臺灣國際政治研究之發展：臺灣國際政治研究方法之反思

全文

(1)162. ;!t.lij;Jf~EASTASIANSTUDTES 2007.if-lfl ~"::'+A~~-,JIij. F1 ill WI ~iBciftliJf~ z lift *. -,,3!f)( Fowler, F. G., H. W. Fowler, and R. E. Allen eds., The Pocket Oxjbrd Dictionary (Oxford, U.K.: Oxford University Press, 1984). Gove, Philip Babcock and Merriam-Webster Inc., Webster's Third New International Dictionary (unabridged) (Springfield, Massachusetts, U.S.A ... Merriam-Webster, 1986). Hoogensen, Gunhild, International Relations, Security and Jeremy Bentham (Oxford, U.K.: Routledge, 2005).. ~~f't=4§-:. E-mail: [email protected]. B M : 2006/9/] 1 lIB!till!~. : 2006111/20. JHf~.. : j.l(~~. 18.-;t:.fiftlll.~IIU.~. Wf~.. ~~-;t:.~~~~~~~.~. .m~. ~)t:t-;t:..~s:2iiff~pffiil1j.~. ltX II1i. ~)S*".UlmiH~Pffifu~.B! 1Ii3:§ J1tJ';r20061f,5 fj 30 8. Jl&m*~~I~HJ~~~'±JlJfz. r lili!i~_mliJf:[email protected].!.Wi. \lIII!.J ~~liJfl\M*t:pi3'it!t1f!lii~~Z.1J'lH3t*J?g. 0.

(2) 165. PJij f¥ (?II ~ IDJ ~ liJf~ ~ OCJ~ fi!1t tfl :ff,'&-;~. ~~**~IiI'I~;,j'i:IllIj~fllt. ~. " ~lIJliJF:9CJ7g~Eru&J~W1:!:~ ~~[ijJ{j(d'~ -r~1'f.~l¥1~f4. '. m{~(t]~~lHlf*~~*J:.:JI::-. M~~nM~.Rl¥1~~'~~~l¥1.HJ:.:'~~IHl~·~~.~ R~~• • ,mm~m*m~ffi[ijJ~~l¥1~~'~~~=OO~~~ '=~ • • m5~~.~~~.5ffilHll¥1.a,. ~:fjpJT~lin. 0. 11~~ , ~T5}1frl¥11ff£ ' ~;;$:J: ' 5'&lWi!ll;=~U9~. ~.~*X.g1B'j ~~IHl{*~~iIiB.. 0. ~.A~m~~~IHl~~~.al¥1~$~~IHl~~~'. PI t)Jf!~n 19301'f.Lf.:J'¥~~ilitR~1:fLf.:J::k:J£Xm~ft1:~mPi-~~{j}Ml '. 2.. ~~~U9Pi-~~~~~~~ • • 5I~A~~~,m~~~~ft1:~. ~PI~~m~~~[ijJ~~~~~~l¥1m~w· 19501'f.{~tJ1&. '. i:l~~*~~1Gft1:rm~~~IHl{*fFilUJf4~. 1'f.j(&is*~m:ft1:~ill¥1 Pi-:x~. , 1955. , PX.J1./f!; 19471'f.U9tl.*~ilitis~~. ~~~~IHl{*mlHlll*f~ , 19631'f.tl*ilitis~~m~~IHl~m 3~~ 0. 1UJ~~#.U9~~·~-MMl_~~A.J1.l¥1~~~~~.m~~ ./f!;j(&m~r'Jl"l¥1·r~14!f4. '. ~,JtMtl'T.Jm. '. illf~U9.~f:tlJa:i. 1. K. J. Hoisti, International Politics: A Framework for Analysis, 4th cd. (Englewood. Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall Inc., 1983), pp.19~20. 2. r ~m:frlW:l J ' ir~5~*tJ!9i-5c!'j!~lIIilO c < http://diplomacy.nccu.edu.tw/chlindex .asp?address=introd&etitle=introd I > 3. r *~ft!j:fr J ' #.*tJ!i&~~!'j!~lIIilO" < http://politics.soc.ntu.edu.tw/about_OI.htm >. ..

(3) 166. ~.~f.lli:~n:tJ!tE. 0. -Ei'_~f4*IY-J~r~5tmcp. ~~~~r~rlY-J--m5t~~W. :fr~*M?~~±*. 1m. f; J,f ~ 1'1iHtia ~ ~.t:i- .ft. .i.52.~~EAST AsIAN STUDIES 2007.!f-ljj jj!;:::.. +A~jj!;-.)IJj. ~ ~is ~ 1963 if.. '. , ~~IHI~~IH'Fmif)a5. ~J$~9.. '. *~IY-J:tJ!1-\;;~~lmf*~~~~mWili5t~. 167. , 1980if.{-\;;. ~1&~~IY-J.f$jttWJm~tt • • '~~W:fr.~~~*·~.ffij. 0. 1950if.{-\;;J...~1&t:j:l~*M?IY-J~~IHI{*~r']fjt. '*~~~~~~~Im{*.r~~i&.'[j:~~.~' ~f$j'[j:~~.. nt 111l ~ 91-111 r~~ B fi1f ~ tr-J ~i. ~,.~m~iIi5t~'.~Jm~~~.~·~5t*~~.Im~.~~. ,~~~~*~~~a~. M'*~~~.Im~m~.*~m.~r~.~J~~'~~~.. ~. ... ~ IY-J IUJ. 9C r. ~'~.~~H~~~~~~.~~. ::-f3&! ' tlD*Jiit~~IY-J~]![ , 1950if.r:f:t~ A'§;*~1J.I!!B~mYl-5c:~ , 1955if.tEcp~Am*~Yl-5c:~IY-J~~ 1: ' ~:tt:7Y1-x~~ 5tE~ftlY-J~~l.f:n¥~~1: ' *~~~IHI{~~. IY-JJm~tlI~. ~tJ.1Iii:U=IY-J~~lHIf*~~m. ~~~ffl@1JJm~~r:f:t~YI-~mlm • •~fl~1JlID~~.om.a. ~ax~~~~at5~. 0. 0. J:\ '. ,~~a~~~IJ~*~~t5tIY-J:±:~ID. a~~&:{¥UPlGY~~IHI{*~~r~lY-J-m~~r~ ~~tHlf*Hiff~tE~f¥1"r::-f[qJlY-JfjtJ.m. 1J.I!!tE*~II%;f5(:~]I~~IHI~~f3IHI~r~. TS9!:&.m ±. ' £*1: '. ~f¥tE1950if.f-\;;. 0. .W.1JOO'fi:fr*.IY-J~~ili~'::-f~.Yl-xy:IY-J.~'*~'. .~fDuff~1J~if1~r<:l']mlY-Jm¥~. Q. 9. ~.~~.Im~~~~ • • ~W~~~~~~*~~,~j!£fl. , f.§ -rm~f1s9~J.m~J....:J,..~ A. [email protected]$jIDH~. '. 9f..~Y:. '. ~~r*. '. ~~Ifif*7t;j:ff. , M-'FWI-Ei'. .~~H~~~~±~@~'±~~.~a~.*~.ffltt• •W ~m:±:. 0. OO§'*~~~Im~~~• •~.~~YI-~H~~~*·m~YI-*. 0. 0. tEuff~lY-JiIfil~:i]1:. , ~&~-~iftJCtt~~~1J$ 81£Yl-xa~~~1Jffi1 ' * _.~Bmili.*.~IY-JG1fB~ , ¥,f5JU*1990if.{-\;;r:f:tMtJ.* ' ::-f~lfli~. *.JJlIDlY-Juff~~IJj!Mr~.t]~iEjc~~*IY-J~~. g;t~f$jIY-JW~ffij~. 1m{*liff~IY-JJm~W1Jr*. 0. , -Ei'.1:E1970if.{-\;;rm~f1j!~~91jj!g§1J~~ ' -·fj:t~~~~~-Ei' ' 91~~~~~1HI{*,~. , uff~IY-J~*.~ , lIDrtl~~~5E • 1t~1~~ .~~.§CIY-J~~mI{*Jm~lflilY-J~~ , 1E!.-Er• •~~B9Imlt§1J~ m~~~· • • ·Jm~'Mftmlm~.Im~~~o ::-f~'l£~~IY-J±m1JOO'~.1JOOj!• • ~r:f:t~Im~· -Ei'1m~IY-JW~'*~1JiIfiIY-JW~~.~IJj!.~ommtt.~~'.. ~ti.i&N~~~~~~~~'~~if.*'a.~~IHI~~~~ili. ~JJ$WJm~'~~T-Ei'_~~H~~~W~~~~1J~*IY-J~. ~j!~lIX1Jfluff~IY-J:::t.. ~'W~IY-J • • ·±.~~.*.~~~~~lmm~~~.·. .~.. r:f:t~*~s9~1m~~~lJtEa~~~:ru!~lY-Jfliti~r. '. '. fE!.~~;tk:'-t!tW.liff~. , W*.~lll±. ' 1J.I!!.tt. £flWl~uff~. fi~a.~*m:±:'-~~~.~@1J~~~~Im~m~~.f$j~ ~o. 6.. *Ett.. ,r~A.li1fH6/H5:lll!.iliili1tt::if.§r:p~~~/i,\I~lll!.~lfIit¥Jli1f9'l:~~~J' {2:.i\t' lim fIi~Mr:J:lIllIiIIlll!IiRJ~i!ialiJf~ (~~* : ~$H:\Fthi)jl± '. $iE~ , fJ~niWWd1 ±~ 1999) , J'i[26. lUlifilil '. ,. 0. 4. ~"1''W! ' r r:pml~~j!j\(i'ti*~f4~~B"J@]iIl!li:!!GP~ J ~~IWl (20051f.lfl)' J!if1-6. '. )iijifiiitl:..~~ (111m) , ~13. 0. 5. ~III r0Jffir:p~~~r~~.Mili:lJl ~i1±:~wt:j.Jml7l-5t.JJ .:f:E':pmlAR*~H~1j,fr J . r:J:l1II A ~ :*!!J! IIIIIlI! IM1 f~ ~ Il!i1! 1Ill'ili < http://sis.mc.edu.cnlnews/shownews.asp? newsid=288> ; r ~1lJt.bi'. J ' 9i-~~1l!i1!1Ill'ili < http://www.cfau.edu.cnlcoillindex. html?id=l> 0. 0. 7. ~1II~v~ , r ~~i!DI:i'ti~:tEr:pmI-.fl}~mI~i!DI:i'ti~lll!.~lfIil¥J r tF ml¥.J 13 .JJJ ' IIIlIlI!iEll ~€:iiJf~ U~:ijO ' 1997¥f;lHWI ( 1997if,2F1 ) , ~1-9 ' 8. ~fl!;l~iTI:!~ , r r:pmI/lfJ~ID1{*li1f9'l:~lft J ' r:J:l1II1II1M11':£*I < http://irchina.orglxueke/ inchinalgaikuangl view.asp'?id=8> ; ~iiF:I± ' r ~mlmI~IUl~~;f4~Jmff:tEB"Ji'i'fru'J lil J ' r:J:lIIIIIIU:f:£*I < http://irchinaorglxueke/inchina/gaikuanglview.asp?id=13 > 9. ~ii"' iIIlH~1I ,rl1fJ~~*1tRi!!IJFt¥J*ml7l-5tJ' .-&tIl' ~IiOO±~ , :*1iI9i ~ : i!ia . ~~m tlt!!l!i U~Jt.: : ~$H:\!t&lit ' 2003) , ~l Q. 0. .. 0.

(4) -. .... "\!o.-:>(". -r.t"J. t;';';f~l!t.lI1)a'lt~~itJll. " ~/ijjlVf~1i$®&J~.t!fiUt~. ftffl~nmr'~~m~W~n~~~~~~ffl~~~~~, J1it~fi/tiffl~ff9mljBWn1:!~ifD nlID ' -][ mfl~¥1:.mff9WII. 0. -~~x.ft~nffl~m±~•• ~~·. ~1I*:w' tJ~.W~.~~f*ffl7'G~¥tlg§n.J'ii.~~.' ~~~~~7M~~~~'~~Wg§hm~~~I~~~Tm~. - " Ii)f~l¥JmlJe. ~n.oili'±:~~~.J1it~.~~.~m.~.Wg§h~?iJf~'~. 1£ffl~ff9mfliBJ: ' tJ~ff9~~ffl~f:f~iff'F#f:a:ff9ij IlH:.t1:;"15m ·'~~~·~*·ff9~~~'.*fflf:f~fi(~~W)~ffl~'. ~#.~~~~~ffl~~X.§c~fi~o. ~m~ij l~m-=¥ff9.~ , ~w!/f;),* ' tJ_~~1:E~~~f*~ffl~t ,. ~5m.][~ij Iffl[§j:f~~ff9~ifD~ , ][~~fljV§n~~~ffl~mG. ~·~~ff9~~V§n(Mm.~.).~~ffl~~mfliB:a:'~m.. ~W~~ff9'±:tlif:f~. 'Ilf!M*~fl~?iJf~~~$Uj8aar~m1fjU ' ±~~f;),~~?iJf~W ft.~oo. '1£?iJf~ff9mmJ:~*~~ffl~• • ff9.~~~M A ' ~}e~~~ , .:£~*JI~,tm~:p..~1f!W!/*~.~ij IJin~'i*3j.~Ill-* '~~~~ff9?iJf~~·1£~~~~ff9~~J:'~~~'~OOft.. ~~~~?iJf7l:1ilq,. 0. aJl1$;:M1B!:~1~ , *~~fliJEf~.uq'/j:~~~X~W~f'Fttf:g.. , ~ff7~:g..~.uqmfB ' :::f~ , {11flffl1it~~~f'F:g..I§*~'Ernft::l .*~~gM'~ ••~m~~fflf:f~fi~ffl~o.~~~m_~ f:f*~>i-3tft.~fI}R~~~m1ilffii~~1RJi:ttm*U;g;-r:!ff9~f'F ' lO. @~~~*f:f~*ff9~~$ftf:m±. 0. 1£?iJf~.~~ij Iffl1.fUii ' *~~Im.:W-MBrfflM:rg I~fRj n.51 ff9~ifD~ , fI!.±:~mf;),~~~f'Fm± ' ][~ij Iffl~n.~iff'F ' m1l1 ~1jS:f#Jt&f~HHiIHt*~¥il!f1fJf=B~ iJl!:Ili!fJWtf:! cp;tt.:9j. X:iiX~!l!f tiFF raJEt-JltJl ' ~ ~. :9j.~i&~ ~ , , 1fu)RfItl1:±~ , iii:t1U;I¥~q~* t!t~ti!~ • ~JlJltllli-if! (J:ffl1 : J:ffl1AWtiill!iiit!± . 1991) , 1'i. , r cP 1lIItt:7 W_j§jjlJ.!J. (1949-1989) . 521-525 0. *~~.~liJf:1'C~Ijt§mJre?v~1!!£ .:lJl~1fjU*~f. '. ' 1:Eftm , 1ff:g..fjj!t~~~. ' *~. WllR~.I&1~~!gM. ' ~mmtl r~q::g..iiJf7~~OO~. ~~~1'~~JtlJ1!~fi~:g..5C~Wft*~ifH~. 0. ="J!I!lffiUl¥JJ!!ffl. 0. *~·~f:f~~~~~~*~~*rm~m~tt~~~~. 10.. 10';1. t:t.~.W'~:iV~g§1f~~filG'mfB. ' ~~¥tlg§n.P1ijgJlifB~fm. iiJf~~~.'~~g§n.~~~~JIifB~~~o~.'£*J:~~~. ' ~*I.~f;),g Iftg§1f:f!fl~ifDm.±: ' *B-ft~~ifH '• • R~ • • ~.~.~'~ • • • :f!fl.~.~J!I!_~ •• ~~ ffitIm1*~J!I!~ifD~fflhiID. yo ~.'lli~*tJ".~~~m~1:EJ!I!.~~ffl1fiIDB.~~'. ' -*PJfig~~~Ntt::-tJ.~~ .~m'-*~~~~~~.~~~~~tt ••~1'~'ffl~mtt fI!~~JtbiJ.~~~ifD~ifD~mfi::lt1fiUI3N'ti. ~3i:!i~~o. 1f!M*~.Wr~.J~.~Wg§1f:::f~I*~.~mM~g. .±~~m~3tft •• W-Bmm~.'ffl~m.~3tfim,' Wg§h~~reg.~mM.m.~~m~ffi1'~':f!fl.mMm. tt,::ltrftm~.J~m.,~~,*~.~.~~~g.~:g..~. .~h~~~. ••~'~~J:'~#~~~.~~.M~~'~~. m~ffi~.H~~.fB.~~~~~o ll. ~:Z'I*~~~IAIf*~~-lm.illlrJi!ftl~~IAIf*l!l!~ifUlf,'f~1f:&*· ~~lAIf*,l!l!~Et-J1§~ rn~m~~ flHI~m~:9j.~if!I!IJ' ~j,!JJ:rnHp~~IAIf*~W1~' 1lmI~lUIiRii!~ic}]~( J: 'Ifj : J:ffl1;l1!-jffi~Wllill.&;f!± ' 1991) . E5-7 0.

(5) 168. --. -*-Q~~EASTASIANSTUDIES 2007.1f-1Jljf;'=:'TA~jf;-JIiJ. ~;tfIilll~M3f;~~.t..1fAl. ~IIHiJf~1ii*B"1&:J~W.l:t;~. ~1:Jm-=¥~~j'iJ[6j.~filiJf~.±:l¥J.~~&·. 1±liJf~1:J1tU_:: ' t:J'.E13Ii$'Wg§1:J:fJlft~~ 1m{~liJf~~!WL~"f. '. • • •liJf~~m.W1:J$.1:JOO'-n.fi~~m~~ ••. • • *~·Ei'• • W-l¥J.~Im~liJf~~~g§1:J~W-l¥J~.·~ ~~.~~~7liJf~l¥J~~·~~Wg§1:JliJf~.!WL'&~~7liJf~ l¥J~.·m±:.l¥J~._m.Ii$'~.~m..~~W~1:Jl¥JliJf~·~. -- fiW1'cl¥Jn=lfB 1±liJf~l¥JmiiliJ: ' Ei'tII~~lmliJf~tMli$'~{'Fm:itl¥Jij litj::t~iJ~ ~ , ~~jjiJljfJ[6j.*~~~/Cft ' ~*fl3!J~1la (~::tlla) ~liJf~ , J!m.~ij lifr~~~"=¥~jfJ[6j. , ~Wlt),* ' Ei'.~*1:E~~lmf*~liJf~. 1: ' JriJ~~][f~ij Im[f.i1:J~~l¥J.~ , n~~~[f.i1:J~~l¥JliJf~J:& ·J!~l¥J~Ug§1:J(M~~~~)'~l¥JliJf~~ • • :it,~• • ~Wt;lJm~±:jm~j~. 169. ~Ei'.l¥J~~Im~liJf~.~~~al¥J.~· *gl¥J~lmliJf~~~amW~~'j'iml¥Jnm~MM'1:Ea~ .jJtl¥JiM~r. . &~*U T~~liJf~l¥JlIDrtJ '. m:~~~l¥J • •. ' :kg. ~~~~~Bffl~~~~~~~.J[6j.*.~·. ='m!~l¥Jimm El.~~W-~m.ff~[f.i1J~~filiijm • . &~¥tlg§11 ~fi\tJ!!I!.~fM. 0. *g~ tMli$'~~Im~l¥JliJf~~*LmUm~ttl¥J.~ ~'~M*g#lmliJf~~~~a~J:~~M'±:.~U.~liJf~W am~~.::t'1±liJf~~a~J:&*R~m • • • l¥J~.~~m :it ' mJ~I,~#: ' ~~]*L'!l,~~----¥~£f!M*g.:~g IffljfJ[6j.l¥JutE--*. iiff~l¥J~Yi. '. .~g§1:J~~Im{~fJ!l.~lfIr&~¥. •. ~*J:fJ1B:~. ~'~~Im~l¥JliJf~~~1±~~~~l¥J~~1:'UM~'~~am. . *a~!!I!~lfIr W.R~ • • ~ • • ~&'~~~~!!I!.~t;l.!!I!.l¥J • • &~ & ~.'lli~*El• • ~Im~liJf~~!!I!.l¥J.ffl1100B.~~·. .::t.l¥JliJf~1:JrtJ·. {1~i~~1.\[jj)f~~!!I!.~lfIr~mfi1t{~~'~ '-*PJfJ!Hf::~IlNIi$'t:J'.~~. ~¥R~U.'*~A~mR~.tt~.l¥J~.W.~~~. &fi7.~l¥J • • m.·~.'m~ffi.~l¥J~~~~*gg1:J~ tt*1Jut),!!I!M ' ~~~J:l.tJ:t*U~;fl3tM~.l¥JliJf~ _lMH'~&l:tW[. ~:I1hf:i'L. !j*g'1-x:am~mg~¥~m~lffffA~&~,tJ:t*U~$~.f'F ' 11I::t.~*!j~~l¥J.~${tf:.::t •. ilIfB::t~~.)7t-XamtliH:I:1-~,~,~~!Jl ' Jf:It),m~'1--xffa ' Llilt. 10. 1±liJf~j'iJ[6j.l¥J ij Iffl:JJffij , *g~Im.W-lMrB RMlij I~ g§1:J ~W-. l¥J~lfIr~ . 11I::t.mt)'lIm~'~f'F.±: '. Ifflg§1:J~~.f'F ' ~fIl. 10. 2~1fimt'&1!tfI$7}*~~'1lf1lf!M'B~*fl-1Wll¥J cp~:9l-5a&wm.:±FffciJl¥J~3i! ' ~ OO~5il ' r cplm!JEf-J IF -~ff~.!1 :9l-3i::i&ffi J ' ~}iSUE ' -®li:tffct~ , iitl:.lil~~P.G* ~ (1949-1989) • ti!:WM!j\' . lm~fDl1lt~ (J:#jj :trtiAf\;.t!:\llJjijfr , 1991) , ~ 521-5250. ~1m~~W~lfIriJ!ffl1:JOO. 0. '. '. ~* J:~t)' ij Ifr~1:JW~lfIra ±:. -*~IJ~:El.tMli$'~~Im{~l¥Jrmr:tJQ.m:Mz/f'~. I¥J:5[ti~y. , liJf~1!Ut. 0. ¥M*g~w-r. J~.~Wg§:JJ~~,*g'.mM~g. .g§11,~re~.~.M • • ~~~$fim/f'~'!!I!.~Am~ tt,1tra~~~J~m~·~ilt,*g~W-~~Im~!!I!.~~~. .W1:J~~!!I!.M~'~~1:'$~~'1--x.~l¥J.~~~' fl&:I:!!1pJTfJg~il1l¥J F",'• •IIIJt! ~¥tl~Mf!itl. 0. 11. ~~*~!!!1!I~lml'*~'1lf'@:~m.jLJ~~Imf;1\m!~il'Jfl1!1lf~* ' [I!l~lml,*m!~l¥J§~ r,-,'~~~m :3~J~~:9l-3i::fi!Ii!J' ~r:l!lt.#jjm[l!l~Imf;1\':!I!1!r~' I;jll*fDl1ltl!~*,m~( :Um:9l-il8f;iCf\l'-H:IIlJji~± ' 1991)' ~5-7 '. #jj. 1::.. '..

(6) 170 ~52.i1f:JtEASTASIANSTUDlES. 20071J'.lfl. jp;-=-+At-~-Jt!J. * ~f:f g:Ef:1:i ~ ~ g f* ~f$J'I~tliJf?i:: 1: ~ ~ 1)'£ I 980fF1~ ~. lIt)i. ,. ~S ' 12*~~Jf-!t1~~rurf*~f-j.((~uJf?i::W~i1rE±~~tEcj(?fi~n1tt) f&;t~~f!Fj.!¥1~JN ' ::f~ , E8~S'ifrdl~~ , f,'.J'*1J~~JL"~76!JrHJ~ 1iJf?i::11*. 13. 0. ± lilt¥; uJf?i:: ~£~W~IfE~fJttl'9 flttl f-rlif5 ~.*~~ Jf- f:f. m~rurf*~8~tl'91iJf?I'C. ~;'If ~ ~j!{{i(;i1f :Jt.:t1i: JIl. ff;- .. ~f),£~*flJ~.t~i:F¥ '*~~iflJtf:fji..J&m'. 0. .1I*~'~W1:E~~rurffi~.I¥J1iJf?i::fi~:1tOO~tt·~.:Jj OO.fj~~.I¥J~.~.w."'m~~.~~~a~m • •fJtl¥J~ • . :;1';;~m~m~rurf*~. *~~IJIl§11&a?E1.fJtl¥Jflttlif8 . f:f~g:Ef :1:i~.I¥J.m~.'H~~m~~~~~B:Jjt¥;Je(m'mm.'~76 ~'§:Jjt¥;~~~8~:ir&m 1: ' ~~$UJe(~t¥;flttlif8 ' , *~I¥Jl!m~;ti!! f1LtIi!JtW.jft¥;m~1:iItJlj!£~ . f:f*~!¥1~~rurf*~8~m~tIi!f;\t:r 0. Xl ~1¥J*~ji..~'§ ~lli1f*;:gllil\1Ji~q:~@]t!~Al¥Jiff'F '. 14;:g~. *~~:W-f§Mm~:ir&fJ1-1;;~ Jl. 0. !5tE0'i:1:i~f$j:fijg[*~. ,*. ~.~H~m~m~.m·me~~tE~~~.~± • • • ~D~ 1:~.:ir&:Jjrt:u. '. ~~t] 1~0'i:1:i~.l!1!.WiiJf~Jji*. 1iJf?i::~rAJ~W~7L1t;. .. 3iS.m~Hf*. 0. 1:E1iJf?i:::Jj$:1:iOO'*~.H~W;:g~~fi~1iJf~~~' fi~.:ir&tt~~·mlli~*.~.fj~~.m.ft;1iJf?i::Jj$~ff~fi. 1iJf?i:: . m - • •Ml:t.::f~$U.W~ ~. 0. " jlIijJ¥ml~JHiJF~B~JWJ* ~mm~.~rurffi1iJf?I'CI¥Jf&~'~~1:EmH1iJf?i::.~~D.~*. • •.fjm~mm~~w~~m.~.o=~. tf:I::W-*Ii'!Ua5Rt& . ~.f'f:m~~/jitw!I¥J~~iW~*~ , ~~rurf*uJf~O"Jpx* • •f§&.1I ' :;FfB.1:EuJf?i::.~1:~MU]:!xl5t@ft;. =="1iJf~1Jt.twjzt~. ti.~$Uj?5:1:i~Jf-tl'9~~ .-~*~ , 1:E1iJf?I'C :Jji* 1:t!::!/!tt$r]j?5 'MmM~~t¥;~·lj!£*' • •1iJf?I'CI¥J:1:i~W.~o. 1:E1iJf~:1:i~:JjOO·ti.~~rur~1iJf?i::.~~.jf~tl'91iJf?i:::Jj '~*~·I¥J·~~~.~1iJf~~±·m~~~~.~1iJf?i::I¥J~ ·.fj~~.rurffi1iJf~.~ Iffl.~1iJf~:Jj~~H'.~.::f. 13.. .. .m1:.tl'9~~ft.·. 0. *~~'J'.I±lffi:1rHljJS1J~IS$lf*Jl:H~ifBtrJ)Z::J!i[ , iiJfj~:@lijlHf!.R ' I i!§1Jffi:{--\~~IS$l{* , m;~r",'JmliJf~ UtJ:iO' 1981:q:.~2M ( I 981:q:.4fj ) • :aS5-64 ; i'llf'.1±l ~~: 1!9H1.A...R;:±IIlBUd:' 1985)0. lit)!}, 'l!iifW~~Jh1rl.... M~ifl~ji..~~1iJf?I'C·::f~'1:E~~ji..~~m'.A'~m'.Mtl'91iJf. 0. ·~.~~.lli-.r.fj~m~~Jt¥;1iJf?i::~.'~S'if·m~* ~c<l1!::0Fi ' ~* ' t):1t1:E*~I¥J.$5~~ , 1:E~m~f$j511 ~~.fj lRIifl;!H'i.. ~Je(m't¥;UJf~8~X. 12.. 0. -.®~'*~~~tt.~ • •1iJf?i::.~I¥J._tt,~.~~. 1990if.1~t)1& ' *~~Jf-Bla:iz5 f~j?5:Jj~W.fjrurtl'9~~~lf. ~~fl¥J£~. fB.e:f[~~~f-=rili:Jj[ffiI¥J~W. 171. '~~~.~~-~n~~~~~.~(~. fuJ1J ,r t!tw~rnJtrJ:m*:'Ht;f[J41j!ll\lI¥JI!WJ~rmf¥Jl:H~ifB J • RA)J:±:~ • ~1!!:*CB9~t~ : t:pm;m;~~fRt~~B9~.I.R (~~ : . 1992) , .N 14-15 '. mlli~~~m.~m~:1:irt:u'~~'1:Em?i::I¥J~~w.~1:,;:gm. m*.H~~.*.I¥J~~o~~'~::f.« • •m?i:::Jj~~~. O"JfJ!~'. , ~ruruJf?i::I¥JRrJm;:gJ!ff;- , +HiJ&Jff~Br~*I*tfiiM .. ~.:w-;:g~m.:W-ffi.*I¥J~M'~~~I¥J'~~~~1:E_rurm?i::. : tlJ:j'j!.9;D~IHfJiijfd: ' 2003) ; *rdJlllG:±w ' t:p9i LUg!jA.R;:±IItJiiJilt ' 2003) ; ~r"Jpx:±:~ , t:p~9~3C'8':(£.~1iII (:t:1JA : llIiffihlf;:±Iftllilil± ' 2003) ; ,*-!I'1lpx:±:w ' 1:f:!~9i-3C'i1UJl.l!fll:*I!f!1!.*1* (:t:Jjj[ : LlJg!j.A...R;:±IltJiiir± ' 2003) ; x.1f'iJ¥j , t:p~.~il11l..~@]lfi (~tJi!: t!fJ'j!.9;[j ~IHll&ifr:t ' 1985) ; lli~ffII ' 1HI;mll (.L~ : .Lw.)(~t!:lll&ifr:t ' 1986), IS. m~!M ' flit~~mlB9t:p~MlJfRt : 9i-~iESl~fUt~wt~ ( .Lim :UIit.A...§!;IHItJiiJilt '. 14. ~a!m : ~:lt~ , 9Ht+~a (~t* m3C~1'NI (:t:Jjj[ :. 2000) , l'[21. 0.

(7) 172. .t5Z.~:ltEASTAsIAN STUDIES 20071f-Ul1jl;~+A~1jl;-.JIJJ. ~;'.f~~,;ti~~:lt.:t.AfAl. ~Je:~~!fl(f~~-::p1i~' 1'fJ!:!1!:~~~pgjf~tt90~~'i!~IYjll'il$. ,. 173. w~m~lHl~m~biIDtt9~N'~m~m~.~tt9~.~'lli~. g~~ftg~*tt91i~. , ~~~:f§'"IE.~DTij~lf~f~ , ep~~:t~Jt~MM tt9*~'~~~:f§'"IE.~un.m*g• •~ ••fi~.m~ ~~~.~~m~~~~ •••~.'~.~:f§'am~h$. tt9IDII;r,9t!~¥"IE.~*~ , ;ffj!:fOOfjxtt9jfd:tW~fJl ' ~~.~:1§'~PJtJtE ;f§!:f~fitt9J'z:~J: ' !fl(1~Je:~B"Jjf~R ' jf~R1¥90rm1t ' .L-~Eds~JtJj.. ~m~Je: • • ~ • • '®H'~~IHl~m~~MU*.-n~m.. ~~&@h~Wtt9~~.~~'~#.m.~.m~tt9.~·. ~. , *~~~W"IE. tl:.rfJiffOl;i:f:! I!!m~~m 1Hll!l!§ffiltt9 §:g-. wm~~~~~tt9m'I!!m~~~m~.-MI!!m*~_jJW~~. 16. 1'.'~.~M!:f~~.~.m~1i.&~tt91'~'~.~~ :UJf~5l:¥Utt911:~~~ ~. , ~f4tW!1~m.~1*:UJf~tt9Mij;l]m!:f"IE.~ ~·MroJ:,.-fttW~m~fi·~#• •WJe:~~mAm.~_ M.tt9.~• •m~'m@fi~m~• • ~.:1§'tt9.~1'~'"lE.1' ~~I!&ij 1Je: ~~~mA..~1Hl1*EI"J:UJf~ . ~:1§'ffJJ~Je: ~B''1l!l!irmi'I'i~ffil ~o. *g~lHlm~m~~.·. • • ~m •• m~mlHl~ • •~*~. .'1im~~OOll'"lE.1'~'1'~~B.!fl(mm-::Ptt9~~1i~'. Je:~tt9>1-~~1tj::. , ~fr:D~*1in~'~1tj:: , Iq}~ 'tE~ffI£l'H!iIJ ' fN ~~m··~~~~~~ • • '~:!1!:*~~lHlm~~~.~~u {B.~ , Mi~*~.jJ(f{J~~ , *g,§h!:f1i~~~~IHl.:UJf~tt919: A1Jo* . ~f1fi*~.ftf1Jo ' ~MtJ*AjJB'919:A1J!!~ , ~JJ/t]!!~~1:EiiJf ~1¥J1iJ:iID::~Lk~Mttf1JO ' .1'~lf~f~m-·-¥jf~ . {El*~1:En~'~1 1Jf.W~tt9;1:~~1jt* . !tf1JoT!:fj:ffljJm~tt9rbZ!fl(~~ • .Ilt1Jf. ' ~jJ.~~~mtt9~~'~~m~~:f§'~• • ~*~.~·m~· , *~~:1§'J:;t~.~:1§' Je:~~Wr§h9;D~~:1§'~1Jf-3('g '*~&~.3(.~W~•• "IE.~*'m~ij;l]~*g~ 16. ~I!;\\I~~,MY*'PJ (A. Doak Barnett) J'i]fmZThe Making ofForeign Policy in China: Structure and Process (Washington, D.C.: Westview Press, 1986) -.~ , flfit!f~:f:irJj ~tla#{f*M1W~I\)j;~I!l!i'I''lijj~1IJl1t ' it ' .¥§llU~l1:: ' jAfijW:~i11JJ.~*fjg#Jl:t~it. 0. 0. l¥J.mtt.,m~.tt9g.~~.~·~~tEm~MjJ·AjJ·~. jJm~m~*'.~Je:~.~tt9~ •• W,tE~.H~m~.~A. • • ~m'ill.~J:~Hl!l!• • ~tt9~_"IE.~~~· *~~~mlHlm~m$~.' • • ~~mw~.~'~ • • ~. m~~att9~~l!l!.,~~~-~~~~mtt9~.jJ~'~~IHl~ mum~.~~. • • tt9m~,~-~ • • ~~~att9g. •· • • i:f:!I!!mM~I!!m~l!l!.tt9~~~~~.,m*~~w"IE.~PJU m~~mlliri:f:! •• ~JI¥J.~'~lli1'~I¥J~m'~.~~M~ mA ' ffJJ,15\ ~ att9l!l!§ifO~ffJJ • , "lE.H!~5mfk~{.~f$J~l&15!:ilG:miEX • •R~tt9l!l!irmi• • '~m~~* • •I¥J.~•••• m~girmi' m1ft.~~1*tt9~~ , ~~l&J&1k.tt9JE',~ , ffjj~~~i:f:!~l&r:fH~. f '. :mil&.fJjHftm~. 0. ~~~W~~~~'H!~m~~.]!!~tt93(mft~'~.~1Hl ~m~.~~lq}gh,.ftWjJ. f$j~1'F. ••. ·m~il&~~tt9R~'.fi~. ' J.a; ~flj~m ~ r~1*tt9 lit/1.IiIlJ . !:f~ ffJJ~ i:f:! ~IlUl~gx:~r1J. .~tt9m~lHl~irmi~'H!~*~£*tt9.®o.

(8) "'-~" , ... ~~". ""'HAN ;:')lUlJIES. 1()07ifIJl1iL:="+A~~-J!JJ. ~~~fflt.<tit;~'Jt.:t.1f-JIl. i3-N.~IBIfR{6Jf~ZI£. *. , .. 2~il'H'JW~~Um~9i-~iJf~3~. .~WJi!iHWj;JIIS~t~. j{~~. iJ:3(.Nl*~!7I-~*,~!!IJ~~~. .. , ~1ifm;1tt:p{i;~. 0. 175. J1-x:~!¥J. 1i{~~R.Rene Albrecht-CaITiePJT;jf~i§5¥. ~SEse.m::E 4:93:f'jm~~ . ~=!t.~1*!1~~r",'!l!IHi1'T.fI~1~ifUA~ 0. .®m:;jff'F ' {EUtft~5~IDliJ.~IUJ~~~ifUEdmm :EL'M 1970if.{i;:tJJWI ' OWJ~~1}r*~{iJf~ttm)tift ' IiJf~llli § 1!1.~*~ftt.tJit, ~~1W~~ ; 5m~~ , Ii*tE!m· £i~~~A!¥J;jff'F 0. '. EJi.Hilil!!fitE1950if.f~rmtItJ ' tEatE!*!~am ' >'1-3(~* i:lilt. *~atE!*~~:}'f!(*~~:f'jW~~r4I{~Htlr41~~f3f~~;fM , {E!.~ ~u&'lJifartlfRi,i~~IJ~~ , j;JJ~{i;~f$JIIN*IJl~ , 1fEf-"f1{lEmm. ~.*~~.~O~··~·¥$. •• *~~~3( ••*~mR.. $~t(~;f§IUI*~~IfE/M;*&'IJifI&tE!~~1J ::G~~~1}i* (5&m :fr ' ) ~~~~ (~~Y:;J , Pf~~ , ) IiJf~fflA ' ~Ut!1Gfi~m:~f$JIiJf~~. llU'if,r5~9lfE1D: 1950if.1i;rpM~ • ~M.~~~w~~m.'ili&'IJif~ • • :tE~.~~OO'H• • 0. 0. ~m:fi-~N. ~1D:i:l~~*~~~~~!¥J~~~~~.ho*m~~~~M.~ IfU~'i'~~~t~~'t1:!¥J;jf{'F. . =!t.lJ~~m1D:~e;. ' MzJt(=!tmfIg5t '!itfr-i:1 ' 6;!:t ~-;jf{'F 9i- SE~9i-SEfIIJ~ ~rJjiHte;~~ Nf*WJ1~;jf~o~~®.,.~ • •~¥tt.'.~.~.&,~MA • •. 3(*B.. ~~~~1D:~,.tE;jf~t:p.~m:~~~~~~~.oo~~~ ~~~• • m*IJl~,. , fJjm~PJ~ tE1970if.fi;t:/=lWl ' :tE~~N~~~ifU~ffij!¥Jfr-*BB~~W~. N~Wf~!¥JHIUf·rm-~-. ,. 0. f~~lltA 1960if.1i;13t ' ~~~~::Eff?~~fi~~~~{*~~. ~~.'fi1D:.~~.*~mH~~.~~~.~(M~~3(a '~~m.~) • •m*·m.a~fi • • m.~:tE*~.~~ ~~~.f* !.~.~"JH*~i$j.{'F±11~U:tE.~1}r* (fljt~4 ' m~.,*.~,tt~.~);~~m.ffiN*~(*.~.~~ R·tt~.·m.~· • •*.)~HMW~·w.~~~m~*. • •tt~.~~,m~1D:ffi~~~~.~~. ~!¥J. 0. 0. •. N~.*~B~.w.~.~,e¥~.·~.::E.'~. ~::E • . ~e;. (-e1f::). ~ • • ~WI~~W*.. ~~ifU~Y:;Jffi¥~~iBlIII. ;. ~~. ,. ~~~{iJf~. ~iftfi!¥J·M~.~~~~.·~e;~. ~.~fi• • o*m~·Nt:/=l·.a~~R*'i:l*ftmm*~!¥J. ::E11. 8. 0. *~~~O. ~~'.~N1D:~3(•• ~.~~.~m. .•~*~.~~~. * ;$:::::C f'F1!f ~~i&m*~:9i-:x li;lf ~r'ITn; ± :!'t~f1!J~\:1i:;:!'t:tE~fl1rlIDB'lJl[~WW ti'i-:5} fJTo 1.. £11f:=: ' r ~1lilI/"*1\lt~~.1LIlilI/~~f;%i'~mbl J ' rR,a~iJf!Je ' ~9~~nOM ( 1970 ) , ]'[57-58. if.7 Fl. 0. 2. *=1t*, . 9HE" (t/Jt : JECPiilFc] , 1962)·. 3, 5!'H~fj- , Iii1l.WJ.fl;{ , 9J.::EiJf!Je (t/::It : il'Ii~E[J1!1lEl ' 1968) 4, ReneA1brecht-Carrie~' ~::::C'~' :!I~~~' i!§;¥9l~!E (t/::It: IEcpi?;fJi'ij' 1966) 5, mfi!1:.' r~~$l~z*I!il?J' rR,a!ijiJf~' ~9~~6M (1970if.3,Fl), .0:6-8:. ffifi!1:.· r iW~$f!j:~~~~:t;J' JIHi*TIJ· ~2~~2M (19701f.10,Fl)· .0:15-22 6. *ij!*, ' m;1I~U\lUI (t1Jt : IECP~1<ii ' 1976) 7. *~~ 9l::E~9J.::Ellllf~ (t1Jt : JEcj"lill<ii ' 1977) 8. 'Wtl~D : *ij!*, ' r mSIlilI/:(£rtl *I¥JID;q"fi:M'fJlflIJ J ' Ei='1lI~f«T3t11:;~UIj , ~24~ (19791f.llfj)' .0:359-404; iG('i" r~~IHl1*cj"lz~i'il1f!~J' .&::i*TIJ' ~9 ~!lIHW! ( 1978if.4fj ) , .0:61-77 ; IHlcp ,r 1l!\iI~lHlf*cp r ~*:tlil.~i1i ~ zliJfiJ'G1r$ J ' m;~IIIIQ\~ • . 19781f.~lM ( 1978if.2,Fl ) , ]ii[2-18 ; ~i&::::C ' r :tE~Tlf1ff-1.:rtlti '¥'1'¥J~tfHjil&l'*Ht~I~ ? J' 1',,~a~iJf!Je . ~ 17~~I:It!] ( 19771f.10fj ), ~6-16 0. 0. 0. ,. 0. 0. 0.

(9) . " 'l"-=-T/\.~~-.l!}J. ~~~ffl!-iltit;~~-<tif-l!l. 1980ij::f"t ' t:l1-H9m~rjJJf*lW~ii~li:!i'!~ff.ljJmliJf}'E~~JIH~ ~ ~;f,It1t~.QZ:9'f.. ' ~m ' ~mffi~ift~A}'~;'!~:1f~1I:Z cp ~:5'{~ ,. 177. 0. .~~. H9.~~~m.liJf~H9ffi~.~~.M.~. 0. #~m'~~'~~~~*~:1f~~~H9~~~f*liJf~gM~~ fiI ,9fffj'~Il~!Jj\~-~fiI~*, ~*m~~f*~:1f~A~Jff$r'j~f1:~. ~ :EtJ.A~ , ~f'F}j;Zd{~·.jJfffj~ii ' ~*'i:iJmz~~$jiJ~~li:!i'!m. 110 • f;f:m:rpW*~~~ffgm*:9'f..~~mH9UH~-jg1JoA 7J1!~H9~~ Hf*,l!f!~ifBlz.;Ff. 0. ~~fff.f>.Wj$rt:l~!Hi. 12m.flJf~rJ.!lli*~m:Effi!~H9liJf~~)f!:a~ff:n§i ,. '. *~t5:2¥U:~!T¥i§I!lm*H9l1j~~i1ft~. . fJIl¥J5ifiiE.. 0. ~~f*Ji.t:9'f..~liJf~H9.mm. 0. 10. 1I:t:9'f.. ' 19801:f-f"tCPM:t-r::t; ,. EJ~~1f)(r~~rtt~JJlZm~~fi{ifW±. ~fiIH9~:1f~3MiJf1:~ , fffj r CPmm~it~1iit J ' r CPm~r5~ft J ~Uf'F~f"t~ttH9~~m*H ~·-l.lt~:1f;iJgiJ~ , ~i1-l¥Jm~~f* liJf§f'e~j:: T ~@JEl)jAVH~ft : , 1i!h.!J:liJf~H9f§~~f'Fij1J1J ; ~.__ ' l!I!~iiliJf~H9~lJttJi!~ ; m_ ' m~~r5~iff~;f§~~f'F~~ij~ §;j1J~~~11f~~~-~~m~~f*~f$j!ilH91f~ , ~JiJ;if(5t~r~. l!ii~rj~~f"t~t£f'FRojif~ ~H9mh.!1. 0. ~~Jjij~~um~iI}~~rmf*~~liJf~:x. 0. ~:x·rm:m:~~~~g.z • • • •~~m~.~fiffim'.. .... ... #.~!ilf;f:m:~n=:x*~~m~~fi{ilW.Z~w~~7~~~. 0. ~H9. .o~~. (international regime) g~ii. '. ~~~~~~ lW'Ij:~R!~rJlt. '. ,~~. ~a±.. ~. ' if:::E*11:::;~. 0. z5&:o. 1990ij::f"trJJM ' iJ_m~~f*H9liJf~~~~mjfJroJ ' *l.lt1¥(~ ~:1f;iJg~f1:~ , :t;tt~)990if-f"tCPM~~~~~J.fitH9irN':JI~ , ~flifJ.E R~.~~~~(~~ffl~*m)~• •ij'~ffift~~7~_. ~~f*liJf§f'e~-*H9~-~ fHr~r.t~H9~ , JJlZifF~~_m~ , :9'f..~. ±:!Hi:tE1990if:1"trp ,. , fg~gJTTj~ , B!J~~1*lW~ii:)(JlI::tE.~MfUPJT1~~H9lXll:fJjf'!'& ' fJHHi~15% ' ;fi:fI} *lH51- ' ~U~~ (Jf[$) 1t~~m~~m.x1J:i** ' ~~ilB40% 13 r&M~jljifi!±rm.:tE~!ilH9i:j1~iizrp. 0. i&mj~'l!f!~.:t('Ij:±.-jgfBi51~¥Ub.:tt:HmH9~~~1*,. mtUl!f!lllffj , liJf~ . !ME §. , fEl..~~~~~~. 0. 14. 0. ~mft~'m~ffi~:9'f..~~liJf~~AA~~oU~*:9'f..~*l¥Jm~0. i.t:P-f!~~1Jg . ~19801f:f"t1ltrEi]$jft~r5t!t ' *~tt (~f1:) ,. ~'~m~~~lli~~0ffi~*'m~~~~Z~~~~0ffiW~ 11f. 0. ~$j , i'<t~:9'f..x~mJi.t~~mEI.H9liJf~ift~-~ftl¥gjfJ~. II. ;U;'f!li!lGXP)5f,/:JRW.&#~:lBZ~f'F' 1li!n:;~~Ji!!iBfli'ftl:I¥:ll!l!i1m~~1r*iB.1BI m;~II1~~m;lI!i!iaUh (a::lt : j;1]1Ii ' 1983); #~;tB ' m;lI!i!ia6h~9B~iI1I:l!ft (#::It : lim ' 1989) iUflZliJf~~rp~i*~ , ~1!l!i1 ' r:tj:jt=f£J~{* ' !jlf)JlWJiU P)lifli~li1f~Zf£J~f[-*?1 ' ~jl~iI\I ' 10. ·.!itIl#i&:m*~.l'nj!&I~~f*liJf§l'l:;t:p'G' , fi..3(':,* ' i&:m,*~IT~tlLliJf§l'l:;'&fj{~A j] , PJ;I]!ll:~~fi..ilB~* (£%*,11) £%14:l/R'&li1f§l'l:;~Iil'li~r"'~JmZfj{1'lifi ' Rlft.roJfll}Z W'. 0. II.. ~~il16AA ' r #iftil\l~~f*~fi..~~u.r~XZliJf§l'l:;l&"'J7.)-fJf (fi:!1!l!i178ij::-87ij::).J ' ~.:lirlJ:E~ , lilA tt-ttUc~iESlih¥ (a~t : rP~iI&:m~l'ir ' 2000) ,. {"l,Ws:! '. I. I. I. I. 0. 9. . ~~lI#a~~lil'liliJf~fi..~WI!l!i1~~m~m.o. Ji299-300" 12. f91J~D : m)!f1~ r 1&~~IWfMt:pI!l!i1*M1J;t:f:iLT~7jffl!l!i1~gf*li1f~Zli'Pf,I;.J' 1;J~1Dl iK:~fi ' 19951f.ml0M (1995i;f:6Fl)' Jii143-191 ; ;tJlj~l1ll ,r 1&r,r~IWfWlrtj;tli-J;t *::Its2:IiiJ~IUl{*li1f';1\;z~: fiIii_lJ!i!S;<$;.J 1;J~1UJiK:¥fi' 1995ff.m10Wl (19951¥ 6fj ) , R79-142 ; 1f1':i& r i&m~j:{tW'5'MI¥JJ;t:91-i&~ : r --OO!f1~ ~ mumS'') ftWil.J iESl5h~~~.' 19961fmTltFl (19961¥6J'j), J:f287-304; ~:=ErlJ' r~1!lIl! !:tHiJ~I'MlIr:1~~-!.!I!.\'ID.:t~£%:EJ\f.J!.:t~.J ~IIIFHU ' m7~m6W:l ( 1992if:6.F.1 ) jl50-59 ; Yu-Shan Wu, ''The Collapse of the Bipolar System and Mainland China's Foreign Policy," Issues and Studies, Vol. 29, No.7 (July 1993), pp. 1-25. 13. [iiUiW r '5'J!!tIi!l!l~lUlfH3:fi..~~f;lijBflixZli1f';1\;l&r<u.5Hfr (~~781f.-871f.).J ' ] l 299-300 14.:OZJi!tr' rf&~l.1~I!l!i1~gf*!f1l¥Jpw~lmf*J }frs:a:!J:fU' m26~mHM (1994if: 7fj ), J!![94-112; :riZItu, .ijiftlY-JlII~~1a] (a::lt: tf:I:W-' 1995 ; Chih-yu Shih, I. I. I. Q. I. State and Society in China's Political Economy: The Cultural Dynamics of China's Socialist Reform (Boulder: Lynne Rienner, 1995) : :ozJi!tr ' 3t1'!.:tillY-JiI1I:5h!J±1FU : iff~~. ? iff~III~? (#~t: IErt li'!fmJ ' 1996) ; ji!(Wt~1§l , r lliIlfalll If' ~lJ!i! ~ ~ .g-~I¥Jfi..~i&~ -~ti.:t~~!f1 Jl;J J ' &:i)4;l~1j!~ , 19981f.m8W:l ( 19981¥f.k~~) ,. R84-104. Q.

(10) 178 ....§.1>JtJtEASTASIAN STUDIES. -JIiJ. 2oo7JrU]. i1;lf~l¥f,ilti€l1>JtJt-ti-1l. WOO~~.'~ • • • ~~®~~~~~.~ •• $.~~ 9:.: p)f¥~~m~®~~~iJfEtl1'I -1m Z:!:fu ' 3:::~Mffw:.mHm !lU¥.i:s-?. ... Q. ·.~-~.~·~.~AW~.~m~·~.~~m~~~.~ .~~Z~o~~~~~.· ~~~~~·iliW~H.®m. ~~, ~1!f~~;:ft~§EE.~.JE. ~J.tt~lJI~f~~~~.~jM~ ~~nOO'~~~~~#~'±~§~.b.~mm® • •:!:fuW& 1'f~®~~A1J#~*~f*. 15 0. ~~~~~n@'.*~~M.®.~.~'ffi.mffi~~~ ~~&~~~~~~~~m3:::~®~~~®'~~~*~~~&~ ·Mfl~~• • m*~~~~~~~~®±.'#~~A~~~ .~ffiiil1t~;!iljl¥J!ii..~jf ~~ /lJPl.m-ft*1!fl¥Jf~A ' ~~~~fOJtli 0. ftj. 0. 0. W!l~[] : JfIl!/il!!I;f;ft)'~I!~W~*s#~/i!UWf~ , ~.9i!.JfIl!/il!!IU ' rilifH~li!liJtl:l:Yi:i1i7l-Zi':tf4tf.&. J ' ~~tsIfil'::l::*Ii\j , fatitB"mJ~III;$9i-:tl~~f§1jii1f~ ( b;ft : $9Hijf5tl!Jt~fiI\lliJf 5tJ5IT ' 2001) , J.'l1-98 m7](Il)Umt),~~*Ji~W~~i*.rti~iMf!!lrJ~j(1!I[ • *m li!1i~ilifH:IJf ( ARF) ~/il!!I~~JIjIJW*'1. ' ~'&f\:ti'i!!tP:fj*sirW~Ml.W/!J!1J~i*lj:lf ~Z~~ ;fElm1~1'F~fjljJf!1lr*EJ13 ' r *mli!1i~ilifHfJlW52:;t'tz::?e: J ' iI$/:~~~~~. ' 1999if.~llWl (1999ij::12fJ ) , 1'i145-179 ; m7](IlJj , r ~~fiHj\$\1{[.ffitlWmlllB i¥J~Jm : 1!JI1J~m11*l!Il.ilifHWffm~i:MHli8Z~~J' r",a~litl~, Pfl;43tl~3Wl (2004 if.5 • 6)1 ) , 1'i[77-96 ; f!1lr7](B)J , r ~trI!Jl1JZ1:R~m:M!!WA:tmf*ll&H'''~1ili J ' fEJ l3ito'j!! .~ , ~13tWl (2006if.4f:j) , 1'i[21~36 •. 0. 0. 0. 16.. 17.. WY~O: ~**. ,r ~j§t~ •. R*W*mfUl{*IY~"~. mit ' b.I!llU.lHlf*:E!l!~tBliJf~~~I*m~ 18.~;f.±~ 19tB ft. mW#7mtB.ho~7~~~~~~*~~.~~tB~.~IHI~. ~ffili~.~'~~~.~~~.mB•• m.·wOOEE~~~~ .lim~~'~~.5t.~~~AAmH••~"A~OO'~~b .~~.. (1&YEl .. ). 3(if:~~~~}jlID~#~JE:i1.t?p-. • 21. ftm'/lJPl.~~~~·.mE~·.m • • ~.~ftjj.~~.. ~~f*jilm. '. tEbit!!:tmm!~~J!1~-JEtBmjf~. ~i&¥tl~PJT ~fjtBfWH\i~'I1:.~~ti 1!f~liJf~. '. . ~JlU~~4-:fJt~~~. fJe1~~F • •3(i£ .~F~*1i~. , fj~~PXJi~~.*:W**~~.!fJi~Jl~Z--l¥J~~. 0. 1i!1i~::l::~WASEANlltffiU : tEf,JJtf~7t;fJT~.Jli\~~&. 1im:l'lhk' .:ffr:tlll.:t:*Iiii ' ffi1!t~tr.Jll~Sli (b~t : lim ' 2002) , ~325~346 ; IliRJiXz • r *§~i11\''l\lE#f;tt:i.ll&~Z~. J ' :iE~iI$/:~~WJi~ , 2004if.~7Wl (2004if.7 J:I ) , ]'{19-46 ; IlIfi!t~ , r ~?Rifficrl!i*af;tlftooW:tltz ~.J' r,,"la~ijf~ , ~44~Pfl;lWl (2005if.1 . 2J:1)' 1'i[H9. j'. ~Wf~~g~~:;t:tt!lli!iijff':::::'1J-ifff:1ti.&1iJ~trl!ll.t'lkJliJf;1epJ(JJ!:~~*stI:l!\& ' .9i!.Jacob Bercovitch, Kwei-Bo Huang and Chung-Chian Teng eds., Conflict Management, Security, and Intervention in East Asia (temporarily entitled) (London: Routledge,. 2006) , ;!tftH{'FabWtJ~U : ~iJ&·~ , r 1!JI1J~~flj>i¥J:tmhW~fjj( : m1~I!JI1J~~Wf!M~!lIY~ ~f};lMilifH j , Jlt~iI$/:;~o'j!!~¥Ii ' 1994if.~3Wl ( 1994if.3f:l ) , Ji[67-95 ; ;f.txf!i!. ' I'j:l:J:Hll1~ljtr.Jl!~~JUJj : *~~;$iilijffl!:I~~g (I%nt : . x x i t ' 2000) 18. ~ir?:ctJ , mt1iSliI$/:~~mt.l : :iEJ;j(~~IlI!~l!I (Fl~t : ~~ , 2002) ; ,*~r:j:l , :iEJ;j(fl:: ~iilijffl!:n~ (tJ~t : ~~ , 2003) ; lliJJliIti ' r ~J:3tif:J:E!lnlij.I!JI1J~B-fF : ilIf!i;!t~~:!J1J 03#[ J ' :iEJ;j(iI$/:~~WJi~ , 2003if: ~4W:l (2003if.1O R ) , ltf25-45 19. ~*~ j!'.±.III~IiJ~IlI!~~;ii::iElitl~ (#~t : ~~ , 2003) ; ~~ , I'j:llll ilflilll~.5lj!Algtr.JlW*" : -1mIiii±.j!m~e<.JU!li (b~t : lii¥J ' 2004) • ?FfI :f}Xft*B ' iW;fJTjfd:1ll'I~tM'±~ , if'F .9i!.!*Ililffiiti ' r ~~IJM1* ~ iii±*y£*j\j±:~l!Il.illilI dJ iff.ffi j ' ~1IX¥:TIj, ~15~*2W] (2001if.][*~)' ].:[199-229; lli:~' rr-tte Alexander Wendt:fjrm~*~1J}lJi!flJ~7t.ffizm1!J : ~)'Il!lII~Il1:i.~~ffiU~WU J ' ~ ~;nlj , ~ 15~*2Wl (2001if.Jll*~) , Ji[265-291 ; :f:iZl'!ltr ' r fi&~§fl!LJi¥Ji&i5 ~-:llrtofP~.±:~t'lkJf3.f~H!fJ~Hlt!J!J J' ~~~Tlj , !'iiH5tlPfl;2Wl (2001if.~*~) , ]'{293-310 20.~.9i!.~51!r:p.±~, 1II~1iJ~iW8~ (tJ~t: 2003); 1~lSftfO' r£~.:t:~Z El~~~&J'nliJmttJl!Il.~iltir!ljzM.b'jHtftij J ' 1II~1iJf*-~¥Ii ' 2003if.~18Wl (20031f,12J:1 ), :aH8; *~BJj , 1II~1iJ~tr.J@iR~&~, (Fl~t : ~fJi' ' 2004) 21 WtJ~[]: *_1: ,;f.tiE~ • *13)] • ;f.txfll • !1lll?M;lli~~2000if:i¥J~2~!'iin:!tIl.lII&~ 1II~ii1f~r.pPJTifz:fjm1ffi{,,~:u:m;&fjj~ X : ~1l)J~ , r {.:e.~ll'Pfr5TI*t[2'tz:~ J ' ~ 1II&~1iCI~ii1f~ , *3tl~3Wl (2001if.7 fJ ) , Jff;f58-81 ; Chih-Cheng Lo, "Taiwan," in Ravinder Pal Singh ed., Arms Procurement Decision Making. VoL II: Argentina, Chile. Greece, Malaysia, Poland. South Africa, and Taiwan (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001), pp. 180-201 ; Yuan-Kang Wang, "Preserving Peaee in the Taiwan Strait," Chinese Political Science Review (iI$/:}~~¥Ii) , Vol. 33 (June 2002), pp. 149-174; ~J.&IIjjU~~ ,r~*smI,ti.~.fiW~~t1.~IlJ' rQ~a~litl~ , m4! ~*2Wl (2002if.3 • 4f:j ) , Ji[23-41 0. ,. 0. 0. mw,. 0. 0. ... ~'·i .l'1. ,",". ,. lii~~~ , ¥.j#tflb·}B~fi! • • • ~f*l'!U~5tfJTf'Fim*s 16ii!JJ1:liJf ~~PH~I3N~.-~~~~#lUmtB1r~ , ~~ffl~~~fJ~h.!if~ .~fio~ • •~ • • ~nQ.tB~~~~~.m~~~tB •• T ' ~~1&*~~* ( • • tMjJjlfi.~iJliJf~,¥:) l¥J~1J ' ~i$Ji~¥U ~ • • • ~f**:Wl¥J.~~ 17 15.. 179.

(11) l 180 .tilZ.~~EASTASIANSTUDIES. 2007lt-UI. ~-="+A~~-JlIj. iI~l!'lfflHt)a~~.zii-~. ,II. i!i ifl (ijIf ~~tlt JiJf~11 ~ Z Jii.w-' lfk. r~WJ2.~~~~Ib~·~~~~'~~X~~~OO'~~~~ lW~1lI5. IIl'I. ~m*~*5TIuJf~FfiIilUf5(~. 181. 0. flltlo~ff,!j~*~. f5.R~:fj7.tffl~. ,. ~± ff-:. .. ~:Qt({I-:~tfrt~:xhtm. '. , {I;{ :p.~I'M~lE2.&\~ a t!£! E 2. ' :g A 7f';WJiit~1'l:~. a~7t~1f~OO'.fi-@.~W&~o. ~.~7t:fj~~&5'~~ffi.~~~tto.ft.~+.~~. flJR'. ~.M~··~.~'~.~_~affl~~'~~B~~+. 1f-~~ £lif.!;lii~1£19701f-fe;, .:f4~Ji~fj!~~*V1H' 3i~x~.-=. . 0. 0. l'1J1tfl~ , 1Iit~1iftE5't$pfTm~lift:p , l'1;!'ti1H=r*)jj1C. @111m ' M~tf:ltlOT-=Jffii.:f4~M:. , (lP~JliMJilIIIt ' ~1fJi#F11ill ' tEi6(rE~. M~~.~.·~~~.~7tMM'~M~.~~;~-~~1!if~. "=m.~,,~lft&~. ~O::'''-S-. ii'.~ B ~~a~~~. 0. ,. ~.B;g_a~7t '. t:p~ r. J =~~Ji!!i ' !Wf51U~3i:~~~JifiID a ;!'tftlH&~~ ~Ji~ , .1!iff~AiMtY . ~~I:&*iE.fl3lM-~~ 2. .~·~.l'1W.RftM; fi~trliZff,!j~. • •Mfl~.~·~~.~~:fj~.~. , ~J!~..g. r :£!I[~ifB J. r.~ J. 11f. 0. iID!;f~.:f4m.rnJ. ' IIIQ~III'.. :etAfR1'WmJ'W~1f1$;~iID~&J~,. '. ~tigllli~ij!1=f~~~mFni. •~. ~JIt-m~'*~~U2.J'Wft~ffl~'Jiitr~~~~J(J'W~m~ ~~W)Wrm~~.J(J'W~m-·=~!Wf~)m:fjoo·~~w ~~&,IjSI,. •. 0. ;!'t::x ' ~~5't r aJ&~* J r ffd:@'M.JWJ J pfTij f?5 ' ~.fr~~ ~affl~7t,~~ram~~Jo~lli~am~~~~*, 113&!5tlmfffl51U$ftf-: . a~)~~ , '&A~fIH~f ' BPilt1Cz.!~JW • 7~tt. ft~~:OO1OO ' :£!I[gffil!;f~i5I&ffi:f~PfT7f'JE 3Mt1'3t ' ~jff5't r (fr~.w.~ J. 0. .& r unitary actor). J '. ~.~fl3lU1~Jf~~f5.R r -*fi~1!if J. (state as. , f~!Hl:lmf*l&ffij11H11t{t*;g~ r mi§f1:~ J ' Mtlo. r ~-tp-~ J ~-=il:lilb ' f!U~1:& r -=1f!;ff,:U Jar _* J 2.T'. J·lfkll\ff ' r ~~i&7a~llfiil¥mAlf* J ' R290~292 •. ~~~~ , iSl)a¥. (1'). (;g.~~. :. lim ' 2006) ,. 2. rI'ij/W ' r ;g.ift~~mAl1*~:9f.3(~r.Jq~XZliJf~J[llJbJ:5:t;ffT ( W;[ijlJ78~871F) J ' filJ,I~U& ' , 1IJ...= +-1!!:*CErniSl5a¥ ( ;g.~~ : r.pI!!!lJi&tE;~* ' 2000) , j!.f295~313 ; ~·~trr ,r ~t:j:rtJ'=~lmf*liJf~Z[i!J~~~~J' fUJjGl,jzg, ~:ELU~ , 1IJ...=+ tIt&ce9iSlJa¥ ' j!.f3 J 5-357 •. 3.ilJ~~~_:n:JUJti\'UlmiJimf8&:~ ~1iLU ' r1i.flJs.£JI!Ht£ : jijij~lIIi~iIT~ (;g.~~ : LEr.p ,1997) '];[2; , r ~mt:j:r!'JkJml¥lmf*l!J!iIlf!f J ' §*ifD' ~:liJ.1J*!il ' ~ 0. m~e9jijij/li!lIIi~Jliit ' ~mlR (tJ'~~ : liJ¥i '. 1999) , .ili34 •. ~,~~~~~~,rr~~~.W:n~&~Z~ .~J'W~,~.~.a~~,~gr~*fi~11fJmR'Ur~. tI.~J W rillW5tlllJ. 1:$1:&jJl. '~J~jtf:l-it[.t)~~~ r~~J. 4 0. r ~~ J 2.179 ' aJ& ~~%~~ r § ±'~ J ( state autonomy) W r iMn J ( state capacity) : ilIIWZI79 . ;!'t~~pfT~t8iM • ~~.f(!if . ~fffrA~W~~~&~~.or~~J2.~,~*.~~r~~ ~m J 8;g~m/ffiU*;g2.T. ' fJ:7tigjJl:;tt r _*flj~ J ' ~)E~~~f'f~. 0. JltRlJf'F1!ifpfTaw r ~i§~A J (dyadic model) • ~1f:*Ml*'~3[t'lii3ii'.~ ~auJf~. 0. 5;fNjJl~-s¥MM. '. _~a¥Er~5tfJT1'~$U*.liHt~. , r ~~ J. 4. ¥tiil&~jj$M;R:PJfjlHsfm~ , Jltnml~PJf1ii'J r 1frj(jj$ J:f8~1i*:±~ J ( methodological nationalism )ffi3& ~~John Agnew, Geopolitics: Re-visioning World Politics (London & New York: Routledge, 1998), p. 50, p. 66. 5. m:if.1fJil!,f1Jltm:~jj!1T&:JjSI,1!:f ' jzD3f.9PlIJ ' I!IiIfIJ)lIllQH!~Ern@IUi~f.it~ (t1~t : m~X11::; , 2004) ; ~~aJJ . :E.jijij/li!~1!!:WIll1e (;g.~t : :1='W ' 2002) ; *9;l;1lJ] , ~Ji.I!il::~f-te9"i:t.~jijij/li!1II1¥ (tJJ~ : 10~ , 2001) ; Ezfif!i*!il ' ItI!lilZr'..' : ImIA 0.

(12) 182. jt52..ijf1}:EASTASIANSTUDlES 20071fi.1J1. Jj!;-=:'+A~Jj!;-,IfJJ. t;)If&l~ai€;.ijf1}:.:;l:AfAl. z.r-]ft-Jr~~ltJlt~ , i:R:m~fj , ~~Xb1E~JWiii ' 3¥5~fiJtJffmi~~ifU. 0. 6. flHf{'1==ifPJT 5il.. ' r ~~m:ct: J lJ~~tn-~l'tmf11Wf ' lfij~f*11:: ' tJ&IDi~3=.1I::S'9Bi¥1~~~~ ; ~1n§j , ~ifU&~ff~uJf1Gft-Jmm '-fW r ~.3=.~ J J5tn-±~ , ¥}~IJAJJ~'@ , j'{1Jjji1[flN ' i!&*Wt~1it r ~ ~f~~ J ' fEltzo~Bi¥~*~ , ~!f!U:,pXtfF B wit; , r~3=.11:: ' £*11::~7frE~ftER!f:1!B ' 'Ei'~~'!filG'$m~*.M~~ , ~&\Bi¥*tlll1'fJlttn-~. 183. id:iti1 I~ , 'Ei'.ft-J~~fiff~ I ~~ r ~.~(r:i] J ' fljj(:z~W:l ' ~1!t 1i!~S'9001t!fg , jz.;lJ1t~:VWg§1J~~iiJf1G ' .1Tl!I!~ifUM;xft-Jf;tal!i : 1Wi ~~Hi!ffl ' ~tIDJ ' ~@]R1Hi!HTf~nWM76 ' J$jfflf;t:?PJi. @ti~-H~'~=if~.~~:~W~ffl§Ati~W• •ft-JR it ' ~flif~jz.;l~-flj~ , ~jfu*al§l r ~~ J W r ~J¥ J m!?t: ' ffHE~:@' 0. ~M;xft-J~.·.~~$~'~~765tF!m~.~~~~tn-~WR. mm1Gz.~o.~=ifPJT5il..'&mz.IDift-Jn$mRIM~m~ft-Jm~. i*fIb~. ~Jm. n.~;~-1f@~Wfiff1Gft-J~*'~1lJ• • m;gft-J~~:@.~o~. '. 1itJtBi¥~. 0. :¥tn-;ttJtm~r* ' rjJJI1Hw.tEM1~m~ft-J r ~~m:ct: J '. ~J W r~pgJ. aw. 0. njiH r ~. --1frniF!~JJl~7tT*tlflifft-J~¥, mtl:l~{w. r r~. ±fOZfS~ J (theory ofdemocratic peace) ft-J5t:fJT 35---J:TillmU1lJ~/\J:l 0. ~-1.fJID~w • •ft-Jm:fJT. '. § fiJ.~~~ll&ml!I!gifU. ' tErf:1l&. -fiff1Gn(r:i]'B.~tn-rf:1fiff~~m• • • • ~~W~~W.~H~. l!I!~lfUlm8J3rp. , 8!ill~'!W*&\~i§t~~ I §fI1*IDi:!1ltfiJW:lR'9~1J1f[tiJ ,1'1=. =if~tE~mr:p'lm~~~;tt.~~o. ~ft-Jpg~ltJ~ , ~~tI:lZPfJtn- r pg~51-~gifU J (second image reversed) ft-JlM~ Jtt51- ' ~1lJ:itli--tf7:t]~ r ~~ J. 0. ~*'~J¥~.'H~'Ei'.ft-J~~W~~I~~ • • ~ll&mfiff. r ~pg J Jif;x , lfMflHS'9 m1G5t:fJT ' ~mtn-Robert D. Putnam~rJT~~z. r ~JifftlJ~ J (two-level games) f~~_1: ' e~~IEJM;xft-JJJ.E1IGffr.$=if ' tzO{OJffllIflJ9iE ' ~. ~. m'W~.o.fu~Z.'§A~j'{.~~m~.~'~tE.fir. :4:.m:lz.lIl~. M;X5-}:fJT J ' *Sit r ~~~m J E1IG r ~~~Yr5*,]iJlf J W 1- lt~ll&Yr5 J E1IG r .tt;~ll&Yr5¥JiJlf J ~Jifu1 ' t1iJm:Mz~1I::m;gft-J~ll&fiff1G 7. ~~~~ffimr51-~ll&m.mJ~1!t'~~.M~~=if·~-fii1. .~m.Mw.~,ti~~a~w:n~&~z_. ~r.$r:p~,f;tpg~W1.f~~ltJ~'~.mM'.~~7frE~.A·ti. 0. 0. tzo:4:mitetf!rJTjz& I 'Ei'.ft-Jl@~uJf1G ' ~flif~r:ptn- r ~-r:p. J. ~.R~'~~~~'~=ifR~~~'mA~flN·~51-I~~R&. ,. (r:i]*f£~~~WR{*Jm~. ~~~~~~~~. •• ~z.,r~~ll&mJwr~WR~J~=if' , 1tBE1IGfIjj(:l!l!~~m1'm ' .tJff5&~~~=if ' "7;fi~~. A~~ll&~g~'~~~jj:jijWfiff1G~~Sm:fJT51-,z.m¥}tJ~WlI. 51-~~*Sm.~'*Sm~~'lID~~~JmM'~~.fiJ*.m~ 'Ei'.f;t~W'~ll&fiff~ft-J.flifW~flifo ;tt.;x,f;t.~~W*lm·~WR~.~fiff!?t:.~'jz.;lR-~r WH~RWfi*~fO~.S'9~~W • • ,~.m.§ft-J.E'jz.;l~. 8. ~~ r jijijt'fllDlf*Wli!IlIlIfil:fijJf*;!!i!81i1i J. '~*~~~m~~~~ffi,tttt~z~M'~A~~~W~Q 7. Jl:tlJ!OJ~~lVcllli ' r :5HIrJff~WIiEI~n,* J ' 5i.5E'*'~ , 1II~lmfJfiM!~ (tr::!t : m. 9.. , ]:[53-55 •. jj:jijWR{*X*.~~m. *~pg'~.~*~H~ft-J.D,jz.;l~'~WmMft-J~.'1WitE~. ii1iJ~lmfJfi99ftlh • • (i3::!t : ~.~)'JHz:fi1f ' 2003) ; Ezl1ftr . fiUlfe;99i&~s~ ~ (i3::!t : 5t;OO ' 2002) ; ;nz.ijtr . ~fe;i:f1I11!i9i-lmfJfilfi~ : i&5sxft:;PM)'J!~Hfi (-Ei'::!t: :tim, 1995) , 6. lZJJlt ' fIH*Jlt--~J:\: ' ~~-1Dl1:t~ml!!li ' ~1'1±l'§1JXf!:fijl(;IF.J:\:iWi~~l'l'9lWilI • !fd ~ , 2003). ; ~--1fJID '. ~~B)J, ~f*~.lillJfJI:~'f-~. a. '. i:f1*fi1f'9i:~i&~S!t!fi1f~PJT.fjlilll. tJf~JJ!J[fl!if,&ijl'. ' JJtJ:1,§ tl:~. :t':iJIT1B::i$:X'. < http://www.ipsas.sinica.edu.tw/projects.php?page = I &step=S&proj ectid=8 ~JS:1lJ ' r i3ltt~*~~J:fi : fr'i~W;!!i!11: J ' B9FfO ' ~::£LlI~ , *mi:f199ii1iJ~1UI fJfiJ!~' ill155&Zf~l'l'9iM~ 0 W*tJf,i;, :g:AOJftJJteU~'M:~:!Ii;' 1"f~:i!!~Ii!IlI~Jii jeaEiWjijijl¥lDlf*l1Jf~. •.

(13) 184. § ~Illk i31 ~~~f(g:W1¥J § I¥J*~ •••. Fljftl!ll~aii1fiJf~2ft~. Yt ' fffl pxJ1$ilittl¥J ~1!:fleftUJt lfm~recr5~:W r~~7.~.I¥JMNtt·.mtt·. J. 185. il';lf ill'fihl'ti*j;Jf~.:t.if-Jl. *-!lli.j;Jf~EASTASIANSTUDIES 2007if-Ul ~;'+A~~-JIij. lFaeIR;fi'llIf:'~lc(,l~ , ~liJf~illttWrp~*~l&:r5~~. .s:f:i. . .tt~l&:. JI;1(W3:;k:.*,ffiumW[ li:lf~fiIT 1j;I]:J:!Il.f!{f1!. ·~~g%·.D• •ml&:r5R.W• •~ • • • ~I¥J~~mm. • f§f[~ral¥JtiJf~~Jt~. 0. J. ~1&. ' JJ:MJ¥g{*retmm. '~~~A~~fffls'il.W*~~~~~~~I¥J~. 111.. , ~1il¥JliJf~]l~ , m5~1.!~l¥JliJf~ J oQJmJlt~-=Fl¥JmJ¥.~ , ~ImW~~~:WI¥J!1al5 ' , .~~~lfm~recml¥JtiJf~lfiB.tJUt.J:W;E rlfm~l&:mJ. "~J¥~~mFF"';;!t~ 1r:p~~~J *xm~I¥J~~n~'-nOO~~n~~~~:w,~~r~l&:J. r .ttl&: J liJf~ , 5J- n1IiHW1E:fII~~mJ¥fiifil ' ~ali r ~rec J r J uJf~ illfB:!t~IIlr.gJr ' J{1J1W~r*»~~l&:. ' 1Z\~Ji.*IiJf ~Il!l!~ , *~fUt~~lJiz ; 1&~J{rjlJi»$~MJjJ¥ ' ii~~6fl~rec ~~ , fJJ¥!111t~~.~!VG 11~SZ ' ~{W.~~~IfiI¥J§~ , fI~~~mJ¥~:W ' ~.*1Z\ifEt.J~D)ji ~J¥l¥Jlfm~recyS~~ , E! 19901f.{-\,:r:-rWH& ' lJf~~mffi:llB ' {11~1!f~1'f)J{'F ' ~fjJJfm32:~ , iiW~5'i-~m~mt ' 0. 0. n~~. r r:p~lJf!illfB J l¥JilJfig. 0. 12mJ¥~rec~:w. '. ~~mtW~mmm'.~~~mn~,. ~recmlJf!~iii. '. ~~1'fl!;fJ~J1:. r r:-r~lJf!illfB J. I¥JTf**~. (t(l&:ys~M~~. ,~~recr5~IiJf~~*W~*OOI¥Jl&:m~. %·fffl~~zOOl¥Jrecm~%mnmft~·.~~~~~o~~,~. '~Y.~~~l&:m*M~»~.~~~*MI¥J ;~~~~*ZOOI¥J.hWti~h~%~~IiJf~;~~' W1n~3trecmffjU ;E~'jiW¥J1Ji!VG3l&I¥JWf~. , ii~Jj~::~ ~l&:m~ ~.::t.i3"J t. ffi.1n~~rec~'~.~_Wf~~.~.JJf'~~~1n~*~. 0. '~~~~~~'~T~~~~'lli*~ffi~1!:f~,~~~~'. 0. , ffflW::~-~7ii~~*rs'I¥J~~t.J»x{t.rm{*,. 0. ~~. ~~~~~ti,m.~m~moo~,~-m~1n~~~*~. OOI¥Jf[.g%;~=m.JIt.~W• • l¥Jn$(~mu~·. .mffjU~.). ; ~:::-3i~:~m . ~m . ~~~!VGl¥Jf§gIiJf~. a. 2. ~"'~~.~ 0. alW#• • ~~~l&:mm*m~MI¥J~.ft~ • • , *~I¥J~~l&:r5Wf~m'fffl_tt*~~~~~~.gW • • tiJf~. 10. !!i!JiLl!' r ~. ~33. . 19;$:fG '. ~JiLllt;lii , *m,*,agjifij~IMIf*-J!I!. 1. U~~. 0. 11. tlDIlI'iW~~PJT;!:f<~ , ~}jI'l9I!11~fflimi ' ~::fOJfigmtlllffl!ll~nu~ , iiW15'Ja;MAI1*~\4f ' 12. ~~ ~~ , 1!II~1MIf*- : 1Ilji.,*,IIlJ!l!~ (JZi'$. • ffijIll'iWrnJ~i¥Ji).if~ . ? : JZi'$A.61;l±lll&lil± ' 2005) •. ,. *~l!llt. '. jijr5~~IUl! (fj:;[t :. lifW ' 1990)' ti 172. 0. ~.f'f~1!f~1:B r ~~j!ilatL.I ' r ilfJ~H1*-.I ' r ~~f;ll~ ~~~ilq:i:fl:ftJj , r l!II~liff~if-J:lIt~tt -.I . tt)1lIll~m:~~11. 2. roJJ:a. 0. 0. < http://www.tisanet.org/Activity/file! 0405160 I.doc.

(14) 186. ~§.j;Jf-~EASTASIAN STUDIES 20071j'-1. Yl. ;ttff£~1J~~~if:&1E1*~fi-3(*. '. i;'~~r!ih,t){;j;Jf-~.:t..~l!l. ~:="-b\.~~-JIil. 187. : ti~. ~~'OO~ • •if:&~tRR~m~ftf¥Jm.,**m~ • •if:&ffl. *.if:&~* • • • ~m·if:&~*.fi-~*·$~*.if:&ffl* • • •. .Jmq'.~hlf~f¥JM~~fi-~~·*~itm~.Jmf¥J.~f1i!~ ft . ~~t'I~~ftft . J;)&£Jf~~~~~liift~==='1flii ' jJ[]J;)~a)j. fiH. 0. ~:v:*~B"J$?t. '. ~t~. ~m·~~M.*.if:&~~m~m • • • ~m~;~:V:*.$ffi' ~1j~*$*.if:&ffl* • • • {~~Jl . r~iT*.~.f*ftif:&m¥ft!~m.. *·~.* • • • • *~.&.*·~.fi-m.~ • • • &*~· 1:Ehlf~~fMJnm. ' if:&1il*• • • • {~hlf~q:t;[j,~ti.l&~m;fj. ~m~w.o~fi-,~~g.~~~M~~~.m~.~B"Jhlf~. fiH '. :. m·.~. q:t:9chlf~~~~£Jf~fiH. .. if:&1tl*.*2hlf~fiH¥ft!ffUIWf. •• *.*m~m·.rr*~~.m·~.*.~*m¥ft!. ~~m·~&m~W~*.~q:t~m~o. 1£~f~1tf¥J{ti.~ , ~fL : :tt!.!f~llift . ~l::Jo/)~tltH~~~*.. ~$U~:f.l· mnf:j,lll~.1Jl:flim· ~**lI:{:I(,. 7l<1ilJM!Jfz ' $W:r5~ . ~.f*.~1P'lJVMT ' ~{ll~~ . f.{~'lmmi!J . j,t~r",'Jm .. .M~~·.~~lJJh~IJJ·~.~~.~r~~·~~wa·~. ¥ft!.M~tRR~~~·~~¥ft!&~M~tRR~.3~~• •~~• •. 0. ( =) ~JGftm~i&ffift'1~~~~. .~~~~*'~.if:&m~m~'~*~~~fi-3(·. ~F• •~~~Jmf¥J.m~t1:f1i! B fMi11. f¥JtRWtB**m~~ll'fJlilii. '. 0. ~~:~ B. ~?VM&j6aEl~.f*ft. .. ~¥-ft § mJtil'HB.~~if:&~~Im~~~ , {JjJ;)J.!Il.~&• •#.ill!!!. • •ti.. ~ • • ~~ • • ~·~~~¥~~.,m*~m·~*.A~.~. '. ) IJ{ft~~ftm:~~lHi. (. ~--~m'~Rhlf~B"Jm~~·~~'**.~if:&~m~~m• • •3C~fH. ' l';11ifi~gljfJT~Jmf¥J~llZi.JfMi't1: ' Jr~~1tJt~ifB~. ~"**1m~ .... " ~»I~ij(11::;. ~P:*~3¥I. 0. '. ~.f*ft. ~ft~.f*ft. .. 1ti~*.ttm · ~U~D r ~~if:&ffl J • r • • ~f~ J • r ~~if:&ffl~m-~~ J r m.0i~ J o. r. •. r .~~Jl~ J. •. r fi-3(i&~ J. •. r j\;~fij?)E J. •. •. r ~.~*,J J. ~¥ft J -~ijJ.B 'It ~~F~~.{~&~~if:&¥"2t~lmt'l~uJf~~. ~f1!ftt~~.f*ft· ~ElW~m~.f*ft· ~'lmmlJJ~¥ft~lii[fiJ 4~fi- '. It ' jffi§)!U"s~~iiijJJEifiz~1~ . &:!tf1i!~.f*~mmlJfMi'I'1Z~~1.j\[J. ;fiit~.if:&m~ mB"J Jiflill fffil§ , 21 tit*c~ Jr. rl:ntit«t'I~£Jf~f1i!!t. .~~ fE!..~~~~f~1tt'l~~1M' ~fIiijl~~m-11ilii' ~~tl*m '. 0. m. 0. WU~Dnfl:jfVjifLl]lr",'m. '. 1qil)fj~!!h.f*E{±AOB"JpJG~ffiit~.~. ~·~HB"J~~ • • • **~~tit~'1:E.Vj.&f¥J.hB~i11* ~.if:&~£}f~~~:@.:~t:Jo/)~tl1'1. z. '. f1!jk.'t1~B.~~fl:rl:f'Jm. .. $i~. .. ~f~. . !lm&.. 0. Im~ r ~f~ftW¥~m-'fi!E-fl J • r ~f~ftf1i!~~i6(~*~tI'f J ~~ffi!. &. 0. fi.fi-,.~~ • •~~*.·m~.*.· • •tt~*.3·ffi. Hm.i6(ffi.~B"Jlii~~.~~ft·1:E.3~.Wm.~·.~m. ~tit~f¥J~~~Jm·~~~Jm·~±~~·~lli~ff·$~~.·. •5. m~~ (~'Rli±~ . f~a3(-~) . ~~~A:fIJ;)&ID"P.m~~~. ' 6. 3. ¥i*.iI}':~~lill1;IrItHJf~*I\'Jt~~1'lfIX?Jflffi . *fW§:ffi . B 4>:J5[r • filT ~miffr . fIUIWT J5fi~. .lltRti~OJft!f~Z~ Jl.tfi- ' **"£~tl!.mi1f~ , "6J~JJiJ;)~l~.O~. 0. 0. 4. ~*'9:~*ilI. ' 2006111~~~fi~ • tlUJfIt.fJ1Ji/6 < http://www.president.gov.tw/downloadl2006---NSC.pdf>. 5. Todd Sandler~ , .*Jft!.~. 0. ,. ~~~iii:t..ag~~. (t:J:.ft : 9GJl ' 2003) , Ja45 • 48. 6. fEllmil!J!~IDl~~~~*H~~"N < http://www.explore.georgetown.edulviews/?viewid =56&term=06A http://ias.berkeley.edu/iastp/2006Summer.html> 0. 0. 111111'"1'.

(15) 186. Jk.sa$Jf~EASTAsIAN STUDIES 2007+1 fl ~ :::'+A~~-JIJl. ~""II~itiaiJf~:z~JJl. Jt.ftfl~rJM3~1i1:il:Xm~~ji- 5G* ' m 1I*~a~J1if5:5t '. : triit *~iI:X~~m.M~m·iI:X~*'~~~·~~*~il:Xm*~.R ~m·~~ • • *~il:Xm~W~mm.M~m~;~~*~$~' ~~ • • *~iI:X~*m.R~m·.tt*~~.~iI:X~w.m. ·~.*.m • • *g.B~*·~.~M~~E • •B*~o o. ~~'OOfi~.il:Xmg.~mffi~~m~'**~~~.il:Xm. • • ~' • • W~~.~~~~~·*~tt~~~.~.~W. ~·.~~ffift~'~&liJf~fi.~~OO~~=1JOO'. ( -). fiJT '. .tm : rp:9<:~~Il*W:~liJf~prr . iI:X~*~~*!TI!liJf~pfiWf!UiWr. . ~itim.*~.~5lipfi . t~iI*~~mprr • 3~.*.!TI!);:pfi1'Ji:1 ~~M'~»$~W~*~~~§fiJT~o. .. ~FL. ~~U~• . m~f$.:m~?Ntmm. ~.1Ii1t. :. .. ~~ffi@ttW'-E~*t;1C. ' ~#~1~ . *iiiJJRIif:z . $r¥-t5~ ,. ~• • ~M~fi·.~M~·~mm.·.~~.· .M~~·~.~.h~It.J·~.~~wm~~B·~~W~'~ .~~~g~~~E·.~.~~~~g~~E~;Jpl't;1C~~• •. ~--~m,~.~~~~.m·~~'** • •il:XmliJf~~m.. ~"**JN~ -. tzgJJ!~~1t:. i$t;1C~~• •. , 1'f1l'HlrPJgrl;ffr• •B9f§lilHl'M~t 'J!:!:~r~1tJt.MBml;. 0. ". ). .*~~~*'m.il:Xm~liJf~'_*~~~~~ . • • • • ~l't;1C31:~m~;[.J' Ef31i1:~lMt5&Hl ' t,W**,~tIlf . jfr±~WA~$fJ! ~ft*~~ , ;Jpi$t;1C~~jjifiJ1!~j!~t1JjilI31~ttt ~Efi0-EI ' ~J*1t 0. 0. ~g~B**iIi:I~~mJWoo ' ~*.»iI:X~~J*1t . Y.:1t~J*1t . $~fB~~.1t· ~8~.m~.1t· ~tfljmlt.J~.1t~[HilpJ 4:5J~ , :E'tt ~.il:Xm*~ 71'flf9M-lliiffif ~ , 21 i!t *c~]I! 1Hl7±:~ i!t 1-t~ liJf ~W i-t • o~~M~··~.~.·~.~~.~ttAD~~~ffifM.~ o~B~~~~~.**~ffii!tft·::f:E• • •~~.hBattt* z . ' m.il:XmliJf~~ffi{~:E!!!W1:.~ffifttt . $75F • *,,1~ . M,\Ui'i&$ 0. fJ!7k.'f1:f§IHl~M1-tF",'JmI. 3.. IJ{ft~.ftUJf~~a. ::f:E~J*1tB~lfj~r-. ::f:EW~~f.1JOO ' il:X1i:l*~~.IHl~liJf~~{J\~triit~1i~:g ~~~W.o~~·#.g~~~~~~~~a~~ • • ~~~. 187. 0. 5. ~:lCft.~il:Xml¥J~~.:f~. I. .ftgn#~ffi.m.iI:X~~R • • @·m~:E!!!.&l't;1C• •. f6~*tt;m:. '. r • • 0$ J. f9U~D r ~.il:Xm J •. r ~.~Jl. J. •. •. r ~• •. r ~~il:Xm J. •. f* J • r • •iI:X~~tIlf' J r ~~lfj~ J. r • •~~*·U. ~'ffiffi$• • N~.zm.·&Jt.w~.~m • • tt~~.~B ~ttt1fo M~. 0. {El.P9fi1i1:~.1t~~~. r ~fj(1tW¥~m~f'l J. •. , ffitll\im:1i1:~1J1fItiOO ' ~f:9U*m . r ~J*1tt1iJ • •il:Xm.m J ~.fj 0. ft~~'R~~ • • m.*~·M~~*~·. • •tt~*'~,. rm••il:Xli:l.fjB~iID~ ~rJ~J.1,ffi~ , tE*~~.f~miU J::. • iHrJ~ ~.31:~ (~'~± • • f-4~31:~) ~.#~hJ1~@!Z~. 0. Jlt~. 4. . .. '$§~.'. , ~1~A~t)&fDZP:liJf~~•••. **1£.f~mi!lJ::.. '. 6. -rlJ~JJAit)~tjB~. 6. mlDl~WilTIf~~*W~-&*Itl]:i < http://www.explore.georgetown.edulviews!?viewid =56&tenn=06A http://ias.berkeley.eduliastp/2006Summer.html> 0. 0. •. •. ~.r~.~J-~.Bm~1i1:.~.~&.~il:Xm.~~liJf~~. ?mw~.£~.·~m~.·. ¥~D::*~~~liJf~~I!*~~f:f~lIflffi ' *i¥fiillf:IT ' B.<$:p)r ' tlLT~lIflffi ' jIU,1fWT ffiW'. , 2006~~'li::~¥lilii!r ' .*1f1A'lI!Il'I6 ' < http://www.president.gov.tw/down load/2006---NSC.pdf> 5. Todd Sandler~ , Ji€*!JQ:~ , *,M~iitt...ag~1i5 (El'~t : .:7t~ , 2003) , :f[45 • 48. "I.

(16) 0'1 00. .......-<. ~ ~ 'I{. it. ~. ~-e. ~. §r. w t!' -i0. ~. \. ~. -<. ;,$. + iI\. ~. m:::. -. .\li0 N. !;. eLl. ""Q. f-. ::> f/l. z. ;:::; -(. "f-" « "". IJ.1 ~. it. T1.J. '€ I :. tIll. *'". t-. ,. m:. rt. 'J:r1 l§ :g; ~ :;;r tt ll«~~ ~~ ~~ ~~. ill:[. ffil(. ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ,. . i1. ~. •. it! ~ -P<. -<. fI. ~ t::!. 1$I1 'lili'. I:I1. . 'ita :g; g~ Ii. $: ~ ;Ifr rK. 0. 4u. lEt- ~ +'( J:j :g; ~ ~ ~. 0. 14-. i:tl t:l. ~. !lii\ ~ ~ ~. :g;. :tH a:* @; ~. 2l. ~ ~. IlA. =. :g; ~ 1. ~t IR ~ ~. ~. II. II ~ II ~ $ :E l!t 11 .!!L m-. ~. ~ . ~ ~. ~. 'h:\ 11. .......-<. "*. 00 00. $. ~~. IIlJ. 1:::1 ~. rt. H{~. **. fI. ~. it!, $:. .. ~ ......... :g; *'" ~ ~ iIlf\ ~ ~~ I: 14- =>. ~ io ~ l$::> ~ ~ f\Ill( ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~ 10' ~~ -+<. ~ ~4< ~ ~. 10' $ 0. .. ,.,... !lii\ ~" ~ 4: . 2l ~ ill :g; ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ Il«~1 ~ ::1r ~~ nll fI ~~. ~. l!?I. .. t::!.. I:I1. •. = **. .II!. ~. 0. 40. .. =. m. me. 1i. 0. !. . •. rt. ~ g~ ~ ~ ~ WJ ~ ~ IIlJ ~ *'". +l $: !lii\ rt 1;c;; EEl ~ IIi~ !lii\ ~ Iii ~ ffi ~ :g; :g;. .!7' -m -,. ~. "':-. L. *e. ~. tt tt. •. .\. 0. .llL. . . ~ ES ~ ~ ~ \ID5 '=" tt ~ 11 B?J ~ ~ ~~ ,"'" ~ ~ . s:m $ f{lll; ~~ 11 :g; ~ ~ -'1 .!7' '. -m $f .!7'= rt ~ 11 . m {tlc J:j r< $ Iii :\111' ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ mC1 . ~ ~~ rt t1B ~ Ii': ~~ :ttl ~ rt ~~ l§ ~~. ~ ~. ~. 0. .\l.\J. 0. ~ ~. • rt. '..,.-. 41II!. ~~. •. ,. .. tIll. *'" .. l§. ~. 1\. +117. ~. ,. ~. ~. 11. ~. **.. B?J. ~. ~. ~. ,. ~*. .. t::!.. 1. I:I1 .. *. it! ',~h:\. ~* :g;. ,. ~. -k;. ~~. $:. ~. ~. WJ. IlL. 8(*. IZ ~. 1. :g;. $. lIil. I:::l. III. " • 0. 0. "J. ~~. f,.,.,j '. €~ rrr::. :ttl"". $'<t \jIl$N. "Jt :W5 $. ~~ ~~ 0 '. 0. JELl#. ~~. · .. -R5 N -. ~:..i ~!l. r-:. .~. •. ~ ~ :1!;! :g; . ~ ilr' IlL 'll ~ ~rr ~* ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Wi ::1r * , ~ ~ a:* ~ 1~ . :g; ~ ~ ~~ g~. It-> ,-.wr* $: $. ~oH!. •. ~ :g; ~ ~ . ~ WJ WJ .\l.\J 4;;0;: ~ :g; ~ ~ ~ I: ~ iO inHl. •. '-/. 0. i:tl 40. IIlJ. ~ ~ ~ ~. ~ :g; ~4 g~ I![ $. 0. ~ IS ~ ~ t¢ S{It h\;:: i.l:C rK. ~. '=' ~ Ilt:1 14 :g; @[ ill :g; 2l. ~o. I:. ~ ~ :g; . I~ *'" ~ f- ~ ~ !!i . . r-.. .. 1::1. ~. =. l$::>. ~ ~ ~ ~ mW. 0. :E 11 ~ ~ "':11 ~ ;tl ~ ~ ~* ~ ~ ~ ~r a:* ~ ~ a:* ~. g~ fL W ~ $ IR ~ ~ 4rr e! :g; ~. wr~ ~4. ~ :; ~o ~ ~ Il [IT""! ~ ~~ IlL. ~rr. ~ J..t:t:. 11 II!'"". 1\1. • •. ~ = 4!Jlt!. ~. 11. tl. ~ ~~. m. 11 ~* ~ m:: ~ :g; q~ ~ Jf """' 0 40 D~ IR ~ . e! . ~ g~ ~ H $: ~ g~ :g; ~ $ {llj,. WI. 4H: 2l. :g;. 1\1. ~. g~. It ~ ~ ~ WJ ~ :1% I: ~. **. ~. ~. 2l. 14<:-. ~ =. 11 io ~ :g; ~ 11 . ~ ~ ~ 11 ffii :¢:; t.a. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~\ ~. 0 .!7' -m ~ .!7' $f ~ -m l!?I ~ ~ ~ :i:(!j ES ~ ~ . ~. mI I: ~ ~ N H{~ '1.J IIi:lI ffil( ~~ RH II gg !W 14 $: :g; 11 It. ~. 1 :g; * $:. 0. . * .. :jnj~. ~. ~. r-.. IT2. tt. 0. ~ ~ ~ "': ~ . ~ ifil( ~ ~ ~ Iii ~ "': ~ hi: l!lM II @; :g; !! J1 -H1 ~ ~. tH ~ ~ ~ ~ :l;: "':~ ~ ~ jifu 10' :ij ~ ~ 2l = IJIl(,. ~. ·. ~. "':-. ~. iO. ~ i§. -P<. ~ "':-. ,. iit?l. ~. , P- ~ ~ ~m · :; . g~ '-' fri $ R6 1;] ~ nlla ~ :g; ~ ~ ~ 1* 4< :g; ~ = I: {III. ~. .. ~ ~ ~. :g;. I ~ 1\1 Cl G\ 10' P< :g; :.q ~ JlI)T! ~ :tH \ttl ~ z2 }E :ti M ~. •. ~ ~ £- ~ ~ :1[( :jnj( · {4< ~. -+< .. *. 1*. *. ~ .~ ~.. rt IS ~ i:tl ~ r,.J'" ~~ $ rt 1* :E ~ :t: ~ ~ ~ ~ Cl ~ £Cl ~ DR ~ -m ~ ~~ ~ II :g; ~ WJ ~ ~ ~ 11 rK :t: 4rr ~ ~ .. ~ :¢:; ~ · IDI $: T\" 1*, +'( ~ !f ~ I: t::!. io ~ ~ ~ I.J.l :g; ~ , ~ "'-1 · Cl ~ ~ ~~ ~ nt g lilt $ ~ £- ..l...J ~ I: . . s:m ~ T\" io ~ ~ ~ rK ~ 1* ~ 1£ ~ 4J g ~ ~ it .~ ~ ~ · ~ W !ll · ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ :g; Jll1IT , m; :ij ffil( ~ IE ~ :g; g~ ~ ~ ~ iIl@ 1£ II Cl $ :¢:; "':ffifn ~ ~ £- I.J.l Cl ~ ~ tnm f{lll; I.J.l nli ~ ~ ~ . ~ r< ~ :g; i£ ~ :11l[I ,.. W~ ~ tg ~~ $ll ~ => ~ :g; liIIB l!!I ~~ l$::> ~ ~ ~~ Cl IE illI I.J.l I: 11 $ '-t1 ~· ~ ~ i£ .iJ ~~ mm wa ~ . io $ }E ~ ~ ~ 2l 1~ . ~ :g; I: ~ · 2m ~ 14<:- io :g' :¢:; Il ~ ~ . -k; QR ~ ~ ~~ 1\1 ~. ~ tnm :g~ ~. ~ ~ 10' ~ fI i:tl :51. f:I !lii\ ~ It-> :t: ill m ,-.~ N ~ ti \1RIlI. 'II. ~ ~ ~ g~. ~. $ ~ "':-. 1::ID. I§. M. '11.

(17)