後冷戰時期東北亞國際政治結構

全文

(1)~a'ID~Z~R~~~.~~~~~m~~~w~%~ww.~ W.~~~~.3°. •• ~Mfu**M~m~.W~.w.~.~. ~t:-1ttf4f~~~~~~~~~.3&~.4*. '. :lJB1JW.~$f:r3t. o~~~~~m~~~R~~±~~mMW.~~~~'~W~. .fHJf~~. ' ~~f4f~3t ' f4f~~if:ffit-lt"'¥fij~ , .mt~$n ~!f3t WEJ ' ~ • .1-75fj./, ~ ~¥ if:-m. It.fif3t W'ij}f$lI11t ' ii~6I1It , jfltHil~~M~mii. W~. •. .mt~. 0. f4f~~if:ffit-ifm~lf&ffilf~[gj. ~~'~~~~~~.Wm~'ij}fW.if:-m.. ••. 'ti¥~.~~ ••. ao*w~~¥if:-m.~~W~¥'~~~~~if:-m.*ifo~~*~. •• ~.m'.u.g ••*~~~='.M.~~••~~o. ~m~~f4f~~~~3t~¥fro'~Z~.~~@lt3tm'*~a. ••~M1tt'.M~~~B.~~'~~~~~.'~B~.. fi*~~~~~11. ~1~J~Jnt~.~"lt. h.

(2) ••• ~¥Z8.0~~*.,.~~.fiE.~~~~~~.~ ?tfJT JiJf~*~~2~E~m9=t~, A *' I¥j~t., 9=t~ II, ~ ~\W~II •• A•• (~Z •• M)~ ••*~~2~E~~.~. J'HiimlH!13. lt~':::+j. 0. iffimi${5H. ~-~.~,&.m.*~~2~E~~¥~.oW~~.~~.~. .~*~~2~E,ill~E.~~~.~m~*,~~~~Ati ••. 11. 3:111 '. ~*~~1i. 3: 111 , 1'!i! J. 0. ,., -. 1JE15!!*~~21l~l!&r€tWUJ~~il:1:."~~:ft~¥mi~.*gg~ ~. ••••• zxmo~~~~tt"~Mm~,~~~~~~fi~. {tr.1f.Jj/J~~ztPIl1!Z~1P1. 0. ••. ~::tB~::k(Mikhail. Gorbachev). ~.Bu=+~,*$.ft.~,.~~~n~.~2*l!&.~~. 15 0 ?&W~~~~1fb~.~~fl1I.fi2*Z~ag, &WSIJ-m2*~EII ~Z~lI 1P11lif&:iili~ •• Ilr:J~'![~~IE~ --JL)\'.li~::tB~::k ~.Z., ••••• ~ •• ,~ma:iilio.~~~~,::tre •• 0. 0. ~~¥~IIr:J~~~~'IP1Ilif~¥~*~~~~ZIl~. ~o~r~~~J.~ag~~~,::tB~::k~~7-*~~2*~ _.~,~1JE~2*~E~.~*~\.$.~.~~.~o(~ ". , i. I¥j.~. 0. • •fii. 1t?'~ 3'Cl!&1$. llka.frB. . " (ttm;. lU~n.~. :tE, Witt 1iZ~~o. .~ftftE. J'l.13., flS t€t.n.~. -)w::treJiJf.Z•• flJj/J,fi*~t2m.ag.~~~D~0~~ tt=, Dnitl'j lit- : flllj(;E.~;k:tJ<J!IT,Itl~llt&;lt5:>::*ili!{. '. ~~~Mikhail. S.Gorbachev, Peres- , troika: New Thinking for Our Country and the World (New York:. Harper & Row, Publishers, 1987); Rajan Menon, "New Thinking and. !1. {!Ii. Northeast Asian Security," Problems of Communism (March-June 1989): 1- 29 ; .~Jf, ~l;1t1j. , }'i14-23. 0. r .I1tJ<J~1tiW5:>::*ili!{. J , PdlllMiFJt '. ~29~ ,. to the of [ntE. tt=: 'StephE the 01. ttlm : David Era,".

(3) 1&~"f/!tIlifWBfi::lt21l ~l!&1it~~. JPJIHl~~i.IIII:I:t!l.. rp. ~nt:MB 19 m~- JLAJL ~ -. ~II'~. J'l §. IwJ'ai ff1ltt. ;. 3J. :~m AA f£ 5llfH:I:t!l. Jij[ft Iii. ••-+li••• '1Itt.~f£*.&.ll9W~Z~+li'~~M.. £:I:t!l.~IHl~~;fij. 5.l~.ffi'~M~rpe~~o(. ~ ti !idHE :I:t!l.~!lLt. :±~,@lliM~ili~~.~~.$~±~2:t:I§f(m~.~,~~~. t~~11A-W~iJE. ~*~.&.2:t::I:t!l.Jij[I§f(~.M~ •••• ·(tt=)~~jt~~ :±~. ,. {!1!*~t2Jij[~pg[jj~L~~¥}M.~:m~~~!YJMmfJL~PzWt. ~,~.~. ::Os 3g. -. •• IHl~tl9ill~•• ,~~~~~~_~~.~~mZ. 0. ~~l1S1~*W~. px:ffi'rtl9ifljti:l:t!l. :til Gorbachev). )~~m.~~.~jtB.~ll9. .~m.z., Jt5'~~I§f(m. 0. ••. ~~n~~~~~.~z*~:I:t!l.~~m.. ~li~(Boris. Yeltsin)ili*f~.~.nz., ~.1*. ;t:t5.1:t:I§f(ftll9lt. ••• fi.,~~ti •• ~~M.~~:I:t!l.Iii.M~me. ~ .·(tt~)~*,.~m•• m~z.JLII.,.-~.~.D. ii:JIJm5.1:t::I:t!l.~1I. ~~h~~II~.~~Z~~.o~.m~~~z~.. LJ\.li 1f jt5 fi~ t § ll9 , jt f£.'it;g~. ~,mf~ti~AAm~.h~.$'.M~. .Z&~of£.$~Iii,.r~.~.ffltt~I§f(~~ffl5l!~~~o. U~. ~r. zll~fl. ~~ff. ••%•• ~.Z~.~. •• B~.~ ••M.~,.~~~tt •• ~~*II:MBI§f(z~. T-:Il:fltl95.1:t:I§f(. ~§~,~~.M~tth.M~~II~.hzm~m~,f£II~~. ~~~.#t. 0. M.hM.~~~miflj~*.o~.~.,llin.T~. fU 51! fHl;!J:ft. 0. (. ;t:t:±. " S.Gorbachev, Peres. ?. World (New York: "New Thinking and. unism (March - June rCl~B:ft.an't. ' ~29~ ,. ••%.&. tt= : Dnitry V. Petro, "Perestroika and Changes in the USSR's Approaches to the Post - Yalta Situation in Northeast Asia," The Korean Journal. of International Studies 21(Winter 1990):505-506. 0. tl:=. : Stephen M.Young, "Gorbachev's Asian Policy; Balancing the New and the Old," Asian Survey 28 (March 1988):317 - 339. 0. tt[!l : David Shambaugh, ·China's Security Policy in the post-Cold War Era," Suvival 34(Summer 1992);96. 0.

(4) %~*~~z~~,li~±.~*~~~~m~~~W. ntOOr. ±~~z. ~fi!t~M±$*.:jt2.~ag~'Hj*9='~*fi!t~=fE11J1~1SI. 1* ,. ~*.:jt2~*~~~. 1SI.tl. *M1l:ilfJ(ag~n. A~~9='~~N~~~~=~9='Z-~,m~.~~~ag$~9='~. J&7~*~1fI$,¥~~#i. mA~m~~~~~~.rItz~~~moW~~ISI~m~ttz~~~. mH:: s *~.rIt:H!! l!i £i'. /I J , $Jt l:H::.~*E. ag§agoW§frJs*~Jl. ~~~)g*a~ ~~.~9='.dffi~~~~mz~.,*.:jt2.~~.~9='~ JJllfrF;U~11Mt-f1l. 0. fiI*Jj-~*~~s*~. ~ ~ _~C:P2*~t~. 11,. JIfE*,j~1l ~bH~14j. ~.. , £Ljl~l!i~pg~* lft;!-, s *1!Jf~~~. 0. II$~. -\~.JI~. ,. j,(Jl~:it~~itFLA. l.~ l!i~5m.m~ttm:~. ~fiI.~:f1:I:sy..~~(Peace. .~~~.~~~.*~*~,~~~.~~~.~9="B.. 1I~.maglJtJJ. *m~. 0. *.:jt2~l!iZ~&l±.~.. ,. ~~~~. , .~;!-*Ji~W. tt~,~~~~~~~W~.o~~_~*~~~~agS*,JJlB dA~~~~ag§AoS*±~m~~A~~ag=+n%Z-'A. I'. [iij~ s *~1. W~m,9='~~~~~~~~~~=~9='ag~~fE1~o.~~*~. #,~~~A~~~.nag~*,~~~~~£*z~.no. .." ,. ,. Jj~ S*ffP~~*.:jt2~~. 0. 1SI.rIt ,. ". ±~*lMt. I=U:t&.~~. ,. 1l!~~IX;~&l~1HUIIJA~~agE%Z7\+. •• ~z-;~~tt~m,s*&~~*.~ , ~~~md.mag~t~ (l'ftn). -~~~~.*.a. 1£*.:jt2~l!i,. 0. s *~. .~MHlagfE1~ ? ~~2itm if~. 0. (l'ft{:;) ISIlft , ~. 1JJ?'&.~~.z1fIn,. ' :tim. ~~~=~~*~ag~mo.rIt;!-, s*~~~~.n~~,*~*. .:$t~~. 0. 0. s *.*IWJt~~ , dA~~l!iJi~Wtt~ag. itlL 'William R.Nester, Ja World Economy: End 1990), pp.219-227.. it* : Ibid., p.13. 0. it-t : Jonathan Pollack and. in a Changing Pacific.

(5) f!~~~Wnf(::lt21i1jlf}i§tra~m. ~.±~7€:tz. '±.*.,~~E1*~:(£.jt~~. •• Dm.~~m.~~~o;f{l. 1Iltf! EI *~P~~.jt~~.1:tl D~.±.m.. ::: ~ IHJ 1l !;51 ilr&:iJW!'iHf ~iit~'i=';tt. 0. 0. :lIHlj($Lt~3Jl-{lj~1HJ. ., ••jt~~.:(£.~\j(a~.~*.E1*,MfiTM~~E1 *M~.~~~jJo!;5l~~~~~.~~E1*B.m.~~~,~ ~T~~~.$~~~~~~~r*.~;tt~~J§~o(tt~) 1f!~. ":Ez;f{l~m. !jJ. 33. EI *:(£~ltf!~~.~ ••~i31~~~f7g~.~11. 0. .jt~. ••~=~*~~E1*~~~IT~~~~~o~~~r*.~;tt~ ~J,$.~~~~.ffi •• ~~~~~'W~IT~~~.~~. ~ § i¥J W§ Btr EI *:(£.jt~:ItI!~~.~ffil1J , {6~j(a~~.m 0. .,~~~.~A.~•• i¥J*.'M.~.~*-.m~ •• ~ tEf!!J~'i='. ' £i3I}tg~~f7gIl.~ EI *~ii:lf ~*, E1*•• ~.~.jJ,lf.~~~7€:t*Il, ••• W~ !!l$9 ' 5!1l~iI~~~rJA~.W1fiiJ~1Jtm~~¥ , ~AJiIl:iJW!mWJ~. ~.. 0. illJ~IU~:fIl3f:Jf;t(Peace Keeping Operation, PKO)£i3I~~~f7g ~'i=',B~. ;r*.~W. E1*,mB. 5tz-,A. •••• i¥JIHJ~oEl*~~.~~~~.~eA~.*,f!!J~~. .~.~~~?~~A~~f7gIl.~~;tt~,~~~~~.~~i¥J jf~. 0. (tt-l:::). !;51~. , ~tI!l$r&~zp..qT:(£.jt~3I.Z\IT.. , fE!. ~~.~;f{l~Z.jJ,-:JfOO~~.jJ.~;~-:JfOO~~.~~. t\+,fim. f!J , ~1f* :(£~~~~. ttli 'William R.Nester, Japan's Growing Power over East Asia and the World Economy: Ends and Means (London: Macmillan Press Ltd., 1990), pp.219- 227. tt* ' Ibid., p.13 tt-t : Jonathan Pollack. 0. 0. ~wttm-~. and James A.Winnerfeld, U.S. Strategic Alternatives. in a Changing Pacific (The RAND Cooperation, June 1990), Chap. 3..

(6) 1t1 S*ZIf'L'. 0. ~~.~~ •• =~~.~~IW~~~.~~~.~mm r,~~~~~~~~W~~~~~~H~,~~1t1~~~~.o. IJij~Jld. ~T~.L~~t,~~£~~.~~~~,~~~a~.~~~. S;. •• o~~~8W.~~~~~~~~Mffi~~~~S~~.,~ D~~*.a§.S~ •• ~mIDr,~~W~~~~~~.a* .~.,~~E~~~~*.W•• ~B •• ~~~D~~*o~ ~~.~Ett •• ,~±.® •• W.~~.,~_&~$.~.. ~~:fi2. ~~aj. fJf1::.~.o. as1l3j(c. 11}tlll. mnNfU. ~~,.j~~~~.~.fJM.~±~~.,K~~s~~~. f£". •• ~S~~H~.~~~ •• ~~. J}I• •(1. •• K~.~~H~z.~~.o~~W~~H~ ~8mM~~.'K*~.~ •• ~~~W.«~~z~~W.~. ¥ttJ[tr. ~H~~.f1::o~~.-N ~,m~s~~. .~o.*~W~, S*W~~~~.~E~~~ffim.,~~~. 8~K.~m. •• ~.A(ttA). '". Confere .. 0. (il. D.~~~WS*.MH~.. ~$*f.Ij. m'W-+.n~H~~S~.OO,m~~z.~~mm.,~~. ~Jt.fl'. ?if~mD. ~,. .j~~~E~mr1J. S'. Z9r~1l. 2.E~.~ilf1::~~~. I'. -r1J. 1¥iI±i. ••M~~~.~~*~.~~~~'Wli. ~. , lI1ff,l. .±.~~&~~~~ID~~~,~3j(.~ilf1::~~~~~.~o. •••~wm~~.a~~,ttm.~w•• ~~~~. tEJL: 1H. .,.Milf1::ld.~~o~*~.~W.'.~~~.~K~~.. 199. .Ym~~. tv\. : Shambaugh, op. cit., p.97. 0. Rie. fs r.. tE-O:.

(7) ~~~flifWl~::jt52mwm~7€t~~. -$.,. '~'.B.~nX.~~~~~ffi'Ii,~~m.~ru~tE.. Si~'lfm. §.~.,E. ~Gilo. fRJ*Ht. ~ffi'Ii~~ ~s!'i. , tE. 35. •• 7~ffi'Ii.~*~~ • • ,~.~ffi'Ii~~m~~;tt. 0. S*J.t:bnSSi5Ii::t. ~*~ ~It1ill'ifl~ ,. ~ ill J!.J;!.m~ tt!1il. 1f!.J!1il$ -fL:t\01f-f-tw , s */J\i1~~~(Kiyoshi Kojima)t!P 0. ~~~*. B~~ill::t~~§~~~ffi'Ii~m~o(ttfL)-fL:t\01f~*M,. m~o9i. ~~IU~~Jffi'Ii~j7gIl~~#lftitJJ1> .fj!f~mt·lfm:IF-' ~ ~~~JlI!. '1f.~.. m:IF~.m,~~_l'i~~~l'i~~~~lDi*~.~,~~*ffi'Ii~ tJ911~o. ,Orh±t ~J-IT/,,-. tE~$~ffi'Ii~*~.~~9i,~~~~m~~::t~~~~.~. ~~~. J1I!$.(Pacific Basin Economic Council,. ~9i;ttIl-f*. .ttJ(~::t~~.~*~.M (Pacific. ~lRJml~~. Conference, PECC) ,. r'. .o(tt-O)-fLAfL1f+-~tE.~~*~~RZ5Ii::t.~*. ~jj §. [~Il-f*\t. ff.t '. I§. !Jl':IF. PBEC)J!Jl1f~. , 1§r ,. Economic Cooperation. ~~:lL~*' Jjtlmt5Ii::t.~*~.1fj{. f1:;llIS-llHil.•M(Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation, APEC) , ~A1f. jjtt.,~~m.~ • •. o. ~. ~*M~1f*~. .\s\.,.,m'.'$'.\~\~'~~J!&.~+=1I. Z*~~.~.*•• oJ;!..m~.SSi~.~~R~~$.~~. ,. ml:f±. ~~~mt. ~,M~~l'iMM~.~~~o~~~jjA~~ffi'Ii~~.~.~~. 0. (~lDi~r",~. lP~nX.:lL¥. tEft : :fj1Hl§:*:it!!II".~r;!f~fFz.J\l ,. "~~Norman. The New Rigionalism in Asia and the Pacific (Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 1991), pp. 133-156;JlJ.~, r §:*:it!!ii~r;!f~fFZ@].~J\lm J , ~=:Jl!l r §:tJHJ\lm J 1j1f1ri1t , 'EJ'~t , ~1!I80:!f9Jj 20 8 .¥,218 0. tt-O:lPlflrtt o. D.. Palmer,.

(8) -~--~----~~--~-. .,... •••~.M. .*""Ji!~1r?t. ).=g~*.~.M. 1I.I!Jf~ft:1lJ. $~~~ • • ·~ • • fi,~~.K.~~*,~~ ·.~.~.Z.~o(. ftftO.~Aa~~.~~, ~~$~~ • •. ~Zf.\4~. 0. • • • ~ • • -.~r&R~ •• ~. Z•• J,(tt-=)~m.~ •• ~.w~na. -ftft-.m: ' •. .:::g~*R~.$tH& • • Mtl~£. .'itiftfIWJM,. 13 , {JJf&lIIH! m. *fl:{JJ1ff.f~jJ. ~,~~~~~~·~~.wm.:::n~.,R~~~~~~~~8. ~7~~m~~~*,~.~~~±~~K~n~o. t'. ft~R.~~~m~,~~~*.~ • • ~,-ftA~ • •-. .. ftAA.~, !;l~*~f~.m~~/J\.~~. S*OO!m S *¥fJ~.n,. ¥U1fH~~~x:f-f. r iZ:il¥fJ#Jll:~. J , EE. ~.*~~tn.1¥Jn, ~~>lt::lt.nlV.'&. ltlJ{9H!fs~J~:il*.~.fiR~~ft:,. (tt-.:::). 3. rlJJa-R71tfr. {£!1ft~.~*:m. Ji!1Mi~.~~. 1:It~~f91Jr£J. jttt'j.71t~~. Ilsl;tg.ll:m:ZRU. .rB*~lI~mU. 1II~.JfBM_1IIt. 0. ~~~~~~*M,.~*.~R~~ft:.~7£1f~Z. ~o=~*~~*~~~.m~~~, S'~.I~~~~mm~. ;. II. I. ~i!f*iL¥!f':::·fi]Hf~B;ijS~rJiJ!~. S'. ~J!I~~~~;fU*i¥J~!I. ~.~~m~~~.~XKW~~m*M~~,(tt-~);ijS~lli. itt-- : Far Eastern Economic Review, November 16, 1989, pp.l0-19 itt-= , I~~~ , ji:ijitt9 , Ji8. 0. 0. itt-.:=:: : Kuang-sheng Liao, "Economic Cooperation in the Asia-Pacific ,).. .. t'. I'..I. Region: An Introduction," in ed., Politics of Economic Cooperation in the Asia - Pacific Region (Hong Kong: The Chinese University of , Hong Kong, 1992), p.8 itt-1m: Kent E.Calder, "Japan and the NIEs: the Political Economy of Rising Interdependence," in Clara Joewono and Harry H. Kendall, eds., Japan, A SEAN, and the United States University of California Press, 1991), pp.225 - 234 0. 0. : Robert A.. The PacifiA. , Ji!. rpJt+ 1m.

(9) f~~~~wnl(t~~21iIlt*iftf€l~m. -----------------------------. 37. ,. tlbJ!.{@~M. m*3jl-~~1L5tI. -.A.~_. ~~~~ ~n~. IIJJt~71f~fFPIJ;.L7t~li1!elJlt;;.:.-§Fit~$h~,II~~'all'Jt:~m. ;.~~ft~.1j. .,~~~M,~~~OO-ft~oW~*~~~~y-+$~~~. ~ i!!lffO PI fi~ ~. h,m•• ~% • • • • ~§Fit~A~,~~~*~~~~••71f. t~M¥l:9ltR. ftfFm1f~~fJo. ,. ~~~~~tTF£~. ~~.~~~~aamll~A&~. ~~ft. J ,. Fit. ff!~. ,. ;ftH.IJ.1f~~. 3.m~*!71f~flI~tt. 't~JlN{XJm. fLA-t~~. 0. J1(::lt~~{9IJ_1'J!~I{~. 0. (ij:--li). •••fim~.71f~ ••. :iUl-R*±1t.:t.Il~JiJT.lOC~. o. 9=t. ~~~~71fm~,~*~.~71f~~~~,~Z~~~~~~$,. mfi.p;j (;_Up~~~A.:t~~~ ,. ll:lt~1J~~. ~ijl®.m:ZJJUt:tJF'¥. t~~~*1-t. ~a*~~~~.}!A~~.~gA,m~J!.9=t*~Il~ •• lOC~. .J!1f *,J zlll. •••• ,~.~ ••• *~.,~*~~~ fJ, ifij~.j{lj~9=t \ IJ\~.~.:t , fflfJ1t:frP , ff!~,ftlHr~~~~t+HIm/J\~. tll~JiJTil.. .d.,.~. i{~.m~1J. ~9=t~~~~~Il~,~~~~~}!~o.n§~OO*.*Z~~. -1m ). OO.,tt~4*a*~~~~~Il~~~;B~~J!.~Il~M~*. ~~~71f. ~~tB. •••. 0. ;ffl&~. ,. •••. *~~om~.~~.~tt,~.::lt~~~p;j. W~~~~~o9=tJt:.~~*B~A~=1!eI+~m~,~~.'. )-19. ¢. ftrtl1t.:t.m~.~J(tt-~)~~,~.~~ •• J!.m~~. Asia - Pacific. Cooperation in University of. ~.~ZIl~'~H~~.$~*~~~~~ ij(~. 0. A~~~.,.~. ::lt~~OO*m~::lt1J~.~IJp;j.~ffiflJMfJzr. , ~~Mi. I Economy of. :y H. Kendall,. 3erkeley,. CA:. iE-li : Robert A. Scalapino, "Northeast Asia-Prospects for Cooperation," The Pacific Review, vol. 5, no.2, 1992, p.01. 0. ~-~:~~~+~*~~.~,~~.,-nn=~+R+~ao.

(10) ~S*~~H~tt~~,~~.~~H~.~,~n~~,~.m. JtmzfM1~T~. • , ••~~nM••~R.o(tt-~)W •• ~~ ••~.n i:E**.*:f£*~~5l:i&lifHf~~WfJ. '. jt~gelXJ¥.q:.;tt,. S* '. m. .;tt~KM,o'Fm •. il~.j!ift~. ,. m~.?1fa1f!:m~~f.i€fA ~.fJo'F~I=IJ.1I!Ml~13t. .Mft,~~.:i&~E;tt~~.B~KMo;tt~~.:f£~?1f~.B. .fJ~Bf}~. ~~'@~:f£~~~~~~~Z~~IA,(tt+n)~~~~~. II>. ••* • • EM~W~m~.~~~IIM~ft~~a•• ,(tt. ~.~~~*z-Ao~m:f£;tt~~.~~~~z~oq:.;tt .§~'. 0. (. =, ¥-ftJl};:. 1.*~q:.11 ~IJllH*1~~. )~~R~:f£~~~q:.II~~~li.~.~~~'~Mm.~. *~~5l:i&B*~q:.lli. ?1fI~,;tt~~.~~~m~~*.~~o~m~WE,q:.;tt~a. nw~~~,.1tfit~WJ. r ft J ~ r m J. mW~~z-oW~.!I;.. z~~m.zq:.oq:.;ttM~.~rftJ.~~~-W'WrmJ~. -nJL-1¥m:~-nn=. ~.~~~~~o~~~~,~~ft,W~~~morli.~.m. It. •• ?1fJq:.,ft#~ft~.~*,.#~m,@~ ••• ft~.. •• J11!.~~,~n~trr. ~o:f£*~~,q:.;tt.~a~.,.~B~~II.~.,~m~.. =+:n:~~.ojtq:.tQffl. m,@w~.~~.~q:.II~~,jtft~~~.~.o~ffl.~.. ~~~~~~~;.*.. 1f!:~~t&~~jtf5L!~. 0. ~*1tWE. '. q:.;tt~14~flID~. ~... 0. -nJL--1¥nJ3 ~~t. fi!m.z~fj tt--t : Donald S. Macdonald, "The Role of the Major Powers in the Reunification of Korea," The Washington Quarterly 15 (Summer 1992): 135 - 137. ,.. 0. .). tt-A : Far Eastern Economic Review, November 26, 1992, p.24. I'). tt-fL : Richard Nixon, Seize the Moment (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1992), p.22. I. ;tt~~H1L~. . ' (tt-J\.) ~q:.l{H~II~H{*JlU~?1f~.*~~~~. @~a~~.~ •• Sli.~.II~:f£~?1f~~a.£.~.· 0. I!. , ~q:.;tt!. 0. 0. ~;~, ;fp~,~~~. tt~it,jtt=ptQ*m.o. iff f$!!Hf:ffl ~ -=fit =n,. ~. 0. tt=O: .. r~r~~~.~J.~~••• a.~~.J'~.~D.~~fi'& , ~l1!lJ\.l1!l#f.l, Ji9-U 0. IiJAt-~fLJjfLf3. tt=- : :il!1fJl:, r fiUIWTa #f.l '. ~/iliI81~10Jj. ,J.

(11) 1~~~~Wnf:!~~lllimm ~l!&#tf.wrlt. •• m. lft~,. i¥J#UIWT~n. *,8*, ltii ~:f:~. 0. ,i:'&(~£5li~1iat. .. rt£f.I~"l:.B. ..) [riJ!!if ~ tit oW ~. J:\=I*~14*. 0. il:i:'&(Jj(_,. -:,. .fflz~i¥J~~,~J:\=I*~~OO~i¥J~*.~o. _*i¥J]Gf¥¥ , ljJ\mmtJ:\=l*J!~~¥tit, ~i¥ilJf~i¥J)]n5m , i;)5m1t* ~~ ••• ,*[riJ.m~j:i:'&(¥i¥Jm.o~*, •• WT.nz~, ~ft~"i:'&(¥m~ •• A~ •• m~, ••••m••• ,~~~ .~~ljJ\~mn.mJ!&.'Im ••l:, •• WTA~&~~~~. .~i¥J •• o(tt=-)~~,~~*~j: •• Bm~,*14.. .0. =, ¥jtlliX. (it. 1.?t~J:\=IIJ*H1~~tfI:f1lti. f~M-rtl~~. *~~n*E?t~~m*.~~ •• ,lft~'."':f:.m.*. J:\=I*i¥Ji:'&(. RJJ!rfflJ. nW~.~,14~~!!ifM~ARZ~~,&~mmt*E~.~i¥J~. j~ ,. ~ffl i¥J;fl. •• ~.~A•• o~Mm¥titmnOO, -nn-~~J!-nn=~mi¥J •• J!i;)$i¥J~~.m~.~i¥J~ -nfL -~fLJj i¥i~~¥tit[riJ!!if)]nA.itm ' ~+=Jj .1Ti¥Ji¥i~~ •• ~1it~!!if,~n~MT~~~~m~lft~'."J!*~H~i¥J =+lilliitl. jtJ:\=l§m:!f.~tt~BJ!~~.1M' ; ~J1:.~:f:~14ji!:!f.. ~Il fnHm :fIl 11. ~~~~~~lft;.*."J!x1t~~,~H~~~~~~1iti;)~. i , 1m r ffl J .IlU. , r 1±1it j:.rtl. ;ft~Ml~Ri¥J.. :. ' ~. 39. 0. ~.~.Z-°Im~~.i¥J. .0. 0. f!m.Z~1To Powers in the ~rly. ~*'~. 15 (Summer. •••~-fLfL-~fLJj~~.~~¥.~m~ ••. tt.~,jtJ:\=l§~i¥i¥tit°i¥i¥titlft~~~+=Jj~~~jt±*l:B& 24. 0. mon & Schuster, r,,~lI.M~fIJ. ,. ~. ff{$Jl1ffriJ~T~~. tt=- :. "'~Jf,. WJ '. ,. ~~~*~~¥tit.~.:I1f!~1f~~~T~tif[i¥J. r ~IlWTi!&~DJi.DGJjij.~nl.[Iij. ~m811f:lOfj , J{32. 0. J ,. rJlll-'iilfJl: ,. ~31;g , ~lO.

(12) Jl-'. , ~tf!f;!J)\1f~llJatJJl~ , [t'IJ;f::1JnAIIII '@:-T-f~UI~at1lt!:~{~iItI (tt==) ~lljl(!dtf!f;Nf~~1f~~jJW;f:a ~:ilI;f;<JitJi!JJ.f*m ' ~llWJi;f:g~.itt!~1!r , JtUT-{!im~tf!f;Il~~ 0. .~1f~~JlHmillJ!. ~±., ~.:[t~%.~~:f. 0. ~-~~~,~X~~!J)\~~S.~o. mf!f;~~*-)!$at~~: z-omf!f;~*;!1tnX.:§it1EfIf. ~II~. .M.~m~at1f.~.,*~.~~~at~oo~fl,mT-~ m~.Il~-.A1f~.tto~~~.@:~. o.-,.~m~@. ~~~+~at%~~~,KmT-~~m~M~Jl~o~~~,~~~. •• JJ.JitjJ~ •• -at~m,wa~*~*#~.Ii.~ [t'IJat~.' ••• M~Il~~~T-~Z~.Q(tt=~)~M~~. :fJififffE.Z~t~ :ll:~~5CIl~~~. it '. ~mT-WJi. ~~~~~~~II.~T-#~'*~. II.-atm*~.o. ~.~M~~~jJ.~~at1f~~,all~.-~.at~~~f*~ ~attat.~,.~~at~att~~,.~.~.m.-at~ato. ~~-.~-,¥l$f~at~W. '. ~~z.~.'I1~.. 0. ffifm:[tf!f;at.-~. W, Jtu~Jt~:I&!.mat~jjF , NJllN:~JiUEi. '. ~m~tf!f;~~jJii. ~-,¥~~~~,~.~A~1f~flZmao. •••• , •• Ii.ate .Ritt!~o~*~.~~~at.~,~IlJT~~~~at •• ,m. ~~II.at~~,.itt!.~~*IlJ~at~~o~~~M.%Aat~ :'. tt=- : Scalapino, op. cit., p.107 tt=::.:: : ;ff1HJ~*~J!!(11U~.p;tUhsJ!!(1l{~~~,~~JL, J;f!1HJ1l J , 'fl1l*l!!.iilFJt ,. ~34;f!t. ,. ~12~. ,. r tm:¥*~*If:tJ!!(1l{~fiI! , :A1O-26 ,. ~i!l80:¥12Jl. A~~~, r.p~r.8J!!(1l{J~r.8I~J~WfiJ,*~*ft,~ 0. J!~-1Lj[. 1. JJ. ~~~.~;. m:mw~,m,.ZAfl. 0. i*~~. ~fl*m~. ,~~,. P31B1fp.AfiJffl ~~~. III~Jt~~Z~.O it1JJ~Z.~,~~!t ~~~Ul. 1m). 0. n ~t'W~. 0. 0. mA~p.~:. mA,. ~~ma1f~~~J. ~j 0. tt\iij~[t'IJ.at~IBlill.~.. tE•••:lr..fttl1!1f ' f.!.1f Rr. 3.1trfllltJfatJII.. 0. 23;f!t , ~1~ ,:AI 19. ~~-~. ~1fImnX.JJ.. .:[t~itt!.Z~II.~~.*.,. ,. •• *al~;. ~{Ii"jjJ • • ~~~.mllJ. "Uf{:ffnX.~. 2.~~~ • • jJat.®. I'. [t'IJltfm.**:fff~'. 0. ~~~~WAfI.JU~,. ,. n=l1!l ' T.~ r *1!f;f"rn~J~ a. 0.

(13) o. E ilt ' rl±*ll'JI( ,. •• ~D.o •• ¥W~¥ •• ~.~ ••••VM.~~~. ..... , 9(; -. of§1: '. f{(. iiM~:@jij¥&I;l. ~1j~il• •Jln:. o~~&~.~M~M'.m.~~. .~~M'~.~ .¥'~. ••~. I~.~'.~*m~.~.~~~~. ••• ~ ••• ~.~'~~o.~.~um~~o(~. ~~~~.li!,. Ufu'~'OOT. 1;I~*mL. =~) 'Y~.~~Y~~~~~.~'Y~~~m~~~~ ~~B~'~~~~.Y~. ••. ~~.~.~*Y~o.~~. ••. ••• ~.~y•• ¥*~~o.M~~~oy~¥.o.m~. ~~~~.~~~.~.~.~.~~~~~,~.Z*~~ o. .£l!~~.£lm~WYpljJ~.. ' ~Illt~j'l}. .&Zti~n~:~~.fu~. 0. .~Z¥:m16~*~.4~~ZiM.!I1!t{. 0. .~ffZ.~~'¥f¥l''Jr.!$.}~:lf*.W~~. 0. .~4.ti~~. ~-~~ti~~. .ifZ~~if~J1. '.;f.~&f~Y.~~'ij}f¥I. ~~.Mo~ •• ~.~.~.¥~~~~'*~;f~~~¥Y~. *~.'~.~~m~~*~~'W~~.o~YZ~~4D~W ~.fu~T~~*!VIZ.~fr ••~.;f.~rn~-~~ , .¥Hitint• •fui}~ , • o. ¥~~ZtiWa~.~~M~V.=¥¥-~~'~.~~~~ .~.£l*m~.M L~ .i1!}lint.jH~~. o~I3~-~. 1dI*f~¥J~~. ,=iltoif!$ l?iH!i:W~. (:. ~*m!t*f s£~~ '-l~ ~~WYpljJfi1!' tll):~Ef}. ,. Yil. .II~. ~~m~~~~~~~~$~0'*ij~~.~~*¥lti~o-Z .~fi.~.W.;f.~~.'.m~~~$.-*.~ti~ o. ~~J~ti~~~ .:j:M~~U~. .~~.~~~.~~£l!~~.¥I' .;f~. I9myuq::j:~.

(14) •• ~~,.~~ ••~~.E~~ft.~ W~ ••Z•• o.*~.~ ••• Z~.~~§,mm~Att. ~~.E~ft •• k*Z.ao~-~A~~~-~~-~~'~. ~1J!t~:tJ. .+E*~.~ft.U~.~,~~.E~T~~,W.Jt~~~. JlIJ1jjE1jl. TE~o(. )~~, S*-M~h~~~,.~.~.Z~. tfJJd:ll!:.'. ~~ft'~*~.*.~~~~°ft~.*~~~m~~**~m. IIP~~.'. i:k:Z. , l¥.iJt.~f}UfH~5jl*.jJ ~*1t~~ l¥.iJt.~hfllbHVi -sE+_ ' Jt••• RU'1~;jtm;I£1:~fltftZ.s5tZ=+ , l¥.i. .~~.~,m~Mfi •• ~Mm.o(tt=~)~.I£m;~~~ ~ft~*~~.~ T1!jf~~tf•• 'I1fI5l~ , .iliJ:E.M~m;.l*lI. ~Jt!!.it~rf. .~~ft~. .~~ • • •. ~~~~m. .z.,~.~ft~a. 0. ·1'. o. •• EM,~m;.~~*&.Z~,~~.M.R.¥~~ ~m;~.~~~;jt~~~~,m~T~~~\ •••• ~M~. ,~~.~B~.~.~Z.±(~l¥.i~\ft~\~ ••• ), ~ji;~f!*;jt.h~~.¥ W-~~-~~f4~~.~ •••Jt M~ •• ~.~~~*~.~,~~ji; ••• ~~f!~~m.I. 4.~. ~ji;~. • • ' §j1. ~.Jtil5'r!l!l. ~. 0. (;. ~ji;J. ff\~tmJiJ .~1lC~,. 27(SU27) fi!. tt \. j( ffo'J. ~o~ji;.~ftr~~J.#z.,.W.~*~'=~**~T. IR'JrtlHfJ,. s5tZE+,(tt=~)~~ilim~~ji;*~~~,~~ji;.~.. ~.J'Ut~. --~AO~1-t1!~fmhM5'r.~~ft. 5.~m;. 0. ~m;-. [t=:n : Gerald Segal, I.. . ,. I~t I. "Managing New Arms Races in the Asia/Pacific,' The. Washington Quarterly 15 (Summer 1992): 84 85. 0. j:Z~#!'. [t=* : Douglas M.. Johnston, "Anticipating Instability in the Asia-Pacific Region," in ibid., p.136 0. [t=-t : Shambaugh, op. cit., p.103. 0. it=A: Far. at=1L 'Ibic.

(15) {t~~Ifij'M*~t52~~~#t~m. ~lUIHf. 4.1ft ( jt ) f~Jlfji¥J5!1t. ~.At±]t. 1ft~~-ftA= •• Wr.~~. 43. Ji¥J*~ •• ,.7lt.~. ~:re~M. •• ~~~.Z*,~ ~t1t~.mng~. .H~~.1tot£D1f~~:re~~•• m~,lftjt0.W~.II, ~JjU~.~~1H~~f1il:~llfj, l!1~j~~ljtniJ~ .tIt11l~~•• , ~«t£.~MR, •• ~$;~z.mM~.o.$;~i¥J •• ~,~. ~ltJm:lD9.. ~~~.~i¥J~~,~~Imlt2~~~i¥JH~olft~~2~~~. -,. ~~~f. •• ,~~ ••~•• H~i¥J§.o.tlt*, ••~~*.W.~ft 1;l.*5'~lfI , •• ~1jtf IftjtEB~*J~Hj!ffl.A~ft~~ , ~~. .~~ft•• i¥J.*$.z-o~~t£~.MBz~, •• ~$~ ~lftjt•• lftllR*~~o Iftjt~ •• ~, B.n7~~~m,~ft~.·ft~~. r$;i¥JJ(. fF'. .1I.1ft.~II. :fUj , ~2t1tf~ ~ngZW. ~.. at£lft~ U~r!1I. f~). ,. 0. 0. ~tm • • ~1JiUE. 0. )-ftft-.W1f• • • • ~ • •. (. .716~il, ti;i1f50• • 5t. 0. rmlft~BrPJ. •• ~.Ji=+Il!l~.t¥t. f~~lt. 27(SU27)~. ' ~f1B~ft§M***31(MIG31).~.' 1It5¥~AAft. j~.I. it·. ~~:t1!l7. (tt=ft) W1f.M~r!@J~U-ft.liO.f-t ~~H~,illl!1§M••• *,Ift(~).H~i¥J~rPJ,~~$;~. ~.1f~. ~.*~t2.j]~.i¥JI~lt. We," The. j(iii5111ft~~. 0. ". 5.• lIjfj15i¥J~1l ~II. ~~~M~f~lI~o=~*~.,.II~~ftA2. *Z.~·~1jtf~.$$~,l!1m.~~±.~~~EB~1jtfi¥J.. l-Pacific. tt=A : Far Eastern Economic Review, January 7, 1993, p.16 • tt=JL : Ibid., Novewber 26, 1992, p.24. 0.

(16) •• o.~.~*.n.n~~~~ •• ~~ jt.ftB~~.~~~~!JIllf~ , ±~ E'l i't~n::~.~llaw~ •• m~~ ~,~~~~~.~. .. ' .1!f~fb~~ -*"NfJnOO,.~. 0. ~~m~,ffi~~~~~*. •• ~~~~~~,W~~T~~~o. .~~A(l)aJltLm • • alit:H:1fifilJ~JV(;*; (2)$.~tJ~~*~~. , tf:i!i~A.~::(£jt.±t f7gJ&t1Jn::~~H~.~:fiA ; (3) .~~f7g.M•• ~aw •• B.~~~~~'~Km~.~~M jt.~~m.;~4.~•• ~S'.M~, •••• ~$~~ • • ff , ~lt*:I&I!I.f~~lU~~jt\lK". .:fimJV(;~~.Jfi 1J1*~~.0. ~~~*,. l~-r~~ S:l.t~. $jG1tl11 ~ aHtl ~o. 0. ~~k~~m,.~B~-nnO~~~T::(£+~f7g*~m~. fft-nAO~. My::(£~*J&t1J~~.,(~~o)::(£~-m~~T~,K~rt~. *~~~m,~~~~Ar-m~~.~n~o~k~~~.~~. Sfil/r-f , ~.I!I~~~. 0. ~T::(£~~mW~:1f~~7r. , .~::(£Jtu~~. :l&1!I~E'l~m.~~ffi~:~.~~'.~1f*~.~;~*.n v.~~I!I~a.ili~;$~~~.A.~~*;~~~T.~ ~. 0. ::(£JJt E'l ~r ,~~lt*~~~~jfin::~. B 1i:~!JIll~A~1:l. n::~~~~~~~.ili~~~~~~±~o(. '. )~~~~~. *,~~::(£~~~~~~~.:I&m,m.~mM~A~~::(£~~.. 1!I~~~~m~~~.~~~~oW~~~*,~A~!JIlltt~A. ~.=::o. : U.S.Department. of Defense, ('Strategic Framework of U.S. Forces in. Asia," News Release, American Institute in Taiwan, April 19, 1990, p.1o ~:::::-. : James A.Baker, ill, "America in Asia," Foreign Affairs 70 (Winter 1991/92): 1- 18. 0. 1I7X~~:ft~~~. ~A-mtffl~~~'1. .0. 1r1t~*~~1. ~. MM.*.M.~.n,~~ili~~~~!JIll~o~~~~*~~. i '.. .1LO~ft1JJaWI. *:tE,~~~~. *. 0. *::f~~:1& I!I:. JllLnt~(confid ;l'.~t~~tilL~. &,.=::=: *:It.5lf,*1!i! lliam T. T( ming Con InternatiOl.

(17) «~~!I1j:lllnf[:jt5E1I ~i!&#l'~f(iJ. {*~lit m~~ •. ~o. *~~. .'~~~~~,~~AS~~~:W~IIH~~~~~.o~~.. -¥/If,1fW '. JlSJiilO!i. ~II Bj.<Jl!x~m. '. :j~ ..!:tjffilitlJij Pif:tm A lIJir II. ,. §. HtrJtU. 8t.ilE~:j~.JflfJ &~T~~1*~r~fU!, Ll17~~~~~lIa •. rI~~~." ~.~*. :A ; (3) ~1I1!fU~. 45. '. ~ 1I1J3~il Pif$l!1f!; ~ rtf1i1h. , Ll1 ilE i5!!{t1'JI~ -fj rPJ 15C ffl'. .~{t~~~~.~~rtf~~,.~~~~.A~W1f~ft~.. ~". ~'\*B. =.0. offfi. r-.::: IlIfflt ff:£~~JLAOif.ft*Wl~_H1~m~. f~fJlI. t~1** :*:j~5i!. ~*.jJ :T~~. ~.~ :3:t~:W t±~.A.. <'orces in. I. 19, 1990, (Winter. *1iit~3:{t~m. ,. ~J-1L. JLOif.ft~_IIJ~~m,Mffim~~.Pifft.B*~,~3:t.ft~. JI?X~~«iB~:It~*~~{t ~A1tffilJijz~tE. mit. 0. " JIU~5i!!&!l[:ll!-NiBsr:~JffilJijz~.. ff:£Ll1.L~M¥:5t:fJT. '. i!$I!m.!Ni.~. ,. fFA~. 0. .~.*:j~5i!ft~~ftw.,~m~~Tz~~!:ttttt.1J3M. i1i, £It. f3:ttltJf.. \. ff~. ,. ~~.PifWlII ~H1~~~.1J3*~*:j~5i!:lII!II[%3:tM~m. *o*:j~5i!:lII!!l[~illm~.~.~~3:t• • ~~*,.~*~m. ~:tr.mn&(confidence- building measures)iB~. J\!.. ~.M~~!:t.ll:~~±*4t.6}, :\lQ:j~1f~/lf,. it=:- :. *~t5H}m:(£fUlm:ll.1'ItM[1Jiti. \. 0. (tt-. ~Jl.' mtHlf/lf,~. , jf£;fffSM,. 1fi:hlJ*flli1>t~.fi. 0. ,. YtWi. lliam T, Tow, «Northeast Asia and International Secunity: Transfor ming Competition to Collaboration," The Australian Jouranl of International Affairs 46(May 1992): 14 - 18,.

(18) mM~.~.~~Z~.o~*,E.~~*. ••m.*.*~.. £~~~'~m~~~~~m~~~o~~~~~~M~~~~m ~tt~.~,.~~.jt~.E~~~~zm.,@~~. •••m. ' ~~.jt~.Em*%~lI;1Elli~~Z~W ~~,~.~ •• *BE.~~*~e~tt,E.*~*.Z ~~~,~ ••• ~.*tt,.~~~**~@~ •• X.lt~o ~*,~~~ ••• %•• Bmtt,@~~.~.~.~- ••• %.M~~{i1J.~. , ml~tl.:. ~.jt~.E, li1~.~.~. .*••• ~,.~~.m.tI~~~~,@~ ••••_E .*tI~.Zlt&. 0. -11It1~. 0. ~. , ~~~.'I1~~1t. ••~~,m •• ~R.,.-~li1~~~~ •• ~,. li1~*~~.~~nOO~m~o~~E.~*~tI~W~,.@*. ~X.lt~,~~~%.~.~*~.#oE.~B.~B*.~ ~,~~. •• ~ •• ~,M~~~.jt~.E~~ ••~.~~.. ~.~{~~~~II.. -iLimE. 0. ~~,E.~~~~~~.ffi~m~*~~~~o~~~.~ .tt~.k. '::lX*~li1*:. .~~ •. .mf.!J. 0~iI..1U/!£'. .,*~.i5'. DJi,*.'::5G~rl. -iLAE li.o~*111. 0. i&:lfI~,tI~. .1'$!H1L~m .~l'$tEmr. #si1r- B. 0. ~Jlt1~e. *-n::a-1I fHIII.u: +-}]iLa~. .3::!Ii:l\titzlJi1:.

(19)