群體智慧網絡與服務價值創造之技術方法與策略模式研究(I)

(1)

** !"#$%&'()*+,-./0**

!" # $

!"#$%&'()*+,-./0%123456789:

!" " #$%!

&'NSC 98(" 2410(H( 004" (" 050 " (MY2

)*+," 98" " -" 8" . 1" /0" 100" -" 7" ." 31" /

123456

78123

9:3;

<=>?!(@ABCDEFGDHI)JK>?#L$>?

M<=>?NOPQRHISTU

#VWXYZ[\]^_>?`a

#VbcdeYZ[\]^_>?`a

YfWghijk^_>?lmnSopq`a

#Wg%r\sWX\s>?t`a

uvwxyzh%r\s{|}z~il3\s{

lQX_

#l[z#`-#-

)*F ¡b¢£

(2)

** !"#$%&'()*+,-./01**

°µ¾ÀÉÌÑÒÓÔÕÖÕÖ×ØÀÙ ÚÛÜÝÞßàâäåæÜÝçìÜÝíîïðòÀÙóôö÷ü ý þÿ !"í#$%&'()Þ*+,-.þÿ/0123456 !7 89:;<=>?@ABCÞÜÝÓDEF/012GH ÔÕÖIþÿJKÙLMNOP8Û/012QÀÞRSÓÔÕÖTNOP8H JÛU/012VWXYRS/012üý ZÿÿU=[\]^XÞ/0_ `abc/012dZefghNOBijklmÜÝ\]no\p íîqríîZstu_`ÛUvàâTwxyz{Ó  !

!"

!"#$%&'()*+,-./0"12,345)67+ 89:";<=>"?@AB"CD,"EFGHIJKLMJNO"PE (Maglio et al. 2006)QLR,STUV"W1,X<"YZ[\]^_`"ab,R ".c,%.deTfg,hiJ?@"jk,MJlm?@no pq,<oprstu,/vwx",yJzA{"\]|d}~"12, e,e"" ¡,5E¢ST£¤"¥¦§ü"©¤ F),ª«¤¬n%"EFop,®¯°±²,³?¤)´¢µtun|"opr sjk,¶·\]¸e"_è¹,W1V"?¤º"_`,»J¼!, e8½ 67+ 1"_`|!"tun|"Vop,5E¢¾c, \]EF"x#Q¢«)*\]e¹"_`)é89:"a$%%&"? @±'Q (¼,".c,)¿À".,E¢¾c£¤" Á½,*.d/0"12,y-.+,-.ÂÃ¡EÄ"o/|rs,0g12 (focus group)|3E,R84/0"o/,(¢5ÅÆ_6"78yGJ&,"927 8,Ç:J;%<|"78±=92,>?(¢_6ÅÆ"@A(BÈÉ),; hÊC%"DËn5EFQª¼±²,(¢/0"o/?¤-.GHÂÃ¡EÄ, ÌhÊrsI!JK"_6ÅÆ,LÍ"_ÎeÂG´>MRÏ)NE '"fg(http://nccupm.wordpress.com/)QOP±,ÄiQ±ÐÑÒ¦R%&ST ".c,U&_6VÆ"EÄ¡-.ÂÃÌW ¡X?@, *"67+,¼RJSY£¤"ÐÑÓ¦Q ÄiQ'()-.V"oÊ,LZ[" ¡,%S["EÄ

(3)

±= ,h iJ Ô MJD y )Ë ÍX Õ "\9 § OP ±, - .]e 8 ]9 : " co-production .,^Ö_¾%Â,_`"`a]AEQ×²,% "bcd=,*"67+,Jea£¤"SYfQ%/TÐ Ñg,34*hØ2ijÙÚk<lÛm"ÜQ¼Ø2ijRJÌno Ýi¢UpQÄÐÑ'()ºÞ!")ß,*"qr "oÊ±c,ÌsËÍ34["àT#$ Stu"vw,JÄÐÑ ©¤"#",ÄÐÑ*º A,^ÖhiJ%V"MJ;<x"rsÚr, "ow,9:"tun?EF"opÙ)<tun|"oprsjk,;yT e]Ïz"Ûm{m,>;\]_`"`a]eQ |L ¡]e c" ¡}~JL" k±,VÆÍ]3y]%á"~â5Jc"£¤¥¦,* Ì7" ¡K/,uI);ãä" ¡".,34'()-.V "Ü,LZ[" ¡,%S["EÄ±=,hiJÔMJDy )ËÍXÕ"\9Q àVÜ%"bcd=,*"67+,Jea £¤"SYfQ%/TÐÑg,34*hØ2ijÙÚk<lÛm"ÜQ (¼,ÄÐÑ#"%&AnVoÊ,©¤Ì=>?@2¢jk, ~z?@På¡.Ï),H-.É3E ±u æQÄiQ^©¤eaSa¢ÄÐÑ±XxÐÑ,|a¢ÐÑoÊ, àaÐÑoÊ±áâ¡ÐÑoÊç,a¢iQèiQ

#$%&

"#$%&'()

lm Urban ¡ Hauser (1980)¡Ý=Ò\] Booz ¡ Hamilton (1982)An"^ ,éTêë,ìÔ(strategic assessment)Ûm(concept development) 6 7 (system design) q (component design) í a (implementation),/TêëJeÂÃk±a,STê !"#$%&'() !*+$ ",!-.$/0123$45#$6789:;%c,ST£¤"7ÇJ "Ûm,RÛmlm Burchill ¡ Shen (1992)An"SToÊi,4±¢ (Concept Engineering),|*=>"OE",«Ì= T1 (1)ÅÆ>¡rR+E=>?@ (2)*=>?@{s¢ì £J¤XX?@rsjk (3)?@rRÀE (4)¥¦qH|rs"u æQ

(4)

!"# _$%"# &'"# ()*+ ! " # $ % & ' ( ) * + , -. / 0 1 2 3 4 % & 5 6 1 2 7 8 !"# _$%"# &'"# ()*+ ! " # $ % & ' ( ) * + , -. ) * + , -. / 0 1 2 3 4 / 0 1 2 3 4 % & 5 6 % & 5 6 1 2 7 8 1 2 7 8 &',- 1 ÛmÜ ¤)[§=>"?@,S¨Ç¤l©ÅÆ_6îª,S«;<ÅÆS¬">¡ _6',©¤eàT_6ÅÆ"oÊ,aJ®¯°0g12¡±²M³ ®¯°º¡îÛ1´=>£5Xx"µ¶rs¯Ò¡<°,S«¯ °"ÂÃ HG?ï.·T¸Â,¯°"^,?ðñrsÍ¹¯ºe5V" »Ê¡¼¹±q,ÇÏÌè½Ù]O=S¾¹¯QS«%¯°c?"¿À ÁêÂÊ (laddering)¬ë-#" (means-ends) ÊX,ÃÄkÅr"o/|}Æ Ò,ÇSTÒ¦"#",J¢«¬n=STÒ¦#""¬ë,-./0GÈ®Æ Ò,ËÍVÆ%&=>"ò (Gutman 1982; Reynolds & Gutman 1988)Q

0g !!""#$%&'#()*+$,-./(0%+!! &'(1)*++2,3!-)4+5.67)4+/0)4891.6(:2; "< +34(+%5"=67>(?!@8A349@ .6(BC+9 @ .6(DA:;E<=>;?+"!1@@AD(DA5 BC34!!FGDE1HI$J$3KLM"NO(FG+PBC(QH+R "BCS34HIM"KLTU(IJ=VWM"K0XLKLD(VWMN+Y BXZ(34+FGR[O\1+]P$KLM"NO(BCQ^_D`5 abYB8RXcQ`dO\(eS+Tf2U3V`BCWgdX(%h+Yi !!YBXZ(QHj\1(kZ+[\"!]^Dl"!m_`+naob+"U3 V`BC/pWqrs(%h+Yt=uA%&!@Wc(BC5bvw Griffin _ Hauser (1993) (xydz+{|XZ(Wc(}pD+~P7!@8R(+q{| XL}p+YivweG(xydz+VWZfgeS+7;(+qSWc(} pD+"Nz;(%h+Yth~+={|WcD+[7?-!{|5 fgeSWc0%h>+&$Xc%h95YiYBRi(Wc+!j "Ezk?lHlZUJ%h(mn+i'[o>={|rsD+8p3+d 8%&Xc%h9iqH+qrs5!!iq+)&lt&_=t&)& "dP!!(%h+bt&_t&+"&'Xc%h(Temn5vwUlrich _ Eppinger (1995) (xydz+XZ!@%h90qH(rs`+"u\Bvg( BC+7xow+;%&Texm(ds8BC{|9(5K0%h(yz >+C{q"&%hWc0%h(|}+~aYB?Q`+%h

(5)

'g(rs+b%h(98wf;E(HID`+"+ %h[\"!cnaBv(_`+d8D+&BC%hWc0+ "3(+Yt&$YB%hz(TU|}>+h[{|( 5 =k?xyu+~a 3""xm(_`_}p+ "9KLu+J¡(+X"!@)¢&(+" Burchill _ Fine(1997)B+£6"NOM"KL+("P$%&K0(+" FG$XP¡('#;;5=]yz(xyu+ "1T¢&¤+_!c ^&F(L+!B8q (`+Yt¥xy¦§[z!@¨9( oQ`+>xyKL(+G!@8© (¡H5  !"#$ ¢ªR+dX(£«¬¤¥"~¦=§c¨P(FGM©ªR+««¬®(B C+b;!j[E19(©ª_p(®5¯¯"+=ek°±(D²+°±-²3W(FGM©ª+"!³T/(´5BS+!!P\VW("8³µ (survey) (QHq34¶F(·¸_«¬¯j³(®5ab+³µQH(®;!j9b ¹º»¼(²´{|5Yt%&!½3b¾0¥(«¬µ¶+T[3¿\· +(ek_ÀÁ8«¬¸q(³5b£«¬¹º¤µ¶5°t(¯¤5

Jk?ÂÃu+£«¬¹º¤ »Äqi«¬(¼ (http://pm.nccu.edu.tw)5Å°+ =Æ½(^WR+&Ç«¬NOÈÉ½Êl«¬NOxo(DCl«¬NOxo(0® =-Ë®(^WR+PÌÍ¾(£«¬¹º¤"Î1988Ïg¿p(ÐÑÒÓÔ] À(£-Ë«¬¹º¤+¹º«¬ÐÑª]-®9¾ ÁB¢ª¶F³µ+ YbÂ!lÀ"ÂÃÀÃ(#$+&Ç%&l'l("lÕl)Öl8ekÄÀ+ X*×Ïq+3k?TU(xy0® (Abramowicz 2006)or5

vw=Ankenbrand _ Rudzinski(2005)(xy³µu+ÅÆÇRVW(«¬¹º( ^W½,]-3Ø½(1) À"fÈ¤É(«¬¹ºÀ"fÈ¤É(«¬¹º)&(Å (=J³µ.=(ek¹º+YB_VW¢ªQH{|³µ(«¬Q`na+2Ùt qS/È«¬¹ºd.W(xyÂÃ5D'!@À8À0¹º¿pµ¶(Ê ÚÛ5 (2) 1H(«¬¹º,2(«¬¹ºË3@],+X@],87«¬ ¹ºd~¦(ÅÌq3+Ü!],¦§YB©_Ã(ÍÎ+Ùt45)6+;" ¢ª(,718XZ(1+b"ZYB9¸:Ì(QHN(1+;Ý+X, («¬¹º"¦§©_Ãp9(<´5Ü*],T)&(Å("¦§[YB «¬¹º(ÍÎNeS+YBXcÍÎeSS{!(Ï5X,(«¬¹º2; "ÞiÜ!],(«¬¹º!Z+"YB=r³,©_ÃA(ÍÎu>5ÐÑ(+ b"YBÏ7«¬¹ºdN(XceS+TÏzq(3ekW?l@Ò Ó5 (3) ß|(@A¤BOÍÎdX!,(«¬¹º'P](Ô[¤+2 "V Wf(CD{|ÍÎ+)&=F(Ì(3Ø@+ÐlE¹dÕlÖF_¶%O5 bT)&(Å("¦§!@×G(µ"+ÍÎ(}µ"qÎJt58{8HØ IB½ÍÎdiÅJKL5 (4) ÙM:y«¬¹ºàNÙM:yd¦§Ú1(®+ X!,(«¬¹ºi@½+!½"WXÛ1P3ÜÙMeÝ(Q`+?!½"Ù MW8«¬ekdVW(«¬¹º+Å°«¬{!O(ÈÉÕÞM"ßÏ¾(>Ð0®5

(6)

¥xy«¬¹º(VW5JÙM:y«¬¹º^W+FPKLÙMMÆ½$J[' HI%hßK5 £«¬¹º¤"YB¹ºµ¶o©_Ã?Q¸q³àá+T<R7³o (®âj5Yt+àá(´}ãi9¹º$³o(á§«¬µ5S@ àá "$j£1á¤+àá1áDP9j³£o¤M"£¸o¤5 To+àá(ÍÎ´}i!Uj)V+T¸o+àá(ÍÎ´}iW+cÝ+ «¬¹º"!½XP[Y(¹º5ËÅq+=!@3U-Ë(£«¬¹º¤u+©_ Ã8?QlZ-+/-(àá+TZ-+/-+543Z-+/-àá(©_Ã P>ÐTZ-+[-+43TUàá(©_Ã5"\-]^5 ?Ö+86Rq_«¬¹º(pW+9j«¬¹º[3`à·+FG ([ä5i'a¨t6`+b$cS@+!gå3 y (de+bXc+G=«¬¹ ºu+ÍÎf?' x g-ÕÞ(àá+=«¬¹ºu(àá+2"VW π (´}Sf EX x ÕÞ(àá+bXc+GhiÎi"XEX@àá(µ" q +=«¬¹º:+ cS@+ "j5eGÎide(P]g+khP]Ñ 7Ri(#l8+«¬¹ºR(àá´}"[mrÚz+©_«¬¹ºÍ Î+G(D`+YBXZ(¼+æªR[32YBÍÎnop\·+(D` (Wolfers & Zitzewitz 2006a; Wolfers & Zitzewitz 2006b)5

«¬¹º:(§@+ j+Tf?(ÕÞ" +ehiÎi"X(àá(µ" f ?àá>deqg(á§çiXEàáD(µrRde(MN+ØRstàáD( µrRde(MN5R`HJP]Ñgâf?(ÕÞãJ f(q)"]P$JÎi"XEàá(uÕÜ+/«¬¹ºu+àá(_%hväD+ ZSå@èá§çTã °®+Gd3(de(y):hiÎi"XEàá(µ(q)A"w¦(x+yrs Tz !" #$!!!%&

(7)

'()*%+,"-!"#". $%/ ,0&!1 0+2343 5"# 678'()9:;$*9:!" +,"<=&!1 1+ %>43?$) @-.!/%430+ABCD-!E5F1GHI&"2J)+KLABCDM N3O!4P+QRST!U5+VWXHIYZ,'QRMN'()[\3!4P (Wolfers & Zitzewitz 200*; Wolfers & Zitzewitz 2006) ]%>+^_`abHcdABCD e;!ABHf+ABCD!678ghijk!lPmn+38J$9YZ='9 op! co-production Rq+:r;stjkhiu+vwx!<=95yZ]

!"#$

^_`abHthiz{+>?+,gABCD!67|/}~O2.!+ ~O@&hijkq+-A,Bhi!C.D+QR&.E m7+2/?|!.DEy/hi+7cdABCD| S@.DE7!hi+F@1SlP!+~O4H&013?G vd[H2I!q+&.JA)[vd!K3+LG &MNOuLPf!Uq+FQGR!+%>wS[!lP4y/& ! +TJwS!U[+7¡)hi!¢£&Y;!¤¥+ ¦§YZ='+,!U[vd!PK+G5}~OwS[lP!H ¨] ABCD!E5jV&W!ABCDE5+G3XYM©!ª?«/¬"u+ F3hijk|0+~O9P!$hiZ)-6m7[XE5¬"+2

(8)

3~O&jV&8!MNu+Su-+\vd]Shi 78+E539T!hiYabJ$2:V!®¯|;+<=^!AB CDE5jV+7MNu$8+HE57¬"!F1+~O°43±)Y aby²!hi+,'+_QRF1³`!´µ43«/~O"<wx!H¨] .;¶·¦§´µ¸ÄBCD!+ª>@&B!E5u+ >Ra&b@?&E5+H¨4H!@+&Ycd¹º!E5E+ ~Othijku+eR%u&Y;!hiRaAgE5n+ ST!fg+&hyMN!vd+%/E5n!»tBd¼+9PYZ !E5MN+%>^_`½ST!fg+jk&<¾+ª.;!· iu+~OA«&.E!YZ´µL+[cd´µR7!S Ey/hi+ Aj@ST!#¿m7+[t!u@+[ÀS hiAgABCD+ÁÂYR!ÃAgABCD6hyABCDÄÅ ÆY!²Z] klm+^_`RA,mCD-!QRnÇop[,+qÈy+H ¨CDÉÊrÉsVËtuvC!DM´µ+wGx!t E+qÈyC#CT!+67SC#CT!AgABCDn+E5 MN+7HË5tMN8:-7!yMF1++±)ÌE'y²<&y³ !lÍ]@1^_`!VW+>G@Uqn!´µ+¿/VW!!gÎ+ FG[¶·PK_GgVWw04Ëz!w=U¿+%^Ï{A½[¶· PKr«/0+67gVW+>m7+[½´µÉ¡©||«E !0Ð]  !"#$%& &W½[}&~!·iwS-+ÑYÒwS[!lP+"GngopÉ ÎmL]½wS[!lP!-+¸Ülrich L EppingerS t 1995!_`n Ulrich L Eppinger (1995)+uOÓvdngop!lP]tuO½ 1jF!_`n+uOÔG¼Griffin L HauserS t1993!HI (Griffin & Hauser 1993)+t¼¹%u!nÇopLÎm!Rqn+Îm2H±)!w Õ+,YPnÇop&T+S~O(2°43JK!;)|]

(9)

%>+3 Ulrich ! Eppinger (1995) "#$ %&'( !)* + ",- ./#0$%1&2'( 34)5*+,-6789:;<8#0$% =>?!)( *. @A%B'CD/E69CDFG#0$%7!)( 0HI1J2+*+3KL4'CDMNO,!P 5=B6FG%Q*.R)S T7 895B:;<15BD=> U?V@ 51J2+*+WX/O,M N 5YZ[\]M?B'3AG^6

Z%3AG^'CD 9:;_/ Ulrich ! Eppinger (1995) :;[7`S Z @A3A M?BC"'a?bD#A3Ac(1) dE/efghEM?ij$ % kl5E&%i6\]?mnopM?./'%qFG(6(2) =rmnZ3A )st*+ 78W\]Z=>MN M?,uvH-!IJ( wx^0 KL6(3) ,uv./U?MN./y0O mn./PN.16(4) _/hEM? Qzy=>R{|}MN %QW\]?<S3ALTMhE!ef )v ~H-?B2z6(5) ,mn./”UV”g5”dE”%3.1 5=./%Q .1 WXYZ^0[R{s%'MNa?z \5%l5\]Z%'CD7?i ]6

<IJ( 3ALMN4 \]?%jMNi^65=FG[N3A \]B_`asbcd.dQMNKL =rve4Z@AO, u8fJ 789:;%jMN^=Cg. Rh6B6=&g >?1i?!Z i?>?5j3B6MN ki?!i? 5kl%jMN0SKL6 Ulrich ! Eppinger (1995) :;js %QB'<MN^LCg.Rh+ 5m9*nK G^ :V'o lM?0SpKjhu8*+@A^6

1hE@Aqr

9:;7`shEs4t 37hu<vR)|}wx4y @A 0[klrMNO, (requirement rating)1e (concept generation)1 (concept selection)6k%&'y 9:;r&'hEzLL%j X F=Requirement Rater1Concept Generator1Concept Selector6{B'y|Requirement Rater 0>?¡v5¢£v5¤\]6sZR)|}wx[ 7jMN5¥}89¢ £¦~g5:§ 8Y¤e mn¨©ªLe«Gc ; 2¬®¯P< k°+J±s²ªhE6{'y|Concept Generator >?¡v³r <FGRequirement Rater±sa?MN @Aª @kehE ´ µ´M?J=³lªg5°+{LhEªv¶6{&y Concept Selector <_/¬®¯i=>? =Concept Generator7eshE i34 ¤±s3vJ{SB·J7_¸¹hE69:;<8} >?º@A>»wii¼½hEBC= _/0hEBC=>9*+!¾ X 8"vf§DEr9¿O6

(10)

3! "#$%

 ! Requirement Rater

9{B'hE5Requirement Rater %'y3a?¡v5?v±sa? MN `À4Concept generator@A6kRequirement Rater5' L F=Sender!Receiver Sender>?PÁÂ¤Ã!ÄÅ7?FsT 7ReceiverDPG!ÄÅC!O, X6 k9:;¢£vFGÄ(¶¤{S%'¸ 9rB'*+eÄÅ Ã!MNO, \lM?H'Æ?G78R)SMN69:;7*+ 4 ISenderÇ_?J3ccÈ'MN (n) <MN*?@Ap«(p) «(n*p) %'«.?@AK»MN'« (T) IM?@AÉMN'«=z T/z H'MN7M?aLi« =r?HM4Z@AO, ÇHO,ÊB z 78M?ÁÂdMNsti«N 78UVSenderÇ_ËM?aOi «8*"iÁÂ 4ReceiverZG!Ã!¤O,ÄÅC ?"%'« .y#u8@PO,3PQ RÈJÌGBS8[SEMNÄÅÆT=%' MN5a? EMN)`@PO,Í4Ã!O,ÄÅ<[K»Sn'MN AÎT={L4v¸¹Ja?ÏÐMN u8FsMN«u8v 0~n l_Ã!O,ÄÅB_?FcÈ' 'RT=[SMNÆla?u 8lFs w T=[K»MNÆa? u8<[S7 JMNÆFs ReceiverU¥}7FsMN <0O, "Va¨sti «3c",O4 "u8FG%Q*+Wc? @AB'XqÉO,6R 1DÑhwÃ«_¡6

(11)

9:;eH¢Òp lM?SYyz'£ 8%'*+@Apu8e ¥},? ZSn' (n < z) ¤YZ¥}P< `Ó`ÓO,bÇ^06 %QX+¸¥Z¦['NWc(TOÔL(TÌÕ k(TGcfOÔ La?T7Ò\§ @k;2°]?T76k%QX+^5JÖ6 v*×« (alternatives) ¨0 BjMjs'vJ3_`3¥( T56' (Hayes 1964; Wright 1975; Bettman 1979; Bettman & Zins 1979)6Hayes (1964) HM:;^js 4'*×ØÙMÇz ÑÚa8'*×6Z%3:; Wright (1975) jsc©6Ò¬ª=3¥bCP« 10'DÇ_5ÌÕ6¬Bettman (1979) ^js cÛZ*×ÌG10' cÛuvJdK(T`X+6A ® KÚWc(TOÔL(TÌÕ k(TGcfOÔLa?T7Ò\§ @ k°]?T7 (Bawden et al. 1999; Iselin 1988; Jacoby et al. 1974a; Jacoby et al. 1974b; Malhotra 1982; Malhotra et al. 1982; Miller 1956; Wilkie 1974)6789:;<ÜÂn 3¥[Ü=6'6 & 1! '()*+, ¯RC¡ ?JMN« @Ap« « IJMN« ¯e n p T z ¦[SKÚWc(TOÔL(TÌÕ k(TGcfOÔLa?T7Ò\ § f<Requirement Rater`gh°Ý46i (x1, x2, …, xn) 5/9*+±s j× 0[ x1 S xj-1 Æ T/z, k T/2z < xj < T/z, xj+1 S xn ²T/2z6k (y1, y2, …,

ym) 5B' optimal solution Þ! (x1, x2, …, xn) lwx6k yk 5{B'aOi«l

xk 5 6uv³´uvJk < j1k = j1k > j&Zµ´ l k < j luv 5=3¥a

Oi«=T/z¥}dEÆBQ6l k = j (x1, x2, …, xn)7Îs RÈ`-Z (y1, y2, …, ym)m 78X%*+Îs `5`Z3_m¿6lk > j (x1, x2, …, xn)7Îs RÈ`-Z (y1, y2, …, ym)m 78X%*+Îs `5`Z3_m¿6Yu¶ FG%*+7Îs HMRÈ5`Z 3_¿ l`VÎS3_´j×6optimal solution_¡57JÏÐS ¸¹n«·5 Æv~8aOT/zi«ÒÎs6 +49:;./B'op %yß¾XG^6/qrÊà<FG #B'Zwii¼½hEBC[B'áhE :§I./wii¼½hEBC] ./ FG|}MNR)^4 R)S st1u~vN1fc¸9 wwhE8¹`ÀBC@x¼½yz{%º'MN5./ÛdG T=ir %já¦~ ./Û`|C:§S]./¼½hEBC6_/9:;Z%â7 *+ <%º'MNiO, 8"4CDu8fDEJ6iãJ10 ¢./Û|C¤@AO, H'lM?»¼7JMN5}a? äM?vº'M N[ K»'MN½~¤O,./Û 5Y7JMN«T`n*p 10*22069JMN'«=º ZM?K»«T20³´4 =r ÇHO,ÊBz UVÁÂ%º'MN`aOsti« kaOsti« ±*.5T/z 520/4=5 %5ZK»MN½~./Û¤O,³´ 4 H'MNUVÒÁÂsti«64<%ã20'5 K» ½H' laOMN e./Ûy»¼[SMN5}!./Û`|C:§S]./¼

(12)

½hEBCJa?w åT=[SMNÆa? 7u8<[ SMN FG g5T=Æla? u8zYlFG634Z[ Receiver7J./ÛGFMN H'MN`st3i«=5i kÞUVÌ GBS8[ 53i )`ÒT=5a?MNkÒH-4@P4BCD kJ{S3i8[MN "S]sti«@AO, zL%CD/E @P4BCD6

"!Concept Generator

Concept Generator 5'L F=Composer!Filter6Composer>?X/ = +!FG¾BCDRequirement Rater7eMNO, Í4§8@AO !"#$%&'()*+,-./,012 34 5678./9:,;<=>!?"@AB#$#C,DE*@FG HI,*+J789:KLM*@% &'NO,!(6#./!"O#P)$% #$#C,QR*S+&,,QRT5UVW',-.//()X569:YZ[ 01%\,!]Composer^_`,#$./01M*@ab./23,Filter c4d!"(56./9:78T5e;)9f*=6+&,T5W-,/6N O+3QR:gWA-,./012Filter6hi#j,klmno,4p$%7qr msYZtu./01,./9:012 !"6 YZ,-q5,sYZ,Requirement Rater^_`,*+vwC ,6(x yz.3@%\B{|}~G,!?bComposer78 ;./019:Km!".<*@ab./019:78T5e;)78t4 !"6]YZ*@R./019:_p,;7q:sYZ,./01t <sC=-Uw,2!] !"wC&'6>sYZ'%QRn?,\6J G7q YZ,v*+\cQRS`7q./019:,*+}6% ,,@A!"#Bv/>CD,*+E78./S%BvUw,*+7 qComposerF./019:YZ,*+}6%,!"#v}6G ,*+ ¡H01>sYZ,Requirement Rater<*S6Requirement Rater_pvKmI2D 3!]=-7qConcept generator,*+7!"[*@3d#(DI2D,3 *+¡H41!">sYZ,Requirement Rater#(3*+¢£v!"1R6 Concept generatorYZ,*+r'¤6!]IJHv,¥r'[/>KD2 %,,¦R !"#n$#r'6D,*+tpJGL78L; rM,@55N§)_`2^6Ow,./01 5)6Gt,./01 ^%¨Pr'52^6-1Ow,./01)_`;67qKm:sYZ,Concept Selector©7,P8@oA-P./9:,ªQUG«¬!]RS6 (2^6-1<,./01T'TX)!?t4®2^6-1O./016T,UAK :E)6G7q !"rmYZ,Concept Selector2rm!"Filter#./9:7 8¯e;)//kV./UVW°,"Wkl,4Km=±dT5D>gWA-, 019:,01nab!":YZ,Concept Selector&'²³´µJcrm,¶·2 X:J yz#:¸,s*;JY<(sYZ,¹·U=6>s*;<! "FB>>sYZRequirement Rater^-p,*+v>9N§º*+ Requirement RaterKm7B>Concept Generator<(º*+Bv Z??[,(5»

(13)

\']S`@UV,./%^A,/BP¼#(º*+abComposerJ789: $%Fp%:2^3-1O$o,./019:(1)?[,(5»(2)\']S`@UV, ./»(3)A,/BP¼»(4)A,/BP¼«½\'`@UV,./»(5)A,/BP ¼«½?[,(5»(6)?[,(5«½\'`@UV,./»(7)A,/BP¼KL «½?[,(5\'`@UV,./N§%,COw,./0124b Composer^_`,(CO./019:[¡abFilter±_./9:78¯e;)Jc¾ ¶Dkl24`./9:78¯e;),a¿KmFilterhi1ÀW,bce;) (x«p?[(5¯A,/BP¼6OE9:O·,dª!?@kV?[,(5*@ 6'Á\ef,g·./ 5@kV(C,(5h0*@¶'s)whtml/Li ,'Fj+&SflashT5ÂqGÃ//4()+&#)=-/BP¼,:k(6O c9:P)=-HI[D>,+&JgWY(C,!]l@#wP ?[(5¯A,/BP¼UV,./019:*=!]mnC./019: [®B%:2(1)?[,(5»(2)\']S`@UV,./»(3)A,/BP¼»(4) A,/BP¼«½\'`@UV,./»(5)?[,(5«½\'`@UV,./2 FilterD78bcKm4dp%,()01¡#()01oKB:sYZ,Concept SelectorbConcept Selector&'²³´µJ78 !",rmYZ3d2

 ! Concept Selector Concept Selector6!"<rÄ@,D,5ÅÆoÇB$%ABDE,019:2 ±5GLMPrScQNO?W°^',YjW[5´µÈp (opinion polls)24 yzq'²³´µL5r±´µÈp\?ÉÊrPÃË,j$2 ´µÈp5%Q¦RC,jWtpoÌstSj,C uLGv),5 %]ÍwSjxwC5,¦Ë2sy4z¿Sj??ÎSoQ ¦RCtpslD,ÃC [oÍwSj,5#RCTMR6sl,.U Ï2*SSN6"@VY{ÀGv3|,}~5RS)Rp 1000WX,Ã C #RCTMR6}3%KÏ2´µÈpr,YÐ5$%'Èp{J78 UV Ñ2´µÈpRSQ)uÁ,WZ[_8?!]$%VYWZ[%^ W5SÎL8?TL,UVÒ2 5´µÈp:Sc,ÐÓ(1) G 'Á4z1\[5LP¼4]^_^%RS)sl ,`\Ë2 (2) Á,\ÔslOab>msc2 (3) S5785Ë )QÕX´Ö4dSÎefC 5sT,g2 (4) Á,5stL O,8?2 (5) ´µÈpRS*@sl,h×»i×»W×4oPS782

²³´µ (prediction markets) 5Ø|35j`©-kaÙ,Gl´µ¦ RaÙÚ~m|3`,¦Ë2²³´µ%:,YÐÓ(1) aÙÁ,n!7Û [)hiUV|²³´µ,ÉÊ[7Ü2 (2) ÝÞ#&'²³´µ,Oo{ß ²³´µ,ÉÊÜ',{bÈp (Wolfers & Zitzewitz 2006; Boyle & Videbeck 2005)2(3) aÙÁ[5|hiÁ)`\,^%²³Ú[5|3`,¦ Ë2 (4) ²³´µp$%6gq»O6r78aÙaÙÚ,sÖxTÜ, ÑÚà (http://nccupm.wordpress.com/)2

áLsy`S',´µ ÑjWSt ÑW (Conjoint Analysis(Carmone et al.1 978) 6yz_âT./<xu)ãv,_âroFBwÁ,xy2t ÑW>

(14)

9_âxv)ãvSÓä\»jn;»ÚGNO_â78z3m6w Áåæ{,|çG()}z_â78èÚq'd":jW#()ãÒ¯ãv~ ,Ã' 4Gsãv%^ãv~,¢@;·p\ÖèÚ,jW2t ÑW K'01>9()ãv015ßÕwÁ,!(41Êl()ãv,à *SCPUL5_â,sãv,CPUL$%ÓPentium IV 631Pentium Duo-Core E-5200Celeron 300/2zK(C;jWé'_âT./K01Êl 78B_âT./K·YZxxj_âT./,ãv¯ãvàt234 y zKyz6./01,9:]YZJêxxj_âT./,ãv¯ãvàt 4'K²³´µjW5X¸ Requirement Rater ¯ Concept Generator Kmr ë./01KtuConcept Selector2t2FG²³´µ¯t Ñ6¨'¯78j$ J78ìr>YKÁjW,M2 2 !"#$%&'()*+,- Ò ²³´µ t Ñ 78j$ x,¡ 1¯ãv¼,ìr{ Gíç,t % 0-100 , ãv¼,ìrVî ^X,Gl GPïÁ RCÈp^Çp, ð¯Á 78,P¼ ï$ñ¸78aÙ t Ñ¥¢mn¥¢ 8- S6%kV~,a Ùï8- ò QÕHÈp9:, w^%w _p FGDEé,01 ãv¼,¢ Gs¶,é¨; $kP¼£¤rÜ FGãl¥¦9l:, £¤r

Concept SelectorX,sYZConcept Generator !" #$%!&'() !*+ !,-./0 1"#2 3!$% !!%-456$78!9+4:;&<=>' "?@A Concept Selector!Concept SelectorBC7DE#7F"G(%)*H I>+JKLMDN!Prediction Market>OPQR%S!5TOPPrediction MarketUA:BVWX?,Y!01)*>+DN#JKZF-.# /[\10%!!*]^V0_=$`%`&abc!'Concept Selector> %SE1#!$bc452de-.#/[\10%!fg./(h%SE#%bc45 2de-.#/[\10%i&bc452de-.#/[\10%?(h%SE#.jDN 3!*45kbc>)lmU%S!*+#n9.j67N!8((h%So! 19*(9:=>pq!,Y!r;st%Su!Yv=<+=8>w,x -.!/0%S9:31!&45+=%S!E=4Z18?/M"+=>y z@{|!&245+=%S9:%2!3A(h%S?BC^!Concept Selector F4}015D:~}%S!8(*Concept GeneratorE6MConcept Selector 01F1F7%S!&"G%SG#n9.jDN>8+mU%S!8(

(15)

H+(h%S/!(h%SoI)oiMJ)o#KL.j!"rA:M )!N45'{d9!r.jQR)o^3!9+BVQRXOA:PBV: M!59BVWX? HIst#QP;R<=(double auction)bSUA:QR!iQR =27stT67v!>stT%S:MXO1#?U>sJXOVr XP!U+T?A #=m%S@WAXXObS?¡>sJXO¢+X )!E45?BXYZ¢+X[XO?AT%S!5J*C\X?AD£VC¢X =mDUE@X]! |.^_!¡>sJXO\+X!`¤¥5?BXYZ\+ X[XO=mT%S!5J*C¢X=mD@C\X?FD!Y(}U!Ej45a *X]&E@OG??=H7IJKLM!@Q*HIA:%'QPXON*b S!5X¢|W!&HI%o)o#430 }b (http://nccupm.wordpress.com/)? Yc3c4>d!KLMH;=!?A =m`XM #¦XM!XM#JK5 DeXO?!§¨XO7A:QR!¦XM#*QR|+f7glXh! ©=LM"Xh)+!QRN1~D!&XhBiMh#Miª}h!fg«= O?Mh¬iJ¦!O?¬-!&J¦`<§J¦ #¡j=!kcKLM =)¦? 3 !"#$%&' H; l® H; l® ?A?m k? A # = mT%S O?Mh¬ f 7 O ? % S ¬ ¦XMXM k 5 ¦ XM b S X M b S A:QR!¦XM P!«7+ f 7 A : Q R Xh J¦ _<mn!¡j =! #§J¦ 4%S1=53H;!%SoA`%Sl®`I)o`MJ)o`?AXO` =mXOiB¯~QX!HIBVM>QE#"BV~QX?%S#QP 0-100 S%S!BVMXE©= 0 V 100 kcTbc#R°k!HI45p±7i6 qrU+%SQR)o!t!'45,HIU+!B²>7] !r!rQR)o t sV!³±*e,HI+f7]bc!r!BV~Q XOe r o!4MXEt´ 100!&S345%SMXE 0!BVµ$ MXO 100 %S!"GE#HIBVmv?

4. ()$%&'

H; l® H; l®

%SoA %SoA ?AXO D e ¦ XM u B ¶?AXO %Sl® u v . / % S · w!¸-xybc ^ g z 1 9( h =mXO D e ¦ XM u B ¶=mXO

(16)

DN{T I)o % S I Q R )o B¯~QX B ¯ } ! ~ ¹ Q RXO s)o % S s Q R )o %S#uBx7}|}!rEUOP}%S"#J!Uuvx y!ruHI-.~!%S"$JF53a!%S`% SQRi%S:Mº %S *»+%S>7(DN!%HI%}>E 01!¤D%S!4 }01E5D~}%S!+4$H;%SoA`%Sl®`I)o` MJ)o!%S>IUIXO+ 50!kc9+T67w'{uD?V¼^ e>½P,WU{T!HIf7(DN#JK[\½P¾¿01)o!,% } 01_=X!(1)YZ`(2)tj[./01`(3)\ ])o`(4)\])o'[Àt[./01`(5)YZ[Àt [./01!%STp±DN01A:Á%~53X%Sº (1) %SoAº½P)o[\--YZ (%Sl®º[ÀYZ45[\½P ¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 jÂMJ)oº% 2007 12 & 31 j)

(2) %SoAº½P)o[\--[01 (%Sl®º[Àtj[./01 45[\½P¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 jÂMJ)oº % 2007 12 & 31 j)

(3) %SoAº½P)o[\--])o (%Sl®º[À\])o45[\½ P¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 jÂMJ)oº% 2007 12 & 31 j)

(4) %SoAº½P)o[\--])oi[01 (%Sl®º[À\])o '[Àt[./0145[\½P¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 jÂMJ)oº% 2007 12 & 31 j)

(5) %SoAº½P)o[\--YZi[01 (%Sl®º[ÀYZ [Àt[./01[\½P¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 jÂMJ)oº% 2007 12 & 31 j)

%S 1 M%S 5 #n9.jDN>8+mU%S!"X%S^oE#H+(h %S/!(h%SoI)oiMJ)o#KL.j!"rA:M)!N 45'{d9!r.jQR)o^3!9+BVQRXOA:PBV:M? %SQR ¡%DNB~%S^V!Bx7E#7ru!A:QR?iQR =2!Yv#ÃistQR=!4=1*i 100000 Mh'(!À 4rA:%S?=)½P!rk¶%S7A:QR)!§¨#7?A #=mKL 7IJKLM!rKLM%)®¶?A =m`XM #¦XM`O?Mh¬i J¦!FKLM%>7ÄIJÅ^V*m!Q*HIA:%!%)o

(17)

#4 30 A:}b!r.j%)o^3!5XON*!^C^E#X¢|W!©= [À¬ÆB¢X|>7¬)!N1*¢X8@W>¬? 'rQRA:u)+!%S?AXO`=mXOiB¯~QXE1=.9>)^ +?j;,Ul!r==f9%SoA!½P)o[\--YZi[01 %S,¦XM!rXh 60 r^3!A:O? 100 Mhgl!_*EKLIJ5 3KLMº KLM ½P)o[\--YZi[01 ?A=mº?A ¦XM XMº¦XM glXhº60 O?Mh¬º100 J¦º§J¦ KLM*m^V!YvA:%~¹P!ToQR|,E1S3 94000 ' (!Ç= 100 Mh%SoA!½P)o[\--YZi[01?&%SoA!½ P)o[\--YZi[01q`E1a~53Wº %SoAº½P)o[\--YZi[01 %Sl®º[ÀYZ[Àt[./01[\½P¾¿01)o I)oº% 2007 11 & 1 j MJ)oº% 2007 12 & 31 j ?AXOº60 B¯~QXº60 Z#Yv%=~¹!'%SE1+53q`!È1=B¯~QXq`º %SoAº½P)o[\--YZi[01 %Sl®º[ÀYZ[Àt[./01[\½P¾¿01)o I)oº% 2007 11 & 1 j MJ)oº% 2007 12 & 31 j ?AXOº60 %S:M %S-LrMJ)o)+!E1É.A::M!>=(h%S1}bA::M! HI1p±>+7@¬!U+:MXO 100 %S¬?BVHI 1m:MXO 100 %S!"E#HIBVmv?cr!-m&Q R^V!HIuX(h%SqrY3>dº (1) %SoAº½P)o[\--YZ (%Sl®º[ÀYZ45[\½P ¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 j;MJ)oº% 2007 12 & 31 jÂB¯~QXº53.4)

(2) %SoAº½P)o[\--[01 (%Sl®º[Àtj[./01 45[\½P¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 jÂMJ)oº % 2007 12 & 31 j;B¯~QXº32.7)

(3) %SoAº½P)o[\--])o (%Sl®º[À\])o45[\½ P¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 jÂMJ)oº% 2007

(18)

12 & 31 j;B¯~QXº10.4)

(4) %SoAº½P)o[\--])oi[01 (%Sl®º[À\])o '[Àt[./0145[\½P¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 jÂMJ)oº% 2007 12 & 31 jÂB¯~QXº87.3) (5) %SoAº½P)o[\--YZi[01 (%Sl®º[ÀYZ

[Àt[./01[\½P¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 jÂMJ)oº% 2007 12 & 31 jÂB¯~QXº93.2)

HI+@mbc!8(©=B¯~QXemo%S1°:M 100!4/ %SEd&ef!B²vY3º

(1) %SoAº½P)o[\--YZ (%Sl®º[ÀYZ45[\½P ¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 jÂMJ)oº% 2007 12 & 31 jÂ:MXº0)

(2) %SoAº½P)o[\--[01 (%Sl®º[Àtj[./01 45[\½P¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 jÂMJ)oº % 2007 12 & 1 jÂ:MXº0)

(3) %SoAº½P)o[\--])o (%Sl®º[À\])o45[\½ P¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 jÂMJ)oº% 2007 12 & 31 jÂ:MXº0)

(4) %SoAº½P)o[\--])oi[01 (%Sl®º[À\])o '[Àt[./0145[\½P¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 jÂMJ)oº% 2007 12 & 31 jÂ:MXº100)

(5) %SoAº½P)o[\--YZi[01 (%Sl®º[ÀYZ [Àt[./01[\½P¾¿01)oÂI)oº% 2007 11 & 1 jÂMJ)oº% 2007 12 & 31 jÂ:MXº100)

^V!HIT1m%SoA!½P)o[\--YZi[01i½P)o [\--])oi[01!"m%S?

 !"#

ÊËOP01yÌu!Í¨!FHI<~aÎ&< Requirement Rater`Concept Generator 5 Concept Selector!,"HIyÌ!L~01 D?HI·&OP:OPÏÐÑÒ!Ó5ÄÔÆÕ^Í¨$!B V@OPÖ=µ$ÏÐ×¬Ø;!LM¤}45n9!, *3&%g !"#$%&'()*+ %,-./0&12%3456. 789 0:;!<=>"?@ !"%!#' AB$C%D2%%EF.G HIJKLMN&OPQ%R&LM !'

!"#

KLMST%.9UVW0:XYZ[\]^_.`ARabcde.B& X YZ[\]0:N!"%,-'KLM`AXYZ[\]^_DRabcde.fgF $.+hRabc\]ijk'.B&'AgES(l'mRabc%noD#.D3

(19)

p">qrst%u$ (Stefan 2007).f0:vwx)*3pNij%Ayz.{+, Ay{4G-$%">3p..|}%`~q7no.4/%.0{=">3p.. `~1no%2%'3KLMhI%TfDXYZ[\]^_z4 u.Ay>$)RabcgE%.@KLM\]|A%Ay>$' fRabc%FLMz.3p%456Bx9LM"7u8%+ -.9:9#;Rabc%<=`~.+,LM6Bx">#.r{# %&<?l9fbc$4%&')vRabc%.3Uf@I% z%bc.?l9AB9:.9r%.m ¡%CDf"UI ¢£EFG.HIJ ¡%+K.3m/0IN¤%LM`~6Bx">( ).6QHanson(2005)N¥%LMz.¥¦§D$¨%deLMN'.O©H &0:lFN(IEFGNij%RabcI`~.9ªB«)ª¬lF%'B / 0 * P 7 % & b c % $ 4 j U : i j L M . A z Q R S * (lying) . T + (manipulation ).%&(sabotage). ,-(embezzlement )U+(retribution ).HansonJ. <$4jUªB/0.®¯VWX%,Y3p:ij.°m|{-%9fv $4jU)vRabcN9±%/EF'Hanson%LMZ. <fbczij% $4jU0°ªB12fbcz%AB3p.U3[; <$4jUN.%Ra bc²\.]³/%4´3p.q¥],%µ^.0³Rabc¶·¸µ%H#' 3.KLMh/0N(IEFGijRabcI`~'

fKLM%\]z.Concept Generator;_1`¹ºRequirement RaterN»%X YaKE¼A.3|,;½»2^6-1PAy¼A.mKLM¾O/0I¾O .4u%Ay>$9#;Rabc%gE'U.KLM*+2\Rabc %I34.BN(fijRabc3p½%bD'KIlFfRabcLMz.¿ F15c%de56X Zocalo (http://zocalo.sourceforge.net/) xijRabc% IN('BG()IN(%fg\V>ijSÀ' ZocalohiIDbc%$Á6j78'3pªBkQ%C+.fZocaloz.9 "ªB\VeÂ{y%:;.m <"ÃfRabcz.3p<= x>l>$% Ay.fRabcz%Ay.¿Fπ%Äm:<´.Bc{uAy!n%¸o.2ÅJ {%=ÄU8Ä.q{H#ªB3pÆ%?>p>J{%?>'3pªBkQ7 %[email protected]ij3pTEbc%Äm' “Ra”. 3p%qr. ªBsAÄm:.q¬ªB_3pjU%'B.x VAy%ÄÇ'ÈCfZocalo zreÅÉijtuÊË.C={vLK%Ì>*+\V'fIz3p%DA>. ÌD3p%wxUÌD%qr.yz{E3p%Fe¸»U¥|.Bc3p% ¸»9#ªBf9DA%3pz.ÍÁ;/'mAy[}tuÄm~G0Q100 . m¿Fv¢£AyÄm$Î%Ì>9maxprice.ªB/0k'Ì>.)Ay3pHÏ ij\V' T`fZocalo%\Vz.{?+tu%ÊË.x: Vbc%'X²Ð'. 3p%¸»9ªB;/Ñ99DAÆe.KIf Ò¾OH<I@I%3 pbD.NBf Ò%\V9F;/%!#'.f3pz.3p%Ó9Æ% ÄÔJ{%JÄm]Ð%Äm.Ñ9=+Äm;>6.f ÒKI9F ÕÖ%R\Ç.=+Äm$G>6'×.3p%¸»U¸KDAy.f3p` ½.ÕÖªB\VØs|¸KÑ9¸KDÍ{Ay>Ls|.KI9FØs |Í{¸K%\V'|}./0Zocalo0ªB\V9DAz.3pªB3UÍ{% l.mªBkQMC%?"Nl..KI?+9Ay>$)Rabc»% .3f3p%0_z.h7Í{Ay%bDNl. \VfKIz9 u@%' fT`Zocalo%6X\]nz.93p>>$%Ay.9l3p. ÄlÙ93p>>$%Ay..Å~ÄlAy±3S}.3pªBÁij Äl%TE./0 ¡%\].ªBhI%8fÄm%O¨.0P½ÏS 2{"A4TEAyÄm'

(20)

20  !"#$%&' IijNF%XYZ[-TU.¥ÚÉPÆ%XY|H12<=BCD'Q R.mXYZ[%¼±aKUBG.QEXYÛFXSaÛ6XÜTXYÛU$ self-serviceÛCD'QR4uGÒHIXY(ÅOJÛQKÛDeckLM)DV*Ü TD3'XYaK%Ýw;Q_U.V*ÜTD3ÛU$self-service (w)ÛCD'QR4uGÒHIXY(ÅOJÛQKÛDeckLM) (w)ÛQE XYÛ6XÜTXYÛFXSa'fIijz.Ùh|}w.FXSa._W ®XYZ[aK.Þ=i´Rabc%Ay>$'Rabc3p9;10l¸Õ.ß àijRabc%3p.9Ay.ij10N3p..GN{ÌD3pOP3 p½.h¥Q`Ay3p)v$6AyRabcSe½ÏDQ&½Ï%3p½ Ï%PX v$6AyN()4%TF,-Sáâ§.B©3pijRa qijbc%3p.4Y VAy=8'54s|ZRIijzSÕÖSn'

(a) Requirement Rater Sender!"#$

(!"%&Sender'()*+,-./012)

(b) Requirement Rater Receiver!"#$ (345678,9.*+)

(21)

(e) Concept Selector !"#$% (Concept generator &'()*+,-./0 Zocalo 123(456 789:;<"#=>?4567@AB($%)

(22)

4 !"#$%&'()*+# ,! -./0123Requirement Rater4567$%"#8$9:;%568&<=> Concept generator456&'?@8A<23BC756DE01 ':;BC?@7 F,8GHIJKL7MNOPAQ()8E!R68STU-V* !"()W8 +XY7BC?@8Z,[\$%&'()]IJKL7^"OBD -._8$%&'"#`-a86b5b4b3&c$9deBC?@63(.da B? @/63f0)8$9:;e31( B?@31)b15( B?@15)b7( B?@7)81SAQ-.W8 !"4AQ729e3181587863D<!g-.h"ijkMl3m7BC O4e1008!gBC?@7-./n#m58<S!5-._84MN7BC6o2 9Epq$8#jAQMN8rW()S6BC?@788!5MNj4567OPa %#98sPm5MN4567t:&u'7;<#88dvZw=8S6BC?@7 MN88%56>xq97#9y8<6BC?@HzIJKL756{x+#97? oD !"#$ %&'()*+, 31 -./0123456789:;<=>08?

-.01 Zocalo AQIJKLMN8Z8eSBC?@ 31 7-._8Zocalo 4$ "|}7@A(9AQm57IJKL~J98%~J974|}7 e8Z8(7$%8B|%iC)*6&'(+,-DSBC?@ 31 7-._8

(f) Concept Selector !"#$% (&' Zocalo ()*+,- !$%(./012"345 !67 89:;()"#5<=>?@ABCDE89FG:;5HI=JK7LE89FGMN)

(23)

/|}DE.F/]MGb0H self-service (IDJ)b'(+,-u)*+$%(s 1,Kb,-bDeck ./) (IDJ)b\0$%b1L/$%8ZH2g$%&'"# AQB$%&'DIJKL/"%ijkMl3 15 J8Hm5-.AQH8+ Sm5!._8IJKL4567OPa%#9D 5 ]? 5 eMH3D 5 BC?@ 31 m5-.7ijkMl? 5 !"#$ 31 % &'(#)* @ !" 1 !" 2 !" 3 !" 1 1 !" 2 -0.20091 1 !" 3 0.138254 0.086343 1 m5-.8!5-.hB5qBCijkMlN7?48}BCJO98 Z%H7m5-.457?48AQu*?(correlation coefficient)7)48ZIq 5-.]ID5-.45#?4AQu?7)4PQUR85S8S)46Iq 5-.]ID5-._8ijkMlN7467&?`-e 50.74194 ] 47.677428j )4S-._8!gBCijkMl]%467&?#T77U8Iq5-.]ID 5-.`-e 13629.94 ] 19454.77Dj/Iq5-.]ID5-.%ijkMl] g-467&?TVVu87WUe-3271.588q9/?:2u?7X8-.q ]-.D7u?de-3271.58/√13629.94*√19454.77= -0.200918u?7)4 _8vZo8!g-.7u?8%3HhYz 0.484oYu7;<8 cvZ8!5IJKL75684op#97568BC?@ 31 7;<8HIJKL7 ,}ax=>7D %'()*+, 15 -./0123456789:;<=>08?

-.01 Zocalo AQIJKLMN8Z8eSBC?@ 15 7-._8Zocalo 4$ "|}7@A(98AQm57IJKL~J98 w29##¡8./+u rBCSprBC?@7[<#8801IJKL4567OPa%#9D

(24)

 6 BC?@ 15 m5-.7ijkMl? 6 !"#$ 15 % &'(#)* @ !" 1 !" 2 !" 3 !" 1 1 !" 2 0.847086 1 !" 3 0.939094 0.782652 1 }!gBC7ijkMl8Hm5-.457?AQM¢7u?)48 u?7)4_8vZo8!g-.7u?8%3Hh£1 0.784o£ u7;<8cvZ8!5IJKL75684o+#97568BC?@ 15 7; <8IJKL7,}x+;97?oD 6 ]? 6 eMH3D %A'()*+, 7 -./0123456789:;<=>08??

-.01 Zocalo AQIJKLMN8Z8eSBC?@ 7 7-._8Zocalo 4$" |}7@A(98AQm57IJKL~J98 w29##¡8./+ur BCSprBC?@7[<#8801IJKL4567OPa%#9D 7 [email protected]? 7 !"#$ 7 % &'(#)* @ !" 1 !" 2 !" 3 !" 1 1

(25)

!" 2 0.985663 1 !" 3 0.947747 0.976149 1 }!gBC7ijkMl8Hm5-.457?AQM¢7u?)48 u?7)4_8vZo8!g-.7u?8%3Hh£1 0.784o£ u7;<8cvZ8!5IJKL75684o+#97568BC?@ 7 7; <8IJKL7,}x+;97?oD 7 ]? 7 eMH3D %B'!"C#

\ -.¤AQ7 !"#$!%& 31'15'7'63(")*+ !"#& 31 ,(-./012345#63017$8/%(9:;<(=>? !" 63 ;&( '@ABCDE>?F((+>? !" 31 ,/)G(ABCD/ 10 *HI +,( +>? !" 31 /,!(-.JK-.@*L34MNOP/Q !(6R// 0(HI+,(SG"#T$ !;U/%(CDESG"#$ !/V1(9: ;<(+ !" 31 //0;2(34 !CD/,U%W%&(+-.05;X67Y CDE89(CDE+,(9&SG$: !L;+;OP/%(LZ+CD,([ \]@^_47`a/b<c=d(e%>fg?,(hi@!/'jWklA((> B)3/b<( !"#*B(CmCDE@*no+p/"#()*q-./%Dr sj, !lA(t1CDEehi@!/'jWk=d !(L6R/-."iAE buFG(9:(@* !"# 63 /H0(2evIw-.2kx hi5JeH !"#/CD(yZ34z({ !"+ 31 ,(|}^_CD34 /sj01%~{e$A/(ZK/%-LB5#-."iLM3W/~ "yZ34z(5#-./&BNO%&eH(PQWR(Z !MNOP{'( ,./~)*+Bz,MN}f !Q W0(Sf#-.XmCb<& 24' ST#-.XmCb& 45(Xf#& 66(5#-.[%1&S 11 LCD/ !("5#-.LCD3W/XmCb[eH(Sf#(sjG* 50%(ST# zU2 50%(Xf#V 50%xZK3(/ !(yZWz( ! 34/6e@|}^_/63Xmx9:(4 -."iBCDE/Y$( }%)* !"#-CDEyZ+p/Z5(hiXw !"#/-. yZ34z({ !"X(-|}^_/637F6$/63(LZyZ p }( !"#+ 63 ,(|}^_/6361D34e$/0x + !"#7z 15 /,!("iB%-L/34([+8 !+eH/-.#"2(L63/ !mCbu7eH("\]NO%9:/(u^_`/%(s ja(mCbFBFG//0(5#/-.[+43(2:/mCb<(6RF8 &/;b34+JK(mCb<<+ 80 B 40 ;U/ !(+5#/-.J(734 F8/&x+ !" 15 /-.J(5#-.L6R/"iLM3 !&cd( 5#-.U/~"( -@u=8* 0.7(%.4~/01(JK>d/~ "(9Sf#-.BS5#-./~"-@u8* 0.7( <(Sf#-.B ST#-.ZeST#-.BS5#-./~"-@u[f* 0.4xXcd(5# -.L63/"iLM/~"( -@u=8* 0.7(.4~xgh/"?( @*+ 8 Jx

(26)

+ 8¡ !" 15(eHK"iL6R/~¢"@A !" 1 !" 2 !" 3 #$ !" 1 !" 2 !" 3 !" 1 1 ! 1 1 !" 2 0.847086 1 ! 2 0.154692 1 !" 3 0.939094 0.782652 1 ! 3 0.798726 -0.37444 1 %& !" 1 !" 2 !" 3 '& !" 1 !" 2 !" 3 !" 1 1 ! 1 1 !" 2 0.998124 1 ! 2 0.864084 1 !" 3 0.877188 0.889348 1 ! 3 0.968549 0.713373 1 )£/0134(q¤¥¦4(@*sjF&§¨/ !(+|}^_J( 6 3/01%i©$A/("t1%JK(sjFe§/ !(+eH/-.J(27 yª6RF8/&x { !"#7z 7 /,!(H£"iB%-L/34(yZ¦45#|}^_ L63/01jTfB(S«%"i¬%\]/NO[yZR%~{/$A(5#-. /"iLM3/~"-@u[* 0.7(.4~//Cx "+ !"#7z 7 /,!(q¤¥34z f7D//0(B !"#®+ 15 ,//0~¯([f£+"iB\]NO[-.7F$A/+4(" !"7z 7 ,(CDE@*4 °/ ! (klFBOP=m/ !)±bEFF !"# 15 ,² =W^¨³nBx¯Fa !"eH/-.L63XmCb&Gd/ !(+ ! "# 15 /-.J()´"om (aZKom)LQm/MNOP !(75T:&{T p H q I B C r , '(,./~) *+MN, z,MN} (Sfd)'{-K self-service, '(,./~)*+MN} (S5d)'{'(,./~)*+MN, z,MN}(SGd)µ+ !"# 7 /-.J(&Gd[%)´"omLXm/MNO P !x%+8'L)s/¶=/-.·/;<(L34z f7D/4Jx )ZK/-.yZ34z({ !"®+ 15 Z2,(v©K¸=&¹ºK©»{ /´¼½( !"#®+ 15 LM(t%]@q¤¥l/|}^_FN/O¾ !"#(e"ª¿^|}^_/637F&$A/63( <6Fª013À+/ÁÂ sjx9:q¤¥+|}^_-c/F2K(hi-.34z/01(`aZ2uÃÄ Å¡ +-.TJ( !"#®+ 15([ !"#-.®zCDEP&yZ"#+ Æ@!'j/H02("|}^_/$r²%7 3Ã(|}^_+sjF§¨/ ¹ºK(L+43W/01F$A(t1%sjFe§¨/¹º( 6321D3 4e$A//0(q¤¥ÇÈ|}^_yZ`avMNlQyw/¿rEsj( 9:+|}^_/63,(+¹ºXO3ÉÊ,(=RyªË¹XmCb<§ FEcO3([\]/¢ÌlAyZ+CD&2@¸=O3/MNOP"# clA("+O3OP,(X6ÄÅH,XmCb<4¾O3/AExi; Jx +-.fJ(yZ34^z([-.f/ !"#¿^|}^_/63734e $A//0("%ÍS5#-.X(²%t734~:XmCb/H0(Z !{T pHqICr}(+5#-.J(XmCb<T:& 12'76'82([Sf#-./01BXa#5("5#-.(²%ª7a#/01U2(9:ÄÅ+

(27)

>?|}^_CD,([fAt70M/,U(";XjyZÍÎv#gÏ !CD(ÐwÑÒMNOP/sj(ZÓFy/63xH,6t%|}^_/ TO()*% e Ô/Äz(S«%= !ÍÎ>?CD¬%=>?ÐwÑ Ò(S¸ÍÎl(\¸=¢ÌlA(UyIw@MNOP>?ÑÒx hi+-.5( !"# 7 /-.JL34z/7D4J(yZ]@;&{Õ@* q¤¥lL`3/YÖ>?WVx+ !63,(Dr@3L7yªÉÊ/É |(%Wt¿^}l°/ !F1D3- (k~FBMNom/MNOP)(H 0+ !"# 7 /-.J(yZ34^z(9:(q¤¥ÄÅ(v>?|}^_,( [¸=_è= !"#*B(BCDEyZ++Æ sj/"#("~ Y/:X6e%;+ !/"#%%j(t1ª+CD/½J»{K© ! ¹º/´¼½(F1D013ÁÂÀ+/sjOP(W(+RmOPQ X( ¿r|}^_WcCD/`2F&67x  !"#$%& &¿)×rq¤¥l(WØMNOPlYÖ/{Õ(+y0 |}^_/ -d½J(yZ7i"#/B~lA(>¿|}^_BMNÙIU/0 i©8(q¤¥hilÄz~/¢Ì(-.(+93(:LÚ3 q¤¥lÛ½J(-Äz-L¸/~"iBlA(+;3(ÇÈÚz ~/"iBlA(Z`q¤¥l/-r°B$rZ5x.-."i(yZ^z Z2u¦4x |}^_F» ¿r*sj¨³/ÉÊK¡[ !"#-.®zCDEP&y Z"#+Æ@!'j/H02("|}^_/$r²%7 3Ã(|}^_+sj F§¨/¹ºK(L+43W/01F$A(t1%sjFe§¨/¹º( 63 21D34e$A//0(q¤¥ÇÈ|}^_yZàvMNlQyw/¿r Esj(9:+|}^_/63,(+¹ºXO3ÉÊ,(=RyªË¹Xm Cb<§FEcO3([\]/¢ÌlAyZ+CD&2@¸=O3/MN OP"#clA("+O3OP,(X6ÄÅH,XmCb<4¾O3/A Exi;Jx ÐwÑÒysÜ/¹º¡>?|}^_CD,([fAt70M/,U(" ;XjyZÍÎv#gÏ !CD(ÐwÑÒMNOP/sj(ZÓFy/6 3xH,6t%|}^_/TO()*% e Ô/Äz(S«%= !ÍÎ >?CD¬%=>?ÐwÑÒ(S¸ÍÎl(\¸=¢ÌlA(UyIw @MNOP>?ÑÒx »{/¹º´¼7Ý*À+¸Ó/¦4¡hi+ !"# 7 /-.JL34z/ 7D4J(yZ]@;&{Õ@*q¤¥lL`3/YÖ>?WVx+ !63 ,(Dr@3L7yªÉÊ/É|(%Wt¿^}l°/ !F1D3-(k~F BMNom/MNOP)(H0+ !"# 7 /-.J(yZ34^z(9:( q¤¥ÄÅ(v>?|}^_,([¸=_è= !"#*B(BCDE yZ++Æ sj/"#("~Y/:X6e%;+ !/"#%%j(t1 ª+CD/½J»{K© !¹º/´¼½(F1D013ÁÂÀ+/sj OP(W(+RmOPQ X(¿r|}^_WcCD/`2F&67x

(28)

!"

\]B6Þ/ !"#$%&!"'%#()*+ $,%-# &.!/01234'56&78 Burchill - Fine(1997)9(:#$%;<'% !=>?@3=>%A)BC*43+%DE,FGA-H3=>I.J/KL MN OPF?@=>QRS(=>TUVWXY+#$%0Z["'%(1X\ ] !=>^_`S(àb2#3=>c3TUK LMNd4`?@ef3 !=>TUghijkl3m$=>RS5n3? @=>of&%6p !"3qr-7s$8"39:tJu8K:v%T;3wx y'%!&=>;<z{|_<0`;<}~'%3=>d(+(J)*XKXY + !"3)*}c-z{3X=>3:f}&-z{`123 !"#?À3*4$L84#& !X=>@3AK67ZX !B -c4L+ S(,CD%LMN9VW_Q3K<Eaz{ -Fc^4L(GvHS( !?@=>ofQY+X !}?@ =>@3S(I&%LMNAC33K LMN !?@=>of3m$dLs4tJRequirement Rater Concept GeneratorKConcept Selector:G3sof 4 !?@=>3 3Ks¡JL]=>¢£3¤¥¦§¨©ª«m$MNA¬ ®klà¯°¢£±²3qr ³HS(´PF?@=>µ:wO6 @-cR.T¶±²3·%KPFBC.3¸¹:·º¡3»uJ¬% P:vwQ¼½.1.¾R.T¶3T:K\6Q´Rb&/z{B¿3 !?@=>K pISLMN=>. !?@=>¸¹31EXTDghijkl3 ÀÁ:f}´Ù01*V3WX-uÂ=Y\6ijkl- !3g hUÃZ'LMNÄÅ=>[IuÂ3sµb:ÀÆX(\; ]¾R LMN=>of}TÀ[À9B3uÂ.Å-=YX)\;VW:¾³G¼ uÂ3.Å-=Y^QÇLMN=>3Àr-È_2K2ÀÆ.Å´ ³ O`(c0É(1) ijklaÊhËÌÍÎO3 !?@T¶@ (2) ÏÐÑÒ !?@3ÌÍ´Ó½ÌÔ3Õ (3) ÊÖ3Õ×Ø2`ÙËÚXB¿3c0K ÛÜ3O !"34'FË !?@=>3B¿b3QÇ+:v != >3of?@`$Ý¦-¸¹LMN:-ijkl3ghQRS(.3T¶ *c !?@=>ÞX\]=>^S(n3T¶IKLMN3+,´(J8 deK Èd;ÉLMNgh !?@=>4`3SU-ijklQ !?@=>Þ X;Fn^fgh4563.T¶:-Ùijkl3±²QU´R3 i7K TU$d;ÉLMNjk=>[IuÂ3sb:[s3:f}¾R LMN=>XÀß^9là893¸¹:ÀÆLMN ]QY+8 LMN=>TUÞS¼mnop-gh.3=Y$Y+TU´:G 3:fd !-ijkl3gh.q/44U*V3TU=>K !d;É !?@=>Sr+/0s7sátT:3Ý¦ =>:X uÂ.Å\]=>^3JâK7ãJ:G¼7sT:\]át$=>?` {\jÅJlàp"'["us+XÀ;3È@uÂát¨v3´_ f2&11XË( z{'"^X=>3:f}IäåSr+<= J1KLMN3=>-(&%w:self-selection9H43·º8ær16 JBC>wFhç¡l3JI.¬Ã@-»àÞ/%Fhç¡l`?@è '%Ï`qYuÂi7ÞXFËÌÍ3jY@´(x`123ÈäåKÛ ÜX@%yË:(1Az-i79\]3»{Xf2@a|´

(29)

éê:v7sátT:}<£wB(conformity)6.Cátgã3ÌÔ66a _c0z{TÀ3SUK¬:ÀÆ.Å32§XTÀ[=>of3:f} ´}=>:563\ë. !?@=>¸¹3ìíJBCX$~3×3= Y}4K:ÀßG3S(=>VWQY+c3 !3S(uÂIK 56LMND`E5MNÝ¦KLMN9Q !?@=>ofghijklîÁ 3=>-F6GX?@=>3de$;R1%apSï3?@TY+V W_:UuÂ3ÀÆËMN¾RFËU'UÃ=>3.T¶-= YKVW¬HÃUJ8"3È°³UuÂ3¨©´ LMN => ImUÃ-×Ø3=>¸¹K 2wLMNc0XQRO`´Ðc3-MNTÉ Èd;É:UJ83=>ÈPFJ83=>B¿ßá#QÇL= >.U×Ø=>¸¹3_±K%+(-#&3=>}XConcept Generator }3Filter-ðBC:1e3T:\]¤XY+7ã_ñ7Jñ3. Å-2ÆY+:svQ¤òQÇ#&of3LïK TUd;ÉLMN-Kd=>3deYX?@dLY+XuFÈofTUU Ã48c3VW_ßUÃJ3=>eÁQÇ=>/2%+(-Ls3;R% !?@+d !?@{4TDÀM?@3 !ðBCÛ Ü\]cS7ãY+X !3N@`93O:LMN3=>b_ ;RTDÀM3 !KÛÜLMN-|PFhç.²3J\]ÀÆ+Xi jkl-LMNP3of}K`$~uÂ36p9È3-S=> 3×Øf2`9J8VWY+dLMN=>È³UJ8ih_ñ¾R UÊhJ8ihO3=Y.-ghK%+(XConcept Generator3;RT U-%óQ[h3T:+7Zd !ßUhm3[hð?`U* V3TU7ã_X[hGWXHÃhR3S&_T|FËOSWX3Filter3 j:Q1s3Lïf2K !d;É !?@=>11%#& !=>3SgY+%U_d=>3 V@'%OÏÐWXdLMN=>c3pS(*# !=>3.T¶ Q !Y+X\]=>^3S(IK%+(-LMN3=>-HB C:;ë !_\]îÁY+'´Ðd=>3VWX:= >TUL<¾= !è'%O>WXJ11¾R !=>3?@´ ;RTDÀM3 !=>b%LMNY+´Ðc3?±3TK

!"

1. Y+o»à9 available online at http://nccupm.wordpress.com/

2. Abramowicz, M. “Predictive Decisionmaking,” George Washington University Law

School Virginia Law Review (92), 2006, pp.4-13.

3. Ankenbrand, B. H., and Rudzinski, C. “Information Markets Report 1: Description & Analysis of Markets,” MOSAIG oHG, December 2005.

4. Bawden, D., Holtham, C., and Courtenay, N. “Perspectives on Information Overload,”

Aslib Proceedings (51:8), 1999, pp. 249-255.

5. Bettman, J. R. “Decision Net Models of Buyer Information Processing and Choice: Findings, Problems and Prospects,” Buyer/Consumer Information Processing, G.D. Hughes and M. L. Ray (ed.), University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill,1979, pp. 59-74.

(30)

Making,” Journal of Consumer Research (4), 1979, pp. 141-153.

7. Booz, A., and Hamilton, New Product Management for the 1980’s, Booz-Allen and Hamilton Inc., New York,1982.

8. Boyle, G., and Videbeck, S. “A Primer on Information Markets,” ISCR, Victoria University of Wellingto, 2005, pp. 2-7.

9. Burchill, G., and Fine, C. H. “Time Versus Market Orientation in Product Concept Development: Empirically Based Theory Generation,” Management Science (43:4), 1997, pp. 465–478.

10. Burchill, G. W., and Shen, D. Concept Engineering: The Key to Operationally Defining

our Customer’s Requirements, MA, Center for Quality Management, 1992.

11. Carmone, F.J., Green, P.E., and Jain, A.K. “The Robustness of Conjoint Analysis: Some Monte-Carlo Results,” Journal of Marking Research (15), May 1978, pp. 300–303.

12. Griffin, A., and Hauser, J. R. “The Voice of the Customer,” Marketing Science (12:1), 1993, pp. 1-27.

13. Gutman, J. “A Means-End Chain Model Based on Consumer Categorization Processes,”

Journal of Marketing (46:2), 1982, pp.60-72.

14. Hanson. R. “The Informed Press Favored the Policy Analysis Market,” Technical Report, Dept. of Economics, George Manson University,2005.

15. Hayes, J. R. “Human Data Processing Limits in Decision Making,” Information System

Science and Engineering, E. Bennett (eds.), McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York 1964.

16. Iselin, E. R. “The Effects of Information Load and Information Diversity on Decision Quality in a Structured Decision Task,” Accounting, Organizations and Society (13:2), 1988, pp. 147-164.

17. Jacoby, J., Donald E. S., and Carol A. K. “Brand Choice Behavior As a Function of Information Load,” Journal of Marketing Research (11), 1974a, pp. 63-69.

18. Jacoby, J., Donald, E. S., and Carol, A. K. “Brand Choice Behavior as a Function of Information Load: Replication and Extension,” Journal of Consumer Research (1), 1974b, pp. 33-42.

19. Maglio P., Srinivasan S., Kreulen J. T., and Spohrer, J. “Service Systems, Service Scientists, SSME, and Innovation,” Communications of the ACM (49:7), 2006, pp. 81-85.

20. Malhotra, N. K. “Information Load and Consumer Decision Making,” Journal of

Consumer Research (8), 1982, pp. 419-430.

21. Malhotra, N. K., Arun, K. J., and Lagakos, S. W. “The Information Overload Controversy: An Alternative Viewpoint,” Journal of Marketing, (46), Spring 1982, pp. 27-37.

22. Miller, G. A. “The Magic Number Seven, Plus or Minus Two: Some Limits on our Capacity for Processing Information,” Psychological Review (63), 1956, pp. 81-97.

23. Reynolds, T. J., and Gutman, J. “Laddering Theory, Method, Analysis, and Interpretation,”

Journal of Advertising Research (28:1), 1988, pp.11-31.

24. Stefan, L. “A Field Experiment on Monetary Incentives in Prediction Markets,” Second

Workshop on Prediction Markets, California, 2007.

(31)

York, 1995.

26. Urban, G. L., and. Hauser, J. R. Design and Marketing of New Products (1st ed.), Englewood Cliffs, Prentice-Hall, New Jersey, 1980.

27. Wilkie, W. L. “Analysis of Effects of Information Load,” Journal of Marketing Research (11), November 1974, pp. 462-466.

28. Wolfers, J., and Zitzewitz, E. “Interpreting Prediction Market Prices as Probabilities,”

NBER Working Paper No. 12200, 2006a.

29. Wolfers, J., and Zitzewitz, E. “Five Open Questions About Prediction Markets,” NBER

Working Paper No. 12060, The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania, 2006b, pp. 3-21.

30. Wolfers, J., and Zitzewitz, E. “Prediction Markets in Theory And Practice,” NBER

Working Paper No. 12083, 2006, pp. 2-9.

31. Wright, P. “Consumer Choice Strategies: Simplifying Vs. Optimizing,” Journal of

群體智慧網絡與服務價值創造之技術方法與策略模式研究(I)

 !"#$%&'()*+,-./0



 !"#$%&'()*+,-./0%123456789:







 !" " #$%!

&'NSC 98(" 2410(H( 004" (" 050 " (MY2

)*+," 98" " -" 8" . 1" /0" 100" -" 7" ." 31" /

123456

78123

9:3;

<=>?!(@ABCDEFGDHI)JK>?#L$>?

M<=>?NOPQRHISTU

#VWXYZ[\]^_>?`a

#VbcdeYZ[\]^_>?`a

YfWghijk^_>?lmnSopq`a

#Wg%r\sWX\s>?t`a

uvwxyzh%r\s{|}z~il3 \s{

lQX_

#l[z#`-#-

)*F ¡b¢£

 !"#$%&'()*+,-./01

 !"

 #$%&

 !"#$

  !"#

 !"

 !"

** !"#$%&'()*+,-./0**

!"#$%&'()*+,-./0%123456789:

!" " #$%!

&'NSC 98(" 2410(H( 004" (" 050 " (MY2

)*+," 98" " -" 8" . 1" /0" 100" -" 7" ." 31" /

123456

78123

9:3;

<=>?!(@ABCDEFGDHI)JK>?#L$>?

M<=>?NOPQRHISTU

YfWghijk^_>?lmnSopq`a

#Wg%r\sWX\s>?t`a

uvwxyzh%r\s{|}z~il3\s{

lQX_

#l[z#`-#-

)*F ¡b¢£

** !"#$%&'()*+,-./01**

!"

#$%&

!"#$

!"#

!"

!"