成年子女照顧者：經驗之初探

全文

(1)42 *ft;t. ~~W$·~~. •• ~M~. ~·M.~m. '11"'". ~ ir..itii; k. "'#:. t" ",;fit 43. California: Wadsworth,inc. Vanneman,R.D. 1980. "U.S. and British Perception of Class," American. ~Jt.-T*I~~~~~: 1~.~Z:{11~*. Journal ofSociology, 85 (4): 769-789.. Weber,Max. 1978. Economy and Society. Berkeley: University of California Press.. "l~. Wong,R. S. 1998. "Multidimensional Influencts of Family Environment in Education: The Case of Socialist Czechoslovakia," Sociology of Education, 71: 1-22.. f~~.t-. Wright, E.O. 1979. Class Structure and Income Determination. New York: Academic Press. Wright, E.O. and L.Perrone. 1977. "Marxist Class Categories and Income Inequality," American Sociological Review, 42: 32-55.. ~.~M~Mi~4.~~~4* •• ~ •• ~ •• ~~.~i • • ~·~ar~ •• ~Lq.~· •• ~.~~~~4i~ •• ~~® *· •• *~~ •• ~.~i.&ff·'A~~~~d •• tL·~4~ .~~~t~·. f*IS~~~4~AB.~·~B.+~~~~4* •• *·. •. ~.~f*t#~~~4~*t#·.~M.~a·i~ •• *~ • Lq4ft~~4-.'A·~IAD~4.~~.ft~Lq·~tA. a· •• ft •• +®ft~64tL·GA"4i~ •• *·t~4ft~ ~M1A·~A~«**~~h4~·. ~~4*.4~~Ai~ •• *~A®·a'A~ •••• *~'~ f •• #·~:.ff.ft~·Lq·.~.~~.·~4~.~Af •• ·~1f.®*~· •• **~&~~~ •• ~.M~'4 •• ~ •• ~~.·41 •• ® ~.·**t~~.·~~.®.·~4.~ .M~Wf.~·4~~t~~.·'A.~~.m~1 •• ~'.M ~.® •• 6'~~'A.~~d.~e.·~~4 •• *.h~*~;. *••. 1~~~ ••••• U'~At~Mt~.a· ~.~L~a**t~~ •• ~.M •• ~·~DM~ ••• *~W 6 •• ~.M •• *·&~*L'M.h.~~.;6A*t ••• ~ • *'.~~~ Lq~~ •• ~ .. •. ••. ••¥:~~4* •• *·.A••. ·~AB.. ·~.~~~ffl~W#k.~~#~~.~~~~M: r~.~*.~~R :!lit I (1+fHIt$" ~ N~(, RQ-24 IL-H-004-007-SSS). •• ~•• a~.

(2) Asr.:r*!!!\.*:t.!~:t:..-WJ#. 44 .~-M\. Adult Children Caregivers: The Exploration of Their Experiences. IIIIIIP"". ~ iL.i!t~(; .:k.~;f±t-~:fIi. 45. ±';ru -=a A[]~.m~:{3{tl¥Jm~rf. ' :{3AI¥J~MWRmtfffl*{ilH!J~g~r.1~ ~"f~ 1ifFJi:t~tB*~:rr~.Ii~®~Al:l¥Jm:~tt ( , 1999; ;ff\:f01it 1993 ; i!iJjYJJ~ , , ¥I3~lsU=t 1995) :&IEP::§IH9'i{E:R~?~ IEP:: ~.Ii~ n!1'r1¥Jfil (8WlW 1999) t)J~:iITpgi6/:$~A#f\l£~ftt~tB~)\ +1i1f:~ , 1i~tJl:~$;E!1j*+f:!fl.1:nsZ~A1'r 9 2 TtL, JJtf.11£J~.t~M.mHit~2:i 10.27% ' :m{.1:(£-JiJ9:*~:ttCi 89.73% ' 77.21%Z'tittm~A ' :(£ *EI3%:A~.Ii (pgi6/:$ , 1996) :(£%:~~.licp , lfc!~I¥JWR.Ii:tt~~ft!i7?~ 1it;k:l¥JttWU ' J1t:(£CP)7)~~ ~ffjjtJfqj~ 64.3%1¥J~~~A:WT:tz:lP.lf.1ttWtl ( pgi6/:15B ' 1997) 'JtCPfu1'rfEl~l¥JttWtl:ll!::EI3T~:tz:t!re::t~~.lil¥Jjfff: , T' :tz:::t~~.Ii:ttJi:J[;ft!i7~:PBJHt ' -w:~z.1'rj]I¥J~J~ tJI!I)7}*1t~ttf ' fu~z.~ifl¥Jl!!:t!'l McGrew ( 1998) qi!!!; 1982 1f:~~~m ~~~1f:~~t~tB:tz:51::t~~.Ii:tt{t!i7m1'r~.Ii:tt1¥J 29% ; Harris ( 1998) i:!2r::tf'ElIUf 1¥J~1f:cpm tB51Tft!i 9::: fj~~ A::t~ ~.Ii~I¥J¥J 1O-12%1¥JAI!!: ' ft!i *~~.Ii~¥J 52%I¥JAI!!: EI3~:{3AA[]I¥J:ttt1J[) , %:~A[]I!!:3Z.fElf:tI¥J~ :Y ' ~PItJ~~~.liI¥JT:tz:I!!:~jt' , ffjjffi±frtlElIJ:ttt1Jo ' 9!~5t,~l!$~mm/f {±:(£1P.I1ISI~m i:!2 ~51T~.li1¥J ttWU:ttt1Jo EI3 J1tPI 5!~1f: T :tz::(£~.li9:::fj~~ 0. I. Mei-O Hsieh. I. I. Abstract. 0. 0. 0. The purpose of this study is to explore the subjective explanation of adult children's caregiving experiences. In-depth interviews were employed with 12 adult children actively involved as primary caregivers in caring for a parent with disability. The content analysis revealed four common themes that emerged from narratives-- gender and birth order, affective feelings, transition of career, and competence and resources. The subjective explanations of their decision in caregiving were consistent with former theories except the factor of enjoying peace of mind. This study also explored the social support of adult children caregivers. Although adult children caregivers received help from informal and formal assistance, they were patch-liked, trivial, and not systematic. Caregiving impacts were identified as negative and positive. In addition, adult children used emotional-focused and problem -focus coping strategies to cope their burdens. Detailed processes were identified. They were more dynamic and informational. Although several meaningful findings were recognized, some limitations were also identified. Practice implication and future research orientation were discussed.. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. f$*1tl:~.li9:::g~I¥J~AffitJ:tz:tl:~.:ttJlS~ (Stone, Cafferata, & Sangl,. ME:5'l"')3 , 1991 ; fi~ml$ , 1993) '*¥J:(£ 70%-80% }tCP1;(ttlfc!~:W:tz:513Z.ft!i7*~1!!: Bft,lalli=+1f:* ' :tz:'t~~W~lIJm~ ::f1T:ttt~ , ft,ffjj~fr1:(£t9ff~.lil¥Jjfffl:M*7rot:P (Scharlach, Lowe, & Schneider, 1991) , IP.I~ , :!I3'tii:!2Jt!g*Jt!gfj~mJmf$*1t'tigUfil~D~6ffjj t!re~. 1987;. ~!im~' i!iJjSf£ '. interviews. 0. 0. .*~9:::fm~AI¥JI 1"1" ' 1iff~9!t~tBft!!1Mll!imi:!2~~ilfj~j]1¥J15tA (Kaye &. Applegate, Key Words: adult children, caregiving, elder care, impact, coping, in-depth. 0. 1f:X:£3:l:Mz/f~ft,~rgl¥Jo. 1990). 0. T:tz:~.Ii:ttll!im1'r E! cl¥JI{'P. :ftt9mfBi~-gm~~~o=E3J.lml¥J.mj] (Loomis &. 1¥J~j]. , ~.li9:::tf~:{3Al¥Jt!f,Ij3Z.:ll!::1'r§~1m1¥J. ' 1'r E! Booth, 1995). 0. ' pJTtJ1t T:tz:1'rE! c. 'Uft,~.Ii:(£~"f~~~:ll!::~PJ. .~I¥J'ffi:ll!::~T~:tz:51m~~fr~g~reWRti.ff~~~~~l¥Jo. ~OfriJl¥J;[J'f:!fl.~~~:ll!::J~t~R~~T. '. fr.T/:tz:t!re~.liX:£3:l¥Jjfff ? ~.liTI. ~Jf1tt9ff~.liI{'PI¥Jjjj{!ZSI ' 3Z.~O{iiJlli~ ? :ll!::.ff ? :ll!::~m ? :ll!::~~~ ? 3.i ~~ }tft!!M~1¥J jjj{!ZSI ? i&!~~iF T ~:tz:~.Ii:tt1¥J liffJi: ~1i5I:;fr~.Ii~~1¥J tt. ~:&WiUl!l¥Jt!f,Ij tt~:P~~Jt::tDI¥JW{t.li*~~:W~)i: , *1iffJi:~~IlfM~ 0.

(3) 46. •. Ji\.1f- -1-* !!i\~ ~ : :!'!'.J!lZlJ] ~. ;it! ~1A. w' ~lm~%A. 1fT 'P.:1:E~.Ef:::ijE~A!¥J*~,~ , ~3U~~:tJI!¥Jlli~ *tiff~!¥J§!¥J:f:! : 0. 17M~1fTf;(1:E~D~§E~1f:)t£3:!¥'¥!¥JI1'F:lJl§. '. ~mi:!1f1~Wllf~~. 0. 0. J&:1f~TWf;(~1:Em~~.T1'F~'~~1:Em~~§~~:f:!~.?. ~o. Horowitz. 0. -t\ '. ADL !¥J~D~1W¥u@lAA,!i}!¥J~.. 0. 47. 1:£jfj~cp~WH~,~!¥J' Tf;(1:E~~~Tf'F!¥,¥it$~!¥J~ll)£!3Bgt~1:EiiE$~~. IiIf'F. 2.M~~~*~.~~~~··ff!¥J~.&~ti~~.!¥J~.M 3.•M~D1lf!¥J%If!I§I1{;f,Wii1±~5Z:~ 4.•lM'ti3IJ1:EM~~,~W*~1:.!¥J~~•. miL.if,t;i; *- "~1.1t"~. (1985) ntH 32. ::g~Tj!1=ri?rlU.lIDJ~~f~~T~jlt!~f~f1$. (. =FA hands-on) $1~!¥Jt6b~ , fE!.~~TWf;(~-fl '1lfl5}!~7~f~M4o/JJ::.~ 111ijfJ:.!¥J5Z:fif*ft;,tt:)t£3:m §3:9} , ~Ttt1:£;,tt~cfllM~¥UTJ~,tt~'ll1ijf'fi!¥J5Z: ~ , i:!1r!:l't::lm ' 'i' ~T~W~~~ , ~~~i:!11lfl5W11:£5§it6b~ Stoller ( 1990) PJ.bt Dwyer *0 Coward (1990) !¥Jtiff~r=;t~tfj , tt~f;(~* ' ~Ttt~~m. 0. 0. 0. :9:~~jt. ~f~~tE!¥JTf'F ,~jlmf;fl;f9aT=rti%~If'F!¥Jt6b~ -:lJltJWl~~~AJ&:1f 0. _,.~~,*~.~~~.~~&~.L~~~$. Tf;(~~1lf~tH~!¥JtiffJi:i:!1tllitfjf;(~m1:Jt~~!¥J-@JAA,!i}~~, ~Tm1:Jt~. ' 5tillltlibWJ fE!.~flQll'~i:!11¥;t6bWJfJ5i~llm~f;('fi!¥JT1'F ' tzo~~%~ , llf44o/J~ I 1'F (Delgado, & Tennstedt, 1997) Chang *0 White-Mean ( 1991 ) ~M4o/J. 1:E~M~D~~!¥Jlli~~'ti~~DW-~R~tt!¥J.~~~~:f:!M~ 7:t ~@lm!7:t1:E%If!~D1lfcptt~mft %1f!~D~t~-·@l~~1m! 0. 0. ,. 0. 0. l1ffJ'C~*~§uiI!l;i'i::f~. 0. tllitfj~.!¥JIf'FJJi§ (tasks) 1:E'fi5iU~1:.JE:W1:f:!M~. %1f!~jUgW~~%~J&:~ml±nEliH1~81=.m (normal everyday life) pJT. ~!¥J. ~*!¥Jt6b~ , %~P"J!¥J~AfI~t6b~ , ~1¥;~1:E~A:f:!~i!~f.t!¥J'~t'£~ (pg , f91Jtzo : 1§I1fr'j~ , 1i*!¥J~'Eni~~ , 1jI8~~fj£ , ImJmnm~.lXfj£~i:it~ (Walker, Pratt, & Eddy, 1995) o:fi&!' ~DW-~~;g~!¥JM~ (aid) Mz:f :@~ m!7:t ' 1&1lffJ5i~~~%1f!1§I1{;f,1I!¥J-tllE1¥;5<:~ (normal exchange). N11t~1t ' ~~.~~T1'FP"Jlilli!¥JIt~~JJi ~ll'~mtfj£3:mEE~~'t:trzg* illl1¥;:f~~m~Tm~~~~Ii1lf (Lee, Dwyer, & Coward, 1993). 0. :f~. , i:!1:f:!~1lfi!jtJm'ti5iUl¥J~.ffij~ll~~,~~1lfW'¥t~.~!¥JIi:i}fiJjUW ' 0. ;'.~~*~.~. ~~!¥Jmft~1:E~~D1lfW~~D1lf~~I§I1{;f,!¥JI!l~W'fi~ (Walker, Pratt, & Eddy,. 1995). 0. ~i§z ' --.!¥J~DI{'F~~3W~D1lfW~~Ii1lfi&!:t~. ... ~~.~M_. n~~-®tiff~~m1¥;~!¥JM~J&:1fTf;(~.~~1f:)t£3:!¥J~~:f:!~. :R~tJ.*t6b~!¥Jtt~WGl§I1f;f,pJT~.ffij:f:!:fIQJ!¥J~$ , ;,ttcp , tt3U;fD'tlttt~ @l1i~!¥J~. (Dwyer & Seccombe, 1991) • tJ.%If!P"Jf;(tt~.1lf§ , EE~. PJ&5<:~~WGR~fi~R~fi. ~1M-W:t!f;fl;%A1=.m1:.!¥J~D ,f9utzot5t:tR '~fri$~m~~I1'F ~®~. aid). 0. 1¥;fJ5ifft5t~.m~'fi81¥;1=.mJfJ~E!¥J~D (IADL) lEffW%~I1'F-~ (Sankar,. 1993) ,tHf;('fiffij~' ~~®~'ll1Mz:f~~DI1'F ill~!f.3ttffij~ , ~~* t~r5f7HiI~*tt~i&!~®%~If'F' ~~tt~:@~~)£!3 3~1:E1:£$~DIf'F i:!1~~tzo~ , Dwyer ~ Seccombe ( 1991 ) f>Rffl 19821f~fll¥J:RM~~1JIIjj1tt~ 1&.!¥J~plE:rt~D1lf~1tt ' ~*~ij[ : tt~***~}t , 7t1=.:f:!Jl!r%'l1!¥Jttf9U~ll ~!3B~1:E1:£~%If!~DI1'Fo~.!¥J~~,~f;(~ffij~'1:E!3%cp~~m T:f~~DIf'F'1:E:)t£3:%~~®~11tgt~~DIf'Fo~T'-:1JiID~!f.3tt ' §3-:1JiID~r-tt ' ~1i~.r ' Jl!~re.m~tE81¥;1=.mJJJ~E (IADL) !¥J. 0. 1It:t~~j\ij. ( attachment theory). (:l:Jt');ffi~,. & Shelley,. '~ill.f:fWG~~fi. (filial responsibility or duty ). (social exchange theory, reciprocity, mutual 1996 ; Call & Finch, 1999 ; Lee, Parish, & Willis, 1994 ; Mercier. 1997). 0. 0. 0. t6b~ff~m~D 81¥;1=.mJ}]~E (ADL) !¥Jt6b~gttt~jl~J&:~jl' 0. 1f*f~~ii1±~ft~D!¥J!II~r' Wf~~*1:EUIi1li~!¥J~IiI1'F1lfl5qf$¥Uii1±~. (-){t(Ilf;f~~j\ij. ~m~~illl1¥;m*M~~If!P"JWf~81¥;ii1±~1=.m!¥JiID~':f:!~~~$% ~WIIJ~tt!¥JRIIJ (Ainsworth,. 1989 ; Cicirelli, 1993). 0. !f.MIt~~~f&1:E¥. §G~~~~m~~!¥JNurtJ.~1~~:3::~f*~ (Ainsworth,. 1989) ,1!t*i:!1fJ5i m¥uJ&:1fTf;(W;,tt~1f:)t£3:~f*6b~!¥J:5t;fFf (CicireHi, 1983, 1993, 1995) ~M~~t~1:E¥~~M ' ¥5lW~Ilf;f~~Mii:1=.!¥J~Ilf;fji~ , ~~.¥U1&* 0. . A~~JNI!i¥!,t!¥J~tI~f;f,. 0. IJ:U~ , A1=.~JNI!i¥!,t!¥J~~1§I11;f,i:!1~~.¥tli&!:t.

(4) 48. A. itt-l-il\. -+ .:r *" !!Ufbi- : $!.f.~ :tAn ;jf.. IIIIIJr. ffi~~~*m~Mo@Rm.~@~~,~~xm~T~~~~ft~~L~ ~~~W~~~,~~~.~~,~.~~~&~~~~~~~~~·~* ~~~ (Mercier & Shelley, 1997) J!ffil..~1lJt ' INf~~Xm~.T~ , fY! T~~7*lIft~M ' ¥a7T~~*fiXAf& ' XmiID~:1N:~~~fJglf,f , ~~X m~ lSii@**IIfHtT~ Allen W Walker ( 1992) 1iJf3i:cp ij Im Ruddick ( 1989) ~.~timfJtl:B~EI~H~)~mt$j;)J,n~~5t.~.~ngm~~jh~' 'fil}~m~'lt!~ ~ (attentive love) Ruddick fJtl:B£J~M!i~T~~*lIft ' ~~ftf1T~{I"* 0. 0. 0. W~~~.~' j;J1!:IJ!~Ht~5t.M!i~£Ji!~<tRllft, mfY!~~jh~:t;rjl(g'@£J:m~ ~* Allen W Walker ( 1992) m~Iii.~ftl~f~)~ib~ Bowlby (1982) fIflI:BT~lSi~*~1Iix:mm~~B~!t*lIft~M~5mJJt~IE~§~ Jlt~~R1i UJ j;JM~Ef!~wx:m~1lii!~~T~ , ~jj{~ftx:m~fjglf,f:a~~.X:£JI f'l= ~~~o~~m~.~~~cp, r~5t.J~.tt• •~*m.~:t;.~. 0. 0. 0. (Ruddick, 1989). !fJ iUHs .k '" *1. -it "':W!. 49. %~fiXjlf1~A~tbbWJ ']J£~ftl1.fr.lti%~t'fJJfff~. (Hamon, 1992). ~. 0. ®1iJf3i:4lf~m~mJi~mfa~rrm ' M?~Fff!~*§ f;f~~x:mt'fJi!~~~~'fi1f ( Finley, Roberts, & Banahan, 1988) 1iJf3i:~;m~~ffftt'fJ-Rrl3~iIi?)g , "tlDfBt 0. m@~if!rtM. ' Wf7JJi:9i'T~MWJx:at'fJ:g)jj (Cicirelli, 1983). Hamon (1992). 0. ..~ Bengston( 1973 )t'fJ1iJf3i:f~tB' ;g:T~J:f~~rl3~~f*d~:0ZfSt'fJ, ~Mt'fJ ' ffi"fft'fJ ' #~t'fJW~m~t'fJ ' :~:!U~mJfff.~rr~ Cicirelli (1983) ~;m 0. ~T~tiX£J~*lIftm~lF-J tt.~t5t:AfJt~MWJ. 0. El3JltUJ ~~mJffft'fJfJ. fY! ' .~LfDT~~x:at'fJ~1li~~ , mg;e~iWillbt'fJ*ll(fJ:!l!.~. 0. T~~x:m. ~~m.ff,i;t~ft.ffL~~lSi.~:t;fJt~~1Iio@~~A1lJtftl1.fr.l~.. IJij: , m~fBz~Jj~ m.~ , ~T~WX:£Jt'fJ~;lli~it1"UJMt'fJMftlF-J ' ~~ • . m:tJfiiJ!t* ? 1"1liBtiPx1"~1":t;ftt(lF-J ' .~t'fJMiID~.f:f:W~ni 0. 0. Hamon( 1992 )@J,ljltF~x~ . f!tB~jf[.fft'fJrrfY!~T~~~fl91~HI;R:~ ,. 0. If'F!I:k~ ''@f±jj~, %cp~i§{7.j~*~ADft ,j;J&~x:mt'fJ~'I1l*lIft~ ~~~~ fui;t~1lJt, ~pfY!~~~~nlJix:mm, fJ;l. .mf~msit-"T~af~ftt. (=)~}]j:Jlfff~~nifi. 0. ~mJff::Et'fJ~;mfttt53aLm~~~. ~~CL.. '. , @~Jii±.ftM~~mlF-J (filial peity) 1Iffi1"~. 0. .~. ~AJtf~'8*~IUm~1"~~~;m~H. ' fElftCP[ilA~;fr±~CP , T~&::'~ *_!tX:£Ji!,-~~~~~~M~oH.m~m*~~%~~~~.~A ~Jfff ' j;J~~il&Jff~m:tJ ' iT:lJOJtt:J!ftt(7$:WL~mfa (Chow, 1996) ~1f.( 1992 )flfll:B~m~-fi1fpj~~~ft~H ,;1t:L}]fjg~1JE~%~t'fJW~ , [IIM~~. ' T~gfJl&,ljx:m~Jfff ' ]J~ftlitfi1%~~~ftmfa~~ ~mt'fJ~5m~ , fY!tl.8"f~mAT~'1~Ul!~ifct~ft ' ~m~Jfff:t;n~~ ~tlt'fJflJftl1.±'~ , 41i53Ij~f1ftl1.fr.l~x:mi! ~~1IFffjilSi ' i;t.1tf~1l1!i: 0. ., 0. 0. 0. 0. El L:t;Wi~ (Horrowitz, 1985 ; Stoller, 1990) ~5t.~f!~.~1li~t'fJtbbWJW B m- ~~ t'fJ~,Ij: 5t.TJfljfJt~.~t'fJ9!ji't1:g~W~FfJUfJ1i~tbbWJ '.9i'tf:${.fMtL .nt~;Iit'fJ%niIf'F ft~ti%~ti~Al&.t'fJJfff~iID ' Piercy (1998) 0. ~@1iJf3i:{7.j~~,ljJ~. 0. 0. ~fi1i1iJf3i:~~=~%~~jlti~A~,ljt'fJJfff'M~I:B=fi1Jfff:fJt~1I. dbfit'fJJ.ifl (environmental quality). 'flflt'fJ;fj!fJtfW~~~~t'fJJ.ifl; ti~A. 1I*~~~lSiJl; (sensitivity) , flflt'fJ~f*iiXmt'fJ§±'1i' ~&::'~lF-J~~X:. et'fJ1f3iS'.~x:mt'fJm~.*~&.~x:at'fJ:gm;~~A~~~jh. ( inclusion) ,mt'fJ;fj!1"~x:a!}.:L}]fjg, ~X:£Jng-m~W~jh. 0. 1iJf3i:4lf. ittl~flJ;\' XfBt'fil}m~fljftl1.±,~/~.J;\[II.flJ;\ (altruism/corporate group. tlftlt'fJJfffl;gm1"3I:~X:£Jt'fJ:ll!~' 1"~~x:m1"~.t'fJ~~ B~ml;g~. W Willis ~m~@~~f~ :j;tm:ngM~tl.T~f1;1tX£J~3ifif ' mWJ~~,Ij ~llt ' *~;fr±rt~~ 1Il*.~m ' 3'I:tJ*_x:m ' 1Il~x:mt'fJ{J'i: ' fY!X£J~~L~~~ttt'fJrr. .~~fi$. model) (Lee, Parish, & Willis, 1994). 0. Lee, Parish. 0. 0. 0. Sheehan & Donorfio ( 1999) t'fJ1iJf3i: • ~JJt~~+-ti~. .~ng£Ji!~~5t.&;1tmi!· @~~l:Bti~mJffft'fJ1i@~JI):'I$:. 1L.'~1i~' ~iTW-)Em~~f~' l!~ftl~~, ~f*t'fJ~*?X'¥'.tt. 0. jtl:IJojlij ttz '. ~~;il!Jffft'fJ~,ljfi~r' T~. 1r)jjl!J 3'I§Bt'fJ Irfjg:tJJ f!~X£J~~:Qlt iJt ' .~~nlJi~;1ti:B ' ]!!~jIij{J'~ti~ , ttfffiDi:.tt ~@ Versetin (1995) (ij I §~mJtJ!? ' 1996) WfJtl:B5m*t'fJJfff~.itl:IJI]Iffil.1it'fJ3ifif ' m.~Fm~1it'fJ3i~ El3Ilt~frlJ!ffimmft~@~~"~Jffflf,f.~~,ljJfl El 0. @~/il±~tt.~~JfffW~ni*.~m (Piercy & Blieszner, 1999 ;. Piercy, 1998; Sheehan & Donorfio, 1999) 'R~m~m~rrfY!~T~t'fJi: )jj~fJg:tJ~~ (Brubaker, 1990) ft@~;fr±. ' ~1Il1f3iSt'fJrr~m~~8"f 0. ~~fRi ~4lfml:B%~fiXjlf1.fft'fJ±..~Jt 'UJngUJj;JmOOlms-~%~~ O}j~-@~jl.f1~ng~AfJtf~~,Ij (Brubaker & Brubaker, 1989) ~At'fJ 0. 0. 0. ~~'@~T~JffflJij:m~~,ljJflEl~I:t;.7ottfffi§~,*~tt~~~ m~ , ~~JI~~X:£Jt'fJ{J'i: ; g§~jfct~~fjmjfrJiJfffW~ni. tJetljj>, m.{7.jUJfi~ftl-®1"~. 0. 0. ;1i53ULt'fJ~~tt. ~5C.~~fl~:t;.~.IJij:, ~lJij:m~~*m.

(5) 50. A~T*!ll\~=t-. ~ ki>l\. llI!~jflr:tM" '. f9!Jtm :. ElYJJ~)(-m:~'/'R~flf ' El?&tf4JI~)(-m:. 0. :. $.tM;:ziJ]~. jG-rtt~tft£. IIIIJI"'"". ~iLA)t;;k~~J:.1t":fIi. ~.)(-m:m~~A~:t~~ T )(-m:~~1I~WJ. 51. Ii' lIlHt~RWJJjj(WU .!l. 0. .tt~~~:tM~~~,~~)(-m:~.tt~~~~'~~tf~~IL~~*. 1!t:f!fif-~~~~rf'J' , ?&fffil'll6li~ra'~~ , 3(~l1Ilf*1lfl5j;),tJ~*it:f!fzP:1tr~£~. Wz¥:~ ,i:t?~~~5(H*~.f:I:~tf!j1JI1I~tt~~f.¥ '1E!~I1*jG-r~)(-m:~. (Call & Finch, 1999) ·liff~t~teli~Jjj(¥Irj1!tfSilf.!£3z.:5G~~~~jitfiijW~JJ. '/'R1'Z¥: ' mUi:t?tfjj1J111'lf~~~:f!fW8m~m~W.Uj. (Dwyer, Lee, & Jankowski, 1994) • fffi 11 ~1t~.~1!t@]¥i~.~~Hte. 0. ~ (~)ifr±tfx~~. , lD!a~liWJ. , ~.~1!tJ1!mlErnf~a~ti:t~~.l1Ilf* (Walker & Pratt, 1992) ,It:t .~~~mJJili1!tJ1!@~Jf!;:( Starrels & Ingersoll-Dayton, 1997) ~fffi§z '. 0. jji±tf3(~~li~~ff-~~~~~~~~~'m~T~~~~'~~~~D. ,. at~Wf~re~A~~iiIflA¥1frtlJ~ , ~t~~~D~¥1flID~~~~D i:t?~~~~~3'iifZ~~~j;).jitlID~:t (Harris, 1998). 0. o?&fffi Call fa Finch. ( 1999) apg£~~DJl!~t:£li}l~jJ.mf*~ , ~~D~fID(u1 CPf.¥~~x~l1Ilf* 0. ~tf*1&¥tlmJJfallI!tE~:J:;R:t'-. '. 0. 0. ..::.. '. P\1f--f*J!!Ui~~a9 .t#~~. 0. fffijJi±1!t x~llI!llilEflfm:#!; I ilH:~~1116li!#i!. ~f:~!#i!.W~if--r3z.:~Dlt ~tJ~)(-m: ' te~li~ (reciprocal) ~itJ~, ~~~:tPfT~~~WJ~@].Z~ $.~fEl~~!ilID (Dwyer, Lee, & Jankowski, 1994). ~¥i1IttJtlH~WW~:tmWJ~@]ml '~x~MH*Jtf1JI1TR~tE . fffi?~9t'TJ}]. fUtt. ,. ltrf'J'~z¥:~~rm~tt. 1&~mrj£~liWJ~@].~itJ~. 0. ;. ~.~~~:f!f*~)1Hm~~ 1ffID (Suitor & Pillemer, 1993) ,:t~~~G ~. , 5LtM$~ , M8:: '. 9i-1£jji±1!tJt~. 0. Horowitz ( 1985) ~W 32. ;:g jG-rj!. f!±tfx~llI!ll6li~[9@]f$<I(>~®g~: Al1'1!tlZ9Aftl!l1,pfTll£A~fJUWi~.fffi. fi.~~.'H~jG-r.t:£lt~~m~I~ttfOM.tt~~:f!f·.~~ (1988) Wt:r.m3z.:~Wf~i:t?t~te ,~~~mmHi!#1;~WJ~A ~9I-' i:t?~. lifEl~~jj' Al1'1!tAftl!11'pfT~¥tl~1IfWi~*:tJj1Jl1fiAfffi~1'~1IfWi~*1~ Yfi~ , A l1'~m1!t:f!f~~fa;itt-flLfjcf~:f!fifliAx~ , PfT~~*1lfl5~n~t:£. .Ii~I f'F (Coward & Dwyer, 1991; Dwyer et aI., 1992; Matthews & Rosner,. ~JE~JJjUlU (If£¥U~~%l:m?~9t'~~~~*jtf1Jl1). 1988; Miller & McFall, 1991) • ;fi~I~!I'i~:f!f (8m~mJ}]tJ~~~.). El Molm & Cook, 1995). 0. (Call & Finch, 1999 51. tlJJfO~*il~~±1!tx~llI!lli~~>L'. 1f1!tWl~t:£X~I1Il1*CPfj1,ft~*~*fj~. , ~tlJJ~. fffi l11!tIU!:Jtf1Jl1jf~%l:mfDi~9t'~ ~~* ~mJJ~-1f~m~tt~~~Jt1JM:t1J&5 ' f13.~~~*ilil:~ ~ , E!n~~mJJ~-1f ' i:t?1!t~~~fffifrp*ilftl!1f ~~1£3(~l1Ilf*cp , I1Ilf* fOfElli ~*il~~lifEl~fUfa*it:f!fZP:ltrfffiID fiX ( Call & Finch, 1999 51 El Molm & Cook, 1995 ; tMm~ ,1996) j;).jji±1!tx~llI!lli*~ , ~D~ZPfTj;).m:#1; ~D7JWl~t:£~DI1Il1*CP1~¥U¥ifl ' ~[J5fH!@]Wl1~*1i¥iJE ' mrj~.~1!t~:\t ~~~~JJ fffi~~.~*~ l1¥IMI*1i¥iJE ' mrj~.~1!t:\t1~1'ZP:~ , 1'0 (Call & Finch, 1999) 1'0ZP:~~~1!t~~~.~m:#!;X~ . ~[J : M4'P.J ~~:f!f ' taWJ~~ , ~WJ~.m-r3z.:~fffiffM (Dwyer, Lee, & Jankowski, 1994 ; 51 El Dwyer, & Miller, 1990) 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. ff~liffJi:J.-j,~w.t.~m*~~:f!f*~~lt5Lffi9$~ ·lZ9~5Lffi.«$~.~~~w.t. . :fJE1£~.~fnWlut."i'iJJ.-j,~¥tli!Jf!;:J}]tJ~ ?&fffi;fi~iL'llI!~:f!ffffi§ , M8::~p~m*~~:f!f*1JM ':f JE&fffi~~.Ii~Hi!t~w.t.liIf'Fi&*~A~~JJ ~ (Suitor & Pillemer, 1993) .~M8::~:f!f~~f!{~~Jji~ttJ( , ~mJJ 0. 0. :t:*~M8::"i'iJj;)'IiJ~lfI:t· f13.~:fJ:Ez~,aP~11Il1*~'I1.J( ,;j~m*it:f!fr:t1'. "i'iJ • ilSI~tt~1!tit~OO~ liff~i:t?t~te ; ~)(ffl:~~w.t.~ . -r3z.:1!til:~OO ~~1JHJm~. ' i!@]OO~m.fBi!f!M*M1::R:~OO~pfT~1t (Brody et aI., 0. 1989). 0. Suitor fD Pillemer ( 1996) ~~~/I1.j{'I1.WfJi:~jll'rsJ~~~:f!fi¥J. ~1t, H~E!n~?trml1llf*~flf~~OO~~:fJE 'i:t?.ilSIA~.If'Ffffiil:~OO ~o. ~ffjj S. , -ry:~fjJi~tt~1!t:t~M8::H~ , tt~ 1'.~:fJE:ttfg@ . j;)'~~fI:f JE11Il1* fffi'tiJJU1£M8::~~:f!f Li:t?a~¥U Jf!;:z¥:~ • tttejG-r ' Y:jGtt~1!t~M8::• • ' jG-r~ljimmE8~'I1.JJUffi±tf1t~ Mf-\fl'~ , ~Z~. (nurturing) ~*~~ ,~trlJEli3~'/'R.j;).&~z~~M 8::~ • • '~jG-r~*-@]A~~'~&WM8::~~~ • • ~(Harr~ 1998) Delgado fO Tennstedt, ( 1997) J! H~jG-rut.~9t'Hi!¥U~ A "i'iJj;).m: Z '. 1£H~~fjJi~JJ~. 0. 1£~.IlICP~x~tfj;).. Ii' lIlf1t~li~Jjj(mfj.!l (generalized reciprocity) *tt f'F ' ~.IlI~~.w~:f!f~m1'1!tWl~1~¥UJLE!ntE~.4'P.J~3(~ , fEl&~ . *~ m~~~:ttaWJ~@].~~W**taWJ~~~'PfT~~l'~1£Ii';ittk~~~ *it:f!fZP:~~X~.!l ( Starrels & Ingersoll-Dayton, 1997) ~ S Z ' -r3z.:~1£ 0. 0.

(6) 52 ~~-ij\. .Ii~Jf-. .:r* !!!C$l:t : !£Mt Z:fJJ ~. l·. /. ~ Jt it}id:. ,,~:±. i'"":fa.. 53. i. ),\. 1:ttm!!tJWG'L\~5[=M: ' ~O*5t.+~±J!fW{1Ii~f'fJ~ , ftl!.1MttttfuJi!:IlfE-f'fJ~1Ii. ~A¥tlp:jijA. ; ~rm~f'fJI{'F1JOO . §WIMI1'Fl¥Jlf==1ll. ' lfI1'Fl¥JnUL~ t lf11.1ftI¥JI{'Fms::f:ftfl5t ; lIij1li:%ff'fJ~JE.Atit:E=A¥tlnA~lf . ~~t)JiIY lli.ff.&~~+tz:;~~~rm1f.ti~~rm:%f*Jit±Ill~5t~A~J!~~lIijrmOO. ifrs t¥tlm:t£#:lf~1f.' t:E-1f.¥U+n1f.~lf; *$?t~rm+tz:~W~Afi'Il11: '. ~ .. hJf 11:: 7J it. Rlf -{ll.~A11:1£~g~fM~.*El'~tb1!+tz:11:. arfj~*lJf~if!i~~rm~*Jit±1ll~~~f'fJ[i~ , 71:!i~*f'fJ@3U1tW § ~[i~f'fJ*a* ;ffl~?fHI~f'fJii~~~~JJJfY1 ' ffl~±*Jitf'fJ~a*~f'fJ ( in 0. vivo) 'iQ;ffl~J{)(1~~tf1l:lf'fJ ( holistic) '~~!lf'fJ~±*~~( Padgett,. ittitffl~!l~~i! ' t)JI~~~!lW@3tl1tf'fJii~ -~. ~. 1998). 0. ~-.. Ii 1i3U fJlJE A. 0. ~5t@~f'fJ1J:A ' 1*,tJ~A~7\+11.~t)1:. ' iffl.¥1Jlf-JJi ADL IADL J;bf!~~J!m!!tJ IDJ~Z+tz:&:\~~-=+~t)1:. ' :Mz§~±Ill~£5t~. ~~W~AlIijrmf'fJI1'F ~51-~J{)(@~f'fJJJjU~Jj~1LIifJ{)(fi ' ~~~~m#l;*lJf 0. B. 1f.~ ~~~. tz:. 39. ~. 65. c tz:. 8~~. +tz: I5t 1. 1m '. E. •••Z@~ii~4. 1ll. ' fi~El'~tf/1~Agli~~JL\*~~~1IigfU~l¥PfJ5Z~A 2lli. ' El'~tf/1~H!,* $:JtIlI 1ll. ' R:t§j@~1M~51-l¥Jr=~~~~ , :Mz*~DXi1mIDJf'fJfi* 11ll. ' t) R:~51-lJf~:%ffAA~~r-tt'l~14z~* 4ill. :t£~YJRj{~fW{1Ii~f'fJfi'IlXif~H!. tz:. 45. ~. 35 8W!. (IDJ r='~ :;;t. 8~. ~1ll.fW{1Ii~zrE1MiQlf~WIDJ~. ..::. .. JHUl{. *.I.*-. 0. 5. fi'Il11:. 1&/\*_ 9c~~*.~. -jlii. ~1*~. l:;;t:;;t ff.&~_ ~~~~~F.l :f5.Ml11.'f-ft~ ~,Iji.ffl. X:~1n~Jit.. 1'1: f§ rnJ 1:. I:t: 11. ' f2B 2 9c~§i3fM!10 !:~ 151-t!* ill 11: PJ 2 007.l<'l:h 111+ 12 lEltt 9c:1: {tluJ< 'I: ' 2. :;;t:;;t~~. if~I1'F ~-=,gg ~~. 1:~~lf1t~ 5 fi'Il11: 1&/\ fJ:J :sp.~fI JE' t)if~I. 40 8W!. 1. G. ~. 51. 8~. 2. 0~Ajlii. H. ~. 50. e~. I. tz:. 50. 8~. 0. !~:. J. ~. 60. .~. K. ~. 50. 8~. 2 OO/j\Mtf I~-·· 5l "5l3 iXra 1 fil&7.l<_ ~f2B'7\ 2 lEl11: i&:Zr5tfil&T ' lfm+f.El.Ml3tl 5l5l3=~. =lr. 11im±. ~:'7\ 1 fi'Ilf1: :;;t:;;ttf:!.:t£I1'1" 2 :;k;jl~~ ~-'f2B 1 lElf1: :;;t;;t:m1iI1U'f!; jlii jlii 5l5l3. ••. l~rpf~J&/\p. ~-=,-. 5l-m. 1 fi'Il11: l~i1;(E$m~ 2 fi'Ilf1: &1Hij7(if~ ~~:;;t:;;tOO~. jf~"t L. ~O~-pJi7G ' :t£+-=;:gIDJ~~~ ·1f.~t:E==+11.~¥U7\+11.~~lf ' iffl ~11.+~~~~iN~;~~Jf)\m.Rlf-lli.*~'~~~~8~;~+tz:ti~. fi'Il11:. ~rm~~&. ~. F. 0. ffIDJ~oIDJ~~~*~ff.&~1Ii~1¥J.~'Rlf~lli.@~~~~~A:t£*IDJ~ ::f1J~'iffl:t£~1Ii~~~1J~I¥J~~~ffo~~IDJ~~~~~~n+?t~o iN~#:n!ZJ;bIDJ~ 12 1ll.~1Ii~f!~~AZn!Z1f.+tz: ' 5t.+Wtz:5t.:f5.:':f: t ~cplf. 11. li'F. 0. **-+?t~ft'~~lf*§~.&~.&~rm~~. lIijrm !5-11: 1f.15t 3(~F 19 fi'Ilf1:. ~§WI~I. 0. :t£~*f'fJJ[~1J1m ' *lJf~t:Et13U ' 1f.~ , w!~Jf)\m. ' fW{rm1J:A~~1J If){1~~fi'11JJi.!Xi~::f~Jf'fJfi* ' t)jtf1JDlJf~~mf'fJ~~ttW!ftm'l1: fi. Ij\~~. ~tz:. ~~gfli8 5G~~. ,. ~l*-*,at.. -~. 5l5l3~~ ~FfJ. 2 ~;.ji!l! ~-,-= :.iPt1* 5G-=~ 50 *W! NA Wff.&/j\ji ~-=t~ 8Y~. ~±~~!lf'fJ~* ' ;ffl~~¥tl~~f!~Xfl}~J!~~m!!tJ ' lIij1li~1J~1JU~:f'fJ ~rm~ :Mz;ffl~Tf!jPf JE. :tE~rmX:fl}$JJif'fJ?t I ' tJR:~Ow~mn!Zff.&±J!~. - ... ~rm:%f~*ii~. ~. 0. 1Ii~f'fJ~~o. 0. fr.. 53. 8~. 2. :t:flfIill¥. ~*,= 13 fi'Il11:. I~WIImI. 5l3-~. 9c~~~.'. 513 513 !Ii] JE Ml R,1ilj RIilj600ft~~.

(7) 54 ~ J::-l1\. .r;\ 4'- -T. *'1!!UJi:<it :. IIIJ. ~.Ull :.tAn ~. ~ iti!t~i'1. k-¥i:l.t--¥:fIi 55. ~ffl~~!w'.Il~!¥J~*·OO.ll~~JE!w'.Ilx:£t!¥J~W~~·*AW~~!¥J:5t. ~ A~* 1f*+. -=- '. IwruH)% . J;J'&~f&l¥Jiii±~5rM= Q. tlo~-.r~~. , ~Al¥J~~~~}\+~J;J...t ; ~*i~~~fO)7}~:&* ; * $:5t~A*=ffg'I1if~~ : ADL r;~taWJl¥Jf[+111 ' 53)7}JXfY{1l:5tlJU~liTmJ:j:lIt *=!&1iE'&~{~*=!&1iE •. lW~*~pJT1ffiJ!¥Jr,mHf'ffitj§': r f3\ZP:#;f~u'y~®OOlimlfF ? {t~jrlM'rs' ? :ata'iillbf7J( -7(= +1m+1M'!¥J~.IlJ.j'F? J • r ~fi-ffl!f3\lt{$m{3\~j::~mf;#!w' til¥JA? J • r f[r~1J~f&!¥JAtaWJ!w'.IlIl'F ? taW:Jl¥JrJg~~ftffl!? J • r wX:/ml¥J~mf)%J,;.ffl!fl?. (. ~= ~.Il~. WrR:. ~A£4:~*'l-. r. lilWii. ~~. A. £t~. B. £t~. 80 96. X~. 81. J •. r ~t:::*A~l3\!¥J~.IlIl'F~J,;.ffl!ml¥J?. J •. f3\WX:/£3:J;JWIruJf)%tlofiiJ?. ~!w'limr",~lHfjffii~J~::f~U,!§. J'. ? tlOfiiJ:5t.fJ! ? :5t~ftffl!If'F? J • r *A~1ZSl ? J,;.ffl!fW~? J ' r 5t.5i5Wfjl1*ruJf)%tlOfiiJ? J • r. '~~ ~~~~liE'~~~~'ADL~~~$~~. 7~1of~m!w'.Iljffi~*~ull~d:!;'~WJ? J • r lf7jtlff£fflull~®~.Ilji~? J. )7)~ .~.*m.'~fflWJffHff~·m~.·~. ~~*$f5}~WJ.IlrJg~MJPil ' ~l&r",'JmMz~9G1&~ff ' %~J!lJj:'l11ifm~~. )7}~ J:j:IIt*=~liE. ' ADL. jJlA:f£')!fmM¥~~. 0. :jtftl:i!w'I.a~l¥J~4:1!*'l- ' M;J:tEIDJ~~jrulf-1cmtH8~;e~~Z:9} , fu*~FI3~fj~i¥J i@fjJ:j:l , 1JDJ;J®t~Ai¥JJM. JWHJlAtaWJ. c. r 13\~Bmf7J\xmfO~ftl:i5t.5i5Wfj~!¥JruJf)%tlO{iiJ?. r :jtt:::*A~:af'fthb£tJJftrl~1im. ~A ~if :;f3 A*=ffl;fjIt. ~~. J'. , ::tf:jl;~. 0. ~. D. mm. E. X:¥l mm. 75 i*~ mUIi#;i§f1ltlAI\7t ,ttJ:j:lmit~· ~l7.R(pg . r%lrtn.J!?1 . 1Jl1!1IiJil* ' {8 ADL :tE~c~taWJl'"fJJ~gH' 79 *~ J:j:Ima+~~'~~·~l7.RmjJlAtaWJ'~ff~' 74 {g#;~1ltl. 1i. '. Ji*'l-:5t:ffTl¥J:JJJ:t~rJg~:5tffT. F G. H. £t¥l X:¥l Bm. 68 *~ 80 )7}~ 80 *~. ¥~*4. ' ¥:5t:ffT '. , B*~rjtm~ , fu::f~~~A. Mzf~iIDrP:Ji¥J~lE. :f£*fiJf~J:j:I. J:j:Imit'ff~::f~,~.jJlAtaWJ'~~~~~. ' it%~~~ , fu1H1r~~i5 ' ' ADL ~~gJ{taWJ. £3:m. J. am. K. x:m. 84 )7}~ WlIi~A'~~~*'ADL~~jJltaWJ 85 )7}~ ~1t~*=~1iE ' ,§.tRr:bfigliUf ' ~~~ . ~*= 80 *~ ttJ:j:l mit • f'T~::f{i!! , ~A taWJf'TltJ ' tloOO.i • ~. L. mit. 83. Beeman ( 1995) m¥UJi*'l-:5tffTi¥J1i~~. 0. 4.tt~~®-1cJJ~JE~iIDrP:Ji¥J:W:~. 0. • 9G~pJTlf~fj~i@fjZ~if~9Gfl&~:f:m~:@. ft:JJ;ct: , ~fN~1n~l¥J~lJU*f~ji*'l-l¥J*1i~W:5t1{. RJ;)j~11?!I11?!I. (jiiffij~ •. 1991). 0. Jl3t)tlW1tf~ITlil¥J±~pg~ , j;J'&liff~~PJT~¥U)t~~~~i5!¥J±~~~ .jiiffij~ (. • •ff~::f~'ADL%~jJltaWJ'~~~~. 1m ' ~ik:k~. 0. fN. 1991 ) m¥u Bogdan & Biklen (1982) 1ffU~~*iI~~lJUi¥J+~~ .l¥J~ttJ:j:l , *fiJf~~mrttJ:j:l~~!¥J[9l1ll~~:JJJ:t ' *l~~*'l-Wtn~...tl¥J:5t ~ , 'ffitj§' : 1.11ifm5E~~~ , JE~liff~~~~~~'I1ifm!¥J~$ , f9lj~O: r ~ .~~;1't!w'I.ax:m!¥JJE~ J ; 2.fiJf~t1~pJTffll¥Jn~ti ' fuit~;1't~~l¥J1Jf@ Wnl¥ti ' f9UtlO: r ~.Ilx:-el¥JJJjU~ J ; 3.m~~~ , m!¥J~Afr]%~:g~1J mi¥J:JJ$ , f9lj~O: r ~.IlIf'F~~!¥J:5tI J ; 4.ruJl)%Wjji±~*Em~~ , ~t!ii Afr]!¥JfTffl~~ , f9U~U: r Wx:-e!¥JruJf)% J ~f9U*~ , l'"1ffU~3t~:f:: r ~ UiII!!ot- tt~Jfultm!¥Jf,t~~~m~:JJiIDl¥J$'fJ ' ~i~Hffl!i.Zit~jtth¥1* ' ~ffill1* 0. : .~~.Il!¥JIfFl1iEl • !w'.Il~~BJE~c. 0. *fiJf~it~~ff~~w~l¥J~*mrJg~'~~~M~!¥J~~~:f:'~~~~. •. ~~l¥JrJg~'ffimj;Xr:~ffiliIDrP:J. , 5.1JOA11?!I. ¥~~~·~~*mfl&~fi:5t:ffTZ~~Q~~~~mi:fOm~ji*'l-l¥J-~~~. ~*m.~1iT1&. I. )7}~. .Mz~mi:lllff.Wiii~lllff.. ~W~A'ff~::f~,~.jJlAtaWJ. ::f:;t:~~~A. 0. N: : l.~vmVg~:5t:ffTl¥J~f'T~;jSt ' 2.~mi::5t~~*'l-l¥Jflm~ , 3.:5t:ffTWf~lE11?!I. ~~~rtn.A~ti~'ADL~~~AtaWJ'%~ ~~. 11- ~Jf ~ it. ~ "tV ...

(8) ~. ,$ ~. ,l-/. ~ ~. •. It. I€ -¥. *"~. ~ ~. ~. '". Ii'). &. ~-lf{n!B!K* ~ ~. . 1+1. :jnl(. ilt4~'alit~ l111J IIIIJ;f -. ~ _. •. ~;{,fu~I!!t:it!. -:t: lEl~ L.. $ _ ·H:1'W:g'. -,. 1ii'&:J1l.tl~ . gg~ or.; H ~~&gg~. ••. ).J;:. ffi! ". -R. -,~. ffi!. m~. ~~ ~R :g'. iji. {[j. ~-p<tf-.. /"'>. 0. .~~. ~~:gj~~. -,W1~ ~ iji ~. ~itIBl:g'~. •. ~. ~~iji-lf{n~~m:s W :g' ~q & -:t: 4g. $ lI3M~~~{~~ ~ 1+1~lI3M,g:ElJ;. lfi: or.; If :g' 'alit ... ~~~~ilt4g.. !PIi~~{]:!;/~~~. ~lI3M. ~or.;.,. ••. ~~~~~~M. ~~,""L... :g'~-:t:~~fl:~:H.;tJ:H~1$. ;{,fu:jnl('alit~~~f. ~E~~~· D.J~mij ~!fl:-L.. ~H:1~ •. !~~ o~ {$II( II: ~ ~ li1itl ~fiR~-,~:g'-N '1lIlK&~~~~. !PI ~ ~~ W:8 • • :gq ~ i!!§ +< -:t: tl. :g'~H·l~ ~~&-:t:l$~. ~ t~. ~~-'IW1. ±Ia :g'. CQ~~iHJ;j. ~~~tit\. ~.L..!B!K. ~!PI~or.; Q~!PI:$tl. jL-~~'alit. 1, m~ Iii' ~ ~~!I~~~ ~. &. .'. & '• .. ,*H~l1,t!/"d. ~ ~. :¥1 -, -p<. ~ • {N<. . ~. ~H ~ ~ ~. ~. ~-N\JR~ o. -tJ$'M~. '*. .-<~tit\ ~ lEl( .g~ ~~~$ ~ ~ ~ m~ ~. ~\tt>:g'~o ~ L.. ill: 1111~ :g'. ,. ~~& ,. ~. ~!PIgg~.~. :jnl(. ~~~:g'~. ~. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~. ~. ~. ,\~. .. .g~ fiR ~ -:t: ~ .g~ ~ ~ -:t:1ii' $'~1V*~$fiR~II¢(':g'. :J '. ~.:::@~*:j:j(ii~~~ .~.E ~.g~WMl\llllll~mw;-:t: ~~8~$o~~l;i!i'~~ ~ 111 @1 r-.. .g~ lEl~ W lfi: ~ @, ~~~$DJI··~. "t:I. .. *' \ ,:':"'-. .g. ~r-..~f,; Q ~lEl/-<~~· r-.. ~ ~ ~~ ~.g~ ~R • H:1 ~ e Cj fiR f! !it .g~ $ ~ f! ~ ~ ~ Q , nl~$$!l;i!i'f'-.lEl( "--'«I~~~~ ~:g't::I~~ tl ~ -HI l;i!i' ~ '11t! 1$Jl IlEl' it! Wt ~a -:; ~ ;{,,fu , mJi~" .$!.tit\. ~. "t:I~. ~ 10+\. ~ ,~~. cf§:1$~~~. . '0$' otl@~~I:jL-~. tt,. ~ a -:t: lEl( :~ Iii' :g' II ~ J;!S :g' ~"--', ~~lEl(~.~!£~. ~. II. .. ~ It IlL: ~ i~ tit\ I: II .~ Iii' • .g~ 1$ ~ -HI. :g'~=~ ~ ~~Mlmgg~-<. .g~ II¢( $ ~. WI ~ ..... {~. -K" ~ ~ -a:r. ..(;'>. lIE. bIi. !B!K :J1l.tl. .. ~. IlIlK. :J1l.tl @1 1. -Y. ~. tH. IJl::!. '='. W H. ~. ~~. & :g'. +t. $. .g~. fl:. ~. ,~. lI3M 1+1. ~~. -If{n. ~. &. \if. ~. ~ ~. ~. ~K~:f;Ija·=m·~·. ,.\J •• ~K:l ~ , I!!!!$~WI~ '" , .... ~ *'"~ .1Iff,f,~~~~ "\JR'-$!. \i~. $\(. f!. IU:f;Ij:8 mJi ~ ~ III1l( ~ ~. ~:f;Ij'l:ii:g'II". *',\. ,14. -¥. ~.~~~. ~. ~ lEl( :g' II¢( :E' {t! m ~ ~ :g' ~. 0. -R~,~1+1~Iii'~{]:!;/\lIlIll:g' ~ :g' ~ ~ ~ III ~ -If{n ~ ~ ~ ~~~E~:g'~.g~~~tl. £(* ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ III $ III ~ ~. ~f,;@'l!ilW·:g'm'lJ!\ :g'~~~:8:g'~~It!)(~~.

(9) 58 $I:k~. AJt.T*,l1!t$f!~. ~'~*~~. ••. ~.!IItZ;fJJ~. :. •. l~bi:...i1ti{; k. 'f;E!¥JfEl~Z'"F. *R.~.M.£.~aw. ",*J:. -t-*:fIl 59. . W:X:fB:!¥J'I'~~tt~H · 'm-nX:m~Rm:1.~!¥JJJjUl9 ®1£)7}A 0. IUBt:'"F ' ili~fl"i].!¥J;g$. 0. 1£*UJf~$ . ~JJi~Rm~t!1:£~l!H'*{!f!¥JlfP:l:W:1.I1~~*&JfJ~RmI f'f!¥JiR:~. 0. 1W~:1.~~'I!1f4l~~4l/Z9~. I. /Z9Jlt~T§ai1t.~)7}. .... 1f- ~ k -!if k -!t ~1J'~ , ~ *- m11 91' -. *UJf~JUf:rilit.Xr~U~JJj{/Z9: r *$mfJ~t15JU J' r tfi~:X:fB:~'I'Pi~H J. If'f!¥ttt!!J '. f. MA~~fi~:tJ. '. ~h;f i, JF~ iRt ~ Mri! ... :V.t kIDLA. iJl. l:V.tr~~Jfit..v.fi!k~;It~~1tS!J:V.t;lt~~~.~. ". ,*"~it.a. r. (~)~~~**~:V.t. ~~{t'~~ •• *~A.{t'~.~~"f~1t~1.~l.k~*_~.. ilit!~.~;®~~:1.~~~Rm~:1.I1!¥Jm~'%~1:£§a!¥J~$ili~o (-)nX:m:1.~~~~JJR!Z9!¥J~lltlfP:I:. ~:~~ • • I.~a?~.'4*~!. '5JUAiim. *Jit~l!Ht*f!f~H J. '. <H. 0. ,~:V.t~. (H Jt1.) ~Jt1.~~~~~~1lF'fHr, ~:V.tA~~1J" (~). 0. Jt1.z~). 0. 1&'*~. ! ~,j,~~&.*.. ~~-~1..t{i~~;f!., ~~*~;t~1t,,~~. ~~A.~{t,~:V.t.~*.{t'''f~;It~~6*~.*'.;.~~~. 1. ~ $~~fJ~'V:f.5JU. -t.ft.~:fP.. 1§iJr ~1§iJ:P.:ii m-~r.tml¥~Rm:x:a!¥JI i'f ' ~9t 5l rili~.*~??-~~ff! ~~.~Rm!¥JI~'ili~~~~~~§ ,®• • • ft~RmI i'f. m Jt1.). 3.1.EH1ID~~~~B9qtt!!. 0. :1.~~Rm~1.EH1j~If'f ~;It~k···~"fYA~~:9.I!.1i~~.tT.:r..1f' it.;It~1J'~ (~~) ~;t~1hf'. ~~Ii'flRJrl'l~~5~'V:f.~'I1i:lJl. '. ' ~{;t , ~~:X:B:J:1:WiIRJ1.Ef[l[;ftIi'fB9,,~tt!! ' i1tl!i:;iliW~~m:1.~~B~!¥J~IlH~i4. 0. *.~·it.;It •• ;It.~~M.·~~~A~~~M.'~~_.~. -k~ ... ~ ~ ~ -t. J1:.:<f )JiJi '. ••. 1!t;lt ~ it ~ 4t A. •. FJf YA fJ~ at 1~ :V.t ;It ~ -100 A... .~-!if-!if~~~~~~1lF«-t.4*,1!t~~at~"f~-t.~~T'~. ~~at~-:t-~.'*~~.~-.'~~~~kMoo*~ •• ~~:V.t+. (L ,Hill.). i!#.1 ' ~;; ;It~i!1tit.*-*:V.t;lt~~1;ltM]. 0. (]. Jt:i). • ~ ~-t. )t~ A.···~;t~ ~-:t-.ffi. ~ JX.1t Jf ... it ~ ~ ~Jj 1t~A.JX.1t Jf ' ~ 1i~ 1;lt , ~ kUA.t~:V.t:t :t1A.t v.fi! (A. 1,t-jfit.{l.:r..1:;f±~, k~~~*~'. 'ttiJt.,. 'Hill.. '~*) ~~~;It~*o~~~;;~~-.~*· *;t"1.1&'~j;1t.'. ···m1tatF~Ht.~. • • ~~.~M.~*~. ... , FJfYA~~5Jt'''H.;JMd,t:fp~{tjf-~. 0. (F Jt1.). ~:V.t~4l4i-l!'~. 0. ... ,. (B Jt1.). ~~~~~~~.~~.,-t.~~~~m~~~.* •• D~.:r..~ 1:1=. tt;lf ~ 'ft. 0. (. K Jt 1. ). ~~.*~#~T~(~.:r..~~i!r~). ~Jt1.;It~*,-~~~~{t(EJt1.Z~). FJfYA{i~i~Alii~JIl~~. A ' ~{i E1"ta"~···. ,~~~.:r..~,~~~~. <C +-klU. 2. !!LJ:X:fB:~'I1f~H. 4. MA ~f1~:tJ ' ~111,*f!f~~f W:X:fB:!¥J~~Hili~nX:m:1.~~Rm~!¥Jm~/Z9~'~®:1.~~Rm~~~ V'-ftHfiiQrJt;.::r:-tr*Fl~/F!l$. I. ~li1.J05$;ftnX:m:1.~~Rm~!¥JJJR/Z9. 0. mtJW;ftftll. *UJf~$ ~Rm~*Jit~1# § a~fi~:tJ*~Rm:X:fB: . ~~~Rm~~??-m §.

(10) ~l. ""--.. 111.C. mI!iYi~~g'. .. ~*"~. g' g' \ti:\ •. llli! -8- 0. g'. \<ii'. ~. W ITR. ~. ::'d :;I; ~. ~ ~. ~. ~. ilfl ~ Ill\!(. '.~. ~. ~. ¢ ~ ~ ~. ~ ~. *. • ~. 'IJ~ ~. 0. ~. ::r::. ~~ ~. 111:!'. fEf ~~ ~ ~. ~. . .. I->. -:r-. I> »>.). ..... ~ ~ >l'I. .".. * ~. ~ ~. I. :~ ~ ;~. ilfl IO~. ~~. ~~. o~. C'-.. ~. ~-.. ~. ilfl 1lI\!(~. ~* $-~. ~ C'-.. fEf. :a. ~. ~ 0. -K~. *~ :a4. 0. ~. '. .~ 0. *'~. .l-\~. *\' ~. ~'t". {~. .~~. ~. ,~. ~~ .Q(. ~~. .~. ~t4. ~*.. ~ ~ ~ \'{oi ~ ~&:Q ~. ~. '*. .~ ~. .\;>1. 0. ;i *'. {'*. .. ,~ ~~ ~. ~~ ~. lEI~ ~ .~. ~-&. ~~ ~~. ~*~. ~~ \'-~ '!'d~. **41. 11. *~~. ~~~. .~. ~~~ . -<. :¥ro~. ~'~. ~~.l-\. ~. ~. ::'d$!. ~. •. 0. I-> l:'>/. -K;:. ~~. o. ~~. ~I->. *' -\Illt'.. 0. :~. ~~ ~~. ~. ~~. ~~. ~~. ~ ;~ ~:;I;. fEf ~. ~~. n( .. ~:;. ~~ ~~. ~~. ~l. ~. ~ ~!I~. !~I~ • Ii!1! ~ ~ ~ W W l.~ g' tf-. ::ll ~:\n1(~ITRtf-.. ~l\t!I{1l!!l+~~ ill I !tl ~ g' £Wl ~m]Q:!:H~a1~ ~~~~~~.. =~.s::t:&I~. ~l!$f!;i,l~-8-~. ~. iJ!!: ~J; ~ ill ;It; ~~ ~~~~~iJ!!:1l:. ~".. ~ml!i 1 g'1H~n@ ~1~~~a1mj:;1g'. £Wljll£Wl£WlM. \i:l\t!I1IE(~t$0. ~.g'Yi~ {~~,~ ~ ~. 1!!l !$ mil. .... ~ g' ,BJ! ill g' ~ ,.>,J Ii ~ !.J L ,g: '-' ~ 1IE( :!:H. ~·~ml!i· ~~.a1~ ..,~~~~I!. 0. !$-<~i~. •. Yii;~. ~. t&. ~. 0. l\t!I$!: ml!i 1~'-'~~ ~.~~~. '.t:>. ... :!~. t& -K ~. 't:\. S!. ~ .~. ~a1. o. IT.J4III!. i;~ ~~. 0. ~~ ~~ ~ ~. §. ~. !iU:;. ~fv(. ~~. 1IE( , :$t-K ~~ !il~ Mr~. g'~. Wi. ml!i ~~. ~'. .~. {]J]~. J!W;5. !t,. \ftM~. 'IE~. '~ \ftM, +Ht!l\'\ 1i!1!*. ~~ ~1IE( m:~. H!l§ .qn g'~. tEl~. t::I~. .l{. ~. ~~. $ ~. ""'~ 1iIl(" -\><. *'. *I ~. ~. "I\< ~. 0 '.t:>. -$. <. 'tJ~ *' :It'f fEf I~ ~~. ~:;I;. u(. * :;1;* . t:a.. ~~. ~~. :;\;i ~l ~~ ~~. &:Q ~. .~. If:. >l'I. .".. ~. .. fEf ....... ..t.<.. .~. ~. .l-\ ~. ~. 1: ~. ~~ ,~ ~. *0. ~. If:. ~. ~. ~:;I; .. ~'*. ~I->. ~~. »>.). ....~ ~ . ~. fE[ ~. ~. ~. .. .. ~. -K. ~~ ~~ !iH€1lI\!( $-~ ':.?{. ~~ :a~. ~~ :;I;~. '*~ '*~. ~ .~. ~~. {~. ~ ~. ·fl. ~. 41~ 1.!~ *. ~. ~. ~ ~ Ill\!(. l;R. ~~. ~.¢ ~~ ~l!!l\'. ~~. -<. iif>t fEf. ~. .r0 l!!l\'. ~. ,. ~. M # ~li& ~. )j::!. M. •. . ~~. a1. 'IFf ill :t!:! g'. ~. ~. ;":!! ~. +4 ~ ~ ~ ~. lEI. ~ I->. ~ ~. ~~ :;I;~ 0. ~. ~..: ~. ~. ~~. .. ~ID ~. ~ I ~~. ~. C'-.. ~. I->. ~-+< {~. !*' ...... . *'. f:T !I§-+<. ~~ _. !lil. ~*. ~~. *w. ~ .~ 1lI\!(~. !I§'t". ~. ';i"~. ~~. .. ~~. T-+<. ::'dill\!(. ~~. \ftM~K-~::ll. :itiV. ~~~~*«tf-. ~~",,","K-Ii!1!ITR. g'mj:;1)!1k(L'lFfO -L1 ml lI* ' iIi1I ~ !.J ~ tEl "')j::!:\!lIl ~Wi~m.:g1] ~~~~~~ 1. ~hlliiig'~~iJ!!: l\t!I+Ha1 L . ~. j iJ!!:~~l\t!I~~ :lit~mK j ~~. 1E~~m~~ . ..;,l\t!I~~K--L1 l\te- 1 0 ~ ~ ~mj:;1~m~~ ~'g'rH. ~~l\t!I4:1;a1. 1 tf-. 'X W 0. l\t!I. •. 1 .~.~(..,iII mj:;111~~~5Q~. 1. !$ml!i.~~L. Yi g'~.&lmW·~. -<.. ;i,l~.JiIg~o~. W-L1g'~tw~iri\ ~~..,·~QRtlt. ~. f:. '~* ~. "'~" :. ~.. ... 0. ~~ ~~. lUI. ~~. -. ::;1;. ~ n(. _.. .. +4~ ~. ~. "d;1. tt N. ~n. ~. £Wl. iE( £Wl. ~. ::'d. ~ ';i". 0. ~$':.?{. :1t. Wg'«g'oll**. ~lli~-S~IR!)j::!. ~#~..,~.. ~~41)!1k(.g' • ~WL~g'&I~. ~:ijiill~ll:~. ~. 0. f:~. ~~. ~~ ~. ~~ :;I;~. ~f: ~ ~. I. ~. ,. ~. Ill\!(. ~~ ~ ~. :;I; ,. ~~* ll!~Ei «~!il. 1!!i.'~g'. 00 ~ ~~. ,. $1'wm. 11ll?1!!i.'$ 1]lm: , -"'* 1tla :jDj' ~~ a1 ~ ~ ~~ g' l!t~. mt-1H@1. ~0iJ!!:. ~H[[. ~~1!!i.' (~. (~~ ~. $g'~. *a1~iII. ~. ......;. ~ ~a, ,-; -!lP. ~. ~ _.. {~. ~~~ :l:I<~~ a1~~ ~ (~ J!S W {Il£. ~.~. ~iII::ll .~ITR. • mK 4:1;. ~. 4:1;~~ tf-..~. ~~ ~33. It> ~. ..,. ~L. g'g')!Ik(. II:. ~. *t:a... ~. \GIl<: 111:!'. l;R. t:a... ,. ~m!l. {]J]!il~. W'+H. mK. .~£Wl. L. ~ {Il!: ~. t!1. ..,t1jp. g' ~ ,~ !ilL L. 1i!1!~a1 # ~tEl~tP\. 1+1Ng'1R!. ~-...-~ ' • .:s: .., \ftM~~!I!/E. ~~. ~i;#~. ~. ~ ~. g' a1. ,. 1!!i.' il L {1l!!l ~~ , ~ . .., ~M~ # ~n@ ~ -Rg')j::! ~~ a1 •. ~m: • t{Ir g'~$!. ~~ .., W'~. ~~@]. Mr ... ~~ m~. ~. i'Ir~. II: ~. !il +H g' {W ;l,1$ ~ ~ ~ ~. 'IE. iI.

(11) p.. ~. :. 1'\.

(12) *. itiF..Jlti~:k "';fl..-",. 65. A -+ .:r J!!UiJi:.t : t.tNt.::t;fJ]:U!. 64 ~~~. ". ;:r:. A.""J-,k-*.;\:.1:.'/fJ:.'/f"'f. o. (L+~). "I'"f! (G;\:.1:.). ~:.;\:'1:.~ • • L~?-*,~~ • • ~~~~.*"-*.~~44 *-~. , ""~~k-*.ifftJ:.,,,"P'Jt:t. ' 4lAtJt ... ~~ , :Jti~ , ~-*.~~4l. AtAj1'. ~1t-~"i' ;.rt4-1q;~k-*.ifftJ:.. -*. fI"l~~~~ if • • ' ± ~at1l-*.~ft:;;r-*,. ~l!fh. 0. 0. ... ~ (;\:.1:.). (E. ifit-DJ:.-*.t-~-*.~4~.~'~t-*.fI"l~;;r-~~.A.* • • ' ~~-*.~~titk;;r-~.~'l!l.-*.~~.·~k~t-~*a-*..*. ~~# .. ·it:f! t-~.~ l!l.:&1A.~44 ~fiE.~tf4~ YA' 1~ • • +~"· f~!.k~"f.1'!!.;;r-fi~it*l' 1!!.k~il.Jl'jJHtat stand by· -*.~fiE.~~.t' 1~ .R nU?, "-t ' 1~ ro e.. ~ ~ ~ :f& -.!- 4t.ft<T J:. tJ9 ~ ~ (F;\:.1:. ). ;\:.1:.z-t:). "'-*.+~-T-II!.t-, ·tt:. 0. <H;\:.1:.). 0. ,-*,~, ~)jlk-*')jl, ~,-*.*. • • • *o~:~~if'*.~?'~ • • T, "1:.;;r-~GJr.lJMfT (A+~). 0. (~) o~.~if-*.~A~ 2.'l1:lJUZ~~. 0. i'iJjJj]~ ( 1995) f!¥IJT~~m'I'R~X*mlilH~f.iLi@~ :tE*m~cp#;fr~ i:t!~~¥U;fElIPJ~tr5:li!! :t.z:)l~Iim)(£3:tt.~~~$'G~~~EIPJ ' IZ5lm~lf~~Mtft ~jt1~~1Ii)(£3:~RT~*' :t.z:)l~tB:t,:~~\~jHt.~~1im0~' rm::jfl3a~ )(£3:0fIi~ ,-tQ1H~T~Em~~,Mfj~ff!~~W~IimIf'F' l3a~)(£3:l3a~1im • I?i)mtB~.¥U:1c~~gf* ' 0~~11lJUft~J:.~IPJ~~. if ~~MJ1~~7J- ' Barber & Pasley (1995) ~4-T*!llt.;t~&~ • • ;t~~'-T* • • ;tM~~.f~~~~a~~~~.ho~if* ~~t-ll!..~ • • ~.~ • • • 9"'f~~~M.t' • • 7J-~~7J-' kr~ • • ~.9*-t:6.J'~ r.~~£AJ '.7J-~*~ -At>"'f:. 0. 0. ~. -*.1'r' *-t: 6 ,tt YA lit ;f*... ~- t1i.~. * it;;r-J.!!, ~ of X. -Bt' l!l. ~ -lejHet' 1'r' ~ ;;r- of ' ... , .R k 1I!!.fI"l -€I' j'f A. ~ -itt $ a k ~ .f!t* it ;;r- rn of. ~1Ii~~~~~I?i)~~1IiW~mm@'~~~1Ii~~~~n~~~~~ ~lt1J. ' ;gwt. 0. it-T~*5Lk-g.~. 'W~fIgm.¥U:!J3-,*~~~ 'i:t!~~RX;~1Ii~;f13~*. •. 0. ~ k~~t-.*.u-"·~l!l.~*. .f'.~~6*t-.*.£,.~at-~*-*.fI"l,~-*.at-ftL-~. <H ;\:.1:.Z-t:). (L. "".,. +-m). 0. 0. -*.~1ltk$1~1t • • h.ll~!-*. ro e..6~-*.;th ifftJ:. ' :l.~~k-*.;\:' .t#-*.' PJfYA-*.*-.~~~t~.h"·~A.~.t#!A~"f'*"~~ (J. .h.I-ll!.;;r-.ak~~'.T • • ~'-*..~~.~.T'~~. }j t~~Ii1-.!-'. .. ·it~*A.~ (.!..!.) ~at~t-~-)'J;~ 'R~a~~~ it:i!... :$" ~ -*. .!. .!. fiU'tj l.~ M ' :$" ~ ~ fi~J'1 .t# -*. it g. -T ftJ:. ' -At> * ~;;r- fi~ .t#~jf;'~-*.-II!.t- • • ~~,it~ a -Ta;;r-*~ T o*if~"f,*"aAJ£ '. 0. '1'~). :l.~~-*.fI"l~.~kl~ifftJ:.~a'.-~6~k __ ;f • • ~o. ~~~-*..-~jf;,~ar~;;r-~~~~~it~~a*l,~~~ft~. il ~ it I'll *-if J (B;\:'1:. ). 0. • • •-*.• • ,~at.-*,~.~~*.'-*.;\:.1:.a~-*.;;r-~ • .!. f'l!l411!!.~.f!ta'.t~k.~-.!-~*it,~ • • • ~,-At>*~fI"l~ • ik t. ... ~ -*. -II!. 6 jl} -*. ;\:,1:. :'tt -*...... ia!i it $X ~ , ~ it:fl-*.-II!. -t j'}4 1; -*. ~1lta-*'''i~4it. ;t..:..::i:h '''1~''i -*,X. -Bt.*1f.~t~~a "i~ , -*.A~~-a:*M -*."f'*"~ ~9t .. , m '1'~). -*.fI"l~~~~if • • '±~l!fho-*..-At>*~~-*.fI"l'~-~A.k. .. ;;r-~~W ~ -*.JJl.ifk f'll T $t~H- '. , -tQ~.¥U~1Ii~%!@:IH!% 0. '. 1.1?i)~1Ii~.:1c~~m. :!J3-,*Il~~~1W. ~at~.hakt-*..!..!.~~~,~at._*.~.kt-.~~ jf;'.*.~.k*-;;r-.~ • • ,.*.ftif-*.fI"l*-' • • ~~7J-.. I. *1:..~at-lttf ,t-~-~~:Jt~*- ..·a... A.. r..,,t!. 0. (K ;\:.1:.).

(13) 66 iti 1:: iI\. A If- f-* ,Il« $Ii:t :. ~~ JUt .:~AJ]. '*. ~~~a.~*~~MkM.~(kk) ,~~~ ••• ~~~~. .£t£JL,*-1!!\,M,. i!~~~:ff1t{ttk~ Bl]~~ ... (F. 7\:.1.). ~it.iOC;tJ;.~;f±'1r~~ 01. lIIr.r·. "'". ffl~~~~~~~.f,~~t-~t-~~,·~~··~~·~~*, 1I!!.~~k~*.~_.-t~~.~*'~kA.~~.-a1!!\a~ftA .~,. (=).:p,IE ~Mt W.:p,IE Hi*, ~7 j:~~.~~7} , jtft!!flm'l'L~.I¥J.:p,IEilHm1liB:ff~{jt@jJEI¥J~~jJj. $~. 0. f:9U:tzO~'ltl'5t71. '. ~~~~*~~3tfif. ... , 1I!!.1r,~~t~.t-$f. 0. (L. ,j'-kR.). l!~1OO.}]4k~~~~~j.itMaOC'k~a~A~4~k~ *~~_.AA1!!\a'~.A1!!\a~~.~J~j'~~i$~l!A~a JUT-#; fI1!.1I"*-*:it~l!iJi:t.t-~ .. ·~Bl]~~ ~Jkif'-' ;;Yk~)t~. 0. 0. i!. 0. (C. .]--kR.). 1!!\.~.-~~.mBl]4kt~.:ff~Bl].~'~.~.~4~.. ft;1OO-IIf.-IIf.' 11.$11.$ 7t1.). it'. 'l!~*t"*,*-~,ti:. 0. ~1:4,*-~1I!!.it.-r. 2.H~. .. ·. *~~: ~O:~Jtft!!.:pJl~H~' gt;~JJfB::f~*~WH7 ~7H±H~I¥J.:p,IE IJII{*,CP , !W-~~tP;ft5M.:p,\El¥Jt1tlfPWtI~~!Jfrt3¥U::ft~. ~k~+.f,~:l,\,;t}] ,lR\.i~. ~~~~4k~~H.:itH.'~~~4~joA+~~:itt-# ~o# •• t-.!~~~t-o#~~k~.k~.'~~~.t-.:itifo. 'f'ft-i?!i'*-:t:t, ;fJ]4ktifj '111!.1rH{r;-x.£JL~,lt;)., -tft, 'llt-ttt, .~1.~ft~4k~~.~1!!\a (G7t1.) ~1!!\.i~i~kJ.lt~Bl] 0. (B. H~I¥J.:p,lE1JII{*,5M~~jJj~ffi]§ ~1N.*I¥J~tI ' pJT J;J!W-~~PJT~I¥J~1l. .£1m~~-1m~~~ft~.:lr.,. i~' j~$t11JJll~l!~. 0. ,. ~~*r!l'. 0. JiJT,,:Uij:-1mA#IliJi:Bl]:ffi!~~-tl. 'llt#;'f't~~ ...• Jj<..t4k~j1tt. 0. 0. 0. (K7t1.). (L ,HIl). ~k-kR.t-;f"~.)J.t"1I!!.-kiJt.IJt' n~~+-llf.t-~1I!!.iJt.;*. 0. (F 7t1.). ~ ~ ~ 1I!!.1I":it~ j -~ i:.J. ~ kfJ~.fil",~.!1t.llt i. J;OtJ£ (/.]:ff S<. ' ~kJ;OtJ£~~llif ·1I!!.~~f~ (.£t£JL) J;OtJ£Bl] ~/kif'- ' n~"iii:t~ , :it"iii 4i; lElaif j c (0.]- -kR. ) 0. Ak~1!!\.4k~.'~~.£M~~ • •. (K7t1.). , .:p,IEI¥J~JjrPJEBmtLI¥Jffi1tljtm: r jC~&:ff~ W~.J ' r:ff~W~.' 1!I~ltH~J ' rJm~I¥J.:p,IEH1*,J ,J;J,& r ~ff31imWJfEl~l¥J.:p ,@1JII1*'J ~j1-1:E.:p,IE1JII1*'1Jjij. 0. 1. jC~1~fl~W~. ~1'!I.:p,IE1JII1*'1¥Jj:~~.;g-lt~¥U'l'JU&. ' .~ , ~~:ff::f0ZP:1¥J'11UfH:e. "ij! 1!I~IID~:tzOIltI¥J.:p,IE1JII1*, ' j:~~jJj;g-~*I¥JDiff!1J~W~*f~ 0. 0. 1I!!.~4~,*-'~.~-M.#,*--*'~A~~~'JiJT~~~~h. 'llt-tt 11>, 11!!. 1i..iE-1OO.£t£JLAit:it ~ ,*-:t k1t Bl]. ' 'tttt ' it-lr, ,t.:iII ~ '*-? m 7t 1.) 0. ... 0. ~~~t- .i.:fh.:fr. ... ~MA~~~{/.]~.t-(#.) '~A1I!!.~.1OO*1.~~·~if'-' ~~k.~J£1I!!.~a.i$~'1I!!.~t-~~~A'~.'*-:it~1I!!.~-~#; r~M.~:it.,~~mH.Bl]:itM~-:it4i;J '~k.#.Ai:.*. a_rBl]'~M~.11JJlI.~a'~:it~1I!!..if'~M.~:it~~.'~ ~~ A4kfll~'tf-' 11!!.~ ~~., "'j.l;A-t:itt1;tit~l~if·" (F 7t1.) 3.Jm~. *1iff~~"ij! , :t:EJm~I¥J.:pJ.EH{*,$ , TP:lt~xm:I¥J!W-DI{'Fmte::fri:iJ. 1¥J~~,ffi]~Jm~I¥J~1J~.w~~.:p,IE~M*~*§ ~~~l¥Jo. ,~m~§al¥J1J.

(14) ,~. ~. ~. +I ~. -l\iit. • ~. ii' ~. 'l';f. *. (. K i. \irlll~~~ ~~~~. i!if~~i!if \Ii?~~+. ~~~:t1 ~ I : Ill\!( ~"$'"$'¥ ~~,*,4<. 0. '« ~ ',~:'!I : ~ ~ '« *..w..~* ~;~~. ~;'IIl\!(~. , #. <"$'1Il\!(. ~.~~ :t1~~~ ~. ~~. ~¢:#. t;Ij. ,. ~. ~£?? ~ \II\l'«~ ;:<"$'~~. •. ,«~~.g..~. 1A;. # '.:.; '« :• # ll;:'I:{ Pt: _.. ~t.\$!JIl!..~~. ~ ~ ~. ~"$'~2~W i!if*"$'~:t1 til •. ~~*'::r&''«. ~.g...~~tton. ~. ~~~~. ~. ~ ~. t«. ~~. ~!ll fH-, I. :¥!mW. :jDj(~~. ~*. fH-,-R. :jDj(:g;'. :¥!Ifl ~~ ~. ~= 0. +~. " till: m:i~. ~@. lBi~. ~]E. mgt+-> ItiMfE 1+1" ·1tiM. tr. ~:g;'. =1llti: ~*. ~. :¥. ~. w: '--". <1:1\~. ~. ~. 11. ~ ~. ~ ~~. ~~. 1£ ,~ *~. ~. ~x ~ ~ 0. ~~. ~. :$1"$' ~. :1. ~* «-Ill\!( .«-. ~. £??. ~~. ~. fH-,~. . ~mg¢. :g;'/fii. ""'~ ~ 4:U.~. t«rffit«. ~€. ~f:::l. ,tI-~. ¥? ~. .$. {'*. >1<4<. ~~. 4.t- ~ '«~ ~:$1~. ~ ,~ ~. ~~~. w:~~. ~:So. ~ -:: .fiJ ~'a'i ~. ~. ~. llf ""- '".. '. :t1 I '«. ..... ~«-~ ho. tC.. !;R ~. {'~~~ *~ 4<. ~. ~~1iI;.If. *,~!JIl!... !JIl!..~~ ..... 0 ~ «-'l!!:! .~ ~ ~. M '. ~ .,....-'-1,.... ~~~. '« - :$1. !~ ~81'. 4t. "* Ill\<. ~ ~. ~. o~. 1lS ~ ~~. «-~. 0. ~~. ~. .tI-~ ~. w::j. ~. ~. ~~. :~. 1Il\<~ ~~ '« ~. 4,11. ~. iiJ .#.$ ~\¢ ~«~ ID. ~~. '«~. '«. ~. ~. I. ~ «-~ ~. ~. ~. ~:$1 ~~ ~. ~. ,.",\. ~~. i« ...... 6. ~. ~* 1:$1 "*~ t\I--~ -< ~. ~. ~w::::~. l~~ 0. '«~o .. ~ . ~<I:I\-~. $~. ~~t;'!/. ~~~ ~:$1~. *'~~. \l. ~ ~. *''« *' * ~2 :":'!/. ~i* ~ .~. '«. '. ~'«. ~ ~. iii. -~~R. Iil:¥!~~ -iIm. 0. ~ ~ ~ ~\. =5~~~ ~.\Ill ~. ,-. Q.;. a(!~~~~ 6/fii~:H~ mg roW ::g -lP( .t:. ~1tiM~-P<:g;'. ,-,1+1'~~ ~roW:¢~~ " till: -lP( ~ ~. ~~W!$~. ,«~~~~. :g;'\l!Hll~tSJ* +<~~~~ !l~ ~ fH-, ItiM 1iim m~ N ' \l!Hll ~ ~~-P<:g;'~ ~@~~~. _ ~ ~ t« till: IIIIIT ~ tf-. JW\ ~. fE~~~i~. :¢W~~. ~~~W t«~-~tf-. ~$it~::g. '..;J 1+ HE • • ~o~it~ ~~~:\!t~ ~Io't«:g;' ~~~\§. ~. ~ ~. rJ. i!if "$' .w:r ~. 41<. ~. ~. ~€. .J!!$. "". !JIl!... ~. ~. ~. ~. ;.;. ~. "$' $. ~. ~. ...... .).]. ~. "'>l. ~. ~.

(15) :t -. miLil.tii; :k~:;flt"~:fII.. AJf-..:r-k,i!1{$l:t : ~~Z;fJ]~. 70 itt~-iI\. ~ 'i":fi- (F. 71. (Hamon, 1992) 'rm@]iI~e~~~WitJljWmWJ' i.t1~~-OOItJ~ ( Walker. JeA.. ). *~~~-OO~:fJ~~Jtftg~~PJT*m:&~ : Wit~~ej!£ ~{/~W~~ ~-a:rff~:fO*1Jfr±1ltW;lltI!:!;;W~~{~~3tft:W;f~~ffi{r1J~ruJ. & Pratt, 1992). «~**~~~4'k~M.*.~~4~o**«~k4.~. ~., .~ .~it V «~~jlj. 'f ~.~a!JJ6~itJ;l. 0. (E. 0. 0. 0. rm1ltfJN/~WfZSl*;g~lm~~~' {!;L3ft)~ttm± ~~~1Jrnl~z.m~. 7\:.1.z-i:). 0. ~Epm'. -(Ii " ~t. .;/>... ~Y;IJ~ ( 1995) m:¥U.AI!~~~~J] <!l%te~~~)lWj!1ite~~*. ~I!Q. ? > ~~~ , ~~ii'.~tE~1~)l~*.5(e7'Jj!te El ~-;fi r .ff J ' rm~)lWJ;)~H~tt'I'R~:mte~ *~~rp~ur:t[¥U~)ltt~1lt1t£*lI1t~~i~ ~~~5(e~OO~o)lr~ur~1lt1t£.ff'~~~~~B~~~~~eo* ~~~~J~~~~~f~ , ~~fZSl:mJt{frmWit~~e~~~ , ~~lm.A~ft!!OO ~~e1.fl~"ljI , ~1lt*~&~ r ~mjI J ~ftgfl',*~j!-lJi~1!~*f\i'gJ , 1:Erp~.A~fN:Mrp , ~n~~~{~~~j!1o/Jj{~JIj , J!~~t~~1&~1'R~ fZSl~~,;J[rB=it ' ~~-;fi{}tt1l!f~~Wit~ ~7\--a:rffg~JJj(fZSlj!l$*1t~~~* IIl1t£W~~ , 1:EWitJlj~fflf*1R¥ ' m1lt~~te~~e~~iPpj rm JL~~~tig~ e ' '1¥;R;1lt~1f~e~~J1Ji: ~rnl'ltMf~~~WJlljI1t£· ~~. 1l,1lj -. .,;t.,J. ....h. .. iI'J IIIQ. 0. *~~~~'rn~~~~w~±~oo~~,~~~~~~e~oo~~~. 5t 8:ei~ . ~?i&i.t1gt~1t;;liI5tJ~ El r;~#:m ' taI!MDIilTI~PifLt1~~~ , HP1lf:~~lPJttJjfJ.~~OO~ , i.t100~~~ ?i&rmff$fNZ ' ~ , ~{Jj ~~-Jtl:;~~~ 1:EZP:IJiJ{Jj~~tEga~~~!1lG~,~, ' {g1:E~~#:k?5t. 0. a. a. 0. 0. ,. ~3jtFJlIj~~~~59l:mZ ~OO~~:fO~~~~l:ftJiiBJ~OO~lJi. 0. 0. ttgarm~~IPJ*-~~ (Dwyer & Coward,. 1990). t) Stoller (1994) ' 19~tzo : *~~ ,. 0. ~If'F. ~f91Jfftt~I f'F. 1990; Horowitz, 1985; Stoller,. 0. , !13ttWit~~~*.Rm:1:J:t1$*1tl:I5~!13t£. o. , lI1G~m~If'F ' t)&~ffH ' rm~~tJH:J:t-1!:!;;. fZSlrtt~fI:~.A~~l6mEl aj!~R~~. 0. tzDlPJfL~~i§ : r 4-Z~~ , ~~ffE. ' . ~fjg~Jt ; ~~ , fiiJJ;)gU3f? J C*~W' 1998) i.t1~t r ~n~ J ~flJ2f1"*~ ·. 0. 0. ~T~~~~~~,:m~~1:E~lli~m~~zoo~~~~~±~oo~~ e~.A. ~1. jbf it. ' A. ~ 1Jt.1:t :f plJ( '1Il! « 1Jt. :it ~ k:f ~ l!!J r.., ~. ? 1:E*~~rp , Wit~~1lt~:l:Ela~~14:' f91Jtzo : ~Fff~*' w~e. M~o~~±l~*,~*-. ~1t~trr, lEtrrj!If'F"~~~1i' OO.Att~~n~1J' ~~~~rm~OO~~ e~. =itT. *~~rp~W:~1:E~.~fN{~f4:1JiJ. ' tEgljl:~~~gt~~l.fl1l. 0. ~~. 0. Lawton, Kleban, Moss, Rovine, & Glicksman (1989,1991) ~:mWit~~. ,. l!!J? 1t~:tt? (C. ( 51 El. Kasper & Steinbach, 1994). 0. ~§. Z · ~~~e~iR:J:E~. 0. .R~i!M~Il~::;;L\t~~. 0. ~tt.!f&trr~,. 0. i.t1gtj!~. OO~~~~i.t11lt±Il~~"Ela~OO~~~. 0. rna. J;)fd:1lt5tt!!!~~rm§ , Call :fO Finch ( 1999) m:¥U~1:f:~:tc~~5(e~. 1:E*~~rp,~~~~Wit~~~"j!~~~~~m~~'~~w.ff' fr±1lt3(~WBJ!Il~:t[1t;; ~~fliite:fO~e~~'mf1Xmj!~Ii~ItJ1J (Allen 0. & Walker, 1992). +-ijI.). ,~, «itk~~.:it.~.~"'«f:~lf.t«4l1Jt.' «f:~li~~*~-6] ak,«••« • • '~A.~1Jt.r~~*.'~~~~:f~J o«.~ ,tJJjljA.1Jt.:it-6].' Jt,) ~4IfUr' ~1.. A. ~~4lt*'jlt"'H:t' M1:t1t• • (F 7\:.±). , ~iI*f.ij , R;mj!-f~~ Mn ~~~&\aJtt~-I!:!;;~rn~g~Ela~iR:J:Ej!lEur~ , J;)1lf:§a~~~*~ 1JiJ~~~~Il~::;;:I:. •• ~~~.·~?~~~~*k#*.. «~~ • •1Jt.«k~k.~~:it • • '~*«.L*l!!J • • '~« ••• ~.~_~,~ •• ~.A.~.~~.:it.l!!J.~,J;lM.. ;~q!l±lllt:gm El aj!~~JE~~nE1J*iPpjJEOO~~~* · *;ft~~~lm~e m~~~~. , :it,,~ ~1. /Dt it. l!!J. "'. · ·~ ·.·.·. .... ¥. '~JE~~1lt~~Ii~e7~£~ftgfl'ntl~JE~.ff~. fr±1lt5t~~~,~:m~~~1:EWit~~~~~~m~~~~T~e~~;fim WJ . rtt7'J£~tftHt~RWJJJj(JlJj (generalized reciprocity) *~~~~~~Wit 0.

(16) Ii. 'Qf :HA.. A+f--kJKt,IIJ:t : ~.!ft::t.;fJ1~. ~. ,li1JB"Jli1t~:ml:f1*f-j)(-BlB"J ~J~tw~~ , fflZ.1f:: T:ft ~,li1J@J~¥tl)(-Bl~~B"J $75 . f-j~~B1~tJ@JtI ' ~~¥tlm,:~· ftttf)jal:~;g~~ , tE@JtI)(-Bl('8 IL<@:l:1~1i1tP!'~~·::f~' :ft5GtJ@JtI)(-BlJ~UlB"J1PJ1f.!j 'tt2~ilf-j)(-Bl( ¥-f )jtl~~) B"Jft{/lH 5G TtE@JtI)(-BlB"JJi~\Ullf.!j , ~1jtt2ftt~~fDiFH!*;gOO,li. 1i¥-f)jU('8~~. ";ii-t"" 73. 0. ~jlfiIT:;t*1f.!j. , ~,li1J~*3tFflt1itl:)jUl:('8~~ *~~5tTWil,rm1J , ~WJilt~:f?i1¥*11 :ft5t~U1Jtt~ltff- , ~flliHLI:ftR~;:tt oi:l[OO~:mfD Harris (1998) lJz. Delgado & Tennstedt, (1997) ~~~ 0. f,!;1~~,rm. 0. Jig:g, :¥~f)t.fffD~U~*;g~,liB"JT:ft ' ::f~tt:)jtl ' fD)(-Bl~;Iillf1-m::f:;t 0. Woffi~;g'OO,liB"Jft{mfi~fD.ff'*mfi~~*l:~Rff'~~B"J,tt2. 0. :m~*l:-~o. ~~~fD)(-Bl1i~;Iift{/iflB"JT:ft~::flt~ § af-j)(-BlB"J~,Ii~l:f1~.ff ' m • ffi~ . Ult~~fim~~@JftafiW~~fDft{lI{lfltl1ifElrBJ *!jffi ~ Z ' f-j~ -Bl1i@Jtl L'B"JT:ft ' im-mtt2lt~:g~ § cfD)(-Bl1ii1f~ft{m (:ft5tfiS~ ) ~£. ~~*~~tt2~:m'~U1J±fi~~§a~~r. 0. J. ,*mJ~~rft. mJ*~~~m('8ffim~('8~:1J~jlUij~.~*ojffi~~1J±fi~~§c~. ~~~~~~B"J~~~*(5tT~:g,) •. UI*~~. r W~m('8ft{m J. '. r W~m@i;11fW J. ('8~U1J. '. ~,Ii('8*~~tt:;~. ~~,tt2~~~o~~~~T:ftB~W~mft{m~~'ill~.fftt2~~,~. ~,liB"JjlfiIT~~~!ie* ' ~~~~:ltftftA.('8WhJtlJW3tFf -:!N:jffi~ , Wil,li. ::tJtt2tt~* ,tt2gt~~::f~*. 0. 1JB"J~~'T:ft'~~~~ltWhJtlJOO,lioffi~~~Wil,li~A~~~*!~~('8. IfF • ffitt2f,!;1~-mlt~.¥tl~~rBJ1*W~~B"JI1IIf,*. 1iI.li.itt it k. ~:1JfD::ftR~B"J'lt~. ; jffi~~::fmj!~w~U('8~flj1J. ,tt21i~*. 0. 0. ~¥, *~~1i-®~Ifj1J9;OjJ[~*~rtijim*Mf('8mJtlJ. 1if!({1l5tT Wil,li1J~f1iI:¥U~ 7 ::f:fff~:;t:;tffg~ . jffi *~:;t:;tWhJtlJ~U ~~~1i-IN:ffMfB''J:1J.~BfIfr:fttl:~~Wil,li1}~ , jffi::f~~,Ii § c('8~-Bl. 0. ~~tt2~1f.!j. fJH!1;7~U1J~:1J('8fffiR i£i®~rtijim§m r fiS*~3!I! J '. r tE~ijim J ' rcm;;j:b ,tJlJz.*§~"~A~B"JWhJtlJ E8~~~efJ~ff~A('8~fIj, ijim**1tOJ ~ffi~fEl~~~B"Jfiltg ~J7g1i~~~:m~Jtl ~rtijimW~~~rt ijim('8lmf**R1m('8 ( g.~ . 1998) 0::f~' ~Jtl~J:tijbimfPJ:p.fftE)jUl: ('8~~ 5tTtt~::flt~~Jtl~J:tijim ' gt.1itE~Jtl ' tt2~E8:;t;kffi~tt ('8.~ ; jffi:ft5tJ:!ljtt~lt~*9f.:W('8~rtHbim ' ~fDg.~ ( 1999) ~~1i. 0. 0. m·~~1i®*~:mtEr~~§c:;t:;t~u~~)(m'mB"J~~*~~~~ Wil.ll$l;:: t1~B"J1}~ tE~~ ft 1r1B"Jli1t~¥U!t~:ft 5tWilU1JB"J B fIfr:fttl:('8 tLi!i. 0. 0. 0. ~.. 0. tE~~rBJ1*~.B"J$ft ' Barber & Pasley (1995) ~~T:ftWil,li1JW~. ~HBIPJI('8~:mo. ~WilU1J;fEltt ' T:ftWilU1J~J[Uijf-j~:g,B"Jfi'3tg"H1H~~~B"J~:1J WilU1J('8. ~~ltf,!;1~Wil,lijffi1iffiffg~'jffif-j§CT:fttt2~lt~~OO,li·OOU1Jim-mlt. :fff~~-~~fiRfD;gif ' {g~OJIfi§fflZOOU1J;f§~*B"J~:1J f1)jU~~11II. 0. . : :. .. 't ~ J:. 69 J.@, }ij. 0. ~~·l:1i-®~~·*~~B"J:ft5G'~~fflZ~~~OOU1J,:g,lt*~~*. ~B"J~~·5GT'~fflZ~~~~U1J'B::f~~~~TB"J~~·~~Am~. 7J1!Efek:llk9} , ~1I1B:fc~::f~~T~WWil,li E8J1t~~~~rBJ1*B"J~.~~,~. B"J.. 1i~~f~l:I.1~m 5tTtf:lIf'F:ttE~ fflZ~~~fIj~:1J('8:ttE15 ' f,!;1~tt2::flttE f'F~ffiWIPJ$~~~UB"J~~W~:1J. tE*~~tp. , 5t T OOU1Jtt~~z.J.I.ij~('83Z:Ff ' tt~::flt±IIJ~*~tE;fd:ltJi~l¥JmJtlJ • ~m ::f~~'§~i1f~ , ff*1t.3Z:FfIllIl::f:;tt1:g~~~Jtl Smyth fD Harris ( 1993) ~2~f-j5tT~U1Jjffi~ , il!JIj~~Ji~llJf!I:g~::f.('8~m ' ~~fElrBJ;fd:ltil I. 0. (Harris, 1998). 0. 0. ~Ult~.¥tl~~B"JrBJ1*'Brody ~A( 1989)~:g~~)(m~~WilUIf.!j ,. T:ftlt~~~~~m~-mB"J$'~oo~~-mlt~~M*fiR~B"J~~~~~o *6}f~~:mWilU)(-BlIf.!j~~B"JrBJ~1i3Z:iiWJl~ , H~~ • f)t*6}f~;g¥U ' ~~~U1Jllf1-m~-ooA~re~$.ff,~~~~:g,~w~~mJtlJ~~'1i ~~~tt2ltft~-®WilUI~.tE*6}f~~'T~:ftW:lt~~~B"JrBJ~~~. flJfI.f!I~IiIIf.!jJ!~~~l:('8Ji*4' tJ11H~ijim('8Ji~' *.ml:~tJ1l&('815 rt·:lt~'±fi~~§afflZ~~U1J('8~~,lt~.~U1J('8~~'illtt21i. ,j. ~t1~~i:I[®~~, jffi1i7::f1PJ('8~~o~~tzDfi:iJ' :¥~~I:I.1~1Jff-®rBJ~ W~-ffJ:~1ttt~::fW('8. ~~·It!lB"J~Ifj~m. 0. • , 1!\!i. , ltfflJfff*~~U('8$ , W~m1ii1f~ft{/ifl('8 .ml:B~l'ff8c&~~~B"J~~ , fH:¥~~tJc~~~rrr.

(17) f1j:.aif;.k*~l:.t"*~ 75. A-++*M,_:t : ~~~.:t.AJJtf. /4 ~:k-i!\. 1¥Jl1{?,~. 0. IZSlJlt. ~l¥Jo. '1£lt~,litt~lHrll~§~~~. , ::t1ti~~I¥J~tIlfW~fi!j;lI;:1iJP)'. ~~ ... m. -'Tft~~tt~m~~*~l¥Jm~W~W~f~I¥J~~~~o. mRB ,ti]jafJJ1iJ;m-¥a-~~~ ft 5G~Mtx: el¥JiWfJHl!P)' f&~fj8~ti0~ , IZSl JIt~&,~ltffi±~*~:iirrtt]j~1¥J flff mE.' IEJtn~~~~Hit.~5tm!-~mtm '¥-f]jtl~ltft5G~Dtt~ W i£mI¥JP)'1£~n~~~Ii;~tn~~tt~~ Jtrp , ft58n~~fluaa:~ ttr!~ Z ' 1iJPJ~~Btti~~-"~lt1:J ' ~~Bttt±ljj..¥JJH'~'I~l¥Jij~n;~§ , fH~~ ml ffiJlt~~~JffW~rdj~.B]TJ:ttl:tJO~1Jrn.lm~~f]{]fJt1~ ~J:.fJJ1iJP).m~~p)'~~f02JS1¥J~~. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. ..=:. .. hJf Jt FlHM. -,tf:9:.~~filil. pgi1&$ , 1997. <r:p~~\lm)\+E.1f.1?;A~ftjJt~:i!f~~) , tlit : pg~$ MtlITlfto. pg~$' 1996. <rp~~~j\+1i41?;A~;kR~:i!fmiJ!7tffD' j7q~g~~ Jr. ~~~ 'tii..li:!f:f£' ~jERSA ' 1991.<~.i.1!!WiJi5<~~~~A::tJ!~Utt ~{iijiff?£&;1tr;*z~~litf~> ' (0~~:!.E) ,. *UJf:re1£UJf:reJ:.~~lIpNfIj~. , W5~:tl*ttty. ,. 0. ;It..ft~~ff81?;. AJ~~~ttPJ"'c~!lS~ , TftiiHm!tt!itF~J!l¥Jtbb~tt~15 *UJf:reW5~lt~pN 0. ~~5I¥JTft::t~~titt ' IZSlJltftA.J:.Y7~t~ 1JoJ:.t§~~WJI¥J1ffM 0. '. IZSlJlt.Rtig~~FIEAriM{liUf~1~~IDJ~~if~~IDJrJ:l' tilfU~l£~~.ft*~~:lI~ 0. tI¥aJa1~tt. ' -erfi5tt]jtl . tt!!.liI ' tfM,~J:E '. B*\1tj~ffi~. , {IIfJJf~~~. 0. *UJf:re§l¥Jftftt±l-~::tftttf]{]*~,~, Mz~~itUlfBf]{]m$ PfiPJ~$m~~ 0. PfitfTftf]{]~B~om='ffi~;II;:~~W5~'~~~~W5~tt~.tf~rp~. J:.l¥JflffffiJJt, 7*~:mJt~j*. , o~~3tti81:1tt~ff • ffiJltlt~fl&flfff]{]~Dtt~. ' *UJf~fJJlt~Dtt::tItif]{]*~~~~, ~~.If'F ' ~. ~~,lif]{]ffi~'~&~Dttf]{]n~~~fJt~7tfif~f]{]~~o*UJf:re~mtt. ]ja~ftW1~.::tIU~~~~~1t~f~I¥J~$' 1iJ~EE~:tl*.*y, ~$¥} 0. 0. 237-247. 8J1Ml ' 1998.<~A~FIEA;fDIEJt!\ijti.~IU1{*L:fJJ~ : tt~AfDB. ~tr:p{,<If'F~ta~~ElI¥J~t~5tffTtH~> ' (utti1&~!fi!~d:1t.If'F~ flD . 2(1). , 3-38. 0. 8J1Ml ' 1999.<~~f.OC~:(£IEAiii±1tn~~~~~15Z:fJJ~ : ttM~'iJ. J:li!1¥J1i!fti7tffT~ Af.OC4 T3(f]{]~15 > ' (\lm~f4~~~1tlitf~.flJ : X~;&id:1tf4~) , 9(2) , 347-363 • *~~~m' 1998. (r:p\lmAI¥J~. ~~) , tlit : ~~)(1t 0. 0. §lfE~~J:.~f]{]llHfttl. TP).7t~. 18(3) ,. **UJf~Sl[J5IrEiJPJ~]l!~f]{]tt*~. , 1iJP)'¥!}~Am1t1. 0. ;tt~. ,. J:ElU1f*;II;:1H*f¥!}:ii-?J7m1~I¥J;[~ *UJf~~m~7fJtfft:$fJ}~mjj.., ~ 0. P)'*~~~WJ~.::t. ' ~~lU1f*ttlft~~~ . f~ , !MlIT~ • fi*f-fJtf]{] , ftW5 ~~'i"~fM~rJ:l'~J:E~i*~ , -IfflMlwttiBl~ : ftfMJt.m~~~m1Hff iIi *~j®JL*I¥JW5~m: ' It* J:EI¥J~®fW~tP.~1tt±lm ' ffiJlt**UJf~~ &,J!¥!} 7Ilm". tfr.t~ . 1993.<1?;AiiiHjr5i:fi!j*~W~Ajji±1tr;* : :Mt~li\p:glljji±~5[ ~m;A> '(U1t3C~r",~mz~~)' .:E\lm~::tji . lUi : ~:ftr:pIE::k ~iii±1tiMIJUJf~J5JT. 0. fi~J!~ , 1993. (iii±W~fj81?;A~FIEA~Uttl¥J¥-fti~~firr) , tl.*~ 0~~~UJf~J5JT~±~)(o. ,. *ml~ 1996. (Mffj!Mm.Zrfl~ : ::ktlittt!!.WiB\1tjf.OC1f.T3(t:llH~1?;4 )tre~Uf]{]~~1:1!M~firr~~) , tl.*~id:1t~litf~J5JT~±~?X: 0. 0. tii..lYJJ~ ,. 1995.. (..=.ttraJ~ : ~,~!Mr.g~n ' tlit : Efmi,. 0. tii..lYJJ~ • .:E~)lG , W~~ , 1995. < ~A~U~fiE~Al¥Jm;l:Jt : -~it ft!M:l!iftl¥J~i5-litf~> '(0~1t~)'. :fa;*!iI~ ,. Il*t&JI§ ,. 1997.. 1988.. 22(2),99-113. 0. ut11UJf:rem~) , tlit : Efmi. •. {~3(I¥J~m~1:1 ' 5[~~Mt ' !M~~{@ft ' \1tjm~JE.

(18) 10 ~*iI\. ~-+-T*,~.:ft. : ~!It:Z:flJ~. ~ iL.Ki{;.k ~;f±,"~:;a 77. IYJliIH*> ' f'Ti!&/5Jt~f41t:~n!IHiJf~iltIU$;*~~ (fltilJlilJiJE NSC76 0301-H004-010-B). "Caregiving Daughters and Their Local Siblings: Perceptions, Strains,. 0. jifIM~. , 1991.. <WIYJ~1W1iJf~::tJ$ > ' ii~t. and Interactions," The Gerontologist, 29, 529-538. : {j<E'tBJt&ifd:. 0. Brubaker, T. H. 1990. "Families in later life: A burgeoning research area,". ~1W*fE' 1992.<~:g:Affrii!:flj1l**lfi!&Jff' ~ra~W~&!IIYJ5tItJ;:it> t:f:1¥ ~~J\+-1f~~Ut~1iJf~1t;jii1tffiii!:fU5tm1iJf3i:¥&~ R ;;:iIDUt. Journal ofMarriage and the Family, 52, 959-981.. 0. lli. 0. ii~t : pqi!&$. 0. 116-134. Call, ; Finch, K. T. 1999. "Caregiver burden from a social exchange. 0. perspective: Caring for older people after hospital discharge," Journal of. ~~~ • ;rJ~PM ' 1995. <UtJLii~tm;jilmi:g:Aooo~~ZliJf~ ___ 9(f1~. ~Aifd:miOOO1l*~1n ' ii~tmifd:1tr.u~~t;.i!1iJf~~~. Marriage & the Family, 61(3), 688-699.. 0. Chang, C. F., & White-Means, S. I. 1991. "The men who care: An analysis. ~~~ , 1982. (fri1t~> ' ii~t :'. of male primary caregivers who care for frail elderly at home," The Journal ofapplied Gerontology, 10,343-358.. "::"~j:~~,,13.l. Chow, N. 1996. "The changing status of the elderly in the AsiaJOceania region," Hong Kong Journal ofGerontology, 10, 115-117.. Ainsworth, M. D. S. 1989. "Attachments beyond infancy," American. Psychologist, 44, 709-716.. Cicirelli, V. G. 1983. "Adult children's attachment and helping behavior to elderly parents: A path model," Journal of Marriage and the Family, 45,. Allen, K. R., & Walker, A. J. 1992. "Attentive love: A feminist perspective. 815-824.. on the caregiving of adult daughters," Family Relations, 41(3), 284-289.. Cicirelli, V. G. 1995. "A measure of caregiving daughters' attachment to. Almberg, B., Grafstrom, M. & Winb1ad, B. 1997. "Major strain and coping. elderly mothers," Journal ofFamily Psychology, 9, 89-94.. strategies as reported by family members who care for aged demented. relatives," Journal ofAdvanced Nursing, 26, 683-691.. Cicirelli, V. G. 1993. "Attachment and obligation as daughter's motives for caregiving behavior and subsequent effect of subjective burden,". Barber, C. E. & Pasley, B. K. 1995. "Family care of Alzheimer's patients:. Psychology and Aging, 8,144-155.. the role of gender and generational relationship on caregiver outcomes,". Journal ofApplied Gerontology, 14 (2), 172-183.. Coward, R. T. and Dwyer, J. W. 1991. "The Longitudinal Study of Residential Differences in the Composition of the Helping Networks of. Barber, C. E. 1988. "Correlates of SUbjective burden among adult sons and. Impaired Elders," Journal ofAging Studies, 5, 391-407.. daughters caring for aged parents," Journal ofAging Studies, 2(2), 133 144. Beeman, S. K. 1995. "Maximizing credibility and accountability in qualitative data collection and data analysis: A social work research case example," Journal ofSociology and Social Welfare, XXII (4), 99-114. Bowlby, 1. 1982. Attachment and loss: Vol. 1. Attachment (2nd ed.). New. York: Basic Books.. Brody, E. M., Hoffman, C., Kleban, M. H., & Schoonover, C. B. 1989.. .. ,. Delgado, M. & Tennstedt, S. 1997. "Puerto Rican sons as primary caregivers of elderly parents," Social Work, 42(2), 125-134. Dwyer, J. W., & Coward, R. T. 1991. "A multivariate comparison of the involvement of adult sons versus daughters in the care of impaired parents," Journal ofgerontology, 46, 5258-5269. Dwyer, J. W., & Miller, M. K. 1990. "Predicting primary caregiver stress and burden: Residential differences in the caregiving network," Journal ofRural Health, 6, 161-184..

(19) mi'L.ilt)~k"~±'i"":fIl. 79 78 ;iij:l il\. A1f.-r-k,flil,,I1Ji;t :. Dwyer, J. W., Henretta, J. C., Coward, R. T., &. ~!~:Z;f}]~. Loomis, L. A., & Booth, A. 1995. "Multigenerational caregiving and well. Barton, A. 1. 1992.. being: The myth of the beleagured sandwich generation," Journal. "Changes in the Helping Behaviors of Adult Children as Caregivers,". Family Issues, 16 (2).131-148.. Research on Aging, 14, 351-375.. McGrew, K. B. 1998. "Daughters' caregiving decisions: From an impulse to. Dwyer, 1. W., & Seccombe, K. 1991. "Elder care as family labor: The influence of gender and family position," Journal. 0/ family. 247.. a balancing point of care," Journal 0/ Women & Aging, 10 (2), 49-65. Issues, 229 Mercier, J. M. & Shelley, M. C. 1997. "Quality of adult child-aging parent. relationships: A structural equations approach using merged cross. Finley, N. J., Roberts, M.D., & Benahan, B; F. 1988. "Motivators and. generational data," Family & Consumer Sciences Research Journal, 26. inhibitors of attitudes of filial obligation toward aging parents," The. (2); 160-192.. Geronologist, 29, 73-78.. PaW , D. K. 1998. "Qualitative methods in social work research,". tt Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.. Guba, E. G. & Lincoln, Y. S. 1989. "Fourth generation evaluation," pp. 228-251. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.. Piercy, K. Hamon, R. R. 1992. "Filial role enactment by adult children," Family Relations,. 0/. W. 1998. "Theorizing about family careg 1vmg: the role of. responsibility," Journal 0/ Marriage & the Family, 60 (1), 109-116.. 41(1),91-96.. Piercy, K. W., & Bliexzner, R. 1999. "Balancing family life: How adult. Harris, P. B. 1998. "Listening to caregiving sons: Misunderstood realities.. children link elder-care responsibility to service utilization," Journal. The gerontologist," 38(3), 342-352.. 0/. Applied Gerontoloty, 18 (4), 440-459.. Horowitz, A. 1985. "Family caregiving to the frail elderly," Annual Review. 3 Sankar, A. 1993. "Culture, research, and policy," The Gerontologist, 3 ,. o/Gerontology and Geriatrics, 194-246.. 497-498. Kasper, J. D. & Steinbach, U. 1994. "Caregiver role appraisal and caregiver tasks as factors in ending caregiving," Journal. 0/ Aging &. Sharlach, A, Lowe, B., & Schneider, E. 1991. "Elder care and the work. Health, 6(3),. force: blueprint for action," Lexinton, MA: Lexinton Books.. 397-415.. Sheehan, N. W. ,& Donorfio, L. M. 1999. "Efforts to create meaning in the. Kaye, L. W., & Applegate, J. S. 1990. "Men as elder caregivers: Building a. relationship between aging mothers and their caregiving daughters: A. research agenda for the 1990s," Journal 0/ Aging Studies, 4, 289-298.. qualitative study of caregiving," Journal. Kramer, B. J. 1993. "Expanding the conceptualization of caregiver coping:. Lee, G. R., Dwyer, J. W., & coward, R. T. 1993. "Gender differences in parent care: Demographic factors and same gender preferences," Journal o/Gerontology: Social Sciences, 48, S9-S16.. Lee, Y., Parish, W. L. & Willis, R. J. 1994. "Sons, daughters, and intergenerational support in Taiwan," American Journal o/Sociology, 99, lflHLlfli11. 13 (2), 161. 176.. the importance of relationship-focused coping strategies," Family Relations, 42(4),383-391.. 0/ Aging Studies,. (. •. Smyth, K. A., & Harris, P. B. 1993. "Using telecomputing to provide information and support to caregivers of persons with dementia," The Gerontologist, 33,123-127.. Starrels, M. E., & Ingersoll-Dayton, B. 1997. "The stress of caring for a parent: Effects of the elder's impairment on an employed, adult child," Journal o/Marriage & the Family,59 (4), 860-873.. Stoller, E. P. 1990. "Males as helpers: the role of sons, relatives, and.

(20) 80 *-l.1i\. A~T*,1!\'{.;t. lil-i!..iIk. if;; k ~;f! i" ~. 81. : ~~.:t:fn~. friends," The Gerontologist, 30, 228-235.. ~~A-~ ~hji €J!j 1t*n-1r A 12ft 1t. -J'A A~,~~tf ~~:t &..ft. ~hi {oo ~ if J!.A1ff. Stoller, E. P. 1994. "Teaching about gender: The experience of family care offrail elderly relatives," Educational Gerontology, 20, 679-697. Stone, R. I., Cafferata, L. and Sangl, 1. 1987. "Caregivers of the frail elderly: A national profile," The Gerontologist, 27(5), 616-626. Suitor, 1. J. & Pillemer, K. 1993. "Support and Interpersonal Stress in the. Jil. • Social Networks of Married Daughters Caring For Parents with. Dementia," Journal o/Gerontology: Social Sciences, 48,. ~ it .. ~J.t* .. ,*-" .. tF.l.f ... ~.f~... JHr-." ~*§... ..". SI-S8.. Suitor, 1 1 & Pillemer., K. 1994. "Family Caregiving and Marital. ~~~.t-. Satisfaction: Bindings from a I-Year Panel Study of Women Caring for Parents with Alzheimer's Disease," Journal. 0/ Marriage and the Family, ~~~Q~~t+~~AI.·.~ •• ~I.AA.~~~. 56,681-690.. (practice-based research) t,l. VA ~ ~ A A • 'b I . (research-based services) '(lHt-<t-f.l~.AA.ilb~~ (agency-based research) t,l.-<t-:;>o..~ ~ -ia 1+ A t: II:. (intervention research: design & development; D & D) • VA. Suitor, 1. 1, Pillemer, K., & Keeton, S. 1995. "When Experience Counts: The Effects of Experiential and Structural Similarity on Patterns of. ~~M.~ •• t,l.$'A~ •• nA~.~~.B~L •• ~.~.~. .~ •• ~~ ••.• ~~.~~~.t,l._~~.~ •• ~.A't,l.~ • •• -<t-:;>o...,._~.~ •• ~~~:;>o..lt·~*~~M.~ •• t,l.$' A'.B*'~.·~.fn •• ~t:II:.t,l..B'.B.~ •• ~e·. .~W~t,l..ft'.I ••• ftM$t:a.~ •• laa~~j·~ •• n.~.~~·~.a~~~+~«~ •• 4~~a~·~.fn.~Q 1 • • • • RI~t+.~~ •• ~~AI~;.~~~~~~·~~·. Support and Interpersonal Stress," Social Forces, 73, 1573-1588. Walker, A. J. & Pratt, C. C. 1992. "Perceived reciprocity in family caregiving," Family Relations, 41(1),82-85. Walker, A. J., Pratt, C. C., & Eddy, L. 1995. "Informal caregiving to aging family members: A critical review," FamHy Relations, 44 (4), 402-411.. ~.AA.~-<t-:;>o..~~·.*·t.ti."*.~~.~~~~A.ta. ~~ ••B•• ~Ah~·a~.~~~ •• A.:;>o..~~~~-<t-:;>o..~~~ ~ •• ~.,M.~et:a~-<t-:;>o.. •• t.~tia1+BM~~ft$.~~ ~4., •• AA.t,l.-<t-:;>o..~~tffl~~~~~~~~~Q~~II.~. t:1I:.'mt •• -~ •• t,l.I~·~L~.*.~La.*.~~f •• ~~t.'4~~.I.~~.~A~t~o. ••~: •• AA.~~~·~:;>o..~~·~··n'~~M.~ •• "A 'I. .~;. ~.. • ;$.iIt1t,4IJ1#t"NSC86-2412-H-031-007 i1t1tsUl ; J..!!,tiifiJ{;1.11Lt$-:i:;;f'KitftJ!.;t:R.· ·~A.'iIt1t~.~#A.~.;;f'*Ak.~t"~6.~ •• ;••*'.·#·*A' ~rek.~.~6.*Q.";.*~I •• C~~6'~~#.iIt~*A.*t" ••• fiA;.A.,~ •••• ~ •• t"~·M."I~.~.M.~;A.~~~~.'. t"~~~I~Q*~.M.f.~;.~.'*~·S~~:i: •• •.

(21)