「新公共服務」對政府再造的啟示：歷史發展系絡的解析途徑

全文

(1)?J~-g-:f.!1t. r iii1~D~~ J !~ia1ffi~~Ir9@m. ' 4,. ~FfiU 1t2SZ.W~JJu , ffiJ!~f,fm~JTfljU1i~. :. ~5E~~~*~~M~JT ~f~. ~-g-~if,j€f~i I-f} EY.-C>.J,-I-;:U-f rt>:T.ur' ,ip/::! I 'J Cx.r.>t"J.ra:}E. :*0fJ§A ~~. 1*,:f:flJ il*@fi. HtF[1o rEIJa~ I%f,K%~{i'lJ ? ;lt1:Ef:!l!~ifuW.3%WB~JEf.lz~ l x: E] J-"" , /'-.:;' :L>; 1J.Jj 1t:1J 1_ if,. 'IS;,:. H.N i=r Y;jt 1'Ff::5'<; F1 WE. , :/t}j![ , {£. Robe rt Dcnhardt i(~'2000 4fr. W. J ane t Den ha rdt. { Pub l ic Ad mi n i s tration. rfri~I.:~JiDt J. ~IUtg.W IIA$. Se rvi ng, no t St ee rin g) - )<::1'&' 5 1 ~f'T. ED~g. Jf'J~)W l¥J JJ[y,zm~ifu. Ii1f0 iit IJllmf. ( Th e New Pub l ic Se rv ic e. , t!2 ;\~j.ii; 7\jj§JifJ!!WJ. ~t!t*c.:t~~. l~liW**~. 3=t: ~ IJ),-~$JT !5j!~25(~ ' fj r1f25( ~ , ph j ~ , tzo:~UJl ifr~:t::J ~ ft:. ). 0. mEE ttt)!:{~ME03=t:f'Tj[:5<:W~JT03=t: ~f:!l!B~m!m ili.D.+r:;:~tJ D / ' I ..n. HiS. .... , ./J 1) 11/ 11. - +-rr§ ;r:hili/ '-. /+'.x../, IJ1/,M/'-.:f±/.!l::L>; ./, l J)I'x..... ,:L>;. .v.AI-!~ '. W!i& <The New Pub li c Se rvice - Se rvin g,. 1&J0B~JE.!Z:{*frfiiJ~$~*~T~± ffiJ NPS. 0~1J1&. lf~. Denh a rd t ~ = A f-t~' NPS l¥JP1li1i ' flf~. 3=t:~f:!l!BS~~~m:*~~ ':i£ ~~[1:i£~~. ~Uffl S'9;f§ lUJfEli1i. ~1iB)iGJfi!i; ~%. 0. 200 3 if:. not St ee ring ). r ' .Mz ~ 1j~~. = ApJTtjE!YJpqli1i~1wJK~. Rev i ell' > ~fUL~* r ~JT03=t:ij~~ : E~~ ,. Mz~~~8~thM4}]. , .MzfJt~. fpJ? {~J;)~-*flj~m;fJT~4-1&J0¥}i§2SZ.~JT 03=t:E ~~f!lIZ:l¥J;f§~JEf.lz ~= ' ~J1J~~0 3=t:E ~fJ§1'F*l~tt BSil'*H ' MzJ;) De nh a rd t ~ . 0. /9::. ,~~~. IfJ. HU ~. l, F.. r ff1&~pfr. JE ~. ,. iJi ... '. -~. '. 1iBIr5 ]}:® A 1~ n~. ,. ~t-~j;;j1t§YlI3J.lMzttf~7~. (Th e Old Pub l i c Admini s t r a. ' $JT 0 3=t:~f:!l!. ti on ). ~13J.ltii!lli§YlI3J.l ~03=t:. ~la n a g e m e n t. , NPM). ( Th e New P ubl i c. W~JT03=t:E~~. Pub I i c Se rv i ce, NPS). l¥J pq~. itfJfJ4-f'T1&25(1f1i:l¥J.:t1JfE:. l¥JI~.. r :i£~~1&R~ J. f-tll:t~i§nlGfiiJ~~~ ?. @ffij[i'=iJfr ~ ~[1. ~:i£~~j[:5<:J0. '. lZSlll:t ' m =. NPS ~~~!YJ1f)Z1~7 NP M. ;ttJE{.lz~{iiJ? ~®f'T1&i3;Zl¥. l¥J ~flliI;ttruJ {* ;f.€,fiiJ. ?. ~ ~ · *y:'BSB~~.tzo{~- > M. ( Th e New. , ;ttTWtjEJE: '. '. 7G ' TI(z§YlRjJ:tmT : * y:. ~ [1l¥J .:t , J±j ~ -. ~03=t: f'T i& B~ r~. ~~~~~~m~Wm.'$0~~~~. m:'~EE~~1&fflWB1&B.~l¥JB1&~. to ' $h03=t:E ~fJ§ M%mz1~$JT03=t:~f:!l!. ( Publ ic Adm i nis t ra tion ,PA) '¥U 1970 !iF. (:i£~~. (New Pub 1i c Admin i . JIJJM). ' nI(Jf{~j[:5<:R~¥}j§ ' f'T1&l¥~JT B~m.~ f9t. {~1'&B~ ~JT 03=t: f'T1&. fl~:1:im. 0. - , NPA) .- 7J 0 - ~f-l-i! -)-dim§ I' -ei'/"' :f±~; s tr a tlon 5xn::«.:c'l'III/, ~ m:L>; __n g. £~~tt B~TWtjE. , *)<::tiHf-tW1&J0f'T J&c;z~;f§~B/::J~f;jtJf:!l!~~m:W{l flliI.:t~ , It -J1t'£:~m:ijf~B~tfElJ. ' [1~ l¥JffijrPJ ~= : ~- , 03=t:f'T1&~~03=t:~f:!l!B~~m: ' ]}:®~~. lJ. ( Pu bl ic Ma nagement, PM) ¥U1 980 !iF{~ BS ~JT03=t:~f:!l! (NPM). 0. fffi;ttrs~pfii'lm:DJ~. , 0 3=t~;f:!l!pJTf~§iDJ r gffi $:i£~ J wm ' Mz:JF§ ~ n~ 1 98 0 !iF {~pJTJml¥J03=t:~. {*ru~. ~.lJ. >1J 03,. AilF.HU. m36~m5111l. i. 213. 9.

(2) ... !J.Mm§ , ~:#1=ri&B"J ~mtl£: CP~1:f~JH~B~m. ~Jt;l]:ct. ~ ' ®~§~~1:f ,~ o~~ ,~:#ft~~. 1, gyt r ~~8~l!B~ freE ~ J 1'F~~ 7T~ £Ul. #~~®~ , ~ ft~:#1=ri&~ M~~~.~. ( Henry' 1989: 20 - 51 ; ~!~ }~t ' R8 1 :. 1PJf1I[1ijJ1* ? ~ -. 7- 17; ~5E~ ' R 87:27-28). m7 ll:tWi*~~3::fffl1~'. 3Zw.:~~ B~B~ ~ pJT~1lz1i':}:E NPA. , :ftll:t:'fl~B~ nJii~cp , NPS. ft. IPM~.L'>-rl1E. '. ~f. fm~~ r ~. ""IJ El F,:ffi-===-±6h*h/. !R }:E~%. '~' JD' f'I~ 'fj'\lJ (2)1jiE(~IJ.~W3. ~. pJTm l:e~. Adm in i s t rat ion ). 3Z1~~y~~§t ]IH~'. 0. ' ffiEZ. $~. (1927- 1937). :. r:t ~ :li:1jj( ~ IZ9 ;~ ~ ~ ~ 1=r i& Dj( 0. (3) B ~ 11' ~ tW iE~ 5t:i ~ ~ 8~ W3 . ( 1 9 5 0 . f. 1970) :. ®. m:~ 1'T j[jz ~. ~~~~~ji®g ' ~M~7T ~MT~f1I[7T. ~€. 0. ~ Ij , j;J:i¥fflG*J3.~§;f~. W, Wi I so n. r 1'Tj[jz B~ m~ J ( The Stud y. '. ( 1 ) iE~5t:iW11'iE(53'118'J ~ W3 (1900-1926) : ~~W\mi&lt1~~% ~;&: B~~:EJ!. '. 197. 7t~Ij ~ :. 0. ~:#fri&y~fj~- )\)\-1::: !if. (4)B ~. :. Henry N~ffi&~B~~ji 7T ~1i@~:M. m~MJ ~3::~' ffi~~~e~~ ' *3Z~ ~~~~~1t<OJD. :. -';.{>. 2 . )jy'l,. r /. fJ. ~~ (~. 87 : 1'Ti&~ 1'I'~PJj;J~. ft jIjz m~ EI/:J W t)].~ f% '. (I ) ~ rN~. 193C. grc: , $1t IDtIE (2) ~=. fif~. {-t. 0. FIS H. ,-----------4. ~ - ;~mH~~ffi$:ii::~. k------~ I. ii:::'l;'t:Wpr'f'=-,I-. I. l ___~~~~~~ __ 1. ~,. ~~. (3) m- B. *tJC. 196C. tl: ' [1]-. * 3Z7T;fJT~;f~. :;~rf4* 1W,. 10 .. A ;iF'HU. ~36~~5Jl1l. 213. : 1'F ~ i3 {f,WJ. 1. j;.

(3) tzSJ~j}:]Aj~1§'1:El*~1:L"'\-;tt~,f_Mrjr)g~. ~m:7tB~~1f. (4)U~1jiE~~tm . , .§!;81 :. B~Wl. ~~BJJ~a~8~r~'~ti. 0. (1956. ~B/'J ' ftU~--117\J\1=f:83. 1970) :. D. Wa 1do ~B. '. (Syracuse University). 8) :. (M i nnowb rook) 1¥r~ii ' 1t&®. ~1i1~8~W'l. '. 0~1=ri&$;fEB~tiJf~. W§~:i}jt1Ti&pJT[§j~m;a~F",'Jm. 0. (5)U~1jiE~~tmi}~ijiE~~8~M. 900-1926) :. J,f.,!-:;7. ,1..I-..A--.:,f-~Jjc:.;;.~<J"--'J9V.J...1..... §.3::. '. ~~ (. c. 1~i;1]mm{* '. fkQ~~~. t- ,';T;!J IM.JJ 1=l'J. 31Lm~a"J22:E¥L±~. ' ~1¥r~iiB~ r *Ff:i}jt1=ri&J '. '"~" ~t::f;Q /"\.±l:/-~~'I.. '1J1!i""IJJ<.t»ilA/,,1Tll')(CCF 0. **~J;JJ:::B"J~ffililll;. , .§!; 87 : 22-27 ;. t~i/i5i:.mSJJ~a"J7t1!lT. 1Ti&~Bfj~mH&lfli §. J..j&**B~~. J~f~;f§~M~ffil~.J;B"Jr~g1~~{JfI;Jii'JJff1lJizm~. 87:43-44) :. m (1950. '. ;f§!ltJn-{fJMJ'EB~0jt1Ti&. r 'fJiA'/"lTll')(:l'!'::*-'1 ~~/\.ff:./.-;J:h-~~"'+. ~r~~_~B~~~~ 2 .if>'l. lTll')(~ 5)L'.C'<:i~:lJ:!:::tl!3!1'£ J. B~fTi&'®:. o. ±~&t§mmB"J~~1ffl(.JfA:7. *!tB~W*~13. :7). (1970. .•. ~7L::>.). , ffJj(. , 7t5JU~ : 1li ~Jt;Effi ~ffil8~ M J 'J;J. , 0jt1Ti&Jlt-tiff§t~~ ' -§t3'7 f!;!MfCBf'J0~1=rj[~. -$:::;:.;a,.'~iE-h'7 -H=ml'l --+--;1'". = +tl:I:*cJ;J* '. ,. BFf~~lfJT0jt. fIIIiTM7t~=.1~Il1'EI~~. 1=ri&'*~~1=ri&~M~~m1iOO~M~. (1. f~. r H¥~;flJ! J. 1930. 1=f:{-\. '. f,lJ§ 1900. , J;J& f~-**J'E:EJ!!~ffilB\fM. ~ffil~~*i1:EJtf5}T*~B/j. 0. Q. Marini. {;\ArPJlfJT:i:}jtfTi& :. ~·m.~.~~~'I~~$~e. ;fp;~r£8"J.fm~ti>. ~ftJ..j&1Ti&-g;:EJ.fliffB~f!jUf:!ff ft. Administration :The Minnowbrook. ' liT. Perspect ive) (2)~=Ill-r5~~~f~IDJ.§ffil8\fM J ~~~ ,. ). .§.~m~!I!fli~~. '. f,lJ§ 1930 ~ 1960 1=f:. . Ii *~ 'itt •. I. G<Hjl]l)] ~ tJiUZ. ~·1=rm$~~.*M&A~mm~~. , OJiW?,~mib~ja~fTi&~ (3 )~-Il1'EIw:m-*m;Effi~ffilfr~M ' J;J Ifflf.& -*mJ r • • ;Effi~J ,~§ [1lfJ~. 196 0. 0. 1=f:{-\~4-. c. ~-:lf~CP. ' J;J. ~·~~m;Effi~~M.E'~-~~. ~ Ii ib tl:. (Towa rd a New Pub 1 i c. -:I;!;"-R'. , {RJt.pg~~JtsJllfJT ( Itll'ii~Flt*. 89 : 5 - 7) :. 1. m[Cj]f§rme!Ji}Kfji& ,F'ff:.iT-~rHf1;'h1J- i;~nf"u. Mar ini. A/,,,. J,.J;)(.!n.:!...~j:::..x. I. ~!}]1'IFf3ZB~1-\;f§~MB"Jr",'Jm. JJ .... liT A. :. ;. ffiH~~Jm;~1=ri&.;fEffiH~~Jmo. 2 . i*F§i~~!:ij.~~~R'9 ~~B"J1Ti&tiff§t~rvrJ;J*ffgil:~ r ;f§~m. tI:B"J~Dg~. J '. '1'1 • Iffl fj2'i't1: • @] ~!!H1: . ~.m~_~&~.~~~~~'1iT m~m~~B"J1Ti&~. ,. a"J*~,~'I'1f!1!~ffilij!1~J:::. i1H1:1.11[![B"JtltrU '. 0. ffiJiFr±1¥r0 IEltt:fi:kJ!. B!~1Ti&~filIJtiH§tT~Ji A~FHU !l/'l36~!l/'l5ll1l. 213+ ::.

(4) ®f-tB'J±'~ ili@. f-'¥JEEl'J0;!=t1=ri&pfT5~w~WJf~ f@w/ft§[q]. 0. 3 . ~JJ!IR±~8'SJ!JJ~/f'9:' OOf-tm±Wr ~ B i:fJ:t~EI'J~?i$tiW1i*-~ti '. ~~P D. <:£Z- > cppfT:7f;. *~, ~. ,. ,~. 1M~f[i. •. 0. JiffT0 fr1=ri&S/J ~lf:tEm~"1=rif'xfi. Burea u l. :15$~ lj mjf~§i~fJ.§ifH~tttjU :EJ.§ifH. iHMjfr±Wr*J5(pfT~* EI'J :e~fl{@~ili@]f~. 0fr1ji&EI'J~*fl{@ - tl P ftm-. , t)$Jj~* r 0frtiJ i¥J. fliJ Boyd fW:*Yt 13'{~. ~1~ M]:x;. EI'J 'g:EJ. o. :mjU ~l~'l',IEt. :tE~:(;jtJS'J5E {lI~fJ@L.tiffiiHf!.f. (jJ0~fl. **$~EI'J lj] m~ rlJrJUtJ.l EI'J~t !j!.x. h a r d t ( 199 3 : 19) gtt~ i±l0. 0. De n. ;!=HTif)ztlP:tE. 4. ~~~~JT8'SJ*fUiJt~ i\. ~~~f):£$WfY'C~tmH § f~§ifHS'J!wlj[e. '. g fflt*fI.*~B~$ili1i'1B~{~EI'J~"*. {-'*Jt.EI'J ' ftmEI'J. hi&W~~~i1-iJ8'J*fI.~~~m:m**m~EI'J. (. Jun ( 1994 : 232) ~Ut§Wf-t. flL~tl. :£Z'(·~MJt.S'J0 fri=rif)ZS{Jij:m.=t.~WJfJT0fr 1=rJf'J. l eg i e ). EI~JA *.=t.~JtFs' El/J ~{*. t~; .pJi~. ~~ *S'J&~'. ~;fj~t§~ tifDI}]~ EI'J$~~ 11£ '. ' JttiffJi:. 0. '. ~fJ.P D. :7f; ( "i§ I§1IBJl{I~ , R 86 : 185). (:£Z=> PtT. Ij":xIi':iJ. 0. ~-oo.wc. 0. ( m;. ( eu s ton. 5 . ~nli~~~fOJ8'SJH:Ui. preneu r. ,~. h )\Oi:F 1::f::/< ' :@. , JJl~~ l±mt!:E. 1=ri& 2)( ~. =**~~ '~I~~«*~~~ , :tE~~. iVJl ' f~~. * * EI'J*fI.~~~m!]Hm~ EI'J ?!j i1-iJ W~. "* ' flAf(li$ili1i'1lf '. Jt~{'FS'JlE~'I:i~~f~. ~~ o. 0fr'g:EJ.EI'J:EJ.§ifH~.~~ tli:lm-fPJ~: *~$:~;l)©Z:1i ~. J. J un (1986) ~ U t~ i±I ' JifJT0~i=ri&~. 1. 0. tll;tJsttM~. A, *1W. tX$t~R. pub 1 i c. 1 , if5<:1i:JWi=rif)i:= 5t 2. ij i&cp:lL 3. ~~$W:£.@: :1J. 1. i&mWi=r1&t§1i~ 1* 2. {1fBfJ.JfH 3. m1.R:F",'lm8'9:Xjz:~. 4, ~e5fflm:ffjU. 4. 5t;fflW~W. 5, ~:x 1t tt ~ 6. JjJi'igEI'J *I:fi!f. 5. ~:x 1t \ ~ i& El'J tt~ 6. JjJi'i~W I fF EI'J mJifJT~~~t 7. ~W'I:i s/JmiWr~tli 8 . .=t.1b1Z9B!F",'lmEI'J M1.R: ' ~ilW~~ 9. ft$.W11{@tttjU~~ 10. *fm§77C EI'J ~Ws'J R.=t. 11 . ~~Wij] 0 R*Wjfct~F""Jt§f!!~ 1.R: 12. ZP:1ji'l{'FWA ~ ~ ~. 7.. JJft:iEl/J '. :EJ.' I:i B'J~t.. iE-hI::r:1J11HIEU'lFi i thtaT.J :"rh *Fllii m ~3!"" 8 . ",ct: f)X~J IL:>.I }Jg; I "'J R8j:l Cl rFF {A ' ~~/ ,"'i'" S 9. $WWfl {@=5t 1o. *f~ltj9:J*f lj :fiJi !!llft EI'J ~~j\. 11 . 5~~ if)Z*5ttfTCP .*El'J jEj-fu 12. m:j]n%§JWJWtl~~ {* 13, :R1JKl:~'j;'Ts'J*fI.~m~ 14. j;[ [Jl~fjt ~;f4*1mt. 12 •. : J . J un, 1986 : 50. A~FFfU ~36~~5llll. 213. 13 . ~ ~~j;[1JKl:T~~*~mgt 14. "ji~15t -e- w~n:5(. 1m. I. (cn tr ep l. A'I: if.

(5) , :;@mP.i1t'!tt0#iT1& 11&'Bf]t~iMJ (Post. 1& 'til J]! ~{5!,fj I¥J :ft m ' Right) '~rrYilJ]! (New Governance). ffff*' Overman ~ Boyd ( 1994) 1J!mtb : 0#>gf!I.LItIlllt!}l§3t 1lffi1tg1JK~lj8~~Jj~M*&fljffiUI¥J~'8S~ffiU ' ~1I6.1:1¥J-x~$\!m: ' ~1zl¥JiT1&W\1Tf!JIJ~fDt83* , ffff {t<M1&'E'Hl1t~~5$gJ\'iJ. *;fJJ ' .R 90 : 1 - 2). ) ~rJmH:::\1-t. fll~j[1:. -YJIJ~rJifln~*l'H[!IH~~~. ~JT0#1TiI&. tegic) ,. ffl. ±~~8'il§. ). Bureaucratic Paradigm). {~=} 0. 1~*3. mu~. ( s tr a. (an tic i pa tory) ,. (market. rship)'. (entre. Wil son ~~ {1T1&1iff~} J;J* ' ~8~aJl1. 0~?2.8~. '. : fr-iL- 041i; , 1{f5ttbfJ!. f!.J. -§jCjj , ~B~:;@EB L. Gul ick ?JT~~I¥J~. h:;@ttmtJ1T1&~¥rrffff~~f!.±:R~0#tUti. 0. rro-iL-t:041i;~:1£*~J]!*~. gIi~0#1&**~Jl1.~1tl0#>gJ]!~1iffJ1:;8~]~. ~f*. ~:;@,Y::rEJtft. 1"]- i& 2)<: ~ t:f '8S 1:;7] 8~ ~m ~~~ '1'1 0 11 ' :fBlJliitr/flBlS"JiSrl} , *- ' ::ktfpJ;)/['rJ]!±:R (manage ria 1ism) , MrjJJ~m~~8~0#1T1& (marke t - based. pub lie adm in i s t rat ion). 'JJ:::.?l"::'Z'.JJ.X-11. (entrepreneurial government)' ==~ -:fX.~. ' BtzOlWXrfTillt '. , #!:5Et18~xikWI3)jJt:~1)ffi ,. 88 : 73). ~-. W.. J\J\. ,~m0#>gJ]!I¥JM~~~(.~~'.R. preneur i a 1 ). f~{BJB~ , ~. ~, 1£fl.l[~. ,. '"-" /., lJ JJ.X- 11 :J 5'~ ,17<.. ~ ~~~;F~1&J&8~ Brown 1ow Comm itt e e '. oriented) ,. (customer driven). (. 0. /,,, ±t /... ;a,. r't{1 J?ii; Fi'i'!. (results directed) , (executive 1. (N e w. , Bozeman (1993) mZm:1£*>gJ]!~f4 ~0#>gJ]!~ (B-approach) ~0#1&*3?E 1~1¥J0#~J]!~. (P-approach). (*1&)] ,. 88 : 23 ; f*4:;fJJ ' .R 90 : 6- 7) -iL/\04f~1&. '. c. ~.:g.~iT1&2)<:~8~. , :;@J;Jm~~~m:f:~B'J;JJl¥m*u ' :1£*. /'=-:-ei'+-m 1 ····,·+-nf'!l'+c.t 1J m::r..SQ~,./,X.:::cSQr19~:JJ.... AX±:R. tim 1iffJ1:; }i;jGt Att1~5E. ~;jf3t*1M!. f4~1Y:filtJ #!:5E~OO ~Wl&rnJ mij!IT~f!~~. , ji8~}i*4 :9f-fr8~ ffiU *":1 12SJ-* *IfJB~fffr ' @J!!!tt ' ~WB~. ..... Flt:f='>'.~~' J::3... S .... ..-...... .J~'U. ttn~5tt~ffiU mffr±1Htl¥J~~. : J. J un, 1994: 232 A~FJflJ il1D6~m51l1l. 213+ 13.

(6) F,!!I[:tY: fiILr '. ijli~J% Rilm ~ W ~ ~ ± ,ffj!!l[ 2 E1~. r ~0~F,!!I[J!!I[2'~ff~*~~~~ '. ,. ~~. 1~mRj§W\§t:§7~~. 0. 1JUJ§W-m~M~:t. Yt:mz~. r ~JT0~~!!I[ ~ J ( N e w Pub lie Ma nage ria lim ) (3%**)] , R 90 ; *Jj I3jJ , R 90 : 26 ) 0. Hood ( 1998) 1£mill!;~JT0~F,!!I[~1i1f~ ~~~ti§i::Jj'. r 0~ J. -~EJfi:~i&mW0~. ~~~,ffij~0~fifJ..~~~~~.. ~0~1l. {§.:;;rfi:~~~~zYt:~*E1~fJ.~Hii. f!iJ5j- l.lIj~. ooZtit ' ~~ o. ~trf;7]A. 2 ,1;:£JfjL~18~~~Fs~~~R'CIII~~1'F3IUB '. tLJ\04"-fi:1& '. :. ,. ~~U~ ~. ~JT0~>gfJ. E1~mjjj$Wf!j:. B~ 1~~. 1£:e~2)(~cpru~ $. ~ , IZSIlttYt:~~Cl"Jk:. ~r.tJWk~ :J 04"- ~M~0~F,fJ.'~ 1£~~Zcp~1iff~. ~~ij. IJIl. ' ~~7A04"-«a ~ ~0~~. ~ ltt ~fJ.~ 2jz. ~F,!!I[~~~,Ki:iJj;J&fiH-P3~. fJ. ; fJ::ljl:t~1z i¥J k~fffl§ , L~E1~f)-~Ji~ ~0~F,fJ. ' If}T0~~fJ.t1Ij¥-'f)jlj fi:~ 7 jJt. 15BF~~rll$:t~~~U. 1E£~i&m2)(~~i$jJ. AEI/:Jf~~. ~~~J§E1~W~(O~O~WjJJJ%'. r ~!!I[ J ~ljfi:~iI~. mWi.\~ij~~jJij Ifrl£~@;!!I[O~1J$. i::Jjj;JEZ.F,!!I[ ; 6"I:l~. *)] , 27). ;. i&~JT0. : ( 1) 1Jl1zrlli1£0 ; (2) s9iftJJl~ , ij~~~. 0. Jf:f '. (4 ) M~~Y!.f~l.lljllm~~'fffi-*. ffij~JT0~~!!I[E1~~~91Ij~. ( 1 ) ~~. ; ( 2 ) *~%<:~~UEZ.jfH:Ui. (3 ) ~~R~m~~mk. ;. :. ; (4) @]J!!tiij~~J§. 0. ¥1J~ I.3J:!t~~EJ.l5j-tJTr.tJ ~O. ' 0 ~"§:l!:!l.~ ~1J/~'- 7L-=-Oiffi:' -t;04"-fi:j;J :r&ffl<.~1=ri& ~fJ~riiJf~~ -:sz: ' J\ 04"-fi::r& ' Yt:t§IijJ~!!I[ IDffi~~)Jf1zffl:fj~:e~i¥J1=ri&2)(~ , ~ij~~t1E f~r.tJ*1tm~~JT0~~";fm IZSIltt ' ;fi~*1Ef)-0 ~~!!I[W~JT0~F,!!I[E1~~1.l 1j ( tzo~~f)- PA W PA m~ ) , t11j~j;XF~@:1J~ : 0. 1 , :r;:£iiJf3i:Jf)Z lru*~ , ~JT0~~fJ.~~0~tr fJ.f:t0~hi&~&iVJ. '. 1£fJ.§iffLtf~~1iff~. 1£~~fJ.tzOf6J ffl:(£0~F~~1=ri&F.fJ.. m%<:m!7t). (tzo. 'i&~~~~fJ.~~fJ.IDffi~oo. A~FFfU m36~m5M. 213. /j\"ff[. 1;:£M);cf:t0~1=ri&W0~F,fJ.E1~IH9:5'51. ~ 1~ E1~ PI ;j;l~ -e;:, EI f-~"; 'fJZ -'-"", ,J:I Jl.!.. , :g. A PJ1~¥Uj;XF Z *5~1fij , .tJ[Uj. 1=r+ct:83=A ZE/+'-':Xiiflfl. mk~~*~. }!g*iiJf~~~-@§~ :. (5) 2)(~ An"- 1mi~!!I[. ; (6) ~~nfij· ~~£@jft ; (7) m!#~~UI:lI=II:l~ ; (8)s9ifti&JM CP:9CZ~JiJ1i:Jj]fig ( ~cpIJj{ , R 88 : 75 ). {~Cl~ '&ii. ft~@!~. (Th7.$: R 88 : 1 3 - 1 7 ; *jJr!l3jJ , R 90 : 26. Zm!f~. 14 •. 0. ( 3 ) t9'*fi:;;r1WT2)(~Wm7t~~~J§. fi~R~W5!J!ti. JL ;. 0. ~~ ). (tzo P~1~W B ~1¥i¥J. ~ ~' .@; PM ~.@~~~~~~. PA~l3jJ~~f)-*-tJi. '. fg~~*§f:t/f~*§~i¥J. 1If@:±iJ:& ' tzo {Iiil - } ?JTiG '. PA W PM :lik~. ~~~iffiiii: (co-evolution) ~:;;r~1*5'l1j ~. 1l:tY'} , 1;:£ PA W PM. E1~!lli1M(*;g. ±iJ:&W P M~:;;rffi~ofi. ~J¥}. r ~fJ.±¥l J. , f~H;ft,a'J PA. ~:@ R"JfJ.. PM ~!lli~m~. . fL J\ (. ~;f!l12~A~15BF~. Yt:ffl<.~~VltrWWF~~±~~. , f.El:M". ( reinvcn. , BP~f:t~1~Mt. ~rwJ J (R. PA ~&~M~~~/f~iiJf~~~ o lZSl~~. t. *;ft, E1~. rg; , 'J Iitt. ion) ,.. PA *§:;;r~~:fj~1-wtjCCl~ PW Yt:~ , 1£ {llil } E1~~f~T ' :g. A PJ tt :(£ PA W PME1~ ~@i~~~~cp , ~m~B';;j1J]. ~:flnRlR~. l£~Jl *~~±iJ:&. r ia lis n. 0. '. ~-~~. 4"-E1~ri&iiJf~-);Ccp?JTm!R. Wi l son 1:£ 1887. '. Yt:g~~:{£ft'i. ffi. r ~JT :L}:.

(7) ~. rgHi; l'Ff~. ~0~fi~m~ ~~B"J~. ; m=*~~~. f~1:E:m~Ji-TIfi. Jt£*B"JrJ.~ffii. ftU7}J3U1f:£frjI;Z:5<:!Z~/f~3W~Jff*Ji~:Hf!~B"JW. ~~~~. ~iitD A. ~fF*~ '. -. 9"J:mffi$wrllLt:~. lItJt53'ZII@BkJ5E L}:#rg;rJ. ' Ii_ J~W B3£' ~BJ. : PA ~~ ~ ~~ i*£~ ~1lJ*1c g1~ m*UBkJ&ib 2 '1f:£0 :#~r.!~ fi'lN ' Jl iJ ~D~ B~1~BkJ{ff~lf:sz rt:a 3 ; fffi ~ PMfffi i3 ' ~Jff~~ i&~* ' 1'T jI;z:*#;:Z5c/f~3 ~c5c:ii ' ~EE rt:alE:* ~~*~~~:£'!Zili1JDJ.-Jc5i:~~~ffil~~ , fti!t:W ~~5IJrnc5i:1fY~~ B"J ' ~~~ff0:#~:£J. 0. ~D"J~ff0:#~. ~~,. rlE:*M~JffJQJ~~ft~0:#. '. Mf4~*~&i:Hf!~~Jff.g~ r ~ ~;:z5c. , J!!~~~1J ' l¥~ff~~1J J.-J& mf'!~~1J ( 1IilIl\\~W~U:f;$1~ , ~ 88 : 10 ) Jt ~.M~ 0. Jff ~m~Jffft~~~Xg~*,Z$ ' ~W. r ~JffBkJlE: *mffi$ J W r lE:*Mg 1~ J $ i3 Z ' ~JffB"JlE:*~~ffi$ , 1*t~ftjI;z:Jff BkJ~ffiU& ~fFZr:p , ~~~~~1f~ rt:a (c h a 11 g e dr i ve n ) B"J[7Jft~W ' ~JLb~W~~~~~5 1 ~1f~ff:£J. Z: ' :1(z!1% Jlt~1f~fffJ.Z:~1tm~~ 0. .t 3illBkJ5t~ffii~. ?@,'J!B"Jc5i:if:£J.Z: ~ z ~ to/J ' -. fiJ55U1~~ T. ffltB"J&mvfffimtfjlE: *Mg1~B"Jj:~. ~. .efi~ffl fi~.~ ; fffiM~lE:*Mg~ ,. ~r.!BkJJfrl9:: %t. , J.-J EH±l~BkJE Ij ~ff:£J. Z: fi~1lID~*~fm~m:~m~ff~ , fffi ~~m1i:M~ HI ' !J \fffi~ , INm~~~JffB"J::t~.& IW~W B ~1~B"J PM®t~ if§~ , 1.& ~Jl rJ W P 3£'1~BkJ PM ~~~6lli ' 19;GWfffii3 ' ~-aJft0:#~:£J.~. ~*,ffi~. ~*:£J.~£~~ ~1~~~~. llt. :1JTIfi~i.$*1tg. , 0*~:£J. ; §5-:1JTIfi. AD'jf~l~~. : A ~A aR. , r=t nJt :?1. 0. , t)@j. ~ :1J.~~ , :1(z U .~ ~ fi~~m:1J.~. , 1J%I!JJ jI;Z:J0f.g~F~~:£J.0:#$:m '. tlP t~ft 0 :#.g~ r~[7J 1f~ff:£J.z:~m~. Kin g , 1 996 ;. 63 ). ~f1~ ~ ifEl [QJ BJ. ffi'.OO~~Nm~~.~.& ~ ~~. (re in ve nt ing. iP~~1i~'i$Mt. )ilf]. &1W~Jff¥}~ B"J::t1m:1J1rnt. 0. 1Z911t1$. , RA-aJ§t , ifi1¥.i*B'j rnJ ~. l so n ft 1887. t § B"J §' 1£:ffi. 1I ilIl\\~fi ~U:f;$ {j:. '. ~. 88 :. /,--.. =<:t; ~ I=I iot¢7EIj~'". "-Cf;. ~ m-=-~~~. ( A Th i rd Cho ice ). 0. ~~IW. *,~,MHllJif*~jI;Z:Jff~-=F:ii1'JB"J~Jff¥}~~t.. '. .m~~Mj:M~ r ~*~~~$~~* J. rj/f[QJY*55U , , i.$*1UI!j PA [ BkJ jl:j~dm:-aJ ~5t }-€mF~ , 1E!'ffi 0. ( Li nde n , 1994 ; Robe r t s &. **i3z ' lE:*M~Jff~j:~ , ~~~~lE: 1ft ::! I /"\.TI:I7f11'l c:f;6:- X1T rti fiii 7R1'P3 1!i't' 5 JJ:!:::L..>, I=I IJI - JI.v<..m JJ.'.x.n't/ ,1E7RiEtLn;g><=lt.t:;. 0. PAW PM ~ffi. ~1~. §~§tfi¥A1'T. 0. =<:t; ,~ -. U~ I1f f~ /f i5. , 1f:£$;f~JGt '. ~~i:R:~m. grJ.B"J:£J.~~£E~~2FWfffi~. -tLJ\04 1~. J (REGO ). 0. '. 1*ft~ff0:#. , ~£f!.-aJffi~A~. lli*BkJ~Jff¥}~~tb. • government) ' AA"m. rJi(!J1f. r jI;z:Jff¥}~ J ( re i nven t jon) , 1*mXg~*' t) r i:~UlftJ:£.!ti J ~£ ® ' 51:ii r ~~ ~rP:f;!b~ffiU J t)& r ~ ~~ ~:iJmme J ' ifEm1'TjI;z:*±l~f~@iji~M ' :1(z~ Ii! r ~ff0:#~:£J. J W r ~:£J.~~ J ( man age r j ali s m) B"J~~ mDffi ' m:~ff~~1'T ~X it, 0:mA 1J ' mJUw~ , ~~ffi U N t)& § ~. ( NPR ) ' ~if. tfj#&~Jff~T!:affi*Ji~¥&E ' tiP ~lE:*M~JffBkJ ~1,!1JU~. 31-32 ). (1;%**)) , ~ 90 :. 0. 1m~lE:*MjI;z:Jff~~~~~~&4BkJc5i: 1fY~~. , BPfu/f 1~~~~mr;:affi~-.t B~1tli~Jj ,. ~- i31it~BkJ~0Jj~1JD 1£Y~. '. ~Jtttt~z~17J/f. , ~17U~~Jt:j:tt~~~MD~. ~W~ljtlfl{!. :. ( ITilIR. , ~ 269 -27 5 ' ~ $J]3: , ~88 :. 39 -40 ) :. Bel10n WGoerl (1992: 131-132 ) tfjl2] @fti~W& ,~,. t~. : J.,lJ,EjflJ lJIil36 ~lJIil5111l 213 . 15.

(8) 1 .:li::* EI'±" I:1W~'±'jHI:'I:1Z~j~. ~i*B~~M5. ;. 2. -i-; ;J:t:li::*ffiWH~:W0 ~~WfJ1[§B"J:1'" J§. ;. 3 . :li::~~ W'I:1W ~'±'I3fJ;fj5tl~Z 1IJ~ ; 4 . :li:: *. '1:1 @.\, ~ 7J< ~ W~ .±. 0 ;J:t ~t Z. ~. m. jHf EELPIfD ' Be lion WGoe r 1 (fJ~~ti[QJ Ef.f:ft¥ r ~'±'1mrtiIJ J W r :li::*~i&Jff J B"J~ 0. rm1~~tiW~N1I5U. 0. 0. *:Y::PJT~~~B"J~~tiMz:lp~:li::*~i&Ji'1 1:E~~ffl¥~~®~4 ,~~~~~~~~. f;f1f'iE:~~i&H18~tlL*U~t~1¥J:;tt1~1@ ~tr37~~1£t1t1=ri&Jff1iji§B=!f. '. W:li::~~i&JffB"J~fi:>J<~§~E?Fi!. , ffiJ ~. ;!t@~W'±'~. '. 1:E~ff8~m. :li::*~i&Jff lj~@~pff31l~(fJ ttt*UW. ~~ ' ~~Wm:Y::~~B37 ' *:Y::,±,~~~ 7f1j i&Jff8~tlL*U. '. ~W~~11lJ ~ti~1J~7\:;~B"J~l1ffij. -BP r ~*1ti&Jff J 16 .. AIJFlflJ. ~36~~5!1Jl. mF'. ~'i/f'i~A ~!:,~~ (. ,f;: *~£. <~->~moom. ? :Y::~~~ff~~'~. n:t~:;tt.±. TiJMtJT. ~1JS. 0. rd. t. W. 553) , ;. 0. *. P:i:' '7. 1fltK...m:L>. ~ *®5E o.~,~~;J:t~R~5Em.~. 0. ffiJ L. de Leon fliJEE11fH@B"Je~ti ' ~*U:li:: ~~i&Jff:;tt1J1ti![ pg Wii-'E!. M*1ftB"J Fl f\(;.±. ~ , FlflJtt ' IidJUtlEHfJ ' $fMf~R~j;)J5Z.~w.r.±. ¥i ' lJ;t!f!f'l'i~1~B'fflt1m~~~1t (L a n & Rosenbloom, 1992) , ~PI~HU~fflGde L eon pff~Z r ~i&Jff J (a na rch i c) B"Ji&*,Fo9m Te r ry ( 1993 : 394) l;f:li::*~i&Jffpff1~ ~~iJ~:li::~~gffltB~tlL*UfliJ~~?~~!~ , ~?Jm:;tt rsNmU1:E~ : 1 . ~M'1t;d~ffILWZ ' 1~:;tt1,\ffiHpg~~Z$mU ; 2 . ~~~1SEiJ?fJT ' ffiJ~t37~1jli:BP5fJtf*J3.~ffl *lE~8~~Wi ; 3 . *~~~~1$*X ' ~~ff~1+1:EB ~B"J 1J1@W 1sfrp. '. §lmm¥U <~- > ~:5J ~JT~f»CP , .:g: AfirJ PI frlf~~M~*~i&!M~ .±.5:&'G1~~?fJT0;J:t~; @-mLH§~ , ffiJf;f:;tttlt*Ujdm*F:l NPA i¥J. ffiJlJ;tfm~1@B"J1IJ~1J)J~:~mu. pg%frB~m1j;yJ§. ~ZT. 1!:1Zi1,iO. 0. B~ 1rN5E. 213. '. ~;g:~~A. ~. W J. S. Den hardt (2000 : 549 - 559) mti=l, giWf;f1J~0;J:t~; @iJ~Wf§i: , *:@3~ 0 b0 r ne W Ga e b 1e r ( 1992) ~ r ?fJTi&!M~IJJ J -f!pff*'1=r8~m:EJ. R. B. Denhardt. fI1!f~ -. i&H1ffi!37@F.lJtffiJ:lpt*~ff~m@~J!. ~~=~ 5)t It!<:..:t:. 7. g~R J. ,. r~. ~ffi±"@"R~. f'tIarrrJJ 0:. 0. I t- --S. !lIe\ J:T:!J. ))8;. ~. P=I. Jf) 1 ~ / ". iJ1e~tiTJ,:J.. ~ffiJ. ' 1±~~ r?fJT J 0;J:t:g~f£ZiW ' fli A ~&\~ 7t;@fil~ r -i-; ;J:tg~fE J iJ~*~mfaJ Rosenbloom ( 1983) mw*fJi&Ji'1ff1£~§~1£ ~~U-t;fm0 ;J:t § ~ , ?T3U~ : 1 .15R~A~(rJ ~ffi1 ' ~tJttW~¥mflJ ; 2. ~i{5Rm. ~~rMi-f ~Irlz. ; 3. m~ , :J5l;:WJ~~~~M ; 4 . 1JD~aW~ mm5EfflG~W~~T ; 5. m#~a~$Jfp~l:) :& @Afi\GJjJ ~ ~Jm:~Wr ; 6. 15R~ EI ~~1J][ ; 7 . 1~~f4~5~3XVltJ~WJ ' t~1JDA B:ffr~ff!!l:~-t: Jffi1 ' .:g: A PI j;) mw*fJ~ r g~~ 'I:1 J ' r ~ffi~ t t J ' r m?¥ti J (~~t1) W r ?T1!jc'l~ J IZB 0. 0. F.!; :. ~ *mm,_~~r~ 6 ft. ( New Pub 1 i c Se rv i cc). fmJjJ~g. ;J:t1=r iE5. ~37CP)7i-:Y::)iU@I~ r 0;J:tg~T% J. 1zff~[QJi&mpffmf~~~;J:t*~ ffct"@"g~R~$I!JWJjJ~g. JM. , 0;J:t:~fM ' , 12S10;J:t$RB"Ji'Bi!lI. ~~Affii:= nflfJ -'",. mlB3:1:tB~ JjJ*~~5E 15: J .llii -'", r ~$~~fE A...f ~l] Jm. If!flA$~. m1:.$ffiJ 7k* 1tm *R~XW+{ti ~I'j@;'@. {;¥; ,. @5jiJ. cp ~·tilH»'.

(9) glji , t&~j;ili&H'fmlfJ~fi~Wmn~~ , rh l i I Flp ~ , r::::1./\..):.\. mzm0;ttH~ro. W;$JT:L~;ft~. ~:::f15fLA¥t¥ff0;tt1§~ro1JDj..:J.k~. ~sNPAI¥J. ',t;; k tv: .~:tE 'illz. Denhardt. C$3:JUJJJ '. ~88. : 87-88). 0. , Ingraham ~~~ (2000) JJ\f8U:J ' ~§~~{!JME#13r' , **8''.10;tt1~~~**JEef'.1~~JJ\ff~1fpJT''~ , lltili;j:~t±5izM~tzD-Y ( . PJT7'G :¥~~ff0;ttH~~R,t;;f~z: ' {:&~l~ Denha rd t Den h a r d t pJTm U:J (2000 : 552 553) , , J'Jt)Jjfs 1};ft1Ti& W~'T 0;tt ~:EI R,t;; 'B ~ fJI! ~ , : r fR:::t8':J0fR:'jft~fJI!~ J ' r miWiW0 0. fft/:'''''-±l:~ :~ JJ""..t->. /" .... r::::=J. R:ffct1¥r~mfF.~ J. Gaebler. lfI1=A. .l:'£illlll. o. '. :- ;$JT0;ttmll9§ J R,t;;tlH.A'I~lZ: : ~- , 1iJ.fi~~ElX1~~!l.In; :. e,t;;fi351:E~'MWJ0fR:~3&~;tt¥e,t;;:¥u. 1£t ' ffiJJP:lE: 1iif'2l~U~ij r~Jiffi±1¥rlWttwr e,t;;1JrtJ 0. m= ' i}~;fUfitt~El~ , ffij~F;U~~ : ffi&~£\g.fl:j!{j]~9J;J1:*IflIW;tt¥R,t;;. 0;tt:¥iJfri):Wz: c lft El ~:illz.;;lFEf3@AI1J ~'ilEt!'i'!60~,*,r,h~ J=1,¥,P:J~)<A~. m '. r *J::i*~e,t;;A*::tfiWrww. 1:E.@t~~~fJmz -y. ,. El=EE.3":. {'F~f~U:J-f::;{~1. ,. ~ 13 ±l:p+rJ~",,::m=/-r:. r /)-. IIIJ:xE/ ,.c. m~ffi1.*tE, ~::tfj~. '*ilf'PflIF¥ 'i&tRW'. :rw;/,y:!,II. :. 1J~£\~.fl:~i&!*IflI~ j] W Er,h R B ~+.H-r'*. ~1Te,t;;m:E.I. ,I"l t'i):em. *13. l1t.t·;\~J....:E.)D" 0. 3 r wr:L~;ft. -. {!JME~0#Gr9 **Jt~,':¥=+--tft*c~:L};ttH~ro*ME. ~W~ti:y j..:J.. 8Z~U. ' :g:. ':~. ~l¥IA~1¥J. l ~'jf1)Jjf:::f. 5$~Jijji&! flIcY1J1JHlU. A::tR,t;;~fflW7ti¥iJ1;;§t;fj<:tJtlJjtJtt~*. 0. 4.1JD59i*~ pg1:EW1J}1:E1fjt¥B''.1t~{AI{[j[. 0. 1*-X"1iS • r " " ~ {)Xf. '. *15()(wr:{tli;§t;~1~ A~*J::i*l § ~ffitiAe,t;;Jj;m. ;ffr~ifrtl:~-f::;. ,. r~wU. '~~~HI~I~~~~#.~;§t;~~~~m*l~~ft. e,t;;§. JIZ9. '. ,fEe,t;;iB~. , $lW~WI1'F~§t:at. cp *f~\H¥On 1L;g.1~!H~I¥]n~j] *Jit.~1A$J;JJij~. :H~,fE J. ;tt~wu. 0. ,. 0. ll~~. 0. ~;f4*1E~. :. raham, P.W., S.C. Selden &D.P. Moynihan(2000:58) A~RTU ~36~~511Jl. 213+ 17.

(10) %[2] , l~fiHqj£~ , ffij~FIi~~ : 0~flj:f.itn~~. S. ' fi'fJ?pf@JAsffjl¥J o. fZ9.llt '. *~. : ,. ~0~§&~E8"J :±=.~!*£\~~+~tL}. :#-§~~I¥J§ifa~M~lEffiJ* ~CPt,,!:i'J"J5E~. J:®:9i '. ~\5JifSJa~ij::~1:zH3¥. '. 'MJ.1~. ,. ;(h- ,'.L,,4ff. t S E E ~ -/:lfij l1E JiliV"" &1_ '" .u.:Ai'p fflJ';;rt. " ~~4~---t-~;',,~..c-~. flJ:f£t. ,. , M'4-1¥J0. ~ij~~E s ~f~~JT0;;!:t~:tJ.1¥J::t=:1frE1i1!{[iliJJ.~f;f -5Ef¥&i'J"J~-Ef. ~JT0:#-§~~I5ll~~. ; jt;j;: , Denha rd t.B2,PJTmZ , 1¥w§v~tm0}tf=r1&!fi~~JT. ~""J±""Q;:mirl'M'~ :tt.:?A,,* -7Ef"DI*. ,. .L../" § -".EIIIJ t'~/'I1ff1l~iLz:e:WE. 0. m/\ ' ~t51A~ , iffi~F.R~t51~~ : 0*~f!I[ A?fr~WI¥J0:#-~;ElJ~lZJt*j~*~;fiJtf:j~ ~~~1i~~mA.B;!;i'J"J-Ef{'F7frEf¥J!Jl!:#-!¥· I'XTCT-L.. fSl0:#-B~~I¥J*~. :- 1&tf~I5IJJ~J!fflU~:r:JJfj~L**-Ef J '{¥JiM§. i~*~.fIlJ.AP,~~@1~i'J"J~. mE ' ~J!:ML~F~~ : 0*~.fIlJ.AII*T{1:~~rtJ. '. '. *~H~fflG:r:JJ. 0. mt,~mfl~.~W£~~~'.~~.. ,. m ~ ({,'tI3R ~,F,,!J:lIrt-;tj. • E'lL/.$, A::-~txr:;:~""::!:f:j-;(h-,,*,,:s:zt:;:~"\.:f± , ]j3l.f~ , /I"offll'fll :J.::.;,.-, IJlJ'.x..!?'<.'fII:.u/,. , ~fr0}t~.fJ.~'.1::t=:5~~~1!I1 , j;]~][Jit~II¥Jt§:~+-q:., •. g~. R. B. Denhardt. J. g~~gX;{li[ili:Ifx~). 0. J. S. Denhardt. (2003 : 28 29) J!:l1t-#7~1lJ*ftI¥J0:#-T=r. ~;r:h. , ~:fj~ r iE*~1&Ri' J (~0 ~t:m"'+I:Il) Jt~EHM[illI¥J~~v ' ~fT:L}}t1t1&~1~ Pff:t~l¥Jftt1UJL~ , {~:P- tt~fT0:#-ij~~~:1::t~. : 0:#-fU:f.itH~:~.J~~ , :L}*~.fl AW0.B;!;:¥lN&tbff:f.itffr±ttl¥Jffi!t ~0:#-~;tff~~ affB"J'r~j5E~. :'£~7fjl :J.::./" {Tll')(.. "*" *8 -J:-#J? S nr:;:/-\.J±/ !?I(/IJ-'("j-'-/.JVL7E:>I'JJ:L, / " 1Jll')(.. B"J::t5N ;. *~fft$. , ffij /G~~1i~0*~.fIlJ.A. illL,+:;;tr:;:~""J±/.~;c/r. 0. §~ugX;PJT -flf~I¥J*6§ilfi. :. ~JT0~!§~~~O. Denha rd t .B2,JiIT::t=:5N:ir ' ~~99i:ntt~1}:jt. , :5tIlU. fi1&~~::t=:5N.~I¥J.~'&L~~:~. pJT7f: " < } L CPffflJW1Uft0:#-f=r1& ' ~fT0 , ~Ff0;;!:t§ ~~l~t=:. :irfi1t§7[ill [P] S"J J!j! -~~~, '*~/G • • Denha rd t .B2, s NPS B"J f!I[ £ 6~~~r.B;!; .B;!;.~f!I[. ~JOl~.~~~0}t~f!I[M'~rnmI¥JM.. 1& '. ~fT0;;!:t~f!I[lZ~JT0:#-HlU!l¥Jr;J;g~. tt~$(D f~[J]}. J,r. J'. ~1~. 0. **-Ef*~lW[illpJT;j~l¥Jfi~6!fit~m*~. nrp),m~i¥:1I&~~ , Jt~~t~::t=:5N. '. NP A W ~PM. ,. 1§.~1J&:f:S)1=f. ~.~!:Wi)P~¥II/GJOl~*&1¥J. M:l~. 1't'1 A* ::t=:~J!J1~11Jmif!I[~ J 1&1¥J::t=:i7:lH§M'~-Ef;. <~[9} cp§lJffirY!~m0. fiE JOl~iifl-Ef T ~fT0;;!:t{f1&§t1~~JT0:#-~f!I[B"J;§i. REGO. 1}~m. ~~11. ~;f4*. 18 •. A~,ErFIJ ~ 36 ~~ 5 Wl. 213.

(11) &'"~wHtt1} Jj~fESk]*m J. '. ~[9. {~MfC0):tfTi&'. lfJT:L}):t"g:£fI! '. ~1T0):t H~fES/'.1:g. 00 [til ttt~~. {*IH{l. '¥~I¥J1}. /i&rtl:£fI!~lf!j , tJfJt.~k]iii± ! *~1~:£fI!~lf!j ,. fJf {@::£fI!~1f. IWff4'l"_PJi.9lf{$ak]l]i±it itf3t:. tliJi&rtlwfljlf!j. £\i1!. dt~J5JT~~. ):t1Ti&tliJ*T ~Ff0):trr!&. ~~oli. 0. I. :¢';J;/'..::H:/.-XEt 7191 A/,,, lTlJ')('. (~1}. 0~fIJ1iiiBkJf~1~. H~fESk]±~ i&~lfJT:L}~. f.£'5¥:. ±'*:t:E:g.~. +4' rJ! C:Mz1ff€tM. f'f~~:L}~. 0. i:;-~. ,jti&*Sk]~! (t$}&f$:f:flJ:1J£sk]yjjtl (0~~ltr±li¥~1mflj ~t~¥j\n) fr ) 11iiiB''.1~*u~iarm). /!&!MftJE. §. I~iilU&,IH'l1'l!B'lm\li1J i. -.~. 1-. /.-. ~:i&!~it1t~:1F:gflj %It1'L0,~:g,. l. :1FitfiJ. ':~1:g.~ffJB'.17J ~fJ ~;f~~U~~mrj~~f& ~;f~~ij~~tJi~JE;f§Jli! *fiffJ Im:f:flJIlIJ] - § fUBk]tJO ~oo 0. ~>t11.~&rf _j:-;r::fr. , / 113. k. =. I"" "'. '''''''""'~"R'''' '" ~lf:r~. IJ!lm. .ll*j{B''1~~. nl'x. IOlP rrJ~. I. J JJ.')(. /'- jq. ':.LA;~OJJJ.')('{Q-p~,nt1~. IJlt%& '. j{. i<J;la J.I~ ~"":ENef r:H: -+- N-r /"-. Frl.. I'. I. BkJ-0):tJj~l:t!. ,N. ~F1lif '+ '±.?3:r. -,J... /,-jq!.lW\/~.'I:<Jl'IJtt:{Z;;. 1=1"-' 1]iJ.. Mak]fJf1@:' i&li:lt~fB '. ::I')(.!.ll"!./'-P:'j A.LA;. (~e~) jtJ5JT~. o*ak]*'1'f*. =. ~r1§!Ji50~fUM. 0. 0. -----+---------+-----------1. /ft§4=1Ti&'§. ~;th=EP:r=I. ~. FE. f)jHft~~:m~. ~~Sk]fW~. NFM. ·H-'fN.'~+n.z!i<±. ~;f::I at:rl=:r~lI\b~. r i~):t,§~fJJ J ~. ~@~: ~p. fIQj~*&1¥J. 0. 1iii n 00 A. frj 1iii I:L} j:~ ffJ 1iii ~ ):t:9: 1ii{@:. J~' J~ ". EJ. m' T!!S- A. :}):t Hf~j:fi ~[J. ~sk]' f!t#UB''.1tJ&1&Jlil .. 1~Bk]. 0. ,0):t flj 1iii 7~ i& iaak] 1m :. ):tfTi&~~JJ1. 0. /._. . !&V1tJ~*~i~:Em'll' *~ : *~:EmtE 'JJ.'tlak]~!C ! fJi&I·1~A.J' ~§ffjBkJ1jt*lf1$t~jlU Ci&iaBkJ' *~1~ ~ sk] , *g~ak]). ... .!.1JrEJ!Il_tl&jt;f§~BkJI';Wl~B/'.1JJ.tl' .AJ~JifT~t~~ A. J 0. :0& J. h''';",,,, W.t::HJ -,,",-'IF! .. lTJJ.'x:t~~. ~;I;:. ~HNBkJ! JlJj{Bk]~i&tJ~Jrz1E:lr~Jt~&\~j[Bk], {H&\~JI ~ak] § f~ 5¥:[lNMjltj{. 1. 0. ~ffJ! Ir§~~ak]!FJ1~' 3m..t-~TBkJID!m-, 5tma~0~*g~'~f~. pg:9}):trQJ~.ft~.· B'lil'fFi. *Jl~taffJBkJ'W1JE. I. r).:.. &. ~H~tJJ!Jd*ak]~mrjW r7\j1*1=l±~m. "gmrj. *'1'fffJ. 0. 0. ,. ","",r, . 0):t H~l:t~ ~rj i&A.! iWTJtWtiffJ ' :X'§Jj~l:t: 1E:~*~t$ , 1!~mJ.ft~j: 0):tH~l:t, ~*~JflkIIiI ~~lfJ~~Bk]1~JE IBkJ1*fLil J~*~tJ~i&JMtJM~ Iit ~t. I. ~f-+*1Jij{. 0. : R. B.. ~. 0. .. J. S, Denha rd t (2003 : 28 -29 ). AllJi'Flfu. ~36~~5Wl. 213. 19. I ,.

(12) I fl MIEPOLtt ) , NPS M,~mjq'> T NPA ::5T ~t3~1:EfJ~Willfflii:g;lmjEj , ~M'l Y-&WB'j~i¥r ' ~!ijj1*po <~li} pJTiG. 0 ~ff ~~ m~~~~ffm.~~~~~. 1J~ ( ~j;¥U. '11' ' 1EI.&;\~J!5€R~JWJfJ'srIELttf~~~~l/1JT~11~~ffli , *JT0~H,*rflfi.~MI']mtlJ ' 7Ujg~~ ~Jj~1fi·(OO:~§5-~tM1~~ , f3H:fi~~illf~~n£ ~~Jf3Z1i;. 0. W~;f~~. 1. 0. <~=} *,!~t*5M31ttB'j7tfJT. '. 2)(1¥LifW~. ~ - 5'&~~-=-,§r~!~ltJ iG~. Ii':iI ' J!!~1:~Ii1Ir:p:e;g~~z ;f§ ~ ~ !ijj1* : NPM. *3tJ;)~~JB¥}i§B'j. , ~H-g- r ii~:EJ.WH J ( Pe ndu l urn Theo ry ) pJTFWiJJz[i;E!"JP9 ~ (~*mW~J1Hij71 ' ~ 92) ~f!P1jj[5(2)(1¥LB~:EJ.~ , ~1:E NPA W NPM B~~~tM:li1jmm ' ffij )\ 0 4-1i;~ 1j. 1*E13 PM~~ffij3k '. ~~1¥LR~T.m~m~~0~~:EJ.~~. 0. ~. , 1EI.~~'.mfJ.ffifH ' :E .A~~gt#F~~Jj~~. NPS U'. ;fEl11t~ NPA ' ~pJT5€RWEJ. E!"J~~~~fJ.~~B"J£*i~j5E. jf-Jm~. ( tl21!~ }c , ?. ~~fj1&25z. ~ '1tt. 1¥Lrf'] }aJiil! ; NPA ~ iJ E13 PA ~~ffij3K ' ~~0 ~'I:1~tlt*U Wffi*~~-Jf~®:lf~ ; ~JfH~. ilm~. f.t~ iJ ij !. ~~IDt~. ~7. ,. EI r. 1j ~ ~. J. '. ~f~1~ & ~ }[1$~ ~. $Ltt ' ffiE)(~L*JT~Ib~EI±l*"Ji: ' 1!NPM~ ~iffI. (. ~. ~~JfijJ. -'fi:f"J F pfTm~. wGpjJi , *3t ~. ff§B"J1i1 pfTm~ )(B~ :=t 1r:J7~. r. JEQ~. !. t~ ffiJE A~(. 1i!I= 1jj[5:1¥*JT~~Z1fi100:~5~~~iG~~ ltN3K1m : ~*1'fl7l ( ~ 92). I**m '. 20 •. A~FHU ~ 36 ~~ 5 1l1l. 213. !'I~ifi1~ Jtli!l1J! ~.

(13) ·'16a3IiUli~ll!£.~·.···fiIl~~OO*,~M@ffl. iS~19IJfjm' ••Ji~}.(~QJJ." ···.<l·dglfO . '06 .~)~~.fi~~.(iij~.·~~.· • • •tlEt '··8sila;f~~Q1OOIl.'·im~f .~.~'~~.iiffll~.?ie' •••iI Mi*l1I~:Qf~~..~~W:2)!l5Sl1I~.{» ~O\:.tti·.E4_. . . . .s.a.~}j.:r.. ••19I~~!m!tUw!6a11l·. ••fm~•. ·~.·~.)$". ·~• •"~filflUjm.$J tIl~- .f:' o.(~.....,ljll. _6);l~~Hil.~jl2{~· '?6~'~&1. *I.tTt$jf~~IU6~. ·.tTt~fi) ~~l'~. ~~~YdbJ}~ , ~r~il:li.~i!N ~E£i!;f~f5 4e:&EMm!l¥ , af¥fu4eg~fjD[t~M~1.~II!::II]jll}.J4a :z;If~§i WeIN M VeIN ' ~*j]&!j~cif±£9:f;j!!ifii~ , !ll:~tm ' ~~ (~]jllHiH~~~Dq) ~M~Ctl;l. ~~J1f~'jI'. (If;Jiif~!If~W~:p::f\3):p::fY. , ~'JETEj3::II ' nl:lff.t?!il~~1{fff!i@}ID ' 8.M1{ff fId~~~fjtJYd~~ili*i1fd~F!)U:1{fffld+JT j liJni!b 1ft$: I j ~*~-¥6~~ I ~0EkY~ ~ ~fi:r ~ , 1~eIN :}}liJiM5f:U'~§!:af¥ SeIN ' ~ :f~4 ' f;J;l~:Y~:!:l9 =t~@]!)u:Yi;liijj[ltlmlJW~*~~af¥m. ~~±£9:~~~&#\3~:'Jtti~¥fu*4*. 'i.~J~1J~~wni~·~~·~~W~~6);l. NJ. .6I;1rli.HiJlJl~.l\l!ID··i m.~~66!i!m }gf.W~W • 5Initjir~m.~¥fl;li£a Mt~.ill9i~~t!I~:n1it '~19!giiil. •• ••.•. .~.~ag.~. ~~'. •••. JETfb#\3~-UtN~§i~:f:'Jt.ill! ?I~'==". l{JBolddB. ~Jii:.£. . . . o·.l12·~. tl;I;I19I!~~G#f~ti~r·~rtIJlmml';roO[ujt~ .1!J.~. ~~;.~.·.9~U:~'eI::EJm!;£·~. ·.!5!ID:.•• ~IS»i£a;f.~.~~.f!!l.~.~.ltlt tIf·.~.tI.~~gilf.M~J2{ •.~ ¥f.!l!ij.$·lftilttf_rJ$.li~liiiHti\ld· ., • (~6~) ~~g*,. MtTt~~~."~~··· ••• $~~ · ($i.Ii.~lf!l!f}.~jn ~.~~ ;fM (al:• •~:sg.) ~~.l9i {.• .~.~~lItfgJf!i·iS~~WdMVosglii·1. $. '*. ( ::fcif±£!rl1a:=Fw+ ifii JETfb '/::7-£-'rt1tY-rT7TJl'iiiiiI2l!I~IJ,Ji>I4M • 2<C£YhTJ~~,* :fF'\:/m--t-'7','.LJJ:..-J.lE~r <+4 .. ".!'f!ll • ~'f#:;Lir ~ ft-m. JET M#\3~ ¥~JET2;[ M:¥}[[t:"f:*E-i=M 4:"f: ) ) I. il;!E~IYI'J-l. SeIN.ill! '. J. ~. ~~~.HW~~~~~~*~~~' !f£~E£i[ltlmn;IfjMD$Nll4e-ij':"f:lM~. '. ~~cif±£9:4eW. -J 4e~~YddtT ' f~ eI N r:11W. '. ~lllft. I. lplBl{UdQ S=£lf:£lYd~~. ,. ;ai.f~ VeIf~:W:. 4t!~.r::r[1tl*3:7~+=§ffug41[gJ~~D[)I;l I ~3I. ~~ J ' ( ~::II~~4e WeIN ~~¥D:J.'tH·mtf*[gJ) ~ ::II~~~ VeIN ti§!:~ SeIN l!#~± ~~4e~H9: W-f5~f;J;l~J!!lt113} , E'=l@f~ § w:}} 4ll§!:aiJ SeIN 1W ' f;J;l~~lli!I#~ WeIN Ilfi VeIN lJ3E~~ , ]jll}jJ~:F}:it:'Jt!i~q:jToo ' ~'4f;J;l~:fJID}1} 0. WeINi!t'iVeIN ,~~* E3 rn~Mm::m,~ J.i~g~fj+IT.?EbDq~t-Ut~~~~~.¥ID.M¥f ' ¥ llil~:Ifm~M~W[yI;lb8J:'Jt ' ~8EDqm (~~m) ~m~:f]!l}jJ4e WeIN VeIN' ¥~]ifftH;H JET!ll:iBl ' < } 'iijq:jT ~~.~H~t!inl:l' ( SdN dtT) ::II~fb~ VeIN :fb~~l1if WeIN rQJ::lr~::J ( 003lI) 4j~:w:~fjtJW ' ~. UWcL\l:fb ~4e$}]. fUkHJET: \3-Utfi ' Y"Y-rTLl. , .l{t:.LJJ: _;r:J'j ~lilH~~Yd. WeIN : :¥} ~'~lO::t1. ""'" -. rE. LfI7I 13. o. cif~~4e*~'. , i1f~f!lj~. ~:w:~~*m~3:70V~+JT~~~:fCtl;l.. !l!!::II ~~$f afJ. fu [Itl ::I.

(14) ~-~~~--~~-----------------------------------.----i'Ei\~. ~87 1j~~. ~::It. Denhardt ~ Denhardt (2000 : 549. 559 ; 2003) ~A~NPS2f~. ' iiftiU1iT ~~ft~~Mi~±~. 0. 0. ~ 81 tjB1¥~~IIl~:O),n' ~::It. iU'5J9I-m~JaJ. NPS f.i9 r!ffi~J (para digm) ,~~-.~~t1~.~ (norma. Jqj ,. J1tfi!lJ!~~:;$::>l:Pfi±~~ PA ~ PM ~FcJ. 125~. 8.. ~Jf~,&tg!ffi~W.~~J!lX1~ PA ~ PM ~ gjjl~m-~~. 7.. ~j~1Ji. ,. ... '9.. : Ei¥i '. ~. 85. m!2tt. • !l~~D~~m!~1i1l1Pffi"if ~::It:~;;*:::·. ~:;$:.f)J. ~ 88 r i} ~. II' ~ ~. . Henr. *. 198~. ~ !l Jii! til. ~J • lN~~Golembiewski~H~a;;. f)J~. • i}~1!m!~Mi:>l:mift (I) ,. ~j~SBJiIljJU'fEt!UI2titHll (~. ~::It. ~. ;$~.~~~'~$·DB~A~'~ 0. ~::It. 200: ~J. 0. 11-12 ) :;$:.:>l:Pfimf.i9fjB$fi~.r;I~~ *J41iIlJli@PJtBHt.I®i§iJqj • JltIl8i1§.!3 UHlft,o. .. 0. ~89 riTi}~Hj~~iTi}~. f~~i'l~Utt~~JH@ia(ftmml.~ "A~fm ~8;~. 'lN~~al:/=l~. if;t;B~ff. (Adml nl strati on State) -~~ ,. B!?11ftf13 Wal do ~ 1948 $~t:I:J ; F . M. I~arx ~ 1957 $~.lIittgjjD~*Elm:&Jlt ~f'F ' tt r&:J ~:OmD~AfiTiTllmm,; at. 90. : 7t~~. •. 10 . ~:;:t;:fJ.l ' i!*vJ'5.£; 92 r n~~I1~mw.;~,~ : J;§~f~Ii:&~B~J. iTi}~IJl,. ,~~~~±. 51Jf!~~iW1jB[3{1l~filtjPffitt.. 11. ~. 86. ::It. : lii¥i. ,;. Bl!gjj~tt • •a. ' t=i. 0. 2. rrfi~ ~ ~gi!flt~ ~88 :il:.~~Jffl: Bl!~'.~ '~m·. t::l::lt ; lilm 3. ;;;:ilij13. 0. ~ 90 lITn~f#f!2Butsm.M~-~j' ~.U~UI ·lDrrB)~;;*::: ..n~Di6l. **TlJt5::t:'¥ruJHii:>l:. 4.. 0. ~n&1.J. ~ 88. : i}:il:I:/=lJI1\. •. 0. ~JIl.. fjB., ~::It : 12. 81:/=l Jjjt:!:Ii ~ 88 lITi}tiEftm! : BJ8¥ll~fl9m!~~*t ~ • ~::It : lii¥i 0 13. ~.~, .1¥rm ' liim. ' if;t;li~ff~~ ~ 88 1jB.i\fi~ , t=i::lt : ~;;*::: • ~87. 1}~ljB~. r n:FliW:002ntlJ .. lNlf~.~ .~.2i}~~fi, ~~t. :>l:ft;o. ". 5,,~~' SIll. 'I!il"~'._.,. . Hood. 1998. 0. i}~'@fm!' ~::It: Ii~. ~::It. 1. >IIJH~. 200. ±.·lIT~~~:OO:~ft¥ll~fl9 J)i1~~.J;§. '.Rm~f:=!;-@Im~~:o. tive model). : Ei¥i •. 7. ~~11l ~ 88 r i}~iliH~2~ft;-- ~tfHt;~~fl9. :t§*~~. (2003). 16. Den 199. 0. 6. !R1I1i!. ~ft~~~~~±~&~~*,~~~~. 5. ~~;$~:;$:fJJ~~1;J5.£; (~92) 6. Denhardt f£=A~:>l:1:/=l (2000) '1I1:/=l. : ~;;*:::. 14. Bozeman. B. 1993 Public Management : The of Art. San Francisco: vv".~cr' Bass Publishers. 15.8el1one,C & Goerl 1992 "Reconciling Public Entrepre neurship and Dembocracy·. PU~1,f. Tic'l\dmi ni stratton 1108,52 .,No.2 ,PDn 130;--:134. . Ingr Moyn. 2000.

(15) ,R. B. &J. S. Denhardt Theories Of Public Mmini stration. 2nd ed .. CA: Brooks! Cole Publishing Company. '''The New Public Service: Serv ing Rather than Steering" Pub lic Administration Review. Vol.50.No.6. (November! December). pp.549-559. The New Public Service: Serving. not Steering. New York: M. E.Sharpe. ~~~. fiI' ilif\. awsk i W~~~,. <::~3i!. If. (I)· •. 0. G:. iTi}:!i:Ifi:;. .~~~~±. ~filijPTI8~". •. i~!ll!MftW* ~il5ff~.. !7i::. 0. The State Jossey.,.·. :0:. Entrepre Bey". Pub. Public Administration and Pub lic Affairs(4ed.). Englewood Cliffs. N. J.:Prentice-Hall. Hood, C.C. 1998 The Art of the State: Culture, Rhetoric. and PubliC Manage ment, Oxford: Caredon Press. .Ingraham. P.W .. S.C, Selden & D.P, Moynihan 2000 .. People and Performance: Chal lenges for the Future Public Service - the Report from the Wye River Conference". Public Administration Review. (January!February) .Vol .60. No. 1. pp. 54-60. J. S.. Philosophy of Administration. Seoul. Korea: Daeyoung Moonhwa International. Lan. Z. & D. Resenbloom 1992 .. Pub licAdmini stra ti on in Transition? ". Public Admin Review. Vol. 52,. 1 Rev~eiV. 134.. tical Guide to Re-engineering in the Public Sector. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers. 23. Mari ni. F. (ed) 1971 Tow a r daN e w Pub 1 i c Administration: The Minnow brook Perspective. New York: Chandler. 24. Osborne. D.. &T. Gaebler 1992 Reinventing Government: How the Entrepreneurial Spirit Is Transforming the Publ ic Sector. MA.: Addison-Wesley Publishing Campany. 25. Overman. £.S. &K.J. Boyd 1994 "Best Practice Research and Post-bureaucratic Reform", Journal Gf Public Administra tion Research and Theory . Vol . 4, No.3. pp.67-83. 26. Roberts. N.C. &King, P. J. 1996 Transforming Public Policy: Dynamics of Policy Entrepre neurship and Innovation. San Franci sco: Jossey-Bass Publishers. 27. Rosenbloom. D.H. 1983 "Public Administration Theory and the Separation of Powers". Public Administration Review. Vol.43. No.3. pp.219-227. 28. Terry. L.D. 1993 "Why We Shoud Abandon the Mis conceived Quest to ReconCile Public Entrepreneurshi~ with Democracy", Public Administra tion Review. Vol.53.No.4. pp. 393-'-395.. A Prac~ A~FHU ~36~~5m. 213. 23.

(16)