第五章 結論與未來研究方向
5.2. 未來研究方向
在本文研究之過程中獲得上述成果。吾人認為尚有值得後續研究之處，分述如下：
1. 實驗工程批之加工等級較一般工程批之雙等級工單高，且實驗工程批途程不一定行經 每一工作站，為調整產品製程方法(recipe)，可能僅執行某一段落之途程，再者重加工 率(rework)與不良率高，若考量製造廠存在實驗工程批，與雙等級工單之產品，將更 貼近實務。
2. 本文並未考量機台換線時，所耗費之順序相依整備時間(sequence dependent sutup time)，以及產品之重加工率，若瓶頸工作站能在考量製程規格與垂直鎖定機台限制 下，多加考量上述之產品製程特性，亦更貼近實務。
參考文獻
【1】 http://www.iek.itri.org.tw/ 工研院產業經濟與趨勢研究中心
【2】 http://www.auo.com 友達光電。
【3】 Akcalt, E., K. Nemotom and R. Uzsoy, “Cycle-Time Improvement for Photolithography Process in Semiconductor Manufacturing,＂ IEEE Transaction on Semiconductor
Manufacturing, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp.48-56, 2001.
【4】 Andersen, P. and N. C. Petersen, “A Procedure for Ranking Efficiency Units in Data Envelopment Analysis,＂ Management Science, Vol. 39, pp. 1261-1264, 1993.
【5】 Atherton, L. F. and R. W. Atherton, Wafer Fabrication: Factory Performance and Analysis, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1995.
【6】 Arthur, M. D., A. Liu and P. P. Chen, “A Heuristic Load Balancing Scheduling Method for Dedicated Machine Constraint,＂ Advances in Applied Artificial Intelligence, Vol. 4031, pp.
750-759, 2006.
【7】 Backus, P., et al., “Factory Cycle-Time Prediction With a Data-Mining Approach,＂ IEEE Transactions on Semiconductor Manufacturing, Vol. 19, No. 2, 2006.
【8】 Banker, R. D., A. Charnes and W. W. Cooper, “Some models for estimating technical and scale inefficiencies in data envelopment analysis,” Management Science, Vol. 30, No. 9, pp.
1078-1092, 1984.
【9】 Blacksone, J. H., Capacity Management, South-Western Publishing CO., 1989.
【10】 Baykasoglu, A., M. Gocken, Z. D. Unutmaz, “New approaches to due date assignment in job shops,＂ European Journal of Operation Research, No. 187, pp. 31-45, 2008.
【11】 Chang, P. C., J. C. Hsieh and T. W. Liao, “A Cased-Based Reasoning Approach for Due-Date Assignment in a Wafer Fabrication Factory,＂ Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Vol. 2080, pp. 648-659, 2001.
【12】 Carbones, T. A., “Measuring efficiency of semiconductor manufacturing operations using Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA),” IEEE/SEMI Advanced Semiconductor Manufacturing
Conference, pp. 56-62, 2000.
【13】 Charnes, A. and W. W. Cooper, “Programming with linear fractional,” Naval Research
Logistics Quarterly, Vol. 9, 1962.
【14】 Charnes, A., W. W. Cooper and E. Rhodes, “Measuring the efficiency of decision making units,” European Journal of Operational Research, Vol. 2, pp. 429-444, 1978.
【15】 Charnes, A., W. W. Cooper, A. Lewin and L. Seiford,” Data Envelopment Analysis: theory, methodology and applications,” Massachusetts: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1997.
【16】 Chung, S. H. and H. W. Huang, “The Block-Based Cycle Time Estimation Algorithm for
Wafer Fabrication Factories,＂ International Journal of Industrial Engineering, Vol. 6, No. 4, pp. 307-316, 1999.
【17】 Chung, S. H. and H. W. Huang, “Loading Allocation Algorithm with Machine Capability Restriction for Wafer Fabrication Factories,＂ Journal of the Chinese Institute of Industrial Engineering, Vol. 18, No. 4,pp. 82-96, 2001
【18】 Chung, S. H., C. Y. Huang and A. H. I. Lee, “Capacity allocation model for photolithography workstation with the constraints of process window and machine dedication,＂ Production Planning & Control, Vol. 17, No. 7, pp. 678-688, 2006.
【19】 Chung, S. H., A. H. I. Lee, H. Y. Kang and C. W. Lai, “A DEA window analysis on the product family mix selection for a semiconductor fabricator,” Expert Systems With
Applications, Available online, 2007.
【20】 Connors, D. P., G. E. Feigin and D. D. Yao, “A Queueing Network Model for Semiconductor Manufacturing,＂ IEEE Transactions on Semiconductor Manufacturing, Vol.
9, No. 3, pp. 412-427, 1996.
【21】 Conway, R., W. Maxwell and L. W. Miller, Theory of Scheduling, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company Inc., 1967.
【22】 Enns, S. T., “A dynamic forecasting model for job shop flowing prediction and tardiness control,＂ International Journal of Production Research, Vol. 33, No. 5, pp. 1295-1312, 1995.
【23】 Etheshami, B., R. G. Petrakian and P. M. Shabe, “Trade-Offs in Cycle Time Management:
Hot Lots,＂ IEEE Transactions on Semiconductor Manufacturing, Vol. 5, No. 2, pp.101-106, 1992.
【24】 Farrell, M. J., “The Measurement of Productive Efficiency,” Journal of the Royal Statistical
Society, Series A, Vol. 120, No. 3, pp. 253-281, 1957.
【25】 Fronckowiak, D., A. Peilert and K. Nishinohara, “Using Discrete Event Simulation to Analyze the Impact of Job Priorities on Cycle Time in Semiconductor Manufacturing,＂
1996 IEEE/SEMI Advanced Semiconductor Manufacturing Conference, pp. 151-155, 1996.
【26】 Glassey, C. R. and S. Adiga, “Conceptual design of a software object library for simulation of semiconductor manufacturing systems,＂ Journal of Object-Oriented Programming, Vol.
2, No. 4, pp. 39-43, 1989.
【27】 Glynn, P. M. and Mary O’Dea, “How to get predictable throughput times in a multiple product environment,＂ Semiconductor Manufacturing Conference Proceedings, 1997 IEEE
International Symposium , pp. 27-30, 1997.
【28】 Hiller, F. S., and Lieberman, G. J., Introduction to Operations Research, Eighth Edition, McGraw-Hill Publishing Company, 2005.
【29】 Kleinrock, L., Queueing System, John Willey & Sons, 1975.
【30】 Kramer, Scott S., “Total Cycle Time Management by Operational Elements,＂ International
Semiconductor Manufacturing Science Symposium, pp. 17-20, 1989.
【31】 Lawrence, S. R., “Estimating flowtimes and setting due-dates in complex production systems,＂ IIE Transactions, pp. 657-668, 1995.
【32】 Li, S., T. Tang and D. W. Collins, “Minimum inventory variability schedule with applications in semiconductor fabrication,＂ IEEE Transactions on Semiconductor
Manufacturing, Vol. 9, No. 1, pp.145-149, 1996.
【33】 Little, J. D. C., “A proof for the queueing formula LW ,＂ Operations Research, Vol. 9, pp. 383-387, 1961.
【34】 Lu, Steve. C. H., D. Ramaswamy and P. R. Kumar, “Efficient Scheduling Policies to Reduce Mean and Variance of Cycle-Time in Semiconductor Manufacturing Plants,＂ IEEE
Transactions on Semiconductor Manufacturing, Vol. 7, No. 3, pp. 374-388, 1994.
【35】 Martin, D. P., “How the Low of Unanticipated Consequences can Nullify the Theory of Constraint: The Case for Balanced Capacity in a Semiconductor Manufacturing Line,＂
Semiconductor FABTECH, Seventh Edition, pp. 29-34, ICG publishing LTD, 1998.
【36】 Matsuyama, A. and R. W. Atherton, “Experience in Simulation Wafer Fabs in The USA and Japan,＂ 1990 Intel Semiconductor Manufacturing Science Symposium, 1990.
【37】 Miller, D. J., “Simulation of a Semiconductor Manufacturing Line,＂ Communication of the
ACM, Vol. 33, No. 10, pp. 98-108, 1990.
【38】 Narahari, Y. and L. M. Khan, “Modeling the Effect of Hot Lots in Semiconductor Manufacturing Systems,＂ IEEE Transactions on Semiconductor Manufacturing, Vol. 10, No.
1, pp. 185-188, 1997.
【39】 Raddon, A. and B. Grigsby, “Throughput Time Forecasting Model,＂ 1997 IEEE/SEMI
Advanced Semiconductor Manufacturing Conference, pp. 430-433, 1997.
【40】 Schragenheim , E. and H. W. Dettmer, “Manufacturing at Wrap Speed: optimizing supply chain financial performance,＂ Goal Systems International Inc., 2000.
【41】 Sexton, T., R. Silkman and A. Hogan, “Data Envelopment Analysis: Critique and extensions,＂ New Directions for Program Evaluation, Vol. 1986, Issue 32, pp. 73-105, 1986..
【42】 Sule, D. R., “Industrial scheduling,＂ PWS publishing company, pp124-126, 1997.
【43】 Srikanth, M. L. and M. M. Umble, “Synchronous management: profit-based manufacturing for the 21st Century,＂ The Spectrum Publishing Company, 1997.
【44】 Toktay, L. B. and R. Uzsoy, “A Capacity Allocation Problem with Integer Side
Constraints,＂ European Journal of Operational Research, Vol. 109, pp. 170-182, 1998.
【45】 Tone, K., “A slacks-based measure of efficiency in data envelopment analysis,” European
Journal of Operational Research, Vol. 130, pp 498–509, 2001.
【46】 Uzsoy, R., C. Y. Lee and Louis A. Martin-Vega, “A Review of Production Planning and Scheduling Models in the Semiconductor Industry Part I : System Characteristics, Performance Evaluation and Production Planning,＂ IIE Transactions, Vol. 24, No. 4, pp.
47-60, September, 1992.
【47】 Vig, M. M. and K. J. Dooley, “Dynamic Rules for Due-Date Assignment,＂ International
Journal of Production Research, Vol. 29, No. 7, pp. 1361-1377, 1991.
【48】 Wang, T. H., K. C. Lin and S. R. Huang, “Method of Dynamically Determining Cycle Time of a Working Stage,＂ 1997 IEEE/CPMT International Electronics Manufacturing
Technology Symposium, pp. 403-407, 1997.
【49】 Wang, Z., F. Q., and Q. Wu, “Scheduling Semiconductor Wafer Fabrication with Optimization of Multiple objectives,＂ International Conference on Automation Science and
Engineering, Shanghai, China, October 7-10, 2006.
【50】 Wein, L. M., “Scheduling semiconductor wafer fabrication,＂ IEEE Transactions on
Semiconductor Manufacturing, Vol. 1, No. 3, pp. 115-130, 1988.
【51】 Yu, C. Y., S. W. Chen and H. P. Huang, “Estimating of Waiting Time for Products in an IC Fab,＂ Proceeding of Joint Conference of the Fifth Int’l Conference on Automation
Technology and 1998 Int’l Conference of Production Research, A1-3, 1998.
【52】 范國基，「晶圓製造廠多等級工單最適比率決策模式之構建」，碩士論文，國立交通大學
工業工程與管理研究所，2005。
【53】 黎翠綾，「黃光區機台群組限制下的投料派工研究」，碩士論文，國立交通大學工業工程
與管理所，2000。
【54】 李幸娥，「晶圓製造廠非穩態環境下之生產排程規劃」，碩士論文，國立交通大學工業工
程與管理所，2002。
【55】 李孟儒，「晶圓製造廠考量製程規格能力與垂直鎖定機台限制下主生產排程修正機制」，
碩士論文，國立交通大學工業工程與管理研究所，2007。
【56】 劉得彥，「以 eM-Plant 軟體建構晶圓廠生產排程系統與模擬平台」，碩士論文，國立交 通大學工業工程與管理研究所，2001 。
【57】 林則孟，「系統模擬理論與應用」，滄海書局，民國 95 年 1 月。
【58】 梁宇帆，「薄膜電晶體陣列廠機台配置機制之構建」，碩士論文，國立交通大學工業工程
與管理研究所，2006。
【59】 賴志偉，「運用資料包絡分析法建構具非穩態需求情境下之產品組合訂定機制—以晶圓 廠為例」，碩士論文，國立交通大學工業工程與管理研究所，2006。
【60】 顧鴻壽，「光電液晶平面顯示器技術基礎及應用」，新文京開發出版有限公司，民國 93 年 3 月。
【61】 郭志榮，「晶圓製造廠考量製程步驟間搬運問題下之生產週期時間估算模式」，碩士論 文，國立交通大學工業工程與管理研究所，2002。
【62】 高強，黃旭男，Toshiyoki Sueyoshi，「管理績效評估—資料包絡分析法」，華泰文化事業 公司，民國 92 年 7 月。
【63】 柯文清，「晶圓製造廠多工單等級下生產規劃模式之構建」，碩士論文，國立交通大學工
業工程與管理研究所，2000。
【64】 黃宏文，「晶圓製造廠區段基礎式週期時間估算法」，博士論文，國立交通大學工業工程
與管理研究所，2003。
【65】 黃友錄，「考量綁機特性之派工法」，碩士論文，國立交通大學工業工程與管理研究所，
2003。
【66】 黃慧雲，「具垂直鎖定機台特性下之產能需求規劃—以晶圓廠黃光區為例」，碩士論文，
國立交通大學工業工程與管理所，2005。
【67】 張盛鴻，王志偉，嚴本立，李榮貴，「晶圓代工廠之派工模式—動態更新週期時間」，生
產排程理論與應用研討會論文集，pp. C65-C69，1999。
【68】 張百棧，朱震家，「晶圓廠之交期指定模式—應用類神經網路」，生產排程理論與應用研
討會論文集，pp. C47-C52，1999。
【69】 鄭照明，「晶圓製造廠交期指定模式之構建」，碩士論文，國立交通大學工業工程與管理
研究所，2006。
【70】 陳志強，「多工單等級下晶圓廠生產週期時間估算模式」，碩士論文，國立交通大學工業
工程與管理研究所，2000。
【71】 陳亞妮，「薄膜電晶體陣列廠生產規劃系統之構建」，碩士論文，國立交通大學工業工程
與管理研究所，2004。
【72】 陳連春，「什麼是液晶」，建興出版社，民國 89 年 6 月。
【73】 曾文萱，「整合 TFT-LCD 多階多世代多廠之生產策略」，碩士論文，國立交通大學工業 工程與管理研究所，2007。
【74】 蘇昱彰，「新興晶圓代工廠生產規劃與排程系統之構建」，碩士論文，國立交通大學工業
工程與管理研究所，1998。
【75】 游淑晴，「黃光區關鍵層機台限制機台指派投料與派工法則探討」，碩士論文，國立清華
大學工業工程研究所，2002。
【76】 楊桂峰，「流量平衡為導向的黃光區綁機派工法」，碩士論文，國立交通大學工業工程與
管理研究所，2002。
附錄
附表 A- 1 產品 A 之加工步驟與作業時間(有檢測) (單位：分)
步驟 工作站 平均加工時間 步驟 工作站 平均加工時間
1 W02 09.30 32 W13 12.30 2 W19 12.80 33 W12 13.25 3 W07 15.00 34 W20 09.00 4 W17 08.30 35 W22 11.20 5 W09 07.36 36 W04 14.43 6 W12 10.85 37 W07 18.00 7 W16 07.13 38 W17 08.60 8 W01 12.30 39 W09 07.36 9 W19 12.50 40 W12 13.60 10 W07 18.00 41 W20 09.07 11 W17 07.80 42 W22 10.80 12 W14 12.70 43 W07 18.00 13 W16 08.00 44 W11 12.30 14 W11 14.23 45 W12 12.80 15 W12 12.30 46 W22 11.60 16 W06 10.23 47 W23 11.30 17 W05 13.65 48 W05 11.65 18 W07 15.00 49 W07 15.00 19 W17 08.50 50 W13 12.70 20 W09 07.36 51 W12 11.50 21 W14 11.60 52 W14 13.50 22 W12 13.00 53 W08 15.00 23 W20 09.30 54 W21 14.16 24 W16 06.26 55 W11 16.10 25 W06 13.17 56 W12 13.50 26 W03 14.83 57 W14 14.20 27 W15 13.16 58 W07 18.00 28 W01 11.10 59 W13 12.50 29 W07 15.00 60 W22 11.04 30 W17 08.00 61 W23 11.20 31 W09 07.36
附表 A- 2 產品 A 之加工步驟與作業時間(未檢測) (單位：分)
步驟 工作站 平均加工時間 步驟 工作站 平均加工時間
1 W02 09.30 29 W12 13.25
2 W19 12.80 30 W20 09.00
3 W07 15.00 31 W22 11.20
4 W09 07.36 32 W04 14.43
5 W12 10.85 33 W07 18.00
6 W16 07.13 34 W09 07.36
7 W01 12.30 35 W12 13.60
8 W19 12.50 36 W20 09.07
9 W07 18.00 37 W22 10.80
10 W14 12.70 38 W07 18.00
11 W16 08.00 39 W11 12.30 12 W11 14.23 40 W12 12.80 13 W12 12.30 41 W22 11.60 14 W06 10.23 42 W23 11.30 15 W05 13.65 43 W05 11.65
16 W07 15.00 44 W07 15.00
17 W09 07.36 45 W13 12.70
18 W14 11.60 46 W12 11.50
19 W12 13.00 47 W14 13.50
20 W20 09.30 48 W08 15.00
21 W16 06.26 49 W21 14.16
22 W06 13.17 50 W11 16.10
23 W03 14.83 51 W12 13.50
24 W15 13.16 52 W14 14.20
25 W01 11.10 53 W07 18.00
26 W07 15.00 54 W13 12.50
27 W09 07.36 55 W22 11.04 28 W13 12.30 56 W23 11.20
附表 A- 3 產品 B 之加工步驟與作業時間(有檢測) (單位：分)
步驟 工作站 平均加工時間 步驟 工作站 平均加工時間
1 W02 09.30 30 W06 11.70 2 W19 12.73 31 W07 17.23 3 W07 18.00 32 W17 08.00 4 W17 08.30 33 W09 07.00 5 W09 07.30 34 W13 12.50 6 W12 10.85 35 W12 12.75 7 W16 07.00 36 W04 14.40 8 W01 11.70 37 W07 18.37 9 W19 12.55 38 W17 09.20 10 W10 12.00 39 W09 07.25 11 W07 18.37 40 W12 13.50 12 W17 07.60 41 W20 12.00 13 W11 14.30 42 W22 11.20 14 W12 12.30 43 W23 12.54 15 W16 07.22 44 W08 16.50 16 W07 18.00 45 W17 08.30 17 W17 09.00 46 W21 14.16 18 W14 13.00 47 W11 14.00 19 W16 07.10 48 W12 13.80 20 W11 14.00 49 W20 09.03 21 W12 13.00 50 W05 12.00 22 W05 13.30 51 W06 11.70 23 W07 16.50 52 W07 18.37 24 W17 07.80 53 W17 07.72 25 W11 14.50 54 W13 12.50 26 W14 13.00 55 W20 09.03 27 W12 12.00 56 W22 11.00 28 W03 14.80 57 W23 10.00 29 W15 13.16
附表 A- 4 產品 B 之加工步驟與作業時間(未檢測) (單位：分)
步驟 工作站 平均加工時間 步驟 工作站 平均加工時間
1 W02 09.30 26 W06 11.70
2 W19 12.73 27 W07 17.23 3 W07 18.00 28 W09 07.00 4 W09 07.30 29 W13 12.50 5 W12 10.85 30 W12 12.75 6 W16 07.00 31 W04 14.40 7 W01 11.70 32 W07 18.37 8 W19 12.55 33 W09 07.25 9 W10 12.00 34 W12 13.50 10 W07 18.37 35 W20 12.00 11 W11 14.30 36 W22 11.20 12 W12 12.30 37 W23 12.54 13 W16 07.22 38 W08 16.50 14 W07 18.00 39 W21 14.16
15 W14 13.00 40 W11 14.00
16 W16 07.10 41 W12 13.80 17 W11 14.00 42 W20 09.03 18 W12 13.00 43 W05 12.00
19 W05 13.30 44 W06 11.70
20 W07 16.50 45 W07 18.37 21 W11 14.50 46 W13 07.72 22 W14 13.00 47 W20 12.50 23 W12 12.00 48 W22 09.03
24 W03 14.80 49 W23 11.00
25 W15 13.16
附表 A- 5 產品 C 之加工步驟與作業時間(有檢測) (單位：分)
附表 B- 1 各工作站相關資訊
工作站編號 W01 W02 W03 W04 W05 W06 W07 W08
機台數 2 1 3 2 2 2 7 3
MTBF (hr) 1400 1400 1400 500 250 300 24 25 MTTR (hr) 5.5 5.5 5.5 8 4 1.67 1.5 1.67 MTBPM(hr) 2160 2160 2160 4320 130 168 163 168
MTPM(hr) 4 4 4 72 2 8 3 8
區域 TF TF TF TF TF TF Photo Photo 工作站編號 W09 W10 W11 W12 W13 W14 W15 W16
機台數 3 1 3 5 3 3 1 2
MTBF (hr) 70 1400 400 500 300 1400 200 450 MTTR (hr) 5 5.5 8 8 3 5.5 4 6
MTBPM(hr) 168 2160 710 4320 717 2160 716 2160
MTPM(hr) 8 4 10 72 3 4 4 3
區域 Etch TF Etch Etch Etch Etch TF Etch 工作站編號 W17 W18 W19 W20 W21 W22 W23
機台數 4 1 3 3 4 2 2
MTBF (hr) 1000 1400 500 1000 200 1400 1400 MTTR (hr) 2 5.5 4 2 4 5.5 5.5 MTBPM(hr) 1000 2160 168 1000 120 2160 2160
MTPM(hr) 0.3 4 0.5 0.3 6 4 4 區域 Photo Test TF Etch Etch Test Test
附表 C- 1 符合工作站利用率介於 0.895-0.905 之產品組合/等級比例
編號 (AN-T,AN-NT,AH-T,BN-T,BN-NT,BH-T,CN-T,CN-NT,CH-T) 1 (0.04,0.76,0,0.005,0.095,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005)
2 (0.08,0.72,0,0.01,0.09,0,0.0095,0.0855,0.005) 3 (0.04,0.76,0,0.005,0.095,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01) 4 (0.04,0.76,0,0.005,0.095,0,0.00425,0.08075,0.015) 5 (0.04,0.76,0,0.005,0.095,0,0.004,0.076,0.02) 6 (0.04,0.76,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.005,0.095,0) 7 (0.08,0.72,0,0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.01,0.09,0)
8 (0.04,0.76,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 9 (0.04,0.76,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.0045,0.0855,0.01) 10 (0.04,0.76,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.00425,0.08075,0.015) 11 (0.04,0.76,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.004,0.076,0.02) 12 (0.04,0.76,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.005,0.095,0) 13 (0.04,0.76,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 14 (0.04,0.76,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.0045,0.0855,0.01) 15 (0.04,0.76,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.00425,0.08075,0.015) 16 (0.04,0.76,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.004,0.076,0.02) 17 (0.04,0.76,0,0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.005,0.095,0) 18 (0.04,0.76,0,0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 19 (0.04,0.76,0,0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.0045,0.0855,0.01) 20 (0.04,0.76,0,0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.00425,0.08075,0.015) 21 (0.04,0.76,0,0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.004,0.076,0.02) 22 (0.04,0.76,0,0.004,0.076,0.02,0.005,0.095,0) 23 (0.04,0.76,0,0.004,0.076,0.02,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 24 (0.04,0.76,0,0.004,0.076,0.02,0.0045,0.0855,0.01) 25 (0.04,0.76,0,0.004,0.076,0.02,0.00425,0.08075,0.015) 26 (0.04,0.76,0,0.004,0.076,0.02,0.004,0.076,0.02) 27 (0.038,0.722,0.04,0.005,0.095,0,0.005,0.095,0) 28 (0.038,0.722,0.04,0.005,0.095,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 29 (0.038,0.722,0.04,0.005,0.095,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01) 30 (0.038,0.722,0.04,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.005,0.095,0) 31 (0.038,0.722,0.04,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 32 (0.038,0.722,0.04,0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.005,0.095,0) 33 (0.005,0.095,0,0.04,0.76,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 34 (0.005,0.095,0,0.04,0.76,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.89) 35 (0.005,0.095,0,0.04,0.76,0,0.00425,0.08075,0.015) 36 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.04,0.76,0,0.005,0.095,0) 37 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.04,0.76,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 38 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.04,0.76,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01) 39 (0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.04,0.76,0,0.005,0.095,0) 40 (0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.04,0.76,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 41 (0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.04,0.76,0,0.005,0.095,0)
編號 (AN-T,AN-NT,AH-T,BN-T,BN-NT,BH-T,CN-T,CN-NT,CH-T) 42 (0.01,0.19,0,0.035,0.665,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005)
43 (0.01,0.19,0,0.035,0.665,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01) 44 (0.01,0.19,0,0.035,0.665,0,0.00425,0.08075,0.015) 45 (0.01,0.19,0,0.035,0.665,0,0.004,0.076,0.02) 46 (0.0095,0.1805,0.01,0.035,0.665,0,0.005,0.095,0) 47 (0.0095,0.1805,0.01,0.035,0.665,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 48 (0.0095,0.1805,0.01,0.035,0.665,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01) 49 (0.009,0.171,0.02,0.035,0.665,0,0.005,0.095,0) 50 (0.01,0.19,0,0.035,0.665,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 51 (0.01,0.19,0,0.035,0.665,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01) 52 (0.01,0.19,0,0.035,0.665,0,0.00425,0.08075,0.015) 53 (0.01,0.19,0,0.035,0.665,0,0.004,0.076,0.02) 54 (0.0095,0.1805,0.01,0.035,0.665,0,0.005,0.095,0) 55 (0.0095,0.1805,0.01,0.035,0.665,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 56 (0.0095,0.1805,0.01,0.035,0.665,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01) 57 (0.009,0.171,0.02,0.035,0.665,0,0.005,0.095,0) 58 (0.005,0.095,0,0.04,0.76,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 59 (0.005,0.095,0,0.04,0.76,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01) 60 (0.005,0.095,0,0.04,0.76,0,0.00425,0.08075,0.015) 61 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.04,0.76,0,0.005,0.095,0) 62 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.04,0.76,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 63 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.04,0.76,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01) 64 (0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.04,0.76,0,0.005,0.095,0) 65 (0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.04,0.76,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005) 66 (0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.04,0.76,0,0.005,0.095,0) 67 (0.01,0.19,0,0.03,0.57,0,0.0095,0.1805,0.01) 68 (0.01,0.19,0,0.03,0.57,0,0.009,0.171,0.02) 69 (0.01,0.19,0,0.03,0.57,0,0.0085,0.1615,0.03) 70 (0.01,0.19,0,0.0285,0.5415,0.03,0.01,0.19,0) 71 (0.0095,0.1805,0.01,0.03,0.57,0,0.01,0.19,0) 72 (0.0095,0.1805,0.01,0.03,0.57,0,0.0095,0.1805,0.01) 73 (0.0095,0.1805,0.01,0.03,0.57,0,0.009,0.171,0.02) 74 (0.009,0.171,0.02,0.03,0.57,0,0.01,0.19,0) 75 (0.009,0.171,0.02,0.03,0.57,0,0.0095,0.1805,0.01) 76 (0.0085,0.1615,0.03,0.03,0.57,0,0.01,0.19,0) 77 (0.015,0.285,0,0.02,0.38,0,0.01425,0.27075,0.015) 78 (0.015,0.285,0,0.02,0.38,0,0.0135,0.2565,0.03) 79 (0.015,0.285,0,0.019,0.361,0.02,0.015,0.285,0) 80 (0.015,0.285,0,0.019,0.361,0.02,0.01425,0.27075,0.015) 81 (0.015,0.285,0,0.018,0.342,0.04,0.015,0.285,0) 82 (0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.02,0.38,0,0.015,0.285,0)
編號 (AN-T,AN-NT,AH-T,BN-T,BN-NT,BH-T,CN-T,CN-NT,CH-T) 83 (0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.02,0.38,0,0.01425,0.27075,0.015)
84 (0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.019,0.361,0.02,0.015,0.285,0) 85 (0.0135,0.2565,0.03,0.02,0.38,0,0.015,0.285,0) 86 (0.01,0.19,0,0.025,0.475,0,0.01425,0.27075,0.015) 87 (0.01,0.19,0,0.025,0.475,0,0.0135,0.2565,0.03) 88 (0.01,0.19,0,0.02375,0.45125,0.025,0.015,0.285,0) 89 (0.0095,0.1805,0.01,0.025,0.475,0,0.015,0.285,0) 90 (0.0095,0.1805,0.01,0.025,0.475,0,0.01425,0.27075,0.015) 91 (0.0095,0.1805,0.01,0.02375,0.45125,0.025,0.015,0.285,0) 92 (0.009,0.171,0.02,0.025,0.475,0,0.015,0.285,0) 93 (0.009,0.171,0.02,0.025,0.475,0,0.01425,0.27075,0.015) 94 (0.0085,0.1615,0.03,0.025,0.475,0,0.015,0.285,0) 95 (0.015,0.285,0,0.015,0.285,0,0.019,0.361,0.02) 96 (0.015,0.285,0,0.015,0.285,0,0.018,0.342,0.04) 97 (0.015,0.285,0,0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.02,0.38,0) 98 (0.015,0.285,0,0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.019,0.361,0.02) 99 (0.015,0.285,0,0.0135,0.2565,0.03,0.02,0.38,0) 100 (0.015,0.285,0,0.01275,0.24225,0.045,0.02,0.38,0) 101 (0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.015,0.285,0,0.02,0.38,0) 102 (0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.015,0.285,0,0.019,0.361,0.02) 103 (0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.02,0.38,0) 104 (0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.0135,0.2565,0.03,0.02,0.38,0) 105 (0.0135,0.2565,0.03,0.015,0.285,0,0.02,0.38,0) 106 (0.0135,0.2565,0.03,0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.02,0.38,0) 107 (0.01275,0.24225,0.045,0.015,0.285,0,0.02,0.38,0) 108 (0.02,0.38,0,0.005,0.095,0,0.02375,0.45125,0.025) 109 (0.04,0.36,0,0.01,0.09,0,0.0475,0.4275,0.025) 110 (0.02,0.38,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.025,0.475,0) 111 (0.04,0.36,0,0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.05,0.45,0)
112 (0.02,0.38,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.02375,0.45125,0.025) 113 (0.04,0.36,0,0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.0475,0.4275,0.025) 114 (0.02,0.38,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.025,0.475,0) 115 (0.04,0.36,0,0.009,0.081,0.01,0.05,0.45,0)
116 (0.02,0.38,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.02375,0.45125,0.025) 117 (0.02,0.38,0,0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.025,0.475,0) 118 (0.04,0.36,0,0.0085,0.0765,0.015,0.05,0.45,0)
119 (0.02,0.38,0,0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.02375,0.45125,0.025) 120 (0.02,0.38,0,0.004,0.076,0.02,0.025,0.475,0)
121 (0.04,0.36,0,0.008,0.072,0.02,0.05,0.45,0) 122 (0.02,0.38,0,0.004,0.076,0.02,0.02375,0.45125,0.025) 123 (0.019,0.361,0.02,0.005,0.095,0,0.025,0.475,0)
編號 (AN-T,AN-NT,AH-T,BN-T,BN-NT,BH-T,CN-T,CN-NT,CH-T) 124 (0.038,0.342,0.02,0.01,0.09,0,0.05,0.45,0)
125 (0.019,0.361,0.02,0.005,0.095,0,0.02375,0.45125,0.025) 126 (0.019,0.361,0.02,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.025,0.475,0) 127 (0.038,0.342,0.02,0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.05,0.45,0) 128 (0.019,0.361,0.02,0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.025,0.475,0) 129 (0.038,0.342,0.02,0.009,0.081,0.01,0.05,0.45,0) 130 (0.019,0.361,0.02,0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.025,0.475,0) 131 (0.038,0.342,0.02,0.0085,0.0765,0.015,0.05,0.45,0) 132 (0.019,0.361,0.02,0.004,0.076,0.02,0.025,0.475,0) 133 (0.018,0.342,0.04,0.005,0.095,0,0.025,0.475,0) 134 (0.018,0.342,0.04,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.025,0.475,0) 135 (0.005,0.095,0,0.015,0.285,0,0.0285,0.5415,0.03) 136 (0.005,0.095,0,0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.03,0.57,0) 137 (0.01,0.09,0,0.0285,0.2565,0.015,0.06,0.54,0) 138 (0.005,0.095,0,0.0135,0.2565,0.03,0.03,0.57,0) 139 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.015,0.285,0,0.03,0.57,0) 140 (0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.03,0.27,0,0.06,0.54,0) 141 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.015,0.285,0,0.0285,0.5415,0.03) 142 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.03,0.57,0) 143 (0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.0285,0.2565,0.015,0.06,0.54,0) 144 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.0135,0.2565,0.03,0.03,0.57,0) 145 (0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.015,0.285,0,0.03,0.57,0) 146 (0.009,0.081,0.01,0.03,0.27,0,0.06,0.54,0) 147 (0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.015,0.285,0,0.0285,0.5415,0.03) 148 (0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.03,0.57,0) 149 (0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.0135,0.2565,0.03,0.03,0.57,0) 150 (0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.015,0.285,0,0.03,0.57,0) 151 (0.0085,0.0765,0.015,0.03,0.27,0,0.06,0.54,0)
152 (0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.03,0.57,0) 153 (0.004,0.076,0.02,0.015,0.285,0,0.03,0.57,0)
154 (0.004,0.076,0.02,0.01425,0.27075,0.015,0.03,0.57,0) 155 (0.005,0.095,0,0.005,0.095,0,0.038,0.722,0.04) 156 (0.01,0.09,0,0.01,0.09,0,0.076,0.684,0.04) 157 (0.005,0.095,0,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.04,0.76,0) 158 (0.01,0.09,0,0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.08,0.72,0) 159 (0.005,0.095,0,0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.04,0.76,0) 160 (0.01,0.09,0,0.009,0.081,0.01,0.08,0.72,0) 161 (0.005,0.095,0,0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.04,0.76,0) 162 (0.01,0.09,0,0.0085,0.0765,0.015,0.08,0.72,0) 163 (0.005,0.095,0,0.004,0.076,0.02,0.04,0.76,0) 164 (0.01,0.09,0,0.008,0.072,0.02,0.08,0.72,0)
編號 (AN-T,AN-NT,AH-T,BN-T,BN-NT,BH-T,CN-T,CN-NT,CH-T) 165 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.005,0.095,0,0.04,0.76,0)
166 (0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.01,0.09,0,0.08,0.72,0)
167 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.04,0.76,0) 168 (0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.08,0.72,0) 169 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.04,0.76,0) 170 (0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.009,0.081,0.01,0.08,0.72,0) 171 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.04,0.76,0) 172 (0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.0085,0.0765,0.015,0.08,0.72,0) 173 (0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.004,0.076,0.02,0.04,0.76,0) 174 (0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.008,0.072,0.02,0.08,0.72,0) 175 (0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.005,0.095,0,0.04,0.76,0) 176 (0.009,0.081,0.01,0.01,0.09,0,0.08,0.72,0)
177 (0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.04,0.76,0) 178 (0.009,0.081,0.01,0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.08,0.72,0) 179 (0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.04,0.76,0) 180 (0.009,0.081,0.01,0.009,0.081,0.01,0.08,0.72,0) 181 (0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.04,0.76,0) 182 (0.009,0.081,0.01,0.0085,0.0765,0.015,0.08,0.72,0) 183 (0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.004,0.076,0.02,0.04,0.76,0) 184 (0.009,0.081,0.01,0.008,0.072,0.02,0.08,0.72,0) 185 (0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.005,0.095,0,0.04,0.76,0) 186 (0.0085,0.0765,0.015,0.01,0.09,0,0.08,0.72,0)
187 (0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.04,0.76,0) 188 (0.0085,0.0765,0.015,0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.08,0.72,0) 189 (0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.04,0.76,0) 190 (0.0085,0.0765,0.015,0.009,0.081,0.01,0.08,0.72,0) 191 (0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.04,0.76,0) 192 (0.0085,0.0765,0.015,0.0085,0.0765,0.015,0.08,0.72,0) 193 (0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.004,0.076,0.02,0.04,0.76,0) 194 (0.0085,0.0765,0.015,0.008,0.072,0.02,0.08,0.72,0) 195 (0.004,0.076,0.02,0.005,0.095,0,0.04,0.76,0) 196 (0.008,0.072,0.02,0.01,0.09,0,0.08,0.72,0) 197 (0.004,0.076,0.02,0.00475,0.09025,0.005,0.04,0.76,0) 198 (0.008,0.072,0.02,0.0095,0.0855,0.005,0.08,0.72,0) 199 (0.004,0.076,0.02,0.0045,0.0855,0.01,0.04,0.76,0) 200 (0.008,0.072,0.02,0.009,0.081,0.01,0.08,0.72,0) 201 (0.004,0.076,0.02,0.00425,0.08075,0.015,0.04,0.76,0) 202 (0.008,0.072,0.02,0.0085,0.0765,0.015,0.08,0.72,0) 203 (0.004,0.076,0.02,0.004,0.076,0.02,0.04,0.76,0) 204 (0.008,0.072,0.02,0.008,0.072,0.02,0.08,0.72,0)