A Study on the Design of Management Teaching: Analyzed from Product Marketing Perspective

(1)

A Study on the Design of Management Teaching: Analyzed from Product Marketing Perspective

Po-Ying Lee

Assistant Professor, Department of Finance Chaoyang University of Technology

Taihor Huang

Part-time Assistant Professor, Department of Business Administration Chaoyang University of Technology

! " #$% &' ( ) * + , #- . / 0 1 2

345 + , 6 7 8 9 #: ; < = > 8 9 ? @ A B C+ ,

D 6 7 E + , F G H+ , I JK + , L M N %+ , O P Q &R S D C T

R S HU V W X 6 7 K Y Z [ D \ ] #^ E D A B _ ` #a b c

d e f 3?8 9 g h Ci < j 300 ^k_ ^` ^#l ^m 280^k293%^4c ⁿ ^_ ^` ^C

o B R S ; #p q rs t u < v w

1. ^3x ^y ^' ^?%+ ^, ^F ^G ^&z%{ ^| ^} ^~ ^&^%{ ^|

& # 1 C

2. ³ ⁽ ^x ^c ⁿ ^?% ^&z%v ^&^# ^c ⁿ

4.08² ^R ⁽ 5⁴^C ^x ^c ⁿ ^?%+ ^, ^I J& ¡ %¢ £ &?¤ ¥ ¦ § N N C

3. ^3x ^y ^' ^?%+ ^, ^L ^M ^&z ^¨ ^e ^© ^ª ^¨ ^{© # 1} ^C

x ; #« ¬ < v W ® ¯ ° #< = D @ A B #± 5 ; ²

³ j ´ µ C

H+ , 6 7 H8 9 H+ , A B

(2)

! " #

/ 0 1 ¶ · ?+ , A B ¸ z¹ º » ¼ #: ½o ? ¾ ¿ À Á

Â Ã ! " wÄ Å f Æ Ã D n G 2Ç È wÉ ° Ê #1985^{Ë Ì} ^{Í #}1998

Ì Î #2002^Ï ^Ð ^{¯ #}2002^Ñ ^Ò ^{Ó #}2002^Ô ^Õ ^{Ö #}2003⁴^#6 ^× ^Ø ^¶ ^·

! " #Ù 6 Ú ! #Û rÜ ¹ Ý Þ Ä Ã ß A B Cß c rà [

á X â R S 2Ç È wã ä å #1998^{æ ç} ^{è #}1998⁴^#z¾ ^c ^Á ^é ^Ú ^! ^ê ^ë

?_ ì Cß 1 a b í 5 î D ï ð 2Ç È wñ ò ó #1988^ô ^õ ^ö ^#

1991⁴^#z¾ ^c ^÷ ^ø ^K ^Á ^ù ^ú ^} ^?_ ^ì ^C

û ü ý þ < v c X â - @ + , < = D ¯ ° # p ?¨

3 22003^4» ^? ^{CÂ Ã} ^#

?¹ º # c Á » ? C

# R S X ?Y + , \ ] #a b K o B 3y

' K ( c n ?+ , 6 7 Z [ #rK à ?! I #^ E < v A B

D #ú } / 0 1 ¶ · ?+ , A B Cv ? 3¸ c " > # Ã

D e f #~ c $ % # Ã Z [ D c n 7 # X â a b 35 # Ã

ß Z [ D 8 9 ~ 6 Y C

D û ?( w

1. ^r+ ^, ^O ^P ^Q ^& ^' ^R ^S ^X ^D ⁺ ^, ⁶ ⁷ ^W ^Y ^Z ^[ ^C

2. ^a ^b ^W ^R ^S ³⁵ ⁺ ^, ⁶ ⁷ ^D ⁸ ⁹ ^2y ^u ^ß ^c ⁿ ⁴^#K ^à

?! I C

3. ^< ⁼ ^> ³⁸ ⁹ ^?% ^A ^B ^&^C

-

Kotler (1980)^?+ ^, ^O ^P ^Q ^¡ ⁽ ⁾ ⁺ ^{, Hc I} ⁺ ^, ^K ^* ⁺ ⁺ ^{, #r,} ^v ^# Ã + , ?- + , (McCarthy, 1978)^{C. ¹} ⁾ ^/ ⁽ ^c ^I ⁺ ^, ⁰ ^z+ ^, ^?- 1 #

+ , O P Q 2 + , F G ?( ) 3 4 Czc I + , ) 5 Á 6 ¬ 7 8 9 :

+ , ?; < #( ) + , K * + + , = 5 ± > ? @# Í A +

, O P Q ?5 W \ ] È s 2r, v ( Ç 4w

1. ^wB ^C ^D ^E ^F ^3?F ^{G #± z 3¤} ^¥ ^» ^G

V ?H I ß 9 J CÇ È { | W } ~ C

2. ^wB ^?c ^I ¹ ^R ^W ^; ¹ ^{R # K} H L HA M H

; N H¤ ¥ ¦ § N N #O r$ ?+ , F G ½F 3C

3. ^wz+ ^, ^I ^JD P # Q 3R W Z S ?á T # U V

ß Q + , F G 1 # ¡ ¨ © He © W W N C ¨ X Y Z [ D P

?, \ V ] H^ _ X ¬ H` a b Hc ' I ø N ± 6 D #Á Z [ C

d e f g #+ , L M > > zh i 7 b ?t u j C

W Ô k l 21999⁴ ^¬ ⁺ ^, ^O ^P ^Q ^K Osborne²1963^4?6 ⁷ ^m ⁿ

N ! o # ( ~ p E q + , 6 7 #F 6 ~ HÍ Hr Hs t Hu º Hy @

m Ha v H¬ w W x Å . N y @+ 3Z #U V Y Z [ 2alternatives⁴^#

^ E q 6 7 K Z [ A B _ ` #rz { / 0 1 ?8 9 g h # + 3@ + , y @C

(3)

6 7 m n ~ + , O P Q | } #m j » c ?+ , 6 7 K Z [ CÂ ~ c F ×

- + , X â ! C ( D A B ~ È C #rs E + ,

O P Q - . ® ¯ ° C

Bloom(1965)^$ ^û ^R ⁽ ^H ^W ^! ^@N ^O ^à ^C ^#

R ( H H~ HR S H« ¬ W $ N à P Q C

D û r ( t # K × ! @û #

( 3à H I ! W P Q c Á Ü # Á - . C

Bloom(1965)^? ^P ^Q ^z ^?R ^: ^# ^Á ^Ü ^? ^# ^c ^Á

Ü ?5 ø \ ] C 6 × # û ? ¡ - . 3y ' ?+ , F

G r ¶ # ( P Q ?5 ø \ ] z û ?y " C

X v H û W ® < v N #p q

D + , F G 6 7 \ ] È s w

^{ ^| ^2½o ^û Bloom(1965)^? ^P ⁴

^} ^v ^2v ^w ^W ^} ^¬ ⁴

^{ ^| ^} ^~ ^2v ^w ^W ^} ^¬Bloom(1965)^?

P Q 4

^´ ^¥ ^D ^{¡ 2v} ^w¥ ^¢ ^£ ⁽ ^¡ ^¥ ^D ⁾ ⁴

^¤ ^¥ ^¦ ⁿ ²Mintzberg(1973): ^§ ^¨ ^© ^ª ⁶ ^× ^« ^¬

# t ® > ¯ × ¬ ¯ n 4

^´ ^° ^R ^ò ^?R ^S ^2½o ^û Bloom(1965)^? ^P ⁴

^´ ^o ^b ^± ^² ^J2Mintzberg(1989)^´ ^µ ^~ ^p ^c ^? Bloom(1965)^? ^P ⁴

^³ ^þ ^´ ^D ^µ ^u ^2v ^w¶ ^¶ ^3´ ⁴

^³ ^þ ⁰ ^D ^µ ^u ^2v ^w¶ ^¶ ³⁰ ⁴

^Q ⁾ ^/ ^· ^J ^á ^2½o ^û ⁴

^p ^¦ ^¯ ^2½o ^û ⁴

!!!! """" #### $$$$ %%%% &&&&

1 ¸ e $ ?+ , I J\ ] r = #¸ ¹ #± K L HA M H

; N H¤ ¥ ¦ § W d M º N 2É L #2000⁴^CHuang (1996)^? ^Y

$Â » \ ] ¼ 4 w½ q #) à § ¾ ¿ ?À #µ u ´ HÁ h K

Â Ã Ä * %¾ ¿ À u Å &C) à ¥ Y ' ( ) à 1 R ¹ Æ ?¾ ¿ # Ç ¨

?§ # 3?§ # ± Y rÀ %´ HÁ h K Â ¾ ¿ À

u Å &?Z J+ r CÂ » u Å K ® ? + , I J6 7 \ ] È s w

1.^A ^J?È ^< ^B ^É ^w ^B ^É

2.^s ⁾ ^Ê ^? B É w2 ¨ > ?Ë #z6 × ; ² ?Z [ 4 3.^¾ ^¿ ^' ^wÌ ^Í ^Î ^H 3R ^¾

4.^§ ^Ï ^W ^Y ^w ^Ð ^Ñ ^N ^H

5.^c ^Ò ^A ^M ^W ^Ó ^Ô ^w ^L ^H ^¶ ^Ò ^L ^H ^Õ ^I ^JHÖ ⁴ ^N

6.^ª ^× ^Ø ^@u ^" ^w² ^¨ ^> ^?Ë ^#z6 ^× ^; ^² ^?Z ^[ ⁴

7.⁶ ^?ª ^× ^w ^¨ ^Ù ^Ú ² ^¨ ^© ^He ^© ^W ^N ⁶ ^× ⁺ ^, ^L ^M ⁴ 8.^§ ^Û ^¦ ^K ^¦ ^§ ^wª ^Ü ^$ ^Ý ^H¤ ^¥ ^¦ ^§

(4)

! # $

9.^§ ^Þ ^ß ^K ^à ^w²⁶ ^× ^; ^² ^?Z ^[ ⁴

10. ^á ⁴ ^û ^?D ⁱ ^w²⁶ ^× ^; ^² ^?Z ^[ ⁴ 11.^â ^ë ^H+ ^j ^Ð ^F ^j ^ë ^wª ^Ü ^$ ^Ý ^H ^N

12.^F ^× ^á ⁴ ^?M ^º ^w²⁶ ^× ^; ^² ^?Z ^[ ⁴

13.² ¹ ^4R ^ã ⁷ ^§ ^w²⁶ ^× ^; ^² ^?Z ^[ ⁴ 14.² ¹ ⁴⁺ ^Î ^ß ^ä ^® ^å ^w²⁶ ^× ^; ^² ^?Z ^[ ⁴

» - . D + , I J#r Õ Z [ \ ( ¨ Y e æ 1 (

Z [ # ¡ Ì Í Î H Ð Ñ N H H L H ¶ Ò L H Õ I

JHÖ 4 N H ¨ Ù Ú Hª Ü $ Ý H¤ ¥ ¦ § W N C × B É #

6 × K \ ] ?* û # Á 6 ¬ á ç - . 8 9 C

+ , I JD ® ¯ ° è Ä # 0 ® 1 R 8 È s w

''

''( ( ( ( !!!!

D R : Ä Cæ ç è (1998)^X ^î ^> ^D ^# ^¡ ^wé

8 H_ ê H. H! ë Hì < J N N C < v

¨ ® > í Ã r¤ ? #z¾ Û n î X j Ã ï

Ã #¯ ð ñ ò È s w

1.^é8 ^w ^¨ ^é ^# 3ò ^éC

2.^_ ^ê ^w ^¨ ^³ ^j ^_ ^ì ^#ó ^d ^3? ^~ ^2l ^ê ^4C 3.^. ^w¨ ³ⁱ ^Ü ^. ^#rÜ ⁾ ^ô ^D ^Z ^Ji ^Ü ^õ ^ö ^_ ^ì ^C

4.^! ^ë ^w÷ ^" ^! ^ë ^øn ^H² ^ù ^Hú ^û ^ß ^ü ^_ ^C

5.^ì ^< ^J ^w 3ý ^c ^! ^o ^@ ^g ^h ^Ý ^Þ ^#r ^3%þ ^: ^® ^&C

6.^_ ^ì ^w ^¨ ^33; ^?_ ^ì ^#B ^¶ ³ ^± ^C

7.^< ^v ( ) ^w 35 ^¨ ^» ^³ ^_ ^ì ^³ ^j ^{A #.} ^{D #f ]} ^{D # p} ^q

C

8.^y ^wÇ ^È ^³ ^j ^@ ^á ^B ^É ^#@ ^Y ^N ^D ^A ^B ^C 9. ^¶ ^¶ ^w ^¨ ^N ³ ^d ^# ^¨ ^¶ ^¶ ^C 10. ^Ñ ^w ^L ^E ^d ^Ð ^Ñ ^ª ^È ^# ³ ^C

11. ^b ^w ^â ^; ß . #r< = ä ® å C

12.^ô ^Ü ^w ^à ^r¤ ^Á ^Ü ^? ^{¨ #¾ ª} ^{#i Ü} ^B ^É ^¬

C

13.^¥ ^d ^w ^¥ ^d ^#r ^¥ ^Æ ^» ^# ^A ^U ^{~ C}

14.^< ⁿ ^w ^¨ ^¹ ^F ^c ^# ^3< ⁿ ^@ ^ß ^ð ^C

15.^à ^[ ^. ^w 3. ^à ^[ ^# ^¨ ^¶ ^¶ ^. ^D ^C

16.^v ^w 3q ^H§ ^ß ^# ^. ^; ^33? ^à ^{[ #}

¨ ¶ ¶ D C

17. ^e ^æ ^f ^w ^² ^! ^º ^# 3R ^¾ ^Ë ^#f ^Ü ⁿ ^C

18.^Ù ^Ú ^w 3 ^¼ ^! ^º ^¼ ^Ù ^{Ú #} ⁵ ^A ^?_ ^ì

D C

' ' '

'( ( ( ( )))) ****

Litwin & Stringer²1968^{4 R} ^¾ ^¿ ^¦ ^! ^' < # ¡ w ' H" H# $ H

% & H ! HÓ h H ' H( ) K Ü N # ÷ j %* + ─^, ^&^H^% ^t ─

- . &H%# / ─⁰ ¹ ^&N ^N ^¦ ^§ ^CÉ ^L ²2000⁴ ^Ý ^Þ ^¦ ^§ ^w½

(5)

o J ?¦ § Þ 2 3 H4 5 | , J 6 Þ ( H; 7 H| , C

Light(2001)^Ã ⁸ ^ê ^ü ⁹ 1600 ⁴ ^: ^Õ ^; ^< ^Ä ^3? ^B ^j ^w

3W i Ü d Ý = > ? @ ( c n #A z Á Ü B C ? 3D

ÏCÂ » 3 ¸ E F ?< v G p q ¢ £ CLight^± ^³ ^q ^H ^¶ ^{1 # ¡}

3 I #Y rJ ) à K Â H ] H 7 D Ï? d M º #A z @ 3|

D L CBain(2004)^< ^v ^M ^N ^¨ ^® ^> ^O ^/ ^3ô ^¬ ^#P ^Q ^R ^S ^T f g #rR 3 U V W CHarris²1998/2000^4< ^v ^X ^Y ^_ ^b ^}

> Ü Z â ?ú [ #ª Ë ¼ × \ ] ? ^ # _ ` ¼ ¬ W ¢ £ ? d ¦ § C

« ¬ ¤ 8 # $ Õ ¦ § R ( ¬ Hf g HN a W ¢ £ N Ä Ã ª R C

' ' '

' ( ( ( ( ++++ ,,,, ----

b #é8 Î a ¨ ?%ñ ò 1 &Ù Ú C ¶ ¶ Î a ¨

?%¶ ¶ 1 &Ù Ú C. H_ ê H< v ( ) ^Hì ^< ^J ^H

_ ì H< n W y N 6 Î a ¨ ?% ¶ 1 &Ù Ú Cà [

. W v 6 u V ¨ ?Ä y Ù Ú C

Bain(2004)^< ^v ^M ^N ^¨ ^t ^¶ ^¥ ^c ^µ ^ì ^?A ^¼ ^# ³⁾ ⁺ ^3%

d _ &# I ª \ d # ; ^ ¶ 3e E f Cg h i 22007⁴

´ ' % - ^² ^J&^#´ ^µ ^¨ ^A ^B ^; ^#r ^¶ ³ ^â

d ?. H5 j Hk ö W N # < = l m ± W Ë _ ì C

Â n ¯ ° o Î a ¶ 1 Ù Ú ?y u 7 C

« ¬ ¤ 8 # $ ¨ Ù Ú R ( ñ ò 1 H¶ ¶ 1 W ¶ 1 N O Ã ª R C

' ' '

'....( ( ( ( //// 0000 1111 2222

p 8 Ê #~ ¤ #Y Y r³ ª n Cz± c

< b #Ç È ( ¹ â ú ® q r L #c 0 s p t Û C #c u u -

. ¶ Ò L D c n 7 C> ? ¶ Ò L c wâ ú c Hr û H ' Hv , ú

w â H A M Hª , x 7 w â C

''

''3333( ( ( ( 4444 5555 %%%% &&&&

; < Jà [ . ?y #z { I Õ ± | } . W ² ~ #

" × w Õ ? ) 4 Ü #o Y rb q W . ?< 1 Cz#z { I

?Ö 4 N À W f g ¦ § Þ ( ~ C½o I ?Ö 4 #Ý Þ ] ù y ¾ ª

?I J#c Y W ¬ ?¦ § ~ C #c u u - . Ö 4 N D c n 7 C

! ! ! ! " " " "

6666 7777 8888 9999 :::: ;;;; <<<< ====

y @?+ 3) / o Î a Osborne(1963) ⁽ ^c ^Z ^Y ^d ^< ^y

@wT $v c + , » c 6 7 ) ) m #: ; 5 ) + , 6 7 - . c x

Y Í Hr Hs t Hu º Hy @ m Ha v ß ¬ w rd < @ + , y @C

í + , O P Q ( & ' #T , ü 8 ? 6 7 Z [ #^ F

Osborne^D ^y @+ 3Z #+ 3@ ?Y Z [ CX ¬ D ; #ª ( - .

D \ ] Z [ ß \ ] & ' #È ø1^» ^. ^C

(6)

! # %

6666 7777 >>>> ???? :::: @@@@ AAAA !!!!

a b / 0 1 5 + , 6 7 ?8 9 #Y rí ¬ R S ß ÷ " Ý n b Ý

CÔ k l 22001^4rPDA⁺ ^, ^Ý ^Þ ^Ã ^Z ^?R ^S #< v ò C

wn Z [

ø1^H ^\ ^] ^& ^' ⁺ ^, ^O ^P ^Q ^D ^Y ^\ ^] ^Z ^[

1

! " # $ % & ' ( ) *

+ , - . / 0 1 2 3 4 5

6 7 8 9 : ; < = > ? @ A 2 B C D E F D E G H 3 4 I J & K L

M ' N O B P Q R S T R S T U V W X Y X Z [ \ ] S ^

_ ` * a b c1de f : ,g h , ,i j c1,i j ,g h ,k i j c 1,g h ,e f : , ,i j g h ,e f : , ,i j

5l m n o p C i p q i r G s i r t f : p q E u v w x

y v w z{|

6f :a b } ~ } ~ } p C v w p q v w 7 > ? ' ( (

g h 1 a 1 f 1 < 1 9 } } #V U

: 2 g #

10 a b } b ¡ &¢ £ #} b ¡ ¤ ¥ #¦ § b

¡ ¨ b © ª } « # ¤ ¥ #¦ § b ¡ &¢ £ #¬ ¡ &

¢ £ #¬ ¡ ¤ ¥ #® ¯ , ° ¡ ± ¯ , ° ¡

11² ³ ´µ M ¶ ´ · M ¸ ¹ º ¶ ´ º ¸ ¹ ¸ ¶ ¶ ´ ¸ ¶ ¸ ´ g

» ¼ 1½ ¾ ¿ À Á 2Â Ã 9 :¿ À Ä Å Æ 3½ ¾ ¿ À Ä Å Ç È É Ê 4Ë Ì Í Î h Ï Ð Á Ñ Ò 5Ó 0 ¿ À :2Ô É Ê 6Ë Ì Õ À Ö Ö × É Ê 7Ë Ì Ø Ù - Ú i Û 8Ü Ý Þ ß à Ðá â 9Ü Ý Þ ß ã :Ðá â 10ä Í } å ´æ H É Ê 11 ç 9 :¿ À :F D

(7)

¬RS2conjoint analysis^4F ^/ ⁰ ¹ ⁵ ^Ä ^{ñ %+} ^, ^! o &2 ñ û º nÁ Ü ?Y 6 7 Z [ ¾ ¬# ¡ H _ Z [ 4?8 9 Ñ (ranks)^g ^h ^#_

¬ Ý (conjoint measurement)^# ^RS# ⁺ ^, ⁶ ⁷ ^ßZ ^[ ⁵ ^/ ⁰ ¹ ^D ⁿ

(utility)^K ⁵ ^y ^u ⁷ ^C¬RSÁ ^ù ⁵ ^?+ ^, ⁶ ⁷ ^z ^{ ⁸ ⁹ ^g ^h (Green

& Rao, 1971; Wyner, 1992)^# ^RS ^¦ ^W ^â ^# ^Á ^ù ⁽

) / C

÷ " Ý nb Ý ÷ " $ + , 6 7 ßZ [ ° m * + Ý #z { / 0 1 5

# + , 6 7 ßZ [ ?8 9 (scale)^g ^h ^# ^r ⁾ ^/ ^?o ^B ^Z ^RSD ^#Þ ^c

F × + , ?- 7 8 9 a b #Ç È È 2 HÔ k l #1999⁴

W 3 ¶ ¶ ) 2 H ¸ H ¡ ¢ #2001⁴^C ^(£ ^f ^g ^K ^< ^¤

H _ Á ¥ # Á ¡ H _ Z [ #» p 8 9 g h Ý Þ ¦ § #Yr

¶ ¨ © ï < Z · C # í ÷ " Ý nb Ý C

BBBB CCCC #### DDDD

÷ " Ý nb Ý D _ ` A B #¸ ¹ < ` 5 W à \ _ * P #ª ÷ " $

ø1^?+ ^, ⁶ ⁷ ^W ^Z ^[ ^« ⁾ ^° ^m ^# ^¬ ^* ^¤ ^® ^" ^Ý n# ì p R

N n. p 6 7 ßZ [ N > 8 9 C + , F G W + , L M N 1 R#p R5⁽

%ª > y '&#4^(%y ^'&^#3^(% ^@ ^&^#2^(%Á ^y ^'&^#1^(%ª ^> ^Á ^y

'&C + , I J 1 R#p R5^(%ª ^> ^c ^n&^#4^(%c ^n&^#3^(% ^@ ^&#

2^(% ^n&^#1^(%ª ^> ^n&^C

_ ` L ¯ e 4 ° c ® B C ¦ ¨ D ± b #- Ã 4 Þ ° l m ?>

ü 1 ² ³ K l ´ @ #r U ¼ _ ` D n< nW \ ] nC

_ ` ¤ ?_ * #µ (á ¦ ?> ü 1 @ a b CRSl ¶ #

W ?< v . ¢ £ # Y » p D g h (c n YR C

..

..EEEE FFFF GGGG HHHH

« ¬¤ 8 # A ¼ - . ?RS& ' #È ø2^» ^. ^C ^#à ^\

Î # ¡ 7 H Y H8Í W N #z ² ø- . ?£

· ¸ ¡ Î C

ø2^H ^RS& ^'

» ¼ è é ê ë

è é ê ë

3 ´ì í

îé ï î ð îñ ³

î&ò ¿ À Ï

(8)

! # &

..

..IIII JJJJ KKKK LLLL """" MMMM NNNN

« ¬ c K 5 + , 6 7 RSW 8 9 a b ?t ñ #³ j D

Ñ & ' #È ø3^» ^. ^# ^r ^& ^' ^ñ ^ò ^D ^W ^Ð ^Ñ ^C

ø3 ^Ñ ^& ^'

3 3 3

3OOOO PPPP QQQQ RRRR

1. ^¹ ^wr ^º ^Í ^? ³ ^(t ^#

< j _ ` 260^{k#l m} ^c ^n_ ^` 246^{kCr »} ³ ^· ^á ^§ ^?

í Û (¶ 2RSÝ 5 D 4#< j _ ` 40^k#l ^m ^c ^n_ ^` 34

k# 27 ^¼ ^× ⁾ ^/ ^¼ ^#7 ^¼ ^× ^C½i ^<

j _ ` 300^k#l ^m ^c ^n_ ^` 280^kC¹ ⁷ ⁸ ^È ⁿ1^» ^. ^C

2. ^a ^b ^Z ^J ^w ^¥ ^c ^< ^, ^_ ^` ^F ³ ^³ ^ê ^C¾ ^¿ ^À ³ ^< ^, ^F ^í

Û ³ ê C¹ Æ (2003⁸5^Á 9^ÁC

21 ó ô 3 ´ì íÐÖ õ

ö µ n % ö µ n %

÷ 66 23.4 ø ñ ³ 35 12.5

ù 214 76.6 ú ñ ³ 135 48.0

û ñ ³ 77 27.5

¨ ñ · Ä Å ü 8 2.9

ø ý þ 83 29.8 ú ñ ñ Ä Å ü 11 4.0

ø ý Í 60 21.3 ñ g Ä Å ü 14 5.1

û ý þ 105 37.5

û ý Í 5 1.8 ë È 30 10.7

} : 27 9.6 219 78.1

´ # ë , È 31 11.1

Ö × ¿ À Ð è é 4

¿ À è é ê ë ÐÖ õ

Ö × ¿ À è

é ê ë Ð} Ö × / ¿ À

è é ê ë Ð

· ó ê ë

¿ À · ó ê ë ¿

À

(9)

S S S

SOOOO PPPP EEEE FFFF 8888 !!!!

⁵ ^> ^ü ¹ ^g ^h ^K ⁺ ^, ⁶ ⁷ ⁸ ⁹ ⁷ ⁸ ⁷ ^o ^{B 5 Á} ^Ü ^?

+ , 6 7 8 9 ª 5 ¹ t^Å ^¼ ^#Ý ^Þ ^z ^Z ^[ ⁵ ⁺ ^, ⁶ ⁷ ⁸ ⁹

ç ¹ t^Å ^¼ ^ß ^Î ^RSK ^Â ⁰ ^Å ^¼ ²Scheffe-test⁴^#r ^RSz

¾ Æ C

#

# $ $ $ $ % % % % & & & &

TTTT UUUU VVVV WWWW 6666 7777 >>>> ???? :::: EEEE FFFF '

' '

'( ( ( ( XXXX EEEE FFFF r 7 8 7 o B RS> ü 1 5 + , F G ? y ' #

È n2^» ^. ^C ^{#> ü} ¹ ^x ^y ^'?+ ^, ^F ^G ⁶ ⁷ ^z ^{ ^| ^} ^~

# ª { | C 1 2N=280, t=3.43***, p.=.001⁴^C Y 3 u ?Á z Bloom(1965)^» ^W ^? ^P ^Q ^C ^z ^y ^'

þ q Ã Ä %ª > y '&? 2) Å r ¤ ?> ü 1 ª > y 'ß Î

4.5^r ^¤ ⁴^{C _} ³ ⁵ ^?û ^c ^Æ ^{#c á} ^RSr ^- ^. ^¾ ^Æ

?u u C

22 ó ô » ¼ ! #Ðr " # V Ï

» ¼ r " µ ! $ b (%)

½ ¾ ¿ À Ä Å Ç È É Ê 4.42 0.64 1

Ó 0 ¿ À :2Ô É Ê 4.35 0.64 2

Â Ã 9 :¿ À Ä Å Æ 4.34 0.66 3

Ë Ì Õ À Ö Ö × É Ê 4.30 0.67 4

½ ¾ ¿ À Á 4.28 0.56 5

Ü Ý Þ ß ã :Ðá â 4.21 0.77 6

Ë Ì Ø Ù - Ú i Û 4.17 0.73 7

Ë Ì Í Î h Ï Ð Á Ñ Ò 4.08 0.61 8

ç 9 :¿ À :F D 4.06 0.80 9

ä Í } å ´æ H É Ê 3.97 0.75 10

Ü Ý Þ ß à Ðá â 3.57 0.89 11

'( ) * + t^, ^- ^. ^/ ⁰ ¹ 1²2³2²3³4⁴5³3²4⁴5³4²5⁴6³5²6³6²

7³7²9³8²9³9²10 ⁵ ⁶ ⁷ ⁸ ⁹ ^: ^; ^< ⁼

' ' '

'( ( ( ( YYYY ZZZZ EEEE FFFF (¹ < v £ · ¸ # ª % & os ?

x ¡ b A B # à \ 5 + , F G y ' á RS#È n

3^» ^. ^Cn ^ü ^O ^m ^g ^h ^. ^#1 ^R ³ ^Ý ^í ^Û ³ ^Þ ^(y ^'% ^³ ^þ

0 D µ u &N O * + , F G # z } \ Ç ª Cn3^x ^; ⁾ ^m ^g ^h

. #Y 3 Ý È 3 y '% p ¦ ¯ &# } \ Ç ª

C # Á ´ µ q á b C

(10)

! # >

23 3 ´ì í » ¼ # V Ï Ð Ö ×

3 ´ì í& » ¼ df F p. ' ( ) ¥ * t ) ¥

ð & Ü Ý Þ ß ã :

Ðá â 4, 264 3.00* 0.019 ø ý þ (mean=4.38)>} :

´ #(mean=3.81)p.=.027

ð & Ë Ì Ø Ù - Ú

i Û 4, 267 5.01*** 0.001

ø ý Í (mean=4.31)>} (mean=3.62)p.=.002

ø ý þ (mean=4.26)>} (mean=3.62)p.=.003

û ý þ (mean=4.14)>} (mean=3.62)p.=.027

ð & ç 9 : ¿ À

:F D 4, 267 4.13** 0.003

ø ý þ (mean=4.21)>} (mean=3.54)p.=.007

ø ý Í (mean=4.14)>} (mean=3.54)p.=.034

é ï & ç 9 : ¿ À

:F D -- -- 0.005 ùé (mean=4. 13)>÷é (mean=3.81), t=

2.82**

*p. + 0.05 , **p. + 0.01 , ***p. + 0.001

TTTT UUUU VVVV WWWW !!!! >>>> ???? :::: EEEE FFFF '

' '

'( ( ( ( XXXX EEEE FFFF r 7 8 7 o B RS> ü 1 (Ã ï * D c n

#È n4^» ^. ^C ^#> ^ü ¹ ^(x ^c ^n? ^z ^v

# ª é 8 C z # c n 4.08^# ^þ ^q ^Ã ^Ä ^(%ª ^>

c n&? 2) Å r ¤ ?> ü 1 (ª > c nß Î 4.5^r ^¤ ⁴^{C _} ³

5 ?c n c Æ #c á RSr - . ¾ Æ ?u u C

24 Ðr " - Ï

r " µ ! $ r " µ ! $

6 7 8 4.08 0.73 3.74 0.79

3.97 0.69 + , - 3.74 0.70

0 1 3.91 0.71 3.73 0.71

3 4 5 3.89 0.74 (! " ) 3.68 0.73

3.89 0.68 . / 3.64 0.79

9 : ; < = 3.79 0.83 $ % 3.53 0.76

3.77 0.76 3.50 0.82

> ? @ A 3.75 0.83 & 3.18 0.90

2 3.75 0.74 ) * 3.09 0.90

' ' '

'( ( ( ( YYYY ZZZZ EEEE FFFF : ^à ^\ ⁵ ^D ^c ⁿ ^á ^RS#È ⁿ5

» . C1 R 3 (. N ï Ã ?c n # } \

Ç ª 2 í Û D g h É Ý 5 D 4# # ¾ ? c n ± o Á q

(11)

ª > c n? # _# ¾ \ 3 5 ?c n ± Ê Ë i

C # Á ´ µ q á b C

= 8Í 3 (. Á z c n í Û 8Í 3 6 Ý Þ ` ¼

nC z ) 8Í ?¥ #= 8Í 3 ?@ Y Ý Þ " p ) 8Í 3 ?b

C ¨ Ì u í . #~ + Î ñ ò C

n5^± ^. ^Y ⁷ ³ ^ò ³ ^s ^p ^! ^ë ^N ^Ã ^?c ⁿ ^Þ ^# ^z

Ç Á z C¸ ¹ ! ë D c ?Ó h # Í o Á ù Î C

25 3 ´ì í - Ï Ð Ö ×

3 ´ì í& df F p. ' ( ) ¥ * t ) ¥

ñ ³ & 5, 266 4.84*** 0.000

: ´ (mean=4.36)>ø ñ ³ (mean=3.50) p.=.018

û ñ ³ (mean=4.08)>ø ñ ³ (mean=3.50) p.=.004

ú ñ ³ (mean=3.96)>ø ñ ³ (mean=3.50) p.=.026

1 . $ & 2, 266 3.28* 0.039 ë (mean=4.28)> (mean=3.94) p.=.047

ñ ³ &> ? @ A

5, 266 3.76* 0.003

û ñ ³ (mean=3.81)>ø ñ ³ (mean=3.24) p.=.037

ú ñ ³ (mean=3.78)>ø ñ ³ (mean=3.24) p.=.035

ñ ³ &+ , -

5, 265 3.13** 0.009

û ñ ³ (mean=3.88)>ø ñ ³ (mean=3.35) p.=.019

ú ñ ³ (mean=3.80)>ø ñ ³ (mean=3.35) p.=.045

é ï & ÷é (mean=4.13)>ùé (mean=3.91), t=2.15*, p.=.032 é ï & 2 ÷é (mean=3.92)>ùé (mean=3.68) , t=2.34*, p.=.020 é ï & ÷é (mean=3.95)>ùé (mean=3.66) , t=2.68**, p.=.009 é ï & ÷é (mean=4.00)>ùé (mean=3.65) , t=3.65***, p.=.000 é ï && ÷é (mean=3.39)>ùé (mean=3.11) , t=2.18*, p.=.030 é ï &) * ÷é (mean=3.36)>ùé (mean=3.00) , t=2.84**, p.=.005

*p. + 0.05 , **p. + 0.01 , ***p. + 0.001

« ¬n4^W ⁿ5^?< ^v ^#Y ^> ^ü ¹ ^(%c ^n&^# ^þ ^%ª ^> ^c

n&? z v Cßð Æ ) ¼ Á p 5 à 3 z x

c n?# c » ¨ í Ã r ¤ ? # ô ³ ´ 3 ? d n

2æ ç è #1998)^{C ×} ^Â ^» ^< ^v ^#% ⁵ ^Á ^Ü ^? ^_ ^ì ^#í ^Á ^Ü ^?

¾ ¬&?% ² J &2Gunter, Estes & Schwab, 1999/2002^4Y ^z ^I ^p ^-

(12)

! # #

. ?Z · CÇ È %. &÷ ø ?%â ë H+ j &! oD ü # 3 T %! ë &

ú û ?} W (C » Á Ü ? _ ì #Ì r Gardner (1983^4?Ä ^Ï ^Ð Ñ b #} Ò Ä Ï Ð Ñ ? t ?Ó e f 2Ç È Hoerr, 2005/2007^4ßð ^I ^p ^± ^{C^ +} ^ë Bloom (1965)^? ^P ^Q ^?± ^Ý ^# ^G

< ? _ ì W Ô 0 µ u Õ + ^ # õ ö » µ ? ² J CHoerr^H ^¨ ^Ö

S Ç ¨ w%- × p ØÙ @ ?? Ú Û # Ü b b Ý Þ ² ) » @ ? ß #ß

1 à & Þ ² Ý r á â c ? ² J C&(p.131)

TTTT UUUU VVVV WWWW 2222 >>>> ???? :::: EEEE FFFF

()^X^X^X^X ÊÊÊÊ ^F^F^F^F ^w ^r ⁷ ⁸ ⁷ ô ^B ^RS> ^ü ¹ ⁽ ^Ã ^L ^D ^c ⁿ ^#

È n6^» ^{. Cn}6 ⁿ16^? ^< ^{v #o W} ⁿ2 ⁿ5^?< ^v ^: ^#½

ß¾ \ y 'ßc n µ ª # Á ^ R . # ) w

. D C

26 B Ðr " - Ï

B r " µ ! $ B r " µ ! $

C D E 4.15 0.69 J &K L 3.86 0.67

G H 4.15 0.68 / D E 3.29 0.94

3 4 I 4.10 0.62

()^{Y Z}^Y^Y^Y ^Z^Z^Z ÊÊÊÊ ^F^F^F^F ^w ^à ^\ ⁵ ^L ^c ⁿ ^á ^RS#È ⁿ7^» ^. ^C

27 ñ ³ B - Ï Ð Ö ×

ñ ³ 0 B df F p. ' ( ) ¥ * t ) ¥

ñ ³ &G H 5, 266 4.24** 0.001 û ñ ³ (mean=4.40)>ø ñ ³ (mean=3.82) p.=.004

ñ ³ &3 4 I 5, 265 3.58** 0.004 û ñ ³ (mean=4.32)>ø ñ ³ (mean=3.85) p.=.017

ñ ³ &/ D E 5, 266 5.47*** 0.000 û ñ ³ (mean=3.60)>ú ñ ³ (mean=3.02) p.=.002

**p. + 0.01 , ***p. + 0.001

. . .

.TTTT UUUU VVVV WWWW [[[[ \\\\ ]]]] ^^^^ >>>> ???? :::: XXXX EEEE FFFF

r 7 8 7 o B RS> ü 1 (© * ª Ü $ Ý Z D c n #È n8

» . C

(13)

28 l m n o Ðr " - Ï

l m n o r " µ ! $ l m n o r " µ ! $

p q E u v w 3.72 0.78 r t f : 3.67 0.74

p C i 3.71 0.70 z{| 3.55 0.95

p q i 3.71 0.70 r G s i 3.51 0.79

x y v w 3.70 0.82

33

33TUVW_`%&>?:EFTUVW_`%&>?:EFTUVW_`%&>?:EFTUVW_`%&>?:EF ''

''( ( ( ( XXXX EFEFEFEFw r 787 o BR S > ü1 ( Ä* N D c n

# È n 9^».C

29 f : a b Ðr " -Ï

f : a b r "µ ! $ f : a b r "µ ! $

p q v w 3.81 0.77 ~ } 3.27 0.92

p C v w 3.70 0.79 } ~ } 3.06 0.93

''

''( ( ( ( YYYY ZEFZEFZEFZEFw à \ 5 N c n á R S # È n

10^».C

210 1 . $ f : a b -Ï Ð Ö ×

d ã ' N df F p. ^Â ⁰ ^Å ^¼ ^ß t ^Å ^¼

d ã ' ï ä Ö 2 , 265 3.72* 0.025 ^?@(mean=4.17)>^A ^B (mean=3.76)p.=.027 d ã ' ï Ö 2 , 264 4.01* 0.019 ^?@(mean=4.07)>A B

(mean=3.63)p.=.020

*p. ^C 0.05

S S S

STUVWTUVWTUVWTUVW ++++ ,,,, ---- >?:EF>?:EF>?:EF>?:EF ''

''( ( ( ( XXXX EFEFEFEFw r 787 o BR S > ü1 ( O * ¨ ÙÚD c n

# È n 11^».C

211 > ? Ðr " -Ï

> ? r "µ ! $

( 4.11 0.67

(Ã ) 4.01 0.72

' ( 3.98 0.72

' ' '

'( ( ( ( Y ZEFYYY ZEFZEFZEFw ª 5¹ t^Å ^¼ ^R ^S ^< ^{v w c} ⁼ ⁸ ^Y ^å ^Æ ¹ ³ ^{( %}

¶ 1 &ÙÚ?c n 2Mean=4.20^4ò ^?× ^%ñ ^ò ¹ ^&%¶ ^¶ ¹ ^&Ù

(14)

! $ D $ Ú2Mean^R ⁽ 3.903.99; N=83; t=3.56***, p=.001; t=2.76**, p=.007⁴^C=

å Æ 1 3 5¶ 1 ÙÚ?8 9 #Y z ( o Í ¾ æ u

^ u Í ) Q C 8 9 n .Â » 3 ç # u Ç ¨ + r ¶ C

~ 8 9 # ¨ Y è é ê ë ? b d û #6 á Ú Ù b #

í ; 7 Ä ¹ ? ß ² J C

5 3 # ¨ ~ ' ² J ?µ u ¶ Á Ü ?ÙÚC W Bain(2004)

?< v g h i 22007^4?´ ^µ ^»Î ^a ^?¶ ^Á ^ì ^B ^C

a a a

aTUVWbTUVWbTUVWbTUVWb cccc )))) **** >?:EF>?:EF>?:EF>?:EF '

' '

'( ( ( ( XXXX EFEFEFEFw r 787 o BR S > ü1 ( Ä* ¤ ¥ ¦ § D c n

# È n 12^».# ^. ³ ^Ý ^Þ ⁸ ⁹ ^¢ ^£ ^W ^¬ ^? ^d ^¦ ^§ ^C

212 g h Ðr " -Ï

g h r "µ ! $ g h r "µ ! $

1 4.34 0.68 < 1 3.54 0.95

f 1 4.07 0.70 a 1 3.27 0.91

''

''( ( ( ( YYYY ZEFZEFwZEFZEF à \ 5¤ ¥ ¦ § c n á R S # È n

13^».C

213 3 ´ ì í g h -Ï Ð Ö ×

3 ´ ì í ─ df F p. ' ( ) ¥ * t ) ¥

ñ ³ & f 5 , 264 4.62*** .000 Ê ^F (mean=4.32)> ^F (mean=3.82)p.=.035 ñ ³ &< 5 , 263 5.89*** .000 Ê ^F (mean=3.93)>^G ^F (mean=3.45)p.=.026 E F (mean=3.93)> ^F (mean=3.09)p.=.001 é ï &< -- -- .013 ^H Î (mean=3.80)>^J Î (mean=3.46), t=2.5*

1 . $ &< 2 , 263 3.29* .039 ^?@(mean=3.97)>^A ^B (mean=3.49)p.=.04

*p. ^C 0.05^K ***p. ^C 0.001 d

d d

dTUVWTUVWTUVWTUVW eeee >?:X>?:X>?:X>?:X EFEFEFEF

r 787 o BR S > ü1 ( Ä* Õ ù J D c n # È n 14^»

.C

214 ¡ Ðr " -Ï

¡ r "µ ! $

: (ø g ) 3.95 0.78

V 3.86 0.71

U 3.61 0.84

} (} ) 3.35 0.78

f ff

fTUVW4TUVW4TUVW4TUVW4 5555 %&>?:X%&>?:X%&>?:X%&>?:X EFEFEFEF

r 787 o BR S > ü1 ( ï * Ö 4 N D c n # È n 15^»

.C

(15)

215 a b Ðr " -Ï

a b r "µ ! $

} b ¡ & ¢ £ # 3.91 0.74

¬ ¡ & ¢ £ # 3.81 0.79

® ¯ , ° ¡ 3.61 0.78

¬ ¡ J ¤ ¥ # 3.32 0.87

± ¯ , ° ¡ 3.20 0.71

} b ¡ J ¤ ¥ # 3.02 0.88

g g g

gTUVWTUVWTUVWTUVW 6666 7777 >?:EF>?:EF>?:EF>?:EF

()^X^X^X^X ÊFÊFÊFÊFw ^r ⁷⁸⁷ ô ^BR ^S ^> ^ü1 ^5O ^* ⁺ ^, ^L ^M ^D ^y ^' ^#

Â à î ~ n 2^?< ^{v w}^%{| ^} ^~ ^&^> ³ ^y ^' ^? ^{× %{}

| &C

216 ó ô Ðr "# V Ï

r "µ ! $

4.26 0.73

3.64 0.82

3.25 0.93

()^Y^Y^Y^Y ^ZEF^ZEF^ZEF^ZEFw ^à ^\ ⁵⁺ ^, ^L ^M ^y ^' ^á ^R ^S ^# ^< ^v ^w Ä8 Í 3 5 ¨ e © y ' (mean=4.44) ^× ⁼ ⁸ ^Í (mean=3.85)

2p.=.008⁴^C ^y ^' ^r ^ï ⁷ ^Z ^J ^b ^2O ⁸ ^Í 4.21⁸ ^Í ^W ^y ^'

® r = .245***, N = 239, p = .000⁴^Cq ^¹ ^Ä8 ^Í ^# ³ ^r ^" ^p ⁱ ^?

y ' ¨ ?e © C

' ' ' ' ( ( ( (

==== WWWW 6666 7777 """" 8888 9999 hhhh iiii jjjj KKKK kkkk llll mmmm >?>?>?>?

+ , F G Z < # 3 x y ' ? û z {| } ~

# {| CY 3 u ?Á z Bloom(1965)^»

W ? P Q # ç u } ? CÂ " \ ð È

¤ ?} 7 C

+ , I J Z < # 3 ( x c n ? z v # Q

( . H¥ d Hà [ . HW _ ì N # ½ o ?é 8

Ã C ñ x c n ?+ , I J ¡ % ¯ È H¹ á Hà [{ &? L

(16)

! $ D %

%¢ £ &?¤ ¥ ¦ § N N C z #à ? c n x q 4.08^#

»r %¾ ¬ J &? ² J Y z ~ c ?| · C5 #ü 8Hoerr(2005/2007)

¶ ² J y @ ? I p ± C

W Light(2001)^KBain(2004)^N ^?< ^{v #° c} ¹ ^R ⁾ ^ò ^W ¹ ^R

ó ?® å C) ò ?1 R c w

1. ^W Light(2001)^o ^< ^v ^¢ ^£ ^W ^¬ ⁵ ^d ^Ý ^Þ ^c ⁿ ^C 2. ^W Bain(2004)^o ^< ^v ^¨ ^¶ ³ ^d ^Ý ^Þ ^c ⁿ ^C

ó ?1 R c w

1. Light(2001) ^< ^v ³ ^¸ ^E ^F ^?< ^v ^G ^p ^q ^¢ ^{£ CÂ "} ^ó ^»

¢ £ ?\ ] C ¨ ?ô õ W ] »æ ?¢ £ ¦ § #± z Ê Ë R ?

3 »µ u ?C

2. Light(2001) ^< ^v ³ ^W ⁱ ^Ü ^d ^Ý ⁼ ^> ^? ^@ ⁽ ^c ^{n #A} ^z

Á Ü B C ? 3 D Ï CÂ " ó » ¬ ?\ ] C( #Light^± ^³

q H ¶ 1 # ¡ 3 I #Y r O / J ) à K Â H ] H 7 D Ï

? d M º #A z @ 3 | D L C

3. Bain(2004)^< ^v ^M ^N ^¨ ^t ^¶ ^µ ^ì ^?A ^¼ ^#ö ^- ³ ^W ^_ ^ì ^Ë ^#

3 ) + 3 % d _ &# I ª \ d CÂ " ó »

¶ 1 ÙÚ?\ ] C. : # ¨ A B ; # 3 < 5# Ã _ ì #

¶ 3 á ! ë H: è H÷ ø H Ç N ? ± W . 2É L#2000⁴^#

z ò U ?¶ ( C

4. ^r ⁺ ^, ^O ^P ^Q ⁽ ^D ^- ⁺ ^, ^\ ^] ^& ^' ^{#Y r} ^X ^¬ ^¤ ⁸ ^®

< v + r ¼ 4 #± Y r B j ý · D J C

CÂ " Ü ¹ \ ð È ¤ ?} 7 C

iiii jjjj nnnn oooo pppp qqqq ==== WrWrWrWr jjjj 6666 7777 """" 8888 9999 ssss tttt uuuu E>?YE>?YE>?YE>?Y ZZ

ZZ

Y 7 3 5 p ¦ ¯ 2+ , F G 4?y ' × È 7

3 # } \ Ç ª CÁ Ü \ 3 ( . N ï Ã ?c n

# } \ Ç ± ª C LH N H ¨ ÙÚH¤ ¥

¦ § H Õ ù J HKÖ 4 N N + , I J 6 7 ± o c : ? 8 9 C P #

# # Á ´ µ q á b # ~ p T y ?

W ² J N _ ì C

==== WWWW 6666 7777 """" 8888 9999 vvvv wwww [[[[ xxxx kkkk >?y>?y>?y>?y zzzz

3 5 + , 6 7 W Z [?y ' ß ( c n ?½ Î

ß ¾ \ Î µ ª 24.5^r ^¤ ⁴^#n ^. ³ ⁵ ^?û ^Ê ^Ë ⁱ

H5 ?c n Ê Ë i H5 ?c n A Ò W N Ê

Ë i Hr K5 ~ c ?+ , L M Ê Ë i C _ <

v ý - 1 ß ) ¾ 3 ª > y ' ?+ , F G 6 7 H ( ª > c n ?+ , I J Z

(17)

[HW ª > y ' ?+ , L M 6 7 C ...

.34⁴ ^í ^Û ^W 246⁴ ^{3 #5} ⁺ ^,

6 7 W

^Z ^[?8 ⁹ ^# ^c ^» ^ù ^ª ^® ^ú ⁷ ^#n ^. ^° ^c ^. ^?Ã ^Ä ⁷ ^C

) ) )

) * * * * + + + +

{{{{ |||| T>?T>?T>?T>? #### DDDD

« ¬ < v W . #û X ® ú 6 7 W Z [( D @ A

B#È ø4^».Cø ^# ^m ^Ð ^Ñ ^ü ¹ ⁽ ⁸ ⁹ ^Þ ^~ ^p ^T ^y ^' ^ß ^í ^?

Z [# m ; 1 ( c Í ¹ ± ~ p Ø @ D J C ¸ ø4^D ^P ¹ ^# ^¡

? ¶ ¶ W Ñ H¤ ¥ ¦ § ?Na d ¦ § H+ , L M ?

¨ W N #Y r Á u + r Ø @ # ( > ü1 ( Â » Z [?c n ß y u

Á C ? Ñ ü ý È ß ^ þ ¹ # } ¸ e ±

\ ¹ î

ø4^H ^> ⁸ ⁹ ^? ^A ^B2E ⁸ ⁹ ^Ð ^Ñ ^m ⁴

1 ¸ 1 6 7 8 2 1 M1 0 1 _ 1 3 4 5 º 1

3 1 9 : ; < = 4 1 1 > ? @ A 5 1 2

¸ ¶ 1 ¸ ¸ 1 + , - ¸ 2 1 ¸ M1 ¸ _ 1 . /

¸ º 1 $ % ¸ 3 1 6* 7 i o 8 9 : ; <

= > ? : É #@ A Û 2 > ? 1. ( 2 1 M1 ' (

Mg h ¸ 1 1 2. f 1 3.< 1

1.½ ¾ ¿ À Ä Å Ç È É Ê 2.Ó 0 ¿ À : 2Ô É Ê 3.Â Ã 9 :

¿ À Ä Å Æ 4.Ë Ì Õ À Ö Ö × É Ê 5.½ ¾ ¿ À Á 6.Ü Ý Þ ß ã : Ðá â 7.Ë Ì Ø Ù - Ú i Û 8.Ë Ì Í Î h Ï Ð Á Ñ Ò 9. ç 9 : ¿ À

: F D 10.ä Í } å ´ æ H É Ê 11.Ü Ý Þ ß à Ðá â

(18)

! $ D &

}}}}{{{{ ~~~~ ~~~~ 2222

3 x y ' ?+ , F G z {| } ~ # ª {| ¡ ?

CÁ ð wz È ¤ ? Á ] ù À ß W } c Ç

û ü È r Ñ ( t u & ' #Â z Á Y Å f ?C± ð

| y @ c u u C| < ù ù ?9 L ¥ d ã #³ d ª n C

Ç È x Ä 3 ( c n ?v # ( c K c Hv M º

Hr K& A v ª N Å #) ÷ c í ?t Û C #Ì E q }

W } ! #e H ú Ù j %v ú û &#Y z v ?9

LC

, , , , - - - - . . . .

T>?T>?T>?T>? #### DDDD

´ µ ¨ ¹ E q ø?\ ] #A B ? C± ´ µ

¨ .Z #ß - í Û R # q } ?v b #è z

1 ? #A B ; #r ¶ 3 < = 2g h i #2007^4} ^?

C

}{}{}{}{ 2222 :::: IIII JJJJ

´ µ | < @ ? LD ; #6 ¹ y #r < v @ ? 3 8 9 #

< = @ ? A BC

tttt IIII JJJJ

a b Á p 6 × ¦ H #´ µ ; ² 1 #

H y #r Å f D < v W t ñ C± Y r Ý Þ Á Ü H 3 D 8 9

ß « ê ë 6 7 + r - . Cß 5 _ ì #- . ¬ 6 ? ² J C

/ / / /

1. ^Ë ^Ì ^Í (1998)^C` ^a ^Ø ^¤ ^?~ (^r ⁽ ^Ç )^C»

» Û ¯ C

2. ^ô ^õ ^ö ²1991⁴^C ^í ⁵ ^î ^ï ^ð ^D ^} ^] ^C

» Û¯ C

3. ^É ^L (2000)^C ^W ^Z ^C» ^w ^¢ ^C

4. ^É ^° ^Ê ²1985⁴^Cà ^[ ^À ^× ^î ^D ^ª ⁿ ^$ ^% ^CÕ

» Û¯ C

A Study on the Design of Management Teaching: Analyzed from Product Marketing Perspective







                               