政權移轉衝擊下我國文官體制的再體制化

全文

(1)- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~~i"1'il. .tIt cf Ji.. VS. ~t~;t~. ••8ftft*r. «I ~ 'rftti*?~ftti~t ;%. an 1rt. 'if fl1f~. I'M. ~. , ~~1it~glGm*;mtn~f*ttB1~*"fJ;t~ , gIG M~tn:U:r*~1:Eff.B1~f:!; , glGM.tn~Jij~. J:::I. m~M~~M*'~~$~g~~~gZ. m~a~~'m/f~~~*~ff;tg~~~ rfJt~~~J~+~~~~~~~$o/f~,. OO~ag~~~oom.Z~a,.~~w~ ~,. • -1ttp~j,~/lf.:g~ , -±t:~"';-o ...;-,._H__-=<>n. 1iffi~.~/f~~~n~¥Z$.,~~~fffu. ,. ,. ~a~g~~~~ff~~~'~~~~m~*. ~1§¥1f!jMm~. ~Z~;~~~~~~~~~~~OO'~D~. ~~~-m~~,~~~~~~~1iffi~.~~. , ~~~~zfiP§JE ; IF,fmm~Jffz1iffi d~~rufB~~~/f~ , ~±*]~L~*5}fI/ff*z. ~~.!. It ' ~~m1L)JN:EI.lli:Mx.~Jl:t-;f~Ji1~\nJ$ l'g , ~1tf*~$~grr~~*/f~~?JTl&. .L,M~~M$~gh~~*/f~Z~a,. ifiHIJ!~. 0. fl1'l~A\nJ*f.ttn;tgfllftU~*fJ;t~B1iw. M1ftpJf/fiifilj ; fJiWU:tt!t~ , 'MfJI1$~t1.fJt~'M. JA=JJ-LJ '. 0. ~rufBWfJJltfJ;Asy.--OO~ll. . Jt!!ff.~~~Jij:$/ftfj~~~f.t~:Jj~ m~~jlljl¥rz~~JHtij~mpJff'FB1jfflfi. 0. ~P1JE. Wo • •. ,;tgfll~~~M*~A~~~$. ~?JTBo~ll'~~~~M. .'. (Policy design) ffi5i~~mIJJCW~h-flI'[i ~j§ , fr~~*/f~3. '. ffij!t'X5i1J[1~7t~~ (ac. countability). ,. ~/f~~~~. ~1JEtnrufBmt. ' fJ;Asy.. ~~~~M**t1.~~~M~o~OO~~~. !fU ll~rm~qFB.E][~rufB~ ,. ~~z,m.N~ • •h~~*/f~.~~. lQj®m*§Sl!t : .t)Ji¥~t~~1iI*~~~~~* liJ!ffi~:1JM!frfm. r ~ff~#J J ~*ffli{J:11!. '. 0. *;t~:ttt)Jl!!J!tz~ r :1}~#5. JJI! J (Citizen Governance) (Box, 1998; 49.

(2) ~~ , ~ 89 ; rIBjj~. : ~ 84) i¥Jfillt '. ~liillWi. :x '. JiC '. 0. 3trg~~*Ua{jP'JffB~!'. : ~$. ~/§.itUi¥JII~Jtwlf-%1~700~T)1IJ~1m. ~~filf1'.~.i.1. s.. 0. 0. W~±a{jm~~ ftfmomt!:AJJj;i7~~~i¥J~fifiJ ltffif~. f. ii1!Z9llt ' :f:E r fJl;~*f,§J~fjgJ (To do more with less) i¥Ju¥~T' r :W~± ~ J ' r ~tI:\~f!jU J i¥J~liil~:g:l!:f~"'Ll: ' t~1i~ filG'Jr-lSZJffl.iJr-i¥Jw"*o /f~ , ro'ImI'If.J~{J\~~&~\;J-I@Hifjn~lJlt r'g ~.f!jU J ~*f~5EI¥'] jH~ (Reformulation) ~liil~lt~ M. Weber l'If.Jl3' ~.f!jU~~~I¥']:JtlJU /f-ffiJJE ' !IJ!~~Djfr±~)L\~~ (Social Psychol ogy) ,~.~ ~1fB (System Theory) 'fJ! ~ ,. • • ~~B.~i¥Jr~$~~J~rkOO~ ~ J ,~~ § f~fl1~@Jii0~rtr~I'If.JJtlfii ; t~ ;=fi~.ifWi?Jj\mIt)ffif~~Im~'M'1i ' ftf~fw ~~liill'If.Jfilltf'F~~~~~I¥~I\!J~. ministrative Productivity) ,*'~m~~OOrP.J'. ,. '. ti. * ~. Ii. ffl. ~. ( Phenomenology) ,1It*1J~. (Critical The. 'P.HI5 : OO~~D~ijU~1ij!f (Knowledge-based econ omy) i¥J1I'-11~5lJl'¥ T ' M:f:EEJ,\GMlWl'If.J0fl.i AJJ. ory) 'R"tt±~ (Feminism) ,t&fJ!1~±i. J:. 1'If.J fiJ It ; ?~ 1ij ftf r ~ l!lI 1:. J1I. ~3](~filJ. ~ J (Managerialism) *~-mfis [i¥Jf®.*]~!J. ;Jt. ~~liil. iZ ft. 3](. ( Postmodernism). ? ~~W;niFB¥~~JE.l-j.ti¥iJEllt~~. ? :f:E~W '. ~~Jt. '. ~/lI*i. '. W~m$roLl:. '. ~D. '.. ~D0:;!:t~m~~1fB (Public choice theory). fiIT1'F~T;fjFf-.i¥JnUfIJ ? 0fl.i*~~~DfiITfJHJN. W5(~RX*~~liil (Transaction cost theory) ~. f§~i¥JIf'F~M£~. , l?d!tHtJ!t~I¥~~~Wf* l$~iM ' t)51m~'I'~Ai¥J r 1~~ro'lm J ( Agency problem) , r cP JL fig JJ J (Neutral compet. ltffiJ1§" , Jtlt~BAJJj;ii~~~JtiOO~Pff~1ti 1'If.J;=fi"=f'±~ , EJ,\GOJ~!li~Ift*~ , 'fg115 : ~~m APJT81ft1'If.Jf!jtjlt11l1tro'lm '. ~re)~~Im?~Z'~. ~i¥Jf!jUlt~1tro'lm ~ 7t~w~. ~. .~i¥J.~W. 2,:. 0. ~mt~~*~. , :f:E~$~~i¥JMImJ: ' lliif.*ffi ~7~§l::$Jf0:;!:t~~. , ~ffMjlt.±. ltret~~B.f!jU~1'F~~*f~5EZ~~. (New public management). JjJ!TI'If.J*JT~')]'±~ (Neo-Taylorism). "rfJ • ". w. , ~~Ft'iht~iWlWl¥~:r:jJfIg]f!ft~JUfIJ ' ffiJ1*Jf>r. ~~!Z9rf!{$:f:J!~~Ti¥JlfJi!.~t1E;fj~8-r. m:. 111 0. J mt~TBf.J~1m ' !!:~-·f.lr!!'l'r1i¥J ' , wmom'11~1fi ;. fi r. 6'GifrI '. ~.~~~JJi¥J • • ~Im~'~.~~M. 1lt1&j;i*'±~i¥J~D~;f.<1iij!fffif1~ '~Bii~jJB«J. (Performance appraisal) 'lji&~£JJ (Ad 50. f1': it. Dol. tt.

(3) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~~t111. 1ft ' 1iJrff&\~ft£ ~)~~. I. ~iH"~ J (Paradigm. gf!I[:±::Rl¥Jmt~JlI~;gf~~~. 1im·~ffm.~~ • • ~. (Double-loop learning). JfIilgU~rgf!I[. g~~~m~Jr8'g1j~~q!§. ? g~~~n~~itl~ x.~fimg,YB"J'Eff~fj§JJU)g ? ~lW~~Jji~UJm. (Innova. .*.~~ff~ff'~m~~JZ~~o~. ' fLff~r'gf!I[*Jf l:~~mi§fjlHm (Genericism) B"Jq!§? l:~ rJJrm~;J Fgf!I[:±::RB"J ¥ -f!I[~6B pfffjg!fl. I ' m1~~~~~ , {ffOJmffitll:B"J~¥ ' ~*l:. ~~~I¥JQlr:IJ~'gf!I[:±::R~~M\~~@~~. Ifi!:!I@]MffiaN~~tw~8'g~i/!&f~;iE. 1Ji~J~a"J1ttiW!,JiJ Jf ~. tion management) if!!~z. 891.~. t£~*fI%'ma"J.Jrq!§ ? 0. 0. · fti!t*c~UjI¥J~~I5lT ' '§~m. l.mm~I¥J~N. , i!?)'lff. *,m. ' ;:;tfm~1iN!§*~MJpff~jl. J ffiflJlil~mlB"J~11!ltkgfgll '. I. WilH&l¥JmJ~. ~lli~. ~I~.~J. , *~~~A~. JjJj! , gf!I[:±::R 0. 1, • • m_.I¥J'§~m~,~~~0~g. *~3D;It:l:ii2~frl!xm-flJlil~ffmt~. 1,~~~~~~*~~~T~Nl¥Jm~o~. mt~*JlflT ~1"f;tt:*~~~~IW*~. ;KP3ii~Uff~:ItlZJJrJ. z(J\ff*5'~ftJ:fIt~~Nl't:J~~. 0. _.a"J~~~lliI. '. M~. Z' !!Pffi&'§~~Ji&~§~~~ (~~) 'AUilJ • Mffii&~,§~~*~~( ) ,~*~~ '~~JX. 0. I. .iElJJ!J!t~ffia{lE~IDA. iillR~~fffl. J I¥Jl5llrlti '. ~1j8~& B"JrJJ~. ' ~~ml8''lfgll.::f~frl!~. W. A. Niskanen (1971). , ffif -t;JJ~*. 0. ••. W~~~M~. mgf!I[:±::R~n~ l:~~J!tmf!I[~Uftqt~. . 'lltt~ , -*mE13. , ~~l't:J. ~'~~U~~~~fi~:. l~ffi~~ili,~§Z'A~~~¥ff~~. 1'§~m.~*1t;J. '. i&flf~"Zf&§Jc1~ilill[ljjl:. , lJ(¥jZ;J~.~,§~1i1i&~gra' , jZ;Jjfj(Jff. f!I[~li.MID~~,~B~ff.~gjZ;J.~. zHE. : ~-l5llfliii2~l:~~1$mlr:lJ ' z(J\E!P1tt. I. ~jJi~flnffii& J ffif1~il1i\~ZYfrE §. _ili. 0. ~. JlJf$~~~J!tfrl!~ I ~~'[1: J ,;It{i~3'M:Rg~. ~tili. fj)'~if~38m. m'~~~~~I¥J~*&N'~~.~gjZ;Jf!I[. l~ ~ i£. ' f:l'P~WJ{fffj[ljjI¥J*~f~UJl~ , ~~ 00- 0 ff~ ~ (Disaggrega. r, m I. ~?l?liiJ J. '. ;It$~z.~~.~gI¥JW~fj§JJ*1t~. 4~8~~tt~~'r~~~~·~~··~hO It.:::. ......... I''It:lJIIIJ::t:.-111tlrt:J ~JL'l·l!:J: . . . I .. il)"HJ fh:J ' lI"I1HB~. {OJ , j/:t)tlX;,~m1ijflij~ra'l¥JjJ:im~ E!c. tion) 'ID~!J!jf~:It~I¥J.~${J\ffia, ~EI3~~. i 13 ±~m (agency) I¥J~ ff ~. ~W. 0. 51. I.. mM. , jL;tt:m;tt: ffiaN~ fjl¥J i%6. (Spoils system) 'fji&~$.lI'. 0. Mj;J. I. , ru5rmm : fji&. '. li.~J~. ' ~ffij~Bfji&*i~~&f; , ~~i&*~".

(4) ~4"if&:¥tJ-1Tif&:=7C~!f!B[Z;];tt~-I;J].~. ttttfEin:~.mZ~~. 0. ,. m[z;]J1t ' [E1Ji'I:ii!! ' 71-11. 8f;]fil!im.®~m~fr-illiJl~8f;]'1Tif&:~~J ?'l:1l'ft¥;+;:;":A,. I 1I-illi'i!fJ:!ll. J ]J~rruft~::x:g. I ~:lLfj~.1J J ij~ , fMl.U-~ IJ\lflfEI8f;]~tt~1~ , flUJ!J::Jl8~rJj~ , )(1' ro~~. , If;ttB~F-ifi~tgJ:!ll. ~±ftpJTfj~mt:R:8f;] II~Jg~tgJ:!ll. J ' J!:i§-I;J]B~ J!t?P bU~U '1Tif&: J I if&:r€:l J jipJ~rJl1l- illilHvJ B~ro~Jm ' J1t~~OO::t?G~~~:tE~*&::x:g~if&: f1!iMpJfilliWl;8f;][9'di~~tEij~. 0. ,. ~.i1J~:fjgA.1J:tltm~tt~~L8f;].mG. OOo.~'jipJ~.~:tE~H~. , l~t2tJ\~~~8f;] I JlJ.t~ J ( ~IINW~±:i .::x: ~:lL).I7t.~J (~mil&r€:l§. tt)zOO,~:fj8f;].m.~~~o~• • ~~. 'W~~m'~~~*L8f;]~~,~~~~. L'm~~~~~±:~fi~m8f;]~*'fffi~~. r€:lff~A. ; iPmPJ:§:tRif&:.~w8f;]lj. ' ff. tutt~~t. ~~4*~W:tE-.~iI&'.~-f1!m~r8f;]. ~fffi. [E1JB~::x:'rt;~h.J1. ::X:'gf1!tu' i1Jf~:a:. 8j:fr-illi1Li1Jfffii§ , W. Wilson f!i~--/\/\ -1:::;4 ' mtH~~B~ 'iI&r€:l-1Tif&:=7t J (Poli tics-administration dichotomy) fi~Ji ' !MiWij] '1T il&Jf!1lLJ5i1&¥tJ8f;]fB~zj~ , 1Tif&:rJj~Mz~Fif&:m. '. ~1FiJEt~:ii!!1¥£~~~~tl111EIJ:!Il.;3:m. ~8f;]Mtt~~J!1Ln:8f;],mm~~~::x:B~. ~fI~-~~~ra~*~~jipJ~8f;]1L. 0. 0. I ~:lLfjl§.1J J M~:MErPJ~-;i®~~~z§l¥J' mJjtJ! ' 1JJ~nm:fj I ~tf1:lL J 1.ffj~~!Uw~m " fff*:m8f;]~* ; J~j~ , PJ5.§Ht; I if&:rtJ@]~'11: J A EE ' i1J.~IIl~if&:¥tJ.1J ' ;i®ttMf$~::5-=fl¥J1 ff::x:g.lli'm*:fj-*~OOz~~;lf~~. ;~tgif&:m~1TiI&~~§~'@~~~~. if&:~~~1JT~fD8f;]if&:r€:lIJ\l,;m~.lBJJI:tR8f;]. , ~te:! I tf1:lLfjl§.1J J .~fOml 8f;] I if&:m@]~'11: J ,~~ '1Tif&:~* J ft;}(Y~ • • ~'fffi~.'tf1:lL~.1JJ*.8f;] • •1. .fiJ:!ll.tE~MI. , f§ ff;m~~t~;i®fjiJ:!ll.Jfl.illiff8f;]i1J~flfBJ:!Il.*~ Z ~ !i ' :tltfffi:fjpJT~ I § ~wf-t J (Displacement. m']J:tE~~:lLA~ffif&:m8f;]0w.1J;~='. of goal) 8f;]~~~~. 8f;]fr-illi~.~~~~*:tEff- • • ~~;1. 1Tif&: J. 0. f~~7t:lLfil!i8f;]~~*5*. '. '. filf~r. ~~3&1T. fffi~~PJ~~~m~±:$ffi. '. ~~F if&: rtJ.1J. Jl: ~ :ii!!M1$ ~PJT:fj 1ft ff:::x: WI lli,~~-~~~-~§8f;]7t.M'~~~1. 0. ~,::t;ttJ!ft~~mm~'0~*~*• •i. 8f;]Wr±* ' 52. J!~m3&~1&. I iI&¥tJmHJI J zliB<Jft I.

(5) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ji-t1IJ. i&"{rJT1~. .*flllJ~Z~I. 0. I. rr. , J!JI~mr~~Jt'gfJI*Ucx1jli:~U~?G*iz~ ~~. ~flJ. , Jtl§'~ • •lt:g~O ' *;t.9i:fllID~ 11& 1E1 J ~ I J fJj~zgI , J1:t!Jlli.&:\~ij l*fA 1&FnJJlfi~;fiTij[~g~~Jt'g , ~t.!~f~HN. ; J!~~-~• • B~fifBij[miB ' pg{r,. *Z• • ':i!iffiW.Jt'g'~a~{r,J (D~. .W*,X~.~~ • • • *z~.:1J· ~'Jl.. m~~Jt. (X~m. '§' ) , :::r~f!jJ~,!§t~• •~O~g , .,!§t ~lIArr$~,\HWa~~~. 0. ~. w. ' ,. aJt. ~flfjtt. , -~JW:!itlfffiJi~B~. I. 1jafifBij[~J!iB J. ~NPH!~~m--~f9t:i:-~. I. W.miB J. poiiticization) ~mJf£ x*m~~Jt'gfJIffiUlE 0. m:~~1r-lIDffij[B~m*. '. ,miB~. ~~F1J~ffuf*t~1~~'~B~1E9MI1*NP~B~. a1E1{r,B~jj!*X~Mm. -~~. , 1&7E1?i:.i*~~ftjJlID (~D'~m~mm ft-) ~~FJlgp~ , i!&;fIiIDJ:~ij[~¥~¥U~j. n ' *fliH1~~fJIB~1jaJ&* ' r:pJ'r~g.:1J ' ~~± t--R-s{z , J1:tlJWJ'rJt'g 1'r:pJ'r~g.:1J J Z~I~UJ:1: '. ' 1j1&Jlf:fJ. z&~~. ¥J@]¥U.~B~Jt'gfJIffiU. '. ' lfi!jftM ' not.! ~mr7z ' 1&1E1mgtIJB~~1I (~[[. ~1Z!l~B''.l1R:*&]I) '~§~~Wd:~~t:jJS~ii. ,. &&MfiJ!fJi~ffu~Im~~~W.B~fifBij[miB~. ~~~Ii. .lft~~ifB ' r*fMJ:~. 1&r:pJ'r J ~*ElIHI~re~mhffi ' lilil~tm~1EJ'rr* ~,i¥i~'@' ; iffiJt'g I • • ~~m~~g.:1J J ~fii. $ Fl Z ' frar:pJ'r1E/.$:JfJ: ' fJYjJ~$m jE- ~lHIil~~ , lit~P~f:fJt'g9i:~~~D{ilr* ~* I r:pJ'r~g.:1J J ,t.!r!PA.a*~fj ? ~ At.! ~ , Jt'g~~~JlfMfS¥ftiJ~,~~1Vrl~~1jafifBij[. ~fI.:1JJ~. 0. *tf~flllJ~g"~p.!r.:6aJt'g~ • •~ilI~~if~. ! t~-fllFnJ~&f&. 1E1~&1. a. 1E~pgP]r*:L}lli.:1JfI£mB~f~ID~. JfiIJi~. Irra-fJIJ. t!l!~21~JjJJ&. ®-R-RA~~,*~wA.R~m,-H~. § , ~211~,~~-H~£t:~j , hfl~~m7t~rm. '. , [It]. ~Jtr§1*~~ffiU9i:~~g~. f~-'flli.l1fEflfcp~ffiJrs~*mSJJ. 0. tiff9i:~f¥r:p. , i!&fj'~~~1J1tj'g~PJ~gmff~f*v'~. , -~Uf~~H1Um~~~~J!m (~¥ l:U**ftu;~ 10 WI ' ~ 85) 'tJ!f:f~A. M'.~~h~rra.~,~~fi~~fl'g~. $~~~£t:mr~,!§t~*~~~~,!§t%ffiJ,~~. )( fr,~ r 1j!iJJij[~ifB J (Action theory). 1E-t~flIHl1T1&r:pJ'r~fiffiM~ J:lliif S. ~OZ~. te:. ~. "'iliflJIitIDm1NMmB~. f!.ffum. , px*i::f~J~fi. , *9l~~~~lli.~Jl~1j.:1J ; fIl;JfA1&tf* ~-~1J.[Hj , ~7~iilJ1:t~j)jJI:im~ (Implicit. .~*iJ&~H' EE·~f~~~,~J:~~.A'. knowledge) z.!l}]~ , ~~~§i1jmlJJ~JlllJ1jJ~. lE~~~*ilif.fft&. ®a*h~. ~A$m~1E~-'g~pg~fl~ili~ft&,. , :i!~MJl~Jt'gB''.lfA1j~.:1J ' 53. I. '. EE±ff~~~F±ff~. &.. , it(.

(6) jJ,tll:tfffi § , )('I§' ~tIJIl§'~~~IRfff$f9J,§1' ~j[!l:f9J 'gft;Jjf!x:i#iffi ~. ffl. ~s~~m~~ti~ft;J~.'ffi~~S~.~ P9~O*~flti~~1L~. ~~r&. ' fiSlll:t". 1*~10!~ ~. , ~1~1L~a'g~F±~~1n. 0. 'R1r,~tUJE-~m.a'g7:tlM*. , ~§EftMIAjf!x:rEla'gii~1I'" J 1t. f&3Z.::fr: r "'pJTJ;JR~~~~J~~tUJE-:g~rFf~ jG~a'g1:tWfir!t~H ' A:;lt~ttl~ft;J1,*~x ' pJT~1fa'gfF-f11*~DfciJ~~ ? ~DfOJ1*~10f9J~ ? 1t1 1n~1fft;Jf':Jjf!x:§~~DfOJttl~? J ~.R~ •• ft;J~R· • • • ~' • • ~. !fIX, ,. I. tI~:tEfrOOtgl]!l:. •. g. A$m.~~-'§~ :g~~~1'rtfH1ii~1Z&a'g. JIlijlrra~m~ft;Jil~tL~fH1. , EE±~IDaJ~~F±~. ' ! J t!~WT § ! ~*:g~ft;J. 0. , tI~-11MAft;J{J\3:1#* f1lt~~~Of5tliffij~l'JlmlJH8'g.~ ; 1'~ , -l}1 is-J!j!8'gffErufB:t£1n ' 0f9JA~8'gte~1f~m'f'B-(g fir~~:ttjf!x:**1J1!f ~DlI:t-* ' fltg)it~~J m*wll*~a'gi)t;ifI ' ~1' te~ft;J0~A , ti1njf!x:*mfrlWfA1j8'g~~x:1'- , ~OJm. , rm~~*AI))\**1n~fJJ~ J~ALr:p1Ll]!~ , )JlHffltJl) (Client) t~ilI' ~f3t1jf~L~~ , 1'§E~ A~IlIIHl1njf!x:mJJi!., ~i!l1' ~tli r 0 f9J A ~ 1*f\!i! ~ iffwll ~ ~ fir J ti*~pJTf~a'g1L~~fOJ ' ~iWry:j~ft;J$~ ~ : )('§f*f\!i!ft;J{lfillim~ry:j~itBii1'ra5U&ft;J~ FJi ! :ttJf ' ;£fa~)('§ft;JfJHiliH*f\!i! ' ~q:iJi;f'J (~ 83) ~tliH±Hjj~ . B ttl ' Fffiij l;iipJT~~8'g r)('§ ~J tUIl ' ~lI:ttUIlr ' ~$m1:f)('Er~m'm. 0. o. ~O. 0. , -lliti~rti~~ • r:p~~~~ ~1f~8'g0f9JA~ , W-lliJJft1:t~t:}~~te!lB3 0f9JA~ffi.'.~JIlijlr.~ffi~ft;J • •1 *~ H~~-.*r11{.f};iiffl ' ~:g: A¥*Dt ~ , lBill:tFJiti1n1'rImJJft f:t~a'g~~!fim?¥mnm ' ~~!n]~x:ft;Jfi~JJ~1ID~IQ]-ft;J , ~jJm~1f ~ilmJ}j\fffi§. ,. f9J*~~~'H~~$~mmff)('§'§Wm f9J*~~'EEr)('§~J EE~~:g~$. ro~l'm9!f~. J~~R~'~~)(,§~~~jf!x:. rElWfijf!x:ft;J• •. mMrl'~. jJ,tt:tWft;J1L~Fffi §. 1L~Jl~OJ.lt~r~. '. ~W~JJ,~m~ 0. Itt:'%. '%..w.h:=E!: - , r Jt.= .R~i])d;Y<"'I!i~,<;:;r; 'tJ,.\J',Jrt. PJTJI)~t&)('§ra~1'r1:ffoJJl:JtJt..~fF-f. ' ?fAJJ±.r.)('§'~. J • r 1'f6Ul]! J 8'g'l'Ff$.~ 1'~ , tU/.tJ: -~~A • • 8'g~'~~~~ • • )(,§~1 ~[J , figi!?~~itB@]~~LPJT* ' A:;JI)~ro~? ~ § L ' lI:t~I]~~1~~J;)* r.~ J W r ~3: J .. ,*,/.~;t:f-rE'.6h~ 1=1. /\.~fJJJ.')('II:IJj:l'J. ~Wr. 0. (Problem structuring). lBill:tra~8'g~~&\~~ff~~~a'g. ,~ • • )('§8'gjf!x:rElm.~. 8'gJiIl~jjj, 0. , ~t!LiE~pJT~~ r 1~~tl:)('§'1 54.

(7) I. ;4jj~t*'J. ----------------------. !IiIl J (Representative bureaucracy). f1iZf1jH:fjI¥J~ifB. ~f. 111· mtg~~mirrEiII¥J[?g*m~ifB3!f=3!9& ' ,It *ll't'5fJT0:1tf'JiI& (New Public Administra tion) fiJT±~B"J r J (Affirmative ac. " 3<: ~ I~ ffiU B~ MI~ ffiU 1t : ~ $ , ~~ , W~±B~m~~. b)I¥JB~,iI&RA~fi~.~H.0~·. ~~ifB~xg~fIiIJI¥J s. ~tJ. ' lJl~B"J0~A:1J~* ' ffi1nl:1J&J~fi ffB9WdJ\<l*Mfii.tt15tl ' 1~fffi1:E~~*tl,t1tB"J~~t ' ~~~I¥J~1JJ$ 1: ' EJ H!iS~ , 1t.tt15~~ffFFrnJ f;fj:I±l~B"J0~ A~ , f~iJ~ftDffiil&l¥J@1H!~g. :;<:E. r. J. t§'D~-$.. ~. r. J. -h!fl::Ei: I -'7 ~A~~~.IB.F;;l. 5liFl. fBMB"JiI£iQ : 0fl :g~rEiIB"J1£JHl ~**l5lxiX ' .:g~:rj)[i*allifB~i§t±l EJ:EfT 0. mtgtmllt, r J *~Slt1'JEj;J j;:jt::f£:t±'M~~f~f-\:±~:1iS,* ' fl'fJU5.Hlfffi ~ JEB91f:ft ' tf<:rnirI¥JB~}j~~~*1m~W~11IT. lI:t-i!~~llifB (Grand theory). A.n l§\J-x,r·-EJ:1:.1-s t-'I"". (. learning) I¥J-~ !l?:\~tf:I~Jl:1J. ~1IlRal'~~~E8~ f(\l.Um\U:Jffifiil1..JD'~. Policy learning. capacity) ,@¥.*~ r ffd:.~~ J. (. , ~JEj;Jftmil&rnfJtf'J}@flIFF. 0. w*EI;:+;;''''D;:V'.' HJ .. e,.... IIIJ7\. -a. ,):::(;~A+8.~,i'! 1~iiffB/+'~ ~~,. ; ~fi '. i~iW. xM~,:g~±~*~fu,x1'}@~-~~ff~ ;%,1:Ea~~:W[QJ*x~@jj~OOm.~l¥JiW. 0. fPJ~z)£tL. lZ.i?1I'~. ~~*~. , ij Ifr8"JP9~fu,IM1rE~t¥jljj , ~~*"§'f3t 1{*-!1EJJ<±1'~~B"JlIJB*&b ' lIt~fu,M,J:iJJ!i!~F :ttk;g* r fiig!j~WTmL J B"J"':JIf fJ1!~. o.. M~fffi~,:g~±~*~tt~1''M°.. Jt '. 0. ffEjj7~llifBB"JAN~~. I#t§'J:iJ~.w.*)£tL. 0. 55. 'I>i:l::~l= A ± ± S y§"'P:lWo t±;t,f:/~j\/I\.jD~~mr. ~m~~~D~~7~~{i/]j[fiPZ!@~. Social. r tJWd:.~rpIL\ J !1iJ r j;J~~~rpIL\ J B"J J:~mlll ' €fAfu,:fij=t/§1!l* ' ~.nft~~ti ~!t:lr1¥J r tI:t:WB J (UI3)j~, ~ 84) ~ ,tE.~Jiiffi]1: ' lIt?Jj\~'MiWXg~*tl r:fij tliliHt J B"J1~it,IjSl,~jj[QJ :¥:~T ' lliif.?Ia3l:R ;fi~$F~B"JB;%fu,~~Wlf-Jm~ , ~{$}f~~lJ¥tl lHlthb:1Jzfl'm ' ~~W~±.rutim~~~~m. ~. ,. ZfJ1!t±lmm:ft ' ~Dj;J~~ft (Typifications) m~Z:1£lII ' }@ ~1¥J5tfJTJii~ , ~iI7:g A 1:E~B~±B"JiWfJ1! l'- , ~-~~~5tfJT8"J~~~}j (tz[J~~ftB"J~ ~N)£fe~) '*~1'J r rr::l'~ J r ffSi: J FdlJ!. til . tf<:rn}@f~.~~iI&rnfiJM;f§ImA (Pol icy stakeholders) , 5Mi3li ' W]ilb ' j;J J. -$. ' lI:t~P&\*J!@1~m0:1t1'JiI&~~~rnJ. /'-:\.:f±fr.g;lHl,w,;:V'.I't~~ffc:rh. r. inl. ~ 1il6 ' r~ I=l /\.k:.. illll! ii:;:t.)!!:!!1:£ ' 'IlR. 11·. Ir\r,ijf~B"J. fu,~T '. '. , fiJT~l¥Jtg~~;%W. 1h'~fjlJ1:E~€fAn~tzD. ? ffij~:rj)[i5Eflz~Jtr-rl;;t-j=iSfi~1¥J. ? j;J&1:E.lim~ffi]1:tzDfPJ1JDj;J~¥~mt.

(8) Mo ~l!i!±~f¥J~i1BWlil. )(!X:5l J. '. *Jimi§J&:*fiJilrnia~ ~.Ilt. 0. a~g:tJ J. r ~* J. ~~FDf-. 'EZffijmtt~Ma~. m~:~il~*W.ifr±~J tIajjf~. 87. , :g:AtJ~tt\a'Mmi1l?G~!iVJ. ~~ftHf¥~Xgtm*~f¥J;§.'rt ' 1imaJ:~::f7~lii r IJ'll!i!'fj: J f¥JJil~J:rr" ' ~~\I.~~~ M'fj: r ~~m~ J l¥J~~mi ' 1j£ffijti~ r ttl. 0. 0. *~tJT. *X~ ~ (0. E. Hughes. nafIfBl!i!~m~ff. '. ~'I111§$z5l. '. ~~.J&:. 0. ¥$~~-tWJt. 0. ~q:?Ji:f'~. , ffl;j:E*~g:li,nEJ5tH '. ~~. ,. '*c~~lhIz:lifj(ffn 0. r*~0~~a{EltpJLZ~·. zf1i ,tp;k:UJfJi:~IX~tiJf~±;J;¥: ::x:'tJ. fl<:~0~~aIEttpJLJf! J. tm*~z~ml.tt~~fJIlJtiJffl~. (i'F~llajj~~ml1latEI:*~. 0;ttfja~*~~. 83 ~. ~~~~f:ji'Fl¥J~9IIU&~W.1~ . ~±~f¥JID!il~~. 82. ~ilI~fja~~ltiJffl~. g::f7g , ..§!;::f7..§!; , jf!{~JtfF " fL"§!;fJi~a~ r fit .,..,,_~~J !l~. : $isx1~· r ~ifXgtpJLf¥Jl!i!*lt : AJ. ~l!i!ama~fiw'}j J. ,. ~~~. ~}(i;E*~~1larEt;k~0. ri"i± ) "",1TJJ.'A+*1l~ . .:f±/.-;a,..Ml ~. ) ~. 0;tt~l!i!~~' -E1~t. 88 1im~g~. 0"§!;~~rOJr?n¥$. r fl<:~0~A:tJ~~Zrn~w. tim : ~Jtfj£0~A~fjafIfBl!i!z~~t ,~,a}ff~i§z:nrOJ J ' ~~fI*:± ;J;¥ : X/gtm*UW.ml*~~UJffl~ ~I1J~t 85 fja~, -E1~t : -=...§!;. mt*5iW~. '. 'ml1lam*. ~~m'~-t+Mo. r fj. W. r jfr±~0SfZ J rl~"""'r::j"'·_. f¥J~Elti*U:tt~::f7~~EZ7t. 84 0. : ~~n:1f:. Frederickson (1996) t)JM:tJN~Mf¥J. '. (J. Forester IJR~). rnitifl:tJf¥JmIIJ ' -E1~ t : 11i¥J rrajH~ 84 r 0;ttfjaifr±~±~f¥Jl!i!~W. (Spillover) , 'ffij~tl1iJt*1JJ&\~J;!~~"§!;. ±attlf¥Jrtll*1&tii'.Ilt~7Jmi. ;tlffi;g-. iIa)lf~. r J~~. (D. Zohar IJR~). ..§!; 90. 0. ~=~.:. ]);fflit-=f ,w*l911l*Jl~EUi§ttJ~~1 A ' -E1~t : ;ki)t{x11:: 0. Box, R. C.. ..§!; 89. r f&;EJ!1~jfr±~0;tt~l!i!l!i!~i1Ba~. ~~:~w~0;tt~l!i!~. l!i! JJ J '. tpml1jafif~. American Communities into the 21st Cen. w~0"§!;~. ,. 1998 Citizen Governance: LeadiJt. tury, Thousand Oaks, c.A.: Sage.. 10 ~~ 1. Cooper, T. L.. 56. 1990 The Responsible Adm' ..

(9) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~~:t1·1. trator : An approach to Ethics for the Ad ministrative Role, 3 rd ed, San Francisco :. tration Review, Vol. 60, No.6. Niskanen, W. A.. sentative Government, Chicago, III : AI. Jossey-Bass. Drucker, P. F.. 1999 Knowledge-Worker Produc. tivity : The Biggest Challenge, California. dine-Atherton. Rainey, H. G.. Management Review, Vol. 41, No.2. Frederickson, H. G.. 1980. 1997. Understanding and Mana. ging Public Organizations, San Francisco, CA.: Jossey-Bass.. New Public Admin. istration, University, Ala.: University of. Terry, L. D.. 1998 Administrative Leadership,. the. Neo-Managerialism, and the Public Man. Reinventing Government Movement with. agement Movement, Public Administra. the New Public Administration," Public. tive Review,Vol. 58, No.3.. Alabama. Press.1996 "Comparing. Administration Review, Vo1.56, No.3.1997. Waldo, D.. 1980 The Enterprise of Public Ad. The Spirit of Public Administration, San. ministration: A Summary View, Novato,. Francisco, CA.: Jossey-Bass.. Calif.: Chandler & Sharp.. Guba, E. G. and Lincoln, Y. S.. 1989. Fourth. Generation Evaluation, C.A.: Sage. Hannon, M. M. and Mayer, R. T.. 1986 Organ. ization Theory for Public Administration, Boston: Little, Brown. Hood, C.. 1991 "Public Management for all Sea. son," Public Administration, Vol. 69, Spring.. Jun,1. S.. 1994. Philosophy of Administration,. Seoul: Daeyoung Moonhwa International.. Kettle, D. F.. ~. 1971 Bureaucracy and Repre. 2000 The Transformation of Gov. ernance : Globalization, Devolution, and the Role of Government, Public Adminis 57.

(10)