行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫 成果報告
知識管理績效之實證研究
計畫類別： 個別型計畫 計畫編號： NSC94-2416-H-006-015- 執行期間： 94 年 08 月 01 日至 95 年 07 月 31 日 執行單位： 國立成功大學工業與資訊管理學系（所） 計畫主持人： 耿伯文 計畫參與人員： 陳彥芬 林建旭 報告類型： 精簡報告 處理方式： 本計畫可公開查詢中 華 民 國 95 年 10 月 27 日
An Empirical Study of Knowledge Management Performance
NSC94
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
"
#
$
*
+
$
,
-
.
/
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
78
9
:
;
<
=
>
?
<
@
A
BC
D
5
6
E
5
6
F
3
4
5
6
G
H
I
J
K
@
A
L
M
N
O
PQ
R
S
T
U
V
W
X
5
6
Y
Z
O
[
\
]
^
R
S
T
U
V
W
X
5
6
Y
Z
R
_
P`
a
b
c
d
W
X
5
6
e
f
g
L
h
'
i
Y
Z
P`
j
U
k
PQ
U
k
5
6
l
Y
Z
m
n
o
p q r
a
j
U
k
st u
r
v
w
b
e
$
x
y
z
U
k
s{
|
e
J
{
}
~
Q
X
e
T
r
Y
>
P
3
[
a
v
+
|
n
a
P
Abstract
In order to follow the knowledge-based economy in this decade, the knowledge management becomes not only an important process for the organization growth, but also a substantial issue for recent management study. However, it is still difficult for firms to survive in such competitive environment, this study, therefore, bases on the framework of business environment, leader’s behavior, and employee’s cognition, according to the conclusions of previous studies to investigate the impacts on the enterprises’ performance from knowledge management.
In view of relative studies, which aimed at the enterprises, which practice knowledge management, foreign companies are mostly chosen for the samples, however, different factors, such as national culture, geographical environment and so on, may as well influence the process of knowledge management practice. Thus, this study focuses in seven domestic companies, which have practiced knowledge management, to conduct such empirical study. Furthermore, many statistic methods are utilized to perform rigorous analysis.
Key words: Knowledge management, survey research, business environment leader’s behavior, employee’s cognition, domestic company
) * + , - * . /0 1 2 3 4 5 6 ) * 7 8 9 : ; < = > ?@ A B C % D E F F G HI J KL M N G HO P Q R S ) * . /TUV M W X Y ?Z[ \ ] ^M _ R ` a b cd e f b g h ) * i j kl m n ( o N 9 W & ' B F G HS w ) * % u v G Hh W R ?d e c ¡ ¢ £ ¤ ¥ ¦ T§¨ r © Tª « r © ?¬ ¤ ® X Y ¥ ¦ ¯ W ° ± ² r © S s h ) * . /TUV M W X Y ?Z[ \ ] h i j kl W ³ ´ d e (¸ ¸¸¸¸F G H¹ º» ¡ K; r © ¼ ½ 9 ¾ ¿ À d e ·¸ Ts h T] R T! " \ TUV R x w Á  ` Ã Ä Å ¿ Æ t m q r Ç È & S É Ê ¼ ½ u v G H Ësurvey researchÌ W Í S Î ÏR ?- * Ð Ñ W t Ò ' Ó (¸ ÔTd e - * Ð 9 : Í 3 4 ?Õ Ö × Ø S ³ ´ Î ÏÙ Ú Û¿ kl 9 : . / TUV M W X Y T [ \ ] Ü i j t m $ % b g ËconstructÌ(¸ ^T i j Ý Þ ß à áâ ã( ä ` à Kå æ ç N è : F é ê ë ì T! " \ ?± í î ï Q ð R h à d e ñ ò (F G Hó ¹ Û ô . / TUV M W X Y T [ \ ] Ü i j t m $ % b g cÕ Ö õ ËpropositionÌc ¡ ¥ ¦ r © ¼ ½ d e h i j kl m n ËrelationÌ(¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸
WiigË1999Ìö ¿ ÷ j W Ëeffective behaviorÌø C ù ä j W ú û ) * q . / ü K ý þ Z[ ½ TZ 5 ô _ T T) * ¥ j ¤ ( M G t m U ` Ã Kh N ) * q 9 : q . / ËHolsapple and Joshi, 2000ÌF G H Ú Ûþ · 2-1 . /t m ` Ã !!!! """" #### $$$$ Nonaka (1991) ¿ á Q ! " ã (knowledge-base)T ¥ (project system)T) * ¥ (business system) ) * . / ~ F ^ a b
Nonaka and KonnoË1998Ì
¿ ô B t h Ý ! " Ëoriginating BaÌT# $ "
Ëinteracting BaÌT% & " Ëcyber BaÌT ' ( " Ëexercising BaÌB ) * . /
GreengardË1998Ì ] á+ , - ÷ . / ã % 0 B 1 2 q 3
Davenport, Long and BeerË1998Ì
h ^4 W G H5 ¦ ® 6 ¿ á7 8 ` ã ËKnowledge-Friendly CultureÌ9 4 ÷ m µ : ¤
Hansen, Norhria and TierneyË1999Ì
I ¤ ; < ê ª r áQ b ã ËcodificationÌá4 Z ãËpersonalizationÌ = * B > ? 9 : X Y ± ² @ A ·F G HÛ % %%
% &&&& '''' ( ( ( ( )))) **** ++++
G H I TJ K T ¥ L Q b ¯ Y M ! " N ) * + , O Ø PU V M W X Y ß $ ' d Q Æ R $ % ä ß UV R S Æ # T U ?M V U UV R W X Y Z [ ZÎ Ïkl 9 : j ~ \ (UV Z ]^ ^ G HM ë ] S Ü / ä B ËYukl , 1981Ì( PS 2-3ÛYuklË1981Ì À _ ½ ¤ ` ÏS Ü à a t m M ` Ã Ñ W Ûô d e · 2-3 UV Z ]t m ` Ã
,,,, ---- &&&& '''' .... ////
Jacobs 1970 UV ø áZ b : à Æ ZS c * ¯ Y d c * ± í e f Z³ g h I i à ö j k l m n o Q ð (ã Stogdill 1974 UV ø áß . p [ Á q b : & ' Æ r H I cF S + ! " Q b cs t (ã Katz and Kahn
1978 UV ø áß ! " ý W ö ¾ u v Y w x k l y z (ã
Rauch and Behling
1984 UV ø á! " . p d { Z | } T ~ U V M kl ! " è : & ' (ã
Kotter 1990 UV ø á Z ; < ¯ TÛô ?J K ¨ [ ã
Heifetz and Laurie 1997
UV ø á Õ ä ò Z 1 ` à Æ ú ë T ] Tu Û; < B Ts t T N ? ~ W ã
± ² @ A ·Yukl, G.Ë1981Ì.Leadership in organizations. Nj : Prentice- Hall. Ë2000Ì&&&& '''' 0000 · ` Henry MintzbergË2000Ì.
1 11 1 2222 3333 #4#4#4#4 5555 6666 7 7 7 7 3333 # # # # ] R A Ý ¡ N ? U ¡ KL M ¿ B R ?` Ï2-4À j ` Ã t m R £ (Û¢ þ · 2-4 ] R t m ` Ã !!!! """" #### $$$$
! " # $ % & ' AjzenË1991Ì 4 Z] £ ½ Ñ W y 1 ¤ Ñ W t m ± A ¥ K ¦ h Ñ W § 0 W ¨ © ] ª ¥ « ( ¬ Ë1997Ì k Z 4 \ ?] ¥ ® á] ê ¥ ã) 4 % q r ϯ ] ? \ & ' ( Richardson(1998) ] R ® ° ± ² ³ T´ µ T+ b T¶ ª L ô · * ] Õ Ö X Y ( ± ² @ A ·F G HÛ 8 88 8 9999 3333 :::: ;;;; <<<< ==== # ¸ S @ i j ¹ ø G H! " W $ % I J B ø UV X Y T[ ¼ J K 1 ) * ; < à º » | ¼ ø % ½ ! " i j ( 9 : & ' Æ ! " C ù B ¾ ¿ Zy TÀ y ? F à Á % | ß N  ! " Ûp i j Ëú à ?x Ì 3 ËMitri , 2003ÄOstro, 1997ÌT1  : ! " M Å ?º Æ Í + b ËAllerton, 1998Ì(PÕ Ö Ç d m ) * È Á j É ø è : Ç Ê t Ë ¤ Ì t $ % ËHeeseok and Byounggu , 2003Ì(| â Í Î Ï! " 9 W 3 4 ? j ® * G Hu b 1 M ¿ * Î Ï s h F G Ha b Ð r £ Ô* % Î ¼ ½ þ · 2-6 i j Î ö } t m ` à > ? >> ?? > ? 9999 3333 :::: ;;;; <<<< ==== @@@@ AAAA Arthur Andersen ? American
Productivity and Quality CenterË2000Ì
± ² ' Ñ TUV T) * ` T± í î ï T i j Î 5 ¦ Ô) 0 Í « Ó É 0 Bukowitz and Williams Ë1999Ì S $ ' ~ \ 6 ´ Å l Te ¡
\ TÒ Ã TÎ T+ , ?s S Ü Ó Ô p q r 5 ¦ ) O0 Í « Ó É 0 B BB B CCCC DDDD
¸¸¸¸F G H W Õ ø ¡ u v G H Ësurvey researchÌ W t m ` Ã Ö §TG × ?ÛÄÇ & ö V Ø Ù TÚ Û Ü G H ? Í e R & Z F Ý @ Æ d e É Ê W ¦ Ü ¯ (¸ EEEE FFFF ¸¸¸¸F G H% ø d e ) * . /TUV M X Y ?Z[ \ ] h N ¸ i j m ´ ¤ (Þ J ` à d e ® 6 ¿ Q ð + , þ º ßàá j R a b ( ºÆ j F G Ha b % ú ) p b g ËconstructÌ·) * . /TUV M X Y TZ[ \ ] ? i j (¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ % % % % GGGG HHHH 4444 IIII JJJJ ¸¸¸¸F @ Þ J G H| ?` à 9 C G Ha b + , G Hõ ?â (r « S ) * . /TUV M W X Y T [ \ ] ?! " i j G Hb g ® ` à 9 V f b g m n + b p õ ?t m â (¸
¸G HGGG HHH KKKK LLLL MMMM NNNN &&&& '''' ( ( ( ( )))) **** ++++ OOOO PPPP QQQQ RRRR SSSS
G HGGG HHH %K%%%KK&K&&& '''' (((( )))) **** ++++ NNNN TTTT UUUU 7 7 7 7 2222 OOOO PPPP QQQQ RRRR SSSS G H 1 G H 1 G H 1 G H 1 KKKK LLLL MMMM NNNN TTTT UUUU 7 7 7 7 2222 OOOO PPPP QQQQ RRRR SSSS ¸ G H 8 G H 8 G H 8
G H 8KKKK&&&& '''' ( ( ( ( )))) **** ++++ NNNN 9999 3333 VVVV WWWW :::: ;;;; OOOO PPPP QQQQ RRRR SSSS G HGGG HHH XXXX KKTKKTTT UUUU 7 7 7 7 2222 NNNN 9999 3333 VVVV WWWW :::: ;;;; OOOO PPPP QQQQ RRRR SSSS G H Y G H Y G H Y G H Y KKKK LLLL MMMM NNNN 9999 3333 VVVV WWWW :::: ;;;; OOOO PPPP QQQQ RRRR SSSS G H Z G H Z G H Z
G H Z KKKK LLLL MMMM & '&&& ''' ( ( ( ( )))) **** ++ ++ T UTTT UUU 7 7 7 7 2222 NNNN 9999 3333 VVVV WWWW :::: ;;;; [[[[ OOOO PPPP QQQQ RRRR SSSS 1 11 1 \\\\ ]]]] CCCC DDDD 4444 ^^^^ ____ Z[ \ ] ) * . / i j º ßàḸ< g ¤ G Ha b ¸
\\\\ ]]]] CCCC DDDD ËÌG Hh ¸ ¸¸¸¸F G H% G Hh ø w 9 : ) * (ã ø 9 : t ¸ m è : - i j c ä Ü PG H) * h 9 : ¸ Í å ¦ B æ & ç (Þ J S S Ñ W d è S é ê G Hh (¸ ËÔÌë { ì a ?{ F @ A ¸ ¸¸¸¸F G HS w | â x t m è : ! " [ í p ã ® N w 9 : î ) * ï ð B T ñ ò | } q ¼ * á- * ï ó ô V ?9 ãõ ö Ëhttp://proj.moeaidb.gov.tw/kmppÌÅ l ÷ ø ø ß } ù ) * ï ú ?Æ w - y y z ¿ û áü Z 9 : Í ãý _ X Y þ é ê ï ð à Æ S » ë { ¯ Y | }```` aaaa bbbb cccc '''' dddd Teeee ffff gggg h h h hTi jiii jjj gggg Tk lkkk lll cccc '''' dddd Tm nmmm nnn gggg hhhhTo pooo ppp qqqq rrrr ?ssss tttt uuuu cccc '''' dddd vvvv wwww Ò ô î ï - * Z ]ËW + [ ª ÷ ø ø áÌé ê [ ¼ Z ë { ì a Ësampling frameÌ(¸ Ë^ÌG H| r ° ¸ ¸¸¸¸F G Hº % | ß N ? F ® ` à + , õ ?; 0 L ð m n Z L ð ¤ G H_ (¸ 8888qqqq xxxx yyyy zzzz CCCC DDDD ¸¸¸¸¥ ¦ ¯ S F ® p í p Æ ë { { F r © Q ð ¿ d e Q ð ä l m n £ ËChauvel and Despres , 2002Ì(ß Pa b F G H ¥ ¦ r © ¼ ½ j ö ¿ ; t m ¤ Z ¡ SPSS 10.0 for Windows W ± ² ¥ ¦ ¼ _ t m ± ² r © ¯ þ ¸ TËDescriptive statisticsÌ
ÔT{|4;|yz{|4;|yz{|4;|yz{|4;|yzËreliability and validity̸ 1
1 1
1}}}} ~~~~ jjjj !!!! """" DDDD Pearson product-moment correlation )T yzyzyzyzËCluster analysis̸
·T yzyzyzyzËDiscriminate analysisÌ
T yzyzyzyz(Linearity regression analysis)¸
#### 4444
F GH Õ S w W ) * [ { F r « d e á) * . / ãTáU V M W X Y ãTá [ \ ] ã ^4 / ;
há i j ã k lm n (F Ý GH Q ú GH M s hF GH ¿ Q R TGH © T ê ± ? @ GH + W (¸ ####
&&&& '''' (((( )))) **** ++++ 4T4T4T4T UUUU 7777 2222 9999 3333 VVVV WWWW :::: ;;;; FFFF RRRR SSSS """" ËÌU V M W X Y ? Z [ \ ] k lm n ¸ ® GH Q ð U V M W X Y hZ [ \ ] - k lP q ? p q r ] ? ë ì t (¸ ËÔÌU V M W X Y ? i j k lm n ¸ U V M W X Y h i j ¹ k l # T U U V ' Ó ¸ hN 9 : i j 6 ä M V U U V h i j ¹ k l B f x GH M ] # T U U V M hN i j ¹ k lñ M V U U V M GH Q ð ~ w ) * ä ø Ê (¸ ¸ % % % %TTTT UUUU 7777 2222 4444 9999 3333 VVVV WWWW :::: ; ; ; ; RRRR SSSS """" ¸¸¸¸® GH Q ð j Z [ \ ] h i j ¹ k l - X k lP q ? p q r ] ? ` à ë ì t (¸ 1 1 1
1 LLLL MMMM NNNN &&&& '''' (((( )))) **** + +++ T UTTT UUU 7777 2222 9999 3333 VVVV WWWW :::: ;;;; F R S " F R S " F R S " F R S " ËÌ) * q . / hU V M W X Y k lm n ¸ ¸¸¸¸P = b g ¹ m n r © Q ð Ô S p + b - ÷ $ ' 0 hM V U U V M W c m n x à f r © Q ð ! j . / " ; hN U V M U V W - t S ' Ó k l( ËÔÌ) * q . / hZ [ \ ] k lm n ¸ ¸¸¸¸I J r © Q ð # 3 P = b g ¹ m n Ô S p + b - ÷ $ ' 0 hZ [ \ ] c m n x à f r © Q ð ! j . / " ; h N Z [ \ ] - t S ' Ó k l(¸ Ë^Ì) * q . / h i j b g k lm n ¸ ¸¸¸¸® GH Q ð j F GH ® ` à ® 6 ·0 9 : & ' Æ $ % . / h i j ¹ k l ½ X k l( P ? K t m ` à Q R t (¸ 8 8 8
8 LLLL MMMM & '&&& ''' (((( )))) **** + +++ T UTTT UUU 7777 2222 NNNN 9999 3333 VVVV WWWW :::: ; R S "
; R S " ; R S " ; R S "
® GH a b W Û p X Y Õ 3 R U V M W $ # T U 1 U V U ! h i j - k l% 1 ± ³ M Ì t ? r & ` = 0 . / hN i j k l B P Q ð ? . / h i j ¹ m n r © # 3 cB Ò ô (¸ ¸ %%%% CCCC F GH GH | d hN Ù Ë t m GH ' ( À ) ì + S * + ·¸ ËÌ, - a b ·¸ ¸¸¸¸® N . / p k l i j n ø 0 S _ 1 û ã h ¸ Ç + n K t m R ` à cz 2 Ê þ é ê Ý Û ô ¿ 4 n ½ Í + G¸ H 3 4 a b (¸ ËÔÌ{ F @ A ·¸ ¸¸¸¸F GH { F @ A % q ¼ * á- * ï ó ô V ? 9 ãõ öËhttp://proj.moeaidb.gov.tw/kmppÌÅ l ÷ ø ø ß } ù ) * ï ú ? Æ w - y y z ¿ û á ü Z 9 : Í ãý _ þ é ê ï ð & w 9 : è : ) * B å N P h 5 p ë { . / c ¡ k 6 N Î Ï Í E _ 6 (¸ Ë^Ì- * ª « ·¸ ¸¸¸¸F GH ~ N » ë { å S î ï - * GH h h Ù Ë GH M ¸ S - - * r © D Ó s hB - * W u v ¦ F ® k F GH a b 7 ¸ w f - * N 9 : ¤ (¸ 8Æ ` q r 9 á : ; < = Ë÷ ø ø ÷ Ì> ? ± F @ R ? Í Æ ·A B (¸ ÷ : ¬ Ëá C C D Ì] ? ¸ R ? E F ß û ·G H (¸ ß: Ë÷ ø ø ø ÌU V · ` I J K L M ¸N O K P Q R J L S (¸ 8T` q r 9¸
1. Allerton, H.E. 1998. News you can use. Training & Development, 522, 9-10. 2. Ajzen, I. 1991. The Theory of Planned Behavior. Organizational Behavior and
Human Decision Processes , 502, 179 -212.
3. Bryant, S.E. 2003. The role of transformational and transactional leadership in creating, sharing and exploiting organizational knowledge. Journal of Leadership
& Organizational Studies, 94, 32.
4. Bukowitz R. W. and R. L. Williams 1999. The knowledge management fieldbook. Lodon: Prentice Hall.
5. Chauvel, D. and C. Despres 2002. A review of survey research in knowledge management 1997-2001. Journal of Knowledge Management, 63, 207-223. 6. Ching, C. L. and J. Yang 2000. Knowledge value chain. The Journal of
Management Development. 199/10, 783-794.
7. Conger, J.A. 1999. Charismatic and transformational leadership in
organizations: An insider's perspective on these developing streams of research.
Leadership Quarterly, 102,145 199/10, 783-794.
8. Davenport, T. H., D. W. D Long and M. C. Beers1998. Successful knowledge management projects. Sloan Management Review, 39 2, 43-58.
9. DeCarolis, D. M. and D. L. Deeds 1999. The impact of stocks and flows of
organizational knowledge on firm performance: An empirical investigation of the biotechnology industry. Strategic Management Journal, 2010, 953.
10. Greengard, S. 1998. How to make KM a reality? Workforce , 7710, 90-91. 11. Hansen, M. T. 1999. What’s Your Strategy for Managing Knowledge? Harvard
Business Review, 772, 106-116.
12. Heeseok, L., C. Byounggu 2003. Knowledge management enablers, processes, and organizational performance: An integrative view and empirical examination.
Journal of Management Information Systems. 201, 179.
13. Holsapple, C. W., K. D. Joshi 2000. An investigation of factors that influence the management of knowledge in organizations. Journal of Strategic Information Systems , 92, 235-261.
14. Knapp, E. M. 1998. Knowledge management. Business and Economic Review, 444, 3-4.
15. Mitri, M.2003. Applying tacit knowledge management techniques for performance assessment. Computers and Education, 412, 173-189 16. Nonaka, I. 1991. The Knowledge-Creating Company. Harvard Business
Review,696, 96-104.
17. Nonaka, I. and N. Konno 1998. The concept of “Ba”: Building a foundation for knowledge creation. California management review, 403, 40-54.
18. Ostro, N. 1997. The corporate brain. Chief Executive, 123, 58-62. 19. Venkatraman, N. and V. Ramanujam 1986. Measurement of Business,
Performance in Strategy Research: A comparison of approaches. Academy of Management Review, 114, 801- 815.
20. Wiig, K. M 1999. What future knowledge management users may expect?
Journal of Knowledge Management, 32, 155.
