身份─契約─制度─功能：台灣社會安全法制法展之檢討

全文

(1)/. f. /. \0. 00. ..;t. I. If'). " ..;t. ~. -\J. '*\. + ~ \if. In{. .~. ~~. 1\. +~. ~~. ..... *. ~-K. *'"''"'~~. -K~ ,t{. ~. V\i[. ~~. 4tII!. ~. I. ~ _r ttte. I. ~. i<. I. ~. 1I\\. ~. $. mg. ~. ~ '::::'" ttre. :ttl t4i1. {~. • ~. M. 40. I. ~. *. ~. *". linD. fail I'. fl~~. W ~. ~m '="', mW. 1m«. 1Dl~. ,. ..ffi:m. ~lli. l§.. 0. :tfi~~. ?;1:i~ttr.;> ' ttL!!.. ~. mW:tfi. 5E~e ~~12. ~. i«tE~. ~m. ,. ~. \. 1ffi~~. ~. -<. 0. \. ~. '-'. ~. ~. .~. ~. ~. :{i;'. ~ -E. o~. ~~. ~~. ~irum. -'. .~. -t!~ ~~. ". ~~ ~\O. ~tl ~ ',," ~ ~ ". 4<~. ~~. ~~. *. .~. tt!i .m. ". :tfim. ~·o. .~\L-. ~ ~. 4<4<. * . !\lII:. :g 4a mJ(. ~~r::: *~\mI::. ~~. mW iIil. 1H~m. ~~~ lo'iK~. ". :g~. -~~. L II[ mW ~~1-1t1. :b-t t;s:. 4a ~ $11:. ~ m~ ~. iK~~. -m$11:. :tfi1IrC'~. ~ ~. lila. ,. m :tfi. ~. lJlIIT"'(~. ~ ~ i«.. ~. ¢~m. ~. ~. mW ~1. ~. 1. wa~i~~. ~~mR:" m:InKm. .5 tOm. /l). ~~$lit?. ~. ml¥i~+<iru. ~. '="'~±1iK }ffi -:~ Iiii:' m ¢~'~ ~ ~ ~ ~' ~. ~~m~ iK iK • .,. -'}ffi. :tfi. ~~~~. ~ ~w. 0. !. ~. W~~.. OJ. ~4lII!:tfi!Itt. ~. 1l11~ tIIj. :tfi i!!. +<. ~ ~ ~ ~. 4r- ~ iIil. L. .If.. !J~. *. n.J~. ~~ .. N~. ~. ~. $l~ 1. ~!. Nf«. ¢. g:rN 4r- -, MU~. WiK. mW 4a ~. ~~ ~ ~!. l#-~. 4:1 ~ 4:1:11 1. ~lffiIa. wm. ~. +<.

(2) I.

(3) ~ft--~~-.jJt-J'.JJng,. 459. m'~~~~ ffi~~~~~~~s~~~M'~~*~~~~~~~-~~n ~'W~~~~~W,~~~+ft~~$.~~'~~. ~~Pff-fl}mtfj~rt:l~~2. 0. .~*. gt!ftffi~JN~~ffi~3i{t~~3. , ~Jl~A. ~~.~~~~~(-A-A~-AA-)ftAmm(. /\ftli) ffi~~'. mmtfj~~*ftffi~m~~4. 0. .Jt ' ;ttm5Iffl~ttflRl1:tE. H~~tEffi~~'W~tE~*~,~m~·~~~ft~~. ~Jl~~~*W~ftAx~o~!ft~~~~~.'~l1:tE~~~,. ~tE.~~m'Wfl*~·2~~~~~~~~ffl~~~*~~o 'ti~D*~~. Summer Maine. ~iBlIllN~ffi. mmtfj. 'JW~,~~~~IF-f{-tm~ Henry. r ~7t¥U~~ J ~~~~~~Hij~~~. ~m~'~~T~~~~/Am. , m5t¥U. ~ffi~m~.oMm-m~~,m. ~~-A*-tfjE~~ftffi-.IF-f,~~~~.*~(;tt~~-W7t 5JUtfjE~- /\*-t:. .-. /\/\li . -. /\nl!]) #rr *tfj#!. 0. ti(m~~~~. ~.~~ftffi,~;tt.~ffi~~~mtfj:ffi~x~~~~~~~~*. .~~.~.W.M ~ft. $. •• ~M~~7tffi~.~~~~ffi~,.~~tE. m~T~;g ~. : The movement of the progressive societies. has hitherto been a movement from Status to Contrace. 0. *~~~~~:iltt&. 2. ;ff !P1 B!] lt~j! ....~ Klaus F. Rohl, Rechtssozio\ogie, 1987 ' JGJt- jf 537. 3. ~l*~~.LB!]~~M'.~'. itA T. ". •• #'.M~~~#*~B!]~~,.t~A*. ~B!]~*AlJJ.tA-" ~-*I!t Lumann 'Habermas l-A.1t~~#B!];fl.it~~'+Jf~'+Jf. *'j , .£ ~ tb Teubner. -f1t~~#1t.B!]-itt*rl p-lj.tjf~Aili: 1~B!] ik* ~JJ.tA-. l-~i.t. JJ.~' *~#f~4<t~ljlttA-" ;ff~1tA-i!j!"'.~ Rohl'. ' ~#~;f::l:."JJ.tA-B!]-itt*,j ;ff MB!] ittA- ' 1! JL"*" ~:t ' Jiil/itii , Jf 65 v). T " "AT· 537 "AT; *~fi:t. 4. Henry Maine, Ancient Law, reprinted 1954 '. Jf. 100 ". Jiil/itlt,. jf. 0. .-itt :£t1tJt. 20 YAT· 34. , 1991 ' jf 105 "AT".

(4) ,. 460. JIt.kf-fh-f;:.fIl. ~~~~.'~~~~$~~llim~~A.~~.~' F~1i. ~~~:f!,5G~~Ht. 0. *~Etrf]{~t~~5tfff6. ~. , -armJj}5t¥U~~~~. ' Jt±~OO. g ;}. ~. ~. ;;±.'l::I:r/.-~. 3t!C1JBI1*. (Al=Frr ~. ±~ f~~. *~7f!f. li?£*l7f!f M~glT. §EE. 1Ttt~$UW~Jt±. ~.. ZP:~WfLm§m. ~lliJj} &JJf" (Kooptation) ~. ~OOA ~. 110M. gtGgtWM gg~JE~± tt i~dlI. (Inititation) tR:JE~±tr::gf1I7. M~mm*M~OOA . ~OOA. ~lm. ~n. EE~-ar~'m.Jj}5t~~~~.R'WJt~~~~~~~llim~. 6. ~:\:. -Nt ~~ Rehbinder 1i<..vt Ferdinand Tonnis( Gemeinschaft und Gesellschaaft, 8 Aufl., 8. Aufl.,1935, J[ 184) z~J.1ltl.1lJii~ 0 ~I. Ji: 7. 83. mRehbinder, Rechtssoziologie, 4. Aufl., 2000,. 0. .... ~ • • ~~~~~~~~~~.Jii~~~.~~&.~~.o~~*~~#.~4'. •• #.Jii~**~~.~,~a~~o4+a,~~~~~#~a~~.#.~ .Mo~~~~~~~~~~.~-.~.~ ~~~~~$~ • • ~4~*.'~~_~~. •• ~. $~~~~-.~.A.*~ (~~~~~,~ ~$~. ••. .~)*'*~~$.~Jii$~~~~.o~~~~'L~.~A~:~~~~~ ~1: ' ~~~~.t*t'*~.~. 0.

(5) \ ~~~~-;)jJt-~k~. 461. ~~'W$~~@lA~*~'*~~~~±~mm~,~ffijmM~m OOA~~~.~~~,~mM~mzp:~~~~~fi~ff!f'~~m~~ ~~.~rao~~~~,. f~ IC/fn:: f~ IJ tTi!J. .fYl.. JJ.-L IIIJ. a. r~l~m6. mr~~. lIB! /\. ,li!, JD' l=I. J,/". I. ~ J. ~~--:fJD. r:lJ i'i7U 1& IllS;. Mff~~m*~~°nt~@lA~m~,~m@lA-arM~~EIffi Rt~jfr±ftfUJ{*~I~. , RP~J5JT~ r. J. 0. ~.A.~ft~,nt~~~~M~Rm.~~~. ,~m~. .*¥$J5JTm*~§.o-AO=~$.~~.'~. $~*. ¥$~~m,~.~~r~~J$~~~-@l~.o~*ft~~.~. ~.*¥$&$~~~.~mA.~~~m*m.,~r~~~~~J ~W~~$'~R~.~ J&~m¥tiEP~. ~~m~.~.'~~~~~~~$$.. 0. ~~~~8~.~' ~~m-~rffi. E~=+~~mM®$$&¥'W.. ~~~J~$$&¥'~~~$$¥$ogtnt,. ~~~~~~-n~~~J5JT~r~E~$W~~ttftJ. 'J5JT~. ~6{l4HE::fI::t;E11- • iUlQ 'j J\'~ '1't- ~ ,.·0 .. 1.r:p~. ~~-@l~.. ,ffij~*~$. ~~~. ~. .,~~m~M~$$;. ~m*~m~$$&¥'±~~~~. •• ~~m~M~~$'~. r ~~ J m~M~~$f!jUJ.t gtnt'~~~~7~~~ ~.. 0. lli~~~m. ~~~~,~~. ~T~T:. ~M~~.~~.~ft~-arM. ~E~~$$ti. ~*~&~~~!fif]jti~m. 0. ······ftfr'R3jtt~~$J;J1&~$. $Wr:p~"6{"t$$~~:W. ' ft~@!-arf{J¥U-~~~m~ , .ep. fUJ~~Ji!JI~~~~~mJE~~9Wm~. 0. ······~ffd:ft~Jt[1J. .-/.

(6) r. 462. 1tkf-fh~.. OO*.'M.·tt~·. •• M,-m~~~WB~.~m,. ~Y$~LB~*~~ffR'-mAR$~LW~~'~~ fl$~L~~~oM~§~'$~$~~~~~M~~ill~. ,*fffilWm1. 80. ~~'fl~$~~$~~~'~~¥~$~~B*&~~*~~ *R+A~~*·=+~~W~$~~~'X~~ti~$·.~.~ $$~~.~'~~W.~~$~~.. DR~.~~N$'~~.. #~~.~N~~~~'ili~~B*~~&=~*~ •• m$.~$ ~$~~~*,~m~.~+A~~*~BM~7~~$~~~~~. ~D-A~A~M.'~.~~~~~·~~~~.~'fffi~~ft· §~~$~~~~ftD~~'~.~R~7$~$~~~~W~~'. ~~~$~~~~*~~.~oill~'~.~$~ •• ,~~.~r~ ~J$~R*~'X~R$.~~.~TWff~~tt~m~~.D~ ~,~eM. ••. 'R~~mLMWM~fi~~~$~~~?. ~~,~m~~-Ali~~R~.ffi¥~~r~~$~~.W$. .U!!Ifl~1t J 'Rp~titim~k~~ffi~ill' Mt~'6m ~fr'~$~~~~~~. :. § ill ~~JJj(~U7 ' ~~jf1:E5G ~. m~. 'UflM~.~5G~IT.7;ffiM~~~~&fl~.. ~i1!ti7. '. m~~k~~&flJJj(lftt@1~. ~.~.7~~,m#~~ fr,~!&.9. ; ······{foJ{~~m~~JE. •• a~~~7~~W~.'~. 0. 8 .~#,t~*_.t~~.,-~A~.~.~$~~ •• *~4nlo 9 £~~,~«~_~ •• tmoo.~re' •• -~A*'*.~~.~*~-~A - • • 'I~'%o.

(7) ~:1t-~~-~JJt-.w~E. 463. ffiIft ~ ~ , 1\ ' -t;+if* ' W~JE1$::f .R!f.*~iJl1rlo , ~:¥~~ ~m~~&~r:p~~tJ~1t;1$~~jt~m~iJIJfHt~~~. 0. f§E!m-i&m. ~.~~~W~.ft&~'~m~~'~ft.~rr~#.oo.ft-OO Ma~ft.,~1t;~~. ••• ~OOm~U~~A~.~1t;1$~g,. ~~r:p~A~~~~m~B~E~~mo~Ift-~m,:¥~.~~1t;. fMOO ~. II ,. ~A:t!;~i&*'HB.ftOO5l:¥UiH~zffif. tJ~nX;7 Ift-~m. ••. '~~~.~JE1$~~.. m~.5~~~,tJ.~~~~~~B. ••• ~~~OO~~~~. ~.~~W~.~o.!ft,tJ.~1t;~ ~fj. '. 0. 1t;~?~!ft'~-hEOif~~ffi~ffi.mlli~.m~ffiftA.~' ftl!~ :.~1f"~ft~~ffi1**FJ~. , ~~~g§tf~jt~1t;1$$lJg , OO~*. ~fE~~m7m~' -~1tX¥ffi~~~~OOii~titt~ff1~$ag. 0. ••••••. *~fE~~,~~~~@~m1$u~~,~oo~m.::f~umm~, *~1f\~~::ft:~rB~Z~3f@. , ~t&X3(~12?. ~ffi~~~,~~tJ.~m-~~~~~.5l:,~~M~~.5l:,. ~~. ~~m~:¥~~M~~B~~.~~. i&m~~. ,. ••. ,@Ift~£m-¥~~. ' OO~F ffifM '. ii*~ffiffr±.iff~ (~~O~~~) ffimI!J~1t;1$fitil. t!m-ffr±.El.~{t~~1$~¥ ~O~ Hirsch m1IHfl}~. ' ~~ti~~ft~. r .~JlI{tJ. 13. , .5l:~~-fjffr±.fjf=.fI4 , ~~mr¥UI*J{t~ffr±. .~m~nX;ffi,~~m~~tt~.5l:o. ~~,m~ffi~mlli!ft~~.::f.RBlli*~~'~:¥B~A7~. -00 ~ *c ' @ t2. ~ ~ ¥} -:tK. ~ ~ El =+~ *c fJ] RPfJti iJ IA~ ~1t; ita ~ 1$ IO~~~-~~~.kM~ ••• *.~.~. II. ... ~~*ft~-.~t.~o. ~~.~.~'~~&~~A ••• ~~~.$.~~~,.t4~~~~~t.o 12 -flM;iB.' Mil8, Jf 2 13~~~rn~~-~'R~.~~* ~~±~ •• ~~A~.rnrnao 14 *-J!«.Jl:.~;f Rezeption als sozialer Proze6, 1981 0. ••. 0.

(8) Jli:k-f-fhf::.fit. 464. a¥~*'&~~.m~ffi~~.m~~.o*meu*,~.ti~ ~$~'~~~$'~@*@~'&~B~7.~.~~~~o~~,. ~*~$.~m~-+ •• ~~U~~~$·~~~~.~~'~~ *~~ft~$ffi~~~&$$&~m~~+~~'~W~7$.*= ~Z-~-~Z-t)'~~16\.~~'. ~*~~,~~. NP-aJJ!Z15. 0. ti(mt).~DIlt'. J11J. $g'.~z~~A~~W~~oti(§~fr~~g. , ~~ · &$&~$l~rf$HPfr57~~4 ; fr.~~7\~4W~~4 § cp 'J1lJfr5 -=-~4* 16 .; B~~D1ft ' ~.ffrrit ' ~~~m~-t;~4W~~4§cp. ~~$.A(~~$.~~I~~ft~~I~~) ~$~a~.~$.a¥,m%A. ••. m~~u~. o. ~~~x'~~m~~.~~*~m-aJ •• fffr'&~m~~~ Ritffl~~.~¥m'-aJJ!~m$~~~~,~~n~$~&*~M. 1117 , i!~~~$iiitl~Uilll!llmftll~. 0. ~~fr~~~][~. •.•. , m.~f*:. 15~~~*~.T~~~~~~~~~~*~~~~.~~#o~~'~~~~~* .~.*.f.~~~ ~~~~.o~.~~~'.~.:k*_$.~.* ~1t~,*~m.~ , 1!!.1fi!1f4tf' ~* " i!li.*Jl~ •• Jf*~16 :k-f~~~. ;f;f 0. M*~*_~~~~~~~~jt'~~~~~~'*~~~Za~~ •• ~~,~ A*~OO~~~A~TE.*~:k~*~~. 3(0. •• z*.~~4~ •• ~#.Z.. ~£*~~#aA.~*~*'~.'ff.*;£** •• "*~~' •• ~A.*' ~~£'*' •• *'~.*'±~*'.«**'~.~*.M~±~S4o~ ~.#a1f_~~~m.Mtf" •• ~*'~*.~M~~*~.#~~T •• ~* ~*_~~Z#a (~tf';f±'.*;fIf.~;f±'.:f&-f'J*). a. .,. .1f~~J:.JNJj44t~1W~#. 0. 17~~.~*.~~41f~M.'K~*.ff*~~M.'~~:k~M ••1f*:. *ff~~~~ro~ff~A~*o~~M1W~~Jl'.~*~t4~~.A~*_ff ~ , ~~.jfj.,,;cJt.~."'~Illftik:~~;f±'.,t1.it 0 .~~ '~#.iitt.*{f.iftJtit~.:iE~f# ~~~.ff~,~#mt4.~.#~A~J:.r~*J~. •• '~.~-~~.~o. ~~'~.JfJ:.~~ •• '~*~~.'~*J:.~~ff •• ~~~o~ •• Jf~~ *~tf'~ff.,~*~~~.~~~ •• o~~ML~~~.~*:~*~.ff* ~.M,£~~~~.~~~~*_~~.,*_~a~.*~~.~.:kZ~±.

(9) ~~~$lJ--$rjJt-.YJfi~. 465. .~.~~~~~~~~~~a~~~~3'ffi~$.m~~~~~ ~~m~.ft~m~.$~~.Mffa~H($.~~~.Mffag. ) "m~m~~~~~?m~T~ru~$A~~~rn~~~'~~ ~ru~g~~.~ •• ?o $'~~~~~~mffi~~$~~~~ - ,~~itA*MJlt:ft ~.~mffir~~~~~~J~~~~~~~~~'~. mT. r. •• ~R. ¥tl § fWmll:: J ~RHmI8 " ~'o]~m • ~~]jU59UJ~m~~~¥tl~. ~~~~~~'~T~~~~~~~~~~;~~~~~~~$~~. .~~~.~'.~~m*¥$&~m~.~~~¥$'W~~Rffi ~~~-~~+n~~$. '~~~~~~~~~"m~~~~,~. ~~~~w.~,~~*~~~~~mffim~". ~*~+n~~$.~~.~~*~~~.~~~&.'~~~ ~~~~m*~¥nft*~~~~.&tt~~~~~~ffimo~rn ~~~'~~~rn~~. ~~'~~®R.~~~~~fi~o~$'. l&lf~~~~ Roscoe Pound. ft- +1!!JtJ)]~:MtiPI9 " m~~~1ltiP '. ~mfi~~~R~'~*~~~~~~lf~~~~rn~~~~-@A 11!ru~~~~~~ffa~. '~Umfl~f-JtU~~~fffif{~.~~1J~20". ,,:{; • 1!!..t;f -t ht • 1Jh't -If i*: l'!1l!l A." (~ .t.1i) 1i 8 • Jf 45) it! »t • ~ At ~if.i~ if ffiJ 1M:. ~-.~~.ff~~~~_,~~-.~fti*:.1l!lA.~~_'~~~~1l!lA.M~4 :J.-'Jl~~_,,!t»t. »tl-;ftAt~l.i:.itt{If.1foJ~~-.·M=~N.~~_~ii~1.i:. 18. 1\!!.{t m1 hitherto - ja.J " »t- 4t )Jlj mli • -If..I.{a .}t:. ~ it;f tp • -f eAt)JIl;ffi' ili r it 4- J ~mli,,~.t...I.~*·li)ft9.Jf~o. 19. 20. 0. ~.t...I.{a* • li)ii 9. Jf 41 " Ii) litii ".

(10) Jt:k.*,fIJ~.. 466. {E n 0 iF- ~ ~ r fJ£ {I~LA. 7ft ¥!J w± t"7ft 21 J -:x ffif ' i:!1 tit HjHii ag t~ te : 'i' ffifag7ft.~~fJ£rOOA7ftJ~.~r~t"7ftJag-OO ••ffifM:OOA 3Z..:~tll:{E~~ag Roscoe Pound ' {E~mag Gustav Radbruch. =. 7ft~~-.~~mm.A~.'W~ffi~agA{E7ft.~-.~~tiM W~. •• ~~.ttag7ft.M~:&Z,~*7ft~amm{Em.R*ag. A~~A~eti~.'~m~~.fi'i:!1m~~H~'~m~~~~. fi · i:!1 mfj~~~~fi'. mfj~~1i. 'i:!1 mfj~~~1i. <>. Radbruch. m.~m·~Rmte7~ffif7ft.W~*~~~R*ft7ft.~ag.~· ~ffifi:!1mte{EftZM'~~M~fiRAA~~'. ~A~~~M~. ag*ff~t!°. ' ~~7ft$fJ~:all9ft~mJ1f!£:1]k1l ' ~Ui:!1*~\ gtft ' J!!~~~~7!~ag~ : ~~7ft.$fJ~~7J!~ffd:**. ' ffd:*§~ag~ ~?&tmft. 0. 'll9fti:!1~*~ag.~n~om~~7ftMagmR'~~~OOAfJ£*. .'~ •• ~.~,~~~~.~aag~~~~M~7ft.~~ag~*. , ~U~-.J!!T.itJiS'\~agrtl~1! ~ttift~rtl~1! ' aga~$ffi Amte r @l~~~7ftt!J J 'HPffi~ Riickkehr zurn Status'. ~f14~:a~¥tlm;t. <>. ag~mno~ft~~7ft·~~H~.o~Mffim&ag~m_Bm,~. .-~ag.M.Il9~.~*[email protected],m~Wi:!1.~r~~*llieW oo~'.ll9agm-~.3Z..~~~M.Z~,~~~~ag~~'-$ffi. 21. ~~ 3:.4 Yom individualistischen zum sozialen Recht tI:.~fd:.t-*fr!} ffl jf soziales Recht 0. It*. *. ~ fJ lit -tt II ;t fd:. t- 4; -i- * Z fd:. t- * Sozialrecht P.lf :! ~j <> Eberhard Eichenhofer, Soziales Recht und Sozialrecht, VSSR 1981 '. *"',. *Jf. z. ~ 1r~.If ik t- JL 19 "A r <>. fr!}lt D)J jk t- JL Rehbinder' ( f.l] 1i 6) Jf 89 <> n~tI:..~~*~a~~~#fr!}~$~A'~lt1:..~~~,~~• • ~ • • fr!}~~,. 22. Anton Menger.A - A:1t:..OlfL~ ~ ~* ~ ~,{ ff ~ Das Biirgerliche Recht und besitzlosen. -:sat ' ~il:t*ff!:.jJt.~'flf-fd:.t-fr!}:!~. Volksklassen. ;fl:.t- J:.fr!}A.fr!}:!~ , -ffh**::f' ~Jt*f±t-*fr!}Jt..!Yiifr!} IJHl1-zJLM- }ttl:. • "tkt-JL Rehbinder,f.l]ji 6, Jf 89 "Ar 0. 0. 1h1'-*ff!:J:.fr!}A.~J"1f. Hugo Sinzheimer ~*~ 0.

(11) ~;t--~~~-1f;tjJt-.JJJfj~. 467. ~.~~~~7UOJ5¥~.OO~$.~.'~~AM$*.~~ W.~.A~H~'. r~~H~J'. r~~~~. ~J~~~$$~~~H~'~±~~M~~~~.~~~~m0$ ~~P)f-fir r ~~~¥tl~~~ji{ttILiJji25. 0. •. J. m~~Mm~tt~~$m~r~~J$~~~$.*~~~~* .o~$,.m.~~&u.#~~:m~$.~~~~,@#.tt. OOA~§~W~~'. .mOOA~§~~~ji~~~~~,~. p):~{'Fm.m.mOOA±~mll~pJ<~iE~]~IL3~26. 0. ~1l~Q[i!t. '. jt~. -~i!tW*.~~~ • • '.R~~.·jt~~tt~~~~R.~. WB~mi!tWA~W§&.ir~ • •. .. ... ..f..ifJ.J4" , Mft 9 ' ~.~#~ ~. 24. Jf 44. 0. ~~~~.~-~*~. ·. ·~~~~~.0~~~. ••• ~M.A~'.:~~~.~ •. .. (.i..~) ,~t_.$~~iIt~tli~' Ji 205 )tAr' .*:.Jit.Jf 224 1t 229 *Jt!::.-fI'.t.T ••• M.MAt~M.A~tkM~~' ••• M.~~A.~M.~.i...~+ Am ~ -it> *Jt!::.- ~M~)tA~..iL ' 9,IJ iiM<:f*.tt.rt.k EJ -f..Ll:~ ~fJT{b&J"~~5* ~~~~ ... ~~a&~~.~»~*~M.o**~ •• ~Jit.~~~~~~ •• • ~~~&.~.~M.~.i..& •• '~R~&.ka~~.~~.,.~~ •• , 0. 0. ~~&~~~.~~*~~»#~r~~._J~~'~M~~-it>*.~~~~~. ••. ~~±~~.~~~~o~Jt!::.'*~ ~J+*'J+-*Z-1tJ+A*~. ~.~~~1t~~~**~4~~±A~~Z.h~~'~&~.~".~4.4 mz~~,.~~tkM~o~~~,~~.~~#.*.~~~.~.tz~t. A.(~~«).~~ •• '~~.~~ •• ~M*.~~.4mz.mo~A' .~-it>Jt!::..*.~~~~.~z~~o~Jt!::.'~~~~(-it>*.)z~4t~,~. •• .... ••. I~~ ~~~ ~~~+*.*»#~~~-*~.I'.t.~~&o~Jt!::.'k~ ~ ~~~;~r.~.h~M.t*'~~.»~.~za.,~~~~a~. •• ~~~+*.*»#~.~.**~*~'.&~ •• ~_M.z~~ •• ~_~li~.~.~k~-f~.~~'. »#JzM_'~~~*~ ~zM~o~M*~. ••. ~~ffli~.~1t~k~.~~~t~~;OO-.+-A+I+-EJ~~~k.. •••• ~# ..z.~r~•• ~.i..& •• ~ J 1tJit.f!#dtJt!::.~rt.:if;z.~ r*:!.•• ~~_~H~ M~z~ltJ (Jt!::.. ~_.~.~z~-Affli~*.~ ~z~~. ~ff!lt. i..M:Jfi.{i'i:.}i ~~~). 26 •. ~ Rehbinder M 'ii 6 '. Jf 89. 0.

(12) Jtkf-fh*=. 468. 3~~'ffiMH.§ •• A.~m~ffi.~'Kll~.mA.®~~ ~~no.~~~'ffiM~.ft~@#@.U~.'M.m~.®. 7t~$fJ. 0. m~~.~.~liO~ft~U~.~.o~~'£ffi~~7~~. 3t ffi ~ rmt ' ~76 mffiHlg ~ 1* yj ff m:um@!lJ[ , ft!JJPJ If,f tl1. t~ te :. tE+fLttt*c*I*JMl, ~f$®m>L\' ~~®f$rtu~d:.*7 · ~~$.;. ~®~1*~~~~~. ~?*~m~. ~:ffiMH.*m®~1*~~~.w*m~1*® ~~:ii~.frj. ,. §®®TPJ~M28. •• ;. 0. -=- ' ~ flS1 ~ #" a9 a9 tit 1. 1£ ~ ~~ffi~'. ••• H.~&~ffi~~M®.~'.~~1*~~m. U~~.~~ttt, @~.7t®~~. ~+fLttte*.U~®~~.Ro.~~~,. , ~~~~~1L. 0. ~4-B '.~~1*f;fA~~1*3taJl®Wt~JjJ~~~IHI5l:$tlrdm29,. ~ffim&~~M~~.ffi.~®~~'~~&.w*m®. •• ~~~. .~~.m~®MRffi~om~WM~+fLttte*.U.H.~®~ 1*~R. ' JtUff~ff®Wt~flID. 0. ~~ Radbruch. $tl~d:.~ J ~P~-tlffflID®mte. kI 7t m:rn M. {~(. 0. ~~z9i-. Die [ruhe Neuzeit),. '. ffimte®. r t£OOA~. .~OOO:~{~~f$.~. If,f M (Das burgliche. ••• •••. n.*~*.*.~,t~t*a£*.~~A~&«'.:.**~ II*' Ji I I'AT ; Hans F. Zacher, Social Insurance and Human Rights, in: .**~ II Ji 31 y,,{ T .. 28 .I..{aJ4- ' f.i1ii 9, Ji 45 29 :itJlt' it Jt It-lrP R6hl (~ii 2) 'Ji 12 I'A T Jl. Ji 540 I'A T ; Rehbinder' f.i1 ft 6 ' Ji 78 I'A T ... *'. 0. *.

(13) ~~~~~-~jJt-.tJJ~. Zeitalter) &1&m~tttW. (Die nachbiirgliche Welt) ij!~$1$~mk~~WiIWiI¥J1fIDt30. 469. I¥JWi?t1J:ct: ' ~U ... 0. ~~Z~'~M~.~~1$Z~~.~Um~'M~g- •• ~. :f5f!lMl¥J1JrtiJ gt~ , Manfred Rehbinder t)..~~1$~~l1 'fffHllli r ~ ?t - ~f-:J - fi3@. J 31 ZJL~ , HPIlJ~~t;fj~~~111¥J1fIDt tit Rehbinder mm z r fi3@. J 3:~frfiPjW!l1~~lI ' 1t-7J~t). Menger, Radbruch, 0. 0. Sinzheimer ~AJf1ntm~I¥J$1$~I¥JAW~±f} ~.~I¥JAI¥J~~3:~ lli.,oom.$1$~~.UAI¥J.~~*~~&~*~@..~mno. 1J@ , Rehbinder ~UIDl:~ Ralph Litqn, Talcott Parsons, Arnold Gehlen ~~*.~m~llil¥J~@'!I1~~fi3@'~~!I1~'OOmlli:~*~~& ~?t,ij!~~*.m~ffilli~~~~ffl~TI¥J~?t'OO.mrtiJ~ffi.. A~~~nffl~~I¥J~?t~ttf}~~;~~~~~gtl¥J~~~~ffi* .~~.rtiJ~~~~I¥J~.,&gt~~@'~~I¥J~.:~~BI¥J~* ~'~7~ffi~f-:J$ffffi~~A~~~~~$1$~~'~~fi3@.$Z ~~;gt~'~~.~fl~m~~~@'~~T~~I¥J~~,m&.~ ~fi3@'I¥J~~ IlJtfgW~~1133. 0. ~*~~.~I¥J~lli~.7 •• lli~$1$$.Zm~'~~lli~. ~*JL$Z*.~~&~Jf1n~m1J~Zli*~.'K~~ffl~~~ 1¥J~~~~1n~m~.~*~~AI¥J~*~~'~~Jf~~*'k~ .W~*'M~ffi.I¥J~*.$1$~~,a~*I~.~~*~~M ~'~~~~@'l¥Jm$IlJ.~~m~7ij!~.W~~~~*~~*JL $1¥J$1$~.om~~m$'BllJfl~m~tt*~$ZJf~W§I¥J'. 30 31. It ~ JL Mitteis Lieberich, Deutsche Rechtsgeschichte, 17 Aufl. ' Ji 295 J-;,t. T It ~ JL.x.,/i. - /t, A if. fiJi";f "Status-Kontrakt-Rolle" in: Berliner FS Ernst E. Hirsh ' Jf 14 J-;,t. T a.x.J'Jt.:i Rechtssoziologie ' MiifJ"ii 6 ' Jf 89 J-;,t. T Rehbinder' M1i 6 ' Ji 90 Rehbinder' Mji 6, Jf 91 J-;,t. T 0. '*. 0. 32. 33. 0. 0.

(14) 470. .il.t::kf-fh-:t:fl. ffiti~~M~~~~$~~~m,~~~*~&g. •• ~~~~,.. ~*~~R~.~o.~~~~~~m~,. ~mMgm.~. ~~~~~*~n~.*'~~~li$g~,. ?~~W§'B. ~. Rehbinder. ~~ilttJotJ7t;fJf. , ~rFjJ~ll ' ft!!m~t~Hr)lffi'i'~5E~::g. o~~¥~:~~,~.7t~~~ffi~~~~*m.g.~Wli. $~~*g~'~ili~.~~H*~~~~ll."o~~,.~~& m~li.~.WBm~~m~tt'ili~mR~BD.~*li$g~~ ~*Jjj{~U. 0. it. Rehbinder~~-ft~. , .~t-fmHi. 1§f9c ' ft!!ft)~!1. 0. ~~~m*,~~~~tt.li$(~~li.~~)ffi~ff7t~m.W. li.~ffl~~*Jjj{~*~~7t~m~W~5E~o~~'~~Dm.~ ~~~~$'~~~ • • ~~~5E~&~-~~-.~w~,w~m *g.~W~*li$g~~~W~n~&OO~.o. ,*~~~g. .~~$e.~~ft'~ffiM~~~§~.7t~~$'~&$ffi~lio R.~~~~~'MA~a~~~$~~~~~~tt~*.m. •. '~~&~ilim-M~gmzft!!ffl~gmR~~~~~tt.o ¥~~~~5E{llm~MA{&7(~nffi1l1~~~±.j~UL. ~~UL~~ft.#~M~'OO~*D~~~ ~. •. •• ~*~~~.~~~m~z~ff'. ~W~.~~$~). ' ~UlI.~. •• ~~,~m~ •• ~ (~~ •• ~. ~.'ili~~~~~OOzM~'Wlli~li.. $,~~tt.. *zAtt~.~~~Wli.M~~~. §. ~'ill~ffi~~o~~'~~~~~OO~M~'~~~~ffi~$m. ~~~'~.~M'&-.~~~R~~~o ~~~~,. r. ~~-~~J. 35. Rehbinder' Mli:. 6 ' 87 fJ. T MiIoi'ti:. 0. 36. *JLlPJIii ' fJ:.t"*~-$tJJt~fJ:.'ti!. 34. ,.~~~m~. 0. ' -Jt.!t.-t:' ' Jf 229 fJ.T. 0.

(15) ~~~~-.jJt-:tJJ~. 471. ~~~z~~'ffi~ill~r~Y~~o~~~~~~~,~~~~~. •• ~o · ~~~¥U~J~ ·. ~ft~~.~~~m~~®r~~_~~_~~-~~J®~. jtf1~-.~. · 1i*7mr~ cpmij[~ r ~~~¥ti~~. ~~~g~~JZ.~~,~~-~mm:. tt~~'~~$'~~$ft*~~'~~f1~OOA~~ ~m~.'. •• ~~~.ffiUA~~®m.U~~~. ~U·*~LT~~~,®~r~~J~m~*~~L.~~ m~~®-.&.L®~~®B,~tt~~.~*,~~~ ~¥B~L'~~ffi~*®~~$,tt~$'~~$~.Z. ~,£~~~~tt~a.®.~'~**~lli®m.'~~' ~m,~~'~m~0~®~~~m,~~~~~~,WOO A~~~. ffiEB ' {'Ff§&'*®~~J. 0. ••••••. ~~-$~cp?JT~:lL. ®~~&'~&*.~~~.~m~~~,~®§A~m~* ~r~~J~~r~~J. '®~~OOAZrg~~EBJT~. ~.~'~~§®ill~m~OOA®£*~ffi'~~~~L~ ~® ~. EB' rfl$ ~ ~ J z.~RJit~m-.YJ~~L®.~. 0. ••••••. ~~f1~~L~~~~~ffi~~~,~$~f1~~~~~EB ~m~·~*~.~tt~$,~~~,~~~~~~U~Z cp'm.~~~EB~~~~,~~~m~~~~EB®~~~ ffQm{~~ ~ mo. ... "'fl$ ~ m~~~~~¥-'-tl§. .~Z~~J®B'U$~m~. r 7t~~m L. •• ~OO~~rOOA.~~. ~~~J~g.'~*~U$~~~.~~.~¥.~~~ ~AA~m0~L$~'~&0~~~m.~w.®. 'm. ~m®~ooA.~'~~~~~~~®R~0$L~~W~. ®~~'A.tt~~m~. •• &~.A.~~~tt~@-'-~.

(16) 472. ltk.f-fJ;"~. ~m~\~®1i¥iJE37. 0. tJ. 7t fff ' Ji ~ f5l ffi I! ¥-i 7Jtlt~ te1f ' 11:W:: : ~O ~ , !ME ?&~~j~~~z¥-i7JUl1.$tJ.:&ffr±1!t$ , *~~$ , ~j}j$~JJl1z®ffr±1t l1.$H,m~q~~~~r~~J.mrE ~~~ •• ~.g~® ~ tLt mfU ~1.JD. -.&~~®~~WBoJ~~,~~-~mte:~1t$'~j}j$fi. .~$~#Ur~~J~.r~~J. 'W:W::~MAzr. ~~~J. U~fi~'~~§®ill~~~MA®~*@~'~~~~~~1f®@ ~,. rU$@~Jz~.~m-.~~~®.*o. ~~.~~'~!ME*~~W.tt,. J~g~rtJ.~liftJ. •• r~.g~J~~w~r. rtJ.SJHiMmSA · mtE~~~·~~f-t~E-~~~. .~$Z~~fi~.,~~~f-t~-$.ffi~ff®~~~~·.~~ ~®~~o.~,~*f-t~~~~~z~m'.U$.~.n~~~ ~~. ®~ft* j~JJl ~U ' IlP *f!f-t ~~. ff}: Wf§ f-t~~ f~ff}: ZSA ~ MUg (. +-+-w). o~~'.M~f5l.ffa.~~f-t¥-i~-~~~W~~. ~M~$~'m~~$~ill~.mm1t~ g~~~®~ft~'. D~~'ffiM •• g~fi. •• ~&~®l1.$m~~u.~o~~~~~,. ~.:W::U~@~®~~~:W::~1tl1.$.W&~·$~~~.mmWZ ~~·K~m:&~&~·$~,~&~m~®.~E*;~fum~. $~~·&~mfi~1tmmlim~®~~7t~~Do. 37. .~:ik. '. PHi 1 ,. Jf. 182-183 (). HM•• ~~~~~ak~~~.~~~.h~B'~~~.~~'.~~ •• ~' ~*~L~~~k~~~o~ • • ~~~*~~4m~~~~~.~#·~.~~ .~~.~A~~_M.,~~~ft4~~L~~M.'~#&.~M.'W~~. ~.kM • • ~9M1~ 39 ~M~-.1J>f¥*t'. 0. ijl ~ Zacher ~tt~jjfi!~.jIi.;'~~;.(5i;W!J 0 lA-~JL Zacher, Das soziale Staatsziel, in: Insensee-Kirchhof (Hrsg.), Handbuch des Staatsrechts der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, Bd. I, 1987, Jf 1045 ~;.("T; Ming-Cheng Kuo, Grundproblem der Volkskrankenversicherung in Taiwan, in: Ruland/von MaydelllPapier (Hrsg.),.

(17) ~~J~}9-.jJ.t-.w~. 473. ru~'~~~~ili'~~~~§ruz~~~~tt~~~tt~ft~, Wfi~.~m~~z.m~o.ffi.~.~m~#m-w~~m~.. ru~~~~o~7~n§m'tt~§mw$~mm~'R~~~tt~. §m~~*m.m.fi~*~.~~*m~o~~,.~~~~.~. t)J4UlfOOA § rum § ~. , JlUW!±~ft~~*E*. ' ~;j¥OOA § ru ' ~flj~. ».'&~'~~.~~.tt~~wmo ~~~~~~,w~~~m:~*~~~~mmr~OOAft ~.~ • • ~~J. ••. ,~~~.*.~.~~~mg~,tt~§mm~. tJ:&W!±~:lI~~UlmW!±~~~41. , Jlut1i~~.m~llifrJm ' ::f~1t. $~~~$efi7fi~~'MrufOOA~~m~~~~~o. ~ ,~)Wtte~~$f6IJ9'9fil8lt: EI3~~[Q]~~;} ? ~~~~~.~Z.'~~Z ~. •• ~.~~*$~ ••. '::f~.. •• ~~~~m~~.m~~'~~~~.~.~~.$~.~~. -m~~o. ~~,~ft~~~~z.~'M~~~. ... •• ~.~.~o~~~. ~-~~~~~~7m.~~.~,~~m=m~~~~~$~ti~ ft~~~~7ffig~~m.oru~~~'mft~~~~~'~%AL. ~.~~7. ,~~~tO~ft~*~.$~wti~mft~~~~. Verfassung, Theorie und Praxis des Soziaalstaat - FS fUr Zacher, 1997, J{ 457 Y.A T ; Ming-Cheng Kuo, Social Change and Social Security in Taiwan: Lessons for the PRC, in: Krieg/Schadler (eds.), Social Security in the People's Republic of China, 1994, J{ 340 y.AT" 40. #. it:: #: ~ flI. Gesetzvorbehalt ~ f1i-1i1 til i"~ flI Parlamentvorbehalt ' ~ 6] ~1t ' ~ <if ~ co .1ilW169i1ii!' lt~JtJt~QJJJt, Jiilft36 , J{ 94-". 1i1~.i.~ta.;X.A.~~flI. ~~Jt~~Jt,&.t$A.~.it::-.~it::.~i"it::it::#:*.69A&.~,Jt*it::. 1tili' , 60 J!JJ ' J{Y.A 303 T ".

(18) 474. JltJe.'f-fh• •. ~&~H~~~~~~m~~*o.~~~~,~~ti~~H~~~ ~m~m. •• m~m.'~~.~Mm~ft~o.~~~~m,&~. ~~m~~~tt~~m~~~~~~~~.o~~-~$ffi~~p. ~. •• Z.,~~~~m+~.m~r~~~ •• ~ •• ft~fi.'. 0~~~~~~~~.~.~~~~.Z$~J~~Zo~~.~~ ~~.ft~mmffi~~~mR.~m~.~M~,~~&~ti~fia. g.~~~m. •••• ox~*'~~~~~~~~.~fi~mtt~. (~g.~~~~~mtt~)~mm?~~~ft~,~~.~~*~ ~tt~. , ~~~.~MHIJl1r~~tt~ , ::tX~~mtiJJ~J~rrf~!m~. $~~Ztt~,.~~~o~~w§,m~~~~~'~~$ffi~~ ~. , {fi1rl~ffimjg~mfl.!. 0. ~~~~m@~'~~k~~-~$o~~-ftA~~~D~. ~Ztrj~~{9tJ, *~~~-~$Z$lj~, iJ'Jl~I~~~~J!~mt1Jlnl. ,. ~~~~~~~~~~,~~.m~mm~~~m~m'~~~.. tt~~~~tt~~~'W~.*~*0mb~~~~~D~~o ~~m~~~~~.ff'~~~~~~~H&~~~.ff,~~~m ~.~m~. •• uo~~~~.mr~.~*·~.m&J. §.~. ft~'~~fi.~~+ft~e~.-~.fir~~.~*.~~.~ ~~J ~~mmtrJ9J~~JJU '~~&fi:#~.mflfi~0jfd:~.9J~ o~~ft~~~~ffi~~@~~~®ft~'&~-W~m~~~ ft~o~~. M~~~~~~m,~~~m~~~~m~a~. :it ' ?f.r\1l A:II~43. •••. 0. 42*~$~~,~ft36'~77~r;$~~'*~~~~f~~~~~~z~~' ~**~~."9~'~37~ro. ~~t~~~*£~~~~.~~L.LA~~~~·t.*~~~.'-A~~. ff~~~~o~~-.ff·~4~~~~~o~~.~~.~«~~~~,-aA. T~*~M*~~~Z~~'m~~~~~'-aATA*~M~~~~z~~'.

(19) 475. :k~~~-"JJ.t-.YJ~~. :t±Iftztit ' ~J~~~]jtl~!1~±Wf$Z~~1JD~J~M. 0. ~±1t$i¥Jl:B. m.~~,~m~~.~~~~*~~~~.A~.tti¥Jm."o~ ,Ift~ft$~~. ••• ~.~.i¥J$~B.~r~~J~Ar~ft. .~~Ji¥J~M'~~.M.Mi¥J.M,~~:tE~.liWf~~~ftm ~=OOO~.~li+~~Z~,~~m~ttWf~~£~0~li+~. 8. ~i¥J~. 0. - " tb 100 $.J ~ ,t.;ijI (oJ fJJ 'It ~ It. ? ~~.~-nliO~. ~-8.~*I~~®~~m~ttWf~~. ~fti¥J~.Z~~'~.:tEttWf~~~ftZ~~'.#~A •• ~@#. '. •• ~~o~~~~ •• ~ftm ••• ~ft~~-~i¥J-nt. ~£~'~-~~m~°:t±-ntt~z~'±~ZttWf~~~ RF46~. J.:lt.. M. :. ~~~~~_~;~OC~ • • ~k~~~*~.~~M,#. _~#~*L~. ••. 'L~.'~A.LA~~~~. ~~o. "*~.~.,~.~*~~. ••• o~*'~-M. •• ~~.'~&~#.-~. •• ~·.:t.~~~~A+.'-~~~·lM3. ~T;.~.·t.~.~**~~s.~.~,.:** •• a*.~~-£. *~~,~OO~'l47~To. •• ~~4t~*~~*~~.a.*,.~.~.a.am~~&~~ • • Aa•• ~~~~·~4&~~~~ •• $.~o • • ~~·~.~.a.,~ ~~.~~~A~~.aMA~.*M~~'#-~.~~~.~*~£~-~.~ ~~ •• ~.~~~A~ft~~.~*~£o ·~.~a~~.~*~£·~l~ •• ~'~.AI~~~~£'.~ •• '~. ~4~~. ..). aM~'~~~~.M.(.~~.~$AM.'~~A.*~~.~~5~M.)' ~.«.(~~.~~.,a~. O~~'*.£.*'.~.~*'~~L. ~~.*am~~4&~.~*ft~~a~·.m~~~.~*~£A~.~M.' m~-*~.o*m.~«~~~k·~.AI~~~~£·~&~*~.~ m~«k-. •• ·. •• ~~*L.*.~~~ ••• ~£o~~~~~~£~•• ~~ •. • ~~.~~~·~L.~ •• ~~.~*~£o.~~~'~~~.~#A~~ .*'~&#~~~~~MA~#'~~~~.~*~~~.o~M~.*~.~'.

(20) 476. Jt:k.f-fh-f;:fI.t. 1950. PjffL&$-%fl~*I15fJ~&lJ)d~U~. 1953 1958. fljrJ JE ~W~ 1J1J A f§fJ!1~ {9U ' ;It r& 25cm ~ 1J A i~Hii 1l*{9U. fljrJ JE i};fj§ A ~ 1* ~ 1~ {9IJ &* I 1* ~ f~ {9IJ '. 1964. pj ffL&$-%fl17mi};fj§ A~Z~1*A~ 1*~. 1973. fljrJ JE .Q.!l iJilE1 flJ $. 1975. PjffL&$%fl17m~j:ZP:3(1*~. -:h.-t;-t;if:z r& ' ±'~Z~~~rj~ : 1980 iM JE ~ AiflE1 flJ $ & 9J MtiflE1 flJ $:ML~ fd: ~~~ $~~T ~ fd: ~ ~WJ$. 1982 . ttlJE fb 1L ~ &¥ilfi ~ 1*If!1l*{9IJ fljrJJEi};fj§ A~ ~~~m1*/f!f~{9U '. :ML~-:h.J\=if:. ' -:h.. A:h.if:·-:h.:h.-if:~*Mi};fj§A.Z~.·~m&~~. fW3A.tlt-1*1f! 1983 ttlJElfi~IDIf~$ 1984. ttlJE*IJJ~~$. 1985. PjffL&$%fl17m~1*i};fj§A~&;lt~.Zif!~1*~. PjffL&$%~~Alreif!Jl1*~. 1989. ttlJE AI ~ i! ~ {§fJ~ 1l*{9IJ ~ffL&$-%fl17m~nre~~~&fl~m~if!Jl1*1f!. 1990. ttlJE~ijiEfJmj:$. ~ffL&$%fl17mU1L~&¥ilfi~~.zif!~1*If!':ML~* ~-:h.A:h.Oif:'-:h.:h.-if:·-:h.:h.=if:~*~i};fj§A. ~Z~.·~m&~~*P'JA.tlt-1*~. pj ff L&$%fl17m{[1&AP if!~1*~. .f[-t$l.ft$.. .1*~Jt~flAJt· ~li36'. Jf. 115 f'{T. 0.

(21) ~~~~-.jJt-:£hi~. 1993. 477. tJiTiJ&1fPtr.Df!!CP{j£r&AP~.Aj$~r5. .n0BAa~~~&0RA • • • ~(. ) 1994. {#WDf!!0~~.ifijirJ. ijirJj£~~i!~i*~~. ftiu j£- - J\ *{tf: ~ l!t[ & 1m ftf,*f9tl 1995. .~J*fX~Ifllt~~~~f9iJ&*fX~@ • • •1'*f9tl. (JJj{ijirJj£. ~-ft~~~)M.Df!!0~~.if~. ftitl j£ ~ ~,. ~ ifri% fU t4t ~r5 f1j 1T1,*f9tl 1997. .~J~~iliifU~{#c~ffi}~:§tJG\~.~i*~~. 1998. ftiUj£3B~~WAi*~~. 1999. tJiTiJ&1fPtr.Df!!*~i*~ ~j£0~Aai*.~~~ftJJj{~Z0BAai*.~&Uft. *fX~@a i*~~f9iJ. 2000. $tl j£~IIIfifM ~ li~ilL!I ~ ~ :jftIJ ~{tf:1m ft ~f9tl. 2001. ijirJj£@~~W~Ii*~~. 2002. ijirJj£filij'ltI {'fZf~~~ ftiuj£~~~~~. ftiU j£ ~ ~ iliifU t4t ~lt f1j 1T~f9tl .~~~.~~~~~~,~~-ft~~~~~,~~~.~~. ~~~~~. •• ~E~7W~~~*om~~z.,. ~~&~ti~. ,~w~m~.~~~~ffim~W~m.o~-ftA O.~ffiM.~-~Z~)£ • • n,m~. 'w~~. •••• ~. ~-~AO.~~~~~A~~*,.~.~*~~*~~.aM*~**'.~~ it$;.iOCi{;~:l!." a ("JL Tsai/Chang, Politics, Ideology and Social Welfare Programs: A Critical Evaluation of Welfare Legislation' ii' k.;i.:l:...... ftj , 1f; 17 J!}} , Jf 233 l-.:,{ To). ,••• t~.*~at •• *~~*,~ •• ~.~~~~~~o.

(22) 478. .Jtk~1h~.. !Itj} ,!It- ~ 1m ffi m~ I¥J (ti( H:l:j~J!f )£ Jfll ~ ll~ , A:;tt ~:£} ¥!cA. jiI¥J iIii flJ. 0. r!t~'~~~.I¥J~~&~'ttnO~~~~W~~~l¥Jtt~~~ft ~°r!t-~~'.~~~.~'~~~.~&~.~MI¥J m~.5A~.~tt~M.M~Z. M"ffHtt. ••. '~~. •• 'OO~~tt~~~~MW~~. 0. ~~r!t~._~~~m'~~~~~.I¥JR*~~~M'~~ •. •. 1¥J~M'~7~~tt*~Zj}'~llim~$.~mao~~~.ffi. ~~MI¥J.~~W~~~.,~~!It~~~I¥J.~'A:;ttttW1m~~'. •• #~~~ft~Z~~~~m.om~~*r!t~maB.*.~' A:;tt.~ffi._I¥J~~iIii~~Mtt&W.I¥J~M~,~~ft~I¥J~~. •• om.~~~'~~I¥JR~.~m .,m*.~~ft~,~~~~.:£}ftAjiN~Z+AI¥J •• ~~' ~~m.'~~A~m.ttl¥J. .~I¥J~~~.~o.!It.fi'ili~~.~tt*~~~~.*.~$. {tl¥Jma. 0. , ~*ftfo~:aNP.~~!lJtll¥J.~? ttm 1[&~ll:lJJji~ILZM" ' A:;tttt~~~OO2~~ZM" ' ~~l¥Jft~ , mJ!l:JJor)J~~I¥JJJ~. ~~:aMm~.I¥J&J!l'.~A.~o~~,tt~~~l¥Jft~'~$. ~ •• ~~~~~~I¥J~.offi~~!It~m.'~7;tt~~~l¥Jtt* ~_j},ftr!t.~a.~ft!lt_~a.I¥J~~~.·~~ft~~_M. 5E~8f. ' Jfll~lllil1X;~Ji®MllUflJ~48 · ~~m~I¥J~L~. 0. mtt~*~. OO&~z~·~~m.~~~ffA&.~Z~,!It-m~~7. 1¥J&~o.~·~.I¥J~~~:a~~~&.&.'l¥Jm~~-M.~. 1[•• ~I¥J~.o •• ~~'m~I¥J~~W~' •• M~*o ~~._.~~.~~~4A~~~.L~~.,ru~~t#~~t,~~~~.~ .~~~T#~tk#~~4~A~~.o~~~4L •• ~~~~'.*L#~. •• k~·.:aa8 ••*~r~4~.~~~. £/~.*·._~.~~4~ • -/t./t.;' • Jf 101 I';,{ T 0. i{!.; JiI J.

(23) -k~-~~-.llt-.w~. 479. B~~~'mfi~~**~~~·~~~m~-ftft~~ft~~ ~~~~~~~m~·~~~m~Lr~ft~~J~r~~§ffi~~. .~J ·~~~A.~o§~'~-~$m~~ftm~.~-.~* ~~~ffi~~~~~'~~m~~-OOffi~.~m~~~~am~~ .~M~am~~o~~·~. ~:Pffftm*rp~1i. · ztFND :. •• ~~~~~·~m.m·ft-~$. l*~~~~$~.~M·~~~~~~. •• ~·~~~N~~. mftZ.~;. ~~m.~~#~mm§m~~~m.($~~~~~.ffi~*. a~'Klli~m~$~~rfia~~J '~~~*~~§m~ ~~*-§Ji) ,~~~mmfia~lIJ( 1!1mfW~~&$~~~JEJ). ftft~.~·~~~~~. 0. •• '~7~~R*~~~$~Z~'. &~~¥~*~ftg.~°ft~.~~·~g.m~~~~m~*. ~7~~~.om.~ft~~Ii'~IIJ~~$.~~~$~.~~·. ••••~~~~Mo~~~~ ~.·*~g*ali-~.~~~~~ •• m~$~.~Mz •• · m~~ti~~.~Ii.m.~~~.ft~*~o~*~g*~~ ••. m~ft~~.B~~~~ •• ,m~ ••• R'~~ ••••• o~ ~1IJ~~mztF.~~*§mm§.·. ftz~,*~g*am~t=.~*.~~~Zm.(1!1m*~~~ Z~~~)~~.H,~~ti~§~~*g~~m.~.~. ••Z.. ~W~tt • • ~o~~'.ffi~~~~~¥·R*§m~~OO~~~ ~.M~o. ~~ •• ~,~*~-~~m*~~ •• ~~.~~.~r*.~~~.~ftltft It~A~.~.J~~.~~. •• ~(Mft~)o~.'~**~~.~AA~. m~~~~a~~t'~.~~M~~~o (~~~~*~.~~OO~~) 50. 1i. .,Hi" f.1t~ fl.,,u , it ~ ~~ flJI Jlt. ' Mit 36 ' Jf 135. f,Cf}.l. 173. I':,t. r. 0.

(24) 480. Jltk~1h-:f:fl. .~U~~~,~.~ft*~~~~~WM~ •• ~'~ffi.* .$~~~$~~;W~.~~,~~~~~~~~m'ft~$~~. ' E§rltt±l.lItJ~m r ~1I7JUgit-m~lIftAl it- J ~ •• rlt51-- ' ~~$ZiM~ , ~rj~:x::fIJM,m~g-lIf9JJ~ ~ ft ' ~~ r ~OO7JUgit-m~:x:~~~ J ~'5~ it EH~mJlt ' *~lI:ltJ IItJmmllftgit-~~JJi 0. 0. 0. ~~~'m~~~~~m~~z~,rIt~~M8~m~~~o~ftm ~~,. r~lI~git-m~lIftgit-J~ft~~$,t±l.E§rltmUM~o. .~~ft~§nmg~~~ft~~M'. ~.~~&.~M~*~.. , ~m~~m~~rr&Mg~rr~~~'W*~7tt~~~Mo. .: .;:::-. , l!*~J:.i""+~ ? ~7n~lIftAlit-~~M51--,g~~~~~'n*ft*~~~~. Mo~m~.fim*ffiUm.li*~~~g·~ti~.~* •• ~U ~.,.#*m7~~~~m.~m~'U.JJi~~.R~~~&.. •• ~ ~ ~ , Jlffij~rj~~d:1t~~~~mt~ra'51 ~ffijIlMf*t!t ~U*~.ft~~~$~~ •• ,*~~ft,~~.*~.~o ~n.li*~~~~ •• ~~~~~,mu~~*t!t~U*~. ft*~~~ •• ·~m~~~I~~*~~~JJi~'~~~JJi~gU ~~m.~~$~~~oU •• ~.mM'M*~~m05A~~.' ~~05A~&~~~~ •• ~.'05A~~ ••• ~.,~ft* ¥UA~. 0. ••• ~.'~I~.,~&.m. &~~~~.,~ft~&~~. ~. ~.,~n&g~~&fl£~~. •• ~.'~~AP.m~.~oX. ft~. •• ~.~70~A~~~.&~ft~&~~~Z~.51--'~~. 51 ~1Wl;fl:.t-.if-~it*"JL Hans F. Zacher, Soziale Gleichheit, Archiv des offentlichen Rechts, Bd. 93 (1968).. Jf 341 vAT; Hans F. Zacher, Geschichte der Sozialpolitik in Deutschland. seit 1945, Band 1 Grundlagen der Sozialpolitik in der Bundesrepuhlik Deutschland 2001 '. JL.:tt. Jf 346. VA T. a. Jil 360 VA T. 0.

(25) . -.:t. 00.

(26) 482. Jtk~:fh:f:.. ~~I 'J.I:~. ~tm1IJja54. Xtj0~AJ~~{9U. 0. ' ~fg0ffjA~W~. ~~ •• ~~~MMW$.'~~~~W~.MM'0~A~~~'. i1iwf!J1iWJ&lI1i!rf-¥~~~m~.. 0. ~~'~~~~®~'~~~M~~®~$~~MM'~~~~ ~~~~®~ II.~. '.ffimE~~~®~~~~oU~.Uftm~®m. , ~PjJ0~A~W~if1t~~I~{9rr '. m. jJ0~. ~®~$3(~'. ~'~~1*$~zf~ (~~¥rr ~. (.fI. 30. 50. M® ~7mm®~~rmJjU~I~~ Z :JJOtjtt~55. ~~P~~1*). 0. ~. '~~1*m1~~~. ' ~P~f!~~~ 90% ' K~ 100%56). 'W~~~~. m•• ~BI~~*'OO~Wft~lIM®~~o~mti~~~~M~ ~,ft~I~~~.®~if1t~~I'mmUM~~~.~~I~~ -~~ff®~$~ffox~~-~~M®~$~M~m~~~M~~. ~~(§OO~~m70. •• ). '~~~~~®~M~. '.~~M®. ~.~,~.~m.~~®~R~,~m~~~M.~~~~~®~. ~~~o~~'~~.m~~$Z~I'.~~~m~~$mm~® ~1*~MMom~~1t~®~.$~(~~~~15$). '~I®_. ~.~~~*'~~~*~M~~.&~.~.MMzm~,~~m ~-MM®~~~~'~~~~M~~o~~~~'~.®il*3( ~ft~.' ~,~~~. 0. ~*.z~$®il*.~~ffi'~~~ •• B~~~~,m~~ ~~~.~~~,~*~t~.L~~~~~.~~~.'~~~A.t~~. ••t. ~~~~~o~*'~~M.~4~W.A.~L~.L~.*ftlo~.t,~ ~~ •• L~lt1t.. L.;.tft l. 0. 55~~~~~'~~~~M~z~~~~~'A:~~~(~) '~~M~L~~~ !t-f[ ,. -iLiLiL ' 1t 261. YAT. 0. ~~~~OO-~+A+iLB~.~r~~a~.ft~J~~~*~~~~M4.~ tb;tilt ~ pJf ~ ~ z:fi dii 1r:t+ 57 ~ ~~ ~ ~ , Ii)"i£ 36 ' 1t 77 YA T L 229 YA T 0. 0.

(27) !r?}-!I09-~llt-.wn~. 483. ffi ••• goU-ftftft~~*~&=ooo~m~'~-MOO~fi ~ffd:ttifliffj3i::te~M 5,460 ficp , 11fi!f[0~1¥J~f*~IDI03i::teRPit 1,816 fi;~~~.~~tt~.·~~WH~3i::tecp'~.~~ffi.~l¥Jtt ~~M~~ti!f[0~A~~3i::te,m~~.130fiI¥J0~3i::te&~it. 220 fil¥J~~~ll · ~~3i::te59. 0. ~~m~~,~~~tt~~~~I¥J •• '~m*~~~~.~~' ~~.*7~.~~~,~~~~.*~~m~~~~w~~woB ~~~~.,m~~§~m~,~.~~~.~~~~&~.~~,. .~ill11fi~.~~~I¥J~~W~¥ •• o~~~~M-.*~~m~. ~MM'~~~~*I¥J~~~w~m.o~~'~~.~~.M=W. ' illt~.~61 x.m ~iil¥J~ , {OJ U~ti~~~~~~~A~p~ •• m~u~~~*£~~~~~~ ~~iJ[J~JIt~t!!x:iM. '. {gt~Jl:~oW. 0. ~o~~%A~fil¥J~'WU~~~~l¥Jm~'~-~~~U~A~ pm~~~. 58. I¥JffiMr •• ~.~JQo~~' •• ~I¥J~.~~'. -:IL A 0 JF- 1.l( .:it. fi-:fJf ' 1! JL Ming-Cheng Kuo, Alterssicherung in Taiwan Grungprobleme sozialer Sicherung in einem jungen Industriestaat, 1990' Jf 72 r.A T tf. 0. C*.:it.•• ~~~~t'~~W%~~~.4.~.AJ~~~o ~SI~~OO~JF-*~~~~~~•• ~#4.~.:it. •• ~r~.~~T • .:it.~~~ JlJ ~J!t.-l.m- J .:it.fi-fcg_* <> roC~*4-:lLAOJF-ft~a~ •• ~±.~.~'~~.~~-M.~.t~*A 4~.:t.:l.4 t~~ Pi:§: lk~JL Kuo' ~li 58 ' ;I(.~ Jf 288 rAT <> 61~*.~~~.~$.:it.~~'.h«~-~$.:it.~~'~.~+.~~~.A'~ 0. ~ •• aD~ff.AJ~~._~.~ ••• ~.D'~JL~.~ •• ~~#W' ;I(.~ftM~~.:it.~~'~~4~~'~~~~A~~.aD. Q~~.:it..~1!~JL$~.'.A.~.:it..:it..~fi-~ ~~M.,a:Cft~~. ••. ~~~~~1~~JF-~~M~. •• :t.a'Jf~7~ ••• ff~ •• ~.:it.~~,~~ •• •• ~4~~ ••• ~~At,#»~. (T)-.A~.~~.~~~. TDtf.~-~~.~~~~~mft.:it.~.~~. •. A~~#a.o~~1~~~~mft~'. lt~A~D.~4.~~~ •• ~~*'~~~~~'~~£'~~A'~~~' #~.'. • • • • • • *'h~~ •• A~~~.*~~-. •• ~fi-M • •1*..

(28)

(29) -k~~~-.jJt-.1JJ~~. 485. m~~m*~~~~'~Htt~~m~ft$'. m*~*~~w~~. · ~~~~~f!Jffl~JJf.Jm •. m~. OO~~~H~·~.W~~~.~~·M.M~.$A~~. b·~A·*~a.&.~.~~~tt~mm~·. ; H~*fr. ~~A~~~IIl{lI~~{5J{'Fml!l53UJtf-lf~ fi-~~. M~~&.~~m~·#.b*W~~A~~*~mffi.· ~~m~~~§~m~~~~®*fr~D~~~~~o. .. MLM~x~Jt~rllllliJ ~~~m~~~$~J .~. •• ~.,. ••. r~~J~M~·~~~*$~~ o~~·~Rm1J.0~~~~~. $~~M~m~M~~.B~~·#~~.~~~. .tt~.o~~'M~.~.&X~tt*~.~.~~~~MM'# .~~LIt~. ~i1fo. .~ML~~'~*E+.~m. •• ~tt~*~~~'.~m~. ~,mili-M~~7M~~m~.,~®~~m. •• ~~$$~~o. '$$x~~~~'B~~~~$Wtt*$$$~M~~,mW. " m~~m~~ft$ . 1J~$r~~~ ·~.~~.~~*$~~~.'WB~ ••• ~~-~.'M.. ili[OJ~tBm@Jjg~~$ijjU~W1~. 7m~~~~·~m~~w~~~*o ~®~f-lf • • ~MW. om•• ~'. ,~~~~~~~~~,. -~~-~~-~~J~~m~~. r. •• ·.~~~~~m~~.~~m.~~o lr UJ. .... ~ jfiC. Hi DC. *.~X~~~M.~~$'Dpr~~~~~J&. •• ~~~~. -ft~~~m.tB~r~~~~~'~~~~~'~~~~~J. ~. ~~m~.'~M~.. +.~*tt**~$M.~~~*. $.

(30) 486. Jtkf-fh'-'=. IJ> ~m*~Ltr~tm~tt~~~$~~~mt~.~$~~~. ~~~~~$Wtt~$$$~M~~LM~tm~~~~*~~~~. .~~~m·fu*~ffl~~~MAAm~RL@m·~~*~~~r~ ~W~~J o~~·m~.~. ••• ~·~tr.~~~~·.ffim~. ~.m~~~~~m·~~ffim~~~~m~o~~~~~m~.7 ~~~~L*.W§~'~~&Wm~~~E~L.~W~W.o~. ~mm~t~ffi*~~m~~$~~M.Ar~~W~~J$~·~ .~~$~~m~~.m~~·~~ffimm~~m~@_~tr~m. ~o~~mm~·~~~.tt~~~*~·~~tt~~~~~~~mo ~®~Mm~~$$tt~~.W$·~~tt.~~mw~~o~ ~'~~liO~~~m~~Bmffi:. rft.~.~m~®A~. •••. •• *·~~m.~MoJ.~' ~~B~m.:. m~®A~ •• ~~~.~~~.~tt~. ~·mG.~L~~.fi~.~~;~ •• *,~~m.~o~*~ .~~~ •• , r~tr~~~J~.~~~'~ill~.~$~.~~ ~~.&.~~.~tt~.~;~. m~~.ox~.~~~ffi.'~~~~~~=+li~~~ffi~r~ tr-~~-~~-~~J. 65. ..f..isJ4-' filii 9. Jf 43. 0. ,.~~.~~m~m~M~~~.~o.

(31)