新生社團參與以及選擇偏好之探討--以環學院96學年度入學新生為例

.fm*#;Jt:k~

•

95

~lf-&ft~~jitt.~~~t~1tJl§..*:ll%

1.4bJ

ft*T

~

*~~

:t;Gip

'm**4~i~~

95

~ ~

It:ft

~ ~Ji

tt

-t-

~ ~£

Jt

tA.1T

!&

*:¥l

%

-, ---.

L.

_ _

*

rtf

.:£

1f 1f

-:¥= :

i 1

(~;~;}. J:!;~

..

~ ~j

El

ft~

: __

5-\-~----'.,_1--,---,

_)

tt

-t"

'±A~

A. :

*+

~ ~i

13

tf

I\.;

*~

M.

Xi¥-

:t-

grp

!' :., ,

t

~ ~{~

--- 3

~

,tt

§

80--- 4

;f- ,

:ft-H :m1T

if;

YJJ

a

~

*(

J9:.)--- --

6

!1t '

,~jl

t

it

Jfl

,It

7f3 -

:l

*-

---11

11i '

,~t

tcg.---

12

ri '

)1(1

1~~

---14

)1(1

1~

- : it

~ ~m

ot1.eti

~

1..

Jl!i:f~ ~jf

;;E.1t 1;

~nUf£---16

)1(1

1;~

-=- :

It

~ ~m

.t1.eti ~

1..

Jl!i:f~ f;c.iff;

*-

---17

m

1~":=-

:

it

~ ~m

;t1:fi

~

1..

)j!i:f~ f~ f~ ~

Jt

tfal

*

---18

1..

Jl!i:f~ f~.eti I'lip

;t

Jt

tfal

*

---19

f{1};~ ~

:

It~ ~m

ot1.eti ~ 1..Jl!i:f~ ~~ r~ ~

-ri:t

---21

)1(1

1~-t :

it

~ ~m

otl.eti

1..

Jl!i:f~ f~:f~

:t-

I'lip

-ri

:t---

22

t~.:t... ~

*:3 ---

25

-­

~.

5i- )

fIJ ;t

f~~

J.:t...

=-x.it 5i-1:$

*

---33

Ni 1*' +

:

r

;f.::J:ml;f! fif,.

~ .f~ ~

I

z

it

t~

..

:ft-

~

*

~ i]::~

Cit.i:tJt

0_ )

a~

t,

,ltli

J

z::J:

it 0_1:$ ;& &.

00

-Jl~

li ---

34

f{i1*,

+

~

:;it

.ft1:

*ifl

1-.{£

~8:t~Jl a~

fiX.

-

'l;&

~fo!~

li

---35

)l(i 1*' +

:

it

1i

~* -ilifl ~

1.1fJt~

*-

~ ~* ·~~.A~ ~

*

it

)t

~Jf t~

-t-

*---

36

f{t1*'+/\..:

r

;f.::J:~fl~fif,.Ji ij5Th'hJl/Jf4.ti~PfT a~it*(1tJA.0_)ra','ij!J

z::J:it

0_1$

&.

00

1f5li ---3 7

Fft1*'+iL :

~fl;f!j:Gi*,;&ru'~_$t'R~z::J:tt0_1$;&'

wMkli&.001f5li---38

Ffi i1

=-

+ :

rif,.

~

1I't1'"

4E.tt

*~;fl

;jitlX.

*

1-

~fl~

fif,.

a~

t,

Jt

~ ~ titz.f~

i*'---40

[\{i 1*'

=-

+ - :

It!lifi

1I't

-If

4E. it

*i;fl

;tit

It

* *

1-

~fl;fh

rif,.

a~

t,

Jt

~ ~

tit

z

~ io~

---41

*~#~~.~~~

• •

~~-4 £.#§'~~*±.~~.~A'~

~~~ft~ft*~

,~ ~* *~~~~D~~'*#.~**Mft~*

~

• •

~

• •

~~~ft~,~ .*#§*~4.~ ~,*~,~ .*~~

ti *

±JlrLf~ ~'*

'

1t

Jj~~ilUtti

* '

JtJr~

i!3&1

~ 1fH~H!P~{M

(Peer Instruction/ Peer­

Tutoring)

'J:)' ~

*tJ'h!l/J

~

*

a~ ~

J\ ft

1r& *

±"~H1Hf(,j;t

,

iJFt{l;"f1..~-'111

a0

~

i!3&1

~~.~R.*~~rt' ~~&*.rt*o

~~- M1t~.*~&ft* ±a.~'~A~aft*~ ~~-.,~

~5itffitJtt~~:

- .

~ 84%a0.*~ifl;titi ±Jlli;f~~~,*~ ~:t: .tm~~ ~

~

• -ij:.a0Et;"f1..

~ ~1l55~1t±-fb ~.*({W9Jl)j-)a~:t:J.iiJt;.=-·

3&1 77.7%4i

~ifl

tst

ti *

a~

±

tfb

A 1±

)jli;f~ ~'* ~

'31

~

1t

ur

J:),

~

*.ti

1::

~ifl

;f;t

tt * ±

~

ii

UWi

)j-)

8~ ~1t; -==- . ~

3&1 87. 9%.ti 1:

~ifl

;fiti * a0 * ±

tfb

A '

Jjli;f~ ~'* ~ ~5

tth

Jl!J

M-

i*

PIT

1~H~

ii* ( itJ:.

~

)

F,,9:iU! '

1ft

~ 8~ Jt~

80

~ ~* ~ ~

*

~

ur

j::),

1t

lji ,

1±!!

1T

~

. '

±~~*# ~!!~'iJF~.1:~&ft*~*±~1±~.~~~

~~ft *~ii*a0~l¥,1tffit~;yJL.: L1!J. j..til'liji(80%)~:t:i!i&lJjIi;f~~*-a0t6h!l/J' ~5

~~ ~

r

M-

*

*

~

ii* (

qWut )1-)

8~

r119:iU! ;

,

Jt

t~ ~iH ;fit

ti 1t

Jj~ ~ 8~

Fa9

1ft

.L

AA~~~~ff'A .AU~OO~~~' ~~~J\~~~.~*~~

•

~iH ;fit

tt *

0 ~,~

'$-

ffit

a~

l'liji

A

1:[\ ~

ii

~iH

tst

ti * *

Jlli;f~ ~'*

a0

;:j] ~5

~

511. '

£:Y

k

1J

~ ,~

fvJ

a~ ~

k

~

Jl!J

a~

, k

1K

~

4;'1T

a0

-L

11

0

-,

ffl

a9

Bell-Lancaster

~

1..

f#u

Ii

$f

*

a9

~

iJt

M

+"3t

-*ifl

fij]

7il

(peer-assisted learning)-k

(peer tutoring) ,

M

.te(peer modeling) ,

M

1~~i

(peer education) ,

M

)lij

(peer

counseling) ,

M

1~ ~

if

(peer

monitoring)~

M

1~~ty(peer

assessment)

0

..

---­

li[1-Alfl

*-

~~1..a0~ ~JL

'

tt1t

~

E0

fl

~;f£(Gyanani &

Pahuja,1995;

Maheady, 1998)

I~Ht

'

*_

o/'~~~*_~~Jl~tt~*_fiG1t.i~~t**£;t.:f§ ~~~tg;p ,~ tfti~ttt~H

§~~ ;t.~~,~*~~~,~~.~~aft*~1..~.~'.~~aft

~~~~,~*~~ ~~a~, ~~4~~~E0~&'~~E0~*~~ ~

t£

~

a0

~

it '

J/ii

~ ~

J1f.:h '

ptf

1-:1,

*_

tt

-t"

~Jl

:l

it

~ ~ 1~

J/iifl

~ f~

1M (Peer

Instruction/Peer-Tutoring)

'~l£

Ji

J/i11i:

a0

M

~

fifl

1ft;

~ffl J~

a0

M

* '

1-:1, ~

thh

JVJ

M

~E0~A~~~1..~g~.,~~@Ji~~E0 ~~~~.M&.*fl~~1

~ &*~~*o ;t.'*_~-t";t.§E0A~~.~~aft ~~~.~, ~

-'M~~~~Aft E0~1..~~a.~~RE0~JVJ ~M~M~~E0 .~

E0M

~'M ft~~~aft~ 1..~.~E0VJVJ ~~TM*1.. 'M:l~~Y~.~~Aft~~ E0~C~.o

- , ;£.:IT-:it

~

:tift

.f>t

$t

~ ~

1..

Jlli$

~

tt~~m.f{~i~*" JHL*~~f/.J;£.:IT- § 2006/9/5

W

~t*

tf·\.;

~t

1zJ,'lj;

~

ttl

iJJ

; 2006112112 i!

-it

~

~ ~.~~.

~~~~~

J

iJJ;fy~;

2006112/28

i!1t~1i.::jVt

'

~l~tt

rit

~mJt*

1.. JJfLf}S-

#.c.

~~ •

J '

r.tt *"

~m

;It <ti

~

1..

JJIi

f}S-

f~

<ti

grp

~ ~?al •

J '

r it

~

it *

iifl

;tit

:ti

*

1.. ~l ~ f~ f~ ~

1f. r

it

*

iifl

:ti

*

1.. ~l f~ f~ ~

Jt

tfo]

~~ tf~- r.ft1f.~!J[5]*~ *,~a~lft;f.Itf 1155~1t'±'fb ~it*(1f.i;fA

t6l ~ ,

,...J j~ J

~

1&

84%

fJ0

f~ ~

[5]

1f.

,ill

!J

raj

*

~

* '

~ a~

J.ft;f.I tf

~

115

5~

11:.

.±.

fb

~

it * (1f.i

;fft

0'-)

a~

LYJi'

ar

it

Pt

T

;$..

tt

~

-100

-R-

It

El

;f;lf-

::it~

it

*

*ij5j"it:ti

*

1.. ~l~

(29.30%)'

[5]~:1rti(48.44%)'

i!1ar:1rti(20.70%) ,

~F ~[5]

:1rti(0.78%) ,

ru

:-j: 7} 1~

&.

00

%

(tk

Jt

~i

1:;y,

+

1L) , ~

ill

1&

77.

7%~t

iifl

.tit:li

M

1.. t~ ~

1f.

~l ~ f~ ~ ~

I

-Z..i&

ar

.t:J-

*-

*

tt 1::

iiij

.tit:li

*

1..

~

it (1*1;fA

0'- )

-*-

$

.}fJH~ ~

93

ill.

1-

.}i

,~Ii ~

r¥.

~

1m

i}f- ,

Jt.}fJl:f7J;&

~*

-'f-

);:0

11L~

34. 70 '

iITJ

*-;fi

1:

nli

th

r¥.

~

1m

i}f-

60

1-

-*

~

178

ill. '

.}fJl

~7J

;&

-'f-

);:0

~

58.3 O(

tt *-

YL

f11

Ji*'

+

~)

,

lif.J

4f.f!.

~ ~Jj

if

~

(independent sample t=8.3 7,p=O.OOO<O.OO 1) ;

k~

iITJ ' ~ft ~

;fi

1:

nli

th

r¥.

~

1m

.:Z..

$

-it.

~

B:;j-.}fJl 60 ;&

~*

69

MH}

~

Ctt

i-

Jt

FH

Ji~

+

~

)

or

fJ..1t

Jjt ,

-it.

1T

*m

i}f-

.:Z..1t,

1-

a0

;&

~*

;f:;j-

~

J:i!:.

*'

flJ

r

.}fJl

* '

-ku

;l'U~~ ~

~

(F=0.004,p=0.94 7>0.05)

Ctt

*­

[l~ ~

115

ttfh

1l/J

M

if~

PIT

3t

~

60

it

$

(1t.bffl

!JJ- )

rc~ ~ J

po,

~

a0

@]

$.

*2

qF

'*

I&J

:t

4f

li

(33.59%)'

I&J:t4fli(54.30%) ,

~or4f6(12.11%)'

ti3::x.it7}1-1fi.t'zllOO1tj

(tt*­

::tt

b

(20%)'

( - ) -It

;flij ;fit

:eft

$ $

1-

~&.:r~ r~ r~ ~

fA

Jt

~

rt

t!

~~. ~A~$$1-

• •

~~~$r. ~A~

~;f1. tf

~S 5~

1

t.

.£

fiJ

~

1t

* (

ft.t

~

)j-)

fIJ

;t

~J;t

;

JJ:i:.!:Ii,!;;;f

or

1;( ~~ ~

a0'&

J.t (

~

YL

F1Hff;

..::.. +

);t

ill '

1§IJ-ko

~ r~ ~ t.~ ~

r

~

if

JJll

A

ilt

1f

~

;y,t

&'<. J '

r

~~

¥}

a0 .i@;f1.

tf

~

c..

~Ii~

;ji

1:~ijl ;t:t:ft

* *

±

*

~

1t

*(it.t~)j-)

ag

;t

~J;t

;

1;(~ B:t.}f~

fIJ

Ji§.~ag~~

Ii

(m

it

+

~

)or ]:).

~t

JJt '

1i

llUt

~~ ~ :t.i! '

*

±

a0

Ji§.

~*

4:t

#.l

!1l!. i!

iV '

ill

T jl:A

*- '

4.(0

:~U·1~

r%t.}fA ;fJ] Ji§.

~* a~] ~

¥ '

1;f,;pt1'-.}fA

*-

Ji§.

~* ~ ~

1f

I~ ~ ~

J!-

UN

~ff;

+

-t::) ,

*

~r

;ji

1:

~ijl t~

-=- '

~

1&

87. 9%;ji

1:

~ijl t~:fi

*

ag

*

±

t.~ ~

,

Jlli;f~

f¥-

~ ~s

t£h

JIj;

M

~fdn- 3l~

ag

1t

* (

1~i:flt

J7'-) fa'

il! '

1;(

Jlli;f~ ~~ ~ 1i~ ~

*

1.

ag

1L

fiJ

J@;f1.

tf '

~t.~ ~

it

100

1;t

~

r

~

*~*~

'*,-J

(~Jtr1i~~"::"+)

,

15I;jl~~:ftgrpt,~~

r

:i!.i@JlIi;fh~~ag~ijl or~+t:­

·~.~A~ T~~*M ~~ MttM~~ff'A~ .~~OO

~~'*M~~A~~~. *~~*3 ~A~

o.

,~ ~~

A.

i~

ill

Jt

it *IH;t

'* '*

mLf~ ~~ a~ ;:j) ~s ~

J#.

~i

'

1i-

Y

It. 1't '1f

.(>

foJ

a~ ~

*It.'1ftM~'It.~ .~$ff~L~c

.~,a*~A~ *±~.~~ ~'~~#3~~ ~~* ~M'

~# ff~ ~'* '1f~M'~#~~~~,*'1f

M'

'1f~ ~J#.~,It.

-1m

~~~~!i!~

4lt.Jl

~ i1!1ta~

Lit

c

Ji'

+A '

r *::X.~fl.f1Ht~tJ5k'hflJJMi*M3t~WJik.*(1~.t;fA-1r )Pt1'~ j .:t.::x.tk.1r1~:tt

&. Jru

1tj

Ii

+~, a~~.*M~1r

•

.:t.~.1r~*'.*Ii&.Jru%1i ~+, ~~M ~.*~~ft**±a~~WJ~~~~

•

.:t.~. ~+-, ft~M.~.*~~ft**±a~~WJ ~~~

•

.:t.~. ~+~, $-:4f;z.~ 15

1.

J-t

"*~.t

Sip1tt ¥lj/:Lfi-

f~ ~

2.

J-t

t*~.t

sip

~

111-

ljli:fi-

ft

~ ~

f-t

~ J!~t ~

if1

Jt

B'if

M

3.

f-t

~

1!1T

it *

*i$l-t-t~.t

* ljli:fi- '

.iE

J~ ~

it *:fi13

;fi~.t

*

1-mi:fi-

~Gj~;fz

4.

~~~.*~.~ 1-a.~. ~~~"*~~

5.

;f§ ~~ tf( t*~.t

sip

7/;'-

*

ftfl

3ft

-m -

:i1!

(~

1 7 )

Wi

it*

*fl

;fit~.t

* * 1-

mi.

~~ ~~ ~

t:

~m. ~~~~a.~~~~.iE~~

6.

~Aitf }'E

+

#Ji 1&

~

M(f it *

*"

-'fit

~i

*

1.

ljli:f~ Il~ ~i

gip

~ t~

gip

~.iE~~t

7.

;fEl

~~

J-t

t*

~.t

gip M(f

?iT

~ ~t.:t..

it* *i13 ;fit

~.t

* 1. Jjfi:fi-

f~ 11~ ~

t:

~ +~Ji1& ~

8.

jtJ],~i3fta'if(~

18

:i1!);j:Eln~.}ft"*~igipM(fit*~i$l;fit~**1-JjIi:fi-jGj;f- ,&jtJ]

tf '

jtJ]

*-

1&

~-tr

(

~

J:.. '

jtJ]

1&

).:t..

Exee 1

{i ~ ~Aitf }'E

+

~Ji

1&

~

9.

Aitf }'E I

J'

~Ji

1!

1f

1ft

~ ~ ~)j-{Jt .:L

1'1=

El

JiA :

- - - -

ai-rei :

-JJlft.&.: _ _ __ ti~:

_ _ __

~1t.: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

Fa'

-Jl!

*-

17

1

_{J :}

.'if

'it

.'if

'it

l.

*-=x

~fLf%-r~ ~ .Ji§ ~ I.:t-i&.

t1t ft

~

*

~

it

* (

fT.i offl; 51-)E~ :t~~

r§]~

D

M~

D

[!,Jar

D

/f:M:t /f:M:t

D

D

2. *-=xmLf!

r~ ~ tit t4!I/J fW ii', rtf il~ E~ tt

*

(ttioffl; 51- ) po':Jl!

D

D

D

D

D

...

...:e-~~c---1.

~1£*rn~M~iX.~* ,~FJ01fI;f£'f ~~E3~1t.

'f/J

1:it*(~i{t)f-)FJ0 ~j{ 0

~f

M

rlfJ

~M

1.

i!i&mtf~f~agt;/}1;WJ ':m~5~ii]

T

1.

~tt*(1~i~5t)8gMi1!

o

qF 'It

fii]

t:

o

fii]

t:

r%ar

'0

-r 8 JX­ L /f"" jPJ,~

o

qF 'It

~ fii]

t:

19 0

~i~ ~1t.~

1t.-

'f'

.1.~i ~ **~~:;Itgrp ~1t.~

lm~i_~-

'f'

_-~~

_*-iL

:;It grp

~lif~f~ ~

ljI

if-

f.;&.

-=:''f'

-'f'

-'f'

-'f'

-'f'

'f'

i~j!~tm.

*%tJJ

;t-I%­

~1ff:

_~f~fX*~

mf •

3ft~IfjJJi-!f4*~=1f:Z}!Jf

iiij.

¥

~*

1n

95

*1f:JJlm=*Mtt{:f*~3ft~W~$*J)JGf4

*~WtpJ~\ rJt*~~~*m~~~J ~~

,

~1tj

IttAA '

j;)~~ryj

0 21

_~f4tx*~

m _

f-t¥~1fcp{,\**~!f ~gm~

95

¥1f:JJtm

=¥Mtti{:£*~3!l~W~$¥~f3f~¥~~

cP

JL\

r

~¥fm~~~g~~~

J

~t_±~

A

t~~~

em '

~j}]{Jl:cjfj\

,

P)~~ryj

0

Att

4

12

3

o

o

21%

63%

16%

0%

0%

/,: .,-' "~t' p ~'" ~,.

t

.~~ 4#~~ ~{;~ , ~..,~~ H

....

,,:..;

..

t,;~. '5 J. ,

-

j:~

..

,~~ :...., ? '.. I ;~..;.?.t_=­ :~. ;-;w,­ .J--:'~: j ( _"',I ~ /L, '~

!

~

..

fd1

l'" ::I; "':'wiI"­ 1 ­

10

~Fl tJ 'l'J .-.) " ",I j ,:1 .jr 1 _'~JI'"'( !"'. ..

r:

~. .',t'

.

,.. \.}

.8

;8

D p~ i '~; ':Ii.'. ~r Ii t.1

-.j

0

D

~1 ;:J ~CI il ,j)

r

:)

-~O, ~iT

o

~

:8,

_I

n

v :)

-·1 v ')

n

_'! iJ,

:8:,

o

;J.p'mfQJ

III

DffiJllJ

i

D/ffQJ

i

L~~pm/f

fQJ_

i

m~+~;k~~~~~~.±~~~~~~*-~*~~~~

{ ..IIi0:{E ~'E

F&~cE1 )\.~

J&/j\{U§:

ZP:f:j{l~ ·'J·~4-b-: i !~ /: " , ..­

178

0

100

58.30.

21.945

,ttJH1J

,ttJJq:J

178

0

100

I

56.48

24.966

178

2

100

61.81

22.575

,ttJJ*

178

I A~ !

93

I

₀

76

34.70

22.214

,ttJJ*JJ

W]rp

931

0

100

49.15

22.527

M*

93

0

99

57.86

24.069

I

93

A~ 60.00 50.00 30.00 35

ZJS1JfD

§EI3N

t~tifD

F

_P

ID~~/tt*~*§w:JlI!lo_~ p ~

1

'Jc-':;x ...

4087.43

2.33

139418.01

1134883.10

144461.22

1

1

268

271

270

4087.43

2.32

520.22

7.857

.004

.005

.947

FIt

it-

+

i\.: r

-*-.::k

Jl!i$

~ ~ ~5 ~

.!l/J

M-

i*

fIb!

l!

ffJ

it

*(

.~ 7)- )

M

~J ~.::k

it

7)-{iji

*aOO%ti1

1':}

₁₈

-.j

o

11 v il il

85

.i1

1'! 1i· ... _~ .l. 1

0%

12%

0%

III

o

#lspJ

01'

37

I

,

i

I

I

I

I

i

I

j

fl(t~+iL JlJi$ ,~c:.it-

$:.

ru,

1l!

1}~Jt

;t.:.ktt

1}~

$:.

,

~~k

Ii

a

III

1f}

Ii

A B

1

'4\ 'is 1 ;'v:

2

~,;~~(~~ ~.~ ~

16

a _{~-: -c- :.JL ~.!}

tx..

3 .:.,."# >'.~~::!-'.. .... "~

fl

4 .=...~ b~t~b~( ."", 'ry~ ~,:" _{:~ ~} t ":₁ ,_J 5 ... '. - " , 6 .~2i ~ ~t:-'7,. ~'b~t 7

-?

'~~::

':;.t

;'5

8 ~-? ~~ ! ~, 9 ..- "':;J "!...:- • + , .:..~- ,.'­ l'~ 10 .~~ t~ ~ ~ . , :t ..~: .:Ji..;;i .... t,:

₄

11 ~~:: ~~~,:" ~.t ;'7 18 /7 ...- : .i", '~. ~ ~,

:t­

.}"'" .:--at :i".. i.XJ ~ ,,_

13 .=....

-

~.

-

~~bt( 14 ~1i .~~

=:

~ ~ 15 ~~~.t::. -, 16 :'l!;. !.r_...

I

-17

81

100

C ':~f:..~

13

8

12

,) .:1 • ' j 1·) \ .) \)

:4

D

:J4,;f.

tt

1 ') 'J

10

.:! 9 0 3 E S:~;<*

'32

1 ':0 .!.'-' 1-1

19

1':'

1.:14

F

6'1

;"

.~ i) '. ':J

4

,:1 ,? -'~\ 9 ,j

4

SJ 18 .J

4

.J

4

(1 Hie, G :;'r:";;; "'!'t,,,...';'''''.~'<.,-,.,

32

_c

4

·31 -" .:.0

111

18

'I­

-F1

~),) ~j .:!

45

4

V,

4,:<1

H ~':.,L

'.

E"

4.43:

O. 89: f•. (3~::, .)~

-:c::·

24,

E.l'

·3.

~j'}: ,), g.}: -J! • ~l -1. " -i·,.,

14.

-1 !

2.

»}': 'j,

S'L

9.:4_{;3 .} 'I

_.

8<:< " ) .

-

_{I • 98~:·} I I

A*rz:jtJn£.~_{.;J fiJ:t 1-IIJ\Jt:.)}

o £il!1Sz£1lI

rp~~

8%

7%

4%

_II

_~JJtct~

_I§1Sz

I

0

-=fE3

~j~~I§I~

i

o

1~5tEr"J

Jf!;ffl

1%

!.

_{f~!1~&~I§I~i}

o

ffl5tB"Jf~JJ

2%

6%

II

D~pR

II

f~~;NISz~I§~

II

1~7tEr"J1S(JJ

o

~JJtct&~~1Sz

o

:~fE3&~·t?EI~

25%

4%

• *J7tEr"Jff!ffl

6%

4%

_·*&I~

.11

~1m

39

..

f~ ~

9:

r ...

*IHit

~t

:iF

~

... '

1!2.

*

ilHr'j

it

N~:iF

f,5) ...

J 0

f~~

10:

r ... ~1r,

f/Hi:iFf,5) ...

J 0

~~ ~

11:

r ... ~~.;ft~t ~Ji 5~HfjLIJ~ ~t

:iF *f

a0

M

*

~

*

~

,

#.

~JJI1 ... J

~,'

'" 14'

r

r¥­

~

. . . .

<tHip 1:

I ...

,f;Y

!l

A

*

1t

&r

jf;?(E.

tt

~ill

;tit

it

*...

it

1&

~ft~ f~

80 flO

or

're -

ll!:. /}:

:i1t

r",'

:t

flip r""

:it!

a~ ~

...

J 0

<tUlip 2:

I .. , ~

'f '

JiHtd

~

A

jf;O(E. ~ffl;tit

<tt

*...

~13JJ

T

:1f

/~

fuJ

a0

~

0

4t~.iE

(t\. 83)

0 M1~Hilp~a~J1.t~.£hJt 0

MiI'$11 ,

30

(2)

'41-49

i~~ (

t\.

81)

0 M

1'i1Hm

¥}4*$,&[ID

4'

a~.!lm 0

Mil

J1

11' 28

(11.12) '39-42

0

Gyanani, T. C.

&

Pahuja, P. (1995). Brief research report: Effects of peer tutoring on

abilities and achievement.

Contempormy Educational sychology, 20( 4),

469-475.

Maheady,

L.

(1998). Advantages and disadvantages of peer-assisted learning strategies.

In Topping, K.

&

Ehly, S. (Eds.),

Peer-assisted learning (pp. 45-65). Mahwah,

New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Good.

Slavin, R. E. ( 1990)

.Cooperative learning: TheOfY, research, and practice. Englewood