從失能老人社區照顧的需求初探服務網絡之建立
全文
(2) 48. 1M~-Il\. «~ft~A~a •• ~.*~. •••••. ilA1t)~ id":f:li""_. ~~A. Community Care Needs of the Disabled. Elderly and the Establishment of. Service Network. EE1n.~f-l.iX!¥Jji;jJ7. 49. ~~ ijl., .p. *'. , ~A!¥J.frJ~fg~~ , J!{t~$:PJtIg3&frJ!¥J~. ~,~~~m~®~WttfrJo~~AU~~~~~.~ffmT*'illfu~~ 9"ttf§lJ!¥J~A. '. aPf.iX~ftB 'lji;1::mmlbJ:'ilW~~ilftJ!AlhhWJ!¥JA. 0. ~lltL. 9t- ' ~A'i1iL~"'lttEm!¥Jttf§llfutt-~A*r~r.u ;flUfliH~ , ~A~:Pi',~3§.=fI!¥J'lt11m ~'tt'l1m91- ' ~AJtt'Jflfru$~m!¥JPJij~'l1furN~ (~~ , MJ l'/i1llJ ' 1984) ft~W3~~~~~~ , ~AIHii1:llE~~~ffllEfu'ilW~~W3!¥J~ Iii· ;fN.1J.f::EW:I:S) (1995) ~Lf2iH' t1.:tt!HI1i~A.*liE~1j?¥ft1.9~4.3% 0. 0. 0. Mei-O Hsieh. L""~· EE1n~m!¥Jl!ltl¥f;lJ[JJ:~~ij'~5filIl!¥JEl~~ft ,ltf~~A~iilj1i].~~ 1::mElJ!l!!¥Jij~::IJ. Abstract This paper presents some research results of survey of health care need and welfare service need among the disabled elderly in Taipei. The establishment of community care network is also suggested. On the one hand, the establishment of community care network allows the disabled elderly to live independently without immature institutionalization. On the other hand, it relieves care burden of families and allows the partnership of the public sector and the private sector. The research result shows that the disabled elderly are widely distributed. However, those who are 75 and older designate the most among all subjects, representing 61.8%. Aging, and the following chronic diseases, is one of the most important factor contributing disability among the elderly. There is 63% of the disabled elderly who have at least three kinds of chronic diseases, representing 2/3 of the subjects. Although the disabled elderly may receive social support mentally, materially, and informationally, they receive least support of information and experience. The information support may be provided by related social welfare agencies. Therefore, before providing necessary services, the information network of welfare services must first be constructed. This is also the easiest part of all provision. The result also shows that demographic characteristics, health status and health service utilization, and social interactions relate to community care needs. In order to make the relationship more explicitly, multiple regression is employed. Finally, a case management model and a blueprint of community care network are presented.. ' *1lffi5§tt1~tm~ij~~A¥:I~=~~1iBA(l5.~ , ~ ' 1994) , tt?¥r.u~1O.8% ' tt~1lIJ65~J..:,U-.~ij~~A!¥Jfi5nI2.5% ~,~ (phillipson & Walker, 1986) , ,gtt~IlIJ~A1::mifj;:~:5rJlffl.l~~!¥J4.6%r.uteltf~ (ttt:r&1lf.Rijljii(B'Iji;1::mJ;iJtI~~ij~ElJ!l!1lf ' f!PADL!¥J1f!Sfi5 ' :Mz*li:!j~fmWJ11 Bm1::mJ;iJij~(IADL )!¥J1f!Sfi5) ~1I. 0. ft~~·3§.~~-~B'Iji;1::m~n'ilW.lhhWJ!¥J~A~H~~~. 8.1O/o(Wiener et aL, 1990) .;g=li:!jlf B m1:: m~ij~w.WJ'11 B'Iji; 4: mJ;iJfj~~m~ liI!¥Jf!U~20% !¥J~ijg~A EE1n~ij~~A~:Pfl ~1lJ}]~~..t.!¥J~if ' ~'ilW J!.1liJ:LijEl~ , ~lltft.~~UI!¥J7t~fummte~l!ltl 0. 0. t).a~tm®~ ';fN.tft1~tmil?x:f&. (1996). 1I~4:.~:!J~8etll.ll. JtJE. ~tm.~~.PJTfF!¥J~~m7f:: §W1JE~tm.~z~Jt~~~~APJTtIH~!¥J~ I*wJ&.R~4033*' ;g=v)'~.~fIl$F~!¥JijEl~m:#tl;{:Unt?¥H.' fJJ~-' .~=f~::g~ij~~A~J5ftJfrr~'&~fI ~~. 0. .,f:. ® it ' 1~H!l~~.!¥J£JffJJr'i'fH~ $'5.t~ijg~A'6J1H~.l:'I1U~~.!¥Jl1llf~fuf§&,ffji (~1::W ' 1994) 0. 0. ~A~fIl ' ft-'f5Jmff~~~fifBJ!I!!¥J~~ftMtfr±llt~. , ~~l~~r:R*~:tt!!~!¥J ~®ili±.~~!¥J;lJ[J~ , 5Ii1Il~~*5.!¥J;f~{J"t (~::IJ ' 1990) ,V).,& ~1li~A!¥J.:t~A::IJ--m:tz:: ' ;1t9l-tegt;~!¥Jtt19l1m:!n (::EIi~ , 1995) ~~ *~ft~fIl~tIg~A(disabled elderly)!¥Jij~::IJ*I/IM~f~ · m'lji;~{J'~~® 0. *'. ::IJ~'@ Jt1n~ij~~A!¥J*~*~' ~;1t':tji;.~~.nrtI~~-~~:fl(m~ (Il1JWIG,J!I!) !¥J~~F ' ,gJt~A® j§j , aP~~~~!¥J~~ ~~liH~*5* 0. 0. ft~, ~1lIJ~A~tfiU~B7tLJ\+1i !¥Jtt?¥~W!efM~T:tz::~,:t C1jil?x:~ ±'H~. , 1994 ; ~~!!lX ' 1992). '*$7t~A ~~ifi;1t~Ilifj;:btt10{fiJffB;ffl-'§i'H:t.
(3) 50 lilt J:ll\. ~~.~A~. .... ~S~~. ••• M.~~~. gI,J ~JtiG :k '" ~±.. ,%: f£t~~~ffi'~?fi' Bra'~~' ~Utl:l~~W3i:$~~ -a:r?t5Jtlt't~mfi1j ,. ft§ c?fi'A~I¥JJfd:lill!fD*&¥ cp E§llt ' ~I5V:Jj~mtWwil~HifUl¥Jm*fr±lill! \l.ij,lt(home-based community care) ~mWJ~A ' ~5JIj~92.:~g~AI¥JHliU':ljJ rEJo. 0. 0. l3n5l'~;~~~~~(~~!t,1994) U"IfF4lJi~fI ' Jfd:l¥J!~,It~IHI1ji&Jfft't1~$ 0. ,. ~:~iii~. .. ~fi!.:i;~A. I! .. 0. I: ;. r". ~.~jt. 0. 0. ~ilIiI¥JWII~ m{,f{:m*~,ltn~l9!i~'iI-'l7'GIEI¥JMtifWmIDIJJ *~3i:1Jj:Jm Q. 0. f:£:t£*flll $-'lfrilil\l.ij,ltI¥J92.:tig~Amfj~. 0. ( -) :1r 1lf1 lilF''l ~ fi~ ::t A lt9 ,OJf it J~ iJL fii&~±~tJj! ( 1994) Mt~t92.:~g~A~,It:fi:rtl¥Jtt-Wtl : fI.:rt3i."!t(V , :Jj.fI•. 3i."lt• •)l¥Jtt-WUtE ]I"861f:1¥J3.96%:ttH~ I 9891f:1¥J1 1.75% ' ~ m*~,It~ljtE96.04%~~19891f:1¥J88.25% ' 19931f:@] 1.37% ' ;ltcpm*\l.ij,ltxm:?tm*A\l.ij,lt, miZ\l.ij,ltfDf1.~,It °,giG r#tt~1fu~I¥J92.:tig~Af'±:{E*fI ' ~mm*\l.ij,ltH~~. Elderly). 71~ '~'ltV!ttt1Wi. ~A~¥U1IHfl¥J:1:$~,It millM&lJi~1J;1.~~Mt¥l¥JjiVltJ '$Jtt{1j'il-'l*~. .::.. ' lEI ~"~Jt 1t 69 ~ ~t. o. 0. '. ' t't:n~$8b:i1f ' 1l;f;7r~:P*AI¥J\l.ij,lt~tI:9f. ' J1:-a:rtJ*iE~*~1E. 0. 0. 92.:ijg~AI¥JJEtl~m Bm~$JiJ~g~92.:~~WI¥J~A ;!;t±-'lI¥J!*E§~ :9f.~~1t. ~:.:t~g. '.-'l.mtl¥J.~A1J 'f~M&lJi~Ij~fi1il-~~~I~*$nal9!i~littIlJtJ~92.:~g. ;ffllWl-t laJ M~ ~Abt-A(Disabled. , j:Jt'tf~92.:tm~. 0. , ~-lnm '-lli~f~*Aft\l.ij,ltJ:tJL1iI¥J~. ,~;!;t~g~¥tli&H1W~rJlfl. (-). ~lltUliI~,It~-,*)1iJ3Z:iittI¥JHa~. 0. .zWr±lill!~,ltjli1jo. ~. 0. wim: \l.ij,lt~ III)J{¥z ' XIlJ tJ liI ?tm~F m*il'r:iliI ~,It(community-based . out-of home services)(MilIer, 1991) ,fDm*l¥Jid: liI~,It(home-based community care) , f~~mHll}~m*~,It m*~,ltX-a:rtJlill!?t~m*v:Jj , m*itl{J!!! ' ~*~mtj..y,,&*$n~~ (If~m ' 1993) m*v:Jjwm*~J!!!IlJM~m#l ItfiOOl¥JtbbWJ ; !l!i*~itl{,&*$ijal9!i~lJpJMmJfd:":fiOOl¥JmWJ WI -lJin~l9!i. 0. -. ' 1993). (.:::.) J6~I!U1i(home care). 0. 1\,. (ii!H~m. 0. 0. ~. .~. , sl:.([flJffl~rdHiSr' , *&¥ ' miZ ' 1;;JJiA~zjlijN,$5l5mjli1jl¥J**J5. A~~k&I¥JVitl{WJfd:"iilflJ~,It t(jf!l§~ • wim:\l.ij,ltIlJtJ~liftE~,It~~1¥J. §WII¥J~3i:' ff®jtfl~A~±~~,It~z~mt~)j(~m*~,It$)j(~. 1TlWftIDIJJ:1i (1IjfHffi:\~ , ~H~ , ~~~ , 1991 ; ~M~ , MflJ:iM1 ' 1990 ;.:f~ 1;;!! ' *~~ m~!IJ ' 1989) ff!1:~JYf~jtfl~M~itl{t~\tf.l¥Jn~ 19!i~filWftIDIJJ:1i(ll7C3S.tta ' 1988 ; ~jd~tta ' 1990 ; *51'1't:l ' 1990 ; ~i:!ftE, ~E51a)j , 1991 ; ~~!! '*film, 51H~BB' ~t51a)j , 1992; #1:13. ' *film '#I:~l.X 'Jia)j~ , ~~!! ' 1991 ; f*.5:2~ '~9IJ 'm3S.:£X 'Ji~~ , 1992 ; f*Q~ , 1989 ; 1Z3S.~ , 7R3S.J§ , ~fflfi¥J ' 1990 ; Jiix~ , 1992) ~~tPJl1jte§WIfl92.:ijg~AiliR:z~I£'~7M (8WJIW ' ~~Jl . 1994 ; f$j~ , 1994) ¥U@92.:~g~A~-M~MfII¥JA ? ;!;t~mtlfj\?5UlOfilJ? ;!;twilill!~ ,It$)j(tzOfilJ ? tzOfilJ~fifrim:\l.ij,lt ? ~ill&l~~MI¥J *~~I¥J Ell¥Jft~1f ' ~ MiJ~tmJfd:m:CP92.:~g~AI¥JVitl{\l.ij,ltWfrlilfJj~~~I¥J$)j( , iiffijiljH~92.:~g~A ~mJfd:m:~,ltI¥JM!'IlIWf$~ • -1riID.illlEl;92.:~g~ Ang1ij:lLffijff#MI¥J~$. ,*fm-- ,. t-"'ell 51. imm~U::l:~Al¥Jm~gtl1j~ffM&fj. : ;It-~. 0. of Daily Living,ADL) ; ~-fj~~WJtiBm~ $$i!Jzm~g(Instrumental Activity of Daily Living,IADL) WI~{gml¥JJ"Ji § ff : ~1!;: , 1*m ' ~tR ' tzoOOi ' 1lLf$. , */J\'f~Et~U 1!t~{gttll¥JlJi§ff : ~~1!;: , n~~ , J!!!M ' lWJ4o/J ' nm~ , fIfl~~*$ , i)ttRfD~m.XimI~ (Guralnik & Simonsick, 1993 : Kane & Kane, 1987) B',lj:5~$$i!Jzm~g(Activity. ~~!t ( 1994 )fl*iJ~tttt!:m:frilil~AI¥JIDIJJ:1i: 92.:tiE~Att-WUitI0.9%. 0. 2¥l\\Iiimffijftl ~ -WUtz03z::'li65-69~1¥J B m- ~$$IfJJiJ~g92.:fig$f1i. 0. 0. to%, J3t1~1.8%' {g75-79~*Jl~IJ7T~ ,?t5JIJ~IO.2%fD7.4% 80~tJl:~1j 0. • •20%fDI5.6%, wim:92.:fig~A*~,ltI¥J'IWID· ft~tiff3i:CP-lli-a:r-m~J! ~.JJ!1¥J173flL92.:~E~XCP , ff7 Az.A~,It , 3AB1'±~3i."ltcp{J' , 4A~ffl 11I:t£~.'tt ' IAs:nmJlfi\l.ij,lt , ;!;t~155A:I:~HB*AmiZ\l.ij,lt , ~FIE:rt\l.ij,lt. 0. 0. ( .::::..) rl.e ,~UJ{(communi~ care) Jfd:lill!~,It{t(~rq]I¥J~~~J:~~j~ffijft~}f:Lt~ff~rq] ;gfflHmmffV~n~~ 0. I¥JWd:liI\l.ij~Wjfd: .. n~~tbbWJI¥JJfd:lill!~,It. 0. ftV~4lJit£JXCP. , Ulil~~I¥JWJE. '. ..
(4) ~~BB. ~H. ' Ji£€15 ' ~~~ ( 1989) j:), iJ'~tll$1519:g65.j:)'J:::f3APJTfltllY-J lfllm::f3AjjJijJ~~IIfiltIY-J~~f~te::f3AjjJijJ~fj~::E~1gfl5rzg1:1lID : '11f~1&1tlJ ' M ~r,,'ml&1tlJ ' ~£1iTJfi5'l:l&1tlJ ' ~*~±1it~~1&1tlJ liff~f~te : ~f*fflr,,'~m ~~~~ ,~~§~~t1T ltt~~D~{,'l!I!jjJijJ~~::f3Am~lY-Jr,,'~ , ;!:tW::f3. ( 1987) ~~f~te ' iJ'~trIH3AJj{~{:±:{E~fflY-J2J69.6% ' ' Jj{~NltM~{E~nIU~IY-Jr:!:i3.8% °. {E~mU~IY-Jr:!:i61%. 0. ~~~. (1992) f;f103{lztpJm\::f3AIY-J~:M~~1:1Af9!fflZ5HJT ' ~~ 310/0(n=3 2)1Y-J tpJm\::f3 A1Wf9!ffl iEJ:twa~ , ;1tr:p 12llif9!ffl {tltlY-J @~ill!I!waii (11.7%) , FiiJIf,ff9!ffl~m3i:JHD{tlt@~ill!I!wail~lf4.80/0(n=5) , ifUMtlt 1Y-J@~ill!I!wa~~el~tJ.l;~~APfifiS1t ' ~~~ffl-t' 1:15tfJT~~~walli~f;fiE J:twalli ({Elttf~~m3i:!t!ijNIt@~wa'il) IY-JOlt ' ~~~m ~PZP:~J& A ' ::f3 AIY-J E3 m ~t!5lJJf!~WltEZ:waa~IY-J~WWlt ' ~~Wf;f iEAwaa89ft ffl ° ~ffl~~~lfIIHlmM5t~, ~PJ&AEZ:::f3AIY-JBm~t!5JiJfii~ifiiflY-J~ Wf;f!EJ:twallilY-Jf9!ffl. 0. A~.IIm{*Wl;J]. 0. (~)~'~A~~~~1;Jjta9~~~~. '. ~P}f9!ffl@~~IIiIY-J~~~.~,mllm89.m~~tQmf;f~~.. ~ -~*IDl ' ~~ifi~ : ftnWifff9!ffl@~~IIiIY-J::f3A ' ;1t:r;J]fii~• • IY-J~ 0. ~1~tt{:±:ftr:pltwaD~.(Intennediate Care Facilities ' ICFs)~*1~t1T (Anderson' Patten & Greenberg, 1980) , ~~ Z ' fi51t;fct~{'t~IIi11f.:f~1~tt. o. .~~.{twaa11fz~.~Dt~t1T. (1988) ~f;fiJ'r:p~P}fi'HI~II@~ • i1!fjl!]fm~~II~~~f;f@~ill!I! wa~lY-Jt~lt ° ~~~~@~f;f@~~l!I!~~89lJJfii~~7;f§1i1;IY-J~JE '{E:S-Iffii § r:p : ~tm r PJMUif~~IY-J~~11 J r iI±~WtW.PJf9!~A{,,3i: J r ff~~~~. 0. ImJi~. -~ffij~'f9!ffl@~~n~~a!ij~.~Dt'~~~Dt'll~~~'~. • ' ,t1ZU ' ~W~~*ftllm (Chapple, 1985; Coward & Dwyer, 1992; McAuley a. Arling, 1984; Wallace & Lew-Ting ,1992; Wallace & Lew-Ting, 1994). AIY-J11i~It~ J r ~9r~Jllf,frdlm:tH~.te J r i~9rUm3Z:te J ~~lf;f§1i1;~. 895t1& (45tj:),J: ' 5~~55t). {fi{E§fj!lteltfflJ:~U~T-)j{;lV~~~. 0. ~l&t.g~J1!~EI3~~{lfd!.te~3Z:N. 0. , Chapple(l985)tt~f9!m@~waDIY-J::f3A!ij-~{:tftf,±~fflY-J::f3 A ' ~~. °. J!ffl ~lf. ~89JJJfi~• •fDtl't1~W<f FiiJIf,ff9!ffl ~f.I@~waDn~~IY-J::f3 A ' ;tt:ft!!Um ' ili±~n~~j:)''&'*E1~:RIY-J?F!EJ:tn~~tQtt.~ ~ MCAuley Arling( 1984)1Willir,,'500{1l::f3Aj:), rlJII!]f;tt:f9!ffl'@~waalY-Jf.I~fDl&J!: ° ~~ 1ft§::. t!5t!5JJJlJJfifg~i!t!1Y-J ::f3A!ijf9!ffl ~f.I@~waDg~~ft~5ffi1Y-J 11m{* :J3ft 11m ill T1iif::f3 A~± Wi ~WlwaDg~~f9!ffl ~DtIY-J~lii3t r:p flii te : ill T1iif::f3A ~r,,'[1± ( 01tiil± ) 11f{r!;9.30/q.... ~ffl~.waDn~~89{r!;5.1 % ' f9!fflft 7.2% ' ;1tft!!@~~~n~~Jj§IY-J{r!;14.8% Bm1==-t!5ti5JJJ~fi~ B m1==- t!5t!5JJJlJJfii~~fi~(disability)lY-Jlt*f~~fDf9!ffl @~~DftD r=.30 & r=.27) {:t~::Xl&fD@~waDtQi¥ r=.28 1Y-J1Im{* !lt~J!:89~~~DtfDitU::XI&~*tQfD@~walliftlm{* {fiWlJtit.:f:;fiJ: _,....;-.+,-/;.. __ m ' " & Lew-Ting ,1992) 0. ( .::.) :IdlE. ~ A a9 1;Jjt f;f~~~~::f3AIt*IY-JJlflf~~~~~ll:: ' f<!rr{t~M~D ° ~~~fii~::f3AIY-J ~!M~{E::E~walli~89~f.U1:1lID(Ji~~~~ , 1988 ; ~~~ , i!i1:ii!ftt ' M51. rlJI ' 1991 ; ~~~ , l*lfm ' ~~BB ' M51 rlJI ' 1992 ; f*2~ , ~m ' fl;Ji IX ' , 1992 ; ~Ji~ , 7.kJii§ , ~fflti¥i ' 1990) °. Ii. --.If. 0. 0. {Eft~.~@~~.::E~waa~~f.UZ~~tpPJOOfiTm-@~ft::f3. AIY-JIt*'~~*$mfiS1t@~ill!I!f;f • • ~.UJ:Z~ft • •::f3A°ltt P} , ft.~-~~~±~::f3AIt*IY-J~~r:p{/.0PJII*~te-@ugm °. 0. 0. 0. 0. lijJr£lM~. , ~Il~' i!i1:i~W: (1994). j:),22{llU~.£~89@~ill!I!~A~. ~r:p, ~~59.l%IY-J~AM:H~65. ~Am~~l!I!r,,'~1gfl5: ~F{l!~t~2)(~. , , iX1t~Dt2)(~ , JHJlr2iJJJS1tflN ' ffi~ilUiR~ , ~~~{'F2)(~ , ~~i'iJ~im • • ' &:"~~'t1S1tm ifi~.i1!@lJJtt~ • •~ftJHI~fi~J:ft~* 89r,,'~, ffijft!ij~~IY-J~imliJJJJ:tQ5'l:;f§~I5. ' .i1!@r"'~~It~UilEZ:ffct 0. ~F*~~2)(~. 0. IA~tb:hWJ2)(~o. ~1it(Wallace &. Lew-Ting,1994) , Chapple(l985) ~waD~;1tn~3Z:~tt.9r :J3P} , i1£**E~1Y-J1IU!l:tzJ1ft~ tti9Uf9!ffllEAIY-J@~waD(Coward & Dwyer,1992) {~~-fJilY-J 0. 0. · ~ti ' '11ZUfD~W~'::::J]i~*jj*4tQi£:1==-1if::fi~ltlY-J;f§1Im Wallace!~ 0.
(5) ~4. R~R~A#. llIB::*,. •• ~~S* •••• M.~~~. , ~:fiilTtf~ftmJ@*!l.e.u~mra~ , 75~J;J.J: ~A:fJ£mHfn~tt65-74~~A~tfj~:p.p:jijf15 Coward & Dwyer (l992)~Ufliitfj 1£~~I¥J~ACP , !JB(p{ttiUfr3fMI¥JWJU ' 1il17X:1f.-=f:9:WJUl¥Jtt!JB(~ ffff.§.1£ ~~I¥J)i;:fjg~ACP , fu:fitt!JB(~l¥JlEAl&U~m$ 11JJU1nm ' :9:;li~Aft m11f7£1';g::!J311~A~~.(Wallace &Lew-Ting ,1992) , ~ffff ' f.N.~1iJ1982 1f.~!ia~:MWJUl!Iltf(National Long-Tenn Care Survey' NL TCS)I¥J*ft~+jJ-:fJT 1'lUmf~ : 1'fHHf:ffl:iJ1f.~fDl1I~7£ ':9:11tt:!J3;I1:~~~~I7X:1f.-=f:9:fDlEAij[~ r§ (fi.) I¥Jl&U (Coward & Dwyer,1992~ IillitilTJMiJJUW}@*WJUft. II ~lti~ J::. ~:f1.1t~~. Lew-tingl¥:JliJf~CPfliitfj1f.~~~~. jj. 1I-:liJf~~fl. 0. ~.~AI¥J~~:. 0. 0. 0. ml¥J~~M1'~~o~~~NhOO,~m~~~N~.§.n~~~!JB(~I¥J~A. ~~!JB(~:fIMI¥J}@*l&Unh!~' ~fD-~ffi:Ml¥JhrEJ1'-:fI' fii!H~3!;-:!V~. M (McAuley &Arling, 1984). 0. 1£~~hOO. • :fi.:JiffijWJl¥JillTWlf~A~m. nh!f9Hi~:~.:JiffijWJ~I¥J=ffi ' mf~*~~)f;!\7£~--OOit!~lsl~ fffffft~-Ill&!i 0. 'R~a~I¥J~A.~m}@*l&u.r§I¥J~m~ill~&~.. Ting,1994) , J'iJT J;J. ailJ 1111~~!H~ nh!~ I¥J r~ iii . & {fU ~ MiGii ailJ ~I¥J A (near-poor)tt~.:iji. £*~R(11JjU ~. '. 1f.~. ,. l~n~AliE • •. I¥J.*:. ~.. , l1Im#;I\l£ ' J@tt~~ ,. ~~)f;!\l£). }@*~~fI*. JlrI'1~m:)f;!\iJ?JM.:lftnh!~. J@*~~~*. l¥J~m (i:Q;f15. : 'lim#;I\7£ ' B. m~mmltJ&.WJ;11: B ~ mmltJJiJfi~. r~~. ~mtbbWJfI*. , f1:~ , ~~ ,. , 'f.Vltj~l2:). *~~~* -lI>. *~~~Wn.R~. .~WA~~*. 0. ~JtlJJ@*WJ.nh!~~ml¥JjZ;;j~z-m~f~WJ.I¥JI7X:* ffH'liJf~ Q. ftmli~JJl.l£. .. l&Ul¥JfJf! . :*:f-:I~3i:llfJf!I¥J~jJ- Z - (Kane &Kane, 1987) 1'~ . *l&UrDt£~ ilT J;J.~f~~I'1IH'WJUI¥J. m . ff!JfJJ~m :fi27%1¥J nh!~~1'~~ I¥J W!~Z ' PI2:)i;:i~)f;!\7£Mitz~A.~m~~I¥JJ@*l&.~~ kSllit ' J@*WJuH~n&r§I¥J~~;I1:WA;l1:ft*~ , ~H7\:;fft&iJ~I7X:*l¥JftJN*~ 0. 0. .=. " ')ftHlt~,. Q. *liJf~:fI*~m~~~:fIffff~·7:tm=OO*~:. 0. l.lE1£~~U~l&UI¥J)i;:fjg~A : U.mJ~11f;fZB1W,fIfl (CP~~!iafJA:",. ~., ~'L'£~.' f'j}1f.~~nh!~cpIL". ~,. ZJf j(:~ i!. Q. Q. jJ-JJUmftl; : 40A ' 24).. , 30A ' 29A. , 19J5!Wr..~WijJjft (!W~7:tJJU W)i;:ij~~A ' ±~l&.~!w~) '&~!w (.flr..~~f*¥f)*hA) '1£lit1J: mtfj)i;:fj~~AZl!Ijft~* · M.litffff~flnh!~~~ - " bJt~~l4~bJt~irl~t. 0. ~fl*I2:~123A. '. m~;f§!W~W~. 1£~I.~!W~~A':fi~~~~ffi· 2.-JI<lffr±m!I¥J)i;:fig~A. Q. 3i: '. 1.1t~. : ~121TiI&m!CP{tthfll.W~AI2:El~~i~!D&:*:. , m~ , :*:151 ' ~tf5J:1iWl'. (liJf~~~EI3=fll.liJf~WJ~{tt.*liJf~. PJTi!i~+Z)i;:fi~~AfrIj~:!I:~3!;1T-~-l¥JfJJ:!Viili~) '1II.~Jf)l-f~m·1II lljj§:m~.Jr..~. , mtfj*liJf~Z®~~D""f :. 1.)i;:fjg~AZ£*~~Wf11i1l&UfI*:fi1.l~ru!1*'. ... ~r ~~95ffi. Q. @J1iI:lL'I~fI20A. · ~:fI*12:10IA '. .~~!W95A. '. ~~:fi. Q. Q. 2.)i;:fjg~AZ~m:)f;!\7£W.~nh!r§l¥JftmWffr±m!l&.fI*:fi~~1BI. f*,. 3!;. fjf11i1l&Unili~ fftcp:1j~lE1£m~J@*l&RmI¥J~'OO)i;:fj~~A~!J ~.fl. *.~Rfi'3tJ'iJTm.z liJf~l¥JliJf~h7-td\~l!Iltt$. f.N.WJ~3tCW*§ru!liJf~. CP~~!iafI+~.a.~7:t.). 3.~~PfT)1U~Z~fi~~A. Q. 3.)i;:fj~~AZ*~Wn.RItJ~f*,Wf11i1WJU~*:fimf~~f~. : EI3~~Nljmfjt+=1iI~~pfT~65~J;J.J:~~ ' EI3~'i'ff,j~nh!~M~flj>L,lJiEl ' kSllit:*:'OOf5.tlifl . '§'~*1JDJ;J.J!Jf ' i&f1i.~!Wr..~52A ' ~1~52f5.t:fi~rt:l~~. B::M.Rmnh!~~~'OO~!J Q. lE~11~~. Q.
(6) Ki1lt ' *UffJi=:~~ff276A '. :fi~A~f± . ~f±AI&~Ijt:E2¥tlI4A/f 'ZP¥=J~l@ f:±AI&ffl,3.29A . (8.0.=2.25A) Um:1*~#f\i£ ' :t£~1tIDJr""~t@,,~ , #ij*~mf~~~~1*~ , iffl~1'fff{iiJ1*~!¥J~AftS7 41.4% ' :fi0 ' , ~ , fA ' .ff1*!¥J~AftS7 40.6% ' ;!tft!?Jimffl,flllH* ' 1tS18% ~~*~1JiID ' 9(fjE~ A t:p , *fciBffrfJJ:fi ~~!¥J*~ (97.5%) ,f:t1'f6A%~~~~~*~ ~A!¥JaAPJ fi" -r:tz:~Mr I¥J A ftSm:*!¥J*~ , :fi-=-71 ~-!¥J~Am¥U fi" Uit~WJ A ~;¥t*~~*~ :fi il!1tiiaA~ftS1i71~- , ;!tf\!l,!¥J*~~IJ717}tl~:fJiIt, l!lii;fOm1ijiWJ~ zts:¥=JJ&A1JOO' :fi:fEl~~!¥J~A*fl~1ltr.,,~· :tf:fi)&fl~~ (168A) ~A!¥JZP¥=JaAffl,I72987t 9(fjE~A zP¥=JiijJi !¥J~m;fOU~.m~lf1~m 16464jC 5'tIDJ~At:p . 1'f28.3%(681240)1jS'tt:pf~J&A!¥J~AWm.!i ffi~~ ftE!¥J~*' 9(fjg~A!¥JJ5f:±.ffim1Ri~fl&-J!t.f~a1l:PJ~air9(ijE~A~ B m~ mmllJ *iff~~m*$fB!¥J~l@:M!./flifffl,~ijE~Arm1JD~*~~1if!! (. 1'f)&r",'~24Iffr !iItE~ff*/f*%~qIHIil 0. ff ' {f!9(t1E~A:M!.~F1'f~U~~fffi ' ~1:1H.tJilM~I!¥JqIHlilff~}j; , :x.*PJ IN:~m:tfjj1±Wit:p!¥J9(t1E~Affl,f;t~ , ~F*.~~A •t&BJI!!itEfjl; *UffJi=:n ~84if:2Ji rdl~ff~A~IDJr",' (fI;1*~3 Ji ~mf) 'IDJr",'1&:M!.nWH~it!H'J~lnUfa 1lfiJWJltf~~A~lifUji;{6t , ~~±itI{'FUffJi=:*sirJtf:+J~~~6. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. ;. ,. J}f~.r..~~)f#~#n-i;!-. 0. *UffJi=:~m~I~nffiUffJi=:~~~~~'.~~~&.~~~!¥J~~§ ff~~t*B.Ar",'~. 0. 0. : (I')~AWlA£*ji;{6t , (2) ~A , (3)~A!¥J~l@W;fr±itlHl{* ' PJ&(4)~. 9(fjE~A!¥Jr",'~1g;fi5. !¥JJ%H~#f\~WUm:nlit~~m$ A~m~~mi£Ww±Wilj~Ujff~M(. 0. 0. 0. 0. jif4JlIm~~f&n~m SAS(Statistical Analysis System )~~t71{IT ~~~ ff71fff o. ~*1t*Jf. !f: ' - ,. ~ ti~:;t A..tA. 0. 4t- 1f ~.J.tiJl.. *Uff~IDJ.Mlm9(ft~A'.~7.MWit:p9(ft~A!¥JMWi~ • •. 31< '. {1:;~$ (9(fjl;~Arl't'~ffi;tt1:~~.~ft~) ffl,41.1%, if~;ttWlA£. *jif4 ' ~4-1 ). J%m~~#f\~WU~nlit~~m. '. ,. ~l@Wifd:it1iIlJ~B)ltlOr: ( i. " (-). ~fi~:tA.a9;f±t-A.o4tjf. *UffJi=:t:p5'tIDJ!¥J9(fj~~A ~fj~~AftS38.2% (92{1l.). ' if:flUlrI!U~3t99~ (21:s'L) ,. r 65-74~ J. , r 75~84~ J !¥J~fiE~A{tS41.1%. 85~PJJ:~~~!¥J~AJlUftS720.7%. (50m). 0. (99fll.). t. rm. ~'I1~fjg~AW:tCtf9(ft~. A!¥JAI&:f§~/f~ 9(fjg~A!¥J'Xn~};l71ffljZf¥=J ' ::f~f!¥J9(fj~~A~ftS 0. , ;tt~/J\~ , t:p~W*.~};l¥=J:tf1i71~-ft:;b ~MliI#f\1£1JiID ' B~!¥J~fj~~AftSm:~1& ' ffl,=71~- , ~fM:tf~fiE~At:pftS~=~1& ,~ 39% ' rmt:E**S~!¥J.J%~Ai:!!rl!U3t7.l% :tf~fIE~A!¥J1i5{t#f\?£fj[ , ~ (1g;fi5*~-r~) &i%-r~~f:±~{tS750.7% ' fJT~&.mi~l@~ftS7*offi~-$m*§ • • !¥Jff*ffl,ftaA~~A'~1lt~1i5~A~~i:!!~ 0/ . ftS20.7% f:tW!fcl1M~{±~:fi27.9% ~l@~{±AI&J: · *${fr9(ft~A 0. 0. 0. ,. 0.
(7) ~4-1 lJi 1f.ti(n-241). §. 65-74~. 75-84~ 85~J;)..t. ::x. ~. B7ttt. §. lJi. ~ffWI!t(n-239). 92 99 50. 38.2% 41.1% 20.7%. l(~l-~,Lt. 9J~WJ3t IJ\~WJ3t. 1'~::f:. '/iJWn-241) ~. !l:.. 126 115. 52.3% 47.7%. 8l1f. 7t@". ~~~. ~fM. 7(:±~. B*~·. *. B 7t tb. III 128. 46.4% 53.6%. 1Ilift5 ~F1Ilift5. 51 53 57 78. 21.3% 22.2% 23.9% 32.6%. 123 7 94 17. 51.0% 2.9% 39.0% 7.1%. ff~~ (n=239) ~fffPJf*~ 1}'~'.'1l. 19.0% 55.3% 7.6% 14.3% 3.4% 0.4%. (n=239) 2AIEJf± 3AIEJ{:l: 4AlEJfi: 5 AIBl f:l: 6AIEJf± 7AlEJfi: 8AIEJ{:l: 9AlEJfi: 14AIEJ{:l: 1Ilift5. 50 191. 20.7% 79.3%. 67 34 27 21 18 10 7 3 2 50. 28.0% 14.2% 11.3% 8.8% 7.5% 4.2% 2.9"/0 1.3% 0.8% 20.9"/0. 43. 18.0%. f~!&A? ~Ff~!&A?. 68 172. 28.3% 71.7%. ~f*. iliif* ~mf.$1IliJLr",~. , :;;mn=24I ) ~*~i;1f*1i T!l:.~~ it~)j&WJ ~i*~ ~~ fll~ ~1ljiWJ. (35.71%) , ffiJ!&Af.lj~120005t~7ff1!:ffl~Aij~R~1~ffj~~(X2 =11.96 ' p<O.OOI) ~ftMlt~ffPJt ? ~"'~*1iJf~~rJ]~f1!:ffl~A• •ij~R~~A $ • fif=@I • •mf:jU~~~f!£!&A~ffE~A • -@IffitiZ9 337\--@I{ifH~ *~~~rzg~~ EB~l&Jft~l!J~rl'l~• •*m{~~ff~~A@*R~1fiJ ' ~l!J f:tfl£!&A~~Am{~ij~R ~:g.@I• •ij~R~ffEjJ( capacity)*ffE1B:5tiJ:kZ .~ , ~~• •iQRff~~~tt~mf:jtij~R~1!£!&A~9diE~A tiDJlt-* ' Eil ~~ffEJJi~/f'-JERf¥~f!£!&A.P1it$ • -a:rff:U~~~ , -·J!j;.;JF1!£!&A~~ ~~A~fif~1ilHi~¥~ij~R ' ~Mz::1'~M~jJpJTffgm~~ , ffiJ~ij~R1~~OO 0. ~~litMzPJT3& (~~4-1). !/'i'jllU~iFfiX'¥ !/'i'jllU~~(fJOOipJT. ~4:t&~. '1!IlW. ~jl(fJr']:~~OOi ~!Ir'j,f!j!. m~ltm~Vii. fif47.l%~~ffg~A~~~-1f:pglU~f±1% ' :jt.$:k~~~1±!I}t~~~ -Ji;\G=~ '~{5~~~~~40.3% .:fVItI~Ili:lJt),~tf19:;:ff~~A~~~ltk~ .,. ~*-1f:pg~.:fVItI~llfif=~*~7f~·~~~z~n~A*~'MA% (48/235):t£~*-1f:pg1f:fi~~.:ff$j :fi~~W:~~~E~AW:fi~.:ffJltj~1l -;fl , t!1~{520A% ' ;tt:$-;.x~W:~~14.5% (34/235)· ~ffi1.~rj~=.¥tlli 0. 0. 0. , r~w:~~ffE~A*ftf-~~~~~15j;t *1iJf~~JJi : 0. ~r~w:;.x~' ~~~f530.3%' :jt.~69.7%il!~~·~fj.iij3J§l~JEr~ 27 21 5 52 16 14 21. 11.2% 8.7% 2.1% 21.6% 6.6% 5.8% 8.7%. .. *~r",~lJif.$~1il<:~r,,~~ , f$~ , B*~¥-:nB~lvH1f:±&it~JE ' 1(z~!/'i'jllUif!B:@; $~f!J3~IDJ~tzDfPJit~~. 0. (~)~~MA~ • • aOC~ • • • ~~ffl. lJi ' :;;mn=24I ) 2.5% 47.3% 30.7% 21.2% 6.2% 2.5% 3.3%. 0. :. ~mf.$1IliJLrp~. 6 114 74 51 15 6 8. :5t~~~. *:f~ {±!I}t , .:ffJltj;fO~w:~ltkR~~ff~~A~~~mltkfifrDl t),~ffg~A. ft5f±J.ftm~Of!i:. *~1J!f*1i. m~JJi:~~IMOO5t!&AZ~n~A'f1!:ffl~~.R~. Q. (n=240) 41.4% 40.6%. 0. 0. JUfffif~J&A?. 99 97. 0. 0. ~~rOJf:l:A~. 45 131 18 34 8 I. ~~~~n~A$'~ffl~~ • • mm~~.@*R~.R~'~ 43.2% :EfJt~lt~z£*¥-f~BlrfO~ffl~~ij~,R~Jire;~~t!H=rrDllf9fdi.:5tfff ' ~rJ ~JJi~A1f~z~f!£;fOf1!:ffl~j;tzij~RfifrDl~ ~~~A (85~t)'l:) um... tt.1f~~A (65-74~) ftfflJf~~~~ij~R(X2 ;26.3,p<O.OOl) 1lt?!,{ , ill tprl'l~-a:rff~~r'i'U~~A~~ijEltk~~Mltzi'& ' :9)7\- ' 'I'i5JU ' 9\j~tX&~.Mz :fltilapX;f1!:ffl~Aij~R~B~~1Jt • ffiJ!&AlfOO • :E~120005ttr::b:5tl1 ' 0. ft5{:l:~~(n-241). ~~(n=237). 1!lUR~ Fa'f!lI f$~" iI!~ ~1f~. ~. lIfj!W~~(n-241). ~*&ElIf iiJt(n=239) *~ii ~F*~ii. (~)~~~A£*#.~~rn~~.~. ~ff~~A£*Jlflz~~:5trE~. ,~. '.B9m7t*. Q. EBJlt-a:rt),~tf1~ffg~A~um~~~1tffl~~~.~Jl11ijl ~'liJ!, 0. ~fiIi:~ltk~ , ~ffg~A'1i!!,~~m1lt$ (fI~) ,j:),1tf!IDl~1500~*mm: .5%) , ~~~r'i'UJ1n~ , 1545.6% • ~Nlfilf1500~~m1540.2% . $J!t\WJ~ • iW~[gJj~m~fif=:5tz-t)'l:~Am:&.~~m ~ffi1.~*m~rJ:t£ z-t)'T tt.~fifH~mtf1*IDtajJ~~{.\lilm . 1526.6% (¥J:t£1/4) ·33 . ··l!ff'L~~m~Jj § j]DtI~* ' ~JJi~ff~~A $ , '1i!!,=Jjt)'l:ttttm~ fif63% • iQgt~IDtll:fflli=:5tz=~~ffE~Afl=-.J]it)'l.:.~~m 11£2fSf:;J . ~fjg~A2fSf:;Jfif3.3J]i~m (S.D.=1.6) ~fjg~A'1i,',~*m7f-JE 0. 0. Q. 0. 0.
(8) gt~~3&Jt~fjgB9~m. 0. *liff~cp¥fJjtljfJjJtt-r<:t'mj!fT7M. '. (33.2%}f01t1mJm~~Wg(24.5%)~PW*Jfi~3&:t5A.~fjgfB'±~J]{~. ~~cpm 0. Jtfttl.~. 'L'lilwg , DNIm1JlIDB9~mWr£'l7R~*1t1JlIDfB~wg~m=*~~m ' 5tJjtl{~. 6.2%' 6.2%W5.4% :t5A._*ffEPfT~3&fB~fj·gslft:::ft1nmMcpB9~ , fJH~3.3%. (8A.) 'rm~El~:t5ft~3&fB~fjg, ii!:fJiff4.1% (lOA.) ~fjM5A.ff~~ J:mt~~mrm~~I1~ ? 238flI@]~B9~fjg:t5A. cp , ff~~~flllmB9f~7 85.7% (204A.) , JtCP@]~~~ Ii' ~MH:M.g ffllA.(4.6%)' II' ~Mij~~.g .ff188A.(79%) , ~~ !' 1i~.g :tfff31A.(13;o)' II' c:pfilqm~.g :tf47A(l9.7%) , II'cpllmm.ll :tffl.f~21A(8.7%) !'1&"tmm.g ~m:';lrm:¥tlfB.~1J~ 'fi. ff2A.(0.8%). ~4-2. r~\. 1_~llj. ,. 0. 5t tt II Jfi. § I~. ~ls5t. (n=235). ' ,(n=235). 0. ~I. § I~. ~fjg:t5A.B9~m~?£. O~. L;X 2~ 4~ 5~ 6~. 187 38 6 2 1 1. 79.6% 16.2% 2.6% 0.8% 0.4% 0.4%. 64 84 6 49 110 35 97 57 26. (n=239). ,CAjirrl. 26.6% cpm 34.9% fliliE 2.5% tll7Rrrl 20.3% ~Iffi~ 45.6% Jj$$~wg 14.5% DNIm~wg 40.2% 1}$k~m 23.7% :t51f._*!fEEX; 10.8% JLd:!f!.~m. 12 41 56 117 36. 5.0% 17.0% 23.2% 48.5% 14.9%. O~. m I-/)( m 2./)( 3~ 4~ 5~. 187 34 8 3 2 I. 79.6% 14.5% 3.4% 1.3% 0.8% 0.4%. 15 80 5 9 7 1 15 3 8. 6.3% 33.5% 2.]% 3.8% 2.9% 0.4% 6.3% 1.3% 3.3%. 1 13 59 13 10. O...J.% 5.4% 24.7% 5.4% 4.2%. 0. -'·lfti:mf.!1l!lLr~'. 0. , ~mn=241 , IL'lilm ;' i:?m. **.~fjg:t5AB9·Bm~r5r5!w~J;I]fjg, *$5t:t5AiEI~';lrff-~Jj]ffg~. ~$5tEX;%~fBtaWJ '~funil*liff~:tEgiiHIJ:B9~~ PJ~.Jfi*l[ , Ii' fT. ,minE. 0. fE:tnZftt!!J:.g , Ii' J:"ftlW.g ~PWlj.:tnflI~Jj]fjg:tf ' ff!li3't~fB:t5A~~ta. WJ ' 5tJjtl~69.6%W67.9% 1i'7Jt~.g 1JlID~~taWJ:tf~f5m':::'flI ' ff60.6%. fB~fjg:t5A7Jt~ffm. 1I'~Jm;::&ij~.11 ' lI'iUf,itWWflI~~flI.g , Ii'OOAJr .g W !' J:JlijPfT.II ' II' *~E:!jM.II ' !' IJ\~E:!$~.g ~lj § 1JlID ' ~ff2/5t¥J ~fjg:t5A ffmlf£ !' j!~.g JtU~tt!li3't:::f~taWJfBJfi § , fl.ff1l3m:¥tl~~ta WJ· :::f~t1n*WI1Uflt¥J:t5Aliff~f'Ftt!li3't' it~ff:f!'j~~t¥J~fjg~~ (~. ~4-2) • B m~r5r5!wJj]ijg:;!:!;;ff+~ , t:t~fjg:t5A:(£~JJ:!;;Jj]fjg~*J:t¥J~. f.iIl~~*l[ , ff22%t¥J~ijg:t5A ffIOlJ,iB9 B m~r5r5!wJj]ijg~~$5tEX;~$. fBtaWJ' Bm~r5r5!wJj]ijg%~1l!11:t¥Jfl.ffl1.2% (27A) , ~a~' fflOlJ,i. B m~r5r5!wJj]fjg~~taWJt¥J:t5Af~~fm:t5A~m:~~' pwlj Bm~tf!ir5!W. Jj]fjg1ltaWJt¥J:t5Af~15.4%' -JfiBm~r5m!wJ;I]fjg~~taWJt¥J{~12.0%' Jt. fttI.~'Ji5:(£10%J;J"f· mi7R~~ID'.W<:t'fB:t5A:(£Bm~r5r5!WrjJfjgJ: ' ¥~pwOO. fjJ1ffl! (~~4-3) •. _.IlR.m :'iliilfIl&. Jj$$~m. 0. ,1IJ1m~m. 0. 0. ~ji-' :(£/\lJ,i~WJttBm~r5r5!wJ;I]fjgcp#E~~$5t~~$t¥JtaWJt¥J:t5. A{~m:~~(l04A'. 43.2%), :(£/\OOlJ,i§CP 'ffIiOOJfi§ffii4/5t¥J~fjg:t5A. ~~taWJ ft(1f~: Ii'~Wim~.g (83.8%)' ll'~m5t~I~.g (82.9%)' li'j}. tf:HI1fl*G§.g (80.9%) ¥1IiimJ!l!MfEffmlf£:tffu{~~2/3t¥Jtt19tl Ii'tHI!t~li.g. :fl] Ii' ij~~.11 ~Uff#~Hlf-*t¥JA PI J;J%~1IiilL El3Jtt PI ~~fjg:t5 A~Fm~~ B. m~r5r5gwJj]fjgfBtaWJ ' :::t;tt:(£H~tEB m~r5r5!wJiJfjg1JlID . ~~!;lHt!;ij~. fE (~1W~4-4) t'E~:f:I~~l[' ff43.2%t¥J~fjg:t5AW#~8JfiB9t!itiWJ't1B. m~r5r5!Wmfjg~taWJ %~fjg~1Iii11::tf ' fl.f~2.1% (~~4-4) 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. f. " £r$k~m :t51f._*!fEEX; 1L.'J!l!~m lfI1~1JlID~m. " BJ~~m • ~\.IlR.~*1t~m ~1!tf&ID1~~m .ttflb,~~. ~~J:,,·tllit~ J!GIt~ X'VU.....L,.. t::H:f1. ",_.',.0'_',- _.. #'. _. ..... '". (n=239) .A.f$i~(n=241) I. PfT(n=241). it(n=241) , jf::tn ZJS :tfu . =240) "ftlW(n""240) mttRft~(n=239). 1t!~f!ill(n=240). Mb~~m. 1£\.IlR.~*1t~rrl. 1t1mJm~~rrl. :t5{t .. Jtfttl.~m. /'. .li3(n=240). 78 114. 32.4% 47.7%. 103 102 146 167 163 117 97 101. 42.7% 42.3% ' ::&ij~(n=241) 60.6% m3:timI~ 69.6% 67.9% 1~~§~~(n=240)1 133 49.0% J!l!MfE(n=241) 157 40.4% 42.1%. ~*g§(n=241) $WiI1*~(n=24l) ~~=241). 131 195 202 209 208 199. 54.6% 80.9% 83.8% 86.7% 86.3% 82.9% 1 55 .4% 65.1%.
(9) ~4-3. sm1:.t5 t5 iiJJ m n~ § tj. ~Jj~~AsR;~tjr§t5iiJJmtJg~~tj§S9~fjr:xl2. ;j.::. 12. ~ tfPx 12. Ef. 5t. tt. ( 1!9) ~Jd~ ~ A ~ ~bt:.. ~flEf5ttt. ' ,1 t' Qg 1i. In. tE*liJf~cpmHtRX= @r<>~tj*~~l:f;::~t;~ AW~Af§~11H~ , mifd:tfli 11JM:k?5L r W~Af§~m~ J ,t£~*ji:MCP1~~1I.lJ5S9:f;::t!t;~A~50A' 0. IZ9JltliJf~CP*.f~Ji49A*@J~Jltr<>~rji (:f;~i~L.tl!~:ff50A*@J~). 0. EE~@J. Otj. 27. 27. 11.2%. 11.2%. ~11fj:fM!\h*t!ljM ' *~I2~tE_=t~I\f~Llj~tEt9i'm3ET@J1§: , 0JltJltr",~tj;L@J. Itj. 29. 56. 12.0%. 23.2%. ~. 2tj. 37. 93. 15.4%. 38.6%. ifjjWmM~,@*ti~f6l'&~12(56.1%) , iTIft£;FWA*ti:tf167115. 7.5%. 46.1%. #. 3Jji. 18. 111. 4tj. 12. 123. 5.0%. 51.0%. 5tj. 14. 137. 5.8%. 56.8%. 6tj. 10. 147. 4.1%. 61.0%. 7tj. 10. 157. 4.1%. 65.1%. 8tj. 18. 175. 7.5%. 72.6%. 9tj. 13. 188. 5.4%. 78.0%. 10tj. 53. 241. 22.0%. 100.0%. , Ifmf*lH~QX~S9gt16TfLRX ' @j~1fm1*~QX1H~~flif6/f¥ti/f¥til/1O ' 0. r ifd:tf. ,st~~Dt J' ffJtJ-f,t{J\l!I!'r1i~J:S9 '4o/J1tJ:S9mlV1,@J~f~~=:t:rtmtJ[JtJ-:ltif!l tf4;.:liJf~Cp:f;::~t;~APfT~¥tlS9ifd:tf5i:~ ,. :fliR '. 0. tJ- lrfJ!f~.4o/J JI ~l'&~(57%) , ff!iA. ~.:y{;,:f;JfiiID5i:~~~;L , 1643.5%. 0. ~Ait~~~S9~ , tEji~Jl.m. ~1IRfJ!f~)JiID ' 1~¥tl5i:~S9ttf5'tif§'i'1~ , f1t!1613.9%(33 A) EEl/t 'fiJ Je.ji~Jl. ' 0. _n.hH31-H-E''l~im~ (Je.~4-5). 0. ~~t;~AW~)'@&fI±tf liiiJJ!l7\3E. 121 Ef 5t ttll tj (0=192). fHH· ~4-4 _...... _. •. .... _. .... WJ tt Sm1:.t5 t5 iiJJ m ~~ tj §. ~. :f;::~g~A.WJttsm1:.t5t5iiJJm~g~~tjElS9~fl~12. _ . ... _ _._ _ - - ... 12. ~fl~12. ... Ef. 5t. tt. I~. 121 Ef 5t tt. (n=237). 74. 99 18. f1l~ ~. § 5i:~~3E. 38.5% 51.6% 9.4% 0.5%. :ffA~. ~AfJ!f~.4o/J :ffAm~jilV1 ~A5i:~. 103 135 33 56. 43.5% 57.0% 13.9% 23.6%. ~flEf5ttt. Otj. 5. 5. 2.1%. 2.1%. Itj. 6. 11. 2.5%. 4.6%. 2Jji. 13. 24. 5.4%. 10.0%. 3tj. 18. 42. 7.5%. 17.4%. 4tj. 16. 58. 6.6%. 24.1%. 5tj. 34. 92. 14.1%. 38.2%. 6tj. 30. 122. 12.4%. 50.6%. 7Jji. 15. 137. 6.2%. 56.8%. 8tj. 104. 241. 43.2%. 100.0%. 48 133 56. 20.3% 56.1% 23.6%. : EE~~Ji41.I%S9~1~Pfs ' l/ttjElttf5'tlf*W. ,. ~d~:t A. B9 :tJ:. g ,1!«.f1i 1; *. ,( -) ~n~~A~1J;fd!f.{~:f;4t,ti!·11. (11;\::11.) ~*Jf tE ~~4800jfi± Wi ~1li)JIIDS9~*tj § cp , M!~50%~ AfJ!& :ff~*S9tj ~t*;f8lJi ' it(Ef 5ttt~.~Hrj F*~ : *fliB~(71%) , IIffrqjgtg , t3ttRflf:t(66.4%) , )f:M~.:lt1!t(58.9%) , M~~~~:f;(58.1%) , M , 6tit:(54.4%)tJ-&:I:.rfiJ.~(53.1%) f,t~~flf:tf:1jS9JfiiID~ , ffJtJ-M ~*tj§ , $*Ef5ttttE30-49%;Lfa9S9tj§ , 'fiJtJ-M 0.
(10) ~!iUWd§tJ]w.;* :.&n~. I. H12@J~§. I. ft<Ef5ttt~.~~37IJ~ : U1JtmWl(4901o) ,. , ,*¥(46.9%) CP1.!£1&AtmWl(44.8%) , 1!i!m5<:~IJl(43.6%) I. (41.9%) {frt15t(39.4%) I. I. ..t.JJWPJT(37.3%) , lIZ:ii(36.9%) ,. ftl!g. n~~3i:~(34%). M(32.8%) , */N~~~Z~~(32.8%)j::)Jst1iLA.~1:.~~(30.3%). ~4-6. JJl. ,~. ~~-~~~,*~~cpm~.m~~~~¥cp'fl=@J.m~~~~ IjiU~CPf:tw.;*. Hfl11@J~§. 0. jtCP71 ~tmWl~~t27.8% ' jtf&ft<ff~ : U:Jj~~~~l1i(25.3%) , n.~3(23.2%) , :Jm 1fI1..~J1Jlmt(18.7%) , .m3i:.(16.6%) , fj~(l5.8%) , U:Jj~Wl:l*;fttmWl I. I. I. (15.8%)' f~Sm~tmWl(l4.l %), B Ffl~:tf;~W~i]i(l3.3%)' 1~~~~( 10.8%) , 9}.~1lf:l$~(l0.8%). 0. *~!&h5~111~~~§. f1if*Ef5ttttE10%.l-:J,"F~ , ~fj~!&~~f.!£f:t~*. , {,\~~~j::J&X,*1*OO~J]I§. ~ , .~1~f:tf1if* (Ji!.~4-6). I. §. ~. I'x. Ef 5t tt J]I. ;f!j:if=!tJ]w.;*. 0. ~1.!£1&A~A ' jZgJlttEU:JjffflWl~CP1.!£1&AtmWl=J]I~w.;*fl{j~~JtI\?£ w.;*Ef5ttU£1O-29%ZFfl~~~§. ~tig~A~J]lf1if*~I'x5t~. , nib. 0. ~. t-t~~tiE~A*. ,. •••. ~.ftl!.~. 171. 71.0%. ~~tmWl. 67. 27.8%. ~[QJgtU. 163. 67.6%. B1Jffa~. 61. 25.3%. t5t:.&n~. 160. 66.4%. n.~3. 56. 23.2%. JEW1~'*tt~. 142. 58.9%. :Jm1fIl~J1Jlmf. 45. 18.7%. fm~~$H1~. 140. 58.1%. .m3i:Jl. 40. 16.6%. lIl'J4tJJ. 134. 55.6%. 1J~. 38. 15.8%. t5t~. 131. 54.4%. ~. 38. 15.8%. :l!:1fIl~. 128. 53.1%. f~*!m~tmWJ. 34. 14.1%. B Ffl~:tf;~. 32. 13.3%. R~~~. 26. 10.8%. 9}."'fffl$~W. 26. 10.8%. 5. 2.1%. t.~. ;sft<~*~JjU~~tiE~A~~* : '§:7tj::)j\ifHFP:¥-gI'x*~ , ~AtE48. I'x Ef 5t tt. ~. CPf:tw.;*. 0. (;)~ • • A#a • • • *~. §. :if=!tJ]~*. f~f:tf1if* lmJmtl7Jt';. ~~f1if*~ZP:¥-gI'x~ 12.1 ' "lligt~~~1:i'l:~AZP:¥-gfl12J]I~w.;* ' ~Ami~. .~tmWl. f1if*~~28~ • ;sft<WJ~2l#f~A~*lii5t~ : Ji:S~1I~ (J]I§3-19 ' lmJm. ~g::&n~,*¥. 118 1}3. CP1~1&A tmWl. 108. 44.8%. J!ftl!*~. 18. 7.5%. 1tm3t~IJl. 105. 43.6%. mO$lif. 2. 0.8%. ~7Jt'; ,. */Jy;ttl$} ,. J!ftl!*~, ~o~if' lmJmwll~ , lI~f~~. '. ~tJ]pg9}~ , M1J1Jl~J1Jlmf ' ~* :l!:1fIl~. ,. , :flH~ , ~(~)Oll~ , ::Sifll~ ,. 49.0% 46.9%. */J\:I!:tl$}. 12. 5.0%. §20-27 , 1bbWln~~' 1~~~. ngw. 101. 41.9%. lmID'tli1II~. 3. 1.2%. ~ , @JA~1:.~~ , 7Jt';1l ' {frt7Jt'; , */Jvf~~~~~' ,~g:.&n~,*¥, ffl[QJ. {frt7Jt';. 95. 39.4%. gj~f~~. 10. 4.1%. gtU) '1:.m~D (lJl§28-37, liZ:ii' ..t.JJWPJT' fm~*$~~' nib, ~ M ' lIl'J4tJJ ' ~iilfjftl!.~ , 7Jt';:.& ' n.~3 ' ~ffl ) ,lfflfmWrJliim ( §. ..t.JJWPJT. 90. 37,0:3%. .~~. 16. 6.6%. liZ:ii. 89. 36.9%. ~tJ]pg9}~. 6. 2.5%. 1bbWln~~. 82. 34.0%. ~*. 10. 4.1%. ~M. 79. 32.8%. :flH~. 12. 5.0%. :f;:iJ~~. 79. 32.8%. ~(~)Oll~. 17. 7.1%. @A~~:tHl~. 73. 30.3%. ~f:i'l:5It1E. 3. 1.2%. ~~g&A. I. 0.4%. pJTj::Jj::J. IL\~-rg~. 15. 6.2%. ~ZP:¥-gI'x~fl*j::J~§ , J;J#t(w.;*~JjUFfl~ztt~ HJn:b~tiE~AtEf1if*..t.~. *~.im. 4. 1.7%. ~:7t;;Xffm : 1:.m..t.~~i]i1bbWl (0.47) 'JiS~~lI1bbWl (0.4) ,*~~4tJJli. x,*1*oo. 10. 4.1%. ~1:i'l:5It1E' ~~iJ&:A' fj~). 38 ' 39 ' ICJ'~1bb~. 'Ji:S~~1I. , *~rJliim). (. j::J&~~~*. (. § 43-46 ' 48 ' U:Jj~Wl. :l*tmWl'~Sm~tmWl,cp~1&AtmWl,~~tmWl'U1JtmWl) 0Ji:S~1I~ ~§. (H 17J]I)cp ,. ZP:¥-g!&~ 1.4~. , mi~ 13~ ; h5~~111~~ §. (~t8~)cp. ,. A~ZP:¥-g!&~3.2~ , mi~~~8J]I ; 1:.m..t.~~i]i(HlO~)cp , ~A~ZP:¥-g. !&~4. 7~ , l&~~~ lO~:. Ii' ~~rJliim.n. W' Ii' IL\~1bb~.n Nij~ § if~~rm. WrJlii!i~JjU ~tiE~AZZP:¥-g1'x~0.08' rm*~~~*(Jlt/f-EIm9}."'fffl$gW I. § , H5~)ZP:¥-g~1.5~ (Jl~4-7). 0. jZg~~~*~§1'x1;;-'ft. I. 0. 1bbWl. (0.3) 'JiS~lI~z1bbWl (0.08) j::J&~imWlfflfmw.;* (0.05). 0.
(11) «~R~A~.H.~S*~. 66 ;ittk~. ~4-7. ~. I'x. ~. ••• M.~~~. ~flE~A~$:~JJUz ZP:~I'x(N=241). m. tt~$:. @*~l!I!~$: @*~~~$: ~t511%I~;lf~$:. .jm~ml~$:. *~~~$:. zP:. ~. fiFf. 12.1 1.4 3.2 4.7 0.1 1.5. .$::i4]~~9MtH l:zmtif*$ 1~. fJ $ ft 6.61 1.59 2.67 3.38 0.30 1.13. f,§6. 5} fB 11 0-28 0-13 0-8 0-10 0-2 0-5. (~~4-8). ; tl2:gt~~ , ~~~I'x~~ , 1&1l!;PJ'irM$::gt~. 0. ~4-8. ~flg~A~:1:;:-tf.Z~~~I'xW~JJi~$:1~n-!'tj Elm~:f§~f~I'xn-:fJT(n=235). ~rM$:. f5~~l!I!. t511%WJ $:. $:. 'l\!1t. ***. ***. 0.24. 0.22. *~~~$:. .. *. 0.21. 0.15. 0.11. ** : p <0.01 ~'.9~ft.A~a (-)~. •• c*~~~. ~flg~A1:E~:1:;:=.1rnJt:lI7'3:ff1Wir~~· tl2~1:E~~$:&~lJi'l\!1t$:J:-J~JJl~. •• A£*.I.~ •• ~S*. *~~r:p. , ~~flg~A83tf.fi '1iJJU ,~l!t ' *~llifrp , ~~fj~ , ~ ~#j(~&lII@W:S: ' n-JJtlfDjjifli\IWJ.~$:i1HT~~1'x5HJT ffi!f~*mHt.rn-fJT *~~uMtHzmiif*$ , 1li:ff=JJin-*'Tillii® ' Pmj)jj;tiOr : tf.fiW@*~llj~ $:(F=3.85 ' p<0.05) , ~~!I7\~W@*~Jl1!~$:(F=4.73 ' p<O.Ol)tJ&~~#j( ~W*~~.~~$:(F=3.76 ' p<0.05):ff~~~f~ ~j§z ' tf.fi~* ' :ffit@ *~llj!¥~~$:~* (~fi*1l83ZP:~1'x3.8' r:pfi*1lZP:~~3.4 ' f~fi*Jl2.6) , ; ~~1nm ' 1i.l!fNfM(W!f!.!1t)!¥~@*~l!I!~$:~*(.~fMZP:~1'x1.6 ' B~ZP: ~1'x0.5) , :ffit*~~W.~~$:tl2ttB~~* (.~flJlJZP:~1'x2.2 ' B~ZP:~1'x 1.5) ~1& ' ~A~:S:lII@1tW;ji±li\I~.~$::ff~ l!I!~lflIl:: ' 1l!f5~A~ $:~*-l!:!;; , m1:E*~~r:p , ~D~~:f§& : lIIf5~A1:Ett~$: , @*~l!I!~ $:' f5*~llj~$:fD~t511%WJrM$:~tt~flllf5~Af~ ~nrflEW*~~r:plll f5~A~:ff~mIE~ijlR~:ff~ *~~r:p , tEIE~~flJ{'X1~83~1ig~A~!f!. f! ' :ff~*:gBf5H~:1II@~A ' lIIf5~Atl2n!:jfi±~ffijijlR~Jf~!¥~:l:r.6 ' fi§l!tftl! 1r'B*~1~~UJ ~IR~ , :gtl'fIJ r ~~ J glR~J ' ~tl2WWaliaceWLew-Ting ( 1994) t~t:B IF :f::fili!~83!&A~tfll1J[]@*WJ.glR~83~m.l -¥5l.. .. 0. 0. 0. . ~. :ff~r~~!'tj~flg~A1:Ettf7it$: , f5~~:OO~$: , f5~~~~$: . 1:t5~ .~$::1JiID1f~-l!:!;; , m1:EA~millir;$::1JiID~U~f~-l!:!;; • tEt)J:-J~Bf.a*~ ~flg~A:ffIIiJ)£~r~~~ '1:E;ji±li\I~.~$:l:~tt~~ • jfu~~!'tj~~g ~AJ'!tlfi§~~~#j(~tt~~ , ;jitli\I~.~$:tl21ftt~~ ttz ' f~mr~~W. *. [. 0. ~~&B9H±I~&t!l7\~nrflg~ft· ffiJ~&tJtJ\~~;Jt.;ji±li\I~.r;$:~~~~ (~. 4-9). 0. ~4-9 ~flg~A~:1:;:-=1rnJ~ :ff1Wir~~Wili±li\I~.~JJi~$:Z t~)£(t-test)(n=238). 0. :ff : 13.7 1Wi : 11.3. 0. 0. 0. (;)~ • • A~ • •. aoc· •••• ~m.~ •• ~s*. ~1ig~A~mgm83'[1i1f:;fD;f,±~~.~$:83~f~. ,nrt)tEi®:1:;:-·tf.I7'383 fi:1I1C ' .f.VW-&~~~I'x*Ojjifli\I~.~$:83Elm~f§~n-*'T~t:B : lWmlJifD~ $:83~f~~*~MtH l:83~if*$; ~ffiJ~~!¥~;;JzIUD~$::gtnrt)~t:B:ffitf¥ 1:Eif~~:~~~l'xfD~~$:,@*lljl!l!~$:,@*~llj~$:W&~t5~.. A~mml. ~-$: 'ie., rnr. *... tfiFi. 2.55. ... : p <0.001. :ff : 1.8 1!t€ : 1.2 *. 2.16. :ff : 4.1 1Wi : 2.7. :ff : 5.4 1Wi : 4.3 *. *. 2.28. -2.27. ***. 3.63. $: :ff : 0.D3 ?me: 0.10. p <0.01 ": p <0.05 ff : ~:1:;:-= 1rnJ t:l :ffr~~~ , 1:E~~iWf$:1~n-!¥JZP:~1'x . • : i&!:1:;:-=1rnJ J=J ?mer ~~~ , 1:E~JJi 1m: $:f#5}!'tj zP: :i4]1'x **:. *~~~~A!'tj. am1:t5miiJr}:jflE.I W IF.WJttam~t5t5I7JJl J}:j~g . t#~Um1rnJ~5} , n-1'x~~~~J)]fjE~~ l!t~J~~n-¥} f§1JOt{J~u!'tj~f7it$: , ~~rM$:5}I'x#&g(m~f§mm5HJT . ~~-.~ Ii'. 0.
(12) 68. *~~. ~~ft.A~ • • • ~I*. •••• ~.~~~. ~TfD Ii' A~rfIi~.!I iWt*11&fEJIHl9J.. . ;tt,*~iWt*~fD~AB'g Bm ~mmttJ& ~jltJ't1Bm~mmttJJ/Jfjg¥-:J:ff~r.uB'gfEJIHl ,~~*, Ji5~tf~iWt*WB mml!J' ~WJ't1Bm~mml!JJ/JijgB'gfEJlHl~.¥r.u*0.6PJl: (Jj!,~4-10) ~~[ft, ~AB'gBm1:.mmttJJ/J~W~WJ't1Bm~mmttJJ/JijgW~~*' Ji5 ~~~~*'J5~tf~iWt*fD~mtbbWJ:ffr.uB'gmlHl;'i'~A:tE1:mJ;mm!ltiJ/J fjg:W:¥~~Nll5IJB'gf~!Jl1tr!tklf-j . ~~~Ji5~~~ , Ji5~tf~fD~mtbbWJB'g"WJ 1l9!1t • fui¥fi:iJPJn1Lfi~~A~mBm1:.mmttJJ/Jtfg(ADL) , ~WJ't1Bm~m. :fi. Bm~mmttJ:r:j]~g(ADL 1-1O)Wffd: ~WitU~*~5t ~. ~4-11. 1). *~11!f. 0. t. til. 0. mttJ:r:j]~g(IADL)B'gll*i£*m~~~*. 4-10 •. 2.97. iUil~. Ji5~~~ IJiS~tf~ ~mtbbWJ A~~~. ***. 0.66 IADL*" 5t. 0. ~~g~ABm~mmttJJ/J~g, ~WJttBm~mmll.r9Jng Wfr±11fi]l~U~JJIiWt*~&:.if!fElIUl1>*I9:;HJT(n=241 ). M~*. ADLM5t. 1.88 ***. ***. 0.61. ~*. iM*. iWt*. ***. ***. ***. 0.37. 0.76. ***. ***. 0.28. 0.61. 0.54. 1.88 1.88. *Ji!m. ~*. 'ftW*. 0.02. 0.11. 0.02. -0.07. 1.88. 1.97. ***. 0.59. 2.11 1.88. .OOBm~mmttJJ/J~W~WJttBm~mmttJJ/J~~~*~~~.. 2.10. ~,~r$5tmWJJ~r%~~tbbWJJ~,.~~.;;ttMr%~~ftJ ~UM~~ft ' ~1&Wlfd:iI~.*,,~* (48~~1JO~5t) , ( ~5t~. m1Jo~5t) j!fft~AE ' ~U~m~lJi§B'gBm~mml!JJ/Jfjg~~~W:g 'it Yft£~~E~AB'g~~~*1::ff~~ (Jj!,~4-11 ' ~4-12) 0. 1.88. it : u* : p<O.OOI I(~ft) : ~lJiBm~mmttJJ/J~g(ADLI-10)~~~MAtaWJ~ , ~JJI~*~5tzp.¥-:J1l!:. (~)~A~~~'~~M~~~~~.~*. *~~~~ffl=OO~lJi*~~~AB'g~~IHl~Wtt~Rl!Jo~AW~~ 1Hl~{E*1tHIfi¥ . Mft~m~ : :/IfW~ , Mft1&B'g~~1Hl1>*W~*j!ff t ~ '~~~~:~~IHl~~:/If'~W*,,~*'Ji5~~~~*fD~m~U~* :fflHlf>* • ~~lHlf*~fB'g . ;tt"'-:'JJI~*¥-:JttlHlf>*~B'g*B'gr.u (~~4-13) 0. D(~~). :. Bm~mmttJJ/J~g(ADLI-I0)~~MAtaWJ~. ,~. JJI~*~5tzp.¥-:J1l!:. ADLl : ~~ ADL2 : ~f.i-,*111ra~~1:sL ADL3 : ADL4 : 1:JrulPff ADL5: ADL6 : fffE~zp.:!:t!!.1: ADL7 : 1:~tI~ ADL8 : !JJl5t1Xm~ ADL9 : :k11:t?lll5iJ ADLlO : tj\11:t?lll5tl. 69.
(13) ~4-12. :S-~iMWrt1 B m ~115115I1JJj]1l6(lADL 1-8)~ifr±m:!lij1imiWf* f45tZ~5E(n=241). KmiWf*. tiL@.. *.* -8.58 *** -8.02 **. -8.58 *** -10.95 *** -7.95 .** -9.20. I: 9.0 IADLI D:14.6 I: 6.1 IADL2 D:13.5 I: 5.5 IADL3 D:13.3 I: 5.2 IADL4 D:13.1 I: 6.2 IADL5 D:13.0 I: 6.4 IADL6 D:13.2 I: 8.8 IADL7 D:14.6 I: 8.2 IADLB D:14.1. •••. -7.79 *** -8.20. :::. I: 1.7 D:4.4 I: 1.0 D:3.7 1:0.9 D:3.6 I: 1.0 D:3.5 I: 1.1 D:3.5 1:0.9 D:3.6 1:1.6 D:4.4 1:1.5 D:4.0. t{L@.. **. -9.44 *** -10.09 *** -10.65 *** -7.30 *.* -6.52 *.* -9.78. ••• -9.71 • *. -B.7B. ~1151hb. iWJiWf* 1:3.2 D:5.9 I: 1.6 D:5.4 I: 1.4 D:5.3 I: 1.0 D:5.2 I: 1.7 D:5.1 I: 1.8 D:5.3 1:3.2 D:5.8 1:2.7 D:5.7. t1lii!. ~~. t{ifi. iWf* *** 1:1.7 -6.88 D:I.4 *** I:l.5 -10.71 D:1.5 *** 1:1.6 -10.17 D:1.5 *** 1:1.3 -11.38 D:1.5. •••. I:l.5. -7.57 *** -8.66 .* • -6.43 .* • -B.17. D:1.5 1:1.7 D:1.5 1:1.6 D:1.4 1:1.6 D:1.4. *** 2.31. ~AEtjifr±llt1iIlJ1'f=@lJI* : ~/ft~A*11 '{Mjffi~A*flj;j:&*11~ .o5t3UWfM*;\i1HT~fH~~5ttff' : ~Aifct~1ijiJZ/f[qJ:tE~~* . ;~~1lI~*ifD*~~~jf~*1riIfi1'f~~ (Je.~4-14) If' ~{-tP.A*ttEtj~ $.11 ifDj@~timifl*EtjIRl$f;:lI::~rtuB'j , {gifD*~~fI*B'jlRl$f;~iJ:lI::IErtuEtj t~(fJM~~: ~~~6~A1'f~J?}!ti~J@~~~' ~l)[e~W,J*~1TIIJ/f1l! ' ~t.~ftj;j.:tlbWA.xtt ; ~jffi*~~f&*i%GEtj)l;:~6~A ' m Tlf9.14*~~1hbWJ ' &,~.:tIlJWAtiflj ~51-:1fiIfiti ' ttrfrPJij~:lI::-rul:A ( ) tt®tffiiJ[ .M:ff*~~tbbWJ ' tt®t/f~Jt~*~.::y.~miLEtjtbbWJ .~~UijlQ.X% 0. 0. 2.11. 0. t#)fi1~{J~f'¥l!!~~1n*~~tbbWJ. ,. 0. 2.14 ~4-14. )l;:1l~~AB'jifr±~1illJt~ifr±m:~UfM*Etj~~~5ttff(n=237). 2.22 >1<. 2.11 2.23. tE/fWA*tt. 2.10. *tt~~. 2.10. F{ifi. : **. : p<O.OOI 1(1IIJl:) : :S-~iMWJtE B m~115115I1JJj]~6(IADLl-B)CP/fiWfftl!A1hb WJ~ , :S-ljfl*f47j<zJI¥Gf!( D(f1XJlij) : :S-ljiMWJtt B m ~115115miJw1l6(IADL1-8)r:pflftl!AtbbWJ ~ , :S-lj'll*f45tZP:¥Gf!( IADLI : IADL2 : .~ IADL3 : ~rmJfih~; IADL4 : ~~n~$ IADL5: ~t'(nlQ. IADL6 : ue:ffl~im.I~ IADL7 : nlQ.~ IADLB : :f!f!M. fMjffit~A*tt. I. W. 12.4 12.7 10.2 * 3.10. ** : p <0.01. *** : p < 0.001. I*~~~*. I ~~ * 3.B 3.4 2.1 .*. 6.72. 1.1. 1.6 1.7 ** 5.23. • : p <0.05. ~Aifr±llt$i:ffiEtj~bttflPJj;jf'Fm~A§Mifr±lltIRl1~Etjtl§~' :tEfl~B'j1§ p,..t . -~j;jmw.m:lI::lIIJl:Etj=@lr,,':fH! 8'1'f~A{tjft!Jl I:. ' ~L1'fif~ !1P19.1'fAMft!EtjAfjg~A • JtJ@~trmi~*~~~J1nfIAMft! z.)l;:ij~~AB'j[E]~~*(t=2.14 'p<0.05); jffi1'fA~T.~~IhbWJZA~6~A ' it:(£~1151hbWJEtj~>1<Ltt~A~.::y..¥.JJtbbWJZ~ijE:tA~*f.il:r(t=-2.4B ' ~<0.0l) m1tMllt1'f~fj~*UJt ? :tEl!i*z~1'fEtj1iJfJle1'Fmtt®tZ~ , ~1tfi 0. 0. 0. 3. ~Ff6~AEtj~£€IRl{*~ifr±m:~U'll*Etj~5E(n=192). Kmfl*. J5~mi:f!f!fI*. ~1151hbWJiWf*. W:12.B. W:1.5 if:0.7. W:5.2 if:2.6. ••. ••. .. 0. PJll~:lI::1'fA~.::y..¥.JJtbbWJEtj~A (~:lI::~ill~¥.JJ~Jl) '.~frY.¥.JJtbb. !pJ , W/f:lI::ftl!{rlpfTJ?}!Etj~115LB''ltbbWJ. ~:8.5. t{L@.. .* -2.71. ** : p <0.01. -3.11. -3.15. ' !II¥J¥.JJ '. IJp11Bm~11511511J:Jjjtf~Zlj§) ; ~~:tm ' ill?lF~ll~ ,~ij~~A~J?}!B'j:lI::tbb WJ;tt~115J:.Etj1llliJl: jffi¥9.1'fA*~-Y.¥.JJ1hbWJEtj~A ' :tE*1iJfJleCP~·§'f~:lI::!J • ' , J3Z:jffi~~1{J¥Uifr±llt}a]~~$Jjf:f!f!J@~OO1imijl;!:mB'jtbbWJ ' f5l1It;f!;~ 0. ~£€lRlf*. (~O :. mmWJZ~*J3Z:jffif~. 0.
(14) ~'~A~P!~~'t*~~~~~~~~#. m1 "1trnL~Jlll~~*J:.P!,1!~~'t* ~ti~~Al'fr.5iHH~Jt:l~lEJ;\;t!flfJHjtz.ij~~ , l'E~ifU .r.ff!~ittE~*.r. l'f. &~O~~t~~Z~,~mft~~*'m~~~~*~~M'.~~* .r.l'f~~. , ~-JN:m11mfljl'f~. 'fH~JtliEJ;\;t!flfiWiij~~flj~ti~~A. m1;~*z511\{¥-9~tn&l'f~Jt:lij~~B"J~~~~A ~4-15. (J1V&4-15). ' tE.r.. -. lEJ;\;ij~~. 0. ~.. * l'ffre:Jt:l :3.68 ;f!\Iifre:Jt:l :2.77. l'f~Jt:l:13.3 ;f!\Iif~Jt:l:ll.1. **. A~m~. 3. * l'ffre:Jt:l :0.13 ;f!\Ii~Jt:l:O.04. ***. - 2.65 *** : p < 0.001. ~ P-'". ~. *. ITO. tfrn!. *. -2.67. **: p<0.01. *:. 1.e~~$¥:1EJ;\;ij~~B"J~~g~A. -1.99. • '. p <0.05. ' :jt;ii±itiiili1flJ~~!I&m~ , ffij~;@:~3i. §cflj~*o. '. :jt~~gMi£!I&Am:. '. ~mHifl'f~*. 3.l'f ~~*B"J~~M~Afii.~g1~¥UfftiitfiU ~1$j.1:.fiU?fffi~fljij~~. 51 ' MMtt Elm 3:.715715mtJJ}J~g~51. .L~ilI:jt~~'f'tt, ~ml'f~Jt:llEJ;\;ij~~flj~~g~Afii'l'tEElm3:.715715mtJJ}J~~. ' MMtt El m 3:.715715mtJJ;I]~f(]1Jf;W,j~lflJ~IJ;f!\IiIi~:ffi ~ , 1:£fre:m lI:Jjij~~.r. ' -IN:1i1r.5it l'f~ ~ fg~wJtI\i£~~ ( ~iBMi£~.1:.tt!l&~) '~IJ~PJ~gf~m1EJ;\;ij~~ tnW*AIBl{,*frTilW;ii±it51M'zl'f;f!\li , tElEJ;\;f~mij~~.LM!.;f!\IiIi~~~ 0. 0. El3tnliJf~1JJ;\;B"J~N1IiU. ' ;f!\Ii$~1=r~~Z51;ffT ' ~JIt. ~~g~A. !"l'ff~mlEJ;\;ij~~flj. ' jtii1±m:l\ij.li~*~fg.!! B"Jff1jH~~lN*1ffli$fI~ , §~;f!\Ii7:t~~~m H .r.m1;Zm~tl ' 1ltl~f~f~~-tv7. 0. 0. 0. ~~~J~ : ~~i®§m51lJT1JiID ' tE~~* ' m~~~3* ' ~3:.7I5IUM .*.r.~Az~~M"jJaJ3i=~tJ.r.: 1:£~~*.r.' Elm3:.715715mtJJ}J~g~, 51 ' 'l'!Io/JztuM ' ~~;;X~ , W~All311i;lBlf~ , ZP:¥-9~A~~*¥-9l'f~1tH.r. • • Z~.'~~.3i~~%;@*.~~*~*flj~OO.~.~It3i 55.73% ; ffij.1:.715mM3*.r.~AZ[900.JJiM"tJPJ~35.56% tiJtJ."B"J . W~~W~ft1lJ!~ltR:i£f(]~)glBlf~Wfftiitlittl'f1Bl ffijiii±it AD¥,jfi~[J1il F.5' ~¥-9~A ' ~U)M*~~3*f(]{J'l'EWl~3*l'f."1J ' fg."tJ~1Nf~( 1Il$:~~4-16) ~4-17f!U*=OOflJ;\;llU)M~{~3*f'F~i®~m51lfT fP]ffflj , 0. 0. fffl'f=*fl~~)M*~~~*:f[JIG'l'E.~~*B"J."tJ~1Nf~ ,~ffij=Ml.~~)M F.5~~JJ~* ' @*.~3* ' ~.1:.miUM3*M"1J~~J:\l~ , ¥,jllU~@ ~.liI3* rmmodel2 'Jff!Dttt1JD~~Mi£~~*JitiJttttJUB"J.~JtftHH* ' El:ult•• 1lJ!mltR:1£B"JilitiJtJt~~ffijlEiliB"Jfilj~I:H~§g~A ~§ z ' ft~±~ ~~~Wn~A~~f=r;ii±hlhl\ij.liIi~tiJ~~~A~~tE~~-~~~W iI!! ' ~~l'f~.:f.~j , ADL~51 ' tJE<:.IADL~51¥JIif ~~ El3J1tYlfifJtJiIi fl.~"fI~MtWI:H~~t.B"Jfii~f#tffi:~ , M!.J!t!~*i1i.fi\l[¥U 0. 0. 0. f~Jt:l lEJ;\;ij~~~it tt*f~m lEJ;\;ij~~~flj El m3:. 715715mtJJ;I]§~&. 0. l'f~~ii.lli51$~lltl. 0. 0. , liJf3i:~¥f~~ A El m.1:. 715715tJ]J:}J~~*,lit ' 1Jf;W,j1\{ , tt~ , .:f.fJtj , iBw E<:.F~W:X1\{. ~51.r.tt!l&~(t=-2.37,p<0.05) 'ffij1@;w:XI\{1i1~1Ht=-2.42,p<0.05). 0. 0. 0. m7~-~ • • l'ffre:Jt:l1EJ;\;.~flj~n~AW&~Jt:l1EJ;\;S~B"J~n ~ A~~1:£~~Mi£1JiIDfii.!I&~. 0. 0. 1if ~aMtf 69lf- mJ Jt. :. 2.B~~$¥:lEJ;\;ij~~flj~A. 0. ,~~~~~~PJtJ."/fIi:lJ~ItB"J;ji±~~.Ii~*' {OO:1~~-·~Jt:lll)J§1m 51tFT*Ilj;M ;$:1iff3i:z 1l)J§1m51tFT51filii1JiID~f=r : -r.;~~i®1m : §3-IHlIJ l.fRjfl'E~ifUWJrum1;Z~~~m-='WflJ;\; 'model lr.;fftiit AD~fi.*J!~~ , model 2~;ii±itAD~fi ' ~~ltR:1£~UJ!~~ , model 3r.;ii1±itA[l~fi ' 1lJ! ~Mi£ ' ~~ii1±itlBlf*'.::::.m~~ tJ7G/ffp]mJ;\;tE~m3*ttttJDM"Z~~ It ~m~~z~J1X7J*Jrum1;Wll3lBlliff3i:~~ ii1±it AD~fi1Q.ffi : 't1llU ' ~~,~~ltR:~'~@'~A'li:lJttAD;glt1lJ!~ltR:i£1Q.ffi:iBW:X~' .:f.OO;jz~' Elm.1:.m7l5mtJJ;I]§g~51' MMtfBm.1:.7I5715IbJ;l]§g~51: ~)g1Bl f~W;ii±itli!WJ1Q.ffi : W~All311i;lBlf~ , fftiitlimtJ ' l'fAftRf! 'l'fAfif:W.~ tuM ' l'f Afi~*~~ , W:1~l'f A5i:M' mlltl~~Il*~~ltR:~:9i- ' ¥-9f«jft~ff 0. 0. ~~g~Afre:Jt:llEJ;\;ij~~W~Wjfti~!\~Um~*Z~~(n=241). ~. JruiIDB51llU)M;ii±it AD~fi ' ~~M*i£ ' ~)gfftiitlimtJW;ii±hlh~~~* ~fi~~tt51tFT ' 1i11Wffi~I!:9~~i1i.Wii1±~~~~*l'f1Bl ~ffij~ltffij. 0. ,. 0.
(15) 14 0fI. *iR.. K~~~A~.~~~.~~. ~4-16. __. .~~Z~~. ~~~*~~tt-ft~~:5t:fJT (stepwise selection). Predictors. b f~. s.d.. ~~*. 'ffi'fl. -1.9675. ~m1fJJWJ~* -3.9734**. 1.2363. IADL~:5t. 0.1241. 0.0787. .¥!.J~t.§,WJ. 2.4267***. 0.5393. 'ffi'fl. 1.9622. 2.7035**. 0.9984. ADL~:5t. W~A;f§~rg1*. 0.3619***. 0.0659. ADL~:5t. 0.1241*. 0.0575. .¥!.J~1fJJWJ. 4.0029***. 0.9128. test of the model. P<O.OOOI. ~~:;'lZfl. 1.4018*. 0.5737. Adjusted R2. 0.3556. *~~~*. !ljt~A:f§~rg{*. 3.5'195*. 1.6975. ZP:¥-g1&A. 0.0443. 0.0238. test of the model. P<O.OOOI. Adjusted R2. 0.4070. @~~J]!~*. 2.3855*** -0.8773**. 0.2838. 1.3965**. 0.5349. ZP:¥-gJ&A. -0.0106*. 0.0050. IADL~:5t. -0.0353. 0.0188. 'ffi'fl. 0.0750. 0.2454. ~~:;'lZfl. 0.4613***. 0.1199. test of the model. P<O.OOOI. ~ttAfl. 0.1669***. 0.0486. Adjusted R2. 0.1784. m1;!U~til. 0.5415*. 0.2627. ttlJU -¥Vffj':;'lZfl. 0.4035*. 0.2026. r.ill1lffif5l~*. 0.3009*. 0.1540. test of the model. P<O.OOOI. Adjusted R2. 0.2526. l5*if~~*. 'ffi'fl. -2.2865. ADL~:5t. 0.0349. IADL~:5t. 0.1035*. 0.0471. ~~~J&. 0.5068*. 0.2046. .¥!.J~t'§'WJ. 0.5367***. 0.4149. 0.0208**. 0.0083. ZP:¥-g1&A *IA5[~. -1.l849*. test of the model. P<O.OOOI. Adjusted R2. 0.5573. 'ffi'f5( 1iI@W:e":i. 0.0106. 0.0312. 0.1781. 0.1201. ZP:¥-gJ&A. 0.0023*. 0.001l. test of the model. P<0.0393. Adjusted R2. 0.0393. 0.6596. 0.1551***. 0.4849. 0.3562. R;f5( UfHim1J 1iI@W:e":i. ".
(16) fV. 'fMo--''"t1t;,.~'''''''I'-r.::.I'·''por". q:~~.Jtf\. 7. U:J tfQ ....J"~V#·.J..1'../~.l',JTJ "'f"1 ..v-.....~,.:L... 1~Hif~*;;(.fIilmM7HJT (-=:'flfl~;;('tt~). Predictors ~fIlH~.. ;litm. Modell S.D. 1*m 2.09085.6139. Model 2 S.D. f*m. Model 3 S.D. 1*~. -0.8257. -3.7348. 0.3611 0.0108 -0.0299 -1.3205 I.F39 0.0429 0.0545. 0.5907 0.0195 0.1148 -0.7851 2.1698 0.0402 0.0443. 1.2138 0.0869 0.2662 0.2997. 1.2680 -0.0301 0.3235 0.1225. p<0.0386 0.0472. p<O.OOOI 0.3200. 2.6578 -1.4258 0.7989 4.6356 1.2436 -1.9368 P<O.OOOI 0.3679. 0.7519. 0.5543. -0.0525. 0.1561 -0.0103 0.5383 0.3665 0.0965 0.0041 0.1803. 0.1904 0.0125 0.4458 0.3066 0.2232 0.0044 0.1655. 0.2933 -0.0076 0.6688 0.5479 0.2678 -0.0006 0.1652. 0.3134 0.1838 0.0471 0.0283. 0.4466 0.2982 0.0302 -0.0383. p<O.OOOI 0.2106. 0.2487 0.3533 -0.2726 0.1111 0.5864 0.1193 p<0.0007 0.2143. jfr:t1tAD~jt. tt7Jtl. if.~. e~mgl. .~1Mmg2. 1Jijf5 i&,A Imf£AD. 0.l686 0.1030 -0.3045 -1.7712 -1.5027 0.0511 0.3083. !lftfmaJti\bL f&;~*fi{. "'¥1Ji*fi{. ADLN!!\7t IADL~7t. ~~lHlf*~Ud:frB:!I!I.1 W~Affi~lJM1*. m±frB:!I!I.1 flAftl{~. ifAm:L~ ifAt'H!H~~ flA1i:~. test of the model adjusted R2 ~~~:J:§!.ff&3J<. ;litfi{ ffd:frAD~jt tE7J~ if.~. e~~mgl .~{Mmg2. 1Jijf5 i&,A 1m,:EAD. !lftfmaJti\rJt f&;~*~ "'¥flfij*fi{. ADL~7t. IADLN!!\7t ~f@.Im{*Wffd:frJI!I!I.1. W*A;fEl~IHl,* ffd:frJI!I!I.1 flAftl{~. fl~. ifAm,:lU~~. ifA1i:fi¥ test of the model adjusted R2. p<0.0002 0.1214. 1-2.3536. -0.7856 ffd:frAD~jt. '117JU. if.~. e~~mgl .~fMmg2. 11)6 Wl,A 1m f:EA 0. -0.0880 0.0411 -0.4528 -0.4734 -0.7140 0.0205 0.1849. -0.2721 0.4943 0.0166 0.0460. !lttfmJ1Jt)jj\~Jt. 0.3838 0.0153 0.1552 0.1319. ~~;.xfM{. ",¥1Ji*~. ADL~7t IADL~.7t. *~IJM1*Wffd:frJI!I!I.1. ~-1.5264. I. 0.2520 0.0208 0.0579. 0.5184 -0.2121 0.1576 0.0971. I 0.4263. W%A;fEI~IJM1* m±frJI!I!I.1 flAmlti. flAmf~. flAm{;~*~~ flA1i:~ of the model R2. p<0.0164 0.0608. L~ ,\RRR. 1.4121 jjitfrAD~1t. tt7JU. if.~. e~mgl. JlI~fMmg2. 1Jijf5 i&,A Imf:EAD. !lftfmJ1Jt)jj\~Jt ~~~~. "'¥fJ\ij;Xm ADL~,7t IADL~7t. ~~mH*Wffd:fr:a!l!l.1 W~A;fEl~lHll* ffd:frJI!I!I.1 flAm~. flAmf~ fl Amf;tt*~.~ flA1i:fi¥ of the model R2. b.6258. 0.5480. 0.0201. 0.2849. -0.4990. 0.4182. 0.0152. 0.0175. 0.2137 0.0662 0.l989 -0.8164 -1.1427 0.0180 0.1302 ,. 0.1878 0.1038 0.0785 0.2410. ·0.1507 0.1197 0.1489 0.1350. I 1.6540.
(17) lil~l!f~~ ~~ ~±itAO~D. 11lJU. if:1Iil. B~mgl ~~1Mmg2. 11115 .r&A. l8JitAO. 3,5679. 3,8362. 2.3650. 0,0309 ·0,0137 ·0.5767 -0.4592 -0,1463 ·0,0046 ·0,1184. ·0,1109 ·0,0099 ·0.4847 -0.4319 -0,1431 ·0,0062 ·0,1l66. ·0,0036 -0,0048 0.5725 0,6675 1.0337 -0,0126 ·0,0729. 0,1302 -0." 194 0.0038 ·0.0342. 0,0502 -0.1l46 0.0040 -0.0423. :!itIHttSt~R ADL~5t IADL~5t. ~1l1ll11*WWd:it1DI;I] W~AffimtMl1*. ffd:itlfJ1iJ frAMti. fr~~. test of the model adjusted R2 jf.ai@i''''::''''ITQ;'1'. p<0.0417 0,0459. ns 0.0480. -0.0233 ·0.7853 ·0.1580 -0.0801 0.3165 0.3195 p<0.0235 0.1223. 0.0811. 0.1584. -0.0393 0.0007 ·0.0790 ·0.0461 0.0095 0.0023 -0.0098. -0.0358 -0.0008 -0.1324 ·0.0873 ·0,0131 0.0025 -0.0085. 0.0144 0.0001 -0.0158 0,0524 0,0926 0.0020 -0.0088. 0.0153 -0.0126 0.0067 -0.0097. 0.0385 0.0157 0.0029 -0.0082. ffd:itAO~D. 1:1lJU. if:1Iil. e~frmgl ~~fMmg2. jiJ15 .r&A. l8JitAO. :!it~JI'~R ~~;.x~. -¥fl~*1fl. ADL~5t IADL~5t. ~lllUl1*Wffd:tt lfJ1iJ ~~AtElJfimH*. ffd:tt lfiJ)] 1'lAMti. fr~~ frA1JH~~~ frA5i~. test of the model adjusted R2. .P<.OOI. tt:zfs:liHJf:tp , :Kfig~.A.1f.~7tf(j1~F1t~ , ::fi@l75~tJJ::K1m89~.A.fti7 61.8% miJ~1f.~~ft ' llSlmpm*89:S-fl'tt'11~~ , ~~.A.:Kfig89m.~JJj(~ L - §3fi-Jlfmtp J!\(33.2%)®1ffm!lJ1~~~(24.5%)~~*tffii?5¥5!:~.A.:Kfig a9::t~JJj(~ *$7t:Ktm~.A.fI~.A.~f:r ' ZjS¥-§J~f:r.A.1l!:~3.29.A. ftcfM~ ::t~89~Jm~ , :Kfig~.A.89~IJ:M?:5Lf!r~Jl~* ' jt.tp1iii@,=tffiitJJ: 1ttt~~89 ' ~lli-=-7t~= ttZP:¥-§JJ:i~ , :Kfig~.A.fI3.3tffii89'It'l1m g:KtigM?:5Lp.x~~M' ::fOJ~fli89m~1& ' :Kfig~.A.itd6\@UEJE89~}iHElg t19gliHlUfi' *~~lli-*89:Kfig~.A.tti@l~-1f.pgtU~1±1I1G 'jt.tptJ- , 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. . =;;xliS~' I1589:Kfjg~.A.tti@l~-1f.pg'tf*~)'@:.:f.Vltj' r~llt~JE~fI2/3iJ9i ~~-1f.pg'tf~llt~fuftiI/5 a:IlIt~:Kfig~.A.tt®-lN:~.A. ' 89~fljJ~~ 0. 0. ~89.mJi~o. 3.22%89:Kffg~.A. fIlOtffii B1t~$$,JJI/Jfig%:3:!~fljJ~fffi7tmWJ tt~ WJtt B 1t~m$lJJl/Jfig(IADL)fljJ~1ZbW]'I1iffj~ , B'lJfI43.2%89~.A.tt8tffii IADLJ:fljJ~fffi7t~:3:!fi~mWJ mt~:Kfig~.A.~.fljJ~tt B1¥; ~$$IIJl/Jfig J:.:y.tJ1ZbWJ ' ::;t~~IJi±""1189B1¥;~$$1JJ 0. 0.2977. 'Iltlfl. '". -,MjQ:. 0. ~~*~ -¥~*Ifl. frA1JHtUfl!~ frA:£~. 1li " ~tl~~~~. ns. ns. 0.0068. 0.0010. **:P<.OI. *:P<.05. -0.0675 0.0241 -0.0272 0.0454 0.0312 ·0.0210 ns 0.0454. 0. 0. :Kfig~.A. OJtJ f;:NJ<ElI!:l1i~ , ~W®JiW\mm:::'1.f[ill1~¥tlpJT.~89Wd:"'2 ~ , ttJiW\ ' *~~mm1Jim ' 1~¥tl2M'89tt{9lHEl1ltfI£ ' liiftil4%. 0. 89~~ , IEW~~±"'fl/l1~!J:f!IHf4OJ tJ..fii1E89 ' llSl !ItfI~;fElg ~ f3i:1JaiJ9iW\,f@Jm ~. 0. /:. :Kffg:t.A.89IJiHlh~Jm.* ' tJ~$J:89~JmmWJ~fljJ~ , ~;;xf?<~~liS ~~NmWJ ' *~~~1lmWJ ' liS~1li:@.m.WJj..~.&.mlllicW~~1ZbWJ 0. :Kfig~.A.891llIJ:M?:5L ' Um§lH<S~ffl®B1t4.$$IJJWfi~ ,~jjii~~Jm "*fIg{~ ~5:E~r'~~' ttjjii~~lifljJ*J:tt~fJ£' ffij~~89:K1i~~.A. ' 1i§~~M?:5L~~ ''''fI~~89iii±~~JmfljJ* :KfiE~.A.tE81¥;4.m$IJJJJJffg Jl.!fI1iWJ'l1 B~~m$lJJl/Jfig~¥tl89~~ijitl~f.l~*!K¥ ' ~.~liS~N:@' , liS~ ~.®~$1ZbWJ fI75tfIfJE:fflIE~• •m#t~§lH<S ' ttjjii~~Jm~.* ' liS ~~• •*®~JmmlllifljJ*..tfI~~ fI~fflIE~• •§lH<S89:Klfg~.A.' 0. 0. 0. 0.
(18) ~. i. \. ~. !. •. ~. -R IIIl. ~. ~. ~ ~. Ui. [g ~ ~. ~ ~. e {\!;/;\m;. ,,J. if. iII*. @!. I. !l£l. ~ ~. ~ ~. em ii\;;l. ~ ~. !1r .®. ~. ~. +<. Ii iii,. ~ ~. [[ ~. I1t<! -R~. m fn • m =I =. =. -R. e. H. ~ rm. ~. ffit ~ ~ ~ ~. := g;' m ~ ~. m~. ~ ~. \1. ~. H I~. R$. ug. 1= ~ ; ___ - •.........oIiIIIiIIIIirI_ _ -. "". 0. • •. 0. l±!~r::i'~ ml ;. tr~.~. ,*mlft*' :g;'~~@!. @!]m,(mt~. mJ m~ l?§: 51 {lllI :g;' ~ .• tW ~ 1::] ;t;ci. "f". ... ~ ihlg BE 'lfr tW' . ~. m)!;!~@!A. t::!..~. ~. :Ill ~ ~ tt ~ -R ;::--fj;r:::r :g;' 1\1 ,.: t!l1' ~ ~~~U!l!~1¥F. ,~. IW~ j@! ~ ~ $11 ~ \!i1 Di~ ~ \Ii , 1 :t4 • nm; ~:g;' 1 ,~ ~ ,leU- $1 ~ • ..... "<~ ~.HmJUi~. *,~.llllI. m. ~~±:1tW~N ~~i@M.g~. lttlll ~ tr .. 1$ ~~~.g~{lb1~ ~Ui~I$!I~ ~f:\\l~E*N*,. ... --',. .. =--.'. ,. ~. .. II). ~. .... -. II). S '" '". '"'"<1:S. '"0 b.O. a. ~. .S. .. ,. ~. ~. {J<. . el). r:. IItI 4!!I!. ~)\\ .l.l.l.l 01. WiS~~£~~-<. ill\'\~41@¢*&-<. .. iil '-. . / .l.l.l.l 41!1! il( l!Q WI is. *'~~~iil~~~~ ,0. :l:ti ~ Jtg {w fE ~ .l.l.l.l JlE tnt ~ l!Q JlE .3 ~ Ui ill 41@ :lti ~ 11( [g~~{nt~*,~~. ~~:g;'ill~~lE ~ ~. ~~-<~~Ui=ali :J!«ffit~~,[g~. Jnt. 0. Jil. [g. ~~~.. -K". M. ~*'. • .l.l.l.l.l.l.l.l ~ ~ ~ '-' ill\'\. 41!1!41!1! , .g~, -<is*~Ilt~I$~i; ~ iil g ~ , • :!;l11 ll! ~l!Q~iS~)~~ 1 .l.l.l.lf ill\'\' -mniil~.\lm 41!1! BHl\-l!Qi~Jtg :~t!l1(~m)!;! in@: ~( ~ ~. ~. ~:lti. t!l1(tu~:rK~ *'. II). II). *'. 11)'. ... -< ~ ill .lit ~ !\lit} ~ &1lE ~ ~_&1lEr:::r 1 -<iu[NN • :g;'ru->Uig-<~IIIlM'mn , ~ ~ ;ae m: I$:> ~ U!l! ~ 01 /lli! ~ ~ ~ Ii ~ ~ mn .l.l.l.l 'lfr ~ ~ ~4l11! ~lE': ~.{J<~,: t!l1,~. tW~·. ",. •. 10... •. Jt>. -.,.,.. 0. @~trill\'\·,--,· :gI]Ui 2:\ll:: ~ ffil;, .g~ tEl mn WI :t#:: j;l~ [g Cl tp( ila~l$~luj[~~. ~~ • In!!it! ~ ~. - -. &.--,,-. JIlt. '-,. . I·~W!~~~W .$!~~*~u*. ","-"",..,. -.. . . : < *~11!1~. - '. Nlt~!s. .-~. '.51 1\ it! d iii ;t; ~ i?-P<lIIlt. '-'. ,. m. llJlKo. ""'"' 4[1 ~~ t!l1' ill!!I. ~~. m'Wi ~ It ¢ ~, U!l!:gj :::=:>-mn ~!I:. ~-. ~l$. ~~ ~ ~~.. ,--,@* U!l!'lfr:g;'. IltI. It ¢ 1::] ~. =lft~ ru ~. ~~m)!;!. ~to:'~ lft.~. iWil-Ljm. '-..../il£!""'"'. -m.lIfl!JJK. •. ~~ tI i. lft~. .. ~~~. '!J(. ~ =""-~~+.,~_.
(19) 00. M. ~. -K ~~. ~ .r.{. iii. '--". ,.:J. i!,l. .. ~. 4r:r. -&~ W~. ~!!Il ~. 1l.*!IIi !@ f:1:l~ ~~ ~lllA :lt1~ ~!IIi. '/w ~ ~. .I.1.1l 4tII!. ~-< ~tW t::!.. ~. !IIi:tK i§!I f:1:l~. ~ .I.1.1l olllI:!. ;t)~. ~" . g: DIJIl(. ~w. r<. {::-<. mil! 0. R.~. ~~;t) ~ DIJIl( ~. .i7El~. ~-<. ~H~. {P.:!. ~. ?1 W ~~ :If;' ~ tI ~~:tK~1E~. ~\:i$I1E~0tlli'. :If;' 1 ~1E{P.:!~ ~ ;{jt ~ :gIl ~ ~ ~ ~ :g'1 ~ N ~ , ~ ~ 0-. ~ tl<\. 0. 4* ~ ~~ il¥ ~~ ~~N]'iil!I;~. ~-R~.~~. ~. ,0... "'"". f:1:l~ ~ 0 ~ tr IR1 ~;,~~!!. Wi 1I"1l 1~. 0-. :If;';!;£~.ffiW. -<. ~ ~. tW -R {$ :gq ~ ~~-<g:~~ :tK ~ ~ ~( ~ ~~~~illlH!ifin {~ •. HUn;. 0-I'. ~. ~ ~ il. ,. ~I~. DIJIl( :If;' ~ :ttl -<~:If;'~g. 0 ~ ill! -< f:1:l~ -1::01 ~ M tmt -< tW : i ~g g; :If;' tW ~ ~ :lt1 {p.:! :. t{!!Il. 1l.* " II. !NW~:tK ~ :a 11110. 1fj@~~I!!Il!t~l!:..~.~. z.!;:~~~ M~.~ill!~g:.a ;tltl<\-<.ei~ '--" .Il ~. ii\i\ ii\i\ ~. .. ~:;!i. ~w. ~!!Il. W. !lli1itt; f:1:l~. i§!I j'-.fl$;. ~@. .roi $:: ~~. 0. :If;'l$ -<#. ~:If;'. rtJ ->«:-. ~ ~lE I:!I2i ' =~ mj!i mj!i. :If;' ,1>-' ...... jlJ!5ji; $;:If;'. ~.!;: ~ ~ ji;!da~ llil~ W Th1(. rt; ~nn ~. I:!I2i. =. lliK ,....., s:: 0 0.. 0 0... ~;::I. 4* e..n. ~~. ~~ t). N Ifj~. ~.. f:1:l~ ~ ~~. ++1 :InK' ~ Th1~ 'i ~-<!a. =. lIItW'-' f:1:lo,4tII! .!J.Il. ". i!:i!lli~. :If;'tI<:If;'. .. ~lE ~ ~. ~~ ~~. ~~~ ~~!IIi. , N. @fl$;@. !t~~. :If;'@:If;' ~~!t:. M W~~.. ••. ~. @. N. ~. Th1~. till: Jtl!; ~. '='. ~ m]!i. m:: ~ ~ ~ ;t) ~. •. ~ ~ 1!P.(" ~ f:1:l~ 1J1!! :InK !IIi!@.~~~~ ~ f:1:l~' "1\11)1) 1;-' 1::H ~,,~ tl @ "" ~ @ ,.......'" .~. ill!. ,. """':-. . .. !IIi:lf;' !IIi. §~~~. ~ ~ f:1:l~ B~++1~. ~~g1J1!!. ~~-<HE ~WtWi§!I ~ ~!!Il ::c -< 11l.*':'tW .!@~~ :If;' I~ :tK -< Itt{ .,tt + nile. I,. ~. z.!;: ~ ;!!£ {mj. ~tW,it?. 12 .. 0. • m ~ ", ~ ~ HE !@ilf+1~.. ~:tK .iJm 111. .~U#1Et--. ~~~~:2r 1\11[[ ~ ~ ~ :If;' lE~ 'w-< ~~!It!!otW. \~~~tr .:ii ITC! •. ~. ,,~. +0 ~-.: "--' '" f+1 JtQ ~ ~~"""'I:lt1l1Rl~ t; ~ jf{. Th1( :l;Q. .~~~O~~ ~~~#m\!;!~~ ..r!t~-<1I'. 1:5~*. ''Q[I!tW:If;'!!E.
(20) 84 ltLHft. ~~R~A~& • • ~.~~ • • • _.~~~. ~::t;"'l§l. ~B.. ' **11. ' #l;:~:£X ' =J:ajj~ , :'ffi!:~'& ,1991. $3.I<W¥{i5 > ' (0~~1:.) '18(3)' 212·235. (15A~~M*btW. 0. ~aJj~,. 1986. (~.$ffii3m:15A~~m:~~1fliff~ > 13(1) , 109·119. -,tp:;t~?)-:. 0. (0;!:t:~1:.>. '. 0. :t:if:t'§J ,1995. (t:r.t~m::$t:~:IlEZmEtJm~~1f > lit 4t=:122-238 0. 0. 15A:$t:~liff~. ~). 0. :tRW' 1995. «(!$:tJ;:WIii±litiEl)(tlU ( t:r t:p!\w:>i-tm~BW. *. ,1996.. t:r~t. : E~1i. 1*5i!~. 0. ZP:~B~M1ti 1:. ~.!&~~:f!l!'ltttm ,~:i'Ji!HRwa~. 1~IDEt.1t~.I2§~z~~) t:r~t$iJi!(Jff. •. 0. 0. O};!:t:1ti1:.> ,17(3)' 285-302. (1ti1:.gm1fi~BEZiI>. 0. (t:p~~~t:r.:tt!!liIA:1J~1mtiim~1f¥R* >. 1=riJi!(Ii1G.±:~t~. ,1994.. (t:p.~~t:r.illiliI15)J*bt~1f¥R* >. tJil&Ii1G~1:.W. ,1994. (t1cii"~~~~1*~Z.nffi' Wm1Jl!i---tJil&li1Gm -t1l!3~f3j.~,rmF""litlli >. ~~.&. ' **ft. '. Sft~. :'ffi!:~'&. '. tiij~. ,. , ~t51aJl ,1991.. t\f<Ij'I~IDEt.1t$3.I<z~1fliff~) g.~. ~m<:tI. a-9~1f). 0. ,1994.. !i7C31.ffll' 1988.. 59.67. 0. U~. (t:r.!§id:.liI71~15A'±:~l\?;'!. (0~~1:.). '19(2),166-177. , *~1rf:t '. I!JtIl~. ,18(3)' 237-247. (~:fII!~~*). ,1988. 0. 0. ,60, 103·110. 0. 0. (t:r~t$J1:t:p!!i.1i1G60J1tt.t1:::{tli1Gm~,tfJ5~ (~1:.f1iJi!(~f!J). '10(2)' 57-68·. ,1984. (t:p~*:tm$151f:Aa-9mm$~mtJ~ITF",'~~ • (t:p~~~m$*~mffi$g~~litlitfID WflJm 0. 0. ~~.& '*m<~. , *1J9j-, f!:l~. ,1989.. ~ifrj. 0. ,35 (1) ,. (J5~t:p)j.mA. (~:fII!~lt*). 0. (0~~1:.). (15A~~J5~~bt,. '16(2)' 149-158. (t:r.15Araml\?;'!,rmft*z~~). ,1994.. m~~. ,1993.. ;i.;"j§jMt, 1994.. (J5~1lI:fI1!W~l!I[z~*~~W¥{i5) (W~~ii"W~A~M~~zml!J). m-tIl!3M ' 67-84. 0. ram. 0. ~~Wifd:.litiJi!(~liff. 'f!fh' 1990.. ,35(1)'. 0. 0. 1ti1:.~~~t;liff~ U~frH.t;lIiU~lfaB). 0. 1=riJi!(li1Gliff~lit. <t:r.illiblut=-t1f:*~pm{j,{tJtl~a-9liff~>. , *~~~ ,1991.. ~1.1~. , ~t}fflj~ , tiijm<~ ,1991. 0. ,. 0. 0. ~J1:t:r. 0. I!JW~. ~1:iX:5&W¥1J >. 0. 0. (t:r.t~w!15A3(.g~~zliff~). .*~ffd:.lit~fU. '. Z'±:~l\?;'!,rm:i'~f<Ij'I1iIDEt.;f§MI2§~Z~~). 69-83 •. ~~¥l' tiijml~. "'1<1:. ,1992. 0. '39(3) 99-106. ~t:p{j,m1i~~fil'jliff~lit (~Agml\?;'!,rmwwrmflJiJi!(rn:zI&~). 0. 0. (~B~tfJ5~l\?;'!~~ttz~~). g~i{1r. , fl&fE:iM! ,1990.. 0. 0. JJ:B.§1ral1 '. Oi±w!~J.&*TU). lJt!l 109·119. 0. otJ1:t:r~t$15A.~**1t:Zliff~--.~m.. t:r~t$ifd:.litr.u~1lf;liff~. 0. ~:fII!m:*Z~~). (t:r.illiliIJ5~l\?;'!~15A'±:~l\?;'!,rm:i' 0. (~:fII!~~>. 0. $3.I<w~~1:.m). (0Jt:~1:.>. 0. ,1992.. SftH ' =J:1!f.7!i ' Sft~itliij ,1989. (t:r~tt~liI151f:AID~H~~~W§W¥~~ a-9M,*,) (t:p~~~> '19(2)' 69-82. ~M~ 0. 0. , ~lS'laJl ,1992.. ,rm:i'z~:1JW$3.I<z~1fliff~). , Sft~ , ~31.:£X '. 1fa-9*11:.mf1~). (~~1*~H:ilttlf1~*--~Mwa~>. ,m-tIl!3M' 85-100. 0. liff~). 15A.m1*~iJi!(~. (fJ:£~~mHq;a-9~$~~~~15A~1\lOO~F",'Jj!g >. id:.7*lIiU~fi>. (~J]!~. 0. 0. :'ffi!:m<:tI' 1994.. 0. Sftm<~ ,1992. (t:r~tilliliI15At:p)j.J~:i'flt!:mi~JtI.l3(lI:1J~~"I2§~Z. 0. ,1992.. ,1994.. ,1989. (tf15AiHF!:J~,:i'~J§!a-9W¥{i5Et.~;Elf!mnffi > , 36(2)' 25~34. 0. tJiJi!(Ii1G'±:H~. f1iJi!(Ii1G~1:.~. 1*5i!~. (~I;!i$~Araml\?;'!Riim:*9G~~1f). <~;Elf!~lt*>. 0. (i¥jt:r.*UIi1G:F.&£~ZI*~~l!I[g~. '18(3)' 249·261. 0.
(21) ~~ftMA~ • • • ~.*~. 86 lit ~~. ~::Ei~. , ,*.:t:J§I ,. ~~). iil!~i¥J ,1990.. '17(2)' 171-180. ~iJ~. , 1996.4J':l68. il!H~~. , 1992.. ~§"~ , tiH~). ~.~.~. ('liJffi!)=lJJjl!ij~Jl!D19fti.O. 0. (0~. 0. Higgins, J.(1989). Derming community care: Reality and myths, Social. <tJ~tm~Am~~fJj~*~~Il~~ZtiH~}. 0. tJ~t. policy and administration, 23(1). PP3-16. Kane, R. A. & Kane, R. L. (1987). Long-term care: Principles, programs,. 0. <~Aft:M~[;j;fEIlMlliBg). 0. tJ~t. : f:Eltt. 0. 1990. <tJ~tm~t~liicp~1fAfjtfifBlIi~~ZllmJ1tt <0~~~) '17(2), 159-169. f*flffiUi ' 0. Guralnik,J.M.& Simonsick, E. M (1993). Physical disability in older Americans, Journal o/Gerontology. 48(Suppl): 3-10.. 0. mjJi:IOM,fct1ffqJ~M:tiH~ il!H~~ ,1993.. •••. 0. .::..,~Jt~1)-:. Able, E. K. (1986). Adult daughters and care for the elderly. Feminist. Studies, 12,479-497.. andpolicies. New York: Springer. McAuley, W.J.& Arling,G.(l984). Use of in-home care by very old people.. Jurnal 0/Health and SocialBehavior, 25:54-64,1984 MiIler,J.A.(1991). Community-based long-term care. Newbury Park. CA : Sage Publications. Molley,S.P.(1994). Defining case management, Home Health care Nurse, 12(3),51-54.. Anderson, N.N.,Patten,S.K.& Greenberg,1.N.(l980). A comparsion o/home. Montgomery, R. J. V. (1992). Gender differences in patterns of child-parent. care and nursing home care/or older persons In Minnesota.Vo.!. caregiving relationships, in Dwyer,J.W.& Coward, .T.(ed) Gender,. Summary, Minneapolis,U of Minnesota.. /amily, and elder care, Newburg, CA: Sage.. Barusch,A.& Spaid,W.(1989). Gender differences in caregiving: Why do wife report greater burden? The Gerontologist, 29, 667-676. Chapple,N.L.(l985) . Social support and the receipt of home care service.. The Gerontologist, 25 : 47-54. Chenoweth, 8.& Spencer, 8.( 1986). "Dementia: The experience of family givers", The Gerontologist, 26, 267-272. Dwyer, J. W& Coward,R. T.(Editors)( 1992). Gender,families and elder care.. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications. Coward, R. T.& Dwyer, J. W.(l990). The association of gender, sibling network composition, and patterns of parental care by adult children.. Research on Aging, 12 : 158-181. Crawley,W.D.(l994). Case management: managing the nurse case management.. Health Care Supervision, 12(4) 84-89. Goldscheiger,F.K.(l990). The aging of the gender revolution, Research on hiM. 12 : 531-545.. Phillipson, C. & Walker, A. (1986). Ageing and social policy: A critical. assessment. Aldershot, Hants, England: Gower. Stone,R.,Cafferata,G.L.& Sangl,J.(l987). Caregivers of the frail elderly; A National profile, The Gerontologist, 27, 616- 626. Walker, A. J.(1992). "Conceptual perspectives on gender and family caregiving." in 1. W. Dwyer, & R. T. Coward (eds). Gender,families, and. elder care. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications. Wallace, S. P.& Cambell, K.& Lew-Ting, C-Y.(1994). Structural barriers to the use of formal in-home services by Elderly Latino, Journal. 0/. Gerontology:Social Science, 49:5 Wallace, S. P.& Lew-Ting, CoY. (1992). Getting by at home community based long-term care of Latino elders, West Journal 157: 337-344.. 0/ Medicine,. Sep..
(22) H15 1it1 *- 1P,. ~~~~A.~ft~~.~. • • • • ~~Z~~. Wiener, 1. M., Hanley, R 1., Clark, R,& Van Nostrand, J. F, (1990), Measuring the activities of daily living: Comparisons across national survey, Journal ofGerontology:Social Sciences, 45, 229-237,. ':i~~~~~AEl r~'~~~{~ift.w~~-tl91~. :. ~~A1tJfl~&.~~~a9af,5ili-i-·. g f .... #. f~~.t-. ••• A~~a~ •••• M~.·~A~~ .ti.A~~4 ••:fM.f}'· A~t.t~I:~~.t.t. •• (respite care) .'M.~·.~.f.~M'.Aa~ •• ~.M~~·t*Ml S~~A.~ti.~·fiti.'+L~a~ •• ~.M~m.~AA ~~4 •• :f·~~M.g~:~~.A~m:f~~~4~.Aa~ ••••• ~~ •••:fMt.,.M•• :fC&M.~;~A~m a~ •••• ~ ••• AM#~~·~.~ •• ,ft~.~h·~~ '~~~ ••• M~a~M~.·~A ••• #~M~~~f·.a' ~~~A~.~.~M~*~~a~ •••• ~.M~~· __ : a ~ ••••. C& •••• · •• fft;$ • ~m:ftut ~~~MQM.4. ". *-.1.. :t fJf i*. rn z. jNt >t 4,dl 1I;f4- -t:/ill B/J 6i} bit !Jt'it.: r :HU; A..1f.if. i(,;fa .if. i(, ~,. ft ,¥< (It • .,*-: NSC 85-2412-H-004-002). lII{f.z.!Jt--~;l. El ~~"!Il;Jt~"zi*.rn~ff!lJ • .u:.aii; *.*,,ji.-t*, ,¥-. jll~;j:t.
(23)
相關文件
Health Management and Social Care In Secondary
“Social welfare” if defined in a narrow sense refers to the services provided by the Social Welfare Department (SWD) and Non-governmental Organisations (NGOs),
Promote project learning, mathematical modeling, and problem-based learning to strengthen the ability to integrate and apply knowledge and skills, and make. calculated
The Senior Secondary Health Management and Social Care Curriculum and Assessment Guide incorporates the key recommendations in the Curriculum Development Council's
The elderly health centres provide people aged 65 or above with comprehensive primary healthcare services which include health assessments, physical check-ups, counselling,
Topic 4 - Promotion and Maintenance of Health and Social Care in the Community 4CAspects of risk assessment and
They are: Booklet (6) – Healthy Community, exploring the communicable and non- communicable diseases and how they affect community health so that students are able to
between the roles of the individuals (private sector) and the public or government in the provision of social care and health services responsibility of the government, e.g.