公部門課責問題之探究

全文

(1)~fdH. 2. t5f: a',. fftLfJ rl\ji1Ji. , ~~.~.~Z- ' lli m W7~ fr~~~ ~mM ~ .mR.~ ' ~~ - ~ ~~~~. iii. - ~ft~~~ ~ ~~tt ~ ~ ~~~~ ~~. {;f(JI;JMF. ll:t 1itt YOll ij :a: 0 ;!t~~r:pm.~(I~J. t!2 ~~. lli.~*~~~~. fffl~~fi ' ~ ~fflJ $iT LJ/:J ~ Jlll. rr [:f: t1J ~ , ~A l@'i l J..:}, ~Jl ' ~ ~. J'm:(JIJ &1ti. 1:. ' nf.it1H~~ * ' rfnffliP - , ~ Ij ~.m~ , ~ fiE ( empolVer mcn t ') f.li~; Hf! ' l-.:tf~ r;l'lltJ:!'I/~r. 1)l'~W''jflHtffll1\l8'~]J:~:a-8'9,:jdJ~ (Da uph i na i ~. & Pede r so n 1995). .~~~~. }l.t {E~~ .Y~J:: ,;g :.ijijUtJl~}:ff. m~~~~~~.~m , ~. ~ · .~.~~~& A ~m. •• ~ .~~. Jff~ ~ iiAWJ 9-I PJTm7f; ln mL IJ. ' WlJ yO : 5tuJfflJ. ~~m. .tiS )JIJ~7 -iJ':: ~ 7f;~.j[:Y JrJ5J-11~j{· ( Accoun t. ab i I i ty). Jik- fj 1JJz IJ:bm'f~lj';-JlijJ1* o t')frn w<;~. ~'ZrJJ ~;{'@/ff[d~n£ ?. (Be I I one and. Goe rl 1992:Hu o hes L998:Lynn 1992: ~ Io e. 19 94). :%t'; ' A J3!: fiJr~t,. Jj{J lE~fJT~ n/:J. r£J.}ji± - ~ijE. ~~ ~A~. w.: i'i~ I#.J m1:;s1. I-I 'J. ~~t',. IIU R K--. * ' iji"t"*. ---. I'll. rd. ~II M ~·t if;OrH'i~ 1"J IJII];) ~~~. fit ilil Jml*~ Ol ffl ffl' '. .. ~ffl~.ffl~~~ ·. {El nIJ-tQfW~{jtUI'9~;fj~U<::illl:ifi ' I t. )\, .c?J1~ 7~. BR~=~~I~ ~. ' ~7.~~~ffl 'Xh 1T:i- i3'i' 'tt: ;1-'; - h ''''' Jl-)('I1;j' l-'-t:i.e [1)(, J.IJ ~H. El ~. ~~ ' .~n ~ ~. ~. r z;[1("l: .,. ' d3}j~RJ.{r~lfi. ,. ~ 1-M'. .tl ~l .. , :tE~J.--B"J U~~ I:. ~$ ~. fIff'1'. ~ r:;\;j {d-r 1& {tHr:@3§: 'ili!il ~ f!X __b~ L'. {EI ~ ,. I. , [:5J rtt '. * -R. I. tt ' ~ ~ k~~9~ ' *~~~ ~ ~~. .F.!rT Wf UH3<': J(J Tl+ ill cr CrmSl ~. 37lj*~~,L._.ti'~. /. J9lU. m33~. 3Jl1l193. !. ~. --fiP:. ~r. ink ,. .H : 'ill'l :U!.rr)f-1J. ... 'jIll 13 n~ ~. '~J' 1....1 l~A f,ro, flt:: - / I"HJ nzJ~ k8 ~ /L I i3 rI ' -' I ~ T ... :. 1, $U!J~ f,* -~ (J<) ,JJ!i ' fF m '. 11'. &, '. H3M fYHJC ' '§' fji[&~@B'9 ~! ~ {~:J:UJDfJ. L iM ' slE JLjfi"tfr.!;;l1TI -: -- "l-~ ~ ~ {~& m,iW fl( ,. H.£'.7"G. j :1~~. , 1;7t. H- - eiI 7" ff~" H 'lLn "t- ['011 ~ll ' :fl- ~ ,F.-.).J ~ !hiiF d li'H;;L 1') 0 . ~. '. f~ :rt,;fD f~:Em _ ± jlj (]ZJ~ l'it§(b: ' BJ av~ 0. ~ .L!lIh. -v:. \\\' ra b i. tEN1~WE' !;~ WT1iJf~i: __ tm;~J2'r. -::ll' 'C- 1I±1 ..';t3 A. IIH i Fl;r.,U "1 fJ;X ,~,. ~.·~ ft ' ~~~~ ~ N~z - , ~ ~. 10 .. · j,ugj. ;. "[I eJ. fl'9 - --~rti' *J~,~~Llfi'!J - l}£~'> Jm - - ~l'· n';".. :¥:l >,~ . I 99 7 1:-T-1i~ ~ ~ m!!Ii ib I '~ }:J~ PJT~~ r: i'rJ ~ r~l! iIfJ7>- 1 !&1 :L} J~ :-t;;J!lF 9- f,jLfftff ~1 @ 41 r1fT H4j / 1 -:; i}j:i.( 1~;J!j1l'1'9. ' ;,m'. ~iI'~ (11;:1 Mf ¥,: !. fill Iff!. _1. '±~1)]U - 5¥tJ fj~~JfJ8~J1F((J:' iTTi,i*::t?rD1 rffi Ell Vj~ tk: ' lit\:: It:: '{ 7£ Jljz: l JfI} ill r& J)] lfl£ I -I'll 0. ~. rr0.PG :. ~. 1f:F. m-m. 0. ~ OO A ~~ ID M ~ ~N ' ®~~. ~ ~~. l-:J'*ti~fj!{.'&. ? ', flf". !l:t1t1B~DJ3T,;",. If'O(~:OIJ1. A. Mtgf~ilft~UO'Jm:aru t nt-t ~ tl ~ v'" rIT1 = '- --7. '£' '. "'t 1*1 . UIJt,;l,. ~,~. ~ f!J~ /. 1ft.IJLA. ~m 1i ff; B'Jff,j~ (T err y. 1It5li- '. {fJt~m1~m UJ ifH~. F/f~ , ~ ~~ft~~m·. llX 1:H il:X!lIYJ f:EJ ~ ,. ol fh~. 0. '. ~:"g . rr~*Jf i'1z7rJf )t. 0*~:E.T A ( publi c manage r ) ff~ ~,tN ~ 0. 1998 : 198) (I~J Fo5Jm. I. ;;H:tJ Yf Jj;::J. I,. ffl; t'-H i J(l<jf.. itU ,.- h ll{j 1"'I,. :bbra ~frlf Jt~lt~':. :Mi. ~O J..~ ~ft . ];) 1~ :F.S~)-fJI·!l:t ,fr~~(1'J ~. '. .. :?1tiJ! \; pons.

(2) ~. !~Q ~. ~ .~ ~. Q. 2, f'AJ~'l" S-~~jtf~:tt1&:Ilt Z FEI~FJl (ti~t4: ' /M ;J:/-. ' L'"IfI~. ~. ==- 1lf.ll:;;E fl3 ?l~ 'P '.rQ::mJi; ~]~m =P6h. f;t)J50U~7t<:.l>l.. ' IS. IJg iill'i*)1£ 1'i. 51" -i'Jr. JJ\W1<: W /5Z: §'~ iVr\: J;Et 1~): "~I ~. •• ~ .~ ~ m @A ~ W .tim. ;®A~ .ff ,. ~* ~~& m ~ * ~. • •. ~~ o . ~,~ m~$~ ~. ~ m-. ~ * ~ ~ .a$ , . ~~m ~ ~. 0. JI: . ffi ~ 0 . ~~ ~. ,. ll .~~ nfi. ' tl:t\:& f~ffl. ~~Q; J~H9~. j~~ fm :rr. •• ~. ~ '. El3 1/~'~:at JJ:l~I~,tB: Cl'J ~ [§] !oJtl:. ••. ' IZSlltt 1iH~. * m~. ••. •• ~ ~ .~Et9.~. ~ o ~ ~, .~~ ~ ~ .~ ~. ~. w ~ m ~~ ,~ ~ a ~ ~ HEIJ'J l!lli: 0'. ,. •• ~ . * ~. JJ:t :9HQf&-UI~ 71' rnJ *~l Km\ 5C H:,. MEl tj(!J~. l ~~ ~~ B~. , ~~. ~~~ R''l. ~~~.-~ ' ~ ~~ ~~*M ~m~ .. ffiU' f,1Z1'1'rri5J t ),:tE Ma rk Bove ns. ~ (]':J -L~ 1~. tti. (The Ques t for Res -pon s ibilily ). lpi1in a i s. tt8 tt~ R JJ:l:Jaf~f?E {~ ;c~8~0V3jJ. •• IIt.~ ~. u. ~ RlJ J" illr! J~ /trf. fl ,~l fiJf. 'Ih -e, fi'J' J~ F J )a - ,. ~J!r. ' llX. ~ -ffl'~ Bl ¥J ~~. ,. ~ J1t. *-rrfl~M% fjE :5Z]t,« IY]i~EM~illi~ti. '. £lil +?l:!'!'lj "I!A ,J, FFJ I ~." .... 1~ 11. ~ IH = rl,t.J,!'m: -<£'-. "''', 1+1. w7j( 1Q ~. '. •. .(:;I.. I- ~ -<:7~. " JrJ.~~-r.::r §M.. - ~fi.~ tt~ %~~ ' ffi U ~~ A~ ~. IEVnW11'W {filiWH;,f , rm Acco untabi 1 i ly cp5( =m :::;!;;: 11J1l'1t .~.r;.; t }<i~ fiJl' Ji'.l. ;:;r fif.' '2i:-. ~. ~\\crab i. -gi;' ' :R: XWJl cfJ ~JtT);"!r. ,.". -;:;1';. - h' -. .L -. "'h 8. 1 i ty ( ~JI: ~ ' 1994). ~. $. 0. A n. fP,ijfrj , rj~. ~ f1Hi}f7t. ~- tl1~~8(] m* u. '!JLt9)G tJ. Fr ink and Rich a rd J, KI imo s ki. 'g tiff '9t LlJ. f~~1fJ ft:,J.lli5ffil. .t7flj~' fM >tc; 0l'el ~ FR -I;!: lvL 1- ') n?K H. 1::< " " ',,, ~ "H I' JE ~. ~. ,Q, ~Ji. m. ~& ~~ ~~fi~~m~ , ~ ~ ~~. ~j] D t:,JJ~. ~ ~~~ ~~~~~m ~ ' ~ A ~ ff~~. ( Ro 1e. '. itI!X tzu ~~. l. !lt ~~IU ~'@!f1~ g A. a:ii1 (llt~:1Jf:f.¥. f!jfF GJJ ~~. 'i; \' * Rl g!fl '11~fF ~rl'l~. ~E 1w.tiJ. r. heor y ). '. '. ~li~I1R ~. Bo vens ~~ XJtf~ m~*. . ' M[~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ tt , ~.ft 0~~ flli~~. ,. if .t:JIiI - * 1JD .t:J~Eij3. (Bove n s '. 19C)8 : 51 ) : ~w. (u ccou ntahil i ty ). 1'l'J~ ~}.j*~J~. *ftilB':J. l~ A I¥J. ( corpo rate). (pe r sonal ). 1fi*&'!'l'J. ~1l'~i'lt;. I'IlJ it!l'. ( bo th ). (some audi e nces). 1;Yd1X ~/FIa] ~ 'I~:tlrm1~HEl. ( 1998 : 9). ( hi era rc hi ca l ) (co ll ec t ive ). (11iI~ Ij A!j. (inJivid LHI I ). Bov e ns ~~:t'IB':J~. 0. JJ:t>' ~. , .~":b: iI~~ :N'm~- ' - tl J'I- *BzJ f lJ\tiff f~ ~ , 21J~ ti IJ l'J 1J~ :9'1- 1£ EI'>] fit ~ $<, )I/W ijE [Q]~~'1lf Mos he. '. , :;ftJE~~lHt). fjE,G<f,l. (Ja bbr a & Dw iv edi, 1988 : 24-25) , ~ ~I1!{ :ft. , :fr~n:. , ;YtcpmtilI:i B~) J({1 (Nc . Mo she r t'/;J?&~W 1:f:. Dwh i gh l D,. y;J e;, ,,1l:I --- ' h -IAn: ~ Fa / - -e;:,) -~ , __it , :Oil> f.7:'-; if'!' ..f 't I::l ' J 1l'-I. ,\3, JJ:: f T R \, "" 1". ~j{~i!t. =1:: f El '§c. ( Re s pons ib iii 1 y) lii:7t ~. ga t i ve Respon s i bi 1i t y). ~~ a ~ ~. @ w ' .~ ~.~ ~ .~~. j~. cp 1l ~ H~i{{1. :IE '. ( tlHf ). JJ:t*. 27 ) f:l(; fDfl3H!f 8'] M~. W1~Wtj!l~ I:lj . 1~. 5ffi ~~' ~3Z 9::I 8/:JRespon s ibi1ity. " ~::« w 1:l //. 1!fcp ( 1998 :. ffi li ~m ' ffi U ' ~.~.~~~+Bm. ilt £L ML"[1-<J'. ,. &~mffi . ~~ ~fi tt ' ~7.~~~~. lEtzo. r pIT J§' BzJ ~Wl.{f ( Obj ec t i ve. Respons ibi 1i ty) - fiJQ ( 198 2 : 9-12 ) ,. jj;j<;j*;lJi[ :. ~I a r k. Bove ns(1 998},The Quesl for Re s pons ib iii t y : Ac co un t ab ii i t y and Citi zen shi p i n Complex Or gani za l ion s, Cambr i dge U ni v ~ r~ i ty,. 1. ;\:)f-@t (c 0 r pO rat e) 8'J ~j{f~A. ' 111Zi-71:E. 1fd:~cP~, =¥J EI±'I~ B~J7(~~ ~\El~ CP. , *Il*~;;!j,:. A~.i=!fij ;:g33~~311Jl. 193 . 11.

(3) ~~~~----------------~-J1}littrmfl § 1'Eli¥J1~m ' fff:f Jlfft~Lrs9ill~. Y.:1tB"J$~. ~fff:f1:£J:.~B"J~~~ili*~·. 0. , ~*jf. PJP)~. JtpJTiIi1Cz.i¥J~fl'l&i¥J~ir~.1k:51. ft:J~f'P. ill1:£Itt ~ fff:f * '. , :;s\¥i1 J:.mt:~.\¥:JW1~ , ~i;!d~lt*~)j *~1=r5t. ' :fX1r~/f1f3J:lJfpH~tllilBjfm~.* rJ*8"J/f~ fi'1) . /B] B~ill i'lJp)mT;R:J::~8"JJE~i&J~ trl=E~i¥JpNitIJ . ~~ J abbra & Dwi vedi ~1~ ~.lli1rp]i¥J~7} . mH~]!!mmWr&JWJ})l , !r ff~Jt§ytSJltm-r(Jabbra & Dwivedi' 1988:. ~Jt.:=t:. $ft:J~j. ~flI*L$. 5-8) :. fl/ffi'1)~. ~ j:f.( fUJ. *tJ9i J~ilJI~. !'1hC:;cr~. 0. •. ~Kft~ ~flIi¥J. (co 11 ec t i ve). *[[email protected]:J=~A.lfJ,t. ~DrrM.i¥J~.m~$ • • ~~~~ ~8"J1i!~. ,. f~U~HH~)1x~n&iij~ti'NJ3Jij\\8"J. ~.~~Mi¥J~~~'@A~.i¥J*~. 0. lft1J} ,. Ai¥J~.~*§~ffifl~~Et:J~flIff~. (organizational accounta bi 1i ty) : 1§~.*WpN$8"J.ffffiBo; ; -~fff:f§ . $iJ-/fSJHii ' 1R{JJj(/f3t~{Eff. l.*H~~.. . TI~Jl~{~~flIff~f~~~~flIEt:Jff , If:tfi~~/ffi'1)J.i~*fEirfJ,t~L~ , rr~1~AW*a~#fi'1)§)i)El=rmfJ~ ,. m~~~i¥Jlffj~i:l. ~~fi'1)*fEirm~$~~m~ffi~)Ei¥Jff. mfJ~'@~Ittfi~.~Affrr~~~. ~l~fu~~B~ym.1t. L$ 81& ' 0. 1£{~J.jUi¥JfJ,t~$~g?2,m*H. ~$Et:JMAm~m§ ft)' J.i~ .:=t & i¥J. 2. \r7~~.. 3.. '.. 1zi!&rt!ft. 0. (professional accounta· biIi t y) : i&Jijif=ri!&A~i¥J$*m~~u '. 4.J1ff.*~Jf. 85). 0. J. .~iID'. 9f-g~. il&J&i¥J~. ffi~ ~g~. li.if:ff. 0. 1f£J:.~pfr·W JEB'-J~*.pgi9*~. ' Boven s rr/f[QJ~.fJ,tj:\'Lrs~B"J 5t.BIJmt~;fEl~'f1: ' /f~~~5tJ'tJ~[QJ , =1~ 5fl!1 ' Jt~~t~i::fjT *Jl*iY.:1t~J.i~~.flI*i¥J , mmT~~Et:J~.m~~J.i~/fIBJMi*i. ~~B"J*. {:E$!:'I"J1. 0. 8"J~;ijt~3=:. 0. 1J<. j:f~~rj~. ffrri¥J~.mA~M~*fEir~@Am~. 5.. ~-. ~1fi[fi¥J!. ~.~~~,m~~~~m-~m~ffi. ~ir'~mrr~.~m$jjpJfimA~/f. 193. r~im1£~. EiJ1ff.*W0;tt*IJ~;f§jJ~~l&1&J:!U@]M:1}. (moral accountability) :i t~.£ii[1~8"Jfl~. ' *~~~lLffd:~mfBffifm .f&:~.i¥J*1L~ . .£ii[{~~.m~fljm:m€P4t. ~33~jl'DI!Jl. 9f-$~j. 0. , If:tW\~nxfji!&Jf1f~. 0. 12. ).J!Ii!=FfIJ. flfIl~&~. M=t-C;'''''-= • ~mil&¥t!A~o/J&\~Jt. •• fff:f , 1~*&r*A~MAmTPfrflA (one for all) ; ~flI8"JmA$~~$~PJTflA mT¥-i¥J@A (all for one) ; fff:frr 1~J.jUEt:JfJ,t~$ , :®t~FJ{~Am§ a~. (each for himself) 3. jjpJ ~ (bo th) 8"Jt~j:t1iHJtir~[lMA tJ,t~8"J. ~fff:f. ft:JFQ~im. (political accounta bi 1i ty) : rr*~fj(Et:J~~$ , il&mii*ft. Et:JM~~~i¥J~m,. Et:JyRir. 1£1 ftEiBOtH. 0. ( 1e g i s 1a t i ve a c co un t a biIi t y) : lLi~ , 'PJ T~i¥J~.ffiB. ' '.i~. fff:f@Ai¥Jffmfu~~~m~~flI;fff:f/f. ?torr ~.,. ,. m~~~~i9~~.m~i¥JMfliID~·i fuftl~WfI:.1£ff!x~J::~Y~l!Jit!tHf:. (res. sib il it y) {'PlEi5tL'rr~ /f~5fl!1 . ,f/j:::.::lil!';Wi!I jQ jjpJ f~ fll~ ~ illZ /f ~~ 1'1= ~f~Et:J ~:5t · 0. fEt~{; i¥JIi. il&f9§1§.

(4) ~~m~~ • • ~~~.~·!If{Wf.~.m ~fl?#2.,rut. ~.~~'~~Ajfff~a.,. ~~. · fRfJlJt*1i. M~£~jfff~~Gjfff~~~~. ~~. n!lf{Wf.~Jf*. ~.. ~'mn~W. ~r' {I!*1lf~~eq*a*. N*m. eq1iHn § eqzT ' ~'W~~n~.jf~~tzD{UJ{'F W- J£ ' =tfjg~flajfm:~eq~~oJt. ? M!:ll eq §' ~ , iliZt r&c5l:~ ~. ,. f '. '. , , :{£f'fr&*lfJlifizT '. ~i&m8''lfilN*~ ~F~~~. edi • 1988 :. ~~~jf,. 0:g~F5. eqrn~. tzD{UJWf.~~J:R~Jr&Jff. ~eq. J;JTBi:1Rt.~~ Kearns (1996 : 35. tz[HUJ1JD~.:J3i'. ,~~z~~. 46)~~.*~fl.jf. 'M!:ZtJt. .@tt~7}~?#2.~IDt~'~~M*~~. fi~~~~$'~~±ffr&~m~'ffr&. sjf{£ilBiI ;. ~$.jfWffr&A~£.jfff~~mm~. !lPGJiS7}~fl. ~m{l!~~~~,~~~~~~~~~~. , :ft1f£~~eq.~~fffi~· , {'F-=effJffl *I~~*i'!~ , *j{5f5I:~*~~ , R¥~Ee/'lm1M~ *IDt~~1j\jr&Jff~jfe*eq~{tf: ' M!:lln~E*. Jl: $. Tjf{£I¥]*1~~~*s ~*Jl~~~:g~RJ}:g[). accounta-. ftJJEN5r~rJ~1if!H=r~. £§: ~ Fo' ~. 85). llimDl! '. 0. , pfrJ;J '. ~J1=rr&A~. {Ifl (.Itt W1J. I. J;J~eq:tfi!i~IDtSJrTffi~ZFI3'.m. I~OO'~.~~~~~ili~ffi~ffi~~. , :tR;1f~~J;J1Rm~eq!lf{ Wf.~jfeq*t'*&Jt{'FmBq}jA ' nlmJtJlIIyU o. ~t§:{~?#2t~cp. Mlr:4o 15\;D'. ~ITD§Z'. , m-::!!P~~~1f~. WLt& '. I. accounta. [3J :B- tJT ?#2. k,,:" -. ffi~. , 11f( rr;:; r.... ~'* ~f. sEa ~ 'I'd, :;: "'-0 W. if~fiAIJ :J~~"r-. ,,3<.i>lt "'-0*l!fi 'tiE. ¥~EeqmfljU. ~gp. J}$. J}:g~. 1~f$. ~*U~!fi1ll:. "gfljUtir&.. tEBjj~!fi 1ll:. 1=rr&~1£. ,. KearnsM!:~~¥U1~~ , Jt~?gmd6\11'twM1JJl~. ~~8111~ i&Jff81~~ig ~. ¢r. II",IIIJ -L~;~ r:P'!'~ ')7\:~1=l:J-:J1'JJ::. t!1IJt. (site visit). pgffl) Ifi~~. 'M~. rtil'W. 'f (respon ! · {'F~~f?,~ '~fM. (SOPs). i&~g. ji*4*~!lf!. : Kevin Kearns, Managing Accoun tabi 1i ty ,(1996 : 37) fJJFlfU 5Il33 ~5Il3 Jllj 193. 13.

(5) B~i\!~~. , :1Jffg~:ft1r~ffg}!i~AJift~f§ip~Jtlf:t ~l~ , ~ffgRM~f:1tJE~f,FujpJltE~~T$ , *lJ3c& IE;c\;n~JIIJCP , ffjH?;:JJ!t.'AlM@R±B~~ffifj*W JE ' tzO[OJ~~ Sha f r it z WLobe (1992, p : ~tJ{k-;t1,-§al~. 10). EE. r-L-'r.:P;"i'f·~fBU:,.b"lIIF='=~Q-t;. s. ~h~~ft~r~~~~~~~§~~~. ffff;jFR~*;I;'j!x:B~t~~$Z;fI~II*B~~{'F. R ' flnB. 0. ftf.&,. Kearns (1996: 43). ~'I'i~i\!l\1li~it7f1'~*D11<:~~~*Jti\!~~ ~fl'r.'t>'!J~l'l.~:L\ ~PI. ~*IIJr!pq:7i-:f!tA1Hta~M~. i\!~. ~!j*~~{1§{1:A~~U. If:tf.l~1~~~I±rr R.:t.1=rilaa~m:~ti. 0. §3:7i-' 1:EGortner, Mahler, and Nicholson (1987, p393) ~~mtcP , Jt~ffl€:!1~~iJlif*& ~ffiUPfT~fflGa~ilf*,7t~ , mmt1:E~f~ft'.J~Jt (rigor accountabi 1i ty) ~~t1i1:ilaH~f;:tR ~@]J!!tH'i (responsiveness) 'f'i ' 1:E{iiHr'B~*fflJcp , IEAa~~Jt~'~':&1:E~ JUW;\j1m'[WDt ~ ::tffg~fEZiti{* ' m-1m;[Nr5l~ 1:k:*~D1=rm~~'~1'[ EE ~~=1!:ff9Hlt*D~JE ; m =f.l'IWY5l~1=rm~~~U~{1:B~pllffiU$Z1~T$~. *1*. 0. tzoJifH1iW;\j1m~ffiU~=1';:ff1:EEkJ. '. ~f~~. ~Jt~~8yt1tfEZilaJMB~@] J!!tE&~:!IJlpJTW. {{; , If:t/fr\5Q~7~Jt~'~R1:ER±B~*f~~ , ilaH~f;:tR~ffIM(ffgflfnj~@]J1l ' ::tffgiti{*~ . 1fLt.iz!!;JJl~~~JtJE~* , Jt~:ft1r'ff~}!{~;\Jm~m~JtBf'.J~{J\ , iEJtt~WEJml±lf,l;'j!x:~~$Z1~tfffiIJ*1B~B~~ , f~I±l~Jt~\~J[r4it0~M~ft:JEl~ , ffffll.:1t ffi.mI±lW~~JtJE~cP~ft~... A. itl~Jt~FI=l~aB~. 14 •. A~F.HIJ. ~~li~t:f!n'f:fe. 'rm ~~\~J[£,1J;f:ift~A "gf!l:!. :';<5<:6~;f~~~DM~ , ::tffg~i{*"~~ft'1{1§{1: lit 0. ~~{~~j\ffit&i'WilaJM1:EfI}@.:r.fj[ cPf;:t~,1{j -rr. ~r. __L. '. ~ffg~~W6~{'F1~. ~J¥-lfJl!~~lM'{{;'I'i. , M-y~Jtf¥:1mrt. 0. ~.'AF J¥-lft:£Jt*~ft:Ji\!l\1lif;:t~JtpJr~ 8''.JJ£ ~*1JotJ~S)i. ' Kear ns ~?6A~.a~;ffi;t~-§ Milf=f~:fEl&m:~a~OOrtu ' ~~-1~OOr~:lT::*fi ~F'1ffl)itl~Jt$~6~&J!!~;fil~Jjft'l ' /fr\EJX;:Ji!: m~ja~ : m={~oortu~ffJl*~A7j;SJH!:7i-$1¥J *~$~ , PfTj£:3:.B~~'ii3~$ZEl}3itif¥:1ft;~~ , PfT~~El)jitia~~*Jtf~~~f~ B*~mJE1£~ tf ' , ~~*S6~~rfiCP ; 1~~ih3'~*~5&~ ~~U~f~ff1:En~UlW1fi{Ui ' m~ , $Z1lf~ JECP'~~~@OOrtuffIJfflG7~@~.'. ~~[OJ~.~;ffi;t~'~nm~~.*~~ ~**flJ (.5i!,~=CPPfT7R) tzo~. :. Kevin Kearns, Managing Accountability,(l996: 45) llI'l33 fflll'l3 Wl 193. , TIfLlit.'AmtE¥¥i} ' PfT~.'A ' {iM?6m1:EOO. , =1';:ff;~fEZ,1JB~@]JJ!~~a"J. ~f~B~(Implicit). jt;pj.*~)jj{:. ,. i=t'I- fir:::r-E ,=!«-.(,;t:> K' ~ "'.Ihf!# .ux..~ Fl!:::.3C '=I.J-~ g. ""Ft'§3Q ~ §al ~. G ,c"\...ft171"1 Elk7.. itr~~{fB~ AW. ff~fJ.f§iptf~l!HiR±~D~t~B~ 0. ~JfH~. [ j. f. [.

(6) ill~*M.m~~WB.~~~M~'Y .[~aEl. ~.~4ff$*i!!~Ga~~Y:1.*~~2£HE{n:k*}. , .l--z'D~~Ga.l-~=2£lTnm~2£lTW':l}~. Q~\!Yilif@. ::IJ ~J £i ~HfttGa~;g~§l0~* , ilf@]Ga£J)i§f¥~g'Wl¥l~.~~g~#. ~.~Ga [gJ:±:: [}a~OO-!fg~~Ef*[}a [gJ:±:: E;3lfl:l£m:. -!fg~Jt~l~fID 6 fl{n:&§**~.~~2£lTGa¥¥itm p :;:r;L8t:<li1:J M")JLg~ E ; ± s ~ljjj\ij'=lEd±I:t~ u. ittt5 ' ~jf'Ml+. ~6tjJGa$lltmD~~. o. ~~ED:t~02£ITGaW'iJ~~ *~.~fu}~. Lll.':ai§:rnio '. *H*trbLJt?Ef~fu. '. tP~..g:[}a SUlEd)! of(ll~. ,. w~~2£lTn~~~~*.~.~ma~w. 2Y4J*nmt El '. M~' (0'[£ : 8661 ' Sd1fanH). .•. 4ff.~*.W= *~~02£ITY:1~' *~.~Ga~~~;gmt~. ~~~[}a~~:z;I:Dl:jfI§} , ~:t}~Ga~jf'.~i!llfa . lfl±*ij}~[}a~fW$.gf.~f1.l!bb. ~g'Wy~. ~¥iI-z'~Wf.~I:k~~~~[gJ:±::~WfWID. L_m_. m-~~~M.. ' fUll. Bil~in!f jfa~~ ~. , mJEl¥. ~j::4f:f. o. ~~JGa~J~g\y~f~~\y4§JilrfY:1 ' , :£-J.~~~~~~Ef*+j ,. ~~.~~M*m~~~~~Wn~M~. , tP~~Ga~~IEE}.~¥~~J~g"ZH~}J~Ga ~~Y:1W. .. &a~ittilf. . £J}.1r§¥Ga~:m£i~WGa!l]t:HM~~[gJ.~f1.l!bb , ~~ilifr~· , ~jfGa~~IQ:::r~.~jJl. 1I~I*Gail. Ga~ItJ~M*~jf'~:mGa~~.fiI!f~4f:f· gjg~.. ~~~§f¥. Ga (1m) ma~tgJOO~fHt;ml:jn§} , ~~.~. jPi4.*Ga. ~f~?#jf&. ~:mfffNi.~2£lTf:b. ...... '. tP~:fwf.~I¥I}~3t. [_~_ ~_~····~_~Ii~~. ••~. '. E • /' 'Cl fifJ B3 Y/fi'fj,;,-h-l ERt~tr'\.::/"'~TY-%" f 'J ;f3!i!m '. o~iI. ;:F.'I". ~[t;tJOOI¥I}~~ : *l!iEY'i;I==J1<j''7''('4:i' , ~~l:lJGa~lIf-!fg:::r=U E~.~.*~~~~Y:1. Dq*OOf;L~~~M4::¥:.l-Y:1. '. wf.~WJ}61IGa SUlEd)!. 4lf-z'~:jT:W}. 0. (~. ~M~fb2£ITn4f:f. .~[}a[gJ:±::~~Ga~:±::Q~\IY~*Ef*n-!f9 ' ~Il , iif~pGa~l!~ 2£lT4f:f~¥~Ga:W}I}!l]t+W~M~~. ~lgittiiiMGaf{I~~Winl*. '. , 1}~Gel+1t. tP~~lII3t. _~ .._ ... ~_·~--Jii-••~~\~~-fi*iI. ' I. , ~,I,±Ga~~.~H~Y~ll~~tmMlu ' EU. ' :::rOO!1rb!1f¥J=t ' * • •~Ga. ~~~·~~~E~~.~3t~~~~.. fit!;rl3*Ga[gJ:±::1@1Q~'I.J'~~I¥I}IDM ' ~jfGa*¥~ 'i!llrr~H~·~M::~2Y4.*~af~ , :::r*• •~Gama , OOf;L~t5 : jf'El~mFf}.Ga:::r~(. 2£lTn*~ , ~fa}::¥:~~=f}~JGa~;g ~;fJ¥Y:1 Q~0'iMjEf~. Q~'IY.~!~H:~J. *~~f~ SUlEd)!. =f}. , ¥**~. L ..... ,---........ Jii~~~. • •~. 0. rn!~m+.jg.fi}~a~~;g~~Y2£lTf:b~. _ _ •••• _ _ _ _ _ •••• _ _. ~. _ _ •••• _ _ _ _ . m. ..

(7) ~. '\'~-------------------------.....-Db. T' , g{JJil!f1jlfS~Jf::f&ij~mIlf1~wi&Yf1~JfU: *T'6'97t5Z pfT~J:ff1lt;flW~5Ei&Jffm&\~z ~mffrJ~6'9§*JfU:~T ' ~5Ehtl!i&..t!¥J~~. ~iilr*~/f~~1-f8':J5!:~g ft~. FFicP;6'§EfI:=M'</ r'th +Ilfi R fiI!1 ,=J-I-t m7f.kr;r:hrJ {'5C.1J)(,F;iJiPf;:ffil.flEmr:l':J.::r..~~1=-11m ' @U:'..~;J;:)(.ll')(.n'.t. 8"JFCl~~UJt:? A5!:~D{5Tf'jg~1iif§0*~IJ.A::::r-:~. ' pRlJtgflt! ~JfB"Jt~:i:t1-tzffijm ' INff!i&JfJ ~!A5!:zrs91Ul1*!¥J2)(~ , A5!:B"Jfl'Js:::FlffJ! t&IIJB"J~~i&H~!¥Jm~;rE , ffijJ!&\~Jf~i@JMT. ~ftQ.1r~1J~:::ftflOr~. c. :::ff'j~j.~8~ti13@1lf!MffrJf~~EI"J~*. 5!:~-§r*1~:f16'9'~i£~1l¥. M1.:k:{.*ft~Jtu:~pfTffi±'EI"J~fr3. *ffi'ti,~!¥JFr:I~Jm. , :fftgfllt:t~5s~ffllij riitm;l:~~ltU ' :MzJ:)JJt~fi&m2)(:E$:8"J~~Z8~ , Jt$~'5tA PfT~~EI"JJ!~D{6J~JfB"JFr:l9Jm ' ~~ft.~?i&~A~!¥Jft.g~W~" ~. ? i§:J!--{WJ.¥q-:::f~m8<:B"JJiJm :ff11$Mft 0. B"Jg{JJ~Jft:fJ!J:t$. , 5s~fliJJ:)FtEJ1iiEl"J1~$tJHiB fi&m~TgfJJJff1B"JOl-~~ , :Mzll~i@JJfi ~fI1ltUBf.J~ ~ *1ii1*g {JJ:ff5!:~i&~-§r *I¥J B'!#ilJz-f ' ?&ffij1l:t;flgfJJ~Jft*A:ff.;rEB"J ~f'F..tBPJll3'l¥Ugt~tx~ , § 8"J,~tm ' lli~iJ:f.ifl;f=ri&:E$:~JfEt:Jm1Ji[ , ~:::f terg{JJm~ff~mf=ri&ZfM ' I~Zffij1~tt( /f~ iM! ' {!$jJft~Jtt*At11J~i&mJt1-fl¥JsJ!1ii'['i. ' BPlNtgJJll..:t,~~iBB"J~m ' ffij~~~t~~ , 1-t ZliTIm8"J~J:)tfl~m~rPJ ' 5s~JijJf,f1J~*n*EI"J ]iU~:&.5!:'~1tB"JfI;fliU'M'1Jfi! ' f=ri&*Jt5&,~~~ = :iffRP~ ij r;i!;pFf ~\1j B"J j£:~(t~Wi&Jff Z T~ , xi.j~~DfiJJij!~ilJJll. ' 0. r;.",.",,,,. ,. ~ffij. '. , f-". g~r'JEI"J~JfU:~~~EJJ:):ff0:g:~F~~ffll¥J:f'&. *COsborne and Gaebler '1992) 'lNltt i§:~'i@JI~J~Jff&ij!mB"J~r~ , J!ij!lLA5!:~g {JJThl~~JfB"Jt~A ' mJJF{~Jl.1J'~~iM!i&~f1A ~ffij. ?. 0~tgflt!5s~Jfij51 iitf-,,:g:~r9B"JtgIJ.~ltU*. H '. 0. ~liTIMffrJtgJJll..:t~. !¥JHl,!{JtIl* $il~~O{5Jjjj1t1i&1f1~l,!{Jf~~'$JTffi~@. $1JEtj}M!fj~Wi&H~ ,*~* ErEpfT~EI"Ji\1a. ¥)]*~.~. '. , {I'Nmmp1J. l&.¥Jt*~i!ifflEl"J'11'f15tJm~~{r~&\~Jfff. ftf9c '. Q. ~1r~&\~Jf~mfktmr~. 6':J~.m~~~D15T!¥JM!:ft. : f-,,:g:~r~B"J~Jt8kJU:~ , EJJ:)fUfflM$A W1-t:f!l'!.A (pr inc iple-agenct ) 8/jt~:i:-t*:1Ja J:),.Hff ' JtJJll.~ilff±~~:f;:t1§,f,'l<fr1!J ' f=r~~ ~;fCL@R~ 7tj!ljcB"Jfl'J f:l1t1M~ffljfr±~ $ :fHi~iff; -1-tJJll.B"JIJt~:iitf=r5J\.tFf ' :MzJ:) 1-tI'Af'jg,~,. !¥J~l1xM$APJT~EI':J'f1'fy5tm~1]Jm ' :ifFt!P~~ , i!$~rblfm:*~_ !¥JThl*JR~.Il~ *5Gff\G~Jt8"J § t~ , JtF.fl~ iM!fUYOO3t$ , fm:~ffl;l:~~~ltU ' *1iif*g*_ 1l~8"J~f'F ' Jtff~Jl'i~~~ (H ugh e s '. 16 • }JJFlflJ m 33:fim 31i!l 193. 0;1. 1.1. 2.2 3.2. ... 1998 : 227) : 1 . J:I~*l'lJ~J~fflj:f:;¥B':JfU~~~*:ftJ;_*~I@!.AIl9. 4.{ 5.2. 2. j£*PJTlIDcm;8!j~5m¥~~~!~BkJf{ij*$:tt. 6.1. 3 . j£*~lIDcm;uJliffi!¥JJ:ing'f'i.. 0. 7/./.. 0. 4. tfl~1"r~~ffit:Th~J:lf[3~6'9 sEE. 0. ffiJtt:~IN~~Jf1m~ 8f'1~ltliJ!1ii1*1~. ' :Mzllf'jg~J;!:I(rnJi , :f;:t1-tI@!.A!¥J;f;fJa'[tl. Af'jgff]M$AB"JflJ~-iJ:. **Jt5&B"Jm* '. ~ffij. ~~t:AW1-tJJll.AZFi3EJ{B. ~~.~~':Mzll.5!:~m~m~I¥J~~. oft ? i&1f1A to/JJ!~g~~:f~B"JJff-f ' Jttl~.N f6J:ff ? :ff1·~UJt5!:±flt!~ilffr:p , A5!:f'jg5EWll¥Jm. anc. ¥1¥J'lwi5t~±.. tB:£ji. 0. '. ~l~J,~~:&[j!i.:t~~!Z9m{-tI@!.A;f;Uffll3. a 8.2 j.

(8) ffiJ~"¥J~~*ig:j)j( S frjs"J:F~~ m~M.~~M. 1995) ,. , ~~~~U~. ~~. (#~,. ~~flj!:fJL~S"Jj£3:.f§,ErX:{~J!l!A~7:t. .~~~{;AI¥'J~~*¥tt1=r. 0. 1:EfLttpr5m~7:t. !li1*1~JlAs"J~m1Jii;. 16\~JifF. fLffl3r~. , fffiEL [fi:j~I¥'J~~i:t:it¥U 3C15li~~ , li&:\;li1ii1:~0:as"J$mH~ , 0ttp M~~~~ftW ~itf! • • *~~m • • it!! ; 5}9f. ' ~17gj£*Jet~~{' ' i-~msr5~liJfL $F~Zr.JJ~~S"J~J~liJ~~ , 19{£r&J{g:~~~ .l'l¥Ji&:H1 ( fa eel e s s gave rnmen t ) ( ~.. s':J.ffzr: '. tzD*0ttprlS/:J;g:f!lt:l:.~~meT. r&{i'l~.S"J&:\~t't. '. Mif}Wrm.~gf4~;g:f-'. ~. n. ~ftr&A~Efj~~$s"Ji§*&:\~j1:Er&ii'lffi~ cp*;g~03:t$~. , PJTtJ. '. 5J<tzD{ilT~:lLr&m. ;m;!~i'I{j~3Z. , illzliifj~£f1tW;gJ!l!~.zrs9s"J. Ij~tt. '. PI /N~i!8"J~Jm. 0. 1995 : 387) ,. B9~j{mt~f[lAft. 0. ~z. '. fLmsr5~.mffi. n. ;g~~Jtm*5:t<tzD{iiJ~lg1~~gtJA~~ :it. .e;:-1nr~J.?. ~l!fffil:S"Jf'l~1ii{*1lt$AtliJ1~~'Azrsls"J-3&. ~ F.:.:! ') "'Ell ;;;S. r't~l!.'l!!!l: -v: ~ /w • / .... Q~..Rr::l:.;aRmR. tt ' 11!~M*rt:ll5JjET ' J!~~ilir~m1:E0ttprl. ~~§Tl.i-~!}fJ1t. $7. '. Xl-r"4L.ili"-Xl-r{Ir::- .z..:\..-7~ i=RtJ.f.. , W)(.{p", , fTw)(. r - / J 1<..7"1 ~ "'-"'I~G. 0. ~:7f.. '. 0fLttr5r51g11ttzrs18"J~~tt:m. '. .L-J:&'1=rr&fErr;~8}Ht*~~y. g ffKm* CPS"J~ 1lt:&.J~~!2:8/Jl=r~ ,illzli ~5rgJ,iJ _ _ ~.e;:-~~M_·(H. ~g,~,Jl. :flJf!~~:ff~~M§~s"J!*[l;l. ma. and Herzlinger. ~~.. 1}fL$F5~j::~~~1:EfKr:37U~~~. !tra~~. 1. 0-ttpr5tl:;~:;;r::~1iJm1=ri1JpJT~~s"Jfrjr~. ~~~tJfj~r&H18"J{s1±:. *itf!.. 2. £'$F5~l:Im1t1JttS"J{~Ii'TI. r&mA~:&'j£.ttgffKW~.~8"J.~~. es. 3.0-ffl3r51:E~~~8"J § ~f[l*me 15ffi]~~N. HLA.a9. f:{~JI. , tllrAlAnthony. (. , 1998) ,. hes ' 1998 : 234). 0. 0. o. 4.:tEffl.*~15[fi:j, mprl~11X*wfctWr*~. 0. ' illzEL~:lL~I~~~. cP , k~tsfrt'1h~m¢g.e;:' tJ.@]ff!,fim':fi-8"J~* ' illzEL. t:tfK1=rr&j::.~gbo.L-JWP5:EtJ1t1J.~~~tt;::%S"J. , 1t~1:Ir:371J ~ ~,liJ;f]f?g. 5. 0-ttprls"J{~~* s. ~~. 6.~rl8"J.{±f[lfLttprl*g*~~~. 1996) :. 7.0-m5rl8"J-r~JM;g£-, '. 1. ~~ : ~~f.~~1iJ.m. ~{~fL$rl~l:I;f§1lt. a9JHf::&.r'S:lJ.!'fs"J¥~{,1. 0. 8. 0-ttpr5*g*~&:\~lif~ ~~g ftfiJr&ji'l}@:fE. , {Jii;1:E1JI2'f?g~tJm.. 1:E~£-'~.m*. ~ffit~~.m*. ~~o. ug -. 1fE~{lmfEl,ljt*}~,~~~. ±~t:t~JtFt:l~Jm~M7:k:15~. :. :t-rttJll1! ~JM:1R. r'f~E~~~. .vAftroLJ:1')if~)()('1~'-F IPJUc01*J ),,!:l.J:1'J1m:-·t. '. (A mman s '. ii&H1~.L-J~~~tzo. , illz li ~~ tJ. tc!fi~1Ellltz rsl ~[P]S"J{:I:%PJT1:E ' litJ..tI:t{tIJ.~.6':fi-1~~~ $0 1~--T-. 9. 0-ffl3rlilik:z. ;g~S"J{tH1E. J::i?1t0fLttprl~~s"Jffi] 1i'TI cP. f1:Ea9. : *.~~51U.f'lgWf~tt!!JiJl37U 15 ~s"J~ijgWm1'J{lL~~* ijg1:Er&*ffili n8"J~~~ , {tIJ.~5J"~~¥!*~m.~~~ 3. ~gJiBi:Jffi~{'l=~9l- B1J~~e'iJI!ii}~u : ~~};[2#. 2. ~%:e'iJji)ffjti.1~c. 0. , ~{r~PItJ.. z.~~. ~M0fLttprl~~~~~ri*Tfrj~f~S"J1iJ.Z. ~~B"J. )11.. •. :H3C. Itt ~. 0. [l;l. 1:EfLmsrl8"J~*.m*~ijg~1ii{*0ttpFl. '. 0. ~ijg~D}j(Mr&*~{'FJ::8"J~~:&'ilik:~~. ,. A~F=lfU m33~m31l1l193.. 17.

(9) mm-m~~fi ~A ~. 0. ~ mw ~ ~ ~.. -' ,~~I,~e~ : ffi::(§f A ~fjE~W+El ~mr~ ttl2B . §5 ji- ' t11/2'jVBL~¥711/:J i!§ff1ff ' *Jl~xifllJ. fJ:gmH~~ i&Jfl:ftf11/2' a;~1t ~ 1&. 15'b1tI¥ Jliii*. '. ~jfJ&U:~. filr~IJlIf~ f~. 4, ~00'lB'iJ. :f±illU:. 0. 4 . ~t __ ~ DT~~ : ~~jz~nu -a<J* *1t11~~t)f~1~iL3<: ~Rl1~BttE.~. , :MLll;j(tJ=tJJ~~(l]m< *~. iI{±fflj:\l~~f~cp. 0. * ,. 1/~A HM]f?f1t:&J7~ OSiflU.m:M~ mi~1Wx'5<:(1"7. 11Wl. C'. mfrITI j§ ~. ~iID rtJ ~fIg t~'@1\'. !zllfilJJE. I~ 1-tJ. " (timely) : tll:*1=1 ~7 ~fl1RA ~gtk. m~' f=dJi {1MA'{r:r~. /If~ JL:Yif,. 0. 6. ~mtH~X5<[§jf6J : aHo-j mfJm:t~1tU &\ ~R5ili. ff!:g f~. ' MUifJ E~1i]1±:t~1tIJ iL3z:m~ IE1)y. ~fPl. i:'{~ r'I/;J. mJ~W. 1J:j[:l?:JfLJ:.RkPf~~·~~. j. : pR1~Lffi:~ I¥J~;S. 5, Em a~~Hl. 5. ~1'F'tle~az~ : ~ !& ,'1foi §1±$*{c'hWJ i.±l~Jt. , *-M~i}1UiitYJ tLJt< ' -tl1 fjg)f; pX,~~fD1=;t g (I/~ {IFffl " 6 . 75~e~~zpi2:i ' §f~€J' ( ~lBO ) &,f,~x5(~ZPi2:l e'iJ f~ ~ : ftl?l;z iH~ :m: f,l~ fJE ffl~ f-f 1jl1iM !'i·~H"HJl. M'If il3<:FfJ;fr .BIHv: '"fjfIT MB0 U1 ttJ ::~) 1M. I. fJj~ 1:'. 0. 1T~ J:m-f:!~~h ljSTIl!fHU JI::. #:. @;J: b'iJ. 0. 7 , *~~B'iJ (nonredundant) : 7~IJ.lldj§H1W 'C::\ ~J! tjE1j!~);:ffilJ~ IJ ' 7f~[i~~Jn~mIJ m: 8, g-H~e'iJ~~ : 1l!IJ £ 11/~f1x7-js:::Ffjg~H r,;!:t:~;UiJ .,' OSf~ iiD ". t~lmc~\. ~ 'm~l. D. Jf'21!:l:1 ~ 1. 9 .1JiJE~.Elm&*e~fJf.i9 : ~IJ ii~~\~~~'J!/~*fi' '( Lj.J1Z$l ~~ ~~JUJ "'l:PfTgf :I ljI~ l-)JHE' ¥.iE B)S. m'nl. , #;l:S&'~U1ifHI ~ tfi!1Jt ify:Jn1j[1* fffj. J,i!t;L):tJ. " ?I,\ffi] , J:.~Lti;1~SZ5<: tlj~I]!9;'if illt~'iJ# ' fIE! ,:. t!£~-'f~J. El1tt)]VJ(W' tl2~ uff§1!fbL3<:Jff § JriJftilli!hY~f\)~~~. ~~~~0~~ A~ ~.~ ~ *~~~ ~#. ~' .lit /f<;. , m ~1- . . f~~JJ[~~1Tl4~~ i'IS I~ , illi ~;;!t~~ fFn<7 h-'l n @115 < Y Ujt~fr1. /] i-]i. : (1). IfF- . : (2) X~flE ; (3) ~3I:$ ; (4) ~. N- ,-- 0 . ""'+<:;!'; a3 r I vj " IE l~rJ 11\'- -m-i I-fr 6.' § I'fl ~"J . " l.iT JE /X!t~ )J)("?!'@§:l - liPl=1/K I ' l~J i l l IO.x. t";;"')'i7!'~-.l Il'J· ". ~u~. , 1PiB~~ ~iiifH?I:[fqJ7fdg!~rm ' fi:r~~1t~;. ;};. , !lire?. ~ jJ , J;) ~1T~.L ffi\kl5&EI~]i!!U. )\::~. : ~- ,. , i~ 5'. If'!. tE l. F'11 I]!] p'<~ i.±l )-;: ~ 1~ 7* if IJ m f IJinr.5J +fT- Jit J~ Hd)~J ' ff,;tj..)J~~rl"J iWi~~J.Jt3K0t ' flrJffJ·j WJEfiiJBWt.. (1J.!~jtf F.. ~ A{]~ m ' Jil ~ ~f!u. .. ) IUITif. ~ii£~U Mckcu1 l r.~R. (Ij. l~~~. 'flli fF~l£';tJ~Jm fFJ:f'l17J( 1~ (keep score). 0. ~:¥J: FI{7Uf"r:p. tt!2 i&!i§:fj;f~f ]'f).( 1~ JtfJlH~. ~. 0. f.'tfffi '. ;;mfJdl]~ rr~QJh5B<]~*it~5<:fEit~. ' l2Sl1Lt ' fi1J£i\§1~. ? tzllfITJr!2,5E frX~ 13"] ~l$nFt ?. J/~§¥II7B$:I¥J ~RrJI}0ffiJr=:f. -imM 1~. ,. 1q] IJ~ttL~. r it!J;fft.L-:J- $;Ii~fnJri*&I~/:J ~. fiE~ 6i.f~~Nr~~ ~~:rE. t¥J ~ft"1"'5<:t§~. ' ,. Jit ~. ' ;/Et B&' I - :d(11. f~t :ar,g' n~)~a;&. , i:t!. i¥;t:t~ ~~. r&:J:ilfu.l1 :fs~ ~.bJ)Jf.j~ (Ammo n s ' 1(96). l.~X5<e~. :. (vaild) : ~"1~~iPiJ E3~E~mU .TIti±\r9T. ti';:~I;1IJ 'IY:J * ~~. 2, D]~e~ ( rel iable) : ~nxJiJtu nfil:~1i] 51! fFJ 1£ :;: r:l o-jll#rf.l9 &Atm 0. 18 . } , F.lflJ sg 33 ~m 3l1li 193. '!isr",9Jm ,. '. 1998) : ')•. ::J<- 'il?!l'1 91 '1'i31?ii. :ijtJi0)j~fj!. ( Hughes' !i'. 1oJ1i/::J*i~)('rL'; JElt1tC ~ ~~ .-. ).JI. I'§!jf. '. ITIT. n~J. /dHili:i]. N ' 19 ,. , :f:n'ij'k ~(:J{Ii!ij ~ifJ '. rJiliMt~~. ' ,d;. ~ -j- L~(;* h ". ~,. ~ i]iJ:-LXx.I-l 'i 1m"-r-~· f)X6, r:.'!7-3 }.E:ox.,J,~ Tj l~ y;n"1: .. %=~lH~ApJT 1W6(~ J. J!z. '. ' :ill!. ,j..jlW:& ~~' .. Jl;1::. ~-£"""" f!h "'lli~A ',rr, -YJ~ Fl. ;n~~~. 0. [email protected]:;(s}:JJtH<:Zli'). ffi~rn, ·t~j$B~~l:\Tffi]¥§'. N1':~rilffli *"~~ 8/:J!t-?r&,. , ~'1!lt:t <~;Zm £\~JL, ~l~9'U%t ~ti¥3:. ::tnrl~fw~5& ~11m T'5<~t§ t~. ~~ ,. =. (ftHft ~. ; ~ll~ r,~J[-~. 0. , il3z ~i:JA to/J C8 fEJ ~.&;t~!:.;.t1fIl:gj~ :. j..:J,~ ~'1tBJc;\l:$mt1IT jf,i) i9IJ. t. ' iI3(f%§ ft ftN(. ~lnN ;1ti&*~~&~ttrI)t ? 9n *~ *Jf'X:rff~L ,.

(10) (~~' ~ mlf0f~' Y!-i~JIf.-rr'Al~- ;M) Ii' •. :l):ff-L/IJ.-l= T ,~~}Jf,!1~. ~J,!i~m';;Yill1-~~GI) 1.I/WffuIU.' l-1, JJt7iJ~'F: J!!J±J . .~_ ZfHffW~d~/JIr,I~~!Z1,'.r,J1-i1f~* :r-j rlr,l lli4.1! ~ilh:::. r'}~:~VJ.l"Ef?J1-' · """ 3f-f-} ~'.nI,l (;) 11 p. .l ;)nl"d .1nq. ~!¥!,:t;.lH}H~';:~V~.Q)1. ,. :n-fi-diW1: L/O ~.I4~E(9~:F. jft:t:~"iJ*~ ~~ Jfo, ~~±bdPI-J: Y9 fJ~~f~[JU:. '. '. l1T l~. , ~r~~ r~~~f.IJM~~29I~jUf~~ ( 866 ! , ¥;;). - [lOU) J:f~K,-*~ GI)~fJi1J I ;QH~i :-J f~ rll,l §{:~ [f! ~. ..I. ~~Y1jIl rll);Jf¥1 ,}~f{ [g) ::t:Ulr~"! ·~ r~~ ,. b~~* r0Wrll)]~!1f mfN'h=F 0;#. '. . · IM(2):.l!Y iU T(!:~~h. 0. 1~~ ~f)4':l1TEj::I , :~f¥f~m ,i€ ~~~~~U~MEfl ~±HJ , ~II~~C ! ,J/SillLt~Xl;a"lm:}~~7J"J'GU giftf JJ1!J.I. ~. _'nw- (~~\} l )·~~ ~IflI!J.lI ' l}:myrIO·~ T4i~1m ij ~ ~ :r;2 [/~1 1$¥ #f~,~. , (966 ! '. m± jJ ffif G,.Q ffi'±~~~lfW W=I~K3isi. l.l JP :pnog ~l IWL[;)P.[I~H H/I,~tG. , 1!. ~U%Y~;:1* ~ ~() 9~t1 !?~1::. rl:HfOf~!J.M: :i:::r. ,. cP~,6 lm) GS ~'. ~'fljJ~~n'Ef. .~. -"J 1 I n ~:)){Jf~. :rt%I1!~ J£I). ;.u M'(1. , fM 11!frl1T !it ~!d-\!i. "* '. '. .c Wl1J. .'Jt --::~~11'1 '';':.t' "r~,*19 1-'11~I-r '. U~~ ~ ~W~~~k ~ ~~~~ M'~. [II). ¥!J;;y; y~~.aWWit'i)-~::rr-~ ' g l~mf L/IJ1v, ffi';t!p1 ~ ('rEJi"1li i+i£/lC" - ~I'I'I-rr ,,,,, I, f;;;r Iv l , ("'-1' ~g."i>..l Vf ~ l:.t_ -f - .,J I:1E !.l)!;:.;.. :~ - -~/-v ~ l±J ~ u:.= ~ -.=.... YH1ri;;W-0 ~ ~ ~,l. :.,-v '. XJrJ. I ~~ 'illJ'rllrlJ,. lffUj'=J T!J "II',-))'(-n--:I 10 I ,. IFf~';(J'Y m~~(,. I}J f.;Ij [*I:~~ ,~ ;.I f: :~ rt!,{~·fG{hl1 j ~~ !·:;;:;11 '. : wm.Jd7,l} :@b If. • ~li~jMX~. 4 ~lUff~~ :w:W*';l)' 4}f~mIfIDJH!H\f. ~kf ~.r~ GI)~f ~N~. Llr(~~'(1tr~'lYm ]I~Q.112'HJJJ ~(tf. ~ &jm~ ) llit: ~-+~ ~::%,8*}tllyg~[~W£L(i!fmrIJ1... Mr ' .;y; ~!L/O Jl~~$!ill18l-2mJ/O~Rff .~J::Uf ~t[IIJ t#,y-: I-~M1fl.~; ~:&~!{f ~ ?lfi~t .ojJ:l[ ~:;:P: , GO£.;g ;. ± ~ :',1" ~J5d!-!:J r11;1 II ~I ,~, n:!: J~ 'Lj:P.l£ ~Jl .J..i1 j~. : ~ R*[ll) g. . '\'!'':''V- ~P?'FJ..~ Y:! ( 66 r ) UO;) IJO ~mn%~ ~J1. ' ~JI~~ c+ r/O~~IZ ~. t1!~~) GIJJ:H£;1!.r.~¥f -V;)cl UW. G,) jf{ L<,J.I .f=f¥4';(1(~( ~GJJ j'g"~~:rr::£m ~~~:¥~(tf @)j. !ill! rJ~fM iTt ();InYi~ ~17 . J) l)3H~1 ril;l~Ljr(ffi '(1*ill!. , nWt~·. ~)fY111:!~ ~ I I ~ -¥"Tt~~!, ,:JlT!lJt ~lIli~~ , l1T 8fJ. • mf~ -g:r"::::; rrli!~m ~ wf.r!r/l) =rf.I,~rffJ*n1Wf UUM , I. ~WF1f!Jf. :t;.11 '. 0'1-1. / 1 /<I' [. ~).I r ,c'". !ZSI3E1. f!¥lf8J '. , 1;1; iTfI !3 :...;+ ~. ~ ,gl1f~*gf;}. -TT-r,t-L + EB:t.'/N. ~ ~lt:g !-JZY11 :Lt. fJ-1::.. . 7 , J-r.t~ /- '". 1m.. B · t[[i,~1f0ruf:!I.,~m14,x,; H ~I,l , ~¥ EI Gl)@. £(..-. ;~ fJJ~r{l}1/~~jJ:li:ra!M.f~{; !~HiIm' iiiJ~:t.!))~~r~'iTI-. , 1 l'!ij.f~ijMN/8 JnftrJ! ;.Jf" W.J ' 'M~ftL/J;ltt !. If!¥~I~~Dr(. PfJLI,~!,~[f.f'i:W3L4::. 1I!Jf ' :T/,I'ITf~ r{iJJ ht~~ ;:lDJlnr~Flni~';;Y , cP. 1 ,. Nj@:t:J:jillrfjlt'PJ[-LJ~i1:';f. t;:]f.,r Hlj!0rJ[(:. ' '. ::Cw.t:r;1~~g:iI.:,. '. ", I j~I5?!:::)i'l 11,.rm. . - , I t7*";)'7 rJ W"~1-'. ~~3J/8 . 1 ~ml!:!J lli"t J~. It~['l~ , :rn,1 ~ n§~ ';(1"'~~. " NI Jf~';(1"( ~¥§lf} L fll}~. f~(f , n~~[t1)-hi l:tf~n~IZ:R;('¥TTI]fO- if{. 2tf~ ,If( [(1) ffi1~Ar,;l~W f:l:iillI1f. J~nZjjg~I L~lYl~:r~. '. : ~ffL{1r/~.y. ~i¥fN£1#alJrr~fog!1. '. '. :r~H*21L; r/[HL~. !f*~QJI 40tTlI 4'ar,~irf3#H~iY. ·ijIT):J¥fN fg~, .. :~TI.. '. a. i. ffHi'i'!; J f?fl~:,;;;, WrlI-5~';;Y nm~ff5. l-1'~';;Y[113 !1 *~~:,2);"[I2nt. $~~W~m~~~n , ~~~ ¥ ~ti~~. n~:th~. , I \-J 6d. *;iWrJ;1 lt~L/I) ~trrlli)ffi ~,IJ']:(. ~R§i; [NJfIlf~~M,!!~!¥ 4= *. ;J!,J,irH1I·;l{l'(ll:Jt[Blrllj ,. ~U ¥!;!lljjlJ · ~ rl~ijlfA1IYiJl. o. 1U", , -jt~rlr~~~1En. . 7..~ !W~ • ~J5d!:h~. ~,~ JYIl~lfLHtI) lJ!! ~00;1:rr31-:. lY~, mflW f:f ~mfi.l~:r;:lIJ b*W!}~W f-. [1,(;9-1. :cr.llJ,t H:f~r*;;W¥1ti~ L)r,I EIT:t~I I~rI6}. . LJ, lY1'GIJmW , rP ftj~{li 1"J.(. ~[Jlt -ti!},I) ~jofn~: ·J , *~{/I) r~k .~fifrj. { jI Grl) ~0- !.t-+Jf -~ ~7/:ff-IJ7Jm. ,. ~!;l:1f~. . ~'n mnr·a~ r/f)r~I 0-r~1. {,;.j~·J1*bo L/J,I["I ~l .Eh~!.il1. In,fJ%IJwrI 8W,!1§U:l'(13't'. ~EI3±:!;i} ' 2/-=MI~JW h-I ·',...·71L3Y rl1JIJY; (,. lJo i:l Li 8'"t1"W".rl-.. ," ,- ,.l='( If. 1.~ xr0r'{!=f~,Jlf.1!* -~:rrLl~. w ~um~ ~± ' ~WW Ug~ · W ~. , rm~i!lGI):~:;;fr! :c:.r~fH. ~~~*q .~ m rn4~~~~ ' M~~ 0.

(11) 1 . It: ~ in ' ~.rr~. 87 fIG ~ miIJ iE5I: Iff ~ i§ ~t ~ ; S\'JOT S'iJ5.HfT~(H~ tsAin~m~~ .&ft J' it~ i* ~ 'iIlJlif!lif!~;j .. S'iJ iE5I: ~ cg ;. ljiE5if~H~. p. 2 . ~~ ~ lj~ ~. 3.. 85. ~*~flJ. ~. 90 . 1jiE5l:~. (-) C). ts~t; ~ TI~r:pA !¥. £:!=t:rg~, =~. ts~t; ~~tI::l~U. ". mlffI ~A. 4. ~. 82 . tt a &,j~f-'l ~ lifl~' ts~t. ;. *~. ~ ,. 5 . liffiij~j~ ~. 87 . ~lI§ rg t.~Jli~ ~ ~~ ~GiE5l:lffS'iJaz:$, ~ FHU, ~. 6. 26. A. ~. ~rzg!tEl". ~ ~.f.!jj:j. 1995. ,;t {-t II I" ~ ~ ~ ~ LE ~ az:$ S'iJ fj [OJ , r:p m1 tt . M~~flj. , ~ 10 Wl'. 7. ~ Itt~ ~. 85 . ljiE5iHiWS'iJ1miI~ln~ ~ ,2.lifl~ - ts~t ffi iE5i1ff 2.B fjj A~ 1iffi~;~ ~2. . ~~ 5};ffT ' ~ .rr iE5i ;f3 A ~ B :!=t: fj iE5i lif! ~ p.fft~ :1J X ". 8 . Ammons, i~. 1995 Accountability for Perfor mance ; Measurement and i'~oni tor ing in Local Government (ed). i,-Iashi ngton. D. C, I Cr~A. 9.Bellone C. and G. Goerl 1992 "Reconciling Public Entrepre preneurship and Democracy , Pub lic Administration Review Vol. 52, 2, 130- 134 . 10.Bovens M. 1998 The Quest for Responsibi-lity ; Accountability and Citizenship in Complex Organizations, Ca ~ bridge Univers ity. 11.Buchholz l R.A 1992 Business En vi ro nme nt and Pub lic Policy (4t h.ed ) , Nevi York; The Free Press.. 20 .. A I=HIJ. !l'!'I33~;g311lJ. 193. 12 Cooper T.L 1993 Handbook of Admi ni strati ve Ethics, Los flngerles,Ca l i fornia, University of Southern California 13 Cooper T.L 1987 Hi erarcy , Virtue , and t he Prac tice of Pub l ic Admini - strat'ion; A Pe r spective for Norma t l ve Ethics, Public Admi ni stration Revie':!,47 ; 300-328. 14.CumminQs L. L & Anton C. 1990 Tile Logica l and Appr'eciative Oi me ns ions of Accountability ; App re ciative Management a ~a Leadership, San Fra ncisco; Jossey-Bass. 15.Dauphinais,B&Pederson,P. 1995 Better Change : Best Pract'lce For Transforming Your Organi zation. Ne\'! York: In!in. 16.0eleon L-inda 1995 Accountabi 1ity in a "Rei nven ted "Government , Public Adml n istration Quarterly, Vol 76, 539-58. 17.D'/!hight D.Frink and Richard J Kl imoski 1998 Research in Personne l and Hu man Resources !~anagement ' Vo > ume 16 Samford .Connec tlcut : JAI press. 18.Ferris,G.R: Hitchell,T.R: Canavan,P. J : Frick,D.D&Hopper.H 1995 Accountabll1 ty inHuman Re sources Systems,ln G. R. Ferris et dl, Han dbook of Human Re source ~1andgernent, Oxfo r d : Blackwe l l Pub ll sher. 19.Fes ler W. &Donald F.Ket tl 1991 The Politics of the Adminlstra t i v e Pro c e s s , Chat ham . Ne'l; Jersey: Chatham. 20.Gortner, H.F.. 19 1. 21. Gor sor 19E. n .Gis 198. 23.Hal 1991. 211.. Hug! 199,. 26. Kear. 1996 199. 27. Lyn u. 199'. 28 . '-jar. 199&.

(12) rti. ve Call. herr.. Prac iar : at i Vt ation. e. Di ... y. :. and sco :. cLi ce gd ni. ven bmin .76.. d J. Hu-. 1991 Ethics for Public Managers . Nevi York : Greenwood Press. 2~ . Gortner . H F. , Mah'e r.J . . and Nichol son . J B 1987 Organiza tio n Theory : A 'Jt..b lic Perspecti ve· Chi cago : Dorsey Press. 22 Gist .J .R 1989 Decision Mak ing in Pub l ic Adm in i stration ."in J.Rab i n. et al, (eds) Handbook of Publ it Admi'listratior .Nel'i York : Marcel Dekker . ins . 23 . tt a ~ acnmi A. & BouckaPf L G. ]996 Organ i Zf' L i anal Performa'lce and Me asure ment i n thp Pub "i c Sector. we sport Conn Quorum. 24 Hugres . O 1994 Pu bl ic Manageme nt and Admin i stration : lin In t roduction. r~e\ri York: St 11arcin ' s Press . 2~ . Jones . T . ~': 992 Ethical DeCision Making by Tn div ; j ual in Organ izatio n: An Contingent Model. Academy of Manag ement Re v i eYI. 16 : 366 395 ;(. . Kearns K. P. 1996 Manag in g Acco unta bi lity . San Franci sco : Jossey-Bass pub 1ishers _ _ _ __ A Strategic Manaa ement of Ac countab i lity in Nonp ro fit Organizat i ons: An An alyt ica l Framework . Publ ic Administra tion Review . Vo154 . no . 2 . 27 . Lynn . L. 19 92 Management \J; th out Man agers: the False Promis e of Admini s rative Reform. Paoer presented at the Co 11 0Que.Pdr is . 28 . Mnrch J . G. and Olsen J. P. 1994 Democra ti c Governance. Nevi York: The Free Press . 1996. I.P . R~~r ri. I. s. Re- rd :. ..r6 Nel'j. 29.Moe . R 1994 The Rp.i nvent i ng GovE'rll me nt Exerci se : Mi si nLerpre" i ng the Probl em .Mi sjudging the Conse Qu ence . Publ i c Adm l nistrdtion Revievl . Vo ~ 4 . 2. 111-22 . 30.0sborne. D and Gaeb ler.T. I992 Rei n v p n tin Q Go v ern In en t . Readings.r~A : Addison Wessey Lo ngman. 31.Phi ll ips J . J. ]993 Account ability ir Human Resource Hanagerrle n~ . Houst on : Gul F Publishing. 32·Rest. J . R 1986 Mo ra l ity.rvlora l Behavior. and Moral Deve l opment.Ne,,' York : ~l i l ey . 33 Rhode R. A. f'li 19':)7 Un der stan d i ng Governd nce : Po i cy Networks.Governan ce. Re fl ex i vity and Accou nta-bility. Buck i ngham : Open Uni ve rs i t y press. 34.Shaf fi r , W. B and Lobe.T.J 1992 The Harpercollins Di ctio nary of American Government And Po l itics. Ne ~ York: Harper collins . 35 . Te lock.PE 1985 Accountabi 1 ty : The i'leg 1ected Social Context of Judgment and Choice : Towa rd a Social Co n tingency Mod el . In M.P.Za nna (E . d). Advances in Experie menLa Social Psycho10gy . vol 7.pp.331-337.N ew York : Aca demic Press . 36 .Tprry L . D. 1998 Adminlstr.jti ve LeaderS hip Nm,l Manageri ali sm. and the Pub l ic Man agement Mov em ent , Pub li c Administ r ation Review . Vol.58 . No3 1. AlJl=HU. M33 f!~3Wl193 .. 21.

(13)