,andformamide+ car-boxylicacidbinarymixtures.JChemEngData2001;46:712.
[35]Wasserscheid P,WeltonT,editors.Ionic liquidsinsynthesis. Weinheim: Wiley-VCH;2008.
[36]FangS,YangL,WangJ,LiM,TachibanaK,KamijimaK.Ionicliquidsbasedon functionalizedguanidiniumcationsandTFSIanionaspotentialelectrolytes. ElectrochimActa2009;54:4269.
[37]WuTY,SuSG,GungST,LinMW,LinYC,Ou-YangWC,etal.Synthesisand characterizationofproticionicliquidscontainingcyclicaminecationsand tetrafluoroborateanion.JIranChemSoc2011;8:149.
[38]MokhtaraniB,SharifiA,MortahebHR,MirzaeiM,MafiM,SadeghianF. Densityandviscosityof1-butyl-3-methylimidazoliumnitratewithethanol, 1-propanol, or 1-butanol at several temperatures. J Chem Thermodyn 2009;41:1432.
[39]Ste˛pniakI, AndrzejewskaE.Highlyconductive ionicliquidbasedternary polymerelectrolytesobtainedbyinsituphotopolymerisation.Electrochim Acta2009;54:5660.
[40]NakamotoH,NodaA,HayamizuK,HayashiS,HamaguchiH,WatanabeM. Proton-conductingpropertiesofaBrønstedacid–baseionicliquidandionic
meltsconsistingofbis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imideandbenzimidazolefor fuelcellelectrolytes.JPhysChemC2007;111:1541.
[41]VideaM,AngellCA.Glassformation,ionicconductivity,andconductivity/ viscositydecoupling,inLiAlCl4+LiClO4andLiAlCl4+LiAlCl3imidesolutions.J
PhysChemB1999;103:4185.
[42]ZhuQ,SongY,ZhuX,WangX.Ionicliquid-basedelectrolytesforcapacitor applications.JElectroanalChem2007;601:229.
[43]OhnoH,YoshizawaM.Ionconductivecharacteristicsofionicliquidsprepared byneutralizationofalkylimidazoles.SolidStateIonics2002;154–155:303. [44]Mayrand-ProvencherL,RochefortD.Originandeffectofimpuritiesinprotic
ionicliquidsbasedon2-methylpyridineandtrifluoroaceticacidfor applica-tionsinelectrochemistry.ElectrochimActa2009;54:7422.
[45]AppetecchiGB,MontaninoM,ZaneD,CarewskaM,AlessandriniF,PasseriniS. Effectofthealkylgrouponthesynthesisandtheelectrochemicalpropertiesof N-alkyl-N-methyl-pyrrolidinium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide ionic liquids.ElectrochimActa2009;54:1325.
[46]ChangJK,LeeMT,TsaiWT,DengMJ,ChengHF,SunIW.Pseudocapacitive mechanismofmanganeseoxidein1-ethyl-3-methylimidazoliumthiocyanate ionicliquidelectrolytestudiedusingX-rayphotoelectronspectroscopy. Lang-muir2009;25:11955.
[47]XuW,AngellCA.Solvent-freeelectrolyteswithaqueoussolution-like con-ductivities.Science2003;302:422.
[48]NittaK,NohiraT,HagiwaraR,MajimaM,InazawaS.Physicochemical proper-tiesofZnCl2–NaCl–KCleutecticmelt.ElectrochimActa2009;54:4898.
[49]AnoutiM,Caillon-CaravanierM,DridiY,GalianoH,LemordantD.Synthesis andcharacterizationofnewpyrrolidiniumbasedproticionicliquids.Good andsuperionicliquids.JPhysChemB2008;112:13335.
[50]FraserKJ,IzgorodinaEI,ForsythM,ScottJL,MacFarlaneDR.Liquids interme-diatebetween‘‘molecular’’and‘‘ionic’’liquids:Liquidionpairs?Chem Com-mun2007;3817.
[51]MacFarlaneDR,ForsythM,IzgorodinEI,AbbottAP,AnnataG,FraserK.Onthe conceptofionicityinionicliquids.PhysChemChemPhys2009;11:4962. [52]BardAJ,FaulknerLR.Electrochemicalmethods—fundamentalsand
applica-tions.NewYork:Wiley;1980.
[53]WuTY,SunIW,GungST,LinMW,ChenBK,WangHP,etal.Effectsofcations andanionsontransportpropertiesintetrafluoroborate-basedionicliquids.J TaiwanInstChemEng2011;42:513.
T.-Y.Wuetal./JournaloftheTaiwanInstituteofChemicalEngineers43(2012)58–66 66