第四章 結論與未來展望
4.2 未來展望
本研究以實驗與模擬探討含脫層三明治結構的挫屈行為,並對含脫層 三明治結構的破壞強度預估已有一套初步的方法,接下來可再進一步討論 的議題如下:
1. 本研究目前只探討不同表層厚度以及改變脫層長度對三明治結構 試片在軸向壓縮實驗時的影響,對於芯材厚度的改變尚未有深入探 討。因此,往後可延續本研究提出之實驗與分析方法,討論不同厚 度的芯材對含脫層三明治結構的挫屈行為、破壞強度與破壞初始發 生位置的影響。
2. 藉由觀察因局部挫屈所導致破壞的試片裂紋發現,在靠近脫層尖端 的裂紋會繞過剛性較強之片膠,以某個特定角度朝芯材方向延伸。
在未來可嘗試利用破壞力學之觀點,預估脫層尖端的裂紋延伸角 度。
參考文獻
[1] A. P. Mouritz and R. S. Thomson, "Compression, flexure and shear properties of a sandwich composite containing defects," Composite
Structures, vol. 44, pp. 263-278, 1999.
[2] V. Vadakke and L. A. Carlsson, "Experimental investigation of compression failure of sandwich specimens with face/core debond,"
Composites Part B: Engineering, vol. 35, pp. 583-590, 2004.
[3] J. L. Avery III and B. V. Sankar, "Compressive failure of sandwich beams with debonded face-sheets," Journal of composite materials, vol. 34, pp.
1176-1199, 2000.
[4] F. Avilés and L. A. Carlsson, "Experimental study of debonded sandwich panels under compressive loading," Journal of Sandwich Structures and
Materials, vol. 8, pp. 7-31, 2006.
[5] T. Southward, D. Horrigan, G. D. Mallinson, and K. Jayaraman, "Failure of Sandwich Composite Structure Containing Face-sheet/Core Disbonds-an Experimental Study," in Proceedings of the 5th Australasian
Congress on Applied Mechanics, pp. 375-380, 2007.
[6] V. P. Veedu and L. A. Carlsson, "Finite-element buckling analysis of sandwich columns containing a face/core debond," Composite Structures, vol. 69, pp. 143-148, 2005.
[7] B. V. Sankar and M. Narayanan, "Finite element analysis of debonded sandwich beams under axial compression," Journal of Sandwich
Structures and Materials, vol. 3, pp. 197-219, 2001.
[8] A. Sayyidmousavi, K. Malekzadeh, and H. Bougharara, "Finite element buckling analysis of laminated composite sandwich panels with transversely flexible core containing a face/core debond," Journal of
composite materials, vol. 46, pp. 193-202, 2012.
[9] F. Avilés and L. A. Carlsson, "Post-buckling and debond propagation in sandwich panels subject to in-plane compression," Engineering fracture
mechanics, vol. 74, pp. 794-806, 2007.
[10] R. Moslemian, C. Berggreen, L. A. Carlsson, and F. Aviles, "Failure investigation of debonded sandwich columns: An experimental and numerical study," Journal of Mechanics of Materials and Structures, vol.
4, pp. 1469-1487, 2009.
[11] L. A. Carlsson and S. Prasad, "Interfacial fracture of sandwich beams,"
Engineering fracture mechanics, vol. 44, pp. 581-590, 1993.
[12] S. Pan, L. Z. Wu, and S. Y. Du, "Investigation of failure behavior in honeycomb sandwich panel containing interfacial debonding," 16th
international conference on composite materials, 2007.
[13] S. El-Sayed and S. Sridharan, "Performance of a cohesive layer model in the prediction of interfacial crack growth in sandwich beams," Journal of
Sandwich Structures and Materials, vol. 4, pp. 31-47, 2002.
[14] M. K. Yeh and Y. W. Chiu, "Finite Element Analysis of Centrally-Debonded Composite Sandwich Beam under Four Point Bending," Advanced Materials Research, vol. 335, pp. 351-354, 2011.
[15] A. Sheppard, D. Kelly, and L. Tong, "A damage zone model for the failure analysis of adhesively bonded joints," International journal of adhesion
and adhesives, vol. 18, pp. 385-400, 1998.
[16] J.-H. Park, J.-H. Choi, and J.-H. Kweon, "Evaluating the strengths of thick aluminum-to-aluminum joints with different adhesive lengths and thicknesses," Composite Structures, vol. 92, pp. 2226-2235, 2010.
[17] "ANSYS® Academic Research, Release 13.0, Help system," 2010.
[18] EVONIK, "ROHACELL WF Product Information,"
Website:http://www.rohacell.com/product/rohacell/en/products-services/ro hacell-wf/pages/default.aspx.
[19] Cytec, "FM® 73 Toughened Epoxy Film datasheet,"
Website:https://www.cytec.com/engineered-materials/products/FM%2073 .htm.
[20] 賴彥錕, "以實驗與模擬探討含脫層之複合材料三明治結構破壞行為,"
交通大學機械工程研究所論文, 2012.
[21] "ASTM C364 / C364M - 07 Standard Test Method for Edgewise Compressive Strength of Sandwich Constructions," 2007.
附表
表 2.1 單軸向碳纖維複合材料之材料性質
Young’s modulus Poisson’s ratio Shear modulus E11
表 2.3 含脫層之三明治結構實驗試片規格
Face-sheet laminate Face-sheet thickness (tf, mm)
Debond length (Ld, mm)
Specimen Buckling load (kN)
Failure load
(kN) Failure mode Specimen - 1 17.8 18.1
“Global buckling”
induce foam core failure Specimen - 2 18.1 18.5
Specimen - 3 18.1 18.4 Specimen - 4 17.8 18.1
Average 18.0 ± 0.2 18.3 ± 0.2
表 2.5 含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片實驗結果
Specimen Buckling load (kN)
Failure load
(kN) Failure mode Specimen - 1 3.4 8.0
“Local buckling” induce face-sheet and core
separation
Specimen Buckling load (kN)
Failure load
(kN) Failure mode Specimen - 1 3.4 7.7
“Local buckling” induce face-sheet and core
separation
表 2.7 [(0/90)2]S三明治試片之實驗結果 Debond
length(mm)
Buckling load (kN)
Failure load
(kN) Buckling mode Failure mode 0 18.0 ± 0.2 18.3 ± 0.2 Global Foam core
failure 10* 17.7 1.9 18.3 ± 1.6 Global
30* 10.8 0.4 12.7 ± 0.7 Local
Face-sheet and core separation 50* 4.6 0.8 8.0 ± 1.7 Local
60 3.6 ± 0.2 8.0 ± 0.6 Local 70 2.9 ± 0.6 7.7 ± 0.9 Local
*[20] 賴彥錕, "以實驗與模擬探討含脫層之複合材料三明治結構破壞行為," 交通大學機械工程研究所論文, 2012.
表 2.8 無脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片實驗結果
Specimen Buckling load (kN)
Failure load
(kN) Failure mode Specimen - 1 21.8 22.5
“Global buckling” induce foam core failure Specimen - 2 21.4 22.2
Specimen - 3 21.7 22.6 Average 21.6 ± 0.2 22.4 ± 0.2
表 2.9 含 10 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片實驗結果
Specimen Buckling load (kN)
Failure load
(kN) Failure mode Specimen - 1 20.9 22.3
“Global buckling” induce foam core failure Specimen - 2 21.0 21.8
Specimen - 3 21.4 22.4 Specimen - 4 22.1 22.7
Average 21.4 ± 0.7 22.3 ± 0.5
表 2.10 含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片實驗結果
Specimen Buckling load (kN)
Failure load
(kN) Failure mode Specimen - 1 8.8 13.4
“Local buckling” induce face-sheet and core
separation Specimen - 2 9.6 13.6
Specimen - 3 9.7 14.0 Specimen - 4 10.4 14.2
Average 9.6 ± 0.8 13.8 ± 0.4
表 2.11 含 70 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片實驗結果
Specimen Buckling load (kN)
Failure load
(kN) Failure mode Specimen - 1 8.7 12.1
“Local buckling” induce face-sheet and core
separation
Buckling load (kN)
Failure load
(kN) Buckling mode Failure mode 0 21.6 ± 0.2 22.4 ± 0.2 Global
Face-sheet and core separation 60 9.6 ± 0.8 13.8 ± 0.4 Local
70 8.0 ± 0.7 11.7 ± 0.5 Local
*[20] 賴彥錕, "以實驗與模擬探討含脫層之複合材料三明治結構破壞行為," 交通大學機械工程研究所論文, 2012.
表 2.13 不同脫層長度之[(0/90)2]S與[(0/90)3]S三明治試片實驗結果 Face-sheet
laminate
Debond length(mm)
Buckling load (kN)
Failure load
(kN) Buckling mode Failure mode
[(0/90)2]S
Critical buckling load (kN)
Buckling load (Exp.) (kN)
表 3.2 挫屈分析與實驗結果之比較 Face-sheet
laminate
Debond
length(mm) Imperfection
Buckling load (kN) Element size
(mm)
Critical buckling load (kN)
Failure area (mm2)
0.4 7.28 2.65
0.2 7.27 2.45
0.1 7.26 2.47
0.05 7.26 2.47
表 3.4 分析步數收斂性
Step number Buckling load (kN)
70 5.09
100 5.06
200 5.06
表 3.5 含 50 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片破壞區域臨界值 Face-sheet
laminate
Debond length (mm)
Failure load (Exp.) (kN)
Critical damage zone size Element amount Area (mm2) [(0/90)2]S 50 8.0 ± 1.7 242 2.47
表 3.6 [(0/90)2]S三明治試片破壞強度預估結果
Debond
length (mm) Imperfection
Failure load
(kN) Buckling
mode
Initial failure position Analysis Exp.
0 0.01 % 17.6(39˚) 18.3 ± 0.2(43.2˚) Global Intermediate of upper and lower half
core 10 0.1 % 17.6(-) 18.3 1.6(47.5˚) Global
10 -0.1 % 17.6(40˚) 18.3 1.6(47.5˚) Global
30 3 % 13.0 12.7 0.7 Local
Core failure near the
length (mm) Imperfection
Failure load
(kN) Buckling
mode
Initial failure position Analysis Exp.
0 0.3 % 23.7(40˚) 22.4 ± 0.2(43.8˚) Global Intermediate of upper and lower half
core 10 0.3 % 23.6(-) 22.3 ± 0.5(47˚) Global
10 -0.3 % 23.7(40˚) 22.3 ± 0.5(47˚) Global
30 0.5 % 21.6 21.7 ± 0.2 Global
Core failure near the
附圖
圖 2.1 試片基本尺寸示意圖
Clamped region 10
Foam core Face-sheet
Clamped region Gauge length
120 10
14
Ld
Unit:mm tf
Gauge-A
Gauge-B Gauge-A Debond region
10 mm
圖 2.3 無脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片負載與應變響應圖
-0.004 -0.002 0 0.002
0
Strain gauge - A Strain gauge - B
Failure load
圖 2.5 無脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片破壞行為
Crack
Clamped range
Clamped range
Crack path
圖 2.7 無脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片破壞情形 Core
Glue
Failure load
Local buckling
o a
b c
d
Strain
L o a d (k N )
-0.0040 -0.002 0 0.002 0.004
2 4 6 8 10 12 14
Strain gauge - A(debond) Strain gauge - B
圖 2.9 含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片破壞行為((a)局部挫屈 (b)試片 一端先行破壞 (c)試片完全破壞)
(a) (b) (c)
Displacement (mm)
Load(kN)
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Failure load
圖 2.11 含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片破壞裂紋路徑((a)整體裂紋路 徑 (b)脫層尖端裂紋路徑)
圖 2.12 含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90) ] 三明治試片破壞情形
Clamped region
X=30 Debond
region
Clamped region X
Y
Face-sheet Core
(a)
(b) Ld=60 mm
Core
Glue Debond region
圖 2.13 含 70 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片負載與應變響應圖
圖 2.14 含 70 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片破壞裂紋路徑((a)整體裂紋路 徑 (b)脫層尖端裂紋路徑)
Strain
L o a d (k N )
-0.002 0 0.002 0.004
0
Strain gauge - A(debond) Strain gauge - B
Failure load
圖 2.15 無脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片負載與應變響應圖
圖 2.16 無脫層之[(0/90) ] 三明治試片破壞行為
Failure load Global buckling
ab
o c
Strain
L o a d (k N )
-0.004 -0.002 0 0.002
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Strain gauge - A Strain gauge - B
Crack
-0.0060 -0.004 -0.002 0 0.002 0.004 5
Strain gauge - A (debond) Strain gauge - B
圖 2.19 含 10 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片破壞行為
圖 2.20 含 10 mm 脫層之[(0/90) ] 三明治試片破壞裂紋路徑 Crack
Clamped range
Clamped range Crack path
L
d=10 mm
圖 2.21 含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片負載與應變響應圖
圖 2.22 含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片破壞行為((a)局部挫屈 (b)表 層與芯材分離)
Strain
L o a d (k N )
-0.0040 -0.002 0 0.002 0.004
5 10 15 20 25
Strain gauge - A(debond) Strain gauge - B
Failure load
Local buckling
ab
o
c
(a) (b)
圖 2.23 含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片破壞裂紋路徑((a)整體裂紋路 徑 (b)脫層尖端裂紋路徑)
圖 2.24 含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90) ] 三明治試片破壞情形
Clamped region
Clamped region Debond region
Ld=60 mm
Core
X=30
X Y
Face-sheet
(a)
(b)
Core
Glue
Debond
region
圖 2.25 含 70 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片負載與應變響應圖
圖 2.26 含 70 mm 脫層之[(0/90) ] 三明治試片破壞行為((a)局部挫屈 (b)表
Strain
L o a d (k N )
-0.002 0 0.002
0 5 10 15 20
Strain gauge - A (debond) Strain gauge - B
Failure load
Local buckling
ab
o
c
(b) (a)
圖 2.27 含 70 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片破壞裂紋路徑((a)整體裂紋路
Debond length (mm)
L o a d (k N )
圖 3.1 挫屈之負載與位移關係圖
P
cr Bifurcation pointLoad
Limit point
Displacement
Nonlinear analysisLinear buckling analysis
Linear buckling analysis - get the 1
stbuckling mode shape
Use the mode shape to give the imperfection into the original shape
Nonlinear analysis - large geometry deflection
Get the buckling solution
Use damage zone method and maximum
principal strain criterion to predict the failure load
圖 3.3 缺陷定義示意圖
圖 3.4 有限元素模型網格示意圖((a)模型整體網格示意圖 (b)脫層尖端網格 局部放大圖)
Face-sheet
Foam core
e
maxt
f(a)
10 mm
3 mm Face-sheet
Foam core
Debonded region
(b)
圖 3.5 邊界條件示意圖
圖 3.6 無脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治結構第一挫屈模態變形圖
Face-sheet
Foam core
Displacement controlled (UY=0)
Debond region
Y
X Clamped boundary condition:
UX = UY = 0
Face-sheet
Foam core
圖 3.7 含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治結構第一挫屈模態變形圖
圖 3.8 不同缺陷之負載與應變響應圖(無脫層之[(0/90) ] 三明治試片)
Face-sheet
Foam
core L
d=60 mm
Strain of X direction
L o a d (k N )
-0.0030 -0.002 -0.001 0 0.001 0.002 0.003
5 10 15 20 25
FEM (r = 0.01%) FEM (r = 0.1%) FEM (r = 0.5%) Exp.
圖 3.9 無脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片變形圖
圖 3.10 不同缺陷之負載與應變響應圖(含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試 片)
Face-sheet
Foam core
Strain of X direction
L o a d (k N )
-0.0020 -0.001 0 0.001 0.002 0.003 0.004 2
4 6 8 10 12
FEM (r = 0.5%) FEM (r = 1%) FEM (r = 5%) FEM (r = 9%) Exp.
圖 3.11 含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片變形圖
圖 3.12 不同缺陷之負載與應變響應圖(含 70 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試 片)
Face-sheet
Foam
core L
d=60 mm
Strain of X direction
L o a d (k N )
-0.0020 -0.001 0 0.001 0.002 0.003 0.004 2
4 6 8 10 12
FEM ( r = 0.5%) FEM (r = 1%) FEM (r = 5%) FEm (r = 12%) Exp.
圖 3.13 含 70 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片變形圖
圖 3.14 不同缺陷之負載與應變響應圖(無脫層之[(0/90) ] 三明治試片)
Face-sheet
Foam
core L
d=70 mm
Strain of X direction
L o a d (k N )
-0.0030 -0.002 -0.001 0 0.001 0.002 0.003 5
10 15 20 25 30 35
FEM (r = 0.3%) FEM (r = 1%) FEM (r = 5%) Exp.
圖 3.15 無脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片變形圖
圖 3.16 不同缺陷之負載與應變響應圖(含 10 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試 片,缺陷值為正值)
Face-sheet
Foam core
Strain of X direction
L o a d (k N )
-0.0030 -0.002 -0.001 0 0.001 0.002 0.003 5
10 15 20 25 30 35
FEM (r = 0.3%) FEM (r = 1%) FEM (r = 5%) Exp.
圖 3.17 含 10 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片變形圖(缺陷值為 0.3%)
圖 3.18 不同缺陷之負載與應變響應圖(含 10 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試 片,缺陷值為負值)
Face-sheet
Foam core
Ld=10 mm
Strain of X direction
L o a d (k N )
-0.0030 -0.002 -0.001 0 0.001 0.002 0.003 5
10 15 20 25 30 35
FEM (r = -0.3%) FEM (r = -1%) FEM (r = -5%) Exp.
圖 3.19 含 10 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片變形圖(缺陷值為-0.3%)
圖 3.20 不同缺陷之負載與應變響應圖(含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試 片)
Ld=10 mm Face-sheet
Foam core
Strain of X direction
L o a d (k N )
-0.0020 -0.001 0 0.001 0.002 0.003 0.004 5
10 15 20 25
FEM (r = 1%) FEM (r = 3%) FEM (r = 5%) FEM (r = 10%) Exp.
Strain of X direction
L o a d (k N )
-0.002 -0.001 0 0.001 0.002 0.003
0
Debond length (mm)
Imperfection(%)
圖 3.25 破壞強度預估流程圖
圖 3.26 含 50 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片主應變分布圖((a)整體試片 (b) 脫層尖端區域)
Analyze the model under experiment failure load
Use max. principal strain criterion to decide the critical damage zone
Use the critical damage zone to predict the failure load Chose one of the experiment data
[(0/90)2]s face-sheet , Ld= 50 mm
Exp. failure load = 8.0 kN
The break strain of foam core is 0.03
Failure
(a)
(b) Ld=50 mm
圖 3.27 含 50 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片破壞情形[20]
圖 3.28 無脫層之[(0/90) ] 三明治試片預估結果((a)主應變分布圖 (b)主應變
Failure
Failure Face-sheet
Foam coreCore Face-sheet
Principal strain direction
Crack direction
(a)
(b)
圖 3.29 含 10 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片破壞情形[20]
圖 3.30 含 10 mm 脫層之[(0/90) ] 三明治試片主應變分布圖(模型朝含脫層
Crack
Debond region
(a)
(b)
L
d=10 mm
Failure Failure
Failure area > critical damage zone
圖 3.31 含 10 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片預估結果(朝無脫層方向翹屈) ((a)試片主應變分布圖 (b)脫層尖端主應變分布圖 (c)主應變方向分布圖)
Failure area < critical damage zone
Failure
(a)
(b) Failure
Principal strain direction
Core
Crack direction
(c)
圖 3.32 含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90)2]S三明治試片預估結果((a)試片主應變分布 圖 (b)脫層尖端主應變分布圖)
圖 3.33 無脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片預估結果((a)主應變分布圖 (b)主應變
Failure area > critical damage zone
Ld=60 mm
Failure Failure
(a)
(b)
Failure
Failure Foam core Face-sheet
Core Face-sheet
Principal strain direction
Crack direction
(b)
(a)
圖 3.34 含 10 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片主應變分布圖(模型朝含脫層 側表層翹屈)
Failure area > critical damage zone
Failure
圖 3.35 含 10 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片預估結果(朝無脫層方向翹屈) ((a)試片主應變分布圖 (b)脫層尖端主應變分布圖 (c)主應變方向分布圖)
Failure
Failure
(a)
Failure area < critical damage zone
(b)
Principal strain direction
Core
Crack direction
(c)
圖 3.36 含 30 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片破壞裂紋路徑[20]
圖 3.37 含 30 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片預估結果((a)試片主應變分布 圖 (b)脫層尖端主應變分布圖)
Clamped range
Clamped range Crack path
Ld=30 mm
X Y
L
d=30 mm
Failure Failure
(a)
(b)
Failure area > critical damage zone
圖 3.38 含 60 mm 脫層之[(0/90)3]S三明治試片預估結果((a)試片主應變分布 圖 (b)脫層尖端主應變分布圖)
L
d=60 mm
Failure Failure
(a)
(b)
Failure area > critical damage zone